News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heresy by Beltalowda on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:13AM (#30977724)
I think this is an important part:

"Fortunately in western countries the suppression of heresies is nothing like as bad as it used to be. Though the window of opinions you can express publicly has narrowed in the last decade, it's still much wider than it was a few hundred years ago. The problem is the derivative. Up till about 1985 the window had been growing ever wider. Anyone looking into the future in 1985 would have expected freedom of expression to continue to increase. Instead it has decreased."

Many people proclaim that "free speech is dead" and all of that, but it's still at an all-time high if you zoom out a bit. You don't even need to go back a few hundred years; look at the number of people persecuted by the government (both through the courts and outside of it) for things like blasphemy, subversion, civil rights, sexual deviancy (homosexuality, among other things), etc. just a few decades ago. In the US burning the flag was illegal in many states until the late 80s when the SCOTUS declared it was legal under the 1st (and only by a 5-4 majority).

Yes, there are some developments I am not especially pleased with either, but it's also important to remember the historical context.

Anyway, I liked this piece of nuance.

Re:Heresy by amalcon on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:07PM (#30979857)
I like to point out the Sedition Act of 1918 here. About 100 years ago, a law that literally made it a crime to criticize the government was not only enacted, but upheld by the courts. Can you even imagine that today?

What people are finally noticing now is that non-government entities can also have negative impacts on free speech. They're not noticing because it just started -- e.g. lots of folks lost their jobs for vocally opposing the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq in the early 2000's -- but because they're on the receiving end for once. This could be a good thing in the end, by leading us to a more complete model of civil discourse, but it's going to be painful for a while before that even has a chance to happen.

Re:Heresy by ratww on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:11PM (#30980601)
> Can you even imagine that today?

Not in the countries I guess we both live, but in some authoritarian places, definitely, unfortunately. Your point still fully stands though!

Re:Heresy by amalcon on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:16PM (#30980657)
This is a great point, and I should've made it clear that I was only referring to democratic countries that profess to value free speech.
Re:Heresy by etherael on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:05PM (#30984135)
I can easily imagine such laws in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. They already exist in Australia. The consensual mass hallucination regarding those places is that they are democratic countries that profess to value free speech.

But of course, it is purely a hallucination.

Re:Heresy by incompatible on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:24PM (#30984255)
Is there a law in Australia the forbids criticizing the government? I haven't noticed any shortage of criticism lately.
[dead]
Re:Heresy by incompatible on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:36PM (#30984331)
Arrested for "incitement", admittedly a vague concept that the government can do a lot with, like "disturbing the peace". But you find that kind of thing in any country, Australia is nothing special.
Re:Heresy by etherael on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:45PM (#30984387)
It's worse than most places that aren't China tier if you simply observe what happened there over the past two years, but it's true that basically the entire world with very few exceptions to lesser or greater extent really draped themselves in shame over the same period. Australia was just by far the worst of a bad bunch.

https://thetruthiswhere.wordpress.com/2021/11/09/dan-andrews...

Re:Heresy by yesenadam on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @09:03PM (#31010069)
That is one of the most ridiculous articles I've ever read.[0] Maybe the most ridiculous. Please stop posting outrageous crap like that to HN, thank you. A conspiracy site and Alan Jones, as you've posted on this page, do not add value to HN. I notice almost all your comments on HN are edgy, flamebaitish political hot takes, maybe you would suit some other site better.

[0] e.g. "The Premier of the Australian state of Victoria, Daniel Andrews, has just tabled legislation in parliament which is possibly the most monstrous ever introduced into a country calling itself democratic. ...the legislation openly stamps him as a totalitarian psychopath. ...This is Australia 2021, not Germany 1935/36. Those who sneer at the comparison are deceiving themselves as the essentials are the same"...

Re:Heresy by yesenadam on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @09:19AM (#31002284)
The talking head in that video is Alan Jones, Australia's most notorious right-wing talk back radio host, or he was last time I checked. That's about as far as you can get in Australia from a reputable news source. His whole thing is stirring up ignorant lynch mobs by being inflammatory. Human flame bait.
Re:Heresy by otterley on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:59PM (#30981659)
I think most jurists would agree that the Sedition Act is dead for all practical purposes. Most modern First Amendment jurisprudence only started being written after the Vietnam War, commencing with Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 44 (1969), and the Sedition Act would be unlikely to survive scrutiny today.
Re:Heresy by voidfunc on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:51AM (#30984795)
The reality though is, SCOTUS can decide to trash precedent at-will once a case is in front of them. If you put political hacks into the SCOTUS and they decide the Sedition Act is legal then its suddenly back on the table.

This is the danger of an overly political SCOTUS.

Re:Heresy by adolph on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:10PM (#30980591)
Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:42PM (#30981497)
Notably, handing out pamphlets arguing against a war isn't especially likely to qualify for this law.
Re:Heresy by temp8964 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:27PM (#30981887)
> lots of folks lost their jobs for vocally opposing the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq in the early 2000's

I am not aware of this history. Is there any data or document? What kind of jobs, private? governmental? academic?

Re:Heresy by MisterBastahrd on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:11PM (#30983104)
Everyone crying about people being cancelled sure didn't have a lot of words to defend the Dixie Chicks when they were against the Iraq war.
Re:Heresy by cornel_io on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:08AM (#30984554)
Actually a whole lot of us did. There are dumbasses on both the right and the left constantly trying to forcefully silence people who they don't like, and there's a rather larger group of us in the center who have been screaming bloody fucking murder about it for over a decade now, but you all keep pretending that we're inconsistent and actually just Republicans (or libtards/groomers, if you're of the other persuasion). It's maddening.
Re:Heresy by hindsightbias on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:26AM (#30984674)
“rather larger group of us in the center who have been screaming bloody fucking murder about it for over a decade now”

Citation required.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/05/23/opinion/inter...

Re:Heresy by cornel_io on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:30AM (#30985022)
That article doesn't at all refute the fact that a ton of centrists have very reasonable beliefs and are loud about them. "Citation required" is a zero-content contribution, please go away.
Re:Heresy by rayiner on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:09PM (#30984155)
I, too, agree that progressives are moral busybodies like Bush-era evangelicals.
Re:Heresy by MisterBastahrd on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:18PM (#30984206)
Check out any state abortion laws lately? How about something called "teaching actual history?" And the best one "we didn't want to teach kids about gender differences, so now teachers are going to ignore gender entirely" in Florida.

But please, do go on about the "Bush-era evangelicals." I'm sure they've totally calmed down since then.

Re:Heresy by rayiner on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:27AM (#30988354)
You're confusing opposition to the left's overreach with evangelical resurgence.

> Check out any state abortion laws lately?

This mistakenly assumes that opposition to abortion is necessarily evangelical in nature. By requiring the availability of elective second trimester abortions, Roe mandates an abortion regime that extends significantly beyond what most people can stomach. Most Americans think elective abortions should be prohibited after the first trimester: https://apnews.com/article/only-on-ap-us-supreme-court-abort.... But highly secular countries like France, Denmark, and Finland also restrict abortions after the first trimester. Most of the developed world draws the line for elective abortions at "when the fetus has a face" and not viability like Roe does. So you will continue to see things like Mississippi's abortion law (which imposes a 15-week ban with exceptions for health of the mother and baby) regardless of the strength of the evangelical movement.

> How about something called "teaching actual history?" And the best one "we didn't want to teach kids about gender differences, so now teachers are going to ignore gender entirely" in Florida.

It's not only or even mostly evangelicals that are worked up about the effort to normalize folks like Robin Di Angelo and Ibram Kendi in schools, or to teach young children about sexuality.

On these issues, the left thinks it’s relitigating issues it previously won, but in reality they’re taking up again issues the far left lost in the 1970s: racial preferences, racial separatism, breaking down social notions of gender, etc.

Re:Heresy by MisterBastahrd on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:00AM (#30989733)
> You're confusing opposition to the left's overreach with evangelical resurgence.

No, I'm not. The opposition to abortion in the evangelical community didn't begin until Republicans bundled the issue with black civil rights and trickle down economics. Both Roe and her lawyer were Southern Baptists, and there were editorials published in Baptist and Evangelical periodicals affirming the decision as the right thing. Religious opposition to abortion rights should not extend to our laws. Oklahoma just passed a 6 week bill with no exceptions for rape, so please, spare me the hand-wringing.

> It's not only or even mostly evangelicals that are worked up about the effort to normalize folks like Robin Di Angelo and Ibram Kendi in schools, or to teach young children about sexuality.

You ignored the part about "teaching actual history," which includes teaching kids about the effects of slavery and Jim Crow and how that permanently damaged minorities because it might make little white minds evaluate the damage their ancestors did and how that continues to harm minorities today. That Florida bill had nothing to do with teaching kids about sexuality, and it backfired and will continue to do so. There is zero way to word those bills that will not result in malicious compliance because they are plainly meant to be discriminatory.

Re:Heresy by rayiner on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:30PM (#30991145)
> The opposition to abortion in the evangelical community didn't begin until Republicans bundled the issue with black civil rights and trickle down economics.

The opposition to abortion was an international phenomenon happening around the same time. Within a few years of Roe, high courts in Canada, Germany, Italy, and France heard abortion cases as well. All except Germany determined that it was a question for the legislature. Germany determined that legalized abortion violated the basic law. To this day, German, French, and Italian abortion laws contain several restrictions that Roe doesn’t permit, specifically limiting elective abortions to the first trimester. Those counties must be full of evangelical Baptists according to you.

Also, nice job projecting the abortion movement’s eugenics roots onto conservatives.

> In response to a question on access to abortion and restrictions on Medicaid coverage of the procedure, [Justice] Ginsburg said, "Frankly I had thought that at the time Roe [v. Wade] was decided, there was concern about population growth and particularly growth in populations that we don't want to have too many of. So that Roe was going to be then set up for Medicaid funding for abortion."

> You ignored the part about "teaching actual history,"

Virginia didn’t just vote for Glen Youngkin (including half of Asians, who are almost all in liberal northern Virginia where I grew up) because they oppose teaching “actual history.” It’s because Fairfax County paid Ibram Kendi $$$ to come lecture to teachers.

> which includes teaching kids about the effects of slavery and Jim Crow and how that permanently damaged minorities

That doesn’t sound like “history” but pseudoscience. Racist pseudoscience at that, conflating Black people with “minorities” and implying they are “permanently damaged.”

> because it might make little white minds evaluate the damage their ancestors did and how that continues to harm minorities today.

“Little white minds,” lol. Gee, I can’t imagine why people think you want to teach White Fragility and inherited guilt (https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/07/dehumanizi...) and that “actual history” is just pretext.

> That Florida bill had nothing to do with teaching kids about sexuality, and it backfired and will continue to do so.

The law is literally limited to “instruction” about “sexual orientation” and “gender identity.” Prior to fourth grade, it’s prohibited. After fourth grade, it must be “age appropriate.” If you think it’s just evangelicals that don’t teachers instructing their kids on human sexuality in third grade, you need more POC friends.

Re:Heresy by hindsightbias on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:16AM (#30984604)
I often wonder if anyone on HN remembers Bill Mahers first show…

Politically Incorrect was literally the name of that show, and it wasn’t cancelled by leftists.

Re:Heresy by adolph on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:55AM (#30989659)
Were the artists formerly known as Dixie Chicks cancelled or did their market fragment and they chose to focus on one segment? For some, is the notoriety of "cancellation" a welcome signal of authenticity and salience to consumers? For example Prince successfully used self-cancellation as a marketing rebirth during a legal dispute.

The Dixie Chicks are joining a growing list of brands, entertainers, and artists making changes in wake of the racial justice movement happening now. Like many, they "want to meet this moment" in history, which is why the country trio will go by The Chicks from this point forward.

https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/life/entertainment/a3297240...

Re:Heresy by wutbrodo on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:06AM (#30984535)
Gosh, this is utter nonsense. Pretty much every anti-woke person on the left was just as critical of illiberalism when the right was flexing its cultural muscles. Are you under the impression that Paul Graham was in support of post-9/11 restrictions on speech? Or that eg the comedians now complaining about cancel culture were totally cool with people losing their jobs for insufficient "patriotism"? For God's sake, Bill Maher lost his show under precisely the same norms that he criticizes now, except that the illiberalism at the time was right-coded.

Are you so unable to conceive of a person holding a principle that you need to create an alternate timeline to resolve the cognitive dissonance? It's always truly horrifying to be reminded that people like this exist.

Re:Heresy by temp8964 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:56PM (#30983379)
Yes. It’s exactly like MIT canceled Dorian Abbot.
Re:Heresy by MisterBastahrd on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:45PM (#30983636)
MIT didn't cancel Dorian Abbot, though.

He still gave a presentation, it just wasn't on his stupid "anti-vaxxers are just like Nazi Germany" nonsense that was beneath both him and the university.

Re:Heresy by deanCommie on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:49AM (#30984786)
I think the comparison you drew is interesting.

Restrictions to free speech used to be in place to protect the Most Powerful - the Kings (still do - in places where there are kings), The Party, even The Government (in places where democracy is but a sham)

In Western democratic nations, new restrictions to free speech are being considered to protect the Most Marginalized - the most weakest, most discriminated against, lowest represented members of society.

It is ludicrous to look at this movement and compare them like-for-like. There is no backsliding here, there is no slippery slope here. There is a very distinct difference between who is protected and who is exploited.

Re:Heresy by FerociousTimes on Monday April 11, 2022 @06:26AM (#30986807)
I still sense you advocating for coercive equity policies in your comment; i.e. redistribution of power from the slightly more fortunate to the slightly less fortunate but on a whim and flimsy excuses and without due process, because let's pretend for a moment that people at the very top; the one percenters would be affected by this cancel culture nonsense, it's always middle class people and every once in a while, a member of the upper middle class get devoured by the SJW monster and that's it.

This whole crusade is just a charade.

Re:Heresy by deanCommie on Monday April 11, 2022 @04:46PM (#30994755)
You sense incorrectly. I have no qualm with democratic institutions of power. (For some reason I have to explain to people on HN that a username with 'commie' in it does not mean I'm a communist)

As long as they're actually democratic. My qualm is with oligarchies and plutocracies. A capitalist system should allow for the wealthy and it is inevitable that wealth can be used to acquire power. But political systems need to be firewalled from this MUCH more than they are in society today.

The thread is about free speech, and my comment was solely focused on speech. I'm not a free speech absolutist in way that you or Paul Graham might be, because I don't believe words and speech is like physical violence. A bullet is egalitarian. It doesn't care who fires the gun or who it's hitting, it will still do the same damage whether it's fired by a billionaire at a homeless person, or the other way around. Words are not. Words need a medium. The medium's control is asymmetrical.

