News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by tw04 on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:55AM (#26540129)
I actually don't see any issue that isn't simply a matter of money.

Everything they list that's an issue seems to revolve around the fact that the employees with domain knowledge for the system have left the company.

Reach out to them and hire them on as contractors. If they left under bad terms because the business was a bunch of dicks, expect to pay 10x market rate. If this is truly "fix this or the business is out of business" - then it shouldn't be a tough decision to make.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by throwthescene on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:23PM (#26542971)
Throwaway purely so that I can comment. I've had this happen before.

Years ago I left a rather awful company - I left on great terms with my boss, though I hated the company. I was the last person who knew how to release X product. While I documented everything, after I left, the wiki lost its mind, backups apparently weren't a thing, and the director of IT moved to Bermuda.

Fast forward 6 months.. a contractual obligation existed to release the software. They still hadn't successfully built (yup autoconf, make and friends), let alone know where to build it. I got the call you always dream about, 30 days prior to the release being due.

My boss asked me to do him a favour - I reminded him that I quit due to a lack of promotion and raises. He asked what I want, and I asked for 125K, which clearly he scoffed at. Then I reminded him that it was a 10M deal they'd signed, because we had an all hands. The CEO got involved and screamed at me for 'torpedoing the company'. I walked out and calmly informed them both along the way the price was now 250K, non negotiable.

I ignored every single mail (and legal letter) sent me way. With 10 days left, they agreed. I had the company deposit a cheque in escrow with lawyers of my choosing. We signed contracts, and I did my thing. Four days of work. It was well worth it.

Dougie, if you're reading this I hope your cringing.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by kstrauser on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:27PM (#26543814)
Hell. Yes. That's absolutely beautiful, and ethically completely correct.

I have bosses at previous companies that I'd help for free today because they were good to me and we parted on friendly terms. One boss helped me move my house once, and I'm not about to charge him to fix some random issue.

I have other bosses whom I'd require a cleared wire transfer of money before I'd lift a pinky to help them, because they were not nice people and I don't want to associate with them or assist them with anything. If someone in this camp approached me, I'd have a story just like yours afterward.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by lenkite on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @05:40PM (#26560715)
This is actually not a very rare situation. Unfortunately many of us don't really have the smarts or courage (overcoming guilt) to negotiate a price like the OP did.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by tofuahdude on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:29PM (#26543046)
I love this with all my heart. You did exactly the right thing at every step.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ryandrake on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:27PM (#26543812)
Yea, this is one of those "I want to believe" stories! It's practically engineer-porn. Everyone who has quit a shitty employer whose technology was a house of cards resting on the point of a needle is cheering OP on. We all have that fantasy that the house will finally fall over, the company will have its comeuppance, and we're the one person in the world with the knowledge to fix it.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ycombinete on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:37PM (#26543173)
Funnily enough it made me sick to my stomach. I manage a small company and the idea of being extorted in such a blasé and psychopathic fashion terrifies me to even think about.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Judgmentality on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:50PM (#26543332)
> Funnily enough it made me sick to my stomach.

That an overworked employee who had already left the company would stick up for himself? Or that a company would go to such efforts to try to manipulate a former employee?

I realize my tone doesn't hide my feelings, but even if we disagree I'd still be curious to hear more.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ycombinete on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:53PM (#26543365)
My apologies, I edited my comment as you were typing I think. I added some more.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by marktangotango on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:30PM (#26544766)
IMO your edit didn't help and you're not getting a lot of sympathy. The point wasn't that the employee is psychopathic as you say, but that management was incompetent by not ensuring a transfer of knowledge and validating before the employee left. You as the buinsess owner should plan for people to not be available and no one person can derail a $10M contract. This is also called the "bus factor".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_factor

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jschwartzi on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:00PM (#26545215)
Also yelling at someone who is the only person who can solve your problem is not a good negotiating strategy, especially when it reminds them of why they left.

Walking away from a toxic situation is not "psychopathic." It's common sense and if we all did it more then the psychopaths who expect us to stick around through it all would finally learn how to treat other people with respect. It's a job, not a marriage.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:08PM (#26547960)
> yelling at someone who is the only person who can solve your problem is not a good negotiating strategy

Sadly, I've seen this. Not first hand, but it happened to a friend and I have no reason to doubt his version of the story.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ycombinete on Thursday March 25, 2021 @12:12PM (#26582038)
It certainly didn’t help at all! But that’s okay, there was a lot of discussion around it. I th
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:55PM (#26543402)
Consider that you are only hearing one side of the story and taking it entirely at face value.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by cogman10 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:06PM (#26543548)
I mean... what could the other side of the story actually be?

"We tried to hire back an employee to build something that we didn't train or try and figure out ourselves and a deadline forced us to pay a large lump sum to that employee".

No matter how you slice it, that's really shitty planning on the businesses side. They should have spent the time and money learning how to maintain their shit. By not doing it, they paid a huge price.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by perl4ever on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:38PM (#26549461)
The other side of the story is it's fake, fake, fake. But it's a nice story.

Every negotiation is about the best alternative the parties have, and it's generally harder in real life than in fantasy because you underestimate the alternatives to a deal.

Applying maximum leverage has a way of creating "out of the box" alternatives. And vindictiveness.

I have no need to judge it if it were true.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by gambiting on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:09PM (#26543597)
I imagine if it came down to it they could try to pin it on him and say he didn't provide documentation he said he did, and that's why this entire 10M project now can't be delivered.

Luckily for him they decided it's easier to just pay the fee.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by cogman10 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:12PM (#26543636)
Even if he was a shitty employee that doesn't obligate him to work for a price favorable to the company. Hell, they could have fired him for not documenting shit.

Because here's the thing, even with how weak US labor laws are, one thing they don't allow is for a company to come back and sue your for incompetence. So long as they didn't go out of their way to sabotage things, they are free and clear.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by nimih on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:12PM (#26544488)
Even if they did "pin it on him," why should he care, exactly? Seems to me like he had no obligations here, contractual, ethical, or otherwise.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by gambiting on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:13PM (#26545366)
Well because if he was taken to court that costs time and money, even if ultimately the lawsuit fails, no?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Sebb767 on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @11:37AM (#26556271)
A bit late to the party, but even when threatening with insolvency-via-lawsuit, this would probably not work for them:

- if he can prove the threat, the company will be in an even worse position

- given the rather lacking precedent (as pointed out by the sister comment), there's a good chance the suit would be thrown out pre-court and therefore be rather cheap

- given that the OP seems to be a valued engineer, it is reasonable to assume that he has the f-you-money to fight this out

- even if won, the drawn out battle would take far too long to fix the software in time and, given that they then lost a 10 million contract, they lack the motivation (and maybe money) to continue

- lastly, even if they won after loosing the contract, they'd probably not be able to extract much in damage payments

So it's a rather empty threat.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by nimih on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:43PM (#26549508)
Maybe this is my naivety showing, but to my knowledge it's not a common occurrence for companies to sue employees for refusing to work for them, especially if (as the OP notes elsewhere in the thread) there's no actual contractual obligation.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by bigiain on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:12AM (#26551645)
> for companies to sue employees for refusing to work for them

Especially ex-employees who've been gone 6 months already.

Shouldn't be hard to find a no win no fee ambulance chaser to happily take them on and get costs awarded and damages as well...

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by notyourday on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:45PM (#26544992)
That won't work in most reasonable countries. A company that is no longer employs someone cannot make that person work. In the situations similar to the ones that are being described, the time is not on the side of the company - they have a dead line, a former employees does not.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by sideshowb on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:55PM (#26544226)
Op says he did provide documentation but they lost it (and hadn't been backing up) after he left
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by gambiting on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:04PM (#26544365)
Of course, but that wouldn't stop them from saying otherwise, suing and binding him in prelonged and expensive legal battle, would it?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by notyourday on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:47PM (#26545028)
Lawsuits come with discovery. Discovery is a terrible thing for a plaintiff that lies in the lawsuit.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by derefr on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:05PM (#26545281)
We're talking about who's morally in the wrong here, not whether it's a good idea to do this.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by mercer on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @10:40AM (#26555594)
The person you're responding to doesn't seem to place moral considerations high on his list, in general.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by gambiting on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @03:31PM (#26559318)
I don't know why you'd make such an assumption about me, please expand.

I think in general all of my comments on this thread have been horribly misunderstood - I was just trying to say that if the company was scummy, instead of paying him the 250k fee, they probably could have sued him instead. I'm not saying that should have done, I'm not saying it would have been the right thing to do, that he deserved it.....literally nothing of the sort. Just pointing out that the company could have made an argument against him in court. As many other people pointed out to me, it would have almost certainly failed. But I don't understand how you can deduct where moral considerations are on my priority list from this?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ptero on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:55PM (#26547785)
This seems absolutely unrealistic to me. Can you find a precedent? A single precedent of the company suing an engineer (individual contributor, not a manager) for quality of work after he left? I think if they tried they would have been laughed out of court; and out of all their future contracts, too.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by bananabreakfast on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:53PM (#26547769)
sure it does. the company would have to prove malicious intent beyond a reasonable doubt and not leaving adequate documentation absolutely does not meet that requirement.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by hharlequin on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:06PM (#26547055)
I think enough of us have been on the same side of this story that we feel fairly comfortable taking it at face value, even if we're only applying it to said personal experience in a wishful fashion.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:41PM (#26548346)
Yeah, HN at it's finest I suppose. He's like you, he says what you want to hear, therefore you believe him. No need to consider the possibility that maybe there might actually be another point-of-view.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by orestarod on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:53PM (#26558770)
The point of view of managers and business owners is well known. Work is not a new concept. You get what you pay for. Nothing is owed to you. Work? Tough luck, you have to pay for it too. On a free market, no less. I don't understand why business owners think the rules are different for them than the rest.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @09:26AM (#26566879)
Straw man what I'm saying, sure, very HN of you.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by DubiousPusher on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:54PM (#26543376)
This is not extortion. The company made choices that left significant leverage in the hands of another business. That business correctly perceived the value of the services it could render and priced them accordingly.

