News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by rdtsc on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:07PM (#38181304)
> at some financial institutions, you can get a SAR filed for knowing what a SAR is, because “advanced knowledge of anti-moneylaundering procedure” is a characteristic only of financial professionals and terrorists.

That is messed up. You ask about a SAR or indicate you know about them in general, you get a SAR slapped on you, and they close your account. You're one of hundreds of thousands, why bother handling SAR-ed user when they can just move on without you.

Are individuals allowed to have a public forum to discuss and share notes of what they did in their account to learn and prevent this from happening in the future? It seems in a lot of cases it's using these payment systems like Zelle or have anything associated with phrases resembling black-listed countries or organization.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by tlb on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:26PM (#38181565)
People are massively dishonest about this, though. Like there are occasional Ask HN posts where someone is outraged that their bank/payment account was closed for “no reason”, but eventually it comes out that they’re in North Korean selling cannabis to Iran or something.

But it does seem like the world lacks a manual on How Not To Get In Trouble With Your Bank. “Structuring” in particular is something someone might innocently do just because they like round numbers.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by mminer237 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:48PM (#38181860)
CTRs are required for $10,000+. Structuring is more like if you're depositing $9,999, which is kind of the opposite of a round number.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AmericanChopper on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:49PM (#38181877)
The only way to get any assurance about staying out of trouble with your bank is to have enough money that they start to not care so much about the risk of doing business with you, and to pay a lot of money to an expert to do the AML compliance for you.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:43PM (#38184739)
The other way is to communicate with the bank. Talk to them. If you're doing something involving a large amount of money, or something unusual for you, call them up, tell them what you're doing and ask for their help.

Don't do everything online. Do the big or unusual stuff person-to-person. It doesn't even have to be an in-person visit. Give them a call.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AmericanChopper on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:27PM (#38185151)
This is a woefully naive position. Unusual activity on your account is an easy way to get a SAR. Calling up to check whether you’ll get a SAR is an even easier way to get a SAR.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by JohnFen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:41AM (#38191943)
It's always worked very well for me for decades.

I wouldn't ever ask whether or not I'll get an SAR, though. That sort of question is pointless. Instead, I just treat my bank as a core partner to my business and include them in my plans. The side-effect is that nothing I do looks suspicious to them.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by opportune on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:52PM (#38181909)
Completely agree that banks should provide prescriptive guides.

IME they really don’t like when you work around their eg 50k/day ACH transfer limit by initiating 50k ACH transfers on 4 consecutive days to move an account of 200k. But they don’t tell you what they actually want you to do if you want to move 200k - and for obvious reasons they probably don’t want to make these transfers fully frictionless. They just assume you’ll know to show up at a branch in person or get on a phone to ask about it and treat you like a criminal if you don’t.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by xeckr on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:21PM (#38182238)
Banks have an incentive to create as many roadblocks as possible to prevent you from transferring large sums of money out of the bank.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by dan-robertson on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:52PM (#38184217)
In particular in the US, they are on the hook for almost all of it if the money was fraudulently moved out.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by xeckr on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:49PM (#38184797)
They'll try to dissuade you even if they know the transaction is legitimate.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by tonyarkles on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @06:37PM (#38198841)
Not the banking industry but I had an issue with a leaked Twilio key once and it was a funny conversation like that. They kept telling me that I had been a victim of fraud (long story, a contractor pushed a key to a public GitHub repo). It only took about 7 repetitions for them to finally acknowledge that it was in fact Twilio who had been the victim of fraud: someone, pretending to be me, had asked them to send $1000 worth of Netflix spam and they obliged.

It wasn’t ever really resolved in a satisfactory way but it got to the point where I was so frustrated and tired that I said “fine, we can settle on $200” because it wasn’t really worth pursuing further (based on my hourly rate and how much wasted time I’d already sunk into it)

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by astrange on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:22PM (#38185550)
If you're the largest customer at a small bank they'll be happy to see you move it out because that much money can make them nervous.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by xeckr on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:34PM (#38186433)
Unless they're so small that you taking out your money results in them experiencing liquidity issues.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by usefulcat on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:12PM (#38186698)
In which case they already have bigger problems.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by astrange on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:56PM (#38186970)
That's the situation that makes them nervous.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by cturner on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:37AM (#38187427)
You may be surprised at how difficult the regulators make life for the banks.

Read this case-study from the UK. https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/decisions-case-studie...

"We thought the spending on Marta’s account was very unusual for her and – after the first few payments – the pattern of transfers from her account should have caused the bank some concern meaning that it ought to have intervened. We thought that if the bank had asked Marta about the transactions she would have told it what she was doing."

Consider the implications of this.

It gets worse, "In deciding fair compensation, we also considered if would be fair for Marta to bear any additional responsibility for what happened. However, as we thought the trading platform and correspondence with the fraudsters was very convincing, we decided against that on the facts of this case. So we asked the bank to refund all the transactions which took place after the point we thought it should have intervened."

This regulator does not respect the concept of personal responsibility.

These problems are also downstream of systematic public policy failure. We have had telephones for about a century. Yet in 2023, it is still routine for pensioners to receive calls from organised fraudsters. There is no reliable way to trace the source of these calls, to block ranges of numbers, to prevent scam call centres, to issue pensioner-friendly forms of telephone with higher safeguards. These problems are not technically difficult to solve. All could be fixed if the telcos behaved responsibly. That work should have been done thirty or more years ago.

Since that work was not done, there is now a fraud crisis. In response, regulators have forced controls to the last point possible, which is with the banks. Huge inefficiencies follow.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by nvm0n2 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:10AM (#38191453)
Ouch. Marta literally answers a get-rich-quick ad, then installs a program that lets a fraudster remotely control her computer to send money to a bitcoin exchange account that was opened in her own name (requiring her own ID documents to do so), and then send the bitcoins onwards the "investing" platform.

> The CRM Code did not cover this type of transaction, because the payments Marta made from her bank account were sent to an account held in her own name with the crypto exchange. However, outside of the CRM Code, banks have other fraud prevention obligations – including to look out for unusual transactions.

In other words although there's a document saying what a bank should try to do, that is actually meaningless because the regulator believes banks should somehow stop all fraud even in cases where people are literally giving random strangers total control over their bank account, deliberately, because they can't be bothered understanding how to operate their own financial accounts.

The cherry on top:

> If you invest in a firm which isn’t authorised by the FCA, you risk losing your money, without any protection.

Apparently not, because if some civil servant thinks you are pitiable and the scam was convincing, they'll force the bank (i.e. other customers) to make you whole again anyway.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by xeckr on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:11AM (#38191460)
Interesting, thanks for sharing.

This situation creates a market for new fraud-detection products, if anything just so that the banks can tell the regulator that they did their due diligence. Of course it depends on how common situations like Marta's are, and how expensive they are for the banks.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by nvm0n2 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:13AM (#38191493)
They have those, lots of them. It doesn't matter if the regulator will take a stance like "we think (with the benefit of hindsight) it looked suspicious, so pay up". And unfortunately this is a very common thing for regulators to do. A lot of money laundering fines against big banks are like this. A civil servant comes in five years later after being handed some evidence that some transactions were criminal, says the bank should have known (without explaining how) and levies huge fines or gets a huge settlement.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by dmurray on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:16PM (#38182179)
Is that even "working around" the restriction? Surely moving 50k on each of 4 days is what you're expected to do in that case. It still means the maximum a fraudster can get away with is 50k if the fraud is discovered in one day.

My last bank had limits like 20k/day and 50k/week, so it seems like yours could have 50k/day and 60k/week if they "really don't like" you using it like this.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by patmcc on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:22PM (#38182254)
No, you're expected to call and set up an appointment with a banker who can sell you on some kind of business account that has appropriate services for moving money in that way.

And yes, this will cost more and take more time than the spreading-it-out method.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by alright2565 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:01PM (#38182772)
no, this is too cynical. just give them a call, authenticate yourself, and they'll happily raise the limit for you.

maybe if you're moving 50k/week they'll try and get you on a business account, but at that point you're already not using the account for the purposed you claimed when you opened the account.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by opportune on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:52PM (#38182670)
One of the reasons banks have these restrictions (besides the obvious thing of making it difficult to take large sums of money out because it hurts their business) is to prevent fraud. They want to prevent the case where some criminal gets physical access to my computer, or my login credentials, and drains my account without my knowledge. So they want you to initiate a manual verification that you really do intend to move such a large sum to prevent that fraud.

If you do what I did, you usually get a temporary hold on your account and some very skeptical bank employee calling you to grill you on what you’re doing.

