"He probably was not the one who stole them."
"Isn't it still a crime to sell stolen goods?"
"Shrug."
Individual property crime doesn't mean shit. A criminal can sell your Macbook if they like, but if they steal from Apple itself? Oh man there will be hell to pay.
>The first example of a statutory police force in the world was probably the High Constables of Edinburgh, formed in 1611 to police the streets of Edinburgh, then part of the Kingdom of Scotland. The constables, of whom half were merchants and half were craftsmen, were charged with enforcing 16 regulations relating to curfews, weapons, and theft.
That sounds a lot like businesses working with government to secure their property.
This replaced, rather then grew out of, a mishmash of informal local watchmen and constables.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinkerton_(detective_agency)
Fast forward to today and it’s very common for private security to be composed of ex-cops and former military, creating a very fluid dynamic of all policing as a paramilitary organization in support of capitalism.
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/07/20/the-invention-...
It seems there were police in the States before the Slave Patrols though.
And also, the slave patrol link has much stronger ties in the southern states where slavery was more prominent. That's not to say it didn't happen in the north, of course it did, but it happened more in the south, the south's economy was near dependent upon both the slave trade and the massive amounts of free-at-point-of-use human labor that supplemented their agricultural industries. That's why the civil war happened and don't start with me about how it wasn't about slavery, the confederate constitution lays out in black and white (beige?) that it was absolutely, definitely about slavery. The south's economy would've utterly collapsed with total abolition.
Slavery was not free. The slaver still had to guard, feed, house, and provide medical care. Contrary to common belief, the only industry where it was profitable to use slaves was cotton. (One reason the South failed to industrialize.) One of the problems the South had was even that was becoming steadily less profitable.
The US became the dominant economic power of the world because of free (as in freedom) labor.
The idea that police are inherently corrupt because they developed from paid security forces ignores that the very process of development is what enshrined the rule of law over power.
Even today courts have ruled that police are under no obligation to protect civilians from direct, inevitable harm. They are not there to protect you, they are there to protect "the peace" which can be fucking anything.
I've never heard this. Reference, please?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheriff_of_Nottingham_(positio...
The Code of Hammurabi:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_Hammurabi
Wouldn't that be useless without a mechanism of enforcement?
Also, you've conflated 'enforcement of the law' with 'the law protects property more than people'. Why?
For most of history the people with the power to create and enforce laws were also the people with the most property. This isn't some big mystery.
Be as that may (and as shitty as that is), this thread is about police forces utterly failing to protect property (or even attempt to).
Yeah, LAPD's "protect and serve" was dreamed up by the City's marketing arm in the 1950s.
And those rulings have come because PDs have stood up and said "We have no obligation to prevent crime or protect people" and the courts have said, "Yup, you're right."
See: Chelsea Boudin and the SFPD. See DeBlasio and the NYPD.
Where do you get the idea that there will be "hell to pay" if you steal from Apple itself? People regularly run out of Apple stores with tens of thousands of dollars worth of merchandise and never get caught.
But they decided that would be worse for business to prevent all theft then to simply have a few people steal stuff.
It being easy for people to grab thousands of dollars worth of stuff and run out of the store is a choice they made intentionally.
The absolute optimum is zero.
>It being easy for people to grab thousands of dollars worth of stuff and run out of the store is a choice they made intentionally.
Risking rape or death when I leave my house is a choice I make intentionally. That doesn't mean that murder is optimal or should be tolerated.
There are straight forward ways crime could be reduced if the public chooses.
There are a number of less extreme suggestions that you actually probably hold (more policing, stronger sentencing, etc.) that people actually do support and are not obviously dead in the water but they have the same tradeoffs on a smaller scale. Do we accept, as a society, less crime that also makes it more likely that you will be mistakenly identified as a criminal? Should we funnel more money towards crime prevention instead of, say, healthcare? Going "we cannot tolerate any crime" sounds great but the optimal amount of crime will always be nonzero.
I also reject your view that everything is social tradeoffs. I think it is a extremely narrow perspective that completely ignores culture, norms, and behavior.
