News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by vasco on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:10AM (#40532255)
American land of the free is being able to bring a gun to school but getting a fine because your grass is too tall. These HOA type stories are always so funny. It blows my mind people buy in places with rules like these.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by unsupp0rted on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:06AM (#40532525)
HOAs are a questionable entity in high-trust societies.

In low-trust societies you wish for an HOA and would gladly pay 10x your property tax to be in one that has rules and enforcement teeth.

Even something as simple as forcing the guy who keeps smoking and talking on speakerphone next to your window from 4pm to 1am to stop doing that.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:28AM (#40532660)
Nope. You'd be hard pressed to construct a narrative short of failed-state-need-24-hour-armed-security-to-survive where I'd entertain the notion of allowing 3rd parties any kind of say over what I can and can't do on my property.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:35AM (#40532690)
You say that, but I bet you already live in a village, town, or city that has quite a lot of rules about what you can and cannot do. Noise ordinances, building codes, safety rules, fire codes, historical preservation, it goes on and on and on.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beaeglebeachedd on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:20AM (#40533632)
No I don't, I purposely bought a property with no code inspections and no covenants and there's been no code or fire check or noise ordinance for 20+ years. None of the scare stories you hear on here came true, but what did come true is you can actual afford a home because you're not the subject of constant harassment and corruption of code enforcers when building.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:31AM (#40533716)
You are in a minority. The huge salient fact about the last 200 years is the continual movement of the population from rural areas into urban areas.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:43AM (#40532732)
There's quite a bit of difference between building codes and empowering my neighbors to bitch about the color of my mailbox...
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by andybak on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:50AM (#40532765)
Yes but I bet everyone will disagree about exactly where to draw the line between the two types of rule. It's the middle where it gets fractious.

Question - Have you ever lived in a high-density environment? apartment block, terrace row etc.? Someone who has will have a different stance on what is acceptable regulation to someone that's only lived in the density of typical US suburbia.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jeltz on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:38AM (#40533040)
Not exactly comparable but as someone who has lived all my life in apartments in Sweden have to say that people who grew up Swedish suburbia and moved into the city seems to be the most into deciding what others are allowed to do compared to people who have lived a long time in dense environments.

Could just be that are used to different rules but I would not say we have more rules in the cities.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:48AM (#40534462)
I've lived in trailer parks, downtown apartments, mid-town housing projects, suburban neighborhoods, hyper rural farming communities, and my car on a few occasions. I don't fuck with my neighbors and won't tolerate being fucked with, regardless of setting.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by andybak on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:17AM (#40535502)
> won't tolerate being fucked with,

OK. So you have your own rules, which you enforce on others? That's swell but I can imagine it could lead to problems. Maybe some form of committee where people can settle disputes and agree on standards?

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beaeglebeachedd on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:37AM (#40535774)
The peoples' glorious committee have never been a good way to protect property rights. Which is part of the reason why many rights are set up to not be subject to democratic opinion.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:17PM (#40538569)
It's like the concept of common decency is mysterious to you people. Rules? Sure, don't be a complete gaping asshole. Short of that I can generally figure out a way to get along with folks. Do you need a committee to instruct you on how to act?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dTal on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:02PM (#40539032)
Do I? Hell no, I'm a model citizen. The trouble, you see, is with all these other assholes...

You are positing an individualist solution (don't be a "gaping asshole" by some vague standard) to a society-level problem (people disagree on behavioral norms, and even if they agreed not everyone would comply). This doesn't work and is tantamount to just pretending the problem doesn't exist - a pretty common failure mode in the conservative mindset. See also: gun control is unnecessary because all you have to do is not shoot people...

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beaeglebeachedd on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:12PM (#40539120)
In theory juries only examine facts but in practice they are equal with judges in they decide both matter of law and fact and can nullify or convict without regard or with regard to either.

The system we use in rural countryside where police basically don't exist, ultimately, is a direct jury of your peer neighbors. It's better if you don't like those decisions centralized to some far away assholes with even less aligned motives.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by andybak on Saturday June 01, 2024 @09:19AM (#40545519)
This is an argument against centralisation of authority - which most on the libertarian left and right would agree with.

I personally think it's a thorny problem with no easy solution - which is why I'm not a libertarian.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by andybak on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:54PM (#40538937)
Not sure who "you people" is referring to but if you're speaking to me then my response would be something along the lines of "I admire your optimistic outlook but even a cursory study of society would show that social consensus is incredibly fragile and to regard it as anything else smacks of naivety".

So - as a society we've tried multiple different strategies to make it easy for people to live in close proximity and they all have different success rates and different trade-offs. Pick your poison.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beaeglebeachedd on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:02PM (#40539028)
Private real estate property satisfaction and attainability for the common man hasn't improved much if at all since suffocating regulations and active committees really ramped up 50 years ago.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by meetingthrower on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:29AM (#40532666)
Do you live in the country in a town with no zoning? You might be surprised...
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by edgyquant on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:55AM (#40535216)
I lived in a pretty small town growing up and we were forced to sell the car I was going to get at 16 because I was 15 and it had been sitting for months. The city gave us a warning and was going to start fining us everyday until we got rid of it
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by meowster on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:21AM (#40535554)
What was the warning for? Not being registered, not moving, etc? Those are things that your parents can fix without you being 16.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by rafaelmn on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:37AM (#40532700)
Umm sorry but that's nonsense - externalities of your property impacts your neighborhood and having rules upfront about what's acceptable is a good way to deal with conflicts and setting expectations. Laws have to be defined for the entire country.

If I buy a house in a nice neighborhood and I pay extra because it's a nice neighborhood - I want to know that everyone has some standard of maintenance.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:41AM (#40532720)
To put it as bluntly as possible I don't give a flying fuck at a rolling donut what you or others likeminded think is nonsense here. I live on 20 wooded acres surrounded by undeveloped forest lots ranging in size from 40 to 200 acres, the closest neighbor is half a mile away, and I couldn't pick anyone that lives there out of a police lineup if my life depended on it. I chose my location precidely to avoid this creeping horseshit notion that you've got rights over the things I own.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by fastball on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:03AM (#40532830)
So you wouldn't mind if someone bought the property closest to wherever your house is on your 20 acres, cut down the undeveloped forest, and built an abattoir right on the property line?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ekidd on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:10AM (#40534060)
HOAs are not the only thing that controls where people can build abattoirs. In much of the US, this is controlled by zoning. And zoning is decided on via local politics, not via a HOA.

I'll take a small town politics over an HOA any day, because the few local HOAs are far more likely to make weird and obnoxious requests.

I live on a dirt road in the woods. I don't care whether my next-door neighbor cuts his lawn or what color he paints his house, or whether he decides to start keeping goats. The landowner across the street is running a tiny part-time farm, and I'm a fan. I know most of my 20 closest neighbors.

I don't mind the occasional HOA for people who want that sort of heavy community control. For me, it was an automatic "no" when buying a house.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by fastball on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:37AM (#40534976)
HOAs are local politics. You're making a distinction without a difference.

Some local politics sucks, some does its job with minimal fuss. The difference is not made by the label you put on the political entity.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ekidd on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:22AM (#40536342)
Small town politics is based on voting and laws. I can participate in Town Meeting, or call the town manager, or volunteer for a role in town government. And unless I make a spectacular nuisance of myself (or ruin the groundwater or dirt roads), the town doesn't much care what I do with my land.[1]

HOAs are basically private pseudo-governments, and most of the ones around here seem to impose far more stringent rules about how people use their land than the towns do.

[1] If I were operating on a scale beyond an individual homeowner or a small farm, the town would pay more attention. Want to keep a dozen goats or turn 5 acres into a truck farm? Go for it. Want to raise 1,500 pigs with a manure lagoon? You'll need to go through a permitting process.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by yourapostasy on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:38AM (#40534353)
The general rule of thumb I've personally observed (YMMV) with those who hold such absolutist externality related positions is they hold it right up to the minute that someone else much more powerful and deep-pocketed than they start unilaterally imposing externalities upon them. Your abbatoir example is a good one, and the other one I've seen in real life is when a Swift, Cargill or other similar mega-agribusiness setting up a CAFO feedlot next door.

The odor externality from the manure piles/lakes usually riles such characters right up, but that is the least of it. Even when the manure management challenges are properly mitigated (and there are no such CAFO feedlots that can mitigate to only 2-3 incidents per year, it is more like 20-30 per year for the average one), neighboring properties like your parent commentator's are adversely impacted with sharply increased pathogen and contaminants control in their groundwater. As rural properties like your parent poster's usually rely upon well water, this becomes a pretty acute issue for neighbors.

Fracking operations also are frequently very sloppy with their adverse impact upon groundwater, even though they are very diligent upon staying on their property. Redress that makes whole including judicial system interaction expenses is difficult, expensive even for single-digit liquid assets millionaires, and rare.

At the end of the day, this has many characteristics of a classic engineering modeling problem, subject to unperceived historical biases. People who hold absolutist property rights interpretations like your parent poster are generally historically biased to a time period when such interpretations were couched in an energy-poor and population-sparse time of our civilization. Back then, as long as one was within approximately human- and animal-power scales of energy over the generational time span, and rural population densities, externalities from large scaling scenarios were rare for most people, and mostly theoretical. With our current access to energy and ability to rapidly densify neighboring properties, the available externalities to present materially change, and the interpretations (which are actually the mental models we work with) break down in the face of a engineering-like scaling step change that requires categorically different solution spaces.

I'm personally very sympathetic to your parent poster's position, but realistically, my personal experience has informed me of the dynamic I've shared, and I've since substantially modified my position.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:10AM (#40534702)
They couldn't if they tried, zoning laws, local labor costs, and the hyper-consolidation of the meat packing industry make that a complete non-starter. You're trying to goad me into admitting obnoxious neighbors are obnoxious which is self-evident. Generally there are ways to deal with obnoxious neighbors that don't require entitling the rest of the neighborhood to make decisions about one's property. Ironically I've taken the starch our of more than one asshat neighbor by threatening to build a hog pen next to their house, so there is that I suppose.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by fastball on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:36AM (#40534963)
What exactly do you think zoning laws are if not the wider community making decisions about one's property?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:28PM (#40538681)
Zoning laws are a combination of unelected civil servants, elected legislators, and the legal system establishing a minimum set of guardrails to prevent shit like building strip clubs and toxic waste incinerators in inappropriate places. They're far from foolproof, are frequently gimmicked to the benefit of wealthy political donors, and they're not something the public gets any kind of real say in. There's no relationship between zoning laws and HOA covenants around what color your mailbox can be or how many cars you can have in your driveway (for example). Some kind of minimal social contract is provably necessary to prevent society from devolving into some kind of libertarian Mad Max you-keep-what-you-kill hellscape, but that hardly requires granting the people around me authority to make arbitrary decisions around trivial aspects of how I choose to maintain my property.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:08AM (#40535384)
seems someone actually did that:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40255509

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:33PM (#40538742)
Oh sure yeah. That's actually a very old strategy I learned from my (now 94) year old grandfather. My impression is that was one of the intermediate steps on the continuum between trying to sit down with a neighbor and work things out and exchanging sporadic small arms fire. Country life was wild back in the day.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by rboyd on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:54AM (#40532785)
You described nearly exactly my little place here in the countryside too. I noticed property taxes were up this year, and the electric co-op cut down two of my favorite trees while I was on vacation because they said they were too close to the lines.

There’s always something. sigh

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:58AM (#40534588)
The power co-op cleared three problem trees after I called them out which opened things up enough that I've been able to drop a bunch more myself with no issues. Got an Alaska mill on the way to process the trunks into lumber, the greenhouse is going in this fall. My only real complaint is the bizarre amount of mice we have on the property, but that's a solvable problem.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jasondigitized on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:19AM (#40533627)
It’s because you don’t give a flying fuck why HOAs exist. It separates those who are of different likeminds. There is a neighborhood in Austin called Apache Shores for people like you but who do give a flying fuck to know their neighbors. It’s best described as a series of junkyards next to zero scapes next to 70s A-frames next to medieval manor homes. It’s awesome for people who don’t care if their neighbors house looks like a donut shop.