On one hand I get it. For every story like mine, where this is just a temporary frustrating inconvenience, there’s probably a story where grandma lost her life savings after talking to the nice man from Microsoft on the phone. But also they don’t make it clear at all what you are supposed to do as non-criminal to work around their restrictions, which is just bad for customers.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by someplaceguy on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:55PM (#38186588)
> So they want you to initiate a manual verification that you really do intend to move such a large sum to prevent that fraud.

Yes, it's hilarious.

One of my banks requires me to do the transaction over the phone if it's above a certain limit.

At which point, you talk to someone in a call center, and they proceed to ask you exactly the same information which you needed to introduce in their web interface to make the wire transfer yourself, and nothing else.

This includes giving your web interface credentials over the phone, which could be heard by someone inadvertently or even phished if you happened to have misdialed accidentally. Or stolen by the call center employee.

It's also great fun to have to spell out 20+ account digits, the names of the other people/companies, phone numbers and email addresses to receive confirmations and even a description of the transaction (fortunately I don't always buy sex toys).

Gosh, how I love to spell out all this information, digit by digit, letter by letter, over a phone call! But since it's for my protection it makes it OK, right? Right? Hello?

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by sidewndr46 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:04PM (#38183605)
working around a restriction is called "Structuring" in the US:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structuring

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by dmurray on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:29PM (#38183928)
This is not true. Structuring is much more narrowly defined, including in that Wikipedia article. It requires you to be working around a legal or regulatory reporting requirement.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by quartz on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:56PM (#38182711)
Couldn't you just send a wire?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by opportune on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:01PM (#38182776)
Yes, but that involves talking to someone and waiting on hold. If there’s no rush, doing 4x ACH is easier, if you don’t know it’ll get you flagged. All I’m saying is banks need to be more prescriptive about telling you “we’ll put a hold on your account if you move large sums without telling us” rather than giving you some fake limit that actually utilizing will raise red flags. This is a common failure mode
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by VBprogrammer on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:56PM (#38184254)
I presume the argument some middle management type makes is that exposing their security protocols makes it trivial for a fraudster to work around. Obviously this is a fallacy because any genuine fraudsters has the incentive to work this all out by trial and error, if the information isn't freely available to them on some dark corner of the internet.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Kalium on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:15PM (#38184448)
Trial and error takes time. Potentially a great deal of time. A motivated fraudster will likely get caught and stopped several times along the way if they're attacking a particular bank.

It's worth bearing in mind that most financially motivated criminals are after easy marks. If you're too hard or expensive to hit, they'll find another target. If you're seeing like a bank, that's a victory and the protocols are doing their job by reducing fraud.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by callalex on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:08PM (#38182859)
Those typically have huge fees.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by gosub100 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:09PM (#38183679)
$25 to move $50k in an atomic, irreversible way isn't a huge fee IMO. when you're dealing with that amount of money, the risk of it getting frozen or flagged for fraud is > $25. A lot of banks will let you send wires for free if you have a large enough balance.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ska on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:17PM (#38183779)
Not int the context of these amounts.

$20-ish to move 200k safely is nothing. If you are doing it internationally, it's typically tiny compared to the FX cost.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Scoundreller on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:33PM (#38183984)
I’d be happier keeping the $25 tyvm.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by hef19898 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:36PM (#38184020)
And risk getting your account frozen "for no reason", really smart.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ska on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:43PM (#38184110)
Sure, write a personal check then and expect a lengthy hold. Or something else on the risk vs. PITA vs. cost framework.

Point is, wires are cheap for what they do. They aren't your only option, but all options have tradeoffs.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Scoundreller on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:14PM (#38184432)
This is a debate between sending 4x ACHs over 4 days (presumably from the comfort of your own web browser) vs a wire (often requiring a visit or phone time).
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ska on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:20PM (#38184506)
right, and the trade off there is you may get flagged for structuring and locked out, right?

As I said, there is a range of cost/risk/PITA options available. This is niche enough I don't think it's particularly worrying the banks don't support it easier.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Scoundreller on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:40PM (#38184710)
What structuring? Both are way over mandatory SAR thresholds.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by nick222226 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:01PM (#38182780)
You do a wire transfer.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by opportune on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:04PM (#38182805)
Yes, my point is that banks don’t make it clear that maxing out their ACH quotas will get your account frozen and that you should do a wire transfer. You shouldn’t have to learn this the hard way by getting your account frozen (which is very stressful when it happens to you for the first time), and banks should make it clear what you should do, which is my point
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ska on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:16PM (#38183765)
It's a pretty niche problem though, so I guess not surprising they aren't great about communicating it (it probably was communicated, on page 30 of your agreement in small confusing text).
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Scoundreller on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:18PM (#38184484)
probably not communicated. Banks usually don't like to say: "your account will totally get frozen if you do this thing up to the limit of what we said you're allowed to do".

They like to keep the impression that account freezes are discretionary not automatic.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:57PM (#38184257)
Whenever I've been moving amounts at that scale, I've already had a close working relationship with my bank as a natural side-effect of my business activities. As a result, I'd be doing those sorts of transfers by talking to my account manager at the bank.

I suspect that's the norm that banks are expecting.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by nick222226 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:41PM (#38185271)
Ok with this context I understand what you are getting at.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by sib on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:24PM (#38185560)
For which they kindly charge you a fee
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by leetcrew on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:38PM (#38185670)
schwab doesn't charge a fee to wire from a brokerage account. by the way, there's no minimum balance or fees required to open an account with them. you pick up the phone, get connected with an intelligent person who understands exactly how to help you, and wire the money. usually you don't even wait for an agent.

I'm gonna sound like a shill, but 99% of the problems people are writing about in this thread would be solved by opening an account at schwab. unless you routinely deposit/withdraw large amounts of cash, there's no reason to waste time with other banks.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by sib on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:58PM (#38194273)
Thanks - good pointer!
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by hef19898 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:34PM (#38183999)
There are some systems, banking for example, where "hacking" them and trying to be smarter than others can, and actually does, backfire.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by creer on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:59PM (#38184289)
Part of the problem is a bank training you on recognizing that they have countless silly obscure rules for their own purposes - for example in what your password may be and how messages to their employees might be (mine limits the messages to be very short - no space to explain anything.) So you are quickly trained to make do with the silly rules. I.E. multiple ACH over several days and move on with your life... Or in the case of messages, I just continue my explanation in multiple messages.

Either way, the bank has trained the customer to work around limits. They can't have it both ways.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:35PM (#38184652)
> I.E. multiple ACH over several days and move on with your life...

Surely, just picking up the phone and speaking to them is faster and easier than engaging in structural transactions like that.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by creer on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:33PM (#38185200)
Is it? Usually no, it's not. At one bank, they want me to always talk to the same person - who is generally competent but also usually not available and sometimes outright on vacation with no warning. At another bank, they want me to go through the basic 800 number - where the person who answers usually knows much less than I do. Picking up the phone is usually not a good solution.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by opportune on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:36PM (#38186446)
One, this isn’t structuring. Just because you read what structuring is 5m before you read my post doesn’t make this structuring. 50k is way over reporting limits.

And also no it isn’t faster to pick up the phone, even if I don’t get out on hold at all. An ACH transfer takes seconds, it’s like writing a digital check. Doing it 4 times takes very little time.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by JohnFen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:43AM (#38191985)
I didn't mean "structuring" in the legal sense, I meant it in the technical sense (arranging transactions in order to avoid something).

I find it's much easier to engage in a 15 minute phone call than to do multiple transactions over a number of days. You may find it different, of course.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by xvilka on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:53PM (#38184842)
And people are surprised why so many were excited to use cryptocurrencies. The current banking system is broken to the root.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by someplaceguy on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:44PM (#38186509)
And getting progressively more broken, due to increasingly stricter and more numerous laws, and more effective enforcement.

Hell, in Spain you can't even legally pay anything in cash if it costs more than 1,000 EUR. In Greece, the limit is 500 EUR.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by slavboj on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:27PM (#38186388)
"But they don’t tell you what they actually want you to do if you want to move 200k"

They will tell you to use a wire transfer.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by darkwater on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:23AM (#38187613)
Don't know where you live but where I leave this thing is pretty common when you are buying some property. The goal in this case should be pretty obvious.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by boilerupnc on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:58PM (#38181965)
Funny enough. Whenever possible, I round all my tips to cause the total to generate a particular two digit cents amount - so that I can easily detect fraud when I scan my statements. It’s my low tech error code check.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by velcrovan on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:30PM (#38182372)
Has this ever turned up anything suspicious?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by eadler on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:28PM (#38183094)
I track almost all of my expenditures. At a restaurant I used to visit fairly regularly I noticed that my costs were often off by approximately ±25 cents. This was inconsistent and not always in one party's favour. Upon reporting and investigation it turned out that (a) I routinely wrote 'math' along with a total instead of a tip and (b) one of the waiters only approximated the math required.