But regardless of what we think about asymmetrical implications of free speech, ultimately my point was that those who's free speech we are talking about protecting shifted 180 over the last century. Pretending that is irrelevant is naive. Is there a difference between a Russian Soldier killing a Ukrainian Soldier outside of Mariupol this week, and a Ukrainian soldier killing a Russian one? Of course there is. And so there is a difference between restricting the speech of a person to criticize the government, vs restricting the speech of a government to criticize a person.

P.S. Using "SJW" as a pejorative falls in the same category as using "woke" in that way. Mike Godwin himself (of Godwin's law) has the right take on it: https://twitter.com/sfmnemonic/status/1504687870006620163

Re:Heresy by sitkack on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:51PM (#30981021)
Re:Heresy by tomcam on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:52PM (#30982547)
> I like to point out the Sedition Act of 1918 here. About 100 years ago, a law that literally made it a crime to criticize the government was not only enacted, but upheld by the courts. Can you even imagine that today?

Only in banana republics like the USA. The patriot act went quite far in that direction

Re:Heresy by rawTruthHurts on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:57AM (#30986630)
> Can you even imagine that today?

Try to give in UK an opinion regarding the State of Israel not matching the Pro-Israel lobyy diktat and you will find yourself in trouble. Ask Jackie Walker.

Re:Heresy by infiniteL0Op on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:52PM (#30980411)
Ask Thai citizens if they can imagine that. Or Russians.

In democracies, society has moved a bit into a direction where many harmless things said will trigger an upset in some very uptight people.

It's enforced socially rather than by the government. Back when you could not say things openly against governments, at least you could speak your mind on anything else.

Today, you can say whatever you want against the government, they are so far detached they don't care.

Free speech is a stupid political term, it has never truly existed an never will.

Re:Heresy by voakbasda on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:33PM (#30981416)
Freedom of speech is a principle that transcends political policies. In theory, it is a clear and unambiguous concept; in practice, governments ruin it with nearly arbitrary rules that run counter to that fundamental principle.
Re:Heresy by incompatible on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:32PM (#30984302)
There are plenty of exceptions to freedom of speech in countries I'm familiar with. Things like advocacy of terrorism, hate speech, threats, disturbing the peace, obscenity in public, blasphemy, pornography of certain kinds, providing financial advice without a license, leaking secrets, copyright.

Edit: fraud, incitement. Who knows how many others?

Re:Heresy by UnpossibleJim on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:09PM (#30978453)
I think the problem with this argument is the free speech "is at an all time high if you zoom out a bit". This is much like the argument, "gun violence is at an all time low if you zoom out a bit" argument.

Both of these statements are true in the macro, but if you look at the trends, they point to a very disturbing line.

The call for the restriction of free speech on the right(1) and the left (2) have increased in very different ways and seem to be increasing, both legislatively and socially. The same can be said of gun violence. We reached an all time low in 2018 (I believe - it might have been 2017) but have been trending upwards ever since.

Most (reasonable) people agree that an effort should be made to curb gun violence, even if they can't agree on the best route to get there. The attack on free speech, however seems to have cheering sections from all sides. As far as the government is concerned, sanctions on the first amendment would be a boon, but the groundswell from the populace in the form of right and left "cancelation" (or whatever BS term you wish to call it) hasn't been seen since McCarthy. Given the rise in the public square with social media, and you have national feeding frenzies with public "witch trials" to take our minds off of inflation, oil prices, pollution and multiple global conflicts of questionable national interest.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-free-speech-is-under-attack...

https://thehill.com/opinion/education/566119-for-the-left-a-...

Re:Heresy by switchbak on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:32PM (#30980163)
I think that's something that often gets overlooked in the frenzy to tribal defence: this is a sideshow to take the spotlight off of the real important issues of the day.

If you really look at it, the left/right dichotomy in US politics seems designed (evolved?) to serve much the same purpose.

When we all calm down on the partisanship, often it's amazing how much shared ground there really is.

Re:Heresy by andrepd on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:49PM (#30980380)
It's not surprising. Divide and conquer is a millenia-old tactic.

Efforts by the ruling class to pit the working classes against themselves have been noted in Western capitalist societies for at least 150 years.

Re:Heresy by bendbro on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:19PM (#30981819)
If I said:

1. "Fuck Jesus, fuck America, kill all men."

2. "Fuck BLM, fuck diversity."

Which one do you think would get me cancelled?

Conservatives have comically little social power. Further, you can basically say anything you want around them, while conversations with the average liberal are a careful affair.

Perhaps though I am blind. Are there contemporary instances of conservative driven cancellations? The definition I like of cancellation is: removing privileges from a person when their qualities do not predict harmful use of those privileges.

For example, in the CBS article you linked, with regard to the parents, schools, CRT issue: I acknowledge the parents are restricting speech, but I don't think it violates the spirit of free speech. Teachers can say whatever they like, and parents are free choose what their kids listen to. On the same note, I think it is fine for schools to be forced to omit creationism when discussing evolution.

On defining cancellation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30770206

My personal axe to grind on left driven cancel culture: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25977399

Re:Heresy by zimpenfish on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:34PM (#30981941)
> Are there contemporary instances of conservative driven cancellations?

Would teachers being fired merely for being gay count?

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/gay-teache...

https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/education/2021/10/27/gay-...

https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/opinion-teacher-i-was...

(three different ones there, there's more in the googles.)

> Teachers can say whatever they like

Except to say that they're gay, it seems.

Re:Heresy by bendbro on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:55PM (#30982105)
Fired for being gay at public school: absolutely cancellation, and wrong.

Fired for discussing sex and gender with students: debatable.

Fired for being gay at a Catholic school: much like I'm fine with Hasidic Jews, Mormons, or Muslims doing "backward" things to maintain their enclaves, so too am I fine with Catholics doing it. Do I want all of society to be like this: please god no.

Whether all of this changes my opinion: no, but I will keep my mind more open. I think more examples, especially ones in public schools could change my mind.

I can also hear an argument against enclaves of the sort I spoke of above having less freedom. I don't have a great one in support of it to begin with. The topic is very messy.

Re:Heresy by amalcon on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:14PM (#30983127)
> Are there contemporary instances of conservative driven cancellations?

Colin Kaepernick is the most obvious.

Re:Heresy by PuppyTailWags on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:18PM (#30983485)
Isn't a teacher being fired for being associated with the LGBTQ club at the highschool she teaches at? In Texas I think, after administrators started banning rainbow flags and stuff.
Re:Heresy by CJefferson on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:25PM (#30981875)
The problem with this kind of argument is that it's very hard to be sure you aren't trapped in your "bubble".

Fox is comfortably the most popular cable news network in America -- and that lends it a lot of social power among people who get most of their news from cable. They don't care what idiots on Twitter are saying, except as filtered through the news they consume.

I talk to conservatives who get furious at the suggestion that Joe Biden isn't a pedophile, or trans-women are women and not also pedophiles.

However, this is my bubble --I don't know which is "real".

Re:Heresy by bendbro on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:04PM (#30982182)
> I talk to conservatives who get furious at the suggestion that Joe Biden isn't a pedophile, or trans-women are women and not also pedophiles

Does their reaction have any odds of extending beyond your discussion with them into your friendship with them, other relationships, your job, or your public reputation?

> The problem with this kind of argument is that it's very hard to be sure you aren't trapped in your "bubble"

It definitely could be my bubble. A lot of the strength behind my opinion formed while living in Seattle and mingling with the locals.

An anecdote: I once was at a friends birthday, and was seated next to a mutual friend I'd had for a year. She asked if I had been to the women's march, and I said "sorry no, I didn't have the time." She said "everybody has the time" and I said "I feel uncomfortable at marches." She said that's not a reason. I said "Okay, the real reason was I didn't have the hat." After that we were no longer friends.

Interacting with the left in the southwest has been a significantly better experience.

Re:Heresy by Beltalowda on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:41PM (#30978806)
It just puts things in perspective; I'm not saying it's not something to be worried about, but you can both worry about something while also keeping the historical perspective in mind.

There is also a lot of hysteria going on; that Maus "controversy" which your CVS article cites (among others) is a good example. The concerns were over some nudity and profanity. You may think that's prudish or a bit childish, but fine, it's not really something especially unusual to be concerned about, or a very new "taboo" to be concerned about. It certainly wasn't an attempt at removing any education about the Holocaust from the curriculum, yet that it often how it was framed. With the author of Maus going so far to openly question whether these people might have neo-Nazi sympathies in an interview.

That there are some instances of unfounded hysteria doesn't mean there are also things that are not; but again, it's good to keep some perspective.

Re:Heresy by lukifer on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:18PM (#30979992)
The Maus case provides an interesting contrast: while I agree the reaction was somewhat disproportionate, a dissenting view was still permissible within the "social Overton window". You might get looked at askance for saying "I don't think Maus is appropriate for schools", but you'd be unlikely to be ostracized or fired. The same can't be said for some other expressions of heterodoxy/heresy, past or present.
Re:Heresy by watwut on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:54AM (#30985872)
> The concerns were over some nudity and profanity

No, they were not. The only nudity in it were mouses. It was not erotic. It did not included ressembleable human parts. This was not about prudity, it was about excuse. It was not childish, it was cynical.

> It certainly wasn't an attempt at removing any education about the Holocaust from the curriculum, yet that it often how it was framed.

The thing about Maus is that it makes you feel bad. It is made from point of view of victim. It is not even idealizing the victims, it does not require the victim to be that great perfect person so that you feel bad about him. Maus also does not end with happy end where they lived happily ever after. It shows long term damage.

> With the author of Maus going so far to openly question whether these people might have neo-Nazi sympathies in an interview.

Did you considered looking at who those people specifically are and what other things they said or done? Or did you just rejected what he said, because it would feel bad for you if he actually was right?

Re:Heresy by Beltalowda on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:05AM (#30988872)
I just read the minutes of the meeting[1]; it didn't support what was often said about the decision at all. Your comment is a good example of that I talked about in [2] with your rather odd "it just makes you feel bad" accusation.

[1]: https://core-docs.s3.amazonaws.com/documents/asset/uploaded_...

[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30978016

Re:Heresy by jacquesm on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:08PM (#30981179)
A bigger problem is that all of this is extremely local, typically affecting a small fraction of the world population, when for the majority the truth is very much different.
Re:Heresy by twofornone on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:08PM (#30979128)
These claims that the "don't say gay" legislation stifles free speech are dishonest. These are teachers, agents of the state, in a professional setting, not private citizens expressing opinions off the clock. If I'm paying taxes for public education then I should have a say in what gets taught, and that includes culture.
Re:Heresy by NoraCodes on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:34PM (#30979455)
Now, wait a second - either it's bad that people get fired for expressing opinions, as Graham states in the essay, or it's not and people _should_ get fired for expressing opinions that you don't like. I don't think you can have it both ways. It's not even as if there's a conflict of interest here, as in the case of public officials being banned from certain kinds of political speech; these teachers are not hurting anyone or disrupting any civil processes, so under what principle is it acceptable to deny them the same freedoms Graham argues for in the case of corporate employees?
Re:Heresy by rayiner on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:31PM (#30980143)
The difference is that what the teacher says is the actual service the teacher is providing pursuant to his or her employment. The government has every right to decide the content of the material being provided to kids in public schools. It’s not a free speech issue at all. Note that the Florida law applies only to “instruction.”

To use a different example: a public bus driver shouldn’t be fired for an offhand comment. But they have to drive the routes the government tells them to drive. That’s not a “freedom of movement” issue.

Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:35PM (#30980207)
Part of the reason this is so prickly is that a huge part of what actually happens in the classroom is ancillary to instruction. And always has been. And is for the good of children.

We expect teachers to be robots when we want to chastise them, but we expect teachers to be surrogate parents when they're helping turn students into productive members of society.

Re:Heresy by drdec on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:38PM (#30980883)
> The government has every right to decide the content of the material being provided to kids in public schools.

An interesting nuance to this particular case is that it is the state government that is imposing the requirement while it is a local (city, town or county) government which hires the teachers.

Re:Heresy by pclmulqdq on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:02PM (#30983737)
In most US states, local governments are explicitly given power by the state government. It is not like the relationship between state and federal governments: the local governments are strictly beneath the state government.
Re:Heresy by rayiner on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:22PM (#30984239)
They are not only beneath, they are organs of the state government and have no separate sovereignty of their own. They’re like wholly owned subsidiaries.
Re:Heresy by tomp on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:56PM (#30979717)
Would you want to take your kid into a kindergarten where the teacher would be showing (or reading) them porn?

If "no", how do you square that with "teachers can say anything they like"? I mean literally no employment is like that (try publicly saying your employer is evil, see how long you last...). Private speech != employee speech.

Re:Heresy by NoraCodes on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:59PM (#30979756)
Right. The argument being had here is about whether or not telling children that gay people exist is harmful, not over whether or not it's ever okay to tell people what they can and cannot speak about. All I'm saying is that right-wingers in these comments will tend to agree with Graham in the abstract, and because he targets the left in the post, but in practice their politics are not aligned with what he says in this essay.

To your point, though, the law is not about porn; that's already illegal. The law is about literally telling children that gay people exist; unless you believe gay couples are somehow inherently sexual in a way that straight couples aren't, you're off the mark here.

Re:Heresy by 0des on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:04PM (#30979810)
People with sleeveless shirts exist, who cares? Its so normal these days I can't imagine all the things I would have to cover first. "Hey son, brace yourself, some people prefer broccoli over cauliflower."

It doesn't even make sense. Teach your kid curiosity and general respect for those different from you and let the rest fall into place. Politics only tarnishes your ability to make this common sense observation because regardless of truth you have discarded half of your audience.

Except pineapple pizza people. They deserve everything they got coming to them.

Re:Heresy by NoraCodes on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:09PM (#30979867)
> Teach your kid curiosity and general respect for those different from you and let the rest fall into place.

It's worth noting that the Florida law, under some readings and I think under its intent, would make it illegal for a teacher to point to a student and her same-sex parents and say "those two women are married and are both raising this child." It's perhaps the most absurd anti-free-speech law I've ever heard of.

> Except pineapple pizza people. They deserve everything they got coming to them.

My boyfriend was a pineapple pizza person and he is now, no joke, allergic to pineapple. They're an accident waiting to happen.

