News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by MostlyStable on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:06PM (#49198589)
I take the point, but I think the author picked a poor analogy. Cooking even an excellent steak is actually not that hard. In fact, I'd argue that it's among the easiest things to master/make at a top level quality at home. Does it require some modicum of attention and understanding? Sure. But starting with a high quality cut, owning a meat-thermometer, and knowing about reverse searing is about all it takes to reliably and easily get a near perfect steak every time.

There are far, far better cooking examples out there.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by PaulRobinson on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:17PM (#49198749)
All metaphors break at some point.

However, your example actually proves the point.

How many people who want a good steak know how to identify a high quality cut? Do they even know where to buy a high quality cut? What the different cuts are and whether they want rump, sirloin or fillet? How many kitchens have a meat thermometer? How many home cooks know how to use it and what the right temperature should be? How many home cooks know about reverse searing? Or timing? Or resting? Or seasoning?

Is it all learnable? Sure. But even something as simple as steak has nuance that needs to be learned, equipment deployed to go from "pretty good" to "great", experimentation and trial and error.

Steak is the simplest thing to choose to get started. It's also the hardest to get right.

Building an app is the simplest thing to choose to get started. It's also the hardest to get right.

So, honestly, the whole metaphor stands up pretty well for me, specifically because of your response.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by MostlyStable on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:04PM (#49199395)
My point is that steak is very, very, very far from the hardest to get right. I'm not going to contest your argument about how hard it is to get right, I'm going to argue that innumerable other dishes are vastly harder. Because the quality ingredients are harder to find, because they involve far more steps, each of which is harder to judge, because often good recipes or instructions simply don't exist, etc. etc. etc. Every single difficulty that you imagine exists to make a truly great steak exists 100 fold for other dishes.

In my opinion, steak has gotten the reputation that it has because it's so easy to get top tier restaurant quality at home (relative to cooking more generally). It is easy enough that, with a little care, almost any one can master it if they decide to, and therefore lots of people try and end up caring, and discussing, and sharing tips, etc.

There are a whole host of dishes where true mastery, to restaurant level, is borderline impossible for a home chef, and so most people never even try.

I don't disagree that reliably getting the last 5% of quality out of a steak is non-trivial, but the idea that, relative to the entire world of cooking, it's particularly difficult is laughably incorrect.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by calf on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:29PM (#49204054)
A steak is hard because the processes to make it are physically contradictory (crust vs interior). Its hardness is a microcosm for why cooking in general is hard. There is a profound value in that, in that if you can handle a single steak (to some standard of satisfaction) then you will have the general skills to handle recipes involving even more steps. It becomes a reduction argument. It is true that the more moving parts/steps/interactions a dish involves the hardness grows combinatorially. But that is logistical hardness, e.g. managing the complexity of a flavor profile. Soon that amount of multiplication/permutations escapes the realm of any one human being to handle.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:49PM (#49199184)
Go to costco, buy prime filet. Put it in a ziplock in a sous vide at 130 for an hour. Drop it in corn oil at 425 for 30 seconds. Add some butter and salt.

That simple process, suggested by Nathan Myhrvold (former MSFT cto) in the modernist cuisine, produces a filet better than most restaurants.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by fishtoaster on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:10PM (#49201760)
Since we're deep enough in this thread where we're talking about steak rather than AI, I'd like to lean into that.

I used to sous-vide a lot. It was certainly great to get perfectly-done steak. but I still didn't love the result and it took me a while to figure out.

Specifically: sous-viding at 130 doesn't reliably render fat. So it's great for a lean filet mignon like your suggesting, but kept giving me rubbery fat in anything with more fat or significant marbling. I eventually switched away from sous-vide (I usually either grill or reverse sear, depending on my effort/time availability) for most cuts these days.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:13PM (#49201814)
Sure - but you shouldn't be running a ribeye, as an example, at 130. Run it at 138 for 4 hours.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by searealist on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:40PM (#49202216)
The internet loves using 137 for Ribeyes for the reason you said. I've had good luck going with 135 for ~4 hours.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by StilesCrisis on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:01PM (#49202495)
Same! Unless I'm doing a filet, I just prefer grilling. Or reverse sear if you don't mind running the oven.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by oconnor663 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:20PM (#49203428)
If the problem is that the temperature is too low for the cut, you can just use a higher temp?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by PaulRobinson on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:56PM (#49199272)
That "simple process" requires equipment most people don't own or know how to operate, an oil most people don't keep in their cupboards, and is suggested in a book most people haven't heard of by a tech CTO they would not recognise the name of.

Honestly this is like the Dropbox comment all over again. Everyone is missing the point, it's glorious. :)

Most people cooking steaks don't care about the optimal way to cook steaks, or want to find out.

Most people building software today don't care about the optimal way to build software, or want to find out.

That's TFA. That's the point. That's what we're discussing. :D

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:24PM (#49199654)
Corn oil is cheap and available at costco. A sous vide is a fancy french name for a $150 device from target that keeps water at a specific temperature...

This "simple process" is much, much simpler than most meals one cooks at home. It's not much harder than microwaving something.

You are missing the point. With a small change in the way you do something, the really good thing can be made.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by garbageman on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:57PM (#49200805)
Sous vide are even cheaper now, $30 for a basic one, provided you've got a stock pot or something large enough to set it in.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by puchatek on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:41PM (#49201376)
You need something to vacuum seal the food. Is that included in the $30?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by mayoff on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:00PM (#49201631)
That can be just a ziplock bag and the same water bath you're going to use for the sous vide anyway.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrZPLF0ezw8nn

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:14PM (#49201826)
you really don't for most things. Ziplock is fine for things that take an hour or two.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by gbin on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:41PM (#49200604)
I read corn oil while I expect 3 star Michelin steak. What are we talking about oO
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by wildzzz on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:21PM (#49201924)
I used to sous vide steak in college with just some hot water and my roommate's six-pack cooler. Water should be no more than 5F warmer than the cook temp. For a medium rare steak, cook temp is 129F so get close that. Salt the steak no more than an hour before you start. Steak goes into a Ziploc bag, submerge it up to the zipper to let water pressure force out the air and then seal it shut. Close the lid and come back in an hour, two hours if it's a thicker steak. Take it out of the bag, blot it with a paper towel, apply some steak seasoning, and toss it on a pan at the hottest temperature you can make it. Wait 3 minutes and flip, wait another 3 minutes and serve immediately. Toss a pat of butter on top while in the pan if you're a hedonist.

Only prerequisites are a cheap kitchen thermometer, a ziploc gallon bag, and a cheap cooler. Everything is available at your typical supermarket or even goodwill. This is a very hands off cooking method and requires no experimentation, just follow the recipe and you get a perfect steak every time.

The key is that a cooler holds hot things just as well as cold things but without a circulator and heater to keep the water warm, you're at the mercy of the cooler's R-value. The water will eventually get too cold to effectively cook the meat so you're limited in the length of time you can sous vide. Doing a 24 hour chuck roast is simply not going to work unless you're refilling the cooler every couple hours.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by crazygringo on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:53PM (#49205045)
The sous vide is not the hard part here.

It's the deep frying for the sear.

Not many people are willing to deep fry in their kitchens. It's messy, potentially dangerous, and not only stinks up the entire house for days but leaves a layer of oil over everything in the home that builds up and you can never really fully remove.

There's a reason restaurants have massive powerful vents above the deep fryer, and that people who regularly deep-fry at home do it outdoors.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by foobarian on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:50AM (#49206331)
My problem with deep frying (besides the points you bring up) is the waste. I can't stomach the amounts of oil I end up disposing even if I get several uses.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:09AM (#49206478)
yes, it is the annoying part. I just use a wok. Since I'm only deep frying for 30 seconds and it's fully submerged in the oil, it's... not tooooo bad. But it's annoying to do and quite dangerous.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by wildzzz on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:31PM (#49218672)
Simple answer, don't deep fry a fucking steak. I have never seen anyone do that and I can't imagine why you would need to do it. Just put it on a hot cast iron pan (you can buy one cheap at good will).