Nothing nefarious and I'm not even sure if I won or lost out of this - but it was interesting to catch.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdntspa on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:37PM (#38183211)
> I routinely wrote 'math'

Why would you do this?

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by dboreham on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:06PM (#38184362)
1+ bottle wine?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by topherclay on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:44PM (#38183310)
I had to reread this because it didn't make sense to me the first time because it's so insane.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ska on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:56PM (#38183500)
Not surprising, right? I don't know what you expected implicitly asking them to do the arithmetic for you, but I would've assumed not much care would be taken.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PKop on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:10PM (#38183692)
Catch what? Why would you do something so silly
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:32PM (#38184626)
> I routinely wrote 'math' along with a total instead of a tip

I, too, am dying to know why you do this. I assume that you didn't intend it to be punitive, but that's what it looks like to me.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by gurchik on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:50PM (#38184812)
I've heard that half the time a restarant's POS is configured to ask the waiter to enter the number written on the tip line, but the other half of the time, it's configured for the them to enter what's written on the total line. Meaning, in the first case, writing "math" means more work for the waiter, and in the latter case, you better be careful the amount you wrote on the total line is accurate.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by lxgr on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:42AM (#38191959)
Writing both the tip and total adds redundancy which helps to avoid data entry mistakes.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by boilerupnc on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:57PM (#38183507)
It actually did. At a wings place I noticed a total that wasn’t my usual last two digits. I called up the place and they confirmed they had an employee who had been altering tip amounts and also skimming cards. They advised me to call my credit card company and ask for a new card. It is now a well defined muscle memory for me. Therefore for very little effort I get a desirable side effect of easy detection. My teen son currently rolls his eyes when I fill out the receipt but I suspect he’ll adopt the habit in some form over time.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by bravura on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:11PM (#38183711)
What about routine credit card transactions that you don’t tip on? Isn’t that the bulk of purchases ?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by SpaceNoodled on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:01PM (#38184308)
He's the guy that tips at grocery stores.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwanem on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:40PM (#38186879)
Transactions that don't involve latency in knowing the final amount also don't offer the same opportunity for chicanery.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by jdadj on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:59PM (#38182741)
I use palindromes. Easy to check and will catch extra dollars added.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by aembleton on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:09PM (#38183689)
I get a notification on my phone when any money is deposited or withdrawn from my account. If its not something I've just done or an unexpected amount, then its probably fraud and I can tell my bank.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by cj on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:15PM (#38186308)
In the US, restaurants immediately charge the price of the meal (without tip). Then the next day the restaurant updates the amount of the original charge to add on the amount you added as a tip.

That means shady restaurant could change your tip the next day if they wanted to pull a fast one on you.

In other words, it’s not possible to get an immediate notification of the total amount charged including tip until 1-2 days after the meal.

(Don’t ask me why the system works this way, makes no sense to me)

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwanem on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:40PM (#38186870)
It works that way because in the 1980s that was the only way to make it work at all, and it still works that way because being able to do the equivalent of an HTTP OPTIONS preflight for money is actually quite useful.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by cj on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @07:18AM (#38189402)
A restaurant could ask for the tip before charging the card.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwanem on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @07:58AM (#38189773)
Okay. Now:

- every restaurant PoS has to be updated to handle this use case;

- you have to wait for your server to make a second visit to your table before you can sign your tab and leave;

- every server has to spend extra time dealing with every table's tab upfront, rather than settling after close when no customers are inconvenienced by the time that takes;

- and all this cost and friction to reduce the incidence of a kind of low-value card-present fraud which is trivial for the customer to have reversed, and quite rare in all respects save the purely anecdotal.

If you're going to worry about any kind of payment card chicanery at a restaurant, the thing worth looking out for is skimming, not this.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by mytailorisrich on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @08:51AM (#38190266)
That's how it works in Europe.

In fact, the card terminals themselved ask how much you want to tip when you pay and then the card payment is taken on the total. I don't think it would be possible to proceed another way with all the safety procedures in place nowadays.

Otherwise, people used to leave cash on the table when they left even if they had paid by card (meal only) and they wanted to tip.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwanem on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:10AM (#38191448)
In the US, it'd be considered déclassé in most sit-down restaurants for the customer to run their own card. You see it at fast food and "fast casual" places, but not really anywhere fancier; to a good first approximation you can quickly understand in which market segment a restaurant would like you to perceive it by how easy or difficult it is to see any point-of-sale equipment from anywhere in the dining area.

I have the sense that tipping is much more customary in the US than in Europe, which may also make a difference. Certainly there is a significant semiosis around the concept here, which would also have to change in response to a change in the shape of the practice; I don't know exactly how much that contributes to things staying as they are, but I doubt it's of no import.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by mytailorisrich on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:21AM (#38191634)
> In the US, it'd be considered déclassé in most sit-down restaurants for the customer to run their own card.

Oh, I see. The US are so 1980s ;)

In Europe all card payments are chip-and-pin so they have to hand the card machine to you for you to type your pin.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwanem on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:25PM (#38201183)
Yeah, there's a lot of tech debt here owing to us having invented payment cards and all ;)

EMV is pretty common here these days, but evidently optional for restaurants; I suspect there's a carveout in the relevant association rules.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by aembleton on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @05:20PM (#38197971)
> In the US, it'd be considered déclassé in most sit-down restaurants for the customer to run their own card.

Interesting; I rarely carry a card and just pay with my phone. I've never been to the US, but it certainly wasn't an issue when I visited Canada. I should probably remember to take my card if I visit a restaurant in the US.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwanem on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:48PM (#38201292)
I'm old-fashioned enough to prefer carrying a discrete wallet, not least since my barbershop is cash-only, but also because to forgo it would promote a lost or broken phone from headache to catastrophe.

That said, I assume even restaurants whose POS equipment is well hidden would be generally able to handle folks who prefer the single point of failure.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Fatnino on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:17PM (#38184464)
Is it 69?

It's 69.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by workfromspace on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:13PM (#38185017)
My guess is 42.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by zoeysmithe on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:10PM (#38182109)
This is a little victim blamey. Banks mess up all the time. Regressive policies in capitalist institutions are extremely common. Incompetence is common. Negative action in service of the profit incentive is common.

There's no shortage of people who found their accounts closed for "fraud" who did nothing wrong, but instead were victimized by the algo and the general incompetence of banking tech.

Personal financial experts often tell people to carry a credit card from a bank that isn't yours or have a checking account at a separate bank because this is so common.

Lastly, the people moving money to blacklisted places aren't opening Bank of America checking accounts. There's entire cottage industries and crypto and shady international banks, etc ready to cater to them. They're not getting banned because they use services that don't ban them for moving money around like this. But everyday working class people get banned randomly for moving gifts or tuition money around, etc.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by r3trohack3r on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:41PM (#38184728)
> The people moving money to blacklisted places aren't opening Bank of America checking accounts.

My understanding of money laundering, and the laws designed to catch it, wasn’t that it’s used to get money into illegal places. Laundering is used to get money back out of illegal places in a way they can spend as legal money - exactly a Bank of America account.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AussieWog93 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:28PM (#38182339)
Anecdata, but I've had both my bank account and Stripe account closed for basically "no reason".

I still don't know why Stripe closed my account (I was selling cheap USB oscilloscopes online, never had a complaint. Couldn't get in contact with them at all when it happened.)

My bank account was closed because I filled in a KYC form incorrectly, and they didn't have a process in place to follow up properly when this had occurred.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ponector on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:37PM (#38183215)
Bank closed it because you lied in KYC form. And you lied again in your comment that they closed for no reason.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by izacus on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:40PM (#38183260)
Making an honest mistake on a complex form isn't "lying" and neither is it an offense that warrants financial punishment. What the heck?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ponector on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:06PM (#38183624)
How about seeing like a bank? From bank's point of view it could be either honest mistake or deliberate lie. And if person is lying and have been caught - they always say it was an honest mistake.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Kalium on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:09PM (#38184379)
All the bank knows is that they tried to get to know someone as required and that person gave them bad info. This is either intentional or unintentional.

