News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by post_break on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:26AM (#28403887)
Wow, we made Apple blink. I did not see that coming. People like me who sold their iPhone and cancelled all services probably are a drop in the bucket, but it looks like the general public and the news picked up on this enough to get the ball rolling to make them step back. So now the question is in what 15.X update do they just sneak it in.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by azalemeth on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:33AM (#28403981)
Part of me wonders if the calculus includes either (a) the open letter signed by (effectively) ~10k verified developers [1], (b) the complaint letters from groups like the EFF [2, 3], or (c) expert and qualified input from their (presumably huge) marketing department...

[1] https://appleprivacyletter.com/

[2] https://act.eff.org/action/tell-apple-don-t-scan-our-phones

[3] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/08/apples-plan-think-diff...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by judge2020 on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:45AM (#28404159)
Or D) employees who weren’t part of the discussions heard about it the day before the official announcement, and made a stink about it internally.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by haswell on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:53AM (#28404259)
E) All of the above
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by lumost on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:43PM (#28410678)
F) They received requests to scan for other forms of content from various governments.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by marcan_42 on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:45PM (#28411901)
G) Turns out they can't know if they're scanning for other forms of content, since they delegate computing the hash lists of banned content to government organizations like NCMEC anyway.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by darwingr on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:19PM (#28418183)
So a hash for a public key used to encrypt something could be in there? Banned books? A video of unsavoury evidence to an institution?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by dave7 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @04:10PM (#28418629)
Yes indeed.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by valkmit on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:53PM (#28410743)
Underrated comment right here
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by jtbayly on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:02AM (#28404363)
E) Their promise that they would only include scanning of images that appeared in multiple countries' databases.

As of right now, is there even a database other than the one NCMEC has? I suspect they are waiting for the NCMEC to spin up its European branch.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by josefx on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:32AM (#28404706)
They are probably just waiting for several countries to spin up their databases of gay porn and blasphemous / regime critical memes. Shouldn't be too hard to find two of those countries working on a shared "child abuse" database now that the feature has been widely publicized.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Animats on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:35PM (#28407065)
There's so much censorship now worldwide, and it's increasing. Russia doesn't allow promotion of the gay agenda. Parts of the Islamic world view criticism of Islam as a killing offense. China won't tolerate the flag of Taiwan, Falun Gong, or criticism of the Party. Afghanistan no longer allows music.

A decade ago, all those things were on the Internet worldwide.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by ilamont on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:40PM (#28407128)
China is also cracking down on LGBTQ groups:

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-57759480

Many of the closed WeChat accounts display messages saying that they had "violated" Internet regulations, without giving further details.

The account names have also been deleted and just read "unnamed".

"After receiving relevant complaints, all content has been blocked and the account has been suspended," the notice said.

The crackdown is the latest example of what some call growing intolerance toward the LGBT community. Last year, Shanghai Pride week, modelled on Pride events in the West, was cancelled without explanation after 11 years of it going ahead.

In 2019, the Oscar-winning Freddie Mercury biopic Bohemian Rhapsody was released in Chinese cinemas, but references to the Queen singer's sexuality and AIDS diagnosis were censored.

In 2018, Weibo said all posts related to homosexuality would be taken down, although it backtracked after massive outrage.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by noduerme on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:08PM (#28411762)
And most recently, China wants to censor less masculine men: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/china-bans-sissy-men-tv/

I have a theory about this that isn't politically correct, but here goes. This has nothing to "conservative values" or homophobia or whatever you call sexual repression in places like Arkansas and Afghanistan. It's not based on religion or culture. It's just the CCP running an actuarial table.

The CCP is a blunt force instrument. It realized some time ago that the one-child policy had left it holding the bag on taking care of a rapidly aging population without enough young people to power the economy in 10-20 years. Not only that, you couldn't easily just repeal the policy and expect a baby boom. They took a look at Japan and realized they were about to hit a demographically driven, deflationary wall. So the party planners moved from repealing the 1CPolicy to actually offering cash bonuses for second children. This volte-face happened within a few short years. But it didn't work as well as expected. Their sudden magnanimous gesture didn't bump their 5-year plan's crop of new Han for a few reasons: A shortage of women (unexpected consequence of the 1CP), more women in the workforce who don't want to have children, video game culture which makes young men stay home instead of going out and impregnating girls -- which is why they're now limiting screen time, gender fluidity / queerness which suppresses baby-generation, and of course western individualism, the great bugbear of "harmony," which encourages people to wait for love and financial stability before having children. At the end of 5 years of encouraging people to have babies, they don't have enough babies. So now they have to get harder on the edge cases.

It's probably safe to assume that gays and lesbians represent at least 10% of the Chinese population as they do in most countries. So that's what, 120 million people? Let's say half of whom are young enough to have at least one child? So we're talking about an extra 30-60 million children if you can somehow get a replacement rate.

That's what I believe all these recent moves by the CCP have been about. And banning test study programs? Same thing. No point having more babies if you're also getting overproduction of elites. They need construction workers and factory workers. And someone was told, we ain't gonna become Germany by bringing them in from Tajikistan, so take this data and figure out how to squeeze as much Han production as possible out of it in the next 5 years.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by himinlomax on Sunday September 05, 2021 @03:26AM (#28422243)
Where do you get that 10% figure? That may be true in, say, San Francisco but that's hardly the case in the population as a whole.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by soundnote on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:06PM (#28438119)
The CCP and other countries are cracking down on rainbow activism because rainbow activism is, in some sense, American imperialism and the enforcement and promotion of American interests and culture on their soil. And the difference between "off-target" boners and the political ideology is hard, so they rather overreach than underreach. History shows you can be really godawful to gay people and not have the society suffer much from it in terms of stability and the like. Those societies are unnecessarily nasty to people, but they did live.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by erosetthanatos on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:28AM (#28412318)
I 100% agree with your assessment. I've thought the same thing for a while. The downfall of the West is already a foregone conclusion purely from demographics. CCP's hardline on reversing the inverted pyramid trend will catapult it as indisputable leader within the next 20-30 years.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by noduerme on Saturday September 04, 2021 @06:46AM (#28413893)
I don't think their attempts at upping the birthrate are going to succeed. The CCP is fighting against the larger trend of decreasing fertility rates in all post-industrialized nations, while trying to promote stability... they started later and they got to the wrong side of the inverted pyramid faster than the west. Now, if they do have success with a baby boom it may come with unintended consequences. The party leadership is aging, worse, ossifying. It's going to get less and less easy to put down youth protests the more Xi starts to look like Fidel Castro. Maybe their technological cage can keep citizens too afraid to talk to each other, but they're too well connected to the rest of the world to not know what's going on. And you can't cut the cord. That's why the laws against video games, and the censorship of LGBTQ media, have to be pushed as a nationalistic marketing campaign rather than forced as Maoist dictats. (Although the idea of Mao banning video games is kinda funny). China will never be a superpower unless they have a liberal French-style democratic revolution. Then all bets are off. A democratic China might take over the world. Other than that, the worst the west has to fear from that quarter is losing our own souls in the process of doing business with a genocidal government. It hasn't stopped us from buying toasters on Amazon yet.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by tg180 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @02:46PM (#28417914)
Highly agree with you.

In the West we have already tried to force LGBTQ people to accept the behavior of their assigned sex. Result? Increased suicides, depression and drug use.

Obviously, after decades/centuries of failure we finally decided to recognize the reality of the facts: you cannot force people into a heteronormative life, nor to make children.

They are in for a hard failure.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by suifbwish on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:16PM (#28416921)
The French Revolution actually marked the end of France ever being considered a super power again. The entire western world mocks their pathetic legal system
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by totetsu on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:31PM (#28410151)
WeChat seems like a pretty big part of life in China and with the know your customer requirements I imagine those accounts are links to individuals. It must be a nightmare to have one canceled.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by ldargin on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:18PM (#28408198)
You can add U.S. states banning "Critical Race Theory" to that list.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by klipklop on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:28PM (#28409629)
You left out the "in public schools" part. You can still look at all the CRT stuff you want on the internet in the US. Stuff like White Fragility are top sellers in the US.

This is not even remotely the same as the Taliban banning music or China cracking down on LGBTQ stuff.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by jandrese on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:51PM (#28409821)
Which was extra silly because CRT wasn't being taught in public schools unless you are also including public universities.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by miles on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:21PM (#28410066)
Yes, critical race theory is being taught in public schools[1]

> Christopher Rufo reported[2] that 30 public school districts in 15 states are teaching a book, Not My Idea, that tells readers that “whiteness” leads white people to make deals with the devil for “stolen land, stolen riches, and special favors.” White people get to “mess endlessly with the lives of your friends, neighbors, loved ones, and all fellow humans of color for the purpose of profit,” the book adds.

> There are plenty of other examples that prove racial essentialism and collective guilt are being taught to young students. In Cupertino, California, an elementary school required[3] third graders to rank themselves according to the “power and privilege” associated with their ethnicities. Schools in Buffalo, New York, taught students[4] that “all white people” perpetuate “systemic racism” and had kindergarteners watch a video of dead black children, warning them about “racist police and state-sanctioned violence.” And in Arizona, the state’s education department sent out[5] an “equity toolkit” to schools that claimed infants as young as 3 months old can start to show signs of racism and “remain strongly biased in favor of whiteness” by age 5.

[1] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/yes-critical-race...

[2] https://twitter.com/realchrisrufo/status/1413292881264005126

[3] https://www.city-journal.org/identity-politics-in-cupertino-...

[4] https://www.city-journal.org/buffalo-public-schools-critical...

[5] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/arizona-education-ba...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by romwell on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:31PM (#28411288)
So what's the data?

30 school districts (out of how many?) use a book Rufo doesn't like.

Any reason why anyone, aside from Rufo, should care?

Half of the nation doesn't teach sex ed because skyperson doesn't like when people bang without signing an exclusive banging agreement in public first. Half the nation teaches kids that the Confederacy was formed to protect "states' rights", carefully omitting that the right in question was to own black people as livestock[1]. But hey, 30 districts use a white-people-bad, and that's the real problem.

And what does the last part of your comment (about AZ) have to do with anything? Telling educators that 5-year-olds can absorb shitty beliefs is now a cOnTrOvErSiAl tHeOrY?

I don't even know where to start here, let's set this one aside.

So, let's focus on this question first: assuming the book you mentioned is bad, which percentage of pubic schools use it, and in which way?

[1] TX is my go-to example. They were teaching that slavery was a "side issue" in the Civil War when I was living there in 2010-2017.

I'm not even going to bother dissecting the bullshit they peddle these days. Feel free to dig in.

Texas oversees 1,247 school districts. Tell me more about the problem of CRT in schools though.

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/texas-will-finally...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by nyolfen on Saturday September 04, 2021 @10:39AM (#28415533)
> this isn't happening

> this is happening and it's good

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by romwell on Sunday September 05, 2021 @06:50AM (#28423212)
> scale doesn't matter, right?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by kbelder on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @02:13AM (#28441491)
Not to rebut an absolute.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by heavyset_go on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:00PM (#28410389)
Christopher Rufo defines critical race theory as everything he doesn't like, so of course he'd see phantom CRTs lurking behind every shadow and around every corner.

From here[1]:

> Christopher Rufo, a prominent opponent of critical race theory, in March acknowledged intentionally using the term to describe a range of race-related topics and conjure a negative association.

> “We have successfully frozen their brand — ‘critical race theory’ — into the public conversation and are steadily driving up negative perceptions,” wrote Rufo, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a conservative think tank. “We will eventually turn it toxic, as we put all of the various cultural insanities under that brand category. The goal is to have the public read something crazy in the newspaper and immediately think ‘critical race theory.’”

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2021/05/29/critical...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by miles on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:24PM (#28410551)
> of course he'd see phantom CRTs lurking behind every shadow

When it comes to teaching children Not My Idea, definitely seems to be more to the concern than just shadows:

The fallacy of ‘whiteness’ https://www.bostonglobe.com/2021/08/08/opinion/fallacy-white...

