Speculative real estate investment is a direct result of restrictive zoning. Consider for example an already developed area of a city that is zoned for single family residential. This makes it illegal for a developer to increase supply in this region by building, say a duplex. A developer is allowed to rebuild a house, but not increase supply.
So of course there is speculative investment! Owners have a legal guarantee of resource scarcity. It’s the reason governments everywhere try to avoid deflation; it causes everyone to hold onto their cash.
Now contrast the situation when a developer can turn a house into a duplex. Supply is elastic. There’s no legal guarantee of scarcity. Of course real estate is still an investment vehicle, but there is no longer the artificial constraint on supply.
I also think it’s weird to lump this in with environmental protection. Preserving natural areas is an unassailably important priority for any nation. What does that have to do with home owners that feel they have a legal right to not live next to a condo? I don’t think the parent (or really anyone here) is advocating we develop undeveloped land.
Finally, I wonder if this is all moot, because the issue at hand is a restriction of foreign ownwers. Won’t native NZ real estate companies be glad to step in to fill the void? Can’t these companies then just shell shares to international investors?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_real_estate_bubble_of_...
""" As a result of these factors, prices for land in the Chicago Loop rose from essentially nothing in 1830 ($800 per acre in 2012 dollars) to New York levels by 1836 ($327,000 per acre in 2012 dollars), a 40,775% increase, with even higher prices around Dearborn Avenue and the Chicago River.[3] Furthermore, Illinois in general experienced a huge boom in real estate prices and town foundations. Walters estimates that the foundations of 1/3 of all towns ever created in central Illinois occurred between 1835 and 1837.[4]
In 1837, there was widespread panic due to credit tightening from England. On May 29, 1837, as depositors began to withdraw money en masse, Illinois banks suspended payments. As these banks fell into bankruptcy, Illinois’ internal improvements, like the canals that were supposed to be financed by the banks, stopped. This led to considerable uncertainty as to Chicago's future, and combined with a general lack of credit, caused Chicago real estate prices to fall approximately 88% from their peak by 1841.[3] """
By definition, it's not. It's a term coined to separate out the impact on prices of people buying-to-live vs people buying-to-sell/rent-and-profit. And if foreigners are more likely to buy for speculative purposes, barring them from doing so will decrease speculative increases in house prices.
Imagine if the stocks of public companies were not fixed in supply. The company at any time could simply decide to have shares for 200%, 300%, or 1000% without compensating existing shareholders in any way. If that was the case, stocks would be total garbage as an investment. Prices would plummet to 0.
The reason metro real estate is so attractive as an investment is because supply is inelastic. If we want to encourage usage, as oppose to hoarding, we should do like we do with fiat currencies and allow more of it to be made.
Banning foreigners might have some tiny effect, but honestly seems a bit like arranging deck chairs on the Titanic. We can check in after a year, but all my money is on Auckland continuing to have an expensive housing market (unless they allow more rezoning). Further, banning foreigners of course is also banning a valuable export and will cut off a stream of foreign money that was previously flowing into the local economy.
Investing in real estate would be purchasing property for its income earning potential.
Speculating would be purchasing for capital gains potential.
You might argue that people do both at once but if you would only make the purchase if there is a potential for capital gains and not otherwise, then you are speculating.
> Speculation is a method of short-term investing whereby traders essentially bet on the direction an asset's price will move.
This is what most people would assume speculation to mean in the context of this discussion. It is quite normal to compare this type of speculative investment with other - especially productive - investment.
Rent and profit is a great investment for the general public. Thats not speculation, thats straight down investment.
Buy to sell is speculation, in the sense that it might not be representing the underlying risks. But even then its doubtful: if you think construction materials will rise 20% in the next year, buying your house to day and sitting on it is a sound investment, one that benefits the whole.
Speculator is an overused word to depict an enemy that kills itself.
You make no sense, all investment is speculation.
While they may have the same meaning in a general sense, and are synonyms from a distance, once you get up close, you can distinguish meaning between them.
That's just how English works. Huge and colossal are the same until you pull out the D&D sourcebook, and then it turns out that colossal is bigger than huge.
Market failure, policy failure, awful planning.
Living here, it's hugely disheartening to see a similar pattern emerging so shortly after a massive crash.
I live in Cork, population ~200k. In 2012, I rented a 2 bed apartment in the city centre for €750 a month. Now, I would be lucky to get a decent 1 bed apartment for €1000. And because bank lending rules tightened after 2008, opportunities to purchase a house/apartment have narrowed. Therefore, those (and families in particular) who cannot purchase have been on the receiving end of the spiraling rents. It took the government till late 2016 to put the brakes on the rent increases by creating "rental pressure zones".
https://www.reuters.com/article/ireland-economy-housing/irel...
Auckland is adding apartments, albeit not at a sufficient rate. Their rents are high enough to make building them profitable. What does that say? It means that local resident demand is high enough to support investment of high-density residential areas.
Auckland's demand is significantly fueled by speculative investors, to be sure. What props up the house prices are the Kiwi families moving to Auckland for better work opportunities.
What Sydney and Melbourne are experiencing is a lack of rental support for their high house prices. That cannot be sustainable.
I'm amazed it was that low. I was inspecting recently and I was blown away, it was like a ghost town. I checked out the carparks of these massive buildings and they were basically completely empty, it was crazy.
