News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hristov on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:50AM (#31111059)
Actually, if you know what you are talking about, this filing actually shows Elon is about 21 billion dollars short. This is because 21 billion dollars of the commitment is coming from him and not from any financial institution. He is a very rich man but almost his entire wealth is tied up in tesla shares which he cannot sell in such large amounts and ownership of spacex which is even harder to sell.

If he tries to sell 21 billion dollars worth of tesla shares, the share price will collapse.

So no, once again he does not have funding secured. And once again he is trying to bullshit his way around the issue, although this time the bullshitting is a little more sophisticated.

It is still possible that he tries to sell a lot of tesla shares to get the cash to buy twitter, but it is unlikely.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rcMgD2BwE72F on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:56AM (#31111161)
>If he tries to sell 21 billion dollars worth of tesla shares, the share price will collapse.

So why didn't the stock price collapsed when he sold $15B in December 2021?

https://www.reuters.com/markets/deals/teslas-musk-says-he-so...

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hristov on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:05PM (#31111294)
He sold that over two months and the overall market was much stronger then. Also those sales were pretty much required for taxes and thus did not send a negative signal to the market. If he sells large amounts of tsla shares to buy twitter, this will be a negative signal -- any other tesla shareholder can sell tesla shares to buy twitter, and why wouldn't they when the tesla CEO is doing it.

It is still possible that he tries to raise 21 billion by selling stock but I doubt it. First if he actually wanted to do that, he would keep quiet while selling and then come out with the tender offer when he had the cash.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mrep on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:19PM (#31111462)
There stock is up because they just beat earnings [0] and TSLA has 24 billion dollars worth of volume per day [1]. I'm pretty sure he could raise the 21 billion given some time.

[0]: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/20/tesla-tsla-earnings-q1-2022....

[1]: https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/stocks/tsla

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by devoutsalsa on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:28PM (#31111571)
He can always borrow it, too. Tesla is a volatile stock, but if he's not borrowing a huge percentage of his stake, he should be able to use it as collateral. Then he can sell later to pay it off when the timing is right.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by deckard1 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:34PM (#31112588)
Musk goes to the bank

Musk: I can haz money?

Bank: You said that Twitter isn't going to be a way to make money. That you "don't care about the economics at all". Your exact words.

Musk: ...

Bank: ...

Musk: Give me money

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by iepathos on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:14PM (#31113186)
Bank: I see your net worth is far beyond what you're asking for and you won't have a problem making payments with your income. I didn't even know credit scores got as high as yours. Here you go.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jjav on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:47PM (#31114344)
> I didn't even know credit scores got as high as yours.

A bit of an aside, but the richest person I know (as in buys multi-million dollar cars on a whim and has many many of those) says his credit score is pretty mediocre because he's never had a loan. I'd thought having gazillion dollars in the bank would give you a good credit score but guess not.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by gonzo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:19PM (#31114690)
correct. a credit score is mostly about one's demonstrated ability to service debt.

Just because you have a lot of money doesn't mean you'll make payments on a loan.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by bmitc on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:35PM (#31117895)
The credit score system is really about incentivizing you to get, use, and keep credit cards, including retail credit cards, and loans, i.e. take on debt.

The fact that so many things require a high credit score is a forcing function for you to take on these debt instruments, and the credit score is a way for the system to optimize that it get its money.

The entire system is gamed against the consumers unwittingly or unwillingly forced to participate.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by HWR_14 on Friday April 22, 2022 @01:50AM (#31118614)
Your credit score is higher if you pay off your credit card in full every month. Although, yes, it does reward having multiple cards with a high limit.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tekknik on Friday April 22, 2022 @08:46AM (#31120944)
It’s almost like they’re testing your ability to manage a fund.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by seunosewa on Thursday April 21, 2022 @07:15PM (#31116346)
I believe the system was intentionally designed that way by lenders to make borrowing a universal habit.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by smoldesu on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:22PM (#31115361)
As another side note, the richest person I know regularly maxes out his credit card so he can pay it all down and rake in the score bump. Every couple times he does this, they issue him an upgraded card with less limits: the cycle continues.

Not a bad way to buy stuff if you have the means to pay it off.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jjav on Friday April 22, 2022 @02:59AM (#31119030)
> regularly maxes out his credit card so he can pay it all down and rake in the score bump

Does it really?

I have a very high credit score but putting a large charge on one credit card (nowhere close to maxing it out though) dramatically drops my credit score for one month until I pay it off in full at the end of the month.

I pay my child's tuition in full for the year each August (school in California is way too expensive so it's a lot of money, but that's a different topic). I put it on the credit card to get some cash back. My credit score drops by about 150 points right away. Once I get the bill at the end of the cycle and pay it off, the credit score goes right back to where it was before. I don't get any bump though.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by devoutsalsa on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:47PM (#31115593)
Imagine the airline miles you’d get by purchasing Twitter on your credit card.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by k_sze on Friday April 22, 2022 @04:44AM (#31119477)
“Nobody’s gonna try to buy Twitter with a credit card, right?”

“Nah.”

“Alright, we don’t need BIGINT in the ‘balance’ column.”

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by no_wizard on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:05PM (#31115173)
I imagine once you have a verifiable net worth over a certain amount (at least 10 million in near cash assets + a hefty amount on hand) you are able to bypass certain things the rest of us simply can't. This is what I've heard second hand anyway
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tekknik on Friday April 22, 2022 @08:47AM (#31120951)
Once you have a balance above a few hundred thousand your bank starts treating you differently. Sometimes you even get a different entrance to the bank, different tellers, so on.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by MrMan on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:15PM (#31115286)
I can only get loans from my private bank because my credit score is bad. I only borrow on margin foe trading I don't really need other debt but it's embarrassing
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by thedailymail on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:37PM (#31116900)
Not having loans is not one of Elon Musk's problems.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by Sebb767 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:31PM (#31114786)
As the saying goes: If I owe the bank one million dollars, I have a problem. If I owe the bank one billion dollars, the bank has a problem.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rasz on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:55PM (#31116179)
The saying goes:

"If you owe the bank $100, that's your problem. If you owe the bank $100 million, that's the bank's problem."

and comes from 1976 "As I see it: the autobiography of J. Paul Getty". There were no billionaires back then. When you owe a bank 20 Billion while being worth 260 you are still in the first category.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by opo on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:47PM (#31141132)
There were obviously billionaires back then. For example, J. Paul Getty was worth an estimated 6 billion when he died in 1976.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._Paul_Getty

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by metadat on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:20PM (#31115326)
Wrong in this case.

Here the bank can reclaim what is owed via other means.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by sangnoir on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:36PM (#31116031)
Having to find "other means" to reclaim is exactly what makes it the banks problem.

Do you think it's easy to get someone with access to billions of dollars (of your money) to do something they'd rather not? They can tie you up in the courts for years since they're basically equal powers: an $800 billion bank doesn't get better lawyers than a guy worth $1 billion. A bank vs someone with just a million dollars means the individual is at a major disadvantage as lawyer fees can easily exceed that amount in attritional lawfare.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by Sebb767 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:10PM (#31116729)
Also, the reason the bank suddenly wants to reclaim that money might be that the wealth has vanished. If Tesla drops 99% for whatever reason, they will have a big problem getting their money back from stocks.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by sangnoir on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:20PM (#31116788)
That's a great point: counterparty risk is a much bigger concern on a billion-dollar loan
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mywittyname on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:18PM (#31114001)
Musk's net worth his highly volatile. Telsa is trading at pretty high 200 P/e, one bad quarter could crater the stock price. Space X is private, which carries its own issues. Add to that the risk to these assets if Musk dies. Or hell, even it Musk merely "spooks" investors with his flamboyance.

This is a insanely risky vanity project.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by littlestymaar on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:57PM (#31114474)
No matter how volatile his worth is, it's just around a tens of the said worth and there's no way it loses 90% of its value overnight, even if TSLA's valuation is arguably nonsensical.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mywittyname on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:43PM (#31114933)
It doesn't need to lose 90% of its value overnight, 30% is enough to trigger a call on margin loans.

