News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Const-me on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:14AM (#14976935)
IMO the best comment from there:

Giulio Prisco said... The results of this incident are easy to predict.

Now everyone at Google (and everyone in large tech companies, and everyone in academy) knows that they can be fired for expressing opinions that dissent from the party line.

Of course they'll shut up for fear of losing their job and the means to support their family.

But they won't change their position. If anything, their position will be radicalized. For example, from classical liberal to alt-right.

Yes, they'll stop expressing their opinion in public. But they'll express their opinion, with a vengeance, in the only place where one can do so in secrecy without fear of witch-hunting mobs: the voting booth.

Yes, that explains Trump.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by fiblye on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:08AM (#14977845)
And when the consequences become obvious, the media will continue to complain about how shitty Western men are and how we need to crack down on them hard and fast.

And it'll just keep snowballing, unless people realize we need to stop and try talking with people we disagree with, instead of doing our best to crush their every outlet to express themselves before they grow bitter and reactionary.

The media can't stop talking about how the internet is "dangerous" because men are being radicalized on it and we don't know why. It's more of a "no shit" situation due them having to hide their every against-the-grain opinion in real life. But yeah, let's start sending the police in on dumb shit that people say on Twitter. [1] That'll really make people reconsider their opinions and not further rationalize their anger.

[1] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/arrests-for-offensive-f...

[dead]
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jshevek on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:09PM (#14983040)
Your statement would be more fair and accurate with qualification, such as "some parts of the left". For example, would you agree that classical liberals are still on the left?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mnglkhn2 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:55PM (#14984699)
When I say left I do it through the eyes of an Eastern European that has been through communist dictatorship. I know how left looks like and what it means to be ruled by double think.

It baffles me to see people in US basically jumping with both feet in this postmodernist social engineering ideology.

I've lived it and you don't want to do it. You'll be reduced to cattle.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by snarkygoblin on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:09PM (#14983650)
Classical liberals are not "on the left." They lean left, maybe, but I would never consider them leftist.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Brockenstein on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:19AM (#14979310)
And the people on the wrong side of history want to talk and talk and talk. They want to stall for time. And every individual who doesn't get a shot to talk and shape the culture feels like they've been robbed and their ideas and beliefs suppressed. They're just ignorant of the fact that these issues have been talked about, at length, ad nauseam, for decades, centuries even. And they don't understand that they don't have anything new to offer, they only have their ignorance. There's no particular reason to tolerate it forever.

And when folks who are apparently ignorant of the subject history get pissy because no one has the time to entertain their ignorant BS, that's a personal problem. Rail against it all you want, it's a losing battle.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by dang on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:00PM (#14984218)
Would you please stop posting ideological rants to HN? It reliably leads to tedious flamewars, and we're hoping for something better than that here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mnglkhn2 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:44PM (#14984601)
I'm all for something better. Can you detail some more what you have in mind? Especially since you seem to be the one making decisions on what is appropriate. Thought police much?!

Plus, you seem to have a leftist ideological bent, moderating off even mild stuff that might not fit your personal preferences.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Bartweiss on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:54AM (#14980931)
> There's no particular reason to tolerate it forever.

> Rail against it all you want, it's a losing battle.

All moral argument aside, this is only true while you're winning. "I don't have to try to persuade you, so suck it up" can enforce ideas, but doesn't spread them. So if there ever comes a day where 51% and rising of people disagree with you, the reason to 'tolerate it' is that you don't have a choice and you've burned all the bridges that could have gotten you somewhere.

I'm not even saying that to condemn using the tactic. More than 99% of Americans accept that the Holocaust happened. I am fully content to leave the <1% of deniers on the wrong side of history, and hope never to deal with them. (Though even there, we ought to be mindful of vigilance and outreach. Without communication, without teaching, that number might well rise.)

My point is only that it's incredibly common for people to find ideological bubbles where they mistake who is going to lose the battle. There were plenty of communists and Confederates and fascists who trusted that their opponents just had "a personal problem" and would lose in the end. If an idea has been discussed "for decades, centuries even", are you really so sure that the arc of history has finally settled matters in your favor right now? Are you convinced that you're guessing better than the people who considered the matter settled 50 years ago? 100?

Burning goodwill to root out dissent in your strongholds is a thing to do after you win the larger battle. After November 2016, it is absolutely baffling to me when people on the left say "they're history, they lose, the time for talking is past". That was not the result, that is not who is in power. And so I do not want the time for talking to be past! I think that might go very, very poorly for a lot of people I quite like!

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mnglkhn2 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:51AM (#14979620)
:) Your comment must be something that came out of an AI bot: right down the middle, ambiguous to the max.

Saying nothing with so many words :) and with the right amount of righteous indignation.

Love it! It proves my point actually.

[dead]
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mnglkhn2 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:39AM (#14980131)
It is obvious that you guys on the left share the same manuals, since you also come up with the "history's dustbin" and "trash opinions". You learn your words and hammer them consistently. At least you get props for that. :)

No pressure to exhibit coherent and consistent argumentation.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by dang on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:02PM (#14984235)
Would you please stop using HN primarily for political and ideological battle? Doing that not only goes against HN's mandate—intellectual curiosity and thoughtful discussion—it actively destroys those things. We have to protect HN against this, and for that we have the 'primarily' test I just described, i.e. when accounts use HN primarily for this, we ban them.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by hobs on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:58PM (#14983541)
There is no argument, racism and sexism are bad ideas that were entertained widely in the past and are not up for debate anymore as potentially positive influences or the correct way to consider the world.

I could have been referencing chattel slavery and your words would be currently for it.

You can take whatever you like from my statement (and clearly are) but you calling me "the left" and pretending I was indoctrinated by some entity indicates your mind is as closed as you intimate mine is.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by dang on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:04PM (#14984261)
Please don't post this sort of tit-for-tat, even when someone else is (or seems to be) wrong and posting bad comments. It only makes the thread worse.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:18AM (#14977201)
It's mysterious to me how literally every action a feminist takes is somehow directly responsibile for all problems that befall them, with every action that might possibly hurt a man being somehow a catastrophe in the making.

Not 3 weeks ago we had a thread here where a woman spoke up about harassment and people said it was exactly the wrong thing. Mad someone for touching your bum? Speak up. You spoke up? Now you're ruining the work environment and being unfair.

In this memo's case, perhaps you're mad at someone for saying you're genetically predisposed to be less capable of individual action (e.g., don't worry I am sure if we set up pair programming that will make it fair for you social women types)? Well it's your fault for not arguing against it. Oh you spoke up and that person got fired for violating some pretty basic corproate policy? Well congrats now it's your fault they're radicalized. Now Trump is inevitable, thanks for putting him in power, I hope North Korea nukes your house!

The only solution that ever seems to be okay is stand there and smile as people say, do, and justify unfair things. Or maybe sit there and "debate" with them as they spout tired 1970s-debunked rhetoric about communication skills and and meticulisly avoid the idea that benefits might take any shape or form beyond what they themselves want this year.

As for that "memo", I still don't get why the underlying premise that Google's level of technical competitiveness was hurt by these policies is taken without a critical eye. That's a pretty big assertion for a company who's essentially leading numerous areas in the world's tech markets and research fields.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ramblerman on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:48AM (#14977359)
He didn't say it the fault of feminists, only that this was probably going to be the result.

And It's exactly why public debate should be had. To come to a better solution in the middle, rather than create fringes on the sides.

Your reaction here is just more of the 'Shock and Awe' and hurt feelings that doesn't really help push the agenda.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Brockenstein on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:41AM (#14979502)
Problem is most of this subject has been in public debate for decades, centuries even. The people trying to maintain the status quo are never going to give it up willingly. They're always going to cry when change comes and they aren't ready for it (IE when they're dead). At some point the debate has to be reasonably over and action expected.

And some subjects don't have middle ground. Women being treated less than equal isn't a middle ground sort of issue.

There are already sides, there have been sides forever. People being pushed or pulled one way or another isn't a new phenomena. And there's no amount of public debate and middle ground treading you can do to prevent people who are going to be polarized as of the result of any backlash of their already fringe beliefs. That's inevitable. And the gymnastics required to keep them in the middle just aren't worth it. The actual goal is the thing of value for the people pushing for it. Not appeasing ignorance and bigotry just enough to keep them pacified.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mistermann on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:03PM (#14981738)
> And some subjects don't have middle ground. Women being treated less than equal isn't a middle ground sort of issue.

Which is why you need to have ongoing discussion, to determine if people are or are not being treated less equally. People who believe they are "right" but are unable or unwilling to defend that position with words ("the debate is over") should not be trusted, ever.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:23PM (#14982597)
> People who believe they are "right" but are unable or unwilling to defend that position with words ("the debate is over") should not be trusted, ever.

So what you're saying is the debate is over about the intentions of people saying the debate is over?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mistermann on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:55PM (#14985795)
Haha, that's a nice turn of words.

Well, assuming you're serious, what's your thoughts on that? Can we have any absolutes? Or is everything indeterminate? If nothing is knowable and communication is not possible shall we stop sending our children to school and go back to living in caves?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:20AM (#14979922)
> He didn't say it the fault of feminists, only that this was probably going to be the result.

So what we all should do is forgive these men their outrageously outdated and somewhat dehumanizing viewpoints and calmly explain to them that currently they are benefitting from a system called patriarchy that has normalized male dominance. We should then calmly suggest that btw, people who are not visually and immediately white suffer a lot under this system too. And I know he benefits but could he please stop?

These folks already hold radical views. He wasn't "radicalized" by being forced to own it. He isn't forced to "vote Trump" because his views are known. He already had them, and they're for the most part outdated, impropable or insulting already.

Why then is the right decision to give him a pass on violating corporate HR policy?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ramblerman on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:34AM (#14980085)
The irony is that all the things you argue against him for, his small worldview, not willing to come to his senses, are what you are doing yourself.

You are kicking and screaming against anything that upsets your viewpoint on this issue.

And we actually agree on the most important facet (as do most people) that any discrimination based on age, gender, or race is absolutely not tolerated.

But how to achieve this in the real world is not a walk in the park. For example, positive discrimination is not a fair system in my opinion. I would think focusing on making the interview process blind is better. So can we argue on these specifics or am I just a bully and a bigot for holding a different opinion?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:44AM (#14980200)
> You are kicking and screaming against anything that upsets your viewpoint on this issue.

Interesting. So in this case I shouldn't debate anyone here. Because somehow that makes me wrong because... By not agreeing my worldview is small?

> that any discrimination based on age, gender, or race is absolutely not tolerated.

Honestly, I genuinely do not believe that many people here believe this. I think they find excuses for men at every turn or rationalize marginalizing women need (e.g., as I write this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14980201) That is part of _my_ larger point about how the natural response on HN is to say, "Well if you had handled this correctly we wouldn't be in a situation where it looks like sexual harassment."

> So can we argue on these specifics or am I just a bully and a bigot for holding a different opinion?

I want you to re-read this paragraph and ask yourself what the premise here is. This thread starts by saying, "We should debate." I point out how dismissive this often I'd on HN and your response is, "You're kicking and screaming and just as guilty as James. Now, agree with me in total OR call me names."

I don't know if you're a bigot, but this is a poor tactic to adopt when coupled with the ultimatum: "Or am I a bully?"

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mistermann on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:06PM (#14981774)
> Interesting. So in this case I shouldn't debate anyone here. Because somehow that makes me wrong because... By not agreeing my worldview is small?

"forgive these men their outrageously outdated and somewhat dehumanizing viewpoints and calmly explain to them that currently they are benefitting from a system called patriarchy that has normalized male dominance" doesn't sound like you're open to a debate, it sounds like you are highly certain that your opinion is correct, full stop.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:31PM (#14982685)
So what you're saying is you don't appreciate my tone?

You can nose around my comments. While I'm somewhat acidic with people who suggest it is the feminist responsibility to endure every negative opinion in perpetuity, I'm engaging in most conversations honestly.

I am quite confident in the core components of these observations, but I was more skeptical of it some time ago. If you genuinely believe I cannot be swayed, why do YOU bother talking to me?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mistermann on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:52PM (#14985784)
Not sure really, I guess it is a bit of a hobby, observing the psychological behavior of humans. To me, it is absolutely fascinating how widespread the affliction is where when you find yourself in a disagreement with a person, you can ask them if they think their position is right, they say yes, are you confident, they say yes (or, perhaps by this time they may already instinctively sense danger and leave the conversation), and then if you say ok, let's make a deal, I will ask you a question, and you must answer the question, the one I asked not a modified version of it, and you cannot change the subject....and then after that you can ask me a question....and so on.

In my experiences, this experiment "fails" 90%+ of the time, either by the person refusing to participate, or refusing to hold up their end of the bargain. Yet, they continue to believe absolutely that they are "right"!

I mean to me, this is very fascinating to observe in action.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by yebyen on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:46PM (#14984069)
I read the thread you linked and I'm not sure what you want us to see. It looks like Sacho is being completely reasonable and you two are having a rational, honest discussion.

I don't see anyone "rationalizing marginalizing women"

It looked like the other poster was trying to evaluate the arguments rationally, that's not the same as rationalizing.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lawnchair_larry on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:45AM (#14980818)
You should really read the article. It didn't say anything negative like you're suggesting.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:24PM (#14982619)
You should read my origin post, I wasn't talking about the top article, I was talking about the character of the discourse on HN.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by _r_o_y_ on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:42AM (#14979516)
There can be no discussion when you start with a bad premise. What can you argue with someone that says the other sex is inferior?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lawnchair_larry on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:46AM (#14980834)
There can be no discussion when people attack a straw man instead of read the article. Nobody said anyone is inferior, at all.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:55PM (#14981661)
That is obviously not at all clear, given the multi-national debate around this issue.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ManlyBread on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:40AM (#14988606)
How does one knows that the premise is bad when you're not even allowed to disciss it? Furthermore, how come the discussion itself is viewed as harmful? If you claim that the premise is wrong shouldn't it be very easy to prove so? What if the other person is open minded and actually willing to consider your arguments, as long as you're willing to do the same?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by kentrado on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:20AM (#14977213)
>Mad at someone for saying you're genetically predisposed to be less capable of individual action?

He never said that. Could you cite the portion where he literally says women are less capable?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:21AM (#14979937)
Do the last two bullet points of his tl;dr count?:

* Differences in distributions of traits between men and women may in part explain why we don’t have 50% representation of women in tech and leadership.

* Discrimination to reach equal representation is [...] bad for business.

Which I read as, "woman aren't as good, that's why they don't already work here, if we hire more of them, they'll not be able to do the job as well as men so the business will suffer"

Is that an unreasonable reading?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TimJYoung on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:08AM (#14980455)
I really didn't want to comment on this topic, but who can pass up a chance at self-immolation ?

Being left-leaning, I've been doing a lot of looking into some of the ideas floating around amongst the right-leaning crowd since the election. Based upon that, I would say that yes, that is an unreasonable reading.

My understanding (subject to being completely off-base, of course) is that the argument is about biological differences related to interests and aspirations, not intelligence and capabilities. In other words, the early developmental stages cause differences in the brain among men and women that affect, in very general terms, what both may end up aspiring to in terms of career choices and hobbies/interests.

Women (again, speaking generally) could easily do any knowledge-based job performed by men, but you're going to have problems finding the numbers that you need if you want to hit a solid 50/50 distribution in certain types of fields. I think this is why certain fields have had very little trouble reaching either parity or female dominance after the women's equality movement started, while other fields struggle to this day. For example, I've read that SV has no problem with the distribution amongst the non-tech fields and that they slightly favor women, but in terms of engineering and tech, the distribution still lags by quite a bit. This would imply that SV is doing everything in its power to hire and promote women, and that there is something else going on that is the cause of what we're seeing. However, it could also imply that tech and engineering are all filled with men that are actively hostile to women to such a degree that women, even women extremely interested in such fields, simply avoid them. I suspect that, like all things in life, it's a mix of both.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:33PM (#14982702)
I think it's a bit of a popular straw man that a 50/50 split is desired. It's more along the lines of, "There are no obvious artificial disadvantages for people in these groups, and if that happens then the resulting distribution will almost certainly change."

If you look at the published #s right now, they're... very striking. It makes the hypothesis that it's just the preference of women and people of various minorities quite an aggressive hypothesis, in a bayesian sense.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TimJYoung on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:24PM (#14983192)
I'm having a hard time making sense of your first paragraph.

As for the second, which published numbers are you referring to ?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:19PM (#14983770)
Google's published diversity report.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Sacho on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:44AM (#14980201)
That can be a reasonable reading, but I don't see what's so controversial about it.

Would you agree that women are naturally physically weaker than men, and this makes for a convincing argument why you would expect more men doing physically demanding jobs? Is this a controversial statement to make?

A difference in traits does not even have to produce a difference in ability to produce a difference in representation. Some of the traits Damore listed allegedly lead women to value a better work/life balance, to focus more on family, etc, which naturally means they would have a lower representation in highly competitive, career-based environments. None of the traits Damore listed seem to discuss "engineering ability", but they do affect all the other skills you need to thrive in the environment.

(This is assuming that the science Damore laid out is sound, which I can't really vouch for, as I am a layman in those fields. However, most of the arguments against Damore seem to be focused on his logical conclusions, rather than the factual basis behind them - e.g. KirinDave seemed to focus on how unfair Damore's conclusions were, rather than how wrong his quoted research was).

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:00AM (#14980364)
> Would you agree that women are naturally physically weaker than men, and this makes for a convincing argument why you would expect more men doing physically demanding jobs? Is this a controversial statement to make?

There is a big difference between agreeing that some differences might exist and arguing that any token gestures for the women who DO qualify under the identical standard are unfair.

That's where this argument breaks down even if we pretend that it's not based on a leaning tower of broscience observations and dated dualist notions of "intellect".

Providing opportunities for minorities in the workplace substantially improves the lot of folks in those categories.

If we could point to the current diversity numbers and say, "Women who do qualify are rarer in the population than men, but tend to equal outcomes once we select for this population? Your argument would make more sense.

But wages are imbalanced, harassment is more prevalent, and turnover is higher. So I'm not as inclined to shrug and walk away just yet.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Sacho on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:31AM (#14980690)
I don't disagree with what you're saying. I want to point out you are employing a classic motte-and-bailey tactic. In your initial post, you said:

> In this memo's case, perhaps you're mad at someone for saying you're genetically predisposed to be less capable of individual action

Getting mad at the memo seems like an unreasonable reaction to me, especially for the stated reason. Now you've moved to:

> There is a big difference between agreeing that some differences might exist and arguing that any token gestures for the women who DO qualify under the identical standard are unfair.

This seems wholly agreeable. I don't know what Google's policies are and I don't think Damore really managed to explain them well, to describe the negative effects of them, and to adequately argument why his propositions were better. I don't see why this is a fireable offense, but I can also support the argument that once the outrage broke out, Google's decision was logical and reasonable. But notice we've moved away from being outraged at his assertions, to just finding his conclusions questionable. Is this worth getting mad over? We are in the motte, in agreement that you should not just take what he said as gospel, throw your hands up and say "well let's dismantle all of Google's efforts", that's the essence of discussion! You can present a reasonable counter-argument to what he said, and I can certainly find many points to agree on it!

What I'm worried about though, is that once we stop talking, you will charge down to the bailey, and decry Damore as a sexist who should never have opened his mouth, because he caused people to get mad. That the science he quoted is "broscience observations" and thus he is stupid(and dangerous!) to even believe it. That somehow him making an argument precluded others from challenging him, from finding his argument unpersuasive, or presenting a counter-argument that may sway him, or others who feel like him. The discussion is already poisoned by this tactic. I believe that's what the author in this thread was trying to get at.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:05PM (#14983003)
> What I'm worried about though, is that once we stop talking, you will charge down to the bailey, and decry Damore as a sexist who should never have opened his mouth,

You're wrong. I've met him in passing, he didn't strike me as worth considering, then or now. I deliberately avoided prior conversations precisely because of how clear it was that he was going to be fired for this. He had to know it would happen. There's only one outcome that COULD have come of writing that memo.

Is he a sexist? I think he holds some sexist notions. This is an unsurprising outcome if you believe that historically society has been quite sexist. Is he a card-carrying MRA of the school of Roosh? I do not think so.

