News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by eps on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:27AM (#28976233)
In related news - ever wondered why Windows 11 can't be installed on "older computers"?

You know, the ones that don't have a TPM chip?

Now you know. Windows 11 completes the lock-up of the OS.

That's why Windows 11 exists in the first place. All other changes are secondary. Microsoft knows they would've not been able to pull shit like this as a Windows 10 update, so they were effectively forced to do a version increase. Against older promises of W10 being the last Windows version ever.

Welcome to the future that Microsoft always wanted, but couldn't have - a platform with airtight control. Just like what Apple has with its AppStore and its wonderful, wonderful 30% commission. Almost there and the lemmings didn't even notice it, distracted by the new and friendly Microsoft front, free upgrades to Windows 10 and centered Start menu in Windows 11.

Mark my words - Windows 12 will severely impede direct installation even of an user-space software, funnelling everyone to go through the store. That's the end goal and we will all be there in a couple of years, whether we want it or not.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dTal on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:07AM (#28976451)
"Dan would eventually find out about the free kernels, even entire free operating systems, that had existed around the turn of the century. But not only were they illegal, like debuggers—you could not install one if you had one, without knowing your computer's root password. And neither the FBI nor Microsoft Support would tell you that."

--Richard Stallman, "The Right To Read"

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:55AM (#28977906)
In a future where laws mandate signed software, the only way out is to somehow make our own hardware. We'll never be truly free unless we can manufacture free computers at home just like we can write free software at home. There is no software freedom if the processor refuses to run our code.

Right now the chip fabs require billions of dollars in investments in order to make our processors. They are single points of failure. There's nothing we can do if the government starts targeting them for regulation in order to curb effective cryptography, copyright infringement or any other subversive technology.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by saganus on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:11AM (#28978065)
But even if you can somehow make your own hardware, how long until governments start requiring interaction with certain services (health, banking, taxes, etc) be signed by an _approved_ OS/processor combo?

Imagine tax software (comercial or gov provided) refusing to work unless you use an OS with TPM support for "security reasons".

Or even worse, what would happen if gov regulations started requiring ISPs to stop working with non-compliant hardware? I.e. something like requiring network devices to attest they are "oficially" approved before allowing to connect?

I don't think this will happen any time soon (hopefully) but I can see how even making your own hardware might no be enough.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by IvanAchlaqullah on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:51AM (#28978436)
> Imagine tax software (comercial or gov provided) refusing to work unless you use an OS with TPM support for "security reasons".

> I don't think this will happen any time soon (hopefully) but I can see how even making your own hardware might no be enough.

This already happened in Android, at least where I lives (Indonesia). Most of Banks, Government Services, and freaking McDonald's apps will refuse to run if your phone are rooted "for security reason".

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by TedDoesntTalk on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:55AM (#28978480)
Honest question: how do those apps know your phone is rooted, and can you still use their websites for equivalent functionality?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by zbrozek on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:14AM (#28978665)
Google provides attestation and it's a constant cat-and-mouse game that the rooters are usually losing.

Websites can't tell, but lots of companies don't provide equivalent functionality via website. I know I can't upload check images for remote deposit unless I use the native banking app.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by IvanAchlaqullah on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:53AM (#28979074)
It's called SafetyNet [1]

What irked me is sometime app developers are abusing it without asking themself "Does this app really need to check for rooted phones at all?"

I'm okay if banks apps are using that. But why does fast foods apps need to use that? Most people that I know are paying with cash when they order foods online (and you can't hack paper money with rooted android phones).

[1] https://developer.android.com/training/safetynet/attestation

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by josephcsible on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:32PM (#28982920)
Here's a question I'd love for Google to answer: why do you need their special blessing to be able to make a file manager app, but not an app that uses SafetyNet?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by rossy on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:49PM (#28983038)
> I'm okay if banks apps are using that.

I'm not okay with it, to be honest. It's my money, and I trust a rooted LineageOS with it much more than I trust the default firmware of most phones. Besides, my bank lets you do the same operations from their website that you can do with the app, so in my case it's pure inconvenience, not security.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by blibble on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:58AM (#28979112)
probably becomes a tick on an auditor's checklist

like having to rotate your password every 3 weeks and requiring 4 special characters/...

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:12PM (#28979247)
Platforms like deliveroo have lost tens of millions to fraud, I don’t blame them for enforcing safetynet.

Perhaps “food delivery” means pizza to you, but there are many places where it also includes thousand dollar bottles of wine.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by zbrozek on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:17PM (#28979933)
Could you explain how the locked-down phone is protection against fraud here?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by novok on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:02PM (#28981886)
Statistically people who do payment fraud crap use rooted phones more, probably to help with things like location spoofing to get around other fraud detection methods when apps use third party payment libraries, so you reduce your fraud cost with something that is a few lines of code. The cost/benefit ratio is too good which is why you see it everywhere that has a payment fraud risk of some sort.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:49AM (#28986022)
This way they can permanently ban your device. Fraud detection stuff works better too, but it’s mostly about the first.

Fraud becomes significantly less profitable and more of a pain in the ass if you need to set up a new phone for each account.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dane-pgp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:35PM (#28982934)
Presumably a website could support WebAuthn and require you log in using a "Platform Authenticator" like Windows Hello.[0] One way or another, websites will end up requiring that only "secure" devices access them (preferably disclosing a unique serial number registered to them).

[0] https://www.hypr.com/platform-authenticator/

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pxeboot on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:39PM (#28979518)
The most popular root solutions have a "hide" feature so apps you specify can't tell you are rooted. It is slightly more complicated with custom roms.

I have Google Pay and several banking apps on my rooted phone without issue.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by SXX on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:17PM (#28982449)
Does your phone pass hardware attestation?

Google can make it mandatory at any moment and then you won't be able to "hide" anything.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:28AM (#28978214)
That would be oppressive but at least the unfree activities are restricted to the parts of our life where we must deal with authorities. We are still free to do whatever we want with our free computers in all other cases.

> Or even worse, what would happen if gov regulations started requiring ISPs to stop working with non-compliant hardware? I.e. something like requiring network devices to attest they are "oficially" approved before allowing to connect?

Looks like we're going to need a concept of networking freedom as well. Ideally, this will be solved by ubiquitous mesh networks that the government can't possibly hope to ever regulate or outlaw. Practically... We'll probably end up living in some dystopian cyberpunk hell since the vast majority of the population is too apathetic to join this cause and help run this decentralized infrastructure.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by novok on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:04PM (#28981909)
Ad-hoc radio mesh networks are constrained by physics and math as far as throughput goes, they are not competitive with normal networks. Governments have also shown the ability to regulate radio usage very well the world over.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:12AM (#28984441)
> they are not competitive with normal networks

It doesn't have to be. The main goal is a free uncensorable network, if we must pay a price in performance for that, so be it. People use extremely old ThinkPads with libreboot because they're the last processors without Intel Management Engine.

> Governments have also shown the ability to regulate radio usage very well the world over.

Yes, because usually it's only a few people at a time who are interfering in radio communications. Easy to respond to a few isolated incidents. What if it was everyone at the same time?

What if every smartphone in the world could create and maintain its own mesh network? In some places there wouldn't even be a need for ISPs. They'd be needed for long distance connections only.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by citizenpaul on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:22AM (#28978727)
AT&T fiber basically alreadydoes this. You cannot connect without their crappy routerbox that authenticates to the network every so often. Some people have created work arounds but they all requie the att box be plugged in somewhereand forward its certificates
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by hilbert42 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:14PM (#28980495)
"AT&T fiber basically alreadydoes this. You cannot connect without their crappy routerbox that authenticates to the network every so often."

If you look at the IT/computing/internet position from a global perspective you'll note that there are many outrageous situations that warrant political action. These issues include copyright overreach, gross privacy breaches by the likes of Google, Facebook, et al, to internet protocols done at the bequest of corporations for their own benefit, to the ever-increasing proprietary nature of both software and hardware including CPUs not to mention hidden proprietary firmware code in vehicles that drivers do not have access to, etc. - much of it done under excuse or the false premise of security.

If one matter stands above all else then it is that there's no cohesive political opposition of any notable size that's capable of disrupting the political system/establishment to the extent where politicians must take notice.

This is a serious problem and it's a fundamental one. For instane, Cory Doctorow noted that the problems with copyright including copyright reform can't be sorted out as the big players have too much money, power and influence and those of us in opposition are just too few in number to make any difference no matter how just and legitiate our cause may be. In essence, in the grand schema of social and political life, copyright essentially amounts to nought - so it's little wonder copyright reform is left to wither and languish (note, this is my interpretation/summary of what he's been saying on various occasions).

Even organizations such as the EFF and influential people such as Tim Berners-Lee and Bruce Schneier have very little influence on their own in the face of huge corporate opposition, MS, Google, Facebook, etc not to mention governments, the NSA, GCHQ, etc.

In essence, it's all a lost cause unless we can all coalesce together to form one overarching body of international standing that's politically able to fight the forces of darkness. Unfortunately, I'm pessimistic that this will ever come to pass simply because pretty much all of those involved have demonstrated that they're very independent and headstrong and thus they're unlikely to be sufficiently united to be fully effective in a common political cause (one only has to look at the hundreds of disparate Linux distributions to see that). Nevertheless, it'd be wonderful if I were to be proved wrong.

In the same vein, I'd suggest that there's a more fundamental problem at stake here. That's the general apathy and unease about democracy currently held by huge swathes of the citizenry. Modern democracy formed hundreds of years ago when life and times were simpler thus the democratic systems that were set up to deal with them were structured accordingly and there's been precious little change since.

This brings us back to issues such as the copyright one I've mentioned. Modern democracy has no simple way of dealing with the many thousands of genuine legitimate causes that have arisen out of the complexities of modern-day life.

Modern democracies with their mainly (effectively) two-party systems can't effectively accommodate all the nuances of these complexities and like the parable of The Man, the Boy and the Donkey, they try to please all with botched compromises and end up pleasing none (for example, just witness the many political shemozzles over COVID).

In my opinion, the only way to overcome such problems is to review and then agree on new - or even which covenants should bind citizens and The State then take it from there (on some issues where there's no common agreement society may have to divide into groups and individuals be bound by the laws of that group, etc.) Whatever the outcome it's highly unlikely to be resoled in the foreseeable future.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by totetsu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:32AM (#28978253)
I think to do your taxes online in Japan you need an NFC card reader and software b that only works in Windows.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:36AM (#28978300)
In Brazil, we have a Java application that works on any system with a JVM. It's pretty nice. Why exclude citizens based on their choice of operating systems?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by cesarb on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:49PM (#28980808)
Note also that this was not always the case. Originally, it was a DOS-only application, then a Windows-only application, then for a while we had both the Windows-only application and the Java application, and then finally the Windows-only application was retired.

I believe that the creation of the Java version of that application was due to complaints from Linux users, so this is AFAIK a case where citizens used to be excluded based on their choice of operating systems, and convinced the government to allow more choice.

Another example is online banking in Brazil; for a while, most banks required the use of an horribly invasive "security plugin" for the browser which ran only on Windows. Nowadays, there's also a Linux version of that invasive software, so users of Linux are no longer excluded from online banking on their computers (it's not perfect because it still requires that invasive software, but it's better than before).

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:50AM (#28984584)
> the creation of the Java version of that application was due to complaints from Linux users

Is this a fact? I too remember something along these lines but I wasn't sure. If that's the case, it's amazing. Those Linux users are still citizens and they pay taxes too, they absolutely deserve to be supported even if they are 0.1% of the population. The government has nor should have any profitability excuse.

> for a while, most banks required the use of an horribly invasive "security plugin" for the browser

Yes, the Warsaw plugin. It's even on the AUR.

https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/warsaw/

I HATE that thing. I tried to reverse engineer it once to see what it does and why it slows everything down so much. I caught it intercepting every single network connection. I actually switched banks to get away from this stupid software. Literally malware.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by voldacar on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:22PM (#28979354)
Well people have already made decently fast homebrew computers with FPGAs. The problems are threefold:

- To what extent do you interop with existing (closed?) hardware, vs trying to recreate the world from scratch. Do you implement usb, pcie, etc, or do you make your own philosophically free equivalent that isn't compatible with existing devices?

- In any case you will have to cope with the fact that homebrew CPUs will always be a decade or two behind the cutting edge intel/amd cpus in terms of performance

- Your system has to be useful in order to get people to use it, but it has to have people working on it consistently in order for it to get to a state where it's useful. A chicken and egg problem.

There is, however, at least one off-the-shelf free computer system - I'm thinking of the Raptor Talos platform. But even then, you're paying significantly more for a computer that performs worse, unless you're running supercomputer-esque workloads on your desktop PC

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by novok on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:58PM (#28982314)
Personally I think the practical solution is companies like frame.work & valve making open hardware and creating software shims like proton because it's part of their value prop and business model to make open hardware.

