News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by flowerlad on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:16PM (#50047373)
This will have no impact on Adobe's shenanigans. They offer click-to-cancel, but then charge a cancellation fee equal to what you would have paid for the rest of the one-year term. Their clever justification is that you received a significant discount for committing to a year, so you still owe them for the remaining months if you cancel early. I didn't even realize I had signed up for a one-year commitment. I'm not sure where they buried that clause.

I expect more businesses will transition to this strategy to counter NYC's new rule. They won't necessarily lower the price, but you will have to sign up for a one-year term, then they will hit you with a massive cancellation fee if you "click to cancel".

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by deadbunny on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:20PM (#50047421)
I hate to defend Adobe but it literally says "Annually, paid monthly" right under the price.

They should for sure list the annual price and the monthly price but it's not "burried".

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by alistairSH on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:29PM (#50047493)
So it's not really a cancellation fee, but is that how they message it?

If I see: "Annual Subscription - $120/year, billed $10/month" I assume I'm paying $120 even if I cancel after 6 months.

But, if I cancel after 6 months, and the message to me is "$60 cancellation fee", I'm very confused - I thought I was paying the remaining $60 I owe them...? The amount may be the same but it's confusing nonetheless.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by firtoz on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:42PM (#50047623)
Wait, so you'll pay the $60, and then, will you lose access?
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by alistairSH on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:24PM (#50047958)
Any time I've had a similar subscription, you retain access for the full period.

The messaging has usually been something like: "Annual subscription cancelled at the end of current period. Access ends on 12/31/2026" (even if today is 6/1/2026)

That's why the "cancellation fee" comment is weird to me - there's no need to message that way, since "pay the rest of the committed period" seems to be a common (and at least to me, very understandable) way to handle this.

Even with monthly services, I don't think I've ever had an immediate loss of access - it's there until the end of the billing cycle. As it should be, IMO. The only exception would be if I force-deleted my account as well as that's a very explicit "I'm done-done" signal to the service provider.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by gruez on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:53PM (#50047705)
Probably? There are services that are relatively nice and will let you use your membership until the last day (even for trials!), but there's also others that are non-refundable and will just yank your access.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by ericd on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:40PM (#50048087)
Hm so you're saying all the SaaS runners should put "Lifetime, paid monthly" in small print under their price? Bam, goodbye churn.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by mathgeek on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:55PM (#50047720)
The cancellation fee is usually the part that's buried.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by gruez on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:58PM (#50047748)
Maybe years ago, but today it very plainly says:

>Fee applies of half your remaining annual commitment if you cancel after Nov 01

and for the prepaid option

>No refund if you cancel after Nov 01

https://www.adobe.com/#mini-plans-web-cta-creative-cloud-car...

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by adolph on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:55PM (#50048259)
> They should for sure list the annual price and the monthly price but it's not "burried".

Buried prices are the next frontier of consumer protection. I've gotten burned by looking up a store product online and then when attempting to purchase finding that unless you ordered it through the site for in-store pickup, you get a higher price. Car dealerships were the same the last time I bought one. And while I appreciate Tesla's challenge in expressing TCO, subtracting average fuel costs from the price of a car smells bad in the same way.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by soulofmischief on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:21PM (#50047943)
Seems intentionally manipulative.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by binlog on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:29PM (#50047491)
With LLMs in the picture there’s no excuse for signing a contract without reading it because it was too long or hard to understand. Adobe makes its terms pretty clear. You are entering a one year commitment.
[dead]
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by mzajc on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:39PM (#50048706)
This is brilliant news, I can't wait for a future without OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, and the like.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by Loughla on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:11PM (#50047850)
I feel real dumb asking this but how will AI help here? I'm sick, so if this is a stupid question, let's say it's because of that.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:40PM (#50048713)
> how will AI help here?

I've been using Claude in what I call iKaren mode. Basically, all the little complaints where I know I'm in the right against a large corporate other but don't want to get emotionally invested into a petty dispute go to it.

I recently had a room in Milan where they were rude at the rooftop–I was ignored after being seated for thirty minutes–and then refused to enable A/C (which they could do remotely) until I called twice, finally yielding at 1AM. I had a terrible night's rest and, resultantly, difficult day of travel the next day. It was a single night at an expensive hotel–I'd ordinarily ignore it.

This time, I passed my booking details and a short blurb to Claude. Between the flight and ferry to my next destination, it negotiated first, a night's free stay (which I rejected) and then a 25% reïmbursement.

