News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by riotnrrd on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @04:58PM (#20099167)
I worked at Valve a few years back, and I could write a book about what's wrong there. I think the biggest problem they have -- which the author of this article touched on -- is that "success is the worst teacher." Valve have discovered that cosmetic microtransactions are big money makers, and thus every team at Valve was dedicated to that vision. When I was there (before Artifact started in open development) there were essentially no new games being developed at all. There was a small group that were working on Left for Dead 3 (cancelled shortly after I joined), and a couple guys poking around with pre-production experiments for Half-Life 3 (it will never be released). But effectively all the attention was focused on cosmetic items and "the economy" of the three big games (DOTA, CS:GO, and TF2). One very senior employee even said that Valve would never make another single player game, because they weren't worth the effort. "Portal 2," he explained, had only made $200 million in profit and that kind of chump change just wasn't worth it, when you could make 100s of millions a year selling digital hats and paintjobs for guns (most of which are designed by players, not the employees!)

I joined Valve because I excited to work with what I thought was the best game studio in the world, but I left very depressed when I found out they're merely collecting rent from Steam and making in-game decorations for old games.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by quadcore on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:31PM (#20101023)
Video games are not like movies, not like content. Since their inception, 1% of the games get 99% of the players. For example, when half-life was released, everybody was playing half-life. In this environment, you can't simply make another fps with a cool scenario and expect it to be a hit. You have to have real hard innovations in your product. A look at the big trends since 30 years clearly shows it. For example, in 2000, 50 games were high-grossing hits over a total of 5000 games that were produced that year [1]. You may think, well, cool story bro but what about Ubisoft for example, they are doing games like content. Most companies that did or do video games like it's content have or will disappear (the data show it all). Now, there is a business in pissing video games like content, but there is only spots for a few big conglomerates that will profits from the quantity, not the quality.

This is in my opinion the reason why Valve is having a hard time doing a new game, not because they don't want to. They want to be Valve and make good games, even if it means waiting years before an opportunity presents itself.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Citizen-Game-French-Nicolas-Gaume/dp/...

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by SXX on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:52AM (#20101594)

  > Video games are not like movies, not like content. Since their inception, 1% of the games get 99% of the players. For example, when half-life was released, everybody was playing half-life. In this environment, you can't simply make another fps with a cool scenario and expect it to be a hit. You have to have real hard innovations in your product.
I hope it's some kind of sarcasm. This is why Call of Duty is best-selling video game in the US 7 of 9 years since 2009:

https://twitter.com/MatPiscatella/status/1134171732053331968

Basically most of video games market is content-driven games be it some mobile, social game or MMO. Innovations mostly occur in games for hardcore or indie audience and market share of these games are pretty small.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by personjerry on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @02:28AM (#20101972)
You ignored the parent comment's next sentence:

> Now, there is a business in pissing video games like content, but there is only spots for a few big conglomerates that will profits from the quantity, not the quality.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Ygg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:45AM (#20102306)
Sure. And if you exclude all browser vendors that have control over some ecosystem, Firefox is #1 browser.

Why is eliminating largest games by revenue in his case justifiable?

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Dobbs on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:23AM (#20102932)
Because the models these games use is not sustainable for all games. Sports games have several things going for them that normal games don't. Like being simulations of the real world, so as players move, etc then the game gets updated. Secondly there is an inherint monopoly on sports games. There is only one official NFL game.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Ygg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:18PM (#20108137)
And two popular soccer games, so there is a slight chance of a duopoly.

Still. What about Call of Duty? What about Sequels?

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by SXX on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:02AM (#20103122)
I just tend to disagree with this sentence too. Basically there a lot of game developers even in hardcore genres who efficiently maintain content-driven games: almost all simulators, economic strategies, Paradox-interactive strategies.

There is number of small companies with only 20-30 employees who maintain their projects over decades basically releasing more of the same every couple of years.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by LoSboccacc on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:38AM (#20102737)
yeh but call of duty, like madden and fifa, are year after year of reskins, not new games in any sense. it's basically a 60$ bundle of cosmetic items.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by SXX on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:56AM (#20103089)
What you explaining is exactly definition of "content driven game". They basically have working game mechanics with very few changes and a lot of content.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Ygg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:12AM (#20101413)
While I agree some games take most of players you know who those players are and which games are those?