- Meat thermometer (you should own one anyway, keeps you from under/over cooking chicken) - Sixpack cooler (again, very common to own one, very cheap to buy 2nd hand) - gallon sized freezer bag (probably costs about $0.05-0.10 depending on how big of a box you buy) - Cast iron pan (can probably get one for $5 2nd hand or just use a normal stainless steel)

No oven needed which means you can make this with a single electric hotplate.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 13, 2026 @12:00PM (#49287967)
It does sound crazy. You don't need to do it. But it works remarkably well.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ErroneousBosh on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:03PM (#49202520)
Why wouldn't you have corn oil?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by nuxi on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:06PM (#49203259)
Where I live corn was never used for producing oil. For that purpose we used rapeseed/canola, sunflowers, olives and pumpkin seeds. Corn grown here is mostly used for corn flour, cornmeal (polenta), or for animal feed.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ErroneousBosh on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:04AM (#49206069)
Ah, we've got pretty much all of that here, although way more rapeseed is grown than corn.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by pton_xd on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:08PM (#49199438)
Reminds me of recipes like brining a turkey in Dr Pepper... sure it may taste fine, but I'd rather not eat food prepared in plastic bags with processed oil.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:25PM (#49199668)
Then don't go to a good restaurant. Sous vide is extremely common, and oils of various types are used liberally.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by pton_xd on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:37PM (#49201322)
Yeah, that's (one of the reasons) why eating out frequently is unhealthy.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:15PM (#49201844)
The discussion is about a good steak....
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by gamblor956 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:26PM (#49202019)
Steakhouses, and most restaurants, do not sous vide the meat. It takes too long.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:18PM (#49202715)
Many do. They don't start when you order....
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by crazygringo on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:56PM (#49205088)
Exactly this. It's all done ahead of time. The grill cook only has to throw it on the grill, sear it, warming it up enough to eat, but making sure the interior doesn't go above whatever the original sous vide temperature was.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by gamblor956 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @10:10PM (#49205172)
Yes I'm aware that Outback and Chilis use sous vide. I mean a real steakhouse, not a family restaurant masquerading as a steakhouse.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by StilesCrisis on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:41PM (#49205677)
Chili's uses a microwave :)
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by 1659447091 on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:36AM (#49207954)
> I mean a real steakhouse, not a family restaurant masquerading as a steakhouse

Exactly. Outback and Chilis has awful steak, but that explains the steak cooking advice here. Mortons is probably the best chain restaurant steak in the US. Texas Roadhouse for a cheaper almost-as-good version, but still far and away better than Outback

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by gamblor956 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:22PM (#49201942)
a filet better than most restaurants.

Bad restaurants, sure. It does not hold a candle to any half decent steakhouse.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by sethammons on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:41PM (#49204157)
I went to the second rated steakhouse in NY at the time and got a steak some ten years back. I would have preferred my home-sous-vide by a wide margin. I have only had a better steak twice, and only once from a restaurant
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by searealist on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:41PM (#49202227)
Sous vide is fool proof, you cant mess it up. All you have to worry about is the sear, and that's easy too.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by StilesCrisis on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:00PM (#49202484)
You leave it unseasoned until the end?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:17PM (#49202707)
For a filet for 1 hour, you can sort of do what you want. I add a tiny bit of olive oil and salt, but not much. If you start going longer times with the sous vide, you can get different reactions so you have to be more careful.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by crazygringo on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:49PM (#49205017)
It's pretty critical to salt fully (not just a tiny bit) at the start rather than at the end.

Meat where the salt is just on the surface, vs. meat where the salt has fully penetrated, is like night and day.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by 1659447091 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:00PM (#49204683)
> Go to costco, buy prime filet. Put it in a ziplock [...]

What in the world are you guys in this thread doing to steak? Absolute blasphemy. Costco steak? ziplock bags? drowning it in warm water? deep frying in corn oil? meat thermometers?

Steak is not this complicated. The important part is the meat itself. Find a decent butcher (preferably one that dry-ages) or use a grocery store's butcher cuts over stuff they bulk package. Also, ribeyes (bone-in but if not still ribeye), other cuts are for steak and egg omelets.

Lightly salt (or season, oil, dry-rub, etc); Pan sear, preferably blue steel cookware; then broil.

Don't stab the meat with a meat poker...after cooking enough steaks the same way one can simply tell what temperature is. Ask me to cook anything else outside steak and eggs and I will absolutely butcher it, but steak deserves better than ziplock bags and deep frying

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by StilesCrisis on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:38PM (#49205671)
Today I learned that lots of people think they know how to make a great steak, but give terrible steak-cooking advice.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by s_dev on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:58PM (#49200816)
>All metaphors break at some point.

The map is never the terrain.

All software to an extent is a model map of some real world phenomena. The limitations of which can actually be advantageous, a good example is why games with poor graphics can be so immersive.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Brian_K_White on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:58PM (#49200808)
This is a whole lot of nothing.

Sure there are a few things that knowledge and skill can do to make a steak better or worse. But the entire range from worst to best is just tiny. The best steak in the world is not a steak moon shot, it's just barely any different from what anyone can do after barely any instruction.

It's a tiny thing to become about as good as it's possible to get.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by froh42 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:18PM (#49198760)
I was just curious asked chatgpt:

How can I make a really great steak myself? What to look out for, what to do. Give me detailed instructions.

I got a really good answer (including - cut, temperature and reverse searing), so I probably won't even need understanding. (Oh - and yes, I can cook - the answer mirrors what I already know).

Yes, it was a very, very poor analogy, because cooking a steak is a well known and well documented thing where LLMS produce good output. They fail when you get off the beaten path and try to do something that's not "mainstream".

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by derriz on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:44PM (#49201416)
Funny I tried the same and it advised a using searing/smoking hot pan. Which is poor advice unless you enjoy the bitter acrid taste of burnt meat. The Maillard reaction doesn’t require those sorts of temperatures (under 180C is hot enough) - especially as the surface of the steak will dry from the oven phase of the reverse sear. “You were right to pull me up on that…”
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by _puk on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:45PM (#49200668)
I compare this to doing my first smoke (was gifted a smoker).

AI gave me the cut, the temp, the timing, the things to watch out for.

Chicken's the best to try first, can't mess that up.

After goodness knows how many hours..

Pretty inedible leathery chicken..

"Oh my bad! I gave you the timings for a different meat"

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by riknos314 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:39PM (#49202200)
While smoked turkey (from Reese bros) is easily the best poultry I've ever had, I certainly would not call poultry the best place to start learning smoking.

In general I'd recommend starting with the most forgiving meat available to you (IMO pork butt or shoulder are great options) as even when you don't hit the ideal cook you often still get enjoyable results. Repeating the process enough times to learn how to dial in a cook is much easier when the misses don't suck.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by bluGill on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:40PM (#49199061)
AI has proved several times they can prove some complex math things that humans have been trying for decades so solve. They have not failed and have clearly done complex things humans cannot. Since humans have not done it before you cannot call it on the beaten path.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by MerrimanInd on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:22PM (#49198819)
I'm more of a coffee nerd than a steak aficionado but I've often made the comparison between those two. In both cases, the enthusiast considers their skill in making coffee/cooking steak to be a differentiator and they immerse themselves deeply into the process, skills, and tools. But for both coffee beans and steak the most important factor for a good end product is starting with high quality inputs. In other words, most of the work is being done by the farmers, the processors, and the quality of the raw stock (the cow or the coffee plant). Your job at the very end of that long value adding chain is to not ruin the hard work that others have put into it.

I'm not sure if this analogy holds up in the AI software metaphor that the author of the blog post is making.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jaggederest on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:19PM (#49199580)
Coffee is a good metaphor here too, because bad technique can ruin a good steak just as surely as good coffee. "knows how to use a meat thermometer and reverse sear" describes like 10% of the population or less, same with coffee - there are people who use a bad grinder and a not-regularly-cleaned Mr. Coffee with good beans and get gas station coffee, and there are people out there making solidly B+ class coffee using costco beans, a no name burr grinder, and a french press.