Re:Heresy by mwcampbell on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:46PM (#30980352)
> People with sleeveless shirts exist, who cares? Its so normal these days I can't imagine all the things I would have to cover first. "Hey son, brace yourself, some people prefer broccoli over cauliflower."

These examples would be relevant if there were factions who vehemently oppose people with sleeveless shirts or who prefer broccoli, and want to make sure they can pass that opposition on to their children.

Re:Heresy by UnpossibleJim on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:29PM (#30980795)
I'm currently thinking of trying to get legislation put before Congress to have all sleeveless shirts labeled as "bras" or "bros", and therefore classified as underwear but I need to do some polling first to see if I have broad public support.
Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:37PM (#30980233)
> Except pineapple pizza people. They deserve everything they got coming to them.

As someone who likes pineapple and jalapeno pizza, I find this remark very offensive.

Re:Heresy by tomp on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:08PM (#30980568)
You're falling for, and perpetuating, left-wing propaganda.

The bill doesn't prohibit "saying gay".

The bill prohibits discussing sexual orientation. Straight and gay alike. Personally I think that at those ages basically all discussion of sex should be off limits (except strictly in a biological sense "this is where you pee" or "naked boys look like this drawing and naked girls like that drawing").

Also your argument is a nasty bait-and-switch. Your original comment was about "limiting freedom of speech of teachers is bad" but then you switched to "of course we should limit freedom of speech for teachers, but not in this specific case".

Re:Heresy by WalterBright on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:21PM (#30980700)
Are you ok with teaching creationism in public schools? Being government run schools, the government decides what gets taught. It cannot be teachers teach whatever they want - they must adhere to the curriculum, which is decided by the government.
Re:Heresy by Koshkin on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:04PM (#30981139)
They might as well teach that Earth is flat - kids are smart, and truth will make its way into their heads regardless. In this day and age, it is hard for it not to.
Re:Heresy by WalterBright on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:29PM (#30981386)
Why teach them anything at all if the truth will seep in anyway?

Besides, I bet I can think of a looong list of human beliefs once held dear by many people you'd strongly object to being taught in public schools. It's not a free speech issue, because it's paid for by taxpayers, and kids are forced to attend it.

Re:Heresy by Koshkin on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:50PM (#30982527)
Teach them reading, writing, and arithmetics. Everything else can be learned independently (which is too easy these days) or in vocational schools (which surely do not care about the origins of the universe).
Re:Heresy by ambrozk on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:25PM (#30980063)
In general, there is nothing wrong with the government legislating what its employees may say when acting as agents of the government, just as there is nothing wrong with a corporation telling its employees what they may say when acting as agents of the corporation. Free speech does not mean, "Your employer cannot fire you for publicly contradicting company policy while on the clock." Note that there are limits to what the government can mandate with regard to its employees' communications, and the Florida bill may run up against them.
Re:Heresy by NoraCodes on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:30PM (#30980127)
You understand that this is contrary to what Graham is arguing in the essay, right?
Re:Heresy by ambrozk on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:31PM (#30980150)
I read the essay and I do not believe it is.
Re:Heresy by rdiddly on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:40PM (#30979530)
According to the Florida bill, it's when the students are 3rd grade or lower. The bifurcation point between "OK to talk about" and "not OK to talk about" is between 3rd & 4th grade.
Re:Heresy by wnoise on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:12PM (#30984172)
Well the "OK to talk about" is "OK to talk about in an age appropriate way", under threat of being sued by parents.
Re:Heresy by NoraCodes on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:47PM (#30979627)
For every issue? Or do you feel this should be different based on the subject matter at hand?
Re:Heresy by rdiddly on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:50PM (#30979653)
The bill is not about every issue and I'm not getting into what I feel. I don't live in Florida and basically am not paying attention.
Re:Heresy by NoraCodes on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:55PM (#30979710)
What's your argument here, then? Or was this just a random fact you wanted to post?
Re:Heresy by rdiddly on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:36PM (#30980224)
Answering your question, on the point you were asking about.
Re:Heresy by twofornone on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:41PM (#30979561)
> either it's bad that people get fired for expressing opinions

They're not merely "expressing opinions", they're teaching children "facts" of disputed veracity and appropriateness.

>these teachers are not hurting anyone or disrupting any civil processes

That's the crux of the whole debate, isn't it? By teaching these topics inappropriately or inappropriately early, they are potentially harming children, if, say, transgenderism is a social contagion.

Re:Heresy by NoraCodes on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:45PM (#30979606)
So - again - it's okay to ban people from talking about certain things, in certain circumstances, especially if you believe those things might cause harm, yes? The debate is not over the thing Graham is talking about, but over whether it's worse to tell young cishet children that queer people exist, or to not tell young queer children that other queer people exist. You don't seem to agree with the essay you're defending.
Re:Heresy by pdonis on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:41PM (#30980917)
Here is the actual text of the Florida law in question:

https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2022/1557/BillText/er/...

It says nothing whatever about "banning people from talking about certain things". It says (pp. 4-5):

"3. Classroom instruction by school personnel or third parties on sexual orientation or gender identity may not occur in kindergarten through grade 3 or in a manner that is not age appropriate or developmentally appropriate for students in accordance with state standards."

In other words, it's the government making clear what the standards for "classroom instruction" are in schools run by the government. Exactly the same as the government has always done for schools run by the government. Teachers in public schools are always required to conduct their classroom instruction in accordance with the rules that the government sets down.

Now, let's consider a couple of examples. Suppose a teacher of a 3rd grade class happens to mention the fact that one of the students has a gay couple as parents. Is that violating the law? Of course not. The teacher is not conducting "classroom instruction" about sexual orientation or gender identity. The teacher is just stating a fact.

But suppose the teacher says: "There should be more couples like the parents of student A." Is that violating the law? It might be. If the teacher was very careful to explicitly state that this statement was just the teacher's opinion and was not part of classroom instruction, and if no student's grade on anything depended on whether or not they agreed with the teacher, then it would not be violating the law. But if the teacher made such a statement part of classroom instruction, and gave students assignments based on it, and graded them based on whether they agreed with it, then that would be violating the law.

Note that this is no different from any other area of instruction.

Re:Heresy by mlyle on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:55PM (#30981061)
> Note that this is no different from any other area of instruction.

Allowing parents to sue for DJ, or request a special magistrate be appointed, with reimbursement of attorneys' fees, is pretty different.

> If the teacher was very careful to explicitly state that this statement was just the teacher's opinion and was not part of classroom instruction, and if no student's grade on anything depended on whether or not they agreed with the teacher, then it would not be violating the law.

I think this is a very curious and unlikely distinction.

A 1st grade teacher who wants to read "Heather Has Two Mommies" to the class because there's been questions about April's two moms shouldn't face litigation and censure.

Look, there's a lot of benefits to students to mention that not all families look the same and to seek to use inclusive language. The kids who have an absent dad or a parent that has died benefit as much as anyone from kids understanding that families may look different ways and it's OK.

Another key point is that the law affects other situations. Some high school students are experimenting with other pronouns at school, and feel they would be unsafe at home if this was reported to their parents. This law outlaws this practice of teachers respecting students' preference of what they're called and not telling Dad, unless we meet a relatively high bar of being able to prove that it is likely dangerous.

> In other words, it's the government making clear what the standards for "classroom instruction" are in schools run by the government.

Yes, and this is clearly a state power that needs to be used responsibly. The moment we start prohibiting the discussion of certain political and social views, or e.g. evolution, we've lost.

Re:Heresy by pdonis on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:55PM (#30981627)
> Allowing parents to sue for DJ, or request a special magistrate be appointed, with reimbursement of attorneys' fees, is pretty different.

First, the parents have to work through the school district first. The district has 30 days to address their concerns.

Second, giving ordinary people an actual legal channel to pursue a remedy, without bankrupting them with legal costs, is the sort of thing there should be more of. One of the biggest problems with our legal system in general is that it is unaffordable unless you're a corporation or a wealthy individual.

> A 1st grade teacher who wants to read "Heather Has Two Mommies" to the class because there's been questions about April's two moms shouldn't face litigation and censure.

First, the teacher won't; the school district will. Nothing in the law makes teachers legally liable. All the liability is on the school district.

Second, the teacher is not the sole judge of what's appropriate in the classroom. Parents have to have a voice.

> This law outlaws this practice of teachers respecting students' preference of what they're called and not telling Dad, unless we meet a relatively high bar of being able to prove that it is likely dangerous.

Where does the law say that?

More generally, whether the student likes it or not, their parents are their parents and are responsible for raising them. The right thing for the teacher to do in this kind of situation would be to bring the parent into the discussion themselves, so the teacher can support the student directly in that discussion, not to help the student to go behind the parent's back.

Re:Heresy by mlyle on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:33PM (#30981935)
> The district has 30 days to address their concerns.

Of which the parents are the sole judge of whether their concerns were adequately addressed before pursuing litigation.

> Second, giving ordinary people an actual legal channel to pursue a remedy, without bankrupting them with legal costs, is the sort of thing there should be more of.

Or, alternatively, giving nuisance litigators a way to make money if they find a plaintiff, which is what laws that provide injunctive-relief-plus-legal-costs tend to do.

> First, the teacher won't; the school district will. Nothing in the law makes teachers legally liable. All the liability is on the school district.

The teacher will absolutely face litigation and censure, which are the words I used. They won't have any monetary liability.

> Second, the teacher is not the sole judge of what's appropriate in the classroom. Parents have to have a voice.

You're free to argue that with your local school district's elected body, etc, instead of putting in place legislation which will cow all of these districts into preventing any such discussion.

It's funny how people love to move things to more local levels of government, until those bodies are not doing what they like. Then, it's time for legislative bodies to set standards for the whole state, country, etc.

> The right thing for the teacher to do in this kind of situation would be to bring the parent into the discussion themselves, so the teacher can support the student directly in that discussion, not to help the student to go behind the parent's back.

Sorry-- disagree. Students should be allowed to confide in educators and expect that those confidences will not be betrayed, unless there is an actual acute danger to the students in question. If a student wants to talk to me about not wanting to pursue the career path their parents have in mind, I'm allowed to talk to them, provide information on this, and I'm not expected to "snitch". But if the student asks me to call them "they/them", suddenly things should be super different? Spare me the pearl clutching.

Look, social mores about gender are fundamentally changing, and this is something that is going to happen. You just get to choose how much it sucks for kids in the process.

Re:Heresy by rossjudson on Sunday April 10, 2022 @07:37PM (#30982880)
I agree with what you say. Also:

This law is intended to provide a small number of parents with an implicit veto over what is taught within their local school districts. It does so by placing the judgement over whether a conflict is "resolved" with the parents, and then empowering those parents to initiate a legal procedure that must be paid for by the school district (in the case of a special magistrate) or specifically contemplates "damages", attorney's fees, etc, being awarded to the parent who complains.

As there are no particular limits declared in the law, no school board can withstand a large enough number of attacks being conducted "in parallel", each of which must be paid for by the board.

What I find at least a little interesting is that there doesn't appear to be any contemplation of what happens when a parent sues in the opposite direction -- specifically saying that X and Y are age- and developmentally-appropriate topics for classroom instruction, and to avoid teaching them is inappropriate.

Maybe that's a stretch. But it doesn't really matter, because it's up to the parent to decide if their issue has been "resolved"...and the parent can just go straight to court if they don't like the answer.

Re:Heresy by pdonis on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:41AM (#30984738)
> The teacher will absolutely face litigation and censure, which are the words I used.

Litigation? No. As I've already said, the teachers aren't legally liable. The school district is. So it's the school district that faces litigation, not the teacher.

Censure? By whom? By the parents? Well, yes, if the teacher is doing something that the parents strongly disagree with, they should expect to be censured by the parents.

Censure by someone else? Who? And on what basis? If it's because other people also think what the teacher did is wrong, isn't that, again, just what should be expected? And if other people don't think what the teacher did is wrong, why would they censure the teacher?

> Students should be allowed to confide in educators and expect that those confidences will not be betrayed

I don't see where the law requires a teacher to reveal something the student told them in confidence. The law says teachers should encourage the student to talk to the parents, but it doesn't require the teachers themselves to talk to the parents. (I agree that this means the teacher is not required to do what I suggested in my previous post, to bring the parents into the discussion themselves. I still think it's a good idea if it can be done, but it's not required by the law.) Nor does the law require teachers to reveal something that isn't part of the student's school record--which a confidential conversation wouldn't be. And the school district can't prohibit a teacher from talking to the parents, but it can't require them to either.

> if the student asks me to call them "they/them", suddenly things should be super different?

Nothing in the law singles out this kind of discussion between a student and a teacher. But note that asking the teacher to call them "they/them" in public is not a confidential request. (If it's just in private between the student and teacher and not in the public classroom, that's different.)

> social mores about gender are fundamentally changing

And there are deep divisions in our society about such changes. A teacher might have strong opinions on one side or the other. But as a teacher, they should not be pushing their personal agenda. They should be respecting all viewpoints, and that includes the viewpoints of the parents. If a teacher believes that any parent who objects to their child wanting to be called "they/them" is automatically abusing that child, that teacher has a personal agenda that should not be allowed to intrude into the school environment.

> You just get to choose how much it sucks for kids in the process.

I certainly agree that having adults in their lives who strongly disagree about basic aspects of life sucks for kids. But that strong disagreement is not just the fault of parents who are unwilling to consider change and let their kids explore new things. Ideologues who push their agendas on kids without regard for the viewpoints of the other adults in those kids' lives bear responsibility too.

Re:Heresy by mlyle on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:52AM (#30984804)
> Litigation? No. As I've already said, the teachers aren't legally liable. The school district is. So it's the school district that faces litigation, not the teacher.

The teacher will not have to deal with the litigation? They're not going to have to show up to depositions, have their actions scrutinized and mocked by opposing counsel, etc?

In practice, this gives every parent a veto right: they can say they're not satisfied with what the district did, and tie educators up in litigation and cost the district a bunch of money.

> I don't see where the law requires a teacher to reveal something the student told them in confidence.

If Thomas says that he'd like to be called "Tom", this is a longstanding request that we'd have always complied with. We'd also typically ask how he'd like to be referred to on his report card and if this is something his parents know.

If Thomas says that they would prefer the pronoun 'she' and like to be called "Tammy"-- we're going to have to create a record of it. If Tammy then says she does not want her parents to know this, we still cannot withhold the information.

> And there are deep divisions in our society about such changes. A teacher might have strong opinions on one side or the other. But as a teacher, they should not be pushing their personal agenda. They should be respecting all viewpoints, and that includes the viewpoints of the parents.

