Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by lores on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:34AM
(#40533338)
Not a dig on you, but I find it telling that in discussions about the freedom of upping up and leaving, money is always mentioned as a limiting factor, but never community. For many, moving means losing the social ties they have, and that can be devastating. I wonder if it's a HN or American oversight.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by alistairSH on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:38AM
(#40533770)
Does HN have a higher than average # of immigrants or first-generation citizens? That could explain it.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by SpaceNoodled on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:01PM
(#40536794)
No, introverts.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by randomdata on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:34AM
(#40534305)
What do you mean? Per the discussion, escaping social ties is the whole point of wanting to leave. If you fit into the community, what reason would there be to leave?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by lores on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:07AM
(#40536150)
You can have a community in the neighbourhood who aren't ruling the HOA.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by randomdata on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:10AM
(#40536194)
But then said community will overthrow the HOA, so, again, no reason to leave. The earlier suggestion of leaving was based on a situation where you don't find the community you need. Escaping the social ties was the sole reason for leaving. Why would escaping a community that you don't fit into be the same limiting factor that keeps you there? That doesn't make any sense.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by lores on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:13AM
(#40536227)
Why would you think that is the case?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by randomdata on Friday May 31, 2024 @11:14AM
(#40536237)
Because I do not believe that HOAs are magic. What makes you think that they are?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by nradov on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:29AM
(#40534878)
My grandparents immigrated to the USA and lost all their social ties. They were better off for it.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by CogitoCogito on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:30AM
(#40533307)
Yeah I'm having trouble understanding how /u/db48x's logic doesn't apply equally well to all political systems. Maybe the next time someone complains to me about Biden's policies, I should just respond that they don't understand freedom.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:15AM
(#40533590)
The USA believes so hard in the freedom of association that we are willing to let people leave whenever they want. You don’t need permission, just find somewhere better and go there. Compare that with the Soviet Union, or East Germany, or China, or North Korea. In those countries leaving may technically be allowed, but may require a lifetime of asking for permission. The Soviet Union didn’t even provide its own people with maps lest they find out where the borders were.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by mlrtime on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:28AM
(#40534240)
As an American "leaving" you may need to pay your taxes on the way out (giving up citizenship).
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by ohmyiv on Friday May 31, 2024 @09:34AM
(#40534925)
> Compare that with the Soviet Union, or East Germany, or China, or North Korea
Would it be better to compare current, non-totalitarian governments, such as EU, Australia, or the like? It kind of sounds disingenuous to use extreme examples. (No dig to you or your opinion, just don't see how using those examples helps.)
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:24PM
(#40539819)
As I already said, many countries have freedom of association to one degree or another. You could spend a lot of effort to distinguish countries with a similar degree of freedom, but I chose to list a few obvious examples of countries that do not have that freedom. Or did not, as the case may be.
I see a dichotomy of "associations with oversight" and the converse (associations with no oversight). If your HOA forces you to build a fence, there is no appeal process similar to if a government entity charges you with a crime (e.g. appeal to a state/federal circuit court and ultimately to a supreme court). Within each is an enforcement mechanism that may or may not work. In your dinner party example, which is an association with no oversight, a naked table dancer may simply crash the subsequent gatherings. In all levels of government, there are those who continue to hold their position regardless of the misdeeds and accusations levied against them.
Perhaps that is the essential trade-off of freedom, to be free to associate with any group of people despite the possibility of being victimized by them (now or in the future).