Now, they could go in for a high-touch customer care process, but that has drawbacks. It's expensive. Every person intentionally providing incorrect information is going to claim it's unintentional, meaning that this high-touch customer care process is going to have to double as a strong anti-fraud screening. From the bank's perspective, this is failure-prone and needlessly risky.

If we're seeing like a customer, this is a shitty experience that they can't understand, negotiate, or do anything about. They're being punished and don't know why. If we're seeing like a bank, it's a way to control a risk for a known price.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by MichaelZuo on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:12PM (#38185469)
Have you read the relevant KYC laws and regulations that the bank must follow? Otherwise how would you know this to be the case?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwaway2037 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:13PM (#38185487)

    My bank account was closed because I filled in a KYC form incorrectly, and they didn't have a process in place to follow up properly when this had occurred.
I'm tired of HN anecdata about "bank account was closed because of silly reason X". I sincerely doubt we are getting the full story. Step 1: Send a written complaint to the bank and use mail tracking. Then they cannot deny it was not received. Step 2: Report this to your local banking regulator.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by idiotsecant on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:55PM (#38186202)
You seem very emotionally invested in the idea that banks don't make mistakes. What is that all about?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by jonathanlydall on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:29PM (#38186808)
I’m pretty sure that they absolutely know that banks make mistakes.

But if you’ve never been on the other side providing customer service, you may be astonished at the systemic fraud/illegal attempts happening constantly.

When I did CS at Blizzard for WoW at least half our work was dealing with compromised accounts (essentially by gold sellers), and then a good deal of “I’ve been hacked!” tickets were by the thieves trying to double steal from an account.

To put that in perspective, it was $100,000s or $1,000,000s in CS costs per month (at just Blizzard) to help customers who were victims of a large scale full time industry (not individuals, organisations) which compromises accounts to make a living.

People banned for confirmed cheating with 3rd party programs would make support requests repeatedly in the hope they’d come across an agent who “makes a mistake and accidentally unbans them”, occasionally you would see lots of them trying the same strategy or telling the same story since they saw a forum post of someone who said “this worked for me”.

Legitimate mistakes happen, but they’re like 1% of the time, the rest of the time it’s systemic attempted fraud.

So the person you’re replying to is most likely aware of this reality and says that “complaining on forums” is most often by people who aren’t telling the full story.

Hence them saying, if your story is legit, take it to the right place to get help, otherwise you’re looking like a just another fraudster (who do this systematically) trying to game the system in some way.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @07:18PM (#38199213)
So maybe it's a bad business model. If your business model requires you to choose between rampant fraud or randomly firing customers, it's a bad business model.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by stouset on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:29PM (#38182359)
I've also heard repeatedly in conversation people frequently admit to structuring financial transactions for a variety of reasons, completely unaware that doing so is a felony.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:05PM (#38182821)
Is it illegal to round up your transaction to $10,001 for the purpose of making the bank file the form so you can't be accused of structuring to avoid it?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:53PM (#38183456)
lol, no. Why would it be?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by creer on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:01PM (#38184307)
(the problem with these ideas is that they make you responsible for knowing all these things - which ideally is what you pay the bank for.)
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by xur17 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:50PM (#38184816)
Does the bank have a human look at / file the form, or is it automatically generated? (Unless they are required to do it manually, I can't imagine they do)
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by sicromoft on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:41PM (#38183268)
It’s only illegal if you’re intentionally doing it to avoid reporting
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by stouset on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:44PM (#38184124)
They are intentionally doing it because of mostly imagined consequences of having the transactions be reported. And committing a felony as a consequence.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by teemur on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:50PM (#38183407)
Sorry, what does "structuring financial transactions" mean in this context?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by sidewndr46 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:06PM (#38183634)
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by acheong08 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:03PM (#38184331)
Anecdote: I hade my Revolut account suspended for 24 hours for a reason they refused to disclose yet admitted as their mistake last week
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwaway2037 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:18PM (#38185521)
The solution is simple: Stop "banking" with entities that don't have a banking license.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by mdekkers on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:45PM (#38185706)
Revolut has a banking license, at least in Europe
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwaway2037 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @08:07PM (#38199592)
In Lithuania. No offense to any Lithuanians reading here, but I do not trust their banking regulators as much as French, German, Dutch, Nordic, etc. Obviously, selecting Lithuania is a clear case of regulatory arbitrage. I still cannot believe people are doing serious business with Revolut. Do you really think the Lithuanian regulators are going to help (catch bad behaviour) during a banking crisis? I have no faith.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by mdekkers on Thursday November 09, 2023 @04:52AM (#38203005)
I genuinely don’t know where to begin with addressing this level of ignorance. All Central Banks, including the Bank of Lithuania, are governed by the European Central Bank. Passporting works because of an equality principle.

Lithuania has worked hard to become a fintech hub for Europe, and that isn’t based on a poor regulatory regime.

If you can bring actual facts to the table as to why the Lithuania banking license is inferior, we can have a discussion. Now you are just spouting baseless “Lithuania banking license is bad because of Lithuania” nonsense.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by throwaway2037 on Monday November 13, 2023 @03:50AM (#38248281)
How do you explain the 2014 Danske Bank money laundering scandal in Estonia? To be clear: I recognize that Estonia is not Lithuania. My point: Estonia is also a part of EU / Eurozone and its central bank is governed by ECB. That governance did little to nothing to stop the money laundering scandal. It went on for years, which implies incredibly weak enforcement of banking regulations. Outside of the economic majors in EU, I am generally distrustful of banking regulation _enforcement_. Yes, the laws are written, but are they effectively enforced? I doubt it.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by acheong08 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:55PM (#38185781)
Sometimes you don’t get a choice, especially when only just moving to a new country.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by rendaw on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:39PM (#38186463)
I'm ready to believe this, but IIRC on previous posts people accused the poster of doing shady things but I don't remember seeing it ever coming out that they actually did. Do you have some links?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ackbar03 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:51PM (#38186555)
>but eventually it comes out that they’re in North Korea selling cannabis to Iran or something.

I only do this on the occasional Wednesday though when things are quiet at work

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by RationalDino on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:12PM (#38181376)
Yes, individuals are allowed to have a public forum for that. We have freedom of speech after all.

However such a forum is going to be of particular interest for would-be money launderers. And therefore you should expect it to be monitored by people connected to the financial system. With the result being that active participation in such a forum may itself become grounds for a SAR to be slapped on you.

A SAR that, of course, you will never be informed of. Because, as patio11 documents, that is the law.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AmericanChopper on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:44PM (#38181788)
Anti-Money Laundering laws are a complete anti-democratic tyranny. With AML you are assumed guilty anytime you possess money, or participate in any financial transactions, or have any assets. If called upon to do so you will have to prove your innocence beyond a reasonable doubt, and if you fail to do so, your assets or money can be permanently seized. All of this occurs without any form of due process.

The government actually wouldn’t be able to make these regulations for itself, and the only way it manages to make AML laws work is with a complete governance anti-pattern. Where they simply tell the banks that if they unknowingly allow any “money laundering”, then they will be punished, rather than actually creating some regulations for them to follow. So the institutions just create these kafkaesque nightmares themselves, because they don’t really care about who gets screwed over by them.

The worse part is that money laundering is trivially easy for anybody who wants to do it, it just costs money to do the compliance properly. The only people who get thwarted by these laws are immigrants who do a lot of remittance, and law-abiding wealthy people who naively think they’re entitled to possess their own money. Two groups that society generally doesn’t care at all about protecting.

I personally make a lot of money off the AML compliance industry, so I’m not really complaining for my own sake. But these laws are the intended outcome of “anti-terrorism” and “anti-tax-evasion” policies.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:09PM (#38182098)
> Anti-Money Laundering laws are a complete anti-democratic tyranny.

But they were produced through the democratic process: we have told our elected representatives that we want them to Do Something about things like organized crime and international terrorism, and these laws are part of the Something That Was Done. The laws will not change unless and until we the people change the incentives we give our elected representatives.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ElFitz on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:44PM (#38182573)
Wether or not laws and policies have, in practice, anything to do with what people want, is still up for debate [1] [2].

It could also be argued that such laws and policies have mainly been enacted by states in order to eliminate threats to their authority, legitimacy, or continued existence, through financial control.

Which may or may not be the case. Just pointing out that states, even liberal democracies, may not always be all about expressing the will of their constituents.

[1]: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-poli...

[2]: https://www.vox.com/2016/5/9/11502464/gilens-page-oligarchy-...