In general, when it comes to the courtesy of names, and now pronouns: we do what students request. With information that students indicate their parents would not approve of, we keep confidences. If they say they don't want to be a nurse like Mom and Dad want, and are thinking of an alternative path, we advise them as best as we can. If they say they want to be referred to be 'she' and their parents will freak out, we keep it in confidence.

> Ideologues who push their agendas on kids without regard for the viewpoints of the other adults in those kids' lives bear responsibility too.

I don't favor "pushing agendas" on kids. But the kids are talking about gender and sexuality among themselves in terms largely unfamiliar to you and me, and there's major social change underfoot. Kids deserve teachers that will A) respect reasonable requests made by students for how they are addressed, B) keep confidences, and C) help them navigate this new world as best as we can. Pushing these concerns into the dark or being a conduit directly to parents is not beneficial for student safety or mental health. If you think these changes are largely driven by school staff I think you are highly confused.

Re:Heresy by PuppyTailWags on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:26PM (#30983528)
> More generally, whether the student likes it or not, their parents are their parents and are responsible for raising them. The right thing for the teacher to do in this kind of situation would be to bring the parent into the discussion themselves, so the teacher can support the student directly in that discussion, not to help the student to go behind the parent's back.

I heavily disagree with this idea that the parent should be brought into a discussion involving their child when the parent is a danger to their children. This goes against how abuse should be handled in any other circumstance. A teacher should absolutely be going behind the parents' backs when they suspect the child is in danger or is being abused such that they can assist the child in getting out of the dangerous/abusive situation.

Re:Heresy by pdonis on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:29AM (#30984688)
> I heavily disagree with this idea that the parent should be brought into a discussion involving their child when the parent is a danger to their children.

How do you know when a parent is a danger to their children? Who gets to decide? On what basis?

The answer for this law is that the state already has criteria for that, and those criteria are to be used. Which means the teacher's personal opinion, by itself, is not enough. And that's as it should be. If the teacher really believes the parent is a danger to their children, they have a process they can follow to get that judgment checked by others, and if necessary acted on. But they can't just cut the parent out of the process based on their personal opinion. That's what this law says, and it's correct.

Re:Heresy by mlyle on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:02AM (#30984872)
> If the teacher really believes the parent is a danger to their children, they have a process they can follow to get that judgment checked by others, and if necessary acted on.

Surely there's some kind of continuum between "needs to be immediately removed from the home by the state, with all evidence in hand to demonstrate this" and "will be supportive and react reasonably to something the student is expressing at school."

Teachers routinely keep confidences for their kids. We hear about doubts in parents politics, doubts in the choices that have been made for their future, etc. We are expected to help kids express their own opinions and keep those confidences.

Outing some trans kids is going to get them thrown out on the street by their parents, beaten, or worse. That's a guaranteed consequence of this law. I think you know that, deep down.

Re:Heresy by teakettle42 on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @06:48AM (#31000869)
You seem to believe your views preempt those of your students’ parents.

You are exactly the type of educator this law is intended to target — quite necessarily, as your comments demonstrate.

> We are expected to help kids express their own opinions and keep those confidences.

You should not be keeping secrets from students’ parents in the first place.

You are not the parent; it is not your call.

> Outing some trans kids is going to get them thrown out on the street by their parents, beaten, or worse.

Actual abuse is illegal. Report it through proper channels.

You do not get to usurp parental authority simply because you think some parents won’t agree with your politics.

Re:Heresy by mlyle on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @12:25PM (#31004786)
> You seem to believe your views preempt those of your students’ parents.

I'm a parent too. I believe that my kids should be able to be their own people at school. I don't know everything that happens with them there.

> You are exactly the type of educator this law is intended to target

I don't work for a government entity. But nice try at being vaguely menacing.

> You should not be keeping secrets from students’ parents in the first place.

I'm just curious if this is what you really think. Anything that happens at school-- anything kids express-- should be rolled up in journal form and provided to the parent? Or is there any role for discretion?

> Actual abuse is illegal. Report it through proper channels.

Waiting for actual harm sounds bad. And there's plenty of harm that's legal or nearly so: if they want to force the kid to leave home on their 18th birthday because of what I told them, that still sucks.

Re:Heresy by PuppyTailWags on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:08AM (#30989856)
The law says the teacher can cut the parent out of the process when it comes to reporting abusive parenting. The current discussion is that a new, additional law guarantees additional child abuse occurring. Using the guise of "cutting out" the parents from the child's identity navigation is ignoring the fact the child is requesting confidence because of the parent's abusive behavior. There would be no need for confidence except for the knowledge the parent is dangerous to their child.

Before one points out there is already child protective services- functionally, child protective services is overwhelmed, underfunded, and overworked. They are shockingly ineffective through little fault of their own.

Re:Heresy by kemayo on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:33PM (#30983931)
For what it's worth, I think that the critical position on this bill is basically extreme skepticism about what the parties initiating legal proceedings are going to consider "instruction ... on sexual orientation and gender identity". Because that's a very vague passage, and I'm not confident that bigots won't cause a large chilling effect on schools by suing over teachers mentioning that gay/trans people exist, even if these lawsuits are eventually lost by said bigots.

> Of course not. ... The teacher is just stating a fact.

A lot of "classroom instruction" is stating facts. You're instructing the children about what these facts are. The law seems very vague on where this line is going to fall.

(The other issue is the extreme lack of consideration of the possibility that parental-abuse is the problem you're now required to inform the parents their child has complained about in the other sections of the bill...)

Re:Heresy by no_wizard on Sunday April 10, 2022 @07:38PM (#30982889)
I just want to point out this line:

>or developmentally appropriate for students in accordance with state standards

This could easily, under the US legislative framework, be interpreted as extending beyond the 3rd grade. The law does not, actually, strictly, limit this to 3rd grade or lower. This line, as I understand it, makes it so the law can be applied to other grade levels as well, because they can simply say its not "age appropriate" or "developmentally appropriate" at any level.

I don't think its an accident this line is worded in a way that would allow this.

Re:Heresy by mlyle on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:45PM (#30983313)
> This could easily, under the US legislative framework, be interpreted as extending beyond the 3rd grade.

The or makes it quite clear this is the intent:

> Classroom instruction by school personnel or third parties on sexual orientation or gender identity may not occur in kindergarten through grade 3

So, no instruction in K-3 is permitted.

> or in a manner that is not age appropriate or developmentally appropriate for students in accordance with state standards.

And in 4-12, it may only be age appropriate / developmentally appropriate as determined by state standards. (E.g. it's not an independent finding of fact by the court as to whether what you said to a bunch of 11th graders was age appropriate.)

Re:Heresy by no_wizard on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:55PM (#30983697)
Right, which is, from all suggested evidence so far, is intended to allow the state to suppress educators from talking about sexual orientation, gender identity et. al.

Hence, the layman’s one liner of “Don’t Say Gay”

Why on earth the Republican Party and it’s voter base is so concerned with non heteronormative information making it’s way into classrooms, where what is suppose to be the fundamental place where our youth are suppose to learn about the world and what things are, has always baffled me.

It’s a disservice to children and adults frankly. It’s not like these things just disappear because people disagree with them.

Re:Heresy by kemayo on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:36PM (#30983953)
Personally, I'm amused by the interpretation that the best way to comply with this law is to avoid all mention of gender and sexuality in classrooms. All children shall be "they"; books mentioning heterosexual romance will be forbidden from reading. It's the only way to avoid conveying some sort of instruction about the concept of gender identity...
Re:Heresy by PeterisP on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:54PM (#30984453)
When teachers are agents of the state, they are bound by the restrictions on what the state is allowed to do, being required to afford equal protections to all people.

While I agree that the people should have a say in what gets taught, and that includes culture, in certain cases that say is (and needs to be) inherently limited. For example, if 90% of people would vote that some 10% minority should have limited rights, they should not (and do not) get a say about that, that minority deserves equal protection from state action no matter what the taxpayers or voters want.

And arguably (though the exact details matter) "don't say gay" legislation violates that by having state agents (i.e. teachers and administrators) apply unequal discriminatory treatment to those employees and students who are gay.

[dead]
Re:Heresy by Beltalowda on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:55PM (#30978971)
Another thing that muddies the discussion is the confusion between the legal protection of free speech and the ethical value of free speech.

"Free speech" does not equal "freedom from being criticized" or "right to an audience". Me making fun of your argument or calling your argument stupid and x-ist is me exercising my free speech just as much as you are exercising yours in making you argument in the first place.

But that being said, I would argue that going on campaigns to get someone fired from their job or preventing people from making their argument in the first place and the like is against free speech the ethical value, even if not against the legal principle.

A lot of times what people are really talking of when they express concerns about "free speech" is the ethical value. This is frequently countered with an argument about the legal protection, but that's kind of missing the point IMHO.

Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:29PM (#30980113)
I think of the two sides as "pro-speech" and "anti-speech" dissent.

I can disagree and oppose your opinions by exercising my own right to free speech. I can afford you your own pulpit, air time, and freedom to make your point, and then I can take mine and make my point as loudly as I can. I can schedule a march or rally the same day, across the street.

This is what "pro-speech" dissent looks like.

I can also disagree and oppose your opinion by removing your right to free speech. I can contact people who might give you a platform, and convince them not to do so. I can attempt to impose consequences for you legally, socially, or physically that discourage you from speaking. I can shout over you from across the street, to ensure people can't hear your speech.

This is what "anti-speech" dissent looks like.

And, IMHO, "pro-speech" is more important than almost* any consequence of speech.

* The sole exceptions probably being speech that inspires imminent action to violate any person's individual rights (e.g. violence) or that has an imminent or fundamental threat to bring about a change in government to one which does not allow, support, and respect free speech.

Re:Heresy by ruszki on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:30AM (#30985379)
> The sole exceptions probably being speech that inspires imminent action to violate any person's individual rights (e.g. violence) or that has an imminent or fundamental threat to bring about a change in government to one which does not allow, support, and respect free speech.

Why do you cut the line there? What evidence do you have to include or not include these or other things? How do you define violence? Is causing brain damage violence? AFAIK it's possible to do that only by speech.

I've never seen an argument which wouldn't be possible to be phrased a way by which it wouldn't be "heresy", and include everything which isn't about changing others' feelings. For example, immigration. Almost 100% of useful arguments about immigration are not "heresies". The problem is when somebody is against immigration, and "forget" to mention that they opinion can cause death. Useful arguments don't "forget" this.

Re:Heresy by blub on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:52AM (#30985869)
Yes, causing brain damage is violence. No, speech can not cause brain damage.

Unless inaction or speech is directly and unmistakeable the cause of someone’s death, then they cannot be held responsible for that death and trying to do so is just an attempt at manipulation.

Re:Heresy by ruszki on Monday April 11, 2022 @04:01AM (#30985919)
> speech can not cause brain damage

https://www.verywellmind.com/childhood-abuse-changes-the-bra...

This states clearly otherwise.

Re:Heresy by blub on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:41AM (#30986533)
Child abuse is not speech… I don’t understand how it is even necessary to explicitly say this. :-/
Re:Heresy by ruszki on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:44AM (#30990365)
So it's not possible to insult or threaten somebody - or in this case a child - during a speech according to you. You need to say this explicitly, because people usually think otherwise. Do I need to send you a random Trump speech to prove it to you, that you just moved the goalpost?
Re:Heresy by blub on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @08:08AM (#31013691)
Yes, it is possible to threaten or insult somebody, but this would not cause brain damage.

You cannot cause cellular damage to a human’s brain by talking to them.

Re:Heresy by philosopher1234 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:29PM (#30980797)
People do not evaluate speech based on its truth, they evaluate it based on its authority, which is a function of many things (including, in eg twitters case, popularity). Fighting battles over whos speech should be afforded the biggest stage makes a huge difference in debate.
Re:Heresy by popcube on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:16PM (#30984194)
yes, if you put a flat-earther and a scientist in one debate, people just thinking that 'oh, maybe earth is flat!'
Re:Heresy by philosopher1234 on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:47AM (#30984772)
You’re joking, but if the flat earther was a New York Times journalist they would.
Re:Heresy by popcube on Monday April 11, 2022 @08:34AM (#30987830)
the problem is, if they hold an 'debate', this will make people trust there are some enough to debate
Re:Heresy by leaflets2 on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:04PM (#30995015)
Yes, or if they write what a dictator says (eg Putin) then people read it and think "hmm the newspapers report that he said this, so it must be important, maybe it's true"

And in that way the dictators can fool the citizens in democratic countries via their own newspapers

Re:Heresy by josephcsible on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:18PM (#30982297)
> "right to an audience"

If Alice wants to talk but Bob doesn't want to listen to her, then he indeed shouldn't have to. But if Alice wants to talk and Bob does want to listen to her, then they should be able to without Karen being able to stop them.

Re:Heresy by leaflets2 on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:08PM (#30995067)
When Alice says "those who look like so:... are kidnapping your babies and control the banks and steal your salaries"

and a year later 100 Bobs kill those that look like so?

That's one consequence of totally free speech unfortunately

Re:Heresy by skissane on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:06PM (#30983763)
> A lot of times what people are really talking of when they express concerns about "free speech" is the ethical value. This is frequently countered with an argument about the legal protection, but that's kind of missing the point IMHO.

That's true, but also I think people sometimes have an overly narrow focus on one single aspect of legal protection - especially, in the US context, the First Amendment. While 1A is the most crucial way in which the US legal system seeks to support that ethical value, there are other ways – something which violates the ethical value of free speech may not violate 1A, yet may violate other legal provisions.

To give just one example – California Labor Code sections 1101 and 1102 outlaws political discrimination in employment in the State of California. This can provide added protection to the ethical value of free speech compared to 1A. 1A does not prevent private employers from firing employees for publicly expressing particular political views – at least in some cases, 1101&1102 will. And a few other states have similar legal provisions, and there is always the chance that more states could adopt laws like this – getting state laws amended is far easier than amending the federal constitution, or putting in place a Supreme Court bench which will interpret it a certain way.

Re:Heresy by tristor on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:56PM (#30978972)
“Deplatforming” is anti-freedom. It violates the free speech of the speaker, it violates freedom of assembly for the listeners, and it violates freedom of association for all of the parties involved.

Showing up to shout someone down who had people voluntarily show up to hear them speak because you feel like you are empowered to unilaterally decide and enforce through aggression who is “allowed” to speak in your city or on your campus, is inherently an act against freedom of speech. It’s also the ultimate act of “entitlement”, getting away with it is the ultimate act of “privilege” to be allowed to so utterly disrespect another person’s rights.