> According to recent reports, public and private elementary schools across the United States have used, as part of racial equity education, an illustrated children’s book called “Not My Idea,” in which a devil with a pointy tail offers the young reader a “contract binding you to whiteness.” The contract promises “stolen land,” “stolen riches,” and “special favors”; in exchange, whiteness gets “your soul” and power over “the lives of your friends, neighbors, loved ones, and all fellow humans of COLOR.”

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by kgarten on Friday September 03, 2021 @08:57PM (#28411134)
CRT is something taught in law school, not in elementary schools. You have an indoctrination problem in the US but it definitely does not come from CRT.

I looked at some of the illustrations of "Not My Idea"... it's a bit wired and cringe worthy sometimes. Still compare that to the indoctrination that is in some of the schoolbooks:

Slavery was just "black immigration" https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/aug/12/right-wing...

The kkk was not morally wrong ... ?? https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/texas-senate-...

Banning of Black and Latino Authors https://www.mcall.com/news/pennsylvania/mc-nws-pa-banned-boo...

Teaching creationism: https://www.arkansasonline.com/news/2021/apr/08/house-advanc...

Are you as outraged about that as you are about a fringe law theory?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by kgarten on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:57AM (#28415138)
Downvotes, but no counter?

Can you name numbers comparing how many books with problematic woke content are used versus the books mentioned from the guardian?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by soundnote on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:01PM (#28438067)
> Christopher Rufo defines critical race theory as everything he doesn't like

Not quite. Rufo knows what CRT is, and importantly, what shares the same problems CRT does. That is to say, different branches of the same general ideology that operate on different topics. The CRT model is kinda like ideological lego, you can just plug in a topic). The demon is legion and has many names. Rufo's stuff is mostly about calling woke thought in general CRT, since the name stuck. I haven't yet seen Rufo label things that aren't wokeness or influenced by wokeness CRT.

It's the same kind of thing as when we call Catholicism, Eastern Orthodoxy and all the Protestant sects "Christianity" even though they are not the same, or how we still call Zen "Buddhism" even though it lacks the supernatural component of its older cousins. None of those things is the same, but they share a family resemblance, they have a character to them that makes them unique among the sea of ideologies, religions and philosophies. Rufo's nailing "CRT" to that family resemblance, because the family is there, the demon is real, and it needs a name to be talked about usefully, not a legion of them.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by CamperBob2 on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:30PM (#28410592)
Is he actually wrong? Seems like it should be possible to judge the citations he's posted independently of his own (admittedly obvious) biases.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by kgarten on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:06PM (#28411174)
It seems he is. I see a much bigger push to prevent any type of critical discussion about issues of slavery etc.

I'm also always surprised how little US citizens know about their own history. Ask somebody about "Birth of a Nation" and see what they can tell you about it.

Ask them if they know about the "Pro American Rally" in 1939 and see what they say.

These things are not taught in school and it's a shame. I know what I'm talking about I'm German and I hated our history education in school as we were discussing the 3rd Reich nearly every year. Yet, reflecting on it and seeing that the same stupid ideas get a hold today again, it was not nearly enough. We should have taught more. The same holds for the German colonial history (that was not covered and is changing slowly).

If you don't know your past, you are condemned to repeat it.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/150-years-lat...

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/aug/12/right-wing...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by josephg on Friday September 03, 2021 @08:57PM (#28411139)
Critical race theory is a mythic story - the sort Yural Harari describes as a religion. It sits alongside replacement theory, humanism, environmentalism, crypto anarchism, liberalism, rand’s objectivism, and so on.

These stories are lenses through which you can describe the world. They’re like software for the mind. And like software, they aren’t objectively right or objectively wrong. Each of these stories (dubiously) explain and obsesses over some aspects of the world, and ignores other aspects completely.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by dragonwriter on Saturday September 04, 2021 @04:16AM (#28413161)
> Critical race theory is a mythic story -

No, its not.

Though there is a mythic anti-”Critical Race Theory” story created by the American Right, and the thing within it called “Critical Race Theory” is a (particularly incoherent, because a number of unrelated and opposing things from the real world that share only that they concern race, and they are disliked by the American Right, and they are not actually Critical Race Theory, are jammed into it) mythic story.

> These stories are lenses through which you can describe the world. They’re like software for the mind. And like software, they aren’t objectively right or objectively wrong.

Actual critical race theory (like critical legal studies, from which it stems) holds the existence of objective features of social structures, with tangible, material, effects.

Like many hypothesized social phenomenon, the complexity of the systems involved may make falsification difficult on a practical level, but the claims it makes are fact claims which are objectively true or false.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by jandrese on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:28PM (#28411831)
30 public school districts out of 13,800[1]. About 0.2%.

Rufo is trying to create the world's biggest molehill.

[1] https://ballotpedia.org/Public_school_district_(United_State...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by kevin_thibedeau on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:47PM (#28407194)
The canary will be when the dissident Winnie the Pooh starts being disappeared.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by camgunz on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:30AM (#28405517)
Honestly, maybe that happened and they went "oh. shit." and now they're "delaying".
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by WaitWaitWha on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:54PM (#28406612)
There is International Centre for Missing and Exploited Children) (ICMEC), Child Exploitation and On-line Protection (CEOP), Parents and Abducted Children Together (PACT), Missing Children Europe (MCE), and more just in Europe.

ICMEC is a fork of NCMEC.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Mindwipe on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:32PM (#28406345)
Yes, the IWF database.

Indeed, the NCMEC database does not have an especially good reputation, much like MCMEC themselves.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by jug on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:45AM (#28405696)
The cite even researchers as leading to the decision. Maybe flaws with perceptual hashes? It took a mere day to discover a hash collision after reverse engineering the system. Granted, the colliding image looked like a grey mess, but I wonder how far a malicious party might get after a year.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mbesto on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:13PM (#28406828)
They also could have had a legitimate claim to non-technical people (at the FBI/NSA/blah) that "you sure you want this? this system will be abused...someone could write a hash collision". The Gov't agency scoffed because they didn't believe it.

So Apple called them out on it by letting the market decide. They now have that evidence.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by notriddle on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:49PM (#28407209)
Never attribute to 4D chess what can be adequately explained by knee-jerk reaction.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mortenjorck on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:09PM (#28407410)
This is an excellent and perceptive Hanlon corollary.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by ksm1717 on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:59PM (#28409893)
Never attribute credence to an argument because it has a name
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by gfodor on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:02PM (#28410404)
Razors are inherently self-identifying as heuristics - not rules. So no need to add more disclaimers.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by ZainRiz on Friday September 03, 2021 @08:33PM (#28411018)
Never attribute credence to an argument because it was stated confidently
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mlac on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:02PM (#28405945)
I don't really understand the argument that was thrown out by many people: "Attackers will frame people by planting hash collisions on their phones!"

So...

a) a bad actor is going to target someone, and have the resources to generate enough collisions that(b) look like CP, but aren't CP? but are close enough (c) to pass human review and cause an investigation so (d) they need the hash collisions to look like CP, but not be real CP? or ????

If a bad actor wants to frame someone, it's easy to do this today - hack their system or home network, open it to the internet, place the photos, call the FBI and report an anonymous tip, with the URL where it is hosted and open to the internet. Don't need hash collisions.

Hacking someone's iPhone (How do you get the photos on there without forensic logs that they were added?) or iCloud so that you can place hash collisions that look like crap and fail to pass the review doesn't make sense and leaves too much of a trail. Oh? And someone won't notice thousands of photos just added to their phone?

A bigger threat would be deepfake CP. When that becomes a reality, it will be a mess, because an attacker could theoretically generate an unlimited amount of it, and it will be extremely difficult to tell if it is authentic. Those hashes wouldn't be in the CSAM database, but if the attacker put them out on a server to be taken down, they would get added eventually and then show up in a scan elsewhere.

But I'd be pretty horrified (and definitely call my attorney, Apple, and local FBI field office) if thousands of CSAM images just showed up in my iPhone photo stream.

Edit: Downvotes are fine, and I completely understand other arguments against this, but this one has just not made sense to me...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by gunapologist99 on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:11PM (#28406082)
This is a very simple attack to pull off; email someone with the colliding image embedded in the MIME document. Set height and width equal to zero or one pixel. Even if the user never actually sees it or marks it as spam, it's still on their device and in their email. For bonus points, spoof the "From" as from Apple. At the very least, they're getting SWATted.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sweetheart on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:18PM (#28406176)
If this were a reasonable vector, it'd already be an issue, at least if you use large email clients like Gmail, which already scan for CSAM.

Edit: Downvotes because?...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by cmsj on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:21PM (#28406897)
Downvotes because nerds love to construct a super super unlikely corner case to argue against something ;)
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sweetheart on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:11PM (#28408109)
I'd call that out as totally unfair... if I haven't found myself doing that many times before hahaha.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by CamperBob2 on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:25PM (#28408958)
We, the nerds, only have to be wrong once in order to allow immense harm to occur. Apple voluntarily put itself in that position.

Conversely, the governments of the world get to keep trying, over and over.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by speeder on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:09PM (#28406784)
Because it IS already an issue.

For example when CIA/NSA tools leaked, one of them had precisely this purpose.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by brigade on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:24PM (#28406926)
Those use a different perceptual hash that's intended to be kept secret.

It's significantly harder to develop collisions for an algorithm you cannot inspect or obtain the output of.

(well also, emailing actual CSAM is way easier and mostly just gets the sender reported)

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by cherioo on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:50PM (#28407890)
Apple also uses a second, different perceptual hash that's intended to be kept secret, on server side.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by therealjumbo on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:33PM (#28408393)
Then why have a client side scanner in the first place?

You're exposing the hashes to the world, you're not able to E2E encrypt anything if you need to server side scan, which you probably do since trusting the client no matter what is generally bad in potentially adverserial situations, and you get all this negative press and loss of reputation and potentially pressure from governments around the world to use this for other ends. Cui Bono?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by nicce on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:13PM (#28409481)
I think you have misunderstood the system.

The second scan applies only for those images which are flagged as positive, which are then accessible by Apple. This is applied to detect adversarial hashes. The rest of the images stays encrypted. So, indeed on-device scanning is the only way to enable at least partial E2EE with CSAM detection.

Yes, this was PR failure Apple. They rushed the announcement because of the leaks, and secondly they thought that people will understant the system when they did not. There is too much misundersting. That scanning for example is built-in so deep into the iCloud pipeline, that one does not simply change the policy for scanning the whole phone.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by therealjumbo on Saturday September 04, 2021 @12:13AM (#28412014)
>I think you have misunderstood the system.

On a technical level I think you're correct. As a holistic approach to the problem, I still disagree. This is too cute for its own good. The PR misunderstanding is a symptom of that.

>The second scan applies only for those images which are flagged as positive, which are then accessible by Apple.

In the end, Apples software is scanning all of the images, why is it any more privacy respecting to do it this way? I guess reasonable people can disagree on that, personally I wasn't fully aware of the cloud side scanning either, and I don't think the public was either. This is similar to Snowden's revelations, if you were paying attention you probably already knew a lot of that, but the incident made everyone aware of it in a very blunt way.

>The rest of the images stays encrypted

I think this is unclear, Apple can still decrypt those other images, how else could you view them in a browser?

This goes back to what Stratechery said about capability vs policy.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by nicce on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:41AM (#28412968)
> I think this is unclear, Apple can still decrypt those other images, how else could you view them in a browser?

Obviously there is change coming to iCloud. Otherwise whole PSI protocol is pointless.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by therealjumbo on Monday September 06, 2021 @09:58PM (#28440027)
You might want to reconsider holding your breath for that. No they aren't doing E2E encryption, if/when they will, they will announce it. Until they announce something everything else is pure speculation.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by gunapologist99 on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:23PM (#28408265)
At least we know that secrets never leak out.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by foldr on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:04PM (#28407349)
Surely the sender is also likely to get reported if they email the image with the perceptual hash collision. Lots of companies run these scans. E.g. if you send the image via gmail it will most likely be scanned by Google.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by chipotle_coyote on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:51PM (#28410327)
Assuming the system works as Apple's described it, then this attack doesn't work. The image needs to be added to the Photos library and the Photos library needs to be syncing with iCloud. Images in email aren't scanned, and an image that's zero or one pixel can't even be clicked on to be added to the library.

