News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:09PM (#38182098)
> Anti-Money Laundering laws are a complete anti-democratic tyranny.

But they were produced through the democratic process: we have told our elected representatives that we want them to Do Something about things like organized crime and international terrorism, and these laws are part of the Something That Was Done. The laws will not change unless and until we the people change the incentives we give our elected representatives.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ElFitz on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:44PM (#38182573)
Wether or not laws and policies have, in practice, anything to do with what people want, is still up for debate [1] [2].

It could also be argued that such laws and policies have mainly been enacted by states in order to eliminate threats to their authority, legitimacy, or continued existence, through financial control.

Which may or may not be the case. Just pointing out that states, even liberal democracies, may not always be all about expressing the will of their constituents.

[1]: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-poli...

[2]: https://www.vox.com/2016/5/9/11502464/gilens-page-oligarchy-...

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:28PM (#38183093)
> Wether or not laws and policies have, in practice, anything to do with what people want, is still up for debate

If we the people wanted something different, we would be voting differently. The fact that we continue to vote for the same incumbents means they are doing what we want.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:59PM (#38183524)
Individual House Representatives usually have high approval ratings from people who voted them in while Congress as a whole has a terrible approval rating. It's not quite as simple as seeing historical election results and saying everybody is necessarily happy with their representation.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:35PM (#38184008)
> Individual House Representatives usually have high approval ratings from people who voted them in while Congress as a whole has a terrible approval rating.

Yes, that's true. (And the Senate is no different.) What does it mean?

I think it means that people do not realize the actual problem. They don't see the two facts you cite as at odds with each other or connected to each other at all. But they are. The reason why Congress can have such a low approval rating while incumbency reelection rates remain high are that people think it's all those other members of Congress who are the problem--if only everyone would listen to their members of Congress, all that stuff would get fixed. They don't realize that, if you send someone to Congress to fix something, and it doesn't get fixed, you need to send someone else. You can't keep allowing the incumbents to hide behind "it's not me, it's all those others" forever.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by aldonius on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:10PM (#38184390)
>> Individual House Representatives usually have high approval ratings from people who voted them in while Congress as a whole has a terrible approval rating.

> Yes, that's true. (And the Senate is no different.) What does it mean?

Red voters tend to live in red seats & states, blue voters tend to live in blue seats and states.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:14PM (#38185928)
> Red voters tend to live in red seats & states, blue voters tend to live in blue seats and states.

This is a tautology. It doesn't change anything I said.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by aldonius on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:56PM (#38186966)
Sure.

I still think it's the most intuitive way to describe the first-order explanation for why people are happy with their specific representatives, but not Congress as a whole.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by ElFitz on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:16AM (#38187324)
Yes and no.

See gerrymandering. See abstention rates and voter apathy.

Politics, like any system, can be gamed. Considering the incentives and interests at play, it is no surprise that it is. Taking into account how long these systems or similar have been in place, it shouldn’t be surprising that efficient tactics and strategies have been devised and refined over time.

Also considering how uneducated most of us are when it comes to politics, it is no surprise that most of us fall continuously fall for age old tactics and strategies.

Regarding "we the people", I personally do not come from nor live in the US. In the country I come from, people chose to do exactly what you suggest and vote for someone new. They eschewed both traditional parties, did not fall into the extremes' traps, and elected… the underdog!

Or so they thought. It seems they hate him now. He did get reelected, but by less than 40% of the people who could vote if they cared to or believed it would change anything.

Nothing new under the sun, really. I’m pretty sure we’d find the same patterns at play in Athen’s Boule and Ancient Rome.

But hey, "with every mistake we must surely be learning".

In case it wasn’t clear, I have personally entirely given up on both my fellow citizens and my home country’s (a liberal democracy as well) politics.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:07PM (#38182843)
There's no evidence that representatives do what constituents want them to do. In fact, there's evidence they do what billionaires want them to do.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:27PM (#38183086)
> There's no evidence that representatives do what constituents want them to do.

Sure there is. "Want them to do" means the constituents decide their votes based on Something Being Done. The fact that we the people continue to vote in our incumbent representatives at rates over 90 percent is a direct measure of the extent to which those representatives are doing what we want them to do.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:37PM (#38183220)
Mostly we vote based on our personal biggest issue, no matter what they do on the other issues. A lot of Republicans vote Republican because they claim to hate abortion, and they literally don't care about the rest.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:46PM (#38183333)
> The fact that we the people continue to vote in our incumbent representatives at rates over 90 percent is a direct measure of the extent to which those representatives are doing what we want them to do.