There is no other way to color this and very little nuance here. “Platforms” in the virtual space have more leeway as they’re mostly privately owned and extended as a privilege of access, not a right. Shouting down speakers in public (or paid and invited) venues though is unequivocally against freedom of speech.

Re:Heresy by godelski on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:56PM (#30979716)
> “Deplatforming” is anti-freedom. It violates the free speech of the speaker, it violates freedom of assembly for the listeners, and it violates freedom of association for all of the parties involved.

Is it though? And to what extent? We don't have unlimited freedom of speech in the US constitution because we agreed that there are limits and realize that words do mean things (like a threat).

But on a platform let's be nuanced. Some people believe that saying a racist word and having their comment removed is deplatforming. Some think they can promote violence. Others think getting down voted is deplatforming. There's a lot of people getting grouped together here and many making claims of being deplatformed are not acting in good faith.

So unfortunately we need to define what deplatforming means otherwise we'll just be arguing and making assumptions because many people will be working off of many different definitions pretending that we all agree on the definition (or that we hold the true definition and others are dumb).

Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:13PM (#30979921)
"Censoring future speech" seems like a decent working definition.

I.e. anything that restrains an individual's ability to make future speech in a manner equal to that of their peers

Another useful distinction in the argument would be between "commons platforms" and smaller ones.

It feels like past time that we recognized market realities and codified them into law to distinguish rights and regulations. If you are Google, Facebook, Twitter, Apple, Microsoft, Snap, or ByteDance (or any subsequent arising entity with a large enough market share in some public/social market) then you the public should have different access rights to your platforms, on the sole basis of their public ubiquity.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:45PM (#30981526)
What is "free speech"? What are your feelings on censoring pornography, gore, or false advertising?
Re:Heresy by bb88 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:44PM (#30982031)
Or ... conspiracy to commit murder, fraud, organized shoplifting, or an insurrection on the capital, e.g.?

Or ... falsely smearing people and companies, potentially anonymously?

Or ... doxxing journalists, government officials (including judges), doctors that refused to give Ivermectin, or rape victims?

Re:Heresy by godelski on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:20PM (#30980010)
So you clarify, you are okay with down voting and removing comments but are not okay withbanning accounts? Bans, even temporary, are crossing the line?
Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:59PM (#30980478)
My feelings on the above are likely contingent of the nuances of implementation. Do downvotes ultimately censor posts? Are votes equal weight? Etc.

From a higher level, I'd grant that (a) platforms have a fundamental right to try to realize their vision, which may include promoting and demoting various types of content & (b) spam and astroturfing is a constant reality in any social platform (and users are better served by less of both).

So I think there are justifiable reasons for censoring, or at least decreasing visibility. I've been on forums long enough and have too low an opinion of the average internet denizen to think otherwise. :-)

Hence, to me, the emphasis on ad vs post hoc restraint.

If I allow you to make speech, and then, on the basis of that piece of speech and NOT on your identity as its speaker, decrease its virality in a way that's still fair (e.g. yank it from feed promotion but still allow direct linking) and then (in rare cases) absolutely censor it, that feels fair. To me.

If I proactively identify you, godelski, as someone likely to say *ist things and consequently ban you or pre-censor everything you post, irregardless of the individual pieces of content, that does not feel fair. To me.

As well, and I should have punched this more in my comment, as emphasizing "individual." Which is to say "1 human person, 1 share of public speech rights."

IMHO, if free speech is a right that flows from our existence as sentient beings then it's difficult to get from there to "you deserve more / less free speech than I do."

---

And finally, because I know I'll get this response eventually, yes, I know playing whack-a-mole with bad actors on a public platform is a nigh impossible task. I've done it. Maybe actually impossible.

Tough.

Uber skirted labor laws in pursuit of profit. Social media platforms are doing the exact same in terms of nuanced moderation in pursuit of profit. "It's difficult" or "It costs a lot to employ and train the headcount required to do it" isn't an acceptable defense, and we shouldn't accept it.

Re:Heresy by efitz on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:10PM (#30981195)

  I'd grant that (a) platforms have a fundamental right to try to realize their vision, which may include promoting and demoting various types of content & (b) spam and astroturfing is a constant reality in any social platform (and users are better served by less of both).  
I don't think that platforms should have any such fundamental right wrt user produced content. I think that platforms should work as either publishers (where they produce and are responsible for all the content), or as common carriers (where they are forbidden by law from interfering with legal content). I think that platforms should have to explicitly choose one model once they reach a certain number of participants or when they incorporate.

I am all for shielding platforms from liability for user content if they act like a common carrier and limit themselves to removing illegal content. However I don't see why we as a society should shield companies from liability when they selectively pick and choose which user content to promote and which to suppress, according to their own preferences.

Re:Heresy by ipsi on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:37PM (#30981451)
I wonder if you've thought this through properly. I suspect that, if your vision were to be enacted, there would be no more forums. No more Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, Hacker News, niche PHP forums, comment sections, etc, etc. Why? Because they'd devolve into spam and/or people arguing past each other. For example, given your current definition I believe it would be acceptable for someone to write a script to post useless replies to every single Hacker News post and comment, effectively rendering the board useless.

Right now, HN has the right to delete those. If it was a common carrier, it would presumably not. Arguably they're spam, but I cannot imagine a way you can define "spam" that is narrow enough to not be redefined by everyone as "things I disagree with", but broad enough to capture someone posting excessively to a forum. Note that this wouldn't violate the CAN-SPAM act because it's not advertising anything commercial.

Re:Heresy by efitz on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:16PM (#30983136)
I have thought that through and considered putting that in my post, but I didn't want to dilute the original thought.

Of course I support the idea of "off topic", but it is something that needs a lot of consideration and however one writes such a restriction, it's liable for abuse and probably has a zillion edge cases. E.g. is it off topic if I post "<your favorite politician> hates cat videos" onto a cat video forum? What if I am a moderator with <other side> political views, and I allow those posts if they come from people that agree with me and disallow them if they come from people who agree with you? What if I divide my site into multiple sub-fora, one of which is "politics of cat videos"? What if de facto use of my forum or a sub-forum becomes political discussion, but that everyone attaches a cat video to each post?

In other words, yes, I have thought a lot about it, but this warrants its own separate discussion.

Re:Heresy by ipsi on Monday April 11, 2022 @04:49AM (#30986221)
That's a very reasonable response. I'd add another thought: A site (e.g., Twitter) could define "off-topic" as anything that goes against its Terms of Service or Code of Conduct (CoC), which would probably result in exactly where we are now. Same problem with a lot of similar ideas - "Spam? Anything that violates our CoC is spam"; "Degrades the experience for the user? We feel that violating our CoC degrades the user experience"; and so on. Not a problem easily (or even able to be, IMO) solved.
Re:Heresy by tsimionescu on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:20PM (#30981824)
This position means that if I create a forum for fans of a band, neither I nor anyone else should have the right to remove comments trying to sell hair products or discussing cooking recipes. Not to mention sharing (legal) pornographic images.
Re:Heresy by efitz on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:01PM (#30981112)
I am ok with downvoting, if I have the ability to change my settings so that I can view downvoted comments. However, I think that downvoting is a less desirable than individual-centric controls.

I strongly prefer to have have the individual ability to block/mute/suppress any comment or commenter, and I am ok delegating that ability to someone or something else as long as I can withdraw my delegation and undo any changes that were made. To put it differently- I might decide that I trust some organization or individual to build block/filter lists and I might consume those lists (as I do for spam blocking, ad blocking, etc.), as long as I can observe what they're doing and opt out at any time. It seems social media is long overdue for that.

I am NOT ok with anyone (or anything) else doing these for me without my explicit opt-in, especially if I don't have any way to see what decisions they made on my behalf or to reverse those decisions.

Re:Heresy by ncallaway on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:05PM (#30981147)
Do you think accounts that post nothing but spam content (so, a twitter account that posts an advertisement in response to every public tweet on the platform), or blatant scams, should not be allowed to be restricted in any way (for future speech)?
Re:Heresy by sangnoir on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:07PM (#30979847)
Deplatforming does not violate freedom of association for all parties: you seem to be forgetting that the platform also has the right to freedom of association, and would be exercising that right by refusing to associate with the individual(s) being deplatformed.

I'm yet to see a convincing argument that broadly, one person's free speech right always trumps other's freedom of association when the other doesn't like your speech, for any reason.

Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:18PM (#30979986)
Because one party is human (the individual) and the other party is corporate (the platform).

Individuals are inherently endowed with inalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Corporations are explicitly allowed whatever rights we choose to afford them, in pursuit of profit and maximizing their ability to put capital to productive ends.

Saying "an individual speaks" is very different than saying "Facebook speaks."

What opinions would Facebook have? And what fundamental desires would Facebook's opinions stem from?

Re:Heresy by sangnoir on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:28PM (#30980107)
...and yet the Citizens United and Hobby Lobby rulings are a thing.

There is no basis (or case law) to say biological people's free speech rights overrides legal people's freedom of association right everytime - but I've seen the "free speech absolutists" take this as a given.

Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:42PM (#30980290)
They are absolutely a thing, and are the current law, but I can and do disagree with them from first principles.

A group of individual persons, associated for a specific purpose, are not equivalent to an individual person in matters of fundamentally-owed rights.

Re:Heresy by throwaway82652 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:06PM (#30980547)
So in your ideal world, all you have to do to avoid "deplatforming" is to find one other person who shares your viewpoint and form a group? Isn't that literally how it already is regardless of your "first principles"? Or am I misunderstanding?
Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:09PM (#30980575)
I'm arguing that platforms (aka groups aka corporations) deserve fewer free speech rights than human individuals.
Re:Heresy by throwaway82652 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:17PM (#30980660)
So if I talk to my neighbor and we agree on something and form a group of two, suddenly we deserve less free speech rights because technically that is a platform somehow? I can't understand what you mean here, please clarify.

If you're trying to say businesses should be required to file with the government and get subject to business regulation, they already are?

Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:26PM (#30980765)
If you and one neighbor form a group, why should your group-of-two be entitled to any more free speech rights than those the two of you possessed before forming a group, and still individually possess after forming the group?

Groups are entitled to greater-than-zero rights, in order to support their accomplishing their purpose in an efficient manner, but I'm curious why they should be owed person-equivalent rights?

Re:Heresy by throwaway82652 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:30PM (#30980812)
>why should your group-of-two be entitled to any more free speech rights than those the two of you possessed before forming a group, and still individually possess after forming the group?

It's not? If I throw my own party I can decide to uninvite the other bad neighbor down the block who always gets drunk and trashes everything. If I form up with my other neighbor and throw a block party, we can also decide to uninvite that same drunk neighbor. Are you saying that because it's a block party and not my personal birthday party, we should be forced to invite this person and have the party trashed, because uninviting them is a person-equivalent right? Or maybe I'm not allowed to do this at a personal birthday party either, because my wife and brother and I all formed a group to plan it? Please help me understand here, maybe this is a bad analogy.

Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:48PM (#30980991)
> Are you saying that because it's a block party and not my personal birthday party, we should be forced to invite this person and have the party trashed, because uninviting them is a person-equivalent right?

To use this analogy, yes.

Or perhaps better, the block party shouldn't automatically have a right to not invite them, because a block party is not a personal party, and the right of the block party to not invite them should be weighed against other rights before being granted.

Because, as you noted, equating block party group rights with your personal rights ultimately leads to "just form a group."

Which, in US law, also clashes with the fact that some core rights we give legal groups (in corporate form) to allow them to operate efficiently are limited liability (with respect to their members as individuals) and limited transparency (with regards to their internal workings and ownership).

So free speech + limited liability + limited transparency = problems.

Re:Heresy by joshuamorton on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:16PM (#30982280)
Doesn't this infringe on my individual right to enforce my own boundaries?

If I dislike someone, and I host an event, it's by definition a "group" thing, there's no real way to distinguish a personal gathering from a group gathering. But under your proposed system, I, an individual, can't exclude any person from a group gathering. Being unable to choose who I associate with is a fundamental infringement on my right of association. If I'm forced to associate with everyone, I'm not free.

Re:Heresy by throwaway82652 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:58PM (#30981086)
Ok, to me what you've proposed just means that nobody in my neighborhood will throw block parties anymore because they don't want to get stuck with the bill when drunk guy breaks a window and urinates on the upholstery.

Edit just to respond to something:

>Because, as you noted, equating block party group rights with your personal rights ultimately leads to "just form a group."

I don't know how you got that, this seems to be very backwards. The group was formed before the rights were even considered.

Re:Heresy by simonh on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:32PM (#30981409)
A group of two is not necessarily entitled to more rights than individuals, but I don’t see why they should entitled to fewer rights. The idea that groups and associations of various forms can have the same rights as individuals has been a legal principle going back to the Middle Ages at least in the west, and even further in some other cultures. I see no good reason to change that.

It seems to me that any scheme for depriving people of the ability to exercise their rights in various contexts, for example because they are trying to do so as part of a specific group, could be subject to serious abuse.

Re:Heresy by raxxorraxor on Monday April 11, 2022 @08:19AM (#30987680)
I am a free speech absolutist. I believe anything else would be decadence living in a first world nation. My country still does restrict speech and did so for centuries now, has spawned multiple dictatorships and still believes it to be a working concept. But that is another topic.

Platforms that promote certain content are absolutely free to do so and should not be forced to do anything else. But it should be understood that this is their motivation and their choice. They do not practice freedom of speech or freedom of opinion. They advertise for something and it is not about any intellectual discourse and probably more about advertising.

Re:Heresy by cortesoft on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:27PM (#30981358)
Ok, so what if a platform was owned by just one person... it would be totally fine for that one person to refuse to allow certain people to post their thoughts on it?

If you accept that, then what about a company that is owned by two people? Or three? Ten? 100?

How many people have to own a company before the owners are no longer allowed to decide who they allow to use their platform to espouse their views?

Re:Heresy by etchalon on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:42PM (#30981498)
All of the parties in your equation are human.

Facebook is run by a collection of humans. Those humans make choices, as humans, that collectively we think of as "Facebook".

Re:Heresy by hotpotamus on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:21PM (#30981306)
"Corporations are people, my friend" - Mitt Romney
Re:Heresy by tristor on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:42PM (#30981503)
> you seem to be forgetting that the platform also has the right to freedom of association

In the cases I'm mostly referring to in my comment, the "platform" was perfectly fine with the speaker, and invited them (or accepted their money in exchange for use of the venue), so, yes, their freedom of association is /also/ being violated when someone comes in to shout down the speaker.

