News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:33PM (#42625688)
I get how the partisan story is easy to tell here, but I'm saying something pretty specific: I think it would have been product development malpractice for this decision not to have been in the works for many, many months, long before the GOP takeover of the federal government was a safe bet. Community Notes has been that successful, and Facebook's fact-checkers have been that much of a product disaster.

I've never seen a wrong Facebook fact-check; I am warmly supportive of intrusive moderation; that's not where I'm coming from.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by rwmj on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:52PM (#42627318)
Clegg left a few days ago, and the Oversight Board issued a statement which sounds like they were in the dark:

> “We look forward to working with Meta in the coming weeks to understand the changes in greater detail, ensuring its new approach can be as effective and speech-friendly as possible.” [1]

So is it possible this was only announced recently. It might have been "in the works" in the C-suite for a bit longer, but there doesn't seem to be any evidence it was widely known before very recently.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/jan/07/meta-face...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by davidw on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:40PM (#42625751)
As a product decision taken independently, maybe. Running one of those things at scale with all kinds of people trying to subvert it for various reasons, including some downright evil ones, is not an easy task.

Announced together with everything else and given the timing, I just can't help but think there's a political component to all of it.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:44PM (#42625787)
I don't at all doubt that they're going to do whatever they can to cast this presumably longstanding product plan in the light most favorable to the governing majority! I just want to get the causality right.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sanderjd on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:24PM (#42627703)
I don't understand though: What makes you think that you are getting the causality right? It seems to me like you're asserting the causality goes one direction, when there doesn't seem to be any evidence (at least in public) for that assertion at the moment. Have I just missed some other information on this that you're basing this on?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tcbawo on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:47PM (#42629142)
I think he is suggesting that this move has favorable PR optics for the incoming administration. Making it appear like a conservative victory may give them some slack or earn them some favors.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sangnoir on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:40PM (#42630647)
Is it not a conservative culture-war victory designed to earn favors? There is no external evidence of this having been anything other than a contingency around November 6 of last year, so it's hard to definitively say it's one or the other.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:14AM (#42631851)
It's not really, tbh. Like the vast vast vast majority of content reviewers are outside California and have been for well over a decade.

The change here is to move the people designing the policies to Texas (basically a stealth layoff, tbh).

That being said, the moderation has been insanely bad for a while now, so all the model tuning seems like a worthwhile change to me.

The Texas thing sounds like PR but isn't really given their huge offices in Austin.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sangnoir on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:58PM (#42636707)
> The Texas thing sounds like PR but isn't really given their huge offices in Austin

That distinctly smells like pork barrel politicking: we're moving jobs from Commiefornia to your great state, and if your criminal [1] state AG sues us again over this function, he'll be putting Texans out a job.

1. Allegedly. Meta wouldn't dare call him thar, but he agreed to 100 hours of community service and paying restitution to those he allegedly defrauded to avoid a trial.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:35AM (#42644240)
Yeah, and it's not really a big deal for them but looks good for Texas politicians. Well chosen pork, I guess.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by markhahn on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:34AM (#42635276)
its called pre-conceding
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by pessimizer on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:50PM (#42625856)
> I just can't help but think there's a political component to all of it.

I mean, of course there is. The pressure to censor that began once Trump started dominating the Republican primaries in 2015, and escalated when the government chose a line on covid that absolved the government from responsibility for covid and made dubious claims about it, is ending. The reason the recent censorship frenzy began was political (nobody was censoring flat-earthers), and the reason it's ending is political.

Now the US can get back to just censoring Palestinians, like the old days.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by davidw on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @02:00PM (#42625972)
Facebook is a corporation and can 'censor' whoever they like. They are not 'the US'.

Part of the reason why they moderate content is the same reason that a bar owner turfs out people who are rowdy and threatening the other patrons: because the normies will leave and you're left with a bunch of nasty, loud people.

That is, after all, why this site we're on right now is so heavily moderated: it makes for a better user experience.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zblevins on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:40PM (#42627181)
I see what you’re saying, but I also think the user demographics of Hacker News reduce the likelihood of moderation to begin with.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sneak on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:53PM (#42627335)
I don’t know if that’s true. SV culture has always been a very big tension between monied military-industrial types and (eventually also monied) antiwar hippies.

It’s well-documented in SV’s military history, as well as recently, where Apple wasn’t involved in FAA702 illegal spying on americans (PRISM) until after the famously anti-establishment Jobs died.

The SV culture seems to have shifted a bit rightward (as has the whole country, tbh) but the tension is still there, and the social conflict remains (although I think there are other factors, not the least of which is the skill and grace of @dang, that keep people on the better side of their behaviors here).

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zblevins on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:10PM (#42627507)
I agree with what you're saying about SV, especially the military-industrial types. I'm not entirely sure what the makeup of HN demographics is, and would like to know. I have a suspicion that it's not just folks in SV. I also should have clarified more. In my opinion, the discourse here is more civil than on other platforms. I would suggest that has something to do with a combination of education and niche interests that attract a different user base. So maybe not in terms of factual correctness, but certainly in terms of the ability to have a civil conversation.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sanderjd on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:28PM (#42627754)
I think you are like a fish who isn't aware of the water it's swimming in.

HN doesn't need much moderation, because the discourse is so civil here [narrator voice: because of the good moderation].

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ethbr1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:42PM (#42627929)
At scale, the long term community civility balance point is likely dominated by the average user's willingness to change their behavior as a result of peer feedback.

The HN userbase, feedback tools, karma-level-locked tools, and new users' personalities seem to create decent outcomes.

Which is to say, if someone acts like an asshat, folks let them know (either through downvotes, flags, or replies), and they modify their behavior to be closer to the community norm.

That said, I'm aware I don't see a lot of the most egregious stuff the Good Ship Dang torpedoes. Or what I expect are non-zero repeat trolls.

And honestly, the fact is that outside of very nerdy street cred, there's little incentive to actively manage discourse for commercial purposes on HN.*

* Outside of, you know, cloudflare tailscale rust (any other crawler alarms I can trip)

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zblevins on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:20PM (#42628372)
That’s a rather reductionist and slightly disparaging point of view. Moderation has its place I never said it didn’t, but do you really think that moderation is the only thing keeping this place from being 4chan? I think you have one deeply entrenched opinion and are ignoring that these are very different platforms.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sanderjd on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @03:00PM (#42637876)
HN is heavily moderated through a number of mechanisms: explicit community guidelines, community moderation (through voting), and active automated and manual moderation.

I think all of this working in conjunction is why it has remained a pretty great community for almost two decades. And I think that's a really impressive feat. I don't think it was accomplished via "a combination of education and niche interests that attract a different user base".

Indeed, I think HN has gotten better over time, even somewhat so in absolute terms, but very starkly relative to the deterioration of everything else. For example, back in the day, when twitter was first getting big in tech, a lot of people felt that it was a healthier place to discuss those topics than HN. I was never completely convinced of that, and have always been more active here than on twitter, but it was at least a very reasonable thing to think for awhile, IMO. But now I think it would be pretty crazy to think that twitter is healthier than HN. Similarly with similar communities on reddit.

I dunno, maybe there are some healthier spaces on mastodon or blue sky or threads or something now, but at least to me, HN has maintained a fairly stable fairly decent level of discourse for a very long time, and I don't think it is a result of luck or magic, but rather of hard and tireless work moderating the community.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zblevins on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:07PM (#42638452)
Yea, I’ve become more aware of this since yesterday. I also think I should have provided way more context to what I was saying. I believe I came off as being against moderation but I’m not, I do think there is something unique about the user base just from the quality of content I see compared to other spaces, but I digress. I appreciate your thoughts and it gave me something to think about.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sanderjd on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:33PM (#42639217)
Yeah, and I probably should have figured out a more tactful way to make the point I was making. I wanted it to be more like a "you're one of today's lucky 10,000!"[0] to point out that I think you've been swimming in water without knowing it[1], but I think it ended up just being condescending.

0: https://xkcd.com/1053/

1: https://fs.blog/david-foster-wallace-this-is-water/ (kind of blog spam, but this is the only place I found that has the full transcript, the audio, and other useful links)

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zblevins on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:47PM (#42639333)
I thought that’s what the reference was. I think it all worked out in the end.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dang on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:16PM (#42630849)
Last I ran the numbers, which was quite a few years ago, about 10% of HN posts were coming from IP addresses correlated to Silicon Valley (well, the Bay Area with a relatively wide radius). About 50% were coming from the US, and so on.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16633521 (March 2018)

I should check again.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zblevins on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:59AM (#42633288)
Thanks @dang. Turned on showdead. I will say that I was completely unaware of the moderation efforts here and appreciate having this pointed out to me. I like this option too. As far as transparency goes I don’t think it gets much better than this.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dang on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:58PM (#42638904)
Thanks for this!
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sneak on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:19AM (#42641880)
Showdead doesn’t work on stories AFAIK, just comments.

For stories on the front page, I made https://orangesite.sneak.cloud.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gnabgib on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:26AM (#42641915)
Of course it works on stories. There are eight right now on https://news.ycombinator.com/newest
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sneak on Thursday January 09, 2025 @08:59AM (#42645553)
Oh, I meant on the frontpage. I am quite curious about stuff “popular” enough to make it out of newest and into the top30, but off topic/rulebreaking enough to get nuked (either by mods or by flags).
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jheriko on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:41AM (#42631645)
i'm not from silly valley, but its the dominant voice here.

some of my downvotes are from bad tone, overreaction, hyperbole... some are because of the silly valley culture not realising they are a bunch of deluded maniacs, or just producing absolute garbage products.

its mostly the former.

as for demographics... well, i'm a single data point, but HN has a wide reach. its why a lot of us are here imo.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mbreese on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:22PM (#42629857)
Do you have showdead on? There is definite moderation going on, but a lot of it is collectively imposed (down votes, flagging). But, if you have your HN account set to show dead posts, you’ll see that even with this demographic there are still a good number of low quality posts.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by asveikau on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:01PM (#42630113)
I read with showdead on. I feel like people don't get modded for opinions here. Usually if the comments are dead it's because something is perceived as ad hominem, hostile, aggressive, violent, etc. It's usually the tone that gets them modded out and the content of the message, and a polite version of the same statement would stand.

There are outliers of course, but that's the general vibe.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mbreese on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:05PM (#42630792)
> I feel like people don't get modded for opinions here.

Agreed. That's why I used the term "low quality". The comments that get downvoted or flagged are usually either blatant spam/trolling or rude. If someone makes a quality argument, regardless of the opinion, it generally sticks around. I'll even up-vote comments I disagree with, if the author is making a good-faith effort. Not everyone does that, but enough people do and do so often enough that it helps to keep a complete hive-mind at bay (about most topics...).

But, I think that it's that simple level of moderation (which, I consider to still be moderation) that helps to keep discourse around here civil and interesting...

Yes, there are some threads that start where you just know nothing good will come from it, and in those cases we do see some admin moderation (hi @dang!). But, even then, I think the idea is that when discussing some topics, the thread will invariably end up going sideways. Those are the topics that end to get immediately flagged. And that's okay with me, because who has time for that, when we have so many other, more interesting things to argue (civilly) about?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zblevins on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:41AM (#42633565)
I do now. Good point. I haven’t been on here very long and should have been more aware before saying something thats incorrect.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by labster on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:33PM (#42629939)
That user has six karma and therefore does not have showdead on.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dang on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:15PM (#42630848)
There's no karma threshold for turning showdead on.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zblevins on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:48AM (#42633228)
That is correct. Possibly would change my perspective. Honestly a lot of these comments have and I do appreciate the input.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by philwelch on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @02:13PM (#42626122)
It turns out that “normies” were people who have the kinds of normal, mainstream beliefs that Facebook has spent the past four years censoring.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by davidw on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @02:37PM (#42626422)
The only thing that "turns out" is they wish to curry favor with the incoming administration. FB hasn't been censoring much of anything as far as I can tell; there are all kinds of vile, nasty comments all over it. Just unfriendly, unkind stuff, not even political things. It's probably one reason it's kind of struggling as a platform - that kind of thing isn't much fun.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by philistine on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:41PM (#42627185)
That's the silver lining through all of that: when right-wing ideologues start imposing their own groupthink model on social media, it stops being fun and people start to leave. Just look at Twitter. It's just not as fun anymore on there.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jjk7 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:45PM (#42627236)
The parent's point, is that the incoming administration won the popular vote... they are the 'normies' now.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by davidw on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:47PM (#42627273)
Most voters don't care much about any of the details of this. They're not terribly unhappy with FB because they're using to keep track of people from high school back in the 90ies, or their families, or local recreation groups or something. Or they're not using it at all because it's for old people like me.

