News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:06PM (#38182832)
> We have freedom of speech after all.

You don't, though.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:27PM (#38183893)
The US does. Most countries don't.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by hef19898 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:38PM (#38184045)
All democracies do, one way or the other.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by Scoundreller on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:50PM (#38184194)
Plenty of democracies with weak or highly overridable constitutions.

Most of Canada’s is like that. Basically governments can suspend all of your “fundamental freedoms” for 5 year periods, renewed as often as they like.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:25PM (#38184561)
Every country is like that, including the USA.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by refurb on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:40PM (#38185260)
No it's not, as evidence by the numerous laws struck down by the Supreme Court.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:47PM (#38186144)
The laws don't mean anything if you get arrested anyway.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by refurb on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:14PM (#38186724)
Sure they do because you’re released.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:52PM (#38195102)
You can't seriously be that naive. Or maybe you're just trolling. Where's the block feature?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by refurb on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @08:29PM (#38199773)
I'm naive to think that people arrested when the Supreme Court strikes down a law get released?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:06PM (#38184358)
Not to anywhere near the same extent. Meaning, not when it matters.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:21PM (#38184513)
The US doesn't have free speech. It just deluded itself into thinking its version of unfree speech is either somehow not speech, or just doesn't count for some dumb reason or another. There are many things you can't say in the USA.

The EU is just more upfront about its limitations. The EU says: Free speech is good, but some of it is dangerous so you can't have all of it, sorry. The US simply says: We have free speech. Then it arrests you for speaking anyway.

Find something you can't say in the US, and ask a (sufficiently educated) American about it. They'll tell you it's not really free speech or it doesn't count or some nonsense like that, and that America has free speech. A (sufficiently educated) European will tell you it's one of the exceptions.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:43PM (#38184746)
> The US doesn't have free speech.

Oh, it absolutely does. It's really the only country that I would say absolutely does.

No other country has free speech enshrined in it's constitution to the same extent, nor such a strong history of caselaw defending it. The US has a lot of problems, but as a people they are almost as zealous in defending free speech as they are in defending the 2nd amendment. In most other countries other concerns might take priority, but often and only in the US free speech will be the first consideration.

> Find something you can't say in the US

Anything can be said.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:50PM (#38184813)
> Anything can be said.

Please, go to your local town square and hand out flyers about your plot to assassinate the President. Report back with your results.

Oh, and I can predict your reply. You will tell me some excuse for why that isn't really speech, or it is speech but it shouldn't be free even in countries that have 100% free speech (which is a completely absurd argument, by the way - I must recommend you try the "that isn't speech" approach as at least that one isn't not an immediate formal contradiction).

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by astrange on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:50PM (#38185748)
People like that often don't get arrested. At most the Secret Service will take note and make them stay home if there's a VIP anywhere nearby.

There's lots of crazy people and we don't keep them in prisons anymore.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:46PM (#38186141)
It's not very free if you can get confined to your house for saying it.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:07PM (#38185881)
> Please, go to your local town square and hand out flyers about your plot to assassinate the President. Report back with your results.

Ah, lol. I thought you might try something like this.

Yes, there are some exceptions, e.g. yelling fire in a crowded theater, but they generally don't count. They are not restrictions on anything you actually want to say or communicate, they are restrictions on causing a riot or disturbance.

The difference is in the US you can actually say anything you want to say to communicate any opinion or information you want. That isn't true in most other first world countries.

Just look at people getting arrested for protesting Charles' coronation in the UK, people all over Australia, NZ, Europe etc being arrested in pro Palestine (NOT pro Hamas) protests, people being arrested or facing legal issues for giving an opinion on something COVID related in countries other than the US..etc etc etc.

> Oh, and I can predict your reply.

Well, you made a disingenuous argument and were well aware that you did, so that isn't entirely surprising. However, I clarified the claim making that tired old fallacious response entirely irrelevant.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by swatcoder on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:59PM (#38186220)
Ideological purity may wish otherwise, but there’s a meta-layer here: there are inevitable limits to “free speech” when said speech genuinely threatens the institution that otherwise allows free speech.

You are not free to earnestly threaten president or call others to do so. You are not free to share speech that’s been deemed classified. You are not free to conspire with foreign enemies. etc.

While the US does protect many forms of forms of political speech that are deemed impotent or that advocate radical position within the rubric of its institutions, it does have roughly much the same ultimate limitations as every other modern liberal democracy (and many modern non-democracies).

It’s not actually very much of an outlier at all.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:37PM (#38186453)
> You are not free to earnestly threaten president or call others to do so.

Because that's not speech, as in an opinion. It's a call to action. But you can speak all day long about how the president is useless and should be replaced. People in the UK couldn't even protest the coronation of Charles without facing arrest.

> it does have roughly much the same ultimate limitations as every other modern liberal democracy (and many modern non-democracies).

Simply not true. People get arrested for speech in other first world countries that would not happen in the US.

> It’s not actually very much of an outlier at all.