I don’t give a flying fuck that you don’t give a flying fuck about your neighbhors. I want neighbors that care about me and ask if they can have a stick of butter or borrow my table saw or carpool my kids to school. My neighborhood is a true community. We help each other. We organize with each other. We raise kids with each other. All from our huge McMansions with perfect lawns adorned with labradoodles who don’t bark at strangers. It makes my life better and I have never once gotten worked up about some bullshit notion that the HOA is treading on me. It’s possible to like conformity while eating suburban Chipotle while reading Kant. You can be a free thinker while also agreeing to not park your car on your lawn. If you want a pink mailbox and want to use your chainsaw in your birthday suit at 6am go right ahead, in any thousands of neighborhoods or hermitages that allow it in the land where the ratio of eagles to hamburgers is nearly equal. I’ll be in my garage with my neighbor smoking weed with our shirts off, making sawdust, listening to Steely Dan. Oh the tyranny

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beaeglebeachedd on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:28AM (#40533701)
Hoa are the mushroom head of covenants, which I see as one of the greatest threats to liberty. Boomers unilaterally reaching out the grave to encumber property on all transfers and heirs. The contract of course is unsigned by the counterparty yet somehow runs with the land. Due to this nonsense it was almost impossible finding land allowing me to build a tiny house for my family despite no zoning or codes against it.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by phil21 on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:13AM (#40534084)
Yep, this is my problem with HoAs. Everyone supporting them loves to bleat about how "voluntary" they are - but any new construction since perhaps the late 80's in my area have been nearly 100%, if not 100%, HoA. This is not voluntary - it's pay to play, and you are practically forced into these living arrangements if you are within a certain socioeconomic class and want to own a home. That I won the lottery and can "opt out" of the situation personally is immaterial. I find the situation at best unethical.

These don't even exist for the standard reasoning any longer. It's turned into a financial grift for developers to avoid paying for improvements, and municipalities to expand the tax base without having to pay for infrastructure. Plenty of "communities" out there currently having their cake and eating it too - at least for the first one or two generations of owners. It's about as sustainable as you'd expect such arrangements to be the more you look into them.

If you want suburban new home construction in my area you have had to buy within a HoA for the past 30 years. It's getting to the point where only the older "city core" and inner ring suburbs come devoid of a HoA. So it's either exceedingly expensive dense urban living or a 2 hour drive from a rural property. Such "choice" indeed.

HoAs kill freedom more than they offer it from my experience. They also slowly suffocate any future development forcing everyone into exceedingly hard to break covenants of the past. The ossification and hollowing out of middle class America continues.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mlrtime on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:36AM (#40534335)
Not sarcasm but this sounds amazing, show me where to sign on the HOA docs.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by demondemidi on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:14AM (#40533228)
Funny I lived on 11 acres carved from a 180 acre plot. The 90 year old owner of the surrounding plot died and his children had it logged. For three years loggers were running chainsaws near daily and 18 wheelers were tearing up my small road as they built new ones to feed it. The road was shared from my house to his through my property. Then his teenaged grandkids started running motorcycles through the clear cut and shooting guns. Sitting on my porch used to be pleasant but now it was constant noise. Since the land was unmaintained and unincorporated I had no recourse. I moved before they finished. I check google maps every few years and they are STILL logging.

I forgot to mention that the lack of forest now means I can see floodlights from the local high school sports fields 20 miles away and can hear the freeway traffic that passes through the nearby town, also 20+ miles away. It’s not deafening just annoying and persistent instead of wind blowing through thick forest.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by nemo44x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:24AM (#40533665)
I think you did well to isolate yourself. But many people are willing to come to agreement on what type of community they want to live in and explicitly regulate antisocial behavior.

It’s great this country is large enough to accommodate all types.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by 15155 on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:18AM (#40532916)
You'll be paying taxes on that land, do you actually own it?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beaeglebeachedd on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:22AM (#40533650)
Not necessarily. Much of Alaska has no property tax, plus you get a paycheck on oil dividends.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:04PM (#40539048)
Of course I own it. I also utilize all of the public infrastructure around my land and enjoy the fact that I don't have to resort to armed patrols to protect it from roving bands of raiders, so yeah, taxes.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ikekkdcjkfke on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:17AM (#40532911)
But leaf blowers 7 am are fine xD
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:30AM (#40533712)
7am is well after sunrise in most places, most of the year. Your personal tolerance for sounds at that hour should not be regarded as universal.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by yourapostasy on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:08AM (#40534044)
A lot of my friends who in their younger years held this position rapidly backpedaled after they added babies to their homes. There are very effective sound mitigation solutions available though, if you're willing and able to afford to remodel the room(s) you want to defend against such external sounds.

I interpret such actions as what to normally expect in a lower trust society and culture. We pay for such settings in many different ways.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by prmoustache on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:27AM (#40534863)
Leaf blowers are noise pollution regardless of the time of the day, which has short and long term effects on health.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:57PM (#40539548)
Well, I don’t disagree with that. My point is only that 7am is a perfectly fine hour to be out doing something productive. Make hay while the sun shines.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mindslight on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:54AM (#40535206)
And electric lighting exists. If you're going to define when noise is acceptable based on when any significant contingent of people are up and active, then noise at 1AM (3AM on weekends) also falls under that definition. Yet the early riser coalition tends to complain about that...

And never mind that the main value add of leaf blowers (over the traditional rake) is to coat your neighbors with debris and dust, thus necessitating even more cleaning (inside too, if they dared to have their windows open).

Also I'd say it's your characterization of freedom that is a narrow misunderstanding. I'd define freedom as the ability for individuals to make their own choices in the presence of society. Being the only person for miles and thus being "free" to do whatever you want isn't some sensible ideal of freedom, rather it's a pathological case that has made freedom irrelevant. In other words, freedom itself directly depends on tolerance. And by the time a city is forcing someone to build yet another ticky-tack fence to hide the mere sight of a perhaps-ill-advised boat it's clear that there is very little tolerance aka respect for freedom.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by xtracto on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:36PM (#40539956)
Maybe HOAs in the UK or in Germany would seem crazy. I lived in those two places for years and in both places people generally BEHAVE. In Germany, you DO NOT throw glass bottles into the recycle bin on Sundays because of the noise they make. People just expect to be civil.

In contrast, here in Mexico (where I am from) you need a HOA (or the equivalent) to avoid all sorts of crazy neighbours. From people blasting music and shouting at 1am, people leaving their trash out in the sidewalk permanently, parking their cars in front of your garage. To really making dangerous modifications to their house that will undoubtedly affect their neighbours.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Hamuko on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:40AM (#40532416)
You have the freedom to sign up to all kinds of ridiculous but enforceable contracts.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by matsemann on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:20AM (#40532308)
Is it some kind of bias in that one only hears about the insane cases, and there are thousands of well-run HOAs for every crazy one? Or is it really that bad?

We don't have that concept in my country. Or, we do have associations that make it so that houses in an area share the upkeep of communal stuff like a park, playground, organize events etc. All things I would think a "normal HOA" would be, but without the ability to impose fines or stuff like that. So I would feel a house with that kind of neighborhood here would be a net positive, as in costs can be shared among more.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by freetime2 on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:14AM (#40532568)
I lived in a community with an HOA for 5 years and never had any issue. Like you say, it existed primarily to ensure the upkeep of common facilities (pool, private road, gym, and community building). The only real rule I remember them enforcing (and fairly loosely, at that) was that residents were not allowed to park long term in visitor parking spots. Which to me seemed like a perfectly sensible rule.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ghaff on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:46AM (#40534448)
Which is often the case. You tend to hear about the outliers. If a bunch of houses share a common road for example, the maintenance/plowing/etc. of that road has to be divvied up in some way--and it's a reasonable bet that, especially if it's on the longer side, there will be people who object to whatever formula is used. People will also routinely disagree about the degree of maintenance and upkeep that's necessary for any shared facility.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ars on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:43AM (#40532434)
It's not that bad, the vast majority of people in an HOA like being in one.

Always remember: If it's in the news it's not the norm. Whatever you hear about a country via the news is the opposite of what that country typically is.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:06AM (#40532524)
I’m in an HOA and they’re pretty fine. Mostly focus on snow removal and keeping people from parking their nine hundred snow mobiles in the guest spots.

We meet once a year to vote on crap. Key is to not have a group of people with nothing better to do.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gibolt on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:33AM (#40532680)
The problem is that you have little control into when one of those people infiltrate the board. Most HOAs start with no issue. It is only after someone new joins that the rule enforcement becomes insane or the big pot of money vanishes.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by bradfa on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:21AM (#40532932)
This can be solved by having all members vote and not just the board.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:26AM (#40535626)
> solved by having all members vote and not just the board

Yup. I can’t imagine what an HOA would need to be doing to meet monthly, let alone delegate decision making to a board.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by kasey_junk on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:59AM (#40536770)
The problem is people talk about HOA like they are some monolithic thing. There are HOA that are only responsible for maintenance of the subdivision sign all the way up to ones responsible for multiple skyrise condo buildings.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:39PM (#40538062)
> HOA that are only responsible for maintenance of the subdivision sign all the way up to ones responsible for multiple skyrise condo buildings

The latter is simply incorrect. Condo associations and co-op boards are separate creatures, in part due to there being an existential necessity to their existing. (You can't have people dismantling structural members their unit abuts.)

HOAs are far more voluntary in nature. That said, I agree that we need a better framework for distinguishing those functioning as direct democracies from those where an elected board gets to appoint itself powers.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by kasey_junk on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:01PM (#40539590)
When people talk about them colloquially and dig in you’ll frequently find them being commingled.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by willcipriano on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:28AM (#40532349)
It's this bad. The problem is Boomers.

Boomers mostly worked one job between two people, and had the silent generation to take care of their kids so they had a lot of time for masterbatory lawn care/putting trashcans away the second the trash truck pulls away/nonsense.

Now they are retired and have even more time, but also authority over people far busier than they ever have been.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jack_riminton on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:15AM (#40532577)
This is one of my favourite HN comments, it’s so true.

Here in the UK the boomers were able to work one job, get a house on an easy mortgage and now they’re old and have nothing to do they campaign against any development that might slightly inconvenience them or reduce their house price (spoiler, most developments wouldn’t)

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by timthorn on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:36AM (#40532697)
They'll have had mortgages at 10% or higher, and tied to endowment policies that were often missold. Mortgages weren't easy for boomers, even if house prices were lower.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jack_riminton on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:03AM (#40532831)
That is laughably incorrect. Mortgages were far easier to afford for boomers (typically 4 times income, whereas now they're more likely to be 9 or even 10 times income)

https://www.financialreporter.co.uk/income-to-house-price-ra...

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gnfargbl on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:27AM (#40532962)
OK, but you've missed the point about relative interest rates on those mortgages. You can't reasonably comment on affordability without taking that into account. As a child in the 1980s with two working "boomer" parents and a modest house in a low COL area, we had no money at all due mostly to mortgage interest rates.

The very real problems with affordability of housing in the UK have a number of causes but the key issue is supply. Successive governments have simply failed to build sufficient housing to meet demand. NIMBYism alone can't explain this lack of investment.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Jochim on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:14AM (#40533585)
Interest rates get brought up every time this topic is discussed and the math remains the same. Even accounting for the difference in interest rates, people are much worse off today than they were in the 80s.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by timthorn on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:35AM (#40533750)
Far more repossessions took place in the 80s and 90s. Times were/are different, but it wasn't easy back then either.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gnfargbl on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:51AM (#40535159)
I didn't believe your statement, so I looked up some numbers.

1989:

- Interest rate: 14.5%.

- Average house price: £58k.

- Monthly repayment: £650 (90% LTV, 25 year term).

- Average pre-tax income: £10k.

2024:

- Interest rate: 5.25%.

- Average house price: £282k.

- Monthly repayment: £1500 (90% LTV, 25 year term).

- Average pre-tax income: £35k.

So in 1989, an average mortgage was about 80% of an average gross income. In 2024, an average mortgage is about 50% of an average gross income.

I specifically chose 1989 because it was a year of high interest rates, but you can repeat the calculation for other years if you wish. I don't think the results will support your assertion.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by willcipriano on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:43AM (#40536596)
If you got a mortgage at 14.5% you can refinance it when rates get lower, and people did.