This is exactly the free market at work regarding labor. Have a problem with the free market if you like, many of us do but do not accuse this poster of criminal action equivalent to a protection racket.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by johnchristopher on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:45PM (#26548408)
What's the rationale for doubling the first price ? Why is it a more fair price ?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by DubiousPusher on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:54PM (#26548520)
The market answer to that is, the seller underpriced their services to begin with, regardless of the personal motivation for increasing the price.

To clarify, the market would likely not allow this specific work to be sold at this price normally. But the buyer wasn't just buying specific work they were buying specific work to be completed by a specific date. The work in isolation does not have this value but the work completed by a certain day does. Companies use this rationale all the time charging more for expedited services.

It's especially common in construction and manufacturing where costs double or even triple when expedited delivery is required.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by johnchristopher on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:22PM (#26548830)
Bullshit.

The way the story is told the price doubled after and because of the CEO screaming.

The market has nothing to do with that except the good old "The fair price is the one that god paid, uh.” I suppose.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by DubiousPusher on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:50PM (#26549098)
"Everything is worth what its purchaser will pay for it." That includes labor. The business was free to try and renegotiate their contract with their customer. They were free to delay the release and offer a discount. They were free to turn down the 125k and the 250k payment on principle and deal with the consequences. They found the most economical solution that met their needs was to pay $250,000 to have the work done on time. Was this poster engaging in rent seeking behavior? Absolutely. But that is a consequence of the market and one companies exploit to their own benefit all the time.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by johnchristopher on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @10:11AM (#26555210)
> They found the most economical solution that met their needs was to pay $250,000 to have the work done on time.

I'd be inclined to believe that if there were some other providers but as it is told working with OP was the only solution. And OP's first offer was 125 000. Two screams later it's 250 000 ? It has nothing to do with economical theory or free market interpretation.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by orestarod on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:58PM (#26558868)
First, he owed no-one anything. He could set the price to 1 billion for all he cared. His former employees could take it or leave it.

Second, you speak as if his claims were irrational. The way I see it, however, you would set for 125k (probably much less judging from what you write) while he, the sentimental fool, scooped up double the money. Therefore, your decisions, which you personally claim are rational, would have left you with half the money the "irrational" player would get. Seems to me, the "irrational" is actually the rational one, as he netted more profits. Economy and market are not math games in a vacuum, and players are not formless ideas.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by johnchristopher on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @03:34PM (#26559353)
> Second, you speak as if his claims were irrational. The way I see it, however, you would set for 125k (probably much less judging from what you write) while he, the sentimental fool, scooped up double the money. Therefore, your decisions, which you personally claim are rational,

The way I see it you are putting words in my mouth and I am definitely not interested in having a discussion like that.

I never insinuated OP was a sentimental fool or wrong to raise the price. I am calling bullshit on the free market and econ 101 as an explanation of why the price got doubled and call it like it is: it's payback from OP because they were dicks to him first, everything else is pedantry and useless justifications.

edit: if anything, OP could be considered a fool since he obviously gave an under the market quote as his first proposal. Had he started with 250K from the beginning he would have gotten more since there likely would have been screams anyway and he would have risen the price all the same.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by DubiousPusher on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @09:30PM (#26575515)
No one said the free market is "why" the price got doubled. Emo drama ended up being the mechanism of price discovery here. But the market accepted this price. It was not a swindle. It was free trade.

And yes. I completely agree with your edit and said as much elsewhere. Their acceptance of 250K showed that the OP under-priced their services at 125K.

And yes. Free markets produce monopolies. Especially when time is important. As I said above, the critical good here was not the delivery but the delivery within a certain time.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by cutemonster on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:50PM (#26557156)
I think 250 was likely under market value, and the seller could have raise the price more.

And yelling, made the prise jump closer to market value.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by johnchristopher on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:16PM (#26557438)
Maybe, maybe not.

I find this explanation (from top comment) more in line with how the world spins:

> If they left under bad terms because the business was a bunch of dicks, expect to pay 10x market rate. If this is truly "fix this or the business is out of business" - then it shouldn't be a tough decision to make.

So, “being a dick” has more to do with price raising than any free market justification (which I am okay with, just don't try to convince me it's the only thing at play. The offer would have been 250k from the beginning then. Or 500K to get 250K, whatever.).

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by nate_meurer on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:16PM (#26558269)
This is such a silly and mundane bit of pedantry you're harping on here. Of course there are emotional factors in price discovery-- it happens all the time, and is a completely natural and rational part of the free market.

Any small or independent contractor in any business will eventually have a blacklist, or a list of troublesome customers who get charged extra. Most of my contractors charge me less because they like me (and I pay on time). My HVAC contractor charges a particular customer double just because the customer is a rich entitled asshole; the contractor has decided that it's only worth dealing with the man's unpleasantness if there's more money to be made. Apparently the man has been blacklisted by other HVAC companies, so he might be in a tight spot, but whatever the reason, he ends up paying a lot more money for the same service.

This is a completely market-based mechanism: the troublesome customer has limited options (in this case, maybe only one option), and is thus obviously disadvantaged in negotiating price. Regardless of the myriad motivations involved in price discovery, it all leads to the same place: if the price wasn't worth the service the customer was to receive, they would not have paid it.

Honestly, this isn't mysterious or profound. It's economics 101.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by johnchristopher on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @03:41PM (#26559434)
> Honestly, this isn't mysterious or profound.

Yes.

> It's economics 101.

Not even that. It's payback, that's all it is. There's no need to call for a more elaborate explanation for what was at play here. Not that I disagree with it. It's humane nature.

> My HVAC contractor charges a particular customer double just because the customer is a rich entitled asshole;

Like you say. No need to even know about market dynamics to (wisely) choose that option. Because the other guy is an asshole.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by nate_meurer on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:18PM (#26549790)
> "The fair price is the one that god paid, uh.”

This is literally the definition of price discovery in a free market. If the price was not worth the service the company was to receive, they would not have paid it.

The fact that they did pay it clearly indicates that the first price was far below what the "market" would bear.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by anonAndOn on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:00AM (#26551301)
He probably even left money on the table. When you need The Wolf to come clean up your mess, The Wolf gets paid well to do so.[0]

[0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ojTKkfgvwvU

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by cutemonster on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:54PM (#26557205)
> left money on the table

I think so too, however maybe better play safe I guess, and be content with 250? The negotiation partner seemed a bit irrational to me

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jodrellblank on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @01:39PM (#26570467)
"The market" has nothing to do with that because one single trade isn't a market; if you and I exchange 1g of gold for $1000 that doesn't say "gold is fairly priced at $1000/gram". If many people exchange gold for money, each with different information and desires, over time the gold will go to the people who pay more, sellers will generally trend their sale price down because higher prices won't get buyers, buyers will trend their buying price up because lower offers won't get accepted, and a range of "price gold is being traded at" values emerge, the spread of those values highest to lowest narrows and hones in on, and tracks a dynamic "price of gold" where it's "fairly traded" - not fair in some Deity decreed way, but fair in that if you trade at close to that price, you aren't buying unusually high or selling unusually low, you're getting no better or worse deal than anyone else, so it's not unfair in your favour or unfair against you, so if it's not unfair then it must be fair - you couldn't get a significantly better trade with anyone else.

Anything distorting those conditions - e.g. there's only one seller, only one buyer, a time constraint, a skill constraint, an information disadvantage, will distort the pricing as well. One trade isn't enough information for a market to exist or to settle on a fair price. I agree there that the market has nothing to do with it.

But I disagree with your implication of "the fair price is the one paid" is somehow unfair in an ethical sense. (I also think OP is in no way obliged to be "fair" in any ethical sense to the company, but that's another matter). The company got a $10M contract for $250k, versus losing the contract, is that unfair? If that really was the pivotal factor between losing the contract and not, the company ought to benefit by spending right up to the point where the contract becomes a money loser, to not lose it. Would it be unfair for the company to get an $8M contract by paying $2M? Or a $2M contract by paying $8M? Is OP obliged to help the company make as much profit on the contract as they can, by charging them less for his services?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by DubiousPusher on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @09:41PM (#26575603)
> Anything distorting those conditions - e.g. there's only one seller, only one buyer, a time constraint, a skill constraint, an information disadvantage, will distort the pricing as well. One trade isn't enough information for a market to exist or to settle on a fair price. I agree there that the market has nothing to do with it.

This is non-sense. Those conditions specifically define a market and make it distinct from any other. To say a market with any of these constraints is "distorted" is to say all markets are distorted and render the term meaningless.

Also, I never said this one trade signified a market. My point was that this is a consequence of free markets. You can make any single trade "irrelevant" by choosing arbitrary criteria by which to separate it from its market. The company could have certainly hired another engineer in hopes they could complete the work in time while running the risk of blowing the deadline. But it was freely and fairly worth at least 250k to them to guarantee the job could be done correctly and on time.

