Melbourne is also experiencing a housing crisis similar to Auckland's due to a boom in prices.
So should Melbourne also pull out all the stops to encourage new building? Interestingly, Prosper Australia has been tracking Melbourne's true vacancy rate for over a decade now, publishing their findings in their Speculative Vacancies Report[1].
Before you look at the report, a couple of questions:
1) Do you believe prices are being driven up due to a shortage of homes? (Your comment suggests you do.)
2) If prices were being driven up due to a shortage of homes, would you expect the areas that experience the highest capital gains to have the lowest vacancy rates? (I think most people would agree with this.)
Now, the most interesting finding from the Speculative Vacancies Report for me was that in fact, contrary to what most people would expect, areas with the highest capital gains correlate strongly with those areas that have highest number of empty dwellings.
My own suspicion is that the demand that is driving up prices is not demand for homes, but demand for investments. A speculative boom creates extra demand.
In 2007, the Irish thought they had an undersupply of housing. A short time later it was revealed that they actually had a massive oversupply (once investment/speculative demand was removed). The RBA in Australia is pointing to the same thing in Melbourne (Docklands has a vacancy rate of ~25%+, other sought after areas are approaching 15-20% according to the report mentioned above).
The best thing that Auckland can do to tackle house prices is to address the demand side of the supply and demand equation. There are tonnes of options for doing this but mostly this is an issue caused by easy credit and tax incentives for investing in property. That's the place to solve this problem. It would be folly to encroach on green areas or otherwise spoil our environment in a mad rush to build. If we do that... Ireland here we come!
[1] https://www.prosper.org.au/2015/12/09/speculative-vacancies-...
Speculative real estate investment is a direct result of restrictive zoning. Consider for example an already developed area of a city that is zoned for single family residential. This makes it illegal for a developer to increase supply in this region by building, say a duplex. A developer is allowed to rebuild a house, but not increase supply.
So of course there is speculative investment! Owners have a legal guarantee of resource scarcity. It’s the reason governments everywhere try to avoid deflation; it causes everyone to hold onto their cash.
Now contrast the situation when a developer can turn a house into a duplex. Supply is elastic. There’s no legal guarantee of scarcity. Of course real estate is still an investment vehicle, but there is no longer the artificial constraint on supply.
I also think it’s weird to lump this in with environmental protection. Preserving natural areas is an unassailably important priority for any nation. What does that have to do with home owners that feel they have a legal right to not live next to a condo? I don’t think the parent (or really anyone here) is advocating we develop undeveloped land.
Finally, I wonder if this is all moot, because the issue at hand is a restriction of foreign ownwers. Won’t native NZ real estate companies be glad to step in to fill the void? Can’t these companies then just shell shares to international investors?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_real_estate_bubble_of_...
""" As a result of these factors, prices for land in the Chicago Loop rose from essentially nothing in 1830 ($800 per acre in 2012 dollars) to New York levels by 1836 ($327,000 per acre in 2012 dollars), a 40,775% increase, with even higher prices around Dearborn Avenue and the Chicago River.[3] Furthermore, Illinois in general experienced a huge boom in real estate prices and town foundations. Walters estimates that the foundations of 1/3 of all towns ever created in central Illinois occurred between 1835 and 1837.[4]
In 1837, there was widespread panic due to credit tightening from England. On May 29, 1837, as depositors began to withdraw money en masse, Illinois banks suspended payments. As these banks fell into bankruptcy, Illinois’ internal improvements, like the canals that were supposed to be financed by the banks, stopped. This led to considerable uncertainty as to Chicago's future, and combined with a general lack of credit, caused Chicago real estate prices to fall approximately 88% from their peak by 1841.[3] """
By definition, it's not. It's a term coined to separate out the impact on prices of people buying-to-live vs people buying-to-sell/rent-and-profit. And if foreigners are more likely to buy for speculative purposes, barring them from doing so will decrease speculative increases in house prices.
Imagine if the stocks of public companies were not fixed in supply. The company at any time could simply decide to have shares for 200%, 300%, or 1000% without compensating existing shareholders in any way. If that was the case, stocks would be total garbage as an investment. Prices would plummet to 0.
The reason metro real estate is so attractive as an investment is because supply is inelastic. If we want to encourage usage, as oppose to hoarding, we should do like we do with fiat currencies and allow more of it to be made.
Banning foreigners might have some tiny effect, but honestly seems a bit like arranging deck chairs on the Titanic. We can check in after a year, but all my money is on Auckland continuing to have an expensive housing market (unless they allow more rezoning). Further, banning foreigners of course is also banning a valuable export and will cut off a stream of foreign money that was previously flowing into the local economy.
Investing in real estate would be purchasing property for its income earning potential.
Speculating would be purchasing for capital gains potential.
You might argue that people do both at once but if you would only make the purchase if there is a potential for capital gains and not otherwise, then you are speculating.
> Speculation is a method of short-term investing whereby traders essentially bet on the direction an asset's price will move.
This is what most people would assume speculation to mean in the context of this discussion. It is quite normal to compare this type of speculative investment with other - especially productive - investment.
Rent and profit is a great investment for the general public. Thats not speculation, thats straight down investment.
Buy to sell is speculation, in the sense that it might not be representing the underlying risks. But even then its doubtful: if you think construction materials will rise 20% in the next year, buying your house to day and sitting on it is a sound investment, one that benefits the whole.
Speculator is an overused word to depict an enemy that kills itself.
You make no sense, all investment is speculation.
While they may have the same meaning in a general sense, and are synonyms from a distance, once you get up close, you can distinguish meaning between them.
That's just how English works. Huge and colossal are the same until you pull out the D&D sourcebook, and then it turns out that colossal is bigger than huge.
Market failure, policy failure, awful planning.
Living here, it's hugely disheartening to see a similar pattern emerging so shortly after a massive crash.
I live in Cork, population ~200k. In 2012, I rented a 2 bed apartment in the city centre for €750 a month. Now, I would be lucky to get a decent 1 bed apartment for €1000. And because bank lending rules tightened after 2008, opportunities to purchase a house/apartment have narrowed. Therefore, those (and families in particular) who cannot purchase have been on the receiving end of the spiraling rents. It took the government till late 2016 to put the brakes on the rent increases by creating "rental pressure zones".
https://www.reuters.com/article/ireland-economy-housing/irel...
Auckland is adding apartments, albeit not at a sufficient rate. Their rents are high enough to make building them profitable. What does that say? It means that local resident demand is high enough to support investment of high-density residential areas.
Auckland's demand is significantly fueled by speculative investors, to be sure. What props up the house prices are the Kiwi families moving to Auckland for better work opportunities.