This is all just loud, performative subjugation to the incoming administration, that does take things like attacking trans people and immigrants as good stuff.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by BikiniPrince on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:00PM (#42629249)
I would actually offer they Facebook is changing because their base has grown tired of their antics. My normy friends and family have complained of censorship increasingly over the last year. When I asked why we still use the platform one friend replied: “birthday reminders.” Then I thought that actually does summarize what I use the platform for. Not a great prospect for a company.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by davidw on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:01PM (#42629720)
What sorts of conversations are you attempting to engage in that it is 'censoring' you? It seems pretty rare to me - even in heated exchanges.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by intended on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:05AM (#42631474)
There is a campaign to capitalize on the idea that right wing people are censored.

And therefore all Americans are censored.

This fight has been fought before, at the dawn of moderation. It’s been fought here on HN. Back when people used to hold libertarian beliefs openly. “The best ideas rise to the top”. No, they frikking dont. The most viral ideas, the most adaptive ideas - those are the ones that survive.

Everyone learned that moderation is needed, that hard moderation is the only way to prevent spaces from attracting emotional arguments, harassment, stalking, and hate speech.

Maybe this time its different.

Moderation is both thankless, soul crushing, and traumatic. Mods r/neworleans effectively became first responders on Jan 1st. I know mods see everything from dead baby pictures, burning bodies, accidental deaths, to worse.

IF this works, and reduces the need for mods, great! My suspicion is that it’s going to radicalize more people, faster. Its going to support the creation of more demagogues, and further reduce our ability to communicate with each other.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ethbr1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:33PM (#42627830)
49.8% to 48.3% of the popular vote.

That's a pretty thin advantage, and still barely not an outright majority.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mcherm on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:01PM (#42628171)
Nearly all the levers of control of the US government to almost no control over the US government: that's a massive advantage. I can't help believing this, not the popular vote, is the motivation.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ethbr1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:47PM (#42628616)
Exactly. Particularly the power of the incoming President to create bad PR (with 50% of the country) and the House to haul people into public testimony and yell at them.

Not to mention the federal money spigot.

Big companies aren't stupid and are largely amoral.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by usrusr on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:18PM (#42628354)
But is it currying favor? Could just as well be "kiss the ring or you'll see your life's work AT&Ted into oblivion"

Perhaps both: might have started as a pragmatic offer to bury the hatchet, then quickly turned into the never ending firehose of demands of an extortionist who just realized that he still all the cards after the extortee has given in.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by llm_trw on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:42PM (#42630669)
Facebook has said it was pressured by the Biden administration to censor topic like covid. This is as clear cut first amendment case as you will ever find.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by RansomStark on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @03:56AM (#42632349)
Your being down voted is amazingly ironic for a topic on the politicization of fact checking. There are hundreds of comments here talking about how objective facts exists and the correctness of fact-checking. You reiterate the statement of the Facebook CEO and what that statement entails and you are moderated.

But facts are facts right?

Zuckerberg did say Facebook was pressured by the Biden administration to censor covid misinformation, and the Hunter Biden laptop story [0], [1], [2] (multiple left-wing references for good measure). If Zuckerberg is telling the truth, that is a clear cut first amendment violation.

A private company can censor whatever it wants (mostly) but not at the behest of the government, there's law against that.

[0] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/zuckerberg-says-the-wh...

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/czxlpjlgdzjo

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/article/2024/aug/27/m...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by NCFZ on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:53PM (#42637247)
If it's so clear cut then why did SCOTUS throw that case out?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by llm_trw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:46AM (#42644311)
>Writing for a liberal-conservative coalition of six justices, Justice Amy Coney Barrett said that neither the five individuals nor the two states who sued the government had legal standing to be in court at all.

https://www.npr.org/2024/06/26/nx-s1-5003970/supreme-court-s...

I short: because it wasn't Facebook that brought the case.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by NCFZ on Monday January 13, 2025 @12:24PM (#42685934)
>She said they presented no proof to back up their claims that the government had pressured social media companies like Twitter and Facebook into restricting their speech. “Unfortunately,” she said, the Fifth Circuit court of appeals “relied on factual findings that are “clearly erroneous.”

Those next two sentences from your article seem to contradict your assertion that it was because it wasn't Facebook that brought the case.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by immibis on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:29PM (#42639185)
And we all know that the first amendment can never be immoral, not even when a tidal wave of deliberate propaganda is causing millions of people to die.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by llm_trw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:47AM (#42644318)
Yes, the lies the administration told about masks are one of the worst things done this century. There should be a reckoning for officials who lie to us for our own good.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jimbokun on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:50PM (#42628024)
Fact checking, Community Notes, whatever you want to call it, is inherently political.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:20PM (#42629416)
To be clear: I absolutely do not dispute this. But in 2025 it seems pretty clear that you cannot run a mainstream large-scale social network without some kind of moderation, so every platform is going to do something. And all I'm saying is: what Facebook was doing before was bad, just as a product experience. Just wretched. Solved no problems, mostly surfaced stuff I wouldn't have paid attention to in the first place.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by oraphalous on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:43PM (#42638767)
How does an average joe evaluate the claim that their content moderation was bad? Cause folks on the left seem very upset that it's being replaced by notes, and folks on the right seem very glad that it's going. How do I judge this for myself?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by DrillShopper on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:20PM (#42628368)
Only if everything you don't agree with is "political"
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jimbokun on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:30PM (#42628470)
Censorship, moderation, what kind of speech is acceptable, what does or doesn’t constitute a “fact”, are all political topics.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jjav on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:54PM (#42628686)
> what does or doesn’t constitute a “fact”, are all political topics.

It clearly is not. A fact is a fact by definition, regardless of what anyone happens to feel about it. There are facts that are known to be true beyond all possible doubt.

If it is uncertain or in doubt, then it's not a fact and shouldn't be corrected by fact checkers.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jimbokun on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:16PM (#42629809)
Well yes.

But how do we distinguish facts from non facts?

That is a dilemma humanity has struggled with for millennia. Humans are very bad at recognizing their own biases and admitting to themselves they were wrong about something.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jjav on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:52PM (#42630385)
> But how do we distinguish facts from non facts?

What do you mean how? Science. The process of science.

There might be people who want to believe gravity on Earth accelerates objects at 1m/s^2, but we can trivially establish through countless experiments repeatable by anyone who wants to try that this is not true.

If you can't measure it or repeatably demonstrate it then it's probably not a fact. If it can, then it is a fact and no amount of emotionally wanting to believe something else can make it not a fact.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tgma on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:44PM (#42630680)
The irony is that the example you cite, i.e. F = G * m1 * m2 / r^2 is demonstrably not the correct formula for gravity.

Science, the process of science, does not prove something as fact. It can only eliminate non-facts, and even then, the experiments may be flawed in their recognition.

> If you can't measure it or repeatably demonstrate it then it's probably not a fact. If it can, then it is a fact and no amount of emotionally wanting to believe something else can make it not a fact.

This is demonstrably false. If you witness an event once, you cannot necessarily repeat it, but you know for a fact that it happened. Unless you redefine the term "fact" narrowly, what you suggested is an ideology.

See how even the definition of "fact" is up for debate.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by computably on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:17AM (#42631862)
You missed a basic element of what they said: "can't measure it or repeatably demonstrate it"; seeing a non-reproducible event with your eyes is a form of measurement, and that measurement could in principle be done by an objective machine (recorded by a camera). The potential for objective evidence is what distinguishes a matter of fact from a matter of opinion.

As to the "correct formula for gravity" - that's just bad faith nitpicking. "Newtonian gravitation is a fact" is both a strawman and completely irrelevant when it comes to social media fact checkers.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tgma on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @03:09AM (#42632129)
> You missed a basic element of what they said: "can't measure it or repeatably demonstrate it"; seeing a non-reproducible event with your eyes is a form of measurement, and that measurement could in principle be done by an objective machine (recorded by a camera). The potential for objective evidence is what distinguishes a matter of fact from a matter of opinion.

No. Recording an experiment does not constitute scientific repeatability of an experiment. (Not to mention Quantum Mechanics explicitly rejects your claim as a universal principle at the micro level.)

> As to the "correct formula for gravity" - that's just bad faith nitpicking. "Newtonian gravitation is a fact" is both a strawman and completely irrelevant when it comes to social media fact checkers.

No, it is not a strawman at all. It clearly illustrates via an example of something we have known to be false for about a century, yet not only we do not censor it on social media, we teach it to kids, and almost no one would object to it.

So, where do you draw the line?

I posit there exists facts that are unknowable by the scientific method. The GP claimed science as the end-all-be-all method to fact-check. My statement is that it's not sound, nor complete, in its ability to fact-check.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jjav on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:27AM (#42631930)
> Science, the process of science, does not prove something as fact.

I intentionally picked a wrong value for Earth gravity instead of the correct one to avoid nitpickery on precision, location, yada yada.

If someone has a feeling that Earth's gravity accelerates at 1m/s^2, they're just flat out wrong full stop. This is the problem with the anti-intellectual crowd who believes everyone's opinion has equal weight. No, it doesn't. If someone wants to believe Earth's gravity accelerates at 1m/s^2, then their opinion (on that topic) is worthless because it is known to be false and they don't deserve any recognition for the nonsense. Facts are facts, beliefs don't make them go away.

> This is demonstrably false. If you witness an event once, you cannot necessarily repeat it, but you know for a fact that it happened.

Not at all. Human memory is fallible so if you are the only one who saw that event and swear it is true that does not make it a fact no matter how hard you believe it.

That's why scientific process requires repeatable results that anyone can (re)validate over and over, not one-off recollections.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tgma on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @03:15AM (#42632162)
> Earth's gravity accelerates at 1m/s^2, they're just flat out wrong full stop

You do realize it depends on the distance of the object to Earth? So perhaps you are wrong not them depending on the context.

Now someone comes up and says I am nitpicking blah blah... well, the author should have been clear and not stating falsehood as fact! This is just your belief which does not change the incompleteness/incorrectness of the statement (as per the original post).

And this is the whole goddamn point. What's "fact" to someone can be incorrect, half-correct, wrong with completely good faith, or wrong with intent to mislead, etc. Who gets to decide all this is not as simple as "I am ScienceTM" Dr Fauci style.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by snowfarthing on Friday January 10, 2025 @01:34PM (#42658506)
XKCD has a fun comic about a guy who recalculates the world records of pole vaulters based on the gravity of the locations of various events. Earth's surface gravity is by no means constant -- it varies, presumably due to the density and altitude of any particular location.

Indeed, "sea level" is defined as the level that the sea would be at, if the area of question didn't have the land mass, but still had the same gravity. Of the various possibilities, this particular definition is useful, in that it you can expect the air pressure at a particular altitude to be the same, regardless of where you are, after factoring in things like temperature and humidity -- which is kindof important if you're a pilot of some sort!

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by fragmede on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:03PM (#42630783)
And if I take a ballon, fill it with the right helium/air ratio so it sinks at exactly 1m/s²? It's a provable scientific fact that it's falling at 1m/s². Even if I leave off the part that it's a balloon, and talk antigravity fields or aliens or some crap, and "let you draw your own conclusions", the fact that the ballon fell at that rate would still be demonstrably true.

People want to sell you lies and get you to believe them, and they'll give all the half truths they can to support their version of the truth. they'll use misleading graphs with real numbers, so you can fact check the numbers on the graph and come away thinking the graph represents the truth of the matter. But X axis that don't start at zero, logarithmic Y axis that don't say they're logarithmic, Or pie graphs viewed from a funny angle, with slices that don't represent the percentage they're labeled by, or with percentages that add up to greater than 100%.

If all we wanted to run were trivial physics experiments, we'd be golden. The real world of social media facts include things we can't run science experiments for, or go back in time to redo, like economic stats that use a different formula today and there's not enough information to see what it was in the distant past. So we get these narratives from people who are trying to convince us to believe theirs by leaving off important context. Which is totally dishonest of them, but they have a vested interest in us believing a particular narrative.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sellmesoap on Friday January 10, 2025 @07:31PM (#42662072)
Lies, damned lies, and statistics!
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tsimionescu on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:50AM (#42631706)
The scientific process works amazingly well for repeatable experiments, but it doesn't do anything at all for non-repeatable events. You can't use the scientific method to figure out who blew up the Nordstream pipeline, just for a relatively recent and hotly debated political fact.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by teamonkey on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:13PM (#42647677)
This is not uncovered ground though. Philosophy and logic cover the notion of truth and reality in some depth. The entire field of law is based on proof beyond reasonable doubt.

