What are the benefits of exporting any work whatsoever?
> Why would foreigners invest in the construction of new rental homes or apartment buildings if the rental price wasn't high enough to profit from?
This is a good question. There is an expectation that rents will rise in the next decade, so that could explain a healthy market reaction. An unhealthy one might be capital flight from China, so investors are willing to take a loss becaue its lower than the taxes/restrictions china has on that money. Housing has exploded globally, its not a local nz problem.
And housebuilding is not linked only to rent, but rather to sale prices: if homeowning is culturally valued, people will pay to buy at higher prices.
With the current (in most countries) banking system, the money available for investing is not limited by the quantity of money in the system, but by the availability of projects with a good return.
A commercial bank can create money if they think that they will have a good return (risk wise). Banks don't lean reserves.
An investor can borrow money from a bank if it has a good project.
Interest rates are decided by the Central Bank depending of the goals for the country economy.
So, the idea of "money available for investing" doesn't make sense in the current fiat economies.
The value of land is proportional to the income you can get from using it, so the forces that regulate land value and rent are irrelevant to the amount of land, but with what you can get from them. If tomorrow Auckland duplicated wages, rentals would skyrocket there, without changing demographics or land.
Assuming it was true that this is such a net positive benefit to a city, it sounds like it stops working very quickly. The second sell on the property is now a foreigner to either a city local, which would siphon the money out of the city, or from a foreigner to another.
So this would only work to increase the city's cash flow temporarily, or in the case where the property depreciate and the foreigner incurs a less.
As long as authorities crack down on loopholes (like foreigners buying property through a fake company, and then selling the company to avoid real estate tax over property sales; or keeping properties empty for an unreasonable amount of time in the face of housing shortages), it's a net positive.
It supplies a property for rent (i.e. it's not like the property disappears), and the extra demand increases the value of properties the locals own.
I think it's only really problematic if capital is cheaper for foreigners than locals.
In that I mean, I feel you'll only get foreign investment to grow your city once its already too expensive to live in. As they build more and it becomes affordable again, they'd stop investing, and it will become unaffordable again. Keeping the city in a perpetual state of unaffordability.
I don't see how this logic is restricted to foreigners. The argument seems to be universally applicable, which makes me suspicious: why wouldn't investment grow the city until rent falls to the cost of capital + maintenance etc.?
(I think the argument doesn't actually work because of the nature of property: location, amenities, services, community; things whose supply isn't easily increased simply by capital. But if it did work to some extent, it would still apply to nationals just as well.)
Which is exactly the problem. Housing is for living, not speculating. Basic human needs should probably not be subject to such speculation.
That said, regulations in building new housing can also exacerbate this problem. At the very least, density should be increasing at approximately the rate of population growth in a region, or you will obviously have a growing sprawl problem.
You are looking at the wrong culprit. If there is a piece of undeveloped land, and a foreigner builds a house completely uninhabited, the housing stock in the market has a delta of 0. If there is an owner that sells their house to a foreigner and buys a new one, the housing stock is till the same. They dont affect supply in abstract, they affect supply if there are significant zoning restrictions that do create artifical scarcity.
We're not talking about supply, we're talking about price. The OP said, "and the extra demand increases the value of properties the locals own." Increasingly unaffordable housing is exactly the problem.
It's a vote-winner though, and property is most people's biggest investment asset. It's a Ponzi scheme, but it's hard to avoid.
My main point was addressed to the economic argument being put forward, however; that it wasn't specific to "foreigners". "Foreigners" as a culprit are a red herring.
Right, that's why I said "speculation" and not "foreign ownership" in my reply. Holding periods for ownership, non-residential use must be rented out, etc.
1. What are the benefits to a city and its local inhabitants of a foreigner buying an existing residential home that it will not inhabit?
It seems there are none to me, unless the city taxes that home way way more.
2. Why would foreigners invest in the construction of new rental homes or apartment buildings if the rental price wasn't high enough to profit from?
In that I mean, I feel you'll only get foreign investment to grow your city once its already too expensive to live in. As they build more and it becomes affordable again, they'd stop investing, and it will become unaffordable again. Keeping the city in a perpetual state of unaffordability.