(Granted, OP might be imagining that one can replicate everything one does with Adobe's software with an image-generating AI. Which one might be able to. But it's not going to be cost competitive with anything Adobe offers for at least half a decade given current power- and chip-buildout schedules.)

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by echelon on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:48PM (#50049870)
I'm imagining we own our iPhones, Androids, and John Deeres.

That every robot out of Figure or Unitree gets its Verilog popped on day one.

A world where Instagram and YouTube and Reddit -- everything -- have no moat anymore. Where these become protocols.

And eventually Anthropic and OpenAI are caught up with and abundant open weights models are everywhere.

This future is not only possible, it's close.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:52AM (#50053928)
> I'm imagining we own our iPhones, Androids, and John Deeres

This should be an option. I should also have the choice to buy my parents something other than a malware trap.

The only way that friction disappears is if we abstract away human preference.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by aurelien_gasser on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:15PM (#50047877)
AI makes it easy to replicate existing software. One can ask a LLM to replicate Photoshop functionalities and, to some extent, it will.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by vjvjvjvjghv on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:27PM (#50047986)
"to some extent" is the keyword here. There is a lot of fine tuning in Photoshop that's very hard to replicate.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by lexicality on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:16PM (#50047896)
Anyone successfully done that recently?
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by aurelien_gasser on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:21PM (#50047935)
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by fg137 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:27PM (#50048579)
These things get forgotten in weeks if not days. Software maintained by professionals with domain expertise who talk to end users is a different thing from vibecoded slop. It may work for some people, but that is far from "replacement".

I don't believe Photoshop/Lightroom will be replaced until I see actually exodus from these products.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by brookst on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:41PM (#50048723)
In addition to disrupting big software that’s now easy to clone, AI makes it easy to be very persistent as a dissatisfied customer.

I never used to bother with asking for discounts and refunds because of the hassle. Now when Instacart delivers crappy produce or the heat press controller tracks to a different temp than a thermometer shows, I just have Claude deal with opening, tracking, responding to support.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by footydude on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:28PM (#50047990)
Another way it would help is making it easier for users to analyse the T&Cs they are signing up for.

Most people aren't well versed in reading T&Cs and whilst LLMs won't do a perfect job, they would likely do a decent job at assessing and highlighting potentially unfriendly clauses such as this.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by edoceo on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:51PM (#50048203)
There are a couple of vibe coded "alternatives" to Adobe Suite.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by mitxela on Sunday October 11, 2026 @07:20PM (#50049101)
I think the idea is you'll just ask Claude to make a photoshop and you won't need adobe
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:42PM (#50048730)
> love the downvotes

You're being downvoted, perhaps, for throwing out a generic (albeit literal) deus ex machina. I flagged for the "comment[ing] about the voting on comments" [1]. Happy to undo if fixed.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by ToucanLoucan on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:24PM (#50047960)
> Companies that are user-hostile have no place in the future.

All I can think of reading this is that bit from Futurama when Bender goes: AHAHAHHAAHAHAHAHA. Oh wait you're serious. Let me laugh even harder.

Yeah we've had near four decades of massive expansion of software, free and not, and AI is definitely what's going to finally make it so companies can't be user hostile. That was what we were missing. 100%.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by echelon on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:48PM (#50048173)
Man, people on HN have no dreams. It's so sad and gloomy.

We can do so much good by just looking up instead of down. We can make the world better.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by solid_fuel on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:09PM (#50048393)
Dreams are one thing. People here are tired of fantasies and wishful thinking. Looking at the problem here - Adobe treating customers like crap and exploiting them - most of us realize that the solution is simply regulation. Leveraging the power of society and government to force the company to behave properly.

Gesturing at LLMs and going “this and the free market will fix it” is laughably naive, especially in 2026. That is why people are reacting harshly. This is a problem that was created by the free market, it’s not magically going to be fixed by some new product.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by ToucanLoucan on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:12PM (#50048421)
Better reply than I would've written.

FWIW GP, I'm not bitter. I just know what won't fix this and cosigning this comment, it's more free sodding markets and more new products.

You want companies to act user-first? Cool. Make it fuckin illegal for em to NOT do that, and watch it happen. I see no percentage in it for anyone, apart from the worst people in our industry, permitting companies to have the option to act unethically. I don't think that adds value for anyone.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by echelon on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:40PM (#50049800)
I'm all for antitrust and pro-consumer regulation, but there appears to be a faster path now.

