News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by nice_byte on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:27PM (#29321259)
i don't understand why the so-called "lab leak theory" of origin for sars-cov2 is treated as some sort of conspiracy theory. it is completely plausible, and things like this have happened in the past (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sverdlovsk_anthrax_leak), not due to malice but due to incompetence.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by kipchak on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:07PM (#29321858)
Pretty much everyone involved stands to lose from it proving to be true that a lab leak occurred. China looks bad, the CDC/US looks bad, researchers look bad, EcoHealth Alliance looks bad[1], the lancelet looks bad.[2] Heck even politifact and factcheck.org reported the idea as debunked for the first year or so, and Facebook for around the same time took down content with that angle.[3] It would also likely result in a backlash against interest in GOF research in general.

The only group that stands to benefit are those who benefit by making those groups look bad, who will also unfortunately exaggerate their claims for greater effect.

[1]https://www.bmj.com/content/374/bmj.n1656

[2]https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

[3]https://www.politico.com/news/2021/05/26/facebook-ban-covid-...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by sauwan on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:53PM (#29322478)
I was with you up to here:

>The only group that stands to benefit are those who benefit by making those groups look bad

I mean, collectively as humans we stand to benefit from knowing what happened so we can make more informed cost benefit decisions in the future about conducting risky research (if that's what happened).

There's going to be quite a bit more externalizing risk while "privatizing" (even if it's nation states) gains in the future with bio-engineering, so these conversations should be had.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by edgyquant on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:57PM (#29323419)
I want to disagree with you and say it doesn’t matter, but you’re definitely right hiding bad situations is in the playbook of the authoritarian and should have no place in our society.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by csee on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:38PM (#29323891)
It matters in the same way that understanding why a plane crashed matters. If you can't figure out why a plane crashed then you can't improve flight safety much.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by inciampati on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:20PM (#29324288)
This is a helpful apolitical perspective. We need to improve social safety. But the pandemic is different in scope. It's not that the plane crashed. Rather, our technology "may have" allowed us to accidentally make a pandemic. It's as if no plane crash had ever occurred before, and now we made one happen. If we understand what really happened, we might see this event as bringing us into a new era in our evolution. The fact that we can imagine this to be the case even while firmly denying it to be what happened it's a firm sign that the times have changed.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by peteradio on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @09:09AM (#29330091)
I'm curious if you would expand on your last two sentences. They sound interesting but I don't quite grasp it.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by wokwokwok on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:32PM (#29325536)
That’s because it’s a mechanical device owned by a single large international company.

You can’t “engineer away” a virus.

The airplane analogy only makes sense of you say the result of investigation is to apply international sanctions against countries who continue to manufacture unsafe aircraft and fly them domestically…

…but, you have a) arguably no business telling them what to do in their own country and b) how are you even going to know, since those aircraft never visit your country?

Ie. yeah, great concept, but it’s so disparate from what we’re actually talking about it’s meaningless in this context.

It won’t fix things, or make things better knowing where it came from.

The only wins will be ideological.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Thorrez on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:31AM (#29327186)
>You can’t “engineer away” a virus.

If the virus is caused by risky research, you can stop doing risky research.

>arguably no business telling them what to do in their own country

Aren't there international standards for dealing with viruses? Also, some of the research in the Wuhan lab was funded by the US. So the US did have business telling them what to do in some cases regardless of international standards.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by DocTomoe on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @03:17AM (#29327917)
The genie is out of that bottle - the research has been done, and can be replicated by less honest actors. Under these circumstances, continuing this kind of research to understand how to combat viruses created by rouge actors might be the right thing to do.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by csee on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:23AM (#29327657)
By figuring out how it leaked, you can fix gaps in lab safety processes.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by darkerside on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:09PM (#29323571)
We have always been at war with Eurasia
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by optimalsolver on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:36PM (#29326034)
*Eastasia.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by darkerside on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:25AM (#29329297)
I'm crushed that it is too late to ninja edit my comment
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by colpabar on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:03PM (#29322607)
> I mean, collectively as humans we stand to benefit from knowing what happened so we can make more informed cost benefit decisions in the future about conducting risky research (if that's what happened).

You're not wrong, but I think what you're missing is that the risky research was funded (in part) by the us federal government, and no one voted for that in the first place. So even if we were all enlightened, what could we change? So many people still don't even know that there was a lab studying coronaviruses in wuhan.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by edgyquant on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:58PM (#29323434)
People voted for it indirectly and if they knew that the virus originated because of that (I’m not saying it did, I have no idea) it would allow them to pressure politicians in insuring it never happens again.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by csee on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:39PM (#29323910)
They voted for it via representative democracy. If it comes out that there was a leak and politicians still want to fund this kind of thing, then they'll get less votes.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by richardw on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:49PM (#29323296)
You could highlight all the research being conducted in future so more stakeholders can weigh in on the risks. You can raise the requirements for conducting such research, or in extreme cases prevent it from being done. The assumption that “nothing can be done” has to be the worst approach, given the multitude of alternatives. Simply trying increases the odds that improvements are found.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by darkerside on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:40PM (#29323911)
Nobody votes for most things in a representative democracy. I don't think you'd be surprised to know that bad press is effective at changing behavior.

The notable exception is Donald Trump, whose superpower is that shame causes him to double down. He's the kryptonite for a representative democracy. Just because of that, I'll never understand why people voted him in.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by baby on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:06PM (#29322663)
Transparency is the most important tool in becoming a better society.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by kipchak on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:55PM (#29323392)
I definitely agree that there's good reason to know what actually happened, if for nothing else for the sake of long term trust in institutions. Instead of group, something more like organizations and institutions with the ability to investigate and hold people accountable would probably be more accurate.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by InvertedRhodium on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:45PM (#29323254)
That's such a diffuse benefit that you'd need to compare it to other things that benefit literally everyone alive - for example, the environment which sustains our existence - to determine how effective a motivator that is.

It's not looking great.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by marcosdumay on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:44PM (#29323249)
> I mean, collectively as humans we stand to benefit from knowing what happened so we can make more informed cost benefit decisions in the future about conducting risky research (if that's what happened).

I really don't think so. Knowing what actually happened makes no difference. What is important is knowing what problems exist and what can possibly happen as a consequence of them.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by nickff on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:47PM (#29323280)
>"I really don't think so. Knowing what actually happened makes no difference. What is important is knowing what problems exist and what can possibly happen as a consequence of them."

Doing a root cause analysis is useful, because it provides you with information about certain modes of failure and their causes. Ignoring past failures, and using a 'tabula rasa' approach will deprive decision-makers of valuable information, and lead to repeating past errors.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by nbardy on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:54PM (#29322506)
This is a spot on description. It's also the sad truth of why our institutions are decaying.

They have become heavily biased towards self-preservation over function.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by whatshisface on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:00PM (#29322572)
The real question is why self-preservation cannot best be obtained through functioning.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by thereddaikon on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:48PM (#29323290)
because organizations are made up of people and people are imperfect. Eventually someone is bound to screw up large enough to put an organization's survival at risk. And the natural response by other members to try and suppress knowledge to ensure survival. That of course just makes things worse.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by iechoz6H on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:53PM (#29323349)
Isn't that because there is insufficient jeopardy for covering up a mistake?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by whatshisface on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:38PM (#29323898)
Good leaders are merciful to sins confessed and decisive towards sins discovered.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by edgyquant on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:59PM (#29323442)
People don’t like to change and a lot of the time for institutions to continue existing they need a radical shift in their approach or outlook.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by richardw on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:40PM (#29323192)
What looks bad is having millions of people die and not learning how to prevent it in future. This should be a blameless post-mortem. Shit went wrong, this is how we fix it. Truth and reconciliation, not hide-behind-feels. The people who want to apportion blame grow stronger from all this cat and mouse.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by xyzzy123 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:15PM (#29324781)
Not easy to achieve though.

If one or more parties are "responsible" then public sentiment (amplified by social media) will bring the pitchforks.

That translates to political support and basically guarantees the election or increased support for certain types of politicians and response, which in turn will impact diplomacy.

It would take some supreme social engineering to get society at large to accept the idea of a blameless post mortem. It's really not part of the broader cultural lexicon. Even companies struggle and they are much smaller and simpler systems.

Responsibility and liability are intrinsically linked in the public mind.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by inter_netuser on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:02PM (#29326199)
and why shouldn't the responsible be liable?

Reparations are OK for some things, but not for causing worldwide pandemics?

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by davisoneee on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:53AM (#29328447)
..the point of the grandparent post is that if we emphasise _liability_, it's less likely we'll get any information.

This is a common understanding in industries dealing with safety. If you want to _punish_, focus on blame. If you want to focus on _helping ensure the problem doesn't happen again_, remove the threat of blame.

Also, mentioning reparations brings up ideas of ...current US political discussion... and is likely to polarise this discussion. Please try and keep this productive.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by inter_netuser on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:33PM (#29336488)
We are WAAAAY past the industry problem. It's not a faulty Boeing or improperly constructed nuclear plant.

This a problem of global proportions. We've had protracted wars over much smaller things in the past.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by coolspot on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:14PM (#29323626)
Governments likely have it in form of top-secret intelligence reports for top decision makers.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by RC_ITR on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:52PM (#29325173)
>It would also likely result in a backlash against interest in GOF research in general.

If general GOF research caused this pandemic, then maybe there should be a backlash against it. Lot's of science doesn't happen because it's too dangerous to human lives, even if the theoretical benefits outweigh the costs.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by christkv on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:35PM (#29324419)
The other problem is the damage they have done to the institutions and the publics trust. Even if it's a natural event they all have to go. Who can trust them to tell the truth the next time. They have burned those bridges.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by jimmytucson on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:38PM (#29323161)
> The only group that stands to benefit are those who benefit by making those groups look bad, who will also unfortunately exaggerate their claims for greater effect.

Does this also hold for Root Cause Analysis?