I don't think it's the most revolutionary games. For example, EA sport franchises make more money than most of their other games. Not to mention casual cash grabs with pay to win mechanics.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Barrin92 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:40AM (#20101547)
it's not like they should have lacked confidence though. They put out a lot of high quality games one after another. I still think the Orange box was pretty much the best game bundle ever to be sold. And given that they're a private company with lots of cash if they're not making great games, who else is supposed to?
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by johnvanommen on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:13PM (#20100421)
> "Portal 2," he explained, had only made $200 million in profit and that kind of chump change just wasn't worth it, when you could make 100s of millions a year selling digital hats and paintjobs for guns (most of which are designed by players, not the employees!)

All of the most successful tech companies are platforms:

* Facebook is a platform for it's users to make posts

* eBay is a platform for it's users to sell items

* Amazon is a platform for retail companies

* Even Google is a platform, because it's taking the Internet itself, and re-packaging it

From that perspective, you can see how things wound up like this at Valve.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by slavik81 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:13PM (#20100695)
* Google also owns the Android platform and the YouTube platform.

* Apple owns the iOS and MacOS platforms.

* Microsoft owns the Windows platform.

It seems to be a very common pattern. I remember being convinced on the matter by an Economist article on European tech: https://www.economist.com/britain/2011/08/06/start-me-up

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ikonoklast on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:16PM (#20101192)
Don't forget Microsoft also owns the Azure, GitHub, Hololens, LinkedIn, and Xbox platforms.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by gsich on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:07AM (#20102134)
Google and Apple can control what software is running on their platforms. iOS is complete control, macos less, Android more or less complete control.

But MS doesn't control what programs are running on the Windows platform.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by slavik81 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:55AM (#20102817)
Microsoft still has soft power, but the benefit of the platform goes beyond just control. Consider that millions of people who wanted to play Valve's games had to buy a copy of Windows first.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by gsich on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:43AM (#20103773)
If those people would have used their PC only for that game, yes. But that's not the case. People didn't have a PC just laying around thinking "oh crap now I need an OS".

On the other hand, if you didn't have a PC back in 1998 you bought one and Windows came with it. Or you already were advanced user, built one from components and installed Windows. Either legally or not, didn't matter much.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by slavik81 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:42PM (#20108349)
I understand that. Most people bought a PC with a bundled Windows license as a prerequisite to run the many applications they cared about. Those are still people who bought Windows, and some of the applications that justified their purchase were likely created by third-party developers like Valve.

I was trying to highlight one of the great benefits of owning a platform: your platform is made more valuable by the work of third-parties who build on it.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by shrewduser on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:24PM (#20100471)
they've made a huge mistake, their competitive advantage, somewhat like Nintendo, is that their platform has / had valve games on it.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by kbenson on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:48PM (#20101085)
Well, given that now Epic is trying to cut into that with Fortnite as the killer/gateway app that gets the Epic marketplace on your system, maybe Valve will be forced to focus on shipping some good new games to retain their position? If that's the case, yay for competition! :)

That said, I think part of what people are missing about Valve is that they are also seem to be focused on what they see as the next big thing in gaming, which is VR. They're supposedly shipping their own VR hardware (headset plus new hand controllers) soon (Aug 1st), and have publicly committed to launching a "Flagship VR" game this year. Probably not what most people want, given the cost of VR equipment (not mentioning the cost of the computer hardware to run it).

Personally, I'm kinda amped up about the Occulus Quest. A hands free (~3 hour charge, can play while charging), self-contained (no PC required), $400-$500 (depending on internal storage) device? I might actually be willing to pay for that as a first VR device. That the games are all $30 or less is a bonus.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by rizzin on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:37AM (#20102271)
I think this is a good point: Valve doesn't make games, but it definitely seems to be trying out other gaming-related things.

Examples:

* Steam Machine [0], an alternative to consoles

* Proton [1], incredible boost to gaming on Linux

* Continued development of the Source engine [2], that, albeit not a first choice for the majority of game developers, is still being used

* Going heavy on e-sports with Dota 2 and The International [3], which, I believe, is also beneficial for gaming as a whole

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_Machine_(hardware_platfo...

[1] https://steamcommunity.com/games/221410/announcements/detail...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source_(game_engine)#Games

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_International_(Dota_2)

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by shmerl on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:59PM (#20106475)
Don't forget their contributions to Mesa: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mesa/mesa/commits/master?utf8...
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by signal11 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:22PM (#20105981)
Halo for PC (all of them, via the Master Chief Collection) is coming to the Steam Store soon. That might be exciting for some people.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by nordsieck on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:08PM (#20101159)
> Well, given that now Epic is trying to cut into that with Fortnite as the killer/gateway app that gets the Epic marketplace on your system, maybe Valve will be forced to focus on shipping some good new games to retain their position?