Within the past year, Telsa stock slide from a $1209/sh peak to $766/sh in the span of about five months.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by littlestymaar on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:33PM (#31115994)
And what? Can't he just add more securities as a collateral if it happens?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by HWR_14 on Friday April 22, 2022 @02:00AM (#31118689)
If he has it. At standard margin rates, he'd need to put up ~$140 billion in TSLA stock to cover his TWTR offer. How much can TSLA slide before he doesn't have that. Keep in mind, private companies (SpaceX, Twitter in this hypothetical) cannot be used for margin purposes.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tekknik on Friday April 22, 2022 @08:53AM (#31121007)
Why would he have tu up up almost 4x the loan amount? He just needs to cover the loan.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by HWR_14 on Friday April 22, 2022 @09:20AM (#31121223)
When using stock as collateral for a loan, it's not uncommon to get a loan for 30% of the value of the stock. Certainly not 100%.

In this case, MS has offered him a loan for 20% of the value of his stock.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tekknik on Monday May 02, 2022 @08:20AM (#31234173)
You can still sell the rest of the stock and cover a majority of the loan. I still fail to see why you need way more money than the loan amount to pay it off.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jack_pp on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:15PM (#31113193)
It's about him defaulting on the loan which is not possible considering his shares in Tesla etc. not about him borrowing for investment purposes
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by colinmhayes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:40PM (#31114266)
There's a not totally unreasonable chance that tesla is 10x lower next year. That would mean his net worth is basically equivalent to the loan he would need. Seems pretty risky.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mehrdada on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:44PM (#31114307)
We don’t know the interest rate of that margin loan but you can be goddamn certain whoever underwrote the loan calculated that risk more precisely than HN crowd such that the rate justifies the default risk.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kurupt213 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:26PM (#31114106)
You can default on a loan regardless of your net worth; you can even default on a secured loan. The default is what triggers the civil proceedings for a judgement and forced liquidation of assets
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by accountofme on Friday April 22, 2022 @05:31AM (#31119722)
I have to disagree. It is about the risk of his counterparties. If their risk is deemed too high, they will start liquidating assets to get minimise their risk.

Just look at what recently happened in the nickel markets on the London Metals Exchange when a Chinese Nickel Producer had a margin call against a $2bn short position.

Tldr: the brokers liquidated their position due to the unnecessary risk of having a margin call over a weekend.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by conductr on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:22PM (#31113283)
Bank: put that sweet sweet Tesla stock in this account and take what you want
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by darawk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:55PM (#31114438)
It's a secured loan. The bank doesn't care if it makes money or not.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by CamperBob2 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @09:03PM (#31117078)
Bank: "Do you want that in twenties, or fifties?"
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by Apocryphon on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:54PM (#31113709)
Instead of the bank, what if he went to SoftBank. Imagine the possibilities of an Elon Musk-Masayoshi Son collaboration.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by gonzo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:23PM (#31114718)
Could be like We Work, Greensill Capital, or Wirecard, or it could be like GoTo.

Only one way to find out though.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by AlchemistCamp on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:33PM (#31114815)
It could also be more like Alibaba and double or triple the 37B profit Softbank's Vision Fund made this year.

I would not bet against Musk.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by Anon1096 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:48PM (#31113651)
The other half of the money was borrowed against his stocks already. He probably can't get a favorable rate on the other half so 21 million is coming out of pocket.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by discodave on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:34PM (#31112592)
Pretty sure that this filing shows he is $21 billion short on the borrowing front.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by valleyjo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:44PM (#31114941)
He’s already borrowing 12.5B via a margin loan against his assets. Maybe that’s the most he can get away with.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hackerfromthefu on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:27PM (#31115946)
Interested in a source for this?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by andreareina on Friday April 22, 2022 @05:21AM (#31119665)
It's this para in TFA:

> (ii) A separate debt commitment letter, dated April 20, 2022 (the “Margin Loan Commitment Letter”), from Morgan Stanley Senior Funding, Inc. and certain other financial institutions party thereto as commitment parties (collectively, the “Margin Loan Commitment Parties”) pursuant to which the Margin Loan Commitment Parties have committed to provide $12.5 billion in margin loans (the “Margin Loan Facility”), the proceeds of which will be distributed or otherwise made available to Purchaser; and

The letter: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1418091/000110465922...

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by spoonjim on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:23PM (#31111503)
One advantage of Musk's positioning as a "nutcase" is that him selling Tesla stock to buy Twitter doesn't signal "I believe Twitter is a better investment than Tesla" as much as it signals "Musk is doing Musk stuff"
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by xg15 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:41PM (#31111754)
This. He communicated his plan pretty overtly: He made no secret that his buy attempt is mostly for political reasons and that his selloff will be a means to the end of securing funding for the takeover. None of this has anything to do with actual investment decisions.

So maybe he hopes to sell his shares to "activist buyers" who want the takeover to succeed and therefore have no interest in dropping the share price.

Of course that is assuming any of the purported motives are real and not just an act.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by deckard1 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:38PM (#31112652)
So you're saying TSLA holders don't care that Elon Musk is an unhinged lunatic. Got it.

Someone remind me again why this isn't a cult?

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:18PM (#31113233)
As a TSLA holder I care that I've made 20x on my stock.

I care it's the best performing stock in the last 5 and 10 years.

I care that Tesla is growing revenues at 50%+ over more than a decade, and profits even faster. Which is a better financial performance than Amazon has at similar stage.

What I do not care is your editorializing of Musk's character of calling me a cult member.

I guess I should be offended but then I take a look at my bank account and it kind of makes me not care about what you think about me or Musk.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by McLaren_Ferrari on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:59PM (#31114488)
Your TSLA gains are nothing compared to what many people in here made on Ethereum.

Yet such people don't roam around screaming off the top of their lungs "Buterin is God!".

Ethereum, much like TSLA, much like betting on Trump back in 2016 are about calling an event and predicting what's gonna be the outcome of a socio-political movement.

Nobody is better prepared to predict such outcome than the guy who can keep his cool and openly admit that such social movement is really just BS and hot air, but that nonetheless it still has steam and room to grow among the populace for the time being.

What you don't want to be is a so called "true believer" as that would prevent you from jettisoning yourself once the movement runs out of steam, if you are a "true-true believer" you might find yourself storming the capitol...or in Musk's case the SEC building as that would be the aim of his rage when the socio-religious movement that he built runs out of steam as they eventually all do.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jokethrowaway on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:17PM (#31115305)
> Yet such people don't roam around screaming off the top of their lungs "Buterin is God!".

You haven't met crypto people yet, I take?

It's normal, you give people money and they worship you.

Think of the "cult" of Steve Jobs linked to Apple gains.

This is nothing new. It's also not a real cult, it's more as admiring successful entrepreneurs.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by McLaren_Ferrari on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:50PM (#31115617)
> It's normal, you give people money and they worship you.

You earn yourself that money by successfully making a prediction. By the same token when you win a poker game in Vegas you don't worship Steve Wynn for providing you the casino and a table. You gave yourself that money.

> Think of the "cult" of Steve Jobs linked to Apple gains.

Apple stock gains came as the product was becoming ubiquitous among the populace, matter of fact it slightly trailed the virality of the product. Same goes for Google, Microsoft, Oracle, Facebook etc.

That is the normal financial trajectory of a company, which differs from a socio-religious movement such as crypto, TSLA, a political candidate etc. Those are all based on promises about the future and getting people galvanized without ever delivering any actual product improving people's quality of life on a scale comparable to the promises made.

> This is nothing new. It's also not a real cult, it's more as admiring successful entrepreneurs.

This is exactly what gets people burned when the socio-religious movement implodes and they fail to jettison themselves. Don't admire, limit yourself to gauge the level of admiration that other people have for the guy and try predicting if it will expand or contract. That's an indicator of the health of the socio-religious movement so that you know when to jettison yourself.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by outworlder on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:37PM (#31116032)
> Your TSLA gains are nothing compared to what many people in here made on Ethereum.

sigh

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by spoonjim on Friday April 22, 2022 @01:37AM (#31118540)
He is both an unhinged lunatic and the best tech CEO of all time and it’s not even close.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tsol on Saturday April 23, 2022 @08:42PM (#31140171)
This is closer to the truth, but it's weird how people are so passionate about either loving or hating him.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by Pyxl101 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:14PM (#31111400)
Can’t he borrow against his Tesla stock, and other assets including his ownership of SpaceX, and personal property, for cash to buy Twitter?