> That the science he quoted is "broscience observations"

This is a misunderstanding I can clear up. I don't really have a problem with observations of behavior based on gender. I'm sure observable differences exist and I suspect mechanisms for these differences are at play in my personal experience of gender.

What's "broscience observation" is attempting to use these studies to suggest (as he absolutely did) that the current crop of googlers has a problem and this problem is caused by the proposed proclivities as a way to shape the experiences of women at Google. Almost by definition, women at Google are precisely the people who wouldn't fall into this category and therefore are mostly asking for simple consideration for their unique needs in the services provided. James's complaint is that any special treatment is "discriminatory" towards him, but that's a somewhat absurd claim that when reduced to its elements actually somewhat deflates his own points.

I'm not sure what "practices" he's specifically talking about, but he alludes to leadership and mentorship programs that are primarily focused on specific groups. Giving him access to those would probably be about as valuable to him as putting a sanitary napkin dispenser in his cubicle, but he seems to take great offense at the idea that of the many leadership and mentorship opportunities afforded to him, one a small handful are not targeted specifically at him.

Biological essentialialism is a very difficult subject to discuss because it's so easy to become prescriptive with it and such prescriptions often greatly damage even modest outliers in the population. And for what? I'm fairly certain google saves money in the long run by attempting to improve employee retention and increase the supply of technical talent they can hire.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lsaferite on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:05AM (#14989221)
No rebuttals to your arguments here, just an observation. You seem like the exact kind of person that I would never want to interact with in person. Perhaps modulating your rhetoric just a tad would make people more inclined to have a reasonable debate with you.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by adrusi on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:43AM (#14980194)
It's an unreasonable reading. If you read past the tl;dr you see that none of the differences in traits he talks about are about ability, just interest, so interpreting it as "women aren't as good" is wrong.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:43AM (#14980794)
Can you explain why hiring women who are just as good as, if not better than, men at the job, but who would prefer (on average) to work elsewhere, perhaps somewhere with more women employees, would make the business do worse?

And can we note that I replied to someone saying "he didn't say that", suggested a place where he did and got replies from different people saying "yes he did say that, and he's correct" and replies saying "no, you're misreading what he said as it's explained in more detail later".

So it appears at the very least (and I feel I'm being generous here), that his words can be misread by people on both sides of the issue, which might be worth bearing in mind for those trying to paint his detractors as a hysterical mob who haven't even read the memo.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by adrusi on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:20PM (#14981216)
Can you explain why hiring women who are just as good as, if not better than, men at the job, but who would prefer (on average) to work elsewhere, perhaps somewhere with more women employees, would make the business do worse?

In the section you quoted, he doesn't say that hiring more women is bad for business, he said that doing so via discriminatory hiring practices, and if you hadn't ellipsized that line, there would have been an explanation for why right there. The full bullet point reads "Discrimination to reach equal representation is unfair, divisive, and bad for business." So he says that unequal representation is partially explained by gender differences in interests, and then that trying to eliminate the differences, specifically via the method of discriminatory hiring, is bad for business because it's unfair and divisive.

To be clear, the reason I'm interpreting the "differences" he refers to as differences in interest as opposed to competence is because of the content in the "Personality differences" section of the memo, which is the only place he addresses specific gender differences. In that section he says that women are less interested on average in tasks which focus mainly on systemizing, and are less interested in high-stress jobs, as well as that they are less likely to advocate for their own promotions.

I replied to someone saying "he didn't say that", suggested a place where he did

No, you replied to someone saying "he didn't say that" and suggested a place where he said something ambiguous — the tl;dr, which is necessarily ambiguous.

So it appears at the very least (and I feel I'm being generous here), that his words can be misread by people on both sides of the issue

Who do you think is misinterpreting what? I've pointed out what I think you're misinterpreting and offered an alternative interpretation. You don't get to simply assert that other people are misinterpreting the memo, you've got to offer some evidence of that.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:37PM (#14981441)
He didn't say "unfair and divisive, and therefore bad for business", he said "unfair, divisive and bad for business". My ellipsis doesn't change the meaning, unless we are, once again, falling back on him presenting his ideas in an ambiguous manner. Which, even if true, makes misinterpretations his responsibility.

In the memo he literally asks for changes to make Google more welcoming for conservatives. He even claims this will be good for business. How do you square this with your contention that any kind of discrimination, even for positive purposes, will lead to negative outcomes due to it being unfair and divisive.

Does it make sense for him to be claiming both these things? I'm not sure that he is even saying that (though it seems tone deaf at the least to present both ideas in the same document).

Also, I'm really not sure that saying women score higher on neuroticism and therefore can't handle stressful jobs as well, or are introverts and so have trouble leading is purely about interest. I'm not sure where this defence about "only talking about interests" comes from, I don't get that from the document. It's certainly not explicitly spelled out.

I'm coming to the conclusion that people aren't just misinterpreting but have actually invented a totally fictitious memo that they find easier to defend than the real one.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Aloraman on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:57PM (#14983528)
You cannot forcibly hire someone who would prefer to work elsewhere (if that someone can really work elsewhere, e.g. not be worried with matters of survival and quality of life). This is probably a reason that in a lot of developing countries (e.g. India) gender gap in IT is much smaller than in developed ones (e.g. Norway, #1 gender equal country)- salary is choosen over comfort.

Now, imagine a situation: 100 persons (80 men, 20 women - ratio observed by actual HR) are looking for a job in Google, which has 10 open positions for them. Google wants to hire the best possible candidate - and hires 8 men and 2 women; both genders are choosed from top 10% of candidates of a same gender (Assuming their skill does not correlate with their gender). That hiring policy does not reduces observed gender gap between candidates at all. So let's introduce positive discrimination (so called affirmative action), and say, that Google wants to hire 5 men and 5 women (1:1 ratio, but even 7:3 will suffice to show worsening effect, albeit in weaker proportions). Now men are choosed from top 6.25%, and women - just from top 25%. The is no gender gap anymore, but now there is a considerable skill gap - top 6.25% men are having considerable advantage over 25% women. More to that: men are not happy because they think they have struggled much more for the same position than women; women are not happy because they think they were hired not for their skills, but for their gender. Also,both men and women being paid based on their performance alone will result if considerable wage gap.

The original memo stated the same, albeit in less transparent form: personal skills cannot be measured with 100% accuracy, so there is always a chance to hire underperforming person (false-positive) or not to hire well performing person (false-negative). Positive discrimination radically reduces false-negatives, which inevitabely magnifies number of false-positives (see Type I and Type II errors in statistics and Neyman-Pearson criterion). Author proposed not to fight on-enter gender gap with discrimination, which would result in negative effect for company's performance, but to make company's environment to be a more attractive (which may reduce on-enter gender gap, reduce number or women leaving industry permanently and won't compromise performance)

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by hackinthebochs on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:13PM (#14986329)
>Can you explain why hiring women who are just as good as, if not better than, men at the job, but who would prefer (on average) to work elsewhere, perhaps somewhere with more women employees, would make the business do worse?

The issue is in the act of finding them. This is where statistics and discrimination comes into play. Lets say that ratio of women vs men that are interested in working at google (and capable of being hired) is 20% to 80%. Then if your goal is to reach gender parity, you must do one of three things: (1) test significantly more women vs men to find those 20% at a higher rate (which involves active discrimination against men), (2) lower the standards specifically for women so that the pass rate for women is higher, or (3) active intervention along gender lines to increase the percentage of women that are interested and capable of passing a google screening. It should be obvious that 1&2 leads to worse outcomes for Google. (3) doesn't directly lead to worse outcomes, but it could be seen as divisive to discriminate against men in these outreach programs, which could indirectly lead to worse outcomes for Google. Now, one could argue that these gender-based outreach programs are just to counter cultural sexism that have kept women from being more interested in engineering jobs at Google. But if the stats in the memo are accurate, at least some portion of the disparity is not due to external factors but individual choices based on inherent (dis)interest. If this is true then such outreach will largely be unsuccessful for the cost in money and resentment.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by johnp_ on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:29PM (#14984946)
Definitely unreasonable reading. Could you explain how you got from the two quoted propositions to your interpretation?

The first bullet point exemplified: Let's say there's a job that requires trait openness / empathy to a certain degree (e.g. early education). Now, some given statistics show that e.g. 40% of the female population and 20% of the male population have this manifestation of the trait to the required degree. Would you still expect a 50/50 male/female representation in the field? The author makes the argument that, if the statistics he found are correct, he wouldn't expect a 50/50 split.

The second bullet point just says that discrimination for the sole sake of said equal representation is bad for business, because given the above it would have to be necessarily unmeritocratic. I would contest this point in a sense that individual merit is not the sole factor at which to look, because it is only a single factor in group success, where the availability of diverse ways of thinking and social compatibility also play major roles.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lawnchair_larry on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:49AM (#14980871)
Very unreasonable. It doesn't say that at all. There are simply far fewer women in the candidate pool.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:09PM (#14983043)
If google showed that their retention of women in tech was similar to men (it isn't), that their pay scales isolated for grade tended to equal outcomes for men and women (ongoing lawsuit says it doesn't in all cases), and that their proportion of women employed was close to the candidate pool?

I think that'd be a fantastic outcome. Then we really could think about "the pipeline problem."

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by bengillies on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:54AM (#14980299)
> This leads to women generally having a harder time negotiating salary, asking for raises, speaking up, and leading.

That is, he's saying explicitly that women find leadership roles more difficult. Generally if somebody finds something more difficult they're not as good at it as people who find it easier. As a result I'm not sure how this could be taken any other way than stating that men are better managers simply because they're men.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:28AM (#14977247)
He says women will benefit from making coding more social. Pair programming.

Remember?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by cm2187 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:48AM (#14977746)
Whether we agree with the memo or not, there was a very good point that guy made and that we should keep in mind, it's the paragraph with the two overlapping distributions.

Even if you admit that all genders, races, any way you want to segment the population, do not have the same distribution, that doesn't mean anything to a person as an individual.

For instance I think it's fair to say that black people are better at athleticism/running than white people (a disproportionate number olympic champions are black), i.e. the tail of the distribution is fatter for black people than white people. It doesn't mean anything to a random individual in that group. I am white, I shouldn't feel offended that another category of the population has a different distribution than my category. And it doesn't mean that no white people can become an olympic athlete either. Just that there will be a natural race imbalance among athletes. And it doesn't mean that a random black man will be better than a random white man at athletism.

So I don't agree with the way you read this memo: In this memo's case, perhaps you're mad at someone for saying you're genetically predisposed to be less capable of individual action. The memo doesn't say that an individual woman will be less capable. What it claims instead is that women have a different distribution for certain skills than men, which you might agree with or not. But it's a very different point.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by hackermailman on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:07AM (#14979800)
This ignores the fact that countries like Jamaica recruit their best athletes into track and field, whereas Australia or China would push those kids into something else. A more accurate statement would be black countries have better track and field coaching infrastructure considering Usain Bolt routinely washed out of race finals until he was picked up by pro coaching staff. It's the same reason Canada usually wins the winter Olympics in Hockey, it's not because Canadians are genetically better at skating and handling sticks, it's because of the coaching, infrastructure to get kids into the national program, funding priorities, ect. Same reason why Germany wins the world cup, it's a financial priority for that country to ensure they do so they can build a national infrastructure of success, they don't have genetically superior athletics for Soccer.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mistermann on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:17PM (#14981873)
For certain sports, it is in fact mostly genetics:

https://geneticliteracyproject.org/2016/08/14/kenyans-sweep-...

It's interesting how introducing certain attributes into a conversation can disable parts of the human brain, I wonder if a study has ever been done on this.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:12PM (#14983065)
An important difference is that in the olympics, a fair and objective qualification system exists. Kenyans are disproportionate in the RANKINGS but not the POPULATION.

In Google's case, women fare poorly in botrh (with rankings expressed in the axis of pay or leadership positions). That's a significant difference.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mistermann on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:18PM (#14983752)
My point was moreso about how prevalent the phenomenon of ignoring obvious objective reality is when certain topics are involved, the key ones off the top of my head being: race, gender, sexuality.

Threads such as this are chock full of examples of people who are normally very logical and scientific, but once the subject turns to one of the above, suddenly everything's different, nothing can be determined, observed, or measured, the entire world is completely random with no patterns whatsoever, etc.

I wonder if all cultures are like this or only us in the west.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:21PM (#14983782)
> My point was moreso about how prevalent the phenomenon of ignoring obvious objective reality is when certain topics are involved, the key ones off the top of my head being: race, gender, sexuality.

Fair. I just wanted to add that it's not terribly applicable to the specifics of the memo and article. People are upset about systemic total representation and undervaluation rather than a lack of singular genius.

But I agree that there are people who find any conversation about statistics as it regards this subject as a form of heresy.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mistermann on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:46PM (#14985749)
> I just wanted to add that it's not terribly applicable to the specifics of the memo and article. People are upset about systemic total representation and undervaluation rather than a lack of singular genius.

It's applicable in that (in my opinion) the majority of the people aren't - rather they are interested in a fantasy version of the situation that exists only in their imagination. This is why even on forums like HN where people are far more logical than the average person, there is no shortage of bickering over obvious misinterpretations, moving of goalposts, etc. For example, how many of the outraged people here are angry about things that literally aren't even in the article, and even when this is pointed out to them, still they aren't able to wake up and realize how their brain is playing tricks on them.

The older I get, and the longer I see the very same arguments over and over again over decades, the more I am coming around to the idea that a massive portion of the human population possibly can't even see reality. Maybe I am one of them!

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:52PM (#14986244)
> The older I get, and the longer I see the very same arguments over and over again over decades, the more I am coming around to the idea that a massive portion of the human population possibly can't even see reality. Maybe I am one of them!

All we can do is dedicate ourselves to following the evidence where we can and avoiding judgement when possible.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lsaferite on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:37AM (#14989494)
> I've met him in passing, he didn't strike me as worth considering, then or now.

That seems fairly judgemental to me.

Edit: To clarify, you are making a value judgement of a person based on some unspecified happening when you met then in passing. That seems to indicate you didn't give much chance in the way to understand that person or the reasoning behind their thoughts.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by HelloNurse on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:58PM (#14981685)
If Jamaica does better than USA in track and field they must be doing something right, but what do you mean by generalizing to "black countries"?

There might be a bias towards track and field programs and careers in poor/small countries, thanks to cheap infrastructure and sustainability with very few athletes, and expensive sports that are practically reserved for relatively privileged people, e.g. swimming and horse riding, but confusing an athlete's race and their available opportunities is silly.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by emmelaich on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:49AM (#14979065)
> fair to say that black people are better at athleticism/running

Is it fair though? Is it supported by metrics of muscle strength and length etc? And does it take into account the differences between blacks (Africans?), west vs south vs central (pygmies!).

Also, there's the possibility that whites of equivalent athleticism find better options for their life than being a professional sportsmen, the bottom 80% [1] of whom end their career at 30 with little to show for it but lifelong injuries.

[1] made up statistic.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by collyw on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:14AM (#14979868)
It seems to be supported by the results at the Olympics and many other sporting events that can be viewed publicly.

And I think that's probably what the OP meant by "better at running". The vast majority of people can run to some extent, so the assumption is that someone is "better" at it usually means "faster". And the obvious place to look for evidence of that would be in sporting competitions, rather than trying to look up metrics that you have described. Obviously its a simplification, but if you don't do that then life would be far to complicated and detailed to navigate.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by kaitai on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:47AM (#14980226)
Right, it "seems to be supported." There's a lot of just-so storytelling going on here. Take a look at American football in 1940. No black players! Hm. Black people must be bad at football, perhaps more suited to being airmen (pilots). Seems to have held up perfectly over the last 77 years, eh?

Do people have no sense of history here? The internet lets you look up all sorts of things, like how the racial composition of US track and field has changed over the 20th century, or how Paavo Nurmi (a poor guy from an underdeveloped country) dominated distance running in the 1920s, challenged only by another couple poor guys from underdeveloped Scandinavian countries. It was clear from publicly viewable sporting events in the 1920s that Scandinavians are really the best at running; east Africans really didn't figure into the competition.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by olala69 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:01AM (#14979722)
Yes, it's all well supported by genetics and biology.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by gibberfish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:08AM (#14977852)
That argument applies to the general population maybe, but that doesn't mean it also applies to the population of Google employees. Everyone there passed their hiring standards, so everyone has proved their individual merit already.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by cm2187 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:19AM (#14977919)
The population of Google technical employees is I think the equivalent to the population of Olympic athletes in my example. If the general population has a different distribution (again whether you agree or not with that assumption), then there should be a natural imbalance among the cream of the top that made it to Google. And as you said, those who made it are all "Olympic athletes" (in theory, they should have been recruited based on individual merit) so these distributions do not mean that a female google employee would be more or less capable than a male, but it will result in less female google employees than male employees.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by pg314 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:50AM (#14979614)
> If the general population has a different distribution (again whether you agree or not with that assumption), then there should be a natural imbalance among the cream of the top that made it to Google.

Your conclusion does not follow from the premise. It's not hard to come up with a distribution that is identical for the top x% but differs for the general population. Or one where the difference in top x% is in the opposite direction of the general population (e.g. two normal distributions where mu1 < mu2, and sigma1 > sigma2).

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:10AM (#14979839)
> but it will result in less female google employees than male employees.

Well, again, the Google memo started by arguing Google's technical standard was being hurt so James doesn't seem to believe his colleagues all got the same interviews he did.

I'd be more inclicned to this sort of argument for racial and gender diveristy if Google & others didn't have such abysmly skewed distributions towards white men. Go look at Google's diveristy report and then do some Bayes Rule hacking with it.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by cm2187 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:45AM (#14980209)
Well, is Google's diversity profile really different from the diversity profile of the computer science departments it recruits from?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:13PM (#14983075)
Incorrect question: you want the graduate rates. Not the staff rates.

Google's diversity rates are worse than the graduate rates for most schools I've checked. I have not found a composite data source to compare a larger average to.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lawnchair_larry on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:04PM (#14981033)
It actually beats them.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mpweiher on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:18AM (#14977519)
No.

First, the section is "Non-discrimnatory ways to reduce the gender gap".

You cannot reduce the "gap" by aiming at the women who are already at Google. This should be obvious. They are already there. To make a dent in the gap, you need to attract more women who currently do not choose to work in tech or not at Google. So nothing he writes is about his colleagues at Google, or by extension women who are already in or interested in tech. It is about potentially attracting those who are not currently interested in that career.

Second, this is about subtle differences in the distribution of preferences in populations with huge overlaps. So when you have an individual in front of you, you simply cannot tell whether they will exhibit this trait more or less by inference from the population statistic. And you certainly can't say "all X have more of this property than all Y". He even has a nice graph for this.

Third, it's not about ability, but about preference. "Women on average show a higher interest in people..." How do you get from "preference" to "ability"?

Fourth, you are assuming a symmetry where "higher X" implies "lower Y that's complementary to X". This would probably be true for interests (if I a am more interested in working alone, I am probably less interested in working in groups). But it does not translate to abilities.

In fact, one of the documented areas where gender differences in ability do show up is exactly a case of this lack of symmetry: you've probably heard that tend to score higher on the math SATs and women higher on the verbals. This is apparently not the whole story: men with high math scores do tend to not also have high verbal scores (and therefore prefer STEM). However, for women the two are correlated, not anti-correlated: those with high math scores tend to also have high verbal scores, so they have more options. And people with more options tend to prefer non-STEM options, regardless of gender.

Fifth, I thought pair programming was a Good Thing™?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by kgwgk on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:53AM (#14978096)
> You cannot reduce the "gap" by aiming at the women who are already at Google. This should be obvious.

That is far from obvious. Everything else being equal, you would increase the proportion of women if you reduced their turnover.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by irishsultan on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:16AM (#14979292)
Only if you reduce their turnover to be below turnover for men. Which at first thought seems to be worse than discriminating only during the hiring phase.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mpweiher on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:34AM (#14978617)
Can we agree that it is obvious as long as we're not talking about retention/turnover?

Well, maybe not "obvious", but "clear that it can't be any other way once you think about it".