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by kipchak on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:29PM (#29323807)
Assuming there was a lab leak, the root cause to me would seem to be organizations overestimating the benefit from GOF research compared to the risks. Why that happened is a bit harder to answer. A couple potential explanations are a leak was actually a one in a million chance (this seems unlikely given past issues)[1], there is some extreme benefit we just haven't seen yet (also seems somewhat unlikely) or organizations are likely to accept risks if it means everyone gets to keep their jobs and grants keep coming in.

How to fix that problem is difficult, as gain of function research is complicated and obscure enough to be off the radar of most people until something goes wrong, so questioning scientific orthodoxy is somewhat impossible for the average person. I'm not sure what can be done about it, other than those with respectable credentials advocating for transparency and and regular people maintaining a healthy sense of curiosity.

[1]https://www.hsdl.org/?abstract&did=837679

[deleted]
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by mistermann on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:33PM (#29323076)
Or so logic would suggest, but observation suggest otherwise, at least for ~mainstream/normal people.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by inter_netuser on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:01PM (#29326190)
If nobody can benefit from truth being public - there is no truth.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by encryptluks2 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:31AM (#29327702)
The only group that benefits are those who want to know the truth, and that is dangerous cause the truth will make the liars look bad? I mean, no offense but that sounds like something a sociopath would say.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by kipchak on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @11:34AM (#29331786)
I wouldn't say the truth itself is dangerous, but it is dangerous to the organizations involved. Those who benefit from the truth such as you or I do not have the ability to uncover it, and the institutions that could have the ability to do so don't benefit from doing so. There's no impartial oversight group outside of regular citizens, who unfortunately lack the ability to hold their institutions to account for a variety of reasons. The (potential) truth is dangerous to the parties involved, so they have an incentive not to investigate or ignore the possibility. They might even give some not completely self serving explanations/rationalizations if asked, such as keeping the peace or not causing a panic.

If for example there was a leak, and it was purely the fault of one country, I would imagine there would be vigorous finger pointing.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by encryptluks2 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:03PM (#29335118)
> If for example there was a leak, and it was purely the fault of one country, I would imagine there would be vigorous finger pointing.

I imagine by the same account, if a person is murdered, it was purely the fault of one murderer, that there would be vigorous finger pointing.

However, if they don't come forward and citizens, media, and prosecutors have to determine who killed someone; not only should they be required to pay significantly more if they have assets, but the punishment should be harsher because they deliberately withheld the truth causing their victims families more suffering.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by jdjdjrj on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:53PM (#29322480)
Politifact and factcheck get plenty of things wrong so I wouldn't say "heck even" to that. These websites are a joke.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by kipchak on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:58PM (#29325243)
I agree they leave a lot to be desired, but they're both at least perceived as somewhat reliable and trustworthy - factcheck is used by Facebook for example. I'm sure lots of people have pointed to those sites as proof, unfortunately.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Fomite on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:25PM (#29325949)
A couple reasons, from the perspective of an infectious disease epidemiologist who isn't particularly a fan of Gain of Function studies:

1) "The lab leak theory" is actually a collection of theories, from the fairly reasonable possibility of an accidental release as part of a lab accident down to a engineered Chinese bioweapon. What any individual means by "lab leak" tends to be whatever is serving their political purposes as the time, and they borrow evidence from each other in a way that's really flawed, etc.

2) There's a lot of personal attacks built into the evidence - whether or not Ralph Baric is a likable guy, for example, fed into a lot of whether or not his lab was "involved".

3) A lot of the advocates for the lab leak hypothesis don't come from epidemiology/public health/virology, but from the intelligence community, the tech world, etc. who tended to reach for "Oh, it's obviously this..." and who reacted poorly to the idea that it might not be that simple and straightforward. Both sides of that exchange burned a lot of good will with each other early on enough that the engagement has, I think, spiraled somewhere not particularly productive.

4) It got coopted by crackpots and conspiracy theorists, as well as those interested in abdicating their own role in the pandemic.

5) The biggest reason, in my mind, is that it is a "fast" solution that gets a lot of press, and for which the alternative explanation - the one that has been true for the last two coronavirus outbreaks - is something that will take the better part of decades to resolve, if it ever does. It's also by and large not relevant for the current state of the pandemic. That creates the sense that there's a whole mountain of evidence behind it, when in reality it's a theory that is going to be rather difficult and expensive to falsify, one way or the other.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by mjfl on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:40PM (#29321458)
The people smart enough to conduct investigations into this know that the only outcomes will be harsher restrictions on lab research stateside without much consequences for China, and thus they are unmotivated.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by siva7 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:46PM (#29321547)
This is the unfortunate truth on the psychological side. There is simply no motivation to push the lab leak theory for those scientists involved. Not for the chinese because that would be their death sentence and not for the outside world because funding and restrictions will get a lot harsher. On the other side everyone can live with the other theories because they imply more research funding and no one has to die for political reasons.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Supermancho on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:16PM (#29322802)
> Not for the chinese because that would be their death sentence

I don't believe it would affect "the Chinese" at all, other than spending time to ladle out a new dose of conditioning for their own public.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by meibo on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:33PM (#29323077)
Maybe they meant the death sentence for the team of scientists working on coronavirus research at the Wuhan virology lab, that surely must have had to make some kind of statement to the Chinese state if it did exist. I’m sure they have the greatest interest to leave the rest of the country and world in the dark.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by nextos on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:06PM (#29321851)
Well, but we certainly need to do something about this. SARS-CoV-2 is relatively mild compared to other potential lab leaks.

It has nothing to do with taking an anti China stance, as this has happened elsewhere.

It would also be advisable to investigate the early stages of the pandemic as clearly many parties were deliberately hiding information. This led to avoidable casualties and, ultimately, the whole pandemic might have been possible to contain.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by nickff on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:20PM (#29322038)
>"It has nothing to do with taking an anti China stance, as this has happened elsewhere."

This is a classic collective action problem, not some nationalistic thing (though some will believe or pretend it is). Each specific lab wants relatively lax rules and no consequences for failures, but everyone else needs higher standards.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Ambolia on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:05PM (#29321827)
We should have leashed very short both politicians and virologists after this disaster, but the blame game has been shifted very skillfully at every point, from anybody worrying about a pandemic, to anybody not worrying about it, to your neighbor who wears the mask wrong, to three guys in the middle of desert who didn't take the vaccine, while nobody with power ever answers about anything.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by yostrovs on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:28PM (#29324937)
As an example, notice how much scrutiny Aaron Rodgers or Joe Rogan received, compared with the fact that we've kept the US/Canadian border closed to car traffic while allowing flights in. What seems like an incoherent policy that affects millions gets next to zero attention. But what Joe Rogan does to his own body, now that we should all get the details and a full explanation about.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by bewaretheirs on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:24PM (#29323743)
Marburg (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1967_Marburg_virus_outbreak_in...) is another notable lab leak.

Might be a better match in some ways as it was a previously unknown pathogen, from a previously unknown family of viruses, isolated only after several lab workers got sick.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dls2016 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:50PM (#29324556)
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC416634/

“ The World Health Organization has confirmed that breaches of safety procedures on at least two occasions at one of Beijing's top virology laboratories were the probable cause of the outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) there last month, which infected nine people, one of whom died.”

It even happened with a coronavirus in China before!

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by asdff on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:39PM (#29321443)
Because there is a whole contingent of people who take the argument in bad faith for xenophobic reasons and there is not a lot of solid evidence in this case to argue in good faith beyond "theoretically possible."
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by umanwizard on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:43PM (#29321490)
Whether unsavory people believe in something has zero bearing on whether it's true.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by fragmede on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:13PM (#29322767)
Unfortunately, the unsavory people don't live in a vacuum separate from us. If it ends up being true, then it's true, and whomever is President at the time will do what they can do. If it ends up being false, however, the people (generally Asian Americans) who have been maimed, or killed by those unsavory people in the meanwhile don't get an undo. Continued discussion with no new real evidence, like the situation with Hillary Clinton's emails, is propaganda, pure and simple.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by boppo1 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:35PM (#29323115)
I dunno, I always though the lab leak theory was less racist than laying blame at the feet of the dietary habits of low-income chinese.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by coupdejarnac on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:22PM (#29324300)
It's almost as if everyone has forgotten that the wet market/eating strange things hypothesis was concocted by the Chinese government.

You guys should see the propaganda du jour- the Chinese government claims covid comes from deer in North America.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by fragmede on Thursday November 25, 2021 @03:09PM (#29344561)
it's almost as if they want us to hate each other! Hmm....
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by systemvoltage on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:52PM (#29323334)
Which was also based on equal amounts of flaky evidence guided by the people that didn't want to associate themselves to the acting President at the time and his party. These people left truth behind, butchered science, eroded trust and sacrificed their integrity. In tough times, our leadership didn't stand up for the truth.

I think the society would be far better off if we completely cut out politics and make it super boring. Relentless push to put behind this tribal warfare and serve the truth, however uncomfortable it may be.

Lex Fridman's interview with the NIH director was eye-opening. They're acting like children. Of course, you can't see how unpopular it was because Youtube has hidden the dislikes. The cocktail of Big Tech + ruling party is equally as scary to me as Trumpism.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by refurb on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:28PM (#29324929)
So you’re saying we should hide the truth because if we don’t people may get hurt?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by fragmede on Thursday November 25, 2021 @03:17PM (#29344621)
No. And I write as much. There's not really any new new evidence so further discussion is stoking the fires of nationalism.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Loughla on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:50PM (#29321618)
That's sort of covered by the second half, though

>and there is not a lot of solid evidence in this case to argue in good faith beyond "theoretically possible."

Also, bad faith arguments tend to be posited on the fact that they are incorrect. Otherwise they would just be arguments.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:31PM (#29325529)
It bears on the signal-to-noise ratio.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by himinlomax on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:55PM (#29323381)
And hiding something because it's believed by bad people is going to make those bad people look like heroes when they turn out to have been right in this particular instance.

If the goal is to make racists look good, that's a great plan.