The aim of fact-checking isn't to be a perfect system that covers every single possibility and edge case. The aim is to reduce the effectiveness of lies and propaganda, so that people are less misinformed when they go about their daily actions and democratic duty.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by sampo on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:59PM (#42629237)
> There are facts that are known to be true beyond all possible doubt.

The problem is that some people believe a fact is one way beyond doubt, and other way believe it is the other way.

Epidemiology: Respirator masks help prevent infectious diseases

Economics: Rent control is always a bad idea

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by somenameforme on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:37PM (#42630961)
The way Community Notes usually end up working in practice is comments that provide sourced context that may be [arguably intentionally] omitted in a topic. For instance if it happens to be that there have been 27 different studies showing no statistically significant reduction in spread of infectious diseases with healthy individuals wearing masks, then that would likely be a community note on the first one. And vice versa if rent has been demonstrated to keep rents below the surrounding means in the cities of Blah, Bleh, and Bluh, then that would often end up a community note on the second.

It basically helps reduce the hyperbole/echo chamber effect of such comments/topics. Vice/versa if those topics were "Respirator masks are useless." and "Rent control is always good." then the community notes would tend to go in the opposite direction. It's just a really good idea. For that matter I think a similar algorithm would also work well on general upvote systems at large.

I'd also add that one of the biggest issues with "fact checkers" was not only sometimes slightly questionable checking, but also a selection bias - where the ideological bias becomes rather overt in both directions. Whether that be in deciding to "fact check" the Babylon Bee (in an overt effort to get it deranked), or in choosing not to not fact check statements from the lying politicians that one happens to like.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by bee_rider on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:55AM (#42631402)
Those aren’t good candidates for fact checking really. They are beliefs really, just very widespread ones with lots of support.

A good candidate for fact checking is something that is well documented objectively verifiable. Politician X said Y on TV the other day.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by computably on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:50AM (#42631700)
Your example is a false equivalence. Economics does not define "good ideas" and "bad ideas," it only attempts to model resource dynamics. Whereas the spread of infectious disease is clearly quantifiable regardless of value assignment.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by shakes_mcjunkie on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:38AM (#42634067)
Economics is inherently a political venture. Organizing markets is political and obviously impacts politics.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by computably on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:34PM (#42637633)
Partly true, but besides the point. Making a blanket statement like "economics says rent control is bad," is only marginally better than saying "physics says nuclear weapons are bad." There is a critical assumption of values which is totally outside the objective of study.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Aunche on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:47PM (#42636604)
The presumed goal of rent control is to prevent rents from rising. If they actually cause rents to rise even more quickly then they are indeed "bad" (at achieving this goal).
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by computably on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:40PM (#42637677)
The goal of rent control, as I infer from the mechanism, is to prevent existing tenants from being priced out of their current homes (eventually leading to eviction) - at least as I have seen in the US.

If the goal were to prevent rents from rising, the mechanism would do so directly, ie. regulate all rent, rather than limiting to continued rentals on certain types of property. Which would by definition prevent rents from rising, presumably along with other undesirable effects.

Anyways, the whole issue with conflating "bad" with objective consequences is the "presumed goal," which is of course totally subjective.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by starspangled on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:32AM (#42633137)
Here's another one - "Trump colluded with Putin to hack the election in 2016".

I have never seen an accepted fact checking site answer this, which is very strange since it is such an enormous and grave conspiracy theory if it were true. The Mueller report is extensive and quite conclusive in stating that no such evidence of collusion (conspiracy) was not found. Yet fact checkers are happy to check peripheral and far less consequential claims around the case for some reason (e.g., https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/mueller-report-no-obstruct...), but are strangely hesitant to address the elephant in the room.

Or for another example, there were many false or poorly substantiated claims made about covid and vaccines during the pandemic. I saw "reputable" fact checkers address a certain set of those claims about the virus and drugs, but were strangely silent when it came to a different set of claims.

So fact checkers don't even need to provide false content at all, they can be very political and biased simply by carefully choosing exactly what "facts" or claims that they address.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by rayiner on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:37AM (#42635317)
Another example: fact-checking prominent race activists in 2020. The public was grossly misinformed about the scale of police violence against black Americans: https://manhattan.institute/article/perceptions-are-not-real...

But even straightforward stuff goes unchallenged. Jada Pinkett Smith released a movie trailer claiming Cleopatra was black. When NBC covered the issue, they couldn’t even bring themselves to fact check her. They did a “he said, she said” article asserting that Egypt contested whether Cleopatra was black: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/queen-cleopatra-black-egy....

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by EricDeb on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:10AM (#42643338)
I think someone said it but there's a difference between facts and making an inference about those facts. The evidence in Trumps case was maybe he had a conversation with a person of Russian descent on Day X. That in itself is a fact. Does this fact or other facts like it mean he "colluded", whatever the definition of colluded means, is a matter of opinion. Even in a legal framework, where "collusion" has a definition, its still up to a jury which can get it wrong. Fact-checking is extremely complex as you are alluding to and cannot be simplified the way it has been thus far
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by starspangled on Thursday January 09, 2025 @07:55AM (#42644836)
Sure, but the fact is that there was never any solid evidence showing that Trump did collude with Putin to hack the election. That's contrary to what many high level politicians were claiming, the fact is that they falsely claimed there was "ample evidence" proving Trump colluded, and they never produced it. That's what was never fact checked, because it is inconvenient, and it would show that many high level people who insisted on there being "ample evidence" to prove collusion were actually being dishonest about it.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by EricDeb on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:53PM (#42649699)
Well there is a lot of connections between Trump and Russia. Wiki here shows quite a few: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Links_between_Trump_associates... I'm not interested in auditing the entire thing, but like I said whether what occurred was "collusion" is something that cannot be fact-checked as it will always be a matter of opinion
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by starspangled on Friday January 10, 2025 @07:02AM (#42654910)
There's a lot of connections between a lot of people. Obama tried to secretly transmit a promise to Putin that he would "have more flexibility" after his election. How do we know it wasn't Obama who colluded with Putin? It was his whitehouse overseeing the 2016 election. Why doesn't any fact checkers check that fact and come up with "inconclusive" because they are unable to prove it false? Because it's political.

Trump Putin election hacking collusion was always a wild baseless conspiracy theory. Sure there is no absolute proof he did not, and there is various incidental connections and circumstantial evidence you could arrange to fit some crazy narrative. But what it not in dispute is that many people lied and mislead claiming to have "ample evidence" of collusion, when no such thing was ever produced.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:54AM (#42635464)
> Economics: Rent control is always a bad idea

Well this is definitely false. If you're a politician who can afford a nice place then rent control is a great idea: it gets you elected (look, I made things cheap for you) and keeps you elected (look, I will solve all the problems underpriced rent brings).

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:35PM (#42629526)
You're reading them as saying that moderation is suspect because it's political, and all I read them to be saying is that political considerations are unavoidable when you moderate, in a manner distinctive to moderation.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Aeolun on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:56PM (#42629212)
I disagree with gravity though. It makes life a lot easier when you can fly.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ikiris on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:50PM (#42631039)
It’s just intelligent falling. They want to keep you in the dark.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by emmelaich on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:49PM (#42629642)
.. from lawdictionary.org :

> 2 : any of the circumstances of a case that exist or are alleged to exist in reality : a thing whose actual occurrence or existence is to be determined by the evidence presented at trial see also finding of fact at finding, judicial notice question of fact at question, trier of fact compare law, opinion

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:38PM (#42629971)
For most of my life, I would have agreed with you.

As I've gotten older, I've become increasingly skeptical of the idea of a "fact".

There's no way to separate information from human context. Even seemingly obvious things like "that shirt is blue". To who? My wife sees it as green, frequently.

Or things are reduced to tautological nonsense like "gravity keeps us on the ground". Hard fact, right? But define gravity. A physicist will give you an answer, that may or may not mean much. A layman's definition might be something like "it's the thing that keeps us stuck to the ground", and now we're back to tautological nonsense. The entire "water is wet" class of "facts".

Anything less trite instantly becomes less fact-like the more humans are involved.

"Trump is a criminal" many people would argue passionately that this is a hard, incontrovertible fact.

Nearly as many, (or maybe more?) would argue the opposite.

I like the approach of the Fair Witness in Stranger In A Strange Land: "What color is that house?" "It's yellow on this side."

I'm increasingly convinced that the belief in "facts" is more about the desire to be right and know things than anything to do with objective reality.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gmueckl on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:42PM (#42630321)
Facts exist. Your first sentence has 11 words. Easy to verify, right? Doesn't matter who's counting.

May I suggest that your confusion comes from a conflation between facts and generalizations. Hard facts exist in strictly defined contexts. Relax the context, and you need to eventually reach for generalizations that less precise and potentially ambiguous.

If somebidy asked me whether the cup in you hand would fall and and shatter when they release it from their grip, my answer would of course depend on a few things I pick up from the context: what gravitational attraction would the cup experience in your current location? What material is the cup made of (porcelain, metal...)? So if we're standing on earth and the cup was made of porcelain, I'd answer that it would fall and likely shatter. Doesn't mean that any cup would shatter. Metal cups doesn't. But that's a different fact. So there is no generalized fact that all cups shatter when they fall. Some do, some don't. We can play the same game with gravity. The cup wouldn't fall if we were floating on the ISS. So the same cup doesn't fall in all locations it might conceivably be.

Many people don't want to deal with the level of precision that hard facts require. They get sloppy and then start these endless discussions of "this isn't true because..." etc. and everyone gets gradually more confused because nothing seems to be entirely true or false. The fundamental counter here is to dig in and tease the generalizations apart until they become sets of constrained hard facts.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:00AM (#42631100)
I think you are trying hard and writing a lot to miss the parent's point. You're thing about the number of words in the sentence is like what the parent is mistakenly calling "tautological;" another way to say it is blatantly obvious and a banal observation. This is not the type of thing we are talking about here. This is entire post is about "facts" and "fact checking" in the case of socio-political issues, the kinds of things for which there are fact checkers. The parent is obviously correct. Just look at the state of actual "fact checking" of this variety in the real world. There is a lot of controversy and a lot of words are used in a very loose way, these are not simple physics problems that you can punch into a TI-86. The issue is clearly about "who are the fact checkers" or put another way "who decides the facts." In a court of the law in the US, the judge is only arbiter of facts, these can not even be appealed.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by intended on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:55AM (#42631407)
Everything is political, which is one of the statements made above.

Facts are political. Because facts actively change how you live your life.

The playwright who created the “kill all climate denialists” talks about how it took years for the play to get onto stage.

And then how he began to see the truth of climate denialists positions. That climate denialists believed the facts, and realized it meant their whole way of life was over. So they had to do something about it. They responded with denial. In a very real way, they lived their beliefs.

The fact of climate change IS political.

EVERYTHING is political, there is no fact that I cannot convert into a weapon, through some means or the other. Blaming fact checkers, is simply trying not to blame humans.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:08AM (#42635010)
No, whether a coffee cup will break when you drop it or whatever that was is not a political thing. I'm not sure what the rest is about. To deny that there is a lot of subjectivity in the kinds of "facts" we are talking about her is just to deny reality.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by intended on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:11AM (#42645692)
The way you eat Pizza became a political thing.

Whether evolution occurs became a political thing.

It may odd, but political reality is a ‘motivated’ reality - there is a goal to be achieved.

Anything that can be used to create a political win, will be used to create a political win.

I agree that subjectivity exists though.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:59AM (#42635516)
How was I mistaken in my use of tautology?

My understanding is that it's supposed to be a reduction of a logical argument into the form A = A, or true = true.

When the words are different, but essentially mean the same thing, and used as a flawed proposition.

Am I wrong about that? I certainly don't want to bandy the word about incorrectly.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:08PM (#42640853)
But I agree with your overall point! :) Ok, so the statement "gravity keeps us on the ground" is not a tautology in the strict sense but you have correctly defined it here. I think it probably seems like a tautology because colloquially we might use it that way. I don't think its worth parsing out too much. This kind of stuff about coffee cups and all that has nothing to do with "fact checking" political statements and anyone else being serious knows that.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:54AM (#42647492)
Thanks!

With "gravity keeps us on the ground" I was trying to point out that the word "gravity" to most folks is the same thing as "the thing that keeps us on the ground", it's just a language symbol/shorthand for that concept, so the statement would reduce to A=A, and isn't a meaningful "fact".

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:00PM (#42630419)
While I get your point, and I think it's strong, I'm entirely unconvinced.

Everything we see, do and understand exists in a context window of an individual. We have a shared language, with which we can inexpertly communicate shared concepts. That language is terrible at communicating certain concepts, so we've invented things like math and counting to try to become more precise. It doesn't make those things "true" universally. It makes them consistent within a certain context.