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by kgwgk on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:43AM (#14978685)
Sure, if you explicitly exclude any way that the "gap" could be reduced by aiming at the women who are already at Google it is clear that you can not reduce the "gap" by aiming at the women who are already at Google.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:04AM (#14979767)
> You cannot reduce the "gap" by aiming at the women who are already at Google. This should be obvious. They are already there. To make a dent in the gap, you need to attract more women who currently do not choose to work in tech or not at Google. So nothing he writes is about his colleagues at Google, or by extension women who are already in or interested in tech. It is about potentially attracting those who are not currently interested in that career.

If that were the case then he would not lead his essay implying that the current hiring policies were hurting Google. He seems to imply standards have somehow been damaged, but right now that's not what Google does.

> Third, it's not about ability, but about preference.

There are so many potential sources of preference, from negative experience to personal ability. It seems very suspect to point to gender stereotypes that a large number of women have been arguing against for decades are in fact the root cause here.

> you've probably heard that tend to score higher on the math SATs and women higher on the verbals. This is apparently not the whole story: men with high math scores do tend to not also have high verbal scores (and therefore prefer STEM). However, for women the two are correlated, not anti-correlated: those with high math scores tend to also have high verbal scores, so they have more options

Sources, please.

> Fifth, I thought pair programming was a Good Thing™?

That depends. If I told you the only way you're going to be competitive and not drag down the standard of my organization is by pairing up with another person, should you take that as a compliment?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lsaferite on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:51AM (#14989622)
> That depends. If I told you the only way you're going to be competitive and not drag down the standard of my organization is by pairing up with another person, should you take that as a compliment?

This is factualy not what was said in the memo.

https://diversitymemo.com/#reduce-gender-gap

> Women on average show a higher interest in people and men in things

> We can make software engineering more people-oriented with pair programming and more collaboration.

That was literally the only mention of pair programming the the entire memo and it was as a suggestion to make positions more appealing to women who were more interested in people and more social. Not once does he equate pair programming as some remedial for your perceived statement of lower quality ability. The guy was trying to suggest ways to attract more women and you flip it around to demonize him. Do you not see that you are large part of the problem? Instead of trying to engage and explain to him why his points are perhaps wrong or misguided, you instead twist his words to simply eviscerate him instead.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mpweiher on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:30AM (#14980034)
> current hiring policies

And he made it clear that he didn't think they were producing "false positives", so every woman hired was qualified.

> There are so many potential sources of preference

Yes. Biology is one.

> gender stereotypes

http://www.spsp.org/blog/stereotype-accuracy-response

[Stereotype Accuracy Is One Of The Largest And Most Replicable Effects In All Of Social Psychology]

> [verbal/math scores correlate for women] Sources

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/rabble-rouser/201707/wh...

> the only way you're going to be competitive

> and not drag down the standard of my organization

> is by pairing up with another person

Huh??? Where did you get that from? Pleaaze.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:14AM (#14980498)
Please excuse the delay. I'll get to breaking your links down shortly. You're asking me to source papers during my commute hour and on mobile it's difficult to grab and source the resources I'll cite.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by 2muchcoffeeman on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:19AM (#14977918)
At this point I would like to see an itemised list of James Damore's points on gender and women's interpretations of them.

This is the pair programming text in full:

> Below I'll go over some of the differences in distribution of traits between men and women that I

> outlined in the previous section and suggest ways to address them to increase women's

> representation in tech without resorting to discrimination. Google is already making strides in

> many of these areas, but I think it's still instructive to list them

>> Women on average show a higher interest in people and men in things

>>> We can make software engineering more people-oriented with pair programming

>>> and more collaboration. Unfortunately, there may be limits to how

>>> people-oriented certain roles at Google can be and we shouldn't deceive

>>> ourselves or students into thinking otherwise (some of our programs to get

>>> female students into coding might be doing this)

My understanding is: if we increase pair programming to make it more of a team activity, more women will enjoy programming, and more women will become programmers.

We don't have to agree with the suggestion. But you've just shown us that our interpretations are wildly different. So, why?

Edit: formatting

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:35AM (#14980087)
Pair Programming is not a technique to improve social contact in software. It's a technique to improve product reliability and give more practical mentorship opportunities.

We might argue James says women are asking for good mentorship opportunities herr. So why do women benefit from this specifically (and that's okay) but other mentorship program are considered unfair in this rubric?

You say "we need pair programming" when reliability is difficult to gaurantee. Not because you're feeling lonely. It seems an awful lot like he's suggesting that women are especially in need of experienced minders.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Sacho on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:45AM (#14980814)
That's a wholly uncharitable reading of what he's saying. A way more good faith interpretation would be the very simple equation of "working with just computer - more thing oriented, working with computer + partner - more people oriented".

This may be wrong(I don't have any evidence to back it up, and neither did Damore), but it is wholly different from the sinister undertones you are seeing.

(In fact, taking your "mentorship" interpretation, it is entirely possible that the women would be the one doing the mentoring, if their skill at engineering was hampered by a disinterest towards purely thing-oriented pursuits).

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:15PM (#14983092)
> That's a wholly uncharitable reading of what he's saying.

I'm sorry, what?

> A way more good faith interpretation would be the very simple equation of "working with just computer - more thing oriented, working with computer + partner - more people oriented".

Except that women entering the field now have no such expectations but he is still complaining about special treatment.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by HelloNurse on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:03PM (#14981745)
If you impose social contact, people are going to practice social contact and improve at social contact. It might not be what some relatively antisocial people want, but it seems like an important improvement for the whole team.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:16PM (#14983107)
I'm not sure why "pair programming" is the go-to tool here. It certainly implies something different to a lot of people, myself included.

Pair programming is not a "social" outlet. It's collaborative, but "social?" That's quite a stretch of the word from where I think James used it.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by 2muchcoffeeman on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:13PM (#14984832)
Like I said, I am not seeking agreement on the merit of his idea.

You specifically said that the suggestion of Pair Programming, was due to James thinking that women are "less capable of individual action".

But you also said "It's a technique to improve product reliability and give more practical mentorship opportunities." Which is also my understanding. I know at least one shop where everybody pair programs. It has nothing to do with programmers being inferior. I also agree that paring is more sociable since every day I will have to greet my team mate, talk about stuff, have a coffee, then get to work.

I'm just trying to understand how "Pair Programming" changes meaning so much just because some dude wrote a manifesto. We can't even have a discussion if our understanding of the same document is so wildly different.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by averagewall on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:07AM (#14978156)
Schoolteachers are trained to provide just this type of variety for just this type of reason. For example, they're supposed to have competitive classes because boys are generally more motivated by competition than cooperation. It's uncontroversially seen as a good and wholesome thing for teachers to do it. Why is it demon spawn for programmers?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by eeks on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:15AM (#14978503)
So now sociability is a negative trait? I for one would be delighted to find an efficient way to make coding more social. Many a reason why software design is so hard is exactly because most programmers are autistic nerds that tend to produce opinionated, hard to maintain code. Pair programming with someone that tends to think more in breadth than in depth sounds like one way of improving that situation.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by nailer on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:32AM (#14977271)
That's not the same thing as telling an individual they're less capable.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:35AM (#14977288)
Why?

What positive connotation could be drawn from it?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by aaronblohowiak on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:08AM (#14977459)
the context of that suggestion was to make the activity more appealing in order to entice more candidates, not to compensate for a skill deficiency.

My interpretation of this point should not be taken as an endorsement of it or the document as a whole

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:16AM (#14980530)
> My interpretation of this point should not be taken as an endorsement of it or the document as a whole

I was hoping not to discuss the document as a whole myself. I largely avoided the last pseudoscientific cesspool of a thread.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by yorwba on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:51AM (#14977372)
Women are better at pair programming?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:15AM (#14980519)
Evidence, please.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by yorwba on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:54AM (#14980932)
> He says women will benefit from making coding more social. Pair programming.

> What positive connotation could be drawn from it?

I'm not claiming that women are better at pair programming, but that is a positive connotation that can be drawn.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lsaferite on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:59AM (#14989708)
You: Suggesting pair programming is an insult because you think I'm less capable.

Author: Pair programming may be one possible way to bring more social women into programming by appealing to their interest in people vs. things

He wrote one thing, your read another. Who's the one with a problem here exactly? The author or the reader?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by therebedragons on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:56AM (#14977402)
> What positive connotation could be drawn from it?

IMHO that is the wrong question. Connotations aren't something anyone can argue for or against - one can have bad connotations for all sorts of words. Actual example: my ex hated the word "negotiate" in any personal discussion as she saw negotiations as something where you tried to screw the other person over (she was a lawyer). This was to the point where she refused to negotiate anything - including where we would have dinner. How can anyone live without negotiating? Hence, ex :)

I think a better question than one about connotations would be:

If we accept that women have a preference for people over things, what would encourage women to want to do a "things" job? The memo's answer: more peer programming i.e. adding a people element to a things/systems job. That is internally consistent, I think, with the evidence presented on average female preference.

Honestly, I find all this inferior/superior talk really troubling. Different != inferior, or superior, it is just DIFFERENT. Is a hammer a better tool than a saw? Depends what I want to do... I find it even more troubling that people against labelling others superior/inferior see everything that way. Personally, I think vive la difference!

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:07AM (#14977839)
The "different = inferior argument" is strongly implied.

If you accept the premise that there's such a thing as a male-dominated work culture with stereotypically male values, then attitudes and actions that match those values are considered better ("normative") by default.

Anyone who has different requirements or interests will always be considered an outsider who will to have allowances made for them while receiving special treatment.

This would also be true of hypothetical female-dominated cultures with stereotypical female values where men would be considered the inferior outsiders who need special treatment. (Do such cultures exist? At work - sometimes, but not often. Outside of work - perhaps.)

The topic is an unholy mess because there are so many implications and assumptions on both sides, and so much outright ranting and bullying too, that useful debate is practically impossible.

My view is that corporate culture isn't stereotypically "male" so much as stereotypically totalitarian. More women won't change that. It might rein in some of the more obvious abuses, while running the risk of replacing them with some new ones.

But real economic and political freedom could only come from equal opportunity at a scale that most (tacitly neoliberal) feminists seem uninterested in.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sheepmullet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:50AM (#14978369)
> The "different = inferior argument" is strongly implied.

Is it?

For the average person working at a big company it is much more important to have a good fun team than a productive team.

After all a fun happy team benefits me on a day to day level whereas if company profit jumps 20% I'm unlikely to see any benefit.

The exceptions are a few tech giants who hand out lots of stock.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by xapata on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:41AM (#14978662)
> Is it?

Yes. In the memo, at least.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by throwanem on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:57AM (#14979130)
Where? How? In what words?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by xapata on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:42AM (#14980179)
Implication means not explicit. Thus it's up to your interpretation. The context also can affect the implications, including the author's actions after the publication (his interviews on YouTube).
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by throwanem on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:19AM (#14980573)
So I should prefer your interpretation over my own because...?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by xapata on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:43PM (#14985410)
I wouldn't expect you to. Inference of tone and context is often quite subjective. I won't bother arguing it beyond pointing out that there can be reasonable differences if opinion.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Veedrac on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:55AM (#14979650)
> If you accept the premise that there's such a thing as a male-dominated work culture with stereotypically male values, then attitudes and actions that match those values are considered better ("normative") by default.

You've just said that if you accept male-dominated work culture exists, males are considered better by default.

Ergo either males are considered better by default or such a culture doesn't exist. You deny the latter, so clearly you are claiming the former.

You just made that claim, not the guy who was fired.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ckastner on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:19AM (#14977528)
> It's mysterious to me how literally every action a feminist takes is somehow directly responsibile for all problems that befall them, with every action that might possibly hurt a man being somehow a catastrophe in the making.

As I read it, the grandparent's sole argument was one of unintended consequences, specifically that censorship only intensifies certain problems instead of alleviating them.

I don't see how this can be interpreted as to hold feminists responsible for something -- I don't even see the relationship to feminists at all. Could you please expand on that?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by devwastaken on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:28AM (#14977248)
>Mad at someone for touching your bum? Speak up.

Where is this being said? People will not take your position seriously if you're not using context, because you're misrepresenting what is happening. This is something thats done in other places, but as far as I know, has nothing to do with the memo, and nothing to do with the parent post you're responding to. Therefore, you're using a strawman.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:28AM (#14977252)
I'm referring to a Hacker News thread not even 3 weeks old.

In that specific paragraph I'm commenting on Hacker News, not the memo.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sokoloff on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:14AM (#14978495)
A random HN thread from possibly several weeks ago to which you don't provide a link.

Are you surprised that some (most?) people couldn't make a connection?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jernfrost on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:42AM (#14979005)
I did without even having read that particular thread. But I know all too well the types of arguments getting thrown around.

I think it is a question of awareness and beliefs. If you firmly don't think there is an issue then you simply don't notice. I've been at the other side of the fence so I know what it is like ;-)

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by dijit on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:23AM (#14979355)
So it's a myth.

"I saw the topic a week ago, I will not link to it, I didn't even read it, but I'm sure of what was in it"

insert snarky wink face

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by KirinDave on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:47PM (#14984624)
If you ask nicely, I'll provide a link.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by _Codemonkeyism on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:09AM (#14979236)
"Not 3 weeks ago we had a thread here where a woman spoke up about harassment and people said it was exactly the wrong thing."

Not sure I can follow,

so the guy is wrong that he spoke up but the feminist is right? Or is the guy right and the feminist wrong? Or are both wrong? Or people who speak up against the guy are right and the guy speaking up is wrong? Or HN is wrong because we discuss this?

Can't follow your argument in the slightest.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Chris2048 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:56AM (#14978751)
> You spoke up?

There's more than one way to "speak up", so there's isn't just two options. In any case, who's opinion are you talking about? A specific subset of HN that sticks in your mind?

> pretty basic corporate policy

by basic, do you mean "vague and unevenly applied"?

> is taken without a critical eye

It isn't, but the conversation was cut short, suggesting that the opposite happened; it was assumed to be false/incorrect.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ksk on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:00PM (#14981708)
Is the brain exempt from being affected by genetics? All humans are genetically pre-disposed to be less capable of being racecar drivers or olympic athletes or physicists. Inherrantly what is it about being a programmer, that necessitates we assume that biology plays no part whatsoever? Note the use of the word biology as opposed to gender, because limiting the context to gender needlessly pits people against each other.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by _b8r0 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:57AM (#14977409)
I made the grave mistake of trying to express that point on Twitter. Twitter seems to be a poor vehicle for nuanced debate at the best of time, but it's a dumpster fire right now full of raging people who don't understand what you've just said.

I was in SV last year for a couple of months during the election, and everyone I met were all paid up members of the church of political correctness up front, but when you spoke to these people in private there were a lot of people who were secretly conservative, but "It's Silicon Valley and you can't be a Republican out here".

I'm reminded of Chomsky's words in his book, The Common Good:

"The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum"

Where things have gone drastically wrong here are that the spectrum is now so tiny that any debate within that spectrum is now impossible. It becomes almost impossible to depolarize the situation and widen that spectrum, and that's going to lead to everything you more eloquently put above, if not more.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by coldtea on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:12AM (#14977881)
>I made the grave mistake of trying to express that point on Twitter. Twitter seems to be a poor vehicle for nuanced debate at the best of time, but it's a dumpster fire right now full of raging people who don't understand what you've just said.

It's worse. They don't care for what you've said, and they don't particularly care about the issues they talk about either.

Some (media people, etc.) use the issues to have a career or an audience. At best, they convince themselves they care, but they don't in any real capacity.

Others use the issues to vent their frustrations from their lives (as a religion substitute and group signifier) and as an excuse to fight with people.

Others are just repeating what is in fashion in their circle (progressive or conservative) and use the issues as a tribal thing.

(And I'm talking about people on both sides of the spectrum here).

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rpiguy on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:22AM (#14979950)
Extreme leftism is literally a religion, so much so that you can't even present scientific evidence that is contrary to their decided narrative.

Born Again/Woke

Transgression/Microagression

Heresy/Dissent

Sinner/(Racist, Misogynist, Bigot, Sexist)

EDIT: Original Sin/(Privilege, Unconscious Bias)

They even follow the same behavior pattern. First they declare you a Sinner. If you've done research they question the motive of your research and claim it is invalid, regardless of its content. Like the Church burning those who tried to prove the Earth wasn't flat or the center of the solar system, when presented with evidence the extreme left says, "Heresy!"

Then they want to be protected from the sinners. The sinners make them feel unsafe. They have to be taken care of.

Seriously I thought humanity got past all this religious nonsense.

We have strides to make in better treatment of women and minorities, but adopting this kind of religious attitude is ridiculous and not the way forward.

Thank God that the US is a place where for whatever reason people inherently seem to not like following the rules.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sctb on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:10PM (#14981102)
When we ask users to take care to post civilly and substantively, this is what we want to avoid. The ratio of insight to inflammation doesn't meet the bar for the kind of thoughtful discussion we're after here.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ruste on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:33PM (#14982041)
I agree that this comment wasn't _quite_ as substance based as many others in this thread, but I think it made an interesting comparison that I hadn't seen elsewhere. I've read the same thing said a hundred different ways in other comments and this one said something different. It's possible that this could be interpreted as uncivil, but It seemed _relatively_ politely put and I think the fact that it's a different perspective is reason enough for its existence.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rpiguy on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:40PM (#14981483)
I will concede the post could have been more civil and I apologize.

However, it is extremely substantive, an entire doctoral thesis could be written on secular religions/orthodoxies and their illiberal and authoritarian nature and is directly relevant to the discussion of the reaction to the Google memo.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sctb on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:43PM (#14982164)
Substantiveness and civility aren't unrelated: a lack of the latter undermines the former. A doctoral thesis would be expressed quite differently, for example.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rpiguy on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:19PM (#14982558)
Yes substantiveness and civility are related. However, making a point in 500 characters vs. 20,000+ characters lends itself to some brusqueness.

I agree however, that lack of civility can undermine your argument. See the very uncivil comments below from Damore's fellow Google employees, including managers. They undermine their argument and literally create a toxic and scary work environment.

I abbreviated the names, but these were all public statements. I just don't want to run afoul of any HN rules regarding naming names.

CB: "You know there are certain "alternative views, including different political views" which I do not want people to feel safe to share here... You can believe women or minorities are unqualified all you like — I can't stop you — but if you say it out loud, then you deserve what's coming to you. Yes, this is "silencing". I intend to silence these views... Take your false equivalence and your fake symmetry, and shove them hard up where the sun doesn't shine."

KB: "I am considering creating a public-inside-google document of "people who make diversity difficult"...which calls out those googlers who repeatedly made public statements that are unsupportive of diversity... Things I'm still pondering: should inclusion on the list require something resembling a trial? should people be removed after some period of time if they start behaving better?

CW: "One of the great things about Google's internal communication mechanism... is that, as a manager, I can easily go find out if I really want to work with you."

KE: "Your reply...ignores the many women Googlers who have expressed the frustration they feel as a result of this. F* off. Thanks for using your real name here, though. Makes it easier to update my spreadsheet."

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rtx on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:40PM (#14984008)
What's more scary someday people like Larry and Sundar will step down. Then these people will have all the Google's power.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by halfnibble on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:32AM (#14980699)
This is quite humorous. Can I use this?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rpiguy on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:14PM (#14981153)
Of course. Just be careful where you post it, you might get added to a naughty list somewhere.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by thehardsphere on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:55AM (#14980316)
Don't forget that they recently created a concept of original sin: unconscious bias.

Thanks to the Implicit Association Test, it can now be demonstrated that everyone has racial bias. If you point out that follow up studies have shown poor test-retest reliability and that there are all sorts of other flaws in this field of research, you'll simply be dismissed as a denier.

So now, implicit bias takes the place of original sin, with white European (even the ones from Eastern Europe that had nothing to do with slavery) slaveholders standing in for Eve. You can never get rid of original sin, you can only ask for Jesus to forgive you. So who or what will be the new secular left wing Jesus?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by peoplewindow on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:02AM (#14980391)
The mob.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by elcapitan on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:35AM (#14977625)
> "The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum"

"What kind of freedom is there inside a corporation? They’re totalitarian institutions – you take orders from above and maybe give them to people below you. There’s about as much freedom as under Stalinism."

Amen to that.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by _dps on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:09AM (#14978815)
There is the freedom to negotiate, and the freedom to leave. Comparing it to Stalinism is silly, and surely disrespects the millions of people who genuinely suffered and died under Stalin.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by obstacle1 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:14AM (#14979276)
OP's quotation is not speaking of freedom generally, which you are; it is speaking of freedom within the corporation, i.e., you are there and you do not leave.