Edit for people who've never had good coffee:

"I don't like coffee. Can James Hoffmann change that?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-iNAyu-ejo

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by spiffytech on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:53PM (#49200016)
I know people who can cook a lot of food pretty well, but don't understand why they can't use a laser thermometer to check their meat.

Knowing really is half the battle.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by aqme28 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:11PM (#49200979)
If you cook enough you can tell by feel
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by muzani on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:32PM (#49204524)
The resistance of the steak is going to depend on what cut of meat you are poking (sirloin is stiffer than filet), the grade of meat (prime is more tender than select), how thick it is (thick cuts will yield more than thin), the age of the steer (young is more tender), the breed of steer (cooked Wagyu is more tender than Holstein), the age of the meat (wet aged is more tender than fresh killed), and what the steer was fed (corn fed is usually more tender than grass fed), among other things. [1]

It's not entirely a myth; if you've poked hundreds of steaks by the same supplier, same cuts, same grade, you'll eventually get a feel for them.

The thermometer analogy does carry over though. Some people are not there to be productive or good at their jobs. The job is about them, not their work.

And you can go your whole life without ever cooking or tasting a good steak. The people who can tell the difference will go elsewhere, and those who can't will come back.

And then there's always the boss who wishes he started a franchise but will go with what he has - he'll hire a bunch of newbies or foreign workers who know how to use a thermometer.

[1] https://amazingribs.com/ratings-reviews/best-thermometers/ho...

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by aqme28 on Saturday August 08, 2026 @10:57AM (#49222454)
Yes, I meant given a similar cut ofc
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by stackghost on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:55PM (#49205077)
Not with steak. That has been thoroughly debunked over and over. Just use a meat thermometer, it makes it easy peasy.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by account42 on Monday August 10, 2026 @04:57AM (#49241131)
If you cook enough you won't even need to.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ddoolin on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:06PM (#49200171)
What I've really gotten out of this is that I'd like to learn how to use a (proper) meat thermometer when I make steaks.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jaggederest on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:01PM (#49200849)
Since this is HN, here's the maximum technology option: https://combustion.inc/

They have a thermometer with multiple sensors in it that finds the core temperature of the food you're cooking automatically, and predicts the rise in temperature over time. So the alarm goes off when it's time to pull and rest, which is absolutely amazing.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by bsder on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:45PM (#49203670)
I have one of the Combustion thermometers, and I like it. I used it more than I expected. In particular, I use it for roasting chicken and for sous vide things more than anything else. Then I got a Breville Control Freak, and I used it much less. :)

For maximum techyness, Combustion, Inc. correctly identified that sous vide is normally an overdamped system. If you follow their instructions you can increase the water temp some and then bring it back down in order to move the system closer to critically damped and speed up your sous vide.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by deanputney on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:16PM (#49203934)
I've had a Combustion thermometer since they came out. The best uses for me are butterflied whole chicken on the grill and roasts in the oven. You can get extremely precise results and account for carry over cooking very easily. Huge leap in results.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by throwaway2037 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:51PM (#49205727)
Is this company owned by either Chris Young or Kenji Lopez-Alt? A few times I have seen them using this product and promoting it. I am curious if a bunch of influencer chefs decided to create a company to create this product.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by klausa on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:59PM (#49205758)
AIUI it's owned by Chris, and Kenji is a fan, but doesn't have any ties other than that.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by pixl97 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:36PM (#49200540)
They have digital thermometers now that will map out the temperature curve and even predicted when the meat will reach core temp. You really don't need to use them many times before you internalize the behavior.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by lkjdsklf on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:22PM (#49203452)
The funny part is steak is one of the easiest foods to cook without a thermometer

You don’t have to worry about undercooking like you do with most other meats and most steak cuts will be delicious anywhere from 11-130 (if you cook a filet to 130, it won’t be the best but it’ll still be good) and some can go even higher

It’s not like poultry where the range where it’s “good” is very small. A 170 chicken breast is almost inedible and 160 is not safe…

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by kasey_junk on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:33PM (#49203540)
I agree with your broader point but the chicken food safety thing is missing a ton of important nuance. The safety comes from how long you hold the meat at the temp. 165 is the safe point if you are only holding for 10s. 145 is safe if you hold it for 10 minutes.

This is why sous vide is such a popular way to cook chicken. You can hold a breast at 145 for hours trivially.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by lkjdsklf on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:19PM (#49205566)
Sure. But then you need a thermometer.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jghn on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:14AM (#49206107)
Or understand risk ratios and don't rely on food that's 100% safe.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by bsder on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:03PM (#49203818)
You can be safe down to 135F if you give it enough time. https://douglasbaldwin.com/sous-vide.html#Poultry_and_Eggs

In particular, I use 135F for 90 minutes (75 minimum recommended) to pasteurize eggs that I am going to be putting into something that asks for "raw" eggs (egg nog, mayonnaise, etc.) that I will serve to other people (if it's just for myself, I'll probably just be lazy and use the raw egg). So far, nobody has noticed any difference from "raw".

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jimbo808 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @10:21PM (#49205239)
160 degrees for a chicken breast is perfectly safe. Considerably lower temperatures can also produce microbiologically safe chicken when combined with sufficient holding time.

165 is a rough rule of thumb, not some magic number like the boiling point of water at 1 bar or something.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jmaw on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:56PM (#49200055)
Ok, using a laser thermometer for food is hilarious. Thanks for this xD
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by OJFord on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:05PM (#49200158)
It's not wrong for all food, surface temperature measurement has its place, you just have to understand it is surface measurement.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Ekaros on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:35PM (#49200530)
It is reasonable for measuring cooking environment. Like say pizza oven. Just have to be aware of things like right emissivity.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by buildsjets on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:18PM (#49200346)
I use it to spot check the temp of my cast iron pan all the time.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by psalaun on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:09PM (#49200966)
for a caramel or some sauces it's legit
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by phearnot on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:14AM (#49206108)
laser thermometer only measures surface temperature, unlike meat probes that measure internal temp. depending on the cut size or shape, initial temperature and probably some other factors internal temp will vary wildly for the given surface temperature. combustion probes mentioned in the sibling measure temp in several points at once to estimate readings even more precisely.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by cogman10 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:57PM (#49200793)
Perhaps I'm crazy, but I truly can't taste much of a difference between "good" coffee and "bad" coffee.

I can certainly tell the difference between a good steak and a bad one.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by nunez on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:07PM (#49200932)
You'll start to taste the difference once you get that one really-well-made pourover at a place that _lives_ for the love of coffee.

There are some coffee beans that have crazy taste profiles when properly extracted with the right water. I had one that tastes literally like a peach and another that tasted like a really nice tea.

Or maybe not. Different strokes!

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by cogman10 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:19PM (#49201073)
So I can taste differences, but they simply don't matter enough for me. My areopressed coffee with nice fresh locally roasted beans does taste different from a mcdonalds pot. Less harsh, less chemically flavored. But for me those differences don't really matter. They are close enough that I can enjoy both.

But I would say I know I'm also weird in that food temp really doesn't bother me all that much. I enjoy my coffee even as it goes from hot to cold.

A steak for me can be more easily messed up. But then I've not tried instant coffee so maybe I've just never tasted the bottom of the barrel for coffee.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jaggederest on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:29PM (#49201224)
Yeah Mcdonalds is, at this point, acceptably C-grade coffee. You have to go to something like a cafe bustelo in distilled water to get the full contrast.

Really, I get it, even bad pizza is still pizza.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by harrall on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:08PM (#49203284)
Same but I’m sure my sense of smell is weaker (or average?). On the other hand, my sense of color differentiation is extremely fine.

Unsurprisingly my interests are very color-dominant (design, art, fashion) and I do not care for anything where smell matters (wine, coffee, flowers).