Re:Heresy by sangnoir on Monday April 11, 2022 @06:42PM (#30996060)
Is the person who comes in to shout down the speaker not exercising their right to free speech - or should it be restricted in this instance?
Re:Heresy by tristor on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @07:24PM (#31009442)
As the saying goes "Your right to swing your arms ends where my nose begins." Shouting someone down who is speaking to an audience that explicitly came to listen to them in a venue they arranged for isn't "freedom of speech", it's disruptive and a form of trespass. It's also made worse by the fact most of the things being shouted when this happens is arguably slander.
Re:Heresy by fumar on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:01PM (#30980505)
What I don’t understand is the nuance between freedom of speech in public spaces versus privately owned spaces. If the US government had a public social network, then people would have the right to shout ZYX. It is not the same on Facebook or TikTok right? Those are privately owned spaces. That would be like you coming into my property to shout XYS and I could remove you from my land. Am I understanding this correctly?
Re:Heresy by bzbarsky on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @01:45AM (#30999039)
There are privately owned spaces (shopping malls, some towns) that have been treated as public spaces for free speech purposes in US court cases, as I understand it.

Basically, if a privately owned space is promoted as a "commons" and acts as one, some of the rules about speech start changing.

Re:Heresy by ss108 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:38PM (#30979515)
In making this argument, you should clarify that you think it's important to not limit "freedom of speech" to its legal definition. Currently, you only make an allusion to that distinction.

To fully make your argument, you need to convince people that the overall philosophical point of "free speech" is worth societal value even beyond that which we have accorded it via law (assuming you're in the US).

Coming from someone who doesn't agree with you, but who doesn't agree with your opponents either.

Re:Heresy by lukifer on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:00PM (#30979759)
The First Amendment doesn't grant a right to free speech as such; such a right is assumed to be pre-existing and inalienable (whether one roots such rights in religious belief or secular humanism). Rather: the First Amendment restricts what laws Congress may pass, which might infringe on that right.
Re:Heresy by ss108 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:25PM (#30980062)
The "right" only exists insofar as it is legally protected.
Re:Heresy by lukifer on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:43PM (#30980308)
I half-agree: many who lean libertarian like to contrast "positive rights" with "negative rights"; and while it's an interesting academic distinction, in my view a purely negative right is indistinguishable from not having a right at all. Perhaps the state cannot proactively ensure my survival with 100% certainty, but a "right to life" is meaningless without some kind of proactive deterrent against violence.

Where I disagree is the "legal" qualifier: while legal protections have an important role to play, so do civil institutions and social norms. Many forms of suppressing free expression are entirely compatible with the First Amendment (economic and social sanctions), and instead have to be defended in civil society, and the court of public opinion.

Re:Heresy by ss108 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:01PM (#30980504)
I see where you're coming from. I just think that if we have to resort to civil institutions beyond courts to enforce something, it's not really a "right". It's some other kind of good or value. So maybe my definition of "right" is too narrow or legalistic--but it is ofc widespread.
Re:Heresy by lukifer on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:29PM (#30980804)
I don't disagree, my position here is "yes, and". However one construes "rights" (it's a thorny topic both morally and empirically!), in my view, legal defenses and civil defenses are each necessary, but not sufficient.
Re:Heresy by Karrot_Kream on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:01PM (#30980510)
The Constitution uses "inalienable rights" for a reason. An individual (and c.f. Citizens United and Hobby Lobby, corporations) is accorded all rights not explicitly circumscribed by a higher form of federal government
Re:Heresy by ss108 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:09PM (#30980573)
That phrase is from the Declaration of Independence, not the Constitution.

The way the Constitution works is that the Federal government only has those powers it is granted, which are limited by items such as the First Amendment, which does not generally restrict individuals (including corporations--there is no "cf" here; corporations are simply people, though they are not 'natural persons", where that distinction matters).

Re:Heresy by Karrot_Kream on Sunday April 10, 2022 @07:20PM (#30982762)
Fair enough. I had something else I was trying to say but I just didn't properly.
Re:Heresy by dragonwriter on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:07PM (#30980559)
> In making this argument, you should clarify that you think it's important to not limit "freedom of speech" to its legal definition

More specifically, to shrink “free speech” smaller than it's legal definition, and erase both part of what is legally protected and the fundamental premise of the legal protection, in that you want it prohibit private exercise of free speech rights essential to forcing ideas to complete in the marketplace of ideas by compelling private actors to actively participate in relaying speech that they find repugnant.

Re:Heresy by ss108 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:21PM (#30981835)
This is a good point as well.
Re:Heresy by LudwigNagasena on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:43PM (#30980312)
It’s interesting how “I support rights of private companies but only when they do something totalitarian” has become such a common position in the US.
Re:Heresy by ModernMech on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:26PM (#30981345)
I'm confused by what you are saying here. Corporations have always been totalitarian in their decision making. How often have you heard from your boss "this isn't a democracy" when they make a decision that's unpopular among the employees?

The more interesting dynamic to me is the free-market, anti-regulation, low-corporate-tax capitalist politicians arguing we should create regulations to make the market less free.

Re:Heresy by LudwigNagasena on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:46PM (#30981541)
> I'm confused by what you are saying here. Corporations have always been totalitarian in their decision making. How often have you heard from your boss "this isn't a democracy" when they make a decision that's unpopular among the employees?

I am saying that people who are seemingly opposed to that stuff are the first to shout that Twitter is a private company and thus can manipulate its userbase however it wants.

> The more interesting dynamic to me is the free-market, anti-regulation, low-corporate-tax capitalist politicians arguing we should create regulations to make the market less free.

Yeah, and it’s good that people finally loosen up their radical stances and start to realize that the state isn’t the only source of oppression.

Re:Heresy by ModernMech on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:42PM (#30982013)
> I am saying that people who are seemingly opposed to that stuff are the first to shout that Twitter is a private company and thus can manipulate its userbase however it wants.

One thing to consider is that this argument is being used rhetorically to force interlocutors into an uncomfortable position. If you are a famous politician who has been championing the unrestricted free reign of corporations to pollute, abuse employees, abuse customers, etc. for decades, but now all of a sudden you're upset about certain decisions those companies make regarding their own products, people are going to throw that in your face.

The argument will continue to be made until those arguing for tighter controls over corporate free speech agree that corporate power in other areas must be checked as well. I'm all for greater oversight of Twitter that would lead to more free speech. But I'm not going to start arguing for it until there's a broader recognition that corporate power writ large needs to be reduced, not just at the corporations which make things politically uncomfortable for certain politicians.

To me, it seems like some politicians would like to pass laws against e.g. Twitter specifically that would help them politically, but they would like to preserve corporate power in general where it benefits them. They want corporations to be people when it benefits them, but they don't want corporations to be people when it's politically inconvenient.

That's not how this works. Until conservative attitudes about corporate power and corporate personhood shift generally, Twitter will retain the power they have now, since they are people according to conservatives.

Re:Heresy by LudwigNagasena on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:52AM (#30985495)
> One thing to consider is that this argument is being used rhetorically to force interlocutors into an uncomfortable position.

That wasn’t my experience. It seems like people are generally guilty in believing what is expedient regardless of their political affiliation.

Re:Heresy by orwin on Monday April 11, 2022 @08:42AM (#30987898)
It is my experience though. I don't really care if people can use Twitter/Facebook to write whatever they want in their own name (yes, even harassment and incitation to violence, as long as it is done under your real name). But I do use the 'but corps are people too!' argument because I know it triggers some people who don't like having their arguments used against them.

My radicals friend all do the same thing, one of them even participate to witch-hunt/deplatforming rally despite being morally against it, just to be able to say 'but isn't a corporation a moral person?'. Until this notion is broken (and if we could break Limited liability too...), i don't think anybody can legitimately argue against deplatforming.

So join with anarchist/trotskyist, ecosocialists and all the radical left against corporation as moral person, and you'll find a lot of allies for your freedom of speech fight.

Re:Heresy by tomp on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:48PM (#30979632)
For some weird reason, the same people can be OK with Cloudflare or Twitter banning someone for their political views, but wouldn't be OK with a bank or electricity provider banning someone for their political views.
Re:Heresy by drdec on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:34PM (#30980839)
An electrical provider is typically a government-granted monopoly, and given that, it is not unreasonable to extend the protection of speech against government action to the electrical provider.

Banks are not however, and in fact, banks and the financial system do act against classes of people. Visa and Mastercard frequently pressure their customers in an effort to prevent sex work in the name of preventing sex trafficking. If their customers do not do enough they will cut them off. This most recently happened with OnlyFans. See also PornHub.

Re:Heresy by PeterisP on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:43PM (#30984381)
You're right about banks in USA, but I think that this is wrong and indicates that the ability of these middlemen to prevent people from interacting in society (being able to pay one another is essentially part of freedom of association) needs to be restricted.
Re:Heresy by PeterisP on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:41PM (#30984367)
In my mind there is a big difference between banning particular views versus banning someone for their particular views.

Like, Cloudflare or Twitter should be free to choose what speech they publish and what they prohibit, but they (and banks and electricity providers) should not be banning someone because of who they are as a person or for their political views expressed elsewhere. Cloudflare should be free to ban Daily Stormer as they did, but if the same people from Daily Stormer were just running a cat picture site through Cloudflare (and publishing their neo-Nazi stuff elsewhere) then IMHO Cloudflare should not ban their cat picture site.

To choose an extreme (but less-political?) example of paedophilia, it's obviously okay to ban distribution of child sexual abuse material, but IMHO someone who's just came out from prison after being convicted for child rape should not get automatically banned from platforms (or banks, or electricity providers) as a person despite being a paedophile child abuser, they should be able to participate in the society unless/until their ongoing acts become criminal and they get removed from the society by the courts. And if that's the case, then it also applies to the less extreme views.

Re:Heresy by tomp on Monday April 11, 2022 @07:38AM (#30987322)
> We're not banning you, we're just want to prevent you from using our electricity for undesirable activities. Well, since we cannot actually distinguish undesirable activities from non-undesirable activities, we'll just stop providing you any electricity, that way we can be sure you're not using it for undesirable activities.
Re:Heresy by leaflets2 on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:15PM (#30995181)
You cannot manipulate people via the electricity network and the power plugs in you house.

But you can, via Twitter and Facebook.

Communication is its own different animal

Re:Heresy by ambrozk on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:18PM (#30979982)
If there is a pulpit in the town square, then the 1st amendment says that a speaker *is* entitled to that pulpit. This is the essence of free speech, and always has been. The 1st amendment is very explicit about this: citizens have a right to assemble *in public* and air their opinions *publicly.* Cordoning off opinions and declaring them unfit for certain public squares is a classic form of censorship. Communists, Republicans, the KKK, NAMBLA, the NRA, GLAAD, Gay Geeks for Bernie and the ASPCA all have the right to march on the National Mall.
Re:Heresy by ethbr0 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:32PM (#30980162)
Exactly. IMHO, we just need to accept that "public" has extended and changed to encompass publicly-accessible, privately-owned platforms of a sufficient size.
Re:Heresy by otterley on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:11PM (#30981752)
That would violate the property and First Amendment rights of the private platform owners.

You could, however, advocate for the creation of a publicly-owned Internet platform where all speech would be acceptable. Why don't you do that, instead?

Re:Heresy by ThrowawayR2 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:01PM (#30982159)
> "That would violate the property and First Amendment rights of the private platform owners.

Much like the Fair Housing Act of 1968 restricts the Constitutional property rights of earlier bigots who didn't want to sell property to the "wrong" type of people, society by and large will likely be okay with violating the Constitutional property rights of the illiberal who don't want to allow the "wrong" type of people to use market-dominant services.

Illiberalism is illiberalism, regardless of whether it comes from the right of the left.

Re:Heresy by otterley on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:22PM (#30983506)
First, this comparison is inapt. We forbid people from discriminating against who can buy housing because a person’s race is something that is part of their identity, they are born with, that they didn’t choose, and has no bearing whatsoever on whether they can afford or deserve to own property. Restrictions in social media, on the other hand, pertain to voluntary behavior that the subject is 100% in control of and should be responsible for.

Second, you can't easily separate the property-rights issue from the free-speech issue; they are naturally intertwined. In this case, that property (equipment, software, etc.) is being used specifically to broadcast speech, and we don't force people to repeat the speech of others (using mechanical devices or otherwise).

Finally, fairness as a platform concept was once a thing imposed by the FCC up till the 1980s (due to the scarcity of broadcast channels) and is now dead. We've replaced that with the possibility of infinite numbers of outlets. There's nothing stopping someone from building an anything-goes Twitter. And in fact, people have tried, as recently as two years ago (remember Parler?), but they end up dying from their own radioactive contamination.

Re:Heresy by ThrowawayR2 on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:50PM (#30997636)
I've seen the first argument made before and IMO it's not a workable refutation because it ignores those protected classes for characteristics one is not born with intrinsically, namely religion/creed, which can change, e.g. people leaving cults, conversions between faiths, and those who become agnostic/atheist, and gender identity, given proponents of that concept believe it to be fluid (as best I understand it). Unless you are denying those classes should be protected classes, then there is significant precedent for protecting changeable aspects of one's identity.

Regarding the second point, actually we do (or did; the Trump administration rolled it back and the Biden administration is trying to re-instate it) "force people to repeat the speech of others"; one of the points of the FCC's net neutrality definition was "No blocking: This includes a right to send and receive lawful traffic, prohibits the blocking of lawful content, apps, services and the connection of non-harmful devices to the network" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality_in_the_United_S...) and even deplorable speech is still lawful.

Regarding the third point, lots of online services died before the dominant incumbents of today came to power, e.g. AltaVista, Lycos, etc. Various conservative media outlets, like Fox News, are still around and thriving; you can bet they are watching and learning from these failures. Whose to say that one of them doesn't dislodge the incumbents and it becomes your viewpoint that needs protection? Public opinion is fickle.

(As an aside, sorry if my original post was confusing; I need to get better at writing.)

Re:Heresy by tylerhou on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:58PM (#30984083)
People’s political beliefs are not, and should not be, protected classes.
Re:Heresy by ByteJockey on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:13AM (#30984930)
And yet religious beliefs, generally speaking, are protected.

How hard does someone have to believe something before it crosses the line into religion? Or is it just a matter of paperwork?