How far it it from Dallas to Houston? On a paper map, it might be a few inches. True, within that context. Or you might get an answer for road miles. Or as the crow flies. In miles? Kilometers? It's only fairly recently (in human history) that we've even had somewhat consistent units of measure. And that whole conversation presupposes an enormous amount of culture knowledge and context - would that question mean anything to a native tribesman in Africa without an enormous amount of inculturation? Are their facts the same?

I'm not trying to make a "nothing is true, we can't know anything" kind of argument, that's lazy thinking.

I'm making an argument for maintaining skepticism in everything, even (especially?) things that you know for sure.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gmueckl on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:29PM (#42630917)
You still have to distinguish between hard, absolute facts which definitely exist and representations thereof in human language. The facts never change (the distance between Dallas and Houstom doesn't change while we are having this conversation), but accurate descriptions require additional concepts and now we get into the imprecise world of human communication. Doubting the precision and accuracy of human language is a fair point, but that doesn't make facts themselves subjective.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:46PM (#42631016)
> hard, absolute facts which definitely exist and representations thereof in human language

It's the distinction that you're drawing between those things that I'm skeptical of.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by brookst on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:37AM (#42631294)
I admire the conviction that things become absolutely true at a sufficient level of specification.

So long as facts are represented in language, they are subject to language’s imprecision and subjectivity. And I don’t think that platonic ideals of facts, independent of representstion, have much utility.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dambi0 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:15AM (#42642990)
What is Dallas? What is Houston? Which parts do we measure. are we talking about road distance? That something doesn't change during a conversation is not the same the thing as them never changing
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by teamonkey on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:22PM (#42647764)
If someone says "it's 250 miles from Houston to Dallas" you know that there will be some error involved. From precisely what part of Houston to what part of Dallas, does it include the outskirts, are they estimating, is it rounded to a nice number, etc.

If someone claims "it's 500 miles from Houston to Dallas" they're wrong.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dambi0 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:12PM (#42650356)
I’m going to pretend to avoid asking what is a mile and what is 250 and 500 :)

I could imagine ways we could interpret “500 miles” the same way as The Proclaimers i.e. as a noteworthy or arduous distance, under which that claim “it’s 500 miles from Dallas to Houston” isn’t contextually false.

More interesting is what knowing that things are not the case tells us about what we can know is the case. I don’t think it reveals much, but I’m not sure

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by teamonkey on Friday January 10, 2025 @03:54AM (#42653893)
This is much of science: taking a hypothesis, understanding where the bounds of that hypothesis lie, then testing the bounds to try to disprove it. Then creating a more accurate hypothesis within the space of what’s left unknown.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dambi0 on Friday January 10, 2025 @11:05AM (#42656847)
Unfortunately, I missed out a key word “… what knowing that things are not the case tells us about what we can know is [absolutely] the case…”

My apologies for this and with the omission I don’t disagree one bit with your reply.

On the other hand I can see how we might imagine ways we could scientifically sarisfy ourselves beliefs are not absolute, but I’m not sure how we could satisfy ourselves they are

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jachee on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:31PM (#42630920)
> How far it it from Dallas to Houston? On a paper map, it might be a few inches. True, within that context. Or you might get an answer for road miles. Or as the crow flies. In miles? Kilometers? It's only fairly recently (in human history) that we've even had somewhat consistent units of measure.

No one’s opinion is going to make them closer together or farther apart, though. The distance (in whatever context) can be known. Can be objectively measured. That makes it a fact.

> I'm making an argument for maintaining skepticism in everything, even (especially?) things that you know for sure.

Are you skeptical about which way to put your feet when you get out of bed? Do you check to make sure every single time?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by brookst on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:30AM (#42631257)
“Facts is facts” works for counting words in a sentence.

It does not work for anything with nuance or context, or for unprovable propositions. It is a fact that there is no elephant in my house. But if you want to doubt that fact for the lulz or for profit, I will be hard pressed to prove it.

That’s where our modern populist / fascists have weaponized disingenuousness to prove that “up is down” is just as valid a statement as “up is up”.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tsimionescu on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:02AM (#42631782)
> Your first sentence has 11 words.

It's, I think, quite relevant here to note that "word" is a famously hard to define concept in linguistics. That is, there is no generalized definition of the concept "word" that works across languages, writing systems (e.g. Chinese and Japanese writing don't traditionally use spaces to separate words), and ways of analyzing language (phonological words are different from grammatical words).

So to make your sentence more accurate, you'd have to say "there are 11 groups of letters separated by whitespace characters or punctuation before your first period".

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Tainnor on Friday January 10, 2025 @09:29AM (#42655825)
> It's, I think, quite relevant here to note that "word" is a famously hard to define concept in linguistics. That is, there is no generalized definition of the concept "word" that works across languages, writing systems (e.g. Chinese and Japanese writing don't traditionally use spaces to separate words), and ways of analyzing language (phonological words are different from grammatical words).

True, but for a language like English, the various definitions for "word" agree in many (though definitely not all) cases, and in the particular example, I think you'd have to argue somewhat harder to convince me that that sentence doesn't have exactly 11 words (maybe if you argue that "would have" often turns into "would've", which is a single phonetic unit, but then I would also write it that way). There are however other cases where it's less clear (e.g. is possessive 's a separate word or an affix?).

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by rayiner on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:00PM (#42630423)
I’d respectfully submit that:

1) While “facts” undisputed exist, there are vanishingly few people sufficiently versed in both epistemology and myriad substantive areas for “fact checking” to make sense. In particular, domain experts are rarely sufficiently versed in epistemology to distinguish between facts they know by virtue of their expertise, and other things they also believe that aren’t really facts.

Moreover, the folks employed checking facts for companies like Facebook typically don’t have any expertise in either epistemology or the range of substantive areas in which they perform fact checking.

2) In practice, the issue in society isn’t “facts” but “trust.” You can build trust by being consistently correct about facts in a visible way. But you can’t beat people over the head with putative facts if they don’t trust you.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by spinnn on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:33PM (#42630934)
It sounds like you may be heading in the direction of postmodernism, and/or post-Marxist Critical Theory
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:19AM (#42635729)
I certainly hope not.

My intent isn't to devolve into some sort of bastardized nihilism, it's to inject skepticism into anything that I can be bothered to think about.

I find it useful as a tool for critical analysis. To question a premise, to poke at the facts, especially the inarguable, indisputable ones.

There seems to be an inverse relationship between the accuracy of a fact and the amount of trouble you get in for questioning it.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by DaftDank on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:22PM (#42630205)
Subjective interpretation is very fundamental to being human and the way our minds work, but the underlying physical reality -- the wavelengths of light reflecting off the shirt -- can be measured objectively. A physicist might say that gravity is the curvature of spacetime caused by mass, which can be measured and tested.

Trump being a criminal is based on a shared legal and societal context. As a society, we accept that if you are convicted before a jury of your peers, you are guilty and have been convicted of a crime. Jury's get it wrong and the justice system is flawed and has made mistakes. A black man in the 1920s (or even the 1960s for that matter) being tried for murder with absolutely no evidence and sentenced to death is a clear miscarriage and corruption of justice. The testimony of Trump's employees during the trial, who all said they loved working there (most of them still worked there), but weren't willing to lie on the stand about checks and phone calls they participated in, was pretty clear cut. This wasn't random people off the street of [insert preferred liberal enclave here] testifying against him: it was his own people who still work for him.

Some people prioritize political allegiance over legal judgments when it suits them.

If we dismissed facts entirely, science, medicine, and countless other fields reliant on objective reality would collapse.

This exchange is a great example of the subjective nature of our experiences: as I've gotten older -- 38 now -- I've come to accept more and more that some things are objective reality, whereas in my teens and 20s, I questioned reality and society on the structural level, torn down to the studs. From Plato's cave, to brain in the vat, Kant, the Hindu Brahman and Maya, Buddhism, etc.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by rayiner on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:38PM (#42630965)
Your Trump trial example actually proves the opposite of the point you’re making. CNN’s legal analyst of all people wrote an article explaining why the prosecutors “contorted the law” in pursing Trump’s conviction: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/trump-was-convicted-.... Remember, the prosecutor initially declined to bring the case. And those problems with the underlying legal theory are still subject to review on appeal, which very well may result in the conviction being overturned. There’s actually a lot to debate there! Including whether the “shared context” you mention still holds in the circumstance of a blue-state jury trying Donald Trump. And I’d certainly not trust anyone—especially people without a legal background—to moderate people’s statements about Trump’s trial and conviction.

Heck, even lawyers don’t treat legal judgments as god-given “facts” except in specific legal circumstances. The questions at the back of every chapter in a law school textbook will ask the student whether a particular case was rightly decided or wrongly decided and why.

The better way to think about legal judgments is not in terms of “facts” but rather “process.” Even a final decision by the U.S. Supreme Court does not establish god given facts. It merely is the end of the line in a set of procedures that lead to a particular result in a particular case. But even judgments of the Supreme Court are second-guessed every day by 20-somethings in law schools around the country!

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:12AM (#42631167)
But, respectfully, even you, in your quest to cite facts require pointing out that your "facts" are not facts at all. The person in question, Trump, was not sentenced and therefore not "convicted" of anything. But this false claim is repeated a lot even by supposed "fact-checkers". Even the rest of that same paragraph is not made up of facts but you are trying to support some vague claim with appeals to things like "his own people wouldn't lie for him even though they loved him" or some such; you're bolstering a negative sentiment but not really clearly delineating anything resembling "facts". That's the issue that is being discussed and addressed by Meta at this point. Sure, we can call high schools physics problems as reflecting facts of nature, that's nice, but this is not what all the fuss is about.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by petersellers on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:11AM (#42631507)
> The person in question, Trump, was not sentenced and therefore not "convicted" of anything.

Sentencing != conviction. Conviction is the legal finding of guilt, sentencing is the appropriation of punishment.

Given your excessive use of scarequotes around "facts", getting this simple fact wrong is ironic.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:05AM (#42634978)
That's a neat story.

"in United States practice, conviction means a finding of guilt (i.e., a jury verdict or finding of fact by the judge) and imposition of sentence. If the defendant fled after the verdict but before sentencing, he or she has not been convicted,"

https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/106159/if-someone-ha...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by StackRanker3000 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:38AM (#42635318)
This is an instance where semantics are nothing more than, well, semantics.

The people who say that Trump has been ”convicted but not sentenced” actually mean that he’s been ”found guilty but not sentenced”, they just aren’t intimately familiar with legal terms of art.

If they simply say ”Donald Trump was found guilty but not sentenced” instead, they’ve silenced the nitpickers while still conveying the exact same message they intended to in the first place.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:14AM (#42635654)
> This is an instance where semantics are nothing more than, well, semantics.

I'm hard pressed to think of an example of a fact that your statement wouldn't apply to.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by StackRanker3000 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:49AM (#42636031)
Sometimes when people complain ”you’re just arguing semantics!”, the semantics do in fact need to be cleared up, because the words being used are confusing, or wrong in a way that’s preventing participants in the discussion from getting on the same page.

Here, no one is actually confused. Everyone knows and agrees that Trump was found guilty, but that he hasn’t been sentenced. The only sticking point is whether you can use the word ”convicted” to describe someone who is in that situation, and whether or not that’s the case doesn’t have any material effect on people’s understanding of reality. It’s just a matter of arguing over which words should be used, i.e. it’s just semantics.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by petersellers on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:29PM (#42637014)
Not true in New York, where this particular trial took place. From your own link:

  S 380.30 Time for pronouncing sentence.

  In general. Sentence must be pronounced without unreasonable delay.
  Court to fix time. Upon entering a conviction the court must:
  (a) Fix a date for pronouncing sentence; or
  (b) Fix a date for one of the pre-sentence proceedings specified in article four hundred; or
  (c) Pronounce sentence on the date the conviction is entered in accordance with the provisions of subdivision three.

So not only is sentencing distinct from conviction semantically, it's also distinct legally in the state of New York.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by monkey_monkey on Friday January 10, 2025 @01:03PM (#42658086)
Well, he is now a convicted felon.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:36PM (#42630280)
I take the "this seems to be true, based on what I know, subject to more information" approach.

I'm ok with not knowing things.

We can measure all sorts of things, and put them in a human context, which is very reassuring. What's a wave? What's a wavelength? What's a unit of measure? These are not universal truths, these are human inventions. Things we've created in order to communicate a shared understanding with each other of things we've observed. It makes us feel knowledgeable, lets us build cool things, and that's a good thing!

It also interferes with learning, and that's a bad thing. For example, (and I'm not taking a position on this either way, because I don't know) I think it's very unlikely, based on your comment, that it would be easy to convince you that Trump is not a criminal. Or, to pick a less controversial topic, to convince the early Catholic church of the heliocentric model of the solar system. Because they already had the "facts."