What Sydney and Melbourne are experiencing is a lack of rental support for their high house prices. That cannot be sustainable.
I'm amazed it was that low. I was inspecting recently and I was blown away, it was like a ghost town. I checked out the carparks of these massive buildings and they were basically completely empty, it was crazy.
The methodology of the Speculative Vacancies Report involves gathering water usage data for all properties. That can mean that if a property is occupied for a single month it isn't counted. A lot of the Docklands apartments appear to be not only vacant investments, but also short-term rentals and 'city pads', so I'm not at all surprised that it appears more like a ghost town than the figures suggest it might.
If there is excess capital, it's the fault of the central banks.
No.
The issue is corruption and lack of distribution of surpluses in developing economies, specifically China.
Think: China is poor on a per-capita basis. So why are so many Chinese trying to hard to get their $$$ out of there? Mass corruption etc..
Westerners send a lot of $$$ to China - and if there were labour laws, environmental laws (i.e. democracy) then those surpluses would be spread more evenly across China. 'Regular' chinese people want to buy a home, a car a TV - but since the money is so heavily focused on a small portion of citizens - they have 'mass surpluses' and want to get their money out. So it comes back to the West.
You mentioned 'lack of investment' - this can't be the case - as there are still hundreds of millions of Chinese people who still don't have proper homes and are way behind in terms of material standards of living.
If they were paid more - they'd have more surplus $ to spend on 'homes and stuff' and guess what? Local investments would make more sense.
We can't have free trade with nations that regulate their economies in fundamentally different ways than ours. If a country for example, allows mass pollution - well - that externalization is a massive economic advantage, kind of like a 'government subsidy'.
The best way to deflate the Western housing bubble - and to fix the internal problems in China is to spread the wealth in China. Arguably US needs a little more of this as well.
Wealth is not currency wealth is things of value, and we have systemic issues with profits from investments being reinvested instead of being spent, as everyone is looking for returns. This inflates the value of things that create future income streams.
It only takes about 5% of home buyers to be foreign buyers who are 'price inelastic' (i.e. they will pay above market/any price) to create a housing bubble.
If the capital were not in their hands, but more distributed through the NZ economy, I suggest that capital would be deployed differently than just in real estate.
*Like gold it can act as a hedge, but long term inflation they has negative returns when you include maintenance costs aka vaults are not free.
Agreed.
And guess what - many of the foreign buyers leave the homes empty.
That they would even do this is evidence of how crazy the economic mismatch is.
Which is why foreigners should not be able to buy property. Doubly important if they are not going to live in it.
...or perhaps property investment is encouraged by the tax system, is favoured by lenders, etc.
Homes in Dublin under €175 (asking, at least) http://www.daft.ie/dublin-city/houses-for-sale/?s%5Bmxp%5D=1...
Also, green space is nice but it is worth considering that the actual natural environment of this island was lost between 1000 and 500 years ago. It used to be nearly all forest, but grazing animals are death to forest as they eat the saplings.
I don't think it works
Oversupply is a problem for owners, not for renters and newcomers. The very people buying property and parking it are not making a sound investment, and they will naturally pay the price for it.
If what is happening is that speculators are dumping all this cash to make properties, then the best course of action is to do nothing. Eventually they will lose, but the buildings are still there. And there is plenty of space to build around. Housing is not a limited asset like its often portrayed. Its truly unlimited, thats why you can find land almost for free.
I don't know if it has been covered specifically about NZ, but otherwise yes, many many times. For example: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/07/nyregion/more-apartments-a... https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/08/nyregion/stream-of-foreig... http://nymag.com/news/features/foreigners-hiding-money-new-y...
I'm still curious whether it has been covered in NZ. Canada, like NZ, is also a commonwealth country, and it's only recently that it is even remotely common that "reasonable people" dare broach such subjects. I find it rather interesting that my comment was heavily downvoted and flagged, as if there is an initiative to silence any voice that dare even suggest immigration may not be absolutely necessary. Is it truly possible that all countries on the planet need more immigration, and in all cases the need is greater than the associated harm?
Was Hans Rosling also a "racist"?
I think you greatly understimate global forces at play when it comes to speculation levels in this asset class in some major metropolitan cities.
Apartments are not the remedy and Chinese money is not a scapegoat, it's a hurricane-level force of real-estate.
it is a hurricane-level force for everything.
if you think the situation in Vancouver and Sydney are bad, think again, think the situation in Shanghai -
a typical recently built 3 bedroom apartment in downtown Shanghai can easily cost you $3m CAD, a typical worker on average Shanghai salary will have to pay no tax, eat nothing, walk to work naked (no $ for cloth) for 300 years to afford that. not talking about luxury apartment with fancy view, just average apartment in an okay area next to busy & noisy roads.
If it's so grotesquely overpriced, why aren't investors jitterish about a downturn? Are they ready to bite a 30% bullet on the investment?
Genuine questions, I want to understand the chinese money exodus effect.
It is a cancer.
You mean income derived from the property? Seems like that could inflate rental prices, and shift the affordability problem to another set of people.
The state government in Victoria (Australia) is planning to tax vacant properties, but it's self reported and seems easy enough to dodge. At first the proposed measuring water usage to determine if the property was vacant, but then you can only tax as much as it would cost to leave a tap on.
No, a regular property tax based on the value of the property. Such as 1% of the value paid in tax every year.
The idea would be that it would be zero net effect if you live in the country (i.e. it's a property tax + income tax deduction that effectively make them together be a "tax on properties owned by foreigners")
Property should not be an investment since it is an essential for living.
Exactly. But the idea is that it's very hard to check whether someone lives in a property, so you check for the next best thing: whether you have income in the country. So if you have income tax in the country then you can get exempt from one property tax.
Otherwise you end up having things like "self reporting" where you live, or local governments trying to check water/electricity use to see whether buildings are occupied etc, which are obviously both expensive and futile.
You could have a 10% market value property tax, and a deduction of 90% of that amount, for one home, on your income tax, then 75% for a second property etc, to make it both prohibitively expensive for foreigners, and a bit progressive for those owning multiple homes.
An increase in average wage growth would support both owner-occupiers and first time buyers.
Speculators can move their investments, but they have to accept the loss in order to do that.
An increase in wages without fixing the underlying drivers for property price growth will not support owner occupiers or first time buyers at all, because property price growth will match or exceed that growth.
Crash prices, keep them low and stable after, it will be rough and unpopular for a while but will eventually be the best outcome.
This is easily gamed if Chinese millionaires are truly at fault. They just set up a numbered corporation and "employ" their nephew whose living there.