This kind of thing is such a common part of the free market, that there is a whole aspect of contract law that pertains to ensuring companies don't get into this position. It's why contracting completed work is so important. Leaving things partly done leaves you vulnerable to others eating right up to the tiniest margin of your profit.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jessaustin on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:48PM (#26549542)
Time was a factor. Negotiations in such a situation waste time. Doubling the price associated the cost of wasted time with additional negotiation in a tangible way. In clarifying the situation, thread parent was really helping that former employer. Had that clarification not occurred, the contract might might have been signed too late.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by sufehmi on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:00PM (#26543469)
"extorted"

This is pure slander

The company can avoid this if they only care to maintain the documentation / wiki left behind by said person

When they failed to do even just basic proper operations, it's their own fault.

I'm a business owner and a consultant, and I too charge more for these kind of asshole clients, because of the extra stress.

But nowadays I just try to avoid them, it's just too damaging for your own sanity. Their kind of stupidity, self-entitlement, and ignorance is on a completely different level.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by dctoedt on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:49PM (#26544139)
> This is pure slander

<pedantry>It's libel (written) not slander (oral); "defamation" is the generic noun. </pedantry>

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by doodpants on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:39PM (#26544902)
Does libel magically turn into slander if a blind person uses a screen reader? Asking for a friend. ;-)
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by gota on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:13PM (#26545372)
Your comment made me curious and I checked - it is not the physical channel that matters, it is whether the media is _transient_ or not.

It seems that paying to skywrite (you know, small plane making artificial clouds) could be slander but not libel

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by dctoedt on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:22PM (#26545476)
> whether the media is _transient_ or not

Citation? By that light, a DVD containing defamatory speech would be libelous, but that's generally not how courts see it.

From the (highly-influential) U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, summarizing New York law (which is quite typical): "Defamation, consisting of the twin torts of libel and slander, is the invasion of the interest in a reputation and good name. Generally, spoken defamatory words are slander; written defamatory words are libel. Libel is a method of defamation expressed in writing or print." [0]

https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=601727562995661...

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by mijoharas on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @06:35AM (#26553319)
There is also "calumny", which is the action of slandering someone (and I assume also making writing libellous statements. After writing that parenthetical, I just googled, and libel is also a verb. So I guess I can say libelling someone)
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by emayljames on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:15PM (#26545391)
What about the other way, subtitles.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by BlargMcLarg on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:01PM (#26543488)
Business is business. The right to fire people, deny them raises and form binding contracts in regards to their work comes at a price. GP did not act malicious, rather, they acted in the same self-interest most bosses, CEOs and companies act while trying to stand on the moral high ground.

Coding standards, documentation requirements, meetings and code reviews exist for a reason, too. It's not like companies are defenseless.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by tcoff91 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:10PM (#26543608)
The fact that you'd refer to this as extortion makes me sick. The management/capital class loves the free market except for when it applies to labor, then suddenly it's extortion when supply and demand don't work in your favor.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by snerbles on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:02PM (#26543501)
The employee documented everything, but said documentation was not backed up by the company. Furthermore, the company did not train or hire an adequate replacement for said employee for _six months_.

This is a gross failure of leadership at the company, and the former employee has every right to negotiate compensation for the inconvenience of having to work for them again.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by woofcat on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:54PM (#26543388)
How is it extortion? If you need 1 resource in the whole world, the supply is 1. If your demand is great then you get to pay the price.

This person left the company, and documented everything. What should they do, come in and save the day for $15/hr?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by leesalminen on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:44PM (#26544978)
I owned a small company. After selling it, and giving 2+ more years of my life for the new owners to figure out how to replace me, they didn’t. On my last day I told them that if they ever needed anything my rate is $5,000/day, non negotiable. It’s kept them at bay for now. I have no ethical qualms with my decision. It’s business.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by vagrantJin on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:30PM (#26545584)
I see and understand your sentiment but, in my rather insignificant few years in the workforce - carrots, dipped in vanilla chocolate and honey, generally tend to work better than the stick.

The company could have apologised, and do a lot more ego stroking before asking a favour which they can pay for and maybe throw in an all expenses paid weekend with the SO as a thank you. Not only will you get goodwill but future problems are going to be significantly cheaper to solve. Even if you have a bad break up - as a business owner you should understand the value of mending bridges. It's cheaper than losing sleep at night and losing your steak dinner to a bad stomach.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by exikyut on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:56PM (#26543424)
"Lack of planning on your part does not constitute an emergency on my par--wait did you say $250,000?"

If your company were in the hands of incompetents, but still kept going in spite of the incompetents because it had gotten its foot wedged in the door or whatever, and then fell apart in ways you could only scorn, how would you view that sort of situation?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by zentiggr on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:45PM (#26544998)
Sounds like your best next step is to become an exemple of software/infrastructure best practices - get everything in the best backup/recovery solution you can, document every detail any time an issue comes up, and above all treat your people like the vaaluable assets they can be.

You may be doing any of that already, since I don't know anything about you except your one comment.

But the answer to your fear of exploitation is avoid making people hate you/your environment enough to want to protect themselves from it.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by 1123581321 on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:54PM (#26543389)
It's a fair fee for such valuable work done for an apparently abusive, and possibly litigious, company.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by OneLeggedCat on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:30PM (#26545583)
Hopefully you wouldn't mismanage your own company and treat your employees like shit. Probably you are a better person than that, and can avoid this ever happening to you.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by acheron on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:10PM (#26545334)
You're terrified that you might treat your employees so badly that you would need to pay a lot to resolve a situation? Seems like that's entirely within your control.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by orestarod on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:50PM (#26558733)
You forget it's all part of business. If you hired an external contractor you would not say a word for demanding their money. And the price of the contractor grows by a lot relative to how much and how soon you need their work. Remember, you need their help, not the other way around. A contractor on bad terms with you would not help at all. How is a former employee any different? Do you think you become family after paying for their work?

If you do not have the money to pa for someone's services you cannot complain. You say you have a company? Have you ever let a client get your products by paying less than their value or nothing at all? Work itself is a product too.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by burnte on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:13PM (#26544511)
Then treat your employees better and adhere to best practices and you won't be subject to such "extortion". Once we have elft yoru company, especailly if it was because we were treated poorly, we are under NO compulsion to help you for free. If the idea of paying 1.25% of the value of a deal to make sure the deal happens seems excessive, you're greedy, and that's why his price went to 2.5%.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Bud on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:37PM (#26544871)
You seem very confused about what "extortion" means, and also about what "psychopathic" means. So I'd suggest starting there.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by yowlingcat on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:29PM (#26544757)
The idea of /you/ mismanaging your company in such a "blasé and psychopathic fashion" is more what should terrify you. Remember, /you/ manage a small company, not the person you hire. If you end up in such a mismanaged position, the manager who let it get there is you, not the employee.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by bitcharmer on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:26PM (#26543794)
Extortion? Wow, you have no idea what you're talking about. Good luck with that attitude.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by arethuza on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:09PM (#26543603)
That's not extortion, simply hard-nosed commercial negotiation.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by xupybd on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:39PM (#26549954)
I hear what you are saying, but it's a bad place to be in when one person can be so critical they can charge that much for four days work.

I feel for them but they failed to protect themselves.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by klibertp on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:52PM (#26545087)
I think this is just flamebait. Uses emotionally charged words without any other substance. Both the comment and responses to it (including this one) add nothing to the discussion.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by 908B64B197 on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:13PM (#26548735)
It's not extorsion.

He left detailed instructions how to release the software. The company managed to screw up so bad they lost the manual he made sure to write on their internal wiki.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by rangerelf on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:55PM (#26544227)
> ...I manage a small company...

And you identify with this band of miscreants? That's embarrassing.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by whatever1 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:58PM (#26544283)
Thinking about business continuity is literally your job. Not your engineers’ job.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by nextaccountic on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:46AM (#26551826)
Extorted? If you didn't like his rate, just hire someone else. Or do the coding yourself.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by heterodoxxed on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:28PM (#26543823)
Have you tried learning to code?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by thrower123 on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:10PM (#26545337)
In this situation, you could always just tell the former employer to take a flying fuck at a rolling donut, and not respond to them.

That's probably what they deserve, if they come asking for a favor and then start getting abusive.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Udo on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @06:40AM (#26553356)
I know this sounds like an empowering story, and it may even be true, but don't actually follow this example. If you're at the point where they'd rather send you legal threats than pay you, even escrow is not going to help you much. The escrow process may force them to pay, but there is no guarantee you'll be able to keep that money if they really decide to go after you.

People like that would much rather spend $2.5M on courts and lawyers than let a worker walk home with 250k, or even 25k. Agreeing to a deal like this is an incredible minefield that may blow up on you even years later.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by SteveNuts on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:32PM (#26543091)
What did their legal letters try to pin on you? Did they try to say you were somehow legally required to help them?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by throwthescene on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:36PM (#26543163)
The letters stated that I had a contractual obligation to assist. But I noticed at the top they were stamped 'without prejudice'. I asked my friend what that meant, and he said that technically it's not a legal letter - so I ignored them.

For a while, I made it game to light the various communications on fire in interesting ways, but it got boring.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by egorfine on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:54PM (#26545114)
> I had a contractual obligation to assist

Did they have a legal reason to think so?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by rolobio on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:55PM (#26543404)
Why a check with your lawyers? Why not just deposit into your personal account?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by bityard on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:02PM (#26543500)
Look up what "escrow" is. When 1/4 million dollars is on the line, you don't take the company's word that they'll pay you afterward, and they don't take your word for it that you'll actually deliver the service.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Aloha on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:36PM (#26544846)
1/8th of a million.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by brobinson on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:45PM (#26544991)
Last time I checked, $250,000 was 1/4 of one million dollars.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Aloha on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:43PM (#26545785)
Oops, I missed the last part of the paragraph where he raised the price.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ghgdynb1 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:00PM (#26543467)
The idea is that you want a trusted third party because either of the two adversarial parties could screw the other over.

