News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heresy by amalcon on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:07PM (#30979857)
I like to point out the Sedition Act of 1918 here. About 100 years ago, a law that literally made it a crime to criticize the government was not only enacted, but upheld by the courts. Can you even imagine that today?

What people are finally noticing now is that non-government entities can also have negative impacts on free speech. They're not noticing because it just started -- e.g. lots of folks lost their jobs for vocally opposing the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq in the early 2000's -- but because they're on the receiving end for once. This could be a good thing in the end, by leading us to a more complete model of civil discourse, but it's going to be painful for a while before that even has a chance to happen.

Re:Heresy by ratww on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:11PM (#30980601)
> Can you even imagine that today?

Not in the countries I guess we both live, but in some authoritarian places, definitely, unfortunately. Your point still fully stands though!

Re:Heresy by amalcon on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:16PM (#30980657)
This is a great point, and I should've made it clear that I was only referring to democratic countries that profess to value free speech.
Re:Heresy by etherael on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:05PM (#30984135)
I can easily imagine such laws in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. They already exist in Australia. The consensual mass hallucination regarding those places is that they are democratic countries that profess to value free speech.

But of course, it is purely a hallucination.

Re:Heresy by incompatible on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:24PM (#30984255)
Is there a law in Australia the forbids criticizing the government? I haven't noticed any shortage of criticism lately.
[dead]
Re:Heresy by incompatible on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:36PM (#30984331)
Arrested for "incitement", admittedly a vague concept that the government can do a lot with, like "disturbing the peace". But you find that kind of thing in any country, Australia is nothing special.
Re:Heresy by etherael on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:45PM (#30984387)
It's worse than most places that aren't China tier if you simply observe what happened there over the past two years, but it's true that basically the entire world with very few exceptions to lesser or greater extent really draped themselves in shame over the same period. Australia was just by far the worst of a bad bunch.

https://thetruthiswhere.wordpress.com/2021/11/09/dan-andrews...

Re:Heresy by yesenadam on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @09:03PM (#31010069)
That is one of the most ridiculous articles I've ever read.[0] Maybe the most ridiculous. Please stop posting outrageous crap like that to HN, thank you. A conspiracy site and Alan Jones, as you've posted on this page, do not add value to HN. I notice almost all your comments on HN are edgy, flamebaitish political hot takes, maybe you would suit some other site better.

[0] e.g. "The Premier of the Australian state of Victoria, Daniel Andrews, has just tabled legislation in parliament which is possibly the most monstrous ever introduced into a country calling itself democratic. ...the legislation openly stamps him as a totalitarian psychopath. ...This is Australia 2021, not Germany 1935/36. Those who sneer at the comparison are deceiving themselves as the essentials are the same"...

Re:Heresy by yesenadam on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @09:19AM (#31002284)
The talking head in that video is Alan Jones, Australia's most notorious right-wing talk back radio host, or he was last time I checked. That's about as far as you can get in Australia from a reputable news source. His whole thing is stirring up ignorant lynch mobs by being inflammatory. Human flame bait.
Re:Heresy by otterley on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:59PM (#30981659)
I think most jurists would agree that the Sedition Act is dead for all practical purposes. Most modern First Amendment jurisprudence only started being written after the Vietnam War, commencing with Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 44 (1969), and the Sedition Act would be unlikely to survive scrutiny today.
Re:Heresy by voidfunc on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:51AM (#30984795)
The reality though is, SCOTUS can decide to trash precedent at-will once a case is in front of them. If you put political hacks into the SCOTUS and they decide the Sedition Act is legal then its suddenly back on the table.

This is the danger of an overly political SCOTUS.

Re:Heresy by adolph on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:10PM (#30980591)
Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:42PM (#30981497)
Notably, handing out pamphlets arguing against a war isn't especially likely to qualify for this law.
Re:Heresy by temp8964 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:27PM (#30981887)
> lots of folks lost their jobs for vocally opposing the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq in the early 2000's

I am not aware of this history. Is there any data or document? What kind of jobs, private? governmental? academic?