If valve doesn't make Linux a viable gaming platform, they are going to be chess maneuvered into a checkmate by MSFT and Apple. Epic recognizes a similar issue too which is why even if they are competitors, they recognize the greater threat and are working together somewhat with Epic porting EAC to Linux & proton.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by voldacar on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:38PM (#28982957)
> I think the practical solution is companies like frame.work & valve making open hardware and creating software shims like proton

Right. I admire them certainly, and I'm thinking about getting a framework laptop myself, but we shouldn't really call their products free/open hardware because they use backdoored CPUs from Intel/AMD

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by novok on Monday October 25, 2021 @03:17PM (#28991905)
They are not currently, because they are forced by current reality to use things like that. But they create the market demand to make open CPUs in the first place. If you become a big enough customer, Intel and AMD start becoming interested in making open versions of their firmware or CPUs, like they do with game consoles today, making custom models just for them. Framework is already interested in making an ARM laptop for example too, and I could foresee them getting AMD to make an open firmware version their CPUs just for the high assurance / open hardware segment that is starting to get created by valve and framework.

Create market demand, and companies start providing market solutions.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by userbinator on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:28PM (#28981095)
In a future where laws mandate signed software

"If you outlaw freedom, only outlaws will have freedom."

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:54AM (#28984598)
Correct. That's why we need the ability to manufacture hardware at home. So we can be the outlaws with the illegal computers that run software not signed by the government.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ddalex on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:24AM (#28976889)
Stallman was ALMOST right.

The fight is not about which programs the user can run, but who controls the user data

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:59AM (#28977949)
No, Stallman was right about pretty much everything. It's impressive how far into the future he saw, much earlier than many of us, including myself. There is no computing freedom without software freedom, and there is no software freedom without hardware freedom.

Control of data is a related problem. It's absolutely relevant but it's not in any way opposed to computing freedom. In fact, they are aligned. Computing freedom helps us retain control of our data even when faced with hostile corporations.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ddingus on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:51PM (#28980281)
Exactly right.

The move to ARM will highlight the hardware freedom in a big way.

People are used to ARM being different and are that much more likely to forget open, general purpose computing right along with that "old" x86...

Heh, I always disliked x86. But now? I look at it fondly.

Strange times.

Edit: It is the IBM PC lineage I speak of here, not just the ISA.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by rossy on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:09PM (#28983502)
No, I don't think it will. I hate this trend of pretending that our relative freedom on PCs has anything to do with the platform. Our freedom on UEFI Secure Boot PCs was hard fought and could be taken away at Microsoft's whim*. They literally hold the keys.

Remember the drama about whether Linux would be allowed to run under Secure Boot at all? That was last decade's reminder about hardware freedom and it had nothing to do with a new ISA. Thankfully Microsoft graciously decided that all Windows 8 logo hardware should allow users to load their own keys, but there's nothing intrinsic about the PC platform that forced them to make that decision, and nothing forcing them to keep it.

* This Ars article seems to say it's already been taken away. I'm trying to confirm Microsoft's current UEFI requirements in their docs, but I can't find them. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/03/windo...

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ddingus on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:31PM (#28983946)
Yes, I do.

There is something intrinsic to the PC: expectations.

The PC comes from a time where we got schematics, could build our own I/O cards...

None of that happened on mobile, and most ARM devices. Maybe the Acorn Archimedes...

And what I meant is ARM will highlight the LACK of hardware freedom. Maybe we agree here and got snagged on words?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ddingus on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:36PM (#28983977)
Also, I am curious about your findings Re: ARS Article, which I need to read.

Frankly, I am learning how to build more things. Probably will need to.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by rossy on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:47PM (#28984032)
To be honest I don't know if it came to pass or not. I'm still trying to find more info on what the current Windows logo requirements for Secure Boot on x86 actually are.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ddingus on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:50PM (#28984043)
I will look too. Ask around. I am a ways away from this stuff right at a time I wish I were much closer.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ddingus on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:53PM (#28984060)
The core point you made is what counts.

They do hold the keys. That is the unacceptable part.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:06AM (#28984419)
> They do hold the keys. That is the unacceptable part.

Exactly. The issue isn't the TPM itself, such a device could even empower us. The issue is who holds the keys. Those with the keys own the machine.

I started discussion about that in this thread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28978028

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dTal on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:30PM (#28980653)
It's not the instruction set - it's the IBM PC-compatible standard that gave us our golden era of desktop computing. Standard bootloaders, standard ports, standard keyboard layouts. We owe it so much.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ddingus on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:19PM (#28981027)
Yes, I agree and just made the reference off hand.

We do!

[Looks over at Apple //e and IBM XT]

We need another open effort. Soon.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Causality1 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:58AM (#28977476)
Are you aware of the enormous amounts of blood, sweat, and tears expended by people on XDA Developers just to unlock bootloader to use functions as simple as custom gesture controls?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by tata71 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:40AM (#28978329)
Are you aware of how often they fail?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Causality1 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:14AM (#28978668)
Exactly. It's very much a war about what programs users can run, and the users don't always win.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by echelon on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:05AM (#28977147)
Tell that to every iPhone app developer.

It's worse than not having the right to execute. You can't even build the program you want. You have to use Apple pay, Apple subscriptions, Apple login. And you don't even get a relationship with your customer.

Truly draconian.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by HeckFeck on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:29AM (#28977278)
And they tell me that automake is bad!
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by depressedpanda on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:40PM (#28979529)
They also prevent installing 3rd party web browsers, while keeping Safari way behind all others in order to ensure that you cannot escape their control.

Their behavior is inexcusable but not surprising; what baffles me is that it's allowed.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:49AM (#28977865)
And we don't that to happen to Windows too.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by appleflaxen on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:47AM (#28977399)
He was early, but he wasn't wrong.

We are still headed directly to the place he described.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by skeeter2020 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:51PM (#28979648)
How is early not wrong?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by temac on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:44AM (#28977020)
There is a fight for both.

And the fight to stay in control of your data is far easier when you use Free Software.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:11AM (#28977566)
>The fight is not about which programs the user can run, but who controls the user data

But the user data is mostly in the cloud, owned by Apple, MS, Google, Amazon, Facebook.

In the future we will be lucky to have apps that work offline with local data.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by hutzlibu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:57AM (#28977921)
"In the future we will be lucky to have apps that work offline with local data. "

Are you from the past? This here is 2021. And right here, the expensive, professional apps still lets you grudgingly do it, but small/casual apps that work really offline? That became rare. Usually it is mainly server and some local cache, you better take care of, if you are in an area with bad connection.

But more and more of my peers realize, how much spotify sucks, when there is suddenly no more internet.

Well, I still have my own music collection(and my own player for it) and use spotify just for discovery. Each to his own and thank you, for the existence of open source and foss.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by johnebgd on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:26AM (#28978203)
Office, creative suite, and your flavor of pdf viewer still all work primarily off local files since cloud storage vendors all compete and don’t interconnect except at integration for the endpoint.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by easrng on Monday October 25, 2021 @03:18PM (#28991919)
Office has OneDrive (IIRC some are cloud-only, OneNote I think) and many of Adobe's apps save to Adobe's cloud.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by FpUser on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:45AM (#28978994)
>"but small/casual apps that work really offline?"

I do not have single small/casual app I paid for or free ones that does not work with offline data.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by jynelson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:08AM (#28978607)
Spotify works fine offline, you just have to download the tracks ahead of time.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by hutzlibu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:23PM (#28979363)
Yeah, but there is a tight limit.

And they get removed after some time.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by HeckFeck on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:28AM (#28977275)
> The fight is not about which programs the user can run, but who controls the user data

Some things were so horrible, not even Stallman could imagine them happening in his worst nightmares.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dTal on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:32PM (#28980671)
Weird take, given this is a thread about Microsoft effectively banning a program.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by cabalamat on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:45AM (#28977833)
It's both.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Arisaka1 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:00AM (#28976714)
I saw the writing on the wall the moment they could sloppily justify the TPM requirement.

Then I got into arguments with people proclaiming that it's just Microsoft enforcing it for the casual user's safety, and that I'm a Microsoft hater. Who? Me, whose first programming language was C#, who worked as an Windows server administrator for years, and my operating systems have been nothing than Windows for 2 decades. And I'm suddenly a hater for daring to raise an eyebrow and question their design motivation?

I'm very convinced that the desktop world is at its worse. You have the commonly owned yet absurdly powerful tool known as a desktop computer have its market dominated by a single company, with no competitors whatsoever. Even worse, Microsoft's deal with hardware vendors ensure that even if a competitor were to rise they'll have to earn their favor as well. The game is lost for any competitor before it even starts.

And with the PC dominance under their thumb they test the waters to see with how much they can get away with, an approach they cannot even afford to consider when it comes to their other products like Azure or even the C# programming language. They also did their best to make Visual Studio Code great, until you realize that this also follows the same pattern.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by HeckFeck on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:36AM (#28977328)
I genuinely miss the days of playing with DOS, Windows 9x and then all the excitement of Windows XP. All on my own hardware, which was whatever I could scrape from parents, savings, neighbours. I could do what I wanted with these old PCs.

There was an openness that existed in the world of computing. Despite all that was said of Microsoft back then, and much of the complaints about proprietary software were true then also, it wasn't anywhere near as bad as this. Back then, new releases actually did improve my experience of computing.

Every time I use Windows 10 I feel like I'm constantly in battle with the PC. Every new piece of news I read, every new feature in software and now hardware I read and shudder, thinking, how much more of my privacy will it cost? What other aspect of my life is being invaded?

And because of the network effect, I'm trapped in their clutches. I have to use these services or I can't work, can't talk to friends. All well and good saying 'use Matrix' but a chat program with no friends is just a note taker.

Such a seismic shift and it was only two decades. I just want this hostility to end. A computer is a machine, which is an elaborate tool, for Pete's sake. I don't feel the same way towards my garden hose or washing machine.

(And I increasingly wonder, were we freer back then because there was still some empathy towards customer needs at Microsoft, or because they were simply stifled from their real intentions by technological limitations?)

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by no_time on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:41AM (#28977795)
I have a theory that this seismic shift is the result a demographic shift of PC users. It gradually went from engineers, businessmen and hackers to a much wider audience including younger people who have trouble grasping concepts such as folders[0]

This by itself is not bad, problems arise when companies use this to justify deny control even from those who can be responsible with it.

[0]: https://www.pcgamer.com/students-dont-know-what-files-and-fo...

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by merrywhether on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:22AM (#28978725)
The problem arises when there is no way to differentiate between the user classes. And while I enjoy computing freedom, I’m not exactly proclaiming its value when I have to deal with a DDoS or hear about people getting ransomwared. I know things like Mirai also exist, and that user error isn’t the only ransomware vector, but poor computing habits absolutely fuel such problems and they cause pain for society as a whole.

I have no idea what the answer is, other than having Linux et al be the place for free computing (protected by its various barriers to entry) while the consumer OS space eventually becomes increasingly locked down. The only other ideas I have are dumb ones like requiring regular examination/certification/licensure to be able to use the “developer” version of Windows or something.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by no_time on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:35PM (#28981173)
Let's pretend there is no financial interest in restricting computer access. I think the best and safest option would be to manufacture all PCs with a similar mechanism to chromebooks write protect screw that you have to remove to unlock the bootloader. But instead of just unlocking the bootloader it also gives you TrustedInstaller privilege in windows.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by userbinator on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:16PM (#28981467)
And while I enjoy computing freedom, I’m not exactly proclaiming its value when I have to deal with a DDoS or hear about people getting ransomwared.

"We are not truly free if we don't have the freedom to make mistakes."

It's nice to hear about cyberattacks and such continuing, because it means freedom still exists.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by userbinator on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:15PM (#28981458)
And I increasingly wonder, were we freer back then because there was still some empathy towards customer needs at Microsoft, or because they were simply stifled from their real intentions by technological limitations?

They've been slowly cooking the frog in the background for a while now with the "trusted computing" stuff. It's over a decade old at this point. Back then the userbase was more technical and likely to smell BS, and DRM was definitely not liked even by the general public.

https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rja14/tcpa

https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rja14/tcpa-faq-1.0.html

...but then they eventually found out that people could be scared into doing anything by justifications of "security" (regardless of what's being secured, who it's being secured by, and who it's being secured from), and here we are today.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by HeckFeck on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:33PM (#28982138)
> ..but then they eventually found out that people could be scared into doing anything by justifications of "security" (regardless of what's being secured, who it's being secured by, and who it's being secured from), and here we are today.

Ah, so they took a page from the politicians' handbook. The same drivel that drives the public to concede privacy and freedom to their hands in the state also applies in private industry (I am thinking of the ominous UK Online Safety Bill). Like it is all the same zeitgeist.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by mrandish on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:29PM (#28980078)
I completely agree with your points.

> I don't feel the same way towards my garden hose or washing machine.

We just built and furnished a remote vacation home from the ground up and the shiny new appliances and even some fixtures (mostly ordered or approved by my wife) default to stubbornly demanding cloud access, often before they will even perform their most basic functions. At the moment, internet is only via 4G hotspot as we await Starlink's rollout next year.