Re:Heresy by otterley on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:09PM (#30982224)
This comes across as a thinly-veiled opinion that property owners should be allowed not to sell to a buyer solely because they are Black. That's what you mean, right? You might as well say it straightforwardly instead of attempting to hide behind a veil of logical equivalence.
Re:Heresy by tbrownaw on Sunday April 10, 2022 @07:07PM (#30982677)
...What? The comment you're replying to is pretty explicitly arguing the exact opposite of what you claim it is.

"People will be ok with this restriction because it's similar to this earlier clearly correct restriction."

Re:Heresy by otterley on Sunday April 10, 2022 @07:35PM (#30982867)
<redacted>
Re:Heresy by tbrownaw on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:44PM (#30983307)
...what?

The second paragraph is saying that the practices that the FHA banned were also illiberalism, just like the current practices of the current service providers.

And there is no charitable interpretation or benefit of the doubt needed; it's crystal clear. In order to even have the option of reading it the way you keep trying to, I'd have to ignore: referring to the landlords who had their bad behavior banned as "bigots"; putting scare quotes around both cases of "wrong"; explicitly calling the current platform providers illiberal.

Re:Heresy by otterley on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:16PM (#30983478)
I apologize to the author; upon reflection, I think your interpretation is correct.
Re:Heresy by ModernMech on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:34PM (#30981425)
> If there is a pulpit in the town square, then the 1st amendment says that a speaker is entitled to that pulpit.

Okay but what about when I want to use the pulpit? By your logic, if you're using the pulpit you are restricting my speech, because I can't exercise my speech while you're exercising yours. And by that token, if everyone in the town square wanted to shout you down and drown you out while you were at the pulpit, you can't really complain on the basis of free speech, right? Because any restrictions on their shouting would encroach on their free speech rights.

Apparently this is what we call "cancel culture", and the reason we're still talking about it today is that people complaining about it have no coherent ideas on how to fix it without also trampling all over the very free speech principles they are decrying have been violated.

This knot people have tied themselves into is fascinating.

Re:Heresy by ambrozk on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:41PM (#30981493)
No, you're imagining complications that don't exist. The very boring answer is that if two people (or groups) want to exercise their right to free speech at the same time, the government is charged with fairly apportioning the space to each of them in turn, in such a manner that both will ultimately be able to express themselves. If one of the parties feels the government is unfairly restricting their right to speech, they can take the government to court, and the court will adjudicate the dispute.

What people are describing as "cancel culture" is a totally different phenomenon.

Re:Heresy by ModernMech on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:52PM (#30982085)
> the government is charged with fairly apportioning the space to each of them in turn, in such a manner that both will ultimately be able to express themselves.

But even if you have the space according to whatever schedule is set up, I and all my friends can still go to the square while you are talking, and we can open our mouths to scream at the top of our lungs for as long as we like. Right? That's unrestricted free speech, is it not? For the government to come along and tell me to close my mouth, that would abridge my free speech rights.

> What people are describing as "cancel culture" is a totally different phenomenon.

I'm not sure. I've seen the term applied to almost any kind of restriction of speech, no matter how benign or justified. It's so broad as to be meaningless at this point.

Re:Heresy by hotpotamus on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:26PM (#30981348)
I've never seen a pulpit or a town square in the city I live in. Have you?
Re:Heresy by ambrozk on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:42PM (#30981504)
Yes, though "town square" is a metaphor which typically refers to public space generally, and usually includes things like streetcorners in its definition.
Re:Heresy by hotpotamus on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:51PM (#30982534)
Ah, then have you seen someone denied from accessing this town square?
Re:Heresy by nonrandomstring on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:14PM (#30978510)
The speed with which society is moving is also a factor.

Tacitus or Voltaire are variously credited with the notion that in any epoch, to know who is in power, ask who you may not criticise.

I think Graham is slightly missing the point about our period. It's not that heresy is on the up, so much as it's on the move. Outrage is a homeless beast. We're in an Orwellian age where it changes with the seasons, so what is heresy in one place and time is a tepid platitude only next door the following week.

Also it is no longer power that metes out punishment, but the fanboi acolytes or loyal minor apparatchik. It would have once been "dangerous" (at least in a fairly pedestrian job) to say that Google is a crappy old search engine, Facebook is a threat to democracy and Microsoft are corrupt criminals. Today it's practically de rigueur to cock a snook at jaded icons. It's practically a credential.

Re:Heresy by kbenson on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:12PM (#30979178)
> Also it is no longer power that metes out punishment

There are different types of power, and what I think we're seeing is that whip traditionally those different types of power have rested in the same individuals, that's not so true anymore.

Financial and political power is still mostly where it's always been. Social power has been democratized far more and far more quickly in recent years, to the point that those same groups that have the financial and political power no longer mostly control it.

I think the mercurial appearance of how that power is wielded is also easily explained. Like any revolutionaries that take power, they are often unrestrained in it's use as they are not used to the problems of wielding it.

Whether the status quo can ever develop into a more restrained arbiter if social justice remains to be seen. As long as the young are the majority of the social scenes used in the decision process (the social networks of the moment) I doubt it, but the demographics of these networks are shifting year by year and those that have been using them longer are learning the trade and solidifying their bases, and those ones making enough money to also join the other power structures. Perhaps in another decade or two this will just be viewed as another period of large change, like civil rights and woman entering the workplace, and the social narrative will again be controlled like it traditionally has.

For most I imagine that thought has parts of both comfort and dread.

Re:Heresy by ambrozk on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:30PM (#30980130)
I agree with most of what you've written but I don't think it's correct to think of social power having been "democratized." It seems more accurate to view the transformation we've seen as existing mostly at the top of society. Highly networked, social-media savvy college-educated elites have figured out how exert power on structures which were previously by other highly networked, college-educated elites.
Re:Heresy by nonrandomstring on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:24PM (#30979334)
> For most I imagine that thought has parts of both comfort and dread.

Yes. What we see as mob rule now may mature into something not unlike a real polis. But (see my recent comment on vigilante speeding cameras) technology may give us a civil arms race that just drives a wedge further down the middle.

Re:Heresy by Angostura on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:35PM (#30978744)
> Tacitus or Voltaire are variously credited with the notion that in any epoch, to know who is in power, ask who you may not criticise.

That’s an interesting, because I suppose at the moment that group would include all through have been historically or currently disadvantaged or discriminated against.

Today’s axiom, at least in liberal countries is ‘you can punch up, but not down’ somewhat different in totalitarian regimes.

Re:Heresy by orwin on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:09AM (#30988133)
> Tacitus or Voltaire are variously credited with the notion that in any epoch, to know who is in power, ask who you may not criticise.

Yeah, so the people in power currently are Ukrainians.

Look, i agree with the rest of your analysis, but this Tacitus sounds stupid (I am pretty sure Voltaire didn't write this). It's ignoring that most pamphlets and songs actually targeted people in power, historically (yeah, thinking about it, no way it's Voltaire). And people mostly take the dominated/wronged side.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:10PM (#30979876)
> Tacitus or Voltaire are variously credited with the notion that in any epoch, to know who is in power, ask who you may not criticise.

The actual source of this quote is a literal Nazi who was using this quote to claim that Jewish people run the world.

It is also a silly idea. It is considered rude to make fun of autistic people at work, but autistic people clearly aren't running the world through some secret cabal.

Re:Heresy by adolph on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:36PM (#30980863)
The political orientation of a thought is orthogonal to an honest evaluation of its accuracy. Call it a broken clock fallacy if you will. The statement was about criticism of the powerful, which is different from ridicule of the relatively weak.

The concept seems facially valid to me although incomplete in that it seems to have an assumption of singular power rather than many different power domains. Taken further, an hallmark of power, prestige, might be defined as those things which seem so natural that criticism would not occur to the larger portion of people.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:00PM (#30981110)
I'm not sure it was about criticism of the powerful. Jewish people don't run the world via a cabal. The original statement was arguing that because denying the Holocaust is socially disastrous and often illegal that Jewish people must therefore secretly be in charge of the levers of society.

Biden is currently one of the most powerful people on the entire planet. Yet people happily chant "f--- Joe Biden" in public, put stickers saying this on their cars, and put up signs on their lawns saying this.

Re:Heresy by adolph on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:13PM (#30983801)
>>>> . . . in any epoch, to know who is in power, ask who you may not criticise.

> I'm not sure it was about criticism of the powerful.

Are “the powerful” not “who is in power?” The comment of the g-g-g-parent did not mention the Holocaust or any other act of genocide. Unless there is some anti-Semitic hidden message the statement is nearly a banal platitude.

Also, your Biden analogy is as flat as your example of workplace ridicule of people affected by autism. A contrary example might be that the jeers of crowds are allowed for so long as they are not truly threatening or subversive. In the lead up to Biden’s election the news of his son’s laptop was suppressed. Effective criticism is not allowed.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:47AM (#30989535)
> Unless there is some anti-Semitic hidden message the statement is nearly a banal platitude.

There is. The original quote is from an actual literal Neo-Nazi who used this statement to argue that Jews secretly run the world because Holocaust denial is ostracized.

Re:Heresy by mwcampbell on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:38PM (#30981462)
An alternative interpretation of the apparent contradiction about Biden is that the U.S. President isn't actually all that powerful, but more of a figurehead.
Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:51PM (#30981597)
You are going to start racking up all sorts of interesting "apparent contradictions" if you go down this route. One would experience some pretty intense social ostracism if one loudly criticized interracial couples. But I find it hard to believe that interracial couples actually run things. Ditto orphans, the disabled, and yes, Jewish people.

Down this route is the precise conspiracy that the original Nazi who spoke these words was pushing.

The original idea here is that because denying the Holocaust is social suicide and illegal in some nations, Jewish people must secretly actually run the world.

Re:Heresy by mwcampbell on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:04PM (#30981705)
I agree with you on all of that. I just thought that the ability to criticize the U.S. President could be easily dismissed.
Re:Heresy by Banana699 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:11PM (#30980605)
>The actual source of this quote is a literal Nazi

This is called the Genetic Fallacy, it is completely irrelevant who said anything as long as that thing is true and/or useful. Nobody owns words. Aristotle supported slavery, you don't interrupt every logic lecture with "You know the source of those funny terms is a literal slavery supporter?" do you?.

>It is also a silly idea. It is considered rude to make fun of autistic people at work

This common retort completely misses the point, voltaire's rule of thumb is just that, it's a heuristic, an extremely good one for detecting and finding hegemonic ideologies, but not an algorithm. A necessary but not sufficient condition.

The kind of offense is also different, nobody rages at you and assembles a mob because you made fun of an autistic person, at most you will get a cold stare and get ignored. Voltaire was talking about a different kind entirely of "Not allowed", the familiar hysteria coming from the fanatically religious when you speak ill of their idols, he was probably speaking about the church, but the wisdom is just as relevant to the new religions.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:22PM (#30980716)
> This is called the Genetic Fallacy

I'm well aware of the Genetic Fallacy. The post I was responding to was falsely attributing the quote to other sources. "Hey, somebody else said that" is relevant information. Discussion of fallacies is also largely worthless in ordinary conversation since we aren't actually making formal deductive arguments. It is completely reasonable for people to reason through other means than pure deductive logic.

And further, my post did not stop there.

> voltaire's rule of thumb

It is not Voltaire's rule of thumb. We just discussed this.

Re:Heresy by Banana699 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:16PM (#30981251)
>The post I was responding to was falsely attributing the quote to other sources.

My point is that is irrelevant, it's the equivalent of correcting a misspelled comment in an open source repo and calling it a contribution, it is indeed, but a very minor one that makes little to no difference.

You also didn't clarify that the quote doesn't belong to voltaire, you simply stated that the other quote paraphrasing it is from a Nazi.

>"Hey, somebody else said that" is relevant information.

Only if you don't want to discuss the thing that is being said itself by vaguely referencing the heretic who said it and implying that discredits the thing being said in and of itself.

>Discussion of fallacies is also largely worthless in ordinary conversation since we aren't actually making formal deductive arguments

It's the exact opposite in fact. Fallacies are literally called "Informal Fallacies", they are coined to give names to common sloppy reasoning tactics and rhetorical tricks in informal everyday conversations and arguments.

They are worthless in formal deductive arguments because they are completely dependent on content and have no syntactical forms, unlike - say - deductive arguments like "If P Then Q, P, Therefore Q". Their usefulness is entirely in this kind of conversation where charged emotional words gets thrown left and right.

>And further, my post did not stop there.

Correct, it continues on to a naive misunderstanding of the quote.

>It is not Voltaire's rule of thumb.

I think you established that quite satisfactorily already, you can move on to other points.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:28PM (#30981376)
Ok. Let's discuss the "merits" of this quote then if you insist.

Which groups can you "not criticize" in the US? Or, at the very least, criticizing which groups will generate the most backlash? I have my own perspective on this list, but I'm very interested in hearing yours. And then I'm interested in hearing you describe how these groups in particular are "in power."

Re:Heresy by Banana699 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:14PM (#30981782)
>Which groups can you "not criticize" in the US?

I can never answer this question from a personal experience because I don't live in the US and never have, but I can give a noisy estimate from my experience of the (quite US-dominated) internet and global media ecosystem.

Here are groups you're not allowed to criticise on the internet without being held to much higher standards than most things :

- Gays

- Transgender people

- 'Progressive' ideas in general, which includes the above two as special cases but also things like feminism and racial minorities.

Those ideas are 'in power' in the sense that they are the semi-official ideologies of the public-facing institutional machinery of western countries: The EU and Euro-American news corporation will worry about the bigoted treatment of lgbt individuals even as an entire country of millions is threatened with an invasion, the UN has specialized bureaucratic organs for "Empowering Women" but not so for men, "Kill All Men" is a funny ironic joke you can make on twitter but "Kill All Women", or even the much milder "Good Morning I Hate Women", is a big bomb to blow anywhere, reddit admins - regardless of the subreddit - will routinely lock or delete any thread that even mentions that trans people are not the coolest thing since kittens were invented. I can go on and on.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:49PM (#30982071)
But the quote isn't about "ideas" being in power. It is about people. I think it is plain to see that gay people and transgender people are definitely not "in power" in the west in any special way. For somebody to believe this is to believe a wild conspiracy based in no facts whatsoever. And I think this is a pretty compelling argument for why the quote is horseshit.

Unless there is some actual secret shadow government operated by women, gay people, and transgender people, the existence of "Kill All Men" as a joke on Twitter is a rather intense indictment against the merits of the quote.

So in addition to being originally coined by a Nazi to argue that Jews secretly control the world, the quote is idiotic on its merits.

Re:Heresy by Banana699 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @07:12PM (#30982705)
>But the quote isn't about "ideas" being in power. It is about people.