The company could say: we’re going to pay you 125 and you could sue us and spend 60k and two years or just settle for that, after he’s already done the work.

The guy could demand the payment directly to his account and then not deliver, and the firm would be in the same situation.

By depositing the funds in escrow, they’re making sure that the money is there and in the hands of people whose only incentive is to give it to the correct party upon fulfillment of the contract.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by andyv on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:28PM (#26543819)
With the check held in escrow, it makes cheating harder.

The contractor knows that the money has been paid by the company and won't be withheld after the job is done.

The company knows that the contractor doesn't have the money until the job is done.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by dqpb on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:01PM (#26543486)
It went into an escrow account, presumably until he completed the work
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by OneLeggedCat on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:29PM (#26545567)
This is the most beautiful thing I've read today. Thank you.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by m-p-3 on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:07PM (#26545298)
Damn, I'd pay a good part of my mortgage in 4 days with that. You played your cards well.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by toyg on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:35PM (#26545673)
“A good part”? Lol, I’d pay it all and have enough spare to buy a midrange car...
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by acejam on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:47PM (#26545020)
This is my dream. Is that bad?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by deevolution on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:18PM (#26545423)
Absolute chad badassery
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by drclau on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:20AM (#26540380)
Not really related to the subject of the article, but your comment reminds me of employers in Romania complaining they can't find people to hire, while they offer small salaries and people just leave the country for better paying jobs abroad. The solution to their problem is really simple: make better offers.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by NewLogic on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:41AM (#26540641)
The exact same thing is happening in Australia in regards to farmers and fruit picking labour. With international borders shut they are unable to exploit foreign workers and complain that young adults are refusing to relocate for $5 an hour hard labour jobs.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by wing-_-nuts on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:30AM (#26542222)
Here in america farmers hire illegals to harvest crops, claiming that no american would do the work. This has always struck me as a really terrible excuse. I'm sorry, you can't simply break the law because you'd have to pay an american $20 / hr to do the work. Sure, it means that your tomatoes are more expensive, but also, now there's a hell of an incentive to apply automation to the problem yes? If you don't like the law, maybe pressure your representatives to reform immigration instead of just hoping everyone turns a blind eye to your exploitation.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by reaperducer on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:52PM (#26543359)
Here in america farmers hire illegals to harvest crops, claiming that no american would do the work

This is a political talking point that has been repeated so often that people believe it is true.

During the recession of 2008, there were stores on local TV news in many places showing unemployed Americans waiting in long lines for the opportunity do do those jobs that the politicians kept saying no American wanted to do for those wages. Meatpacking plants, especially, had more than enough Americans to choose from who were willing to work for low wages.

Because these things happened in "flyover" states, they were only very rarely shown on television on the coasts, and so the meme stuck.

A similar oft-repeated lie is that American farmers are all a bunch of Republican hillbillies who hate brown immigrants.

Around 2010, I attended a conference in Seattle for farmers in the Pacific Northwest. The main topic of discussion was how to increase legal immigration from Mexico so that they could have more farmworkers to pick the cherries and apples and mint and whatnot. These people were talking about goals of making people from Mexico and Latin America U.S. citizens in staggering numbers.

The more you actually go places and do things and meet people and talk to them, the more you realize that the words coming out of the political organizations on the coasts are mostly for their own benefit, and do not reflect reality.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by fredophile on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:40PM (#26544924)
I don't think your points really contradict your first statement. First, people tend to drop their standards on the type of work they're willing to do and pay they'll accept when they're desperate. In 2008 a lot of people needed a job. Any job was better than no job. I'm not surprised that jobs that would normally be unpopular had lines of people applying at that time.

Your second point about farmers trying to increase legal immigration in 2010 clearly indicates most Americans won't regularly do this work for the wages being offered. Why else would farmers be looking to hire immigrant workers just 2 years after locals were lining up to get these jobs?

While it would be nice if there was a way to get enough immigrants working legally to fill those jobs that doesn't seem to have happened. Short of another large economic downturn I don't see Americans working those jobs either. That leaves people who are working in the US illegally to fill the gap.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by 908B64B197 on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:14PM (#26548753)
> A similar oft-repeated lie is that American farmers are all a bunch of Republican hillbillies who hate brown immigrants.

> Around 2010, I attended a conference in Seattle for farmers in the Pacific Northwest. The main topic of discussion was how to increase legal immigration from Mexico so that they could have more farmworkers to pick the cherries and apples and mint and whatnot. These people were talking about goals of making people from Mexico and Latin America U.S. citizens in staggering numbers.

Farmers are, for the most part, single issue voters: Whoever has the best plan to support agriculture and small businesses gets their vote.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by perl4ever on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:56PM (#26549604)
>Because these things happened in "flyover" states, they were only very rarely shown on television on the coasts, and so the meme stuck.

How do you determine from TV that the people lining up for meatpacking jobs were not undocumented immigrants?

Like, it is generally accepted there aren't any in "flyover states" or something?

I never really thought of it until this moment, but you know how within 100 miles of any border, your constitutional rights are somewhat compromised so DHS can operate? That ought to mean a pretty substantial incentive for people who are undocumented to migrate inward. So I would bet they do.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jbroson on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:37PM (#26543941)
My somewhat educated guess is that these farmers in the PNW don't share the same politics as farmers in the rural south or midwest.

That and Republicans have grown way more hostile to immigration since 2010, so it's an interesting anecdote but not sure how well it translates across the US, where polling shows farmers are overwhelmingly Republican who tend also tend to hate immigration legal or not.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by reaperducer on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:21PM (#26544640)
My somewhat educated guess is that these farmers in the PNW don't share the same politics as farmers in the rural south or midwest

When you say it's an "educated" guess, educated how? It only seems to reflect the usual bigotry that comes out of the coasts.

polling shows farmers are overwhelmingly Republican who tend also tend to hate immigration legal or not

If you're going to make a statement that sweeping, you really should back it up with credible sources.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jbroson on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:28PM (#26571158)
"When you say it's an "educated" guess, educated how? It only seems to reflect the usual bigotry that comes out of the coasts."

I lived first 28 years of my life in the rural south and now live in the midwest.

My entire family and most of my friends growing up are the people you claim I'm bigoted against...

"If you're going to make a statement that sweeping, you really should back it up with credible sources."

The fact that farmers are generally far more conservative and republican than the median voter or average American isn't exactly some shocking new insight.

You seem to have never spent much time around these folks or have done much research on them if this comes as a surprise to you.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/06/03/why-y...

Are these just bigoted facts "out of the coasts" too:?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by enriquec on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:07PM (#26544402)
"where polling shows farmers are overwhelmingly Republican who tend also tend to hate immigration legal or not."

source?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jbroson on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:29PM (#26571170)
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by enriquec on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @05:57PM (#26653659)
so no, no source. cool
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by FireBeyond on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:41AM (#26542389)
A couple of years ago, a serial offender food producer was raided, multiple times. 600+ undocumented workers were found, and all spoke of management knowing their status.

The workers were detained, deported, and so on.

After several raids, not so much as a misdemeanor was levied against a single person, nor a fine to the company in general.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by aaron-santos on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:52AM (#26542537)
Kind of makes me think, what's the point when these laws aren't actually enforced?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by abxytg on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:33PM (#26543105)
The point is to punish and cause pain to the immigrants. Regardless of the original justification of a system, the point of a system is what it does or will do. That is what this system does and will do unless changed.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by HarryHirsch on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:29PM (#26543830)
"For my friends, everything. For my enemies, the law." Getúlio Vargas had it all worked out.
[dead]
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by perl4ever on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:22PM (#26549823)
I don't know anything about it, but from the Des Moines Register, it seems like a lot of people felt there was a miscarriage of justice:

"There was false testimony and willful manipulation, and that makes this a shocking case of prosecutorial misconduct."

"An unprecedented letter, recently sent to Kevin Techau, U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Iowa, signed by 107 former high level Department of Justice officials, FBI directors, federal judges and prestigious law professors attests to the extraordinary prosecutorial misconduct which exacted the most possible punitive sentence for Rubashkin"

https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/opinion/columnists/i...

Trump commuted Sholom's sentence in 2017, apparently.

I'd suggest a different phrase than "prominent Jews"; the family are "ultra-Orthodox Jews of the Lubavitcher hasidic movement" not representatives of some sort of Jewish privilege in general.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Animats on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:17PM (#26546309)
About half of US hired farmworkers are illegal immigrants, says the U.S. Department of Agriculture.[1] It was only 12% in 1991, but passed 50% by 2000.

[1] https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/farm-economy/farm-labor

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by lisper on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:30PM (#26543068)
> reform immigration

That's easier said than done. The problem is that in order to reform immigration you have to do one of two things:

1. Start treating people fairly, with the result being higher food prices, which will make some of your constituents very unhhappy

2. Codify the current class structure into law so that you can continue to exploit cheap labor legally. The optics on that are really bad.

Exploiting people off the books is the path of least resistance for everyone, including the workers (manifestly so, or they wouldn't risk life and limb to be here).

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by greeneggs on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:53AM (#26542554)
Of course it isn't that simple. If your farm's tomatoes are more expensive than your neighbors' tomatoes, then nobody will buy them. You'll quickly go bankrupt.