This of course includes the Samsung TV but extends to the Denon amplifier, all the major appliances from washing machine, refrigerator etc all the way down to the light switches, thermostats and 'smart' toilets (which I view as 'input-only' devices). Fortunately, I intercepted the light switches before installation and hacked open source firmware on them but that required opening each one and temporarily soldering to reflash the firmware (I had to draw the line somewhere).

Most of the devices can be coaxed into functioning without permanent cloud access but it's a time-consuming escape-room adventure through dark UX patterns. The rest will require blocking at the router firewall level.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by HeckFeck on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:41PM (#28982192)
Well, when the story began I though this sounds like a pleasant getaway, and I was happy to read you've acquired such a place.

Then the rest of it was just a dour decline. Man, oh man. The worst of it is that all these devices could integrate genuine 'smart' functionality, but a user-respecting way would be locally run from a central box with open and interoperable protocols across devices. Exactly how a router and server works on a LAN. It isn't impossible to design this in a consumer-friendly way either. But the will and the demand just isn't there.

I wonder how these devices will be when the remote servers are inevitably switched off. I learnt this lesson very early on with online games (think GameSpy), the servers are not forever.

What has come over the population? It wasn't that long ago that they burnt identity cards in the UK (at the end of the second world war), the public were glad to see the back of them despite the touted 'benefits' by some politicians. My grandmother shuddered at the thought of giving any financial details online. In the early days, I never used my real name anywhere on the Internet. There is just so much passivity now.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by mrandish on Monday October 25, 2021 @01:43PM (#28990807)
It's still going to be a pleasant getaway, just one requiring much more effort during set up to configure it in a long-term sustainable way.

> There is just so much passivity now.

For anyone interested there is a large, active online community around the open-source Home Assistant platform. I'm using it and the community has been a terrific resource for finding those still too-rare devices which both work well and are willing to work sans-cloud. There are thousands of contributors and hundreds of thousands of HA users now and together we comprise a market large enough for even low-cost Asian manufacturers to notice and start targeting products toward.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by paulryanrogers on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:11AM (#28978629)
That early era also included some controversy over Windows XP requiring online activation. It was a watershed moment, soon followed by their authenticity check to install certain updates.

We are firmly in a new era of increasing DRM within the OS. As a producer I can see the desire but am saddened as a consumer with fond memories of a freer time.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:34AM (#28976951)
>I saw the writing on the wall the moment they could sloppily justify the TPM requirement.

Microsoft doxed itself on the TPM limitation being purely arbitrary when Windows 11 compatibility checks passed on a Pentium 4 CPU and installed just fine due to a mistake from Microsoft where they forgot to blacklist that CPU family lol.

https://twitter.com/Carlos_SM1995/status/1448561898035851264...

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gruez on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:49PM (#28979624)
>Microsoft doxed itself

Does "dox" mean "anything vaguely secret" now? I still remember the days when it meant "personal information".

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by FDSGSG on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:42AM (#28977009)
>purely arbitrary

As if years of experience hasn't taught us that opt-in security is stupid. This would be arbitrary if the TPM was useless, but it isn't.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:10AM (#28977174)
We have to disagree here. The threat models where the security that TPM offers are mostly applicable to the enterprise and business sectors where all devices on the network/AD/VPN have to be trusted and their storage encrypted. There TPM makes perfect sense.

You average consumer/home user does not benefit at all from the features of TPM since they're not subject to the same threat model. Here TPM, and also stuff of the UEFI security chain like Management Engine and Secure Boot in the past, act more like hostile wall-gardening that limit what a user can install on his system (remember how enabling secure boot originally meant you couldn't install any linux distro?) rather than add any meaningful security (will TPM and Secure Boot prevent grandma from getting her PC infected by malware off some shady phishing site? No? Then don't force those requirements for private users)

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by EvanAnderson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:12AM (#28977577)
To give an example harm caused by the TPM / disk encryption feature in the consumer space: A recently-deceased friend's wife contacted me about getting personal data off from her late husband's computers. I ended up being able to get nothing for her.

My friend, no doubt influenced by dementia and paranoia he was feeling, changed the passwords, made no note of them, and subsequently died. The computers in question run Windows 10 using Bitlocker and key storage in the TPM.

The data is effectively gone. I believe he was using encrypted backups to a "cloud" storage provider, too, but I'm also fairly certain the key is only on these computers. (The Windows accounts on these machines are local accounts so the Bitlocker recovery keys weren't saved on Microsoft's servers either.)

Matters were arguably handled poorly on my friend's part prior to his becoming of unsound mind. He wasn't terribly technically savvy and I'm not sure he considered the "losing my own mind" threat model. Nonetheless, it adds insult to injury that Bitlocker, which added no security for his day-to-day use, effectively caused the loss of his data.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by shawnz on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:22AM (#28977653)
I'm sorry for your loss, but did your friend not have a right to privacy just because he had dementia? Should we be building dementia backdoors into all our platforms' encryption systems? What about cases where people are estranged from their spouses?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by EvanAnderson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:47AM (#28979016)
As I said, it wasn't handled well. I don't think we should be building backdoors into secruity systems. I also don't think my friend explicitly requested the functionality or would have understood the ramifications even if he did.

Bitlocker is, apparently, enabled-by-default on consumer machines that, I'd argue, don't suffer from a threat model that necessitate its use.

There is a huge problem with technical and legal constructs associated with the rights to accounts and data after death. I don't have the answers for everybody. I've done what I can for myself and my immediate family.

The "I've lost my mind and undermine efforts I made, while still in my right mind, for successors-in-right to access my data" is one that I'm not sure how to defend against, and one that scares the willies out of me. I can document my last wishes but if I, in a fit or paranoia, change keys / passwords / remove recovery mechanisms, then those last wishes might be irrelevant.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:30AM (#28977708)
This is similar to why enabling 2FA actually scared the heck out of me! I use a password manager to generate strong unique passwords, so I think the chances of someone getting in that way are incredibly low. But I can absolutely see myself loosing all of my 2FA keys some day in a freak accident.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by vetinari on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:42AM (#28977806)
Nowadays the password managers can store the 2fa secrets and generate the codes as needed.

It kind of defeats the purpose of the second factor -- the password manager becomes it -- but at least it makes the services that insist on it happy.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by marcosdumay on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:57PM (#28981837)
Nowadays 2FA are always about something you know and somebody that vouches for you (SMS, email, whatever). Nobody seems to do any version of it that relies on you alone. So a password manager won't improve its reliability.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Tijdreiziger on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:18AM (#28978695)
You are supposed to store the recovery key(s) in a secure location. Then if you lose your 2FA device, you can reset your 2FA from those recovery keys.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:33AM (#28978862)
What secure location? My sock drawer? Or am I expected to go buy a safety deposit box? I'm really not that organized and I loose slips of paper all the time, it's a major reason I was drawn to computers growing up.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by deadbunny on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:48PM (#28980799)
I keep mine in a file in a drawer. My threat model doesn't cover people breaking in and finding them as well as knowing my password managers master password.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Tijdreiziger on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:06PM (#28989429)
Sock drawer, wallet, locally on your computer, wherever. If the recovery keys are compromised, that really just downgrades your 2FA back to 1FA.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Wowfunhappy on Monday October 25, 2021 @02:09PM (#28991151)
I’m not concerned about the keys being compromised, I’m concerned about loosing them, since the idea is they’re unneeded for many years and then suddenly become essential.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by kenjackson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:56AM (#28977918)
This seems like a plus not a problem.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matthewfcarlson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:19AM (#28977636)
If you can log into his microsoft account on the internet, you can recover the bitlocker key from there if his account on his machine was a microsoft one
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by imchillyb on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:50AM (#28978430)
> (The Windows accounts on these machines are local accounts so the Bitlocker recovery keys weren't saved on Microsoft's servers either.)

Reading the comments, before posting, helps.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by batch12 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:44AM (#28977821)
Did he enable a boot pin or are the drives just encrypted?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by EvanAnderson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:49AM (#28979046)
The drives are encrypted without a boot PIN. If I could exploit a vulnerability in the OS I could get the data. There will probably be a vulnerability discovered, at some point, that will allow access. I'd advised my friend's widow to hold onto the computers for the time being.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by BugWatch on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:21AM (#28984481)
Please also advise her to power it on every 2 or 3 months or so (and leave it running for a bit), so that SSDs continue keeping the data, and HDDs don't get "stuck".
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by batch12 on Monday October 25, 2021 @07:52AM (#28986766)
Just as long as she can keep it from connecting to the internet.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by FDSGSG on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:47PM (#28981267)
This assumes that home users don't have any data worth protecting. I think that's a ridiculous thing to assume.

IME does not affect your average user at all, so I'm not sure why you'd bring that up.

>remember how enabling secure boot originally meant you couldn't install any linux distro?

A lot of people were spreading this FUD back when secure boot was being introduced. It was a lie back then, it is a lie now.

> rather than add any meaningful security (will TPM and Secure Boot prevent grandma from getting her PC infected by malware off some shady phishing site? No? Then don't force those requirements for private users)

Secure Boot essentially killed off bootkits, that's a significant achievement. Perhaps you should learn what these technologies are actually used for before attacking them?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by shawnz on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:19AM (#28977635)
What about the scenario where your laptop is stolen and the attacker reads your data off the disk? All modern mobile devices protect against this scenario by default, but Windows devices required additional configuration to be protected.

And in fact Secure Boot does protect against Grandma being infected by boot-time malware. And when has it ever been the case that it prevented you from installing Linux?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by vetinari on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:46AM (#28977836)
> And when has it ever been the case that it prevented you from installing Linux?

There was a window, when shim.efi was not signed.

> And in fact Secure Boot does protect against Grandma being infected by boot-time malware.

When it was the case that grandma was infected by boot-time malware? One-half-like malware happened decades ago, and under windows they need administrator rights anyway.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:44AM (#28977828)
>And in fact Secure Boot does protect against Grandma being infected by boot-time malware.

And how can grandma get boot time malware at Home? IIRC those were common back in the days when people were plugging in infected floppy disks or thumb drives everywhere and you'd try to boot off them. Can't remember last time I saw this type of malware in the wild as phishing and ransomware is a lot more profitable for malicious actors than boot time malware.

>And when has it ever been the case that it prevented you from installing Linux?

This was always the case ever since secure boot launched and any OS that didn't have it's first stage bootloader signed by Microsoft could not boot. Even To this day, to install arch or puppy on my XPS i had to disable secure boot. Ubuntu and other major distros are fine here though but this gate keeping doesn't make it ok in my book.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by vladvasiliu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:00AM (#28978527)
> This was always the case ever since secure boot launched and any OS that didn't have it's first stage bootloader signed by Microsoft could not boot. Even To this day, to install arch or puppy on my XPS i had to disable secure boot. Ubuntu and other major distros are fine here though but this gate keeping doesn't make it ok in my book.

But this is kind of a circular problem, isn't it?

If everyone's bootloader is signed and recognized by every Secure Boot implementation, then signing is useless since it doesn't afford discrimination between "known good" and "dubious" bootloaders.

I'm not familiar with XPS computers, but to me what's important, as another sibling says, is that the user be able to load their custom keys with which they sign their own bootloader. This is how I run Arch on my HP computers.

This way, I can be reasonably sure that when I boot my arch linux, it's actually mine, and not some random live medium based of arch's (or whoever's) install disk that will sniff my passwords or whatever.

To me, this is what SecureBoot is supposed to offer, and I don't see how you would implement this if you could easily get anything signed and accepted by most PCs.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:14AM (#28978667)
>to me what's important, as another sibling says, is that the user be able to load their custom keys with which they sign their own bootloader. This is how I run Arch on my HP computers.

Like I said above, this and stuff like management engine and TPM makes perfect sense in the enterprise environment where the owner of the device (the employer) is different than the user (the employee), so IT needs to strictly control what's running on the devices they trust on their infrastructure, but why should we expect home users to have to sign bootloders to use whatever software they want as they're both the users and the owners of the devices and the network infrastructure in their homes?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by vladvasiliu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:36AM (#28978895)
I agree that the process could be more straight-forward, especially as, from what I read, some computers may need some coaxing into changing the keys.

But the thing is that, like it or not, most people simply don't care enough, so they'll just use Windows. I remember a while ago, when there were many live CD-based distros and there was no such thing as SecureBoot, people wouldn't even be curious to give Linux a spin. All it would have taken was to pop a CD in the drive and boot up. To paraphrase another commenter, I think many people feel the same way about their PC as their washing machine: just another appliance. Of course, lock-down platforms don't help instill curiosity in people...

So you get, roughly-speaking, two populations: those who care and those who don't. And usually, those who do care are curious enough to follow a few simple steps to disable SecureBoot for the installation and then set up their own signing process.

But I stand by what I said earlier: the process cannot be fully automatic, or it defeats the purpose. But I do think that willingly making it a pain is wrong.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by shawnz on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:03AM (#28977984)
> Can't remember last time I saw this type of malware in the wild.