Depending on his banking relationships, and other assets that he can use as collateral for the loan, he might be able to borrow a fairly high percentage of the current value of those assets as cash (maybe 50 to 70 or 80% or more if the collateral assets are diversified or the bank simply has high confidence in his effective credit rating or ability to repay — and he may be doing other business with that bank incentivizing them to give him a favorable deal).

I’m not a billionaire but by establishing a strong relationship with a bank, have been able to establish a credit line with a limit that is a high percentage of my assets that are invested by the bank in a diversified portfolio, along with other assets, at a low interest rate (mortgage levels - a credit line at approx 2.5% interest of an amount almost equal to my total assets at the bank).

I also recently refinanced my house with this bank starting last winter and was able to achieve getting a 15 year fixed mortgage at a 2.125% interest rate - a huge reduction from my previous rate of 3.5% on a 30 year. I now pay less per month and will own my home much sooner, consequently paying considerably less in interest over the remainder of the loan, and building much more wealth in the process.

With some wealth and favorable banking relationships you can accomplish things that most ordinary people don’t know about and I myself didn’t know about until I started looking into the possibilities. I am sure a billionaire has access to even more options than I can conceive of.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hristov on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:20PM (#31112383)
He already did. And he got 12.5 billion and that was the maximum the banks were willing to lend him against his stock. He is still 21 billion short.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:20PM (#31113256)
I'm pretty sure that's not the maximum, just the amount he felt he needed to secure.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by weeblewobble on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:37PM (#31111695)
He could, but if TSLA goes down and he gets a margin call things could get ugly
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mise_en_place on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:32PM (#31112560)
It is risky but keep in mind the proposal in non-binding and contingent upon several other conditions.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mcintyre1994 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:56PM (#31111978)
Tesla has a rule limiting borrowing against its stock to 25% so that's probably his limiting factor.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by londons_explore on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:46PM (#31113628)
Does the rule apply to all shareholders? I don't really see how a publically traded company can put an arbitrary condition on what can be done like that - any borrowing can be a totally private deal between you and a bank (or another private individual) - Tesla isn't even privvy to such deals, so how can they enforce any rules about them?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by bombcar on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:45PM (#31114956)
Large shareholders have different rules and restrictions. For example, you can go buy TWTR all you want, but Musk had to report when he had obtained a certain percentage.

Remember that Musk is not only a shareholder of TSLA, but also an employee.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:22PM (#31113293)
Tesla is not the lender, Musk's broker is.

Therefore Tesla has zero input into margin rate broker decides to give Musk.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by colinmhayes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:44PM (#31114305)
No, Musk has an agreement with tesla that he can only borrow against a quarter of his shares. He's already borrowed against quite a few too. Musk could go to the board to get that number bumped up, but until then he can't just borrow the full $21 billion against his shares.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:15PM (#31111416)
> If he sells large amounts of tsla shares to buy twitter, this will be a negative signal

Not necessarily. It's conceivable that TSLA shareholders could interpret Elon Musk acquiring more political influence as good for TSLA. The question would be whether Musk can use control of twitter to actually influence politics in favor of his other companies. I don't know if that would actually work, but I think it's conceivable that many of those who own TSLA might believe it will work.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by NoOneNew on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:07PM (#31112144)
You know... I have a feeling you might be the most right in this discussion.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by FerociousTimes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:06PM (#31113881)
Is Musk known really for his shrewd political skills and sharp maneuvers?

If I were a Tesla shareholder and this was his actual masterplan to maximize value for shareholders, I'd unload my stake in a heartbeat because I know his brand and business holdings will got tainted by his politics like what happened with Trump, and the plan will most likely backfire and decimate his business empire.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by AlchemistCamp on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:54PM (#31115055)
> Is Musk known really for his shrewd political skills and sharp maneuvers?

He should be. Solidly Republican-leaning Texans are buying and driving electric vehicles, in some cases believing that doing so is "owning the libs".

Tesla seemed like an impossible long shot 15 years ago, not just for the considerable technical and business challenges but also because most Americans were happily buying gas-gusslers and even fantastic hybrids like the Prius were still somewhat niche. At the time, not a single major car company was willing to invest seriously in building electric vehicles.

Now there's gigafactory right outside Austin. It's something I did not think would have been possible. Tesla has threaded a nearly impossible needle to get to where it is in 2022.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by sangnoir on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:41PM (#31116073)
> He should be. Solidly Republican-leaning Texans are buying and driving electric vehicles, in some cases believing that doing so is "owning the libs".

Could this attempt at buying Twitter be part of the same vice-signalling[1] schtick, then?

1. As in "See how I hate the same things you do?"

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by FerociousTimes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:40PM (#31115529)
All these examples are business bets and not political ones. Don't get me wrong, they're astoundingly impressive but of the wrong type.

I don't dispute that he's a shrewd businessman and fancy visionary but when it comes to the world of politics, I have my doubts and reservations.

I'd like to see action and results first before I can vouch for him in that field.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by TapWaterBandit on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:34PM (#31116011)
> I don't dispute that he's a shrewd businessman and fancy visionary but when it comes to the world of politics, I have my doubts and reservations.

In this day and age you don't become a billionaire without being good at politics. Navigating the regulatory state is an enormous task even when you don't have people laser-focused on you like Musk would due to his wealth and size of his companies.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mehrdada on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:30PM (#31114144)
> If I were a Tesla shareholder and this was his actual masterplan to maximize value for shareholders

Doesn’t have to be either-or. Marketing strategy is an important part of running Tesla and given the empirical dislike of media establishment of him, ensuring Twitter won’t go against him on a whim of the board seems strategically important.

> business holdings will got tainted by his politics like what happened with Trump

Is there data on Trump businesses doing materially worse overall after the taint? I assume the half of US that like him bolster it and the other half see the taint but the vector sum is material here.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by matthewdgreen on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:42PM (#31114284)
Alternatively he stops being the whimsical "fun" billionaire that people find amusing, and starts being the tyrannical billionaire that people hate. This results in political backlash and a massive boycott of Tesla's consumer products.

To be clear: Elon buying Twitter doesn't necessarily trigger any of this. Elon using that influence to actually push Twitter around in ways that are "useful" to Tesla shareholders potentially does. For Tesla shareholders I'd say the risk here is much higher than any possible reward.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mehrdada on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:52PM (#31114409)
> massive boycott of Tesla's consumer products.

I mean we could speculate at length but the condition you’re describing already exists. People have polar reactions to him. Some hate with a passion, some love him. As for boycott, I’m not surprised if a lot of people already feel like they won’t buy a Tesla. Hard to imagine it can get worse from here.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:31PM (#31114789)
> Hard to imagine it can get worse from here.

He could get indicted for the FSD scamming and bring the whole thing tumbling down. If he stuck to just selling battery powered cars I'd be a lot more bullish on TSLA, but he hasn't and I think his antics represent a serious threat to the company in the long run.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by TapWaterBandit on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:37PM (#31116033)
I think the opposite. Getting it right once is hard enough but the fact Musk has been a core figure involved in the development of:

- Paypal - Tesla - SpaceX

Tells me that his success isn't a fluke. You might get lucky with one of those companies, but with three? Don't think so.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by HWR_14 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @07:14PM (#31116340)
> . Hard to imagine it can get worse from here.

I imagine a lot of "save the earth" and "Let's go to Mars" people overlap with the "Fuck Donald Trump" people. So letting Trump back on Twitter may cause them to swear off Teslas and DogeCoin. Alternatively, not letting Trump back may cause a bunch of truck-driving Texans he's been targeting to convert to electric to tell him to fuck off.