It's a comfortable position to know things.

It's uncomfortable to not know. As I've gotten older, I've become more comfortable with being uncomfortable.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by DaftDank on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:26AM (#42635809)
It would indeed be hard to convince me Trump has not committed crimes, considering a jury found that he had and the whole, "Walks like a duck, quacks like a duck," thing. Tony Accardo ran the Chicago Outfit for 4-5 decades and never spent a single day in jail. I don't think most people would agree that because he was never convicted (or even charged), he was not committing crimes.

If you read a story about a drug kingpin being convicted at trial, do you assume that he might be innocent?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by claytongulick on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:14PM (#42647685)
> If you read a story about a drug kingpin being convicted at trial, do you assume that he might be innocent?

That's a very fair question.

To answer: I try as hard as I can to not draw any conclusion from something like that.

I'll be 50 this year. I've seen so many examples of media manipulation, "spin", crooked prosecutors, etc... that I try very hard not to jump to a conclusion. Especially with stories like "child pornography was found on his laptop". There are countless examples of police and three letter agents getting caught red-handed planting this stuff, that I'm always skeptical of news stories like that.

Then there's the whole argument of "what's a criminal?". It's frequently the ethical choice to violate an unjust law. Was Ghandi a criminal? If someone broke a law, but then the law was changed or removed, are they still a criminal?

What kind of drug kingpin? (I'm purposefully being pedantic here for rhetorical purposes) Were they "dealing" ibogaine? Maybe for injured vets? It's strange to me that it's a schedule 1, and I definitely wouldn't consider them to be a criminal for doing that. Or maybe they were doing some combination of things, some good some bad. Or maybe there's a good reason why it's schedule 1, and I just don't understand and they really are a bad guy.

My point is that there's usually nuance. I don't trust stories like that, I don't "believe" news articles. I read them, take them in, and reserve judgement. Really. My initial, unconscious reaction and inner voice immediately says "are they framing him? What's the other side of the story? If he is a bad guy, does he see himself that way?"

I've just been burned too many times in my life by getting sucked into media stories that I believed were true, and made an idiot out of myself because I didn't think critically about it and jumped on a bandwagon that later turned out to be BS.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tsimionescu on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:15AM (#42631854)
> Trump being a criminal is based on a shared legal and societal context.

To think that someone is a criminal, you have to believe they committed a crime. A trial is one way of establishing whether they did with certain standards of evidence and process. But it is very far from the be-all-end-all of the matter.

For example, virtually everyone believes OJ Simpson is a criminal, even though he was found not guilty at trial, and even though plenty of biases worked against him in that trial, theoretically.

For myself, I do believe that Trump was rightfully convicted and is a criminal. But that doesn't mean that "he was convicted" should force anyone else to believe this. It only means that a particular group of jurors believed it given the evidence that a judge found correctly collected and presented to them.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by motorest on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:02AM (#42631778)
> As I've gotten older, I've become increasingly skeptical of the idea of a "fact".

I think the problem actually lies in your personal interpretation of what a "fact" should be, and how it contrasts with what facts actually are.

The definition of "fact" is "things that are known or proven to be true". Consequently, if you can prove that an assertion is not true then you prove it is not a fact. If your wife claims your shirt is green and not blue, does that refute the fact that your shirt is actually blue? No. Can you prove your shirt is blue? Can she prove your shirt is green? That is the critical aspect.

Just because someone disagrees with you, that does not mean either if you is right or wrong. You can both be stating facts if it just so happens you're presuming definitions that don't match exactly in specific critical aspects.

If your shirt is cyan, you can argue it's a fact the shirt is blue and argue it's a fact the shirt is green, because in RGB space both the blue channel and green channel is saturated. You can also state that it's a fact that your shirt is neither blue or green because there's a specific definition for that color and this one is in fact cyan, not blue or green.

If you can prove your assertion, it's a fact. If you're making claims you cannot prove or even support, they are not facts.

And more importantly, the problem tackled by fact checking is people making claims that are patently and ostentatiously false and fabricated in order to manipulate public perception and opinions. Does anyone care if your shirt is blue or green? No. Does anyone care if, say, Haitians are eating your pets? Yes.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Tainnor on Friday January 10, 2025 @09:35AM (#42655881)
Tautologies are not necessarily uninteresting, all of mathematics is essentially about finding tautologies (on some level), but they're far typically from obvious.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by astrange on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:02AM (#42631775)
Answering this question has to be a political topic, because there's an infinite stream of people asking you the question (by posting things that may need to be fact checked), and you have to decide which ones to prioritize.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by intended on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:46AM (#42631353)
Yes and no.

This is the line in the sand that makes sense in the pre internet era.

Online, EVERYTHING is political speech, because moderation is the only effective action we can take, and moderation is currently conflated with censorship. Even though it’s on a private platform.

I was working towards researching this and building the case out fully - but online speech efficacy is not served by the blunt measures of physical spaces, where the ability to speak is not as mediated.

Online, diversity of voices, capability of users to interact safely, resolution of conflicts, these are better measures of how healthy the market of ideas is.

The point of free speech is to have an effective exchange of ideas, even difficult ones. The idea of free speech is not in service of itself, its in service of a greater good.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by boxed on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:31AM (#42631600)
1+1=2 is not a political statement
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by lazide on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:54AM (#42634854)
Apparently, it is now.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by portaouflop on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:53PM (#42629177)
There are few things that aren’t political regardless how you feel about them
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by adamredwoods on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:34PM (#42629942)
The earth is "round" can be made political, but there is a factual consensus.

Therefore, we rely on experts that decipher information to transcend political opinions. It saddens me when scientists become political, only to add confusion to the consensus, in an attempt to weaken it.

Long live Wikipedia.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:37PM (#42630637)
The US is going to endure four more years of post-truth governance. It isn't in Zuckerberg's interest to have his organization pointing out that the emperor is unclothed when there is real risk of blowback in round 2.
[dead]
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jimbokun on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:35PM (#42628509)
Classically liberal, sure.

Modern progressives shut themselves off from any ideas they don’t already agree with, making it impossible for them to discern whether what they believe is true or not.

Of course this is also true of many religious conservatives. It’s just now equally true of those on the far left.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Henchman21 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:49PM (#42629154)
Please provide one example of your assertion.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dgfitz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:12PM (#42629360)
Seems like legal vs. illegal immigration is low-hanging fruit.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by greenthrow on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:36PM (#42629542)
What about them? That they exist? No one disputes that. That illegal immigrants cause crime? We have hard data on that; it's not true. That they are a drain on society via social programs? We have data on that too; they get taxes witheld but cannot claim refunds and cannot enroll in social benefit programs due to their lack of SSN.

On any topic you want to pick it's typically the radical right wing who have their fingers in their ears.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dgfitz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:59PM (#42629707)
I think the bit where it’s illegal is the issue.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by greenthrow on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:01PM (#42629719)
Nobody disagrees whether it is illegal. Whether it should stay illegal is the thing people disagree on.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dgfitz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:17PM (#42629819)
I think you made the GPs point for them.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by greenthrow on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:40PM (#42629988)
How? Whether it should remain illegal is not a factual question. You are being deliberately obtuse to avoid admitting you are wrong.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dgfitz on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:55AM (#42632611)
People are mad about a double standard: rules only apply to some people.

This isn’t hard to grasp.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by greenthrow on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:02AM (#42634303)
What's hard to grasp is how you think this applies to a discussion about differing facts based on political leaning. Nobody disagrees with the facts here, only on what should be done going forward. So, not really relevant to the discussion.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dgfitz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @07:32AM (#42644627)
If you see it that way, things will never change.

I don’t care about immigration either way, I don’t have an axe to grind.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by immibis on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:02PM (#42636745)
The people who think illegal immigrants shouldn't be illegal don't think anyone should be illegal. What's the double standard? It's not like they think black people should be allowed in but white people shouldn't.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by avarun on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:10PM (#42629333)
Noah Smith’s entire twitter feed is dedicated to pointing out progressive lies.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Henchman21 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:41PM (#42639817)
Apologies I have no idea who this is or why I should respect their authority on this subject?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by pstuart on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:23PM (#42628968)
"Modern progressives" -- that's a wide net you're casting.

I consider myself to be a progressive and am more than happy to critique "lefty stuff" all day long. I know I'm not alone in that regard.

Try me.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by singleshot_ on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:53PM (#42628675)
Is it universally true that every truth test requires leveraging the existence of false claims/things I don’t agree with? For example if Socrates is a man, if all men are mortal, what false fact would you need to draw the logical conclusion? Or am I missing your point?

I’m not reflecting this idea, of course, because I’m a progressive. It does seem a bit imaginary, though.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dabbledash on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:03PM (#42628781)
I guess it depends

Is climate change driven by human activity? Do males have a natural advantage in sports? Do vaccines cause autism? Does rent control make housing more available?

The major political tribes are full of BS, because politics mostly isn't driven by disagreements about facts but by conflicting material interests. Partisans believe whats convenient.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by oblio on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:10PM (#42628844)
> Do males have a natural advantage in sports? Do vaccines cause autism?

I won't argue about the other two, BUT.

We have facts for contact sports and for speed and strength sports, we've had these facts for millenia.

For the vaccine one, we also have facts. You're more likely to win the lottery than to get autism from them. I think they're probably the same odds as dying from a potted plant falling on your head while walking but anti vaxxers don't seem to be wearing helmets everywhere, that's so weird...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mewpmewp2 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:33PM (#42629520)
I am not saying vaccines cause autism or anything, but where are you pulling your odds out from?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by dabbledash on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:22PM (#42629858)
I don't think any of these are ambiguous. My point is that sometimes right wingers take the nonsense position and sometimes left wingers take the nonsense position. Neither side reliably follows the evidence or "believes the science" so glib lines like "reality has a liberal bias" are shallow and silly.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tsimionescu on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:24AM (#42631910)
The point of the phrase "reality has a liberal bias" is not "liberals never take a nonsense position", it's "more of the facts that liberals [just as tribalistically] believe in happen to also be true, when compared to conservatives".

That something like this might happen is not surprising. If you have two political groups and you assign both beliefs from a bag in a purely random process, odds are that one of the groups will end up with more true beliefs than the other, through no virtue of their own but through pure chance.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by HPsquared on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:07AM (#42633334)
Liberalism is just another ideology. It's built on a set of axioms which are taken on faith. They are not empirically determined and, as moral judgements, can't be. It's not in the realm of science.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by paulddraper on Saturday January 11, 2025 @05:58PM (#42669639)
> You're more likely to win the lottery than to get autism from them.

Citation?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by seadan83 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:49AM (#42631365)
How do you distinguish partisans from actual knowledge? The Steve Bannon philosophy of flood the zone with shit so it all looks the same seems to have killed public discourse IMO. It is easy to label everyone as partisans.

To your questions, the best explanations for climate change are human causes (and with very considerable evidence).

Women have higher pain tolerances and greater natural buoyancy, they are greatly advantaged at long distance cold water swimming. Many other sports require physical size and/or strength - so it does depend. Vaccines have no evidence of _causing_ autism, and the big paper that made that claim was retracted. I don't know about rent control and do not know what data exists.

Yeah, the answer of, yes, and here is all the evidence just doesn't seem to fly. I feel that trolling and trolls, and science illiteracy just have simply won the day.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by immibis on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:03PM (#42636759)
> The Steve Bannon philosophy of flood the zone with shit so it all looks the same

FWIW, it's called the Firehose of Falsehood and the Soviets invented it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firehose_of_falsehood

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by nearbuy on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:21PM (#42628378)
Conservatives believe the truth supports conservative beliefs, and liberals believe it supports liberal beliefs. This type of comment is about the same as just saying "I am a liberal", which almost by definition means you think liberal beliefs are true. It doesn't add much to the conversation.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by DonHopkins on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:25PM (#42628415)
But only one party rode into office hysterically warning of immigrants eating dogs and cats.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mewpmewp2 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:36PM (#42629549)
I am on the US left by any survey measurable by my principles, while not from US, this logic also sounds juvenile. Stooping to the level that a single person should be able to represent a whole side, did you see Joe at the debates?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by the_gastropod on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:18PM (#42629831)
Oh boy. Are you trying to do the "both sides" thing? Joe was pretty bad at the debates. His voice was weak. He stuttered. He misspoke. It was bad. And then what happened? He stepped down as the party's candidate, and the rest is history, as they say.

