Re:Seeing Like a Bank
by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @04:04AM
(#38188164)
It's not actually that difficult to know, you can look it up. It isn't 90% effective, or 10%, but rather 0.2% effective.
The other major problem here is that what you're deterring isn't the underlying crime that generates the money but rather the activity that triggers AML scrutiny. So you have little hope of deterring the underlying crime, all you do is cause people to organize their finances in a different way. Which is hardly worth imposing significant costs on millions of innocent people.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank
by margalabargala on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:48PM
(#38194115)
It's "0.2% effective" by measuring in an arbitrary and frankly unrelated way. That figure comes from "what number do we get if we take the amount of illegal funds caught, and divide by the amount of money spent by other companies complying with the regulations?"
I'm sure you'll agree that this doesn't actually relate in any way to the specific number discussed above, aside from sharing the adjective "effective" used as a descriptor.
The cost of compliance to legitimate parties does not have any obvious mechanism to directly affect the deterrence effect.
> It recovers 100x less than its compliance cost.
The proportion of crime that it catches is of interest to criminals and is what will have the deterrence effect, but whether it catches 10% or 90% is difficult to know as a layperson.