Re:Heresy by MisterBastahrd on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:11PM (#30983104)
Everyone crying about people being cancelled sure didn't have a lot of words to defend the Dixie Chicks when they were against the Iraq war.
Re:Heresy by cornel_io on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:08AM (#30984554)
Actually a whole lot of us did. There are dumbasses on both the right and the left constantly trying to forcefully silence people who they don't like, and there's a rather larger group of us in the center who have been screaming bloody fucking murder about it for over a decade now, but you all keep pretending that we're inconsistent and actually just Republicans (or libtards/groomers, if you're of the other persuasion). It's maddening.
Re:Heresy by hindsightbias on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:26AM (#30984674)
“rather larger group of us in the center who have been screaming bloody fucking murder about it for over a decade now”

Citation required.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/05/23/opinion/inter...

Re:Heresy by cornel_io on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:30AM (#30985022)
That article doesn't at all refute the fact that a ton of centrists have very reasonable beliefs and are loud about them. "Citation required" is a zero-content contribution, please go away.
Re:Heresy by rayiner on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:09PM (#30984155)
I, too, agree that progressives are moral busybodies like Bush-era evangelicals.
Re:Heresy by MisterBastahrd on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:18PM (#30984206)
Check out any state abortion laws lately? How about something called "teaching actual history?" And the best one "we didn't want to teach kids about gender differences, so now teachers are going to ignore gender entirely" in Florida.

But please, do go on about the "Bush-era evangelicals." I'm sure they've totally calmed down since then.

Re:Heresy by rayiner on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:27AM (#30988354)
You're confusing opposition to the left's overreach with evangelical resurgence.

> Check out any state abortion laws lately?

This mistakenly assumes that opposition to abortion is necessarily evangelical in nature. By requiring the availability of elective second trimester abortions, Roe mandates an abortion regime that extends significantly beyond what most people can stomach. Most Americans think elective abortions should be prohibited after the first trimester: https://apnews.com/article/only-on-ap-us-supreme-court-abort.... But highly secular countries like France, Denmark, and Finland also restrict abortions after the first trimester. Most of the developed world draws the line for elective abortions at "when the fetus has a face" and not viability like Roe does. So you will continue to see things like Mississippi's abortion law (which imposes a 15-week ban with exceptions for health of the mother and baby) regardless of the strength of the evangelical movement.

> How about something called "teaching actual history?" And the best one "we didn't want to teach kids about gender differences, so now teachers are going to ignore gender entirely" in Florida.

It's not only or even mostly evangelicals that are worked up about the effort to normalize folks like Robin Di Angelo and Ibram Kendi in schools, or to teach young children about sexuality.

On these issues, the left thinks it’s relitigating issues it previously won, but in reality they’re taking up again issues the far left lost in the 1970s: racial preferences, racial separatism, breaking down social notions of gender, etc.

Re:Heresy by MisterBastahrd on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:00AM (#30989733)
> You're confusing opposition to the left's overreach with evangelical resurgence.

No, I'm not. The opposition to abortion in the evangelical community didn't begin until Republicans bundled the issue with black civil rights and trickle down economics. Both Roe and her lawyer were Southern Baptists, and there were editorials published in Baptist and Evangelical periodicals affirming the decision as the right thing. Religious opposition to abortion rights should not extend to our laws. Oklahoma just passed a 6 week bill with no exceptions for rape, so please, spare me the hand-wringing.

> It's not only or even mostly evangelicals that are worked up about the effort to normalize folks like Robin Di Angelo and Ibram Kendi in schools, or to teach young children about sexuality.

You ignored the part about "teaching actual history," which includes teaching kids about the effects of slavery and Jim Crow and how that permanently damaged minorities because it might make little white minds evaluate the damage their ancestors did and how that continues to harm minorities today. That Florida bill had nothing to do with teaching kids about sexuality, and it backfired and will continue to do so. There is zero way to word those bills that will not result in malicious compliance because they are plainly meant to be discriminatory.

Re:Heresy by rayiner on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:30PM (#30991145)
> The opposition to abortion in the evangelical community didn't begin until Republicans bundled the issue with black civil rights and trickle down economics.