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:28PM (#38183093)
> Wether or not laws and policies have, in practice, anything to do with what people want, is still up for debate

If we the people wanted something different, we would be voting differently. The fact that we continue to vote for the same incumbents means they are doing what we want.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:59PM (#38183524)
Individual House Representatives usually have high approval ratings from people who voted them in while Congress as a whole has a terrible approval rating. It's not quite as simple as seeing historical election results and saying everybody is necessarily happy with their representation.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:35PM (#38184008)
> Individual House Representatives usually have high approval ratings from people who voted them in while Congress as a whole has a terrible approval rating.

Yes, that's true. (And the Senate is no different.) What does it mean?

I think it means that people do not realize the actual problem. They don't see the two facts you cite as at odds with each other or connected to each other at all. But they are. The reason why Congress can have such a low approval rating while incumbency reelection rates remain high are that people think it's all those other members of Congress who are the problem--if only everyone would listen to their members of Congress, all that stuff would get fixed. They don't realize that, if you send someone to Congress to fix something, and it doesn't get fixed, you need to send someone else. You can't keep allowing the incumbents to hide behind "it's not me, it's all those others" forever.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by aldonius on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:10PM (#38184390)
>> Individual House Representatives usually have high approval ratings from people who voted them in while Congress as a whole has a terrible approval rating.

> Yes, that's true. (And the Senate is no different.) What does it mean?

Red voters tend to live in red seats & states, blue voters tend to live in blue seats and states.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:14PM (#38185928)
> Red voters tend to live in red seats & states, blue voters tend to live in blue seats and states.

This is a tautology. It doesn't change anything I said.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by aldonius on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:56PM (#38186966)
Sure.

I still think it's the most intuitive way to describe the first-order explanation for why people are happy with their specific representatives, but not Congress as a whole.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ElFitz on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:16AM (#38187324)
Yes and no.

See gerrymandering. See abstention rates and voter apathy.

Politics, like any system, can be gamed. Considering the incentives and interests at play, it is no surprise that it is. Taking into account how long these systems or similar have been in place, it shouldn’t be surprising that efficient tactics and strategies have been devised and refined over time.

Also considering how uneducated most of us are when it comes to politics, it is no surprise that most of us fall continuously fall for age old tactics and strategies.

Regarding "we the people", I personally do not come from nor live in the US. In the country I come from, people chose to do exactly what you suggest and vote for someone new. They eschewed both traditional parties, did not fall into the extremes' traps, and elected… the underdog!

Or so they thought. It seems they hate him now. He did get reelected, but by less than 40% of the people who could vote if they cared to or believed it would change anything.

Nothing new under the sun, really. I’m pretty sure we’d find the same patterns at play in Athen’s Boule and Ancient Rome.

But hey, "with every mistake we must surely be learning".

In case it wasn’t clear, I have personally entirely given up on both my fellow citizens and my home country’s (a liberal democracy as well) politics.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:07PM (#38182843)
There's no evidence that representatives do what constituents want them to do. In fact, there's evidence they do what billionaires want them to do.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:27PM (#38183086)
> There's no evidence that representatives do what constituents want them to do.

Sure there is. "Want them to do" means the constituents decide their votes based on Something Being Done. The fact that we the people continue to vote in our incumbent representatives at rates over 90 percent is a direct measure of the extent to which those representatives are doing what we want them to do.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:37PM (#38183220)
Mostly we vote based on our personal biggest issue, no matter what they do on the other issues. A lot of Republicans vote Republican because they claim to hate abortion, and they literally don't care about the rest.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:46PM (#38183333)
> The fact that we the people continue to vote in our incumbent representatives at rates over 90 percent is a direct measure of the extent to which those representatives are doing what we want them to do.

This is an artifact of the districting system. A given district wants the local military base to stay open, or tax credits for the local industry. Their representative gets them that, so they get reelected. To get them that they screw over the general public in a thousand ways -- mostly by trading other representatives for the things that aren't in the public interest but their districts want -- but none of them are big enough for the people in the district to change their vote, and most of them couldn't have been prevented by a single representative anyway. So the bums fail to get voted out.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:39PM (#38184060)
> This is an artifact of the districting system.

Which in no way contradicts what I said. The fact that what the people want (or at least a voting majority of us) actually screws over the general public does not mean the people don't want it. It just means that what the people want is not actually good for all of us in the long run. Welcome to reality.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:18PM (#38184483)
The fact that people given a choice between "abortion is illegal" or "poors don't starve to death" choose "abortion is illegal" doesn't mean they want poors to starve to death (although they do want that); it just means they want abortion to be illegal more.

Okay, it was a bad example because those kinds of hardliners do want all the bad things to happen. People given a choice between "close the military base and lose your jobs" and "keep your jobs, but we drop more bombs on brown people" don't necessarily want to drop more bombs on brown people, but they do want to keep their jobs.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:19PM (#38185965)
> given a choice between "abortion is illegal" or "poors don't starve to death"

What are you talking about? No voter is faced with that choice.

> those kinds of hardliners do want all the bad things to happen

Who are these "hardliners" you speak of?

> People given a choice between "close the military base and lose your jobs" and "keep your jobs, but we drop more bombs on brown people"

No voter is faced with that choice either. Closing the military base in a particular district doesn't mean the military downsizes. It just means the base gets built in some other district whose representatives were better at getting pork for their constituents.

None of these things have anything to do with the basic problem I described.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:39AM (#38187700)
You implied that the majority of voters want Something To Be Done and so keep reelecting the people who do this. In fact what happens is that the majority of voters don't even know that this issue exists, but some interest group wants it and captures a representative whose district isn't going to notice or care what their representative is doing on this and then trades votes on other issues their district also doesn't care about to get what they want from other representatives.

There are existing laws that couldn't command majority support in any district much less a majority of them but remain on the books because the representatives who support them continue to be reeelected for independent reasons.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by RationalDino on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:21PM (#38183824)
No, that doesn't measure that they are doing what we want them to do. That measures how effectively they can convince us that the other candidate would be worse, so you should vote for the lesser evil.

On most topics, there is NO candidate who is for doing things outside of the current Overton window. If, for example, you don't like our AML laws, you probably don't have a viable candidate on the ballot who wants to change our AML laws. Therefore your vote can't show your support for changing AML laws.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:38PM (#38184041)
> that doesn't measure that they are doing what we want them to do. That measures how effectively they can convince us that the other candidate would be worse

If we are convinced, then they are doing what we want them to do--because they convinced us that there is no point in wanting anything else.

> On most topics, there is NO candidate who is for doing things outside of the current Overton window.

Yes, but what is the Overton window? It's the range of policies that most people will accept. So by definition only policies within the Overton window can possibly be what the people (or at least a majority of us) want.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:26PM (#38184574)
It's actually the range of policies that we won't literally riot about if they push on us.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:16PM (#38185936)
No, that we won't vote them out of office (or refuse to vote them into office) about. Which is functionally equivalent to "accept".
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:14PM (#38186714)
Voting them out of office doesn't matter. Their opponent supports the same policies.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:37PM (#38184033)
> On most topics, there is NO candidate who is for doing things outside of the current Overton window.

Sure there is.

They aren't likely to be a major party candidate, but then, that's pretty much true by the definition of the Overton window -- if it is supported enough to be a tolerable position for a major party candidate that isn't an extreme outlier within the party, then it is not outside the range of acceptability than the Overton Window refers to.

(Of course, the major point of the Overton Window is that, in a system with elected lawmakers, laws largely aren't set by lawmakers preferences, but by forces, largely external to lawmakers -- including both concentrated interest groups and grassroots activists -- that shift the Overton Window and set the bounds for what it is practical for lawmakers to support.)

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by peyton on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:21PM (#38183014)
Nonsense. It’s entirely possible for tyrannical laws to become self-sustaining by applying them for political purposes.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by injeolmi_love on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:28PM (#38185158)
Just a reminder- modern democracies are a set of democratic institutions such as civil service, independent courts, free media, and some elected representatives. Rule by the people has not meant democracy for over a hundred years.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by lawlessone on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:50PM (#38181888)
>and law-abiding wealthy people who naively think they’re entitled to possess their own money.