Personally I rate the plausibility of a lab leak at over 90%. Quick back of the envelope: there is one such lab in China, where there are about 100 cities with over 1 million inhabitants. The probability that a pandemic randomly appeared in any one of them is therefore 1%, or put another way, there is a 99% probability that it appeared in Wuhan because of a link to the lab. There has been no new information in the past two years to change that assessment.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by drran on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:15AM (#29328246)
90% of what?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by himinlomax on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @05:08AM (#29328506)
I mean I'd wager good money on it being the cause with the assumption of winning 9 out of 10 times.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by sobkas on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:41PM (#29322327)
I don't know how to think about this article https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/10/nih-admits-funding-r...

It looks bad

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by rsynnott on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:40PM (#29321469)
Well, there's not much evidence for it. And, honestly, there's arguably an aspect of wishful thinking to it. "This was the result of a leak" is much less scary than "this just showed up", because in the leak scenario, the next one probably _could_ be stopped through better procedures, whereas the entirely natural scenario... well, there are some precautions that can be taken, but good luck preventing exiting new viruses from showing up from time to time.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by torstenvl on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:57PM (#29321726)
Closest known relatives of virus behind COVID-19 found in Laos

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02596-2

The NIAID claimed that it didn't fund research into BANAL-52 and similar. "the closest known relatives of SARS-CoV-2 . . . were not studied under the EcoHealth Alliance grant"

https://www.niaid.nih.gov/diseases-conditions/coronavirus-ba...

However, that was recently revealed to be extremely unlikely, since bat coronavirus samples were in fact collected from Laos, where BANAL-52 was located. Even more suspiciously, the Laos genetic samples disappeared from the WIV database in late 2019.

https://wap.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/wu...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by postalrat on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:23PM (#29322069)
So what's the harm in accepting it was a lab leak? You might end up with better procedures?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Fomite on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:29PM (#29325976)
That depends on what you decide to do about it.

1) I've seen people call for a ban on research at all on BSL-3+ pathogens.

2) If you "accept that it was a lab leak" you are implicitly accepting that it was not a natural event - which is going to cause you to focus more on long-tailed, low-probability events like lab leaks, and less on zoonotic transmission events.

Which if you're wrong would be a serious problem.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:02PM (#29322601)
Better for whom? Certainly not for the labs. It's far better for the labs to draw their own conclusions from the leak, privately, at their own pace. Also, there's a significant financial disincentive: funding for gain of function research will be severely impacted by recognizing the lab leak as the most plausible explanation.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by inciampati on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:24PM (#29324315)
Right now I'd conclude that you can accidentally release things from labs with virtually no consequences. Just make sure that a similar virus exists naturally somewhere on the same continent, don't share any internal records, don't let your staff talk to the press, and you have plausible deniability.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by MilnerRoute on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:11PM (#29323600)
> ...good luck preventing exiting new viruses from showing up from time to time.

But even with a "natural origin," there are things that could be done. I've heard it said that the real Chinese cover-up in that scenario is the widespread trading of wild animals (with one wild animal vendor even travelling from Wuhan to other markets which China had insisted only sold frozen food and kitchenware).

https://news.yahoo.com/virologist-suggests-coronavirus-origi...

You still have the same problem in the end: a "lack of transparency" (if not downright dishonesty) from the Chinese government. And also, an obvious avenue for reforming the dangers that helped spread the 2020 pandemic -- which is not being explored because of difficulties in even establishing the facts of the initial outbreak.

I honestly don't know why this idea -- this possibility, this scenario -- isn't getting equal consideration.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dehrmann on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:47PM (#29326745)
> there's not much evidence for it

The fact that the first(?) major outbreak was in a city with a major virus research lab that researches coronaviruses is pretty strong circumstantial evidence. China's "nothing to see here" handling of it was also suspicious.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by elif on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:48PM (#29323989)
NYT treating it like a conspiracy theory is consistent with their editorial deference to official government narratives.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by p49k on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @03:06AM (#29327854)
NYT and others were reluctant to talk about the lab leak theory because Trump put them in an impossible position by constantly stirring up racial tensions regarding COVID. His actions led to real violence against Asian Americans and promoting the lab leak would have furthered it.

We could have easily been able to have an open conversation about the lab leak possibility if we had proper leadership at the time.

The first thing Bush did after 9/11 was go on TV and essentially say to everyone: “hey, don’t be racist towards Muslim Americans because of this attack; they are fellow Americans and have nothing to do with this” and it was largely effective.

(Not that I'm praising Bush as a president, but this specific act was an instance of good leadership)

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by zionic on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:33PM (#29322225)
Also the emails saying things like "this could do to virology what chernobyl did to nuclear science".

They know their cushy careers and research grants are gone if they normalize the lab leak.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by throwawaygh on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:22PM (#29322911)
> They know their cushy careers and research grants are gone if they normalize the lab leak.

These sorts of comments on HN are always fascinating to me.

Scientific researchers make $20K/yr for 6 years of their 20s, often working 60 hour - 80 hour weeks. If they are successful, around the age of 30 they will then make between $40K and $60K in a temporary, term-limited position (post-doc). This might repeat several times -- each more stressful than the last -- until they land a permanent job. Still working like dogs the whole time, btw. That final permanent job, which very few will ever actually get, probably pays between $60K and $100K. A very lucky few among the lucky few might make up to $200K by the time they turn 40, but most will never surpass $150K in their lives.

My undergrad mentees all make $160K+ as 22 year olds, often get to $300K pretty quickly, and will max out in the >$500K range some time in their 30s.

Software folks accusing life scientists of getting fat off of research grant money is really something else.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by chipotle_coyote on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:56PM (#29324073)
I've often found that when people take a "follow the money, man" position on an argument, they are not in fact following the money. e.g., the arguments I used to see against anthropogenic global warming based on essentially the same idea you're pushing back on -- that it was a fraud perpetrated by climate scientists so they'd keep raking in the donations and grants. When I inquired as to why "follow the money" wouldn't in fact suggest far greater skepticism of oil companies in the debate, I never got much of a response.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Fomite on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:07PM (#29325812)
This.

In the lab where I did my postdoc, the folks who went on to work for Amazon, Rackspace and Facebook are doing way better than those of us who went to work for universities, the CDC, etc. monetarily.

I have, what is for an academic a great job, and it pales in comparison to what I could make if I retooled for industry.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dekhn on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:57PM (#29326162)
Heck, I left academia for industry and ended up publishing fewer, but better and more cited papers. It was the first time I was finally given freedom to explore an idea, significant capital, and management support for my ideas (thank you bill c, alan e and urs h).

I'm 10 years closer to retirement as well, able to own a house in the bay area, etc etc. However, I'm quite aware few who go into industry were given the level of research freedom I was.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Noumenon72 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:29PM (#29325509)
Your analysis should start with the people who got the final permanent job, as those are the ones whose careers are at risk. And your comparison of a "cushy career" should be compared to the median American, who earns $36K, not the extreme outliers you mentor. $60K to $100K for high-status intellectual work is something most people would cling onto.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by throwawaygh on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @03:31PM (#29334771)
> Your analysis should start with the people who got the final permanent job

LOL. I was being generous to you be doing otherwise.

Faculty running successful large wet labs at R1s could jump to the private sector and make millions/yr minimum. Those people are the equivalent of a Director in the tech world. (Or, at the very very least, a Staff/Principal. But really more like Director/VP).

Look at what faculty who run large DARPA-funded labs in CS make when they jump to industry. They usually enter as either Principal/Staff or more commonly as Director. Those are very high six / low 7 figure positions. It's comparable in biotech.

To be perhaps excessively blunt, you have no fucking clue who you're talking about.

> should be compared to the median American, who earns $36K

WTF? Why are we comparing STEM PhDs to the median American?

The average virologist has a STEM undergraduate degree, a PhD, significant additional training, knows their way around complicated lab equipment, has experience designing/debugging complicated experiments, and is usually not such a half-bad programmer either.

(And, again, those are the losers. The average successful PI has all of that plus is leading a group of 10-20 employees in complicated R&D. Possibly also has an MD.)

Even the losers could easily find jobs that leverage those skills or mildly retool to get a high-class software job. In either case, they would earn much more than $36K in any number of industries. Because they have significant experience and training. Unlike the median American.

> not the extreme outliers you mentor.

My mentees are not extreme outliers. They come from a no-name university with an unexceptional CS program. $160K is not an outlier total comp in tech. It's pretty darn normal. National statistics say that the average Software Eng salary is $110K. Salary. Not Comp. Salary. Throw in typical stock/bonus and you get to $160K pretty easily.

But even that $110K number is a shitload more than the $20K virology phd candidates are paid (often for 60-80 hours of lab work each week).

My undergrad mentees are a much better group to compare STEM PhDs against than this "median American" thing you're suggesting:

1. In some cases it's a direct comparison. Many non-CS STEM PhDs are at least as qualified for entry-level software jobs as CS undergrads from unexceptional places. Or can be in very short order. Lots of lab work these days involves significant programming. All lab work involves building a the skills and mindset that make for excellent debugging. And soft engs with domain expertise are valuable.

2. Software isn't the only industry that pays well; the biotech industry also pays quite well. The sorts of people working in virology weblabs are almost certainly able to get WAAY better paying jobs at Biogen or Amgen or whatever.

3. Lots of virologists are MD/PhDs. I don't have to tell you that MDs make more than $35K/yr, right?

> $60K to $100K for high-status intellectual work is something most people would cling onto.

Sure. But -- and this is the point -- it's NOT a good monetary or social status outcome for the people who actually fucking QUALIFY for those jobs. Which, again, isn't the "median American".

Literally no one working on NIH grants is maximizing their earning potential. If you can't concede this point, then you're choosing willful ignorance and there's not much point in having a conversation.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by inter_netuser on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:22PM (#29326312)
People in academia are smart enough, they made that choice voluntarily and nobody held a gun to their head.

It's a voluntary trade-off for lower pay to work in the field you want.

There is a difference between churning out code you really hate for 500k/yr, and doing what you are interested in for 80/10/150k. The vast majority people in software aren't aching to reinvent the wheel, but in a new js framework every year, they just do it for the money.

Research grant money is still money, even if the academics decide to take a trade-off others don't.