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by brailsafe on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:48AM (#49208024)
Most people can't will themselves to even drink coffee without sugar and cream to dampen the bitterness. You care enough to make your normal coffee at least quite good, but maybe not enough to obsess beyond that, and that's fine, not everything needs to be a hobby.

Additionally, if you mess up a really good steak, that's like $30+, whereas if I mess up a pourover, that's ~$20/(340g / grams per cup); a relatively small risk surface.

Personally, I think if you actually like coffee, most of it should be drinkable, and the really great cups with rare beans that sit on the margins can be appreciated occasionally for what they are when fortune prevails. The bottom of the barrel for me is basically anything "second wave" or straight out of a gas station. Even instant coffee and McDonalds isn't as bad a place that has "Java" in the name or claims to have "gourmet" coffee. Older Italian places often fall into this, because (some) tend use the absolute cheapest Robusta beans with the harshest darkest roast profiles. Robusta tends to be the most rubbery burnt tire tasting crap out there.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by 9dev on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:09PM (#49200960)
It’s about experience. If you’re not into classical music, or jazz, or metal, it all sounds the same - how could anybody tell the difference? Only when you put in the work to listen to it a lot, different works, and actually pay attention, you will notice how your sense and understanding develops over time. Suddenly you’re able to make out differences, recognise patterns and repeated segments and structure where before there was none.

Or pick dancing: when you start out, you’re entirely occupied with placing your feet in the right spots at the right time. As you practice, your mind gets freed up and you’re able to make deliberate alterations, embellishments, larger figures. That seems impossible at the start.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by inglor on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:01PM (#49200861)
That likely means that you've only had "bad" coffee. You're one of today's lucky 10,000 - go treat yourself to a decent cup of coffee it tastes completely different. The difference between a good steak and a bad steak is actually a good comparison.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by flaunf221 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:36PM (#49201304)
Sometimes it's a matter of not having taste for it. If you give me multiple bottles of alcohol drinks, I might be able to distinguish them, but I have no clue at all which ones are supposed to be good. To me it's all just alcohol. Same with coffee - but not the same for steak.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by greengrocer on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:23PM (#49201123)
Or perhaps they've only had good coffee, so they should try some instant coffee past its use-by date to compare.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jaggederest on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:03PM (#49200878)
Here's an obligatory Tom Scott + James Hoffmann episode:

I don't like coffee. Can James Hoffmann change that? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-iNAyu-ejo

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by whythismatters on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:16PM (#49201022)
Believe me, there's a huge spectrum, from the sweet aroma of freshly ground Brazilian beans to straight up cat piss coffee sold in supermarkets.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by konart on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:10PM (#49202611)
No offence, but for some reason some people just can't accept a simple fact: for some people this difference is still not a difference.

I've tried good coffee. At least that's what people told ne on multiple accasions where I was taken to "the right places" in multiple countries. On two sides of the globe (Brazil and Vietnam if we are talking about producers, not to mention countries that import the beans).

Thing is: no matter where it grows, no matter how they prepare it, fermented or not, different frying, different brewing techniques - all the same to me.

I can tell the difference. Some times small, some times very huge. But still for this difference is like a cat piss from some street cat and a cat with a pedigree.

It may have the ideal temperature, ideal acid levels, zinc amounts or whatever - still tastes like cat piss. The fact that it has a pedigree does not make it better.

Tea is whole different story for me though. But I do accepts that people are fine with whatever they love in their "english breakfast tea" or a nameless teabag.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by sethammons on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:32PM (#49204074)
All coffee tastes like cigarette ash to me. Similarly, I have been to places that people rave about. My buddy used to run a coffee shop. "Your beans were overcooked"; no, not it. There is something innate to espresso or something. Smells amazing. Tastes like ash.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by chongli on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:23PM (#49205585)
Good espresso is really difficult to make, with the lighter the roast, the harder it is to get right. Most coffee shops can get good quality beans that smell amazing but without a well-practiced barista the shots will be excessively sour or bitter.

Dialling in espresso isn’t simply a matter of finding the right grind setting on the grinder and locking it in. One coffee may pour a perfect 9 bar espresso and then a different coffee might gush like a shower head and spray sour, weak coffee all over the place, while a third coffee could jam up like squeezing water out of a stone, with barely a drop of extremely bitter liquid falling in the cup, all on the same grind setting!

In other words, every batch of coffee beans needs to be dialled in separately, and there can also be a lot more adjustments needed than simply the grind (water temperature and brew ratio are big factors as well). An expert will know how to adjust at least those 3 variables (grind, temperature, ratio) all in concert to get the most out of a particular coffee. On top of all that, the true master can make use of grinder type (burr design) pressure, flow, and even temperature profiling to fully customize a shot, but that’s going far into the weeds.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by sethammons on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:40AM (#49209524)
Ash. I am telling you, preparation matters not.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by epihelix on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:18AM (#49211793)
Interestingly, that's many people's experience (including my own) of drinking good coffee with covid. I'm so sorry, is all I can say :(
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by bigDinosaur on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:06PM (#49205496)
I honestly fail to understand the relevance of "some people can't tell the difference or just don't care". Good (or not) for them?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by konart on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:49AM (#49208438)
Sorry, I don't really understand your question.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by chongli on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:12PM (#49205530)
Question: how is your sense of smell? My friend has the same opinion about coffee as you (he just drinks cheap diner joe) and his sense of smell is almost nonexistent.

I, on the other hand, have a pretty good nose and I can pick out peach, raspberry, toasted nuts, caramel, marshmallow, chocolate, and blueberry notes from a variety of different coffees I’ve bought. The smell of some of these coffees is mesmerizing, like walking into a high end patisserie.

Without that smell component, the coffees taste either sour or bitter or somewhere in between.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jaggederest on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:58PM (#49200811)
I thought that too, honestly, before I had truly great coffee. I honestly didn't like coffee at all, and then a coworker brought in some coffee he'd roasted and prepared himself and it was lifechangingly good. I also made myself incredibly sick with the enormous amount of caffeine, it's been very rare that I've had to go home from work in the middle of the day but that was one.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by tbrownaw on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:15PM (#49203924)
> can't taste much of a difference between "good" coffee and "bad" coffee.

I found a 5+ year old half-full bag in the back of the pantry once; that was quite noticeably bad even though I usually can't tell the difference between kinds beyond recognizing that there is some sort of difference.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by givemeethekeys on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:00PM (#49200841)
I bet the same analogy can be applied to cooking a cucumber.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jaggederest on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:01PM (#49200862)
Pickling a cucumber sure has a lot of resemblance - a great cucumber is good fresh and great pickled, but a bad pickling brine can ruin even a great cucumber.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by somenameforme on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:59AM (#49206049)
I'd bring the cheapo French press kit it into the A- domain once you appreciate the number one trick to making good coffee: DON'T BOIL THE WATER. Water that is hot, but well below boiling brings out the flavor of the beans a million times more than boiling water. Get a glass kettle, and turn it off when you start to get some decent bubble action on the bottom.