That doesnt mean it is the best solution theoretically possible.
If I threatened you with the choice between death and paying me money you would probably choose the money. However, surely you think it would be better not to be threatened at all.
I think it is extremely closeminded to think that there is nothing that nothing else could be changed outside of apples control.
It is absurd to think that this is the optimal configuration of society and culture.
Other options include making sure people have enough success that they have something material to lose from getting caught stealing.
My main rejection is the idea that the current state is the best possible situation given all possible permutations.
Define optimum. It would be trivially easy for Apple to make theft at their stores absolutely zero.
How is that optimum though? The same measures that make theft zero would also drive away pretty much all legitimate business. Is that optimum for you?
Surely you agree it would be best if Apple could have no theft, and no extra costs?
There are factors within apples control and factors outside apples control. Apple has limits to what it can do, but that doesnt mean that no better solutions exist outside the control of apple.
There is a best solution of those you can choose (relative), and also a best solution out of all those that are possible (absolute)
I'd also like a unicorn and absolute eternal world peace, if we're wishing for unrealistic things.
It isnt like blatant and normalized property theft is an unchangeable universal constant.
Even in my local area, I can huge differences between areas a dozen miles apart, and have seen huge changes over time.
This is why I think it is silly to think nothing could be done differently, and whatever is being done is the best possible solution in every way.
This is basically saying every choice is perfect, and there is no room for improvement. This is defeatist and frankly wrong.
Consider my standard example of this: electric power. We insist nuclear plants be insanely safe, making them uneconomic, making us use far more dangerous sources of power instead.
For the sake of argument, lets assume nuclear power is the safest option available given current technology.
That doesnt mean that no improvement is possible and we should reject alternative design that are even cheaper and safer poses no benefit.
Just because something is the best choice available to apple doesn't mean it is the best choice available to society.
There are cities that have gotten proactive and fought against high car theft rates by handing out free Bluetooth trackers to the public and having people hide them in their car.
https://www.cnn.com/2024/03/08/us/denver-police-raid-wrong-h...
I suspect there has to be more evidence than just the AirTag, but it is possible that the police used that tip to kick off an investigation that ultimately led to the warrant and search. Or they already started building a case. Based off the estimated 15,000 stolen tools, this theft ring was in the millions of dollars and was quite possibly already on their radar.
I suspect just one more data point would be pretty easy to manage, peek in a window, or even have the dude drive around the facility and see if the location was consistently reporting.
https://www.amazon.com/Jiobit-Real-Time-Waterproof-Encrypted...
Big time vs. small beans
The scale seems very different to reach any such conclusion as grand-parent.
I assume what got them to show up was that they didn’t want the bad press if the dude got shot.
I think in texas you can defend your self/loved ones/property with a gun.
In california, you can take a gun to the target range (in your trunk, unloaded). Not sure what else you can use a gun for except maybe get in trouble.
Having lived in Mountain View & Sunnyvale, CA as well for a decade my experience was Howard County itself had quicker and better services than those cities.
It doesn't surprise me at all that their police department is competent and helpful.
You can imagine an alternative system where if someone steals your cat the government has to pay for that.
The couple of times I've interacted with them, it's been painfully obvious to me that they feel like they need to put on a performance for me, even if it's clear that it's an unsolvable crime. (In both cases, it was a property crime worth reporting, but also one with literally no evidence to follow up on.) I honestly wonder if some of the less well resourced people in my neighborhood even get a similar time of day from the police - my impression is that they probably don't.
https://www.kqed.org/news/11988510/case-of-former-san-jose-p...
If a cop is making $30/hr, and we allow "pennies" to be as much as $0.25, they would have to complete the entire dusting for fingerprints process in 30 seconds.
I had a break in. Thieves took my check books, and tried to cash one in at a payday loan place at a neighbouring city. The payday place called me, and of course, I told them not to.
I called my police department with additional information, and they told me to file a report in the neighbouring city instead... And of course, the other police department told me to file with my police department as the original crime did not take place in their city...