How would you like to NEVER receive grant money again? Gonna bite the hand that feeds you?

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by throwawaygh on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:13PM (#29335234)
> There is a difference between churning out code you really hate for 500k/yr, and doing what you are interested in for 80/10/150k.

LOL, no.

Industry is way better than academia on the qualitative stuff.

First, STEM PhDs who qualify for R1 faculty positions but who instead go into industry are not doing shit with javascript frameworks. What kind of insane company would waste such specific and highly developed skills on that kind of nonsense?

Second, people running wet labs aren't "doing what they want". They're doing contract work for funding agencies. In terms of both freedom and enjoyment, it's much closer to a mid-level manager body-shop position at Accenture than a "life of mind". FAANG IC life is luxurious by comparison.

My friends in academia are constantly tweaking/justifying what they work on. I do what I want, make 5x-10x more, and have way better resources/staff.

And that's all before giving a 2 hour lecture to 500 kids while wearing an N-95, then going home and giving the same lecture to another 200 kinds on zoom.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by inter_netuser on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:17PM (#29336354)
I've exaggerated only a little about js frameworks. I've had a PhD from Geoff Hintons group do manual QA once for a few months. Far worse things occur on the regular, nobody really cares about highly theoretical concerns such as "waste of potential" in practice.

Some FAANGs even have a policy of hiring talent just to deny it to competition. Figure out what they'll do after you hire them, no real planning on that part.

However, the larger point remains: people in science labs for some reason stay in the lab. Why? Maybe they just like complaining or suffering? Maybe so, but if they want to - they can quit any time, but they for some reason remain.

I had a friend from Fermilab who left to do quant finance on wallst, only to return to physics because he found finance boring, even though very well paid. Much better paid than FAANG.

You just happen to like what you are working on at FAANG. Not everyone does, and plenty burn out and leave the field entirely.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by m0zg on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:25PM (#29325945)
Fauci is the highest-paid US government employee. That's even ignoring the fact that he will make tens of millions of dollars after he ceases to be a government employee. The previous head of the FDA, Gottlieb is with Pfizer already. The guy who replaced him, Stephen Hahn, is with Moderna now. I find it bizzarre how people instantly forgot how profoundly evil US Big Pharma was considered even a couple of years ago. These people will let diabetics die for a buck, and yet I'm now supposed to treat them as the second coming of Jesus, and pretend they can do no wrong.

And I can guarantee you Daszak and a bunch of other hangers on make a lot more than "20K". In fact 20K might not be enough to get him out of bed in the morning.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by throwawaygh on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:13PM (#29335240)
> Fauci is the highest-paid US government employee.

...And? What's your point?

As a Chief Medical Officer at a pharma company, which he more than qualifies for, he's be making 10+ million/year. E.g., darryl sleep, the CMO of Amgen, made $20 million last year. You make this point yourself.

So Fauci is greedy because he.... didn't sell out? This take is so astoundingly ignorant that it's hard to believe it's made in good faith.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by m0zg on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @09:45PM (#29337717)
My point is, until we ban the immediate popping up of these figureheads on Big Pharma boards (something Trump tried and failed to do, and Biden won't even try), there's a massive conflict of interest, and everything they say and do should be regarded with a lot of suspicion. Pay them twice as much, but then say "you can't take money from the companies you're charged with regulating, directly or otherwise, for 5 years or you go to jail". The situation we have right now is just dumb and corrupt AF across the board. Fauci generated somewhere near half a trillion dollars of revenue for Pfizer just on COVID alone, and there's nothing whatsoever in US law preventing him from collecting a de-facto deferred bribe after he leaves NIAID. Happens to every single one of these figureheads, without any exceptions. I strongly suspect that's why they take these relatively unexciting jobs in the first place - for the potential to earn something more "exciting" that they wouldn't be able to get otherwise.

If you think they have your interests in mind, I suggest you reconsider. At best, your interests might sometimes align with those of their true masters. But if they don't, who gives a shit - Pfizer has legal immunity now.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by throwawaygh on Thursday November 25, 2021 @12:30PM (#29343197)
I largely agree that moving between gov't and private sector should be illegal or at least highly constrained, particularly in leadership or decision-making positions. But I also think you're unserious and insincere.

> Pay them twice as much, but then say "you can't take money from the companies you're charged with regulating, directly or otherwise, for 5 years or you go to jail"... Happens to every single one of these figureheads, without any exceptions.

You know how I can tell you're an unserious? You're criticizing Fauci for doing exactly what you want -- staying a well-but-not-unfairly-paid civil servant for his entire career. If Fauci was going to cash out, he could have done so decades ago. He's been at the top for a long time.

Which, BTW, is FAR more common than not. The people you're describing are not the median or normal outcome.

I don't think you have thought seriously about your criticism here, and I don't think you're commenting on this issue in good faith.

Have a good Thanksgiving.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by MilnerRoute on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:59PM (#29323448)
> ...the so-called "lab leak theory" of origin for sars-cov2

That isn't what this article is about.

I thought the article actually did a real public service by moving the discussion beyond whether Covid did or didn't emerge from the Wuhan market. Because either way, it's much much more important to say, "how could we, in the future, prevent the scenario of a lab leak from happening."

It keeps the discussion focused on what's important.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by mackal on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:20PM (#29323694)
I think part of the push back from the lab leak theory is that it's often accompanied by lab created and leaked. I'm far from an expert, but from what I understand, there are 0 signs it was lab created. Now isolated from the wild in a lab and then leaked is still considered possible, but they just don't know.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Nasrudith on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:17PM (#29326603)
It is trope-y enough to lend some suspicion. That is most conspiracy theories are about some sort of "reassuring" narrative that it takes evil people who you already expect to create big problems. As opposed to the world being a chaotic uncontrolled and uncontrollable place. That isn't hard disproof of course but it is a resemblance to other conspiracy theories.

The lab leak theor(y/ies) (is a/ are) "the hoofprints may have come from zebras" sort of situation - possible but not the most likely in absense of other evidence.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by hoseja on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:56AM (#29328462)
You're near a watering hole in southern Africa.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by k4c9x on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:15PM (#29323643)
It never really was. Reasonable conversations were being had, just not on polarized platforms. People's knee-jerk reactions to downvoting and "cancelling" every thing that mentioned it, in good faith or bad, last year was a direct response to the powers-that-were choosing the "China did it (maybe on purpose)" narrative to misdirect peoples anger and frustration.

If those same people would have said things like "obviously, it's _possible_ it was leaked from a lab, we're going to work on finding that out and let you know what we find as we do. In the mean time, here's what we're going to do about the immediate problems we're facing..." and ended it there, there wouldn't have been any backlash. That's what going on now, and that's why this post (good or bad, I can't say, I can't access it) wasn't flagged into oblivion the second it hit the front page.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by UnFleshedOne on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:25PM (#29323753)
When one slightly orange tinted guy can effectively ban discussion of any topic on all platforms by vaguely mentioning it, the problem is not that guy, it is everybody else.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by musicale on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:07PM (#29325811)
> It never really was. Reasonable conversations were being had, just not on polarized platforms

Does "polarized platforms" include the Washington Post, the New York Times, and The Lancet?

https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/media/the-media-cal...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by TaylorAlexander on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:35PM (#29323861)
I think to some extent our media has developed an attitude towards inconvenient ideas that they are conspiracies. They can't discuss stuff like that without emphasizing how totally not true they are. I am not saying it is or isn't true but that the media will tend to suggest inconvenient stuff is not true.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by cryptonector on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:10PM (#29323576)
Malice is also completely plausible. Biowarfare is like chemical and nuclear warfare, it's not new, it has been used before, and it probably will be used again.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by darkerside on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:00PM (#29324110)
Hanlon's Razor says, never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.

In this case, the malice explanation demands stupidity because it was released in their own city. Not sure what Hanlon would say about that.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by notahacker on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:44PM (#29324508)
Not to mention the stupidity of developing what would surely be the least useful bioweapon in history (most people of fighting age get mild and brief symptoms or no symptoms, but it's infectious enough to get back to your own population and kill similar proportions of your own vulnerable before you figure out how to deal with it)
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by hoseja on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:50AM (#29328434)
Hanlon's Razor is only applicable to individuals IMO.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by GuB-42 on Friday November 26, 2021 @05:53AM (#29349105)
I guess you never worked in a big company...

When everyone thinks the other guy is responsible for something and no one really is, when promotion is mainly determined by office politics, when departments that should work together compete with each other, you get levels of stupidity that is difficult to achieve by an individual.

Government entities tend to be even worse. At least companies have a clear goal they can always refer to: profit. Governments follow the whims of the political ideas of the moment.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by cryptonector on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:41AM (#29327230)
The topic was what is plausible.

> In this case, the malice explanation demands stupidity because it was released in their own city.

Lenin said that "if for the sake of Communism it is necessary for us to destroy 9/10ths of the people, we must not hesitate". Tito killed 1% of his country's population. Stalin killed or starved 20 million. Mao killed or starved 60 million. Pol Pot killed or starved 25% of his country's population.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by cardosof on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:55PM (#29323384)
I don't understand why lab leak isn't, like, the first or most important investigative line. It's just a matter of asking and checking - thoroughly - every person and every machine involved with the lab in that timeframe. After all, "the disease is the same name as the lab!" [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSfejgwbDQ8

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by ayngg on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:57PM (#29324075)
iirc it is because it heavily implicates both Peter Daszak, who was the head of the UN investigation of the Lab Leak theory, who orchestrated the Lancet letter denouncing the Lab Leak theory, who has now been shown to have conducted gain of function research on bat coronaviruses at the WIV, and Fauci who provided funding for this through Daszak's EcoHeath Alliance and NHAID after there was some sort of restriction on that kind of research stateside. On top of that China is completely uncooperative with the effort and wouldn't provide any evidence to implicate themselves.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by gennarro on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:29PM (#29321295)
Presumably people are being more careful now. Would like to see some sort of news or legislation about this but I’m sure it’s unlikely.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dylan604 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:34PM (#29321368)
And what kind of legislation would tickle your fancy? Intentional release is already legislated against. How do you legislate the prevention of accidents? Are you specifically talking about disclosure? I can get on board with that, but I'd be shocked if there's not already legislation around that.