The 2nd group can't "refinance" all the extra principal they owe.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Jochim on Sunday June 02, 2024 @09:34AM (#40553971)
Nationwide actually publish data about the monthly mortgage payment to take home pay ratios of first time buyers[0]. Compared to Q1 2014, repayments accounted for a lower proportion from when their data begins, in Q1 1983, until Q3 1988. Repayments remained higher until Q4 1990.

In 1989 interest rates were at record highs and mortgage interest relief was still a thing. Despite interest rates hovering between 8-12% for the rest of the 1980s, mortgage repayments were consistently a much lower proportion of income.

In 2024 there's no interest relief and we're exiting a period of record low rates. The rise to 5.25% already puts us in a worse position than when rates were at 10%, 14.5% would disastrous.

[0] https://www.nationwidehousepriceindex.co.uk/charts

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gnfargbl on Monday June 10, 2024 @08:28AM (#40632845)
A very late response, but just to say thanks for this. The full dataset you found is actually available at https://www.nationwidehousepriceindex.co.uk/download/ftb-mtg....

It is worth looking at the mid-2000s numbers (post-MIRAS, but pre-crash) and comparing them to today's numbers. They're really not so different.

No argument on the relative leverage: 10% would be impossible and 15% would probably precipitate a revolution.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jack_riminton on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:34AM (#40533332)
And how do you think NIMBY’s have influenced government policy? Perhaps by not voting for anyone who might allow houses to be built near them
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gnfargbl on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:33AM (#40533732)
I think the younger generations (me and you both included) have failed to effectively direct British political discourse towards the issues that actually matter to us. Instead, we allow lazy cliches ("blame boomers", "blame Europe", "blame immigrants") to dominate the conversation. We need to stop doing that.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by chownie on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:51AM (#40533893)
"blame Europe" and "blame immigrants" have had their claws in the UK electorate for longer than the younger generations have existed.

"Blame boomers" has existed for perhaps a decade if we're being generous.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Lio on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:34AM (#40532684)
Please stop with the cheap ageism. Whatever generation[1] you're in will be doing something out of your control that the next generation will look down on too.

1. ...and no, I'm not a Baby Boomer either.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by piyushpr134 on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:03AM (#40533170)
you would be surprised to note as to how universally true this comment of yours is. Reporting from India. Here, these folks fight these elections as if there is a billion dollars at the end and then do moral policing ALL day long. Level of turf fights, and self importance behaviour on display at these RWAs (we call them resident welfare association and believe me there is anything there apart from welfare!) is just mind boggling. It is always boomers who win these elections and are president, secretary and treasurer of these RWAs
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by UweSchmidt on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:05AM (#40534011)
Either address the fundamental economic issues and how to solve them in a pragmatic fashion

... or pour oil in the fire of the great culture war, here in the secondary frontline of young vs. old, and accomplish nothing.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mint2 on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:37AM (#40535781)
A lot of HOAs have reasonable boards but contract out a lot of management to companies (I wouldn’t be be surprised if they were owned by private equity firms).

These companies are incentivized to find infraction to fine, and drive around regularly to make sure every rule is strictly adhered to. Trash bins out too early or late? Fine! Fence painted the wrong shade of soulless beige? Fine!

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Simon_ORourke on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:13AM (#40532275)
What would be the repercussions of not paying any fines and bringing a case against the city for over-reach on private property?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by sethammons on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:20AM (#40532309)
In NC, the HOA can force foreclosure on unpaid fees, even if the home is paid off. And 80% of available houses are in an HOA. They have us. Anti-HOA legislation is needed, but the legislature is greased by their lobbying.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by newswasboring on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:37AM (#40532400)
I may be ignorant on this, but how can HOAs have lobbyists? They are made up of local people right? Or am I behind on this and there is already a HOA industry?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by shiroiushi on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:42AM (#40532427)
I'm not sure about this (someone please feel free to chime in), but HOAs are only "local people" after the developers have sold all the houses and moved on, at which point the HOA becomes controlled by the homeowners in the association with the most Nazi-like mentalities. Before this, the HOA is set up by the developer that bought all the land and developed the subdivision. So, presumably, the "HOA lobbyists" are actually the lobbyists for housing developers, which I think are definitely a real thing.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by michaelt on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:24AM (#40532637)
> how can HOAs have lobbyists?

They don't. For all the power an HOA might have in their street or apartment block, outside of that very small boundary they're nothing. We're not talking about Boeing or Morgan Stanley or PG&E here.

HOAs are actually popular by choice - developers wouldn't set them up for "80% of available houses" if the houses were more valuable without them.

2% of people have horror story experiences with corrupt HOAs pocketing their cash. 23% of people just get poor value for money where some asshole changes a lightbulb and charges 100 residents $1 each. 75% of people have a tolerable experience, and quite like the fact their neighbour can't park an RV on their driveway and rent it out on airbnb, and if that means limiting what people are allowed to do on their own driveway, so be it.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by hahajk on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:38AM (#40533357)
Cities also like them (alot) since they assume costs that cities usually pay for. Neighborhood parks are usually maintained by the HOAs. Less commonly sidewalks, roads, and water lines are maintained by the HOA.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by forgetfreeman on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:33AM (#40532678)
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:42AM (#40532723)
I could be wrong, but I am pretty sure that statistics like that only apply to newly–built housing. Older houses are far less likely to be in an HOA, because HOAs were simply not popular when they were built.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by wdh505 on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:26PM (#40538656)
I understood that cities just like free property tax (no cost of maintaining infrastructure) by making hoa zones
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by themoonisachees on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:15AM (#40532287)
The HOA is generally allowed to put a lien on your house, through the contract you were forced to sign with them.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by LeafItAlone on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:27AM (#40532342)
> through the contract you were forced to sign with them.

Except for Texas, I have not heard of being forced into an HOA. You choose to join one when buying a property in a neighborhood that has one.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jolmg on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:57AM (#40532497)
> Except for Texas, I have not heard of being forced into an HOA.

What's the story with Texas?

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mint2 on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:34AM (#40535723)
It’s not a choice when the overwhelming majority of available homes to buy have HOAs.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ikekkdcjkfke on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:20AM (#40532928)
Forced to sign a contract?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ornornor on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:48AM (#40532459)
Aren’t HOAs private entity? It was an HOA demand in this case, not a municipal one I think.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by afpx on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:58AM (#40533474)
I tried to have the HOA enforce rules against cutting down of trees. I even took it to a lawyer. I found out that many HOA covenants are written so poorly that they're not enforceable.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:33AM (#40532679)
Someone always scoffs, but I think it is usually a sign that they don’t really understand freedom. In particular, the freedom of association. Many countries recognize it, so I don't need to get in to the exact legal justifications for it.

Put plainly, this is the freedom to form groups that govern the behavior of their members. A group could be a dinner party, a study group, a book club, a circle of friends. It can also be much more serious. It could be a corporation, a union, a church, a political party, or a religion. Or it could be an HOA, or a town, or a state. If you like one or more of those types of groups then it is important to protect the freedom of association, even if you don’t like any of the others.

Every group has rules, even the most informal. When you invite your friends out to dinner you probably don’t sit down and vote on the exact rules your dinner party will follow, but your party has rules regardless. And every group punishes violations of the rules somehow. If you get drunk and dance naked on top of a table, then you will suffer some form of sanction by the other members of the dinner party. At the very least you probably won’t be invited back. More formal groups like HOAs, corporations, and towns tend to have written rules and proscribed punishments for violations. They also have built–in ways of changing those rules.

Ultimately some HOAs are useful while others are petty and run by vindictive idiots. An HOA that was useful for 50 years and never created any drama could turn bad next year when they elect some new board members. An HOA that is bad today _could_ elect new board members and then become drama–free and stay that way for 50 years, even if it seems unlikely. People who end up in a petty HOA usually regret it, and come to see joining any HOA as a big mistake. People in a sane HOA often wonder what the fuss is about.

But here’s the truth: true freedom includes the freedom to make mistakes, even big mistakes.

The freedom of association allows us to join any group we want, but sometimes joining will be a mistake. You can’t prevent people from making those mistakes without limiting their freedom. You can’t even reliably predict which mistakes they’re going to make, so you would end up preventing them from doing things that wouldn’t be mistakes too.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by robryk on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:34AM (#40533333)
HOAs require more than (or a very specific extension of) freedom of association to exist: they require an ability to bind any future owners of a piece of land to join the HOA (regardless of how they acquired that land: via sale, inheritance, bankruptcy, ...). For property that's not real estate that's usually not possible (see e.g. inability of companies to provide binding promises on how the data they have are used after they go bankrupt). Given that this ability applies very inconsistently across types of property, it doesn't seem like an essential part of freedom of association.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by throw0101c on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:27AM (#40533692)
> HOAs require more than […] freedom of association to exist: they require an ability to bind any future owners of a piece of land to join the HOA […].

You are often not buying a piece of land when you move to a HOA-linked residence, rather you can be buying a particular unit, but there are also 'common areas' that are the property of the legal entity of the HOA.

If you do not want to be part of an HOA then you have to purchase what is called (at least in Canada) freehold land.

> While most people hear the word “condo” and think of an apartment style unit, that’s not always the case. Some townhouses (and even certain detached homes) are considered condos too.

* https://teamkate.ca/difference-freehold-condo-home

* https://www.squareyards.ca/blog/freehold-vs-leasehold-regart...

* https://wowa.ca/freehold-meaning

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freehold_(law)

If you do not want to be part of an HOA tell your real estate broker that this is one of the criteria for where you want to live.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by anymouse123456 on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:45AM (#40534430)
I have no idea about Canada, but in the US, there are lots of single-family home neighborhoods that have, "Home Owner's Associations".
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by skeeter2020 on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:01AM (#40534613)
the GP wasn't talking about the type of structure but the legal organization of the property ownership. Canadian provinces have a Condominium Property Act that defines the legislative framework. The implementation can vary by types of units (ranging from apartment-style to single family homes) and the ownership - typically "you own the inside; communal outside" or "you own the inside & dirt; communal outside and shared public spaces". You don't hear talk of "The HOA" but rather "The Condo Board"
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by anymouse123456 on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @08:18AM (#40573701)
Thanks for the clarification.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by NoMoreNicksLeft on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:08AM (#40535393)
> If you do not want to be part of an HOA tell your real estate broker that this is one of the criteria for where you want to live.

Yes, tell your realtor "I don't want to look at any of the properties you have for sale, or any properties within the greater [insert city here] metro area, or for that matter any geographical location within 100 miles of here". He'd look at you less strangely, and might even chuckle instead of telling you to go fuck yourself and to not waste his time.

And the best part of all is that these two requests are essentially identical.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by nilamo on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:24PM (#40537876)
People talk to real estate agents? I thought things like Zillow completely eliminated that step...
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by insane_dreamer on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:50PM (#40538202)
All Zillow does is put you in touch with a real estate agent.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by marssaxman on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:12PM (#40538496)
Where do you live? That sounds terrible.

I would never consider any house encumbered with an HOA, and I would fire any realtor who ignored my wishes by showing one - but it's never been an issue, here in Seattle.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jghn on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:14PM (#40539710)
At least where I live such a request would barely remove any houses from your search. Your response is very location dependent.

I for one would not only not by an HOA encumbered home but I’d not move to an area where that would be an issue

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by javagram on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:51AM (#40535960)
The local government in many areas is often requiring an HOA to be formed for new developments to manage stormwater and road maintenance that they don’t want to be responsible for.

In those situations the HOA could be seen as government imposed rather than purely “freedom of association”.

I own a 100 year old home so there is no HOA but it’s difficult for most people to afford such homes since there’s a limited supply and they’re often either in highly desirable or blighted city centers.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by BobaFloutist on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:41PM (#40537268)
In all fairness, if the majority of the members of the HOA don't like them, surely they could vote to disband it?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:06PM (#40539647)
It can be done, yes. If the HOA owns and maintains common property then it has to dispose of that somehow. For example, it might need to sell the pool, get the city’s parks department to maintain the playground, and the wastewater department to maintain the drainage pond first.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by soco on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:50AM (#40532764)
There are many countries in the world which don't measure their freedom in eagles per square burger yet are totally free to associate, and they do. I cannot do much in my neighborhood either (Switzerland here) but there is a respected process for raising cases and handling exceptions and all that. We call this the rule of law, by no means perfect either. This doesn't seem to be the case with the HOA where the system guarantees you living under the will of the leadership - be they idiots or geniuses. So if liberty is defined by randomness, yes, HOA defines the land of the free. Otherwise please allows us to scoff.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mattmaroon on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:29AM (#40534245)
That is not how HOAs work. They have a very defined set of rules, and a very defined process for changing and enforcing those rules. You are not at the mercy of anyone.