>Comparing it to Stalinism is silly, and surely disrespects

No, making a comparison of abstract forms of government is not in any way disrespectful to people who lived under a regime. It can only be construed as disrespectful if you are looking for an emotional tangent to distract people reading from the argument at hand (which, incidentally, indicates that you know your argument is bad!)

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by _dps on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:24AM (#14979360)
By exercising your freedom to negotiate and threatening to use your freedom to leave, you can attempt to cause changes in the corporation.

Please don't attempt to tell me that I know my argument is bad.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by obstacle1 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:36AM (#14980102)
>Please don't attempt to tell me that I know my argument is bad.

I didn't attempt to tell you that, I did tell you that.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jules on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:22AM (#14979951)
The freedom to leave gives you leverage within the company, even if you don't leave. Imagine how it would be within companies if the government forced people to stay.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by smoyer on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:38AM (#14980122)
Effectively this is what Utah's new non-compete laws achieve. You won't leave if you can't work at another company in your field.
[dead]
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rayiner on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:05AM (#14979778)
> So we'll see what we see in every other company now also at Google. No mixed teams.

Do folks really believe that's what gender-balanced work places are like? I used to work at a large New York law firm where 40% of the lawyers were women. All of my teams were mixed, and out of happenstance I spent the bulk of my time working for women partners. Nobody was "terrified" because everyone knew how to act like a professional adult.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Sacho on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:27AM (#14980008)
I don't dispute your conclusion, but for the sake of argument, how can you be sure nobody was "terrified", given the claim from GP that people would hide their opinions on the matter very carefully?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rayiner on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:43AM (#14980795)
I guess I don't know if people were secretly terrified of the mixed-gender situation. But the recruiting process at a big firm involves 12 weeks of alcohol-fueled social events, and I saw pretty much everyone participate. People socialized and made friends with people of the opposite gender, as if we were in a first world country where that was okay. And when I started full time, I never saw any friction in the exclusively mixed-gender teams I worked on.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Brockenstein on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:08AM (#14979225)
That's a pretty unrealistic black and white picture you're painting. Cultures and groups within a company that are already diverse and are truly merit based aren't going to be bothered by these sorts of events. They're already got their house in order, so to speak.

The people you're describing of being so terrified by these events or adopting unofficial policies against women already had a misogynistic bent. They were already a problem. Them using an event like this to justify their anti-social behavior is typical, but it is not the cause. They weren't accepting bastions of equality until they were frightened into sexism. Putting them on notice isn't the end of the world for anyone.

Whether we appease bigots or confront them, some people are going to be assholes until they die. I'd rather confront them and leave no question about which way the world is going.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by grey-area on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:06AM (#14979788)
Make sure no women passes any interview. Obstruct women and generally get them out of the team, or at least don't work with them when avoidable.

Why are you so scared of women?

We all know this is how Directors and VPs and the like think, we just don't say it.

It's really not.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by marcosdumay on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:45AM (#14980207)
Yes, the top calls all the cards. Yet, it is still a human organization, with all the features of a human organization.

As to answer. Inside a corporation, there is as much freedom as the top allows. With the consequences of that emanating from all the levels, so it is wise to not make it entirely freedom-less.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by toyg on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:25AM (#14977571)
> Twitter seems to be a poor vehicle for nuanced debate at the best of time

Understatement of the century. How on earth can you expect to have "nuanced debate" with only 140 characters?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Cthulhu_ on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:08AM (#14977854)
Plus the fact that the 140 characters are done from a soapbox with possibly tens of thousands of people ready to pounce on it.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by maxerickson on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:36AM (#14979455)
This is like complaining that our mouths can only make 1 word sound at a time.

How can you have a nuanced debate with a serial device? It just won't work.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by kogepathic on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:57AM (#14977780)
> How on earth can you expect to have "nuanced debate" with only 140 characters?

Oh come now, it seems to work fine for Trump! /s

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by marrs on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:19AM (#14980571)
Made me laugh
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Chris2048 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:47AM (#14978706)
Sad!
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Chris2048 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:15PM (#14981161)
I was downvoted! Sad!
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jondubois on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:26AM (#14978913)
Whenever you have a discussion about a topic in which people feel personally invested, their reasoning skills drop and their sentiment analysis ability goes up.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by _b8r0 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:39AM (#14978982)
I've noticed that. But it does appear that for a lot of normally rational people this personal investment is at least amplified, if not manufactured almost entirely through the media.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by atilaneves on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:54AM (#14979103)
A "normally rational person" is a person that is emotional at least 50% of the time but convinces themselves otherwise. Facts that seem to go against a person's beliefs provoke cognitive dissonance - it doesn't matter how technical they are or how logical they need to be to do their jobs.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by adrianratnapala on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:20AM (#14979317)
It goes beyond that, Sabine Hossenfelder is better than a "normally rational person", she is seriously very smart it is in her bones to make a decent rational case for whatever she is saying. And here I am talking about her blog posts, not her job -- I have never read any of her papers.

But in this case though, she is does repeat some interweb fallacies about the memo, even though she has certainly read it herself and thought about it for herself.

But she does get the important thing right: which is that even if the memo is as bad as she says it is, it's still no reason for a sacking.

[Disclamer: I am a Googler, but quite obviously I am not speaking for the company here.]

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by halfnibble on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:34AM (#14980719)
Is that what the PC police told you to put at the bottom of all your online posts? ;)
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rayiner on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:05AM (#14979203)
Explains the sloppy reasoning of the Google Memo perfectly.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by trb8 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:48AM (#14980239)
> I was in SV last year for a couple of months during the election, and everyone I met were all paid up members of the church of political correctness up front, but when you spoke to these people in private there were a lot of people who were secretly conservative, but "It's Silicon Valley and you can't be a Republican out here".

I guess they did not consider the voting booth to be private, as SV is one of the areas that swung towards Clinton?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mrybczyn on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:21AM (#14980595)
Hard to say what the actual numbers are, but from the anecdotal evidence, a percentage of people felt that they had to pretend to be politically correct / leftist liberals. If you multiply any percentage, times the 80 million people in California, that's a lot of mental anguish and repression.

As long as there's food and shelter for most, things will continue as they are. First little bit of suffering, and it will explode into revolution. Normal way of things.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by snikeris on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:54AM (#14979637)
> "The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum"

For further reading on this topic:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by nowo on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:56AM (#14978754)
You realize his paper was posted to a list at google called "pc-considered-harmful"?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by _b8r0 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:38AM (#14978980)
Can you indulge me in a thought experiment. You seem like a reasonable human being but I think your question shows that you may have fallen into a moral trap.

Can you explain to me the point I've made that you're arguing for or against with your question. Show me how your question has any impact on that point.

If you're taking a side and saying "But did you know this person was literally Hitler" then you may have fallen prey to the manufactured outrage surrounding the issue. Take a step back and ask yourself if it matters if the list was called pc-considered-harmful, woodchipping-kittens or fluffy-bunnies? What is the impact on the list's name on the situation?

If you're associating any questioning of the situation with the other side then it's worth spending a moment to see if you might have tied your beliefs to identity. When we tie our beliefs to our identity, we associate questioning of those beliefs with attacks on our identity. This is being exploited at the cost of completely polarizing your view.

The next step would be to see how upset you are. If you're very upset or wound up, or maybe you're not but you've commented a zillion times about this elsewhere, why are you doing so about this matter and not other things? What is it about this issue that gets you so riled up and why? Why would you care about some guy you don't know getting fired more than the President's involvement with Russia, or the killing of innocent civilians in the Yemen? What is it about this subject that gets to you in a way other's don't, and why?

You might find some serious answers, but probably more questions here: https://medium.com/the-mission/the-enemy-in-our-feeds-e86511...

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by nowo on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:02AM (#14979744)
> Can you explain to me the point I've made that you're arguing for or against with your question.

The idea in your comment is that you can't, or at least are dissuaded, to express certain opinions. Most the things I hear about Google, including the existence of a list talking about the harms of political correctness, that the author felt free to write such a report and many other reported freedoms at work indicate that this isn't the case. That in fact people at Google are more free to express themselves in these types of issues than at other companies.

You're the one who seems to be upset. I wrote one line and you jump to conclusions, question my motives, dig into my comment history and even managed to bring up Hitler. I try to argue the facts. Maybe you should question yourself as you question others.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by marrs on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:17AM (#14980542)
They might not be feeling so free to express themselves since this guy got fired.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by yequalsx on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:48AM (#14979583)
You make excellent points and are, logically speaking, correct. We are emotional creatures and we usually respond emotionally. If the list was called "hitler is my hero" there would be a visceral reaction. The framing, the contextual anchoring of a comment does matter and it should matter since we are social creatures that respond emotionally.

I very much agree with the top comment made by Const-me and the overall points you made. Unfortunately fear and anger are what drives political discourse and media feeds that fire.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by yequalsx on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:38AM (#14980127)
I like the downvote I got. It reinforces the point I made about humans being emotional creatures!
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jamesrcole on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:46AM (#14979032)
There's a lot of questions here

- did he create the group?

- how long had the group existed before he posted the memo?

- was Google as an organisation ok with that group existing?

- is there anything wrong with there being discussion surrounding the value of PC viewpoints?

- What other sorts of lists exist at Google, and what sorts of viewpoints to they cover?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by avn2109 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:59AM (#14979141)
Any group like that is surely an HR honeypot, either by design or ex post facto.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by afpx on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:28AM (#14980015)
It's fascinating to me that Google even has places to express opinions. When I was in my 20s and 30s, the workplace was just the place where you did work. There was no room for self-expression. You worked, you got paid, you went home. Seems like it opens the door for trouble - a false sense of individual rights when there are very few.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lloydde on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:45AM (#14980206)
Google and the like greatly benefit from creating an environment where work and the workplace can be all consuming.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ttkeil on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:45PM (#14998637)
So, what are the odds that Damore read this thread and immediately turned around and wrote his essay? Note the Chomsky quote and use of "heresy".

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/why-fired-google-195400805.ht... (Non-paywall version)

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by GVIrish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:31AM (#14977608)
> Now everyone at Google (and everyone in large tech companies, and everyone in academy) knows that they can be fired for expressing opinions that dissent from the party line.

This is an example of people taking exactly the wrong lesson from this situation. The guy wasn't fired for having a 'dissenting opinion'. He was fired because he basically said women are underrepresented in IT because they are biologically unsuited for it. If someone's 'opinion' is that phrenology explains why black people are underrepresented in tech they'd meet with a similar fate

There are a lot of situations these days where people are expressing opinions at work that are insensitive to or outright disparage another group of people, then getting shocked when they're fired.

The problem is that tolerance in the workplace of bigotry towards any group is rapidly eroding and some people don't know where the line of appropriateness is. They've never had to think much about the impact of their opinions on minorities and women so they're almost blind about what is over the line.

The thing is that many people who get into these situations have at least some idea that what they're gonna say is offensive. They'll preface things with, "I'm not racist but..." but continue right on saying it. Like they know on some level it's offensive but they don't consider that 'hey, maybe I'm in the wrong and I shouldn't go there'. 'No, it must be that liberals are out to censor me and destroy free speech'.

It's funny that some people point to a situation like this and say, "This is why we have Trump." If people voted for someone who routinely espoused racist and misogynist attitudes as a reaction to being criticized, that pretty much means they actually are bigots on some level. If you're not a bigot, the reasons to vote for him would be his policies, not his crude and prejudiced 'political incorrectness'

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by dx034 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:37AM (#14977635)
> He was fired because he basically said women are underrepresented in IT because they are biologically unsuited for it.

I don't understand why people keep repeating that statement. He said that biological differences explain the different ratios of men and women, NOT that women are not suited for tech jobs. He explicitely did not say (nor mean) that a woman can't be a good software engineer. Just that on average, more men than women will show the features needed for software engineers.

That is a huge difference. It doesn't disqualify any woman working at Google. It just means that the goal to reach 50% women could lead to a worse outcome.

Disclaimer: I don't necessarily support his claims, nor do I support his memo as such. I just think that it's worth thinking about and that there should be more scientific studies to explore this. Diversity campaigns should be based on science, not on populism.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by davidiach on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:14AM (#14978494)
I think it has to do with low knowledge of statistics.

The funny thing is that all the following sentences can be true at the same time:

1. Across the whole population, fewer women than men have the biological/psychological traits needed to become software engineers.

2. Female engineers are underrepresented in Silicon Valley and face many different forms of discrimination.

3. Female engineers at Google are on average better than their male colleagues.

I'm not suggesting any of these sentences are necessarily true, just that they can be. This is not intuitive, unless you know a bit of statistics.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by GVIrish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:30AM (#14977984)
> I don't understand why people keep repeating that statement. He said that biological differences explain the different ratios of men and women, NOT that women are not suited for tech jobs. He explicitely did not say (nor mean) that a woman can't be a good software engineer. Just that on average, more men than women will show the features needed for software engineers.

The problem is that his whole argument is based around biological determinism and those are the same arguments that true misogynists often use to discriminate against women. He even stated 'Neuroticism' as a trait women are predisposed to, which could've been pulled right out of an argument for why women shouldn't be allowed to vote.

Damore devotes zero attention to the impact of culture on what fields women go into. And in a nutshell, that's a major reason this manifesto is problematic and got him fired. Women in IT sometimes have to contend with attitudes that 'women are bad at math' or 'women are irrational' or 'women only care about aesthetics'. These are the attitudes that make some technical fields unwelcoming to women.

He hedges a little bit by saying 'distribution in traits between genders may be a part of why the gender gap exists' but then he proceeds to discuss that as the only reason the gender gap exists.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by type0 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:24AM (#14978249)
> The problem is that his whole argument is based around biological determinism

It's not based on biological determinism, he provides references to the current state of psychological research and simply wants a discussion about the policy

> this manifesto

it's not a manifesto by any means unless you want to call everything a manifesto including your post.

> Women in IT sometimes have to contend with attitudes that 'women are bad at math' or 'women are irrational' or 'women only care about aesthetics'.

There were no such things in his text, not even remotely close

> then he proceeds to discuss that as the only reason the gender gap exists.

He explicitly questions those causes, please stop projecting your ideology on things you read

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jlouis on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:57AM (#14978416)
The term "neuroticism" stems from the five factor model of psychological traits. The memo author doesn't really mention this too much, but if you know about the model, he uses the other factors throughout his work, which means he has read and understood the model.

There have been several studies showing that women scores higher in the agreeableness and neuroticism factors, on average (and with a quite large variance and a rather small effect I might add). The memo author makes it clear by writing "in part" in multiple places: a moderate effect can't explain the whole story: either there is another factor which truly dominates, or we are just looking at one piece of the puzzle as a whole.

Neuroticism has a very specific meaning in this case and it pertains to "negative emotion" in the sense that extremely high scores make you more likely to be stressed, anxious and so on. Likewise, extremely low scores make you overconfident and so stable you are unlikely to venture out into new ideas.

From an evolutionary phsych. standpoint, any score which exist tend to serve a purpose some way or the other. There are no desirable or undesirable traits, because too much or too little of a trait will be challenging in some situations, but a great advantage in others. So the question to ask is: if women scores higher in neuroticism, what advantage does that buy them in what situations? More anxiety could for instance have you second-guessing yourself in more situations, and that could lead to you finding more bugs in programs up front, which is an excellent trait to have in software development.

The other factor where there is a measurable gender difference, agreeableness, is a two-edged sword: High agreeableness scores are highly desirable for building coherent and working team/group structures. Low agreeableness allows people to pick an individualist/isolationist path when needed and make something great by ignoring the group consensus. Good group dynamic requires both traits to some extent.

My hunch is that if you scored the women at Google on the five factor model, they'd be likely to fall somewhat outside the gender norms. There is a considerable selection bias if you only consider tech people who work for Google. You are easily looking at a small fraction of the population as a whole, and the hiring selection process is likely to skew the scores quite a lot from the average norm.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by GVIrish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:49AM (#14979059)
The thing about pointing at the 5 factor psych model then applying it to something like gender disparity in tech, is that it's a pretty big leap to take scores from research studies to then draw conclusions about gender disparities in a given profession. Especially because at the core, it's very difficult to disentangle gender differences in psychological traits from learned social behaviors.

You bring up a lot of questions about what effects predispositions have in this case and that is exactly why it creates problems when people take findings on predispositions and run with them.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jlouis on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:27PM (#14984468)
I think the key point the author is trying to make is: "Does biology play a role in what choices women make when it comes to selecting a career path?"

Clearly, this is not attributable to a single argument or factor. Rather, you have to look at several different reasons. Some are likely cultural, some are likely genetic and the interplay is going to be vastly complex (see e.g., epigenetics).

To make the argument, you have to survey a larger number of areas and show that they all point in the same direction, which is what the author is trying to do in the first place. And in particular, you have to demonstrate how the areas contribute to women making a choice against tech in general.

Hence, the studies showing how men are more often systemizing than women and so on are far better markers/arguments from a pure biological standpoint, than a difference in the 5 factor model.

Personally, I think most diversity programs fail to achieve any kind of success in improving the gender balance. In two prongs, you have to retain women who are already in tech, and you have to get more women into tech. The latter of those two is a hard sell if women simply don't want to be in the tech world, no matter how much you try to seduce and coerce them. And I think it would be too authoritarian to force them into a role they don't want to belong in.

I think the author is spot on with the observation that more competitive fields are more likely to have men employed over women. And more cooperative fields are better at retaining women. E.g., Law in Denmark has an almost 50/50 gender split, but women are far more likely to be employed in the public sector as lawyers. The law firms, where 80+ work weeks are the norm, are usually employing men. Jordan B. Peterson, whether you like him or not, posed the question as to why men are willing to fucking do that, and I happen to find that question quite interesting.

I also think tech in general would benefit from having some ventures which are more cooperative, but this is not likely to come from a highly competitive venture capitalist private sector, I'm afraid. Nor do I think Google can pull that one off.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by AnimalMuppet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:49PM (#14984647)
> Some are likely cultural, some are likely genetic and the interplay is going to be vastly complex (see e.g., epigenetics).

OK, let's say that some segment of it is cultural. Now what?

Let's say that I'm female, and I have some talent for engineering/programming, but I'm raised in a culture that says "Women don't do that. Women marry, stay at home, and raise children." And I look at my mother, who is doing exactly that, and I see how trapped she feels, how stifling it is, and I really don't want to wind up in the same place, but because my culture is what it is, I don't think I have any other choice. Clearly, that's bad.

But let's say instead I look at my mother, and see that she's fairly content and happy, and I think, "That looks pretty good." It's still the same cultural constraint, but now I am willingly assenting to it. Now, is that still bad? (Yes, it's still bad as for the general culture, because it's still constraining others who don't want that. Is it bad for me specifically?)

If you say "Yes, it's still bad", you're saying that you know better than I am what decisions I ought to make. (This presumes that I genuinely understand the alternative. But don't say that, if I really understood, I wouldn't want to choose that. That's cheating. It's also insulting.)

Note that, in my example, the differences are neither genetic nor cultural. The difference is in the example that I see growing up, whether or not people are happy fitting into their culturally-assigned place.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by marrs on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:26AM (#14980639)
It's no greater than the leap required to attribute gender disparity to internalised misogyny.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by UncleMeat on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:21PM (#14982578)
Except we do have direct evidence that gender bias leads to worse callback rates, worse initial evaluation of qualifications, worse promotion results, greater punishment for negotiating salaries, and expectations that are outside of job requirements.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by marrs on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @09:13AM (#15017871)
But we also have direct evidence that the distribution of genders across the disciplines increases as opportunities between the genders become more equal. That strongly implies that biology does have an affect on life choices.

It also has to be said that not all evidence is equal.

I was reading an article about this just today, as it happens, complete with citations: https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/rabble-rouser/201707/wh...

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TeMPOraL on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:18AM (#14978213)
> He even stated 'Neuroticism' as a trait women are predisposed to, which could've been pulled right out of an argument for why women shouldn't be allowed to vote.