That is quite different from making up wild stories about immigrants eating cats, fabricating nonsense about widespread election fraud / stolen elections, suggesting injecting bleach is a sufficient remedy for coronavirus, sharpie-ing atop hurricane maps to prove previous incorrect statements were totally real because... look: sharpie! And this man has never had more widespread support.

These. Parties. Are. Not. The. Same.

By the way, it wasn't just one man making this "immigrants are eating our pets" thing. In addition to Trump, other prominent Republicans such as J.D. Vance, Marc Molinaro, and Laura Loomer also repeated this lie.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jimbokun on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:37PM (#42628526)
Just because one political party is obviously worse doesn’t mean you should take everything said by the other political party as gospel truth.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by roenxi on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:30PM (#42629504)
Statistically, most US seems to believe that the Democratic party is obviously worse at the Federal level. They just lost an election on every metric, although they did win the lost-to-Trump-twice award after almost a decade of opportunities to come up with an effective counter-Trump strategy.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ChocolateGod on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:33PM (#42628491)
Trump and his antics are not mainstream conservative thought, especially not on a global or even 'western' level.

He does however have a knack for attracting people disenfranchised from politics.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by the_gastropod on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:26PM (#42629472)
He's been the undisputed head of the "conservative" party in the U.S. for 10 years now. And just won his second election, this time winning the popular vote. If that's not mainstream, I don't know what is.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by davidw on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:59PM (#42628736)
Sure they are. People like the Cheneys or Mitt Romney are not mainstream conservatives in the US any more.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ethbr1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:14PM (#42628877)
Accurate. It's difficult to argue that the mainstream US Republican isn't a populist now. Twice is not a fluke.

And ever since the 70s there's been a tension between the blocks of the Republican party: fiscal business conservatives, foreign policy hawks, and rural/religious conservatives.

After couple decades getting the final group fired up, they decided they wanted to drive. And the primary system rewarded them.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by defrost on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:49PM (#42629639)
> the final group fired up, they decided they wanted to drive. And the primary system rewarded them.

I've been an outside observer of US politics for many decades, I'd characterize what happened not so much as the primary system rewarding them but more as a consummate grifter and snakeoil carpetbagger fooling them into thinking they've won.

They got fired up, they got the candidate they voted for, I'm not sure the expected rewards will follow as hoped and expected.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ethbr1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:34PM (#42630620)
I think folks undersell Trump's intention to deliver. Just, to him, there's no objective reality outside of the message and the public reaction.

So he says "We'll build a wall!", then throws up a few miles of fencing, then takes some photos and says "We built the wall!", and people believe him?

That's job done.

Sure, there are a lot of interests around him, but I honestly don't think he's playing a master plan. He just lives inside messaging.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by moomin on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:48PM (#42628627)
I have definitely heard conservatives complain that reality has a left-wing bias. Not in quite those words, but close enough that you wonder if it’s possible to die of cognitive dissonance.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by immibis on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:04PM (#42636770)
Well, no. It means when facts are tested by objective means, more of them align with liberal beliefs than conservative beliefs. Unless you believe that facts can't be objectively tested?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by nearbuy on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:34PM (#42651901)
If you comment with evidence showing that, you might be enriching the comment section. Simply having a bunch of people leave unsubstantiated comments like "truth has a conservative bias" or "truth has a liberal bias" is only adding noise. And it shows a certain lack of self-awareness.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by bluescrn on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:31PM (#42629027)
Liberal as in classical liberalism, or as in progressivism (which is becoming increasingly authoritarian)?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Henchman21 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:47PM (#42629138)
Could you give an example of increasing authoritarianism from progressivism?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by portaouflop on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:55PM (#42629196)
This was a thing in the 2010s when “cancel culture” and other SJW shenanigans were prevalent.

As far as I can tell the culture war is over since end of the pandemic - now the class war has begun, it’s going to be interesting

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by SyzygyRhythm on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:30PM (#42629503)
Tim Walz claimed there is "no guarantee to free speech on misinformation or hate speech, and especially around our democracy." That's false--the First Amendment has no such carveouts for those things. So it's concerning that Walz would think otherwise.

Hillary Clinton has made similar comments, saying "But I also think there are Americans who are engaged in this kind of propaganda, and whether they should be civilly, or even in some cases criminally, charged is something that would be a better deterrence, because the Russians are unlikely, except in a very few cases, to ever stand trial in the United States." But again, there is no First Amendment carveout for propaganda, Russian or otherwise.

There are some limits to protected speech, but they're rare and mostly limited to direct incitement of a crime or other threat.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by HideousKojima on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:04PM (#42629279)
Landlords in NYC can be fined up to $250,000 for misgendering tenants, i.e. compelled speech:

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/transgender-pronouns-fine-...

And Canada has similar (and far more widespread and severe) laws punishing people for expressing wrongthink about trans issues.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by lo_zamoyski on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:50PM (#42629651)
In the final analysis, I don't think it matters. The former leads to the latter. The same is true of things like attempts to keep the LGB, but toss the T. The T follows from the LGB. The LGB already presupposes all that is needed to infer the T. You would be drawing an artificial line in the sand otherwise. It's ad hoc and doesn't work.

One common error people make is that they think they can pick and choose beliefs and positions a la carte and expect them to remain stable as fixed parameters of the environment. But that's not how ideas work. They aren't static in this way. Rather, they function much like presuppositions that, over time, are worked out, dialectically, if you will. Society is like a machine that works out the consequences of ideas over time.

So, I always find it amusing when anyone appeals to some fondly remembered status quo that held in a prior decade, believing that all one needs to do is return to that status quo "verbatim" and all will be well, as if these things were just a matter of arranging the furniture a certain way. You can't roll back the clock, and if you could, you would only recreate a similar development that led to the undesirable state of affairs in the first place.

This isn't an argument for some kind of Big P progessivism, or against tradition, only an account of how cultures develop over time. In our case, by understanding the tensions and contradictions within the liberalism tradition, we can come to explain why Western societies have moved in a certain direction over the last 200 years. Heck, we can go back further to the influence of Luther, or even further to Ockham, without whose ideas liberalism would arguably not exist.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by lo_zamoyski on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:26PM (#42629462)
If you begin with liberal blinders on, then that might be the picture you receive.

(I define here "liberal" and "liberalism" not in the lazy, colloquial partisan sense, as in "own the libs!" or "left wing", but the philosophical definition in the tradition of Hobbes, Locke, and others. In this sense, "we" are all liberals in the liberal West.)

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by numpad0 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:19PM (#42629838)
Not a huge problem so long it remains a means to indicate that the post is hallucinatory. Content of checks/notes don't matter, it's tone policing.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by PaulHoule on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:44PM (#42630009)
People are going to believe it is political whether or not it is. I've been working at hard at talking about difficult issues in a depoliticized frame. It's hard.

Lately I've been talking with a lot of people trying to help find answers and something I am learning is to delete all the duckspeak from my vocabulary (there was an otherwise good article about "placement poverty" in medical education that I didn't post last weekend because but "X poverty" is duckspeak)

If I say anything at all to anyone about this or that and get a negative response about the words I use I take it very seriously and most of the time resolve to use different words in future.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by seadan83 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:04PM (#42630787)
What are more examples of duckspeak and is it context dependent?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by lodovic on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:02AM (#42631770)
Orwell defined it as thoughtless or formulaic speech.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by PaulHoule on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:09AM (#42634381)
There is an essay at the end of Orwell's 1984

https://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks01/0100021.txt

called "The Principles of Newspeak" that coins the word.

The slogan "My Body My Choice" has some of this character. It rolls off the tongue and stops thought. There is no nuance: the rights of the mother are inalienable. Opponents will talk about the inalienable rights of the fetus. There is no room for compromise but setting some temporal point in the pregnancy is a compromise like Solomon's that makes sense to the disengaged but gives no satisfaction to people who see it as moral issue. [1]

Note that this phrase turned out to be content-free and perfectly portable when it got picked up by anti-vaccine activists.

"Illegal Alien" is a masterpiece of language engineering that stands on its own for effectiveness. I mean, we all follow laws that we don't agree with or live with the threat of arrest and imprisonment if we don't. It's easy to see somebody breaking the law and not getting caught as a threat to the legitimacy of the system. "Undocumented Migrant" has been introduced as an alternative but it just doesn't roll off the tongue in the same way and since it is not so entrenched it comes across more as language engineering.

(Practically as opposed to morally: Americans would rather work at Burger King rather than get a few more $ per hour to get up early for difficult and dirty work which might have you toiling in the hot or the cold. An American would see a farmhand job at a dairy farm as a dead end job. A Mexican is an experienced ag worker who might want to save up money to buy his own farm. Which one does the dairy farmer want to have handling his cows?)

My son bristles at "healthcare" as a word consistently used for abortion and transgender medicine to the point where he shows microexpressions when reading discussions about access to healthcare in general.

This poster burns me up

https://www.pinterest.com/pin/741405157385448245/

in that teaching small children the alleged difference between two words will make a difference in the very difficult problems that (say) black [2] people have in America trivializes those problems. It trains them to become the kind of people who will trade memes online as opposed to facing those problems. In the meantime I've heard so many right wingers repetitively talk about "Equality of opportunity" vs "Equality of outcomes" which is a real point but reduces a complex and fraught problem to a single axis.

[1] There's a great discussion of this https://www.amazon.com/Rights-Talk-Impoverishment-Political-... although that book has a discussion of the Americans with Disabilities Act that hasn't aged well

[2] Bloomberg Businessweek has a policy to always say capital B when they talk about "Black" people. Do black people care? Does it really help them? What side of the barricades are they on when they write gushing articles about Bernard Arnault and review $250 bottles of booze and $3000/night hotel rooms.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:51AM (#42635444)
> "Undocumented Migrant" has been introduced as an alternative but it just doesn't roll off the tongue in the same way and since it is not so entrenched it comes across more as language engineering.

It definitely comes across as language engineering. It's a legitimate category ("I'm an asylum seeker directly on my way to claim asylum from the nearest office") but expanded to include people who are just in the country illegally. It's too obvious to convince many people for very long.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Jerrrry on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:36AM (#42635302)
Crossing the border is fine, unless it's a state line.

Then you cannot cross it or the intent is murder.

Unless your intent is to murder, than you can cross it - that's Healthcare.

Healthcare is a right. In fact, it's an societal obligation. Trust the Science(TM).

Your body, the state's choice.

Are you a racist, or a communist?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by pyrale on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:32PM (#42637038)
> My son bristles at "healthcare" as a word consistently used for abortion and transgender medicine

In terms of cost, the items you cite are vanishingly small, and to conflate the two, one must have no experience of the medical system beyond twitter.

Is your son on his own? Did he have to pay the cost for a broken limb or a child's disease, or has he seen a family member go through a cancer? Maybe he would have a better sense of what "healthcare" means if he had actually been facing these situations.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by shakes_mcjunkie on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:35AM (#42634031)
I think you'll find basically everything is political. Do you have a fear of debate or criticism?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by throwway120385 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:03PM (#42636190)
Actually very few things have to be political. Politicising, that is rendering the concept to decision by a "body politic" is a choice that we're making right now, and we could choose to not do that. In fact, we have done that throughout our nation's history, and it's only in the last 20 years that I've seen the rise of "everything is political speech" to the degree that the brand of beans you buy in a store signals something to some group.

To wit there are a lot of totalitarians out there, and just because some group claims to be on your side or looking out for your interests versus some other group it doesn't mean they don't want your mind, body, and soul for their own purposes. We must take it upon ourselves to think for ourselves and to hold our own interests rather than to adopt the interests of the group we're in. Humans can engage in enterprise as a group for their own reasons, and we ought to embrace that instead of seeking to identify so wholly with the group that we lose ourselves.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by PaulHoule on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:12AM (#42634413)
No. I can't stand it that so many Americans have fallen under the spell of a fraudster while others are sharing hateful memes online and think it is activism. I need stronger language, not weaker language.

I don't like the word "debate" because it makes me think of a high school debate where you are assigned which side of the issue and it is about to winning or losing.

https://depts.washington.edu/fammed/wp-content/uploads/2018/...

in the current situation people feel they have exactly one candidate to vote for every time and thus we have no ability to vote out corrupt politicians. The political class wins and the rest of us lose.

(I am so concerned about people's inability or reluctant to change that I've experienced a call to the ministry and I'm working to use practices that I developed for selfish ends in the past to help others. Ideally when I offend you I want to strike you at the core and leave you haunted for months and not be able to think about the issue the same way ever again. If you're reacting to bits of trash somebody else stuck on me that I'm not aware of, I'm not going to get that strike in.)

