Always remember: If it's in the news it's not the norm. Whatever you hear about a country via the news is the opposite of what that country typically is.
We meet once a year to vote on crap. Key is to not have a group of people with nothing better to do.
Yup. I can’t imagine what an HOA would need to be doing to meet monthly, let alone delegate decision making to a board.
The latter is simply incorrect. Condo associations and co-op boards are separate creatures, in part due to there being an existential necessity to their existing. (You can't have people dismantling structural members their unit abuts.)
HOAs are far more voluntary in nature. That said, I agree that we need a better framework for distinguishing those functioning as direct democracies from those where an elected board gets to appoint itself powers.
Boomers mostly worked one job between two people, and had the silent generation to take care of their kids so they had a lot of time for masterbatory lawn care/putting trashcans away the second the trash truck pulls away/nonsense.
Now they are retired and have even more time, but also authority over people far busier than they ever have been.
Here in the UK the boomers were able to work one job, get a house on an easy mortgage and now they’re old and have nothing to do they campaign against any development that might slightly inconvenience them or reduce their house price (spoiler, most developments wouldn’t)
https://www.financialreporter.co.uk/income-to-house-price-ra...
The very real problems with affordability of housing in the UK have a number of causes but the key issue is supply. Successive governments have simply failed to build sufficient housing to meet demand. NIMBYism alone can't explain this lack of investment.
1989:
- Interest rate: 14.5%.
- Average house price: £58k.
- Monthly repayment: £650 (90% LTV, 25 year term).
- Average pre-tax income: £10k.
2024:
- Interest rate: 5.25%.
- Average house price: £282k.
- Monthly repayment: £1500 (90% LTV, 25 year term).
- Average pre-tax income: £35k.
So in 1989, an average mortgage was about 80% of an average gross income. In 2024, an average mortgage is about 50% of an average gross income.
I specifically chose 1989 because it was a year of high interest rates, but you can repeat the calculation for other years if you wish. I don't think the results will support your assertion.
The 2nd group can't "refinance" all the extra principal they owe.
In 1989 interest rates were at record highs and mortgage interest relief was still a thing. Despite interest rates hovering between 8-12% for the rest of the 1980s, mortgage repayments were consistently a much lower proportion of income.
In 2024 there's no interest relief and we're exiting a period of record low rates. The rise to 5.25% already puts us in a worse position than when rates were at 10%, 14.5% would disastrous.
It is worth looking at the mid-2000s numbers (post-MIRAS, but pre-crash) and comparing them to today's numbers. They're really not so different.
No argument on the relative leverage: 10% would be impossible and 15% would probably precipitate a revolution.
"Blame boomers" has existed for perhaps a decade if we're being generous.
1. ...and no, I'm not a Baby Boomer either.
... or pour oil in the fire of the great culture war, here in the secondary frontline of young vs. old, and accomplish nothing.
These companies are incentivized to find infraction to fine, and drive around regularly to make sure every rule is strictly adhered to. Trash bins out too early or late? Fine! Fence painted the wrong shade of soulless beige? Fine!
We don't have that concept in my country. Or, we do have associations that make it so that houses in an area share the upkeep of communal stuff like a park, playground, organize events etc. All things I would think a "normal HOA" would be, but without the ability to impose fines or stuff like that. So I would feel a house with that kind of neighborhood here would be a net positive, as in costs can be shared among more.