They should be fine as long as they show receipts.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AmericanChopper on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:56PM (#38181949)
I really hope this is a joke lol. The amount of paperwork required today is far in excess of anything required pre-GFC. Basically any wealth acquired prior to then is up for confiscation, and this happens all the time. But again, nobody cares, because injustices delivered upon the rich are fine. Imagine you inherited a property from your parents, how do you imagine you’d be able to prove the provenance of that asset? Or the cash used to buy it/pay the mortgage on it? You can’t.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by eschneider on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:20PM (#38182229)
If you inherited it (at least in the US) there will be probate records. And property transfer records. There's LOTS of documentation for that sort of thing.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AmericanChopper on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:28PM (#38182338)
Records that you inherited it are not enough. Where are the records that your parents acquired it properly? Where are the records that prove the money they used to acquire the house were acquired properly? This is the trouble with a presumption of guilt, proving these things are basically impossible.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by eschneider on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:40PM (#38182515)
No. Probate records that you inherited it are enough to get property transferred to your name and the title recorded as such. If you want to be covered just in case your parents somehow stole the land and falsified their ownership, title insurance is a thing.

None of this is impossible. None of this is unknowable. This all happens everyday.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:51PM (#38183430)
The problem (this time) isn't that they try to deny your title to the property, it's that you sell the property and they freeze your account with the money in it and now the burden is on you to prove that your parents acquired it lawfully, which you have no way to do because it happened many years ago and your parents have passed away.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by eschneider on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:15PM (#38183754)
No. If you have title, it's presumed that the land has been lawfully transferred. If someone/.gov wants to claim otherwise, they need to prove that. The entire mortgage market is predicated on that. Can someone cite an instance where someone who "inherited property had to prove their parents acquired it legally because their funds were frozen after a sale" because I'd be very interested in seeing that. I'd be a LOT more willing to believe that a sale fell through because the BUYERS couldn't verify the parent's title, but that's not what's described here.

Do buyers here not do a title exam?

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:24AM (#38187626)
It's not the title which is the issue. You transferred the title and received the money and then the bank took the money. The buyer still has the title and doesn't care about you anymore, and you have no claim to get it back because they actually paid you. But then the bank stole the money they paid you because you couldn't prove how you got the title to begin with.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ls612 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:09PM (#38182099)
>Imagine you inherited a property from your parents, how do you imagine you’d be able to prove the provenance of that asset? Or the cash used to buy it/pay the mortgage on it? You can’t.

Do you have an example of what you mean by this? Like they will say "well you don't have your old paper pay stubs from the 1990s when you were paying the mortgage on your house so we will confiscate your house, go die alone in the gutter"? Because I find that hard to believe. Most people with wealth have an obvious reason for that wealth which is documented in the formal bureaucratic system.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AmericanChopper on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:25PM (#38182304)
> well you don't have your old paper pay stubs from the 1990s when you were paying the mortgage on your house so we will confiscate your house

Yes this is basically how it works. The only contrived thing about my example is that we’re talking about one house a person inherited, rather than millions of dollars in assets.

Here’s a well documented example of this happening in real life

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-09-30/judge-ba...

> A federal judge ruled Friday that the FBI’s seizure of tens of millions of dollars in cash and valuables from 700 safe-deposit boxes in Beverly Hills did not violate anyone’s constitutional rights.

> The decision by U.S. District Judge R. Gary Klausner endorsed law-enforcement tactics that tested the limits of how aggressive federal agents can be in seizing money and property in the absence of any evidence that the owner committed a crime.

> The ruling did not address some of the most controversial aspects of the raid, such as the FBI’s attempt to confiscate assets from box holders on the presumption they were criminals, even in cases where agents had no evidence to validate their suspicions.

Of course, nobody cares, because those people are rich, so they probably didn’t deserve that money anyway…

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by vkou on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:45PM (#38185304)
I assure you, rich people care very deeply about having their money taken away, and are, as a class, incredibly litigious, and are often politically connected.

I am not very impressed by implications that of the truly downtrodden and powerless people in the United States, the 'rich' are anywhere near the front of that line.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by k1t on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:32PM (#38185625)
To be fair:

“The government seized the nests of safety deposit boxes because there was overwhelming evidence that [the deposit box storage location] was a criminal business that conspired with its criminal clients to distribute drugs, launder money, and structure transactions to avoid currency reporting requirements, among other offenses,” they said in papers filed in Los Angeles federal court.

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-04-02/fbi-beve...

You can request your items back here: https://forms.fbi.gov/u-s-private-vaults-claim-form

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AmericanChopper on Sunday November 12, 2023 @01:52AM (#38237966)
Personally I don’t think there is any “to be fair” interpretation of the government making a presumption of guilt and placing the burden onto members of the public to prove their own innocence.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by novok on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:19PM (#38182216)
IMO AML should be abolished because it is ineffective, inefficient and nothing would effectively change if removed. It recovers 100x less than its compliance cost. It’s the TSA of banking, it’s motion without progress.

https://content.11fs.com/article/aml-is-the-worlds-most-inef...

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by RationalDino on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:30PM (#38182369)
The question isn't how much crime it catches. It is how much crime it prevents in the first place.

(No, I'm not suggesting that I have an answer to that question. Just that you're measuring by the wrong measuring stick.)

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:35PM (#38183191)
How much crime it catches is directly related to how much crime it could prevent. If the measure is totally ineffective and criminals hardly ever get caught then there is no deterrent.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by margalabargala on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:09PM (#38183688)
The absolute magnitude of crime it catches is completely irrelevant. The earlier poster is incorrect saying is useless because

> It recovers 100x less than its compliance cost.

The proportion of crime that it catches is of interest to criminals and is what will have the deterrence effect, but whether it catches 10% or 90% is difficult to know as a layperson.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @04:04AM (#38188164)
It's not actually that difficult to know, you can look it up. It isn't 90% effective, or 10%, but rather 0.2% effective.

The other major problem here is that what you're deterring isn't the underlying crime that generates the money but rather the activity that triggers AML scrutiny. So you have little hope of deterring the underlying crime, all you do is cause people to organize their finances in a different way. Which is hardly worth imposing significant costs on millions of innocent people.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by margalabargala on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:48PM (#38194115)
It's "0.2% effective" by measuring in an arbitrary and frankly unrelated way. That figure comes from "what number do we get if we take the amount of illegal funds caught, and divide by the amount of money spent by other companies complying with the regulations?"

I'm sure you'll agree that this doesn't actually relate in any way to the specific number discussed above, aside from sharing the adjective "effective" used as a descriptor.

The cost of compliance to legitimate parties does not have any obvious mechanism to directly affect the deterrence effect.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by spicymapotofu on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:10PM (#38183698)
This is clearly not true. Why else do organizations involved in large scale ML move to locations with more lax AML regimes? E.g. crypto in eastern Europe. If the risk of being caught was no deterrent, ML activity would be dependent on 'amount of launderable funds' and independent of AML regime - can you offer an argument showing this is true?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by TacticalCoder on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:16PM (#38184459)
> E.g. crypto in eastern Europe.

Ah the crypto boogeyman! That argument is ridiculous. The CIA factbook estimates that the proportion of the GDP linked to crime worldwide is 3% to 5%: that's 3 to 5 TRILLION USD directly linked to criminal activities.

Cryptocurrencies do not even register here. It's not even a drop in the bucket.

Moreover public ledgers are what law enforcement and IRS' employeees' wet dreams are made of.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:44AM (#38188060)
One of the reasons it's so ineffective is that you can move to jurisdictions with different laws (or corrupt governments), so the law only negatively impacts innocent people in your own country, meanwhile criminals have stable alternatives.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by RationalDino on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:11PM (#38183708)
It really isn't so simple. My views on this are informed by https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/money-laundering-and-..., so you might want to read that.

First, there are widely known techniques to beat AML. Criminals use them. Using them imposes costs. So you can reduce the profitability of crime, and therefore its frequency, without catching much crime directly.

Secondly, one of the goals of AML regulations is to make it easy to construct a money laundering case against a criminal caught another way. This is kind of like putting Al Capone in jail for tax evasion. Tax evasion isn't why you want him in jail, it is just the thing you can convict him of. Prosecutors see value in these easy convictions.

Are they worthwhile? That's above my paygrade. Certainly patio11 makes a case that they might not be. But both of the things that I just mentioned show that the rules are valued for reasons other than routinely catching a lot of crime.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:21AM (#38187937)
> First, there are widely known techniques to beat AML. Criminals use them. Using them imposes costs. So you can reduce the profitability of crime, and therefore its frequency, without catching much crime directly.

This is only reasonable if the same measures don't also impose costs on innocent people, which is not the case.

And the value of doing this operates inversely with value: The crime you deter this way is the lowest value crime which is the easiest to deter through some other means, but the innocent people you most harm are the ones already at the margin who you don't want to deter/bankrupt, but you do.