It very much is.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:16PM (#38186732)
Calls to action are speech. When I open my mouth and words come out of it, that is speech. When I punch you in the face, that is not speech. When I tell someone else to punch you in the face, that is speech. When he punches you, that is not speech. I don't know how much simpler I can make it.

If I'm not free to tell someone to punch you in the face, then I don't have absolute free speech.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:37PM (#38186856)
> Calls to action are speech.

Yes, technically, but come on now. You're being disingenuous.

Let's forgo the semantic bullshit which is a pretty shoddy attempt at making a point to begin with.

Instead of saying 'freedom of speech', since you want to be so technical, we can say 'freedom to express any opinion'. The USA has significantly more freedom for people to 'express any opinion' than other first world countries.

> I don't know how much simpler I can make it.

You're not making anything 'simple', you're making a disingenuous point to try and support an even more, forgive me, asinine point that isn't really correct except in a meaningless semantic way. You're ignoring the spirit of what is being discussed and acting like you've refuted a claim; you haven't even come close.

Why don't you actually try and address the claim made instead of playing silly semantic games in lieu of an argument?

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:52PM (#38195096)
But people aren't talking about "freedom to express any opinion". They're talking about "free speech".
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by PrimeMcFly on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:36PM (#38195770)
Yes, and as generally used and meant, it means "freedom to express any opinion".

No one reasonable disagrees that you shouldn't be able to yell fire in a crowded theater. There have never been people advocating for that when they argue for free speech.

Pointing out there is a restriction on causing riots or disturbances to argue that there is not truly free speech is rather meaningless. It's a 'victory' only in the most technical sense, and not one worth recognizing considering how irrelevant it is to the actual discussion, which relates to "freedom to express any opinion".

Just to be clear, the claim is that the US has significantly more freedom to "express any opinion" than any other first world country does. In this context, "freedom to express any opinion" is generally referred to as "freedom of speech".

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ruszki on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:50PM (#38184197)
Freedom of speech almost never meant and never will mean to be able to speak whatever you want to whoever you want wherever you want whenever you want. No matter what propaganda tells. There are limits and will be limits, and except anarchists nobody can say that this is what they really want in good faith. We know as a fact that uncontrolled free speech is harmful.

Currently, almost everybody who say this, want something else, and this is just a tool to achieve that other thing. A proven harmful tool.

There is free speech in the USA.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:20PM (#38184498)
> Freedom of speech almost never meant and never will mean to be able to speak whatever you want to whoever you want wherever you want whenever you want

That is quite literally what it means. Everything else is a retcon. (It still doesn't mean freedom of social consequences though)

You said it yourself: uncontrolled free speech is harmful. That means there should be mostly free speech, but not completely free speech.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by r00fus on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:40PM (#38184701)
> Freedom of speech almost never meant and never will mean to be able to speak whatever you want to whoever you want wherever you want whenever you want That is quite literally what it means.

>> That is quite literally what it means.

From a platonic ideal, true. But in reality platonic ideals do not exist. Does pure capitalism exist anywhere? No, because without some regulatory scheme it would devolve quickly into plutocracy, planned economy or a regulated capitalist economy.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:47PM (#38184784)
So you acknowledge that freedom of speech is a platonic ideal, which the USA doesn't have.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ruszki on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:25PM (#38185134)
So are you saying that nobody wants free speech (except anarchists as I mentioned)?
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:47PM (#38186149)
I don't care how many people want free speech. That is completely irrelevant. You are the one defending that the USA has it.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ruszki on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:56AM (#38187816)
It matters because if the USA doesn’t have it because of your reasoning, then all of those people lied.

And currently, your words against basically the whole relevant literature, laws, and basically almost all of humanity. Especially those which describe how people use expressions meaning a scale as an absolutist term, which happens continuously, like in your case too.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:51PM (#38195085)
Yes, I think all those people lied. Didn't I say that? American "free speech absolutists" keep finding poor rationalizations to exclude the kinds of speech they happen to dislike from the definition of "free speech". By contrast, in Europe, those people simply don't call themselves absolutists, state openly that free speech has some exceptions, and don't have to rationalize anything.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:57PM (#38184888)
> That is quite literally what it means

Legally in the US, it has never meant this. No freedom, even Constitutionally enumerated ones, is absolute. It logically cannot be different than this because every freedom we have can be used in a way that infringes on another person's freedom. The path to maximal liberty for everyone always requires some limits on individual liberty.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:14PM (#38186723)
Sticks and stones can break my bones, but speech rarely infringes on my constitutional rights.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ruszki on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:11PM (#38185008)
It didn’t mean that in Ancient Greece because whoever used that idea didn’t thought that slaves were humans, it didn’t mean that in Middle Ages because everybody who used that used it for specific locations or forms, and it definitely doesn’t mean that since Mill, because nobody use that without including some level of harm principle under an asterisk.

The exceptions are as old as the idea itself. The retcon is thinking otherwise.