Further, if people are actually employed and paid, they also pay income taxes. So now the property is even higher cost. Since to pay a person a minimum wage over the year (and the taxes and added costs that gives) is probably more than the property tax for foreigners would have been. Most importantly, the cost of either the property tax or the income tax solution should be higher than any expected gains in the property value (or at least enough to make it useless as an investment).
The best way to game this system would probably be to shadow own it behind some 18year old that has a full time job but lives at home. They have the tax space to make the deduction.
If you’re trying to rent an apartment you’re screwed.
If you’re trying to buy a house you’re really screwed.
It’s not all Chinese money but it’s a lot of foreign and local investors. I can see investors being important for building or upgrading condos and apartments, but investors being able to buy so many single family homes and “flip” them just makes the whole Norman Rockwell picket fence thing seem pretty unattainable.
With the new football stadium going in there are “rundown” areas getting “gentrified” and it’s crazy to see one renovated 2 bedroom house in Baldwin Hills sell for $900k and be on a street with sales from the two years prior in the 200-300k range. [1]
[1]: a 200k house in LA is a shithole
Edit: See this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=tmnvix
1. What are the benefits to a city and its local inhabitants of a foreigner buying an existing residential home that it will not inhabit?
It seems there are none to me, unless the city taxes that home way way more.
2. Why would foreigners invest in the construction of new rental homes or apartment buildings if the rental price wasn't high enough to profit from?
In that I mean, I feel you'll only get foreign investment to grow your city once its already too expensive to live in. As they build more and it becomes affordable again, they'd stop investing, and it will become unaffordable again. Keeping the city in a perpetual state of unaffordability.
What are the benefits of exporting any work whatsoever?
> Why would foreigners invest in the construction of new rental homes or apartment buildings if the rental price wasn't high enough to profit from?
This is a good question. There is an expectation that rents will rise in the next decade, so that could explain a healthy market reaction. An unhealthy one might be capital flight from China, so investors are willing to take a loss becaue its lower than the taxes/restrictions china has on that money. Housing has exploded globally, its not a local nz problem.
And housebuilding is not linked only to rent, but rather to sale prices: if homeowning is culturally valued, people will pay to buy at higher prices.
With the current (in most countries) banking system, the money available for investing is not limited by the quantity of money in the system, but by the availability of projects with a good return.
A commercial bank can create money if they think that they will have a good return (risk wise). Banks don't lean reserves.
An investor can borrow money from a bank if it has a good project.
Interest rates are decided by the Central Bank depending of the goals for the country economy.
So, the idea of "money available for investing" doesn't make sense in the current fiat economies.
The value of land is proportional to the income you can get from using it, so the forces that regulate land value and rent are irrelevant to the amount of land, but with what you can get from them. If tomorrow Auckland duplicated wages, rentals would skyrocket there, without changing demographics or land.
Assuming it was true that this is such a net positive benefit to a city, it sounds like it stops working very quickly. The second sell on the property is now a foreigner to either a city local, which would siphon the money out of the city, or from a foreigner to another.
So this would only work to increase the city's cash flow temporarily, or in the case where the property depreciate and the foreigner incurs a less.
As long as authorities crack down on loopholes (like foreigners buying property through a fake company, and then selling the company to avoid real estate tax over property sales; or keeping properties empty for an unreasonable amount of time in the face of housing shortages), it's a net positive.
It supplies a property for rent (i.e. it's not like the property disappears), and the extra demand increases the value of properties the locals own.
I think it's only really problematic if capital is cheaper for foreigners than locals.
In that I mean, I feel you'll only get foreign investment to grow your city once its already too expensive to live in. As they build more and it becomes affordable again, they'd stop investing, and it will become unaffordable again. Keeping the city in a perpetual state of unaffordability.
I don't see how this logic is restricted to foreigners. The argument seems to be universally applicable, which makes me suspicious: why wouldn't investment grow the city until rent falls to the cost of capital + maintenance etc.?
(I think the argument doesn't actually work because of the nature of property: location, amenities, services, community; things whose supply isn't easily increased simply by capital. But if it did work to some extent, it would still apply to nationals just as well.)
Which is exactly the problem. Housing is for living, not speculating. Basic human needs should probably not be subject to such speculation.
That said, regulations in building new housing can also exacerbate this problem. At the very least, density should be increasing at approximately the rate of population growth in a region, or you will obviously have a growing sprawl problem.
You are looking at the wrong culprit. If there is a piece of undeveloped land, and a foreigner builds a house completely uninhabited, the housing stock in the market has a delta of 0. If there is an owner that sells their house to a foreigner and buys a new one, the housing stock is till the same. They dont affect supply in abstract, they affect supply if there are significant zoning restrictions that do create artifical scarcity.
We're not talking about supply, we're talking about price. The OP said, "and the extra demand increases the value of properties the locals own." Increasingly unaffordable housing is exactly the problem.
It's a vote-winner though, and property is most people's biggest investment asset. It's a Ponzi scheme, but it's hard to avoid.
My main point was addressed to the economic argument being put forward, however; that it wasn't specific to "foreigners". "Foreigners" as a culprit are a red herring.
Right, that's why I said "speculation" and not "foreign ownership" in my reply. Holding periods for ownership, non-residential use must be rented out, etc.
The buildings are built with promises to investors of huge target rents. New developments typically rent for 20% more than smaller/older buildings, and the rents will be increased annually for the unfortunate ones who rent in these new buildings. These buildings use many tricks to make it seem affordable, like 2 months free rent, free parking, etc. But they're expensive, and they drive up rent in the surrounding buildings.
SF, please wake-up and realize that the city is not the enemy in the housing crisis, it's the profiteering.
Today's luxury housing is tomorrow's affordable housing. Being angry at lux high rises is like a dog being angry at its owner after a bee stings its ass. Without those high rises for the hedge fund bros to move into, they occupy merely nice apartments, pushing the rest of us into tenements and everybody else out to the fringes.
I live in a 5 story complex next to downtown - it's an amazing place to be here in Auckland.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/82540876/New-Unitary-Plan-re...
Or reducing demand, I suppose, if they value their current way of living. Of course, discouraging population growth, if that is doable, is more long term, and might not have much effect immediately.
Wouldn't developers stop investing in new projects as soon as prices became stable or started dropping slightly, causing the same cycle to start again when demand catches up in a few years?
Developers would stop investing in projects as soon as projects became forecasted to be unprofitable. If the housing supply is being artificially restricted below its clearing price, there's a gap between minimum profitable housing unit, and the housing units that can currently be sold. The idea behind lifting the zoning restrictions is to allow supply to reach market clearance.
And if it turns out that if new housing wouldn't be profitable, there won't be any changes. (Though a pattern we see in cities with less strict zoning (see: Montreal) is that we get expensive, cramped apartments near the city center, with lots of empty land around the edges. This is okay too! It's good for other reasons, by reducing commute times and making mass transit more affordable. Density is good!)