And oh, I also had airtags that were taken so I knew which building the thieves took my stuff to. But because it is a multi-tenant building, the police wouldn't do anything. I offered to trigger the sound to narrow it down, but they didn't allow that either... Eventually, the thieves found the airtags and threw them out.
Anyway, I contacted my representatives to give police more help to help in cases like mine, but crickets is what I heard back. Not even an acknowledgement.
The same thing works with stolen goods tracked via AirTags: the police will almost laugh in your face when you request their help with retrieving the gear, but if you call the police (not 911) and tell them you are about to confront the thief in a physical altercation, they’ll be there within five minutes.
Called the cops. They responded by sending a helicopter over 15 minutes later. It shined it's spotlight around for a moment and then flew away.
"job well done" - LAPD probably.
Not exactly batman level detective work here, this case was cracked because it was handed to them on a silver platter.
Another buddy was woken up one night by a drunken stranger pounding on his door. He called the MVPD and within 5 minutes 3 squad cars showed up.
I used to live in Dallas. One night an entire floor of cars parked in my apartment garage was broken into. I called the police and reported it. Then I asked when they're coming and if I should stick around to wait for them. They told me they're not coming. The next night, the thieves returned and broke into all the cars on the next garage level.
Funding really matters. Mountain View is one of the handful of cities in the country with a triple-A municipal bond rating.
Having Google headquartered there probably helped their finances.
It's a struggle for cities to pass/raise business taxes... the businesses threaten to leave, and the cities back down.
(The latter part reinforcing your argument that we didn't try "depolicing" so much as, uh, "unpolicing"?)
> Covid may have accelerated this trend, but attrition and hiring issues predate the pandemic. In the 2019 budget, Council approved over $700,000 for hiring incentives, citing the police department's difficulty filling positions.
Actually the very first sentence in the article immediately refutes your claim -- what a bizarre source to 'back up' the argument that Seattle defunded the police;
> "Why has Seattle lost so many police officers?" The answer is not that the Seattle Police Department was defunded.
>The answer is not that the Seattle Police Department was defunded.
What do you think you are refuting?
Edit: And how on earth do you cite a hiring bonus as an example that they have been defunded?
https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/defamatio...
https://www.bigcountrynewsconnection.com/local/seattle-counc...
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12656567/Seattle-la...
The suburb cities did not experience an exodus, so it has nothing to do with the pandemic.
So we all agree that SPD wasn't defunded. Thank you.
Small town life exists even in major metro areas if you're wealthy.
edit: found it, the Santa line made it easy to search for lol: https://www.mercurynews.com/2011/08/27/the-best-of-atherton-...
Some highlights
A resident reported a large light in the sky. It was the moon.
A man was reported to be lying on the ground, possibly writing.If you think preventing and solving crimes, then American police are objectively bad at their jobs. If you think of police as revenue generators, then they're good at it. Because the police spend all their time on things like traffic citations. Even the police unions occasionally say the quite part out loud, like when the NYPD union famously said that they would not arrest anyone "unless absolutely necessary". Unsurprisingly to people that have looked into policing, crime doesn't increase during police work slowdowns.
(if only real cops could get that kind of response time/clearance rate!)
like that’s just a shitty argument yourself, you lost the argument on the facts so you’re complaining about how the presentation. Lazy argumentation, it’s a way to attack the messenger(‘s presentation) instead of addressing the argument.
It’s the highbrow version of “minor spelling mistake!!!!”.
Fucking chill. This is a website, few of us are politicians and our opinions barely matter.
sealioning is right, bringing it up in the first place was a distraction, by design. if you don't want to discuss copaganda, get mad about the fact someone used the word copaganda rather than contradicting its existence or usage.
that's why tone arguments are a logical fallacy - they're an ad-hominem, you're attacking the speaker rather than the argument. it's far too easy to let this all slide into "well I would have agreed with you but now you've gone and offended me with your tone!!!" as a way to slam the door on a discussion you're losing.
as difficult as it is, the mature thing is to simply accept that this is a way that people legitimately feel about cops and their marketing/relations with the public, and that they feel there's very good evidence and backing for it. It's unfortunate that you feel offended, but you can't derail the discussion because of that.
