We reduce production, US, Russia, and Saudi Arabia would be more than happy to fill the gap. Actually Saudi Arabia prefers prices that are lower than the strike point for non-traditional oil, so it can get rid of competition from likes of Canada. How should we convince Russia and Saudi Arabia to take a hit to their exports in order to help us out, when we cannot even convince our biggest ally, the US?
Of course, you might get pilloried for the artificial scarcity, but hey... nobody ever likes the capitalist :)