The opposition to abortion was an international phenomenon happening around the same time. Within a few years of Roe, high courts in Canada, Germany, Italy, and France heard abortion cases as well. All except Germany determined that it was a question for the legislature. Germany determined that legalized abortion violated the basic law. To this day, German, French, and Italian abortion laws contain several restrictions that Roe doesn’t permit, specifically limiting elective abortions to the first trimester. Those counties must be full of evangelical Baptists according to you.

Also, nice job projecting the abortion movement’s eugenics roots onto conservatives.

> In response to a question on access to abortion and restrictions on Medicaid coverage of the procedure, [Justice] Ginsburg said, "Frankly I had thought that at the time Roe [v. Wade] was decided, there was concern about population growth and particularly growth in populations that we don't want to have too many of. So that Roe was going to be then set up for Medicaid funding for abortion."

> You ignored the part about "teaching actual history,"

Virginia didn’t just vote for Glen Youngkin (including half of Asians, who are almost all in liberal northern Virginia where I grew up) because they oppose teaching “actual history.” It’s because Fairfax County paid Ibram Kendi $$$ to come lecture to teachers.

> which includes teaching kids about the effects of slavery and Jim Crow and how that permanently damaged minorities

That doesn’t sound like “history” but pseudoscience. Racist pseudoscience at that, conflating Black people with “minorities” and implying they are “permanently damaged.”

> because it might make little white minds evaluate the damage their ancestors did and how that continues to harm minorities today.

“Little white minds,” lol. Gee, I can’t imagine why people think you want to teach White Fragility and inherited guilt (https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/07/dehumanizi...) and that “actual history” is just pretext.

> That Florida bill had nothing to do with teaching kids about sexuality, and it backfired and will continue to do so.

The law is literally limited to “instruction” about “sexual orientation” and “gender identity.” Prior to fourth grade, it’s prohibited. After fourth grade, it must be “age appropriate.” If you think it’s just evangelicals that don’t teachers instructing their kids on human sexuality in third grade, you need more POC friends.

Re:Heresy by hindsightbias on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:16AM (#30984604)
I often wonder if anyone on HN remembers Bill Mahers first show…

Politically Incorrect was literally the name of that show, and it wasn’t cancelled by leftists.

Re:Heresy by adolph on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:55AM (#30989659)
Were the artists formerly known as Dixie Chicks cancelled or did their market fragment and they chose to focus on one segment? For some, is the notoriety of "cancellation" a welcome signal of authenticity and salience to consumers? For example Prince successfully used self-cancellation as a marketing rebirth during a legal dispute.

The Dixie Chicks are joining a growing list of brands, entertainers, and artists making changes in wake of the racial justice movement happening now. Like many, they "want to meet this moment" in history, which is why the country trio will go by The Chicks from this point forward.

https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/life/entertainment/a3297240...

Re:Heresy by wutbrodo on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:06AM (#30984535)
Gosh, this is utter nonsense. Pretty much every anti-woke person on the left was just as critical of illiberalism when the right was flexing its cultural muscles. Are you under the impression that Paul Graham was in support of post-9/11 restrictions on speech? Or that eg the comedians now complaining about cancel culture were totally cool with people losing their jobs for insufficient "patriotism"? For God's sake, Bill Maher lost his show under precisely the same norms that he criticizes now, except that the illiberalism at the time was right-coded.

Are you so unable to conceive of a person holding a principle that you need to create an alternate timeline to resolve the cognitive dissonance? It's always truly horrifying to be reminded that people like this exist.

Re:Heresy by temp8964 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @08:56PM (#30983379)
Yes. It’s exactly like MIT canceled Dorian Abbot.
Re:Heresy by MisterBastahrd on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:45PM (#30983636)
MIT didn't cancel Dorian Abbot, though.

He still gave a presentation, it just wasn't on his stupid "anti-vaxxers are just like Nazi Germany" nonsense that was beneath both him and the university.

Re:Heresy by deanCommie on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:49AM (#30984786)
I think the comparison you drew is interesting.