And, to at least respond to two obvious counter-arguments I've looked into:

"But it's just one line of code to change it to scan images (that aren't uploaded to iCloud) (that are anywhere on the device)!" No, it isn't; if you read the technical documentation and the more technically-oriented interviews Apple's given on this, there isn't just one hash that needs to be matches, there are two hashes, one on the device and one on the server. (I think Apple did a very poor job of communicating this to a general audience; it certainly wouldn't have alleviated all the concerns, but if it was understand as "client-server scanning" rather than "client-only scanning" it might have at least changed the tenor of the conversation.) That doesn't mean they can't do a combination client-server scan on every single image or even file on the device, but it makes it both more difficult to do and more difficult to hide.

"But what if the system doesn't work as Apple's described it?" Well, if you don't trust Apple to some degree, all bets are off. They already do ML-based image analysis of all photos in your photo library regardless of iCloud status and they've literally demoed this on stage during iPhone keynotes, so if Apple was going to secretly give government access to on-device scanning, a different technology -- one that works (questionably well) on all images, not just already-learned ones -- is literally already there. The only way you "know" what Apple is doing with your data on or off device comes from a combination of what they tell you and what third-party security researchers discover.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by jackTheMan on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:27PM (#28411826)
That is a huge-huge difference if they do it secretly, or if they do it announced.

If they get caught doing secretly this in China that would be a big blow. But if they are doing openly and it is known that the government provides the hash, they can wash their hands.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by misnome on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:30PM (#28406316)
How does this theoretical attack get them to save the attached image to iCloud?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by skoskie on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:56PM (#28407273)
I think there's an unspoken assumption that photos are only the first part of this scanning exercise. IMO, Apple will likely end up scanning all content you choose to put on their servers.

Tangentially, I think keeping their servers clear of illegal material is actually Apple's main motivation. This, in turn, supports claims made by nay-sayers that Apple could scan for other types of images/content in more repressive countries (but not necessarily report the people who did it). However, this assumption also contradicts arguments that Apple will start scanning for pictures of (e.g.) drugs, or weapons. Such images are not inherently illegal and therefore of no interest to Apple.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by misnome on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:21PM (#28407548)
> Tangentially, I think keeping their servers clear of illegal material is actually Apple's main motivation

My guess about this whole debacle is that - with pressure from the government to scan their cloud storage - that this is the alternate scenario to avoid giving up (or being forced to) the "encryption" guarantees of their cloud. I'm not sure what technical process they have in place to "only decrypt with valid law enforcement requests" or allow account rescue, but it seems likely that not just any employee can view whatever they want, before or after this system.

Saying that I can maybe see a way the pressures are on this doesn't mean that I'm saying this is a good solution though. Clearly technically implementing this is opening a can of worms that can't really be closed again and makes a lot of other scenarios "closer".

Also, evidently, people are a lot more comfortable with the idea of them actively scanning stuff people store in the cloud than transmitting the information in a side channel so they don't even need to handle decrypted data without a hit.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by skoskie on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:19PM (#28408903)
> My guess about this whole debacle is that - with pressure from the government to scan their cloud storage - that this is the alternate scenario to avoid giving up (or being forced to) the "encryption" guarantees of their cloud.

This is exactly the case. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/12/senate-judiciary-commi...

> I'm not sure what technical process they have in place to "only decrypt with valid law enforcement requests" or allow account rescue, but it seems likely that not just any employee can view whatever they want, before or after this system.

They have master keys that can be used to decrypt almost everything you upload. They can be compelled to decrypt and turn over information on anyone. Another (unsourced) comment in this thread indicated they do so 30,000 times per year. The new encryption scheme will effectively stop this for photos, and no doubt other files in the future.

Apple's side will begin using shared key encryption, which will require ALL ~31 keys to decrypt the offending images.

The decryption keys are only generated on-device, and only from a hash that results from a CSAM match. The other photos, simply won't have the decryption keys generated, so they don't even exist.

As an interesting side note, this means that a person who surpasses the CSAM threshold will still only reveal the images that actually match the CSAM database. Every other image, including those that have CSAM unknown to authorities remain encrypted. This is hardly a big win for the big scary government. They now have far less ability to search for evidence of any other crimes. You could upload video of your bank robbery to iCloud, and as long as your personal device remains secure, nobody will know.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by dwaite on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:14PM (#28408152)
> IMO, Apple will likely end up scanning all content you choose to put on their servers.

Even if that was a goal (and I would argue they have a hard stance against it), this system as built is not usable for that.

While they can scan locally, every step of recording, thresholds, and subsequent automated/manual auditing is built to require content to be uploaded to iCloud Photos.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by skoskie on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:28PM (#28408993)
I agree that the current photo scanning system won't work for other types of files. Further, I don't think they really even need to scan text files except to see if it's actually a filetype that should be scanned. And they can already easily scan music and such, but have shown no interest in it from a legal standpoint. Video seems like a prime candidate for the next generation of this tech. And I very much think they will be able to do that before the decade is over.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by newbamboo on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:00PM (#28409897)
iCloud is trivial to hack. Recall the massive leak of celebrity nudes a few years back. As long as iCloud is forced on users (you cannot apply security updates to an apple device without an Apple ID and an attached iCloud account) these attacks will be simple to do in mass, with very little risk to the perpetrators. Terrible security model, with a long history of spectacular and avoidable breaches which go totally unsolved.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by misnome on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:33PM (#28410168)
Let’s ignore the fact that you just shifted the goalposts from “emailing a 1 pixel image SWATs them” to an extremely wide scope for a minute -

Even assuming that is true that iCloud is trivially “hackable” - and as I understand it, that was never clear how those leaks happened - how does uploading to iCloud help when it specifically needs to be uploaded from the users phone along with the scanning metadata.

In fact, isn’t apples proposed implementation here the _only_ cloud service that protects against your proposed attack - while other clouds scan stored data and can be triggered by your attack, Apple’s requires you to upload specifically from a registered phone on their account; data stored on-cloud is never scanned.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by newbamboo on Saturday September 04, 2021 @12:30PM (#28416464)
You can choose to use an iPhone. Most people will never be targeted. Hell you could use a phone with no security at all and odds are you’ll be safe. But if you have enemies or are a high profile target, apple has made you easy to destroy. iPhones themselves can be hacked with no click attacks and we know this because macron’s phone was one of many that was listed in the recent fiasco. Icloud can be hacked because legions of celebrities had their nudes published. If the device is not secure, even for the president of France, and iCloud is not secure for legions if celebrities, then people can and will be hit with this attack and have their lives permanently destroyed. Worse than having you sex photos leaked, worse than having all you calls and communications intercepted, you’ll become known as a pedo. You can’t undo that. To be sure, that probably won’t happen to most people, but political figures, those with enemies working in infosec, etc…. I want a secure phone, and iPhone no longer meets that need for me and many others. You can do you.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by AmericanChopper on Friday September 03, 2021 @08:29PM (#28410997)
The described attack is completely unnecessary. Just send colliding images to people on WhatsApp. They go right into Photos, and then to iCloud if that’s enabled. There’s no reason most people would assume that this is what was happening if somebody sent them some slightly weird looking images.

The response to this is “yeah but then a human will review it and nothing will happen to the victim of the attack, because it’s just some slightly blurry ordinary images”. But it ignores to entirely likely harms that could result from that.

1) Law enforcement use it as the basis of getting a search warrant, but conveniently leave the bit about the alerts being false alarms off the warrant application.

2) The list of people who have had CSAM alerts is inevitably leaked to the public, and the victim has to spend the rest of their lives explaining to people like employers why Apple flagged them as possessing child sexual abuse material.

At the end of the day, all the gaslighting about “no potential for inadvertent harm” is bs, because it’s my device, so get lost. Go run your anti-privacy software somewhere else, imo.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by misnome on Saturday September 04, 2021 @07:07AM (#28413999)
As I understand it;

- Law enforcement doesn't get _anything_ unless it triggers a large number of images that match the perceptual hash

- It also needs to match a -private- perceptual hash, that isn't distributed to devices, and so we don't have a reliable way of generating collisions for or even knowing that collisions are generated

I mean this whole thing is bad enough on its own without having to artificially manufacture extremely specific scenarios and extrapolating from there to invent hysteric conclusions.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by AmericanChopper on Saturday September 04, 2021 @07:37AM (#28414182)
Well if you think a tech giant that’s partnered in a surveillance program with the NSA isn’t going to share anything they feel like with the government, then go ahead as use that as the basis of coming up with your own opinions.

But you’re right though, the possibility of the list being leaked and ruining countless innocent lives is the much more likely of the two scenarios I described.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by misnome on Saturday September 04, 2021 @07:42AM (#28414202)
> if you think a tech giant that’s partnered in a surveillance program with the NSA isn’t going to share anything they feel like with the government

In that case, nothing is stopping them from scanning everything already uploaded anyway, and nothing is stopping them pushing code to your device to scan it without telling you about it. Nothing is stopping them or the government from making these "lists" anyway.

I'm not saying you (or anyone) should trust Apple, but if you already don't - then this changes literally nothing.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by AmericanChopper on Saturday September 04, 2021 @07:58AM (#28414288)
By my own personal assessment it changes the way I view them, because this is the most overtly anti-user, anti-privacy thing they’ve ever done. Perhaps I should have never had any level of trust for them, but you live and learn I guess.

Feel free to respond to my point about the alert catalog inevitably being leaked and ruining lives. Or you could just have a go at gaslighting me a little more if you prefer.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by misnome on Saturday September 04, 2021 @08:56AM (#28414660)
Gaslighting? Your proposed scenario is:

- Send colliding images

- image gets uploaded to icloud automatically

- image _also_ collides with private hash <- completely unclear how this happens

- Only the colliding images are looked at by apple and are determined to be innocent

- user goes on a list (This is an imagined scenario)

- User is reported to law enforcement even though the images are innocent (This is an imagined scenario)

- Law enforcement uses this hypothetical report to file a warrant (This is an imagined scenario)

- Law enforcement uses the hypothetical warrant to extract images that are completely innocent, and somehow build a case around this

- The "List", which is entirely a hypothetical of yours, "leaks" (This is an imagined scenario)

Which also requires:

- Apple does not counter the meaning of "the list"

- Apple is not sued for vast quantities of money

I expect the first argument is that none of this matters as long as "the idea" is out there, the reputational damage is already done. Except if that's true, then none of this is necessary at all, just make the accusation.

So, sure, continue to thread the needle between "They are automatically sending all information to the government, so promises are meaningless" and "This new process, on top of them potentially sending all information to the government, somehow makes it worse".

I mean, this is all a million times more difficult and less likely than just, like, sending them CP in the first place. Or uploading it to their Gmail or any other cloud they use. Or just send a report that they have it to the police without actually doing anything.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by AmericanChopper on Saturday September 04, 2021 @09:52AM (#28415098)
That’s absolutely not an accurate representation of what I’ve said, or how this system works.

All it requires is somebody to send somebody else a colliding image.

This will send an event to Apple. There is nothing imaginary about that, it is exactly how the system works.

Now that Apple has this information, the only thing left is for it to be leaked or compromised in some way.

This is much simpler than the scenario you’ve described, because they require the attacker to first commit the crime of possessing CP. Its also possible to do without tipping off the victim in any way.

Apple, in case you didn’t know, is a company that had already been the source of a couple of the most notorious data breaches ever (and has somehow managed to so far avoid getting “sued for vast quantities of money” for them).

What you’re trying to do here is quintessential gaslighting.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by FabHK on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:11PM (#28407435)
Apple's proposed system does not scan all the pictures on the device, only images about to be uploaded to iCloud. A picture in an email would not be uploaded (whether visible or not).

Even if uploaded to iCloud (such as pictures sent via WhatsApp by default), and above the threshold, they would still be scanned by a second algorithm and subject to human review. So, your "very simple" attack fails on at least three counts.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mlac on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:33PM (#28407040)
I would expect the human review ("Swatting") to be transparent, unless it was actually CP or looked like CP, at which point the person would be taken for a ride... But this is a real threat with actual CP now.