“As we have documented, despite many careful and thorough empirical analyses, drawing firm general conclusions about the linkage between local regulations and housing prices is not possible. Many careful analyses report some effect of regulation on housing prices, but many exceptions exist.”
I think there’s a decent contingent of YIMBYs who do oppose development - the suburban kind. I think it would be productive to reframe as pro-density rather than pro-market.
In Minato ward — a desirable 20 sq km slice of central
Tokyo — the population is up 66 per cent over the past 20
years, from 145,000 to 241,000, an increase of about
100,000 residents. In the 121 sq km of San Francisco, the
population grew by about the same number over 20 years,
from 746,000 to 865,000 — a rise of 16 per cent. Yet
whereas the price of a home in San Francisco and London
has increased 231 per cent and 441 per cent respectively,
Minato ward has absorbed its population boom with price
rises of just 45 per cent.
And this is for a particularly popular part of Tokyo.
In the 1980s, Japanese cities were experiencing the same
inflated housing bubbles that U.S. cities are today. Their
planning methods, moreover, were rooted in Western notions
about separating uses and limiting density. The federal
government recognized that these regulations were the
problem, so in 2002, it passed the Urban Renaissance Law.
The law stripped municipalities of the ability to control
private property. As a result, owners can build a variety
of uses on their land, regardless of resistance from local
bureaucrats or neighbors.
https://www.forbes.com/forbes/welcome/?toURL=https://www.for...This is in fact completely western zoning, just not american zoning which I expect is what Forbes really means when they talk about "Western notions about separating uses and limiting density": these concerns exist in european zonings but not even remotely to the extent that they do in "Euclidian" US zoning.
People seem to forget that property isn't like other investment classes. Everyone needs somewhere to live and it can only be built on land which is very scarce where the jobs are.
Japan and Tokyo do housing right. Pricing largely stays the same, quality of living increases.
I absolutely don't mean this about you, but the general sense that I get is people largely don't want to admit someone else is doing things better. People are convinced that their city/state/country is really special and any problem they have are just problems that clearly have no solution. If a solution did exists, obviously, they'd have it. It's ego and pride.
(1) https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3...
People seem to forget that property isn't like other
investment classes.
Other investment classes provide value from services or production.Speculative real estate relies on artificial scarcity (local laws preventing building upward) is extracting value from suppressing more construction for more people.
Like gold or bitcoin?
>Speculative real estate relies on artificial scarcity (local laws preventing building upward) is extracting value from suppressing more construction for more people.
There are many cities where they build upwards massively but the property prices increase massively. See Beijing or Shanghai. Actually compare China now to Japan in the 80s and you see lots of similarities.
When I say property isn't like other investment classes I mean it shouldn't be. People need places to live and if left to the market the lower end of the market will just be left out on the street or in horrific housing conditions. The only solution will be government building of housing. IE compare Singapore with Hong Kong.
Actual developer response would depend on how much price changes with supply.
The whole point of NZ is everyone gets their slice of paradise, but once you move to apartment territory your just dealing with population management, quality of life goes down and disconnection with the land breeds mental deficits that bleed into policy (every country has it's hatred of people from Paris/Toronto etc). One of the nightmares of NZ is that it's beaches turns into Hawaii's with giant hotels and thousands crowding the surf.
It's a fundamental difference in thinking that foreign investors are not aware of, they just try to shoehorn their learnt development strategy into the place. It has bad effects on the locals on many levels and turning NZ into another branch of starbucks just makes it loose all appeal.
The problem is for the quality of lifestyle NZ'er expect, there is a population limit. Fortunately increasing population is no longer needed for economic growth.
And there isn't a "point" of NZ. We're a large island in the South Pacific - we have huge problems with poverty, family violence, and (I believe) the worst teenage suicide rate in the OECD.
As an aside, bear in mind that, due to the quirks of New Zealand law, it doesn’t apply to Australians.
But yeah, it’s a dumb rule likely to create immigrant enclaves. And that never ends well.
Japanese zoning (which you'd expect to be quite concerned about quake standards) does not distinguish single-occupancy houses and apartment buildings, as a result non-central urban residential zones have a significant mix of houses and apartment buildings of 2~4 floors and 4~10 flats/floor e.g. this is a typical apartment building on the outskirts of Tokyo City: https://www.google.be/maps/@35.6352621,139.6260533,3a,75y,20...
In much the same way, "inner-city" parisian appartment buildings mostly follow the Haussmannian standard of 5 floors.
Because China is big and we are little this has a disproportionately large effect on our house prices - which makes them look like a good investment etc. etc.
If the real fix is politically unpopular, is it a real fix?
I mean, what people want should be accounted somehow, that's the point of a democracy, isn't it?
What people want is often contradictory. They want affordable, nice housing near their work, but given most people work near other people, they don't want high density housing like condos. You can satisfy all of these demands simultaneously.
Ah - exactly.
They want to make the local citizens pay for their overseas retirement then?
No thanks.
Again - community centric economic policies for domiciles is imperative.
Globalization of these things will hurt 99% of us.
They want to make foreigners pay them their foreign retirement, in that case.
> Again - community centric economic policies for domiciles is imperative.
It is the government itself that is creating the problem, by overly restrictive zoning policies, similar but even more pronounced in NZ.
I don't agree.
The government should have never allowed non-citizens to buy property in the first place.
Zoning is not the issue, there's plenty of space, granted, they could change that if they had to.
Massive surpluses of cash from wealthy 1%-er foreigners is the issue really.
Here's an idea: you can't have 'free trade' if one side is willing to allow de-facto slavery, corruption and externalization of things like pollution etc..
Because that means jobs are lost in 'high regulation country A' and move to 'corrupt and low regulation country B' - particularly into the pockets of their 1%-ers who can then rule their own country, and then come ton country A where surpluses are more evenly distributed and also take over and use their wealth as leverage.
No.
Just like you need certain things in order to have a common currency - you need certain things for free trade.
We understand that 'strategic dumping' and 'government subsidies' are generally not allowed in 'free trade' - but we should be aware that 'government allowing pollution' etc. - is like a form of subsidy.
There is already a trade war with China, so it would be best if the West simply added a tariff for imports that reflected these things, and certainly had capital controls. Nothing heavy, but domestic property ownership should definitely be regulated as well.
Why allow citizens to leave the country while we are at it. Lets just close all the borderds, never allow foreigners in, or locals out. That is the recipe for economic prosperity!
You are forgetting the foreigners have let their cash into nz. They gave it to homeowners, to construcion companies, etc. Those in turn spend it and reinvest it locally.