It's all stochastic hill climbing, and the gradients are changing. The new salient is using AI to tear down moats and make the grading factor how good companies are to customers.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by ToucanLoucan on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:59AM (#50056592)
You know what, I'll bite.

> It's all stochastic hill climbing, and the gradients are changing. The new salient is using AI to tear down moats and make the grading factor how good companies are to customers.

If we take this hyperbolic future at face value, against all the indicators of how bad and unmaintainable AI code is, especially the more it scales up, if we just ignore that and pretend for a moment that Claude can make actual, honest-to-god, functional software based on nothing but prompts: then why do any companies survive at all, apart from Anthropic? Why would you buy Photoshop, any Photoshop, irrespective of it's quality and how good Adobe can be, when you can just have Photoshop, for the cost of the Claude subscription you're already paying for?

Why does ANY software house survive? Why does ANY game developer?

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by echelon on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @01:24PM (#50091357)
> "how bad and unmaintainable AI code is"

You don't know that.

Do you know how bad and unmaintainable human genetic code is? Eh?

We called a lot of it "junk" for the longest time. Vagus nerve, etc.

You have to look at all of this with a radically different perspective. Keep your systems thinking, but reframe things.

AI code is genes.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by oatmeal1 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:43PM (#50048115)
That falls under deceptive advertising.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by SXX on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:48PM (#50048170)
Btw its likely still possible to change subscription with Adobe to different one and then cancel it free of charge due to new 14-days window. Not sure if it works right now, but worked like charm before.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by tomnipotent on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:52PM (#50048219)
> discount for committing to a year

It's worse than that. They don't even offer a monthly subscription contract - it's purely annual, but they advertise and promote monthly with fine print.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by colejohnson66 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:24PM (#50048549)
Yes they do, but they hide it. On the plans page,[0] if you click "see all plans", a true monthly subscription option appears. But the prices are unreasonably large to force you into the "annual, billed monthly" trick. For example, the full creative suite (Creative Cloud Pro) is $35 "a month" with the annual contract, or... $105 on a monthly contract!

[0]: https://www.adobe.com/creativecloud/plans.html

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by tomnipotent on Sunday October 11, 2026 @07:00PM (#50048932)
Looks like this may be a recent change after they were ordered to pay $150M for deceptive practices.

https://www.theverge.com/tech/894555/adobe-75-million-doj-se...

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by charcircuit on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:24PM (#50049664)
They have always had a monthly subscription.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by kalleboo on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:56PM (#50049942)
They always had it, I'm checking my email receipts from 2011~2013
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by tomnipotent on Sunday October 11, 2026 @09:01PM (#50049974)
They've always billed monthly, but the thing they got in trouble for was that it was attached to a 1-year commit where customers were getting hit with early termination fees pro-rated to the rest of the contract. If they did offer this it was hidden deep in the sign-up flow enough that they lost a lawsuit over it.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by kalleboo on Sunday October 11, 2026 @09:09PM (#50050041)
I'm looking at adobe.com in the wayback machine for 2015 and while the CSS is missing, the <select> dropdown right on the /plans page include:

* Annual plan, paid monthly

* Annual plan, prepaid

* Monthly plan

And this is how I remember it back when, I signed up for a short gig where I only needed it for 3 months and went for the monthly plan, and then when the gig became a contract I switched to the annual paid monthly.

I think what changed is now the plans page says upfront "early termination fees apply" right next to the price.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by user3939382 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:59PM (#50048310)
If you actually ask them and push a little they’ll forgo that fee. Disclaimer: Adobe is the worst and can’t wait to see them crumble. If Intuit could also go…
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by SnowProblem on Sunday October 11, 2026 @07:23PM (#50049140)
I found FreeTaxUsa and Claude to be a wonderful combination this year
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by kaonwarb on Sunday October 11, 2026 @11:10PM (#50050931)
Second this. FreeTaxUSA is great. Better interface, lower cost (truly free for federal, no catch). And coding harnesses are very good at handling taxes as well as a cross-check.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by dalyons on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:25AM (#50051373)
Freetaxusa still can’t import many and various investment account forms. Sadly It’s still worth paying a little to TurboTax so I folding have to manually input all my betterment , etfs, etc
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 11, 2026 @06:35PM (#50048660)
> you received a significant discount for committing to a year, so you still owe them for the remaining months if you cancel early. I didn't even realize I had signed up for a one-year commitment

Does this law apply retroactively?

