News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by semiquaver on Monday September 21, 2026 @06:58AM (#49785622)
Did anyone actually read the linked wiki in full? It’s basically saying “if there are embedded ads in certain live (likely sports) content we carry you may see them even on an ad-free plan because we don’t have an alternative. Also we might try to promote different tiers of Disney+ itself within the app so to the extent you see that as an ad, that’s an exception to ‘ad-free’”

I’m all for consumer awareness but I’m begging everyone to stop freaking out over prosaic non-issues like this.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by DonsDiscountGas on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:10AM (#49786242)
> Also we might try to promote different tiers of Disney+ itself within the app so to the extent you see that as an ad, that’s an exception to ‘ad-free’”

Yes I see that as an ad. Do you not? Does anyone not? And if I'm on the highest paying ad free plan, what are they promoting to me?

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jmathai on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:22AM (#49786375)
I’ve been a paying customer of Dropbox’s consumer plan for over a decade. Each time I visit their website I am greeted with a full page modal ad asking me to upgrade to a different plan I have no use for.

I’ve dismissed it every time. I don’t mind being shown that ad once. But it bothers me that they don’t care enough about my experience using their product to provide a “never show this again” option.

Or just use some metrics to know that if I dismiss it 50 times then maybe I’m not interested.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:13AM (#49786873)
This is a bigger problem than it may appear. The business lifecycle is well understood, whereby a company innovates, expands, and then when it has a sufficiently large customer base, it monetises. I.e. it enshitifies its products - making them more expensive over time relative to the value. This process is death by a thousand cuts. A PM might see that having the modal you hate show every time you load the site increases conversion by 3%. That's $1M ARR you just made the company! Wow! You get a bonus and a promotion! The problem is you erode customer sentiment by some undefined unit. Many people think NPS measures this, but it doesn't. That measures how many people love and hate the product. It omits the vast majority of people in the middle. They just add it to the increasing list of annoyances until one day there are so many annoyances that they leave. At that time it's very difficult for the company to understand why the user churned. It wasn't any one thing. It was a concerted effort over years to squeeze every cent out of the user at minimum cost.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by slyzmud on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:08AM (#49787503)
> At that time it's very difficult for the company to understand why the user churned. It wasn't any one thing.

It's very easy to know for people inside the company who actually care about the product and for their clients. It is really hard for directors and VP that anything they understand are numbers.

If I say "hey this modal/pop up is making customers angry" they are going to ask how much they care (is there even an unit for that?) and how much revenue is lost. The only way for them to handle a project is creating a goal for next Q and assigning people, when in most cases what you need is actually the opposite.

The problem is not that no one knows how to fix it, the problem is that managers organize around big problems and become useless at improving the small things or details. They become blind. It happened to me 100 times. They do not want things to be fixed unless there's a clear revenue increase, which is stupid.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by SoftTalker on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:10AM (#49788311)
The concept is called "goodwill" and it can be recognized in the balance sheet.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by avhception on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:50AM (#49786646)
Do you want to upgrade now or later? Will you upgrade now or do I need to nag you to death?
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jmathai on Monday September 21, 2026 @05:17PM (#49793571)
no
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:27AM (#49786413)
I strongly agree, and it frustrates me when people and companies claim that advertising their own products "doesn't count." I cancelled my YouTube Premium plan because of ads. These are all the ads they permit on Premium, despite advertising everywhere that Premium removes all ads:

* Ads in YouTube feeds for other google products and services.

* Ads underneath videos for products from the channel owner.

* Sponsorships within videos from the channel owner.

* Advertising overlays (supported IN THE APP BY GOOGLE) for products and services from the channel owner.

* Email advertisements for Google products and services.

* Community post advertisements from channel owners which show up in the YouTube feed.

I contacted support to enquire and they state these are not considered advertising.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by hdgvhicv on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:25AM (#49787008)
I don’t mind the in video sponsors. Some are good (ok map men ones are good), but crucially it’s not really something YouTube could directly block. They could put terms and conditions in place, but you’re driving product placement and it becomes a slippery slope.

Howver recently I’ve noticed adverts for “membership” for channels, and that is getting me close to picking my youtube habit. Same with Spotify and advertising concerts, but that seems to have gone away for me after I complained.

Sadly even the bbc does adverts on iPlayer. You used to be able to instantly skip them, but then in a big (internal) fanfare some idiot decided they could make them not skippable and increase some metrics and then get a promotion.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by alex0015 on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:14PM (#49789235)
What ads do you see for channel membership? I run a channel and put some of my videos behind a membership gate. I mention the premium videos in some of my free videos but otherwise don't see options in the YouTube UI to actively promote my membership in any other way. Is it putting graphics or something inside the video to tell you to click the membership button?
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by kmeisthax on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:40AM (#49787177)
YouTube actually does block sponsor spots in videos if you have Premium. They call it "Skip Ahead" and don't really talk about sponsor spots, but practically speaking it's 9/10 just the "skip sponsor segment" button.

I remember about 10-15 years ago YouTube actually did try to ban sponsor spots in videos, but the backlash from creators was strong enough that they walked that back to "ok well we'll allow sponsor spots but you can't just insert the sponsor's own ad, it's gotta be your ad read and B-roll".

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by elondaits on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:20AM (#49787657)
Most of the UI features that YT added over the last few years can be thought of as a way to skip sponsor ads. e.g., thumbnail previews on the seek bar, the little histogram on the seek bar, auto-chapter detection, and playing at 2x when you click and hold on the video.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Dylan16807 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:42AM (#49787923)
They make it slightly easier to find the end of a sponsor segment, while still requiring me to manually interact with the video. As an ad blocker I score that either F+ or D-.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by hdgvhicv on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:14AM (#49788376)
Yes it tends to work one at a time, but some videos have two sponsor segments and it doesn’t work the second time. I assumed it skipped to where people often skip to.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by stravant on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:53AM (#49788891)
I'm pretty sure that skip ahead is deliberately broken to satisfy advertisers.

Sponsorblock has zero issue jumping to the precise moment after the sponsor vs jump ahead always leaves just enough time to still hear the name of the sponsor.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by fweddi on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:13PM (#49789223)
100%. YouTube makes the skip button appear a few seconds after the start of the sponsored segment, and ends the skip a few seconds before the end of the sponsored segment.

That's their choice, and it's deliberate – it gives enough of a window for advertisers to get their message across, while still selling Premium users the notion that they've 'avoided' the ad.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by hhh on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:28AM (#49787749)
that's not blocking though. It's allowing you to skip over the areas people commonly skip in videos where they take the data from everyone. I get them at sponsor slots of course, but also intros often. Because it's not removing it entirely, I would not consider that blocking.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by SllX on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:40AM (#49788715)
The parent’s characterization is fine. 9/10 times (more in my own experience) it is the functional equivalent of a sponsor blocker. That it technically isn’t that specifically is immaterial, because if it works, that’s because people are skipping the sponsor segments in large enough quantities for it to easily become that.

