News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @09:55AM (#28977906)
In a future where laws mandate signed software, the only way out is to somehow make our own hardware. We'll never be truly free unless we can manufacture free computers at home just like we can write free software at home. There is no software freedom if the processor refuses to run our code.

Right now the chip fabs require billions of dollars in investments in order to make our processors. They are single points of failure. There's nothing we can do if the government starts targeting them for regulation in order to curb effective cryptography, copyright infringement or any other subversive technology.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by saganus on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:11AM (#28978065)
But even if you can somehow make your own hardware, how long until governments start requiring interaction with certain services (health, banking, taxes, etc) be signed by an _approved_ OS/processor combo?

Imagine tax software (comercial or gov provided) refusing to work unless you use an OS with TPM support for "security reasons".

Or even worse, what would happen if gov regulations started requiring ISPs to stop working with non-compliant hardware? I.e. something like requiring network devices to attest they are "oficially" approved before allowing to connect?

I don't think this will happen any time soon (hopefully) but I can see how even making your own hardware might no be enough.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by IvanAchlaqullah on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:51AM (#28978436)
> Imagine tax software (comercial or gov provided) refusing to work unless you use an OS with TPM support for "security reasons".

> I don't think this will happen any time soon (hopefully) but I can see how even making your own hardware might no be enough.

This already happened in Android, at least where I lives (Indonesia). Most of Banks, Government Services, and freaking McDonald's apps will refuse to run if your phone are rooted "for security reason".

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by TedDoesntTalk on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:55AM (#28978480)
Honest question: how do those apps know your phone is rooted, and can you still use their websites for equivalent functionality?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by zbrozek on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:14AM (#28978665)
Google provides attestation and it's a constant cat-and-mouse game that the rooters are usually losing.

Websites can't tell, but lots of companies don't provide equivalent functionality via website. I know I can't upload check images for remote deposit unless I use the native banking app.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by IvanAchlaqullah on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:53AM (#28979074)
It's called SafetyNet [1]

What irked me is sometime app developers are abusing it without asking themself "Does this app really need to check for rooted phones at all?"

I'm okay if banks apps are using that. But why does fast foods apps need to use that? Most people that I know are paying with cash when they order foods online (and you can't hack paper money with rooted android phones).

[1] https://developer.android.com/training/safetynet/attestation

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by josephcsible on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:32PM (#28982920)
Here's a question I'd love for Google to answer: why do you need their special blessing to be able to make a file manager app, but not an app that uses SafetyNet?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by rossy on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:49PM (#28983038)
> I'm okay if banks apps are using that.

I'm not okay with it, to be honest. It's my money, and I trust a rooted LineageOS with it much more than I trust the default firmware of most phones. Besides, my bank lets you do the same operations from their website that you can do with the app, so in my case it's pure inconvenience, not security.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by blibble on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:58AM (#28979112)
probably becomes a tick on an auditor's checklist

like having to rotate your password every 3 weeks and requiring 4 special characters/...

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:12PM (#28979247)
Platforms like deliveroo have lost tens of millions to fraud, I don’t blame them for enforcing safetynet.

Perhaps “food delivery” means pizza to you, but there are many places where it also includes thousand dollar bottles of wine.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by zbrozek on Sunday October 24, 2021 @01:17PM (#28979933)
Could you explain how the locked-down phone is protection against fraud here?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by novok on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:02PM (#28981886)
Statistically people who do payment fraud crap use rooted phones more, probably to help with things like location spoofing to get around other fraud detection methods when apps use third party payment libraries, so you reduce your fraud cost with something that is a few lines of code. The cost/benefit ratio is too good which is why you see it everywhere that has a payment fraud risk of some sort.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by ryanlol on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:49AM (#28986022)
This way they can permanently ban your device. Fraud detection stuff works better too, but it’s mostly about the first.

Fraud becomes significantly less profitable and more of a pain in the ass if you need to set up a new phone for each account.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by dane-pgp on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:35PM (#28982934)
Presumably a website could support WebAuthn and require you log in using a "Platform Authenticator" like Windows Hello.[0] One way or another, websites will end up requiring that only "secure" devices access them (preferably disclosing a unique serial number registered to them).

[0] https://www.hypr.com/platform-authenticator/

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by pxeboot on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:39PM (#28979518)
The most popular root solutions have a "hide" feature so apps you specify can't tell you are rooted. It is slightly more complicated with custom roms.

I have Google Pay and several banking apps on my rooted phone without issue.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by SXX on Sunday October 24, 2021 @06:17PM (#28982449)
Does your phone pass hardware attestation?

