News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by PaulHoule on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @08:44PM (#42630009)
People are going to believe it is political whether or not it is. I've been working at hard at talking about difficult issues in a depoliticized frame. It's hard.

Lately I've been talking with a lot of people trying to help find answers and something I am learning is to delete all the duckspeak from my vocabulary (there was an otherwise good article about "placement poverty" in medical education that I didn't post last weekend because but "X poverty" is duckspeak)

If I say anything at all to anyone about this or that and get a negative response about the words I use I take it very seriously and most of the time resolve to use different words in future.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by seadan83 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:04PM (#42630787)
What are more examples of duckspeak and is it context dependent?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by lodovic on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @02:02AM (#42631770)
Orwell defined it as thoughtless or formulaic speech.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by PaulHoule on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:09AM (#42634381)
There is an essay at the end of Orwell's 1984

https://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks01/0100021.txt

called "The Principles of Newspeak" that coins the word.

The slogan "My Body My Choice" has some of this character. It rolls off the tongue and stops thought. There is no nuance: the rights of the mother are inalienable. Opponents will talk about the inalienable rights of the fetus. There is no room for compromise but setting some temporal point in the pregnancy is a compromise like Solomon's that makes sense to the disengaged but gives no satisfaction to people who see it as moral issue. [1]

Note that this phrase turned out to be content-free and perfectly portable when it got picked up by anti-vaccine activists.

"Illegal Alien" is a masterpiece of language engineering that stands on its own for effectiveness. I mean, we all follow laws that we don't agree with or live with the threat of arrest and imprisonment if we don't. It's easy to see somebody breaking the law and not getting caught as a threat to the legitimacy of the system. "Undocumented Migrant" has been introduced as an alternative but it just doesn't roll off the tongue in the same way and since it is not so entrenched it comes across more as language engineering.

(Practically as opposed to morally: Americans would rather work at Burger King rather than get a few more $ per hour to get up early for difficult and dirty work which might have you toiling in the hot or the cold. An American would see a farmhand job at a dairy farm as a dead end job. A Mexican is an experienced ag worker who might want to save up money to buy his own farm. Which one does the dairy farmer want to have handling his cows?)

My son bristles at "healthcare" as a word consistently used for abortion and transgender medicine to the point where he shows microexpressions when reading discussions about access to healthcare in general.

This poster burns me up

https://www.pinterest.com/pin/741405157385448245/

in that teaching small children the alleged difference between two words will make a difference in the very difficult problems that (say) black [2] people have in America trivializes those problems. It trains them to become the kind of people who will trade memes online as opposed to facing those problems. In the meantime I've heard so many right wingers repetitively talk about "Equality of opportunity" vs "Equality of outcomes" which is a real point but reduces a complex and fraught problem to a single axis.

[1] There's a great discussion of this https://www.amazon.com/Rights-Talk-Impoverishment-Political-... although that book has a discussion of the Americans with Disabilities Act that hasn't aged well

[2] Bloomberg Businessweek has a policy to always say capital B when they talk about "Black" people. Do black people care? Does it really help them? What side of the barricades are they on when they write gushing articles about Bernard Arnault and review $250 bottles of booze and $3000/night hotel rooms.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:51AM (#42635444)
> "Undocumented Migrant" has been introduced as an alternative but it just doesn't roll off the tongue in the same way and since it is not so entrenched it comes across more as language engineering.

It definitely comes across as language engineering. It's a legitimate category ("I'm an asylum seeker directly on my way to claim asylum from the nearest office") but expanded to include people who are just in the country illegally. It's too obvious to convince many people for very long.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Jerrrry on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:36AM (#42635302)
Crossing the border is fine, unless it's a state line.

Then you cannot cross it or the intent is murder.

Unless your intent is to murder, than you can cross it - that's Healthcare.

Healthcare is a right. In fact, it's an societal obligation. Trust the Science(TM).

Your body, the state's choice.

Are you a racist, or a communist?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by pyrale on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:32PM (#42637038)
> My son bristles at "healthcare" as a word consistently used for abortion and transgender medicine

In terms of cost, the items you cite are vanishingly small, and to conflate the two, one must have no experience of the medical system beyond twitter.

Is your son on his own? Did he have to pay the cost for a broken limb or a child's disease, or has he seen a family member go through a cancer? Maybe he would have a better sense of what "healthcare" means if he had actually been facing these situations.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by shakes_mcjunkie on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:35AM (#42634031)
I think you'll find basically everything is political. Do you have a fear of debate or criticism?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by throwway120385 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @12:03PM (#42636190)
Actually very few things have to be political. Politicising, that is rendering the concept to decision by a "body politic" is a choice that we're making right now, and we could choose to not do that. In fact, we have done that throughout our nation's history, and it's only in the last 20 years that I've seen the rise of "everything is political speech" to the degree that the brand of beans you buy in a store signals something to some group.

To wit there are a lot of totalitarians out there, and just because some group claims to be on your side or looking out for your interests versus some other group it doesn't mean they don't want your mind, body, and soul for their own purposes. We must take it upon ourselves to think for ourselves and to hold our own interests rather than to adopt the interests of the group we're in. Humans can engage in enterprise as a group for their own reasons, and we ought to embrace that instead of seeking to identify so wholly with the group that we lose ourselves.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by PaulHoule on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:12AM (#42634413)
No. I can't stand it that so many Americans have fallen under the spell of a fraudster while others are sharing hateful memes online and think it is activism. I need stronger language, not weaker language.

I don't like the word "debate" because it makes me think of a high school debate where you are assigned which side of the issue and it is about to winning or losing.

https://depts.washington.edu/fammed/wp-content/uploads/2018/...

in the current situation people feel they have exactly one candidate to vote for every time and thus we have no ability to vote out corrupt politicians. The political class wins and the rest of us lose.

(I am so concerned about people's inability or reluctant to change that I've experienced a call to the ministry and I'm working to use practices that I developed for selfish ends in the past to help others. Ideally when I offend you I want to strike you at the core and leave you haunted for months and not be able to think about the issue the same way ever again. If you're reacting to bits of trash somebody else stuck on me that I'm not aware of, I'm not going to get that strike in.)