That said, I don’t think YouTube owes it to Premium subscribers to add a sponsor block. That’s part of the video’s content as it was provided to YouTube, and YouTube never advertised YouTube Premium as something which will block in-video sponsor reads. This is part of how YouTubers make a living & a Premium sub doesn’t replace the money they receive for those the way it does for YouTube’s own ads.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Grombobulous on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:40AM (#49787895)
It’s such a great feature, and I see why YouTube gates it to Premium.

Once you’ve transitioned from an ad-watching customer to a paid one, YouTube actually turns into something that treats your product experience and satisfaction as important.

It’s fascinating how it switches that off for non-paying users. Not a lot of companies’ services do that so obviously and blatantly.

In other words, when YouTube is being watched for free, they have that typical engagement incentive: keep you watching as long as possible, watch as many ads as possible, etc.

When you’re paying? Who cares, skip the content if you want. Use Gemini to summarize it, we don’t care if you watch the video.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by godshatter on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:01AM (#49788190)
Try watching YouTube without logging in through a VPN with an ad blocker. You get 5s black screens and "Experiencing Interruptions?" popups.

If they don't want people watching videos without logging in, they should gate them behind a login screen rather than fucking with their users.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Xirdus on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:27AM (#49788527)
I was getting that when logged in, without VPN (but still ad blocking.)
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by godshatter on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:09PM (#49789134)
I wasn't sure which of the parameters was causing it. Looks like ad blocking is the one, then.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Grombobulous on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:07PM (#49796361)
That’s because you’re not a YouTube customer. You want to consume their product without paying and without viewing any ads.

They are very logically making that difficult for you. They are exercising their right to refuse service to you.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by fragmede on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:13PM (#49796405)
Aka a leech. Even torrent sites look down on that behavior.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by colejohnson66 on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:00PM (#49790883)
Are you sure that wasn't the VPN's fault?
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by notpushkin on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:48PM (#49791589)
That is quite deliberately YouTube’s fault. It only occurs with an ad blocker (VPN is irrelevant here, though it might be rolled out only in some countries), and the “experiencing interruptions?” thingy links to an article basically telling you to disable your ad blocker.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jonhohle on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:59AM (#49788155)
I worked on Prime during the rollout of Prime Video and shortly after (maybe a year or so) pre-roll for other Prime Video content was inserted. I brought it up in a meeting with our org (but the Amazon Video team wasn’t present) and one of our business guys shrugged it off as not interrupting content, blah, blah, blah. I said the agreement was ad-free content, not uninterrupted content. The conversation stopped and nothing was done.

I worked on backend subscription management and the implementation of benefits. The team that business guy worked on was the group eventually at the center of the predatory subscription issue (I can’t say whether they were still around when that happened or not).

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by sanex on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:03AM (#49788216)
Cheap corporate sellouts are the problem with every big company.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by ApolloFortyNine on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:14AM (#49786887)
>* Ads underneath videos for products from the channel owner. > >* Sponsorships within videos from the channel owner.

I actually agree this is a bit annoying, but also the alternative is Google banning Youtubers from finding their own advertising partners, which I'm sure people would hate.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:26AM (#49787023)
I'm sure content creators would hate it because they would make less money. Billions of YouTube users around the world would be very happy.

To be clear, I'm not opposed to the practise, as long as that's clear up front. YouTube advertises Premium as an ad free experience, and in reality it's full of ads.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by SoftTalker on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:59AM (#49788156)
Do you only watch videos from creators who are not trying to make money?

If they couldn't make money, 80% of the content worth watching would not be produced.

Premium works for me. Is it perfect, no. But there's that saying about perfect being the enemy of good.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jdb9001 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:36AM (#49787123)
Do they not have a little sponsor skip thing? Where like if many people skip a segment, itll pop up like hey, wanna skip? I mean, thats about all they can do besides forcing youtubers to disclose exact segment lengths which would concretely hurt them whereas this provides a little sort of breathing room, or just straight up ban them, both of which would dramatically hurt the platform.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:05AM (#49787454)
I understand they have an opt-out feature now. With positive interaction one can skip one sponsored segment (which works most of the time). The problem is that it's not automated. It required digging one's phone out of their pocket, or reaching for the remote. That's still really annoying. To point: it's still full of ads, even if they have the skip button now.

YouTube could tell content creators not to include sponsorships. The terms are long and onerous. Of course content creators would be upset and they would make less money. Ultimately my issue is that YouTube advertises an ad free experience with Premium and it still has a LOT of ads.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by LoganDark on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:42AM (#49788744)
YouTube Premium now has "skip ahead" which is basically this. Or you can install SponsorBlock and get a much better version for free.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:45AM (#49787220)
I'm in favour of people making money from their work. Maybe I'm old fashioned that way. IMDB, Duolingo and Wikipedia have encouraged the model of using unpaid labour.

YouTube isn't paying people properly, despite its vast revenues. At least with sponsorship the people themselves make some money.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by godshatter on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:06AM (#49788261)
I'm not saying this is the way to go, but damn do I miss the old internet where passionate people presented information for free, at worst showing an affiliate link for an information-related book.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:49PM (#49789768)
People need to be able to make a living and when this is taken away, the living expenses don't disappear. Most people can't pay for their electricity or food with voluntary work.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by godshatter on Monday September 21, 2026 @05:11PM (#49793500)
The people who were doing this on the early internet were not trying to make a living off of it, they were just doing it because they enjoyed it and wanted to share what they built with the world. If you could cover your server costs then that was considered a win.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @02:33AM (#49797447)
There are plenty of people giving away their labour for free, which makes it harder for people who need to be able to make some money in order to support themselves.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by godshatter on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @10:43AM (#49802162)
People making passion projects for free don't owe anyone a business model.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @06:48PM (#49809366)
They aren't always making passion projects. They're told unpaid labour is good for their CV/resumé, or that they're helping society (sometimes the case, but sometimes not).

Massive corporations such as Alphabet do have the resources to pay YouTubers, especially given how much tax they avoid in most countries.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by choo-t on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:00AM (#49787412)
Wikipedia predates Youtube by five years.

Unpaid cooperation of human to generate knowledge or entertainment predates YouTube by tens of thousands years.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:54PM (#49789874)
YouTube is part of Alphabet, one of the biggest corporations in the world. It can easily afford to pay people. It isn't co-operation, it's a corporation which takes the work of other people and makes lots of money off them, without paying them properly (or at all in many cases). Wikipedia's content is used by LLMs and other such outlets who also profit off unpaid labour.