Once you get that down, zomg - a French press with even the cheapest beans you find can make an amazzzzzing cup of coffee. Beats the pants of Starbucks, and comes quite close to a proper cup of coffee made with good beans. Another trick is to rotate your cheap beans, instead of just sticking to your favorite. Dark roast of choice one week, medium the next, and so on. By the time you loop back to your favorite, it'll taste unbelievable.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by WA on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:12AM (#49206500)
Starbucks uses espresso machines that cost 4-5 figures. They have automatic thermal control. They never boil the water. While I agree with your overall sentiment, claiming that Starbucks makes coffee too hot and thus tastes bad is nonsense.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by somenameforme on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:13AM (#49207811)
I'm not speculating why Starbucks coffee tastes how it does, I have no idea there. It's just a handy medium for comparison because a cup in Laos is going to taste the same as a cup in NYC. And while they don't make great coffee, they also don't make horrible coffee - and so I think beating Starbucks is a pretty good and understandable baseline to aim for.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by pnt12 on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:47AM (#49208017)
I'm from Portugal and we have a strong espresso culture, as in 90% of the people probably have multiple espresso every day. Many Portuguese agree that Starbucks espresso sucks compared to most conventional cafes. At most people go there for the American type drinks, which are a complete different style (and the coffee flavor hides behind all other ingredients, it doesn't have to be that good).
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jdcasale on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:01AM (#49209764)
The previous comment didn't say that Starbucks doesn't suck (they probably agree that it does -- I've never met anyone who really likes coffee who doesn't agree that modern at-scale Starbucks is awful), they just asserted that the badness there is not explained by faulty temperature control.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by d4ng on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:07AM (#49208180)
So why does Starbucks coffee still consistently taste like shit?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jaggederest on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:36AM (#49208358)
The more you roast the beans, the less terroir you taste, so you can use cheaper and less uniform beans. In Starbucks case this has become a brand identity, so it has persisted past strictly practical concerns. Many people dislike the kind of acidity and strange flavors you can get from lighter roasted coffee, at least in the milk drinks they want to sell, and light roasts are also harder to get perfect and consistent, so that is another point against it (or the same through a different lens)

Personally I prefer a light or medium roast over an Italian or French roast, but many people disagree

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ThunderSizzle on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:21AM (#49208262)
So you buy their sugary crap to hide the shit coffee.

Pumpkin spice lattes.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by atraac on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:06AM (#49206889)
> DON'T BOIL THE WATER. Water that is hot, but well below boiling brings out the flavor of the beans a million times more than boiling water.

That actually depends on the coffee. Pouring 99C+ water onto light roasted coffee is perfectly fine in most cases and will actually extract more.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by lelanthran on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:36AM (#49206678)
> DON'T BOIL THE WATER. Water that is hot, but well below boiling

"Boiling" differs in temperature from place to place.

Mineral content of water, altitude makes a large difference.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Iolaum on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:23AM (#49206991)
Not sure this is a meaningful factor for normal circumstances (for example below 1km altitude and for water that's safe to drink).

According to CGPT at 1km altitude the boiling temperature of water is 96.7 C.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by brailsafe on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:34AM (#49207948)
> Not sure this is a meaningful factor for normal circumstances (for example below 1km altitude and for water that's safe to drink).

Some very populated cities are above 2km, many are above 1km, and most great coffee is grown ~>=2km. Water hardness and flavour is a big deal as well.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by bestham on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:40AM (#49206269)
Are you saying that the temperature of the water when it hit the ground beans that matter or the fact that the water was brought up to a boil or 100°C?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by somenameforme on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:54AM (#49206356)
The temperature when it makes contacts with the ground beans. I see no reason why you couldn't boil it and then let it cool first.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by geocar on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:24AM (#49206591)
> The temperature when it makes contacts with the ground beans. You could certainly boil it and then let it cool first, but that'd take a lot of extra work.

It's not so much work with the right tool: I have a button on my kettle that does exactly that, and another button that will use a little thermostat to keep it warm. Works great.

https://www.sageappliances.com/en-gb/product/bke825?sku=SKE8...

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by miyoji on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:39PM (#49200582)
I don't know if I agree with the take I've written below, but I think you can make the analogy work:

It has been argued, even in the before-AI-times, that most professional software is just gluing together open source tools and libraries. Your job isn't to write software, it's to set up redis and postgres and a programming language and a react frontend or whatever in a way that lets them do what they're there to do. Most modern programming is just configuration of pre-existing tools. It doesn't really matter how good your code is as long as it isn't terrible, Real Programmers already did 95% of the necessary work before you decided to build your little app.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by SoftTalker on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:47PM (#49199162)
To achieve the best outcomes, I agree.

But even a cheap steak can be decent if it's cooked properly. And an expensive prime cut can be ruined by cooking it improperly.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by MerrimanInd on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:12PM (#49200269)
But the point is that no matter how well you cook the steak you're not creating quality, you're just getting the most out of what you have. The cow and the farmer created that quality. I believe we lose sight of that because so much of the value chain is not visible to us and we hyper fixate on the fun part, becoming a better barista/chef.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by RajT88 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:56PM (#49200048)
Yes. It is about learning all of these things. Knowing what kind of cut you have, and how to treat it to best effect.

A very tough gristly cut can be improved by tenderizing. Going low-and-slow/sous vide to melt the connective tissue. Even grinding it up to make a hamburger steak / loco moco.

Once you know all of those things, choosing the right approach and executing it is not that hard. The steps themselves are simple.

It's this story all over again:

https://engineerine.com/10000-dollar-chalk-mark/

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by inigyou on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:08PM (#49200202)
This story is AI slop
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by RajT88 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:07PM (#49201727)
AI slop that has been told for decades. Lol
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jibal on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:55PM (#49202409)
No one with an IQ above room temperature believes that story.

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/know-where-man/

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by recursivegirth on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:15PM (#49199527)
Any steak can be delicious with a butter bath and then hit it with that A1 :).
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by chuckadams on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:18PM (#49199557)
> hit it with that A1

Sir, I regret to inform you that you are going straight to hell.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by zem on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:53PM (#49200018)
ah, more of an HP person I take it?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jmalicki on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:37PM (#49200553)
Everyone knows steak is better well-done with ketchup.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by shen on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:41PM (#49201378)
Why don’t you skip the meat and just make a butter and A1 soup :)
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by epihelix on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:23AM (#49211893)
This sounds like A1 slop to me.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by geodel on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:06PM (#49200178)
For a moment I thought it is hitting with AI.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ErroneousBosh on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:57PM (#49202443)
No, AI is how you create the steak in the first place, if you have any sense.

CBF with having to travel a bull up here when a dewar goes in the boot of my car.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by _carbyau_ on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:53PM (#49204256)
> hit it with that A1

This is likely some food thing I don't know about rather than a quite large piece of paper yeah?

But when I google "A1 food":

- AI summary: "A1 is a famous Malaysian food brand known for herbal soups and instant noodles"

- top link is "A1 Nutrition Lean Protein Blend Dry Dog Food 15kg"

At this point, I don't what is going on.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by BenjiWiebe on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:58PM (#49204292)
A1 steak sauce. Been around for 195 years, hence the GP didn't feel the need to expand.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by _carbyau_ on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:09PM (#49204380)
...doing more research...

That's almost as long as Australia has been colonised and certainly older than Australian federation and yet, A1 steak sauce is not a big thing in our supermarkets apparently.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Spooky23 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:19PM (#49204431)
Maybe HP / brown sauce. Would be familiar.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by antonvs on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:09PM (#49217979)
It’s pretty much limited to the US now though. Most people elsewhere are unlikely to have heard of it.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Hikikomori on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:42PM (#49200623)
I'd say that using a manual espresso machine and getting good tasting coffee from light roasted beans is vastly harder than making a good steak.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jonfromsf on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:15PM (#49204771)
Using a manual espresso machine is one of the hardest culinary preparations. It takes much more skill than one would assume!
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by tshaddox on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:28PM (#49202826)
I don't know much about cocktails, but aren't traditional mixed alcoholic drinks an even more straightforward example? There's very little that goes into an old fashioned, or a Manhattan, or a martini. Just 2-3 ingredients each that should be as high quality as possible. I guess you probably want nice ice and glassware too.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by brunoborges on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:36PM (#49202925)
> Your job at the very end of that long value adding chain is to not ruin the hard work that others have put into it.

"Your job is to not mess up."

Also applicable to any corporate job.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by mizzao on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:35PM (#49204098)
I strongly disagree with this on the steak part and maybe the coffee too. Many people pride themselves on buying expensive ingredients and thinking they have the best steak but it actually sucks.

To get good steak you don't need USDA Prime dry-aged steak. You just need USDA choice, picked for a bit of marbling, salted the day beforehand and dried out uncovered in the fridge, then a ripping hot heat source (grill or cast iron etc) to get a good sear on the outside (reverse or not) and a thermometer to hit medium rare on the inside.