Why not give them free healthcare?
Why not subsidize their education abroad?
Why not let foreigners pay our politicians to make legislation - the money goes to lawyers, consultants etc. i.e. right into the economy!
For the same reason we have borders, that we don't allow foreigners to buy some kinds of assets (i.e. wireless spectrum) - or do some kind of banking, own certain kinds of companies.
?
If you take away foreign investment in homes, then housing prices will be affordable.
The only way housing is not affordable otherwise is if there is 'bubble like activity' - like the Silicon Valley - and even then, this has a lot to do with foreign money flowing in, just as LP's and investors and not as home owners.
Point blank.
Toronto and Vancouver have massive foreign investment and have unaffordable homes.
Montreal - with similar economic conditions - has a little less immigration, and no foundation for Asian buyers - and guess what? It's super affordable.
Everywhere you see a lot of international speculation - you see affordability problems.
Ban foreign ownership of property unless it's commercial. There's absolutely no reason to be speculating with our homes.
FYI - this creates a serious problem: Toronto and Vancouver are Ponzi schemes - construction is a big part of the economy. If the zillions of homes stopped getting built, it would mean a 'reality based economy' that Canadians can't deal with - because we don't export valuable things and we are addicted to an ever-increasing number of warm bodies.
My comment should be read in context as "No, it's Kiwis that will ultimately pay the price, as it's Kiwis that are getting screwed by unaffordable housing [caused by unfettered speculation, foreign and local]".
Why do you think person C is getting screwed if A sells to B?
A thought experient: What if the landowners went the opposite way: property can only be sold to foreigners that are poorer than nzlanders. How would that go in this scheme of things.
The primary purpose of housing is not to make people money, it's to house people. To serve that goal the lower the price is the better.
In that context it's clear that it's not the relative wealth, or even foreigner vs local that's the problem, it's speculation of any kind. So no, in your thought experiment it's no better to sell to foreign speculators regardless of their relative wealth.
A more interesting thought experiment is what happens in an economy when property speculation doesn't happen. House prices are lower, as demand is only from those that want to live in them and those that want to buy them to lease them out. With lower prices paid, there's more money (on average) in everyone's pockets - including those that rent, due to lower rental prices. This increase in money stimulates the economy, especially because most of the relative benefit accrues to those on lower incomes that spend most of their income to live. The economy is further benefited as much of the money that would have otherwise been dumped into non-productive real estate speculation instead flows into real investment.
The end result of discouraging property speculation is enormously beneficial to the country. Investors can speculate in the stock market or whatever else they like, because people don't live in shares, but the housing market exists to serve a purpose... and that purpose is not to make people money. That's an acceptable side effect so long as the primary purpose is fulfilled, but in NZ and AU it's failing.
Ha!
The government is already collecting taxes because of home sales, it doesn't need to restrict it to solve it with its magical redistribution powers.
That said, government revenue isn't even the problem, the excessive cost of housing is the problem.
The government is already interfering in the housing market by not taxing it at the same level as normal income; by making it tax advantageous to earn capital gains rather than by labour it pushes money into that market.
I'd prefer that they stopped messing with the housing market by treating it the same.
However home owners that are not actually benefiting from higher prices are incredibly attached to their paper gains and so any policy that threatens that will be wildly unpopular.
A person that moves from one city to another, a person that sells their home to go back to renting, a software engineer thinking of moving to nz for a job has now found that he might never be able to purchase a home. The effects on pricing are not in par with wages: someone downsizing their home will get a smaller difference, and someone upsizing has found it is cheaper. Real estate agents income drops, tax revenue drops, tourism drops, etc.
There are more circumstances that we can imagine and my point is that is very presumptuous to think all those people have been benefited. Lots of landowners would vote against it, and they get no compensation from the ones that voted in favor of restrictions. The principle is not to benefit a majority. If we wanted to do that, we would just seize things from the top 49% and give it to the bottom 51%. There is no fundamental value satisfied here but the capacity of landowners to get use the government to tell what other people can or cant do with their property.
I reiterate: this is not about what nz wants, its about what some people want.
Yes, it is.
> If we wanted to do that, we would just seize things from the top 49% and give it to the bottom 51%.
No, we wouldn't, because that wouldn't achieve it.
> I reiterate: this is not about what nz wants, its about what some people want.
Reiterate all you like, you're attacking a strawman of your own creation because nobody is claiming otherwise.
> a software engineer thinking of moving to nz for a job has now found that he might never be able to purchase a home
It'll be a lot easier for him after a crash in the NZ property market, doubly so if foreign money is pushed out leading to drops in the NZD on top of the crash.
"If you've bought a house to live in and the market doubles then halves again, you didn't benefit from the rise nor suffer from the fall. The main losers for a drop in prices are speculators, the main winners are practically everybody."
This was what I said and you haven't actually disagreed with that anywhere. Yes, there are some that will be worse off, but increasing prices harm more than they help. Decreasing prices help more than they harm. It's not possible to do nothing, because doing nothing is doing something by continuing the current policy mix which inflates prices.
Crashing the market is the only way to improve the situation, but is politically untenable because people are very attached to paper gains even though they don't actually benefit from them. The end result will be an uncontrolled crash in the market that will leave the government with no revenue with which to help those that are harmed by a falling market; deliberately crashing prices through appropriate taxation would leave most unharmed, but would extract money from those that had benefited from a bad situation to help those that were really harmed.
It's the right thing to do, but no government will do it.
No, they can't purchase an existing home. You can always build a new one.
somebody should invent that.
(sorry for the snarky tone, but why is this even worthy of discussion here?)
Auckland does appear to have legitimate supply constraints even absent demand (see articles with families living in tents, cars, etc in this first world country) and the geography does put constraints on efficient sprawl.
The solution is hard because existing property owners have more rights, incentives, and skin in the game then potential residents.
To be fair though "existing property owners" would also include people who own land in low-density-zoned areas and would like to build high-density housing on their property, but are prevented from doing so by neighboring property owners. It seems like their rights are also being infringed upon, no?
Yes, there is a social contract that ends up codified into zoning/code, but that is governed by local government, which is governed by local property owners.
EDIT @ closeparen: I'm really sorry to hear that you feel that me supporting property rights are cartoon villainy. They are the foundation of modern civilization unfortunately.
EDIT 2: > What you're really talking about here is the political power over others that's embedded in property rights. This power is ultimately delegated to property owners by states, and the correct response (and what we're starting to see in CA) is the state seizing that power away from property owners and granting it to the population at large.
You're suggesting subverting democracy. Again, in violation with a democracy that is the foundation of modern civilization. To deprive someone of living in your own home is not a violation of their rights. Socialism I can support, but not communism (ie "the state seizing that power away from property owners and granting it to the population at large").