It is also difficult because of the two tiers of labor. A farmer will try increasing wages by $1/hour, and still struggle to find enough workers. Wages would probably have to be doubled before new workers—Americans—would start to enter the industry.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jandrese on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:44PM (#26543255)
This is the reason tariffs exist. You levy a fee that makes the imported food cost as much as food picked using domestic labor.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by mixedCase on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:26PM (#26545522)
Or, you know, you let unprofitable endeavors be substituted by profitable ones, and you just import food from different places where it is profitable. Just make sure not to wage war with them all. That's always an alternative to subsidies and tariffs, but it's not as politically useful.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jandrese on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:50PM (#26547717)
This is how the US gave up its ability to manufacture so many goods.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by mixedCase on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:38PM (#26550384)
"gave up" sounds like an unnecessarily ominous take on "delegate". But what's your exact point? Do you believe this is an irremediable situation or that know-how has been lost to time in the age of information?

I'm assuming you're implying a conversation about China and their manufacturing capabilities. But worst case scenario short of nuclear war, assuming US-China burns bridges and somehow for some reason now US is fully unable to import Chinese manufactured goods; how does this eliminate the US and all other countries from investing in an area that has now become more profitable? You could argue that prices would increase, but then again you aren't owed cheap manufacturing, and subsidies and tariffs are paid by either the taxpayer or the consumer (which tends to have a knock-off effect on the rest of economy, anyway). There was never a free lunch.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by yellowapple on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:10PM (#26549260)
It's also in general how we end up with monopolies. Well-funded companies operating at a loss until they're the only noteworthy players ain't exactly unheard of.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by colinmhayes on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:32PM (#26543093)
If farmers paid enough to get Americans to do seasonal farm labor their produce would cost twice as much as central/south American produce and they would immediately go out of business as everyone buys cheap imported fruit.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by nitrogen on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:42PM (#26543224)
A labor-protectionist strategy has to be paired with a goods-protectionist strategy (tariffs or bans on imports).
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by rjmunro on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:49PM (#26543329)
You can fix this with import duties. If the country you are importing from doesn't have good labor laws, you charge them 100% extra.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by colinmhayes on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:56PM (#26543418)
People get really pissed off when food gets more expensive. Politicians realize that and will therefore never pass legislation that would cause such drastic price increases on food.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by wing-_-nuts on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:23PM (#26545485)
If they enforced the laws already on the books, they'd have to pass new laws to fix things. I see that as a net positive. If you selectively enforce against illegal immigrants, well, that's very much a 'rules for thee, not for me' situation isn't it?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by pg_bot on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:28PM (#26545550)
Now everyone is poorer.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by renox on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:14PM (#26549289)
This kind of reasoning can be used to justify slavery..
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by colinmhayes on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @07:18PM (#26561618)
Except giving someone a job isn't slavery... it's actually the complete opposite.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by freen on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:45PM (#26543269)
Sounds like they don’t have a business, and should shut down.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by scruple on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:22AM (#26542116)
> complain that young adults are refusing to relocate for $5 an hour hard labour jobs.

USD $5/hour is what I earned as a teenager working the fields by hand (picking corn, beans, and fruit for sale same-day at the farmers small stands throughout the area) in the early 1990s... That's insane. Is that USD $5 or AD?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ballenf on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:41AM (#26542383)
I think people will one day demand higher pay for desk jobs over outdoor work. Looking back on my early life, the hard outdoor work was incredibly valuable to me. Desk jobs sometimes were soul-sucking, depression inducing. Not always and my dev work now is desk work that doesn't suck.

Now, outdoor work with a high injury rate is a different story.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by shakna on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:21PM (#26549341)
That's in AUD.

What I've seen first-hand in some farming communities was closer to $10AUD/hr, but that is still far below our actual minimum wage of $19.84AUD/hr.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by AdmiralGinge on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:26PM (#26545524)
Sounds like exactly the same problem British farmers are having post-Brexit with things like fruit-picking, they're scratching their heads wondering why British workers aren't keen on having half their wages taken for "rent" to live six people to a crappy caravan on-site and do backbreaking labour day in day out. Their only choices are to improve their wages, conditions, both, or go bankrupt.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by kolbe on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:56AM (#26540815)
Farming is low margin. Farmers don’t get to set the price of their products, and they aren’t handed billions in capital to burn through or 1000x multiples on their profit in the public markets. When most businesses say they can’t hire someone and the reason is because they don’t pay enough, the underlying cause of their low pay is usually because that’s what the company can afford.

Sure, farmers could pay $10/hr, but unless your Doritos were $10 a bag, they’d lose money.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by WJW on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:03AM (#26540904)
...yes? The alternative to farmers is not harvesting their crops at all, since with the borders closed foreign labor is not available.

If nobody wants to buy $10 doritos, that means the product can't exist in a market without cheap labor.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by antihero on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:11AM (#26541018)
Well perhaps that's the problem of the market. That it can't particularly function to enrich some people without gross levels of exploitation.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by kipchak on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:16PM (#26542868)
To me it always seemed a bit similar to justifications used for the "peculiar institution" - the system can't exist without slavery, therefore slavery must exist. The benefits of cheaper labor was well appreciated; Carnegie called immigration "the golden stream which flows into the country every year."[1]

[1]https://www.ebooksread.com/authors-eng/andrew-carnegie/trium...

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ihsw on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:44AM (#26542422)
Being paid $5/hour farming in Australia vs $0.50/hour assembling shoes in Malaysia. Wow, such exploitation.

"Exploitation" is a relative term, some people would rather be exploited in the countryside of a first-world nation rather than the countryside of their homeland.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by shakna on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:30PM (#26549406)
> Being paid $5/hour farming in Australia vs $0.50/hour assembling shoes in Malaysia. Wow, such exploitation.

The Australian national minimum wage is $19.84/hr.

Getting paid about a quarter of minimum wage is very clearly exploitation. There may be other benefits for actually working in Australia, but that's not really relevant here when you're trying to attract native Australians to work for you.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by stubish on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:48PM (#26550016)
In particular, when the wage is low enough you have slavery in all but name. People working for your shitty pay staying in your shitty dormitory eating your shitty food because they can't afford not. The end result people leaving when visas run out with more debt, and headlines about people forced to pick fruit in bikinis and allegations of sexual assault, because that happens when some people gain that sort of power.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by antihero on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:43PM (#26543239)
Yes, they are both exploitation and they are both evil.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jacobolus on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:16PM (#26544553)
Which is more exploitative, working for $5/hour in agriculture in a wealthy country, 50¢/hour in an urban factory in a poor country, or $1/day in a rural peasant village somewhere or having no work at all?

It’s all relative.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by riskable on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:45PM (#26544995)
That's a bit like asking, "Which is worse? A shot to the head or an overdose of morphine?" Either way the person's going to die.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by thrower123 on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:16PM (#26545397)
Doritos aren't going to get more expensive, because like all the real staple crops, corn is completely mechanized, and you have one guy driving an air-conditioned tractor or combine, following GPS-plotted courses.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by relaxing on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:14PM (#26542842)
True! Except it's not just doritos, it's everything you eat.

And it's not just cheap labor, it's labor exploited under pain of deportation.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by SilasX on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:13AM (#26541053)
Not sure that’s the best example to use, since food costs are a trivial fraction of the retail price of a bag of Doritos, and harvesting labor is a trivial fraction of the price of food.

Edit: that was just based on my general memory of non-perishable food economics. But I googled it and found this (sorry, quora) from someone who would know, a 2 oz bag of potato chips costs 15 cents to produce and bring to (retail) market. Of that, a fraction is potato prices.

https://www.quora.com/How-much-does-a-bag-of-57g-of-Lays-act...

Edit: fix Verizon math.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by raffraffraff on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:22AM (#26541216)
The reason I buy expensive eggs, milk and cheese is that I know that the supermarkets fuck over the farmers. I never buy the supermarket brand, unless it's the last one on the shelf. The price difference is sometimes 1.5x but unless you're really "broke" broke, you don't notice the difference. It's a few cents a week.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by solarkraft on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:42AM (#26541497)
Good idea, but how do you know the extra money is properly passed on?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by knightofmars on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:52AM (#26542542)
While, like most things in life, it's not a guarantee, doing basic research about the farms and the cooperatives that produce the goods will provide some insight. Almost anything is better than a CAFO (Concentrated animal feeding operation).
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by kbelder on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:05PM (#26542712)
I always buy the supermarket brand, even though I can easily afford more. It's not because I want to save a few pennies on each purchase; it's helping to drive prices down on all overpriced goods, helping out those really in need.

Same reason I avoid organic whenever possible. We don't need boutique food.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by cammikebrown on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:23PM (#26542976)
I agree much of the “benefits” of organic food are not really true or meaningful, but I do try and buy local when I can.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by jessaustin on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:02PM (#26549654)
That doesn't even make sense in neoclassical economics. One person's effects on the market are necessarily tiny, but if buying more of Brand X has any effect it will be to drive up the price of Brand X. You're actually harming "those really in need", and you should feel bad about it.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by csomar on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:24PM (#26542989)
> Farmers don’t get to set the price of their products

Actually farmers could set any price if they colluded to manipulate the market. People will buy food at any price and everyday.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by clipradiowallet on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:36PM (#26544861)
This is offset by imported food. If 100% of American farmers colluded to fix prices, they'd have their lunch eaten(hah) by food importers. Obviously not everything is importable(eg rice), but there is more to the market than the American farmers.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by anonAndOn on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:14AM (#26551362)
You're right, there is more to the market but not how you describe it. Tariffs are available to any American cartel willing to buy enough politicians. Take a look at sugar, for example. [0]

[0]https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/candy-coated-cartel-tim...