Now, the crux, whatever legislation you come up with, how does that apply to a foreign country?

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by merpnderp on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:16PM (#29321988)
Well for starters, the reason a lot of this research was pushed to China was congress had grown tired of finding ways to punish the CDC for lab leaks and mistakes here in the US. It was only recently that the CDC had been allowed to restart a lot of its more dangerous research. So how about the US stop funding dangerous research regardless of where it is at?

Either the lab leak was true and this was a self-inflicted wound, or it was highly suspicious and uselessly dangerous research, as it didn't help us stop the pandemic.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dylan604 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:15PM (#29322790)
But in very weird round about way, it did allow us to see that mRNA technology is viable. So, happy little accident? Apologies to Bob.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by nsxwolf on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:42PM (#29323217)
I used to think Mission:Impossible 2 was ridiculous, now it's one of my favorites.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by tombert on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:45PM (#29321528)
I know basically nothing about foreign policy at all, but just in the "tombert thought experiment" land I'm going to give my "asshole opinion" [1].

-----------

> Now, the crux, whatever legislation you come up with, how does that apply to a foreign country?

Conceivably couldn't we do some kind of trade agreement/embargo on countries that don't follow a minimum level of disclosure/safety protocol? E.g. if country A is shown to have covered up a massive lab leak, we impose some kind of tariff on them for N days.

Obviously there are no easy solutions to problems like this, but I think that would be the place I start, because obviously US law doesn't really apply to places outside of the US; the only thing we could do (at least the only thing that I could think of) that's even close to punitive enforcement would be to apply leverage.

[1] "Opinions are like assholes; everyone's got one and most of them stink"

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dylan604 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:06PM (#29321850)
>Conceivably couldn't we do some kind of trade agreement/embargo

Imagine, if you will, a scenario where one country is manufacturing such a large percentage of products so that an embargo would cause massive disruptions to pretty much everyone everywhere. Now imagine that country being the suspect in a situation where the punishment is that very embargo. What do you do?

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by lelanthran on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:35PM (#29323863)
> And what kind of legislation would tickle your fancy? Intentional release is already legislated against. How do you legislate the prevention of accidents?

That's a ridiculous line of reasoning: legislation helps mitigate accidents all the time.

Pilots don't want their bird to fall out of the sky, and yet legislation around pilot training, practices and certification limited the number of accidents.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dylan604 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:37AM (#29330992)
That same logic also applies to automobiles. You must be licensed to drive, yet accidents happen daily/hourly accross the country. Fatal accidents are frequent. Laws will not save you 100% of the time. Your logic is flawed on the ridiculous side.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by lelanthran on Thursday November 25, 2021 @06:09AM (#29340297)
> That same logic also applies to automobiles. You must be licensed to drive, yet accidents happen daily/hourly accross the country. Fatal accidents are frequent. Laws will not save you 100% of the time. Your logic is flawed on the ridiculous side.

It sounds like you're claiming that removing the requirement for drivers licenses would not change the percentage of accidents per driver. Are you?

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by redog on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:38PM (#29321428)
> Presumably people are being more careful now

Probably so, but just like hollywood and guns.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by OwlsParlay on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:49PM (#29321608)
It's plausible, sure, but it'll never be proven, especially at this distance.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by mcculley on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:59PM (#29322560)
Also the U.S. Army lost control of some anthrax in 2001: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_anthrax_attacks
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by sterlind on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:07PM (#29322665)
that whole saga was so fascinating. the culprit ended up (likely) being one of the scientists involved, with the motive of justifying funding into anthrax research. because of the incredibly low mutation rate of anthrax, they couldn't identify the strain by DNA testing.

they had to do new science to fingerprint strains based on the quantities of different populations in the samples vs. the bottles - an investigation the culprit himself was involved in. as they uncovered the flask responsible and the very limited number of people who could get their hands on it, the attacker killed himself.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by bediger4000 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:58PM (#29324085)
The pushback on the lab leak theory happens because proponents of the lab leak theory are pushing that theory in bad faith. If there's a lab leak, then they can excuse mis-handling of the USA COVID response.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by secondcoming on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:25PM (#29324888)
What about the mishandling that occurred elsewhere in the world? Trump was only president of America.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by bediger4000 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:27PM (#29325501)
What about it? The excuse-seekers aren't looking to wave away Sweden's mishandling, for example.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Gunax on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:25PM (#29323754)
Sorry to grand-stand a bit, but I think the narrative is missing the point of the 'lab leak theory'.

The 'lab leak' is actually a bit of a misnomer. What they really mean is that it was created/modified/bred intentionally, versus just being discovered in some bat cave or whatever.

It's not the leaking per se that is what worries people--it's the idea that this has a human-created origin. It's an experiment or weapon which was accidentally leaked to the world.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by bufferoverflow on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:09PM (#29323570)
Not only it is plausible, it's very very likely. What are the odds that a lab that works on gain of function of Corona viruses is the exact place where the epidemic started?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by chipotle_coyote on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:50PM (#29324008)
The "exact place" the epidemic was discovered is in Wuhan, which is also where the lab is. That's a correlation, and clearly worth investigating, but it's not in and of itself proof.

I was originally dismissive of the "lab leak hypothesis", in no small part because of how quickly it got caught up in politics. I'm less so now, but I do think it's important to remember that when we ask "how likely is it that a novel coronavirus epidemic would start in a city that also has a laboratory working with novel coronaviruses and it just be a coincidence," the answer may be "not very" if the city with the laboratory is the size of, say, Frederick, Maryland (78,000), but "maybe more than you think" if it's the size of New York City (8.8M).

The lab leak idea bears further investigation, but "authorities have been too dismissive of that" shouldn't lead us to assume "well, it was obviously a lab leak."

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Someone on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:40PM (#29325054)
Also: how many laboratories working with novel coronaviruses are there in the world? How concentrated are they?

I don’t know the answer, but it could well be that a significant fraction of the population of China (or the USA) lives in a city with such a lab, making it not too unlikely that the first patient will be found in such a city.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by RC_ITR on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:58PM (#29325251)
Wikipedia has a list of all the biosafety level 4 facilities.

The answer is around 30 active sites that deal with threats as serious as the Wuhan facility. Of those, less than half work on viruses, and even fewer do GOF work.

So not that many.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosafety_level#Biosafety_leve...

EDIT: and to address your implication, China has 2 such facilities, Wuhan and Harbin (a metro area of 10mn)

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Fomite on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:31PM (#29325993)
One note:

"Where the epidemic was first detected" and "Where the epidemic started" are not the same thing.

Especially given the relative prevalence of mild disease in COVID-19 cases.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by api on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:50PM (#29322434)
Everyone I've seen discussing it treats it as possible. The "conspiracy theory" part comes in when people claim or speak as if it's proven when it absolutely is not. There is no smoking gun evidence for it, but it can't be ruled out either.

That in itself is kind of scary though. It means a lab leak could happen silently and we may never correctly attribute it.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by jrm4 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:27AM (#29327167)
Add to this how fabricated the "wet-market" theory just feels. Perhaps it may be a viable theory, but it smells like such BS, the kind of bad-but-effective theory you know you could get away with thanks to classic "ooh weird foreigner food racism." No one's going to stop to ask, uh, why NOW?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by corinroyal on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:17AM (#29329230)
Doesn't seem fabricated to me. Zoonotic disease transmission is the norm. Add population growth, rampant development encroaching on habitats, stresses and migrations due to climate disaster, and the "why now?" seems pretty obvious.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by beervirus on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:36PM (#29323874)
There are some thoughts you just aren’t allowed to think, lest you be labeled a trump-supporting nazi racist.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by wwweston on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:46PM (#29321565)
Because it's almost inherently conspiracy fodder, true or not.

It tickles the part of human psychology that looks for threat agents, rather than just threats.

Lots of us here on the more analytical side might have trouble understanding that fully, especially if we relate to Fauci's early 2020 statements which more or less amount to "it doesn't really matter which plausible origin turns out to be the case, either way the task in front of us is to figure out how to mitigate the damage and address the virus."

It could have been a lab leak. It could have been (and now looks more likely to have been [0][1]) natural spillover from increasing contact with zoonotic reservoirs. What's the difference?

The answer to that question on a practical level is re-thinking safety protocols for related research (and perhaps a conversation about the risks of conducting viral research vs the risks of viral ignorance).

On a less practical level, though, the answer is that it prompts inhabiting a narrative where they key issue is human threat agents.

The irony is that many of the people who choose that as the most important thing to pay attention seem slower to consider how human threat agents might use that narrative.

[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2021/11/18/coronavirus... [1] https://www.science.org/content/article/why-many-scientists-...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by zimbatm on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:41PM (#29322322)
Imagine if a policeman was saying the same thing about a crime; why investigate, finding the culprit is only conspiracy fodder, let's only take care of the victims.

Not investigating, and hiding the truth is what gives room for conspiracies to grow.

Also how can we better understand and prevent pandemics whithout understanding where they come from. Wasn't the coronavirus research lab founded on that premise?

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by akavel on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:06PM (#29323545)
I don't find the parallel good. Trying to invent a better one, I thought I'd say the coronavirus situation is IMO more like a question of whether, say, some particular volcano's explosion was natural, or human-induced.

As such, one can either focus on generally being more prepared against volcano explosions, or focus on trying to find a person among volcano researchers and tourists who may have done something to tickle the volcano to explode.