Local laws supersede HOA rules where they conflict and often cause “grandfathering” when HOA rules change. For instance, my condo board tried to get me to remove my grill. I pointed out that nowhere in the condo bylaws was a grill mentioned. They said something about city fire codes, so I got a note from the fire department. They were unable to force me to do anything.

HOAs in my city have passed rules saying owners may not use their condos for short term rental. But my city law says that changes do not apply to people who owned their rentals before the rules changed. So new owners may not but old ones still can.

Rule of law still applies, and everything is agreed to when you buy the property. You could simply buy a home outside of an HOA, so this is, squarely, freedom of association.

Nobody was implying that other countries do not have this freedom, in fact, he said the fact that they do is why he did not need to justify it.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mechanicalpulse on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:32AM (#40535707)
> That is not how HOAs work. They have a very defined set of rules, and a very defined process for changing and enforcing those rules. You are not at the mercy of anyone.

This. I live in a drama-free HOA and appreciate it for what it is and does. I had to review and agree to the covenants of my HOA as a condition for closing. The rule most likely to be in violation here is something along the lines of “only operational automobiles in good condition are permitted to be parked in the driveway; any boats, recreational vehicles, broken down or unsightly vehicles must be behind a fence”. The whole point is to maintain a clean, safe, attractive, and ultimately desirable neighborhood so as to protect property values on behalf of the association’s members.

Although this homeowner’s actions are characteristic of malicious compliance, I believe the net effect is precisely in line with the stated purpose of the HOA: in compliance with the rules, an elegant mural depicting a pristine boat now adorns a new fence that restricts sight of and access to a boat of unknown condition. Anyone driving by looking to buy might come away with a chuckle and the sense that the neighborhood is committed to maintaining a safe and attractive environment for homeowners.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by NoMoreNicksLeft on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:15AM (#40535472)
> You are not at the mercy of anyone.

In many jurisdictions within the United States, an HOA can assess fines for exceedingly trivial violations, then after the fines remain unpaid for a time period as short as 6 weeks, file to sell your home at auction to pay the fees. They can take your home from you, evict you from it, and this is deemed perfectly legal. Do they have to provide proof, for instance, that your grass was actually one half inch too tall? No, there is no adversarial process where they would have to prove that were the case.

> I pointed out that nowhere in the condo bylaws was a grill mentioned. They said something about city fire codes, so I got a note from the fire department. They were unable to force me to do anything.

It must be very thrilling to be able to be an amateur lawyer and win a case. Have fun, because those people tend to hold grudges. My experience is that you'll never have a week of peace for as long as you live there again.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mattmaroon on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:29PM (#40537131)
This all happened 3 years ago. I’ve never heard a word from my HOA since. I think the HOA board actually believed it was against fire code, but it turns out that’s only true if you’re not on the ground floor. (My community is 4 stories so 3/4 of people cannot have grills). Other grills have appeared since.

They can only assess you fines for violations of rules you agreed to. And fines are usually small. For instance, in my last HOA, they fined me $15 for having A flag holder. I ignored the warning because it was there when I bought the place and I didn’t really want it anyway, and then when the fine came, I simply removed the flag holder and paid $15. Most of the cases were the end up confiscating somebody’s property is because they are simply egregiously not doing something they had already signed a contract saying they would do. I am sure there are cases, they always are, but it isn’t a legitimate problem.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jjav on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:54PM (#40540715)
> That is not how HOAs work. They have a very defined set of rules, and a very defined process for changing and enforcing those rules. You are not at the mercy of anyone.

This is very idealistic, but not quite how it works. HOA boards can and do constantly violate with impunity the rules they are supposed to follow. Most often to embezzle funds but also to enforce their personal will.

You can contest this of course, you can go to court. It takes pretty deep pockets to pay for lawyers and years of persistence. I know multiple people in years-and-years-long legal battles with HOAs. Those who have enough money to see it through often usually win, but it takes a lot of patience and money. Most people don't have that kind of cash to blow on fighting corrupt HOAs.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Lendal on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:08AM (#40534036)
Most people in the US don't live in an HOA. You may join one and enjoy its benefits, or not. Nobody is forced to. Many people want to join an HOA to enjoy its benefits but not obey its rules. These are the type of people who believe they are the center of the universe yet are in such a unique position that the laws of the rest of the universe don't apply to them.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by _heimdall on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:22AM (#40534159)
Its worth noting that its common, at least in my experience, for HOA membership to be part of a real estate purchase contract. Meaning, if you want to buy a house and it happens to be in a neighborhood with an HOA, you don't have the option to buy that house and not join the HOA.

I've never understood why we allow that to be legal, just like neighborhoods or complexes that are age restricted, but we allow it none the less.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mattmaroon on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:41AM (#40534396)
We allow it to be legal because:

1. Most homes aren’t in an HOA, so you have plenty of options if you don’t like it.

2. It prevents all sorts of tragedies of the commons.

3. HOAs would have no power at all if you could opt out. It has to be part of the contract. They can be dissolved entirely, but that’s the only mechanism for getting out.

4. We believe in individual freedom, which includes the ability to chose to trade freedom for certain benefits. I trade my freedom to leave a rusty old boat in my driveway for the benefit of not having my neighbors do that. Most of us don’t have or want the sorts of things that bring down property values and don’t want to suddenly find ourselves living next to people who do.

This is perhaps a symptom of a larger problem: homes are very expensive. If homes were cheap and moving were easy, perhaps HOAs would never have been invented. But for most Americans who own one a home is a substantial portion of their net worth. We want to protect it.

People who complain about HOAs existing are the same as the people who complain about EVs. If you don’t want one, don’t buy it.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by supplied_demand on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:14AM (#40534737)
==If homes were cheap and moving were easy, perhaps HOAs would never have been invented. But for most Americans who own one a home is a substantial portion of their net worth. We want to protect it.==

It may not have been the reason for their invention (I can't find information on that), but they certainly exploded in popularity in an effort to restrict people from selling their homes to non-white people (see: Racially Restrictive Covenants). It's kind of ironic to see people laud them as a form of "freedom" while their history as a tool of blatant racial discrimination is available for all to read.

==People who complain about HOAs existing are the same as the people who complain about EVs. If you don’t want one, don’t buy it.==

Doesn't this act as a type of restriction on housing supply thus increasing the upward pressure on housing costs by limiting options? Not to mention the actual costs of funding the HOA, which directly increases housing prices.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mattmaroon on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:24PM (#40539244)
I would not be surprised if it once served a racist function, a lot of things did, and I’m glad that’s now illegal. I wouldn’t be surprised if it still happens sometimes but I’m sure it’s the exception rather than the rule.

Most HOAs don’t even have the right to screen tenants, if you can purchase the house and will sign the contract you’re in and have the same voting rights and responsibilities as the other residents.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by supplied_demand on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:53PM (#40541177)
==I would not be surprised if it once served a racist function==

It is a verifiable fact found across the country [0]. Many of the covenants still exist today, although they are legally unenforceable. That said, I have read many comments on this site about how non-competes have long been considered legally unenforceable, but can still have a chilling effect on those impacted (Thankfully, this has recently changed).

I think the more interesting aspect, in regards to today's world, is how HOAs lead to even higher housing costs during a housing affordability crisis. This happens through both explicit expenses (monthly HOA dues) and implicit expenses (lawn maintenance, regulation of architectural changes/additions, rental restrictions, etc.) on homeowners.

[0] https://www.npr.org/2021/11/17/1049052531/racial-covenants-h...

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by _heimdall on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:21AM (#40534797)
> 1. Most homes aren’t in an HOA, so you have plenty of options if you don’t like it.

That'd be an interesting stat to see, I assume it varies greatly by location.

> 2. It prevents all sorts of tragedies of the commons.

How so? Collective power can make tragedy of the commons problems worse. While a single family likely wouldn't buy up an adjacent piece of woods to clear for a neighborhood park, an HOA may be able to do that before someone else buys and develops the woods.

> 3. HOAs would have no power at all if you could opt out. It has to be part of the contract. They can be dissolved entirely, but that’s the only mechanism for getting out.

HOAs have whatever power the community gives them, there's nothing saying an HOA couldn't be optional. I actually lived in a neighborhood outside of Seattle with an optional HOA, it worked just fine.

> 4. We believe in individual freedom, which includes the ability to chose to trade freedom for certain benefits. I trade my freedom to leave a rusty old boat in my driveway for the benefit of not having my neighbors do that. Most of us don’t have or want the sorts of things that bring down property values and don’t want to suddenly find ourselves living next to people who do.

And that's totally reasonable. My point wasn't that there aren't incentives for homeowners to make that choice for themselves, only that it has always felt like an infringement of rights to legally bind a property to HOA governance.

> People who complain about HOAs existing are the same as the people who complain about EVs. If you don’t want one, don’t buy it.

I'm not sure where you're getting this anecdote, but here I am complaining about HOAs and I own an EV. This analogy really doesn't fit, one person's decision to buy an EV has no impact on other's right to choose what to buy where as an HOA does.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mattmaroon on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:08AM (#40535388)
I suppose the commons issue depends on how you define the commons. HOAs often have communal areas like a pool. A communal pool with many owners no HOA would quickly become a disaster and probably form something like an HOA really fast.

An optional HOA would just be opted out of by the worst offenders. If the whole goal is to keep your neighbors from ruining your property value, the ones who do would just opt out. The guy with the car on blocks can just sell himself his own house to get out of it.

How is anything you get into willingly an infringement on your rights? Nobody ever had to buy a house that had to remain inside an HOA. They chose to and can choose not to.

That’s what I meant by the EV thing. You’re complaining about a choice other people made willingly. Why not just not make the choice and let others do it?

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by _heimdall on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:11PM (#40538484)
That's interesting, I'm not actually sure how a community pool would really exist without an entity that's responsible for it (either an HOA, the city/county, or a private club).

> How is anything you get into willingly an infringement on your rights?

Sure, once you sign the contract you've agreed to it. My point is just that it seems unreasonable for an HOA to effectively claim authority or ownership over a piece of property. I once lived in an HOA neighborhood that was in legal proceedings with a neighbor who refused to play along, the neighborhood was pretty damn close to foreclosing on the property before the owner finally sold and left.

The EV example is still very different though. Buyers can choose to but any vehicle they want, there is no higher authority attempting to claim authority over some vehicles and requiring you submit to their rules and pay a membership fee. Buy an EV or don't, its totally up to the buyer. Additionally, when an EV owner wants to sell they aren't limited to the pool of buyers willing to join a private club, you just sell the car.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mattmaroon on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:22PM (#40539217)
Well again, the person who the HOA was in legal proceedings against signed a document saying they would do “x” then did not do “x”. The document also outlined what happens if they didn’t do it, including, at the very end, taking the house. I believe every state has laws that make it very hard for an HOA to foreclose, they do not just do it on a whim. It’s simple contract enforcement, just as you’d get your house taken if you didn’t pay your mortgage or city property taxes. I don’t see what the issue is. I’m sure there are some egregious corner cases, there always are, but as a rule I see no problem with someone who signs a contract being bound by the terms of the contract, in fact I’d see a problem if they weren’t.

My point about the EVs is people who hate EVs and do ridiculous stuff like block chargers are simply getting mad about other people’s decisions that don’t effect them. I don’t want an EV so I don’t own one, but I’m in no way angry that they exist or that you do.

Hating your own HOA I totally understand, there are days I hate mine, but hating the idea that someone else is in an HOA willingly I do not.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by NoMoreNicksLeft on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:30AM (#40535675)
> Most homes aren’t in an HOA, so you have plenty of options if you don’t like it.

If we are talking about suburban/urban homes, some large percentage are in an HOA. Most people who own instead of renting do have to contend with HOAs. There are not plenty of options. In many cases, there are no other options at all.

> It prevents all sorts of tragedies of the commons.