That's exactly because widespread secure boot has made it impractical!

As for niche Linux distros, it's been mandated since the beginning that you can install your own Secure Boot keys on Microsoft certified desktop platforms.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by yjftsjthsd-h on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:21AM (#28978166)
That branch of malware was already rare when uefi secure boot was introduced.

> it's been mandated since the beginning that you can install your own Secure Boot keys on Microsoft certified desktop platforms.

...on x86; on ARM they mandated that the user couldn't install their own keys, which shows that they will lock users out as much as they think they can get away with.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Jiro on Monday October 25, 2021 @01:21PM (#28990506)
It hasn't been mandated at all. A number of years ago, Microsoft made headlines by changing their policy to get rid of that mandate. See https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/03/windo... . Microsoft's page at https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/manufactur... says that you can "usually" disable it, so I don't think they've changed their policy since then.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by tata71 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:23AM (#28978745)
> And how can grandma get boot time malware at Home?

Depending on the demographic, they can: get caught up in during some (possibly unrelated, likely automated) attack, click the wrong ad, or load the wrong common page with JS.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:01PM (#28980385)
Can you please provide some sources for JS ad-based boot time malware you mentioned that one can get off the web?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by SXX on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:34PM (#28982556)
Usually JS part it's just exploit that is just a first step. After there is compiled and native "loader" malware that required to setup actual trojan / rootkit.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:07AM (#28978028)
The issue isn't the TPM, it's who owns the keys to the machine. If the user configures their own keys, it becomes an empowering technology that allows them to verify their boot process hasn't been tampered with. If Microsoft owns the keys, they own the computer and the technology becomes their means of control over the user. They will use this technology to oppressively deny the user their software freedom while simultaneously extracting rent out of any developer who wants to reach that person.

Those who own the keys own the machine. We must ensure we are the ones holding the keys at all times or suffer the consequences.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ngneer on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:06AM (#28978585)
Insightful analysis, though "oppressively deny" sounds harsh to me. There is not a blatant malice in TCG per se, mainly a neutral desire for control and by proxy profit. The treacherous versus trusted computing debate really does boil down to control. Do we trust vendors to be stewards of control on our platforms? Do we even have a choice?

I do not recall giving the keys to anyone, and yet it feels like the person building your house is telling you that they can pop in for dinner and lock you out should the need arise (deny you the ability to run your choice of software and your control is forfeit).

There is something flagrant when the question is brought home to the personal computer. No user complains too much about not being able to replace the firmware for some faraway BGP router, yet that router is also part of the infrastructure like the PC and the OS installed on it. If a consumer thinks about the PC less as providing a personal computing service and more as an Internet terminal, then the problem goes away a little. Naturally, the PC does both, but since the two are at odds with one another, the PC has conflicting interests, serving two masters.

A similar issue exists with cell phone debug, where the carriers log into your phone to troubleshoot. Granted, debug is control for the sake of helping the user and does not deny the user the ability to run software (the OS and app store do that).

This just leaves the problem of where can a user actually go to do secure compute. An abacus works nicely, but is impractical. Free open source hardware (FOSH) is really the only option.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by userbinator on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:16PM (#28982008)
There is not a blatant malice in TCG per se, mainly a neutral desire for control and by proxy profit.

The originators of the idea were thinking of DRM and came from the content industry. I don't think it's a neutral technology at all.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:36AM (#28978886)
> A similar issue exists with cell phone debug, where the carriers log into your phone to troubleshoot.

You cannot be serious. How do I know if this can happen to me?

> Free open source hardware (FOSH) is really the only option.

Yes.

> No user complains too much about not being able to replace the firmware for some faraway BGP router

The network is a very clear line to me. The BGP router is not my computer. It's the ISP who should be demanding free software from their hardware manufacturers, so that they too could enjoy complete control and trust.

> If a consumer thinks about the PC less as providing a personal computing service and more as an Internet terminal, then the problem goes away a little.

In these cases, the user is not using a computer. They're using appliances that just happen to have computers inside. Modern consumer products make every effort to hide the computer. There is no computing freedom if there are no computers we can use.

We must oppose all "consumer" products, all "fully integrated and converged" solutions. Computing is about simple parts in the form of hardware and software; from these parts, powerful systems emerge. Consumer appliances are these whole things that have swallowed up the entire system. They are indivisible, non-interoperable, uncontrollable, they only do what was foreseen by the corporation that made them despite the perfectly capable computer inside. I can't interface directly with the computer controlling my air conditioner, I need an infrared controller for that.

This article is linked from Stallman's website, it covers this matter with a lot of depth:

http://contemporary-home-computing.org/RUE/

> We are giving up our last rights and freedoms for “experiences,” for the questionable comfort of “natural interaction.”

> But there is no natural interaction, and there are no invisible computers, there only hidden ones. Until the moment when, like in the episode with The Guardian, the guts of the personal computer are exposed.

> Every victory of experience design: a new product “telling the story,” or an interface meeting the “exact needs of the customer, without fuss or bother” widens the gap in between a person and a personal computer.

> The morning after “experience design:” interface-less, desposible hardware, personal hard disc shredders, primitive customization via mechanical means, rewiring, reassembling, making holes into hard disks, in order to to delete, to logout, to “view offline.”

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by raxxorrax on Monday October 25, 2021 @03:33AM (#28985299)
The logistical problem of key exchange hasn't been solved. Boot viruses are very real, but the most severe threats is information extraction which works fine in user space.

I doubt I will activate TPM on my home PC as it doesn't offer much security to me. You can already say that some services will use remote attestations and I think these services can do without me.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by iforgotpassword on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:08AM (#28977164)
And they will get away with it. The generation that grew up with smartphones primarily, getting a computer only later on (if at all) will find this totally normal. Even Android is getting locked up more and more over the couple last releases too, even most Chinese vendors stopped letting you unlock the bootloader, and nobody complained.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by heavyset_go on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:28AM (#28976566)
> ever wondered why Windows 11 can't be installed on "older computers"? You know, the ones that don't have a TPM chip?

> Now you know. Windows 11 completes the lock-up of the OS.

Stallman[1] and others[2] talked about exactly this 15+ years ago.

[1] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/can-you-trust.en.html

[2] https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rja14/tcpa-faq.html

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by jeroenhd on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:32AM (#28977302)
Microsoft is doing its absolute best to move everyone to the Windows store by packaging the new apps everyone should be making into weird formats such as appx and msix which can't or previously couldn't be easily installed without command line funkiness. Luckily, Microsofts own incompetence is preventing this plan from working.

There's another part to the exclusion of old hardware, which is that modern chips are a lot more reselient against crashes according to the telemetry Microsoft collects. The same is true for secure boot and other security lockdowns every Linux user disables. You could make the argument that this means that Microsoft is failing to provide stability for this older hardware, but it doesn't necessarily mean that it makes business sense for MS to put money and resources towards resolving the issue. Not making Windows 11 available on old chips doesn't hurt sales, helps them boast with great stability and security statistics and barely makes a dent in their reputation. Most people with a negative opinion of the company here were hating on Microsoft long before Windows 11 was even announced.

The TPM story makes sense from a Windows Hello standpoint. I don't think there's any doubt that the hardware trust system is more secure than the previous system. However, that trust is completely useless because Microsoft STILL doesn't enable Bitlocker unless you pay extra. It's current_year and Microsoft still hasn't brought data security to the masses. This is an area where proper use of the TPM can be benefit users massively.

Linux is having the exact opposite problem, I want to use my TPM and secure boot to leverage the hardware security built into my devices but it's as if every part of the Linux boot chain has implemented some kind of limitation to make the process difficult. Bitlocker works great, and I want it on Linux too, but nobody writing code for the Linux ecosystem seems to share my preferences here.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by croutonwagon on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:47AM (#28977398)
TPM, at least older version <1.2 were still subject to physical key exfil attacks [1] because the chips communications with other parts of the board were done in the clear.

So it was/is recommended to use a pin/key and/or recovery key to ensure the security of the data. Unless your only threat model was to protect against common thievery and assume the attack had no technical prowess (and that’s perfectly fine, I do this for my company). Not to mention they were kinda used as a warranty canary for Truecrypt [2]. There were suspicions that nation states may have hardware bypasses worked out.

Later there were implementations of hardware encryption found to be vulnerable. So even now bitlicker does everything in software by default. [3]

So I understand why FOSS devs would rely more on standard practice (shared keys) with LUKS and not embrace hardware enclave options like TPM. They haven’t been the most reliable over the long term and are harder to patch/fix.

[1] https://pulsesecurity.co.nz/articles/TPM-sniffing

[2] https://threatpost.com/of-truecrypt-and-warrant-canaries/106...

[3] https://www.technadu.com/bitlocker-to-use-software-encryptio...

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by smoldesu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:39AM (#28977781)
Plus, many Linux users just outright distrust the NIST encryption employed by security subsystems. Why encrypt your drive with SHA-2 keys that might be backdoored when you could just as easily encrypt with Ed25519?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by jeroenhd on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:44AM (#28978991)
Bitlocker still uses the TPM on modern installs. Hardware encryption on SSDs and similar aren't used anymore, but those aren't directly related.

Bitlocker is still vulnerable to key exfiltration attacks because it's not using any encrypted communication protocols that exist in the TPM standard, but that can be (and should be!) fixed.

In the end, I use encryption to make sure nobody can just plug in a flash drive and copy all my personal files and passwords off my laptop. If they have the time and tools to exfiltrate the security key through the SPI bus, they probably have the means to install a hardware key logger in my keyboard as well. The attacks against TPMs are out of scope for my threat model and honestly they probably should be for anyone but businesses carrying secrets as well.

If the United States or China wanted my passwords that badly, they'd probably just drug me or hit me until I hand them over. Defending against such adversaries requires more than just encryption, you'd need to use something like Qubes and alter your entire lifestyle to be secure.

What I want is to have a Linux system where I can turn it on without a password and have a good reason to believe that my files weren't compromises by the maid and that the OS didn't get keylogged. That requires several parts working together.

Getting secure boot to work is easy enough these days, but once you get through secure boot you're in for a challenge. I don't know of any stable bootloaders that don't allow you to edit the init binary to /bin/bash to give you a root shell from the menu, which is a requirement for the ease of use Windows provides. I also don't know if it's even possible to get a chain of trust from initramfs back to the hardware like Windows allows for. The *BSDs seem to be doing some kind of checksumming, but I don't know how far Linux is along with this.

In my ideal world, you get prompted on how to encrypt your Linux system upon install. "Disabled", "Automatic" or "Secure", with a note that "secure" is probably what you want if you can't pick but you have to provide a password at boot. I'd also like for popular distros to switch to full disk encryption because the unencrypted boot partition defeats half the point without secure boot and custom keys (which nobody actually uses).

Microsoft proves that this can be done, although their default allows for booting without a password a bit too easy. If you buy Windows with a Pro key, they'll encrypt your system in place with the click of a button. Everyone can set it up, and in many cases it's even the default. This is a basic usability security feature that Linux just can't compete with, and in my opinion that's a shame.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by andrekandre on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:49AM (#28977422)

  > modern chips are a lot more reselient against crashes 
sorry for a basic question, but im not sure how a chip itself is more resistant to a crash (in os? user space?)...
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by jeroenhd on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:47AM (#28979014)
I don't know the cause, this is based on the numbers they reported to defend their decision to exclude older chips.

I think it has something to do with the modern instruction sets being kinder to the kernel and the fact that on computers with recent processors certain processor features are enabled in the UEFI config by default more often, but I couldn't tell you which features that would be. My hunch is that I has to to with stuff like virtualisation based security and the like?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by abcd_f on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:03PM (#28979162)
This is a grade A bullshit, with a strong smell of marketing spin to it.

If a program crashes on an older CPU, it damn sure will crash on a modern CPU just as well.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by cesarb on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:04PM (#28980916)
> If a program crashes on an older CPU, it damn sure will crash on a modern CPU just as well.

Not necessarily; if the crash is caused by an instruction that's absent on older CPUs (for instance, trying to use an AVX2 instruction when the most the CPU has is SSE2), it will work on a modern CPU but crash on an older CPU.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by abcd_f on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @08:23AM (#29093627)
Taken to the extreme, that’d be on par with an exe having a valid PE header but random noise for the code.

If foo can be launched on a platform that it’s not meant for, it’s an issue with foo, not the platform.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by depressedpanda on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:04PM (#28979781)
> I don't know the cause, this is based on the numbers they reported to defend their decision to exclude older chips.

Why would you present Microsoft PR as fact?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ls65536 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:58AM (#28977475)
> modern chips are a lot more reselient against crashes according to the telemetry Microsoft collects

Sort of a side point, but this got me wondering...Is there something inherently less stable about these older chips, or maybe is their stability somehow a function of their lifetime that would really matter here? My own anecdata (which is from a far smaller dataset than what I imagine Microsoft would have access to) would suggest that this isn't really the case, at least for anything otherwise capable of running something like Windows 10 or Windows 11, but I'd be interested in reading more about it.