Restrictions to free speech used to be in place to protect the Most Powerful - the Kings (still do - in places where there are kings), The Party, even The Government (in places where democracy is but a sham)

In Western democratic nations, new restrictions to free speech are being considered to protect the Most Marginalized - the most weakest, most discriminated against, lowest represented members of society.

It is ludicrous to look at this movement and compare them like-for-like. There is no backsliding here, there is no slippery slope here. There is a very distinct difference between who is protected and who is exploited.

Re:Heresy by FerociousTimes on Monday April 11, 2022 @06:26AM (#30986807)
I still sense you advocating for coercive equity policies in your comment; i.e. redistribution of power from the slightly more fortunate to the slightly less fortunate but on a whim and flimsy excuses and without due process, because let's pretend for a moment that people at the very top; the one percenters would be affected by this cancel culture nonsense, it's always middle class people and every once in a while, a member of the upper middle class get devoured by the SJW monster and that's it.

This whole crusade is just a charade.

Re:Heresy by deanCommie on Monday April 11, 2022 @04:46PM (#30994755)
You sense incorrectly. I have no qualm with democratic institutions of power. (For some reason I have to explain to people on HN that a username with 'commie' in it does not mean I'm a communist)

As long as they're actually democratic. My qualm is with oligarchies and plutocracies. A capitalist system should allow for the wealthy and it is inevitable that wealth can be used to acquire power. But political systems need to be firewalled from this MUCH more than they are in society today.

The thread is about free speech, and my comment was solely focused on speech. I'm not a free speech absolutist in way that you or Paul Graham might be, because I don't believe words and speech is like physical violence. A bullet is egalitarian. It doesn't care who fires the gun or who it's hitting, it will still do the same damage whether it's fired by a billionaire at a homeless person, or the other way around. Words are not. Words need a medium. The medium's control is asymmetrical.

But regardless of what we think about asymmetrical implications of free speech, ultimately my point was that those who's free speech we are talking about protecting shifted 180 over the last century. Pretending that is irrelevant is naive. Is there a difference between a Russian Soldier killing a Ukrainian Soldier outside of Mariupol this week, and a Ukrainian soldier killing a Russian one? Of course there is. And so there is a difference between restricting the speech of a person to criticize the government, vs restricting the speech of a government to criticize a person.

P.S. Using "SJW" as a pejorative falls in the same category as using "woke" in that way. Mike Godwin himself (of Godwin's law) has the right take on it: https://twitter.com/sfmnemonic/status/1504687870006620163

Re:Heresy by sitkack on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:51PM (#30981021)
Re:Heresy by tomcam on Sunday April 10, 2022 @06:52PM (#30982547)
> I like to point out the Sedition Act of 1918 here. About 100 years ago, a law that literally made it a crime to criticize the government was not only enacted, but upheld by the courts. Can you even imagine that today?

Only in banana republics like the USA. The patriot act went quite far in that direction

Re:Heresy by rawTruthHurts on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:57AM (#30986630)
> Can you even imagine that today?

Try to give in UK an opinion regarding the State of Israel not matching the Pro-Israel lobyy diktat and you will find yourself in trouble. Ask Jackie Walker.

Re:Heresy by infiniteL0Op on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:52PM (#30980411)
Ask Thai citizens if they can imagine that. Or Russians.

In democracies, society has moved a bit into a direction where many harmless things said will trigger an upset in some very uptight people.

It's enforced socially rather than by the government. Back when you could not say things openly against governments, at least you could speak your mind on anything else.

Today, you can say whatever you want against the government, they are so far detached they don't care.

Free speech is a stupid political term, it has never truly existed an never will.

Re:Heresy by voakbasda on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:33PM (#30981416)
Freedom of speech is a principle that transcends political policies. In theory, it is a clear and unambiguous concept; in practice, governments ruin it with nearly arbitrary rules that run counter to that fundamental principle.
Re:Heresy by incompatible on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:32PM (#30984302)
There are plenty of exceptions to freedom of speech in countries I'm familiar with. Things like advocacy of terrorism, hate speech, threats, disturbing the peace, obscenity in public, blasphemy, pornography of certain kinds, providing financial advice without a license, leaking secrets, copyright.

Edit: fraud, incitement. Who knows how many others?