False distinction, people are machines inhabited by ideas, just like how programs inhabit computing machines. Ideas can't be in power, just like programs can never actually be "ran". Both are electromagnetic patterns in the physical medium of some computational architecture (mammalian brains/Von Neumann processors), "Ideas In Power" was a metaphorical shorthand by me, what's in power are people inhabited by those ideas, and the obvious result is that they mount strong resistence to any opposition and make it quite costly to criticize or make fun of their ideas.

>I think it is plain to see that gay people and transgender people are definitely not "in power" in the west in any special way.

They are, in the sense that their identities and thought patterns motivate and emotionlly charge people in institutions ranging from the white house to mega corportations to do things they might have otherwise not done, sometimes to the detriment of the institutions.

Your implicit argument seems to be:

- for a person to be in power, he/she/it has to wear funny clothes and be referred to with funny titles.

That's a very naive view of how power works. The catholic pope in the middle ages was never directly in charge of more than a small principality's worth of land and people (although he did wear funny clothes and was referred to with funny titles), yet he had immense power that spelled the downfall of the byzantine empire, demarcated the whole world between 2 other empires, and ignited a series of civil wars that killed millions. That's because his "Ideas were in power", i.e. the papal way of thinking and typical thought patterns inhabited people of immense power and motivated and charged them to behave and say as the pope behaves and says.

Ideologies essentially assemble people believing in them into super-organism, just like an ant colony can be a force to be reckoned with while an individual ant is a trivial organism; In the same way, one can say that gays, transgender people and feminist women/men are in power but none of them - individually - necessarily holds any special power.

(Note the 'feminist' modifier on women, it's quite disingenuous to equate women with feminism, one is an ideology, the other is a natural subset of humans whose vast majority haven't even heard of the ideology or care enough about it's first world problems).

>Unless there is some actual secret shadow government operated by women, gay people, and transgender people

That's quite a funny cartoonish version of the argument that you have constructed for yourself right here, the "secret" and "shadow" modifiers also serve no meaningful role other than to evoke a general vague sense of ridicule.

It almost never works like that, when communism were in global supremacy in the 1950s and the 1960s it wasn't a secret shadow government that controlled the world behind the scenes, it was a bunch of (sometimes contradictory) ideas that inhabited various powerful people and motivated and charged millions to live and work and die. Communism was in power. You were allowed to criticize Stalin or Lenin in plenty of times and places, in fact in some of those times and places you were even suspect if you didn't criticize them, but you were never allowed to criticize the Ideas in power, which were all a variant of communism.

The quote never actually says that

- The people in power are a single monolithic entity that is omniscient and omnipotent

- The people you aren't allowed to criticize are the same as the people in power

Which seems to be 2 implicit assumptions you keep making. It's most obvious interpretation is "When there are disproportionate costs to criticizing some idea or group or lifestyle, that idea or group or lifestyle is that of people who have dominion over you in some way or another". This is almost tautologically true: People in power will not be pleased to see anyone criticizing something they believe in.

>the quote is idiotic on its merits

Not the quote, the peculiar interpretation of it you have, which seems almost constructed to be easily refuted. The natural interpretation is so obvious as to be trivially true, which is to be expected of an aphorism.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:10PM (#30983452)
> They are, in the sense that their identities and thought patterns motivate and emotionlly charge people in institutions ranging from the white house to mega corportations to do things they might have otherwise not done, sometimes to the detriment of the institutions.

This is an extremely strange definition of "in power." I donate a lot of money to the local food bank. This doesn't make it so that starving people are actually running my life.

Feel free to keep your conspiracies to yourself.

Re:Heresy by Banana699 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:52PM (#30983681)
>This is an extremely strange definition of "in power."

Is it? It's a rather straightforward one in my view, power is the ability to influence the real world. Do you have a simpler or more convincing definition?

>This doesn't make it so that starving people are actually running my life.

This is because donating your money is an entirely voluntary action to an inanimate object that only affects yourself. If you were donating the money of someone else, or if you were donating the time/work of someone else, then the starving people who benefit from those food banks would be indeed in power over you. They affect (through a complex indirect chain of cause and effect) the world so that you do things you have no good reason to do, that's power. But voluntarily donating is not like that, you have very good reasons to donate without being coerced, power only happens when you do things against your natural incentives, i.e. Coercion.

The actions against people criticising the "Sacred Cows" of western progressives are neither of the 3 things :

- They are non-voluntary as there is quite a bit of consensus-manufacturing and lobbying that those groups or groups affiliated to them engage in

- The actions are typically done to humans (firing, censoring,...) and affect a lot of people

Therefore, these Sacred Cow groups are actually in a lot of power, they bend the incentive landscape in their favor in a way that other groups do not. That's a very clear power differential.

>Feel free to keep your conspiracies to yourself.

I advise you to know the definition of words before using them. Conspiracies are unproven and unlikely non-falsiable stories about the world, the fact that you can't criticize the list of groups above is one you can trivially verify for yourself on any social media website.

Re:Heresy by kemayo on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:45PM (#30984004)
> This is called the Genetic Fallacy, it is completely irrelevant who said anything as long as that thing is true and/or useful. Nobody owns words.

Is it irrelevant, though? I mean, there's a reason you haven't edited your post to say "Kevin Strom, a noted white nationalist[1], is credited with". (Or even just "Kevin Strom is credited with", with no reference to his politics at all.)

Notably, you're employing a fallacy as well -- "Tacitus or Voltaire" functions as an appeal to authority here. These famous people said this, it must have merit. A resistance to correctly attributing the quote suggests that the mantle of authority is the point.

(I don't care about debate fallacies, really. I just like to bring up when people complaining about them are employing their own. Petty, I know.)

[1]: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/05/30/fac...

Re:Heresy by Banana699 on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:06AM (#30984536)
>Is it irrelevant, though

Yes, it's as irrelevant as Aristotle's opinions on slavery is to his work on formal logic. The words bear no evidence whatsoever of the author's opinions, therefore it's fallacious and irrelevant to bring them up.

>there's a reason you haven't edited your post to say

Correct, and that reason is that I don't care. I'm entirely ok with quoting a white nationalist, I have quoted worse human beings.

>Notably, you're employing a fallacy as well -- "Tacitus or Voltaire" functions as an appeal to authority here.

I think you're overreaching here a little bit to fit my words to a fallacy rather than the other way around. I don't care one bit who said the words, you can attribute them to whoever you like, go ahead and attribute them to Einstein or Ghandi, that won't increase or decrease their truth value. It's a tautologically true aphorism, anybody can say it and it would still ring true.

>A resistance to correctly attributing the quote

No such thing, I immediately conceded that point when it became clear to me it's a misattribution, the reason I haven't back-edited the comment is that my comment doesn't depend on it, you can substitute "X" or "Santa Claus" for "Voltaire" and you would still get a comprehensible argument that you can either side with or oppose.

>people complaining about them are employing their own

Eh, I wouldn't say your rather stretched interpretation of my words are evidence they are an appeal to authority, sounds to me like you really just wanted to use the words "Appeal To Authority" in a sentence.

Regardless, if the mention of Voltaire annoys you, remove it from your mental cache of the comment and I will defend every single word of the resulting argument, provided you didn't remove or add any other thing.

>I don't care about debate fallacies, really

You should, they are convenient names for extremely common and sometimes-involuntary logical shortcuts that people take all the time which make arguments and conversations blurrier and less fruitful. Me naming a fallacy in an argument doesn't automatically mean that argument is invalid, it just means the argument defender wants to hide something (possibly from themselves), it's not a gotcha to catch your opponent doing then declare victory, it's a "code review" tool to make conversations clearer, more honest and consequently better.

Re:Heresy by dibujante on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:41PM (#30981999)
It's also just a stupid idea. You "can't criticize" many groups of people who hold no real power. The quotation was devised solely to apply to criticizing "the Jews" (and by extension implying they "rule over you") and laundering it through Voltaire just puts the flakiest of intellectual veneers on top of this nonsense statement.
Re:Heresy by dibujante on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:01PM (#30979040)
They're credited with it but that quotation is actually from neo-Nazi Kevin Alfred Strom and has been repeatedly laundered through social media to seem like respectable intellectual rigor, instead of an attempt to legitimize the kinds of completely insane conspiracy ideology that is present on social media today.
Re:Heresy by eternalban on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:04PM (#30979080)
> Outrage is a homeless beast.

Well said and true.

> it is no longer power that metes out punishment, but the fanboi acolytes or loyal minor apparatchik.

Pretty sure this modality of power has been with us since ancient days. (The beast may be homeless but there is always a beast master.)

Re:Heresy by randomtwiddler on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:19PM (#30979275)
> Tacitus or Voltaire are variously credited with the notion that in any epoch, to know who is in power, ask who you may not criticise.

That doesn't work if/when a value claimed by those in power is to turn the other cheek. At least if it is followed, then this wouldn't be accurate.

Re:Heresy by Ma8ee on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:22PM (#30981320)
In 1985 you could say “homosexuality is a disease and all gay should be locked up” and you wouldn’t have to be too worried about your employment. Today you can say “I’m gay” and don’t have to worry about being fired for it. I like today’s freedom of expression better.
Re:Heresy by gedy on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:57PM (#30981643)
People like to bully on the outgroups, now as then. Same as ever.
Re:Heresy by _clhx on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:18PM (#30983151)
You do see the difference between saying gay people should die and being gay right? Lol
Re:Heresy by gedy on Monday April 11, 2022 @08:19PM (#30996983)
Of course, I'm commenting that "<some outgroup> needs to DIE" is always bad.
Re:Heresy by Ma8ee on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @03:50AM (#30999772)
Nah, "all Nazis need to die" isn't so bad (with the conventional western definition of Nazis of course, not the one that is used by Russia today).
Re:Heresy by Ma8ee on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:07AM (#30986338)
I like to see it like we went from bulling minorities to shunning assholes. It’s a bit concerning that you don’t see the difference.
Re:Heresy by goto11 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:17PM (#30981799)
Censorship is much more visible in modern social media because it happens after the publishing. Somebody publishes something, and then the platform reviews the material and decides to block it. In print media the filtering happened before material was published. Newspapers only print a tiny fraction of the "letters to the editor" they receive, but it doesn't feel like censorship.
Re:Heresy by mjburgess on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:52AM (#30978232)
The 90s was a strange ideological moment -- the eastern religion failed, so the western religion admitted pluralism within its own denominations. It was an interregnum in which the liberal democratic order was unchallenged.

It is, today, challenged from all sides. What PG et al. call "free speech" was just the peace of a political moment. In every other era "free speech" is a demand with costs; we should expect that to be the default.

Re:Heresy by analog31 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:51PM (#30979658)
Indeed, and the very concept of "heresy" has changed over the centuries, to the point where the analogy to Newton is probably meaningless. "Heresy" was considered to be an immediate mortal threat to the eternal life of the soul. It was not just a disagreement with social customs. It was the spiritual equivalent to yelling "fire" in a crowded theater, or driving a truck into a crowd.
Re:Heresy by ambrozk on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:31PM (#30980140)
Are you telling us that it was literally violence?
Re:Heresy by naniwaduni on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:21PM (#30982315)
When you believe in an eternal soul that can be harmed, there are harms that are worse than violence.
Re:Heresy by chmod600 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:12PM (#30983115)
Interestingly, there were 3 justices that were around for both the flag burning case and Citizen's United (money-is-speech case): Scalia, Kennedy, and Stevens.

Scalia and Kennedy were in the majority (broad speech rights) in both cases and Stevens was in the minority (narrower speech rights) in both cases.

So, I guess (loosely speaking) if fire is speech, then money is speech too.

Re:Heresy by ricardo81 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:51AM (#30978195)
True enough, recently my Scottish Parliament pardoned those condemned of witchcraft (and fwiw a lot of Scottish ex pats formed the US constitution)

I think a lot of the issue revolves around us celebrating our differences rather than trying to polarise them.

But clearly scientific evidence (ie lack of witchcraft) also play a part.

The vibe I get from the post is just that, being OK with people having a different point of view without having an adverse reaction. Maybe another component to it is the black box algorithms of major platforms that may magnify differences of opinion or 'filter bubbles' as it were.

Re:Heresy by fsckboy on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:41AM (#30985809)
you quote him: Anyone looking into the future in 1985 would have expected freedom of expression to continue to increase. Instead it has decreased.

and you state: Many people proclaim that "free speech is dead" and all of that, but it's still at an all-time high if you zoom out a bit.

It can't decrease and remain at an all time high. You are disagreeing with him, not finding a nuance.

Re:Heresy by Doxin on Monday April 11, 2022 @04:42AM (#30986178)
It can be decreasing currently, and yet increasing recently. Those aren't contradictory.
Re:Heresy by throwmeariver1 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:49AM (#30978176)
The problem with the whole free speech is dead argument is that it gets tangled into plain stupid lies. Flatearth, holocaust denial...
Re:Heresy by randrews on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:01PM (#30979042)
Conflating a valid point with a bunch of total-nonsense points in order to discredit it is an effective strategy.
[dead]
Re:Heresy by Beltalowda on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:02PM (#30978347)
I don't see how someone's year of birth is related, or important?

If anything, I find it valuable to see perspectives that fall outside of my own experience. I was born in 1985. I don't remember what the world was like in 1985, or 1975, but I'm eager to learn about it to see what we've gained since then, or maybe lost, to better guide the path we should take in the future.

Re:Heresy by xboxnolifes on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:12PM (#30979187)
> I don't see how someone's year of birth is related, or important?

It's related because people are incredibly biased toward liking things "as they were" when growing up. I'd be more impressed by accounts of people growing up in a time before the one they are praising.

Re:Heresy by Apocryphon on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:37PM (#30979490)
Personally, as someone who came of age during the Bush administration and the War on Terror, all of these cancel culture wars bore me because it’s all I’ve ever known. Since 2003 or so, I’ve never not seen American politics and civil society as a hyper-partisan wonderland of information bubbles and people shouting heresy.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30210730

Re:Heresy by dTal on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:26PM (#30980080)
Indeed; those complaining most loudly today about "cancel culture" were the first in line to "cancel" the Dixie Chicks all the way back in 2003.
Re:Heresy by alanlammiman on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:17PM (#30981258)
Regardless of whether one agrees, I had to smile at this, because it is simply a more formal way of saying 'OK, boomer'
Re:Heresy by alanlammiman on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:37PM (#30983963)
800+ comments on an article about cancel culture and this is the one that gets negative points. Well, ok boomers! LOL :)