And again, there is the whole fact that you received the email and there is a log that you received it.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by vlovich123 on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:32PM (#28407684)
"Human review" here means basically minimum wage person who's looking through a lot of abuse images on a daily basis & has significant fatigue. I view it more as a CYA thing than any meaningful protection mechanism.

Additionally, the images sent to review are significantly downscaled versions of the original & could easily be made to be ambiguous.

The most difficult challenge in this SWAT story is that Apple has a secret secondary hash that's checked on a collision. That's the part of the SWATting story that feels difficult on a technical level. However, there are also really smart people out there so it wouldn't surprise me if a successful attack strategy is developed at some point given time.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mlac on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:57PM (#28408669)
Sure. I mean, my main concern would be people planting actual illegal images. Not just colliding hashes. If anything, a handful of images that have hash collisions, once they made it to the authorities, would then be reviewed in detail and shown as a false positive, and then ignored in the future / whitelisted. Or investigated because someone is generating images to directly tamper with the program / frame people.

No one is going to be prosecuted on "significantly downscaled ... ambiguous" versions of original fake images with a hash collision that flagged a review and was handed to the FBI accidentally because a "minimum wage" fatigued person passed it on.

I get the counter-arguments, but the hash collision thing is just, sort of... weird? I even get the argument that an innocent hash collision may have your personal and private images reviewed by some other human - and that's weird. But I can't really see it going further (you'll be arrested and sentenced to life in prison from the HASH COLLISIONS!).

It's just using technical terms to scare people who don't understand hashes and collisions and probability, and not really founded on reason.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by vlovich123 on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:45PM (#28410278)
> once they made it to the authorities, would then be reviewed in detail and shown as a false positive, and then ignored in the future / whitelisted

Which typically will be a court case, or at least questioning by police. This can be quite a destructive event on someone's life. Also, there's no mechanism for whitelisting outlined in the paper, nor can I imagine a mechanism that would work (i.e. now you've got a way to distribute CP by abusing the whitelisting fingerprint mechanism or you only match exact cryptographic hashes which is an expensive CPU operation & doesn't scale as every whitelisted image would have to be in there).

Also, your entire premise is predicated on careful and fair review by authorities. At scale, I've not seen this actually play out. Instead either the police will be underworked & not investigate legitimate cases (too many false positives) or they'll aggressively police all cases to avoid missing any.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by tyingq on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:23PM (#28409574)
Going down a rabbit hole, but a colliding image could be an adult that doesn't look like an adult.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by a1369209993 on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:35PM (#28410190)
> email someone with the colliding image embedded in the MIME document. Set height and width equal to zero or one pixel.

(I think) the complaint is: how is that different from just using CSAM images, no collision required?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sweetheart on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:15PM (#28406139)
I also don't understand the vector everyone seems worried about. Also considering that perceptual hashing isn't new, as far as I'm aware, and it hasn't seemingly yet led to any sort of wave of innocent folks being screwed over sham illicit images.

I think there _is_ an argument to be made about a system like this being used to track the spread of political material, and it's easy to see how such a system would be terrible for anyone trying to hide from an authoritarian power of some type, but that'd already require Apple is absolutely and completely compromised by an authoritarian regime, which isn't high on my list of concerns.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by azalemeth on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:48PM (#28406546)
The main issue is that the system is basically a bit of snitching spyware dolled up with cryptographic magic to make it only work with really bad stuff, honest.

As recently posted on HN [1] one should be very wary of backdoors, no matter how much one believes only the right guys could ever use them. Once they're there, they're there: it's arrogant beyond believe to think that opponents of yours won't exploit them.

I won't use an apple product with this feature. I've been using apple's ecosystem since about 1994.

[1] https://twitter.com/matthew_d_green/status/14334701097425182... and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28404219

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mlac on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:10PM (#28408799)
I understand your points on backdoors, but I don't understand people trying to argue that the "Cryptographic Magic" is the bad part that will send people to prison due immediately upon "HASH COLLISIONS", in my view, takes away from the actual concerning points.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Zak on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:44PM (#28409770)
What most people are focused on is that this is spyware built in to the operating system. The fact that perceptual hashes have some weak points could also lead to problems, but that's not the main focus of most opposition to this system.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Griffinsauce on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:07PM (#28406763)
> Apple is absolutely and completely compromised by an authoritarian regime

I don't understand this, they can just be legally compelled.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by cmsj on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:22PM (#28406912)
And they already are, Apple (and indeed all companies) have to follow all sorts of rules in all sorts of countries. Some of those rules are fairly harmless, some of them are about radio power levels, some of them are "don't show the Taiwanese flag in China".
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mlac on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:37PM (#28407088)
And I also understand the concerns with this (and the potential downsides of the technology).

But a motivated bad actor has a lot easier time just putting an image of the Taiwanese flag or propaganda on someone's phone than trying to make it a hash collision that triggers... If an attacker is really after someone, I would expect them to put the actual material on that person's phone...

... It's like trying to frame someone for drugs in their car and going through the hassle of synthesizing a chemical that triggers drug dogs to react, but it isn't actually the drug. Wouldn't they just... buy drugs and stick them in the car?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by zzo38computer on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:24PM (#28407599)
> Wouldn't they just... buy drugs and stick them in the car?

Maybe they want to create too many false positives deliberately, or maybe they do it just because they want to see if and how synthesizing such a chemical can be done.

When putting pictures on someone's phone or computer, there are ways to add false positives as well as maybe doing false negatives sometimes (e.g. by encrypting the picture or using an uncommon file format so that it must be converted, or using complicated HTML/JS/CSS to render it instead of just a picture file).

Also, if someone has the picture or drug or whatever to find if it is what they are, can you accuse them (maybe they are the police) of liking pictures and drugs, too?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sweetheart on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:08PM (#28408072)
Yeah sorry, I was a little vague. I consider that willingness to comply as already having been compromised. And I think, to be fair, if companies like Apple are ever in the position of using technologies like this to track individual dissidents of an authoritarian regime, we are already royally screwed.

But, to be clear, you make a legitimate point.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by FabHK on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:13PM (#28407450)
> there _is_ an argument to be made about a system like this being used to track the spread of political material

How so? Unlike other cloud providers, which do scan all uploaded images server side, this system is specifically designed to prevent this.

(As you say, if Apple is entirely compromised, then all bets are off anyway.)

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by chillfox on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:01PM (#28411435)
The colliding images stopped looking like a grey mess within the week and just looked like a normal low quality image.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by koheripbal on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:39AM (#28405619)
More likely D) The regulatory threats from the EU.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by gambiting on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:40AM (#28405627)
Wasn't the feature meant to be US only - at least for now anyway?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Mindwipe on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:33PM (#28406364)
Apple said themselves, there's only one iOS ROM, so it was there on everyone else's devices regardless.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by FabHK on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:15PM (#28407484)
But enabled only for the US region initially. That is bad in itself, though, I think, insofar as it signals that the system can be switched on and off, and thus maybe configured, on a per-region basis, which does seem to open the door for government pressure and abuse.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by threatofrain on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:02PM (#28406708)
The EU's mood is cloudy here, as there's also legislative pressure against child porn coming up this year.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by newbamboo on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:54PM (#28409848)
They ruined their reputation for being relatively secure devices. I’m done with them, for good. Anybody who cares about security has likely jumped ship now too. Normies will eventually ditch them when they realize most tech people have bailed. Unfortunately the best alternative, google, is even worse. Hopefully the loss of demand causes a decrease in device sales across the board. Landlines still work. Smartphones and their consequences have been a disaster for the human race.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by headmelted on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:36AM (#28404756)
Apple didn't blink. They just don't want the bad press hurting iPhone 13 sales.

It'll go live around December when the Christmas sales push for iPhones is winding down and people are distracted with everything else going on.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by haswell on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:53AM (#28405009)
A more charitable take is that both are true. Apple blinked, and one of several large contributing factors (probably a very big one) is the upcoming iPhone launch.

When the tech news cycle is dominated by bad press about a move like this, and every tech nerd community is discussing this topic almost daily, it would be insane for Apple not to take some notice.

I know many are pessimistic about this, but Apple has learned from bad mistakes before. They rarely directly admit they're wrong, but conceding to pressure from the community is not unprecedented: see the return to the "Magic Keyboard" in their laptops.

Edit: removed the word “never” and replaced it with “rarely directly”.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Bud on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:20PM (#28406192)
Could we please not say silly, easily-disproven things like Apple "never admit[s] they're wrong", when 10 seconds of Googling instantly gives the lie to that assertion?

It might not happen every day, but it happens frequently enough that it's easy to find a lot of examples.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Bud on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:32PM (#28406342)
I expected the knee-jerk lazy downvotes from the usual suspects, so:

Apple admits mistake, says it’s back in EPEAT https://channeldailynews.com/news/apple-admits-mistake-says-...

Apple Admits the Mac Pro was a mess https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/4/15175994/apple-mac-pro-fai...

Apple Admits iPhone 7 Manufacturing Fault https://www.theguardian.com/money/2019/feb/11/apple-iphone7-...

I could go on for pages, but I trust the point is made.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by haswell on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:38PM (#28406421)
Ok, Apple rarely admit they are wrong, and when they do, they tend to spin it heavily. I don’t think this meaningfully changes the primary message of my comment though.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by dhosek on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:48PM (#28406539)
Or the changes to the new version of Safari in response to user feedback.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by FabHK on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:18PM (#28407519)
But that was GP's point: They listen to feedback and improve things, but typically quietly, rather than admitting a mistake. Exceptions do prove the rule.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by dwaite on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:17PM (#28408191)
What was the mistake for this example though that they would admit to? Iterating aggressive UX changes in a beta?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by ksec on Saturday September 04, 2021 @06:03PM (#28419741)
Every single one of them was to the point Apple could no longer hold the bad press or damaging to sales figure they admit they were wrong. Or more like they didn't, they just accept defeat.

Mac Pro was a mess when one of their largest customer told them they will switch their whole studio away from Apple right in front of Eddy's Cue face before some thing was being done.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by karmakaze on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:26PM (#28408973)
I wondered if Apple would ever say that you want more than one mouse button. They started having an option to use each side of the mouse as a separate button (even if it looked like a single one and defaulted that way), but I've never heard that two buttons are better than one from Apple. With Steve gone, who even cares now?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by ksec on Saturday September 04, 2021 @06:15PM (#28419852)
When Apple was designing Mac as personal computer for everyone, a single button mouse is truly godzillion times better than two button. There used to be an Apple guideline on how to move a mouse and not to lift the mouse up into the air, but mapping the horizontal plane of the mouse to the vertical plane on the screen. Even that was difficult for some people.

People just dont realise how normal people have problem with mouse. Of course as we progress I think Two Button mouse could make sense as default. The role of PC also changed. The PC for everyone is now an Smartphone.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by the_other on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:09PM (#28409971)
One button is better than two, for people who don’t know how to use two. I imagine the number of such users is higher than most of us here assume.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by unityByFreedom on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:24PM (#28410549)
> One button is better than two, for people who don’t know how to use two.

It's like the three seashells. They don't know how to use them.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by karmakaze on Saturday September 04, 2021 @11:09AM (#28415775)
In the early days of Macintosh they tried hard to make this true. The excessive and inconsistent use of click vs double-click in apps even then was confusing.

These days it's hard to find an app that can get by without Cmd+click which is harder than click on the right button, which would be even easier if the right button was physically distinguishable. Long-press is super annoying as well as force click--I never want the action that comes up when I accidentally force-click. With the prevalence of touch phones, the two-finger-tap might be the easiest of them to remember (if not as precise).

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by setpatchaddress on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:52PM (#28409270)
The primary input device to Apple hardware is the trackpad, so it’s kind of irrelevant. But two button mice have been well-supported since classic Mac OS circa 1997-1998.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by FabHK on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:16PM (#28407499)
> A more charitable take

No, no, GP clearly has direct insight into the values, ulterior motives, and decision process of Tim Cook and other top brass at Apple.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by caeril on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:25PM (#28406941)
This is the most likely outcome. Moreover, they won't even announce it.

Apple learned a valuable lesson here. Roll the panopticon out in secret, and don't announce it. They've done a very good job locking down their modern devices, enough that security researchers would have an exceptionally difficult time proving that they're doing it anyway.