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by khafra on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:26AM (#42632784)
What I've read of the Community Notes algorithm casts it as far more neutral than any hiring decisions about professional content moderators could possibly be. If it's "political," it's in a similar way to comparing the GDP of various countries is political--reality gives the verdict, the politics is in whether that verdict was the optimal one to ask reality for.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by toasteros on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:55AM (#42631729)
> I just can't help but think there's a political component to all of it.

"We're moving to Texas to eliminate perceptions of bias" is the biggest giveaway of this.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ARandomerDude on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:56AM (#42632068)
Austin is very left of center. If they end up there, they will have ideologically strayed in California while geographically moving to Texas.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by throwaway48476 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:06AM (#42632981)
Stayed not strayed.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by shakes_mcjunkie on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:30AM (#42633981)
Infowars was based in Austin. Joe Rogan is in Austin. How does moving to Austin mean they are "ideologically" in California?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:47AM (#42635408)
Joe Rogan also moved from California.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tough on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:45PM (#42636591)
Elon too, isnt it cheaper taxes for business there?

i mean they can just pretend and get paid

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by robertlagrant on Thursday January 09, 2025 @08:29AM (#42645197)
Texas does not have a corporate income tax but does have a gross receipts tax with rates not strictly comparable to corporate income tax rates.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ARandomerDude on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:02PM (#42636748)
Visit Texas. Then visit Austin. You'll know what I mean.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_United_States_presidentia...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:52AM (#42635456)
People move to other states due to state laws. City laws can easily be avoided by living and/or working just outside the city limits. Or more likely, state laws will preempt city laws that go against state level politics.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by isleyaardvark on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:32PM (#42640228)
The intent is clear.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by friendzis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:00AM (#42643646)
The political bias I agree with is better!!1
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gadders on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:51AM (#42632588)
There was always a political component to it. The Twitter files told us this. It's just the political component is going the other way.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by red-iron-pine on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:41AM (#42635352)
what are the twitter files?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gadders on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:00AM (#42635530)
The documents provided by Elon Musk to Bari Weiss, Matt Taibbi etc when he took over Twitter.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ethbr1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:53PM (#42625883)
I expect it was an easy bone to throw the incoming administration, which the tech world learned from v1 is placatable by giving them PR / sound bite wins.

To the broader concern, this feels like Facebook making their original sin again.

Namely defunding and destroying revenue for a task that takes money (fact checking) and then expecting a free, community-driven approach to replace it.

Turns out, hot takes for clicks are a lot cheaper than journalism.

In this case, where is the funding to support nuanced, accurate fact checking at scale from?

Because it sure seems like Facebook isn't going to pay.

> I've never seen a wrong Facebook fact-check

Did you mean to say Note here?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:56PM (#42625923)
No, I meant to say Facebook fact-check.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ethbr1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @02:00PM (#42625973)
> Facebook's fact-checkers have been that much of a product disaster.

> I've never seen a wrong Facebook fact-check

Confused between these two statements, then.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @02:07PM (#42626070)
Do you believe the success or failure of these moderating features comes down to how accurate they are? People actually like Community Notes; they're part of the discourse on Twitter (even if most of them are pretty bad, some of them are timely and sharp). Meanwhile: Facebook's fact-checking features really do work sort of like PSA's for trolls. All the while, fact-checks barely scratch the surface of the conversations happening on the platform.

Facebook and Twitter are also unalike in their social dynamics. It makes sense to think of individual major trending stories on Twitter, which can be "Noted", in a way it doesn't make sense on Meta, which is atomized; people spreading bullshit on Meta are carpet bombing the site with individual hits each hoping to get just a couple eyeballs, rather than a single monster thread everyone sees.

(This may be different on Threads, I don't use Threads or know anybody who does).

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ethbr1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:28PM (#42627751)
Success in what definition?

PR/political success is certainly not correlated with accuracy, given the very act of telling a group they're wrong tends to piss them off.

In terms of encouraging discourse that maximizes user enjoyment of the platform? That's a difficult one. Accuracy probably doesn't do a whole lot there either: HN knows the people love someone being confidently wrong.

Success in terms of society? Probably more yes, albeit with the caveat that only a correction that someone feels good about actually wins hearts and minds. Otherwise they spiral off into conspiracies about "the man" keeping them down. (Read: conservative reality)

It's also important to remember that Zuckerberg only tacked into moderation in the first place due to prevailing political winds -- he openly espoused absolutist views about free speech originally, before some PR black eyes made that untenable.

To me, both approaches to moderation at scale (admins moderating or users moderating) are band-aids.

The underlying problem is algorithmic promotion.

The platforms need to be more curious about the type of content their algorithms are selecting for promotion, the characteristics incentivized, and the net experience result.

Rage-driven virality shouldn't be an organizational end unto itself to juice engagement KPIs and revenue. User enjoyment of the platform should be.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tsimionescu on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:50AM (#42632032)
> he openly espoused absolutist views about free speech originally, before some PR black eyes made that untenable.

Note that openly espousing absolutist views about free speech means less than nothing. Elon Musk and Donald Trump openly profess such views, while constantly shouting down, blocking, or even suing anyone who dares speak against them with any amount of popularity.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by FireBeyond on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:30PM (#42630252)
> Do you believe the success or failure of these moderating features comes down to how accurate they are? People actually like Community Notes; they're part of the discourse on Twitter (even if most of them are pretty bad, some of them are timely and sharp). Meanwhile: Facebook's fact-checking features really do work sort of like PSA's for trolls. All the while, fact-checks barely scratch the surface of the conversations happening on the platform.

You're making a whole host of assumptions and opinions about this, with little in the way of data (I get it, you don't work at FB, how much data could you have?), just making blanket statements: "People hate Fact Checks", "People actually like Community Notes" and accepting them as accurate.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:41PM (#42630316)
I use Facebook, a lot (again: all the politics in my town happens there), and almost nothing is fact-checked; I see one fact-check notice for every 1,000 bad posts I see. I feel like I'm on pretty solid ground saying that what they're doing today isn't working.

Meanwhile: Community Notes have become part of the discourse on Twitter; getting Noted is the new Ratio'd.

Accuracy has nothing to do with any of this. I don't think either Notes or Warnings actually solves "misinformation". I'm saying one is a good product design, and the other is not.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by psyklic on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:00AM (#42631106)
Not seeing fact checks likely means it's working: "Once third-party fact-checkers have fact-checked a piece of Meta content and found it to be misleading or false, Meta reduces the content’s distribution "so that fewer people see it.""

The issue with Community Notes is that if enough people believe a lie, it will not be noted. This lends further credence to a certain set of "official" lies.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by freejazz on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:39AM (#42635921)
> I feel like I'm on pretty solid ground saying that what they're doing today isn't working

How does that follow at all?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by curtisblaine on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:22AM (#42631893)
It's not that they're inaccurate, it's just that they cherry-pick the topics to fact-check and their choice (in my limited experience) is always biased leftwards. You can be absolutely correct and absolutely malicious at the same time.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by energy123 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:10AM (#42631831)
Obeying in advance, especially the Dana White appointment. Not that this move to community notes wasn't also a good product decision.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Barrin92 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:08PM (#42626815)
>I think it would have been product development malpractice

the thing is both community notes and top down moderation, if they have any purpose at all, are product malpractice. If they work, they are always going to be intrusive because that's what they're supposed to do, correct factually wrong information. Community notes is the neighborhood police, top down moderation is the feds but if they do their job either one is going to be annoying by definition.

If they're not intrusive they don't perform a corrective function and that's what largely happened to community notes. As time goes on they're more and more snarky and sarcastic meta comments rather than corrections.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by _DeadFred_ on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:15PM (#42627576)
But because they are community driven, they are snarky in a way that represents the community, which makes me question if they are intrusive at all. They are what the community grows them into.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:15PM (#42626913)
It seems pretty clear to me that one of these features generally makes users happy and, at the same time, does correct some misinformation, and the other catches about 0.0001% of the bad stuff and turns it into advertisements for how bad the site is.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mrguyorama on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:51PM (#42628658)
How can you possibly call community notes on Twitter a "success" when they demonstrably have not reduced the amount of actively made up shit on the site, and the same people who complain about a fact checker saying "no, vaccines do not change your DNA" are just as upset when that info comes from the community notes box, and the only reason there hasn't been widescale anger about them is because Elon wants to pretend it was his idea.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:39PM (#42629569)
I'm not saying Twitter it is good. It is demonstrably not. But you're kidding yourself if you thought Facebook fact checking was suppressing the antivaxers and flat-earthers.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by freejazz on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:44AM (#42635982)
Oh, so community notes on twitter are actually not good, but its good that Facebook is implementing them anyway? You make no sense and are constantly equivocating back and forth in all your different posts.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by melodyogonna on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:10AM (#42631833)
They're not there to eliminate made up shit, they're the to add context - e.g "this post is made up and demonstrably false".
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by hn_throwaway_99 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:22PM (#42628391)
As a product decision, I agree.

But I think that can still be addressed separately from the fact that all the tech leaders in Silicon Valley are bending the knee to Trump (e.g. the Mar-a-Lago visits, the "donations" to his inauguration, etc.)

I'll give you an example I find analogous. When Bezos forbid the Washington Post from giving a presidential endorsement, he wrote an op-ed, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/10/28/jeff-bezo.... I pretty much agreed with the vast majority of what he wrote there. What I think is total BS, though, is his purported rationale and the timing of the decision. I think it's absolutely clear he did it because he didn't want to piss off Trump should he win (the "obeying in advance" part), which he did. The reason I believe this is because he made this decision so close to the election, and he apparently didn't feel the need to do this in previous years, or even the fact that WaPo made other political endorsements (e.g. Senate races in Maryland and VA) just before the presidential endorsement was banned. Bezos subsequent Mar-a-Lago visits and Amazon's inauguration "donation" pretty much confirm my view in my opinion.

In Zuckerberg's announcement, I thought the part he put in about fact checkers being "politically biased" was unnecessary (not to mention dubious IMO), and cleared seemed done to curry favor with the current powers that be.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:37PM (#42629554)
As someone active in "resistance"-type organization from 2017-2021, with fundamentally the same politics now as I had then: I think all this "bend the knees" shit is mostly working to the benefit of the GOP, and I wish people would stop it. We lost an election, in part because we bet that the median voter was prepared to disqualify MAGA Republicans. They are not. Find a new angle, so we can win in the midterms. This isn't working.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by hn_throwaway_99 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:20PM (#42629849)
I'm not trying to convince other voters. The "bend the knee" shit is not something I'm saying to try to change opinions. Like you say, clearly the majority of Americans don't care.

But it I'm pretty surprised at the outright transparent speed with which all these business leaders were willing to pay these naked fealty bribes, especially since for so long so many of them talked about these lofty goals besides just making money.

Italians in the 1930s didn't care either when Mussolini made corporations an arm of the state. But that doesn't mean what is happening now is any different.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:35PM (#42629951)
I'm pretty sure they do this every cycle no matter who wins, but Democrats notice and recoil when it happens after a Republican win, and vice versa. There's also a titration of the news media mining clicks from a framing that de-"normalizes" the Trump administration. But that ship has sailed: you could say "This Is Not Normal" in 2017, which was a fluke nobody saw coming, but Trump won decisively this cycle, and absolutely everybody knew what we were getting into. It's time for the media to retire the schtick.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by JeremyNT on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:27PM (#42630908)
Is it a "schtick" to report such brazen cronyism?

I agree with the parent that Americans in general seem not to mind corruption, but we can't become so jaded as to think that it's not even worth mentioning that this is a problem.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by tptacek on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:11AM (#42631163)
Referring to public company CEOs warmly greeting the newly elected president as "brazen cronyism" is a schtick, yes.

It annoys me a lot that I have to point things like this out, because I think Trump is a grave problem for the country, but you have to beat him at the ballot box, and the schtick obviously isn't working there.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by xorcist on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:38AM (#42632520)
Moving employee jurisdiction to suit the incoming administration is hardly the same as a warm greeting though, is it?

In my country we have a different word for people giving large sums of money as gifts to incoming politicians, yet we seldom impose that definition on others. US politics is different and affects the climate here too, even though that population is around 20% or less of all Facebook users.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mythrwy on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:09AM (#42632995)
The way to win is with a more appealing set of policy proposals.

More centralized government control, "Karen" style moralizing, DEI, gun banning, global warming, more bureaucratic (and ineffective) regulation, abortions everywhere and the entire "woke" platform apparently isn't it.

I'd suggest defocusing on those and instead return to being the party of the "working man" and a stable economy.

"Wealthy corporations want to force you to work 80 hours a week to enjoy unfair profits or they will replace you with immigrant labor" should be the vibe while never once speaking about things like systemic racism or climate change. Also "the rent is too damn high!". Definitely don't have the party fronted by people who appear airheaded or unintelligent.