What sort of "tragedy of the commons" does it prevent, exactly? That because I was laid off and had to take a lower-paying, higher-houred job, my house goes unpainted a little too long, and now the paint's peeling and chipping? That because of weather, I had to wait 3 extra weekends to mow the lawn (can't do it when I go home after work, not allowed to do it after 6pm or whatever) and now it's too tall?

These aren't tragedies.

> HOAs would have no power at all if you could opt out.

Exactly. But you never bothered to ask why they should ever have power at all. The people who have these powers are people who should never have power under any conceivable circumstances. If there were a way to somehow discover people who craved to be on HOA boards, I would support a constitutional amendment to rescind their voting rights.

> We believe in individual freedom, which includes the ability to chose

Spoken by the sort of person who cheers on as the non-HOA choices dwindle to nothing.

I have a compromise that just occurred to me. If, for instance, only 1.2% of homes within a given region (perhaps legislative districts) could be included within an HOA, and if the HOAs had to bid on an HOA license, such that they're competing with each other to be included in the HOA... then the true cost of HOA apologism could be factored into the market. If you want to live in one, and if that HOA has to pay for a $12 million annual license (they could easily be bid up this high, and if you're honest with yourself you know I'm right), then who am I to tell you HOAs are bad? You're paying a premium for it and it's restricted to a tiny fraction of all available homes.

> If homes were cheap and moving were easy, perhaps HOAs would never have been invented.

Not even close to how this works. The people who favor HOAs are emotionally invested in how others manage their own households. They're not the kind of people who are easily chased away. Quite the contrary, they want to chase others away. You know, the wrong kind of people.

> People who complain about HOAs existing are the same as the people who complain about EVs. If you don’t want one, don’t buy it.

Funny that example, you belong to a political constituency that is doing whatever they can to make it illegal to sell any non-EV.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mattmaroon on Saturday June 01, 2024 @11:27AM (#40546527)
I thought you were an idiot until the last sentence and now I know it. "Eighty-nine percent of homeowners who live under an HOA say the HOA's rules protect and enhance property values". You can't tell someone's political constituency when they belong to the same group as 90% of people. You're certainly wrong about mine, and nearly everything else you said, to the point where there's nothing here worth responding to. This drivel belongs on Reddit.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by freeopinion on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:32AM (#40534914)
Let's say I sell you a basketball with some restrictions. For instance, you are never allowed to kick the ball. If you ever kick the ball, some pre-defined penalty is imposed.

You might say that I didn't sell the ball. I sold a bundle of rights regarding the ball, but I retained some other bundle of rights.

Your gym membership accords you some rights, but not all rights to the gym equipment. Do you think that should be illegal?

As long as a contract clearly delineates which rights are included and excluded I don't understand why you would want this to be illegal.

You might question why somebody would buy a car that contains a radio but the purchase of the car doesn't include the radio and the new owner is not allowed to manipulate the radio. It may not make sense to you. But that doesn't make the arrangement illegal.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by SpaceNoodled on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:57AM (#40536752)
Illegality and immorality are too often at odds.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by _heimdall on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:12PM (#40538491)
Laws that the majority view as immoral should just be abolished. We don't do that nearly enough, but that'd be a part of any functional legal system that's actually designed by and for the people.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by hylaride on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:41AM (#40535842)
I don't understand it myself, but some people like the forced conformity and the legal requirement to fund and maintain certain amenities, including streets, etc. Maybe it's an (over)reaction to "to much freedom" in some sense of the phrase. It's probably also a way to bypass greater government and keep infrastructure funds more hyper-local, which can have social consequences.

That being said I live in a condominium, but it's an apartment-style one. It's the only way I can afford to live in the central city. In that case there needs to be some setup to maintain the elevators, overall structure, and other common elements. But if I owned a house with actual land, the only restrictions I'd want are on actual nuisances (mostly continuous noise - a party once in awhile is fine) or safety.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by kennethwolters on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:48AM (#40533089)
Switzerland is an "ultra-localist" country according to Nassim Nicholas Taleb and I'd agree. The Kantons have more power than the federal government. So in essence, Switzerland and the USA are much alike. It's just that the USA has a flavor of this localism so extreme and chaotic that the resident in a way is supposed to relocate to a better place if they don't like it (see residents fleeing California for better places). Switzerland seems to have a more orderly form of localism where instead of the resident, the representative moves.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by AmericanChopper on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:26AM (#40532956)
> So if liberty is defined by randomness, yes, HOA defines the land of the free

It’s the freedom to choose an HOA, or alternatively, anything else you like.

Also, while HOAs might make decisions stupidly, I don’t think they do it randomly.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:18AM (#40533262)
they are doing it to exclude those that don't fit into their style of life. it's discrimination, plain and simple.

to compare with europe: as far as i know germany or austria don't have the equivalent of a HOA, but what is allowed and what isn't is defined by local law. the closest example i could find are rules a landlord is allowed to impose on their tenants. for example, if i rent a house with garden, then the landlord can demand that i take care of the garden, but they can not specify how often i am supposed to mow the lawn or how high i let it grow.

if not even a landlord can make such rules for their own property, then a HOA would have even less chance to make such rules for homeowners.

that said, local laws can be quite far reaching, especially when it comes to aspects that affect the character of a neighborhood which includes rules on the outside design of the house and the front yard. not something i am happy about myself. beyond that these rules are mostly about things directly affect and cause problems for the neighbors. otherwise a homeowner has the right to do whatever they want on their property.

as for the freedom to choose an HOA. no such freedom exists. because my choice of where i live is not defined by the HOA but by other considerations like location and cost and most importantly, availability. the argument that i could have moved somewhere else if i didn't like this HOA is not really reasonable given the housing shortage in most places.

the right to live somewhere trumps the freedom of association

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by germanier on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:42AM (#40533804)
In Germany there is the in some - but not all - aspects similar concept of WEG (Wohneigentumsgemeinschaft).
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:53AM (#40534522)
ah, right, but those are only in apartment buildings. it's a good place to research though what responsibilities and powers those have.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by germanier on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:15PM (#40539733)
In buildings with differently owned apartments it's required but in theory (and in some places in practice) you could also setup multiple buildings on a common plot of land with one.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by AmericanChopper on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:45AM (#40533830)
> they are doing it to exclude those that don't fit into their style of life. it's discrimination, plain and simple.

Freedom of association is the freedom to associate with whoever you choose and not to associate with anybody you choose not to. You can’t have feeedom of association without the freedom to discriminate against people you don’t want to associate with.

> the argument that i could have moved somewhere else if i didn't like this HOA is not really reasonable given the housing shortage in most places.

Less than a third of US households are a part of HOAs, with most of them being apartments (where that type of regulation is typical almost everywhere in the world). Your argument that HOAs are monopolising housing supply doesn’t stand up to the facts.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beeboobaa3 on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:07AM (#40534030)
> Freedom of association is the freedom to associate with whoever you choose and not to associate with anybody you choose not to

Yikes. Got it. You're a horrible racist and your opinion is invalid.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by AmericanChopper on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:15AM (#40534102)
I really hope you’re joking. Freedom of association is fundamentally the freedom to discriminate. Either you don’t understand that, or you just don’t like the concept so you’re trying to imply that I use it to discriminate against racial groups.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mlrtime on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:23AM (#40534178)
Am I the only one that sees the quantity of these low value comments entering in HN?

To the parent and top thread op, Please stay on reddit and off HN.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beeboobaa3 on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:03AM (#40535322)
Calling out racists? It's not worth the energy to engage with them beyond that.

> You can’t have feeedom of association without the freedom to discriminate against people you don’t want to associate with.

Is code for "no blacks or jews", especially in the context of HOAs.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by AmericanChopper on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:53AM (#40536712)
It absolutely is not. Freedom of association means precisely what I have described it to mean. There are legal constraints on how that freedom can be used, as well as ethical considerations in how it should be used (which is the same with every conceivable freedom).

If freedom of association didn’t grant you rights to discriminate against people you don’t want to associate with, then you wouldn’t have the liberty of discriminating against the racists you don’t want to associate with (though in this case they exist exclusively in your imagination).

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by AlexandrB on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:02AM (#40533978)
> You can’t have feeedom of association without the freedom to discriminate against people you don’t want to associate with.

So I should be free to leave an HOA? No wait, I can't without selling my house as well. Restricting the right to free association as a condition for purchasing housing seems onerous.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by AmericanChopper on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:14AM (#40534090)
How could you end up in an HOA without choosing the be in one? You couldn’t…

Freedom of association isn’t a magic ability that means you can never regret entering a contract.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:57AM (#40534574)
how? by not being able to find a house that is not governed by an HOA
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by nradov on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:25AM (#40534834)
Don't be ridiculous. Every metropolitan area has some homes for sale which aren't part of an HOA. If you don't like the price or location or school district or something then that's your problem, not an issue with the concept of HOAs.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by lupusreal on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:39AM (#40535006)
But you can, so what are you even complaining about?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:55AM (#40534549)
80% of homes on sale today come with an HOA (according to john oliver)
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by crmd on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:57AM (#40534564)
In the United States it would be discrimination if, for example, the rules were selectively enforced against people of a certain protected class such as race or religion.

HOA control is simply a covenant written into the deed of certain properties by the original developer that is then inherited in perpetuity by future deed holders.

The deeds of all properties on certain blocks in my neighborhood have a similar covenant saying that your building must be set back 14 feet from the curb in order to create a luxury boulevard-width sidewalk.

A homeowner can’t sell me the right to build up to the curb or the right to ignore the HOA because they can’t sell a right they never owned in the first place.

Freedom of association is not relevant here.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:36AM (#40534967)
it is also discrimination if a rule applies to everyone, but only a certain group is actually affected by the rule. for example forbidding to build a ramp would be discriminating against wheelchair users, whereas others don't even need a ramp.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by CRConrad on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @07:59AM (#40657075)
> In the United States it would be discrimination if, for example, the rules were selectively enforced against people of a certain protected class such as race or religion.

To modernize an old sawhorse, those don't-lie-down-here spikes on flat surfaces make it impossible for millionaires and the homeless alike to sleep in many places. That's not so much of a problem for the millionaires.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gpvos on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:42AM (#40533378)
Freedom? You usually have to live somewhere near your work or where other family lives, and most HOAs have very similar cookie-cutter rules with the differences determined by something akin to mob rule.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:02AM (#40533499)
Most housing in the US is not part of an HOA. In fact, around half is apartments, and apartment dwellers are subject to rules made by their landlords. In an HOA (or condo association), at least you can vote on the rules or join the board.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by arghwhat on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:20AM (#40533271)
You do not have the freedom to choose an HOA, only the freedom to move somewhere else. Unless you define "freedom" as "not held captive", I don't think that really counts.

A fun John Oliver video on how corrupt HOA's are: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qrizmAo17Os

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by AmericanChopper on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:39AM (#40533773)
I think HOAs are dumb, but who had ever been forced to buy a home that’s part of an HOA?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:03AM (#40534637)
according to the video, that would be 80% of those buying a home today.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by lacksconfidence on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:18AM (#40534769)
It's not a force, it's a choice. When we bought our home every home built in the area in the last 40 years had an HOA. The only non-HOA choices are basically taking a giant gamble on how terribly the previous owners updated it to modern standards, instead of buying something built with modern plumbing and electrics. So sure, the HOA was a choice. But it was forced.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by maicro on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:30AM (#40534891)
As an American with a strong general preference for the metric system, "eagles per square burger" is my new favorite sarcastic unit.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jl6 on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:16AM (#40533250)
It's an interesting tradeoff of freedoms when you consider how free a person is to leave a HOA. Purely legally speaking, they are free to leave at any time if the HOA starts to enforce unjust restrictions - but practically speaking, moving house is onerous and many are not in a position to do it. This is essentially a contract where you enter freely, but the other party has the ability to vary the terms unilaterally, and your only recourse is to exit.

A tech analogy comes to mind. We freely choose to host our workloads in a Server Owner's Association (sorry, cloud service provider), and we take on the risk that the provider may change the offering and impose restrictions that we don't like. They will tell us that we are free to leave at any time, but switching clouds can be non-trivial to say the least, leaving us feeling trapped and decidedly unfree.

