News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by socalgal2 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:36PM (#49204115)
The analogy I'd use is using LLMs for coding is like a movie director does for movies. A movie director does not draw storyboards, they ask an H.I. (Human Intelligence) storyboard artists to do that. They don't make the costumes they ask an H.I. costume maker to do that. They don't control the camera they ask a H.I. camera person to do that. They don't usually act, they ask H.I. actors to do that. They don't make the soundtrack, they ask an H.I. composer to do that. They don't edit the video the ask in H.I. editor to do that.

Further, they don't just accept what each of those H.I.s does on their first try. The most visible example is when the H.I. actors don't act exactly as the director wants, they retake the scene. But, the same is true of all the rest. As the "director" they "direct" each of those H.I.s toward their vision.

IT seems similar for coding with an LLM. I become the director. I direct the LLM. I check it's results and if they are unacceptable I re-take with instruction on how to do things closer to what I actually want.

Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by antipurist on Thursday August 06, 2026 @08:00PM (#49204306)
One major difference is that H.I. often cares for the outcome, so directing them is enough. LLM has no capacity to care, it is just a tool, more like watercolors that you paint with than a H.I. storyboard artist that can promise you meaningful results.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by BrandonM on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:45AM (#49206747)
That and you can find good people that get your vision or just do good work and use them on your next project. Or you can mentor a promising person. Etc. Mapping HI to AI as the gp did misses all the major deficiencies of collaborating with a team of agents vs competent humans.
Re:Almost no skill required to cook a steak by jfengel on Thursday August 06, 2026 @07:44PM (#49204187)
You can always tell a director who does do their own storyboards. The film is always visually bats**. In a good way.

I'm looking at you, Guillermo del Toro.