This is an artifact of the districting system. A given district wants the local military base to stay open, or tax credits for the local industry. Their representative gets them that, so they get reelected. To get them that they screw over the general public in a thousand ways -- mostly by trading other representatives for the things that aren't in the public interest but their districts want -- but none of them are big enough for the people in the district to change their vote, and most of them couldn't have been prevented by a single representative anyway. So the bums fail to get voted out.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:39PM (#38184060)
> This is an artifact of the districting system.

Which in no way contradicts what I said. The fact that what the people want (or at least a voting majority of us) actually screws over the general public does not mean the people don't want it. It just means that what the people want is not actually good for all of us in the long run. Welcome to reality.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:18PM (#38184483)
The fact that people given a choice between "abortion is illegal" or "poors don't starve to death" choose "abortion is illegal" doesn't mean they want poors to starve to death (although they do want that); it just means they want abortion to be illegal more.

Okay, it was a bad example because those kinds of hardliners do want all the bad things to happen. People given a choice between "close the military base and lose your jobs" and "keep your jobs, but we drop more bombs on brown people" don't necessarily want to drop more bombs on brown people, but they do want to keep their jobs.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:19PM (#38185965)
> given a choice between "abortion is illegal" or "poors don't starve to death"

What are you talking about? No voter is faced with that choice.

> those kinds of hardliners do want all the bad things to happen

Who are these "hardliners" you speak of?

> People given a choice between "close the military base and lose your jobs" and "keep your jobs, but we drop more bombs on brown people"

No voter is faced with that choice either. Closing the military base in a particular district doesn't mean the military downsizes. It just means the base gets built in some other district whose representatives were better at getting pork for their constituents.

None of these things have anything to do with the basic problem I described.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:39AM (#38187700)
You implied that the majority of voters want Something To Be Done and so keep reelecting the people who do this. In fact what happens is that the majority of voters don't even know that this issue exists, but some interest group wants it and captures a representative whose district isn't going to notice or care what their representative is doing on this and then trades votes on other issues their district also doesn't care about to get what they want from other representatives.

There are existing laws that couldn't command majority support in any district much less a majority of them but remain on the books because the representatives who support them continue to be reeelected for independent reasons.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by RationalDino on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:21PM (#38183824)
No, that doesn't measure that they are doing what we want them to do. That measures how effectively they can convince us that the other candidate would be worse, so you should vote for the lesser evil.

On most topics, there is NO candidate who is for doing things outside of the current Overton window. If, for example, you don't like our AML laws, you probably don't have a viable candidate on the ballot who wants to change our AML laws. Therefore your vote can't show your support for changing AML laws.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:38PM (#38184041)
> that doesn't measure that they are doing what we want them to do. That measures how effectively they can convince us that the other candidate would be worse

If we are convinced, then they are doing what we want them to do--because they convinced us that there is no point in wanting anything else.

> On most topics, there is NO candidate who is for doing things outside of the current Overton window.

Yes, but what is the Overton window? It's the range of policies that most people will accept. So by definition only policies within the Overton window can possibly be what the people (or at least a majority of us) want.

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:26PM (#38184574)
It's actually the range of policies that we won't literally riot about if they push on us.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by pdonis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:16PM (#38185936)
No, that we won't vote them out of office (or refuse to vote them into office) about. Which is functionally equivalent to "accept".
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by immibis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:14PM (#38186714)
Voting them out of office doesn't matter. Their opponent supports the same policies.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:37PM (#38184033)
> On most topics, there is NO candidate who is for doing things outside of the current Overton window.

Sure there is.

They aren't likely to be a major party candidate, but then, that's pretty much true by the definition of the Overton window -- if it is supported enough to be a tolerable position for a major party candidate that isn't an extreme outlier within the party, then it is not outside the range of acceptability than the Overton Window refers to.

(Of course, the major point of the Overton Window is that, in a system with elected lawmakers, laws largely aren't set by lawmakers preferences, but by forces, largely external to lawmakers -- including both concentrated interest groups and grassroots activists -- that shift the Overton Window and set the bounds for what it is practical for lawmakers to support.)

Re:Seeing Like a Bank by peyton on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:21PM (#38183014)
Nonsense. It’s entirely possible for tyrannical laws to become self-sustaining by applying them for political purposes.
Re:Seeing Like a Bank by injeolmi_love on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:28PM (#38185158)
Just a reminder- modern democracies are a set of democratic institutions such as civil service, independent courts, free media, and some elected representatives. Rule by the people has not meant democracy for over a hundred years.