Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’
by postalrat on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @02:23PM
(#29322069)
So what's the harm in accepting it was a lab leak? You might end up with better procedures?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That depends on what you decide to do about it.
1) I've seen people call for a ban on research at all on BSL-3+ pathogens.
2) If you "accept that it was a lab leak" you are implicitly accepting that it was not a natural event - which is going to cause you to focus more on long-tailed, low-probability events like lab leaks, and less on zoonotic transmission events.
Which if you're wrong would be a serious problem.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’
by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @03:02PM
(#29322601)
Better for whom? Certainly not for the labs. It's far better for the labs to draw their own conclusions from the leak, privately, at their own pace. Also, there's a significant financial disincentive: funding for gain of function research will be severely impacted by recognizing the lab leak as the most plausible explanation.
Re:The Next ‘Lab Leak’
by inciampati on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @05:24PM
(#29324315)
Right now I'd conclude that you can accidentally release things from labs with virtually no consequences. Just make sure that a similar virus exists naturally somewhere on the same continent, don't share any internal records, don't let your staff talk to the press, and you have plausible deniability.