Bottom line, it puts Musk in the unenviable position of having to piss off a third of the country by deciding if Trump has a Twitter account. And while I would still swap with him in a second, this is an additional burden he's putting on himself.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by smaudet on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:55PM (#31118021)
See this is precisely why I am bearish of Elon's companies, he's a savvy businessman, not a technologist, precisely why my opinion is that he is an idiot not a savant - PayPal is known for having been a flaming dumpster fire, it succeeded because of early market penetration (banks unable and unwilling to produce online payments systems in lieu of pushing credit cards). Ironically it is most useful now in traditional payment systems online, there are now reasonable more up to date payment systems available which largely supersede PayPal.

Again, Tesla is known for creating more hype fewer cars, expensive messes and underdelivering on promises - he has stimulated the market into considering alternative fuel sources, which is good but in a lot of ways showmanship not vision, more top down execution and spectacle than forethought or planning.

SpaceX is the most evident of these, Musk is busy taking tax dollars and building efficient rockets, which I guess is good but not about getting us to Mars.

So I think you are right to call out pandering for sales, it's what musk does best, not tech or vision.

It's like calling flappy bird visionary - popular yes but preceded by hundreds of sidescroller helicopter games with a single button controlling altitude. Difference being Flappy broke in on a verdant mobile market while the two color LCD version I played 25 years ago on a flipphone didn't even have Facebook to get popular on, while Flash versions of the same thing that had been out for decades suffered from anti Flash sentiment and a smaller mindshare.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:47PM (#31114339)
> For Tesla shareholders I'd say the risk here is much higher than any possible reward.

I think that's probably right. But do those Tesla shareholders believe it?

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by FerociousTimes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:52PM (#31114400)
> ensuring Twitter won’t go against him on a whim of the board

Can you tell me please what you mean by this?

AFAIK, Twitter is decentralized and fragmented for any actor to orchestrate an all-out political witch hunt where everyone on the platform goes against anyone in particular.

As far as Trump's business holdings go, Trump Organization runs like a brand management firm where they license and operate businesses with Trump name plastered on them, and I believe it's safe to say that the brand name's risk profile increased greatly due to the association with Trumpism from 2015 onward.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mehrdada on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:56PM (#31114451)
> Can you tell me please what you mean by this?

Twitter can find an excuse to ban his account (you can easily imagine this sort of risk exists after some of his recent meme tweets for example). I believe that is a single point of failure in Tesla PR strategy and a risk to be mitigated.

> brand name's risk profile increased

Risk profile sure but has the net value decreased or increased due to his presidency? I don’t have data to say it’s one way or another but looking at the downside without the upside as well is futile.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hackerfromthefu on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:31PM (#31115979)
Well .. not really. Not at all. How could you even think it matters?

Musk could simply setup muskannouncements.com and blog his own tweets. No one may search for your announcements, but you better believe for his site he will still get full coverage.

ergo he's not doing it for his own announcements. it will be for a mix of media influence, and to address the bias in twitters 'fact checking'

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by smaudet on Friday April 22, 2022 @12:10AM (#31118105)
> ergo he's not doing it for his own announcements.

I do agree he is doing things for reasons besides his own announcements, but I cannot agree that it's not part of it. Some people may simply not care enough about EVs to bother, as technologists we assume people see the world through our lens but I bet you many people have barely bothered to research his cars, they only know Tesla in a cursory fashion the same way you might know Nissan or Kia, or even computers (people exist who struggle to use anything more complex than a power button, these can be intelligent well read people even).

If you do use Twitter say, to follow XYZ (not even certain this is correct, I don't and struggle to use Twitter although I have a general idea how it works), if they see some promoted or retweet involving a Tesla, they are likely to learn more or investigate further. Owning this would be a non insignificant marketing advantage.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mehrdada on Friday April 22, 2022 @02:38AM (#31118905)
This is patently ridiculous—it's like saying since everyone can post on their own blog, why would anyone publish an OpEd in NYTimes? Obviously reach and distribution of the medium is fundamental. How would you notify 80 million people that muskannouncements.com posted a new entry?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tekknik on Friday April 22, 2022 @09:04AM (#31121100)
> How would you notify 80 million people that muskannouncements.com posted a new entry?

an app with push notifications. email. sms.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hackerfromthefu on Sunday April 24, 2022 @05:21PM (#31148462)
You've missed the point here - it's not that EVERYONE can post on their own blog.

But Elon Musk is unique, HE would still get full coverage. Journalists and influencers and the fanboys and outrage crowd would post his stuff to twitter for him lol.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:34PM (#31114197)
> Is Musk known really for his shrewd political skills and sharp maneuvers?

The question should be whether TSLA shareholders think he is, and I think most of them probably do.

(I don't own any TSLA, btw. But from what I've seen, many of his fanboys love him for being conniving while simultaneously claiming he's done nothing wrong. I believe this is an example of double-think. But the subject of this discussion is how these people might react to Elon Musk controlling Twitter, not whether their allegiance to Elon Musk is rational and rhetorically consistent.)

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by FerociousTimes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:04PM (#31114544)
Is really the makeup of TSLA shareholders a bunch of WallStreetBets dummies?

I really doubt that this is the case. I know that there's some real retail investor interest in the stock price movement and for a minority the fundamentals, but I'm sure there's some institutional investors and smart money who are in it for the long run and who analyze the company's financial statements, and evaluate and scrutinize the founder's every move and decision and this Dr. Evil's scheme of taking over Twitter and turn the platform as a tool of propaganda for Musk's financial interests and self-aggrandizement looks very concerning to put it mildly.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mehrdada on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:07PM (#31114585)
> tool of propaganda for Musk's financial interests and self-aggrandizement looks very very concerning to put it mildly

How is it any different than Bezos buying WaPo, in principle? That does not seem to have been detrimental to Amazon shareholders. And how does having a propaganda arm detrimental to Tesla financial interests? Marketing is a euphemism for propaganda after all.

(I can see legitimate Tesla shareholder concern for Musk attention being spread too thin, but to claim having Twitter makes things worse beyond his existing presence as a user seems ridiculous.)

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by notahacker on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:00PM (#31115113)
Bezos bought WaPo for what is (to him) a relatively small sum of money to be a hands off owner of something he thought should continue to exist and has potential for Amazon style economising. That's a bit different to Musk proposing to offload or borrow against a significant chunk of his TSLA shares whilst declaring winning an argument with the management of his favourite social media platform about rewriting Twitter's policies on controversial stuff is more important to him than making money. And yes, Musk's record of posting Tweets unhelpful to TSLA as a user is another reason for them to be alarmed at controversy on Twitter becoming increasingly important to him.

It's not just the inevitability of less time to focus on managing TSLA (though running Twitter being a full time job was an issue for Dorsey, and he was only running one other company and wasn't at war with the management) but also the hints that this is an obsession.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by FerociousTimes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:19PM (#31114686)
Correct me if I'm wrong, I have not seen WaPo pushing Amazon propaganda in their content.

I'd like to take this occasion to remind you that my first comment was a rebuttal to someone's argument speculating about the motive or rationale behind this acquisition and posited that Musk's control of the platform would afford him political influence to further his own financial interests, hence my opening reply.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:27PM (#31114747)
> posited that Musk's control of the platform would afford him political influence to further his own financial interests,

Clarification: Positing that many TSLA shareholders presently believe Musk's control of twitter would afford him political influence to further his financial interests.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by FerociousTimes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:08PM (#31115213)
Well, I stand corrected then if that was your initial intent but the delusion with these folks is really strong to come up with such ridiculous scenarios to justify their unquestionable attachment to that online persona.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:09PM (#31114605)
One thing I feel relatively sure of is that present TSLA shareholders are the sort of people who, up until the present, see fit to own TSLA shares. This despite everything that is already publicly known or said about Elon Musk.

If I keep myself in my personal mindset of a Musk skeptic and try to model the behavior of TSLA shareholders, I would anticipate TSLA shareholders selling immediately (today, and every day previously in the past several years), because that is what I would do if I were gifted TSLA. But that's obviously not what TSLA shareholders do, so my personal mindset evidently makes for an inadequate model of TSLA shareholders.

