News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:26AM (#49787023)
I'm sure content creators would hate it because they would make less money. Billions of YouTube users around the world would be very happy.

To be clear, I'm not opposed to the practise, as long as that's clear up front. YouTube advertises Premium as an ad free experience, and in reality it's full of ads.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by SoftTalker on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:59AM (#49788156)
Do you only watch videos from creators who are not trying to make money?

If they couldn't make money, 80% of the content worth watching would not be produced.

Premium works for me. Is it perfect, no. But there's that saying about perfect being the enemy of good.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jdb9001 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:36AM (#49787123)
Do they not have a little sponsor skip thing? Where like if many people skip a segment, itll pop up like hey, wanna skip? I mean, thats about all they can do besides forcing youtubers to disclose exact segment lengths which would concretely hurt them whereas this provides a little sort of breathing room, or just straight up ban them, both of which would dramatically hurt the platform.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:05AM (#49787454)
I understand they have an opt-out feature now. With positive interaction one can skip one sponsored segment (which works most of the time). The problem is that it's not automated. It required digging one's phone out of their pocket, or reaching for the remote. That's still really annoying. To point: it's still full of ads, even if they have the skip button now.

YouTube could tell content creators not to include sponsorships. The terms are long and onerous. Of course content creators would be upset and they would make less money. Ultimately my issue is that YouTube advertises an ad free experience with Premium and it still has a LOT of ads.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by LoganDark on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:42AM (#49788744)
YouTube Premium now has "skip ahead" which is basically this. Or you can install SponsorBlock and get a much better version for free.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:45AM (#49787220)
I'm in favour of people making money from their work. Maybe I'm old fashioned that way. IMDB, Duolingo and Wikipedia have encouraged the model of using unpaid labour.

YouTube isn't paying people properly, despite its vast revenues. At least with sponsorship the people themselves make some money.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by godshatter on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:06AM (#49788261)
I'm not saying this is the way to go, but damn do I miss the old internet where passionate people presented information for free, at worst showing an affiliate link for an information-related book.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:49PM (#49789768)
People need to be able to make a living and when this is taken away, the living expenses don't disappear. Most people can't pay for their electricity or food with voluntary work.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by godshatter on Monday September 21, 2026 @05:11PM (#49793500)
The people who were doing this on the early internet were not trying to make a living off of it, they were just doing it because they enjoyed it and wanted to share what they built with the world. If you could cover your server costs then that was considered a win.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @02:33AM (#49797447)
There are plenty of people giving away their labour for free, which makes it harder for people who need to be able to make some money in order to support themselves.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by godshatter on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @10:43AM (#49802162)
People making passion projects for free don't owe anyone a business model.
Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @06:48PM (#49809366)
They aren't always making passion projects. They're told unpaid labour is good for their CV/resumé, or that they're helping society (sometimes the case, but sometimes not).

Massive corporations such as Alphabet do have the resources to pay YouTubers, especially given how much tax they avoid in most countries.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by choo-t on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:00AM (#49787412)
Wikipedia predates Youtube by five years.

Unpaid cooperation of human to generate knowledge or entertainment predates YouTube by tens of thousands years.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:54PM (#49789874)
YouTube is part of Alphabet, one of the biggest corporations in the world. It can easily afford to pay people. It isn't co-operation, it's a corporation which takes the work of other people and makes lots of money off them, without paying them properly (or at all in many cases). Wikipedia's content is used by LLMs and other such outlets who also profit off unpaid labour.

It is a basic right of people to be able to afford to live. It's easy to work for free when you have family money but you cannot support yourself when you don't.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by Gareth321 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:08AM (#49787498)
> I'm in favour of people making money from their work.

That's completely fair. YouTube offers content creators many ways to do this. For example, they can put content behind a paywall. They can ask for donations. They can ask for memberships. Members get all kinds of fun perks. The part I have an issue with is YouTube advertising an ad free experience with Premium and then allowing content creators to fill their videos with ads.

> YouTube isn't paying people properly

I hope we can both agree that the solution to this is YouTube paying people properly, and not allowing content creators to shit all over viewers. That's pitting the little guys against each other while Google laughs all the way to the bank.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by johnnyanmac on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:30AM (#49787770)
>I hope we can both agree that the solution to this is YouTube paying people properly

The solution is proper competition to google. Because Youtube is pretty much the one true monopoly out there. But as we all know, video hosting alone is very,very, very expensive. It really is something you need to be a billion dollar company to do, and Youtube wasn't profitable until like... 2 years ago?

So I tolerate the user ad reads as the best compromise because nothing else would work. I don't think Youtube is a model where Google is being greedy so much as practical. At least not in how it monetizes creators (there's plenty of hostile means they do to creators as is, but the monetary structure seems fine).

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:23PM (#49791233)
There are alternative streaming platforms, but many of them have become associated with certain political viewpoints.

There is also a very limited range of content on Odyssee, Bitchute and all the rest. If you want to find music tutorials for example, you're unlikely to.

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by nephihaha on Monday September 21, 2026 @01:02PM (#49790016)
You have to put in a disproportionate amount of work to get anything back. Almost no one makes money off a single video, but instead you make a string of videos and get a following. (The cases of a single video making money are few and far between.)

You don't get hourly pay for it, it's vaguely commission based and you do all your own promotion. They can demonetise you at a whim and refuse to pay you (I've seen this happen to craft channels and other content that wasn't remotely controversial.)

Re:Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in a... by jasonlotito on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:09AM (#49788306)
> To be clear, I'm not opposed to the practise, as long as that's clear up front. YouTube advertises Premium as an ad free experience, and in reality it's full of ads.

I think it's clear. I don't want YouTube going in and editing movies and creator videos removing any form of advertising. Maybe you want them deleting that content. But the average person realizes what Premium means by no ads. Being obtuse or willfully ignorant isn't reasonable.