Is it that old systems tend to not be physically maintained as well thus resulting in cooling issues and more overheating?

Is it that these "crashes" are application crashes due to the attempted execution of instructions in (newer) x86 extensions not implemented by these (older) chips?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by jeroenhd on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:58AM (#28979113)
Those are all valid questions and I think they do make Microsoft's defence a lot less credible. I believe there are some improvements, like speeding up certain commonly used instructions, the hardware SPECTRE etc. defences and better security features, but I don't think those will impact stability that much.

Whether it's because only newer chips without wear and tear come out on top in these statistics or because there's something in the hardware itself, the perception that Windows 11 is more stable is something Microsoft can market. Dropping chips that lack certain instructions also make their support and testing workload lighter. In the end, the quality and range of support Microsoft provide for their operating system depends on how much money they can make off their sales. If their losses from the move are lower than the cost of supporting older hardware, it's a decent business decision to do the unpopular thing and drop support. It's a private company, after all, focused on making their shareholders money.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by no_time on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:04AM (#28977137)
Correct. It's one thing that the general population doesn't know what a TPM is but I just can't fathom how do governments deal with the fact that their entire nation's computing is about to be run under lock and key controlled by an american company. You could make the argument that up until this point it was possible to coexist with window's BS because despite it's closed nature, it was extensively documented and had workarounds to all to all treachorous functionality. But it's about to get a LOT worse with 11.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:02AM (#28977976)
>Correct. It's one thing that the general population doesn't know what a TPM is but I just can't fathom how do governments deal with the fact that their entire nation's computing is about to be run under lock and key controlled by an american company.

And the said company would oblige to help NSA getting access to some users data.

Both China and Russia demand users with sensitive information to use their own operating systems and they also build their own hardware because they don't trust the hardware.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by AwaAwa on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:32AM (#28977725)
In my experience most people at government orgs simply follow the recommendations of 'someone' else. Said someone is in the pocket of some vendor, and 'champions' their cause. The relatively few folk that actually understand the details, are usually not the type to be able to wine n dine their management (because no vendor supported expense budget). Or worse, are single handedly tasked with the responsibility, and no reward (outside of securing your 'country', which effort will be diluted in front of your eyes anyway).

Everyone just buys the ABC company's TPM to put it into their heads and out of their minds.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by zigzag312 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:44AM (#28977022)
I find it interesting that, one one hand they are implementing features "in the name of security" that limit the owner of a computer what he/she can do with it and on the other hand they are adding backdoors so that government agencies (or anyone with right information) can spy on citizen that use this "secure" OS.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:08AM (#28977162)
I will personally pay you twenty thousand US dollars (in the cryptocurrency of your choice, bank transfer, western union, whatever) if you can prove beyond reasonable doubt that Microsoft has ever secretly shipped a backdoor in their OS so government agencies could spy on their users.

Perhaps you will be the first person to actually prove the existence of the NSAKEY backdoor? (I doubt it.)

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by iforgotpassword on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:15AM (#28977196)
Why would this even be necessary to prove? At least for me that's not required, NSA_KEY plus Snowden leaks are enough. Microsoft is known to have no problems cooperating with governments requests, or how do you think they can operate all their services in China?

Any hard evidence for such a backdoor wouldn't really change anything towards Microsoft for me.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ptx on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:54AM (#28977457)
They don't need a backdoor anymore. Microsoft now routinely collects your data and pushes mandatory updates through the front door.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by zigzag312 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:48AM (#28977412)
You might be right and there is no backdoor that was intentionally implemented. Although, numerous leaks do show that neither are always law-abiding saints, so a backdoor might not be too far fetched. From what I've heard (I may be wrong since I'm not from US), US company is not allowed to publicly disclose requests from NSA, so proving it would be very difficult.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:05PM (#28979176)
I strongly believe that there’s just no point in backdooring Windows, this is complicated software with extremely large attack surface.

We’ve seen NSAs incredibly cool 0day exploits leak, we’ve seen some of their backdoors exposed, but so far there hasn’t been anything indicating a desire to backdoor Windows itself.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:09AM (#28978041)
What about this old NSA backdoor? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_EC_DRBG

If MS or Apple or Google or some hardware makers or some communication equipment makers have some backdoors for NSA, why would you think they would do such a poor job that anyone can pay $20k to prove it?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:47AM (#28986013)
I feel like convincing the world to use your backdoored encryption algorithms is a bit more interesting than planting yet another RCE bug in Windows.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by tata71 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:42PM (#28980204)
Who needs a backdoor when you can just exploit the print spooler from 1999???
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:45AM (#28986004)
Exactly!
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by zepolen on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:00AM (#28977492)
Is that $20,000 just for proof or also showing the method?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:56AM (#28979101)
For example: I’d be very curious to learn about the actual mechanism by which the supposed “_NSAKEY backdoor” would work. I’m not interested in the private key if that’s what you mean by method :)

AFAICT it doesn’t, you can’t hit those code paths unless you already have access to the machine.

(This is a pretty unfair example though, _NSAKEY is the “Bush did 9/11” of backdoors.)

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by sgblp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:01AM (#28976722)
We notice the Microsoft front. Microsoft has marched through the "open" source institutions and employs a sufficient number of OSS people.

In Python, Microsoft employees (who don't develop much ...) have two seats in the Steering Council and GvR, who still seems to pull strings.

Opposition on the mailing lists is shut down ruthlessly and is censored. The new "JIT" project has all the hallmarks of NIH and will end in minor insignificant speedups. The C# guys will be amused.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by keddad on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:42PM (#28980212)
Can you elaborate on the problems with JIT implementation in Python? I'm far from Python development, but it seems intresting
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by aaaaaaaaaaab on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:39AM (#28976990)
B-but they supposed to have changed for good! :’( Haven’t you heard? They love™ open source! They write JavaScript! Surely it’s just some misunderstanding…
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:07AM (#28977535)
>Mark my words - Windows 12 will severely impede direct installation even of an user-space software, funnelling everyone to go through the store. That's the end goal and we will all be there in a couple of years, whether we want it or not.

This would be stupid. People use Windows because it's usable and because they can use software they want. But forcing the users and developers going through an app store won't be taken lightly neither by users, nor by developers.

If Adobe and Autodesk would sense something like this is planned, they would start porting their software to Linux. Microsoft doesn't have a chance to lock their system down. What would be the next step? Use Windows only on MS hardware? They can't pull an Apple and I think they've realized it.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by anonymousab on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:03PM (#28979767)
> People use Windows because it's usable and because they can use software they want

Most people already use computers that, by default, only allow them to install signed software through app stores. For perhaps a majority of them, that's their primary or only computer.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by watermelon0 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:41AM (#28976623)
Or maybe this is related to the security, and Windows is the only widely used platform that didn't enforce TPM until recently?

macOS is even more locked down, but they don't impede or force users to use Mac App Store.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by antman on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:05AM (#28976757)
Ofcourse they don’t force anything because of the competing windows platform which is more open up to now. Apple assumed market dominance and locked everything down on mobile.

What I infer from your observation is that closing down Windows could also adversely affect Mac users, since Apple would not miss this opportunity.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by datavirtue on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:33AM (#28978861)
So if one OS company moves in a certain direction, the other one can do so safely. Implicit collusion.

Apps need to run/execute in an open source runtime environment that operating systems can choose to integrate...and would need to if they wanted to run any of the applications on the market. The browser is not the answer.

Once these guys get settled in they are going to push for regulation that will somehow preclude people from using Linux desktops.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by neilalexander on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:14AM (#28976826)
Apple could have done it with the Apple Silicon transition and yet didn’t. More inclined to believe actions over words at this point.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Jensson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:59AM (#28977109)
Not without massive loss of users. Both Microsoft and Apple would love to lock down their platforms, but they have to do it in tandem or users will flock to the other. So we will see a slow lock-in creep until they look like current day smartphones.

Only way to stop this is to react strongly, so if most users are apathetic like you then it is inevitable. Of course I believe that you are right and most are this apathetic, so from my perspective this is inevitable. When they roll out the enforced appstore you will say something along the lines of "but this appstore is secure and I can get all the programs I wanted from it anyway, and even if I couldn't would I really want an insecure program?".

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by neilalexander on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:19AM (#28977223)
Apathetic — no. I’m aware of the control creep in the industry, but I do think that it seems unnecessarily alarmist to think that Apple just can’t wait to lock down macOS. There is nothing to gain by them doing so and I would be incredibly surprised if they didn’t already know that.

iOS is and has always been a closed platform. We knew that the day they announced the first iPhone and they have been consistent in their messaging about that ever since. iPads and iPhones are globally successful though, far more so than the Mac, and with a far wider target audience that encompasses most people. It would be great for power users to be able to side-load without jailbreaking, but there are plenty of less technical people out there for whom side-loading actually presents much more of a risk than a benefit. That’s what makes it a complicated issue.

The Mac, on the other hand, doesn’t stand to benefit from that same closed model in the slightest. The real target audiences for the Mac (i.e. software developers, professional photography/cinematography, music production, publishing) all live and depend on software that requires flexibility, plugins etc and they stand a much greater chance of knowing what they’re doing. They would walk away from Macs in an instant if the platform stops being useful to them.

Apple Silicon was the perfect opportunity for Apple to close the platform if they really felt strongly enough to do so, but here’s the thing: Microsoft tried to do it with WinRT, it was an absolute disaster and the market spoke accordingly. It doesn’t seem worth the risk.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by e12e on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:12AM (#28977574)
> iOS is and has always been a closed platform. We knew that the day they announced the first iPhone

Didn't the phone launch without an app store an web/html based apps?

https://www.businessinsider.com/first-phone-anniversary-2016...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPhone_OS_1#Third-party_appl...

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Jensson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:59AM (#28977488)
> They would walk away from Macs in an instant if the platform stops being useful to them.

Only if there was a better alternative. That is the point, both Microsoft and Apple works towards there not being any better alternatives out there. It wont happen in 5 years, but almost surely in 20, as they have to do it slowly enough for all major programs to get into the appstores.

Just have to slowly make it more and more difficult shipping software that isn't in their appstores. Then you start paying for exclusives, imagine if Apple paid photoshop to only ship in their appstore and not distribute indipendent binaries for macOs for example, people would quickly learn to use the store. Ship cheaper variants of the OS with only access to the appstore etc. There are so many ways for them to reach that destination, and 20 years is an eternity in this space.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:26AM (#28978202)
>Just have to slowly make it more and more difficult shipping software that isn't in their appstores.

Valve established their Linux presence because they thought MS might force developers ship only through appstore. What is stping others to make the same move if they sense the same danger? Big software companies won't be dilighted to be forced to use the app store. Nor would smaller companies.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by addicted on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:59AM (#28977489)
Is it really alarmist to believe that Apple would like to make their less popular OS more like their significantly more popular OS?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:22AM (#28978173)
>So we will see a slow lock-in creep until they look like current day smartphones.

So we will see the rise on Linux on the desktop.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by fsflover on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:08AM (#28978606)
...and on smartphones.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by wongarsu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:11AM (#28977180)
> Apple assumed market dominance and locked everything down on mobile.

Apple has about 26% market share on mobile globally, that's not exactly market dominance.

Them locking down the platform limits piracy, which is one reason why developing for iOS is much more profitable for many kinds of apps, which causes better apps that drive consumers to the iPhone. That's the reason they put so much energy into locking down the platform

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by AwaAwa on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:42AM (#28977808)
I have to assume that them taking 75 percent of the profit in the smartphone industry, gives them a blank check to do as they wish, and the rest of the industry must follow.

https://www.counterpointresearch.com/global-handset-market-o...

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:29AM (#28978222)
Locking things down and snooping are always presented as an advantage. Stoping piracy, stoping CP, stoping drug dealers and so on.

Maybe we should have some company lock us in our houses for safety? You know, if you wander outside you might get robbed.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by wongarsu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:27AM (#28978781)
Explaining the economic reasons why things are done is always seen as an endorsement of them. I don't think that's justified.

I don't like how Apple locks down their phones, that's why I prefer Android. That doesn't mean I can't appreciate why they do it and why some people might prefer it.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by addicted on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:03AM (#28977513)
The gulf between OSX apps and Windows/Linux apps in quality was far greater than any sort of edge iOS apps have over competing platform apps. So it’s hard to see how the argument that locking down the platform leads to better apps works.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pjc50 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:15AM (#28976831)
> they don't impede or force users to use Mac App Store

.. yet. The notarization and signing requirements are steps towards that; there's an escape hatch, but they could close it when it suits them.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by cma on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:35AM (#28977320)
> but they don't impede or force users to use Mac App Store.

They briefly pulled Epic's desktop signing keys, which they promised were for security only, over an unrelated iOS business dispute.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:42PM (#28979557)
This is a terribly dishonest take.

There was no “unrelated iOS business dispute”, Epic was simply using their keys to sign software that they had agreed not to sign. Epic made it clear that they can not be trusted with signing keys, you can’t claim that this is unrelated.