If instead I try to suspend my own beliefs and imagine myself as somebody who thinks owning and holding TSLA is a good idea, then my new assumed mindset says that Elon Musk getting more power, by hook or by crook, is a good thing for me.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by 111111101101 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:20PM (#31112375)
> It's conceivable that TSLA shareholders could interpret Elon Musk acquiring more political influence as good for TSLA

For that they would have to see through Musk's grift. Most retail TSLA holders are Musketeers and they truly believe that he is a visionary genius. To them, fluff like Twitter doesn't matter when they have the real life Tony Stark at the helm.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:30PM (#31112529)
Believing Musk is a visionary genius scarcely seems inconsistent with believing Musk owning Twitter will be advantageous for Musk companies.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by 111111101101 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:38PM (#31112650)
Genius doesn't need publicity. Its influence is inevitable.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by MegaButts on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:55PM (#31112900)
I bet for every genius that becomes publicly known, there are at least 10 who are never heard publicly.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:49PM (#31112818)
It doesn't seem very genius to fight with one hand tied behind your back just because you can.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by wutbrodo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:12PM (#31115806)
> any other tesla shareholder can sell tesla shares to buy twitter, and why wouldn't they when the tesla CEO is doing it.

Because they wouldn't be taking control over the company... That's the purpose of those whole situation. Musk isn't just making a play on the basis of thinking "one dollar of TWTR is worth more than one share of TSLA"

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by dgfitz on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:11PM (#31111351)
I don’t think it’s possible for him to quietly sell 21B shares. That’s all very public information isn’t it?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hristov on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:19PM (#31112360)
It is possible. He has to file certain forms when he sells but the SEC often lets large buyers and sellers have a bit of a delay when making these forms public to avoid front running.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by trappist on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:50PM (#31112821)
> Also those sales were pretty much required for taxes

His reason - or at least his public justification - for that sale was to deliberately generate a tax liability. If you recall people were getting pretty bent about him not having such a thing, as a zillionaire.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tonfa on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:44PM (#31114314)
Yeah that's the story telling but not the reality, most of the sales were to cover taxes due on option exercise (had to do it in 2021 to avoid a tax regime change that was starting in 2022).
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tekknik on Friday April 22, 2022 @09:13AM (#31121172)
> If you recall people were getting pretty bent about him not having such a thing, as a zillionaire.

Some people, a minority, from a particular political bend. the overwhelming majority of americans don’t consider his finances at all

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by philwelch on Friday April 22, 2022 @02:37AM (#31118898)
“Any other Tesla shareholder” is less capable of successfully executing a hostile takeover of Twitter, which is why they wouldn’t and Elon would.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by godelski on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:06PM (#31114573)
Typically these sales are scheduled and announced well ahead of time and then, like another user pointed out, may be solve over the course of months. So the market typically reacts near the announcement and it isn't much because it looks like business as usual. From the article you linked it specifically says that he was exercising options that would have expired. IIRC he also has another large stock allocation that expire in August of this year and so will be selling those.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by nemothekid on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:29PM (#31114772)
There is no reason why he can't do the same here.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by godelski on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:38PM (#31114877)
I agree. But what I'm saying is that it will take a few months to execute. I was just trying to expand on the above discussion and why his sales didn't make Tesla stock crash but selling out of the blue would.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hawk_ on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:02PM (#31111252)
because selling another $21b of tesla would indicate he has found other more interesting things to do.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:24PM (#31113320)
Or, following Ockham's Razor, it would indicate he needs money to do something with it.

Maybe buy $600 million yacht or maybe buy money losing company.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rcMgD2BwE72F on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:24PM (#31112453)
He bought ~9% of Twitter already. I'm sure his co-shareholders prefer that he takes control over companies he bought in, because he can then easily develop synergies (cf. Boring Co and Tesla, SpaceX and Tesla, SolarCity and Tesla, etc).
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by gopher_space on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:21PM (#31115892)
The problem with this idea is that nobody's really on Twitter for the free speech. He might take the company to new and exciting places, but it won't be with the current userbase.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by _fat_santa on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:23PM (#31111505)
This raises another issue, that is can he even sell that many shares of Tesla and still stay in control?

IIRC he made a comment about how he was "cash poor" a while back and it basically came down to he can't sell more of Tesla/SpaceX without dipping below 51% and loosing control.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rootusrootus on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:49PM (#31112810)
> cash poor

I wonder what a paper billionaire's definition of 'cash poor' is compared to mine.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by RansomStark on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:09PM (#31113918)
Grimes gave an interview on this:

"[Musk] lives at times below the poverty line," Grimes said, per Vanity Fair. "To the point where I was like, can we not live in a very insecure $40,000 house? Where the neighbors, like, film us, and there's no security, and I'm eating peanut butter for eight days in a row?" [0]

In the same article Grimes complains Musk wouldn't replace a broken mattress.

No idea how Much this shows Musk is cash poor, and how much it shows crazy rich person, but it gives a glimpse either way

[0] https://www.businessinsider.com/grimes-says-elon-musk-someti...

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mywittyname on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:29PM (#31114137)
This sounds like Musk being a "eccentric" person.

I have a difficult time believing Telsa couldn't put him up in executive housing and cover a security detail. Or, he couldn't send out a tweet and get a $50 million line of credit, uncallable line of credit to live on. Especially given that he can at get 13 billion dollars to acquire another company.

I think he likes bragging about being a homeless couch surfer.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by colinmhayes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:33PM (#31114810)
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kurupt213 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:28PM (#31114132)
‘In the same article Grimes complains Musk wouldn't replace a broken mattress.’

That’s just a humble brag.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by Teandw on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:39PM (#31114243)
He's billionaire cash poor which is a lot different to our cash poor.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by colinmhayes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:46PM (#31114332)
Musk only controls 17% of tesla votes, he's already out of control.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hristov on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @03:40PM (#31172205)
Well if you needed further proof, look at the Tesla price action today. It is doubtful that Musk has even started selling, but the price is already collapsing.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by layer8 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:11PM (#31111354)
He’d have no trouble borrowing money against his assets though. As far as I know, that’s what most billionaires do.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kingbirdy on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:29PM (#31111589)
There are limits to how much he can borrow against his assets, both due to banking risk models and Tesla bylaws. He's too close to those limits already to borrow another $20B.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rcMgD2BwE72F on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:27PM (#31112482)
>He's too close to those limits already to borrow another $20B.

What are the limits and where is he now? Please tell us.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by TrapLord_Rhodo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:45PM (#31116949)
You have no idea how much money he has, how much connections he has, how many VC's, bankers, nationstates are willing to put money behind him. you hve no idea how much Eth, BTC and DOGE he has. He's up at least %14,000 on Doge from when he started tweeting about it.

You have no idea how rich this man is, people need to stop acting like they do.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rcMgD2BwE72F on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:02PM (#31169149)
How wrong you were. https://www.reuters.com/business/musk-tears-up-buyout-playbo...

"Musk himself has committed to put up $33.5 billion, which will include $21 billion of equity and $12.5 billion of margin loans against some of his Tesla Inc (TSLA.O) shares to finance the transaction"

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by FiberBundle on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:26PM (#31111541)
Even billionaires don't just borrow $21 billion.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mise_en_place on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:36PM (#31112624)
He just borrowed $25.5 billion[0]. So your assertion is false. The issue is coming up with $21 billion worth of equity which is contingent upon TSLA stock price.

>[0]https://twitter.com/exec_sum/status/1517137710699458560?s=21...

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:48PM (#31111862)
'Just' is doing a lot of work in this assertion.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by dlivingston on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:31PM (#31112542)
> So no, once again he does not have funding secured

For the reader’s consideration: Musk’s TED interview [0], he claims (quite forcefully) that he did in fact have funding secured, but effectively “pled not secured” as to get a more favorable response from the SEC.

[0]: (time stamp: 0h27m00s) https://youtu.be/cdZZpaB2kDM

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by dtparr on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:52PM (#31112863)
Because he keeps going around saying that in public, there was a recent request for a restraining order to stop him from repeating it since it poisons the jury pool. It quoted the US District Court's ruling from 1 April of this year[0]:

"the evidentiary record demonstrated that no reasonable jury could find Musk’s tweets on August 7, 2018 accurate or not misleading. Likewise, given that Musk was intimately involved with the facts leading to that conclusion, the Court also held that he recklessly made the statements with knowledge as to their falsity"

Which is to say, a federal judge has ruled that it was inaccurate, and he knows it was inaccurate.

