Re:Seeing Like a Bank
by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:40AM
(#38188038)
Proportionality doesn't have to be linear, and in this case it's unlikely to be, but in the way that makes the AML rules even more worthless.
You might deter the large majority of crime if the chance of getting caught is one in three, because the cost of getting caught is also high. But if the chance of getting caught is only 0.2%, from a psychological perspective people are much more likely to see that and discount the possibility of it happening at all, and mathematically it would be unreasonable to impose a penalty high enough to compensate for such an abysmal rate of effectiveness. So ineffective rules aren't just useless, they're disproportionately useless.
If you could actually prove that, I think you'd become quite famous in sociological/economic science.
So no, I think you're making an unwarranted assumption: "How much you can catch" is not necessarily proportional to "How many would have tried except for the fear of being caught."
In particular, actual/would-be violators have a distribution of different motivations and tolerances for risk.