The freedom to enter into private contracts is the freedom to bind oneself.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:08AM (#40533537)
I would say that your first recourse is the ability to read all the financial documents. As a property owner in an HOA you have every right to read the contracts that your HOA has signed, to audit the books, and to otherwise verify that the HOA board is doing their job correctly. Second recourse is to vote in the elections. If you elect petty tyrants, you get petty tyranny. Third is to run for the board yourself to make sure things are being done correctly.

And if all that is too tiresome then yea, sell your property and buy a house that isn’t in an HOA. Most houses aren’t.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by pavel_lishin on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:05AM (#40534005)
Isn't this just the "if you don't like it, leave" argument?

Selling your house and buying a different one that isn't in an HOA isn't as trivial as you make it sound. And in some parts of the country, it's rather difficult to find a house that isn't part of an HOA - in Texas, many neighborhoods get built with an HOA built-in.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by FeloniousHam on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:39AM (#40534364)
There's a disconnect in these comments that suggest a homeowner is forced into an HOA; for the vast (vast!) majority of cases, the HOA (and it's publicly available rules) are pre-existing to the home purchase. The rules can be annoying, but the primary purpose is the preserve the sale value of the properties.

I'm ambivalent about an HOA, but my father's neighbors probably wished they had one when they were selling their house (he had two broken cars and one broke down lawn mower in the driveway for years).

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by pavel_lishin on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:17AM (#40534758)
Well, that's true - nobody is forced to buy a house. (Though, sometimes, they inherit one that's hard to sell due to an HOA.)

But on the other hand, housing supply is limited. Sometimes your choices are "a decent house close to a decent school with an HOA" or "I guess we'll move seven hours away from everyone we've ever known" or "The neighbor's meth lab probably won't detonate this year, right?"

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by alistairSH on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:36AM (#40533756)
Most houses arent

I’m sure this is true nationally, but does it hold locally for areas with good employment prospects? And once you remove apartments (which don’t have HOAs but are subject to the tyranny of the landlord instead)?

Genuinely asking because I can’t think of too many areas in NoVA that don’t have HOAs.

Correction… There are areas of older housing without, but any subdivisions built since the 80s seems to have one. The areas without tend to be older “downtown” areas (Arlington - very expensive) or on the outskirts (Fairfax Station - very expensive).

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:39PM (#40539984)
I don't have any statistics ready to hand, but my recollection is that most households are not in an HOA, but that most newly–built houses are. It is my understanding that cities have started to rely on HOAs to own and maintain infrastructure that would once have been the domain of the city, and that cities are doing this to avoid raising taxes.

On the one hand that makes a lot of sense. If you want your neighborhood to have a park, but you also want the streets built so that they lengthen all trips in and out of the neighborhood, then the park is really only going to be usable by people who live there. It is therefore unfair for people on the other side of the city to pay for maintenance of that park.

On the other hand, HOAs can turn into drama factories. Too many people vehemently hate their HOA for being petty tyrants.

On the gripping hand, city governments can be pretty annoying too. San Francisco apparently takes an average of three years to approve building permits. A few years back my favorite restaurant (not located in SF) was being remodeled, and the owner took the opportunity to replace the front door. The original was 40 years old and wearing out, so she replaced it with a virtually identical steel and glass door, the kind you can find on commercial buildings from here to Vladivostok. The city spent an extra month hassling her about it, worried that she was destroying the historical character of the town. Madness.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Lendal on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:29AM (#40534249)
This is a great analogy. I can think of one area in which it might be different though. In smaller HOAs such as mine, the HOA almost never takes any action of its own volition. It's almost always the result of some neighbor making a complaint forcing the HOA's hand, then the neighbor hides behind whatever action they compel the HOA to make. The HOA becomes the boogeyman and goes on the news, while the actual complainant gets to remain safely anonymous.

I've seen corporate firms that run HOAs professionally where they run a much more proactive/activist HOA, but in the case of my neighborhood we didn't like the results so we fired them. It was too much hawkishness about rules and the fees were heading through the roof. The more leisurely neighbor-complaint model seems to work better unfortunately. It's more efficient, even though it's quite a cowardly system if you ask me. It's better than the alternatives such as having anarchy.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by primitivesuave on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:25AM (#40532952)
I would add that this statement might equally apply to government - that is, if you disagree with the policies of a local government (property tax too high, school district underperforming, etc), move somewhere else. If you disagree with your state, move to another one. And if you disagree with national policies, immigrate to a country whose policies you agree with. But therein lies the pitfall of freedom of association - if you disagree with your HOA, or your local/state/federal government, you may not have the financial or legal means to change your situation.

I see a dichotomy of "associations with oversight" and the converse (associations with no oversight). If your HOA forces you to build a fence, there is no appeal process similar to if a government entity charges you with a crime (e.g. appeal to a state/federal circuit court and ultimately to a supreme court). Within each is an enforcement mechanism that may or may not work. In your dinner party example, which is an association with no oversight, a naked table dancer may simply crash the subsequent gatherings. In all levels of government, there are those who continue to hold their position regardless of the misdeeds and accusations levied against them.

Perhaps that is the essential trade-off of freedom, to be free to associate with any group of people despite the possibility of being victimized by them (now or in the future).

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by lores on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:34AM (#40533338)
Not a dig on you, but I find it telling that in discussions about the freedom of upping up and leaving, money is always mentioned as a limiting factor, but never community. For many, moving means losing the social ties they have, and that can be devastating. I wonder if it's a HN or American oversight.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by alistairSH on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:38AM (#40533770)
Does HN have a higher than average # of immigrants or first-generation citizens? That could explain it.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by SpaceNoodled on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:01PM (#40536794)
No, introverts.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by randomdata on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:34AM (#40534305)
What do you mean? Per the discussion, escaping social ties is the whole point of wanting to leave. If you fit into the community, what reason would there be to leave?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by lores on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:07AM (#40536150)
You can have a community in the neighbourhood who aren't ruling the HOA.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by randomdata on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:10AM (#40536194)
But then said community will overthrow the HOA, so, again, no reason to leave. The earlier suggestion of leaving was based on a situation where you don't find the community you need. Escaping the social ties was the sole reason for leaving. Why would escaping a community that you don't fit into be the same limiting factor that keeps you there? That doesn't make any sense.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by lores on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:13AM (#40536227)
Why would you think that is the case?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by randomdata on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:14AM (#40536237)
Because I do not believe that HOAs are magic. What makes you think that they are?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by nradov on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:29AM (#40534878)
My grandparents immigrated to the USA and lost all their social ties. They were better off for it.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by CogitoCogito on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:30AM (#40533307)
Yeah I'm having trouble understanding how /u/db48x's logic doesn't apply equally well to all political systems. Maybe the next time someone complains to me about Biden's policies, I should just respond that they don't understand freedom.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:15AM (#40533590)
The USA believes so hard in the freedom of association that we are willing to let people leave whenever they want. You don’t need permission, just find somewhere better and go there. Compare that with the Soviet Union, or East Germany, or China, or North Korea. In those countries leaving may technically be allowed, but may require a lifetime of asking for permission. The Soviet Union didn’t even provide its own people with maps lest they find out where the borders were.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mlrtime on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:28AM (#40534240)
As an American "leaving" you may need to pay your taxes on the way out (giving up citizenship).
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ohmyiv on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:34AM (#40534925)
> Compare that with the Soviet Union, or East Germany, or China, or North Korea

Would it be better to compare current, non-totalitarian governments, such as EU, Australia, or the like? It kind of sounds disingenuous to use extreme examples. (No dig to you or your opinion, just don't see how using those examples helps.)

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:24PM (#40539819)
As I already said, many countries have freedom of association to one degree or another. You could spend a lot of effort to distinguish countries with a similar degree of freedom, but I chose to list a few obvious examples of countries that do not have that freedom. Or did not, as the case may be.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by kennethwolters on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:26AM (#40532958)
The more a person is dependent on "associated or local governments" [1] relative to "national or supernational governments", the more freedom they enjoy.

This is somewhat counter-intuitive because one might think that if e.g. every resident of a nation had to obey a singular and simple set of national rules, that would promote freedom more than having governments and rules differ between regions.

I wont go deeply into the underlying mechanisms of why the more chaotic choice promotes freedom while the more orderly choice reduces freedom but it has something to do with organisations competing for members and members being willing/free to move between those organisations.

[1] HOAs, school districts, unions, chapters, guilds, bars, insurances

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by eru on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:01AM (#40533162)
I'm OK with national governments, if the nation in question is a city state.

All hail Singapore!

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:51AM (#40534494)
but there is no competition among HOAs. there isn't enough freedom to move around. there isn't even a chaotic choice because most HOAs are the same. and when 80% of homes sold today are governed by an HOA there is also no choice not to join one.

and i am not buying the whole argument. if we accept a hierarchy of governing structures, from the HOA at the bottom, and let's go all the way, the united nations at the top, each level has a a certain set of responsibilities and powers. the difference in the levels is determined by how centralized or distributed those are. but there is no escaping the levels.

the problem is that it is unclear who is responsible to deal with overreach. in the US HOAs are largely unregulated, and so there is no protection against overreach. and in particular, they are not government but private organizations.

i am of the opinion that mandatory membership in an organization makes that organization an extension of government, and thus it should be bound by the rules local governments must follow.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by kennethwolters on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:30AM (#40535679)
I anticipated this type of reply that states that for HOAs there is not enough freedom of movement and diversity of "HOA flavours" to reap the benefits of this localist/federalist system. And you are right. The situation seems dire and the question is how do we solve this problem?

Do we do so by smashing HOAs (and giving the responsibilities to someone else)? I believe this is the wrong approach because it will destroy any potential for this localist (and thus inherently good, imo) system to heal. You're basically passing the baton onto another entity that might do a better job off the start but will inevitably fail because it is even less capable of evolving.

I'd rather try to discourage rigidity/complacency and incentivise innovation in the HOA-space which is much more complex to implement but better than smashing HOAs.

Regarding your point about "not buying the whole argument": I think it would be foolish to organise a military or pandemic-prevention-force on a municipal level. The levels need to exist and some higher levels have responsibilities that the lower levels don't have. I absolutely believe that this is good.

In conclusion, somehow communities of a certain region need to be organised if they want to be organised, especially when the region is densely populated. I'd rather organise these communities through self-emergent associations than top-down mandated government. And yes, the self-emergent association-type HOA is broken. I'd rather fix it than replace it with a inherently worse alternative.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:00AM (#40536063)
sorry for not expressing myself clearly. by not buying the argument i was referring to the idea that we can be more or less dependent on levels of government. i believe we are always 100% dependent on all levels. but in some ways we are always less dependent on local levels of government because we can move. but i have the impression we are applying different definitions to terms here, especially to what it means to be dependent.

for the most part i actually agree with you. i too favor a localist/federalist approach. and where i said you can't escape the levels, i might have added: nor should you want to. because as you say, the levels need to exist.

one of the problems i see in the US is that while the system is doing relatively well at the federalist approach, not enough is done to protect the weaker individuals from those with power over them. especially at the local level.

so while i agree that experimentation is good, certain basic rights need to be safeguarded.

another thing is fixing vs replacing HOAs. again that comes down to what fixing or replacing mean.

it is important to me that organizations that govern my life in a community are actually considered government.

an HOA currently only involves homeowners, but not those who rent there. that's the first thing i would fix. so HOAs become neighborhood councils. and beyond that it is just a matter of levels. so if you mean that replacing local HOAs with a community council covering a larger area is a bad idea, then i agree with you. i mean to replace it with a different democratic structure at the same level, with largely the same responsibilities but with more clear restrictions to protect individual rights and freedoms.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Saturday June 01, 2024 @05:48PM (#40549344)
one of the problems i see in the US is that while the system is doing relatively well at the federalist approach, not enough is done to protect the weaker individuals from those with power over them. especially at the local level

interestingly, i just came across this democracy index:

https://www.democracymatrix.com/online-analysis/matrix#/char...

and it shows that "guarantee of rights" is the weakest, which fits my feelings

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by anhner on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:32AM (#40533726)
There is no freedom of association if there is no freedom FROM association.

That is, if your only option is to buy a house within a HOA or not but that house, you're not really free...

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by shadowgovt on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:08AM (#40534039)
But when those groups are tied to real estate ownership they aren't free associations, they are serfdoms.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by _the_inflator on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:53AM (#40533118)
Interesting details and case analysis from your side here. HOAs are subject to debate frequently.