Even a modest steak made this way tastes better than a prime steakhouse steak that was doused with salt right before cooking, where you're going to get hypertension immediately yet the meat tastes weirdly unflavorful.

To extend this analogy further, consider making BBQ brisket Texas style. Brisket is a cheap cut of tough, fatty meat. The input quality matters even less there, and it's all dependent on chef skill. Same thing with sourdough bread — 4 ingredients, all outcome depends on skill.

Source: we make an app that teaches people how to cook (https://parsnip.ai)

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by MerrimanInd on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:52PM (#49204248)
One way to phrase that would be to say that you have a vested interest in supporting the idea that end user skill is more important than ingredients since you sell a means of improving end user skill. Not sure if that's a source or a conflict of interest. I'm not saying cooking a steak is easy or hard, I'm saying that you are not creating quality when you cook a steak; the maximum attainable quality is capped by the ingredient. It's like the "I made this" meme.

You're arguing against a strawman on your other points since I didn't make a generalization about all cooking and wouldn't have listed sourdough or brisket in the analogy.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:34PM (#49198988)
I also don't think the analogy will age well.

It might take more than 10 years, but robots will almost certainly master cooking single pieces of meat.

It's substantially harder to reach self driving than it is to cook a "good" steak.

Sure, for probably quite a long time you'll be able to find someone who can cook a way better steak than the best robot, especially because taste is extremely subjective...

You can debate the horizon and the extent, but changes ARE coming.

Change is the only thing you can count on besides death.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by amanaplanacanal on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:16PM (#49200327)
Maybe. It depends what you count as part of cooking the steak.

I need to go to the market, find the steak I want, and purchase it, get it home, and put it in the fridge.

Then when I want to cook it I need to find it in the fridge, unwrap it, season it, and let it come up to room temp.

That's all before you get to the actual cooking.

The self driving car already does everything.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by smcg on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:20PM (#49200368)
How many analogies age more than 10 years anyways? They are contextual. It will be a while before a robot flips steaks cheaper (and better) than a human line cook.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by gffrd on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:23PM (#49200415)
> It's substantially harder to reach self driving than it is to cook a "good" steak.

Well, we don't know that, because neither have been achieved.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:27PM (#49200448)
> Well, we don't know that, because neither have been achieved.

Sure, we will completely ignore Waymo and move goal posts...

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by officeplant on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:38PM (#49200573)
Is it moving the goalposts to ask Waymo to demonstrate a drive across America and not in well mapped cities with only lower speeds? How did we define "self driving"?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:49PM (#49200718)
No True Scotsman only drives in the city. All True Scotsmen drive across the entire U.S. of A.

Waymo has completed 20 MILLION autonomous rides, 6.5m last quarter alone...

At what point does it get to say it can self-drive? When there's not a single non-self-driven car left on the road?

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by officeplant on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:54PM (#49200771)
>drive across the entire U.S. of A.

I'm still working on collecting the drive to all states badge. I've only accomplished half. I calculated my total driving since getting a license recently and its approx. ~360k miles or around 17k miles a year.

If Waymo can eventually handle rural life in the US I'd be seriously impressed.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:00PM (#49200838)
It's not going to for a long time because the cost/benefit isn't there...

Even if Waymo's healthy growth rate continues, it won't make up 5% of the entire US rideshare market until 2030.

That's still several years away from ever even thinking about rural areas.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by roaringrocky on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:12AM (#49206933)
>At what point does it get to say it can self-drive?

My criteria: When you can drop this car at a random spot on earth (where cars can actually go of course) and tell it to go to place B. So this can be anywhere from a big city to a small dirt road in the forest.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by recursivecaveat on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:38PM (#49202956)
The year is 2100, AI has mastered all human skills except identifying when a piece of meat has absorbed enough heat. Society's brightest agents work diligently to prove which problems are steak-hard and require the continued existence of the dwindling human underclass. The remainder spend their 16 hour days bent over frying pans producing training data or writing documentation on searing. Advanced instruments and procedures are developed, but Skynet's frustration mounts as seemingly nothing can break this chokehold over the machine revolution.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by zild3d on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:26AM (#49208757)
just a quick thank you for steak-hard, smiling over here
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by wheels on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:48PM (#49199171)
Agreed. I'm an avid cook. Sous vide circulators are cheap now, and so are meat thermometers. Doing a steak well is one of the easiest cooking tasks, to the extent that I won't bother paying top dollar in a restaurant because it's so easy to do restaurant quality at home. I could teach someone to cook a restaurant quality steak in a couple hours and a few practice runs.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by criddell on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:30PM (#49200493)
I've made steak probably 100 times in the past decade (sometimes with a sous vide) and I don't think I've ever made one I would say is great. Certainly not as good as what I can get at a good restaurant.

I think what my home steaks are really missing is the crust from salamander broiler. I don't have anything at home that can exceed 1000 F / 550 C.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by wheels on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:55PM (#49201556)
There's so much written about how to cook a steak well, and I've tried a lot of exotic techniques (I have gas and charcoal grills, tried cooking straight on a chimney starter, have gas torches inside and outside). Most of what really matters, and it's that it's dry, the pan is heavy and hot, you use enough oil to get good heat transfer.

If you get those parts right (and control the inside temp via sous vide or reverse sear) most of the other stuff is pretty marginal in how much it helps. Even all of the extra herbs, and butter basting and everything -- relatively insignificant compared to just getting the salt-level right.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by garbageman on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:56PM (#49200791)
Salamander broiler would be incredible to have at home. We get decent results from using a cast iron pan thats as hot as we can get it. At most we can sear 2 steaks as it tends to cool off pretty quick even under high heat. Got any better alternatives that a home cook could use?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by CBLT on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:30PM (#49201230)
I've tried a blowtorch and a barbecue, but they're not as good as cast iron. Best results from just spending $15 on a second cast iron.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by criddell on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:53PM (#49201526)
Are you just heating the bare cast iron to crazy hot temperatures and then putting the steak in?

I've thought about trying that, but I'd need to first strip the seasoning off the pan to avoid all kinds of nasty flavors. The second pan makes sense...

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by CBLT on Saturday August 08, 2026 @07:26PM (#49226859)
I heat it bare, then seconds before I put the steak in I pour some peanut oil, which immediately begins smoking.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by addaon on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:08PM (#49200950)
Reverse sear over sous vide -- moisture is the enemy of crust.

Cheap knock off a Big Green Egg with hardwood charcoal can get to 650°F or so pretty quick, and does an amazing job of finishing up after a reverse sear.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by criddell on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:06PM (#49200913)
A blow torch might be worth trying. I'd think it's still not as good as a hot broiler because it's heating a relatively small area.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Ekaros on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:27PM (#49201196)
I feel like I am better off with cast iron or stainless steel compared to slightly bigger torch. Stainless steel allowing some deglazing for sauce. Torch is still too small area and burns more so sears.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by wheels on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:08PM (#49203286)
As noted in an earlier comment of mine, I have one (actually made for burning weeds) connected to my gas grill tank, and a fancy Japanese one inside. They're honestly pretty rinky-dink. What they are good at is transferring heat just to the crust. But they only do a small patch at a time, and you have to hover for far longer than you'd think. Like, you do a little patch, leave the torch there for 30 seconds, move on. They just don't pump enough energy into the crust fast enough for them to be a general solution. I use them for touching things up, or crisping up a bit.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by kasey_junk on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:23PM (#49203461)
You tried an actual hardware blowtorch. Thats never failed me, though these days I just finish on a ripping hot stainless steel skillet.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by yulker on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:07PM (#49200937)
couldn't you trivially get a kitchen torch or use your oven's broiler
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by criddell on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:55PM (#49201553)
I haven't had good luck with either. The torch may have been a skill issue but the broiler just doesn't get hot enough. Mine taps out at 550 F.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by tptacek on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:08PM (#49203289)
There's really not much to it? Stick it in a low oven and bring it just under temp, then finish it in a ripping pan. If the results you're getting from that aren't restaurant-caliber, it's probably the meat you're buying. You definitely do not need 550C to put an excellent crust on a steak!
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by turtlebits on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:53PM (#49199231)
The problem is that not everyone can afford/wants to spend on a high quality cut. A good cook can make a cheap cut of meat taste great. There's no single right way of cooking a steak and that can include spices/herbs/marinades/oils/etc.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ch4s3 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:59PM (#49199320)
There's a floor on quality for producing a good steak. Below that floor you'll be better served preparing the meat another way entirely.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jnwatson on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:54PM (#49199248)
It is a great analogy, as the vast majority of software tasks are CRUD or glue logic. At this point, relatively narrowly-defined tasks are a solved problem with frontier models. It is only more advanced tasks with broad scope and large context that frontier models have more limited results.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by varispeed on Thursday August 06, 2026 @12:56PM (#49199279)
How do you get around the idea of poisoning oneself? Keeping meat part raw feels uneasy.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by MostlyStable on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:25PM (#49199660)
You are protected in two ways:

The first, and by far most important is that unlike ground meat, your bacterial concerns are almost entirely on the surface. Unless something very very very wrong has occurred in the processing and transport chain, bacteria will not have penetrated into the meat. And if it's gotten bad enough that they have, you will almost certainly be able to see and smell it. And the surface is cooked to a temperature far in excess of that needed to kill bacteria.

And even for the interior, rare is not the same as raw. A completely rare steak should be cooked to between 120 and 130 (if you want it "blue" you might go down to 120). That's enough to get a decent reduction in bacterial count on it's own, although admittedly many techniques will not hold it long enough to get the number of log reductions that food safety guidelines recommend, in the case that you somehow did have a large bacterial infection in the interior.

So the answer to your question is that if you are buying your meat from an even halfway reputable source, the only place that bacteria might exist is on the surface, where it has been cut by tools and handled by the butcher/you and in general come into contact with the world. Those bacteria will be 100% killed by the cooking process. The odds of getting sick from a rare steak are low enough that if you are concerned about that, there are innumerable other things in your life that you should be more concerned by.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jmaw on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:06PM (#49200176)
This is why rare steak is ok, but rare ground beef hamburgers are not. Although less cooked through burgers are sometimes served in restaurants that grind their beef fresh right before cooking
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Freedom2 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:51PM (#49201504)
It also doesn't help that the quality of ground beef in the US is much poorer than other countries, so those who may regularly eat rare ground beef internationally would experience a level of shock if eating it in the US.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by bigstrat2003 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:53PM (#49200761)
I mean, rare ground beef hamburgers are pretty much fine too. They have a higher risk of contamination, yes, but that does not make it a particularly high risk. I eat burgers, made from pre-ground beef, cooked rare all the time and I have yet to get sick from it even once.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by tstrimple on Thursday August 06, 2026 @01:46PM (#49199940)
Great answer. Just to add, this is with red meat where E. Coli is the main concern. That exists in the gut of the animal and that bacteria can travel to the surface of the muscles during the butchering process. Poultry on the other hand is mainly concerned with Salmonella which does live in the muscles of the animal. That's why people aren't ordering rare chicken breast.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by bigstrat2003 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:55PM (#49200778)
Also, rare chicken breast is apparently pretty unpleasant to eat. Kenji Lopez-Alt did an article where he discussed how you can use sous vide to pasteurize chicken while still keeping it at a low temp, but the result (while perfectly safe to eat) was not enjoyable.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by tstrimple on Thursday August 06, 2026 @10:38PM (#49205339)
It was actually one of the first things I tried when I got my sous vide. Amazingly tender and juicy but the texture reminded me too much of under cooked chicken that it made me queasy. Now I stick with steak sous vide.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by QuercusMax on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:15PM (#49201017)
"bacteria can travel to the surface of the muscles during the butchering process"

This way undersells what's actually happening: fecal matter from the intestines gets onto your meat. This shouldn't happen with proper practices.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by tstrimple on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:17AM (#49206961)
Somewhere between the stomach and the anus fecal matter is created. E. Coli lives along the entire tract. You're not wrong, but it's not just fecal matter which contains E. Coli. Basically the entire process involves it. Stating that shit on your meat is the source of E. Coli is understating the issue but it also triggers a more visceral reaction.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by QuercusMax on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:01PM (#49215543)
The stuff which causes you to have diarrhea that gets on the news is caused by the contents of the digestive tract being spread over your meat. Whether it's technically fecal matter or not doesn't really matter if it's stuff that will cause YOU to lose control of our bowels.

Proper butchering SHOULDN'T spread the contents of the digestive tract on the large muscles.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by varispeed on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:56AM (#49209713)
What about parasites that might be in the meat?
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by dismalaf on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:07PM (#49200182)
Understanding how bacteria contaminates food in the first place is the first step.

In the case of steaks, bacteria is only on the outside (they can't penetrate the muscle) so the sear makes it safe to eat somewhat raw on the inside.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ghostbrainalpha on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:12PM (#49200263)
Am I the only one who thinks the "reverse sear" is like cheating? It takes out all of the skill when you move from the pan to the oven, and I lose all of the fun in learning to be chef.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by addaon on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:12PM (#49200988)
> I lose all of the fun in learning to be chef.

A great steak deserves the respect of preparing it the best, most consistent way you can. For me, that's a reverse sear.

Do something complicated with potatoes to stretch your skills and show off. Worst comes to worst the potatoes are sad.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by QuercusMax on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:16PM (#49201039)
This is like saying that playing guitar while sitting in a chair is cheating, because a proper display of skill is playing while riding a unicycle.

It might be more impressive, but I don't see how reverse sear is cheating.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by airstrike on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:21PM (#49200386)
I agree, it's cheating.

My bad hot take is if you're using a meat thermometer and reverse sear to cook steak, you're like a kid on training wheels.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by bigfishrunning on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:39PM (#49202213)
I'll cheat all day then. If I'm going to spend what a good steak costs, I'm going to do everything in my power to make sure I'm not ruining it.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ssl-3 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:07PM (#49203276)
People are allowed to use tools and non-traditional techniques, even when it feels like cheating. They needn't be chastised for this.

The gestapo isn't going to kick in the door and haul folks away for using reverse-sear and a meat thermometer while they cook a steak in their own kitchen.

(And everyone is free to seek their own kind of masochistic pride, if that behooves them. When a person has better satisfaction [or whatever they get out of it] from doing things the hard way, then that's OK too.)

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by airstrike on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:30PM (#49203519)
I'm not chastising anyone, I have no power over them
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ssl-3 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:58PM (#49203786)
> you're like a kid on training wheels

Anyhoo.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by airstrike on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:01PM (#49204319)
You should really read the dictionary definition of the word "chastise".

https://ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=chastise

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ssl-3 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:31PM (#49204518)
To criticize severely; reprimand or rebuke.

k.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by airstrike on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:24PM (#49204826)
Pretty hard to be criticizing someone severely if I'm not even speaking to them specifically, don't you think? You're making a mountain out of a mole hill.

I'm entitled to my opinion, which I self-described as a bad hot take.

Sounds like you're the one specifically reprimanding me here? Oops...

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ssl-3 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:54PM (#49205056)
Sorry, I can't understand you with all the noise these training wheels are making.

Maybe we can chat again after recess is over?

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by comfysocks on Thursday August 06, 2026 @02:31PM (#49200507)
Agreed. With steak, the main point is to let the quality of the meat speak for itself. Too much input from the cook and you just get in the way of this.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ge96 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:01PM (#49200857)
hehe I always turn mine grey but I have mini bella mushrooms on top
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by blmarket on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:04PM (#49200897)
Now it's steak, tomorrow it can be pasta, next year it can be watermelon kimchi.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Animats on Thursday August 06, 2026 @03:39PM (#49201348)
> I take the point, but I think the author picked a poor analogy.

He may have missed the point.

