News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by alkonaut on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:41AM (#15565979)
Are they bought as speculation by foreign residents?If that's the case then just fix it by making it less attractive to buy for speculation. For example, a tax on property matched with a deduction on income. If you don't have any income then the property tax would be higher than any expected yearly gain in property prices.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by h0l0cube on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:59AM (#15566047)
> For example, a tax on property matched with a deduction on income.

You mean income derived from the property? Seems like that could inflate rental prices, and shift the affordability problem to another set of people.

The state government in Victoria (Australia) is planning to tax vacant properties, but it's self reported and seems easy enough to dodge. At first the proposed measuring water usage to determine if the property was vacant, but then you can only tax as much as it would cost to leave a tap on.

http://www.sro.vic.gov.au/node/5816

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by alkonaut on Friday October 27, 2017 @02:05AM (#15566075)
> You mean income derived from the property?

No, a regular property tax based on the value of the property. Such as 1% of the value paid in tax every year.

The idea would be that it would be zero net effect if you live in the country (i.e. it's a property tax + income tax deduction that effectively make them together be a "tax on properties owned by foreigners")

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by bdamm on Friday October 27, 2017 @04:42AM (#15566684)
Tempting, but what if I live in the country and own two properties? Then do I get to perform the deduction twice? If not, then am I punished for having two properties? It would be pretty tough to fine tune this.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by lhopki01 on Friday October 27, 2017 @04:53AM (#15566730)
Yes you should be 'punished' for owning two properties. Or more specifically if you are well off enough to own two properties then you are well off enough to pay for them.

Property should not be an investment since it is an essential for living.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by bdamm on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:15AM (#15567068)
Yes, but the idea was to boost property tax for the purpose of avoiding foreign investment. I'm saying that this might suppress domestic land ownership as well. Someone is going to be the land-lord, it might as well be domestic.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by lhopki01 on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @04:35AM (#15591750)
Why exactly do we need much private rental accommodation. Singapore seems to be doing very well without a market based approach to housing.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by ericd on Friday October 27, 2017 @02:49AM (#15566244)
I agree with you that tax incentives are the way to tackle it. I think the issue with this specific proposal is for people on low/fixed incomes (typically retirees). I think the normal way to do this is via a high property tax and then a "homestead exemption" that you take if you live in the property.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by alkonaut on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:03AM (#15566278)
> "homestead exemption" that you take if you live in the property.

Exactly. But the idea is that it's very hard to check whether someone lives in a property, so you check for the next best thing: whether you have income in the country. So if you have income tax in the country then you can get exempt from one property tax.

Otherwise you end up having things like "self reporting" where you live, or local governments trying to check water/electricity use to see whether buildings are occupied etc, which are obviously both expensive and futile.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by ericd on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:12PM (#15570294)
Good point. So what if homes have to have a single name/id attached to them, and a single identity can only claim one homestead exemption statewide (and ideally states would share data) and you have to file state income taxes to get them. No homestead exemption for company held houses, no second exemptions if you're a dependent or you file married/jointly. Still not sure how one could handle the case where someone lives in a state but pays no tax, since you can do that for nearly free in a state you don't live in. Maybe it could take age into account.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @05:50AM (#15566965)
No exemptions, tax them all. Homes will, ironically, be cheaper if they're taxed because it will further drive out speculative money.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by alkonaut on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:45AM (#15567168)
Yes I'm not saying property taxes are inherently bad, but this would need to be pretty high, such as property taxes of e.g. 5-10% of the market value. Probably a bit hard to swallow for e.g. people who have retired and have bought their homes ages ago for say $100k and it's now worth $1M and the pensions doesn't cover the $50k annual property. Moving would net the couple $900k minus a hefty chunk in profit tax, after which they can't afford buying a new home. We had this situation here and it's not good.

You could have a 10% market value property tax, and a deduction of 90% of that amount, for one home, on your income tax, then 75% for a second property etc, to make it both prohibitively expensive for foreigners, and a bit progressive for those owning multiple homes.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:19AM (#15567325)
OK,fair call; I don't want to drive people out of their homes, I want to a) crash prices and b) keep them low, so I'd prefer to tax gains (even paper ones) in combination with other speculative disincentives (mainly the removal of the current incentives and special treatment). In an ideal situation no revenue is collected from capital gains because there are none to tax...
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by akadruid1 on Friday October 27, 2017 @10:05AM (#15568352)
Your policy of "crash prices and keep them low" has the greatest impact on owner-occupiers. If you look at historic collapse of housing bubbles, it's the negative equity / underwater owner-occupiers who suffer losing their home or losing their mobility. Speculators simply shrug it off since they have the flexibility to move their investments.

An increase in average wage growth would support both owner-occupiers and first time buyers.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @05:58PM (#15572545)
Most owners are not impacted by "crash prices and keep them low" because they have experienced enormous capital growth. Auckland prices have doubled in the last four years; a 50% crash would leave almost everyone in the property market before then no worse off.

Speculators can move their investments, but they have to accept the loss in order to do that.

An increase in wages without fixing the underlying drivers for property price growth will not support owner occupiers or first time buyers at all, because property price growth will match or exceed that growth.

Crash prices, keep them low and stable after, it will be rough and unpopular for a while but will eventually be the best outcome.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by ericd on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:05PM (#15570231)
There are deep structural reasons for the lack of wage growth, so that's not a feasible near-term solution.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by elyobo on Friday October 27, 2017 @05:58PM (#15572551)
It's not a solution over any time period, because without fixing the drivers of the price growth in the property market any increase in purchasing power will be met with property price growth to absorb it.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by ericd on Sunday October 29, 2017 @06:05PM (#15581717)
Good point, I agree.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by conanbatt on Monday October 30, 2017 @07:06PM (#15589786)
The goal is not cheap housing, its the amount of people that get homes.
Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by naasking on Friday October 27, 2017 @08:51AM (#15567779)
> So if you have income tax in the country then you can get exempt from one property tax.

This is easily gamed if Chinese millionaires are truly at fault. They just set up a numbered corporation and "employ" their nephew whose living there.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by alkonaut on Friday October 27, 2017 @09:02AM (#15567866)
Seems to be more difficult than leaving the tap on at least.

Further, if people are actually employed and paid, they also pay income taxes. So now the property is even higher cost. Since to pay a person a minimum wage over the year (and the taxes and added costs that gives) is probably more than the property tax for foreigners would have been. Most importantly, the cost of either the property tax or the income tax solution should be higher than any expected gains in the property value (or at least enough to make it useless as an investment).

The best way to game this system would probably be to shadow own it behind some 18year old that has a full time job but lives at home. They have the tax space to make the deduction.

Re:New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses by raquo on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:55AM (#15566032)
The new BC government was planning to implement such a tax. Until they were elected, now no one really knows.