Philosophically, freedom has, among other dimensions, the dimension of negative and positive freedom: being free from something and free to do something.

Freedom usually refers to individual rights against the state. Freedom to have private contracts is part of what distinguishes socialism from capitalism.

What you describe regarding group associations is correct. Others are correct, too, when they appeal to freedom as the right to be spared from something.

Freedom to form groups does not mean being forced to join them. That's the point here. HOAs are partly like cartels, in my view.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Calavar on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:42AM (#40532726)
Freedom of association is missing the point when it comes to HOAs.

There's some very significant differences between freedom to associate in a book club and freedom to associate in an HOA. If you don't like a book club, there is no scenario in which you are contractually obligated to join it and pay membership fees indefinitely. And the bookclub doesn't have broad legal authority, backed by the courts, to dictate how you maintain, use, and sell your personal property or even aspects of your lifestyle.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dullcrisp on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:11AM (#40532884)
Book clubs aside, the ability to join a HOA is a freedom. Contrarily, if the Supreme Court forces New York City to allow guns in its Walmarts, that would be a restriction of freedom.

Freedom isn’t the same as lawlessness.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by hiatus on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:05AM (#40533181)
Businesses can't discriminate against different races either, you give up some freedoms when you hold yourself open to the public.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dullcrisp on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:22AM (#40533282)
You’re right, disallowing race-based discrimination is also a restriction of freedom. I’m not arguing that all freedoms are good.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by maxerickson on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:17AM (#40533612)
HOAs are often tied to a piece of land, with it being mandatory to join if you buy the land.

You are free to not buy the land of course.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by throw0101c on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:32AM (#40533720)
> HOAs are often tied to a piece of land, with it being mandatory to join if you buy the land.

Legally speaking one is often not buying the land but rather buying the unit. The land on which the unit sits is owned by a corporation (HOA), and as a condition of the lease you must abide by the corporation's rules.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leasehold_estate

If you don't want to live by an HOA's rules then don't live on the HOA's land, but rather your own land:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freehold_(law)

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by 15155 on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:16AM (#40532902)
NYC banning guns in Walmart is a restriction of freedom, per Bruen.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dullcrisp on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:39AM (#40533049)
The SCOTUS doesn’t define the concept of freedom.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by madeofpalk on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:14AM (#40533586)
Is there a freedom to not join a HOA? Freedom to not associate?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:19AM (#40533625)
Of course there is; just don't buy a house that is part of an HOA. Most houses in the US are not part of any HOA. Apartments are also not part of HOAs (but of course anyone living there has to follow the rules put down by the owners, and it’s not like the residents get to vote on those). Condos are always part of a condo association, but those are a fraction of the housing in the US.

Also, if your neighbor asks you to vote to create an HOA, vote against it.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beaeglebeachedd on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:35AM (#40533753)
Covenants are separate from the deed and title searches fail to uncover them all the time. That's part of the problem, you buy a deed and some boomer crawls out from 6 feet under to unilaterally impose his will. It's infuriating as this crept up constantly when I was looking for land to build a tiny house and many sellers didn't even know some dead boomer made it illegal to not build a mcmansion in some ancient document the title clerk digs up.

That some dead previous owner can unilaterally say 'none of that' and it be binding on subsequent transfers and heirs is opposite the freedom of association.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gpvos on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:48AM (#40533414)
It would be a freedom if you could own a house in that area and not join the HOA.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:55AM (#40532791)
I never said that all groups were equivalent, only that they are similar. Book clubs have rules, and if you violate them they will punish you. Very likely the punishment will be limited to not inviting you back, but that is because book clubs are very informal. HOAs are formal, and are formed for the specific purpose of regulating the use of property, particularly common property. Thus it should be no surprise that they do so.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by kashunstva on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:17AM (#40533605)
> regulating the use of property, particularly common property

I don’t think anyone would argue with their regulation of common property; it’s their petty interference in private property that’s the rub.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:27AM (#40533691)
Remember that everyone disagrees about what is petty and what is not. Take the current article: some would argue that requiring a vehicle (such as the boat) to be parked in a place where it cannot be seen from the street is petty, and that the HOA is petty for having such a rule. Yet many many cities and towns across America have similar parking rules. They were put in place by a reasonably democratic process, so it must be that there is a fair amount of disagreement over whether they are petty or not. You have the same recourse in both cases: vote, join the local government, or move somewhere less petty.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by okasaki on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:20AM (#40532930)
This is some extreme mental gymnastics where restrictions are actually freedoms.

By the same logic, how about a freedom for the government to limit your speech? Now censorship is freedom and free speech is a restriction.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mensetmanusman on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:35AM (#40533746)
Traffic signs are limits on freedom, but they increase the net freedom to travel. Some things have a higher second derivative of freedom.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by eru on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:04AM (#40533173)
The ability to do censorship would be a freedom for the government, yes. It's also a restriction on you.

I don't like HOAs, but the ability to form or join a HOA is definitely a part of individual freedom.

Just like the ability to eg enter into a non-disclosure agreement or any other kind of contract.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:26AM (#40534207)
I agree. You can be free without having total anarchy. Some (but not too many) laws/rules/restrictions ironically make us more free.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mihaic on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:28AM (#40534874)
Your position seems a bit ideological. Ultimate freedom doesn't exist, since pretty much all societies agree that they want to stop people from murdering one another for instance.

Any legal system always has to balance individual liberties and the tyranny of the majority (or a law-giving minority).

> An HOA that was useful for 50 years and never created any drama could turn bad next year when they elect some new board members.

That's why countries for instance have constitutions, so the system is hard to change even when someone new takes power.

> true freedom includes the freedom to make mistakes, even big mistakes.

That's pretty much the reason why we don't have "true freedom" and we want to stop people from making really terrible and easily avoidable mistakes, like eating food that kills them.

Limiting HOA against petty bullshit requirements (with more freedom for an initial set of bullshit requirements) at least is one of these limitations.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by tuyiown on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:45AM (#40535070)
> People who end up in a petty HOA usually regret it, and come to see joining any HOA as a big mistake.

I'm pretty sure that freedom of association is strongly tied to being able to quit the association freely. I don't think that the condition of having to change home to quit an association is a reasonable term.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gizmo686 on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:51AM (#40535150)
HOAs are not a story of free association. They are a story of privatization.

We used to have local government deal with local governance. But local governments decided they didn't want to do that anymore, so they started encouraging the creation of HOAs to deal with all of those pesky local governance issues.

If all thar mattered was free association, the fix would be very simple. Enshrine into the the right to leave an HOA. But states won't do that, because once people leave, they will except their local governments to start providing the same services the HOAs do, and all of those local governments are going to complain to the state government.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by corysama on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:05AM (#40535363)
Felt this when I bought my first house and a week after the sale finalized, my situation changed dramatically and unexpectedly. I needed to move across the country, but the HOA had a strict No Renters clause.

So, I had to choose between 1) Spend 30 years paying the mortgage for a house no one can use. 2) Turn around and sell the house I just bought.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:41AM (#40536570)
that's why i don't like to buy property. presumably you didn't want to just sell again because of the effort involved. if buying and selling was easier and guaranteed to never sell at a loss, then this would not be an issue. how did you resolve the problem?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by corysama on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:33PM (#40537989)
I ate it. Turned around and sold at a small loss on price, bigger loss on all the costs associated with the process.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:54PM (#40539513)
do you think you could have avoided a loss if you were not under pressure to sell, but say, had a few months of time before the move and find a good buyer?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by corysama on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:04PM (#40540222)
I did have a couple months. Was still rough.

However, the market turned downward later and I think the buyer sold at a bigger loss after five years or so. So, could have been worse.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by em-bee on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:35AM (#40536497)
this is really the crux of the issue. HOAs should really be treated and organized like neighborhood level government councils.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jameshart on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:51AM (#40535151)
This is a good perspective, and a great case study in understanding how freedoms are always in tension.

The usual remedy to protect people from freely making the mistake of entering into associations that harm them is regulatory, of course.

Employment regulations place certain rules on what you can expect when you choose to throw yourself into association with a company as an employee, to prevent you accidentally finding yourself at the whim of an abusive employer.

Regulating what kinds of things HOAs can demand is a perfectly reasonable thing for governments to do to make it safer for people to purchase houses with confidence they won’t be subjected to egregious restrictions.

So we do end up limiting freedom of association. You can’t join up into an HOA with your neighbors that bans any of you from selling your house to a black family.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by xdennis on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:01AM (#40535297)
> Someone always scoffs, but I think it is usually a sign that they don’t really understand freedom.

Others understand freedom from the perspective of the individual. Americans understand freedom from the perspective of the state.

In the first case, you're free if you can practically do something. In the second case you're free if the government doesn't ban it, regardless of whether you can actually do it.

Take for example the issue of ads on Smart TVs. There's no law that says you have to have ads on them, but in practice it's impossible to buy a TV which doesn't flood you with ads.

People in the first case consider that if a law is passed to ban embedding ads on TVs, then that increases the freedom in the world. Americans consider that banning such ads is a horrible government overreach which hurts the feelings of poor billionaires, and that if people want, they can always buy TVs with no ads, even though no such TVs exist.

They prefer an imaginary freedom to a practical one.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ein0p on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:34AM (#40535731)
Yeah, mortgage debt slaves are forced to associate among themselves and pay money to the most insufferable local busybodies available. That’s the “freedom” we’re talking about here. I’m generally against big govt, but in this case I would gladly pay the same amount to the municipal government instead so that they’d maintain the road and public greenery, and otherwise get out of my hair.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by UniverseHacker on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:51AM (#40535958)
Unfortunately, in practice most people don’t choose HOAs, they simply can’t afford to live anywhere without one.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by nozzlegear on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:36PM (#40542426)
I’d love to see numbers on that (not asking you to find them) — it seems logical for me that a home in an HOA would sell for more than a home outside an HOA.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by UniverseHacker on Sunday June 02, 2024 @10:40AM (#40554557)
Most HOAs are in low cost and high density multi-family housing: condos, townhouses, etc. In those cases many of the people living there are renters, but subject to following the rules through their landlords.

When you have an HOA with regular single family homes, it generally has to have been setup by the contractor, who build the entire planned community. These mass produced planned communities are also typically cheaper and lower value than individual one-off single family homes, as they are built to a price point for a profit.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by insane_dreamer on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:38PM (#40538052)
The problem with HOA vs other types of voluntary associations is that it’s very difficult to get out of an HOA — you have literally one recourse: sell and move. That’s a huge barrier because even if you wanted to you may not be able to afford to sell and move. And HOA rules change so the terms you now object to were perhaps not even in place when you agreed to join the HOA. It becomes coercive. When my wife and I last moved to another city and were looking to buy, our first requirement was that our house not be encumbered with an HOA.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Ferret7446 on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:41AM (#40532719)
Do you even live in the US? If so, where exactly? Schools are one of the few places you are almost universally not allowed to bring guns.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by thbb123 on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:57AM (#40532805)
Not American here, so would welcome some explanation. If I own a piece of land on which my house sits. Even if it's within a district that has a strong HOA, what prevents me from leaving the association and set my own rules over my patch of land?

Surely in the individualistic land of the free, it should be a fundamental right?

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by abestic9 on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:06AM (#40532850)
In short: land covenants. In HOAs you will see titles containing terms about the property being subject to restrictions voted for/applied by the association. If you continually decline to adhere to the restrictions, you can be legally compelled to sell and move on.

Note: I'm using phrasing local to me, I expect there may be minor differences but the same gist.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by 19870213 on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:04AM (#40532837)
But to buy that home/land from the previous owner you have to sign a contract stating you can't leave the HOA and that when you sell you only sell to those who will join the HOA and contract.

This goes back to the construction company/realtor investing to build the entire suburb and putting down the roads and such.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by bdowling on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:14AM (#40533229)
> you have to sign a contract

You have the right idea, but there isn’t a contract that a buyer has to sign.

A restrictive covenant is attached to a property when a developer (e.g., of a condo complex or subdivision) deeds a subject property to an initial buyer. The restrictions “run with the land” and are enforceable against any subsequent buyer. (The restrictions are a public record kept with the county recorder, so any buyer is on “record notice” whether they actually knew about them or not.)