Did you read this article? Or references linked by the original memo? Even this article clearly points out that "neuroticism" thing is pretty much established, accepted, and uncontroversial science.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by xapata on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:48AM (#14978709)
No, I don't think it is. Not even the definition of neuroticism is uncontroversial.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:50AM (#14977754)
> He explicitely did not say (nor mean) that a woman can't be a good software engineer.

> Just that on average, more men than women will show the features needed for software engineers.

Read those two sentences you wrote again. You'll be shocked when you see it.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jcims on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:15AM (#14977892)
I took the liberty of labeling one of the diagrams in the document with two points labeled A and B. How would you interpret the relationship of these points if A was a man and B was a woman?

http://imgur.com/a/kWyTi

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:09AM (#14978170)
I would definitely agree that A was to the left of B. I would also concede that B is to the right of A. But since the only label on the graph is an unidentified "Trait", I couldn't really comment any further.

What point are you trying to make?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by exergy on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:29AM (#14978283)
The point he's making is that, on that graph, it is clear that many women are better at software engineering than many men. The women closer to the tip of their graph will easily beat men at the tail of theirs. Women can be very competent software engineers. That is clear to all (Sandy Metz is a great example).

But if, in general women prefer different roles, is that unimportant to you?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by irishsultan on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:25AM (#14979369)
Why does it matter which trait this describes? Surely this demonstrates that averages don't matter for how a trait is expressed in individuals, no matter how it's distributed in different groups?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TeMPOraL on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:21AM (#14978224)
That the value on the y axis, for those two points taken from presented distributions, is the fucking same...

It's hard to make that point even more obvious.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by depressedpanda on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:27PM (#14981300)
What? It's a normal distribution graph. The height of the curve denotes how many of a particular group (group is denoted by the blue and green curves) score with regard to some trait x. The y-values for A and B on the graph are irrelevant.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TeMPOraL on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:31PM (#14981357)
You are right, of course. A dumb mistake of mine.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jshevek on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:43AM (#14979527)
It's pretty clear from the totality of this person's comments that they are here to obfuscate and troll. Not sure why this is allowed on HN.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:51AM (#14988673)
Would you care to revise your statement given https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14981300 ?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:54AM (#14979108)
Does anyone know if this graph is to scale?

Seems to me it would have radically different interpretations depending on scale, and I'm not sure if it's just illustrating the concept of overlap or if it's claiming to represent "software engineer ability" or any other real measurement.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by throwaway257157 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:00AM (#14977799)
I'm not seeing it. Help me out? It's not a contradiction, if that's what you're implying. Have you ever taken a statistics class?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:07AM (#14978157)
Oh, throwaway257157, if I thought you were posting in good faith, I'd certainly engage with you but using a newly created account means you aren't.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by anon_d on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:15AM (#14979282)
They are publically defending an argument that got someone fired, so using a throwaway account is totally reasonable here.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by depressedpanda on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:30PM (#14981335)
The point the throwaway raises is valid, though.

Where is the contradiction?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:28AM (#15007286)
If you can't see it already, I doubt anything I could say to you would help that.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by depressedpanda on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @09:35AM (#15027301)
What I see is that you don't understand statistics. And, rather than offer a snide comment, I will try to show you why. Here are the two statements you quoted:

> He explicitely did not say (nor mean) that a woman can't be a good software engineer. > Just that on average, more men than women will show the features needed for software engineers.

Rephrased:

a) a woman can be a good software engineer b) on average, more men possess the skill set required for a software engineer

There is no contradiction between a) and b) whatsoever, since a) is about an individual and b) is about average features of different groups.

Of course, one may argue about the veracity of either a) or b). But, regardless of their factual accuracy, you did not make the point you think you did.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jshevek on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:41AM (#14979503)
No.

Assuming someone is posting in bad faith for this reason is an act of bad faith.

Your statement reveals hypocrisy.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:09AM (#14979827)
A throwaway account created specifically to post one comment is a sign of bad faith. It's entirely possible that I am wrong but the lack of subsequent engagement suggests otherwise.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jshevek on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:49PM (#14982863)
"using a newly created account means you aren't."

This is wrong. Using a newly created account does not mean the communicator is approaching this in bad faith. That's a complete non sequitor.

"lack of subsequent engagement suggests otherwise."

Not at all. There are numerous reason they might not engage further within this time frame - or ever.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:52AM (#14988054)
> Using a newly created account does not mean [...] bad faith

Specifically to post one (1) comment strongly implies it though. You disagree, fine; we'll agree to differ on this.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by coldtea on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:16AM (#14977901)
>This is an example of people taking exactly the wrong lesson from this situation. The guy wasn't fired for having a 'dissenting opinion'. He was fired because he basically said women are underrepresented in IT because they are biologically unsuited for it.

He never said that women are "biologically unsuited" for IT. Here's what he sead in full: https://medium.com/@Cernovich/full-james-damore-memo-uncenso...

In short, he said that biological differences (with citations) can explain in the aggregate (not in the total absolute of the population) different preferences, job options, etc., and even suggested ways to change the working environment to alleviate those issues and make it welcome to more personality traits associated statistically with women (as described in citations and statistics he gave).

What kind of person misattributes another with straw-man arguments they didn't say and gloats on their misfortune of being fired?

What he said might or might not be true, but in any case it's no basis for firing someone (as it's not related to their job performance), and it's something that absolutely should be allowed to be debated and studied.

The assumption "all sexes/cultures etc are equally predisposed to everything or even if they are not they should be considered as such and nobody should talk about it again" is not a way to have any kind of dialogue.

>There are a lot of situations these days where people are expressing opinions at work that are insensitive to or outright disparage another group of people, then getting shocked when they're fired.

If the tide turns, or you live in a country where the reverse tenets are held (e.g. Saudi Arabia), don't be surprised and don't complain if you are fired for saying what you believe then...

It's all par for the course and well as long as the majority or those in control of your job believe that you should have a specific sensitivity, right?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by GVIrish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:34AM (#14978961)
> In short, he said that biological differences (with citations) can explain in the aggregate (not in the total absolute of the population) different preferences, job options, etc., and even suggested ways to change the working environment to alleviate those issues and make it welcome to more personality traits associated statistically with women (as described in citations and statistics he gave).

He is extrapolating from a few pieces of evidence to form the basis of an entire argument about why women are underrepresented while devoting zero time to the role of culture or bias. I think he tried hard to be even-handed but then there's things like, 'Women have higher neuroticism'. He hedges his language a bit by saying biological differences "may in part" explain the gender gap, but then goes on to talk exclusively about biological differences as the cause.

> What kind of person misattributes another with straw-man arguments they didn't say and gloats on their misfortune of being fired?

Who's gloating? I am neither happy or unhappy he got fired. If Google chose not to fire him and instead used this as a teachable moment I wouldn't really have any criticism.

> What he said might or might not be true, but in any case it's no basis for firing someone (as it's not related to their job performance), and it's something that absolutely should be allowed to be debated and studied.

If you say or do something that contravenes the values of your company, it usually is a fireable offense, regardless of job performance. Some people may disagree with Google firing him but ultimately they decide what their culture is. Maybe in this case they've run afoul of California employment laws, but in most at-will employment states people can be fired for any reason or no reason at all.

> The assumption "all sexes/cultures etc are equally predisposed to everything or even if they are not they should be considered as such and nobody should talk about it again" is not a way to have any kind of dialogue.

Eh no. Predispositions is one thing, but when people extrapolate that to say, "This group's abilities or outcomes are different because of biological differences," you're always walking into a minefield. Most serious studies about that stuff stop faarrrr short of making conclusions about career/life outcomes based on genetic behavioral predispositions.

It's not that people can't talk about this stuff, it's that it is very easy to get it wrong. And a lot of people have trouble recognizing that it is easy to get it wrong.

> If the tide turns, or you live in a country where the reverse tenets are held (e.g. Saudi Arabia), don't be surprised and don't complain if you are fired for saying what you believe then...

A. I choose not to live in a monarchy that has capital punishment for minor offenses. B. If what I believe doesn't match the values of a company, I'm either not going to join that company or I'm going to refrain from publishing manifestos on the corporate intranet.

> It's all par for the course and well as long as the majority or those in control of your job believe that you should have a specific sensitivity, right?

It's their company, they can do what they want with it. People are free to not work for them and customers are free to choose another search engine.

Either way, Damore chose to publish this document internally, because he wanted his manifest to have impact. This is not a case of someone minding their own business and getting terminated for expressing an unpopular opinion. He created a real problem internally and Google chose to cut him lose for that. And we don't even know if there were other factors to his firing.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by coldtea on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:45AM (#14980203)
>He is extrapolating from a few pieces of evidence to form the basis of an entire argument about why women are underrepresented while devoting zero time to the role of culture or bias

Well should everybody making an under-representing argument be fired then? Because that's almost everybody, everywhere. How careful should one be? Isn't this a pointer that it's more about the "no touch" subject than about him under-representing in his case?

>I think he tried hard to be even-handed but then there's things like, 'Women have higher neuroticism'

If that's supported by research, should he just push it under the rag because it's inconvenient? (E.g.: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/may/22/women-men-me... ).

>It's not that people can't talk about this stuff, it's that it is very easy to get it wrong. And a lot of people have trouble recognizing that it is easy to get it wrong.

Well, the ability to talk about something also includes the freedom to "get it wrong". They call you for it, give their arguments, and the conversation moves on. If you have to tiptoe on eggshells lest you be fired or beaten up or whatever, then it's just as if you can't talk about this stuff.

The idea about "freedom of speech" as only meaning freedom from persecution from the government is extremely limited, allowing for any powerful employee, media mogul, the dictatorship of the majority, vocal minorities, etc to bully anyone who says something they don't like. Speak should be met with counter-speak and opinions with counter-opinions. Not with firing people, beating them up, hate correspondence, threats and so on.

>B. If what I believe doesn't match the values of a company, I'm either not going to join that company or I'm going to refrain from publishing manifestos on the corporate intranet.

Well, there are people who want to be able to work in a company AND speak their minds. I don't find it inconceivable. And this climate affects both men and women in many aspects.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by maehwasu on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:48AM (#14977737)
"You can say anything you want, unless you're saying something that I choose to define as unacceptable."
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by GVIrish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:11AM (#14977873)
When has that ever not been the case in the workplace? Every workplace has norms and values where someone who runs afoul of them may be fired.

Norms change over time. There was a time when it would've been okay to use the 'n' word to insult black people in many work places, now it's not okay. There was a time when lewd and demeaning talk about women was ok in the workplace, now it's not.

The people who sign the checks have always been able to define what is and is not acceptable in the workplace. Some people are feeling caught out because the line has moved, but it has always been there.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by maehwasu on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:25AM (#14978252)
Completely agree. The point here is that the situation isn't static: many people don't like what is now ok in the workplace, and are trying to shift it back.

Simply calling them "racist" or "sexist" as if that ends the discussion completely misses the point.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by GVIrish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:57AM (#14979127)
Yeah and maybe what needs to happen is people need to talk more about how 'the line' is moving so people can understand better where people are coming from.

I agree that labeling people as racist or sexist for being caught out by shifting norms is not productive, but at the same time people need to put effort into empathizing with others and educating themselves.

There are jokes I would've made 10 years ago I wouldn't make now. There are comments from others that might not have set off any alarms before, but now I know more about why they might be exclusionary or hurtful. Ultimately it's a process.

Which is why maybe a guy like Damore shouldn't be made to run the internet pitchfork and torch gauntlet for what he did. Maybe it could've been a teachable moment instead of a firing. But the other side of that is that I don't know if there were other components to his firing that we haven't heard yet.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by marrs on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:12PM (#14981125)

    I agree that labeling people as racist or sexist for being 
    caught out by shifting norms is not productive, but at the
    same time people need to put effort into empathizing with
    others and educating themselves.
Maybe that cuts both ways
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sheepmullet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:52AM (#14978093)
The difference is senior leadership lying through their teeth about valuing diversity of opinion.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by GVIrish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:05AM (#14979198)
But surely not all opinions are welcome in the workplace. If someone spread a document that said, 'we shouldn't hire muslims because we can't trust their loyalties', surely expressing that opinion would merit firing.

And there's also the question of how opinions are expressed. When you post something publicly for wide distribution, there's much less room to walk things back or to discreetly talk through things. Damore intended for his document to have impact, which it did. But that also means that if the impact is negative it's more likely to lead to his dismissal.

I'm not sure he should have been fired in this case but I can see why it was done.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sheepmullet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:03PM (#14984765)
> If someone spread a document that said, 'we shouldn't hire muslims because we can't trust their loyalties'

That escalated quickly!

I think a closer example is someone saying "I support the trump immigration ban".

With the far left crowd who have been hyped up by the media this causes the same feelings as saying "I want to ban Muslims" and "I hate Muslims".

> And there's also the question of how opinions are expressed.

That's true. I'm not suprised he was fired.

From reading some of the leaked internal posts it looks like there is significant bullying of conservatives.

It doesn't look good for Google. Wage fixing, being investigated for pay gap issues, clearly bully conservatives, etc.

Hopefully a court case can reveal the truth.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by slededit on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:14PM (#14985581)
When you have quotes from key people like Giuliani saying on national TV: “So when [Trump] first announced it, he said, 'Muslim ban.' He called me up. He said, 'Put a commission together. Show me the right way to do it legally.'"

There is strong evidence the immigration ban is targeted at Muslims. If it weren't for quotes like that Trump wouldn't have had an issue with the courts.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Chris2048 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:12AM (#14978832)
> When has that ever not been the case in the workplace

In progressive companies like google.

> There was a time when

And it changed because the public became outraged over it, and individuals concerned fought back with social and legal options. Same may happen here too.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by christophilus on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:53AM (#14979100)
As I understand it, this is a misrepresentation. He did not say they were biologically unsuited for it. If I could rephrase in my own words, I'd say that the evidence shows that people who tend to be good at both language and the sciences will lean towards more social career paths. Women are unlike men in that they tend to be good at both where men tend to be lopsided: e.g. much better at math than English, say. This is not saying that women are unsuited for science. Quite the opposite. It is saying that women who are suited for STEM are more likely to also be well suited to more social endeavors, and thus less likely to choose STEM than the typical man who is well suited for STEM. The memo, I think, was essentially saying: "Thus if we want to attract more women to engineering, we need to appeal to the non-STEM side of the spectrum."
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by tryingagainbro on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:56AM (#14979668)
Of course they'll shut up for fear of losing their job and the means to support their family.

Totally agree, but it was like this. Religion and politics never mixed while working, outside a small circle of friends. Even then, if one was "offended" and complained, you'd be screwed.

But Google did the right thing--if you ask 100 top corp lawyers, advisors and politicians. Better to fire a guy than having to deal with the wrath of the side currently winning the debate. In the end Google is there to make money for its shareholders: not to advance workplace free speech or to deliver the most useful results for its users.

Google will probable spend a few million to fight and then settle this case. It will feel like losing a dime to the average person.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jondubois on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:07AM (#14978805)
Suppression of free speech is the most dangerous - Eventually people reach a breaking point and then they snap all at once. I think that is a cause of extremely violent events like WW2 and most revolutions. Oppressed people start quietly labelling who their enemies are (often without proper justification) and wait for consensus to build.

After this, although I disagree with the engineer, I don't think that Google is the kind of company I would want to work for.

This event is eerily reminiscent of a comment I made on HN 2 months ago about big corporations and suppression of free speech (see last line): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14527934

I think that if these companies get too big and keep suppressing free speech, eventually they will get mutinied from the inside.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by falcolas on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:43AM (#14979530)
I'm not sure any mutiny will have a chance of survival, for one simple reason - too many people want to work for those companies, even if only to have that company on their resume.

If a mutiny did occur, all the company would need to do is fire the loudest voices in the name of diversity, let the rest quit quietly, and replace them with the millions still banging at the doors to get in. You'd need someone at a C level solidly on your side for a mutiny to succeed, and you don't usually get to a career C level by having strong ideological stances (aside from, perhaps, a strong love of capitalism and how it lines your pockets).

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by manicdee on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:19AM (#14977527)
That's a gross oversimplification of the issue.

Would the same outcome have happened if this guy had posted his manifesto on a blog outside the office, rather than distributing it to colleagues at work?

Would the same outcome have happened if the various arguments in the manifesto had been individual articles on a personal blog over a period of time?

Would the same outcome have happened if the manifesto hadn't been explicitly critical about diversity hiring at Google, and rather had been generally critical about EEO law at the state and federal level?

There are so many ways this situation could have been different, but the lesson you choose to take from it is "don't express your opinion in public"? That's what really explains Trump.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by dictum on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:49AM (#14978073)
> Would the same outcome have happened if this guy had posted his manifesto on a blog outside the office, rather than distributing it to colleagues at work?

Yes.

The only thing that could have prevented his firing was to have never published it under his real name (and this is not completely safe).

Since it's an internal issue, I think he did the right thing in this aspect: he published it in the internal forum, instead of dragging the dirty laundry for the world to see.

Most codes of conduct explictly apply all their conditions to venues that are not related to the project itself, so I doubt the outrage would be different if he published it elsewhere, under a pseudonym, and was IDed later.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ordu on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:55AM (#14978746)
> That's a gross oversimplification of the issue.

It is the way most people think. The only way of thinking available for them. So this conclusions is exactly what they draw from the story.

> the lesson you choose to take from it is "don't express your opinion in public"? That's what really explains Trump.

I'm not sure that Const-me took _this_ lesson, but the point is: the most people took this lesson. The reality works this way. Therefore this lesson is the true one, it is like self-fulfilling prophecy. If enough people belive in it, than it is true.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by minipci1321 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:07AM (#14977843)
Didn't read his memo, am not interested in the debate, and am not saying he should be fired or kept.

That said, I'd think that he was fired not because of his opinions, but because he seems to have done an irreparable damage to Google's image: for good or bad reasons, people will react strongly and negatively to the publication of his memo, and whatever Google does -- keeps him or lets him go -- this negative impact will stick.

EDIT: many, many people will react negatively.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by humanrebar on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:10AM (#14978817)
> ...he seems to have done an irreparable damage to Google's image...

1. From my perspective, the firing was more damaging to Google's reputation than anything in the article. People still remember the Eich incident with bad feelings for Mozilla. This one is actually worse because there's no "CEOs are PR officers" reasoning to fall back on. If there's still damage when the dust settles here, it will be due to blowback originating from people who misunderstood the text or don't care that it's basically misunderstood. That's my next point.

2. It's becoming more apparent to me that a large portion of the outrage is due to a misunderstanding of the text. I suspect that people haven't actually read the text, not really. The concrete objection I notice the most ("he said that female engineers are inferior") is not true and directly addressed in the text. There are comments in this thread that are misunderstanding or uninformed about what he wrote about overlapping distribution curves.

3. With that in mind, I can't tell if Google leadership is having a reading comprehension issue, a problem understanding statistics, or if they are making a purely political/PR decision here. None of those situations should make a Google engineer confident in their leadership.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by peoplewindow on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:12AM (#14978183)
The memo wasn't published. It was leaked. Whoever leaked it is the one who damaged Google's reputation. They then damaged it more when they claimed they respect diversity and then fired the guy in response to mob outrage.

The damage to Google's reputation here is on them. Almost by definition.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by minipci1321 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:53AM (#14979102)
You are correct, but letting this outside is only the first item on the list of consequences. Next comes -- many, many people inside Google probably stopped working productively and are still absorbing-the-shock/digesting/battling/persuading/discussing/ruminating-alone -- again, for good or bad reasons, but many of them. The leaker didn't do that.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by syshum on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:34AM (#14978003)
>> but because he seems to have done an irreparable damage to Google's image

The same can be said for the firing, it is also doing irreparable damage to Google's image, likely more so than the publication of the memo

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by virtualized on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:53AM (#14978730)
Google could have published a letter that addresses the issues mentioned in the leaked memo in a diplomatic way without firing anyone. Google's immature reaction damaged the perception of the diversity ideology instead of defending it.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by dandare on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:00AM (#14977421)
I totally agree, this will add tons of ammunition to all kinds of sexists, racists and extremists. Damore made several well sourced arguments that you are welcome to disagree with. But instead of discussion, counter arguments and "embracing diversity" he was silenced and probably illegally sacked. This will strengthen the position of all kind of haters and populists and if you think it's not a big deal, yes, go and check who is your president.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:35AM (#14977027)
We'll see how the trend moves going forward, but even after capturing (by rhetoric if not act) the white house, the alt-right continues to be a radical fringe, and suffers from serious internal contradictions that make any serious movement building doomed. The movement has attracted the attention of a lot of white nationalists, anti-semites and hardline fascists (amren, natall, kss), while also attracting a new wave of online-prominent trolls and shit-stirrers.