If you don't want to a skyscraper built on your land, don't sell your land.
Your neighbor's land isn't "your own home," it's his.
>You're suggesting subverting democracy.
Subverting a council of the landowning aristocracy (local city govt) with a democracy (state government).
>the foundation of modern civilization
Single-family-home zoning, FAR, parking minimums, sunlight plane, height limits, etc. have barely been around 100 years. Laws dictating that all places must look like modern American suburbs are certainly not "the foundation of modern civilization."
Well, this law is proposed by state government (democracy).
> Subverting a council of the landowning aristocracy (local city govt) with a democracy (state government).
If we want to regulate population growth, fine. But we will have to start rationing birth the way we ration condos if it's really so important to us to avoid the scourge of homes.
EDIT: supporting property rights would be supporting the rights of property owners to build on their land. What you're really talking about here is the political power over others that's embedded in property rights. This power is ultimately delegated to property owners by states, and the correct response (and what we're starting to see in CA) is the state seizing that power away from property owners and granting it to the population at large.
I wouldnt be surprised if a measure like this ends up unconstitutional (no idea about nz constitution)
I'd argue that if a person can no longer reasonably expect to buy a house in their own country then they're being deprived of their rights and that this is a more significant loss than others losing their "rights" to tax free profit from their property speculations.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_New_Zealand
The government can always come in an and kick you out. They can raise property taxes to 100% of the house value. It is within their capacity.
The problem is hard because existing property owners have more rights, but those without have plenty of incentive and skin in the game too, as the overall cost of never owning a home is significant. Arguably the property owners should have less rights than they do when those rights are causing significant hardship and economic damage, which is the case.
It sure doesn't feel that way in the UK where noone seems to be able to stop every green space being turned into "luxury executive apartments".
(This happens with domestic buyers too but the problem of huge empty investment properties seems to have come along with foreign investment?)
Not quite.
A wealthy citizen of a 3rd world country has used the fact that he can pollute and treat his staff like slaves - to make tons of money.
He can then go to another country wherein surpluses are spread more evenly - buy up property - and start to dominate those people economically as well.
One could make the cases that 'you cannot buy homes in our country unless you're a citizen of a country with similar rules regarding externalities like the environment, human rights' etc..
Because a lot of this money is coming from countries where all sorts of externalizations are made.
Same thing for manufacturing: we 'stop hiring' in locale A and go to 'locale B' where we can pollute and have slaves. You can't really look at it solely from the context of locale A.
For the same reason different nations have separate currencies, I think we need to separate domicile policy.
How does this reason translate to housing policy?
Housing - and capital inflows/outflows - are primary drivers of inflation! (FYI I know housing is generally not included in inflation targets, but it really should be because it's where inflation can effectively be hidden).
Ergo - strongly related to the issue at hand.
Put simpler: those who come from countries with a different currency should not be able to buy residential property. :)
The parent post may've meant to imply race.
cultural factors may play a role, of course. quality of life is better when you have more things in common with your surroundings. this is about preferences, not perceived superiority though. at the very least you'd want your kids to have a common language with their classmates though.
>> What's next TOXIC WASTE DUMPS IN OUR KIDS BREAKFAST CEREAL?
I'm not sure its possible to make a more dramatic statement.
The parent arguments are both far more reasonable.
and the answer to that is "because of negative externalities"
The challenge for every generation and every society is to decide where to strike the balance between the individual and the group; it's never all one or the other, but always somewhere in between.
And I like this "your land isn't actually yours to do with whatever you please, no limits" idea. Count me in.
... new policy designed to stop soaring house prices ...
... said the new plan was designed to stop rising house prices and will apply to non-residents.
If someone else is willing to pay more the seller should have the opportunity to sell it to them. These laws privilege the desires of some buyers over both the desires of sellers and non-native buyers.
It looks like ban will apply to non-residents rather than non-native. If you're non resident, why do you want to buy? Rent to check out the city, get residency which you'd need to live in a country anyway, then buy.
I never said that I did.
> If someone else is willing to pay more the seller should have the opportunity to sell it to them. These laws privilege the desires of some buyers over both the desires of sellers and non-native buyers.
And if the areas in question had been rezoned to increase supply instead of reducing demand, that would have privileged the desires of a different group of people.
All laws privilege a certain set of desires over other sets of desires.
Why shouldn't people who live in an area have the right to decide how they want to collectively structure their lives and economics?
Housing is a human right, and lots of US cities have all kinds of regulations around affordable housing. I think we're not far at all from "you do have the right to buy a house at a particular price," we just dress it up in fancier language.
The sales of every good and service are regulated.
Capital transfers are regulated.
Taxes are based on different kinds of economic activity.
It's not even remotely strange that non-citizens should get a different tax treatment or whatever for sizeable personal assets.
I'm surprised that people are even allowed to do it in the first place.
I have no expectations that I can just 'go to China or Geramny and buy some houses'.
Therefore we need to consider other subtleties to the act of trading such assets: how are my assets impinging on other assets nearby? Is it butt-ugly, does it fit the local decor, does it drive insane density in the neighborhood, does it drive prices displacing neighbors at an unsustainable pace, does it disrupt the local community, anonymizing neighborly relations, does it damage residents’ way of life?
You see, to not about money alone
Some people are better than others because they are born closer. Let the others burn because as part of the ultra rich (almost all NZ people) I want to be richer and this seems to be the best way.
And nationalism isn't always bad, a group protecting members of that group (say based on geography) to the exclusion of the out-group is just how groups function.
"foreigner" is not a race, and isolationist or protectionist policies are rarely based on perceived attributes of specific races.
It's bad for the economy and NZ society.
But this is politics not rational thought.
> The Treaty established a British Governor of New Zealand, recognised Māori ownership of their lands, forests, and other properties, and gave Māori the rights of British subjects.
Although it was and remains a stark contrast to the way the British approached the natives and land of other colonies, there are ongoing issues with implementation today, see the link.
> Because the English and Māori versions of the Treaty differed significantly, there is no consensus as to exactly what was agreed upon.
So it does little to clarify. The Maori are a minority now. Anyone arguing that some of the land of NZ should not be sold to the highest bidder may want to explain how that relates to the not-so-ancient trade of all the land in NZ for compensation of a disputed nature and extent.
Only a vocal few are 'blaming it 100% on foreigners'. I say this as a foreigner in NZ.
What is recognized and being responded to here is that foreign investment in property/land in NZ is A factor contributing to the current housing bubble in the country. A factor. One factor. Not the factor.
How much of a factor? Difficult to establish since there has been wilful obfuscation of the facts. Right now the gathered official information on foreign property market activity in NZ puts it at anywhere from 3% to 57%. Yes, the data really is that flawed and it's likely not an accident.