I mean, it's sure also not a perfect analogy; but how I see it, focusing on preparedness and handling of a situation that does happen naturally from time to time for sure, sounds to me like a sensible choice to focus effort into. With that said, totally, if there's some possibility it might have been human-induced, it makes sense to try and track and prevent it in the future; thing is, me personally, and I would risk theorizing that also many other people, am strongly afraid of such approach too quickly and too easily turning into a witch-hunt, anti-XYZ propaganda, and stirring hate by unscrupulous people - with scapegoating seemingly socially much easier to turn towards, than tiresome and "boring" epidemologic preparedness and discipline.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by czzr on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:39PM (#29323905)
A better analogy is a forest fire - perhaps a human triggered it, maybe it was lightening. Whichever caused this specific fire, you cannot build a fire prevention strategy solely around stopping people lighting fires.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by echelon on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:54PM (#29321678)
> Because it's almost inherently conspiracy fodder, true or not.

No it's not! Reasonably minded persons consider this entirely plausible.

The way the conversation is being actively steered away from this topic is concerning.

> It could have been a lab leak. It could have been (and now looks more likely to have been [0][1]) natural spillover from increasing contact with zoonotic reservoirs. What's the difference?

There's a huge difference. Each scenario has different lessons to learn, culpability, etc.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by wwweston on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:10PM (#29321902)
> No it's not! Reasonably minded persons consider this entirely plausible.

I didn't say it was implausible. In fact, I have at least one sentence in my comment that acknowledges it is plausible to entertain. It doesn't appear to be plausible as a conclusion (see the two articles I linked, which do include sources who initially wanted to explore the lab leak theory), but it was plausible enough as a hypothesis.

What I said is that even if it is the truth, it evokes conspiracy-oriented thinking in a specific way, and elaborated on the dynamic.

> Each scenario has different lessons to learn, culpability, etc.

"Culpability" -- thank you for reinforcing my point about human threat agents. And also regarding "lessons to learn", or as I put it, managing risks in viral research vs the risks of not doing viral research... which of course is a conversation that goes on anyway.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by krinchan on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:52PM (#29323338)
I have to agree. The desperation to “blame China” seems to be driven by people with fantasies about going to war with China. Not even economic war with China beyond current tensions is possible without completely wrecking the economy in ways that will take all of us but the Bezos of the world down. Very little of this seems grounded in reality or good faith desire to know the truth of the matter.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dylan604 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:14PM (#29321964)
>There's a huge difference. Each scenario has different lessons to learn, culpability, etc.

Perspective matters. Yes, learning to not have it happen again is an ideal thing. However, from Fauci's point of view at the time and his role, the how/why absolutely didn't matter as he stated.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by sleepysysadmin on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:53PM (#29321657)
>i don't understand why the so-called "lab leak theory" of origin for sars-cov2 is treated as some sort of conspiracy theory. it is completely plausible, and things like this have happened in the past (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sverdlovsk_anthrax_leak), not due to malice but due to incompetence.

It's remarkable how quickly they settled on bats and everything but this was misinformation that would get you banned from various american tech companies.

It's also remarkable how quickly they moved to shutdown many discussions. The lab leak only months earlier from Canada where a chinese national shipped viruses to wuhan. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/chinese-researcher-e...

There's no evidence of coronavirus being involved at all with the canadian lady, but they sure did call it conspiracy theory and shutdown talks quick.

Throw this in context of a pissing match with China and Canada. https://www.cnn.com/2021/09/26/china/meng-wanzhou-china-arri... and China in return arresting and putting Canada diplomats on death row.

I think lots of answers came along from fauci's emails. All of these are not coincidences and China is probably not the source of covid. Hence why there was such a quick reaction to blame china.

Blame Canada!

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by __turbobrew__ on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:22AM (#29327144)
> where a chinese national shipped viruses to wuhan

No where in the linked article does it say that Dr. Xiangguo Qiu shipped viruses to Wuhan.

NMLs lips have been sealed and there was never a reason given why they were dismissed. Going as far as saying that they were shipping viruses to wuhan is baseless speculation.

A more recent article from CBC had more up to date details than the article you linked: https://www.google.ca/amp/s/www.cbc.ca/amp/1.6090188

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by sleepysysadmin on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:22AM (#29329265)
>No where in the linked article does it say that Dr. Xiangguo Qiu shipped viruses to Wuhan.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/canadian-scientist-s...

>All of this has led to conspiracy theories linking the novel coronavirus responsible for COVID-19, Canada's microbiology lab, and the lab in Wuhan.

There's no evidence that coronavirus was involved with this lady.

>NMLs lips have been sealed and there was never a reason given why they were dismissed. Going as far as saying that they were shipping viruses to wuhan is baseless speculation.

Like, Wuhan is certainly involved. It's possible coronavirus was already at wuhan and they used these canadian viruses for the 'gain of function' stuff. Oh it's much better than that. Those government officials have outright defied orders requiring them to disclose this information. Even better, we all know how strong unions and such are. They came out originally fighting for this lady and then suddenly they stopped altogether. No fight at all.

And where did this lady go? She has been missing...

Even better? Early on in covid Indian universities looked at the covid make up and found that it wasn't a natural virus. A natural virus would have been spitting out many new variants early on. They made some predictions about where those gain of function points would have been from. But then the censors came along and shut them down.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by __turbobrew__ on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @05:36PM (#29335976)
Ah I didn’t see the other article about her sending viruses to Wuhan. That is a really bad look especially after she was forcibly removed for unspeakable reasons. The look is even worse after she disappeared off the face of the earth. I’m sure CSIS has had many eyes on her for some time.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by whywhywhywhy on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:42AM (#29329403)
Because it was useful politically for the media to treat it that way. They had one goal and this was something that needed to be done to achieve that goal.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by seventytwo on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:41PM (#29325601)
Yeah… all hypotheses are “completely plausible” until they’re not.

Plausibility is a starting point, not an answer.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dekhn on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:59PM (#29326170)
no, the set of all hypotheses taken together form a distribution (determined by the prior probability). For example, if you proposed that space aliens delivered COVID to us, I would say that is lower probability than any lab leak because we have zero evidence for space aliens, and it's certainly not required to explain anything about COVID that we've observed.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by seventytwo on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @08:59PM (#29337480)
Entirely pedantic and missing my point.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by bedhead on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:54PM (#29323375)
Because political ideals. The left treats this as a conspiracy because:

(1) Trump initially blamed COVID on China and the ethos of the left is that Trump isn't ever allowed to be right, and "resist" means unconditionally doing the opposite. So once Trump said it, half the country unplugged their brains.

(2) It's no fun to blame a lab in Wuhan when the left could instead blame DeSantis/Republicans/Unvaxxed.

(3) The US is kinda wimpy about a real fight over this, regardless of who is in office. Xi would tell Biden (or whoever) to pound sand if the US ever really tried investigating this and seeking some sort of retribution. Again, the path of least resistance is to stick one's head in the sand and find a convenient scapegoat like Joe Rogan or whatever.

(4) Too many people have already definitively declared it impossible so they're pot committed to their position even if it's wrong, no different than mask efficacy (zero). There have been a couple issues where one side went all-in so there's no reversal or even slight walking back because the repetitional risk is too high.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by himinlomax on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:04PM (#29323507)
I'm pretty sure there was a conspiracy. Not a conspiracy to create a pandemic, but a conspiracy to hide an accident due to incompetence. Not all conspiracies are myths, just consider Watergate: there was a conspiracy to hide Nixon's shenanigans. The only difference is that one happened in a dictatorship while the other happened in a democracy with a free press.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by bedhead on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:08PM (#29323567)
Oh I agree, at a bare minimum there's nothing even remotely wacky about the lab leak theory. I'm just explaining why half the country has counterintuitively decided to brand it as lunatic fringe conspiracy rather than it being self-evidently plausible if not likely.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by downWidOutaFite on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:38PM (#29326713)
Well I'm guessing that because of your political ideals you're committed to the wrong position that masks are ineffective so studies like this won't convince you, https://www.bmj.com/content/375/bmj-2021-068302
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by bedhead on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @09:21AM (#29330195)
No, it's my commitment to objective analysis and not bizarre herd behavior combined with religious/cult undertones that led me to this conclusion.

I always love when someone posts like one single "study" that almost always doesn't even qualify as amateur hour (eg data mining) and thinks it's some sort of mic drop, as if there aren't 25 disconfirming studies or data points for every one thing saying masks have even a faint amount of efficacy.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by downWidOutaFite on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:13PM (#29333905)
The link was to a rigorous meta-analysis in one of the top medical journals of several studies with combined n=389k that concluded that masks showed a 53% reduction in covid-19 incidence.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dekhn on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:05PM (#29326219)
it's too bad this was downvoted because it's probably the best explanation.

I'm not totally sure about 3, my guess is that we have collected far more useful intelligence that our agencies have released, but nothing sufficient to make a geopolitical claim about China, and the cost of being wrong with such an accusation is huge.

[dead]
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by knownjorbist on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:02PM (#29324126)
The irony in this statement is palpable. You're so obviously ready to confirm your priors that you'll actively go out of your way to avoid other plausible explanations.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dekhn on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:06PM (#29326229)
I'm a democrat and I definitely think a lot of left-leaning scientists really made themselves look like idiots by saying that claiming China had a lab leak was "racist". It was always a reasonable (IE, not impossible or even extremely unlikely) hypothesis, and only some of the people who suggested it were doing so out of racial hatred for China.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by alexvoda on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:31PM (#29323822)
Because people get polarized and are incapable of nuance.

It's important to remember what some of the lab leak theories have said:

- that it is a engineered bioweapon

- that it is genetically altered to contain parts of HIV

- that it was intentionally released during the 2019 military games

Once in a camp it is difficult to accept nuance.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by freyir on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:26PM (#29325954)
We can’t talk about the lab leak theory for the same reason a third of the country refuses to get vaccinated: it became a politicized issue somewhere along the way, at which point people’s brains turn off and their emotions and tribalism take over.
[dead]
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by edgyquant on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:45PM (#29321540)
I don’t think so. Not that I believe it’s impossible it originated in China from a lab accident, I think you should have proof before claiming that but okay. But when people started claiming it came from China they weren’t doing so off of hard evidence or being rational. They were doing so because of xenophobia and nationalist pride and it’s just easier to blame these problems on an other than it is to believe shit happens.