You wouldn't have a claim under the "straightforward cancellation process" part–same way this law doesn't enable one to walk away from a long-term lease for shits and giggles. But you may under the "clearly explain subscription terms to you" bit.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by close04 on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:34AM (#50053254)
Rare to have these laws apply retroactively. The costs will probably be explained very clearly with the usual "take the 1 year discount". People look at the final price and ignore the implications.

I bet going forward everyone will prominently implement a fake massive discount or waive a fake one time fee when signing up just to have something to claw back if you ever want to cancel.

P.S. Just checked Adobe's site from the EU, prominently displays a "Save 50%" badge and a crossed out original price with the discounted price next to it. There's also a link to the cancellation policy which tells you exactly what to expect for a refund. The cancellation process itself looks 1-click. Hard to claim misinformation.

This reminds me of the ISPs where the technician would insist to plug in your internet cable and a "check" that took all of 5s but was billed heavily in a waived one time fee. When you wanted to cancel the contract they'd ask for that fee back.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by ceasesurthinko on Sunday October 11, 2026 @07:32PM (#50049228)
Worth keeping an eye on ArtCraft (https://getartcraft.com/apps).

They're building a free, open-source Adobe Creative Suite alternative entirely in Rust. It runs super fast with minimal overhead, works completely offline, and aims for near 1:1 feature parity with Adobe products like Photoshop, Lightroom, Illustrator, Premiere Pro, and After Effects. It also supports command-based actions, making it easy to integrate into AI agents and automated workflows. They have Microsoft Office alternatives too.

Their Photoshop clone, PhotoCraft (https://github.com/storytold/photocraft), has around 47k GitHub stars right now.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by sodapopcan on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:17PM (#50049610)
How does this compare to Affinity Products? (I know I can ask "AI" but I'm asking you, though no pressure to respond).
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by spiderice on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:31PM (#50049736)
Canva now owns Affinity. So regardless of the answer to that question, more options are nice. I have 0 faith that Canva will be good stewards of Affinitys original mission, despite making all of the Affinity products free (for now)
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by TeMPOraL on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:07AM (#50054595)
They're already proving not to be good stewards, as Affinity now got compressed into one app, AFAIK it's still lacking 100% feature parity with the original ones, and it being free is just a vehicle to make you sign up for an account, and to continuously show you upsells for the cloud subscription, right there in the UI, with the growing amount of "pro" features only available on paid subscription tiers.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by InsideOutSanta on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:54AM (#50057309)
I have no doubt that they will eventually enshittify Affinity, but combining the three apps into one was, imo, a good move. The suite was clearly meant to be one app from the start, but was sold as three separate apps for commercial reasons.

All three original apps contained each other's functionality. As a result, the new combined app is barely larger than one of the three previous apps, and switching between the modes is now much more convenient and has a better UX.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by sodapopcan on Monday October 12, 2026 @01:11PM (#50059476)
That actually does sound nice, hmmmm.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by sodapopcan on Monday October 12, 2026 @01:10PM (#50059466)
> Canva now owns Affinity.

Insert Michael Scott "God no" meme

That's terrible news. I only use photo-editing software to lay stuff out for print once in a while, so hopefully I can get away without upgrading indefinitely.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by IAmBroom on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @03:34PM (#50077367)
So use any of a large group of cheaper, simpler photoediting tools.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by walrus01 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:29PM (#50049723)
Why wouldn't they point their LLM tools at forks of gimp and inkscape (for raster and vector work), which already have many of the necessary features?
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by internet2000 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:31PM (#50049737)
Those projects come with existing culture and ways of working which isn't compatible with how to do things with AI.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by mattmaroon on Sunday October 11, 2026 @11:02PM (#50050852)
Forks don’t.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by ares623 on Monday October 12, 2026 @01:55AM (#50051869)
But think of the hype though. "Vibe-coded fork of Gimp with UI and UX equivalence to Photoshop" may hit the HN frontpage, but not media outlets.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by teaearlgraycold on Sunday October 11, 2026 @09:53PM (#50050344)
LLMs have already ingested that code as training data.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by inSumErgoCogito on Monday October 12, 2026 @02:43AM (#50052218)
My guess is that the AI companys already decompiled any binary that makes money internally - and used the source as training data.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by TeMPOraL on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:09AM (#50054617)
Because the point isn't to kill Gimp, it's to kill Photoshop.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by robbiep on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:13AM (#50052487)
JFC first release of photocraft was 2 October
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by troupo on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:07AM (#50054077)
> Worth keeping an eye on ArtCraft

No. No it's not.