But what happens when the 4chan poster with the anime pillow who denies the holocaust just to get a rise out of the libcucks crosses paths with an actual hardline anti-semite who is interested in building an even-more-final solution?

To use a colloquialism, what happens when the rubber meets the road? Do the fascists tolerate what they would consider to be total degeneracy for the sake of finally building a mass movement? Does the online troll recognize that what was an ironic joke for him is a hard reality for others, and move to push their real-life activism away from those types of groups?

This is what I mean by internal contradictions, the kind that can kill a mass movement before it even starts.

So while there is a common refrain of "this is why Trump won, and the movement of contrarians, devils advocates, trolls, anti-pc crusaders, people who tweet about white genocide, stormfront regulars and conspiracy theorists is only going to grow if you being offensive towards them", the reality is much, much more complicated.

Trust in Trump has plummeted, even amongst his core. The vote is very quickly slipping out of the grasp of the Right, and was always a race against time demographically to begin with. And if you're in a position where you can't win through democratic means, you have to use other means (boycotts, protests, organizing, etc). And the alt-right is utterly lamed by it's own hand before that race has even started.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rufus_2 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:20AM (#14977211)
> Trust in Trump has plummeted, even amongst his core. The vote is very quickly slipping out of the grasp of the Right

This is certainly the message being broadcast into every home on the planet for the last 6 moths. In reality it seems a bit optimistic when we consider the Democrats are coming from a decade-long losing streak (http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2015/jan/25/...), a monumentally embarrassing, record cost $1.2B failed 2016 Presidential campaign (http://nypost.com/2016/12/09/hillary-clintons-losing-campaig...), and following these up by going 0-6 in federal elections (http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2017/06/21/georgia-special-e...) leaving them with their lowest representation in American government since the 1920's (http://www.npr.org/2016/03/04/469052020/the-democratic-party...).

I think it's pretty safe to say that the American leftist revolution is _not_ right around the corner.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mathw on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:35AM (#14977285)
Indeed but I think a lot of leftists would be very happy just to get rid of Trump. A right-wing government with a President who displays any kind of understanding of diplomacy, international politics and everyday reality would be an improvement.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rufus_2 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:59AM (#14980360)
I fear what Trump would be replaced with if the establishment GOP and Democrats actually managed to oust him.

The environment that catalyzed Trump's rise to power has not changed - if anything, it has intensified.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:43AM (#14977331)
Right now, we have two indicators: The way the swings on the special elections are going, which are all violently swinging away from the Republicans, even if Republicans end up winning, it's barely by single digits in double digit districts.

And the polling, which in aggregate, across all demographics, has been continually moving more and more negative each passing month. Even polls like Rasmussen, which have a traditional right-wing bias, have shown a consistent drop in support.

Metrics like the ones you mentioned aren't useful as predictors. Yes, the Democrats spent a lot of money. So did the Republicans. Big money elections are the norm now, and each election has a loser.

Your reference to losing special elections only tells half the story. These are races that should have been as safe as safe can be. That's why they're special elections, because when Presidents make appointments, they only tend to choose people from their party who are in such safe districts that they can easily be replaced. Often-times, the national party doesn't even send monetary support to these special elections, because they're re-won so handily.

Take Ossoff's challenge in Georgia. He lost by 4 points in a district that went for Trump by 19 points. Moreover, the Republicans were required to spend $25 million in order to defend a seat that they had most likely budgeted around $0 for. That's what's called a weathervane. Or a canary in a coal mine.

Even further down this rabbit hole, the 0-6 loss article is from June. Since then, we've had Phil Miller win by 9 points in a district that Trump won by 21 points, which means that's a 30 point swing! We also have Kevin Cavanaugh winning by 23.4 points in a district that Clinton only won by 0.1 points. There's also been sweeps of state legislatures in traditionally VERY deep red states such as Oklahoma.

Every single trend points to a very difficult 2018 for the Republicans, and an especially difficult 2020.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by akvadrako on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:01AM (#14978134)
This is a nice debate topic, because we'll have a clear cut answer next year. If you truly believe there is at least a 50% chance of Democrats controlling the house or 20% chance in the senate, you can make some easy money:

house: https://www.predictit.org/Market/2704/Which-party-will-contr...

senate: https://www.predictit.org/Market/2703/Which-party-will-contr...

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rtx on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:40AM (#14978653)
Here is something that will explain what happened. Though it may disappoint you.

Ossoff got 125,517 votes Handel got 134,799 votes.

Compare

Dem - 124,917 Rep - 201,088

As you see there was no swing in Dem's favour.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rtx on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:27AM (#14980646)
The second stat is from 2016 elections.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:40AM (#14980769)
You know, people think elections are about convincing one side to switch over to the other. That's actually not how swings occur. They happen by people deciding to stay home or come out.

A special election is a hard sell. Democrats sold it. Republicans didn't.

Mid-term elections are also hard sells. We'll see who can sell it.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by flukus on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:20AM (#14977541)
> Take Ossoff's challenge in Georgia. He lost by 4 points in a district that went for Trump by 19 points. Moreover, the Republicans were required to spend $25 million in order to defend a seat that they had most likely budgeted around $0 for. That's what's called a weathervane. Or a canary in a coal mine.

Isn't that normal? In Australia these sorts of elections usually swing heavily against the government of the day but are very poor predictions of what will happen at a general election. Is this not the norm in America?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:25AM (#14977570)
For mid-term elections, yes, they usually swing against the party in power. The extent to which they swing varies wildly, though, so all we know is that there likes will be a traditional anti-establishment swing, but the magnitude of it is unknown.

However, a special election within the months after a Presidential election should follow the same results, since there hasn't been the time to build the resentment necessary for a significant change in voting patterns. That, however, has not been the case with the Trump presidency.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by flukus on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:47AM (#14977735)
That mirrors our experience after the 2013 federal election, the fell hard and fast but changed the leader and still snuck through at the last general election.

We've also seen the trend at state level for the last few years, it seems swings are coming harder and faster.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by generic_user on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:47AM (#14977729)
I think this this is the talking points for the Democrats but its not very convincing.

> The way the swings on the special elections are going, which are all violently swinging away from the Republicans.

The Republicans won all 6 special elections.

> Take Ossoff's challenge in Georgia. He lost by 4 points > the Republicans were required to spend $25 million

He lost. And it was the Democrats who spent $23 Million (the most ever spent) on the election not the Republicans. The republicans spent like $3 Million dollars.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:01AM (#14977810)
> The Republicans won all 6 special elections.

By slim margins in what should have been extremely safe districts.

Then they lost the next 2, one of which by way a 30 point swing.

The swing is not something you can hand-wave away. It's one of the best metrics we have as a predictor for 2018.

> The republicans spent like $3 Million dollars.

Estimates on how much was spent on the election range from $40-$60 million.

$23 million is the amount of fundraising that was done by Ossoff's campaign, independent of the DCCC or traditional DNC PACs, which means none of it came from their "warchest". The DCCC provided an additional $5 million of TV ad spends in Ossoff's favor.

On the Republican side, they spent way more than $3 million. The NRCC spent about $6.7 million on TV ad spends. Paul Ryan's SuperPAC spent about $5 million on airtime and $2 million on additional costs. Two other conservative PACs raised an additional $1 million.

https://www.issueone.org/money-behind-expensive-u-s-house-ra...

The breakdown is very complicated, because money can come in from dozens of different types of sources, and the numbers aren't usually finalized until long after the election ends.

The $23 million figure, however, was mostly crowd-sourced in small donations. So to be very clear, you can say that came from citizens who identify as Democrats and be generally right, but to say it came from Democrats as an organization or a political entity, that is not correct.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by supremesaboteur on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:53AM (#14978735)
Democrats spent a lot more money on these races and were still not able to win. This is clearly a problem for them. The swing in margins can be explained by the fact that the President's party mostly always loses some points
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:41AM (#14980781)
> the President's party mostly always loses some points

Not in the double digits, they don't. And not in special elections shortly into the first year of the Presidency, especially.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Const-me on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:17AM (#14977199)
Very likely you’re right about the current state of alt right movement (I live in Europe and haven’t been monitoring the subject).

But GP only mentioned alt-rights as an example of where might the voters turn their preferences.

Even at Google where James worked, many employees agree with his memo (36%), and the majority, 54% of them think the memo is harmless and was OK to share: https://basicgestalt.wordpress.com/2017/08/06/press-f-for-ja...

After Google fired him, these 54% will inevitably think about what other ideas they think are harmless might cause them to be fired. Not exactly comforting thoughts.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:47AM (#14977355)
For the life of me, I cannot find a legitimate source for that poll. I see the image popping up on a lot of less-than-reputable websites (wordpress blogs, tweets, businessinsider, etc) but no actual source for it, let alone any idea of its methodology.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by panda88888 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:59AM (#14977417)
Since it's allegedly Google internal poll, you probably won't find more information on it beyond screenshot. After what happened to Damore and calls for his supporters to be fired as well, most people are probably clamming up now.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:01AM (#14977425)
I can't say that inspires confidence that the poll is even legitimate. Do we at least have proof that it actually was an internal Google poll and not someone's 15 minutes in photoshop?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:50AM (#14978077)
Assuming it was legitimate, 282 self-selected responses from a company with tens of thousands of employees wouldn't pass even the most basic "is this poll statistically valid?" test.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TezlaOil on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:29PM (#14985663)
> wouldn't pass even the most basic "is this poll statistically valid?" test

It totally would. Statistically, a sample size of 282 out of a population of 60000 is pretty good.

If this test was authentic, we would be 95% sure that the true percentage of the population who think that the memo is harmless is between 47% and 60%.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:50AM (#14988040)
Presumably that would require a population-representative sample of 282 though, not a self-selected (and therefore potentially biased) sample.

Otherwise you could run a poll "Who thinks [minority] should leave the USA?", get a high "yes" response, say "THE POPULACE AGREE!" but then discover only racists/whatever have replied because Breitbart/4chan dogpiled the poll - which would make it 100% invalid, no?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Const-me on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:30AM (#14977601)
No, we don’t have that proof.

However, the design matches the defaults of google forms, exact colors and their sequence, too: http://imgur.com/WPC0ogZ

Also the header says "gd-jpeg v1.0", it’s a cross platform open source C library with bindings for all modern programming languages including Go and Python: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GD_Graphics_Library

Even if that’s a fake, it’s a good one.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:43AM (#14977691)
I mean, GD has been around for over 20 years. It's not obscure. It's extremely popular. Most coders have used it at some point.

I could whip upa similar graph without breaking a sweat that says whatever I'd like, and it would have all the same hallmarks of this one. I could even do it in PHP using ImageMagick (if I felt masochistic) and fake the file header to say it was created using GD. Or build it in photoshop, and pull it into a binary editor.

So I think unless there's someone who can point to greater evidence that this is an internal graph, there's just no reason to believe it is.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by yorwba on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:11AM (#14978180)
> So I think unless there's someone who can point to greater evidence that this is an internal graph, there's just no reason to believe it is.

So I think unless there's someone who can point to the actual internal graph, there's just no reason to believe this is fake.

The distribution this poll shows is not so outlandish as to be unbelievable, and importantly it does not lend itself to overwhelmingly support one side over the other. Why would anyone spend time and effort to fake it?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:39AM (#14980758)
> Why would anyone spend time and effort to fake it?

It's a heated argument on the internet. There'd be plenty of incentive to fake a graph in order to bolster one's opinion.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by yorwba on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:03PM (#14981018)
My point is that if you are going to fake a graph to bolster your opinion, you might as well fake one that actually bolsters your opinion, instead of just mildly suggesting that not everyone disagrees with you.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:49PM (#14982865)
I'm really disappointed we're even having this conversation on Hacker News. A graph with no source, no methodology, no context is useless. We're computer programmers, we should know enough about data to recognize this and dismiss it until we have those things.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by cm2187 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:27AM (#14977579)
I am not sure I get your objection. It's like saying that Clinton couldn't win the election because she had far-left/communist sympathisers. I am sure she did. And I am also sure these were a marginal portion of her electoral base. I don't see how these extremists would stand in the way of a broader movement.

I am not bullish on Trump long term, but not because some extremists also support him, but because of his own randomness and inability to get things done in Washington.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:38AM (#14977644)
It might be important I clarify that I'm not talking about the right, I'm talking about the far right (re-branded as the "alt-right"). This does not include most people who vote Republican or consider themselves traditional conservatives.

The traditional conservative movement is dying out. Quite literally, it has a demographic problem that it is not sure how to resolve. In it's place, you have the alt-right, which does tend to be more youthful, but which acts as an umbrella for a wide variety of extremist viewpoints, everything from extreme libertarianism to conspiracy theorists to white nationalism to single-issue anti-islamic advocates and a whole host of others. And within that milieu, a large proportion of people are not singularly committed to those hard-right ideologies as much as they define themselves solely in their rejection of liberalism, the left, or social justice. The result is a whole host of confusion. The alt-right is constantly infighting about cultural issues such as traditional masculinity or gay rights, to the difference between opposition to illegal immigration (a viewpoint which can claim to be more centrist) or opposing immigration altogether, including legal (which is held by the nationalist wing of the movement).

As the voting base disappears, these groups will have to figure out how to grow their movement, make political demands, maintain a presence without burning out, etc. Just like all movements do. But that's exactly where those intense internal divisions come in and wreak havoc.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sheepmullet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:34AM (#14978300)
I don't think so.

The alt-right is not constantly infighting.

The left are more likely to devolve into infighting.

This google guy was moderate left wing and the hard line social justice response from Google and the media will alienate a lot more of the intellectual left.

Hispanics and African Americans often lean socially conservative.

Gay men are a lot more fiscally conservative than you might think.

None of those groups identify with single white woman.

Etc etc.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:52AM (#14978728)
"This google guy" was a self-declared conservative, and mentioned cultural marxism, an alt-right touchstone, in the very memo that is being discussed.

His first interviews were with alt-right Youtube channels.

I agree with your points about lots of minority groups being socially (and/or fiscally) conservative. It's lucky for the left that the white social conservatives have been driving them away consistently for decades.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sheepmullet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:32AM (#14978949)
Certainly a conservative compared to his coworkers.

I'd argue he is still left of center.

He is just interviewing with the groups who will give him a fair go.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TheAceOfHearts on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:45AM (#14979548)
Jordan Peterson is alt-right?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:12AM (#14979856)
I'd never heard of him till yesterday, when I read a comment where he replied to one of his fans who wanted to form a breakaway state so his children could be raised only among their own ethnicity, and his reply was (paraphrasing from memory, but it was a weird enough answer that it kind of stuck) "Strengthen your soul to achieve your political goals".

So yeah he's definitely in that general area.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by cm2187 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:59AM (#14977792)
Ok, but agreeing with the infamous memo doesn't make someone a far right extremist. The parent comment suggested it will push them to vote for a harder-line movement but there is a big margin between being opposed to affirmative action and white supremacists.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:04AM (#14977824)
I absolutely agree that agreeing with the memo doesn't make someone a far right extremist, and I don't believe I ever stated or insinuated that. That's a bit of a non-sequitur, though. This is the exact point I was referring to:

they won't change their position. If anything, their position will be radicalized. For example, from classical liberal to alt-right.

This is been a common sort of mantra since Trump won the presidency. Whenever we have a controversial event like this, people make a statement that any actions by those on the left will only further radicalize people in the other direction. I don't think it's true, but most of all, I don't think that other direction really leads anywhere useful. For the reasons I outlined previously.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by tiogemini on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:56AM (#14978112)
Do you think the author will be radicalized? When I try to empathize with Damore the alt-right looks welcoming while liberals look very unwelcoming. I could see myself being drawn towards the group that accepts me (or doesn't attack me). That's the process that I assumed from the radicalization idea. Have I missed the mark?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by michaelchisari on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:45AM (#14980817)
> the alt-right looks welcoming

Superficially at most. When you go to some of the most popular alt-right facebook pages, and you see caricatures of Jews and whole racial groups consistently disparaged and stereotyped, and when you see just how many people posting in them have cross-interests with white supremacist and misogynist movements, you realize that "welcoming" is a very, very narrow term.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by xapata on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:09AM (#14978813)
He was alt-right to begin with.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Chris2048 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:17AM (#14978862)
> But what happens when the 4chan poster with the anime pillow who denies the holocaust just to get a rise out of the libcucks crosses paths with an actual hardline anti-semite who is interested in building an even-more-final solution?

Sounds like an amazing sit-com. Stay tuned, folks!

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by norea-armozel on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:27AM (#14980001)
Honest question, do you really think that their opinions weren't already extreme in light of the fact that the science on the differences between the sexes (and the races, tangentially) aren't significant enough to define hiring practices? I ask because I think we're seeing not a backlash from corporations because they're anti-science but because they're anti-scientism. We've had two centuries of science being misused to excuse unscientific policies in law and even corporate policy (and to some extent we still do this). Google, in my opinion, is right to ignore the science on the differences between groups of people because the science at this point speaks very broad terms and worse still it doesn't define social and moral goods. Science is good at describing a thing but not describing what should be done with the thing it describes, that's for philosophers, law makers, and preachers to do. And folks like Damore fall into the tar pit of scientism where they try to describe concepts of morality and philosophy in disguise when they claim they describe things in terms of a science. There's nothing scientific about fairness. It's just something we feel is fair in a given era. A century ago giving women an equal say in society whether by vote or employment would've been seen as unfair. Today? It's totally fair and expected. How that changed I won't go into but the fact is the change occurred independent of science (as it should). Science works best when it attempts to be as value free as possible. But hiring practices aren't in the sphere of science and Damore should have known this well before he wrote his letter. He should've focused on fairness and defined fairness in scope of being an employee (potential and actual). That way his point might've been accepted because at the end of his letter he spells it out as a matter of judging people on individual ability. So the rest of his letter is actually useless and hides that important point he made. All because he got caught in the trap of scientism.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by archagon on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:18AM (#14978212)
I find it disturbing that somebody would even consider switching to the alt-right over this. Do people not have deeply-held beliefs anymore? Personally, that is a line that I would never, under any circumstance, cross, even if I was the one who got fired and blacklisted. It is a non-negotiable position.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by beobab on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:08AM (#14978463)
You are right to find it disturbing. It is disturbing. Once it becomes dangerous to express your ideas, then people with contrary ideas will either be crushed or rebellious.

There is a stupendously thin line between a sane person and an insane one. It is possible to break minds, and the vitriol that can be poured out from the depths of the internet is quite sufficient to break the typical human being. Some people start off closer to the edge than others.

I'm glad I do not know the true extent of the outrage that this subject has unleashed, but I'll wager it includes credible death threats considering the size of the audience that it has reached.

If you pour hate over something long enough, it will bear fruit.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by protomyth on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:12AM (#14978829)
It’s not that someone would switch to the alt-right, it’s that the definition of belief is moving the line so others are defining you as alt-right. As an example, Ben Shapiro is by statements and beliefs not alt-right. He was attacked by them quite a bit. Yet, people have started calling him alt-right in media and forums.

I too would never cross that line, but I believe others will be happy to redraw that line regardless of my actual beliefs. This is what happens when others can slap labels on you and there is no real debate.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by eregorn on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:41AM (#14979496)
I feel like this happened because it seems he accidentally presented himself to the outside world as alt-right. You'd only know he was a right libertarian (my impression at least) if you regularly listened to him.

For example, Look at his Wikipedia article vs his /r/politics AMA. His Wikipedia article paints him as alt-right, because all of his major accomplishments that reach outside the audience are hyper-focused on culture wars and academia influence on politics. His support of Israel was mentioned, but he did flip to an alt-right acceptable view. The only thing suggesting on the wiki page he's not alt right is not supporting Trump, but it doesn't help that its implied they mostly attacked him for being Jewish.

From that alone I would think it was a Milo situation, where they are alt-right that are unaccepted by the "alt-reich" because of a specific character trait.

