Re:Apple Delays Rollout of Child Safety Features
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday September 03, 2021 @06:36PM
(#28410200)
"So now the question is in what 15.x update do they just sneak it in."
It would be nice if the general public and the news therefore now picked up on the issue of opaque "automatic updates". To date, they have been trained to always every update without question.
Conventional wisdom: Never, ever question any particular automatic update. Don't think, just enable. All updates are created equal.
Assumptions: Every update is for users benefit. Software companies never operate out of self-interest. There are no trade-offs. Whats good for them is good for users and vice versa. Theres no reason for end users to trial updated versions of software ("A/B test") before deciding to use them "in production".
Thought experiment: User installs Software from Company to perform "Function #1". Company makes changes to Software, described as "Fixes and other changes." Software now performs Function #1 plus Function #2. User allows new software to be installed automatically. (Automatic updates enabled per "expert" advice.") When user downloaded and installed Software she based her desicion to use Software on its ability to perform Function #1; however, did she have any interest in Function #2. Did she agree to Function #2. Company says yes. Developers say yes. What does User say. The license agreeement places no limits on what might comprise Function #2. It could be anything. It could have no benefit whatsoever for User. Moreover, Company is under no oblgation to disclose Function #2 to User. With automatic updates, Company is free to keep changing Software. User originally chose Software for Function #1 but Software may look very different after many "automatic updates". Would she choose it again in its current state. Segue to discussion of "lock-in".
It would be nice if the general public and the news therefore now picked up on the issue of opaque "automatic updates". To date, they have been trained to always every update without question.
Conventional wisdom: Never, ever question any particular automatic update. Don't think, just enable. All updates are created equal.
Assumptions: Every update is for users benefit. Software companies never operate out of self-interest. There are no trade-offs. Whats good for them is good for users and vice versa. Theres no reason for end users to trial updated versions of software ("A/B test") before deciding to use them "in production".
Thought experiment: User installs Software from Company to perform "Function #1". Company makes changes to Software, described as "Fixes and other changes." Software now performs Function #1 plus Function #2. User allows new software to be installed automatically. (Automatic updates enabled per "expert" advice.") When user downloaded and installed Software she based her desicion to use Software on its ability to perform Function #1; however, did she have any interest in Function #2. Did she agree to Function #2. Company says yes. Developers say yes. What does User say. The license agreeement places no limits on what might comprise Function #2. It could be anything. It could have no benefit whatsoever for User. Moreover, Company is under no oblgation to disclose Function #2 to User. With automatic updates, Company is free to keep changing Software. User originally chose Software for Function #1 but Software may look very different after many "automatic updates". Would she choose it again in its current state. Segue to discussion of "lock-in".