Fort all of Adobe's faults, Photoshop and other offerings are products, with support timelines, features added etc. [1] This so far is "let me vibe-code some thing with no intention of maintaining it further".

[1] And there are others competing as well. From opensource like Gimp to Affinity Design, Pixelmator etc.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by TeMPOraL on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:09AM (#50054611)
Products are exactly what AI is set to subsume, so yes, it's worth keeping an eye on IMO.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by troupo on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:19AM (#50056838)
lol. AI was never set to subsume products. The marketing around AI pretends it is.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by TeMPOraL on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:47AM (#50057205)
Sure it is. That's literally the main use of it anyone has at this point.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by troupo on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:56AM (#50057344)
People in tech should learn to talk to real people at least once in their life.

Or to actually try and maintain/change/fix vibe-coded software for longer than a few days.

No, AI isn't subsuming products. Not now, not in the forseeable future.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by TeMPOraL on Monday October 12, 2026 @11:49AM (#50058168)
Sure it is. I know of e.g. people doing graphics and copywriting that barely even open Canva / Figma or Word anymore, because they learned how to get 90% of the work done directly inside ChatGPT. And it's not low-quality work, it's just the same or better work, done much more efficiently, and without the need of some previously-used products.

And software developer's perspective on this is exactly how future looks, because for me, Claude Code now manages my personal computer fully - installs new software as needed, and uses it as needed.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by troupo on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:30PM (#50063313)
> And it's not low-quality work, it's just the same or better work, done much more efficiently, and without the need of some previously-used products

Oh, I highly doubt this. Since I use ChatGPT for generating images quite often. There's no chance in hell they are doing consistent high-quality work in ChatGPT 90% of the time. Or your (and their) definition of high quality work is far from a common definition.

This is especially true in the past few months when OpenAI removed any way to directly prompt their image generator. So ChatGPT is often stuck in the same generator seed, the generator never gets the full prompt, regenerates images (inconsistently), messes up details, ignores input (because the model never generates the prompt to the image generating model correctly) etc. etc.

Good enough to generate a restaurant slop-menu or a quick TTRPG image. Consistent high quality? Lol.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by vessenes on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:52AM (#50055734)
Since it's open source and you, too, can run a coding agent, perhaps that concern matters less than three years ago.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by oblio on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:50AM (#50056458)
That assumes the necessary maintenance and enhancements are cheap or even doable since vibe programmed code bases aren't beacons of maintainability.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by skeaker on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @07:44PM (#50097222)
Could not disagree more. Ask anyone art inclined, anyone at all, and they will lay upon you their passionate hatred for Adobe and all it stands for. That Adobe continues to exist is only thanks to the billions it accrued from past good will that they have long since burned.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by Matl on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:06AM (#50055181)
Worth keeping an eye for sure, but the vibecoded vibe puts me off.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by trollbridge on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:04AM (#50056650)
Probably not, as projects like this have a tendency to die off once the initial excitement wears off and it becomes hard to find contributors who want to work on an all LLM generated codebase.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by jychang on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:00PM (#50065218)
You're thinking in past terms, not accounting for future change.

Opus 6 or Opus 7 probably would be fine with working on an LLM generated codebase.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by trollbridge on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:18PM (#50065775)
In which case it can just vibe out the entire app for me exactly the way I want it.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by bitmasher9 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:27AM (#50070609)
If your career is spent using adobe products you probably want to start with adobe-like as a baseline and make changes on top of it.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by axus on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:53AM (#50057298)
Isn't the main audience for these applications opposed to AI? And the businesses that like AI would skip using artists altogether.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by stronglikedan on Monday October 12, 2026 @11:13AM (#50057628)
Linus Tech Tups tested this and determined that it's nowhere near ready for professional use. It's good enough, or even great, for amateur stuff though, so it has it's place. However, that won't even make a dent in Adobe's books, since the vase majority of their licenses go to professionals.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by td521534f12 on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:26PM (#50058744)
The LTT video was not about this project. It was some other, significantly more "vibe coded" project.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by dzonga on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:29PM (#50062567)
there was a company that provides decent alternative to adobe products. I think they were acquired by Canva. used to be one time purchase.