Google can make it mandatory at any moment and then you won't be able to "hide" anything.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:28AM (#28978214)
That would be oppressive but at least the unfree activities are restricted to the parts of our life where we must deal with authorities. We are still free to do whatever we want with our free computers in all other cases.

> Or even worse, what would happen if gov regulations started requiring ISPs to stop working with non-compliant hardware? I.e. something like requiring network devices to attest they are "oficially" approved before allowing to connect?

Looks like we're going to need a concept of networking freedom as well. Ideally, this will be solved by ubiquitous mesh networks that the government can't possibly hope to ever regulate or outlaw. Practically... We'll probably end up living in some dystopian cyberpunk hell since the vast majority of the population is too apathetic to join this cause and help run this decentralized infrastructure.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by novok on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:04PM (#28981909)
Ad-hoc radio mesh networks are constrained by physics and math as far as throughput goes, they are not competitive with normal networks. Governments have also shown the ability to regulate radio usage very well the world over.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:12AM (#28984441)
> they are not competitive with normal networks

It doesn't have to be. The main goal is a free uncensorable network, if we must pay a price in performance for that, so be it. People use extremely old ThinkPads with libreboot because they're the last processors without Intel Management Engine.

> Governments have also shown the ability to regulate radio usage very well the world over.

Yes, because usually it's only a few people at a time who are interfering in radio communications. Easy to respond to a few isolated incidents. What if it was everyone at the same time?

What if every smartphone in the world could create and maintain its own mesh network? In some places there wouldn't even be a need for ISPs. They'd be needed for long distance connections only.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by citizenpaul on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:22AM (#28978727)
AT&T fiber basically alreadydoes this. You cannot connect without their crappy routerbox that authenticates to the network every so often. Some people have created work arounds but they all requie the att box be plugged in somewhereand forward its certificates
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by hilbert42 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:14PM (#28980495)
"AT&T fiber basically alreadydoes this. You cannot connect without their crappy routerbox that authenticates to the network every so often."

If you look at the IT/computing/internet position from a global perspective you'll note that there are many outrageous situations that warrant political action. These issues include copyright overreach, gross privacy breaches by the likes of Google, Facebook, et al, to internet protocols done at the bequest of corporations for their own benefit, to the ever-increasing proprietary nature of both software and hardware including CPUs not to mention hidden proprietary firmware code in vehicles that drivers do not have access to, etc. - much of it done under excuse or the false premise of security.

If one matter stands above all else then it is that there's no cohesive political opposition of any notable size that's capable of disrupting the political system/establishment to the extent where politicians must take notice.

This is a serious problem and it's a fundamental one. For instane, Cory Doctorow noted that the problems with copyright including copyright reform can't be sorted out as the big players have too much money, power and influence and those of us in opposition are just too few in number to make any difference no matter how just and legitiate our cause may be. In essence, in the grand schema of social and political life, copyright essentially amounts to nought - so it's little wonder copyright reform is left to wither and languish (note, this is my interpretation/summary of what he's been saying on various occasions).

Even organizations such as the EFF and influential people such as Tim Berners-Lee and Bruce Schneier have very little influence on their own in the face of huge corporate opposition, MS, Google, Facebook, etc not to mention governments, the NSA, GCHQ, etc.

In essence, it's all a lost cause unless we can all coalesce together to form one overarching body of international standing that's politically able to fight the forces of darkness. Unfortunately, I'm pessimistic that this will ever come to pass simply because pretty much all of those involved have demonstrated that they're very independent and headstrong and thus they're unlikely to be sufficiently united to be fully effective in a common political cause (one only has to look at the hundreds of disparate Linux distributions to see that). Nevertheless, it'd be wonderful if I were to be proved wrong.

In the same vein, I'd suggest that there's a more fundamental problem at stake here. That's the general apathy and unease about democracy currently held by huge swathes of the citizenry. Modern democracy formed hundreds of years ago when life and times were simpler thus the democratic systems that were set up to deal with them were structured accordingly and there's been precious little change since.

This brings us back to issues such as the copyright one I've mentioned. Modern democracy has no simple way of dealing with the many thousands of genuine legitimate causes that have arisen out of the complexities of modern-day life.

Modern democracies with their mainly (effectively) two-party systems can't effectively accommodate all the nuances of these complexities and like the parable of The Man, the Boy and the Donkey, they try to please all with botched compromises and end up pleasing none (for example, just witness the many political shemozzles over COVID).