[0] - https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.33...

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:28PM (#31113378)
Actually, the judge just denied plaintiffs motion saying it's too broad.

First Amendment strikes again!

https://www.cnet.com/news/politics/elon-musk-doesnt-have-to-...

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by dtparr on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:52PM (#31113692)
Right, he denied the TRO, but that doesn't change the prior ruling regarding the accuracy of the tweet. Also "accuracy of the tweet" is a horrible thing to have to be debating in a court of law.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:39PM (#31114238)
> Also "accuracy of the tweet" is a horrible thing to have to be debating in a court of law.

I agree. The lawsuit is laughable and should be thrown out of the court.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by colinmhayes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:49PM (#31114372)
He also claimed FSD will be better than humans within a year in that interview. I'm not buying it.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by bombcar on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:48PM (#31114986)
To be fair to Musk, humans are pretty @#$%@#$ bad.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by outworlder on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:40PM (#31116066)
Better than the best human driver, or better than your average driver? If it's the latter, it's probably there.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by macksd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:14PM (#31111389)
As someone who doesn't really know what they're talking about, I'm also wondering how he would be getting around the widely-reported "poison pill", even if he did have $21B more.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jhugo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:25PM (#31111522)
By asking the board to remove it. If faced with a serious tender offer backed by financing and accepted by a majority of shareholders, the board would find it difficult not to allow it to go ahead (by removing the poison pill).

That doesn't mean they couldn't refuse to remove it, but since they should act in the interests of the shareholders, they would need a good explanation (e.g. another better offer, or a plausible plan for extracting more value from Twitter than they currently do).

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by xg15 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:29PM (#31112512)
So, total noob here in that whole area, but I have a question about fiduciary duty.

The popular understanding seems to be that a companies' board is legally bound to act in the best (financial) interests of the shareholders - and only those. This is why hostile takeovers are a thing at all: If the acquiring company gets the majority of the target's shareholders on board (or becomes the majority), then the target's board of directors is legally bound to accept the takeover, even if it would be harmful to the company (nevermind the company's employees or customers)

How far does this go? If I'm a shareholder of McDonald's, could I sue them because they could have increased profits by lacing their burgers with cocaine but chose not to? (Or say some synthetic drug that's technically legal because it hasn't been banned yet).

If a company could make more profit but is kept from it by some regulation, could I sue them if they didn't try to lobby against that regulation?

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rurp on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:00PM (#31112968)
My understanding is that courts and regulators give board members a lot of deference on their decisions, as long as they are well considered and not obviously ridiculous.

It's perfectly fine for a board to say that the legal and reputational risks far outweigh the benefits of lacing burgers with cocaine.

Most decisions, such as lobbying, involve complicated calculous and don't have a simple way to verify the ROI. The board can defend most positions (from no lobbying to lots of lobbying) by arguing that they believe it's the right decision based on their experience, judgement, and analysis of the situation; probably with some written analysis defending whatever their decision was at the time.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rsstack on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:48PM (#31114984)
They don't have to make the best decision to advance the interests of the shareholders. It is impossible to know if an option that wasn't taken would have been better. They're require to act in a reasonable way that fits market norms and the data they had at the time. The decision of whether to accept Musk's proposal, regardless of how much he claims it to be the "best thing to do", is very subjective and complex. As long as they don't rely on immaterial facts (such as their dislike of Musk), it's impossible to prove that they made the wrong decision because we can't A/B test reality. They might still believe that Twitter can be worth $60B in a year and if they have enough data to support that, they can do whatever they think is right.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jhugo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:11PM (#31113148)
Could you sue them? Sure. Would you win? Probably not.

The board would likely make a compelling case that the long-term effect of lacing burgers with cocaine is a net loss for shareholders given the inevitable reputational harm, lawsuits, payouts, etc.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by macksd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:20PM (#31113253)
One key thing to know here, in addition to the replies you already received, is that the role of fiduciary duty is dramatically overstated by a lot of other HN comments.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jaywalk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:36PM (#31111688)
The poison pill is there so he can't do it without approval of the board. If he comes in with a serious offer that the board decides is worthwhile, they can remove it just as easily as they added it.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by swores on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:26PM (#31111537)
By persuading the board, either directly or by turning shareholder opinion strongly enough, for them to put it to a shareholder vote.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by skeeter2020 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:07PM (#31112143)
Forgive my ignorance, but rich people routinely get access to cash secured with their assets though, so why can't he do that, pledging his huge equity ownership?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by zdragnar on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:13PM (#31112257)
It is still borrowed, which means still needs paying back. If you don't care about the stocks (i.e. they are only an investment vehicle) this is fine.

Musk controls Tesla by way of owning more than 50% of its stock. He'd be trading Tesla for Twitter, which I think anyone would agree is a terrible trade.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by giobox on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:36PM (#31112629)
What? He's the single largest shareholder, but even recently its approx 17 percent of Tesla he owns. Musk hasn't owned more than 50% of the stock anytime Tesla has been a public company.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by HWR_14 on Friday April 22, 2022 @02:18AM (#31118787)
Which is about the same percentage of AMZN that Bezos owner pre-divorce. Interesting.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by exdsq on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:16PM (#31111429)
He can just borrow the money. He’s the worlds richest man - he can borrow < 10% of his net worth against his Tesla stocks if he wanted to.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by colinmhayes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:52PM (#31114402)
The funding already includes a $12.5 billion loan against his tesla shares. He is limited by tesla by laws and banker risk aversion to how much loans he can take out against his shares. I would speculate that the $21 billion in his equity is there because he couldn't get more loans.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by snowwrestler on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:44PM (#31114944)
And I believe he has already pledged other Tesla shares to secure previous loans.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hristov on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:25PM (#31114090)
Sorry to respond to my own post, but after writing it I ran across and article in Bloomberg that basically confirms what I am saying. Apparently Musk is looking for equity partners to provide the 21 billion equity part of twitter's bid.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-21/musk-is-s...

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hkdobrev on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:07PM (#31115187)
The SEC filing shows there's now a commitment to provide that equity investment. Elon Musk has formed a Delaware corporation which investors could invest into to provide the money behind the "Equity Financing". The article does not confirm your point and your top comment is misleading.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by NationalPark on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:13PM (#31111384)
I wonder how Tesla shareholders feel about this situation. It seems like by leveraging with his Tesla shares, he's passing on the risk to everyone who owns Tesla stock. If they have a couple bad quarters or some kind of macro change happens and the price starts going down, Musk gets margin called and has to dump his stock on the market, which could start a spiral of panic-selling or even open Tesla itself to being corporate-raided.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:37PM (#31113494)
As a shareholder, Musk multiplied my money by 20x

Even though I'm obviously so much smarter than him on matter of acquiring public companies, I'll graciously allow him to do whatever he pleases as long as he continues growing Tesla at 50% compounded rate.

Which he did this quarter, and the one before that and the one before that.

I'll be concerned when that stops happening. Until then I give him my blessing to do whatever he pleases with HIS money.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by coldcode on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:16PM (#31113988)
And how can Tesla keep growing at a 50% rate, buy out all the other car companies in the world? There is a limit as to how many people can afford to buy $60k+ cars. The stock is already far beyond what the company profits will ever be worth. Today it seems like no one cares about profits, but will that always be the case?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by zarzavat on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:57PM (#31115689)
Tesla is not about cars. It’s a marketing company and its product is the Tesla share price. This Twitter stunt is just one in a long line of stunts that Musk does to get attention for himself. People invest in Tesla because they want to invest in Musk as an individual.

This media hijacking is similar to the way that Trump got elected in 2016.