We'll see. There have been a number of game marketplaces over the years that have tried to compete with steam. For the most part, they're all gone, and the games they hosted are gone too.

At this point, it would take something pretty unusual for me to spend any money on a non-Steam game. I just don't believe other platforms will be around in 5-10 years.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by kbenson on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:55PM (#20101338)
> At this point, it would take something pretty unusual for me to spend any money on a non-Steam game. I just don't believe other platforms will be around in 5-10 years.

I agree, but I think it's important to consider that they can succeed even if they don't get you or me. There's hundreds of millions of people that have installed it (approaching 250 million a couple months ago), tens of millions playing each month (almost 80 million as of a few months ago) and over 10 million people playing concurrently.[1]

How many of those are young players that might want to try a new game they see some youtuber play, and see it on sale in the epic store they might use to launch Fortnite? That's a hige captive audience, and this battle won't be won by swaying you or me, but by swaying the huge number of new gamers coming onto the market, which are mostly our kids. I know my son who's 9 probably wouldn't care about Steam if I wasn't sharing my library with him. Then again, his computer can't play much and he plays Fortnite on the Switch.

Steam is entrenched, and does have it's own user base, but given that Fortnite along as of a couple months ago has ~66% of the concurrent users of Steam overall[2], I wouldn't count it out. That's a lot for Epic to make something out of.

1: https://www.pcgamesn.com/fortnite/fortnite-battle-royale-pla...

2: https://store.steampowered.com/stats/

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by tuzemec on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:07AM (#20102390)
I buy something from Steam only if it's not on GOG. Games from GOG let you play them without the headaches of the launcher.

I don't play very often and when I finally find time for it, it looks like this: - clicking on the game icon - the launcher starts updating - the launcher restarts and asks for my account, because why not? - the game starts updating, often downloading patches above a GB ... and so on. And that applies for Steam, Bethesda Launcher and the rest of the bunch. And don't let me get started on the Bethesda Launcher because that thing alone takes 500MB of memory.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by StavrosK on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:22AM (#20102923)
GoG is amazing, my preference is GoG, Steam, and piracy is a distant third to the point where I haven't pirated a game in a decade.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by endemic on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @11:55AM (#20105687)
Totally agree. However, one major selling point of Steam for me is the practically seamless Proton compatibility layer (while acknowledging the philosophical disconnect between running Linux and buying DRM'd games...)
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by irq-1 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @11:25AM (#20105353)
Before Fortnite was Minecraft and Pokemon Go and Angry Birds... It's in the nature of video games to come and go like fads.

More telling (to me) is that Epic started making a game very different from Fortnite but was both flexible enough and perceptive enough to change the game.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by kbenson on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:36PM (#20106969)
The difference is that Epic is leveraging their current popularity to turn into a platform. Pokemon Go and Angry Birds were already only really available through platforms, so that wasn't an option for them. Minecraft maybe could have, but it seems somewhat opposed to the idea of the program, which is all about user control and users creating an ecosystem. Now that Microsoft owns it, there's already a platform for it, and it's not game specific (the Windows Store).

Fortnite has as many or more monthly players as Minecraft (which is huge), but much more control over the ecosystem and content. As the controlling party of what's (by this point most likely) the most popular online game in history in it's peak (until next month, most likely), that gives them a somewhat unique and powerful position, which they seem eager to exploit.

Will that be enough? I don't know. I definitely think the situation is different than the examples you cited though.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ansible on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:30AM (#20103299)
I'm on the Epic store because they have been giving away games I had wanted to play, specifically Transistor and What Remains of Edith Finch. It remains to be seen how much money I'll spend there. Most of my purchases these days are on GOG.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by jaggederest on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:50PM (#20101312)
FWIW I'm a diehard steam user from the beta in 2002, and the Epic store is every bit as good at this point. Absolutely disappointed in Valve for resting on their laurels for this long.

Frankly I'm almost in the opposite camp now - why would I buy anything on Steam when it's clearly being left to rot.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by wlesieutre on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:12AM (#20101412)
>the Epic store is every bit as good at this point

So it has cloud saves and you can buy games to send as gifts?

They have the “Buy game > download game > launch game” flow working, but there’s a heck of a lot of catching up to do. Frankly I’d say that cloud sync for game saves is table stakes for a game store in 2019. If Epic weren’t throwing around millions of dollars on exclusives and discounts, no one would use it.