Epic could have sued Apple and proceeded with their business dispute without abusing their signing keys, but instead they made a calculated decision to abuse their trusted position for a PR stunt.

Even if you fully agree with the position Epic is pushing in their lawsuit, these facts remain the same.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by cma on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:44PM (#28983691)
> Epic was simply using their keys to sign software that they had agreed not to sign.

Epic never abused their desktop signing keys, which are stated to be for security only, what are you talking about?

Apple did more than that too, they also briefly pulled their Apple logins, which they had surprise mandated on everyone who allowed third party logins. They went full mask off.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:04PM (#28984106)
It is downright pathetic of you to attempt to differentiate between desktop and mobile signing keys.

Epic made it clear that they can’t be trusted with any kind of signing keys.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by cma on Monday October 25, 2021 @11:19AM (#28988789)
Apple made a distinction for desktop that the keys there were to be for security only. The iOS stuff was a payment/business dispute, not security related.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Monday October 25, 2021 @08:16PM (#28994943)
This is completely ridiculous. Epic agreed to not sign certain software, but they did.

Epic promised not to do certain things, but they decided to break that promise. You can call that a “business dispute”, but that doesn’t portray Epic as any less untrustworthy. Epic obviously can’t be trusted to not abuse their signing keys.

Why should Apple allow a known untrustworthy party to sign OS X apps? Honestly, the idea that you should somehow separate these things is probably the stupidest thing I’ve heard during all of my years on HN.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by cma on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:52AM (#28998369)
You are talking about unrelated mobile business dispute stuff. Desktop key signing was for security only. Mobile payment things challenging a monopoly force are totally unrelated.

Apple even promised: security only for keys on desktop, none of their iOS control games.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @11:11AM (#29014362)
I am talking about abuse of signing keys by Epic, not about “mobile payment things challening a monopoly force”.

Your PR spin does not change the important facts. Why epic did what they did is completely irrelevant.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by e12e on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:05AM (#28977524)
> they don't impede or force users to use Mac App Store.

They do for iOS, though? I'm not convinced we won't see something similar for desktop (possibly with an "opt-out" for power users, where you can manually sign and accept binaries - much like you can build a dev build of an ios app, but not distribute it).

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:15AM (#28978106)
>macOS is even more locked down, but they don't impede or force users to use Mac App Store.

Until now. And because it faced competition from Windows. If they gain some market share, they will.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by shukantpal on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:03PM (#28979157)
Wouldn't it always face competition from desktop Linux?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:39AM (#28976993)
macOS still runs on Intel Macs without a T2 chip, if that’s the TPM-equivalent you’re thinking of.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dane-pgp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:52PM (#28983734)
The first Mac with a T2 chip was the iMac Pro 2017, and that product line was discontinued as of March 5, 2021. Does Apple still sell machines without an equivalent level of TPM?

For what it's worth, it looks like macOS tends to support hardware that's up to 7 years old[0] and macOS versions tend to stay supported for about 3 years[1].

My guess is that by 2027, all Windows and macOS releases for non-enterprise users will either require a TPM or be out of security support, and governments will start banning the latter versions from accessing the internet.

[0] https://www.macworld.co.uk/feature/what-version-macos-compat...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacOS_Mojave

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by schmorptron on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:33AM (#28976946)
Does a TPM chip actually bring any relevant security advantages for end users, or is it just for DRM?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by slaymaker1907 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:23AM (#28977242)
It brings enormous security benefits to end users. TPMs drastically reduce entropy/complexity requirements for things like passwords/pins since the TPM can rate limit guess attempts. Doing that without a TPM is impossible since an attacker can always read the encrypted password off of the drive/directly from memory and then brute force it.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by frankzander on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:49AM (#28977424)
an who of an average user does need that? I'm not an average user but I never need that. I also know no one who can't wait to get it or even think about wanting it. I only read in blogs or HN that one would need it. I think "you need that because of security" is PR/propaganda from certain companies.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by kevingadd on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:21AM (#28977648)
As someone with executive function and memory issues, being able to use short pins/passwords to access my secured hardware is incredibly useful.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:33AM (#28977732)
I think that’s a wonderful use case for a TPM, but I don’t think it means all users should be forced to buy a TPM in order to get security patches past 2025.

(I realize this is a slightly different goalpost, but I’m not GP.)

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by concordDance on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:27AM (#28978782)
What threat model do you have that has people breaking I using a short password?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:12AM (#28978070)
HDD content can be encripted without storing the password anywhere, without a TPM. If the ecryption algorithm is decent, good luck waiting billions of years to bruteforce, even with the next gen hardware.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by slaymaker1907 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:23PM (#28981519)
What secret do you use to encrypt the hard drive? That itself ends up being a password/key file that needs to get stored somewhere whether it is someone's brain or a more secure storage location. I guarantee you that whatever password average users pick will not take billions of years to brute force, more like an hour tops.

I don't think it should have been required for Windows 11, but TPMs are a useful tool for mitigating brute force attacks.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by nly on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:49AM (#28979043)
A dictionary/cracklib check, password length requirements and good password hashing go a long way to protecting users as well.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by e2le on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:37AM (#28976973)
Measured boot and secure storage of keys. It's not all bad.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by schmorptron on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:05AM (#28977142)
That's good to hear then! So will most computers having a TPM chip lead to easier integration of secure boot with i.e. linux distros as well?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by e12e on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:02AM (#28977509)
As long as most computers ship in a manner where the owner can adjust the keys in TPM/SecureBoot - you could argue its a good thing.

Eg,like: https://ubuntu.com/blog/how-to-sign-things-for-secure-boot

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by rightbyte on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:11AM (#28977573)
I had to disable secure boot to get Nvidia's drivers to work. So I guess the end result might be more hardware trouble for distros, with a subsystem that tries to prevent usage of the computer when it is not happy.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by vetinari on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:58AM (#28977936)
You can also enroll your MOK (Machine-Owner-Key) to UEFI and then sign the nvidia driver with it.

That way, you can leave Secure Boot enabled. However, leaving the secret part of MOK on the machine and let the dkms or whatever updater of kernel modules to use it unattended kind of defeats the purpose.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ziml77 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:25AM (#28978767)
Is the NVIDIA driver already signed? If it is, couldn't you create a certificate signed with the root key that says that the NVIDIA key is trusted?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by vetinari on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:36PM (#28979495)
No, last time I used it, it was object file and source for a shim. You had to build the shim for your specific kernel and link together with the supplied object file. The result is kernel module, that is unsigned because it is you who built it.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by canada_dry on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:39AM (#28976995)
> security advantages for end users

I'd say about as much as Intel's Management Engine. /s

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by technion on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:36AM (#28976969)
There's a practical benefit that it leads to seamless Bitlocker deployment without making users manage keys or do things that would lead them to prefer to not have Bitlocker.

That definitely counts for a lot. It's just a shame that they can't let that stand on its own with their current marketing.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by FDSGSG on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:38AM (#28976986)
Huge benefits.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by robertlagrant on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:09AM (#28977167)
> In related news - ever wondered why Windows 11 can't be installed on "older computers"?

Except of course some older Surface line hardware, because why even be subtle?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pjmlp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:29AM (#28976239)
But it will be built on top of WSL3 and all hackers will jump of joy with Windows/Linux.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gavinray on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:04AM (#28976423)
Relevant tweets from self:

https://twitter.com/GavinRayDev/status/1446459866059612162

https://twitter.com/GavinRayDev/status/1446460168389136395

WINE and the very popular/well maintained Linux distros have gotten so good in recent years that the scenario is nearly identical to Windows + WSL2, except with the DE reversed.

And WINE is never going to run entirely as smooth/easy as regular Windows, though it's pretty damn close.

I prefer Linux DE, both for aesthetic and resource (but mostly resource) purposes.

I think Win11 looks great despite internet's opinion, but wow-ee I cannot justify/cope with the amount of resources (modern) Windows takes just to idle and run explorer.exe

Now -- OLD Windows? Windows 98, Windows 2000? That was (is) some good stuff.

ReactOS recently released an x64 compatible build and I've booted into QEMU with it and toyed with the idea of trying to use it as a daily driver/work, even for a week as an experiment.

https://reactos.org/blogs/newsletter-101/

Feels nearly identical to Windows 2000 or so.

Can check news announcement here and get the x64 MSVC build from the nightly page + boot into it using QEMU or whatnot (I used LiveCD to test):

https://reactos.org/getbuilds/

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by nmfisher on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:37AM (#28976613)
FWIW, I recently tried WINE/Codeweavers again after hearing everyone rave that it ran practically everything, and it was an absolute disaster. Literally 5/6 of the applications I tried didn’t run (and the sixth was Telegram, which actually already has a Linux client IIRC).

I doubt it’s really an option for 99% of people who need Windows for serious work.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gavinray on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:49AM (#28976659)
Damn that sounds like bad luck to be honest. Or maybe the opposite -- I got very lucky and the apps I used were almost all compatible.

Off the top of my head, I've gotten:

- Ableton Live 10

- FL Studio 20

- A lot of popular Windows games

To work without any bugs (Borderlands 3 had a bug loading an asset once)

The one program I couldn't get working with WINE was Studio One 5.

Ableton and FL Studio are multi-GB programs with dozens of .dll's, really complex -- and all I had to do was:

  wine <installer-name>.exe
Then click through them

So yeah it could just be a crapshoot as far as what works. Maybe it winds up that a lot of the apps you personally use/need don't run at all, which would really suck =/

But WINE sees constant improvement, including contribution from Valve who have a vested interest in Proton for running games. Not to be cliche, but it's always improving.

(I've never used the paid Codeweavers product which is supposedly better, so can't comment on that one. Maybe someone else can chime in with recent experience if they have?)

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pjmlp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:48AM (#28977056)
If a full Windows/Linux ever happens, expect it to be as free beer as ChromeOS and Android are when not installed via official OEM distributions.

It will be the same driver dance and boot loader stories since Linux exists.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gavinray on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:59AM (#28977480)
I am fine with this tbh, I am a pragmatic person.

In spirit, I love FOSS, though I won't cripple myself by sticking to if something that works better for me comes along/use it to my own detriment.

In fact, I would be willing to pay a good amount of money for Windows 98/Windows 2000 with a modern kernel, x64 support, and icing on the cake would be a Linux shell.

If there was "Ubuntu: Windows 2000 UI Edition" they could take my money.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by orionblastar on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:57AM (#28976701)
ReactOS runs on old PCs that couldn't run Windows 2000 and up. It only requires 48M of RAM to install. They are getting closer to a beta build. I use the alpha builds in Virtual Box, along with HaikuOS, AROS, and Linux.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gavinray on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:15AM (#28976832)
Have you ever tried to do work in it or use it as a general purpose desktop?

It wasn't really feasible (IMO) until they put out that initial x64 build in August, but in my ignorant understanding with x64 compatibility there's nothing stopping someone from running VS Code or whatnot on there right?

What're your opinions on ReactOS?

The 30 minutes I played around with it on QEMU were amazing.

We've truly regressed so much in functional UI design. I genuinely felt able to focus better because there was less "going on" on the screen. Felt like my brain wasn't overstimulated with visual information.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Snetry on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:19AM (#28976854)
difference is WSL2 is more of a virtual machine than a translation layer like wine or WSL1
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by intricatedetail on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:47AM (#28976326)
Many people only use Windows because the software they have don't have a Linux build. Maybe people should start pressuring vendors to make Linux builds and that could end Windows.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gavinray on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:55AM (#28976374)
Bingo.

Switched from 10 years of Debian-based linux (mostly Ubuntu, recently Pop_OS) to Windows because of some MIDI driver thing I could not get to install in WINE.

I have had a significantly less pleasant time on both Win10 and Win11, and it's slow as hell. Ubuntu/Ubuntu-derivatives with Regolith as a DE + Tiling WM is the best computing experience I've ever had

(Disclaimer: Have never used a Mac. Have been told OSx is better than Linux by people who have used both for long time.)

https://regolith-linux.org/

The ironic thing is that, I later had a passing convo with a developer of a DAW, who told me that MIDI driver stuff is usually for running specific software from the vendor and that MIDI is universal over USB.

So I never even needed to switch in the first place! I was just too hardware-stupid to know this!

Oh man it hurts my soul.

I could switch back but it takes a whole weekend to properly backup + wipe and setup a machine. I think I am going to go back to Pop_OS or Ubuntu though.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by nicolas_t on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:28AM (#28976572)
> (Disclaimer: Have never used a Mac. Have been told OSx is better than Linux by people who have used both for long time.)

As someone who used both for a long time, I would agree 2-3 years ago, now though I'd say I prefer Linux. I do really love the new m1 macs in term of temperature control and performance though.

