News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by microcolonel on Thursday October 26, 2017 @07:29PM (#15564180)
Apartments suck. Most people vastly prefer not to live near them or in them if they have the option. If they have 1000x the land (still remembering that a lot of that is grazing land), then what they need is transport, houses, shophouses, townhomes, and lowrises. If the land price is higher in the the middle of town, then so be it. At least the current residents aren't having the sky systematically parceled away by a corrupt bureaucracy for paltry favours.

I'm not totally fond of the way NIMBYism ends up working, but the fact is that these people would otherwise have their land value degraded by amendments to local zoning. The rules for projects like this should at least include compensation for the decrease in assessed value of their property.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:16PM (#15565138)
Hell no there should be no compensation; the entire goal of the government should be to crash prices hard and if increasing density achieves that by simultaneously increasing supply _and_ decreasing values due to people having to see higher density property then that's a double win.

As an aside, apartments can be awesome, precisely because of the services that higher density housing allows. I own and live in one in the Melbourne CBD, I have amazing views, no need to drive for any services (groceries, doctors, liquor stores, restaurants, cafes and more in the same block). While a house might be tempting in some ways it terms of convenience it would inevitably be an enormous step backwards.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by microcolonel on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:47PM (#15565303)
> While a house might be tempting in some ways in terms of convenience it would inevitably be an enormous step backwards.

This is really what I was trying to get at: if you have a lot of land to potentially develop, and a relatively clean slate, you can get the best of both worlds in terms of convenience and hominess.

I think the world's most connected sprawl would inevitably be a better place than the world's tallest city core.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:28AM (#15565922)
I think that's inherently wrong; you need a mixture of densities, but everything low density sprawl is a nightmare. Increasing average density has benefits even for the left over areas of low density, e.g. reduced traffic, lower infrastructure costs per resident, lower average distance to amenities.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by harryh on Thursday October 26, 2017 @09:04PM (#15564741)
This comment reminds me of the old Yogi Berra gem: "Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded." If people didn't want to live in downtown apartments the prices wouldn't be so high.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by closeparen on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:11PM (#15565107)
This is a non sequitor. The “nobody likes high rises” argument is about the people who don’t want to look at high rises. Obviously their aesthetic satisfaction is more important that others having places to live.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:18PM (#15565147)
The OP mentioned living in them, so the reply was on point - clearly some people _do_ want to live in them. I love my apartment, but would admittedly be less keen on suburban apartment living as the convenience factor would probably not be so hot.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by microcolonel on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:33PM (#15565224)
> ...if they have the option

This would qualify as them having no option. If they want to live in the city, they want to live in the city; but if you're trying to make a city that people will continue to want to live in, apartment buildings may be the worst way to accomplish it.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by closeparen on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:49PM (#15565321)
If it contains only small buildings, it isn't a city. Perhaps you mean village, town, or suburb?
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by microcolonel on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:57PM (#15565346)
I have a hard time labeling it. A sprawling continuous town centre is really what I'm thinking of: low rises, shophouses, some mid-rises. But ideally fewer mechanistic glass plinths blocking out the sky. I just think you can justify the amenities and convenience of a well developed city without half the buildings being forty or more floors.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by closeparen on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:20PM (#15565443)
I like such places and I think they should exist. I grew up in one. The problem is insisting that global centers of industry and culture should also be that way.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:29AM (#15565928)
Consistent low to mid density sprawl is pretty much the worst of all possible worlds. You need a mixture of densities.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by closeparen on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:33AM (#15565944)
It's Los Angeles, isn't it?
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by dredmorbius on Friday October 27, 2017 @12:48PM (#15570064)
Paris achieves high densities with almost entirely low-rse structres.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:02PM (#15572943)
Depends on your definitions I guess; I call Auckland's 1-2 story sprawl low, I don't call Paris' 5 story sprawl low.

Aucklanders seem to generally be against even Paris levels of density.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by dredmorbius on Saturday October 28, 2017 @05:21AM (#15574524)
Point being that 10, 50, or 100 story towers, and the resulting oppressiveness, aren't necessary.

