Simply calling them "racist" or "sexist" as if that ends the discussion completely misses the point.
I agree that labeling people as racist or sexist for being caught out by shifting norms is not productive, but at the same time people need to put effort into empathizing with others and educating themselves.
There are jokes I would've made 10 years ago I wouldn't make now. There are comments from others that might not have set off any alarms before, but now I know more about why they might be exclusionary or hurtful. Ultimately it's a process.
Which is why maybe a guy like Damore shouldn't be made to run the internet pitchfork and torch gauntlet for what he did. Maybe it could've been a teachable moment instead of a firing. But the other side of that is that I don't know if there were other components to his firing that we haven't heard yet.
I agree that labeling people as racist or sexist for being
caught out by shifting norms is not productive, but at the
same time people need to put effort into empathizing with
others and educating themselves.
Maybe that cuts both waysAnd there's also the question of how opinions are expressed. When you post something publicly for wide distribution, there's much less room to walk things back or to discreetly talk through things. Damore intended for his document to have impact, which it did. But that also means that if the impact is negative it's more likely to lead to his dismissal.
I'm not sure he should have been fired in this case but I can see why it was done.
That escalated quickly!
I think a closer example is someone saying "I support the trump immigration ban".
With the far left crowd who have been hyped up by the media this causes the same feelings as saying "I want to ban Muslims" and "I hate Muslims".
> And there's also the question of how opinions are expressed.
That's true. I'm not suprised he was fired.
From reading some of the leaked internal posts it looks like there is significant bullying of conservatives.
It doesn't look good for Google. Wage fixing, being investigated for pay gap issues, clearly bully conservatives, etc.
Hopefully a court case can reveal the truth.
There is strong evidence the immigration ban is targeted at Muslims. If it weren't for quotes like that Trump wouldn't have had an issue with the courts.
In progressive companies like google.
> There was a time when
And it changed because the public became outraged over it, and individuals concerned fought back with social and legal options. Same may happen here too.
Norms change over time. There was a time when it would've been okay to use the 'n' word to insult black people in many work places, now it's not okay. There was a time when lewd and demeaning talk about women was ok in the workplace, now it's not.
The people who sign the checks have always been able to define what is and is not acceptable in the workplace. Some people are feeling caught out because the line has moved, but it has always been there.