The advantage of Linux is that when it doesn't work it's much easier to diagnose and fix by yourself, that didn't use to be a problem on macs because Apple's QA was much better and they were pretty stable (if you skipped the first 3-4 months of a new OS release) but nowadays, it's a lot less stable, my mac cannot even go to deep sleep properly (which ironically used to be a major pain on linux) and it's just a black box that's hard to diagnose but doesn't work well enough to justify it being a black box. And for the mac, I used to use things like SIMBL to modify the system exactly how I liked it but all of that has been slowly removed by Apple. Now I just want the flexibility of Linux.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gavinray on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:34AM (#28976599)

  > "I would agree 2-3 years ago, now though I'd say I prefer Linux"
This is an interesting anecdote. Do you have anything in particular that makes you think this, or is it an overall shift in feel? Also curious to hear which distro you use

Call me a heretic, but I am jealous of the M1 performance-for-price being outside the Apple ecosystem and have thought to buy an M1 laptop and wipe it + put Asahi Linux on it hahaha

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by nicolas_t on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:44AM (#28976633)
I mostly use Arch Linux. Used to use Gentoo for years before that. Mostly it's the continuous QA problem I've been getting (my mba not going to deep sleep is a big one), the dumbing down of the OS X interface and the fact that I can no longer easily use tools like SIMBL to extend applications.

It's a bit the straw that broke the camel back. As time went on, little things became more and more aggravating.

I'm eagerly watching Asahi Linux's progress :)

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by timellis-smith on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:58AM (#28976704)
I have a core i5 mini computer which I spin up every couple of months and it always amazes me that for the first 20 minutes or so the CPU runs at 100% while windows checks for updates (obviously this wouldn't happen if I ran it daily, but still Linux never does this)
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by swiley on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:13AM (#28976490)
>slow as hell It's surprising how poorly Windows performs. Many people who don't use it may have not noticed how bad it's gotten in the last 5 years.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by peteri on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:11AM (#28976806)
There are several reasons for Windows popularity today:

Active Directory - The centralised control it gives corporates.

Games and DirectX - Although this seems to be getting to be less of a reason.

Backwards compatibility - Windows 16 bit apps are now dead, but you can take the VB6 code I wrote pre-Y2K and run it today.

Linux fragmentation - It's difficult to support all the Linux variations with a single binary (or at least it feels that way to me) I suspect it has a very high support cost. Related to this is the GPL and it's potential to force release of source code.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Krasnol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:20AM (#28976860)
There is also one reason many here don't see:

you don't have to bother with the console. Everything can be installed and run with a mouse.

Don't take me wrong. I understand the good sides of console programs. You can do a lot there but your average user doesn't care.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:08PM (#28979205)
I've definitely had to use a windows console on occasion, and regedit which is at a similar level or worse.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dotancohen on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:05AM (#28977139)
What popular end-user software cannot be installed and run with a mouse in e.g. Ubuntu?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Silhouette on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:23AM (#28977661)
Not long ago I upgraded an Ubuntu system to 21.04. It took me more than half an hour of looking around to realise that the "Ubuntu Software" screen everyone was referring to was a separate application that wasn't installed by default. Then I could look up the CLI command to install it via apt.

That sort of thing would be a small (though very irritating) waste of time for many of us on HN but it could have been a showstopper for other potential Ubuntu users who aren't technically inclined and just want a system that works.

Unfortunately in my experience that still sums up desktop Linux in a nutshell. You probably can fix just about anything if you know what you're doing. If you do, you get the benefits that come with running Linux, including avoiding the kind of controlling behaviours we see from Microsoft and Apple in their desktop platforms these days. But the reality is that most normal people won't know what they're doing to that degree and so can't fix the problems.

So continues the cycle where "normal people" don't use Linux and so there is no big market for commercial applications and so most commercial applications don't run on Linux and so "normal people" don't use Linux.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dotancohen on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:49AM (#28979045)
The "Ubuntu Software" screen should be installed by default.

  > Ubuntu Software Center is a one-stop shop for installing and removing software on your computer.
  > It is included in Ubuntu 9.10 and later. 
  > - https://help.ubuntu.com/community/UbuntuSoftwareCenter
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Silhouette on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:28PM (#28980067)
The "Ubuntu Software" screen should be installed by default.

"Should" being the operative word unfortunately. It clearly wasn't installed by default for this machine that had been upgraded through earlier versions (starting around 16 I think so well after 9.10), nor was there any obvious indication to the user that it was missing and available to be added.

There were some other oddities after that upgrade, for example Firefox no longer appearing for one-click launching from the default UI layout when it had before, so the lack of Ubuntu Software (and, apparently, its underlying apt package) wasn't the only anomaly. It just wasn't a polished experience that a non-technical user should have to deal with.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dotancohen on Monday October 25, 2021 @03:56AM (#28985421)
Ah, the "should-have-but-didn't" class of frustrations! Often undocumented, often not even believed when asking for help online.

I understand your frustration!

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by yarosv on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:10PM (#28979222)
Is synaptic not a thing anymore? I haven't used linux in a number of years.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Silhouette on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:29PM (#28980084)
Synaptic still works fine but it also needs explicitly installing and it is aimed at more technical "power users" and so solves a slightly different problem.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Krasnol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:11AM (#28977181)
The fact that you had to narrow it down to some arbitrary "popular" category to not touch the topic speaks for itself.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dotancohen on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:39AM (#28977349)
Alright then, what unpopular end-user software cannot be installed and run with a mouse in e.g. Ubuntu?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by addicted on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:10AM (#28977563)
I’m also struggling to understand why it would be difficult to create a mouse driven GUI for any CLI based app.

In fact, there are apps that can do that automatically. Admittedly these apps tend to create not very good UIs, but the point is that it’s not hard at all.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by jenscow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:35AM (#28977748)
Honestly, the only examples I can think of which support your claim are development related tools/libraries.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pjmlp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:08AM (#28976453)
Ironically I have been using Linux via VMWare for about 10 years now, because I got fed up with Year of Linux Desktop, which to this day still doesn't provide a proper experience to anyone that cares about graphics programming and usable UI/UX tooling.

When my Asus Netbook dies (1215B with XUbuntu), the next UNIX travel laptop will be an Air.

So you can spare the talk about how much GNU/Linux has progressed, since I see it every time I take that netbook into use.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by broodbucket on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:19AM (#28976527)
Have you ever considered that there's a huge amount of users that don't care about "graphics programming and usable UI/UX tooling"? Maybe Linux on the desktop doesn't suit your individual needs, but you seem awfully combative about it on the basis of your specific niche.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gavinray on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:41AM (#28976622)

  > "Maybe Linux on the desktop doesn't suit your individual needs, but you seem awfully combative about it on the basis of your specific niche."
I see your point. Devils advocate: we're each the center of our own universe, so whatever it is we find important is the marker for usability for us.

Ideally an OS should have tools for everything. Though I'm not certain if "Graphics Programming" means like GUI in C++ (pjmlp often talks about C++ Builder and C++/CX, so I believe he means that kind) or programming GPU's via CUDA. I don't think it's the second one -- Linux is much easier for GPU stuff (IE most ML projects/tutorials are only set up for Ubuntu) than Win.

I imagine the argument stems from a lack of Visual Studio equivalent on Linux. It looks like the only version that runs properly on Linux is VS 2005 -- LOL!

https://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?iId=892&sClass=ap...

If you work with some of the Visual Studio specific tooling around things like XAML or C++/CLI etc, yeah there's absolutely no substitute.

It's like Sketch on Mac (god I hate that company for being Mac-only) or Xcode. You're SOL, better buy a Mac.

Lettuce pray for the day WINE is good enough to run Visual Studio.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by broodbucket on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:57AM (#28977103)
VS on Linux would indeed be great. I had to make a Win10 VM the other day to compile a C# WinForms project that I could run fine in Wine but couldn't modify. Similar deal with reverse engineering, Cheat Engine runs surprisingly well in Wine but none of the Mono stuff works.

I do think it's a little reductive to discuss Linux struggling with things like Visual Studio that are only relevant because Windows is relevant, but that is our unfortunate reality.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pjmlp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:32AM (#28976935)
Yep, pretty much it.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by patrec on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:25AM (#28976894)
> Have you ever considered that there's a huge amount of users that don't care about "graphics programming and usable UI/UX tooling"?

Have you ever considered that this "huge amount of users" might not care about graphics programming or usable UI/UX tooling, but that >99% of them sure care about either graphics (games, photos, video, digital painting, ...) or usable UIs and UX?

I'm using Linux all the time, and it's quite amazing how terrible anything Desktop related is. Who is going to fix that if the state of graphics and UI/UX tooling is so poor that it either drives away or stymies all the people with relevant skills to drive some improvements?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by broodbucket on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:02AM (#28977129)
I'm not saying those things aren't important, but they don't warrant the outright dismissal that I was replying to.

Linux has an obvious lack of contribution from designers, designers are employed for products, noone is making money selling desktop Linux as a product. Also, most designers aren't tinkering with open source software alternatives in their free time like developers do.

I also feel like I'm missing something because my experience on desktop Linux is way better than anything I've ever had on Windows or Mac, meanwhile everyone's saying it's unusable. Can't be easy for the handful of people working on desktop environments and the like.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by blep-arsh on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:15AM (#28977605)
Honestly, I think the entire situation where we have multiple DEs/toolkits/video drivers/window managers/input methods is unmaintanable. It would be likely unmaintanable even for a well-funded corporation.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by broodbucket on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:14AM (#28978088)
If there was a well-funded corporation, they would naturally focus on their stack of choice. I think that's what Red Hat does, focusing most of their desktop stuff on GNOME.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:10AM (#28977558)
Some Linux Desktop are loudly combative about how great Linux Desktop is and seem to consider it some kind of failing if someone else doesn't agree. It's always "you chose the wrong distro!"[0] or "you have to be more picky with hardware!"[1], or even "it works for me, so you must be lying!". I imagine decades of experience with that person on internet forums is what has shaped parent's combativeness.

[0] for literally any distro choice

[1] even when it isn't a hardware problem

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by jenscow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:52AM (#28977884)
> It's always "you chose the wrong distro!"

I know what you mean, but in this instance the complaint is poor UI/graphics while the distro in question is using a very cut-down desktop environment (running in a VM).

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by gavinray on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:17AM (#28976517)

  > "which to this day still doesn't provide a proper experience to anyone that cares about graphics programming and usable UI/UX tooling."
Genuinely curious what doesn't work in IE Ubuntu 21.04 for you?

Not one of those raving Linux zealots (don't really care that much about privacy), I've just had positive experiences on Linux -- not using it masochistically for ethical reasons, but because it worked very well for me.

So I would be interested in hearing the other side of the coin, since you've been around the block a time or two.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by blep-arsh on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:26AM (#28977678)
I'm not the person you were replying to, but here's the straw that broke this multilingual camel's back: unless Gnome is running under Wayland, switching the keyboard layout steals the input focus away from the foreground window briefly, causing focus-loss event handlers to fire. This might seem an easily fixable minor issue but it's actually a decade-old hairball which significantly harms the experience and can't be fixed cleanly under X.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by yyyk on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:41AM (#28978346)
I don't recall this ever happening to me in KDE under X, at least not in a way I've noticed.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by blep-arsh on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:06AM (#28978584)
It's a Gnome-specific thing
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by e12e on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:34AM (#28977737)
Isn't Wayland standard in 21.04? So it's already fixed?

Ed:

> it's actually a decade-old hairball which significantly harms the experience and can't be fixed cleanly under X.

This is literally the whole argument for Wayland - things that can't be fixed under x11?

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by blep-arsh on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:27AM (#28978789)
I didn't notice Wayland becoming the default, tbh. Thanks for mentioning this. As for the specific bug, it was introduced by the implementation of a non-essential feature (the languague switch HUD) which was then left in place, likely because the Wayland transition was juuust around the corner. While Wayland does address many architectural issues, I don't think X users should deal with regressions caused by Wayland-optimized features just yet (and definitely not 8 or so years ago).
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by e12e on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:32AM (#28977726)
> a proper experience to anyone that cares about graphics programming and usable UI/UX tooling.

I suppose the only answers here are qt or game engines like godot/heaps.io etc - and they probably aren't as good as windows. But it's a little tricky to know exactly what you mean.

> When my Asus Netbook dies (1215B with XUbuntu), the next UNIX travel laptop will be an Air.

> So you can spare the talk about how much GNU/Linux has progressed, since I see it every time I take that netbook into use.

If you're looking for a "windows desktop replacement", you should probably compare it to one of the "big" desktop projects - ie: Ubuntu standard desktop (not a spin, like xubuntu), Red Hat or SuSe.

It's also not clear which version of xubuntu you're running - 20.04 lts?

Personally I think 20.04 with Wayland and pipewire has made great strides as a "just works" Desktop - and I'm looking forward to the next lts (pipewire baked in, hopefully).

That said, I doubt much will beat an m1 Mac in the near future, if you're happy with apple/macos.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pjmlp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:43PM (#28981717)
Qt isn't a OS framework like Cocoa, or WPF/Win32.

It is the best cross-platform C++ GUI framework, but nothing specific to Linux per se.