Now this year there have been more scientific minded people who have proposed a pretty rational set of circumstances that it could have came from China, but

1. These circumstances are not proven and are little more than a hunch of what could be, and

2. The type of people who push the “Chinavirus” rhetoric aren’t those same scientific minds thinking rationally and instead they’ve had their opinion slightly verified by more recent understanding (again, slightly, because there is no proof.)

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by systemvoltage on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:15PM (#29323635)
> But when people started claiming it came from China they weren’t doing so off of hard evidence or being rational.

Here is the NIH director being asked uncomfortable questions and being completely irrational: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mRZE-SJShkE

This comment summarizes it better than I can:

> I'm curious why Dr. Collins believes so strongly that a lab leak was unlikely, that is his reasoning, given that he states SARS had leaked on at least a couple different occasions resulting in some deaths, yet was quickly contained. The non-answer to this question, or his reference to an investigation into the intermediary, which he admits has not yet been found and will take much time, are insufficient to address the elephant in the room. It's frustrating hearing "trust the experts and bureaucracy" when throughout the interview so many instances of incompetence and failure exist in history. The question needs to be asked regarding gain of function and yet Mr. Collins is more concerned about the reputation of the scientific community. Both are important, but how can we have a public conversation without probing Senators like Rand Paul? "Public" conversations within the scientific community are referenced by Dr. Collins as well as the achievements of the Human Genome Project, but I don't understand how he can be so defensive of public figures' reputations. Again, how are we to have conversations and trust when the bureaucrats and scientific community don't communicate answers to these huge problems! Excuse us, Mr. Collins, but we just had a major pandemic and this current version of SARS was not contained and you can say you wish China were more forthcoming, but perhaps those three instances of gain of function research in the flu versus your woeful insufficient in my opinion defense of a natural gain of function and leak in the case of SARS covid-2, at least deserves some respectful, humble conversation. Labeling Senators as playing politics is not helpful since, in regards to Dr. Paul, what alternative to asking questions do you propose to serve the public interest? (This is coming from someone who read Dr. Collins book "DNA The Language of Life" having enjoyed this book as one of the best on the topic of science and faith.)

I am sure the Director of NIH didn't get to this position with incompetence. Good men are being turned into a hot mess. I would still trust NIH but they really need to clean up. I want to hold CDC and NIH more accountable than say some lunatic saying "China virus" on Parlor.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by ceejayoz on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:23PM (#29326323)
> I'm curious why Dr. Collins believes so strongly that a lab leak was unlikely, that is his reasoning, given that he states SARS had leaked on at least a couple different occasions resulting in some deaths, yet was quickly contained.

“A known, widely researched pathogen was present in a lab” and “a brand new, unknown pathogen was present in a lab” are vastly different scenarios.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by systemvoltage on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:22PM (#29326904)
Coronavirus research has been going on for a decade at the Wuhan Lab. They sent a staff of half a dozen people to a bat cave in 2013. Dr. Zhengli was a coronavirus researcher there. See [1] for in-depth history of Wuhan Lab.

[1] https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/06/the-lab-leak-theory-...

[dead]
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dpbriggs on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:15PM (#29325394)
Who's the bottom tier of society?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by edgyquant on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:48PM (#29321583)
It’s like religion in the ancient days. When a plague or earthquake hit people didn’t understand (didn’t want to understand) that these are the effects of a giant mechanical system and not the fault of anyone. The ancients created gods to justify these things, modern people blame the great other.

If you were French in the 1890s you’d love to blame any societal tragedy on Germans, if you were German in the 20s you’d be blaming France, etc.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by opportune on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:37PM (#29323139)
Yeah. There are still plenty of people in modern times that want a singular scapegoat for an accident. And even people who think natural disasters are a result of god punishing us for allowing people to be homosexual
[dead]
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by merpnderp on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:10PM (#29321898)
Wouldn't the type of heated rhetoric you used be part of why it is difficult to talk about?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by tunesmith on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:27PM (#29322138)
Fine, referring to them as "stupiderati" was over the line. But generally, it is the people who hear "lab leak" and immediately jump to the conclusion that it was 100% deliberate that make it difficult to talk about.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by SamoyedFurFluff on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:43AM (#29329423)
I think the entire attitude of a “them” that can be labeled that way is indicative of the sort of heated rhetoric that makes it hard to discuss things. One could’ve made this entirely blameless by simply describing the behavior without using an amorphous them. Think of it like blameless discussion of a program during a war room scenario.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by hiddencost on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:49PM (#29322428)
Most of the people pushing the lab leak hypothesis have the specific goal of fomenting anti China sentiment. Trump ignored covid despite the extensive advice of experts and then tried to distract from his failure by trying to foment war with China. This argument is an extension of that.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by s5300 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:52PM (#29322463)
Probably more so trying to distract from the fact he’s over $200m in debt to the CCP. Wouldn’t want anybody looking too deeply into that.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:07PM (#29322669)
What Trump believes or uses for his political gain does not magically become incorrect by virtue of being believed or used by Trump. I don't think you're trying to suggest anything as silly as that, but still worth explicitly pointing out.

Trumpian tempests should remain in a teapot of their own, and lab leak theory should be discussed on its own merit. Xenophobia innuendos and "but Trump" dog whistles are unhelpful in sussing out the truth.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by rootusrootus on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:32PM (#29323848)
> What Trump believes or uses for his political gain does not magically become incorrect by virtue of being believed or used by Trump.

OTOH, I will tell you that I definitely look at what my daughter says with a far more critical eye than I do what my son says, because my daughter has a track record of lying and my son does not.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by LatteLazy on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:20PM (#29322037)
Because it's completely untestable and short of someone "admitting" it we will never know for sure.

So whether you believe it or not depends entirely on you're prejudices. I'm prejudiced not to but others may feed differently.

And it makes absolutely no difference at all. You still need a vaccine, you still need lockdowns and quarantines and to manage your healthcare. And we should all be taking action on China whether it's incompetence (around food hygiene) or incompetence (around bio hazard management).

This is why I hate the whole Lab Leak thing. It's people "straining out a knat and swallowing a camel". It's a distraction and it unnecessarily complicates messaging and discussion that can be pretty vital.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by nsxwolf on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:07PM (#29322672)
It absolutely makes a difference, because we need to stop this from happening again. We can't just accept that labs are going to continue to release dangerous viruses and then just deal with the effects every time.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by LatteLazy on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:37PM (#29323145)
The issue here is China. My evidence for this is that this keeps happening in China (SARS etc).

So if it's lab leak, the problem isn't the US or Russia or Butan doing lab work. It's China doing lab work insecurely.

And if it's a food hygiene thing, it's not a world food hygiene thing, it's a Chinese food hygiene thing.

So the action here is to sanction the fuck out of China. And that is true whether it's lab leaked or zoonotic or any other unimaginable source.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by fullstackchris on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:47PM (#29323975)
Uh... are you forgetting about a thing called H1N1? Granted, it wasn't as dangerous as COVID, but that originated in the good ol' US of A. I wouldn't be so quick to jump to harsh ideas just for the sake of it - this could have happened in any country really - all you need is human interaction with animals and enough time.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by himinlomax on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:59PM (#29323451)
> Because it's completely untestable and short of someone "admitting" it we will never know for sure.

What a weird assertion.

It would be perfectly testable in any democratic country. Set up an independent commission, give access to the lab's complete files, perform a lot of tests on samples held there. That's exactly what would happen. Opposition parties would be demonstrating non stop demanding answers.

Instead this is China, a communist dictatorship with, on top of that, a strong culture of never losing face. It's only untestable because of that, not for epistemological reasons.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by LatteLazy on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:47PM (#29323984)
So it's testable, but only if we overthrow the CCP, make China a functional democracy, change Chinese culture to encourage openness, seize the records before they destroy them (which them might already have) and if we can't find those records or they say nothing incriminating, we accept tthat they're innocent because abcence of evidence is evidence of abcense?

Sounds untestable to me...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by himinlomax on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:07PM (#29324166)
In the context of a scientific hypothesis, "untestable" means that it can't be tested, not that someone doesn't want it to be tested. The fact that someone really really really doesn't want it to be tested does not make it untestable. It makes it untested but eminently testable.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by notacoward on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:53PM (#29321666)
Nobody associates it with a conspiracy theory just because it gets mentioned. That happens because the people most aggressively pushing it online often make that association themselves. In between demands for expensive new investigations, they often veer off into talk of Dasczak is part of a vast gain-of-function underground and Fauci is helping them cover it up, and Big Pharma is pushing vaccines because they can't make a profit from ivermectin, and something something about discouraging masks at the start of the pandemic, and mask/vaccine mandates are somehow part of a plot to destroy America, and so on ad nauseam. Seen plenty of it right here. Such people might be a small minority of the people who think we should look more closely at virus research standards, but they're an incredibly visible minority and their stridency causes the whole issue to be framed in conspiracy-theory terms.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dnautics on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:58PM (#29321736)
What? Unless I'm mistaken, There is no GOF underground with Dasczak, it's very above ground (to be clear, the NIH didn't fund GOF on SARS-Cov2, just on... adjacent viruses). Don't know if Fauci is covering it up, but he certainly hasn't stepped forward to condemn Dasczak, even though the NIH already has condemned EcoHealthAllicance.

It's also kind of insane that Dasczak was a lead signatory to the "this is not a lab leak" opinion piece without disclosing a MAJOR conflict of interest. He should have stayed out of it.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by merpnderp on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:07PM (#29321868)
If you don't think a lot of people died early on in the US because the Surgeon General went on TV and said masks were basically useless for the average person, with every talk/news show running pieces about how you'd just touch a doorknob then your eye, and thus are more likely to get infected by wearing a mask, then you either can't remember what happened or are ideologically driven.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by lazyasciiart on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:53PM (#29323345)
But that's totally irrelevant to where the virus came from, unless you're arguing that there's a massive global conspiracy.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by merpnderp on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:02PM (#29323491)
I was just pointing out that in his etc etc ad nausea example, at least one point the people he disagreed with were making was right. And they’re partially right about the vaccine motivations which is to make money. Ivermectin doesn’t need big pharma to make it look bad, but if ivermectin worked it wouldn’t be a big change from historical norms for large corporate competition to downplay it. It’s not some weird conspiracy theory to say big pharmaceutical companies have done shady stuff and broken laws to push their drugs.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by adt2bt on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:40PM (#29321462)
If I had to guess, it's something along these lines (again I'm just guessing, these are general social sentiments that I observed over the past 2 years):

1. Trump mismanaged the pandemic, this resulted in cognitive dissonance amongst his supporters. (they like him but their brain doesn't like the feeling that it was wrong)

2. A 'convenient' explanation to avoid this dissonance is COVID is a Chinese bio-weapon. They (big bad China) released COVID to make Trump look bad and to kill Americans.