It is a basic right of people to be able to afford to live. It's easy to work for free when you have family money but you cannot support yourself when you don't.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:08AM (#49787498)
> I'm in favour of people making money from their work.

That's completely fair. YouTube offers content creators many ways to do this. For example, they can put content behind a paywall. They can ask for donations. They can ask for memberships. Members get all kinds of fun perks. The part I have an issue with is YouTube advertising an ad free experience with Premium and then allowing content creators to fill their videos with ads.

> YouTube isn't paying people properly

I hope we can both agree that the solution to this is YouTube paying people properly, and not allowing content creators to shit all over viewers. That's pitting the little guys against each other while Google laughs all the way to the bank.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by johnnyanmac on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:30AM (#49787770)
>I hope we can both agree that the solution to this is YouTube paying people properly

The solution is proper competition to google. Because Youtube is pretty much the one true monopoly out there. But as we all know, video hosting alone is very,very, very expensive. It really is something you need to be a billion dollar company to do, and Youtube wasn't profitable until like... 2 years ago?

So I tolerate the user ad reads as the best compromise because nothing else would work. I don't think Youtube is a model where Google is being greedy so much as practical. At least not in how it monetizes creators (there's plenty of hostile means they do to creators as is, but the monetary structure seems fine).

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:23PM (#49791233)
There are alternative streaming platforms, but many of them have become associated with certain political viewpoints.

There is also a very limited range of content on Odyssee, Bitchute and all the rest. If you want to find music tutorials for example, you're unlikely to.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @01:02PM (#49790016)
You have to put in a disproportionate amount of work to get anything back. Almost no one makes money off a single video, but instead you make a string of videos and get a following. (The cases of a single video making money are few and far between.)

You don't get hourly pay for it, it's vaguely commission based and you do all your own promotion. They can demonetise you at a whim and refuse to pay you (I've seen this happen to craft channels and other content that wasn't remotely controversial.)

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jasonlotito on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:09AM (#49788306)
> To be clear, I'm not opposed to the practise, as long as that's clear up front. YouTube advertises Premium as an ad free experience, and in reality it's full of ads.

I think it's clear. I don't want YouTube going in and editing movies and creator videos removing any form of advertising. Maybe you want them deleting that content. But the average person realizes what Premium means by no ads. Being obtuse or willfully ignorant isn't reasonable.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by kdkdkejdjwj on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:31AM (#49787774)
This would destroy YouTuber culture AND rid us of ads on there. This is my own personal heaven. Nirvana. Eden. Promised Land. Paradise.

Let’s freaking do it.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by layer8 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:25AM (#49787010)
More importantly, it would lead to more “product placement” and other underhanded product/brand promotions.

And the real annoyance with YouTube Premium is that the UI is still full of engagement dark patterns.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by RugnirViking on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:45AM (#49787955)
no it wouldn't, such things are straight up illegal in most places? You have to clearly disclose ads + have clear distinction between ad content and rest of content. A bunch of youtubers have gotten in trouble for this?
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by pbasista on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:36AM (#49788663)
> I cancelled my YouTube Premium plan because of ads.

That would make a great title for a write-up of your experience.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by loloquwowndueo on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:23AM (#49786984)
Pro tip. Ublock origin gets you that mostly ad-free experience you were hoping for. Donate the money you save from the YouTube premium sub to ublock origin instead.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by dormento on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:38AM (#49787144)
Also, SponsorBlock. Can't recommend it enough. It even works on """smart""" TVs if you're controlling youtube from your phone.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by thesuitonym on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:55AM (#49787346)
uBlock Origin + SponsorBlock is the only way YouTube is even remotely watchable these days. Even still, it's not really worth it. I frequently find it better to spend my time doing anything else.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by dleslie on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:59AM (#49788965)
It's mostly AI generated drivel on their home page now.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by loloquwowndueo on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @06:44AM (#49799149)
Oh absolutely - we banned “casual” YouTube use at home 5 years ago and we don’t regret it one bit. Still use it when looking up a concrete video on a specific topic or when a web page directs me to a tutorial or something there, but don’t use it for regular “entertainment” (I’m bored, let’s hit YouTube).

Some people can’t seem to live without YouTube though.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by piltdownman on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:08AM (#49787504)
Is there a viable solution for YouTube on a Google TV nowadays? They've started doing 60 second ads which are absolutely egregious.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by scun on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:08PM (#49789110)
Just get one of those Fire things. What's it called again, Fire Tube? Oh I remember: axe.

Get a Fire Axe. Put it in the TV. Enjoy life.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jampekka on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:04AM (#49788238)
SmartTube
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by JoshTriplett on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:49AM (#49787272)
Sadly they don't accept donations, but send it to your favorite channel's Patreon or similar.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:25AM (#49787001)
Thanks! It's great on Mac/PC but sadly it doesn't work on iPhone, Android TV and Apple TV. I have solutions for those now too.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bink on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:48AM (#49788815)
Mind sharing them with the rest of the class?
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @03:29AM (#49797742)
Sure! On Android TV, SmartTubeNext is fantastic. Installation instructions are in the GitHub repo. For Apple TV the best option I have found is MuTube. It's basically a YouTube repack without ads and with SponsorBlock. The catch is that it requires sideloading or an Apple developer account. Sideloadly etc can automatically refresh certificates while on wifi, but I ended up purchasing a dev account because it works for all the Apple devices in my home. Which leads me to the iPhone. There are many YouTube sideloads. I use uYouEnhanced. As above, you can use Sideloadly or sign the app yourself. An LLM or coding harness can walk you through the process (or do it for you). With an Apple dev account, signed apps last for a year, so I don't need to worry about refreshing the certs.

SmartTubeNext automatically updates itself, but the Apple TV and iPhone apps don't. Surprisingly, it has not been an issue. They keep working fine without updates for the year. I just update once a year when I refresh the certs.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jtbayly on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:00PM (#49788977)
I cancelled my Spotify subscription when they wouldn’t stop trying to advertise podcasts to me.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by sbarre on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:08AM (#49786829)
I mean, the stuff that's in the video is not really under Google's control.

Are you suggesting that the burden should be on channel owners to upload variations of their videos that don't include sponsor blocks? That's a bit onerous. My commercial agreement is with YouTube, not with the video creator.

If you don't like ads from creators, don't watch those channels?

YT Premium does provide the "skip ahead" functionality that almost always jumps over sponsor blocks.

I will say I've been a YT Premium subscriber for years and I've never seen any ads for other Google services in my feed, and I don't get advert emails either.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:21AM (#49786956)
> I mean, the stuff that's in the video is not really under Google's control.

It is completely within Google's control. They have a hundred pages of terms of services, dictating everything the content creators may and may not do and say, down to individual words, symbols, and opinions. If Google wanted to, they could tell content creators to stop adding sponsorships. I understand you'd make less money.

