News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by alistairSH on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:29PM (#50047493)
So it's not really a cancellation fee, but is that how they message it?

If I see: "Annual Subscription - $120/year, billed $10/month" I assume I'm paying $120 even if I cancel after 6 months.

But, if I cancel after 6 months, and the message to me is "$60 cancellation fee", I'm very confused - I thought I was paying the remaining $60 I owe them...? The amount may be the same but it's confusing nonetheless.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by firtoz on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:42PM (#50047623)
Wait, so you'll pay the $60, and then, will you lose access?
Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by alistairSH on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:24PM (#50047958)
Any time I've had a similar subscription, you retain access for the full period.

The messaging has usually been something like: "Annual subscription cancelled at the end of current period. Access ends on 12/31/2026" (even if today is 6/1/2026)

That's why the "cancellation fee" comment is weird to me - there's no need to message that way, since "pay the rest of the committed period" seems to be a common (and at least to me, very understandable) way to handle this.

Even with monthly services, I don't think I've ever had an immediate loss of access - it's there until the end of the billing cycle. As it should be, IMO. The only exception would be if I force-deleted my account as well as that's a very explicit "I'm done-done" signal to the service provider.

Re:NYC's "Click to Cancel" rule is now in effect by gruez on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:53PM (#50047705)
Probably? There are services that are relatively nice and will let you use your membership until the last day (even for trials!), but there's also others that are non-refundable and will just yank your access.