In my opinion, the only way to overcome such problems is to review and then agree on new - or even which covenants should bind citizens and The State then take it from there (on some issues where there's no common agreement society may have to divide into groups and individuals be bound by the laws of that group, etc.) Whatever the outcome it's highly unlikely to be resoled in the foreseeable future.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by totetsu on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:32AM (#28978253)
I think to do your taxes online in Japan you need an NFC card reader and software b that only works in Windows.
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:36AM (#28978300)
In Brazil, we have a Java application that works on any system with a JVM. It's pretty nice. Why exclude citizens based on their choice of operating systems?
Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by cesarb on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:49PM (#28980808)
Note also that this was not always the case. Originally, it was a DOS-only application, then a Windows-only application, then for a while we had both the Windows-only application and the Java application, and then finally the Windows-only application was retired.

I believe that the creation of the Java version of that application was due to complaints from Linux users, so this is AFAIK a case where citizens used to be excluded based on their choice of operating systems, and convinced the government to allow more choice.

Another example is online banking in Brazil; for a while, most banks required the use of an horribly invasive "security plugin" for the browser which ran only on Windows. Nowadays, there's also a Linux version of that invasive software, so users of Linux are no longer excluded from online banking on their computers (it's not perfect because it still requires that invasive software, but it's better than before).

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:50AM (#28984584)
> the creation of the Java version of that application was due to complaints from Linux users

Is this a fact? I too remember something along these lines but I wasn't sure. If that's the case, it's amazing. Those Linux users are still citizens and they pay taxes too, they absolutely deserve to be supported even if they are 0.1% of the population. The government has nor should have any profitability excuse.

> for a while, most banks required the use of an horribly invasive "security plugin" for the browser

Yes, the Warsaw plugin. It's even on the AUR.

https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/warsaw/

I HATE that thing. I tried to reverse engineer it once to see what it does and why it slows everything down so much. I caught it intercepting every single network connection. I actually switched banks to get away from this stupid software. Literally malware.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by voldacar on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:22PM (#28979354)
Well people have already made decently fast homebrew computers with FPGAs. The problems are threefold:

- To what extent do you interop with existing (closed?) hardware, vs trying to recreate the world from scratch. Do you implement usb, pcie, etc, or do you make your own philosophically free equivalent that isn't compatible with existing devices?

- In any case you will have to cope with the fact that homebrew CPUs will always be a decade or two behind the cutting edge intel/amd cpus in terms of performance

- Your system has to be useful in order to get people to use it, but it has to have people working on it consistently in order for it to get to a state where it's useful. A chicken and egg problem.

There is, however, at least one off-the-shelf free computer system - I'm thinking of the Raptor Talos platform. But even then, you're paying significantly more for a computer that performs worse, unless you're running supercomputer-esque workloads on your desktop PC

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by novok on Sunday October 24, 2021 @05:58PM (#28982314)
Personally I think the practical solution is companies like frame.work & valve making open hardware and creating software shims like proton because it's part of their value prop and business model to make open hardware.

If valve doesn't make Linux a viable gaming platform, they are going to be chess maneuvered into a checkmate by MSFT and Apple. Epic recognizes a similar issue too which is why even if they are competitors, they recognize the greater threat and are working together somewhat with Epic porting EAC to Linux & proton.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by voldacar on Sunday October 24, 2021 @07:38PM (#28982957)
> I think the practical solution is companies like frame.work & valve making open hardware and creating software shims like proton

Right. I admire them certainly, and I'm thinking about getting a framework laptop myself, but we shouldn't really call their products free/open hardware because they use backdoored CPUs from Intel/AMD

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by novok on Monday October 25, 2021 @03:17PM (#28991905)
They are not currently, because they are forced by current reality to use things like that. But they create the market demand to make open CPUs in the first place. If you become a big enough customer, Intel and AMD start becoming interested in making open versions of their firmware or CPUs, like they do with game consoles today, making custom models just for them. Framework is already interested in making an ARM laptop for example too, and I could foresee them getting AMD to make an open firmware version their CPUs just for the high assurance / open hardware segment that is starting to get created by valve and framework.

Create market demand, and companies start providing market solutions.

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by userbinator on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:28PM (#28981095)
In a future where laws mandate signed software

"If you outlaw freedom, only outlaws will have freedom."

Re:Microsoft no longer signs Windows drivers for Process Hacker by matheusmoreira on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:54AM (#28984598)
Correct. That's why we need the ability to manufacture hardware at home. So we can be the outlaws with the illegal computers that run software not signed by the government.