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by CydeWeys on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:32AM (#26541363)
People have to eat food. Food in aggregate has one of the most inelastic demand curves imaginable. If the price rises because the production costs increase, people will still buy food. They might buy different food, and you'll see a decrease in acreage given over to labor-intensive crops, but that's just the free market at work.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by smnrchrds on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:46AM (#26541554)
The thing is, if farmers in Australia increase wages and thus their product becomes more expensive, the product on supermarket shelves will not become more expensive. Rather, supermarkets will import food from another country. Food is, with few exceptions, a commodity. The producer does not set the price of the commodity, the market does.

I am telling this as an engineer working in the Canada's oil and gas sector. Since 2014, salaries in our sector have decreased and firms are struggling. "Just raise the price of oil" is not an actionable advice. The price of oil is not ours to set. It's the market's

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ksec on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:53AM (#26541682)
It just shows most people working in Tech Industry, and specifically software ( or web ) development ( as oppose to Tech / software within Oil Industry or any other industry ) have absolutely zero idea on market or commodity trading.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by wing-_-nuts on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:34AM (#26542279)
I consider food security a national security issue. Produce is one of the few areas where I would consider a tarif justified. Every country should be able to feed it's citizens with the food grown there, or they risk hunger when cut off by war or natural disaster.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by smnrchrds on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:58AM (#26542611)
And countries do that, but for a few strategic ones, not everything. Canada produces lots of wheat and dairy and maple syrup. It even has a strategic maple syrup reserve. But it does not produce a lot of citrus fruits or pistachios or dates. It may be possible for US to produce everything within the country—it is a gigantic country and has just about every climate there is. But it would be an ecological disaster if countries without those attributes do the same. Think of all the heating required to produce warm-climate fruits in Canada.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by wing-_-nuts on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:14PM (#26545373)
Oh! One of my favorite ag articles talked about the challenges of growing oranges in russia!

https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2020/04/fruit-trenches-culti...

You're absolutely right that perhaps not everything should be grown everywhere, but I strongly believe that a country should have a local source of all the calories and vitamins / minerals they need. In Canada, for example, maybe they encourage farmers to grow greens, brocolli or potatoes instead of citrus for vitamin c, but they absolutely need a source.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by csomar on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:31PM (#26543084)
Apples and Oranges. If you include global supply, then you have to increase salaries "globally". We all (I assume) should know that demand/supply set the price.

But imported products don't fly right into the country. There is customs, and denying/tariffing them is a policy that countries are very actively using. So at the end of the day, it's a political decision.

Edit: On the other hand, if you are exporting stuff (oil for Canada), then you can't really do that for the external market. Might explain why the government will let some sectors run with illegals (to remain competitive); the alternative being their ultimate demise.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by smnrchrds on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:41PM (#26543220)
If you ban import X from a country, the country will likely ban import Y from your country in retaliation. Sometimes the net effect would still be in your favour, but often times it would not be. Do you know why American brands dominate the US truck market? It started with a tariff on American chicken by some European countries and it quickly snowballed into much more [0][1].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicken_tax

[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/01/25/511663527/epis...

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Symbiote on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:46AM (#26542447)
The EU sets fairly high tariffs on food imports, since food security means we must maintain local food production.

Australia does not use this approach, and instead seems to have pushed other countries to eliminate their own tariffs for the TPP.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by smnrchrds on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:59AM (#26542637)
What tariff does is that it moves the price point at which the retailers switch to imports a bit higher. Tariff does not eliminate the ceiling. There still would be a ceiling on price, determined by international commodity price + X% tariff.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by freeone3000 on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:21PM (#26542945)
So the tariff needs to be high enough to be absolutely ruinous. See, for example, Canada's tariff on dairy. Since Canada runs a cartel on dairy producers, Canada does set the domestic price of milk at $4/gal. This is incompatible with the US subsidy model, where it prices out to around $1.50 a gallon -- so there's a 270% tariff on dairy imports. The great thing about numbers is there's always a bigger one.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by smnrchrds on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:26PM (#26543011)
Yes, you can do that. It's not something the farmers strapped for workers can do, but the government certainly can. It would not be particularly popular in most political climates, so passing such laws in democracies are always difficult. But as the Canada example shows, not impossible.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by zentiggr on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:08PM (#26545310)
So.... reduce production, and supply/demand curves should get you back financially on track?

Of course, you might get pilloried for the artificial scarcity, but hey... nobody ever likes the capitalist :)

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by smnrchrds on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:43PM (#26545780)
We reduce production, US, Russia, and Saudi Arabia would be more than happy to fill the gap. Actually Saudi Arabia prefers prices that are lower than the strike point for non-traditional oil, so it can get rid of competition from likes of Canada. How should we convince Russia and Saudi Arabia to take a hit to their exports in order to help us out, when we cannot even convince our biggest ally, the US?
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by skykooler on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:45AM (#26541544)
Sure, but they'd lose less money than if they didn't hire anyone and couldn't sell their crops at all.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by filleduchaos on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:33AM (#26540531)
> The solution to their problem is really simple: make better offers.

That's certainly a simple solution.

The problem with simple solutions is that they are near guaranteed to not actually be feasible or realistic.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by yrgulation on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:08AM (#26540962)
Unrelated to the initial post.

> The problem with simple solutions is that they are near guaranteed to not actually be feasible or realistic.

This. There is no amount of money anyone sane can be given to stay in Romania. Most recently i’ve read they (hospitals) were tying covid patients to their beds.

Couldn't help but comment on this as some of things i discovered are shocking for an eu member country (or any country for that matter), such as EU leading human trafficking, police corruption, collapsing health care, and the list goes on.

But sure, the simple solution is to give people money, not the constant abuse taking place at work and outside that makes people want to flee that place.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by fishtacos on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:23AM (#26541232)
That's every poor country in existence. Not everyone has the same mindset as you, however. Provided with basic incentives, many, if not most, would not want to leave family, friends, common culture, etc, just for a wealthy life - they just want basic stability.

Companies paying more (offering more at least) would begin to slow this domino effect, which raises standards of living and provides more funding for the government to provide services and ultimately pressure for increases in quality of life by the voting public. Everyone wins.

Ultimately not everyone can emigrate - it's an impossibility. The brain drain will continue to be real, so it's incumbent upon these companies hiring to raise their wages and retain talent.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by yrgulation on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:25AM (#26541262)
Agreed - my statement is in regards to "simple solutions".
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by fishtacos on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:36AM (#26541413)
That was my point. The simplest solutions are sometimes the most effective, as well. Incentivizing brain power to remain the country via pay increases seems like the most basic approach one can take, considering the GP was talking about Romanian studios complaining they can't find/hold talent and they are competing with the rest of the EU.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by notahacker on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:00PM (#26545213)
The simplest solutions are the most effective, until you realise it isn't at all simple to match the 200-500% pay increase they're emigrating for.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by randomswede on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @04:44AM (#26552552)
Step in as a multi-national company, open a software engineering office, pay well over "local market value" and you get good software engineers, at a lower price than moving them elsewhere. They, in turn, get a better quality of life, don't have to emigrate (which for some is a bonus, and for some the opposite (a malus?)) and relatively speaking have more spending power than they would have had, if they moved.

It is really not as easy as go "this is the exchange rate" and simply use that to compare pay in different countries.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by alecbz on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:56AM (#26540813)
If it's literally this or the company folds, that seems realistic.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by asdfman123 on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:34AM (#26541379)
Well, the problem is this: it might not make economic sense for those specific companies to hire people at a higher rate.

Companies aren't going to say "I guess we're inefficient and should just die." They're going to fight to survive and thrive, which is what you're seeing.

Then again, some companies ARE just cheap. You never know.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by phkahler on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:01AM (#26541797)
I was at a hotel with crappy service and asked about the problems with house keeping. The manager told me everyone in town (Traverse City MI) was trying to bring in foreigners to do housekeeping because they couldn't get local labor.

They said the standard is 30 minutes per room per day. I figure at a very generous $50 per hour (100k / year) it should run $25 to have my room taken care of. Now that doesnt cover the shared costs - doing laundry, cleaning the pool, front desk, etc... but my room was something like $150 per night. How the fuck can they not find people to clean rooms?

Answer: they're too cheap to pay a decent wage. But why? My suspicion is that all these places are actually leveraged far too much and paying rent/interest/dividends so much they can barely operate.