3. Liberals, seeing through this, push back on this generally unsubstantiated claim (at the time and potentially even now) that COVID is a bio-weapon. In the eyes of most, Liberals have taken the side of 'COVID is a natural random mutation, not a lab leak'.

4. Now whether or not it's a lab leak or natural is a political game, where your team wins depending on where the facts finally lie (or if you can manufacture enough support for your 'side').

5. See: Rand Paul v Fauci in various senate hearings about gain-of-function research and funding for a Wuhan lab & generally liberals trying not to talk about it because it would be another example of them 'lying' in the eyes of conservatives (think 'masks don't help' but alllll over again).

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dwaltrip on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:54PM (#29323366)
This seems like a pretty good take to me. As an American who cares a lot about having compelling reasons for my beliefs and opinions, it's so fucking exhausting.

Lately, I've been getting more comfortable with just saying "I don't know" for the latest controversial topic. It's not great for making small talk though.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by umanwizard on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:44PM (#29321526)
Spot on. Nearly everything these days gets shoehorned into the insane US culture war, including the origins of Covid.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dnautics on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:06PM (#29321846)
I don't buy this, obviously not an unbiased sample, but most individual liberals I know are on board with it being a lab leak. Can't necessarily say that about 'liberal leadership class' in the US, though.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by TMWNN on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:15AM (#29327356)
I've read that most US/western scientists in the field immediately thought that COVID19 was likely a lab leak, and were dumbfounded by the Daszak et al. letter in Science denouncing any discussion of same as unfounded racism.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by dnautics on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:07AM (#29329171)
Anecdotal, of course, but this tracks with the subset of my friends/former colleagues who are researchers in biotech. As an Asian person, I thought the focus on the wet markets to be weirdly racist/exoticist. If anything the lab leak hypothesis is anti chinese-state, but not racist, but the Chinese state loves to conflate being anti-chinese-state with racism in it's propaganda.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by adt2bt on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:39PM (#29322303)
(GP here) I generally agree with this. It's why I wrote 'in the eyes of most'. IMO liberals are bad at defining their own opinions in the court of public opinion, and often are viewed as !Conservative, even if their views are more nuanced.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by TeeMassive on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:02PM (#29321798)
For the same reason we were influenced to used COVID-19 as a name rather the presumed geographical place of origin as is traditionally done.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by ceejayoz on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:20PM (#29326302)
There are lots of “traditionally done” things that turn out not to be great. There are some good examples of the issues with naming viruses geographically in this article.

https://www.cnn.com/2020/03/28/us/disease-outbreaks-coronavi...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by TeeMassive on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:06PM (#29326830)
Your article says absolutely nothing about the geographical naming causing the prejudice against minorities and it doesn't make sense that the place of origin, which is of public notoriety, would either be forgotten or is the cause of the prejudice anyway.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Jerry2 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:38PM (#29323163)
By cherry-picking that particular lab leak, you're making it look like this only happens in 'other' countries. Plenty of lab leaks have happened right here in the US.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_laboratory_biosecurity...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by tshaddox on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:45PM (#29321542)
Has a virus ever leaked from a lab whose existence (or ability to transmit along humans) had not previously been known? Surely the vast majority of new human-infecting viruses have been novel mutations that happened naturally.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by TTPrograms on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:53PM (#29323350)
If the lab leak was real, covering it up to the extent they did requires a literal conspiracy (not to mention hypothetical function gain research). In the absence of concrete evidence, it is quite literally a conspiracy theory.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by legolas2412 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:51PM (#29324014)
Hypothetical function gain research?

You mean the literal proposal to put furin cleavage sites on coronavirus collected in the wild, filed for a grant in 2018, which was rejected for being too dangerous. Also, SARS-Cov-2 is the only beta coronavirus with a furin cleavage site. And if you have ever been anywhere near academic grant process, you'll know that you use a previous grant to do the next grant work, as preliminary results.

So tell me it is just a coincidence that just after writing this grant proposal in 2018 to take coronavirus in the wild and putting furin cleavage sites on them, the first beta coronavirus with a furin cleavage site turns up in the same place right next to the lab, right after they moved their sister BSL-2 lab.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by epakai on Saturday November 27, 2021 @10:19AM (#29360798)
Furin cleavage sites aren't as exclusive as you are making them out to be. It has already been established that such sites occur in other corona viruses.

https://virological.org/t/tackling-rumors-of-a-suspicious-or...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by burnished on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:02PM (#29324135)
I'm under the impression that the viral precursor they were expecting to find in animal populations has not been found (and that if it were a natural occurrence it would have been found) and that at least one researcher at the Wuhan lab had previously proposed gain of function research like this before. I'm sure stranger coincidences have happened but with that in mind I think its fair to elevate a lab leak theory from 'premature/purely political in intent' to 'reasonable'.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by varjag on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:03PM (#29323496)
There is no evidence of animal host transmission either. Does it make it literally a conspiracy theory too?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by TTPrograms on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:04PM (#29323528)
Do you believe animals literally conspired to transmit to humans?

I believe what you're describing is rather "the coordinated malevolent animal transmission theory".

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by varjag on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:08PM (#29323565)
What does it even supposed to mean? The lab theory is not that humans conspired to spread the virus, but it happened due to negligence. What's happening then is a cover-up, not a conspiracy.

Cover-up is the default mode of handling failure in an aspiring Communist state. When a major accident happens that can be covered up, it will be covered up.

The above mentioned Sverdlovsk outbreak was presented as natural as well: the official culprit was cough a wet market nearby cough. Took 13 years and the dissolution of USSR to admit the cover-up.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by thedorkknight on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:15PM (#29324250)
I mean... if you think the animals actually maliciously conspired I suppose
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by varjag on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:43PM (#29324500)
Do you really suppose the lab theory is Wuhan virologists conspiring to spread the virus?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by thedorkknight on Monday November 29, 2021 @05:01PM (#29385833)
The comment you replied to says "covering it up to the extent they did" which would indeed be a theory about a conspiracy, yes.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by __turbobrew__ on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:25AM (#29327158)
The Soviets successfully covered up a lab leak for multiple decades even after independent investigations: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sverdlovsk_anthrax_leak
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by UnFleshedOne on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:29PM (#29323799)
There is nothing wrong with literally conspiracy theories when literal conspiracies are likely.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by TTPrograms on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @04:46PM (#29323970)
The problem with literal conspiracies is that the probability of public disclosure increases exponentially with the number of people who are "in" on the conspiracy. This is why a priori one typically assigns low likelihood to them (especially if they require a large number of conspirators).
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by himinlomax on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:33AM (#29328329)
Watergate was an actual conspiracy, that consisted in trying to hide Nixon's shenanigans. Real conspiracies exist. Most of the time if not always, their aim is to hide something inconvenient, not to produce some dramatic evil result. The very plausible conspiracy here is that the Chinese government and some foreign individuals are trying to hide an accident. An entirely implausible conspiracy would be that the virus was deliberately leaked, which makes no sense however you slice it, based on both motive and technical aspects.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Giorgi on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:47PM (#29321573)
It is Hacker News trope really, more and more evidence mounts that it was indeed - a lab leak, there has been lengthy research reports from journalists on this matter, but Hacker News remains in doubt. Which is strange, one kind of expects Hackers to weight everything and see if theory withholds scrutiny.

Same thing happens with that ultrasound attack against US diplomates in Cuba, Hacker news users claim it was just grasshopers while more and more evidence mounts it was a Russian attack.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by wwweston on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @01:51PM (#29321631)
> more and more evidence mounts that it was indeed - a lab leak

Perhaps you mean "less and less evidence"?

https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2021/11/18/coronavirus...

https://www.science.org/content/article/why-many-scientists-...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by wwweston on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:17PM (#29321997)
If you read the links I've posted, you'll note at least two things about them:

1) They include observation from figures who started open to the idea that the lab leak hypothesis was plausible enough to explore, but have concluded that it's unlikely (and explain why)

2) They are more recent

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by drran on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:32PM (#29323055)
If you read links you've posted, you'll note that the BSL4 lab in Wuhan, China is ruled out only. Did they rule out «Vector» BSL4 lab in Novosibirsk, RF?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Giorgi on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:14PM (#29332367)
If you yourself read the links you posted, you'd know these two thins are just speculation

1) They do not explain way, Worobey just assumes that first patient was different person, with connection to wet market, while it is known that both WHO and China identified earlier patient without connection to the wet market. If you read long enough you will find that he is being criticized exactly for that assumptions without any proof.

2) Does not matter.

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by knownjorbist on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:04PM (#29324145)
Why would you link older articles as though they're part of a trend, when the person you responded to had more recent information to share?
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Giorgi on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:08PM (#29332282)
Because articles published recently are not "more recent information". It's just confirmation bias.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by callmeal on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:04PM (#29321814)
>i don't understand why the so-called "lab leak theory" of origin for sars-cov2 is treated as some sort of conspiracy theory.

Because wildlife->human is a lot more plausible than that. Consider for instance a novel mutation that arises from [0], transmitted to humans and is coincidentally discovered near a lab that was researching this disease. Would that also be considered a 'lab leak'?

https://www.wbur.org/npr/1054224204/how-sars-cov-2-in-americ...

Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’ by Ambolia on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:07PM (#29321861)
Lab leak doesn't mean modified virus, and yeah those types of bats don't exist anywhere near Wuhan except inside that lab.