The AMA however gave me the idea he's right libertarian. A lot of his answers seem to circle back to the free market. His pro-life opinion is even a slight extension of that, where he believes life needs to be guaranteed to at least participate in the market. This, however, required direct drilling of the guy to actually get.

So TLDR, He talks libertarian, but his noticeable acts are alt-right. I think this is a bit his fault, considering he didn't think to advertise his libertarian ideas at all in books or speeches even though he started his career before he even graduated college.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by protomyth on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:28PM (#14981323)
> I feel like this happened because it seems he accidentally presented himself to the outside world as alt-right.

I would love for you to find one place Ben Shapiro presents as alt-right.

> His Wikipedia article paints him as alt-right

of course it does, Conservatives of all stripes have been complaining about the bias of Wikipedia for some time. It paints anyone who is sorta conservative as alt-right.

If you believe he acts "alt-right" then pretty much every libertarian is alt-right, and that's just wrong.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by eregorn on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:19PM (#14981895)
You can complain about Wikipedia, but you missed the point of me mentioning it. Here's a question I want answered because otherwise he might as well present as such:

Do you think the Wikipedia page is missing anything important he's done? Specifically anything of note that has to do with the free market.

Otherwise, its basically a "just one goat" situation, except he done like 7 goats. the day to day things are just not gonna stick out as much as the big things so what he says on his podcast isn't enough to change that perception.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by protomyth on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:17PM (#14982529)
I am trying to figure out what exactly he has done to make him alt-right since they attack him constantly.

From the Wikipedia page: > n May 2016 New York Magazine reported: "Shapiro...has increasingly found himself targeted by the so-called alt-right movement, a loose conglomeration of online personalities—many if not most of them anonymous—currently devoted to tweeting and posting their support for Donald Trump and attacking those who disagree, often in racist and anti-Semitic ways. They have been denigrating Shapiro as a 'pussy', a 'cuck', a 'Jew' and a 'kike'."[54]

He supports Israel which actually isn't an alt-right thing.

I'm trying to find what in that article makes him alt-right.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by eregorn on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:05PM (#14983610)
Welp, I made a mistake. He's had multiple opinions on Israel, and he's currently pro-Israel at the moment, this was the offending quote:

"A decade later, however, Shapiro reversed his position. In an article published on March 13, 2013, Shapiro wrote, "Some on the right have proposed population transfer from the Gaza Strip or West Bank as a solution. This is both inhumane and impractical. Moving millions of Palestinians out of areas they have known for their entire lives will certainly not pave the way to peace" and while "both right and left agree that a population separation is necessary," he proposes that Israel "has no choice but to weather [the anti-Israeli propaganda]" until a realistic solution comes to light.[37]"

This however was followed by the UCLA section which I misunderstood. Either way, I don't think there's much point on focusing on Israel. The Don himself is probably more pro-Israel than he is. Opinions like that are less identifying of alt right and more as weapons to be used when the alt reich feel betrayed.

That mistake is also why I'm forgiving you on the whole being attacked by the alt right. I've already said why that doesn't matter, it was also in the paragraph right after that one: "I've experienced more pure, unadulterated anti-Semitism since coming out against Trump's candidacy than at any other time in my political career". If he was alt-right he wouldn't be the first to be turned on like with Milo and the Daily Stormer.

I think there's something I need to clarify here. Another poster here posted how alt right means Nazi now. I DONT believe that, and if you may notice I prefer to say Reich for the Nazi side. I see the alt right as someone who has taken to the right socially, possibly being opposites with libertarians with left economics, but are not evangelicals because they're a revolt on social justice (not against it, but specifically a "what about us?") and, most important here, the reaction to such opinions by colleges, news, and businesses. Also, please remember my second comment before you bring up Wikipedia's own article on the alt right.

Which makes the whole discussion a bit funny but confusing. The guy is definitely alt right, despite what everyone's saying here. A bunch of people here are alt right too but, again, don't want to say so. What happened is history has repeated itself as alt right is to alt reich/Nazi as liberal was to socialism/communism.

It doesn't actually matter in the end how I separate them in the end. Much like the mere mention of redistribution was likened to communism, The fact that alt right can be fiscally left has been taken advantage of to frame everything they believe as Nazi under a simplistic understanding of it. The end result is people seeing a thing as alt right, even if they define it differently somehow.

I'd recommend not replying to this comment as quickly as the last, it had to be long to clarify myself and I won't read the reply till tomorrow anyway.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by protomyth on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:25PM (#14983836)
I'm not bringing up Wikipedia or anything else. I am going to one of the main alt-right people to define their beliefs and membership[0].

Vox Day is alt-right. That probably is not a controversial statement to anyone. I would assume that he knows who is alt-right and who is not. Given that he wrote an article[2] that declares Ben Shapiro and enemy of the alt-right and later tries to classify Mr. Shapiro[3], I am given to believe being someones enemy is a pretty good sign that you are not that same someone.

I think you desperately want to classify Ben Shapiro as alt-right for some weird reason. I would assume so you can ignore any argument he puts forward with a cheap label.

0) having to read some of this stuff to actually reply is truly painful and frankly its bad enough I have to read far left stuff, reading alt-right stuff is just as painful.

1) https://infogalactic.com/info/Vox_Day

2) http://voxday.blogspot.com/2016/03/an-enemy-of-alt-right.htm...

3) https://voxday.blogspot.com/2016/04/does-ben-shapiro-belong-...

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by eregorn on Friday August 11, 2017 @08:33AM (#14988968)
I think you completely misunderstand me. A bit my fault cause I usually plan out how I argue and I honestly did not expect this type of questioning. I'll reiterate my first comment in that I know the guy's libertarian (I think, definitely not alt right)?

I mean shit, this whole argument has nothing to do with whether I want to listen to his arguments. It was an explanation of how silly things like this happen in the first place where a libertarian gets confused for an alt right person.

Maybe the goat metaphor wasn't the best thing to go for, since the goat lover is an actual goat lover regardless of the other things he does. Maybe framed 7 times with a goat makes more sense? Maybe plain words are better: He's advertised the things people consider alt right, but not the things about him that prove he isn't. The actual alt right notice these discrepancies regardless and correctly identify him.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by protomyth on Friday August 11, 2017 @10:37AM (#14990041)
I'll point out how you started this thread:

> I feel like this happened because it seems he accidentally presented himself to the outside world as alt-right.

Through all this, I still don't understand what you think he did to "present" himself as alt-right? I really hate when people put labels on others just to be able to dismiss them and calling someone alt-right should be backed up with a little bit of evidence.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by eregorn on Friday August 11, 2017 @12:53PM (#14991823)
I hinted it earlier, but if you insist:

The books except the one about presidents (which seems to be just history) and the Iraq war piece (which was in the tail end of being career-ending if you criticized), the organization he co-founded, and the speeches he's done that aren't about Israel.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by protomyth on Friday August 11, 2017 @03:25PM (#14993307)
So, nothing actually specific just a list without any examples.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by throwanem on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:05AM (#14979205)
"Alt-right" means "Nazi" now. It didn't always. Somebody dragged Richard Spencer out from whatever rock he lives under and into the public eye, specifically for the purpose of changing that meaning - or, as you have it, moving that line.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by archagon on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:34AM (#14979445)
Really? From Wikipedia:

"Spencer and others have said that he created the term 'alt-right', which he considers a movement about white identity. Breitbart News described Spencer's website AlternativeRight.com as 'a center of alt-right thought.'"

This matches with what I know. White supremacy was also featured prominently in the sidebar of /r/altright before it was banned.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by throwanem on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:50AM (#14980258)
Really.

I mean, Spencer says a lot of things. Do you believe all of them, or only the ones you find convenient? And the same Breitbart article [1] quoted there also devotes an entire section to disposing of the three dozen or so legit would-be Nazis on the fringe.

Of course, that Breitbart article also dates from March 2016. Spencer didn't hit the big time for quite a few months after that - not, in fact, until just after the election [2], whereas "alt-right" in general had never really left the zeitgeist after its first big splash in August. But that changed when the media made Spencer its darling, because of course it did - the man is eminently hateable, which is precisely why he was made so notorious so fast.

[1] http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2016/03/29/an-establishment-co...

[2] https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=2015-01-01%202...

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by speeder on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:24AM (#14979973)
This one I can reply:

I am someone that don't like feminism (but I won't discuss that now).

My political position is kinda anti-authoritarian, and I don't trust corporations, early on my life it was considered left, people would call me anarquist or socialist.

After a while people started to call me liberal, libertarian and minarquist, and call me "right"

And now with the popularity of the term alt-right, I get called alt-right too.

-----

That was one way to 'become' alt-right, I know another one, sadly a really bad way...

I visit sometimes some anti-feminist forums and whatnot, and I see there LOTS of seething rage, people that have a deep raging hatred against feminism and women. (and if you visit 8chan for example, or voat, you see open racism, anti-religion, etc...)

One day someone made the brilliant decision to create in one such forum a thread where people ended discussing their personal lives... Every single "raging" person were deeply screwed in the past, for example one guy that hated all women were raped when he was a teenager, and when he sought help, people refused, when he sought help from a women shelter, he got raped again. Another guy was being forced to pay for child support for a child that wasn't his, another one had the opposite problem: his ex-wife was a drug addict that cheated on him with a lawyer, the couple took custody of his kids, and made a motion prohibiting both visits and child support, all that he wanted was pay for child support and for his kids to know he cares about them, so that they don't believe he was the one that fled the marriage. Another guy there was in prison for several years due to a false rape accusation, when people found out the accusation was false, he was released, but he still can't find any jobs, and the accuser wasn't punished. And the list goes and goes and goes on... lots of extremely sad stories, it became clear why you can't reason with those people, they had traumas that in a way 'prove' that moderate points of view were wrong, and that only their extremist views (for example raped guy defended that all women should be literally enslaved and used by the state only for breeding and nothing else), can protect them and others from the same fate.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Vaskivo on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:18PM (#14981882)
I believe there are two important reasons two to listen to people with opposing or extreme positions.

1 - Those oppinions _may_ have a single grain of truth. And, as reasonable beings, we cannot allow that truth to be buried or silenced.

2 - Regardless os the validity or truthfullness of that opinion, we should try to understand _why_ that person holds those opinions. This helps us understand why and how some ideas and opinions still persist to this day.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by AnimalMuppet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:25PM (#14981945)
Re 2: And maybe how to explain it to them in a way that can make them actually reconsider.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by humanrebar on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:16AM (#14978856)
> I find it disturbing that somebody would even consider switching to the alt-right over this.

It's logic too cynical for me, but it's basically:

1. OK. They decide this culture war out there is serious and nobody is looking out for them.

2. They find "their" camp and support it.

3 (sometimes). After switching/limiting media sources to match new political assumptions, opposing views seem more malicious and more unhinged.

It's worth noting that a lot of the blowback from this incident is due to #3 happening for a different group of people.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Chris2048 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:15AM (#14978846)
I notice that there appears to be a competing definition of "alt-right". One is the age-old white supremacist groups that pre-existed Trump et al. The other is Milo and right-leaning you-tubers etc. I think there might be some confusion over this.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jshevek on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:04PM (#14982995)
> But they won't change their position. If anything, their position will be radicalized. For example, from classical liberal to alt-right.

You make an excellent point. I am a lifelong feminist, anti-racist, pro-LBTQ atheist who passionately desires a fair, just, egalitarian world.

In the last three years I've discovered: Many conservatives actually share my fundamental values, and do so with more integrity than most liberals I have known.

I seek out honest, rational, factual people to listen to - only to have the media and my liberal friends try, absurdly, to defame them as "alt right"

What does "alt right" even mean, any more? I understand its racist origins, but going by actual usage, it appears to include "good people, with good intentions, who also value reason and evidence"

Edit: To clarify the relevance of this to your comment - I would never have been exposed to so many views on the right if it hadn't been for the irrational, hateful, totalitarian intolerance that I've experienced in recent years from some parts of the left. Not all, obviously!

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by virtualized on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:38AM (#14978644)
I see another problem: If you can't be openly sexist (or whatever you call it), you will still be in secret.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TeMPOraL on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:43AM (#14978681)
I see yet another problem: if you're a rational person who happens to hold wrong beliefs on the topic, you will have less chance to discover and correct your mistake, because the only way the others are willing to engage with you is with stupidity and violence.

This low standard of discourse hurts everyone.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by doubleshame on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:35AM (#14978965)
Except... wait for it... the employer: Google.

Employees at work: shouldn't be discussing issues that distract them; shouldn't be socializing with each other because work and personal life should obviously be separate; they should just keep their heads down and keep working.

There's no doubting that all recent controvertial topics have led to the ideas that: divide up society into individuals afraid to express their opinions; human expression is not an important goal and that the workspace where you spend most of your time is ONLY to do the job like a machine.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TeMPOraL on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:05AM (#14979206)
Recent discussions have unearthed this plot twist: Google soliticed employees' opinion on the topic. They asked people what they think, then sacked an employee who did what they asked.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by durgiston on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:55AM (#14980321)
Nobody cares if you have sexist thoughts and opinions if you keep them to yourself and treat women with the respect and dignity they deserve. So I would say this is a step in the right direction.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by mikeash on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:17AM (#14979890)
It's weird how many people are eager to blame the left for Trump. Can we not blame the people who actually voted for him? They weren't forced to choose the asshole con-man to be our leader. And this is the "party of personal responsibility."
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by tossit248 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:04PM (#14982394)
Anecdote to support this comment:

I feel as if could be called slightly right of center. That being said, I use logic to evaluate different issues then rank them in importance to me. In November, I voted for a third party candidate because I had serious issues with both main party candidates. That said, I seriously considered tossing aside my moral issues with Clinton and voting for her as a vote against Trump because I saw a scenario (which ended up happening) where Trump could win.

Nine months later, my position has completely flipped. If Trump runs in three years, I am seriously considering voting for him as a "fuck you" vote due to the reaction to his election and Presidency over the last 9 months. I grew up and live in a rust belt city that used to be a manufacturing center. The complete slander, and misunderstanding, of the people I grew up and live with is incredibly difficult for me to swallow. I'm sure that everyone would love a former President who is campaigning for his wife coming into their back yard and disgustedly refer to them as "coal people," while expecting their vote. [1] When it is repeatedly espoused that we don't understand what we voted for, or when a SF elite tells a us that we need to be fixed to attract people with the right ideas [2], or that we should simply move to a place where there are jobs (friends, family, and community be damned) it gets harder and harder to explain that it isn't that simple. And when we try to explain what we feel or we believe we are told that someone else has it worse and to just adjust so that we can be accepted. I'm tired of being labeled as a racist or homophobic and being told my opinions are so obviously wrong, they are not even worth discussing.

So, yes. There are definitely people who aren't going to speak out, who are going to toe the line, and then they will cast a giant "fuck you" vote come November 2020. I might be one of them, but I will probably end up voting 3rd party again instead of letting my emotions get the best of me.

As an aside, follow Chris Arnade [3/4] on twitter. He does great work covering the Rust Belt and similar areas in a balanced perspective.

[1] http://pittsburgh.cbslocal.com/2016/09/09/hundreds-gather-in...

[2] https://ethicsalarms.files.wordpress.com/2017/01/melinda_bye...

[3] https://mobile.twitter.com/Chris_arnade

[4] https://www.theguardian.com/profile/chris-arnade

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by relics443 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:32AM (#14977014)
Are you saying that Trump was only elected because he was appealing to the alt-right? Surely that was part of it, but why is everyone so eager to "blame" it on the marginalized alt-right? Is it a scare tactic for 2020 /r
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Const-me on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:25AM (#14977237)
I’m not saying that, and the GP mentions alt right just as one possible outcome.

But I think Trump is definitely more right than left, at least compared to Clinton. This might have contributed to his victory.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Super_Jambo on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:30AM (#14977602)
'More right' Clinton is a neo-liberal and Trump is a lunatic.

It's pretty hard to put that into a left-right economic spectrum.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by lordCarbonFiber on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:48AM (#14979580)
So, I've done some work in finance, and I just, don't see it. At the major banks you've got literal hours of training about the things you can and cannot say with association with the firm and with its image. Fuck whatever you think about diversity and playing nice with the feelings of everyone, the brand damage alone would (and did in Google's case) have gotten James fired if he was working in the "real world".

Freedom of speech is not freedom from consequence. You want to cost your company thousands, if not millions, in bad PR maybe don't expect to have a job when you come in monday morning. There's nothing to be gained in appeasing bad science and faulty logic just because you're scared of populists.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by throwaway12124 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:31PM (#14982690)
It'll be interesting to see whether any of the leakers that caused that bad PR are actually fired. Seems doubtful.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by fsaneq2 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:13AM (#14977181)
EDIT: Removed comment. See better response below.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by CobrastanJorji on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:29AM (#14977255)
That's a really weird conclusion to draw based on that statistic. Another way to say the same thing would be "Donald Trump performed more poorly in California than any other Republican candidate since 1936."

(I see he removed his comment. For posterity, he argued that Donald Trump got "almost a third" of the votes in California and, therefore, liberals were on the decline).

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by fsaneq2 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:55AM (#14977393)
My point was more that it was surprising to me that someone as vilified as Trump still got almost a third of the votes in CA, but I agree that your point makes that look substantially weaker, so I retract it.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by 9point6 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:51AM (#14977375)
The difference spin makes.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by SidiousL on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:02AM (#14977433)
It's funny how some companies now literally enforce a "don't ask don't tell" policy when it comes to some points of view. In the academia it is probably even worse than in the industry. Except this time, it's the left that is "promoting" hiding your true self.

You may say that for the army it was the government doing it, which makes it worse. In a sense I agree. However, in the case of private employers it touches on a more consequential right for us as a society: the right to free speech.

Maybe people should be more accepting of somebody's views on controversial topics as diversity, gun rights and abortion, as they are to gay people in the military.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:19AM (#14978531)
Does that explain how Trump won the Republican primary?

The alternative explanation of large parts of the population being heavily divorced from reality seems to fit better.

That is the respectable right-wing position on the memo, correct? That it's just science facts that the left can't handle?

Like Obama being a secret muslim that wasn't born in America. Like him trying to destroy American industry by going along with a Chinese Hoax about climate change. That trade wars with Canada and Mexico are good for American jobs? That you can't even wish people Merry Christmas anymore. That Hillary Clinton and Obama literally smell of sulphur. That one third of the population doesn't believe in evolution. That there was "no racism before Obama".

To me, that explains Trump far better. Whatever tiny sliver of people were going to vote Democrat but got upset about being called sexists and so actually became fascists is only marginal at best. But apparently everyone is too "Politically Correct" to talk about this large group of people who've abandoned reality and instead we need to listen to their concerns (which apparently translates into giving tax cuts to billionaires and dumping pollution into the air and water). The memo writer was calling for people with these kind of "conservative" viewpoints to be given affirmative action at Google after all.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by idibidiart on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:19AM (#14979314)
Sexism is not free speech.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by scandox on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:59AM (#14977790)
If a person is engaging in reasonable dissent then why is this true: "If anything, their position will be radicalized."?

The (true) implication is that their reasonable dissent actually is a bland cover for a position that is much more radical once it is reduced to its core propositions.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sheepmullet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:04AM (#14978146)
Nonsense.

If you treat me with respect I will treat you with respect. We can have a civil disagreement and the next day I'll happily help you out.

Being able to disagree is healthy. I disagree with my wife and with my children on some pretty important issues.

On the other hand if you try and ruin my career, or if I think you will try and ruin my career, then I will knock you down at every opportunity.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by scandox on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:38AM (#14978317)
Just because someone attacks you doesn't mean your hypothesis or arguments should change. If you believe what you say is reasonable then it is not rooted in a personal animus. That is all I am pointing out.

Often, however, our arguments have a strong unacknowledged bias. When we're challenged the bias becomes more visible.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by AnthonyMouse on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:48AM (#14979048)
There is a difference between challenging someone by exposing the flaws in their argument and challenging them by campaigning to have them fired.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by scandox on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:14AM (#14979278)
I agree, but that difference would not itself make me change my position.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by AnthonyMouse on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:36AM (#14979456)
> I agree, but that difference would not itself make me change my position.

You're considering things from a formal perspective rather than a practical one.

In theory the fact that someone unjustly attacked you should not change your positions on anything, but it may reasonably cause you to stop associating with them.