Alongside this is a high rate of immigration (this is different from foreign investment land/property holdings, but the two do intertwine especially when it comes to properties being purchased by overseas students on temporary visas, which appears to be fairly widespread).
That's about it as far as factors that the racists and anti-racist racists can jump on board and shout about. Another factor is the geographic realities of NZ (while Auckland's low building height zoning seems unnecessary, it's very much a necessity for most of the rest of NZ which is one of the most earthquake-prone regions of the world).
Yet another factor is the expense and complications of constructing new housing stock here. First, the country's remoteness means a great deal of materials required must be shipped great distances and this costs both dollars and time. Second, there is a stranglehold monopoly on the supply of many building materials wherein a single corporate entity has managed to lobby for esoteric compliance requirements for said materials, to the point that they are functionally the only possible provider of said materials. Third a great portion of the building workforce has been tied up with the Christchurch rebuild (that little thing six years ago that pretty much levelled the third largest city in the country). This drove a reduction in workforce, materials and equipment availability for the rest of the country and so development has been consequently slower since. That rebuild is by no means complete.
Finally, zoning is not as simple as 'just do it'. Aside from the tectonic risk mentioned earlier, New Zealand maintains high percentages of protected green areas within it's cities, and aside from the aspirational and cultural reasons behind this, it's a important element of maintaining the country's overseas reputation as a clean, green tourism destination. Since that's 4% of GDP here (9% if you count the downstream stuff), it's important to maintain it, and chucking up dense residential, commercial, or industrial actively harms that reputation and will reduce GDP. On top of this, you can't simply change zoning and expect infrastructure to keep pace. It must be built to accommodate higher density and then the higher density can follow. As mentioned earlier, NZ's remoteness is a significant barrier to the kind of infrastructure investments required (and ten plus years ago too, if you want to look at solving the problems of today).
So, this is just a slice of what is a very complicated situation. I have by no means covered all the major factors above, just a few. This move to reduce foreign property speculation in NZ is sound, but only part of the picture. With any multi-faceted economic issue the impacts may not be exactly what is desired and the second-order effects of this might bring things that are even worse.
NZ is a country of immigration, and gives full rights to all citizens. This has nothing to do with where anyone is born.
> What gives .. any more rights than anyone else
Property rights are laws. They can be made, altered, and revoked. What gives NZ citizens the right to buy existing houses will be NZ laws, promulgated by a democratically elected parliament.
> This myopic nationalist mindset is ridiculous
There's a perfectly reasonable non-nationalist approach to this kind of law change, based on trying to keep housing available for people who can't bid against the global rich. I'm sure plenty of NZ progressives would love to protect the world's poor from the depredations of the 1%. But given the NZ parliament's limited jurisdiction (viz., to NZ), this seems like a reasonable start.
It's like going to your friend's house and rearranging the furniture there because "we were all born on planet Earth".
That's a different topic from what I was commenting on, ie. NZ's putative duty to write its laws for your lifestyle convenience.
And you mention living a transient lifestyle. Please tell me more about the property you own in Singapore then, because i'm sure you're happy paying a double digit percentage stamp duty in a not entirely stable market for 1-2 years of living here.
/s
administrative divisions on multiple levels make sense. this way i can politically participate in shaping society around my physical location. this has nothing to do with rejecting foreigner's ways of live, it's about having a voice in how your own surroundings work and then see how these compare to other places based on other choices on a wider stage.
Blanket banning foreigners from purchasing does 2 undesirable things. It stops people being able to lay foundations to eventually migrate and it deflects attention from the real solution (perhaps a third is that it encourage cross-border trade but I'm not sure of the reality around that). The real solution is to build denser urban areas with a suitable supply of high quality subsidised public housing. This allows the poorer inhabitants to firstly live in areas that are economically feasible and, secondly, it is well documented that higher density cities have increased economic output of a non-linear nature compared to low density cities. An added benefit is that by fitting more people into less space we reduce our environmental footprint. It should have been part of the Paris climate accord to force cities to zone for building up not out.
I also live in Singapore, and the high density here has a severe impact on quality of life (i'm using this term in a very wide sense here). I would never use this as a model for my home country. If anything, living here made me much more aware of the benefits of low population density.
Your 2 undesirable things might not be that undesirable for everyone.
Singapore offers a great quality of life. If you don't like it why do you stay here? High density has it's unique characteristics that may be less desirable for certain personalities but if you care about the environment and bio-diversity even in the slightest you would understand that taking a self-centred "I like my garden" approach to housing is absolutely the wrong way to go. This mindset has totally and utterly destroyed Ireland, my home country.
i didn't say i don't like it. i said i'm conscious of the consequences of high population density.
this is the first time i'm hearing about ireland being destroyed. do i need to send blankets? potatoes? :)
please cut the hyperbole, it's polarizing and not helpful.
Just because you house multiple families in the same building does not mean you head straight for highrise central or ultra high-density concrete slabs.
Not really. It isn't an acceptable drop in quality of life that I would ever be willing to take.
>Inner-city Paris
Not affordable. Most people live in high-rises in the outer areas. Also paris isn't very nice anymore anyway.
Most people don't. Unfortunately they also want to live close to work, which is probably closer to city centres, which is where almost everyone works, which means you can't simultaneously satisfy both desiderata. The greater good here is higher density housing, not aesthetics.
Why? It's clear that efficiency drops precipitously with increased latency, which increase with distance. Locality is thus critical to efficiency, not to mention resource distribution is far more efficient in denser areas.
> Also, moving from a house to an apartment sure isn't just aesthetics. It is a massive drop in quality of life.
Only if your apartment complex and neighbourhood was poorly planned. Focus on that.
Sounds like a great place to live
> Here's 97% of your house pricing problem. Not foreigners, not low interest rates, not land taxing policies.
Not really, you can still have a small city and keep it a that way if you keep the population under control and avoid speculation, which is sounds like what they're doing.
You could turn it into a big city like Los Angeles or Vancouver but that just creates different problems - and as they show - doesn't even keep prices low.
If you're seeking to artificially limit growth and prohibit buildings from being developed in the largest urban area in the country, than it'll inevitably suffocate economic growth as younger generations and entrepreneurs turn elsewhere.
> It will limit only unsustainable growth which would lower (possibility of) crisis usually following influx of cheap money (e.g. most of Europe in '08).
Funny, I was reading the statements about Auckland and thinking, this sounds exactly like Vancouver's problem. Parts of downtown are quite dense but the vast majority (80%) of the city is zoned SFH.
Vancouver is not a big city.