Auckland (or San Francisco) could greatly increase housing supply with fairly modest density increases.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by closeparen on Sunday October 29, 2017 @05:11AM (#15578613)
You would need huge increases in transit capacity to do that, and it would probably also push car-accessible streets to the point of total uselessness, wrecking any bus service that doesn't have dedicated lanes. The buses and trains from San Francisco's low-rise districts to its downtown are already crush loaded and Muni doesn't seem to be capable of adding capacity.

Towers in/near the central business district have the distinct advantage of getting lots of people within walking distance of their offices. SOMA et al. also have low-rise commercial uses that can be converted to mixed uses. It's important to get as many units as we can out of this rare land, because tearing down existing housing is so destructive (and a total political non-starter). Our west, almost everything is already residential and is cheaper than whatever new construction would replace it (in the immediate term, which is all voters care about).

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by dredmorbius on Sunday October 29, 2017 @08:56AM (#15579125)
Yes, curiously enough, increasing density does require increasing infrastructure, including transit capacity.

This has been recognised going back ... quite some time. A century or more, for cities. Millennia, at the scale of nations, empires, and/or tribes, back when "transit" generally meant some form of water-borne craft.

Muni hasn't had the will to add capacity. The physical possiblity exists, as evidenced by numerous cities around the world with far higher-capacity transit systems. (Though, admittedly, effectively none in the U.S., outside NYC.)

The most straightforward approach for SF would almost certainly be transit-designated routes, with no non-transit or non-emergency traffic allowed. There have been multiple plans for developing additional dedicated subway capacity, though in the case of SF, the common congestion and lack of a bypass trackway (either a third bypass route, or full dedicated dual trackage in both directions) along the Market Street route especially is a particular problem.

Longer trainsets (possibly breaking to two-car trolleys above ground, or remaining as, say, four-car systems on dedicated rights of way) would increase capacity.

Dedicated rail along major corridors (Geary, Irving, 3rd St. Market, Columbus, Sunset, etc.) might also help.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by Johnny555 on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:34PM (#15565235)
I like apartments, and would probably still live in one if I lived in an area with reasonable rent control. The last time I lived in an apartment, the rent raised 20% one year, 20% a year later, and then I left when they wanted to raise it nearly 30%. (original rent was $2000, the last rent increase pushed it over $3500)

Housing prices rose during that time, but not commensurate with rent. I ended up buying a condo outside of town. But I'd rather have the flexibility of an apartment -- if I get a job farther away, I'm pretty much stuck with the condo, but if I had an apartment, I could live closer to work.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by wbl on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:19PM (#15565153)
Being able to build a high-rise on your property increases its value. So sell out and move to the hicks if you don't like living around people.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by microcolonel on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:41PM (#15565271)
> ...the hicks...

Did you mean: the sticks

Living in low rises is by no means not living around people. Nobody builds shophouses or townhouses in the boonies, to think that is to have a truly distorted view of the world.

The presence of high rises ultimately screws you in the end. Paris is cool (despite it being basically impossible to live there for real) because it's low-rise and cohesive. There is one big shiny eyesore of a plinth which has haunted the place since its construction. Sure, if there's a concentrated business community, a block approved for high rise development is going to be valuable to them, but it degrades the surrounding area.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:31AM (#15565937)
We might be talking at cross purposes to some extend; Paris is not what I would call low rise, it's far more dense than Auckland is (and Auckland is low rise).

A continuous genuine low rise city like Auckland is a nightmare, and a hypothetical continuous high rise city (does one exist?) would be similar. Continuous mid rise like Paris, Barcelona etc is probably better than either, but having a good mix would improve things.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by wbl on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:07PM (#15570248)
Manhattan comes close to continuous high rise.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:01PM (#15572561)
True, quite a lot of the southern end of it does... and Manhattan is awesome, vastly preferable to endless low rise sprawl.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by wbl on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:07PM (#15570241)
Paris low rises are 5 stories, which is basically illegal in much of the Bay.