I suspect low interest rates and other incentives to "stimulate" economies are actually causing these problems.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by zebnyc on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:52AM (#26542532)
The service industry might be labor intensive but is hardly the only cost for the owner(s). What about mortgage payments, marketing, integrating with third parties (expedia), gas & electricity, general maintenance / accounting / security etc. I am sure there are hundreds of other costs that I have no visibility into
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by phkahler on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @09:11PM (#26562379)
That was exactly my point. Probably loan payments are the reason they cant afford to pay people to clean rooms.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by thitcanh on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:36AM (#26542315)
You make no sense. No one will pay $25 to clean a single room in a hotel. Just because your room is $150 it doesn’t mean that “there’s plenty to pay everyone 100k/year.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ghaff on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:35PM (#26543133)
I assume the cost of a room cleaning (including costs other than direct labor) is closer to $5. That's about what hotels will often give you in some sort of funny money to skip a cleaning.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by cortesoft on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:09PM (#26542763)
If they weren't leveraged that much, some other company would pay more for the property by being leveraged that much.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by intrasight on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:24AM (#26540427)
That is, of course, the solution everywhere that companies complain about not being able to hire skilled employees. Fund it and they will come.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by smnrchrds on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:53AM (#26541673)
This kinda sounds like saying "why are poor countries poor? Can't they just pay everyone more and then they won't be poor?" I get what you are saying but I don't think this will work if the problem is country-wide. You can't just magically increase everyone's wages in a country.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by intrasight on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:57AM (#26541737)
1. The problem isn't country wide. 2. Don't have to increase everyone's - just those with a "shortage". Companies want a market economy - except when it comes to salaries.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by smnrchrds on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:33AM (#26542270)
> 1. The problem isn't country wide

Sorry, I though I was on the Romania subthread.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Verdex on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:36AM (#26541411)
At college I had a professor who I worked for who grew up in Romania. Apparently the song that kids had back in the day was: "We pretend to work and they pretend to pay us."
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by vbezhenar on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:35AM (#26542292)
https://youtu.be/-Jh0EN1De4Q

sorry for pun. But that's not always a solution. Sometimes employer is greedy. Sometimes his business just does not allow to pay enough salary.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by 908B64B197 on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:35PM (#26548970)
Don't forget the whining from bureaucrats when American tech takes over the local market, and ships profits back to it's headquarter where... they employ Romanians expats!
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by k3oni on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:05PM (#26543541)
Ha, I know this all too well(2000-2006) and it's strange to see/hear it's still happening now.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by psychlops on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:00AM (#26540857)
You've just described the US H1-B visa program.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Accujack on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:05AM (#26541869)
It's slightly more complicated than that, depending on how much time has passed since the creators of the system left, but you're correct in general.

Usually, since admitting that they were stupid to let all the knowledge of the system walk out the door requires more emotional and intellectual flexibility than managers who let this sort of thing happen possess, the biggest obstacle isn't even the money... it's getting the managers to admit they're idiots.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by at_a_remove on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:41AM (#26542384)
Yes. I had an ancient system where the holders of domain knowledge kept either dying or retiring, one by one. I was frantic, but nobody listened to me. The system began to fail on the day I announced my departure. I would later find that one of the previous architects had reached out to my manager to offer assistance, but this was never made known to us. It wouldn't have even cost anything.

Anything but pride, I guess.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by criddell on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:29AM (#26542199)
The person who started the thread added this comment:

> The company that built this ERP solution went bankrupt 6 years ago, and we don't have the source code. It uses PostgreSQL and MySQL, and also has a built-in key-value database for which none of us has any credentials. We don't have the source code for this software (it's built in C and delivered to us as compiled packages..).

Sounds like finding their old employees wouldn't help. They need to find old employees of the company that wrote the system and hope they kept a copy of the source code.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by yellowapple on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:03PM (#26549678)
> and hope they kept a copy of the source code

Which from a legal perspective might be fraught with peril, at least in theory. In practice, if the company folded then it'd depend entirely on the litigiousness of the current owner of the copyright, which could range from "nobody" to "some holding company consisting almost entirely of lawyers chomping at the bit to eat you for dinner".

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by hinkley on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:15PM (#26542852)
Coworker used to have a boss who literally said where she could hear: "Lose a monkey, get a new monkey."
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by viraptor on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:08AM (#26540245)
There's the possibility that those employees are happily retired and don't care. Or they're just not available in many ways.

I know of a hospital which is still refusing to migrate off of a system which is not supported for a decade. Pay more money? 3 people worked on it: Adam had a stroke, Bob retired with enough money, Charlie left the country.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by notyourday on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:16AM (#26540329)
I bet if the hospital is to pay Bob/Charlie $1M for 6 months, post tax to fix it they would gladly do it. Note: this does not mean "We will pay you up to a million dollars, Net 90, after an invoice is approved and signed off by fifteen people". This means "We will wire a deposit of $250,000 today. The rest will be wired every month in 24 hours after an invoice is issued"

The reality is company execs like to talk about fixing problems with money but rarely are they actually willing to fix a problem with money. In my career I dealt with the exact three companies where execs decided to throw money at the problem bypassing all the fiefdoms and bureaucracies created to avoid rapidly solving problems using money in favor of slow moving, don't step on Jackson the IT manager's toes, approaches. All three solved their problems, destroying the local fiefdoms in a process.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by TheRealDunkirk on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:05AM (#26540919)
This modern-day feudalism with corporations is really the root of the problem. Managers "patch" broken IT systems with lots of manual labor to actively avoid pointing out how some other manager's system is borked. They doom the company to spend hundreds or even thousands of man hours a year to work around these processes, refusing to allow it to be fixed, keeping the "power" and influence of the broken system with some other manager. They do this hoping to curry favor for the sake of their career prospects.

After 25 years, I'm an expert at making small, efficient software tools to fix local IT workflows. God knows, in the Fortune 250's I've worked at, there are endless opportunities. And, while I've written many solutions, I've seen this political game of thrones thwart my efforts many times. This is how you get the kind of 20-year legacy mess described in the original post: People sacrificing long-term success of the company for short-term success in their careers.

I guess there are 2 kinds of people. Those that think this is just how the world works, and find this to be a perfectly-cromulent way of getting through it, and those, like me, who find it odious. Luckily, I now work for people like me. We do what we can.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by notabee on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:36PM (#26543931)
This applies to similar problems in government as well. Some people care, some just kick the can to whoever is unfortunate enough to inherit the problem in 5-10 years. If you get a few of the latter people in political power, often the best thought out solutions are offered many times and denied because of internal political wrangling.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by zikzak on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:30AM (#26540502)
I have personally turned down an offer very much like this. I could have paid my (at the time) salary and benefits with about 2 days work a week with the option to bill as much time over that as I wanted as long as I agreed to work at least 2 days a week on thier top issues.

The ERP system was a nightmare, though, and the company was difficult to work with (key, long term employees). It was a system I inherited, built out of garbage, that I tried to improve. Before I left, I found a very experienced contractor to take over, on-boarded him, and stayed as a support resource for a couple months. Six months later, he's retired and I'm getting panicked phone calls. I valued (and still do) my current job far more, even though I would probably have done better financially in the short term with the alternative.

A few years ago, I heard they migrated to a new ERP at long last.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by viraptor on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:20AM (#26540377)
For $1M they can get the new version of the same system installed and likely get a step by step walkthrough of the whole thing by any number of new engineers they want. Also it's a public hospital - for a fraction of $1M they could get people who's only job is to replicate that system running around with pen and paper - they wouldn't have $1M to just drop on a support issue the same day.

In context of this case - if they don't have money to fix their backups (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26539988) they likely couldn't drop lots of cash without a serious credit line.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by tw04 on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:39AM (#26540605)
>For $1M they can get the new version of the same system installed and likely get a step by step walkthrough of the whole thing by any number of new engineers they want.

A new system isn't going to do them much good when they don't even know who their customers are. I doubt any customer is going to hang around for a year while you rebuild your system from scratch, ignoring the fact that if they're an MSP the customers may not even have their own copy of the data.

All of that is ignoring the likely contractual obligations they're likely under to maintain the data on their systems.

>Also it's a public hospital - for a fraction of $1M they could get people who's only job is to replicate that system running around with pen and paper - they wouldn't have $1M to just drop on a support issue the same day.

Hospital? He said they're an MSP on reddit:

>Yeah we're an awful MSP. I've been trying to find a new job for quite some time.

https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/ma4mwl/the_absolu...

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by viraptor on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:45AM (#26540695)
> Hospital? He said they're an MSP on reddit:

This thread is about a different case.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by notyourday on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:25AM (#26540433)
That's called priorities. I'm sure as every public hospital it pays a lot money in salaries to those protecting and growing their personal fiefdoms within the hospital.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by gregmac on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:52AM (#26542539)
I knew someone who was a specialist in doing calibrations on some very specific industrial measurement equipment, much of which was out-of-date but massively expensive to replace.

He had retired, but took another 12 or 18 month contract flying around the country servicing these things. Apparently they asked, and not wanting to do it he quoted what he thought was an insane "go away and leave me alone" fee, but then they said yes. (I have no idea what that fee was or what multiplier he applied, though it definitely brings to mind patio11's standard advice [1]).

[1] https://www.kalzumeus.com/2006/08/14/you-can-probably-stand-...

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by plorkyeran on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:45PM (#26543264)
There's a pretty big gap between "happily retired with enough money to not be worried" and having zero interest in ever getting more money regardless of the rate. After a decade a happily retired person who left amicably and didn't hate their job might even enjoy a short-term contract if you can isolate them from all the petty annoyances that come with a normal job. Charlie leaving the country shouldn't be a dealbreaker either unless you literally have tried to track them down and couldn't.

If the long-gone ex-employees hated their employer and would be happy to see if go out of business then you're in quite a bit more trouble.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by JKCalhoun on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:00AM (#26541770)
Is there another industry where a few employees with "domain knowledge" can sink a company?

Asking because, while, yes, throwing money at the problem might be a solution, I think the obvious bigger issue is how does one allow themselves to get into this situation?

Or rather, how does one avoid getting into this situation. Because it seems to me that the software industry of late has become so mired in esoteric layers of abstraction that this feels less like an outlier scenario for a mismanaged company but more like an inevitable one for many otherwise well managed companies in the industry.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by gregmac on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:21PM (#26542941)
At the highest level, this is a leadership issue. There's a lack of someone at a sufficiently high level (eg: C-suite) that properly understands technology, and that's probably caused by the rest of the leadership team not understanding their limitations.