I'm not totally fond of the way NIMBYism ends up working, but the fact is that these people would otherwise have their land value degraded by amendments to local zoning. The rules for projects like this should at least include compensation for the decrease in assessed value of their property.
As an aside, apartments can be awesome, precisely because of the services that higher density housing allows. I own and live in one in the Melbourne CBD, I have amazing views, no need to drive for any services (groceries, doctors, liquor stores, restaurants, cafes and more in the same block). While a house might be tempting in some ways it terms of convenience it would inevitably be an enormous step backwards.
This is really what I was trying to get at: if you have a lot of land to potentially develop, and a relatively clean slate, you can get the best of both worlds in terms of convenience and hominess.
I think the world's most connected sprawl would inevitably be a better place than the world's tallest city core.
This would qualify as them having no option. If they want to live in the city, they want to live in the city; but if you're trying to make a city that people will continue to want to live in, apartment buildings may be the worst way to accomplish it.
Aucklanders seem to generally be against even Paris levels of density.
Auckland (or San Francisco) could greatly increase housing supply with fairly modest density increases.
Towers in/near the central business district have the distinct advantage of getting lots of people within walking distance of their offices. SOMA et al. also have low-rise commercial uses that can be converted to mixed uses. It's important to get as many units as we can out of this rare land, because tearing down existing housing is so destructive (and a total political non-starter). Our west, almost everything is already residential and is cheaper than whatever new construction would replace it (in the immediate term, which is all voters care about).
This has been recognised going back ... quite some time. A century or more, for cities. Millennia, at the scale of nations, empires, and/or tribes, back when "transit" generally meant some form of water-borne craft.
Muni hasn't had the will to add capacity. The physical possiblity exists, as evidenced by numerous cities around the world with far higher-capacity transit systems. (Though, admittedly, effectively none in the U.S., outside NYC.)
The most straightforward approach for SF would almost certainly be transit-designated routes, with no non-transit or non-emergency traffic allowed. There have been multiple plans for developing additional dedicated subway capacity, though in the case of SF, the common congestion and lack of a bypass trackway (either a third bypass route, or full dedicated dual trackage in both directions) along the Market Street route especially is a particular problem.
Longer trainsets (possibly breaking to two-car trolleys above ground, or remaining as, say, four-car systems on dedicated rights of way) would increase capacity.
Dedicated rail along major corridors (Geary, Irving, 3rd St. Market, Columbus, Sunset, etc.) might also help.
Housing prices rose during that time, but not commensurate with rent. I ended up buying a condo outside of town. But I'd rather have the flexibility of an apartment -- if I get a job farther away, I'm pretty much stuck with the condo, but if I had an apartment, I could live closer to work.
Did you mean: the sticks
Living in low rises is by no means not living around people. Nobody builds shophouses or townhouses in the boonies, to think that is to have a truly distorted view of the world.
The presence of high rises ultimately screws you in the end. Paris is cool (despite it being basically impossible to live there for real) because it's low-rise and cohesive. There is one big shiny eyesore of a plinth which has haunted the place since its construction. Sure, if there's a concentrated business community, a block approved for high rise development is going to be valuable to them, but it degrades the surrounding area.
A continuous genuine low rise city like Auckland is a nightmare, and a hypothetical continuous high rise city (does one exist?) would be similar. Continuous mid rise like Paris, Barcelona etc is probably better than either, but having a good mix would improve things.
This is an economic solution. They chose to lower demand to keep prices down. If you would do something differently, say raise supply to keep prices down, how would you do that? Would you make more land? What would happen to people who you rezoned out of their houses?
Yes, I did read the comment I replied to. I asked how supply would be increased, because I want to know how he would do that. Hence, why I asked him what he would propose.
You didn't answer the question either, simply restating dissatisfaction with how people live. So, what would _you_ do to increase supply instead of decreasing demand?
P.S. Nobody is outlawing the making of homes. That's false hyperbole on your part.
What point are you trying to make? The article doesn't talk about people being banned from building houses but about a ban on foreigners purchasing homes.
1-https://theintercept.com/2016/08/14/nsa-gcsb-prism-surveilla...
Oh goodness, have you been suckered into the 'illegal gardening' joke?
>A man set himself on fire to protest the horrible family court system
That man's wife had left him and taken their kid to Japan. I'm not sure what kind of non-horrible family court system you imagine NZ could have, which would be able to direct outcomes in the Japanese system.
As for family court, you know in NZ it is a frequent but macabe quip: it is easier to kill your wife than divorce her? People say that for a reason, and people don't just light themselves on fire so easily.
I live in NZ and I've never heard anybody say this. You should think twice before repeating horrible comments on the internet. Particularly comments about violence against women.
Also, I grow a number of avocados at my NZ home. They are not illegal.
What if New Zealanders don't want apartment buildings?
They just want to be able to live in affordable homes?
I'll give you a more direct economic argument: when a foreigner 'buys a home' in say, Toronto - what they are benefitting from is the 'stability of the economy' - which is paid for by the local citizens. The legal system, justice system, heck - even the education system - all play a factor in 'keeping those home prices up'. So it's only fair that foreigners pay more taxes - otherwise they are externalizing those costs, just like a company dumping Co2 in the air.
Having lived in SF, Toronto, Paris and London - I'm acutely aware of how this globalism issue is working out.
I also lived in Germany were real estate prices are very stable.
We do not want 'free trade' for our domiciles - this is not a solution.
If you are not living in a home - it should be taxed - if you are not a citizen, taxes should be higher.
If's funny people are accusing Jacinda of 'Venezuela' i.e. socialism - if Donald Trump did this - they'd call him a 'Nationalist' or 'Fascist' or whatever.
There will always be 'internal problems' but the globalization of homes has to be addressed.
75% of Auckland is zoned for 1 or 2 story buildings (according to http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&o...).
Of that 33% is the most restrictive single house ("The Single House zone currently covers around a third of residential Auckland and is very restrictive, allowing for only one dwelling on sections smaller than 600 square metres." according to http://www.stuff.co.nz/auckland/75219048/Aucklands-controver...).
5% is zoned for apartment buildings.
Here's 97% of your house pricing problem. Not foreigners, not low interest rates, not land taxing policies.
New Zealand has total population of ~2x Paris and land 1000x of Paris.
This is Venezuela style of fixing problems: instead of addressing underlying economics (limited supply meeting increasing demand causing raising prices) by increasing supply, find a political scapegoat (all nations are xenophobic so outsiders are always a good target) to get people to vote for you and create ineffective rules.
The real fix is politically unpopular. Unsurprisingly, Aucklanders are NIMBY with the best of them. The plan to upzone is "controversial" and anti-upzoning arguments are the same you see in SF and everywhere else where that comes up.