> "Maybe Linux on the desktop doesn't suit your individual needs, but you seem awfully combative about it on the basis of your specific niche."
I see your point. Devils advocate: we're each the center of our own universe, so whatever it is we find important is the marker for usability for us.Ideally an OS should have tools for everything. Though I'm not certain if "Graphics Programming" means like GUI in C++ (pjmlp often talks about C++ Builder and C++/CX, so I believe he means that kind) or programming GPU's via CUDA. I don't think it's the second one -- Linux is much easier for GPU stuff (IE most ML projects/tutorials are only set up for Ubuntu) than Win.
I imagine the argument stems from a lack of Visual Studio equivalent on Linux. It looks like the only version that runs properly on Linux is VS 2005 -- LOL!
https://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?iId=892&sClass=ap...
If you work with some of the Visual Studio specific tooling around things like XAML or C++/CLI etc, yeah there's absolutely no substitute.
It's like Sketch on Mac (god I hate that company for being Mac-only) or Xcode. You're SOL, better buy a Mac.
Lettuce pray for the day WINE is good enough to run Visual Studio.
I do think it's a little reductive to discuss Linux struggling with things like Visual Studio that are only relevant because Windows is relevant, but that is our unfortunate reality.
Have you ever considered that this "huge amount of users" might not care about graphics programming or usable UI/UX tooling, but that >99% of them sure care about either graphics (games, photos, video, digital painting, ...) or usable UIs and UX?
I'm using Linux all the time, and it's quite amazing how terrible anything Desktop related is. Who is going to fix that if the state of graphics and UI/UX tooling is so poor that it either drives away or stymies all the people with relevant skills to drive some improvements?
Linux has an obvious lack of contribution from designers, designers are employed for products, noone is making money selling desktop Linux as a product. Also, most designers aren't tinkering with open source software alternatives in their free time like developers do.
I also feel like I'm missing something because my experience on desktop Linux is way better than anything I've ever had on Windows or Mac, meanwhile everyone's saying it's unusable. Can't be easy for the handful of people working on desktop environments and the like.
[0] for literally any distro choice
[1] even when it isn't a hardware problem
I know what you mean, but in this instance the complaint is poor UI/graphics while the distro in question is using a very cut-down desktop environment (running in a VM).
> "which to this day still doesn't provide a proper experience to anyone that cares about graphics programming and usable UI/UX tooling."
Genuinely curious what doesn't work in IE Ubuntu 21.04 for you?Not one of those raving Linux zealots (don't really care that much about privacy), I've just had positive experiences on Linux -- not using it masochistically for ethical reasons, but because it worked very well for me.
So I would be interested in hearing the other side of the coin, since you've been around the block a time or two.
Ed:
> it's actually a decade-old hairball which significantly harms the experience and can't be fixed cleanly under X.
This is literally the whole argument for Wayland - things that can't be fixed under x11?
I suppose the only answers here are qt or game engines like godot/heaps.io etc - and they probably aren't as good as windows. But it's a little tricky to know exactly what you mean.
> When my Asus Netbook dies (1215B with XUbuntu), the next UNIX travel laptop will be an Air.
> So you can spare the talk about how much GNU/Linux has progressed, since I see it every time I take that netbook into use.
If you're looking for a "windows desktop replacement", you should probably compare it to one of the "big" desktop projects - ie: Ubuntu standard desktop (not a spin, like xubuntu), Red Hat or SuSe.
It's also not clear which version of xubuntu you're running - 20.04 lts?
Personally I think 20.04 with Wayland and pipewire has made great strides as a "just works" Desktop - and I'm looking forward to the next lts (pipewire baked in, hopefully).
That said, I doubt much will beat an m1 Mac in the near future, if you're happy with apple/macos.
It is the best cross-platform C++ GUI framework, but nothing specific to Linux per se.
Thanks for educating me on Linux distributions, pity that I have been using them since 1995, and yes it is the LTS version, it tends to break less.
VMWare is crippled performance wise, doesn't detect autorotate, and using it in full-screen requires me to resize the VMWare window every time I reboot the VM.
VMWare also doesn't detect all the buttons in my mouse.
When my Asus Netbook dies (1215B with XUbuntu), the next UNIX travel laptop will be an Air.
So you can spare the talk about how much GNU/Linux has progressed, since I see it every time I take that netbook into use.