not these llm vibe coded shit.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by charcircuit on Sunday October 11, 2026 @08:23PM (#50049657)
If you buy an annual subscription of course you have to pay for the whole year. They offer a monthly subscription for people who don't want to lock in for such a long time.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by dmonitor on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:06AM (#50051267)
What they offer is an annual subscription on a monthly fee, which is a pretty deceptive offer
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by sokoloff on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:53AM (#50052885)
Isn’t basically every typical residential lease advertised exactly that way?
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by vrganj on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:59AM (#50053437)
"Why are my apples harder to peel than my oranges?"
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by wallst07 on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:47AM (#50053873)
Good point, Adobe MBAs: Make the commitment 30 years just like your mortgage. :facepalm:
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by LordAtlas on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:34AM (#50056258)
No, while they've been deceptive with how the "annual, billed monthly" plans were advertised — and previously without clear disclosure of the cancellation fee of 50% of the remaining annual commitment — they've always had monthly plans. It's just that the true monthly plans were 3x to 4x the price of the "annual, billed monthly" plans, which was ridiculous and intended to discourage people from going for those plans. I've been an Adobe CC subscriber for more than a decade. The only thing that keeps me with them is that Photoshop has no real alternative that's equally powerful. Hate the company but let's get our facts right.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by dyauspitr on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:11AM (#50051298)
I mean, if you sign up for a year yes you’re on the hook for a year. What’s the problem here?
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by trymas on Monday October 12, 2026 @01:27AM (#50051699)
Where I am from this sort of dark pattern is used by most service companies at this point. There’s some regulation, though too little.

Most gyms, ISPs, mobile carriers, any sort of services with continuous subscription have this scheme:

- they sell you subscription with some ridiculous (and perpetual) discount (often with “first three months - it’s free”);

- there’s minimum commitment clauses/fines (so you won’t leave too early);

- there’s clause to “pay up all given discounts on canceling the contract”;

- they “balance” two rules above in such a way that it is never “good time” to leave.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by bart7782 on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:47AM (#50053875)
Did they change this recently? Or did you sign up somewhere else than the website?

Because if i try signing up on their website today, the difference seems pretty clear to me.

See: https://imgur.com/a/G8o8Viw

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by crazygringo on Monday October 12, 2026 @04:02PM (#50062177)
No, it's been that way as far as I can remember.

But nobody wants to take personal responsibility for consciously choosing the cheaper monthly option. It comes with the annual commitment, as opposed to the more expensive monthly option that does not have the annual commitment.

I have zero love for Adobe, but at the same time in this particular case it really is people wanting to have their cake and eat it too. They want the cheapest monthly price, but also the ability to cancel.

If you think you might need to cancel, that's what the monthly option is for.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by bko on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:12AM (#50054122)
If they offer you two prices, one month to month and and other for 1 year, and the 1 year is discounted, I would think that the 1 year one is a commitment. Is this not the case? Why would they offer a discount compared to the month to month if there is no difference as to whether you can cancel?
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by TeMPOraL on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:13AM (#50054651)
Because they get more money up front?

As for why they would set things up like this? Who the frak knows? Pricing tiers is literally the primary means of legally scamming people. The only logic it follows is that people who believe it does follow obvious logic are easier to scam.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by mmmlinux on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:45PM (#50059062)
It's cheaper to pay your car insurance up front then per month too. They still give you a prorated refund if you cancel early.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by HDThoreaun on Monday October 12, 2026 @03:36PM (#50061798)
Adobe offers 3 payment options. A yearly payment upfront, a monthly payment, or a monthly payment with a year long commitment. OP was on the monthly plan with a year long commitment.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by DeusExMachina on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:13AM (#50054125)
> I didn't even realize I had signed up for a one-year commitment.

I think that's handled by the rule. From their webpage:

> Companies must clearly explain subscription terms to you

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by johnnyanmac on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:13AM (#50056761)
Probably worth it. They are trying to re-invent cable contracts from first principles again without realizing why people cut the cord to begin with. oppressive contracts are indeed one of those factors.

Adobe as a huge market leader won't be affected, but I don't know how many other studios will get away with that.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by m463 on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:46PM (#50059095)
but the nyc website has a one-button "file a complaint". think it will make a difference?
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by vsl on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @02:56AM (#50067789)
> I'm not sure where they buried that clause.

It’s cleverly hidden on the checkout page, right under the no-commitment plan…

https://www.adobe.com/creativecloud/plans.html#miniplans-buy...

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by jrflowers on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:47PM (#50081013)
> I expect more businesses will transition to this strategy to counter NYC's new rule

Pretty sure the other businesses that can afford to openly despise their customers to a comical degree already do stuff like that