Which damages the most competitive markets with businesses that were operating with the thinnest margins and forces them to consolidate into something that can absorb the compliance cost. The cost of inducing that kind of market consolidation is enormous -- as we've seen time and again.

> Secondly, one of the goals of AML regulations is to make it easy to construct a money laundering case against a criminal caught another way. This is kind of like putting Al Capone in jail for tax evasion. Tax evasion isn't why you want him in jail, it is just the thing you can convict him of. Prosecutors see value in these easy convictions.

Undoubtedly the lobby in favor of AML laws is lazy prosecutors who can't be bothered to prove their case honestly and would rather have a vague law that causes common behavior to be a chargeable violation. But that purposeful subversion of the rule of law isn't a legitimate reason even if it wasn't imposing major costs on innocent people.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Scoundreller on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:38PM (#38184047)
Thing is, if you’re laundering money, you’re probably doing something incredibly profitable (importing kilos of something that cost you $2k and then selling for $20k, or just straight up stolen funds with no cost basis).

These groups have no issue with the few percent cost of added transaction friction.

But it really costs people running low-margin businesses or unsophisticated honest people just trying to move overseas, remit funds to family or buy a home overseas.

And the knock-on effects of the bypasses becoming things like “buy a front-business and care less about the legitimate competitors that can’t compete with someone unworried about profit” or “buy a house and let it sit empty”.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Terr_ on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:26PM (#38185581)
> How much crime it catches is directly related to how much crime it could prevent.

If you could actually prove that, I think you'd become quite famous in sociological/economic science.

So no, I think you're making an unwarranted assumption: "How much you can catch" is not necessarily proportional to "How many would have tried except for the fear of being caught."

In particular, actual/would-be violators have a distribution of different motivations and tolerances for risk.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:40AM (#38188038)
Proportionality doesn't have to be linear, and in this case it's unlikely to be, but in the way that makes the AML rules even more worthless.

You might deter the large majority of crime if the chance of getting caught is one in three, because the cost of getting caught is also high. But if the chance of getting caught is only 0.2%, from a psychological perspective people are much more likely to see that and discount the possibility of it happening at all, and mathematically it would be unreasonable to impose a penalty high enough to compensate for such an abysmal rate of effectiveness. So ineffective rules aren't just useless, they're disproportionately useless.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by paulusthe on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:21PM (#38185543)
That's overly simplistic. AML laws serve more purposes than simply catching money laundering, they discourage the underlying crime in the first place. Discouraging that can't be counted, yet you are saying is "AML doesn't catch anything!" But you can't prove the negative.

AML also serves to buttress public support in the financial system because the public interest is being served, and at least recently, without AML the housing crisis would be significantly worse.

"Let the criminals put their cash wherever they want, because it's too expensive to stop them" Isn't exactly the rallying cry you think it is

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:06PM (#38182832)
> We have freedom of speech after all.

You don't, though.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:27PM (#38183893)
The US does. Most countries don't.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by hef19898 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:38PM (#38184045)
All democracies do, one way or the other.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Scoundreller on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:50PM (#38184194)
Plenty of democracies with weak or highly overridable constitutions.

Most of Canada’s is like that. Basically governments can suspend all of your “fundamental freedoms” for 5 year periods, renewed as often as they like.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:25PM (#38184561)
Every country is like that, including the USA.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by refurb on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:40PM (#38185260)
No it's not, as evidence by the numerous laws struck down by the Supreme Court.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:47PM (#38186144)
The laws don't mean anything if you get arrested anyway.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by refurb on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:14PM (#38186724)
Sure they do because you’re released.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:52PM (#38195102)
You can't seriously be that naive. Or maybe you're just trolling. Where's the block feature?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by refurb on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @08:29PM (#38199773)
I'm naive to think that people arrested when the Supreme Court strikes down a law get released?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:06PM (#38184358)
Not to anywhere near the same extent. Meaning, not when it matters.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:21PM (#38184513)
The US doesn't have free speech. It just deluded itself into thinking its version of unfree speech is either somehow not speech, or just doesn't count for some dumb reason or another. There are many things you can't say in the USA.

The EU is just more upfront about its limitations. The EU says: Free speech is good, but some of it is dangerous so you can't have all of it, sorry. The US simply says: We have free speech. Then it arrests you for speaking anyway.

Find something you can't say in the US, and ask a (sufficiently educated) American about it. They'll tell you it's not really free speech or it doesn't count or some nonsense like that, and that America has free speech. A (sufficiently educated) European will tell you it's one of the exceptions.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:43PM (#38184746)
> The US doesn't have free speech.

Oh, it absolutely does. It's really the only country that I would say absolutely does.

No other country has free speech enshrined in it's constitution to the same extent, nor such a strong history of caselaw defending it. The US has a lot of problems, but as a people they are almost as zealous in defending free speech as they are in defending the 2nd amendment. In most other countries other concerns might take priority, but often and only in the US free speech will be the first consideration.

> Find something you can't say in the US

Anything can be said.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:50PM (#38184813)
> Anything can be said.

Please, go to your local town square and hand out flyers about your plot to assassinate the President. Report back with your results.

Oh, and I can predict your reply. You will tell me some excuse for why that isn't really speech, or it is speech but it shouldn't be free even in countries that have 100% free speech (which is a completely absurd argument, by the way - I must recommend you try the "that isn't speech" approach as at least that one isn't not an immediate formal contradiction).

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by astrange on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:50PM (#38185748)
People like that often don't get arrested. At most the Secret Service will take note and make them stay home if there's a VIP anywhere nearby.

There's lots of crazy people and we don't keep them in prisons anymore.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:46PM (#38186141)
It's not very free if you can get confined to your house for saying it.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:07PM (#38185881)
> Please, go to your local town square and hand out flyers about your plot to assassinate the President. Report back with your results.

Ah, lol. I thought you might try something like this.

Yes, there are some exceptions, e.g. yelling fire in a crowded theater, but they generally don't count. They are not restrictions on anything you actually want to say or communicate, they are restrictions on causing a riot or disturbance.

The difference is in the US you can actually say anything you want to say to communicate any opinion or information you want. That isn't true in most other first world countries.

Just look at people getting arrested for protesting Charles' coronation in the UK, people all over Australia, NZ, Europe etc being arrested in pro Palestine (NOT pro Hamas) protests, people being arrested or facing legal issues for giving an opinion on something COVID related in countries other than the US..etc etc etc.

> Oh, and I can predict your reply.

Well, you made a disingenuous argument and were well aware that you did, so that isn't entirely surprising. However, I clarified the claim making that tired old fallacious response entirely irrelevant.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by swatcoder on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:59PM (#38186220)
Ideological purity may wish otherwise, but there’s a meta-layer here: there are inevitable limits to “free speech” when said speech genuinely threatens the institution that otherwise allows free speech.

You are not free to earnestly threaten president or call others to do so. You are not free to share speech that’s been deemed classified. You are not free to conspire with foreign enemies. etc.

While the US does protect many forms of forms of political speech that are deemed impotent or that advocate radical position within the rubric of its institutions, it does have roughly much the same ultimate limitations as every other modern liberal democracy (and many modern non-democracies).

It’s not actually very much of an outlier at all.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:37PM (#38186453)
> You are not free to earnestly threaten president or call others to do so.

Because that's not speech, as in an opinion. It's a call to action. But you can speak all day long about how the president is useless and should be replaced. People in the UK couldn't even protest the coronation of Charles without facing arrest.

> it does have roughly much the same ultimate limitations as every other modern liberal democracy (and many modern non-democracies).

Simply not true. People get arrested for speech in other first world countries that would not happen in the US.

> It’s not actually very much of an outlier at all.

It very much is.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:16PM (#38186732)
Calls to action are speech. When I open my mouth and words come out of it, that is speech. When I punch you in the face, that is not speech. When I tell someone else to punch you in the face, that is speech. When he punches you, that is not speech. I don't know how much simpler I can make it.

If I'm not free to tell someone to punch you in the face, then I don't have absolute free speech.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:37PM (#38186856)
> Calls to action are speech.

Yes, technically, but come on now. You're being disingenuous.

Let's forgo the semantic bullshit which is a pretty shoddy attempt at making a point to begin with.

Instead of saying 'freedom of speech', since you want to be so technical, we can say 'freedom to express any opinion'. The USA has significantly more freedom for people to 'express any opinion' than other first world countries.

> I don't know how much simpler I can make it.

You're not making anything 'simple', you're making a disingenuous point to try and support an even more, forgive me, asinine point that isn't really correct except in a meaningless semantic way. You're ignoring the spirit of what is being discussed and acting like you've refuted a claim; you haven't even come close.