> If you don't like ads from creators, don't watch those channels?

I stopped paying YouTube and I use SponsorBlock now. You're not entitled to my time or attention or money.

The problem is ultimately that Google advertises an ad free experience, which it's not. I'd be willing to pay for an ad free experience.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by sbarre on Monday September 21, 2026 @01:51PM (#49790740)
> You're not entitled to my time or attention or money.

Ahhh but you're entitled to someone else's hard work in producing the content you watch, and god forbid they'd be entitled to compensation for that work.. Got it..

Rules for me, not for thee..

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @03:32AM (#49797769)
You're free to put your content behind a paywall. YouTube makes this very easy.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by cwillu on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:12AM (#49786864)
If google can't provide an ad-free product, they shouldn't be selling an ad-free product.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by thesuitonym on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:56AM (#49787363)
All creators that are on Nebula already upload sponsor-free versions there.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by whatevaa on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:07AM (#49788270)
Nebula is mostly irrelevant. Even Nebulas creators wouldn't survive without youtube revenue.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by thesuitonym on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:55AM (#49788914)
Maybe so, the point is there is a non-zero number of creators who already do sbarre thinks is too onerous.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by notpushkin on Monday September 21, 2026 @03:06PM (#49791829)
> Are you suggesting that the burden should be on channel owners to upload variations of their videos that don't include sponsor blocks?

No, just mark the sponsored segments, so YouTube can skip over (like SponsorBlock does). And they already pay more per view from Premium users vs ad-supported ones, so it just makes sense to skip ads in the video as well.

That being said, I think paying creators directly is more sustainable in the long term.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by websap on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:36AM (#49787120)
I'd pay $20 / month for a Youtube subscription with no ads or sponsored content. Unfortunately even with sideloading on iOS there's no alternative live youtube vanced.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by DANmode on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:52PM (#49789835)
Brave seemingly blocks YouTube ads on iOS.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @03:31AM (#49797757)
FYI I use (https://github.com/arichornlover/uYouEnhanced) on my iPhone (I sign with an Apple dev cert) and it's great. It blocks ads and has SponsorBlock built in.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jasonlotito on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:06AM (#49788256)
And then on the flip side you have people who won't blink an eye with Apple doing it. Shame, really.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:42AM (#49787193)
Sponsorship within videos at least gives money to the uploader. YouTube has forced that by demonetising videos or paying peanuts.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by redanddead on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:03AM (#49788223)
What sucks is it’s never enough

It always gets more expensive for a lesser enshittified version, removed/fucked with features to keep a bloated product team employed

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by carlosjobim on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:13AM (#49786883)
YouTube Premium now has integrated sponsor block. At least that's something.

And any ads underneath a video is at least not shown in the Roku YouTube player, nor are ad overlays as far as I know, since I've never seen one.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:24AM (#49786993)
It helps but I understand that it's not automatic. Is that correct? If so it significantly undermines the functionality. SponesorBlock automatically removes ads. Meaning I don't have to scramble to open my phone or find the remote every time I don't want to hear/see an ad. That opt-out UX likely means most people ultimately watch the sponsored content.

It could be that this is a phased approach so as not to anger their creators too much.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by carlosjobim on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:46AM (#49787233)
For me personally it is as easy as pressing one button on the remote. But I don't put on videos in the background very often.

Worth noting is that there are thousands of high quality YouTube channels without any sponsored content. So those are effectively completely ad free with Premium.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by ipaddr on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:10AM (#49787526)
That's like complaining you purchased netflix subscriptiomn without ads and saw a product placement ad in a movie. I guess you want netflix to not show the movie, start cutting up the movie or ask that the movie be remade without any products.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by lucaspm98 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:24AM (#49787704)
YouTube sponsor segments are not subtle “place a Coke can facing the camera” integrations. They are dedicated ad segments with scripted (typically by the advertiser) promotions, often entirely unrelated to the video or channel.

To the end user they are indistinguishable from other video ads on the platform except the ad read is often (not always) done by the creator.

I don’t have hard data on the ratio but it’s not uncommon for a 10 minute video to have 1-2 minutes of full-interrupt ad segments embedded in the video.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bearcobra on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:42PM (#49789665)
"Ad free" meaning we do not insert ads seems like a reasonable standard to me. The alternative of policing creator content is kind of untenable since it destroys the economics for the creators and there's so much grey area.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by semiquaver on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:29AM (#49786430)
I grew up with the Disney channel on cable as a kid in the 90s. Disney channel at that time was ad-free except for cross-promotions for other Disney channel shows, most of which I (as a kid who liked the Disney channel) wanted to know more about. I have HBO Now/max/go/whatever and before most shows there’s a skippable promo for HBO stuff. So yeah, I don’t think this is new and Disney+ as it is now is way more ad-free than either of those, so I’m not surprised they are trying to nudge the status quo back to a historical equilibrium; it’s just what these companies do

I’ll always pay more to see fewer ads. My kids see far, far, far fewer ads than I and my peers did growing up watching linear TV in the 90s and I’m going to keep it that way. If Disney+ gets in the way of that I’ll stop paying them and stop using their service, easy as that.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by cogman10 on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:39AM (#49786521)
Anyone that doesn't see the obvious play here probably wasn't alive when cable was the "ad free" tv option.

These media companies cannot help themselves. Advert money is very tantalizing and they'll always want to find ways to sneak it in whenever and wherever they can.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by alt227 on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:12AM (#49788347)
> My kids see far, far, far fewer ads than I and my peers did growing up

But now these are targeted ads based on browsing data for ad profiles linked to your IP and devices. IMO just a few of these are far worse than the general run of commercials we used to have on TV. Corporations obviously think so too otherwise we would still have that.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by thesuitonym on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:11AM (#49787544)
I remember those days, and when Cartoon Network was the same. I didn't mind it then because, like you, I found the promos were a great way to know what was on the channel at different times. Especially in the age before on-screen guides.

But there are a few crucial differences between then and now: The ad spots were there to keep the timetables accurate, which is no longer necessary. They also served as a way to let you know what else was on the channel, which again is no longer necessary because that app opens to a menu of all available programming. And, now this is the important part, back then I wasn't specifically paying for ad-free access.

Anyway, I guess what I'm saying is, my Jellyfin server is about to get much more use.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bena on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:47AM (#49786611)
One of the most egregious examples of this that's happened to me was with the DVD set of the second or third season of Mad Men. One of the unskippable pre-menu ads was for the next season.

And I didn't know what to say. Either I like the series and I'm going to buy the next season or I don't and I won't.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by dijit on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:02AM (#49786768)
I get super bent out of shape when Apple TV+ advertises shows before the one I am trying to watch; even sometimes advertising the show that I am trying to watch itself and spoiling things.