Thanks for educating me on Linux distributions, pity that I have been using them since 1995, and yes it is the LTS version, it tends to break less.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Shorel on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:20PM (#28979335)
VMWare vs Native Linux running last Gnome is a very, very different experience in my laptop.

VMWare is crippled performance wise, doesn't detect autorotate, and using it in full-screen requires me to resize the VMWare window every time I reboot the VM.

VMWare also doesn't detect all the buttons in my mouse.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pjmlp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:39PM (#28981681)
My first Linux distribution was Slackware 2.0 bought in 1995's Summer, and have used VMware since 2010, so all anecdotes.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Shorel on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:19AM (#29012927)
That's a complete non-sequitur and doesn't mean VMWare is as fast and featured as a native installation.

I also started with Slackware.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by Arisaka1 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:41AM (#28976621)
The thing is, vendors will only invest resources required to make Linux builds if there's a market that justifies the investment. The only pressure companies can feel is the pressure that comes from the promise of making more money.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dncornholio on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:03AM (#28976420)
You mean, just like Apple did?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by huhtenberg on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:27AM (#28976564)
It obviously won't end Windows. Not will actually make any sizeable dent in Windows marketshare. That's a pipe dream.

Vast majority of people use Windows because it comes preinstalled. And it comes preinstalled for business reasons that are very hard to counter or reverse.

The only way to weaken Windows is through legislative measures and that ain't likely to happen.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by sn_master on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:12AM (#28978646)
Call me paranoid, but I am completely certain that TPM has a backdoor disguised as a very sophisticated bug for plausible deniability.

I'll never trust BitLocker or anything that relies on TPM to encrypt any data I actually care about not being compromised (read: my very personal data, not work data).

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by smoldesu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:39PM (#28980170)
I doubt it. A much more likely suspect is the Intel Management Engine, which unlike a TPM module, runs an entire operating system alongside your computer and hides it's outgoing traffic as encrypted TLS data. Yikes.

A much more likely explanation for TPM is that it can enforce weak and vulnerable cryptography at a hardware level. It's an open secret by this point that the NSA weakens elliptic keypairs to make them vulnerable to differential cryptanalysis. With TPM, software can now be forced to use hardware crypto, which is almost always weaker than the programmable software crypto we had before.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by surajrmal on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:43AM (#28978973)
You're in luck then! Everyone seems to be ditching TPMs in favor of their own security chip technology. Google has titan, Apple has T1/T2, and Microsoft now has Pluton. While the TPM is a well defined spec, I have no idea how fair.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by kenjackson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:02AM (#28977971)
People always say this sort of stuff, but I feel like never really ask, is there any reason why Microsoft would do this?

Desktop revenue from apps is small and will get smaller. MS gets that the web will continue to grow larger.

I just don’t believe the App Store angle. I don’t think Satya does either. The cloud runs the company now. They did this for a different reason. I just feel like people aren’t even trying to reason through what it is.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by fendy3002 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:24AM (#28978189)
My 2 cents, if MS control the app and store, it means no pirated office / sql server running on both servers and development machines.

Open source solutions may also meet a hindrance when they somehow collides with MS's line of business (postgres).

Theoretically Microsoft can get a cut from adobe subscription (no longer puchase, screw them too). They can also potentially force valve or epic for a fee or shared revenue, which is why steamOs are there. Netflix and spotify are also potential targets.

Then no telemetry can be published if MS said so, forcing third parties to deal somehow with MS.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by kenjackson on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:48PM (#28979612)
But for Office they are already trying to move all the revenue to O365. That's the future and there you don't have to deal with piracy. I've never heard pirated copies of SQL Server being an issue.

And then, sure there's Adobe, but 99% of apps are pure web apps. No desktop client needed. Netflix Windows dekstop usage is small compared to their webpage and if MS pushed hard on this, they could just pull the app altogether.

The app store angle just isn't going to be this revenue monster for them long term. When I look at my desktop the only apps I have open are Microsoft and Adobe apps. That's it -- and the occassional game.

IMO, I think the thing they should care about the most is preventing ransomware/malware on their devices. Apps will be in the cloud, but the entry point is the device. Enterprises will want to have the most secure and easy to use entrypoint.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by 29athrowaway on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:12PM (#28979241)
Microsoft fanboys will finally get the maximum security digital prison they asked for, built with their own money.

We tried to tell you, but you were too busy playing your dumb DirectX games. It's not that those same games could not have developed for Linux, though.

Let's see how long you tolerate having to kiss Satya Nadella's ring every day now that you have forced choices.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by im3w1l on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:54AM (#28976371)
People weren't distracted by the friendly Microsoft front. People were distracted by all the other companies being even worse.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by hdjjhhvvhga on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:22AM (#28976541)
Yes they were and they are. You can see it regularly on HN, saying that today's Microsoft has nothing to do with the ugly beast from the 90s, the times have changed, they are now a completely different company, they contribute to Open Source and even Linux, and they can now be trusted because they built the best code editor in the world. I don't know if people actually are that naive or if it's a part of Microsoft's intensive efforts to game HN.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by rnd0 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:58AM (#28976705)
It's a little of column "a" and a little of column "b" and also because there's a whole generation which has come and gone since the Halloween Papers and the general MS fuckery of the 90's.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by passivate on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:43PM (#28980759)
>Mark my words - Windows 12 will severely impede direct installation even of an user-space software, funnelling everyone to go through the store. That's the end goal and we will all be there in a couple of years, whether we want it or not.

People have been saying that forever. At our company we rely on windows backwards compat to run older commercial software which has saved tens of thousands of dollars for us. It seems to me like people are not exposed to a large swath of the computing landscape that uses industry specific commercial software that isn't going anywhere.

Also who are the "lemmings" in your analogy? Hopefully you're not referring to normal people who make rational decisions based on their needs.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by shin_lao on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:08AM (#28977549)
It can be installed without a TPM chip. My computer does not have a TPM and they say it will soon be eligible for Windows 11. If you can't wait, you can do a full install using an ISO image.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by vetinari on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:03AM (#28977989)
You can't install W11, not even from ISO, if your computer doesn't meet all the requirements (yes, I tried).
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:15PM (#28979910)
There are some remastered ISOs floating around.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by DeathArrow on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:08AM (#28977550)
>Just like what Apple has with its AppStore and its wonderful, wonderful 30% commission.

At least Google is planning to lower their 30% commission for a bit.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by fuzzfactor on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:49PM (#28979623)
SecureBoot and UEFI were foisted to dampen continued viability of Windows XP and Windows 7, plus functioning as roadblocks to Linux booting and adoption as has been seen.

It's been years but Linux remains much more badly sidelined compared to working under BIOS, rather than UEFI.

TPM is to hasten the demise of Windows 8 & 10 and the hardware that dragged them in.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by blame-troi on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:43AM (#28978361)
Back to the Mac for me. Yeah, they have the walled garden problem too, but *nix environment for my development hobby is better there than I have on Windows 10. I’m not willing to go all the way to Linux for my main system since my wife has to be able to use it.

Numerically developer desktops aren’t significant, but mindshare is.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by IshKebab on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:59AM (#28978517)
Apple are doing exactly the same thing. I'd even say they're slightly ahead of Microsoft on the storification of their desktop OS.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by fsflover on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:05AM (#28978571)
> I’m not willing to go all the way to Linux for my main system since my wife has to be able to use it.

What is the problem with using it? My non-technical relatives are quite happy with their Debian which I installed for them.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by mickotron on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:34AM (#28976955)
We all won't be, only those still choosing to run windows. For those not doing so, we are not affected.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pabs3 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:42AM (#28978354)
Someone recently got Windows 11 installed and working on a Pentium 4, so it doesn't seem that the restrictions are hard to bypass.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by FDSGSG on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:39AM (#28976992)
This reads exactly like the crazy conspiracy theory nonsense that FOSS-clowns were pushing out regarding Secure Boot.

How did that end up? Well, turns out that they can now safely be called clowns.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by no_time on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:51AM (#28977072)
The water is getting so hot the frog is having problems breathing from all the steam.

"Crazy conspiracy!" He yells between two heavy gasps for air.

[dead]
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by no_time on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:48AM (#28978406)
I like how the author acknowledges that some people claim that TPMs are evil but doesn't actually refute it.

As long as I can't extract the Endorsement Keys from a TPM I legally own you are not convincing me otherwise.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by nix23 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:36AM (#28976270)
It's absolutely fascinating that an open OS like windows (not open as opensource, but open to run every program) takes that route.

Microsoft really thinks they can compete with platforms like android or iOS, i have to say: Thank you Microsoft!! You accelerate the downfall of Windows! No one will need you in the future, Adobe on M1(Apple), Development on Linux, Gaming on Linux, Workstations Linux maybe some Apple.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by watermelon0 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:31AM (#28976585)
Huh? Android, iOS, and macOS have their own versions of TPM, Microsoft is just late to the game, and it's slowly catching up.

Out of the bunch, Microsoft is the only one that even allows custom kernel drivers, since Apple deprecated them with macOS Big Sur, and iOS/Android never really allowed them.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by nix23 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:01AM (#28976726)
I don't say Android or iOS is more open...quite the opposite.

>Microsoft is just late to the game, and it's slowly catching up.

Why do you think people want yet another platform but in the Microsoft-verse, you choose Windows because it's open and you can run ~every application on it. There is no catching up by closing down your hard-ware framework (aka OS)

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by watermelon0 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:39AM (#28976994)
I assume majority of people want a secure platform where they can run apps/games, without worrying about ransomware and malware.

For those few that want to test things or run custom drivers, they can still disable driver signature enforcement, but some features/apps might be unavailable in this mode.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by can16358p on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:28AM (#28976573)
Yeah my thoughts!

But on the other hand people also use Windows because its the default that comes with their new computer. (Not talking about HN community, talking about regular Joe) As long as Microsoft keeps lobbying OEMs to include Windows and there's no good alternative (looking at you, non-tech-savvy user-friendly Linux distros and major software vendors like Adobe, Autodesk etc, they will only keep locked to using Windows.

I'd love to see an alternative world where everything has an equivalent open-source software that people can switch to, but let's get facts right, many open-source software is inferior to their counterparts (especially on the design/photography world against Adobe).

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by commoner on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:19AM (#28977634)
> I'd love to see an alternative world where everything has an equivalent open-source software that people can switch to

Keep in mind that software doesn't need to be open source to run on Linux. Developers can still support the Linux ecosystem by creating/porting proprietary software for Linux, and users will consider it when they choose an OS.

Examples of proprietary Linux software that is used professionally:

- DaVinci Resolve (video editing suite): https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/products/davinciresolve/

- Bitwig Studio (digital audio workstation): https://www.bitwig.com/overview/

- JetBrains Rider (IDE for .NET): https://www.jetbrains.com/rider/

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by nix23 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:11AM (#28976808)
>But on the other hand people also use Windows because its the default that comes with their new computer.

True, but if Windows cannot run the application regular Joe wants, people will just switch to Chrome OS or Apple or Linux (wine?). Sometimes regular Joe's uses more exotic Software we can imagine, and they choose windows because it runs on it since 25 years. Just some examples i have seen:

-VisualBasic 6 (for model train automation)

-A 20yo siemens software for relay automation

-A ~25yo CNC maschine (Windows software to convert CAM to N-language (self-written postprocessor again in VB6))

And much much more

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by can16358p on Sunday October 24, 2021 @08:44AM (#28977379)
It's kind of a chicken-egg problem there too: Windows is the most ubiquitous OS when it comes to "computers" as the society knows, and more software gets written for it, and because of it, OEMs would prefer it even if MS doesn't push them anymore.

Not sure about the solution.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by formerly_proven on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:44AM (#28977023)
I've ran a lot of these weird 90s-looking "The OEM did a thing" applications on wine, most work pretty flawlessly. Even a few that talked to hardware (over serial, though).

However I don't think you can expect to run e.g. a machine controller on another OS.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by kaetemi on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:31AM (#28978245)
Wine is pretty bad for any serious creative software. Tablet pressure support has been broken for an eternity. Alt+mouse combos don't work correctly. There's patches, but they keep getting ignored and broken by whatever else is supposedly more important. I went back to Windows, because Wine's broken contribution process was a waste of time.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by nix23 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:00AM (#28977493)
Well it's not a controller, it's a post-processor that converts and sends the specific N-Code to the CNC (heidenhein "OS") (serial or ir)...CNC then executes the stored code.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by MikusR on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:14AM (#28976502)
It started with Vista. Due to DRM you can't play your own videos. Only DRM protected ones.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:33AM (#28976593)
How so? I could play all my pirated DVD rips just fine back then (DivX .avi), same how I can play pirated Bluray, Netflix, Amazon, etc. rips on Windows 10 and 11 (.mkv).
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by huhtenberg on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:29AM (#28976919)
I'm guessing GP is referring to the introduction of Protected Media Path stuff in Vista, which broke some existing video players. It didn't break non-DRM videos though.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_Media_Path

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by MikusR on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:57AM (#28977105)
Yes that didn't happen. It was FUD spread around back then. Like with TPM now.