Why don't you actually try and address the claim made instead of playing silly semantic games in lieu of an argument?

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:52PM (#38195096)
But people aren't talking about "freedom to express any opinion". They're talking about "free speech".
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:36PM (#38195770)
Yes, and as generally used and meant, it means "freedom to express any opinion".

No one reasonable disagrees that you shouldn't be able to yell fire in a crowded theater. There have never been people advocating for that when they argue for free speech.

Pointing out there is a restriction on causing riots or disturbances to argue that there is not truly free speech is rather meaningless. It's a 'victory' only in the most technical sense, and not one worth recognizing considering how irrelevant it is to the actual discussion, which relates to "freedom to express any opinion".

Just to be clear, the claim is that the US has significantly more freedom to "express any opinion" than any other first world country does. In this context, "freedom to express any opinion" is generally referred to as "freedom of speech".

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ruszki on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:50PM (#38184197)
Freedom of speech almost never meant and never will mean to be able to speak whatever you want to whoever you want wherever you want whenever you want. No matter what propaganda tells. There are limits and will be limits, and except anarchists nobody can say that this is what they really want in good faith. We know as a fact that uncontrolled free speech is harmful.

Currently, almost everybody who say this, want something else, and this is just a tool to achieve that other thing. A proven harmful tool.

There is free speech in the USA.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:20PM (#38184498)
> Freedom of speech almost never meant and never will mean to be able to speak whatever you want to whoever you want wherever you want whenever you want

That is quite literally what it means. Everything else is a retcon. (It still doesn't mean freedom of social consequences though)

You said it yourself: uncontrolled free speech is harmful. That means there should be mostly free speech, but not completely free speech.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by r00fus on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:40PM (#38184701)
> Freedom of speech almost never meant and never will mean to be able to speak whatever you want to whoever you want wherever you want whenever you want That is quite literally what it means.

>> That is quite literally what it means.

From a platonic ideal, true. But in reality platonic ideals do not exist. Does pure capitalism exist anywhere? No, because without some regulatory scheme it would devolve quickly into plutocracy, planned economy or a regulated capitalist economy.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:47PM (#38184784)
So you acknowledge that freedom of speech is a platonic ideal, which the USA doesn't have.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ruszki on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:25PM (#38185134)
So are you saying that nobody wants free speech (except anarchists as I mentioned)?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:47PM (#38186149)
I don't care how many people want free speech. That is completely irrelevant. You are the one defending that the USA has it.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ruszki on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:56AM (#38187816)
It matters because if the USA doesn’t have it because of your reasoning, then all of those people lied.

And currently, your words against basically the whole relevant literature, laws, and basically almost all of humanity. Especially those which describe how people use expressions meaning a scale as an absolutist term, which happens continuously, like in your case too.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:51PM (#38195085)
Yes, I think all those people lied. Didn't I say that? American "free speech absolutists" keep finding poor rationalizations to exclude the kinds of speech they happen to dislike from the definition of "free speech". By contrast, in Europe, those people simply don't call themselves absolutists, state openly that free speech has some exceptions, and don't have to rationalize anything.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:57PM (#38184888)
> That is quite literally what it means

Legally in the US, it has never meant this. No freedom, even Constitutionally enumerated ones, is absolute. It logically cannot be different than this because every freedom we have can be used in a way that infringes on another person's freedom. The path to maximal liberty for everyone always requires some limits on individual liberty.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:14PM (#38186723)
Sticks and stones can break my bones, but speech rarely infringes on my constitutional rights.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ruszki on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:11PM (#38185008)
It didn’t mean that in Ancient Greece because whoever used that idea didn’t thought that slaves were humans, it didn’t mean that in Middle Ages because everybody who used that used it for specific locations or forms, and it definitely doesn’t mean that since Mill, because nobody use that without including some level of harm principle under an asterisk.

The exceptions are as old as the idea itself. The retcon is thinking otherwise.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by matheusmoreira on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:47PM (#38184163)
I think it's pretty clear by now that "anti money laundering" is just the financial arm of warrantless global mass surveillance. Money laundering may be a crime but it does not justify this. "Monitoring" people and punishing them because they "might" be some money launderer or terrorist is completely backwards and should be a violation of basic rights.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by zb1plus on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:58PM (#38181964)
What can be done as an ordinary people to abolish this system? I firmly believe these types of systems are gross violations of the 1st amendment
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by jgilias on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:24PM (#38182292)
As the Nobel laureate, economist F.A. Hayek said in 1984 - take the money out of the hands of the government using some sly or roundabout way.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by matheusmoreira on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:56PM (#38184244)
There's no hope of ever abolishing such a thing. Our only hope is to subvert it with technology. Cryptocurrency and self-custody. Monero seems like the best option.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by astrange on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:53PM (#38185770)
There isn't a 1st amendment for international banking; that's what international means.

There also isn't a banking system without abuse prevention, and there can never be a way to write down the abuse prevention rules, or else they wouldn't work.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Ridj48dhsnsh on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:50PM (#38186553)
One could argue that cryptocurrencies solve these issues (while creating some of their own).
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by astrange on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:56PM (#38186965)
Oh, they've got the same abuse problems, especially if you try to start a company over them. In fact, with flash loans they managed to invent all new kinds of them!
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by rnk on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:03PM (#38182029)
When I worked at google they made all the devs in my team take the anti-money-laundering class. It was pretty basic stuff like "don't carry a suitcase full of cash across international boundaries". I remember everyone was amazed that I passed the test. And it must have been suspicious ;-)
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by cyberax on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:53PM (#38184847)
Amazon had a similar class, with nice helpful tips like "pay bribes in untraceable cash, not via bank transfers".
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by rnk on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:43PM (#38194032)
Wow, you aren't kidding? Wouldn't they be afraid the training material would leak out, plus that's actually wrong.

At the big G they told us we weren't allowed to pay bribes. And then there was a long section about not giving people noncash gifts to influence them, but what about bringing them to the free lunch, I think that was okay.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ypzhang2 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:33PM (#38182411)
Effectively, its all just based on what indicators have a sufficient signal-to-noise ratio. If the signal-to-noise is high enough for any detectable behavior, then it can become a SAR.

You can absolutely have a public forum to share tips on how to stop this from happening. Just know that said public forum will be mined by money launderers and fraudsters and whatever work around is posted will most likely fail to work within months.

You have to imagine that the banking system exists in an adversarial environment with money-launderers and fraudsters. And instead of code that will always do whats written, the interface is a squishy human for a majority of these interactions.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by lozenge on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:36PM (#38184019)
If you know about SAR, you know that banks can't share information about them or their criteria with the account holder. So the only reason to mention it is if you are angling to bribe an employee to break the rules.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Ridj48dhsnsh on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:53PM (#38186568)
It is possible (and likely quite common) for a layman to only have partial knowledge of how SARs work.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Seattle3503 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:12PM (#38184407)
In a world where being connected to the global financial system is an existential question, the lack of transparency and accountability for these hostile practices does seem to violate the spirit of due process.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by raincom on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:41PM (#38184722)
Currency Transaction Reports(CTRs) are strictly dollar-driven: if someone deposits/withdraws an amount over $10K in a single transaction, CTR is filed automatically. However, if you Zelle to X for a few times, and this X seems to receive too many Zelle payments, both you and X (assuming both have accounts at the same bank) can be reported through SARs with "this transaction has no apparent economic, business or lawful purpose."

How banks figure out which transactions don't serve economic, business or lawful purpose? They can only figure out in a negative way. Either you should become a private banking client (in which case, you get a royal treatment through manual overrides, different compliance teams--just like first class vs economy class flights) or your banking routine should be four paystubs, 20 billpay, and debit card purchases. The more transactions (zelle, deposits, withdrawls, money orders, cashier checks) one is engaged in, the higher the chance that one will be SAR'ed though "transactions don't serve economic, business or lawful purpose".

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by phil21 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:17PM (#38185943)
The best part about all this is you explain what a SAR is to nearly anyone for the first time, and their immediate response nearly 100% of the time is to suggest committing an actual felony by structuring to avoid them.

Even if there is literally no crime to hide.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by raincom on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:09PM (#38186267)
Yes, most of the time people worry about CTRs when they try to withdraw or deposit in an amount more than $10K in one transaction. So, people go around to avoid CTRs. CTRs are never a problem: for every SAR, 10+ CTRs are filed.

In other words, people exacerbate the problem by 10 times.