I have actually cancelled my subscription because of this.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bravoetch on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:57AM (#49788944)
My journey went from downloading movies and TV shows to paying for Netflix, Apple, and Prime. Then back to torrents to avoid all the trailers and ads and curated feed. It's so peaceful now.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by k2enemy on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:05AM (#49787466)
I've talked to Apple support about this. Their website says...

    Apple Originals are always commercial-free.
But you are forced to watch ads for other shows before viewing an Apple original. The support person said that because the ads are before the show you are trying to watch, that the show itself is indeed commercial-free. Language lawyering at its finest.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by smelendez on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:21AM (#49786947)
Yeah, I actually canceled Netflix when they started making it impossible to look at the available shows without seeing previews of each of them. I am trying to leisurely decide what I want to watch, not have 15 different actors scream catchphrases at me.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by layer8 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:29AM (#49787051)
You can turn it off: https://help.netflix.com/en/node/2102. Does that setting not work for you?
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by loloquwowndueo on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:25AM (#49787009)
I don’t see this maybe because my Netflix app is older (on a 2018-era Roku tv). But it is annoying as shit on my friends tv with chrome cast.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:16PM (#49789260)
Good for you. It's impressive how many around here get jerked around but don't do the obvious thing and cancel the damn service. More people should feel outraged and insulted by these shenanigans.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by dijit on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:21PM (#49789339)
Well, you'd be surprised how annoying it is to be a curmudgeon these days.

You can't even find wired (aux) headphones... So tempering expectations when you finally decide to "go back" to simple things is required.

I like to buy my media rather than pirate (I am a man of means after all) but I can't even buy modern media.. Silo, Ted Lasso, Severance and Slow Horses do not have purchasable releases at all. At least some Prime TV shows have blu-ray releases I suppose.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by smelendez on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:05AM (#49786801)
Yeah, those kinds of ads are always aggravating to me because you’re not even making money by showing them to me. They feel like a display of power more than anything else.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by etothet on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:05AM (#49786804)
I agree. I noticed recently an ad directly inside of 1Password. I’ve paid for a 1Password subscription since 2013, and have had a family plan for many years. I know the company changed hands several years back after AgileBits sold to VC, but this type of disrespect caused me to cancel my membership. There are plenty of alternatives that haven’t turned their focus to the “Enterprise” and aren’t trying to extract as much money as possible from their paying customers.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by isaacaggrey on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:16AM (#49786906)
What would you say is comparable experience wise to 1Password? I’ve found particularly the 1Password Family plan there’s not really a good alternative of rolling with KeepassX, Bitwarden, etc.

The answer could be nothing and I still respect the choice to speak with your wallet.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:17AM (#49787612)
Bitwarden, while not quite as polished, works well. If you have your own server at home you can even self-host, which I do. It's an open source server side app called Vaultwarden [https://github.com/dani-garcia/vaultwarden] which connects to the Bitwarden app.

I think the iCloud password manager also works pretty well, provided you're using Apple products.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by thesuitonym on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:06AM (#49787475)
The closest I've found is Bitwarden, but even that isn't quite as good as 1Password.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by JoshTriplett on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:51AM (#49787287)
If you don't need to share passwords between people (other than manually), Firefox Sync is perfect.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jghn on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:05AM (#49786805)
I may be an outlier but I don't really mind being shown a relatively short ad before watching something. I'm almost never really paying attention yet anyways. Like yes, I'd prefer it not to exist but it doesn't cause me to get into a fit of rage.

But ads in the middle of something I'm watching? Fuck right off with that.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by hdgvhicv on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:23AM (#49786986)
Yes I see those, and adverts for other services (watch this program etc) as adverts.

I don’t see adverts embedded in content as adverts. Be sure I’m watching the World Cup on bbc and see an advert on the players shirt doesn’t mean I want my money back, I’d rather we had no adverts, but it’s not unreasonable.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by serbuvlad on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:52AM (#49787303)
If I use service X I am MUCH less annoyed by an advertisement of subservice X.Y than I am by an advertisement of Nord VPN and Raid Shadow Legends.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by sandworm101 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:42AM (#49787922)
An add, but no more than catching a glimps of a restaurant long after one has ordered. When standing in a shop it is normal to see prices for other products on offer.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jasonlotito on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:05AM (#49788240)
> Does anyone not?

People turned a blind eye to Apple advertising it's own services in it's products for years. I saw people defend here, on HN. So, while yes, it's advertising, Disney is far from the first to do this.

I'm not saying it's right, only that people who claim to be opposed to ads are accepting of the type of ads we are discussing.

> if I'm on the highest paying ad free plan, what are they promoting to me?

I'm assuming they aren't showing you ads for the plan you are on.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by mattbee on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:16AM (#49788397)
The BBC in the UK makes a great play of having "no ads" but 6Music (their indie music station) has constant cross-promotions interrupting the music, sometimes for jarring TV murder shows. Cross-promotion is just as annoying as ads for insurance, I hate it!
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nonethewiser on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:54AM (#49788896)
> Yes I see that as an ad. Do you not?

You are implying something false. That he’s suggesting thats not an ad. Hes not suggesting that at all.

What he’s suggesting is that that’s very different from Disney gating or interspersing movies with ads. Which it is. You may disagree with that but you’re strawmanning him.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by charcircuit on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:40PM (#49789637)
It is an upsell. It is a sales tactic. Sales isn't the same thing as advertising even though they both are trying to get you to buy something.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by josefresco on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:18AM (#49786321)
"because we don’t have an alternative"

Ads embedded on the playing field? Sure. Billboards visible or sponsor logos on uniforms? I get it. Actual commercials? This is a solved issue for decades, there are "alternatives" as others have pointed out. This is a "Boiling frog" situation.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by scotty79 on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:21AM (#49786362)
> Ads embedded on the playing field? Sure. Billboards visible or sponsor logos on uniforms?

To be honest if I'm paying for no ads I'd be expect to have an option to blur that crap on inpaint it with AI.

Monitors and TVs should have this option.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by chrismorgan on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:21AM (#49787662)
A lot of the ads on the field and perimeter are themselves inpainted. And becoming more and more offensive over time, with animation and flashing and such as technical capabilities improve and viewers become accustomed and don’t revolt.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by gosub100 on Monday September 21, 2026 @01:22PM (#49790319)
I'm sure somewhere there's an ad exec ready to rollout personalized in-game ads that say "hey Chris Morgan, try Henson's ball wash!" From data provided by your smart TV and your secret profile from data brokers.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bena on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:55AM (#49786703)
No, there's nothing really to do. They aren't producing the feed, they're essentially hosting a stream from another broadcaster.