GrapheneOS is still a viable option until Google ends upstream security updates in 2023. That's a solid two years for Purism, PinePhone, and anyone else working on linux phones to bring their performance and feature set up to modern standards.

The correct course of action is to buy a Pixel 5, run GrapheneOS for the next couple years, while donating to the main privacy-focused linux phone projects, and make the switch again in 2023.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by farmerstan on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:35PM (#28407067)
> Moreover, they won't even announce it.

That's a terrible idea. Apple knows that researchers are going through every bit of assembly code on the phone.

If all of a sudden they say "Hey we found some code that scans all your photos and sends information up to the cloud" how bad would that look? It's better to explain upfront rather than get found, because they will get found.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by caeril on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:45PM (#28407168)
Is this still possible? My lay understanding is that the SEP decrypts kernelspace on-demand, loads the opcodes on a very temporary (and randomly allocated) basis, and makes dumping any meaningful amount of the contents out of RAM very difficult.

Not a jailbreaker at all, so happy to be completely wrong on this.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by dwaite on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:20PM (#28408235)
The default for images is signed, not encrypted. A new section of self-modifying or encrypted kernel code would probably trigger some red flags.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Hackbraten on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:35PM (#28408413)
> The correct course of action is to buy a Pixel 5, run GrapheneOS for the next couple years, while donating to the main privacy-focused linux phone projects, and make the switch again in 2023.

Alternatively, get a Linux phone right now and donate time by contributing bugfixes.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by noptd on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:57PM (#28406632)
Exactly, it's (sadly) a temporary victory at best.

Ten bucks says they take a page out of our politicians' handbooks and sneak it in as a small, vague footnote in a much larger, unrelated announcement once the initial bad press blows over.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by darwingr on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:25PM (#28418238)
Honestly, that's what I assumed they did in MacOS 11.5.2 where they refused to give details of the change. It's likely the last update for many intel devices.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by godelski on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:09PM (#28407412)
Your description sounds like a blink to me.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by thehappypm on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:45AM (#28405699)
The bad press led to them blinking.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by brundolf on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:06AM (#28405180)
It was a torpedo to the heart of the privacy marketing campaign they've spent who-knows-how-much-money building up over the past several years. That translates directly to wasted dollars, which they do care about.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by echelon on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:27PM (#28406281)
Well done, screeching voices!
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by wintermutestwin on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:46PM (#28408547)
But isn't their privacy marketing: we will protect you from abusive surveillance capitalists, not we will protect you from state level actors?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by lrem on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:13PM (#28409491)
Wasn't there a very public "no, FBI, you cannot get the shooter's phone contents"?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by xvector on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:40PM (#28409143)
privacy is privacy, you can't pretend to care about it while at the same time pushing something like this through
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by wintermutestwin on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:16PM (#28409509)
>privacy is privacy

Are you asking Apple to come out and say that they are supporting privacy against state-level actors? After snowyD, why would anyone believe that anyway?

I'm not advocating against or for - I'm only wanting to add more clarity to the discussion because I think it is an important distinction that is often left out.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:46AM (#28405707)
Congrats on selling your iPhone so fast. I managed to purchase a System76 laptop in the meantime, typing from it now.

The cat is out of the bag. You and I have realized Apple can make these type of changes whenever they want.

I'm disappointed to report that Linux needs a lot of improvement to be viable for most people. I'm forging ahead, donating to open source software and hardware projects, filing bug reports, and generally bringing the Mac spirit to Linux. "It just works."

What phone did you switch to?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by rconti on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:21PM (#28406903)
> I'm disappointed to report that Linux needs a lot of improvement to be viable for most people.

I'm continually surprised that people are continually surprised by this. I'm sure this post will get a lot of anecdotal replies; of course it can work fine for many people, but that's not the point. I used it exclusively on the desktop from 1995 to 2002. I could make it work for me, today, if I wanted to.

> You and I have realized Apple can make these type of changes whenever they want.

Was this not obvious? I'm pretty shocked that, for example, Docker can decide to change their license, and now in a few months a bunch of companies owe them money for every single user they have, even if the users don't do anything different. If they opened the license agreement and chose NOT to upgrade. If they never use the software again. But bam, terms changed, now you owe us money.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mrtranscendence on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:04PM (#28408034)
> I'm sure this post will get a lot of anecdotal replies

I tried Ubuntu last year, briefly. Almost everything worked fine, except ... OK, I'm a trackpad user. I have a couple Apple Magic Trackpads and I prefer to use those over a traditional mouse.

It worked fine for, like, a day? And then out of nowhere it just stopped responding. Reset or reinstalled everything I could think of and it still failed to work. OK, whatever, I bought a traditional bluetooth mouse. Which went to sleep every time it remained still for more than a split second, rendering it basically unusable (not a problem on Windows on the same machine).

Maybe a whiz could have fixed one or both issues, but googling completely failed me. This was pretty basic stuff, surely? And yet I couldn't even get bluetooth mice to work on the most mainstream distro.

(Now, admittedly, the trackpad doesn't work properly out of the box in Windows either, since Apple doesn't provide drivers that work outside of Boot Camp. But at least there are paid drivers that work really well.)

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by kaladin-jasnah on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:26PM (#28418250)
Anecdotally, I have installed Linux on older MacBooks and have had the Magic Mice working fine without any issues.

Anyway, I don't know. People have all sorts of annoying issues with Linux that end up being things that I have never encountered before. I usually use wireless mice with USB transceivers, which have never had problems and I feel like not everyone has such a bad experience (although I know many people who do). Perhaps it's because it's Apple hardware or something, but, admittedly, I have had MacBooks work perfectly on Linux before.

I think that, however, you use Linux on a desktop rather than a laptop, you will find that the hardware experience is quite pleasurable and does not have nearly the same number of issues. Between the two, Linux does manage to shine decently on desktops.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Saturday September 04, 2021 @08:06PM (#28420584)
Interesting, did anything lead you to use non-bluetooth wireless devices? I'm wondering if the future of Linux might be abandoning bluetooth entirely.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by kaladin-jasnah on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:07AM (#28424439)
> did anything lead you to use non-bluetooth wireless devices

Not really. I just had them ["non-bluetooth wireless devices"] laying around and I think the non-Bluetooth ones are cheaper.

> I'm wondering if the future of Linux might be abandoning bluetooth entirely.

Abandoning Bluetooth just because your experience was unsatisfactory is not something I agree with at all, sorry. IME, Bluetooth support is completely fine for all the Bluetooth devices I have (like speakers or my cell phone)—and I know others who haven't had any issues either.

Besides, Android uses the Linux kernel. While I don't know if Android uses Bluetooth drivers from the mainline kernel, if it does, that would just make Android's life harder while pointless removing something that usually works fine.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:19PM (#28408896)
Yeah what a bad deal. What can we so about this?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by TaylorAlexander on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:58PM (#28409875)
> I'm disappointed to report that Linux needs a lot of improvement to be viable for most people. I'm forging ahead, donating to open source software and hardware projects, filing bug reports, and generally bringing the Mac spirit to Linux. "It just works."

IMO it would go a long way if we taught computer literacy and specifically Linux literacy to everyone in school. Microsoft and Google have all the school contracts and they bring people up on systems that "just work" (actually they have paid system administrators). If we taught people from a young age to use Linux and handle problems, then the small problems that often come up with open source need not be barriers to adoption. Even if every regular person can't always solve every linux problem, if they were familiar enough to use it and had at least one expert friend, they'd be fine.

That's not to say we shouldn't strive to make Linux "just work" for most people, but we can attack the problem from other angles as well.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:07PM (#28409949)
I agree more tech literacy is needed. The learning curve for Linux seems so steep. For what it's worth, I took UNIX classes in high school, and know how to get around.

But Linux is just far more than I can handle, even just to install apps and configure settings. For example just trying to get my mouse not to stutter, I dig and find a solution. I copy and paste it into the terminal. It doesn't work and I try 3 different solutions. I'm curious about solutions but it wears my curiosity out pretty fast. I need to get work done.

In the sense that computers are like cars, I'm okay not knowing how exactly it works under the hood.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by TaylorAlexander on Saturday September 04, 2021 @06:41PM (#28420043)
Yes this kind of thing is frustrating. And I may be very wrong, but I have been wondering, what if this is what open source is always going to be like. I am 100% pro open source and I think everything (cars, trucks, washing machines, factory machines) should be open source. But I guess if we got to that point, where the people producing the computers and the people writing the code were all on the same side, maybe things wouldn't break so often.

Also FWIW I have learned, even though I run debian, to check the Arch Wiki for tips on problems like that. One more place to check in addition to stack overflow.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Saturday September 04, 2021 @07:08PM (#28420206)
Ya I wonder as well. To me it seems like Linux will always need a gooey center of tinkerers and builders. But it needs to establish mutual respect with people who can't use the CLI but need to get work done. Open source is important to the success of Earth.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by TaylorAlexander on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:01AM (#28421530)
Agree. And the grumpy user-hostile developer archetype is a real problem. I’ve been very pleased with the diversity movements inside of for example Debian. My end notion is a world where no one strictly must work for survival, and in such a case there would be lots of volunteers to keep the systems running. But for now it’a tricky to attract devs to non paid work.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by luxuryballs on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:33PM (#28410611)
I mean I already have accepted the fact that they allow Signal type apps because if the FBI or whoever requests it they can just access your display driver layer and see what you’re typing locally, no need to ban encrypted messaging. I just keep remembering how Lavabit shut down because he refused to comply and otherwise had no choice in the matter. Computers and software should not be easily trusted.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by post_break on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:08PM (#28408774)
S21 ultra. Out of one place into another I know. But it's also the principle of the thing. I don't share my location data with the bare minimum, and sideload stuff. I don't see hardware good enough to go completely off-grid from Google yet so this was my compromise.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:17PM (#28408867)
Understandable. I suggest donating to open source options as part of your compromise. Purism, PinePhone, Ubuntu Touch....or buying something from them if it's not an option.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by post_break on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:41PM (#28409739)
Unpopular opinion but I mostly donate to charities that are confirmed to spend the money on more than administrative people. Open source donations I make for software I use. If an open source thing comes around that can replace my Samsung phone I'd buy in a heartbeat.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:31PM (#28411290)
Yes! And because of this, this means you need to donate ahead of time so things can be built to replace your Samsung phone. After it's built well...what would they spend your money on? Donate early, donate often.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mrtranscendence on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:07PM (#28408067)
> I managed to purchase a System76 laptop in the meantime, typing from it now.

If I could just get a decent higher-than-1080 panel from System76, I might consider it for my next laptop. I've been spoiled by Macs. As it is I might go with a Framework laptop instead.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:17PM (#28408877)
Email them and say that! We need to be more vocal as customers so vendors don't waste time.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by abnercoimbre on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:22PM (#28406907)
Is the System76 experience worthwhile so far? I'm about to invest in a Pangolin [0] this Labor Day weekend and could use an honest review from a fellow HN ex-Mac user.

[0] https://system76.com/laptops/pangolin

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Raineer on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:58PM (#28409880)
I ordered a Pangolin yesterday as I've been waiting for an AMD laptop forever. This is my third System76 laptop, and the first two are still great.

My first was a Galago Pro, and my only complaint was that I went HiDPI. That was just a bad choice on my part. The software supports it fine, I just don't prefer it in a laptop unless it's literally a Mac-level Retina-quality panel. It wasn't, but it's half the price point.

My other is a Gazelle 15", which dual-boots Arch and Windows. I use it primarily as a gaming box when I travel (remember those days?). I spent a lot of raid nights on various MMOs from hotel rooms. It works great.

Really looking forward to the Pangolin. Mine is still in "building" status.

I see a lot of sh*t written about System76 because they are just rebranded Clevos. Well...yeah? They are, and they are fine. I would rather give money to a company like System76 a thousand times over than someone dripping with anti-consumer behavior like Dell.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:33PM (#28411301)
System76 is incredible. I have nothing but good things to say. They are the future of Linux.

Re: Clevo - obligatory copy pasta from System76 Chief Engineer right here on HN [1]

"System76 UX architect here! This vastly trivializes the work System76 does for months and sometimes years leading up to a product release. We don't simply take an off-the-shelf product that already exists, throw an OS on it, and sell it.