Also, the way most HOAs work, there is no joining just as there is no opting out. You are a member if you own a subject property. That’s it.

I mainly know about California, but it should be similar in other states.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by raverbashing on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:36AM (#40533030)
I wonder how many times this way of doing contracts was tested in the Supreme Court
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dilyevsky on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:34AM (#40533019)
Same thing that prevents you from declaring sovereign state on “your” land - the laws =)
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by pulse7 on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:09AM (#40532866)
A US supermarket is not allowed to sell Kinder Eggs - because they are "dangerous for children", BUT they are allowed to sell guns...
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jkaplowitz on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:29AM (#40532978)
They forgot the Kinder Egg amendment to the Constitution when they were drafting the Bill of Rights.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ndsipa_pomu on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:33AM (#40533734)
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mensetmanusman on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:40AM (#40533780)
A fun workaround would be an air cannon that launches kinder eggs with a warning to not eat the chocolate ammo.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by sparrish on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:20AM (#40536308)
Where in the US is there a supermarket that sells guns? I've never seen one. They'd need a FFL (Federal Firearms License) and anyone purchasing would have to go through a background check and in some states, a mandatory wait period of 3-10 days.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jkaplowitz on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:36PM (#40538777)
A large fraction of US Walmarts sell both groceries and guns, to name one example. I suspect this correlates with the states that don’t impose a mandatory waiting period, though I haven’t checked.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by vixen99 on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:38AM (#40533359)
For those wondering as I did: HOA is 'home owners association'.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by philipwhiuk on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:05AM (#40533516)
For the UK a HOA is conservation area if it were run by the folk on Nextdoor.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by chownie on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:46AM (#40533848)
Christ, it really spells out how dystopian it really is. Could you imagine if Jackie on nextdoor got to hit you with the legal stick every time she didn't like your front garden?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dylan604 on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:46AM (#40535090)
Okay, so now for someone not from the UK, I'm now curious what Jackie and Nextdoor means to someone from the UK. Is Nextdoor the same app for people living in neighborhoods, or is it a BBC show (I'd be interested in seeing it if so). Is the concept of Karen known as Jackie in the UK?

C'mon mate, exchange some culture!

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by chownie on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:53AM (#40535979)
Nextdoor is an app (maybe a website too? not sure) which acts in my area sort of like a twitter feed for the people living in the houses nearby. It's not that useful unless you're in a built up area because I'd say the likelihood your neighbours are on it is actually pretty low.

The stereotypical Jackie is not like a Karen. Where I'm from a Jackie is a lady who's usually a little older and working class, great conversation IRL, very inappropriate, the type who says stuff in her back garden and you roll your eyes and close the windows so your kids don't start repeating it.

The cultural collision is that Jackie is not as much fun on Nextdoor, because something about the anonimity and having to write out the things she says out makes them sort of horrible, and she very easily slips into being a bit of a bully.

For what it's worth I think the UK equivalent of a Karen is Sandra, whose husband is Terry -- whereas Jackie is obvs with Barry.

When you really examine them, stereotypes are weird.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dylan604 on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:23PM (#40537056)
So where does Keeping Up Appearances' Hyacinth rank on the Sandra/Karen and Jackie scale?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by chownie on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @07:51AM (#40573463)
Hyacinth is Sandra's nan, 100%
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by alt227 on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:46AM (#40534439)
I am a UK resident and had no idea of what an HOA is or how it is run.

Your analogy instantly brought me up to speed, and spells out just how bad it would be.

Thanks very much!

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by graemep on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:15AM (#40533596)
Are Americans allowed to take guns to school? I would have thought most schools would ban guns?

On the other hand we did have guns in my school in the UK (only for use on the rifle range).

That said, I think it is very weird that Americans accept this level of regulation on what they do on their own property.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by disposition2 on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:36AM (#40533757)
By and large, no.

I’m not sure of any states / places that allow a student to bring a gun to school. A lot of schools have a police officer present, and I imagine they would typically be able to bring their gun. And some states are debating (or have authorized) allowing faculty to bring a gun to school; the caveat being (in most instances I have seen) said faculty would have to pass enhanced gun safety training.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by sokoloff on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:42AM (#40533802)
HOAs serve a pretty useful purpose: to coarsely/imperfectly segregate people who want to live in an HOA away from people who would never want to live in an HOA and vice-versa.

Those two groups are somewhat prone to having conflicts with each other and HOAs let both be happier than if they were to be annoyed by living next to each other.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by HEmanZ on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:53AM (#40533902)
I’d be fascinated to see the geographic and demographic distribution of HOAs. In American Suburbia basically every neighborhood I’ve seen has an HOA. But in some cities I’ve lived they seem completely absent.

I’m guessing there was a particular (white flighty) period of time and kind of people who really wanted these things. Neighborhoods built before this time don’t have them, and newer buildings (at least where I live) don’t seem to have them either. So these may be mostly phenomena of a specific period.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mlrtime on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:40AM (#40534383)
Every single condo or apartment also has a "HOA". They are just called something different.

When you buy a condo anywhere in the US, you also get a (sometimes huge) document of all the rules and regulations. You're also required to pay fees every month.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by trashface on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:04AM (#40535332)
Nowadays you see them everywhere, but originally they were made popular with retirement communities (age restricted 55+) because the HOA is what is required to establish that restriction. Governments can't discriminate on age legally but an HOA gets an exception. In practice they often soft-discriminate in a plausibly deniable way on many other characteristics including SES, race, etc.

My parents are elderly and live in one. They have there share of stories, some of which are pretty bad. People have moved out solely due to conflicts. They kind of hate it actually. But I asked my dad if he agrees with all the enforcement and he said basically, well you don't want someone to paint their house purple. Which I think illustrates the preferences of people who seek these communities.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by alamortsubite on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:54AM (#40533926)
A lot of them, yes. Half of U.S. states allow their schools or school districts to make their own rules regarding guns in schools. About a dozen states explicitly allow concealed firearms in schools.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Ancapistani on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:59AM (#40536766)
... and none of them allow people <18 years old to carry a handgun on their person to school.

Armed (and trained) adults are very different from "gun-toting high-school students", which is what seems to be implied here.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by alamortsubite on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:58PM (#40537515)
An important distinction for sure, though I had assumed the opposite, which is that the GP was in disbelief that adults can bring guns to U.S. schools (and that it's totally obvious that children cannot).

When you're discussing our gun laws with foreigners, I guess you're right that it's always necessary to spell out the fine details, like the fact that we have separate rules for gun-toting people who are over 18 and gun-toting people who are under 18, because from their perspective it's almost certainly just one big jumble of insanity.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by nemo44x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:20AM (#40533639)
There’s plenty of places share there’s no restrictions like this. But people that live in communities have the right to regulate how community members use their property. It’s for the greater good.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by alistairSH on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:23AM (#40534811)
Students - generally, not allowed to bring guns to school (too young to legally own/carry).

Teachers/staff - depends on state/local laws.

I'm assuming the OP meant the lack of overall regulation that leads to be people illegally bringing guns to school (and using them).

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Ancapistani on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:03PM (#40536813)
The only cases where students may possess firearms on school property of which I'm aware are when they are necessary for a school activity.

For example, my oldest daughter is involved on the trap team (a shotgun sport). Her firearm is cased and unloaded except on the shooting range itself, and practice is outside of normal school hours. In practice, that means she only has it in my vehicle when I'm taking her to practice or picking her up from practice. It's a non-issue.

As of about five years ago, when I went through instructor training for shooting sports, there had never been in an injury caused by youth shooting sports in our state in the ~100 year history of the program. Further, the group I was working with, 4-H, had a perfect safety record nation-wide. To muy knowledge that is still the case.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by jakubmazanec on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:25AM (#40533680)
HOAs are often awful. Obligatory John Oliver video on the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qrizmAo17Os
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by CalRobert on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:45AM (#40533836)
Sure, but this isn't the HOA.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mattmaroon on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:22AM (#40534168)
I have a few of each experience, homes without HOAs, and homes/condos with. (Nearly all condos have them.)

There are, of course, pluses and minuses to either.

I bought an expensive home in a nice suburb, no HOA. My neighbors, who were there before me, suddenly decided to fill their back yard with old rusty cars on blocks they were “working on”. And get a fake deer for target practice. This cost me then of thousands of dollars when I sold my house.

No HOA restrictions I’ve ever dealt with were worse than that so I’m now fairly pro-HOA. I have plenty of freedom and opportunity to buy a house without one but I likely won’t again.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by lrvick on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:27AM (#40534225)
If an HOA can remove you from your home for non compliance with whatever extra-legal rules they come up with, you do not own the home.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by mlrtime on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:41AM (#40534394)
Try not paying your property taxes and see what happens, do you still own your home then?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by lrvick on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:56AM (#40534552)
That is an actual law of the land in a democratic society that could change it if we all wanted. Everyone plays by the same rules there.

Meanwhile an HOA deed restriction is you giving a private non government organization the permanent and irrevocable right to remove you from your home and sell it if you do not comply with whatever extra-legal discrimination they make up to impose on you.

Plain and simple, HOAs are not a country or a government. They are a scam.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by rpdillon on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:01AM (#40534624)
You mentioned HOA-type stories, and seem to have spawned an enormous discussion about HOAs. Just want to point out that this has nothing to do with an HOA. Second paragraph:

> When the town of Seaside, California ordered homeowner Etienne Constable to build a fence to conceal the boat in his driveway, he erected the fence all right. And then he hired his neighbor, artist Hanif Panni, to paint a mural on the fence—realistically depicting the boat itself.

So all the discussion about contracts entered to into freely with respect to HOAs simply don't apply here: this is the government imposing the requirement to build a fence.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by xdennis on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:46AM (#40535083)
> American land of the free is being able to bring a gun to school but getting a fine because your grass is too tall.

What's wrong with bringing your gun to school? It was common (up until the 1970s, I think) to have shooting sports at school. That's how kids learned gun safety.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by edgyquant on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:52AM (#40535185)
You are not allowed to bring a gun to school. What a ridiculous statement
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by NoMoreNicksLeft on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:04AM (#40535340)
> It blows my mind people buy in places with rules like these.

What choice do they have? Their job is nearby, and long commutes are not so far off from a prison sentence. Literally hundreds of hours per year trapped in a tiny space that you can't leave.

Only so many houses/homes are for sale, and every time a critical mass of busybodies manifests, they can vote in a new HOA which is effectively immortal. They're simply easier to create than they are to uncreate. Until we get where we are today, and you may very well not have any non-HOA choices.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by ein0p on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:31AM (#40535698)
Correction: only school shooters can bring a gun to a school in 2024. To the rest of us it’s a “gun free” zone.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by DontchaKnowit on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:47AM (#40535919)
Okay, you cant bring a gun to school, so what the fuck are you talking about?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dvngnt_ on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:00AM (#40536066)
you would probably be fined for bringing a gun to school
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by sparrish on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:15AM (#40536254)
It's a felony. You'll go to jail.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dvngnt_ on Monday June 10, 2024 @01:54PM (#40636185)
they also fine you
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by burningChrome on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:07AM (#40536153)
>> American land of the free is being able to bring a gun to school

Is this sarcasm?

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gklitz on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:14PM (#40537735)
People buy in places like this because “the neighborhood looks nice” and then immediately complain about not being able to break all the rules that led to them having that opinion in the first place.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by webninja on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:29PM (#40538705)
Yeah, I never understood the idea of paying someone to tell you what to do. My family members only buy homes outside of HOAs.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by m463 on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:47PM (#40542190)
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by whoiscroberts on Saturday June 01, 2024 @10:45AM (#40546143)
You’re not allowed to bring a gun into a school. If you do your breaking the law, if your point is that you’re free to break the law and face the consequences, then yes, you’re right. You can bring the gun and be arrested and you can let the grass grow and be fined. What’s your point?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dang on Saturday June 01, 2024 @06:56PM (#40549826)
Please don't start flamewars on HN and especially not nationalistic ones. We're trying for something other than that here—more interesting and less repetitive, for starters.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by vasco on Monday June 03, 2024 @04:27AM (#40560471)
The thread below was an interesting discussion I thought. I believe this reply on an HOA topic on my specific comment is ironic comedy gold though, so I take the loss with a smile and will think again next time. Thanks for you work Dan!