For instance, if you have Paramount+, you can watch sports broadcast by your local CBS station through it. That station is going to be running commercials, Paramount+ has no input on it. The most they can do is run ads over their ads.

I'm assuming there's something similar with Disney+. You can watch your local ABC broadcast or ESPN broadcast of a game, but you're just getting that broadcast as being currently aired.

But even for broadcasts wholly owned and controlled by a streaming platform, like Thursday Night Football on Prime, there are just times when it would be dead air. I don't entirely mind commercials in that instance. Nothing else is going on.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by itopaloglu83 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:08AM (#49786836)
Let’s reverse the situation, they were able to add ads to sport events, so they can definitely remove ads and show the main event cameras if they wanted to. But they’re picking up showing ads indirectly through some other service.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bena on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:33AM (#49787086)
Who is "they" in this situation?

I noted that the streaming service, like Paramount+, would be able to overlay their own ads over the broadcasted commercials, but they won't have control over the cameras. That's on the broadcast station, they're the ones controlling the remote production.

Paramount+ can only rebroadcast what my local CBS affiliate is broadcasting.

I think only Netflix and Prime have deals to actually produce sports broadcasts.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by notpushkin on Monday September 21, 2026 @05:00PM (#49793356)
I suppose it’s a response to this part:

> But even for broadcasts wholly owned and controlled by a streaming platform, like Thursday Night Football on Prime, there are just times when it would be dead air. I don't entirely mind commercials in that instance. Nothing else is going on.

I.e. instead of dead air, they could show some live feed in the spot that other broadcasters use for commercials.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bena on Monday September 21, 2026 @06:10PM (#49794130)
Have you been to a live sports event?

What's happening in that time is just random bullshit. They'll run bits on the jumbotron, hold raffles, go play games with people in the stands, etc. All sponsored by "<SO AND SO>, the official <THING> of your <LOCAL SPORTS TEAM>". Or, in other words, ads.

You could show the players and coaches on the sidelines, but that's also rather boring. It'll be a couple of guys shooting the shit on a bench, or a couple of guys hunched over a table, or some guys warming up.

The best thing they can do is like information from other games maybe.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by notpushkin on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @04:17AM (#49798068)
Honestly, I was going by my most recent experience, which was F1 in Singapore last year. (I’ve been in Singapore at the time, but haven’t managed to get to a good spot, so I was watching it online a couple blocks away.) That thing had ads every minute, but the race obviously doesn’t stop during the breaks.

> What's happening in that time is just random bullshit.

Are most sports events like this? It sucks then, but the playing games with people in the stands thing sounds better than just plain ads. Mix that with sidelines shots, some alternative commentary maybe (with some instant replays?), and sure, information from other games, and you get a nice, coherent broadcast with some ads from the stadium but none that are as out of place as the usual commercial breaks.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Kinrany on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:19AM (#49786933)
Ads consume attention, so I do prefer static. Then again, I don't know why people watch TV (at all) or browse without uBlock.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bena on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:29AM (#49787046)
Does uBlock work on commercials aired as part of a stream/broadcast? I don't mean where they interrupt the stream and insert an ad, I mean that it's part of the video produced.

I genuinely don't know and am asking out of curiosity.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Kinrany on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:35AM (#49788643)
I wouldn't know, for the same reason: I don't see the point in watching a stream rather than something one specifically wants to watch.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by eek2121 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:33AM (#49787799)
Depends on the service.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by 1317 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:32AM (#49787084)
Do like international broadcasters do for these things and opt out to your own presenters with analysis etc
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bena on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:38AM (#49787140)
I'm unsure. I believe I've seen Telemundo at certain events, but they could have deals to rebroadcast and they'd have the same options as Paramount+. They can run ads over the broadcast ads and swap the audio feed with their own. The broadcast feed should have at the very least; a video feed, a crowd/stadium audio feed, and the commentary audio feed. So they could just not rebroadcast the commentary audio and replace it with their own.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by ChrisRR on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:32AM (#49786465)
I read it more as a contract issue rather than a technical issue
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by shakna on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:02AM (#49785652)
This is the same terms of service that were stretched to indemnify against theme park accidents. [0]

Why would anyone give them the benefit of the doubt?

[0] https://lawcouncil.au/international-law/ils-insights/tangled...

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by echelon on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:57AM (#49786136)
Your link doesn't appear to work for me.

In case folks aren't aware, Disney tried to avoid an allergy-related wrongful death lawsuit from a restaurant at Disney Springs (large publicly available outdoor mall that doesn't even require tickets) because a couple had a Disney+ streaming trial:

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c8jl0ekjr0go

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by gruez on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:09AM (#49786230)
The original lawsuit was spurious to begin with because the restaurant wasn't even operated by Disney.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by oivey on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:19AM (#49786333)
Incredibly irrelevant. By asserting their ToS this way, they clearly would have tried to use it in any situation where they had potential liability.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by gruez on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:36AM (#49786501)
>they clearly would have tried to use it in any situation where they had potential liability.

That's just how lawyers work. They'll try to invoke any defense that's vaguely applicable, just like any plaintiff lawyer will try to invoke any cause of action that's vaguely applicable, like the plaintiffs in this exact case.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by LPisGood on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:50AM (#49786647)
That’s not true in general. Plenty of jurisdictions do not allow you to use contradictory arguments in hopes that one is persuasive.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Dylan16807 on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:16AM (#49788392)
That sounds bad to me!

The TOS argument was so awful it deserves some kind of bonus loss, but let's put that aside for now.

Let's say I paint a fence, and my neighbor complains I ruined a particular segment that shouldn't have been painted. Why can't I argue that this segment was on my property and that my neighbor gave permission to use that paint on all segments on their property?

Let's say there's a 15% chance the survey was wrong about the fence location, and a 15% chance the court disagrees with how I'm interpreting the agreement. If I can use both arguments I have a 2% chance of losing, which seems fair to me. Both arguments are reasonable, so why should I have to risk it on only one?

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by gruez on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:23AM (#49786971)
In the context of this story (ie. US), it's specifically allowed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_pleading#Civil_law
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by ndriscoll on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:10AM (#49787529)
Don't excuse poor actions by saying these sorts of people just normally act poorly. It's their choice to act unethically.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by oivey on Monday September 21, 2026 @06:28PM (#49794311)
That’s not at all how lawyers or businesses work. The job of the lawyer is to represent the client. Lawyers didn’t ultimately decide to use the ToS in this way, Disney did. Disney estimated the reputational risk and calling attention to their morally (and legally) questionable ToS was worth the risk.

Stop infantilizing these people as if they have no other way to behave. It isn’t a law of nature that companies have to behave immorally. Hopefully you apply that understanding to your own job, too.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by rubyfan on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:22AM (#49785792)
They already run ads for Disney parks, Hulu, ESPN, and other Disney owned content in the Premium tier. They just call them promos or sponsorships in the prior agreement.