The methodology of the Speculative Vacancies Report involves gathering water usage data for all properties. That can mean that if a property is occupied for a single month it isn't counted. A lot of the Docklands apartments appear to be not only vacant investments, but also short-term rentals and 'city pads', so I'm not at all surprised that it appears more like a ghost town than the figures suggest it might.
If there is excess capital, it's the fault of the central banks.
No.
The issue is corruption and lack of distribution of surpluses in developing economies, specifically China.
Think: China is poor on a per-capita basis. So why are so many Chinese trying to hard to get their $$$ out of there? Mass corruption etc..
Westerners send a lot of $$$ to China - and if there were labour laws, environmental laws (i.e. democracy) then those surpluses would be spread more evenly across China. 'Regular' chinese people want to buy a home, a car a TV - but since the money is so heavily focused on a small portion of citizens - they have 'mass surpluses' and want to get their money out. So it comes back to the West.
You mentioned 'lack of investment' - this can't be the case - as there are still hundreds of millions of Chinese people who still don't have proper homes and are way behind in terms of material standards of living.
If they were paid more - they'd have more surplus $ to spend on 'homes and stuff' and guess what? Local investments would make more sense.
We can't have free trade with nations that regulate their economies in fundamentally different ways than ours. If a country for example, allows mass pollution - well - that externalization is a massive economic advantage, kind of like a 'government subsidy'.
The best way to deflate the Western housing bubble - and to fix the internal problems in China is to spread the wealth in China. Arguably US needs a little more of this as well.
Wealth is not currency wealth is things of value, and we have systemic issues with profits from investments being reinvested instead of being spent, as everyone is looking for returns. This inflates the value of things that create future income streams.
It only takes about 5% of home buyers to be foreign buyers who are 'price inelastic' (i.e. they will pay above market/any price) to create a housing bubble.
If the capital were not in their hands, but more distributed through the NZ economy, I suggest that capital would be deployed differently than just in real estate.
*Like gold it can act as a hedge, but long term inflation they has negative returns when you include maintenance costs aka vaults are not free.
Agreed.
And guess what - many of the foreign buyers leave the homes empty.
That they would even do this is evidence of how crazy the economic mismatch is.
Which is why foreigners should not be able to buy property. Doubly important if they are not going to live in it.
...or perhaps property investment is encouraged by the tax system, is favoured by lenders, etc.
Homes in Dublin under €175 (asking, at least) http://www.daft.ie/dublin-city/houses-for-sale/?s%5Bmxp%5D=1...
Also, green space is nice but it is worth considering that the actual natural environment of this island was lost between 1000 and 500 years ago. It used to be nearly all forest, but grazing animals are death to forest as they eat the saplings.
I don't think it works
Oversupply is a problem for owners, not for renters and newcomers. The very people buying property and parking it are not making a sound investment, and they will naturally pay the price for it.
If what is happening is that speculators are dumping all this cash to make properties, then the best course of action is to do nothing. Eventually they will lose, but the buildings are still there. And there is plenty of space to build around. Housing is not a limited asset like its often portrayed. Its truly unlimited, thats why you can find land almost for free.
I don't know if it has been covered specifically about NZ, but otherwise yes, many many times. For example: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/07/nyregion/more-apartments-a... https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/08/nyregion/stream-of-foreig... http://nymag.com/news/features/foreigners-hiding-money-new-y...
I'm still curious whether it has been covered in NZ. Canada, like NZ, is also a commonwealth country, and it's only recently that it is even remotely common that "reasonable people" dare broach such subjects. I find it rather interesting that my comment was heavily downvoted and flagged, as if there is an initiative to silence any voice that dare even suggest immigration may not be absolutely necessary. Is it truly possible that all countries on the planet need more immigration, and in all cases the need is greater than the associated harm?
Was Hans Rosling also a "racist"?
Melbourne is also experiencing a housing crisis similar to Auckland's due to a boom in prices.
So should Melbourne also pull out all the stops to encourage new building? Interestingly, Prosper Australia has been tracking Melbourne's true vacancy rate for over a decade now, publishing their findings in their Speculative Vacancies Report[1].
Before you look at the report, a couple of questions:
1) Do you believe prices are being driven up due to a shortage of homes? (Your comment suggests you do.)
2) If prices were being driven up due to a shortage of homes, would you expect the areas that experience the highest capital gains to have the lowest vacancy rates? (I think most people would agree with this.)
Now, the most interesting finding from the Speculative Vacancies Report for me was that in fact, contrary to what most people would expect, areas with the highest capital gains correlate strongly with those areas that have highest number of empty dwellings.
My own suspicion is that the demand that is driving up prices is not demand for homes, but demand for investments. A speculative boom creates extra demand.
In 2007, the Irish thought they had an undersupply of housing. A short time later it was revealed that they actually had a massive oversupply (once investment/speculative demand was removed). The RBA in Australia is pointing to the same thing in Melbourne (Docklands has a vacancy rate of ~25%+, other sought after areas are approaching 15-20% according to the report mentioned above).
The best thing that Auckland can do to tackle house prices is to address the demand side of the supply and demand equation. There are tonnes of options for doing this but mostly this is an issue caused by easy credit and tax incentives for investing in property. That's the place to solve this problem. It would be folly to encroach on green areas or otherwise spoil our environment in a mad rush to build. If we do that... Ireland here we come!
[1] https://www.prosper.org.au/2015/12/09/speculative-vacancies-...