News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by Calavar on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:42AM (#40532726)
Freedom of association is missing the point when it comes to HOAs.

There's some very significant differences between freedom to associate in a book club and freedom to associate in an HOA. If you don't like a book club, there is no scenario in which you are contractually obligated to join it and pay membership fees indefinitely. And the bookclub doesn't have broad legal authority, backed by the courts, to dictate how you maintain, use, and sell your personal property or even aspects of your lifestyle.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dullcrisp on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:11AM (#40532884)
Book clubs aside, the ability to join a HOA is a freedom. Contrarily, if the Supreme Court forces New York City to allow guns in its Walmarts, that would be a restriction of freedom.

Freedom isn’t the same as lawlessness.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by hiatus on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:05AM (#40533181)
Businesses can't discriminate against different races either, you give up some freedoms when you hold yourself open to the public.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dullcrisp on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:22AM (#40533282)
You’re right, disallowing race-based discrimination is also a restriction of freedom. I’m not arguing that all freedoms are good.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by maxerickson on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:17AM (#40533612)
HOAs are often tied to a piece of land, with it being mandatory to join if you buy the land.

You are free to not buy the land of course.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by throw0101c on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:32AM (#40533720)
> HOAs are often tied to a piece of land, with it being mandatory to join if you buy the land.

Legally speaking one is often not buying the land but rather buying the unit. The land on which the unit sits is owned by a corporation (HOA), and as a condition of the lease you must abide by the corporation's rules.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leasehold_estate

If you don't want to live by an HOA's rules then don't live on the HOA's land, but rather your own land:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freehold_(law)

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by 15155 on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:16AM (#40532902)
NYC banning guns in Walmart is a restriction of freedom, per Bruen.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by dullcrisp on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:39AM (#40533049)
The SCOTUS doesn’t define the concept of freedom.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by madeofpalk on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:14AM (#40533586)
Is there a freedom to not join a HOA? Freedom to not associate?
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:19AM (#40533625)
Of course there is; just don't buy a house that is part of an HOA. Most houses in the US are not part of any HOA. Apartments are also not part of HOAs (but of course anyone living there has to follow the rules put down by the owners, and it’s not like the residents get to vote on those). Condos are always part of a condo association, but those are a fraction of the housing in the US.

Also, if your neighbor asks you to vote to create an HOA, vote against it.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by beaeglebeachedd on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:35AM (#40533753)
Covenants are separate from the deed and title searches fail to uncover them all the time. That's part of the problem, you buy a deed and some boomer crawls out from 6 feet under to unilaterally impose his will. It's infuriating as this crept up constantly when I was looking for land to build a tiny house and many sellers didn't even know some dead boomer made it illegal to not build a mcmansion in some ancient document the title clerk digs up.

That some dead previous owner can unilaterally say 'none of that' and it be binding on subsequent transfers and heirs is opposite the freedom of association.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by gpvos on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:48AM (#40533414)
It would be a freedom if you could own a house in that area and not join the HOA.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:55AM (#40532791)
I never said that all groups were equivalent, only that they are similar. Book clubs have rules, and if you violate them they will punish you. Very likely the punishment will be limited to not inviting you back, but that is because book clubs are very informal. HOAs are formal, and are formed for the specific purpose of regulating the use of property, particularly common property. Thus it should be no surprise that they do so.
Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by kashunstva on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:17AM (#40533605)
> regulating the use of property, particularly common property

I don’t think anyone would argue with their regulation of common property; it’s their petty interference in private property that’s the rub.

Re:A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence by db48x on Friday May 31, 2024 @07:27AM (#40533691)
Remember that everyone disagrees about what is petty and what is not. Take the current article: some would argue that requiring a vehicle (such as the boat) to be parked in a place where it cannot be seen from the street is petty, and that the HOA is petty for having such a rule. Yet many many cities and towns across America have similar parking rules. They were put in place by a reasonably democratic process, so it must be that there is a fair amount of disagreement over whether they are petty or not. You have the same recourse in both cases: vote, join the local government, or move somewhere less petty.