I bet that if SpaceX ever went public it would cause Tesla to fall as everybody who wants to invest in “Musk is a genius” would invest in SpaceX instead of Tesla.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by johnamata on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:44PM (#31117955)
Agreed. Also in other countries like mine where EV cars and the climate change issue and environmentalism movement that's being pedalled by the western media arent a thing, mostly Asian countries, Tesla here is more synonymous to batteries and sustainable energy. We've got a presidential election next month and some of the presidentiables, including the one who's most likely to win according to polls, are calling for more Tesla energy adoption for the country during their campaign. Musk diversified his company's products well
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tekknik on Friday April 22, 2022 @09:27AM (#31121291)
> This media hijacking is similar to the way that Trump got elected in 2016.

Please elaborate.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by NationalPark on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:48PM (#31113652)
Well yeah, of course you would be concerned if that stopped happening, even more so if it means the CEO is suddenly compelled sell a bunch of his stock at a discount to avoid violating his debt covenants. You don’t get any upside from the twitter deal, so unless you think Musk will use Twitter to boost Tesla’s price (suppressing bad news?), it seems like all downside for current Tesla owners.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:46PM (#31114325)
Like I said, I'm a very benevolent person.

Trust me, I'll unleash my wrath on Musk the moment his actions cause my net worth go down due to TSLA stock going down.

But in my infinite compassion for lesser human beings, I allow Musk to continue doing things that are not 100% related to increasing TSLA stock price.

He has my blessing to purchase Twitter, if that makes him happy.

Don't get me wrong, there are limits to everything. Recently he asked if he can have a 9-th child and I said "absolutely no".

Another child would distract him from running a company and I, as a shareholder, absolutely cannot have it.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tekknik on Friday April 22, 2022 @09:29AM (#31121316)
Read your post again. You talk like you have more money than Musk, which maybe you do but I doubt. You also have a huge ego. I know, I know “when I go look at my bank account I stop caring…”
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:41PM (#31114278)
> so unless you think Musk will use Twitter to boost Tesla’s price (suppressing bad news?)

Or bullying American politicians. Or simply preventing himself from being banned.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by AndrewUnmuted on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:52PM (#31115031)
The USA's politicians can stand to be bullied a lot more than they currently are. Many of them got to where they are now by being bullies themselves - Twitter bullies in particular!

They say the United States Congress is really just Hollywood for ugly people. In a sense, social media is really just Hollywood for smart people. Given Elon Musk's circumstances, and no matter what his motivations, they seem to be the correct ones to maximize his possible outcomes.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by robonerd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:02PM (#31115138)
I certainly understand the schadenfreude aspect of it. But when I said bullying I mostly meant that as a euphemism for a sort of aggressive lobbying. For instance, manipulating politicians into supporting his companies by threatening to signal boost their opponents during the next election, or promising to suppress them.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by bfz on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:55AM (#31111134)
I may be mistaken, but I believe he can achieve $21bn in short exposure to Tesla through swaps and never have to report the "sale" publicly
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kgwgk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:05PM (#31112110)
If he needs $21bn in cash, how does $21bn in short exposure to Tesla through swaps help?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by bcrl on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:54AM (#31111122)
Or he'll trade TSLA shares for TWTR. I can imagine that some investors in TWTR would be happy to take him up on such an offer.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by blake1 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:21PM (#31112387)
Not in this case: this is a tender offer, and what you're describing is a merger. Which might actually make sense, but it would be something that goes through the TSLA board, and can't be done unilaterally by Musk.

Of course, he must be supremely influential with the board, but there is a governance structure that can't just be bypassed.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by weeblewobble on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:38PM (#31111713)
If TWTR holders want to trade for TSLA they can simply do it on the open market
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by motoxpro on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:54PM (#31111950)
When you see "Acquired for 50% cash and 50% stock" this is a company "trading" x shares for y shares. So yeah this happens all the time not in the open market.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jay00 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:56PM (#31111984)
Not for the premium he's offering to take it private.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by HWR_14 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:58PM (#31112008)
This is true. But if he was talking about trading shares of SpaceX for TWTR I would probably rearrange my holdings.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by csense on Friday April 22, 2022 @12:31AM (#31118234)
Some quick searching says TSLA is about $1000 and Elon owns 178M Tesla shares.

Assuming Elon owns all those shares free and clear, aren't there plenty of investment banks that would eagerly loan Elon the $21B if Elon pledges ~63M of those shares as collateral? (I got the 63M number from assuming the lender requires collateral value equal to 3x the loan to protect against price drops.)

Then presumably Elon would sell 21M TSLA over the next year or three to pay off the loan and get the other 42M of collateral out of hock, but sell slowly enough not to crash the price of TSLA.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by anon_12012020 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:10PM (#31112197)
Funding is secured via multiple strategies that best fits the case. How can you possibly think he does not have funding secured, when in fact he has more options than anyone private citizen in the world right now?

Ludicrous

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by JumpCrisscross on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:14PM (#31112289)
> How can you possibly think he does not have funding secured, when in fact he has more options than anyone private citizen in the world right now?

He’s already margined a lot of his Tesla shares. The rest is largely illiquid. Tesla shares are expensive to margin, especially for $10bn; we’re seeing an unusually-large consortium of banks assemble to provide that tranche of financing. That implies having to sell large, market-moving stakes in, all likelihood, Tesla and/or SpaceX. Something feasible, but unlikely pleasant for Musk or other shareholders in those names.

Also, Musk is someone who said “funding secured” without funding secured in 2018.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jefftk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:17PM (#31112321)
> Musk is someone who said “funding secured” without funding secured in 2018.

Yes, though that was a Tweet and not an SEC filing

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by JumpCrisscross on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:24PM (#31112448)
> that was a Tweet and not an SEC filing

Most people, at this point, believe he has funding. When he first tweeted his bid, however, the stock dropped.

He still has to come up with $21bn. He’s tapped out on margin loans, so that will involve some selling of assets. And market conditions are volatile enough for those funding commitments to fall through.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by bombcar on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:52PM (#31115035)
Some portion of that remainder can come from TWTR shareholders who are willing to go private.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by HWR_14 on Friday April 22, 2022 @02:23AM (#31118821)
How would that work. They'd loan Elon money? As a private company, Twitter would only be allowed to have 999 shareholders.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by TuringNYC on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:22PM (#31111493)
>If he tries to sell 21 billion dollars worth of tesla shares, the share price will collapse.

He can execute an equity stock swap agreement with an investment bank and not unload any shares.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by titzer on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:36PM (#31112630)
> If he tries to sell 21 billion dollars worth of tesla shares, the share price will collapse.

Stock swap agreements are a thing. He doesn't have to outright sell them on the open market to get cash. Even if he did, it's not like the price is going to crater because he's losing confidence in TSLA or something.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kgwgk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:43PM (#31112727)
According to wikipedia:

  An equity swap is a financial derivative contract (a swap) where a set of future cash flows are agreed to be exchanged between two counterparties at set dates in the future.
That kind of arrangement doesn't get you cash today, does it?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by titzer on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:47PM (#31112773)
That was not what I was referring to.

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/stock-swap.asp

While this case wouldn't be TSLA acquiring Twitter, stocks are fungible assets that can be traded as part of an agreement.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kgwgk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:21PM (#31113275)
Oh, I misundertood.

I thought that when you said that "he doesn't have to outright sell them on the open market to get cash" you were referring to an alternative way of getting cash - not to an alternative form of payment.

I'm not even sure that it would be really feasible, in any case it would surely be very unusual.

As that link says, the way it goes normally is: "A stock swap occurs when shareholders' ownership of the target company's shares is exchanged for shares of the acquiring company." But here people would not be getting shares of the acquiring company, they would be getting shares of an unrelated company. There is no reason why they would want to keep those shares, so they would quickly flood the market.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by outworlder on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:42PM (#31116079)
Unless a contract specifies that they cannot do that for a certain period of time.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by rockinghigh on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:05PM (#31111293)
> If he tries to sell 21 billion dollars worth of tesla shares, the share price will collapse.

Elon Musk is routinely selling billions of dollars: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/TSLA/insider-transactions?p=...