System76 works with upstream manufacturers (like, yes, Clevo for laptops) to determine what types of products to develop, including their specifications, design, etc. for months up to a release. These products do not exist before we enter into these conversations.

Once that has been determined, designed, and goes into production, we start on firmware. We ensure all components are working together and with the Linux kernel (often requiring changes to the components' low level interactions with the OS, since the upstream components themselves are often manufactured with the assumption they will be used by Windows).

Once that is complete, we test with Ubuntu and Pop!_OS specifically, ensuring the OS is working perfectly with the hardware. If there are any OS-specific changes to be done, we write that behavior into Pop!_OS and/or our "driver" which is preloaded on all machines (and available in any Ubuntu-based distro, Arch, Fedora, etc.), with the intent to upstream that into Ubuntu, GNOME, and/or Linux itself as quickly as possible. When this is more generic like ensuring HiDPI works great out of the box, this actually ends up benefiting competitors like Dell's XPS 13 probably as much as it benefits us, but we put in the effort to file the bugs, track them, write the code, and get it upstreamed.

Once all of that is complete, we finally offer it for purchase and market it with all of our pretty photographs, sales pages, etc.

What ends up happening, then, is Clevo offers a machine with a similar-looking chassis for sale as a barebones laptop. This is the result partially of the decision making System76 has made for what to produce in the first place. These products, however, do not contain any of the firmware or driver work that System76 has invested in. They do benefit from the nice photography and advertising System76 has done, and since they look similar, people assume they're going to get the same machine for cheaper "directly from the manufacturer."

Edit: regardless, this is a bit beside the point of the linked blog post, and is also becoming less and less true as we work on designing and manufacturing our products completely in-house."

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17040293

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Raineer on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:22AM (#28412874)
Thank you for the quote, I hadn't seen that. I certainly didn't mean to trivialize their work (obviously? since I've voted with my wallet 3 times)

Their work on both the firmware front and with Pop!_OS should not be overlooked. And, it should be mentioned, if one is familiar with their whole product line - they now go far beyond just laptops for the open source community. And their powerhouses are absolutely not from some other OEM.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Saturday September 04, 2021 @08:07PM (#28420596)
Yes excited for custom System76 laptops someday. When they're ready of course, slow and steady is the way to go.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Jayschwa on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:33PM (#28409058)
I've been using an Oryx Pro (v5) for a few years. It's mostly fine.

My main disappointment is that it doesn't "just work" with the kernels shipped by Ubuntu. System76 provides their own kernel packages, but they sometimes cause weird conflicts with other low level packages, and it can't hold its charge when suspended. I haven't attempted to debug the issue because I usually stay plugged in when I'm working, but I suppose I ought to engage tech support. They have been helpful in the past.

At the end of the day, I'll probably still give them my first look if I'm shopping for another laptop.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mark_l_watson on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:58PM (#28409878)
I also have had an Oryx Pro for several years. I stuck with System76's branded Linux, just do updates as they are available, and so far all has been well. I like that they keep CUDA working with very few hassles.

Compare this to my migration to a M1 MacBook Pro: I love it, but it is rough doing deep learning on it.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:28PM (#28408325)
see my comments above in this thread. specific comments are welcome. i love talking about this thing :) As a Mac user, the build is about what you would expect from a PC. It's not one of those nightmare shit PCs. It does its job.

Get that Pangolin before they sell out! Is there a Labor Day sale or something?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by abnercoimbre on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:09AM (#28412234)
I'm hoping there's a Labor Day sale :) Thanks for the comments, I'm motivated to take the plunge now!
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:38PM (#28411330)
Also, what pushes you to get a Pangolin (AMD) instead of Lemur (Intel)? I'm curious because I don't really understand the meaningful difference and bought the Lemur when it was in stock.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by abnercoimbre on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:07AM (#28412230)
For APUs there's no beating AMD Ryzen, especially if you're into gaming. Also my Windows laptop has a Ryzen and I'm just used to it now.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by inpdx on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:40PM (#28410237)
"I'm disappointed to report that Linux needs a lot of improvement to be viable for most people."

Evergreen.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by nbzso on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:00PM (#28411719)
As a designer, the only thing that I miss on Linux is graphical software at least on a level of Affinity Designer. Everything else is more than viable. Blender. Resolve. BitWig Studio. RawTherapee, Krita. For web development is perfect, my engineers run ARCH/Manjaro over soon to be abandoned Apple hardware. Even my old MacBook Air is supported, Pop!_OS is working perfectly with properly mapped keyboard keys (keyboard backlit controls, audio, playback, etc). The only thing that I have done is to plug thunderbolt/ethernet adapter, clicked on popshop update, restarted and wifi started working flawlessly.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Saturday September 04, 2021 @08:08PM (#28420601)
Just a gut check -- what about wake from sleep using an external keyboard? That required me to do github work, install a system service. It's these touches I miss from MacOS.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by nbzso on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:40AM (#28424662)
https://bit.ly/2Yj9n5F or for time based cycle RTCWake https://bit.ly/38KqdfI.

With broad addaption use cases like this will be solved.

You can install and configure Linux Desktop nowadays without touching the terminal.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by pshirshov on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:37PM (#28406405)
Buy a Pixel and install Calyx or Graphene with sandboxed Play Services.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by RussianCow on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:43PM (#28407148)
How does sandboxing Play Services compare with using microG?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by pshirshov on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:38PM (#28411332)
Well, push notifications are lot more reliable, safetynet passes basic check and app do not complain about play services issues.

But network location provider doesn't work, that's an issue.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by istingray on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:39PM (#28411336)
Is Pixel open hardware? I'm assuming not but props to them if so.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by pshirshov on Saturday September 04, 2021 @04:55AM (#28413340)
It's not. Unfortunately there is little open hardware around.

Though proprietary hardware plus mostly open OS is better than proprietary everything.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by digisign on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:23PM (#28406915)
I ordered the pine64 but it still has not arrived.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Hackbraten on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:42PM (#28408503)
Not GP but I took a leap of faith and ordered a Librem 5. It’s supposed to ship early 2022 but I’m not holding my breath.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:41PM (#28406453)
Just before everyone starts high-fiving each other, even the release itself brands it as a delay. I accept that it is a positive development, but do not read as anything but that: a temporary delay to let the furor die.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by hutzlibu on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:03PM (#28409389)
"So now the question is in what 15.X update do they just sneak it in."

I think they cannot really sneak it in. Some people do read updated TOS. And I think a "featurechange" like this, requires one.

And yes, the question will be, if the broad attention to the topic can be brought back on to it, if that happens. And they clearly say it will come, only with some "improvements" (but I cannot think of any improvements, that can be made, without abondoning the basic concept):

"we have decided to take additional time over the coming months to collect input and make improvements before releasing these critically important child safety features"

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Zak on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:41PM (#28410244)
> I cannot think of any improvements, that can be made, without abondoning the basic concept

The concept of scanning for CSAM during the upload process, or the concept of making the user's device do it? Apple could do the former on their own servers and essentially nobody would be upset.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by hutzlibu on Friday September 03, 2021 @07:01PM (#28410398)
The basic concept of Apple running private pictures through an KI algorithm to detect something worthy of investigation.

The algorithms never work 100% right. That means there will be always humans in the loop, sorting through false positives etc. which means probably very private pictures here in this context.

And to the end user it does not matter, whether this happens on the server or on their device. The message is: your pictures are not private with apple.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Zak on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:44PM (#28411360)
It matters very much with regard to the distinction between yours and theirs. I strongly believe the operating system of your device should never actively work against your interests, and checking whether you're using the device to commit a crime, then reporting it to the device manufacturer who will tell the government is potentially strongly against your interests.

If that's too abstract, it matters in that it's a foothold for further scanning of data on your device. Without this system, if a state wanted to pressure Apple to create spyware and add it to their operating system to look for something else, that would have been easy to refuse. With this system, the spyware is already there, and despite Apple's protests to the contrary, it's just a matter of a few tweaks to repurpose it.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by teitoklien on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:42AM (#28404115)
> People like me who sold their IPhone are a drop in the bucket

I doubt it , they will bring this up again very soon , if they cancel it, they’ll get very bad press too.

And second, a company that once shows its intention to breach your personal privacy while disregarding its user’s best interests altogether. Wont hesitate to do it again.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by judge2020 on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:48AM (#28404196)
Apple could lose a million customers over this, but they still sold >200m a year in 2018 and beyond.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/276306/global-apple-ipho...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by spacebear on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:54PM (#28407252)
If the million customers they lose also happen to be people who build apps and influence the tech buying decisions of everyone they know, that could be a very big problem over time.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by darksaints on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:06AM (#28404398)
The developer mindshare really matters to apple. As long as they are on apple devices, some significant fraction of them will be creating software for apple devices. Without 3rd party software, apple is toast.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by defaultname on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:12AM (#28404474)
Do you believe that most developers are up in arms about this, ready to abandon the platform? I doubt more than a tiny fraction really care about this at all, and the hysterics on HN (threads brigaded by a small percentage of HN users) are not representative. Predictions of some massive sales drop -- or even a sales drop at all -- are deluded nonsense.

Apple is delaying this, I suspect, because it confuses the privacy message: If every time they talk about privacy someone can make them look like hypocrites by pointing out the on-device scanning, well that's just ugly for Apple. I suspect the on-device scanning element is going to be removed and it'll be on ingress to iCloud, which is what I said on my very first post to this. It was ill-considered to do it on device given Apple's privacy push.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by darksaints on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:47AM (#28404917)
Most? Probably not. But developers are more sensitive to privacy issues in general, because they work in the most privacy invasive industry that ever existed. They know how much corporations dig into your stuff, and they might have even implemented some of it. At least speaking personally, I know my purchasing behavior changed on Amazon when I worked for them and realized how much they tracked me.

More importantly, there is an oligopoly in tech and up until now, only one of the manufacturers of tech devices cared about privacy. And to that extent, I wouldn't be surprised if vast majority of developers who care about privacy have biased themselves towards apple. And now they have a reason to treat apple like every other privacy invading company.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by wallacoloo on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:13PM (#28406105)
> And now they have a reason to treat apple like every other privacy invading company.

That’s right. I like the idea that on android, I can use stock tools like rsync to manage the photos/music on my phone. With Apple it’s been a constant battle against iTunes to do those basic things. The only reason I chose Apple last time I bought a phone is because I’m willing to sacrifice a bit of convenience for the perception of better security/privacy. If they lose on that front, then I’ll hop to whichever phone is easiest for me to use the way I want to.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by digisign on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:44PM (#28407159)
What does Amzn do besides tracking your purchases?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by FabHK on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:34PM (#28407710)
> Predictions of some massive sales drop -- or even a sales drop at all -- are deluded nonsense.

I remember, when that recalcitrant dentist was dragged of a United plane, endless predictions of United's imminent demise, people would never fly United again, yada yada yada. Needless to say, nothing much happened.

> I suspect the on-device scanning element is going to be removed and it'll be on ingress to iCloud, which is what I said on my very first post to this. It was ill-considered to do it on device given Apple's privacy push.

Not sure about that. Apple's approach (private set intersection run on half client, half server) preserves more privacy than scanning it in the cloud, and leaves the door open for E2EE.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by adventured on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:28AM (#28404658)
> The developer mindshare really matters to apple.

The developers are going nowhere so long as the money is there to be made from iOS.

Did they all quit when it was revealed that Apple was part of PRISM? Of course not. They barely blinked.

It doesn't matter if a billion developers sign a petition. It's empty. The vast majority of them will promptly capitulate if Apple goes forward. By vast majority I mean 99%.

Did you see all the people desperately fleeing from Australia due to the rise of the extremist police state there? Nope. Did you see the tens of millions of people flee from the US when the Patriot Act was passed or PRISM was revealed? Nope. Did you see everyone rapidly flood over to mainland Europe as Britain became a police state? Nope. How about the hundreds of millions of people fleeing out of China over the past decade with the rise of Xi and the entire demolition of all human rights in China? Nope. Perhaps you're spotting a predictable human nature trend in all of this.