The new agreement allegedly introduces a third term “advertisements”.

> We’ve clarified that all Service Plans may include: (i) promotional content, (ii) sponsorships, and (iii) advertisements before/after playback of Content and in channels, live/as-live, special events, and any third-party services content.

I say allegedly because I haven’t received any communication from Disney yet but various reporting refers to email people in European markets have received.

https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/tv/articles/disney-putti...

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by mrweasel on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:42AM (#49785985)
I feel like they stopped doing that, but there was definitively ads for other movies and shows because some movies on Disney+, but I haven't seen it in a while. It was pretty badly done, because you'd get confused and assume you'd started the wrong movie, so maybe they rolled it back?
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by exe34 on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:24AM (#49786392)
The quoted text is identical to what I have received in an email from Disney+. I only tend to get a month at a time when I want to watch a given show, but if paying doesn't remove adverts, I'm not going to pay.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by abirch on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:47AM (#49787240)
It sucks that Disney+ cancelled Bobba Fett and other great Star Wars series. One month at a time makes sense especially with the lack of new content that I want.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by amelius on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:57AM (#49786131)
Why can't they remove the embedded ads with AI?

Sheesh ... they're a big company. This should be easy.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by basisword on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:18AM (#49786319)
If you're talking about sports stuff:

1. Now you just have a blank screen. Sure some people might like that but others will think there's an issue with the stream.

2. They're purchasing the rights to show the sports stuff, not actually producing it themselves and removing the ads would make the cost of the rights astronomical.

Even when expensive linear TV packages were the norm, they still came with ads. With live TV paying has never negated the need for ads.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by oivey on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:25AM (#49786396)
1. There doesn’t have to be a blank screen. Major League Baseball’s streaming service, for example, plays highlights or a placeholder video saying a commercial break is in progress.

2. What? They own ESPN which is producing the content, right?

Baseball literally has an ad-free tier for its live streaming service. I’m sure it’s not the only live service that does.

None of your points seem well considered. Why run interference for these companies?

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by duckmysick on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:14AM (#49786889)
I'm not familiar with MLB, only with NBA. But even their "ad-free" really isn't - there are still ad banners inside the arenas, on the court itself, and on the jerseys, the announcers often read ads ("this segment was brought to you by ..."), and if there is arena feed during the regular breaks, the in-arena events like a half-court shot are often sponsored as well. Plus there's standard service ads that announce next games.

Unless MLB blurs/bleeps all of these, it's not really ad-free.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by basisword on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:45AM (#49787956)
1. I hate the MLB one the most. I'm international so maybe it works differently but each season they come up with these horrible clips that they play on repeat. Sometimes it's a little short history snippet or this season some stuff about food. Problem is they have minimal content and so many breaks that by day two of the season they're tortuous. I'd rather have ads.

2. It probably depends on what sports we're talking about. Again, I'm thinking internationally where they've started showing La Liga this season.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by rascul on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:32AM (#49787074)
> 1. Now you just have a blank screen. Sure some people might like that but others will think there's an issue with the stream.

NASCAR has a separate feed for international broadcasts without their ads. During the ad break they'll just show an overhead camera or maybe an in car camera.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by basisword on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:48AM (#49788006)
Yeah I'm familiar with that. I guess it all depends on the sport and country. Ads during the sport is quite unusual in the UK for example so we get that NASCAR feed where the camera continues with no commentary during US ad breaks. We also have a cool setup for Indycar where a local UK commentator jumps in to talk over the feed while the US goes to a break. For MLB (on their own league pass product) we get a blank screen or non-ad montage thing in between innings (although as I mentioned in another comment that's its own kind of hell).
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by TeMPOraL on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:09AM (#49786238)
They could. They won't, because those ads are probably - if you excuse a little Claudish - the load-bearing part of the contract that allows them to show the content in the first place.

(More cynical take: the ads are the whole point, the content itself is just a vector to get those ads in front of people, and prime them to be receptive.)

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by fabian2k on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:22AM (#49785784)
There are a few cases of ads that might not be practical to remove, though most of that would be more like sponsors and ad content that is a part of the show. You can certainly get live sports without ads, though you will of course still have the pauses in the game that allow the ads in the first place. But it's not unusual to see e.g. the halftime in soccer filled with analysis on public television that doesn't allow ads in that circumstance.

And ads for their own services are still ads.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by mr_mitm on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:33AM (#49785887)
> You can certainly get live sports without ads

Jerseys, the floor, the ribbon fields and other places in live sports display ads that are near impossible to remove. There are ads in the teams' and venues' names. The NBA is even doing things like having the announcers say "this timeout is brought to you by Gatorade".

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by hibikir on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:19AM (#49786334)
In most of these cases, you will see a place like D+ carry the same announcers as the TV station. Here Inbet it would be ESPN crews. So having a different, special crew just for ad breaks would not be exactly great. And given the density of ads in, say, the Super Bowl, you would be hard pressed making this a good experience.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by micromacrofoot on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:49AM (#49786058)
In every large org, including disney, there are people who will fuck with you to the full extent of the terms and laws if they think it can increase profit... they do not care about quality, experience, or morals. I've fought these people about marketing emails at dozens of orgs as a consultant.

I guarantee they will eventually use this to show more ads. The goldfish grows to fit its bowl.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by GuB-42 on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:15AM (#49786288)
That's why I don't really care that much about terms and conditions. Just because they say they can doesn't mean that they will, conversely, the writing can be misleading to anyone who isn't a specialized lawyer, so most people can't really tell what the terms and condition let them do anyways.

I usually go for reputation and precedent rather then legalese. And in the case of Disney, they had ads in their video tapes and DVDs, so I don't need to read the user agreement to know that it has a good chance to come to Disney+, whatever the legal pathway is.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by mitxela on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:57AM (#49786128)
They don't stop at terms and laws. They stop at what loses money, through customer churn or lawsuits.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by mohamedkoubaa on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:32AM (#49786464)
Typically the only restraining force is a founder who cares.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by mosura on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:38AM (#49786511)
Who they will paint as an asshole in order to get them ejected.

And it will be true because the only way to defeat these people is actually being an asshole.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by micromacrofoot on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:41AM (#49786551)
look we know 99% of people hate being tracked but we need the data to see if 0.1% or 0.5% people are clicking the links, you've got to be a team player here
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by micromacrofoot on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:37AM (#49786507)
there are execs and product people that care, but it's rare and they often get worn out
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by deathhand on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:03AM (#49785656)
Boohoo the billion dollar giant can't do the same thing that regional sports have been doing for the last 20! years with the likes of NFL and Baseball.