At a lower level, it's allowing individuals to become knowledge silos (or having a bus factor [1] of 1); lack of documentation; not having+testing disaster recovery plans; neglecting systems, code bases, and platforms; letting technical debt accrue endlessly (or worse: not even realize that's what you're doing).

How to avoid? Make sure there's a strong, competent technology leader with a vested interest in the company succeeding, and empower them to make the changes they need to.

What should that person be doing? Making sure all the stuff I just said doesn't happen.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_factor

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by foobiekr on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:01PM (#26545231)
There are a LOT of industries with this problem. Specialist stuff like military shipbuilding is an example, but also things like precision ball bearings. Knowledge gets lost all the time and old timers have to be brought back in after the fact. Or the technology is just lost and a replacement has to be reinvented (famously, the production of tamper material for the US thermonuclear nuclear weapons).
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by shagie on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:20PM (#26545445)
The precision ball bearings thing reminded me of a news item from a few years ago: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/01/18...

The relevant part of the article:

> To anyone outside of the ballpoint pen manufacturing world, it might seem hard to understand what, exactly, is so surprising about this development. China already produces 38 billion ballpoint pens a year, according to China Daily, which is about 80 percent of all ballpoint pens in the world. That's a lot of pens, but there was a catch: China had long been unable to produce a high-quality version of the most important part of the pen, its tip.

> The tip of a ballpoint pen is what makes it a ballpoint pen. At the tip, a freely rotating ball is held in a small socket which connects it to an ink reservoir that allows the pen to write or draw lines. Manufacturing a ballpoint pen tip that can write comfortably for a long period of time requires high-precision machinery and precisely thin steel, but for years China was unable to match those crafted by foreign companies.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ufmace on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:53PM (#26545098)
> Or rather, how does one avoid getting into this situation.

IMO, the problem is technical debt. Most likely, in the majority of these cases, the engineers working on the system knew perfectly well that it was a mess, was very difficult to learn how to maintain, and many parts were dangerous to modify. Most likely they told management multiple times that this was a problem and what the consequences of it would be. They would have refused to budget resources for improving it, so everyone either saw the writing on the wall and quit, or gutted it out and learned how to manage the system eventually. Maybe the system limps along for a while longer, but it's only getting worse and the knowledge needed to maintain it more siloed and specialized. Eventually you lose a key person, something breaks that nobody left can figure out, or maybe the whole thing just implodes like the main story here.

To avoid it, you must understand the pattern, hire good technical people, and give them the resources needed to improve the system in an orderly fashion.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by hunter-2 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:15PM (#26543681)
>Is there another industry where a few employees with "domain knowledge" can sink a company?

I guess any company where leadership got there without progress on the technical side. Law firm partners get there after being lawyers. Consultant partners get there after consulting.

But if you are the CEO of an IT company without ever having to code, then you may never know the things you must take care to prevent a washout.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by 908B64B197 on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:12PM (#26548725)
> Or rather, how does one avoid getting into this situation. Because it seems to me that the software industry of late has become so mired in esoteric layers of abstraction that this feels less like an outlier scenario for a mismanaged company but more like an inevitable one for many otherwise well managed companies in the industry.

Mentorship and documentation.

You need to set aside time and resources for these two things, and make contributing to them worth something in the performance review.

If all you do is count JIRA tickets closed, you'll forever end up in this situation.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ISL on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:02AM (#26541811)
> Or rather, how does one avoid getting into this situation.

Documentation?

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by giantrobot on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:16PM (#26542871)
The issue with "documentation" is there are never enough resources devoted to it at most companies. When given a schedule it only covers the main project goal(s) and no time for documentation or refactoring or any quality of life improvements.

Significant documentation is also not something easily written in slack time. With any non-trivial project good documentation is a full time effort. It also needs to be updated as the project evolves lest it become out of date and incongruous with the behavior of the system.

There's dreams of in-line documentation but that's only going to cover individual methods and classes and not necessarily whole modules or major subsystems of a project. It's also not going to necessarily cover in-line documentation from other parts of a project in different languages e.g. comments in config files.

There's lots of technical ways to help documentation but there's no replacement for documentation being a high level project goal with resources allotted to it.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by gregmac on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:37PM (#26543171)
Part of a way around this is broadening your definition of "documentation".

For example, in code: good naming, simple structure, unit tests, and useful comments all can count. A set of easy-to-understand unit tests that cover real scenarios is much better than even the greatest documentation ever written.

A fully scripted build and ideally also deployment (CI/CD pipeline) beats a checklist with tens of items that have to manually followed.

An issue system with good descriptions of changes (including why and what), reproduction steps, expected outcomes, links to related issues, etc also can go a long way.

All of this stuff has the side effect of making day-to-day work simpler, overall, while actually just being a part of that work.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by giantrobot on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:00PM (#26547863)
> For example, in code: good naming, simple structure, unit tests, and useful comments all can count. A set of easy-to-understand unit tests that cover real scenarios is much better than even the greatest documentation ever written.

1. Naming things is hard. It's a bit of a joke but good descriptive yet usable naming is hard. It can get harder after refactoring or adding in features you didn't expect the last time you were in the module.

2. Project structures start out simple. Then you need to add some feature or fix some major issue with a due date of last week. As a project gets bigger the simple structure of yesterday might not serve the needs of today. Resources for refactoring are usually somewhere around the priority level of "Good Documentation".

3. Comments need maintenance like explicit documentation. Tight schedules lead to "# TODO add documentation here". Then you get the assholes that believe comments or in-line documentation is something you put in check in notes.

4. A "unit test" that covers a "real scenario" is not a damned unit test. It's an integration test (or however you label it) and it's not likely something your CI/CD system can run on the regular. If a real scenario is touching a production-load DB or something it's a big deal to run the test. Tests like that need resources to run and non-trivial resources to write. You're not just making sure a method returns a float or throws an error correctly.

I'm not saying your suggestions are bad or shouldn't be used. The issue is management rarely sees any value with documentation, tests, or even code cleanliness. They're rarely incentivized to care about those things so they don't. They get their bonus on feature checkboxes or hitting a deadline. At the end of a project they'll schedule a "documentation" sprint or some dumbass thing that accomplished little useful output. It's worse when you've got a "move fast break things" chanting moron doing the scheduling.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by flukus on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:02PM (#26546993)
It doesn't help that "Technical Writer" is now an incredibly rare job title, it was one of the first in a long line of specializations that were pushed on to general developers. As you mentioned, they were never allocated the extra time but also don't have the training and experience that technical writers once did. It was also a very poor target for outsourcing.

The specializations common on a team even 20 years ago was much closure to the "Surgical Team" model from the mythical man month than what we have today.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by rantwasp on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:36AM (#26542312)
nah. documentation only goes so far.

you handle this by having and exercising a disaster recovery plan and having (and listening to) competent people that would spot this issue in a jiffy.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by foobiekr on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:03PM (#26545256)
This. I actually think just documentation is, well not completely worthless but close to. Imagine telling someone they could learn to weld airframes by reading. Just no.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by twobitshifter on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:23PM (#26546394)
For software, it’s the maintenance task that’s helped by documentation not building. They still need to know how to build but it’s a lot easier with documentation. I know that when we use software packages we all rely on the documentation to understand how to use it and code our desired behaviors. It’s obvious that our own code can benefit from documentation in the same way.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by rantwasp on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:17PM (#26547236)
documentation is required but not sufficient. also, documentation is usually outdated really fast if the person maintaining the system leaves and/or does not care
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by joezydeco on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:37AM (#26541418)
then it shouldn't be a tough decision to make

You'll continually be amazed at the human tendency to double down instead of admitting a mistake.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by m463 on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:01PM (#26542654)
They could also hire expensive consultants (who will just call up the ex-employee, and listen. maybe to laughter.)
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by blunte on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:05AM (#26540219)
Yes. And after the boat is righted, fire every exec from IT Director upward through CEO.

That last part may not be necessary though, as customers will jump ship and the company will probably sink anyway.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by Nextgrid on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:15AM (#26540328)
> customers will jump ship and the company will probably sink anyway.

Depends, they might have a captive market or a customer base that's non technical and doesn't understand how bad this is.

If their systems are like this, chances are their offering isn't anything groundbreaking and the competition already provides a better service for possibly even cheaper, so the customers who are willing to jump ship would've done so long ago and the fact they're still in business suggests they have a complacent customer base that's likely to stick to them even despite this incident.

The same reason this technical debt was left unchecked for ages applies to customers. The task of migrating to another provider will most likely rot forever in a Jira board somewhere and they will keep paying their bill in the meantime.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by ghaff on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:56AM (#26540810)
Even if you open a checkbook wide, there's no guarantee that someone remembers the specifics of some kludgy system they worked on years ago. And if things are really snafu-d, there's no guarantee that even someone who does have domain knowledge can recover things.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by WJW on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:12AM (#26541033)
And, of course, there's the scenario where the people with domain knowledge are already dead. Money won't help in that case.
Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by geoduck14 on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:47AM (#26541576)
Let's not forget about the Mythical Man Month. Sure, specific people amd money can fix the problem, but we can't just assume that throwing people and money can fix this.

I would anticipate a mix of: the people who know where the right bodies are buried, the right incentive (yes, that includes money), but also people to look over the entire program, a designer to make sure it is designed correctly, an organized person to make sure it is properly documented, and someone to make sure it is adhered to in the future.

Re:The absolute worst scenario happened by temp8964 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:17PM (#26543705)
What if they lost contact information of their former employees?