All the tech employees of Google, Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft, Apple, etc. They've all quit in droves over the past decade over human rights abuses - including vast privacy abuses - and concerns for what these companies are doing? Whoops, no, the exact opposite. There was a price for their integrity as it turns out, and they grabbed the money, which is what most people do.

The iOS developers are going nowhere, either. Besides the fact that their livelihoods depend on it, there's no vast green field to run to from what's happening. Sure, some might change jobs, or switch industry segments, it will be a small group though. It's going on in just about every liberal democracy simultaneously. What huge platform are developers going to flee to that's better and is never going to feature forced on-device scanning spyware? It's coming for Android too, bet on it.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by cmsj on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:29PM (#28406993)
Not sure why you're getting downvotes.

iOS is where all the profitable users are. While that holds true, developers will be there to sell things to the profitable users.

The principled indie developers might leave in protest, and that would be a terrible loss for the platform's soul, but realistically the vast bulk of money flowing through the App Store is not going to the indie developers.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by poetaster on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:22AM (#28405425)
Hmm, having experienced the influx of 1.5 million people into an area smaller than Alberta, and the social consequeces in the last 5 years, i'd say you are being very glib. Thr shit show is just starting.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Lamad123 on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:49AM (#28404215)
They've already lost my trust!!
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sneak on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:09PM (#28406048)
The fact that they are going to sneak this backdoor in the back door later against the wishes of their customers is sufficient for me to decide that Apple has abandoned any values they may have once had.

I won't be purchasing any more iPhones, and I've had every one.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by babypuncher on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:49PM (#28409804)
I think the internal backlash helped a lot. The initial move was very contrary to the culture Apple has cultivated over the years and it did not go over well with them.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by bobbytit on Saturday September 04, 2021 @02:39PM (#28417838)
Yeah their orig mac ad was 1984 will not be like 1984.

They were just out by 37 years.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sharken on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:16PM (#28409513)
Generate enough bad press for long enough works wonders for creating change.

The battle is not over though, as you say Apple might include the feature unchanged in a later release.

If they do, should come as no surprise that they will lose a lot of business.

The correct business decision will be to cancel the feature and double down on the privacy angle.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by jimbob45 on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:42AM (#28405654)
>People like me who sold their iPhone and cancelled all services probably are a drop in the bucket

Yeah, very few have the financial independence to be able to do something like that. However, over the next few years when everyone gets their free upgrades, I imagine we'll see some slower, yet more robust, switching.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by rconti on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:23PM (#28406924)
Financial independence to... spend less money?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by post_break on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:11PM (#28408815)
Most people finance their phones. To sell them means to pay them off which is extremely hard for most people. I had the luxury of paying off my phone, and buying another while waiting to sell my current phone. In that timeline it was about $2,000 in cashflow. So yeah, I'm blessed to be able to do so at the drop of a hat.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by rconti on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:49PM (#28418441)
Gotcha, yeah, I was focusing on the "sell phone / cancel services" side and didn't even think of the prerequisite to be able to sell the phone. (and, i guess, buy a new one before you ship your old one off!)
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Grustaf on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:33PM (#28407700)
Just like people stopped using google and facebook because they also scan for CSAM?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by ksec on Saturday September 04, 2021 @05:57PM (#28419689)
I posted on HN [1] that I really wish they stand ground, it makes decision on Apple a lot easier. Now they wont. Half of the people will forgive them, the rest will most likely forget about it in a few years time.

But to me, it did at least look like this scared the shit out of Apple PR.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28221869

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:36PM (#28410200)
"So now the question is in what 15.x update do they just sneak it in."

It would be nice if the general public and the news therefore now picked up on the issue of opaque "automatic updates". To date, they have been trained to always every update without question.

Conventional wisdom: Never, ever question any particular automatic update. Don't think, just enable. All updates are created equal.

Assumptions: Every update is for users benefit. Software companies never operate out of self-interest. There are no trade-offs. Whats good for them is good for users and vice versa. Theres no reason for end users to trial updated versions of software ("A/B test") before deciding to use them "in production".

Thought experiment: User installs Software from Company to perform "Function #1". Company makes changes to Software, described as "Fixes and other changes." Software now performs Function #1 plus Function #2. User allows new software to be installed automatically. (Automatic updates enabled per "expert" advice.") When user downloaded and installed Software she based her desicion to use Software on its ability to perform Function #1; however, did she have any interest in Function #2. Did she agree to Function #2. Company says yes. Developers say yes. What does User say. The license agreeement places no limits on what might comprise Function #2. It could be anything. It could have no benefit whatsoever for User. Moreover, Company is under no oblgation to disclose Function #2 to User. With automatic updates, Company is free to keep changing Software. User originally chose Software for Function #1 but Software may look very different after many "automatic updates". Would she choose it again in its current state. Segue to discussion of "lock-in".

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:52AM (#28413036)
s/always/& accept/
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by spacebear on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:23PM (#28409583)
My bet is they wait a few months and quietly announce that they’ll do the scanning on the iCloud servers instead. That would be relatively uncontroversial in the tech press and probably never make it to the mainstream press.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by rajacombinator on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:56PM (#28407276)
Yep they’ll just quietly backdoor it in next time.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by albertop on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:17PM (#28406864)
Are you sure they did? Or it’s just a doge to avoiding bad press at the time they getting ready to introduce new devices.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by 5faulker on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:03PM (#28407334)
Hmm... this is getting more serious with potential ramifications many years down the line.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by gojomo on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:02PM (#28407327)
A "blink", or the iterative strategy of a skilled manipulator/abuser/groomer?

Push to the level of their target's discomfort, then back off – without respecting the "no!", pretending to hear only "not now".

Come back later from a superficially-different angle, when the victim's defenses are down.

Couch the next attempt, or the next, or the next, in some combination of feigned sweetness ("but I waited & changed things for you"), or esteem-attacks ("you're so nasty you deserve this"), or inevitability ("this is going to happen whether you like it or not, so stop fighting").

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by beckman466 on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:57PM (#28409337)
> A "blink", or the iterative strategy of a skilled manipulator/abuser/groomer?

Exactly. Note this description of the cycle of abuse:

"[The abuse] cycle involves four stages:

1) building tension

2) an incident of abuse

3) reconciliation

4) calm

Rinse and repeat."

Source: https://www.healthline.com/health/relationships/cycle-of-abu...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by float4 on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:23PM (#28407566)
Yeah, this has been done many times before by other tech companies. Facebook being the prime example.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by delaaxe on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:41PM (#28407788)
Don't forget public safety matters ("but COVID!")
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by gojomo on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:24PM (#28409599)
"We're sorry to inform you that Apple iCompliance AI Eyes, as of last night's updated version 16.4.2, has identified the following violations of laws & emergency edicts in your recent local photo roll:

• Unmasked proximity with non-household member

• Unlicensed gathering of more than 6 people

• Association with unidentifiable individuals (no faceprints on record)

These are your 2nd, 3rd, and 4th strikes so your phone has been disabled and you are now under arrest. Do not leave your immediate vicinity. As always, keep your phone on, charged, and in your personal possession at all times.

Due to large violation volumes, we are currently experiencing long physical arrest team hold times. Your arresting agents should arrive at your location in approximately... 5... hours.

Thank you for using Apple products, the leaders in Social Safety. 'Better Safe – Or You'll Be Sorry!'™"

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by new_realist on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:15PM (#28408160)
Wow, this is unhinged.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by scubbo on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:18PM (#28408205)
Yes, it is terrifying that companies behave this way.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by orangepurple on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:51PM (#28408597)
It's also known as shifting the Overton window.

It's a way to inch toward the unthinkable by obtaining concessions. You propose the unthinkable and after extreme push-back, the concession seems completely reasonable. However, if the concession would have been proposed alone instead of the unthinkable, it would have been rejected. It's an absolute deceptive manipulation technique.

Another example of manipulative Overton window shift at play: You may also recall deep state puppet Kathy Griffin showing Trump's severed head as the deep state testing the waters of a possible coup or assassination. The more you expose the public to the unthinkable, the more it becomes acceptable.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window

See also the Door-in-the-face technique and Foot-in-the-door technique

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foot-in-the-door_technique

The door-in-the-face (DITF) technique is a compliance method commonly studied in social psychology.[1][2] The persuader attempts to convince the respondent to comply by making a large request that the respondent will most likely turn down, much like a metaphorical slamming of a door in the persuader's face. The respondent is then more likely to agree to a second, more reasonable request, than if that same request is made in isolation.[1][2] The DITF technique can be contrasted with the foot-in-the-door (FITD) technique, in which a persuader begins with a small request and gradually increases the demands of each request.[2][3] Both the FITD and DITF techniques increase the likelihood a respondent will agree to the second request.[2][3]

Foot-in-the-door (FITD) technique is a compliance tactic that aims at getting a person to agree to a large request by having them agree to a modest request first.[1][2][3]

This technique works by creating a connection between the person asking for a request and the person that is being asked. If a smaller request is granted, then the person who is agreeing feels like they are obligated to keep agreeing to larger requests to stay consistent with the original decision of agreeing. This technique is used in many ways and is a well-researched tactic for getting people to comply with requests. The saying is a reference to a door to door salesman who keeps the door from shutting with his foot, giving the customer no choice but to listen to the sales pitch.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by ak391 on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:18PM (#28407518)
also check out the neural hash demo here to test it out on your own images https://huggingface.co/spaces/aliabd/generate-neural-hash-co...
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Bud on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:35AM (#28404009)
Apple doesn't "sneak in" stuff like this. That's complete bullshit. Could we at least discuss in good faith?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by npteljes on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:55AM (#28404281)
I think OP referred to the finding that Apple already rolled out parts of the detection thing

https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/p6hsoh/p_a...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by spywaregorilla on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:08AM (#28404432)
Isn't this the bad part? Like... it being there is the problem, not apple specifically using it for child porn detection. Right?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by macksd on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:22AM (#28404590)
Correct. If we could magically end the rape of children and stop the propagation of images of such, I think we'd all be on board. But when a system would realistically just push most of it elsewhere and violate a bunch of innocent people's privacy, people get nervous.

It's like being asked to have an invasive, detailed scan of your body shown to TSA personnel (and recorded) when you fly. The motive is apparently to prevent violence. But there were still incidents on flights when that was being done. It wouldn't have caught the box cutters on 9/11. The stated motive ceases to be part of the equation for me.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by azinman2 on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:14AM (#28405302)
Pushing it elsewhere is still a win. You don’t want this to have easy cover. Keep in mind FB reported close to 17M pieces of CSAM last year. So if having the ability to detect it was such a deterrent, why are their numbers so high?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sbuk on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:24AM (#28405450)
Because the don't tell anyone what they are scanning?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by azinman2 on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:49AM (#28405750)
They literally publicize these numbers. It’s not like I somehow know this FB secret. Every cloud provider scans, except Apple.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sbuk on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:02PM (#28408015)
Apple currently do scan for CSAM in their cloud.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by azinman2 on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:30PM (#28410138)
Their reported numbers were like 350 last year, compared to almost 17M for Facebook. You could theorize Apple has little CP, except in the Epic lawsuit we saw exec emails released that said the exact opposite. So clearly not much scanning has been going on.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by dwaite on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:34PM (#28408410)
For email only
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mlindner on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:15AM (#28405304)
I think it's actually impossible to use an AI to determine this type of thing. Even courts of humans sometimes rarely get it wrong sometimes with images that are open for debate (for example missing context) on whether it was abusive or not (parents bathing their kids, as one example). Then you have the whole can of worms that pedophiles will find sexual interest in images taken in non-abusive contexts but will use them none the less. How is an AI supposed to determine that. Even our laws can't handle that.

There's also images that can be abusive if made public but non-abusive if kept private. For example what about a kid taking pictures of themselves nude (many kids don't have parental moderated accounts) and putting them on icloud (iphone does this automatically with default settings).

It's a complete nuthouse and there's no way to do it.

(Also don't get me started on drawn artwork (or 3D CG) that people can create that can show all sorts of things and is fully or partially legal in many countries.)