Words matter. Words in advertising should matter. The slope is ice when we allow corporations to wordsmith around what they sell you.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by cyanydeez on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:20AM (#49786348)
Guys, guys, tthe cook only turned the boil up a degree or two, ypu cant even feel it!
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by reptileIllumina on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:20AM (#49786352)
Advertising is just a front for the surveillance capitalism/state and the one of foundation to the digital prison system. Of course they want ads on your devices.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by GolfPopper on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:55AM (#49788098)
It's worse than that. Advertising is a vector for dumping who-knows-what into our minds. Would you let random corporate sponsors put whatever they wanted into your food after you'd already put in the work to choose what you're eating?

To me, my time has value, and my thoughts have more. A party whose goal is to interfere with both, and who actively schemes to interfere with the integrity of both is not merely greedy, they are a hostile actor.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by ChrisRR on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:31AM (#49786450)
> I’m begging everyone to stop freaking out over prosaic non-issues like this.

This fight was lost at least a decade ago. Everything must now be a constant source of outrage

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by gatlin on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:04AM (#49786792)
Whereas you would never stoop to exaggeration or your own contribution to this fight since it’s already lost, right?
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by pluc on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:47AM (#49786614)
I'd argue that since TiVo, if you're showing ads because "we don't have an alternative", you actually want to show ads or at least won't make any effort to implement a 20 year old technology for the sake of convenience.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by myko on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:53AM (#49786681)
Those are definitely ads and definitely not what I want out of a streaming service I am paying for. This is why I don't use Amazon Prime Video much, even Apple TVs subtle ads for other programs are distasteful and I get Apple TV for free, it still pisses me off.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by 0manrho on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:07AM (#49786814)
When you select play on the media, does that media play, or some other bullshit get inserted first?

Call it what you want, if it's serving me content I didn't ask for, I'm not happy about it, especially if I'm paying extra for them to not do that explicit thing.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by dml2135 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:23AM (#49786983)
Their alternative is to not advertise a plan as “ad free” if that is a lie.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by pickleglitch on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:27AM (#49787030)
Our research shows that people with peanut allergies buy a lot of candy bars. We want to tap into that market, so we make a product call NoPeanutBars. But making them in a dedicated peanut-free facility costs a lot of money and extra work, and we really can't figure out how to do it. So we just put a disclaimer on the back that says NoPeanutBars may actually contain peanuts. What's the big deal? We don't put the peanuts in there on purpose!
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by dwedge on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:29AM (#49787056)
I'll be clear that no I didn't - I read the announcement when Disney+ emailed it to me with no further context, plus adding this disclaimer was the reason for the email. So I disagree that this is our fault.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by ghusto on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:41AM (#49788726)
They mailed me too, and I did read it in full. There's a link right there in the e-mail. I read it, and understood it's not at all what everyone here is claiming.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by dwedge on Monday September 21, 2026 @01:07PM (#49790099)
The email contains the full subscriber agreement (which is also the link in the email).

The full text for that section:

All Service Plans may include: (i) promotional content, (ii) sponsorships, and (iii) advertisements before/after playback of Content and in channels, live/as-live, special events, and any third-party services content.

Perhaps you could share, from the email, what you read that everyone else is missing.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by deaton on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:40AM (#49787164)
Even in live sports, Disney fully controls ESPN, so they absolutely have an alternative.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by epolanski on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:41AM (#49787180)
> Also we might try to promote different tiers of Disney+ itself within the app so to the extent you see that as an ad, that’s an exception to ‘ad-free

I don't like when I press play and an advertisement starts for some other freshly released content on the same platform.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by giancarlostoro on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:03AM (#49788224)
I don't mind self-ads especially if its like "Hey we're releasing this new movie in 2 weeks, are you aware?" just so long as I can skip them after the first time, and they are pre-cached when I open the app so you can download my movie / show in the background while this one plays. Guess I'm being wishful about good engineering. ;)
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by notpushkin on Monday September 21, 2026 @05:14PM (#49793542)
Even that is a bit too much to my taste. For self-promotion pre-roll kind of ads, if I can skip it the first time I see it, and I don’t see it ever again, and I don’t see more than one ad like this per day per series, then I’m reluctantly okay with that.

But ideally, just stick to some non-video recommendation UI during the credits, and let me discover things on your platform by myself otherwise, and don’t get in my way when I’m trying to enjoy the show.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by AlwaysRock on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:09AM (#49788303)
Well they do have an alternative. ESPN and I'm sure plenty of other live events will often play ads. But if you have a pihole or some issue that causes the ad not to play, the screen will just display something like, "Ad cannot be loaded. Event will resume in 1 minute and xx seconds."

Is that a GREAT alternative to seeing an ad? Nope. But in many peoples opions it sbetter than being force fed the same ads over and over when you paid for an ad free service.

And if you read the wiki in full you will see it also is talking about preroll content. I dont HATE the HBO pre roll ads for their own shows that play before I start an episode but it is still an ad. Its for content I might actually enjoy instead of for paper towels or insurance but it is still an ad. This is something that is entirely optional and that disney/hulu has decided doesnt count as an ad.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by ghusto on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:42AM (#49788739)
It's like HN has been taken over by Redditors. Nobody's interested in facts, just righteous indignation.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by bradly on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:45AM (#49788781)
When I watch motorcycle races live on Peacock with my no-ab subscription they just go quiet for the commercial breaks that other providers/plans run. No announcers or on screen displays, but it does keep a live feed or the race. So the whole "we don’t have an alternative" part I do take exception with.

fwiw... I believe Peacock is also allowed to run ads during live events, but at least during my motorcycle races they do not. a couple seasons ago they would go to a peacock banner and not show anything during the commercial breaks, but at some point they switched to just showing the raw video.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by spying_lg_tv on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:09PM (#49789125)
Corporate simp detected
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by wat10000 on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:23PM (#49789382)
All that matters is the actual agreement. The agreement says there's an exception where "streaming rights or other limitations require certain Content to play with ads," and that "no ads" and "ad-free" tiers can contain "limited promotional content," with some examples of what "limited promotional content" might include, but no actual restrictions on it.

That's extremely broad. They won't show you ads, unless "other limitations require" them to? Would "our internal agreement between our streaming division and our content division requires ads" qualify? What would qualify as "promotional content" and in what sense is it "limited"?

This reads to me as "we can show ads anywhere we feel like it even if you paid us not to have ads." The only actual limitation will be their desire not to piss off paying subscribers.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jester997 on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:24PM (#49789408)
Honestly Disney+ app is the gold standard. No auto play like Netflix. Classy and thoughtful design. Amazon is the worst. Those Buy Now buttons on commercials good God what a load of crap.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by tripzilch on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @04:26AM (#49798118)
> I’m begging everyone to stop freaking out

someone has to protect Disney from these unjust opinions!