And associating with different people will cause you to hear different arguments, which is likely to change your positions because it changes the ratio of convincing arguments you hear from each side.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sheepmullet on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:04AM (#14978452)
> Just because someone attacks you doesn't mean your hypothesis or arguments should change

In practice that is just not true.

Many of my positions are self-moderated by the understanding that smart, kind, and reasonable people have opposing views.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by matwood on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:13AM (#14979266)
> Many of my positions are self-moderated by the understanding that smart, kind, and reasonable people have opposing views.

A great example of this revolves around religion. Many smart, reasonable people are religious. I think a lot of the atheist crowd comes across as complete assholes, which does not help one win in any argument.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by thinkfurther on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:35AM (#14978012)
> If a person is engaging in reasonable dissent then why is this true: "If anything, their position will be radicalized."?

Uhmmmm.... because they get fired for deviating from the party line, not for being unreasonable. How can you skip that "detail"?

In this case, it seems to be even lamer than that, seems like he was not fired for the memo, but the reaction to it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14977750

> Damore said he initially shared the memo a month ago, but "no one high up ever came to me and said, 'No, don't do this,' even though there were many people who looked at it," Damore told Bloomberg. "It was only after it got viral that upper management started shaming me and eventually firing me."

So, what's hiding under this leaving out crucial parts and misrepresenting in the context of destroying people while paying lip service to being for people being unafraid? Anyone else seeing this?

> The (true) implication is that their reasonable dissent actually is a bland cover for a position that is much more radical once it is reduced to its core propositions.

This is so incredibly sinister and you don't even know it. Here's an example: a kid has a legitimate grievance, or at least legitimately thinks it does, but when it brings it up modestly, non-radically, it gets hit in the face. Now it will do something "bad", like cuss or somehow act out, because it is not allowed to place the grievance where it should be -- and then that is used to excuse that initial oppression or however you want to call it. Another example is SS officers despising people in concentration camps for being the diseased husks they turned them into, seeing this as a confirmation for their inferiority. Roll your eyes how much you want at that, chose whatever example you want, but that is the mechanism, that is an apt analogy just as much as bad parenting. Heck, get hung up on me somehow equating the Holocaust with a kid getting hit, I really don't care because people who don't want to understand always find something.

Granted, even being fired is no excuse to be radicalized. He's not a little kid, and he's not being made physically sick. But he also has a mob against him, plus the support of many he actually might not want want to be a martyr for (I mean, does anyone even allow for the fact that he is not some kind of closeted alt-right monster?), and that's more pressure than someone who was not on the receiving end of stuff like this can imagine, so I'll call that a wash. The point isn't (to me) "would he be justified to go loopy now", but "was this an okay reaction by the stronger party, and should this be normalized". My answer is no, and no. But not because it might lead to things I don't want, because it itself is already something I don't want either. Kinda of like I don't think corporations shouldn't turn street kids into sausage "because it would lead to a backlash and therefore make bad financial sense", but because it'd be evil. And I might not even want to sit with people who want the right thing for the wrong reason, because this is some very fundamental and serious stuff IMO.

If the memo caused a shit storm or went viral amongst assholes or both, but the memo itself was not grounds for termination or even internal criticism, then the spineful thing to do for Google would have been to have the discussion, not fire the guy, drop him like a hot potato, and then patting themselves on the shoulder for it. That's disgusting. They have just proven in action what a human life is worth to them, the rest is lip service, plus a whole lot of distortions which are the main hard data points so far.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by scandox on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:42AM (#14978331)
I don't understand your point. Mine is that being attacked should not change one's ideas. Getting fired is bad, but it isn't new information pertinent to the original debate. It may inform your ideas about the climate in which the debate is occurring, which may radicalize you personally. It shouldn't radicalize your position.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by thinkfurther on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:01AM (#14978439)
"Getting fired" is a bit of an euphemism though, there is a lot more going on here than just that. Just start with Gizmodo leaving out some stuff at first and so on. The claim is that he is being treated unfairly, at the least.

> It shouldn't radicalize your position.

In some fantasy world, where marijuana being illegal didn't make a single person try harder drugs because shady types were the only ones they could get weed from, and so on. Where a person is somehow separate from a position they hold.

I think people shouldn't steal. Reasonable, yes? Hacking off the hand of someone who stole some bubble gum is not so reasonable and much more radical. If you can somehow treat someone so badly for suggesting stealing is not okay that they harbor murderous thoughts about thieves, does that now mean the original idea of stealing being bad is not reasonable? I don't know who is to judge a person for their reaction to mistreatment, but never the ones doing or excusing the mistreatment, that is for super fucking sure.

But even granting that this is no excuse to go off the deep end, which I did; to focus on that, instead of the original action without which the debate about the reaction to it would be completely moot is not okay, and that is my point. There can be only bad results from this, that is the takeaway. If people downstream from this could alleviate this a bit by being saints is besides the point.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by scandox on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:29AM (#14978583)
Well I didn't mean to imply "you" - I meant "one's" position. Hopefully it didn't come across in any way personal.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by thinkfurther on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:53AM (#14979098)
No worries, I did get that, I also find "your position" much easier to write (and read) than "one's position".
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by thinkfurther on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:07PM (#14984294)
FWIW, I totally disagree with this comment being downvoted. It's a fair response made in good faith, very polite even seeing that I did come on kinda strong. So thanks for being a good sport about me ranting.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by cf on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:45AM (#14977708)
People can express any opinion they want in public. Inside a company isn't public. Also while you do have a right to an opinion you don't have a right to it going unchallenged and questioned.

Also how can you be so sure he wasn't alt-right already. "Classic liberal" is essentially the closest you are allowed to get in public.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jamesrcole on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:42AM (#14978045)
> People can express any opinion they want in public. Inside a company isn't public. Also while you do have a right to an opinion you don't have a right to it going unchallenged and questioned.

It's grossly misrepresenting the response to the memo to imply it was just a matter of challenging and questioning. A quick read of any of the forums where it's being discussed makes that clear, and remember how the author was fired?

A lot of the issue people have with the response is precisely that it wasn't making a substantive attempt to actually question or challenge the memo's content.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by cf on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:46AM (#14978352)
I'm sorry you didn't feel any of the challenges had substance. They were still challenged.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by jamesrcole on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:59AM (#14978425)
You're misrepresenting what I said
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by timgrahamtech on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:45AM (#14977710)
Then the goal is making him understand that he got fired for how he expressed those opinions. He didn't just talk to HR or his manager, he published a rant for all the world to see making it the CEO's problem.

Anyone who publishes an incoherent 10 page manifesto insulting their coworkers and trashing their company's policies can reasonably expect to get fired. It doesn't matter if any of the bosses agree or disagree with the opinions expressed; it's just an unprofessional thing to do.

To be honest, he was the bully in this situation. I have more concern for the women at Google who could fear losing their jobs and the means to support their families. If a coworker of mine started publicly saying that I'm not genetically qualified for the work I do, I would be worried for my job. However, I don't think those women would become radicalized over this. Why? Because intelligent professional people don't become radicalized when other people disagree with their opinions.

A note about Trump: I grew up in a red state and lived and worked in two others. I never spent more than a few months in a blue state so I don't know how it is there, but in Trump country people openly and aggressively express all sorts of opinions without fear of recrimination. There may be a few voices of dissent, but there are no "witch-hunting mobs" forcing them to keep their views a secret.

I think this scenario Giulio describes fits better to Brendan Eich who was essentially forced out of Mozilla over his views. But Brendan didn't become radicalized. He picked himself up and founded a new company, because that's what professionals do.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Aeolun on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:11AM (#14977874)
Publishing something on an internal board that's aimed at discussing diversity is hardly 'publishing the rant for all the world to see'. I just don't get how people who're obviously upset about this memo and must therefore have spent some time reading up about it (right? Right?!) still get this basic fact wrong.

This guy expressed his opinions, and a witch hunting mob, because that's what it was, descended on him from all over the internet to rip his reputation to shreds for things he didn't do or write (most of the outrage was about 'perceived' slights).

It's just sad... The worst part was that it validated a lot of what he said, and people somehow just don't see the irony in that.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by timgrahamtech on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:18AM (#14978209)
Let's not pretend he didn't know what he was doing. There are textbook examples about people who blast off a rant to the entire company and then are somehow surprised when it becomes public (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/1...).
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by alexknvl on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:46AM (#14978700)
It wasn't even meant for the entire company. He gave it to a small community of people within Google who later distributed it across the company AFAIU from his interview with Jordan Peterson (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEDuVF7kiPU).
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by rtx on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:24AM (#14978556)
Again he didn't share it with the entire company.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by dcole2929 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:21PM (#14983162)
He shared it in a forum that any and everyone in the company can access, and is intended to be able to access. That's essentially the same thing. This wasn't a private email chain that was leaked but an intentional dissemination by the engineer to google's employees at large.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by averagewall on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:34AM (#14978301)
> If a coworker of mine started publicly saying that I'm not genetically qualified for the work I do

Why are you changing the meaning of what he wrote? He didn't say that at all. He was very clear that he was talking about the group not any individuals.

If you choose to misunderstand what someone said, when they did a good job of explaining it clearly, then I think you shouldn't spread that misunderstanding around in a way that will hurt people, as it hurt this guy.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:51AM (#14978379)
> He was very clear

But, see, it's equally clear to other people that he was dogwhistling like crazy. This is the problem with this "discussion" - one side is doing the "only exact literal words count for meaning" dance (which, for me, is complete bullshit) whilst the other is saying "that's not how the real world works, context and implication is important".

The two sides are never going to agree - which is ok - but one side is going to struggle with this kind of issue forever until they accept how reality works.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Karunamon on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:04AM (#14979769)
It seems that “dog whistling” is a non contextual argument. If you don’t like someone, you can imply that what they’re writing has all manner of hidden meanings.

Kinda like an awful high school literature teacher.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:07AM (#14979797)
> If you don’t like someone, you can imply that what they’re writing has all manner of hidden meanings.

Of course but when many people agree on the same hidden meanings, you surely have to consider that they might be there.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sbmassey on Thursday August 10, 2017 @08:22PM (#14985624)
"Only exact literal words count for meaning" is the only fair way of interpreting any given nonfictional writing. Without that, you have nothing to stop yourself from falling into mass hysteria, conspiracy theories, witch burnings and the like, based on nothing more than a bunch of preconceived ideas about people you happen to have in your head.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by zimpenfish on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:47AM (#14988021)
> "Only exact literal words count for meaning" is the only fair way of interpreting any given nonfictional writing.

We'll have to disagree on that - subtext is an important factor to consider, especially in political / charged contexts.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Lukasa on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:44AM (#14978344)
> He was very clear that he was talking about the group not any individuals.

Since when does that excuse anything? If he'd written "Jews are, in general, hateful monsters. Not the Jews who work here, they're great, but most of the rest" does that statement become acceptable?

More importantly, Mr Damore does not know all the women at Google personally. He cannot. So when he says "In general, women are less suited to/interested in programming careers", he cannot possibly implicitly mean "but clearly that does not apply to every woman currently employed at Google, who were all hired because they are the best in the world at their jobs". Damore asserts that Google practices discriminatory hiring practices. For this to be true, Google must have at least once hired a woman where a better male candidate was available, and more importantly must do so more often than they do the reverse.

If you are going to make general statements about a group of people, then you should not be surprised when individuals in that group assume you mean that statement to apply to them.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by bluecalm on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:13AM (#14978488)
I say: black people are more suited to be NBA players. This is obvious looking at black players % in the league in comparison to the total population as well as the fact that black people are poorer on average and get less opportunities (or even chances for proper nutrition, let alone training).

Should white NBA players be offended by that statement? The answer is obvious: they shouldn't as that only means they were the ones on the tail of the genetic distribution and made it anyway or maybe even they overcome disadvantages to get there.

Now I say: women are in general less likely to be interested in tech and less likely to become good programmers because they are, on average, less competitive and less likely to devote themselves to solitude practice which is often necessary to become a very good coder.

Should women, who already made it to Google be offended? Of course they shouldn't for the same reasons as above. We can however do something with this information: we can try changing tech world to be more welcoming to women. This way we can avoid sexist hiring practices (gender quotas are clear discrimination) while still achieving more diverse environment.

Those are the points of the manifesto. Being offended by that is the problem of those taking offence as it doesn't speak well about their ability to reason about distributions of traits in a population.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Lukasa on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:38AM (#14978642)
> Should white NBA players be offended by that statement? The answer is obvious: they shouldn't as that only means they were the ones on the tail of the genetic distribution and made it anyway or maybe even they overcome disadvantages to get there.

I don't know: I'm not an NBA player and have no idea what the experience of becoming one is like. But there is a difference in kind here. He didn't say "Men are better suited to be Google employees", he said "Men are better suited to be programmers". The closer analogy here is to say that "Black people are better basketball players than white people", and here it might well be fair for white NBA players to be offended. There is a distinction between saying "More of X are good enough to pass this bar", and "X is better than Y". People who can pass the bar are unlikely to be offended for themselves (though they may be offended for others who don't attempt to cross that bar), but they may be offended for themselves if the suggestion is that they are worse than their colleagues.

But if you said, in addition, "The NBA currently employs discriminatory hiring practices that favour white athletes at the expense of black ones", then they should be offended. At that point you are saying "I believe that group X is better than group Y, and many of group Y are here despite there being better members of group X". That is offensive.

> We can however do something with this information: we can try changing tech world to be more welcoming to women.

I have a suggestion as to how to do that: stop saying that women are worse at coding. Just don't even bring it up. This goes doubly because there is no evidence for that at all.

You can make the tech world more welcoming to women by welcoming more women, and then give them the opportunity to succeed. Writing think pieces about how women are so ill-suited to coding doesn't just display a stunning lack of understanding about how the industry got started, it also makes it clear that right now you think women don't belong.

But if the view is that "software work as it is today is just not women's work, so we should make it more like women's work", then I'm sorry but you've already lost.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by PeterisP on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:51AM (#14978722)
Have you read the memo? By saying "stop saying that women are worse at coding" you are putting words in his mouth, as the memo states a very, very different thing i.e. that women are less likely to choose coding for various reasons, including biological ones. There's a world of difference between these two arguments.

And there is solid evidence for that difference, and it should be brought up, and asking to stop the discussion is, frankly, ridiculous - we can all see that there is an important open problem with different viewpoints and thus it should be discussed, and expressing all kinds of possible viewpoints should be facilitated.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Lukasa on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:31AM (#14980045)
> Have you read the memo? By saying "stop saying that women are worse at coding" you are putting words in his mouth, as the memo states a very, very different thing i.e. that women are less likely to choose coding for various reasons, including biological ones. There's a world of difference between these two arguments.

I wasn't replying to the memo, I was replying to bluecalm, and bluecalm said this:

> Now I say: women are in general less likely to be interested in tech and less likely to become good programmers because they are, on average, less competitive and less likely to devote themselves to solitude practice which is often necessary to become a very good coder.

Note "less likely to become good programmers". I feel pretty comfortable with my response given that.

> and expressing all kinds of possible viewpoints should be facilitated.

I disagree. Many kinds of possible viewpoints construct hostile work environments, and should be forbidden. It is simply not necessary to allow a workplace to tolerate all views. We don't allow people to cover their cube in swastikas, walk around greeting all their colleagues with "heil hitler", and to push for the dismissal of all their Jewish colleagues in an attempt to reduce the influence of the hidden Jewish conspiracy running the world.

If Mr Google had wanted to write this on his personal blog I wouldn't have cared at all. But he didn't do that: he wrote it at work, in his professional capacity, and posted it for his co-workers to see. Guess what: speech at work is something that can get you fired. See Colin Kaepernick for evidence.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by SamReidHughes on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:27PM (#14983849)
The funny thing is, you might be wrong about black guys and NBA suitability. The reason is, black people hit puberty earlier, and that might cause them to be selected for and receive extra attention and training because of a temporary athletic advantage, in much the same way that hockey players born in a certain part of the year (the oldest among their cohort) tend to be.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TeMPOraL on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:48AM (#14978713)
> he cannot possibly implicitly mean "but clearly that does not apply to every woman currently employed at Google, who were all hired because they are the best in the world at their jobs"

He clearly can, were it not for affirmative actions - if you assume perfect recruitment based on merit, you can expect everyone accepted to be suitable for the role. But in this case you'll also find, as the memo author explained quite sensibly, that the gender ratio might not be 1:1 due to distribution of interest in the population, which affects the distribution of the candidate pool.

I mean, come on, this is a pretty obvious point - and I'm starting to believe that it takes intent to misread it like you did.

> Damore asserts that Google practices discriminatory hiring practices.

Yes, that's the definition of affirmative action. It's literally discriminating in order to counter perceived discrimination in the opposite direction.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by Lukasa on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:13AM (#14979864)
> I mean, come on, this is a pretty obvious point - and I'm starting to believe that it takes intent to misread it like you did.

I...don't think I did misread it? I said "he cannot mean this", and you appear to agree with me: due to the facts on the ground, he cannot have intended to mean that. Therefore, I have to assume he did not mean that.

So if he believes that Google employs discriminatory hiring practices, then he presumably believes that some of his colleagues are not the best possible choice for their role, and do not deserve to be there. That seems like a straightforward reading of his text. Am I wrong?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by sever5 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:58AM (#14980961)
How do you make any business decisions when taking things this personally?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by marchenko on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:07AM (#14979219)
I think that the media and Google itself did a horrible disservice to the memo author in mis-representing his words, and I'm fairly certain they did so on purpose and will continue to do so. However, to be charitable to googlers offended by the memo:

If the author asserted in the memo that Google practices discriminatory hiring practices ("Hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate" is the only relevant language I encountered), wouldn't that imply that some members of Group X currently employed at Google are less qualified than the members of Group Y who were discriminated against? Otherwise it would seem we are discussing a situation where tiebreaks tend to be decided in favor of the current minority group, or recruitment efforts for underrepresented groups are more intensive. The "lower the bar" phrase would seem to imply that he believes there are different standards in effect for selecting current employees.

The memo author's point about differing interest distributions does not necessarily imply anything about ability differences in the current Google employee pool, but claiming discriminatory hiring practices might.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by syshum on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:29AM (#14977976)
>>he published a rant for all the world to see making it the CEO's problem.

Except he did not publish it, My understanding it put it on a internal system shared with a few people, other people inside google shared it more and more people inside of google until another Google Employee sent it to Motherboard or Gizmodo who published it for the world to see.

So then would you support Google firing who ever sent internal communications to a "news" organization which is likely in violation of company policy?

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by timgrahamtech on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:29AM (#14978285)
Would he have been fired if he had instead expressed these views to his manager in a room with closed door?

I'm not aware of any executives of large institutions that are perfectly happy with leaks. They just usually aren't dumb enough to pretend that a rant like this wouldn't get leaked.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by syshum on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:50AM (#14978376)
You have a vastly different definition of rant than I do, aside from that why do you believe this should only be discussed behind closed doors, that is infact one of the points the author was attempting to explorer the idea that with in google anyone that did not have left political leaning felt they were not allowed to express those positions with in the company.

You seem to agree

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by int_19h on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:10AM (#14977866)
In one of the previous discussions, it was said that it was published in an internal social network, in a group that was specifically dedicated to diversity hiring at Google. Is that incorrect?
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by TeMPOraL on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:52AM (#14978725)
Moreover, as it was uncovered in previous discussions, it was a response to Google soliticing opinion of employees about their diversity programs.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by js8 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:08AM (#14977847)
"Anyone who publishes an incoherent 10 page manifesto insulting their coworkers and trashing their company's policies can reasonably expect to get fired. It doesn't matter if any of the bosses agree or disagree with the opinions expressed; it's just an unprofessional thing to do."

I agree completely. Just like these guys: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charter_77

Very unprofessional!

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by timgrahamtech on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:35AM (#14978309)
Ale mluvim cesky a to znam dobre. You're actually going to compare Google's hiring policies to the oppression of a eastern bloc state? Do prdel.
Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by js8 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @07:45AM (#14978698)
Yes, because it is the same argument.

The GP didn't talk about about hiring policies, he talked about institutional criticism. The subject of the criticism is irrelevant.

Re:Outraged about the Google diversity memo? by pi_qed on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:33AM (#14979429)
That's an insult to Jan Palach. I doubt any of the critics of Google have the same level of conviction.