You have to speak to the concerns of the voter which I think are individual freedom and economic prosperity.

Once in power you can do whatever you like of course, as is traditional in politics and Trump won't be any exception.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by smolder on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:54AM (#42633260)
Unfortunately there is no party of "the working man" since the citizens united ruling opened the floodgates for legal & private bribery, and arguably before that. Bernie Sanders, whatever you think of his proposals and views generally, is the rare exception who stands against the bribery and acts as a true populist, and for that he was undermined and defeated as a presidential candidate. People know the democratic party is two-faced, and I don't see how that can ever change, with money being so essential to US politics now.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mythrwy on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:49AM (#42633621)
MAGA didn't win with money. The democrats spent far more. They won with a message.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by JeremyNT on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:09AM (#42634380)
I'm fairly sure this is either untrue or unknowable. If the official "Harris campaign" spent more than the "Trump campaign" that doesn't actually mean much, considering how many other avenues exist to spend money that escape public scrutiny.

Even if you could account for all the dark money, that still leaves you with leveraging soft power - e.g. Musk using X as a de facto propaganda arm of the Republican party, which doesn't show up on any books.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mythrwy on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:39AM (#42635333)
I'm pretty sure it is knowable. The democrats spent far more.

Musk and X propaganda helped. Also Rogan and other podcasters, but look at how much propaganda the democrat side has/had. All the major media outlets. Reddit, etc etc. Plus the power of the federal government in censorship, courts and the like.

Look, I don't really care and don't trust anyone running for office much. I'm just pointing out what a winning platform would look like. MAGA won because they were speaking to things that more people found important. When the Democrats figure this out, they will be in the winning seat again. If they don't, then they will not win.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by freejazz on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:34PM (#42639229)
Wow what brilliant political insight - this place is shocking sometimes.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mythrwy on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:02PM (#42640815)
Thanks. I help when I can.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by smolder on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:36PM (#42637080)
I'm saying that the democrats lost because they keep taking corporate/oligarch money and are at odds with the values of the people who would otherwise support them. They aren't the party that supports the little guy anymore, so they're basically without an argument aside from "not Trump". I don't think you understood my previous post, which was a critique of the democrats, which used to have "the working man"'s back.

Republicans have always been and continue to be pro-elite, pro-oligarchy, and against the economic interests anyone outside the upper class. They still have a better message than the democrats at the moment.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mythrwy on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @03:40PM (#42638216)
Ah gotcha. I misread and agree completely with what you state. That does appear (to me anyway) exactly what happened.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by EricDeb on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:15AM (#42643363)
You could argue a particular person spent 44 billion but its a fuzzy argument. It's hard to tell..
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:26AM (#42635804)
> More centralized government control, "Karen" style moralizing, DEI, gun banning, global warming, more bureaucratic (and ineffective) regulation, abortions everywhere and the entire "woke" platform apparently isn't it.

I totally agree with that.

> The way to win is with a more appealing set of policy proposals.

I completely disagree with that. At this point I think it's a bit laughable to think that the majority of Americans care about policy proposals. Trump's appeal, I believe, is that he gave a voice and an outlet for anger to large swaths of people who felt they had been ignored (which they largely had) and talked down to for years. The "elites" (often of both parties) had basically told people in hollowed-out communities and those with failing economic prospects that it was their fault - you just should have gotten a college education, or retrained for the new economy. The Democratic messaging made things worse by also saying "Hey, you know those social standards that were the norm up until the mid 90s? Well, if you believe those, you're a knuckle dragging bigot."

When people have simmering anger and rage, a "nice guy" approach isn't going to cut it. That's why so many people vote for Trump even when they find so many aspects of his personality distasteful.

I'm baffled why a politician hasn't taken more of the lead with the rage that has exploded since the CEO murder. Some elites on the right are trying to frame this as "The crazy Left condones murder!", while I see some elites on the left doing their usual useless finger wagging against insurance companies (see Elizabeth Warren). I just don't understand why a politician hasn't taken this torch and gone into "We're going to tear it all down" mode. I mean, of course there's Bernie, but at this point it needs a younger and more "firebrand" type of person.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by toss1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:22PM (#42628956)
If it was in the works for a long time, then Zuckerberg has been planning to bend the knee to Trump for a long time.

Today, Trump in press conference (video at [0]:

Q: "Do you think Zuckerberg is responding to the threats you've made to him in the past?"

TRUMP: "Probably. Yeah. Probably."

This tells us all we need to know. It has nothing to do with facts and everything to do with yielding to political pressure to bend the media to his whims.

This is just the most standard and basic elements of autocracy, the autocrat must make all the institutions serve him, not the people. This includes not only the branches of government, but also of society, starting with the press, but also the corporate world, the academy, social groups, and everything else.

This is bog-standard autocracy, not democracy.

[0] https://x.com/atrupar/status/1876683641113248036

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by emmelaich on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:06PM (#42629756)
Bending left and right according to the government of the day doesn't tell you where the true center is.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by toss1 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:53PM (#42630718)
Autocracy is not Left or Right. It is corrupting all the institutions to serve the will of the autocrat, not the will of the people.

Bending the knee to the autocrat, in this case explicitly changing your rules and operations to enable the autocrat and his followers to more easily spread their lies and intimidation is not political flexibility, it is obeying in advance to be complicit in implementing the autocracy.

It would be better if you didn't have to learn that the hard way, but our educational system and information distribution system has failed. This is just a more advanced and accelerated example of that failure.

[Edit: yes, my mistake to phrase it as political pressure — it was nothing of the sort — it was authoritarian extortion. Note Zuck has a case before the FTC.]

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by curtisblaine on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:29AM (#42631940)
Autocracts doesn't get democratically elected, as far as I understand. Trump is a democratically elected leader who will end his term at most in 2028. Autocracts tend to not be democratically elected (or to change the rules once they're elected to never be deposed). Zuckerberg will bend his knee to the Democrats if they win next term. This is not autocracy, this is just knowing where the wind blows.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by xorcist on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:46AM (#42632564)
That doesn't make sense with the common use of the word. Autocracy is a much wider term than a militia style dictatorship, and is mostly used in the context of democracy.

Most, if not all, autocrats are democratically elected (with some wildly varying definition of democracy of course).

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by toss1 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:11AM (#42635639)
In current times, democratically elected autocrats include Putin of Russia, Orban of Hungary, Erdoğan of Turkey, Chavez/Maduro of Venezuela, Bukele of El Slavador, and more. Jumping back a most notorious autocrat, Hitler was democratically elected.

Autocracy is not typically imposed by conquest, it is mostly created by corruption of institutions. It is not binary, it is on a scale.

In full democracies, all the institutions of government, legislative, executive, and judicial, are independent and serve as checks & balances against each other. And the institutions of society, industry, trade, press, academic, sport, social, etc. are also fully independent.

Under autocracy, all of these governmental and societal institutions are corrupted to bend to the will of the autocrat, often by his using force of government to his corrupt ends.

This is exactly what Trump just admitted to and Zuckerberg just did — he threatened Zuckerberg with unfair government actions, and Zuckerberg is now converting Facebook to work to further Trump's goals instead of remaining an independent institution.

Here's just a few resources on elected autocrats [0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/meet-the-new-auto...

[1] https://nps.edu/-/nps-professor-takes-a-deep-dive-into-elect...

[2] https://academy.wcfia.harvard.edu/publications/democrats-and...

[3] https://press.umich.edu/Blog/2022/07/Elections-in-Modern-Dic...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by immibis on Friday January 10, 2025 @09:59AM (#42656143)
Most autocrats in history have been democratically elected or inherited their position from other autocrats who were.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by motorest on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:08AM (#42631824)
> I get how the partisan story is easy to tell here, but I'm saying something pretty specific: I think it would have been product development malpractice for this decision not to have been in the works for many, many months, long before the GOP takeover of the federal government was a safe bet.

You're just stating that, in your personal opinion, a scenario would be bad. That says nothing about it actually taking place.

You're expressing your personal opinion in response to a message listing facts supporting the belief the scenario is actually taking place.

Meaning, it's still plausible this is what is actually happening.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:33AM (#42632813)
I don't understand your point at all. Community Notes on E(x) has been ineffective, because ultimately the point of moderation is to delete posts which aren't true so they receive no reach and spread no disinformation.

Not to turn them into a public debate which might as well continue in the posts themselves.

Meta's political history has consistently been shady. Meta patented behavioural targeting technology in 2012 and was fined $5bn for its "accidental" links to anti-democratic election-fixers Cambridge Analytica/SCL, who have ties to far-right oligarchs in the US and the UK.

If you're looking for an ideological position, look there. The historical record is absolutely clear.

And then there are comments from Meta insiders, who - perhaps - have a clearer picture of what's going on than outsiders do.

As for malpractice, consider the recent AI rollout and rollback. It was an absolute fiasco for all kinds of reasons, PR and technical, not least of which was the way the bots themselves turned on the company.

Threads has already had a mini-exodus because of slanted moderation.

Meta is simply not a trustworthy company. So "Oh, let's scrap our moderation and do community notes" is hardly an isolated slip-up on an otherwise unblemished record of noble public service.

https://fortune.com/2025/01/04/meta-ai-accounts-bots-false-r...

https://www.platformer.news/meta-fact-checking-free-speech-s...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by RansomStark on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:54AM (#42634858)
> ultimately the point of moderation is to delete posts which aren't true so they receive no reach and spread no disinformation.

That assumes that the correct amount of disinformation is zero, personally I wish to maintain my right to be wrong, and my right to tell others of my wrong ideas, and I hope they maintain the right to tell me I'm full of it.

Your position on censorship, moderation, as you call it, is your opinion, and your opinion only, and it is at odds with the position of X, and now Meta, who are taking the position that the point of moderation is to respect everyone's right to speech, while making it very obvious to those that care, that the speech may be less than truthful. Essentially everyone gets to speak, and everyone gets to make up their own mind. What a concept!

I also maintain a position of truth dies in the dark, and lies die in the light.

Most people aren't stupid, community notes breaks the echo chamber and provides a counterpoint.

That debate of free ideas has been working pretty well so far. So much so that we can usually tell who the bad guys are by how much the create darkness; how much they take on the role of arbiters of truth, how much they silence critics, think Soviet Russia, or North Korea for some good examples.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by freejazz on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:46AM (#42635389)
I don't think the point of the fact-checkers is so that facebook users like them, and it seems odd to pretend that was ever the point.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by panarky on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:10AM (#42635628)
Both professional fact-checkers and Community Notes have a pretty low false-positive rate.

It's the false negatives that are the differentiator, but false negatives are by definition invisible to the user.

When you evaluate moderation as a "product" you place more weight on factors that are mostly losers for third-party fact checkers and winners for Community Notes: speed and annoying tone.

But since false negatives are never seen, there's no visible "product" to be annoyed by. Sure, the platform fills up with even more disinfo, but users blame that on other user, not the moderation "product".

And this is where Community Notes fails. Because Notes require consensus from multiple groups with histories of diverse ideological perspectives, when one perspective has an interest in propagating disinfo, no Community Note appears.

Some studies show something like 75% of clear disinfo doesn't get a Community Note on X when it involves a hot partisan shibboleth.

False negatives are mostly invisible failures that make the entire platform worse, but the user can't blame it on a "product" because it's really the absence of a product that's the problem.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mike_hearn on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:16PM (#42639590)
> I've never seen a wrong Facebook fact-check;

Probably because fact checkers are able to make content become unshareable so you not seeing them is the point? But "fact checking" NGOs have a long history of embarrassingly stupid, biased and self-serving decisions.

To pick just one example, in 2020 an op-ed in the New York Post arguing that COVID might have come from the coronavirus research lab in Wuhan was banned from Facebook and Twitter because of being labelled by an anonymous fact checker. Who was this fact checker? Turns out one of them was Danielle E. Anderson, an assistant professor at Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore, who had literally conducted experiments at the Wuhan lab and collaborated with its scientists.

You can't possibly get more biased than that, but because she was an academic the sort of people who chose the fact checkers assumed she would be automatically correct. And worse, that anyone who disagreed with her - even mildly - should therefore be banned from the internet.

That is the common pattern in every incident that make people mad at "fact checkers" and the reason they have no credibility is that these events happen all the time, are always in favour of left wing beliefs, and they never attempt to learn from these events strongly implying they're deliberate. Indeed the assumption that government funded people are always correct is basically hard-wired into the fact checker ecosystem. They don't attempt to actually work out what's true themselves, so they can't be fixed.

This is the kind of thing that Zuck is referring to when he says they're discredited. Wrong fact checks are commonplace, you just won't notice them if you rely on news feeds they control.