I am ambivalent on the topics in question. I could be persuaded either way by facts. But once someone reveals strong emotion motivates their argument, I am distrustful of their “facts.”
Sure, that might be quintessentially ad hominem, but we aren’t talking about mathematical proofs here. There is no indisputable proof. It’s just hearts and minds.
I’m not offended nor immature. I’m not tone policing. Speak and believe whatever you want. I was just commenting that I find that tone unpersuasive.
Just like I find the hypocrisy of calling me immature in the same comment that you lambast me for an ad hominem attack unpersuasive.
Anyhow, good luck storming the castle.
We can read the the entire thread.
Take your L and go home and cry.
I admit to an ad hominem argument. Then I point out that my critic is themselves using one. That’s not gaslighting. Gaslighting would be if I denied it.
And yes, I say that is hypocritical and unpersuasive. But it is unpersuasive because it is hypocritical not because it is ad hominem.
I doubt this is persuasive to you. It sounds like you are emotionally invested in this. But hopefully you can at least see my intention was not to deceive or manipulate.
If the bosses want jaywalking tickets, they swarm like bees. Arresting someone for robbery fucks up the metric for the local commander.
It’s like any big dumb company. The officers are like salesmen, and they are trained to do whatever bullshit the boss wants.
But seriously, why he combative? People used to be able to ask questions without being told to take it up with the NYPD. The entire world wants to fight and frankly, it’s embarrassing.
https://policescorecard.org/md/police-department/howard-coun...
Two years ago, WhistlinDiesel youtuber used trail camera's and his air tags to bust his neighbors stealing from him. It took a few calls, but he got it done. He was smart and used the cops as mediators and didn't just go over and start yelling at the dude to get his stuff back.
Apple is well aware people use it as an anti-theft device, just as Unilever is well aware that people use Q-Tips in their ears.
Steal a guys watch or TV, fine. He will go without. Steal his tools and his kids don't get Christmas. Even the most gruesome mob hitmen would turn their noses up at stealing a working man's tools.
The only reason why they can sometimes work against theft is because thieves do not realize they are being tracked. That's because Apple's anti-stalking measures are sometimes insufficient.
As well they should. The last thing Apple wants is some parent tracking down their kid’s stolen bicycle using an AirTag and wind up getting killed by the thief. They want people using these things the way my dad uses them: to find his car keys (or whatever else he might lose)!
Because if people would rely on that then I'm pretty certain some would go and sue Apple if they fail to retrieve their property - e.g. because a thief noticed the "you're being tracked" notification on their iPhone or Android.
OTOH I'd really really REALLY love it if all the modern cordless power tools and their batteries would come with smart tags integrated that work with Apple's, Google's and Samsung's Find My networks.
And I'd love it if I could somehow tell my iPhone, my Android and my wife's Android which tags belong to the respective other... right now when we're travelling for longer than 2h, she gets notifications from my AirPods and keychain tracker, and I get a notification on each of my devices for her stuff. Makes the anti-stalker thing pretty useless if you routinely have to ignore it.
Would recommend airtagging: even if you aren't as lucky as I was, at least you'll have the reassurance of knowing you did what you could.
That's pretty much the definition of implicit. You know, the exact opposite of explicit.
In alot of places, police tend to take care of friends and referred people first. The top down control involved in that discourages the rank and file from doing more than required.
Hope is get to read about the thieves getting pinched soon. Who knows, that huge caper in a Canadian airport just finally yielded arrests, so my optimism has been somewhat restored in _some_ aspects of the justice system.
Kind of sad, that I was surprised they did that. It's definitely a local thing. I'd expect the police to shrug, and say it's too bad, just file a report to use for insurance.
I remember people saying "so what if you have tags, police won't do anything and you shouldn't be confronting thieves anyway".
Apple, on the other hand, is also explicit about tags not to be used as an anti-theft device. The word "theft" doesn't appear even once on https://www.apple.com/airtag. It would be interesting if they still released a puff piece as a response: "Oh look, a carpenter `found` his tools in the next state, in a warehouse along with other tools. We don't know how they ended up there, but isn't that great?"