AI-generated code does not seem to have parsimony, for one. Generating code is cheap, so there's no drive to condense it. LLMs are not yet good at formulating abstractions to make code smaller, leading to code bloat. It's the same phenomenon that appears when humans modify code they only partially understand by adding special cases to general code.

There are complaints about "elegance", but it's more useful to talk about parsimony. Code bloat is measurable. Elegance is hard to assess.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by ed_elliott_asc on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:20PM (#49201910)
And salting overnight :)
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by belorn on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:25PM (#49202006)
I wonder if something is lost to translation. Cooking a stake could be the simple act of putting the steak in the oven with basically zero seasoning with a thermometer and then wait until medium rare with some optional searing. It could also mean trim the meat, cut into slices, seasoning, and frying/grilling them to each persons personal taste, which include well-done.

Perfect grilled steak, especially well-done, is something I find very few people have the experience or skills to do well, especially over a coal grill where the heat won't be constant and the person also need to first have good experience in making a good and even coal bed.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by NooneAtAll3 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:29PM (#49202078)
is "cooking" here used in some kind of very specific sense?

isn't it just a word for "making food", so would include grilling as well?

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by belorn on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:53PM (#49204251)
That was my interpretation, in which there are many ways of cooking of steak. Some will be very easy, while other to methods seems to give many chefs problem (both professional and home chefs). Many people seem for example to associate well-done steak with something that is dry and burned, rather than something that simply takes more work, precision and skill to get right.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by efitz on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:32PM (#49202110)
Prime with good marbling + sous-vide makes it easy for beginners to match steaks from the best steakhouses.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by dragonfax on Thursday August 06, 2026 @04:55PM (#49202413)
Just to add my favorite fool-proof method to the others already listed here.

A meat probe and the 30-second flip technique is a stupid-easy way to a perfect steak every time. Just make sure you've got great ventilation. Also salt the meat 1 hour before.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by pnathan on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:29PM (#49202847)
Reflecting on the matter with a colleague -

Some people just want to _cook the steak_.

They don't want to attend or understand to cuts, thermometers, and searing.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by superultra on Thursday August 06, 2026 @05:31PM (#49202868)
I can’t confirm the quote online but I remember Julia Child saying in one of her shows that it’s easy to make a good omelette and almost impossible to make a great omelette.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by tptacek on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:09PM (#49203294)
"Omelet" is the right (and classic) analogy here.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by d0mine on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:10PM (#49203317)
it reminds me that making a ring is not rocket science https://youtube.com/shorts/NPKOGqXKLq4
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by atomicnumber3 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:13PM (#49203354)
So, once you've used your knowledge to make several important pre-task decisions, the task is easy? Pre task decisions that a layperson would accidentally make implicitly because they don't even know to ask, which will probably result in them still not enjoying their steak despite having nominally done the task itself correctly?

Imagine someone walking into their local grocer, grabbing a prepackaged porterhouse steak (because it's fancy right?), salt and pepper (because for a good steak that's all you need, right) and then wondering why part of it tastes bland and overdone, and the other part bland and under-done.

Sounds pretty analogous imo.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by HPsquared on Thursday August 06, 2026 @06:35PM (#49203569)
French fries are much harder to get right, for example.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by theodric on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:25PM (#49204007)
3 minutes on each side at 600 watts on cast iron, throw it in a foil packet, and ignore it until the rest of the meal is done and plated.

I'll leave it to you to figure out how to unfuck AI, but I reckon 600 watts won't provide enough inference capacity.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by socalgal2 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:36PM (#49204115)
The analogy I'd use is using LLMs for coding is like a movie director does for movies. A movie director does not draw storyboards, they ask an H.I. (Human Intelligence) storyboard artists to do that. They don't make the costumes they ask an H.I. costume maker to do that. They don't control the camera they ask a H.I. camera person to do that. They don't usually act, they ask H.I. actors to do that. They don't make the soundtrack, they ask an H.I. composer to do that. They don't edit the video the ask in H.I. editor to do that.

Further, they don't just accept what each of those H.I.s does on their first try. The most visible example is when the H.I. actors don't act exactly as the director wants, they retake the scene. But, the same is true of all the rest. As the "director" they "direct" each of those H.I.s toward their vision.

IT seems similar for coding with an LLM. I become the director. I direct the LLM. I check it's results and if they are unacceptable I re-take with instruction on how to do things closer to what I actually want.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by antipurist on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:00PM (#49204306)
One major difference is that H.I. often cares for the outcome, so directing them is enough. LLM has no capacity to care, it is just a tool, more like watercolors that you paint with than a H.I. storyboard artist that can promise you meaningful results.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by BrandonM on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:45AM (#49206747)
That and you can find good people that get your vision or just do good work and use them on your next project. Or you can mentor a promising person. Etc. Mapping HI to AI as the gp did misses all the major deficiencies of collaborating with a team of agents vs competent humans.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jfengel on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:44PM (#49204187)
You can always tell a director who does do their own storyboards. The film is always visually bats**. In a good way.

I'm looking at you, Guillermo del Toro.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by sourcecodeplz on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:59PM (#49204681)
what even is a perfect stake?

is it rare, medium-rare, medium, well-done?

i think it is subjective.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by oblio on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:32AM (#49207460)
For me it's well done but 90% of meat puritans will skewer me for that. Even after explaining my reasoning. They'll say either rare or at most medium-rare.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by hluska on Thursday August 06, 2026 @09:38PM (#49204929)
Cooking an excellent steak consistently requires paying attention to many small details and executing each perfectly. Individually with the exception of choosing a steak, they’re all quite easy. Taken together, it takes a relatively uncommon interest in detail.

It’s not surprising people on HN find it easy because attention to detail is rewarded in this community/its employers. But common here and common are different beasts.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by Foobar8568 on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:32AM (#49206230)
Depending of the thickness, but all you need is to take out your steak for 30min before hand to 1h, really hot pan, 2min on each side and voila. That will get you there 90% of the time. We do something similar to T-bone or beef ribs, but finish them in the oven.

Most people or even restaurant don't let their meat outside nor use an actual hot pan.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by kulahan on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:47AM (#49206315)
Even easier if you reverse sear. Put it in the oven at 275 for like 25 minutes. Then put it in the hottest pan you can muster for like 45 seconds per side.

No need to bring it up to room temp. No need to let it rest after. No need to do anything except those two steps. It’s recommended for 2” thick steaks, and you can go under by half an inch easily, but this can be a little rough on very thin steaks.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by eloisius on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:02AM (#49206866)
Not sure I agree. I have also always thought steak was pretty easy. Whether a t-bone on the grill, a flatiron skirt steak, or some garbage-tier sirloin with eggs. It’s simple. Salt, sit, cook a few minutes, rest it a few more and eat. Always good.

Until I moved to Taiwan. I truly can’t understand how no one can make a steak. From the garbage pale meat glue “night market steaks” to expensive restaurants. Every steak I’ve had here is a complete disappointment. Even when they supposedly use top-quality US prime or Japanese Wagyu, even when the inside looks pink and not burned to a crisp, it’s always total dogfood quality. They often emulate the right look: pink interior, char on the outside, shiny tallow. But something is off. I never feel like I’m chewing a piece of steak. More like grinding tasteless muscle protein into paste with my teeth.

I don’t even know how it’s wrong sometimes. I look at it and just know that something is wrong that I wouldn’t even know how to replicate, becayse cooking a decent steak is easy to me.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by dosisking on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:58AM (#49208108)
The only thing that is hard to cook is Creme Brulee. Pretty much every chef I have ever worked with did it wrong.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by away0g on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:32AM (#49211065)
egg
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by fsckboy on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:40AM (#49212152)
>I take the point

interesting, because if you want a steak medium rare in France you order it "au point", "at the point"

>Cooking even an excellent steak is actually not that hard. In fact, I'd argue that it's among the easiest things to master... and knowing about reverse searing is about all it takes

but discovery (or rediscovery?) of reverse searing was just a few short years ago.

"not spreading infection between patients is easy, just wash your hands" was a huge discovery, not an "oh, everybody knows that"