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by scoopertrooper on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:04PM (#28405974)
They're not using an AI for that purpose. They're just sending a hash of the image and sending it along with iCloud uploads. The hashes are of images that have been identified by humans as containing child pornography.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by eurasiantiger on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:57PM (#28407280)
No, the hashes are visual hashes. It is completely possible that a clean shaven adult taking pictures of themselves could get flagged.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mrtranscendence on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:18PM (#28408204)
It's also possible that a picture of an avocado will get flagged. A nude photo of someone who's shaved themselves is unlikely to look so much like an actual CSAM photo that it'll get flagged. It's certainly possible, but again, so's the avocado.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by godelski on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:17PM (#28407502)
They're not hashes in the way md5sum or sha256 is a hash. They are _neural_ hashes. Which is not trying to fingerprint a specific image, but tag any image that is deemed sufficiently similar to the reference image. Hashes are unique, neural hashes aren't.

To add, there are natural neural hash collisions in ImageNet (a famous ML dataset). Images that look nothing alike to us humans.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Grustaf on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:31PM (#28407676)
Since the threshold is 30 images, and those images are matched to a curated database of abusive material, what you write here simply doesn't apply.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by vmladenov on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:16PM (#28418162)
Apple already does virus scanning on device and has for a decade. I fail to see how you trust one proprietary binary file scanner to stay in its lane and not spy on you, but fear a different one with a different stated purpose.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mlindner on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:05AM (#28405161)
Yeah but no one's found any evidence that any code calls it. (At least not that I've seen.)
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by arminiusreturns on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:17AM (#28405351)
Black box closed source systems sorta make verification of what the device is doing rather difficult.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by djrogers on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:00PM (#28405913)
Not really - there are a ton of ways to profile and monitor a Mac to determine what processes are calling into what, and spotting something activating this code oth would be trivial if it were happening.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by arminiusreturns on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:55PM (#28406616)
You say that, but there are also tons of ways to hide such things (there is an entire field dedicated to side-channel leakage). The point is you don't know unless you have the source code (and can compile it yourself, I'm ignoring the trust of compilers at the moment). You can try to reverse engineer and analyse all you want, but it doesn't mean you know what the system is really doing...
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by cwkoss on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:44PM (#28407819)
It may be trivial to look under a given rock, but when there are hundreds of thousands of rocks, the likelihood of someone noticing something left under a rock is low.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Piskvorrr on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:28AM (#28405487)
"Yeah, we have this really suspicious code here, sure, but we have not started calling it. Pinky swear."

The issue here is not the trustworthiness of the pinky swear...

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mlindner on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:43AM (#28405662)
I'm not saying it's a good situation, but it's not terrible yet.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Piskvorrr on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:49AM (#28405748)
I am reminded of the joke "an optimist falls from a skyscraper. At second floor, he thinks: 'so far, so good.'"

In other words, a situation that seems to be a feature toggle away from becoming terrible is terrible in itself.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by post_break on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:39AM (#28404055)
Well I don't mean by doing it without telling everyone. I mean wait until it dies down, then just be like oh btw 15.X includes CSAM scanning as a change log bulletin.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by haswell on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:56AM (#28404287)
Given the uproar on this change, and the fact that the uproar was big enough to cause this delay, can you imagine the bad press if they come back later and roll this out quietly?

Editing to add: I think this will play out more like the butterfly keyboard debacle. They won’t ever really acknowledge how bad the original thing was, but they’ll return to a solution the community finds palatable (server side scanning), and wrap it up in a bow like they did with the “magic keyboard, now on our laptops”.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by vxNsr on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:43AM (#28404864)
They just need to time it right.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by stjohnswarts on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:54AM (#28405034)
They were trying to make a small press release about it and be done hoping no one would notice. Instead everyone got mad and called them out on it. That is where they attempted to sneak it in. Not everything is black and white and the terminology is sufficient to describe the situation.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by djrogers on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:05PM (#28405994)
Wait a sec - this wasn’t a ‘small press release’, it was a huge one, made several months in advance of the feature launching, accompanied by a bunch of interviews with execs.

If you look at the tone of all of it, they also honestly felt this was the most privacy preserving way to do CSAM scanning - likely so they can enable E2EE on everything iCloud.

What they got very very wrong was the public reaction to it.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by TimTheTinker on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:39PM (#28407108)
> What they got very very wrong was the public reaction to it.

What they got very wrong is that this fundamentally changes the nature of iPhones -- they are no longer user agents; in fact, they're actively scanning user data on behalf of another party. That change doesn't just make people feel uncomfortable, it opens the door for untold myriads of abuses.

It's one thing if iCloud servers scan user data - those servers never were assumed to be user agents. It's entirely different when user-owned devices do this.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by Zak on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:31PM (#28406333)
What they got very very wrong is the idea that spyware running on the user's device is the most privacy preserving way to scan for illegal content hosted on their servers.

Apple has not announced E2EE for files stored on iCloud. If that is their intent, they likely would have had a somewhat improved public response by announcing it at the same time as the on-device spyware.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by sneak on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:11PM (#28406078)
> likely so they can enable E2EE on everything iCloud.

Refers to facts not in evidence.

Additionally, they have previously voluntarily declined to enable e2e on systems to aid government surveillance.

This is baseless speculation, and, given what we know about Apple's history with e2e, not only baseless but actually unlikely.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by azinman2 on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:15AM (#28405315)
A press release is the exact opposite of sneaking something in.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by behnamoh on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:32PM (#28406343)
> Could we at least discuss in good faith?

I'm afraid good faith is not gonna protect your privacy.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by yummypaint on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:59AM (#28404318)
Their practice of suripticiously pushing updates to older phones to kill the battery life would seem to fit that bill. Their updates aren't open either, people just take them at their word. If the law or EULA doesn't ouright prohibit them from doing something it's prudent to assume they already are.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by api on Friday September 03, 2021 @09:39AM (#28404062)
Google or (worse) Facebook would have just put this in with no press release.

My read is that Apple is trying to placate governments by throwing them a bone without totally abandoning their privacy stance, hence the drive to put the scanning on the actual device so all your photos don't have to be shared as-is with Apple. That way they can encrypt iCloud but still keep the feds from accusing them (in bad faith) of being a child porn trading platform.

The alternative is to keep iCloud unencrypted and scan in the cloud, which is what they and everyone else already does.

One of the pieces of feedback they got though is that people are more okay with that than with scanning on the device. People expect that things that go to the cloud are no longer private unless you run some kind of local encryption that you control.

The reason they don't care about photos not sent to iCloud is the trading platform angle. It's one thing to let people store shit on their own devices. It's another thing to be a large scale and easy to use secure channel that people can use to share CP. The nightmare scenario for Apple would be to become a de-facto standard in the CP underworld for sharing content.

Sure people can use Tor, private VPNs and mesh networks, PGP, or many other things, but that requires a level of technical knowledge that greatly reduces the size of the audience.

Maybe a better alternative for Apple would be to add iCloud encryption but to stipulate that any sharing of content disables encryption for the shared content. That way they could scan shared content only. For unshared content iCloud is basically just an encrypted backup.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by simion314 on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:28AM (#28404656)
>My read is that Apple is trying to placate governments by throwing them a bone

You would believe this if you only read/watch Apple PR and ignore reality. The actual reality is that Apple always collaborates with all governments. The reality is that Apple did not announce any new end to end encryption that would use this feature and did not promise such a feature.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by api on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:50AM (#28404965)
Apple isn't altruistic, but I do think they want to have strong privacy. They cooperate with governments to what seems to be the minimum extent required to do business in a given country. They can't change governments.

In China and other more authoritarian nations that means cooperating a lot. If you don't you do no business in China. In the USA they seem to be looking for a new minimum level of cooperation, or trying to enhance privacy a little without moving the needle.

In any case this particular strategy looks like a failure in the market. They might re-engineer it or backpedal or just toss the whole idea of encrypting iCloud.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by simion314 on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:11AM (#28405245)
>Apple isn't altruistic, but I do think they want to have strong privacy.

Maybe if you define privacy that Google and FB do not track you and only Apple do. You open an application on your Mac and the event was sent insecure to Apple , find a definition of privacy that is not contradictory with what Apple was doing.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by nick__m on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:29PM (#28406308)
If it was the trading platform angle, could they just scan on share or am I missing something ?
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by eldaisfish on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:49AM (#28404942)
what apple are trying to do is minimise damage to their bottom line from bad PR. At the end of the day, more people must realise that corporations are beholden to one thing - money.

Morality barely matters and legality is something easily skirted around with the right legal argument. Apple, google etc with continue working with governments so long as their profit can flow from those countries.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by tyingq on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:49AM (#28405747)
I have to wonder if the sequence was somewhat deliberate on Apple's part. Like:

- The government is pressuring us to do things that don't fit with our "privacy is good" sales pitch

- Let's propose something, but in a ham-handed enough way that it gets a ton of public push back

- Now we can argue our point with the government in a way that has already has more public support and existing discourse/debate

Somewhat risky though, since it hurt their public image.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by labcomputer on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:52PM (#28406586)
Then why wouldn't they say, "the government asked us to do this"? Apple is taking all the negative publicity this way.

My favorite theory is this:

Apple wants to create a chilling effect on reverse engineering iOS. They're starting to catch regulatory attention and lost their recent suit against Corellium. By putting neural hashes in the encrypted OS image, they can accuse anyone who reverse engineers iOS of:

1. Being in cahoots with child abusers

2. Knowingly possessing CSAM

I would hope that most courts would see through that paper thin logic, but the idea would be simply to introduce enough doubt that most reverse engineers don't want to risk it.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by xvector on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:45PM (#28409204)
> Then why wouldn't they say, "the government asked us to do this"?

NSLs are routinely issued to silence companies.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by labcomputer on Saturday September 04, 2021 @02:08PM (#28417559)
Oh, you're so close... what was the rest of the context?

It was that Apple somehow gets negotiating leverage with a three letter agency.

So how does Apple get negotiating leverage in a context with a TLA when they can't say "they made us do it"?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by mackrevinack on Friday September 03, 2021 @04:05PM (#28408749)
they could be under a gag order which would mean if they did mention anything about the government they could get into deep shit
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by upbeat_general on Saturday September 04, 2021 @12:10AM (#28411999)
I can't imagine how the gag order would allow Apple to announce a CSAM scanning system but not announce that the government forced them to.

What basis could there be for that? And I'd be even more skeptical if this originated from a single case of abuse.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by labcomputer on Saturday September 04, 2021 @01:59PM (#28417438)
Sure, but look at the context. The hypothesis was that Apple was doing this to create negotiating leverage with some three letter agency.

How does Apple get leverage if Apple gets all the negative publicity, and can't even say "TLA made us do it"?

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by yyyk on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:38AM (#28404791)
>Wow, we made Apple blink.

Did we? I suspect the real issue the original client-side proposal had a lot of holes. What if the bad guys upload CSAM which hasn't been tagged by NCMEC yet? What if they then delete it from the device (but keep it on iCloud)? Or what if they zip the CSAM images and backup that?

In order to be even semi-effective, the client-side scanning has to be more invasive, or they have to implement server-side scanning too. Apple may well be looking whether they can implement this scanning without even more backlash.

Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by stjohnswarts on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:59AM (#28405099)
I don't think you're right. Apple didn't care about CSAM policing, it's just they weren't opposed to it and throwing governments a little bit of what they wanted to make them shut up. They thought this through very thoroughly. I read the whitepapers they put out on it. Clearly this wasn't done overnight by a confederacy of dunces. I think they thought they were picking a middle ground on surveillance and privacy (clearly they weren't as they broke the 4th wall of "this is my damn iphone you're scanning on!") . Anyway, they didn't want to be the police and they aren't going to be doing more to police your device as you are pointing out. They never cared if they caught anyone, just trying to make the US government a bit happier.
Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features by yyyk on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:17AM (#28405340)
Apple may have thought this thorough technically, but politically I find it very unlikely the proposed method is a sufficiently effective scanning.

Sooner or later government and NCMEC will push them to complete the feature (understandably so from their POV), and when they do, Apple will have to expand scanning. Apple may have already been pressured to do so.

Sometimes choosing the middle ground is like choosing to drive on the white line in the middle of the road as a 'compromise' between the lanes.