* $1,007,908,791 on Dec 28, 2021

* $333,647,031 on Dec 22, 2021

* $594,924,622 on Dec 22, 2021

* $325,723,600 on Dec 21, 2021

* $528,016,861 on Dec 21, 2021

* $738,683,277 on Dec 13, 2021

As long as the trade is small compared to the daily volume, the market impact is limited.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by recursivequine on Friday April 22, 2022 @06:44PM (#31129144)
You clearly don't know what you're talking about. A holding company is responsible for the 21 billion. Elon happens to have created & owned that holding company. It's a perfect vehicle for him to allow private investors
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by michelb on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:58PM (#31112019)
Isn’t Musk set to receive a 23 billion dollar bonus for performance?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by winternett on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:38PM (#31114875)
For far less than $21 billion of investment I, or many other people, could redevelop and scale an entirely new social platform that would outpace Twitter, and I could probably do it multiple times over until it succeeds... The goal seems rather "Captain Ahab-ish" in nature...

I think the story is quickly turning into more of a hype effort than actual advancement.

Twitter would still need time and labor to be re-worked, which in itself is a massive undertaking. It looks like Twitter has multiple problems in scaling beyond it's current state, and that's why it has only made gradual changes over time for many years.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by anonygler on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:10PM (#31113935)
You can absolutely take out low interest loans using your stock as collateral. That's how the wealthy pay for many things.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:56PM (#31114461)
It's how they scrape by on a $1 salary so they can engineer themselves into a lower tax bracket.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by AndrewUnmuted on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:56PM (#31115075)
This is pretty misleading. Don't you think the government's forcing "income" to be defined as w2 salary has a lot to do with why this happens, and is therefore an important qualifier? They literally invented a new industry by arbitrarily restricting terminology. Those loans would never exist if we did not pray on individual earners to "fund" the government's "services."
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by elisharobinson on Friday April 22, 2022 @03:07AM (#31119073)
once again HN demonstrates how much it does not know anything . he does not need to own 100% , 51% is well and good. musk + jack + ark invest + JPM already have 25% they need to get the other 26% which should be very achievable with tesla stock . All SEC fillings aside this is pretty much a done deal .
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by polishdude20 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:50PM (#31117986)
This brings about an interesting question. If I've got $1000 in cash, that's valuable because I have it now and I can spend it now without many strings. When we talk about billionaires we look at the 21 billion musk has in Tesla and just extrapolate that $1000 in the pocket but to $21 billion in elons pocket. But in reality, he doesn't REALLY have 21 billion because he can't actually spend it all.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by nojito on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:52AM (#31111087)
Why does he have to sell a single share?

He routinely takes out loans against his shares to disturbingly high levels.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hristov on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:58AM (#31111195)
He is trying to take out a loan here as well. One of the letters included in the story is actually a margin loan commitment from morgan stanley. But that was for only 12.5 billion. This was all he could get against his shares.

It does seem low in comparison with the value of his shares, but banks are well aware of the self reinforcing negative spiral a margin call can have on a share price and will not give out massive margin loans.

My point is that even after he got the maximum loan he could get, and then got the maximum margin loan against his shares, he is still 21 billion short.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by HWR_14 on Friday April 22, 2022 @02:28AM (#31118842)
> It does seem low in comparison with the value of his shares

He's only putting up 62.5 billion worth of stock. So that's 20%, which is a little low but not insanely so.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jhugo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:26PM (#31111545)
You don't know that those are the largest loans he was able to get. They might just be the largest loans he wanted to get.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by lkxijlewlf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:40PM (#31111742)
But why? Why would this be the number he wanted?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jhugo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:09PM (#31113120)
The loans have different risk characteristics than his equity stake, he balances risk by deciding how much of his own money to put in vs. how much borrowed money to put in. (There is no doubt a ceiling — how much of his own money he is able to put in — but there's no reason to assume he wouldn't invest less than that ceiling.)

If you have enough cash to buy a house, you might sensibly still take out a mortgage, and you'll need to decide how much cash to put down as a deposit vs. how much to borrow. (The bank will likely set a lower limit for the amount of cash, but you might choose to put down more.) Someone could ask you "why did you choose that number", and you'd give a similar answer.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hristov on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:22PM (#31112407)
Why would he intentionally put himself in a situation where there is a 21 billion shortfall?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jhugo on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:04PM (#31113031)
You don't know that there is a 21 billion shortfall. The source of funds for his intended equity stake is unknown to us at this point. It could be his imagination (especially given his history with the phrase "funding secured"!), or it could be something we are not aware of.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by oh_sigh on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:27PM (#31111560)
What is disturbing about taking a loan out using an asset as collateral?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by xbmcuser on Friday April 22, 2022 @03:27AM (#31119173)
He does not need to sell he could get a loan by using his shares as collateral
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kurupt213 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:27PM (#31114116)
Maybe he has 21 billion available in his margin account on Robinhood
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by mangoTangoBango on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:32PM (#31111618)
Why can't he take out a loan against those shares?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kgwgk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:31PM (#31112545)
He's also doing that:

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-21/elon-g...

  Elon Musk needs about $46.5 billion to buy Twitter at $54.20 per share: about $39.4 billion to pay for the 91% of Twitter’s stock that he doesn’t currently own, about $4.3 billion of debt to refinance and various miscellaneous costs. To pay that, he has:

  A letter from his banks offering to lend $13 billion to Twitter, if he buys it, with $7 billion of that coming in the form of senior secured bank loans and $6 billion coming in the form of junk bonds. 
  A letter from his banks offering to lend him $12.5 billion personally, secured by $62.5 billion worth of his Tesla Inc. stock. At yesterday’s closing price, that comes to about 64 million shares, or about one-third of his Tesla stake.
  An agreement with himself to put up the other $21 billion, give or take.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by flabbergasted on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:31PM (#31111604)
Seriously, how can I buy some of his shares of spacex?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by malfist on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:38PM (#31111705)
Easiest way? Buy Alphabet stock. They are a spacex investor. Otherwise you can't, it's a privately held company
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jefftk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:24PM (#31112432)
Looks like Alphabet owns ~7.5% of SpaceX. Alphabet is worth $1.67T; SpaceX is worth, say, $150B. This means ~$11B of Alphabet (~0.66%) is SpaceX. That is an extremely dilute method of gaining exposure to SpaceX!

(Disclosure: I work for Google, which is part of Alphabet)

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by antonvs on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:07PM (#31113081)
Dilute is better than zero I suppose. Presumably the play is that SpaceX might end up controlling an extremely profitable Mars colony, creating the ultimate gigaunicorn, and making that 0.66% seem much bigger. This influx of cash will also allow Musk to become President of Earth, at which point even those with dilute indirect holdings in SpaceX will be sitting pretty. It's a classic long-term play really.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by gigaflop on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:39PM (#31113516)
Well, he's just following the American model. Leave, displace and colonize, rebel, and declare sovereignty.

To those who would follow him on such a mission? Sayonara. He's spoken about how it would be mostly work for those living there, and I wouldn't be surprised if he tried to implement a 9/9/6 schedule.

I would trust Weyland Yutani with a Mars colony before I would trust EM.

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by malfist on Friday April 22, 2022 @01:47PM (#31125311)
Call me a nerd, but that's be an acceptable cost to being a colonist on another planet for me. 9/9/6 would be a cheap cost for insuring the success of the human race.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by kjksf on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:47PM (#31113633)
The point is that 10% swing in Google's performance (in either direction) has much bigger impact on stock price than 1000% swing in SpaceX performance.

Amdahl law applied to company performance.

Don't buy Google to own SpaceX.

Wait until Starlink IPO and buy that (if not too expensive).

Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by jefftk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:10PM (#31113929)
If you're goal is to own a piece of a potential Mars colony, owning part of Starlink doesn't help.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by hef19898 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:47PM (#31114968)
Plus Starlink is just another profitability goal post of SpaceX that is again moved out into the future.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by outworlder on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:45PM (#31116106)
My sarcasm detector is having a lot of trouble with this comment.
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by auspex on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:47PM (#31116120)
Or just takes a loan against his shares
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by tomcam on Thursday April 21, 2022 @07:17PM (#31116369)
u mad bro?
Re:Musk announces funding secured for Twitter buy by darawk on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:54PM (#31114428)
He can easily get a loan against the value of his shares for this, combined with his own personal wealth (he recently sold a huge amount of stock, he has lots of cash on hand). It's not bullshit at all.