I’m sure there are other missing features, the ones mentioned above are just what came to mind from when I looked into EGS after Borderlands 3 was announced as an exclusive.

They might be on track to catch up to Steam sooner or later, but it’s far to early to say they’ve done it.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by pferde on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:03AM (#20102609)
You're completely correct. Epic store is just a bare-bones program, it lacks features which we consider completely basic and natural in modern online marketplaces, such as a shopping cart. Yes, you have to buy and pay for games one by one.

There was this amusing incident not long ago, where the store's fraud prevention mechanisms were blocking users who bought five or six games quickly in a row. There were many, many blocked users, because at that time, the Epic store happened to have a "mega sale" event going, where many games were discounted. In a store without a shopping cart feature, that translates to lot of purchase transactions, one following quickly after another.

https://www.pcinvasion.com/epic-store-blocking-users-purchas...

If only they invested slightly more money into their store implementation, and less into buying expensive exclusive game releases, right?

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ajsalminen on Thursday June 06, 2019 @03:46AM (#20112405)
> There was this amusing incident not long ago, where the store's fraud prevention mechanisms were blocking users who bought five or six games quickly in a row.

That's funny, recently numerous users were also blocked from purchasing the Valve Index VR system on Steam because of fraud prevention mechanisms.

To their credit Valve did later offer an opportunity for people who ran into this to buy a kit in the first wave of shipments.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by slavik81 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:49AM (#20103054)
I have faith that the developers at Epic can improve their store. It's a purely technical problem, and an easy one compared to creating the Unreal Engine.

In a few years, if the store is good, nobody will care about the growing pains. The bad old days will be forgotten like Diretide.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by lmm on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:14AM (#20102411)
If it doesn't take several seconds to load up a game's page, and if it gives me a way to look at multiple games from a recommended list without having to go one at a time, then it's already ahead of Steam in the ways that matter to me. Steam's store UI is astonishingly slow and cumbersome for what's essentially an embedded web browser. It reminds me of iTunes on windows.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by bluescrn on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:58AM (#20102357)
Valve has an almost 2-decade head start. I’m sure Epic will continue to improve their store/platform at a fair pace.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Haga on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:09AM (#20101653)
Maybe most of the monetization "features" are regarded as a CON by most players? Just because sb develops this and his lifelihood depends on it, does not make something good or important in the customers 's eyes.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by fnordsensei on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @02:52AM (#20102081)
The killer feature with Steam for me at the moment is a combination of,

a) some 300-400 games in my library, picked up over more than a decade, and probably 95% purchased on sales. There always seems to be a sale. This offsets the price of a computer as opposed to a console.

b) Steam Link, which lets me play those games in the living room using a regular Xbox One controller. The Link has recently migrated from being a hardware device to being software that runs on your TV (I have a Samsung TV) and now recently on iOS (iPhone/iPad/Apple TV).

Link works very well and has effectively moved me to the living room for enjoying games.

It has also made my game library available to my wife, who wasn't going to sit down in front of a computer to play games any time soon, but who has found some games she really enjoys playing by virtue of the simpler, more direct interface that is Steam's big screen mode.

While Steam the desktop app is a horrible, ancient mess, the big screen interface is surprisingly decent.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by roel_v on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:42AM (#20102757)
"The Link has recently migrated from being a hardware device to being software that runs on your TV (I have a Samsung TV"

Wait what? I have a hardware Link and a Samsung tv. Are you saying I can dump the hardware? How do the controllers connect?

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by fnordsensei on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:13AM (#20103179)
Like the sibling says, 2016 and forwards essentially. I'm running it on a Q7F (I think it is). If you can get it to work, it's excellent. Supports 4K, whereas the physical one does not. I'm guessing the Apple TV 4K should support 4K streaming as well.

Yeah, so due to how bluetooth works on the Samsung, some controllers work well and others don't. I set up VirtualHere[1] on the router (which is pretty close to the TV), and connected a USB bluetooth stick to the router. I have a wireless Apple keyboard, a Logitech mouse, and two Xbox controllers connecting through the bluetooth stick, and it works flawlessly. No discernible input lag.

1: https://www.virtualhere.com/

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ValentineC on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:58AM (#20103100)
Steam Link seems to work on 2016 and later smart TVs: https://support.steampowered.com/kb_article.php?ref=5613-TAD...

Amusingly, there's also a version for the Raspberry Pi 3B: https://support.steampowered.com/kb_article.php?ref=6153-IFG...

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Impossible on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:34AM (#20101516)
This was Steams initial competitive advantage and it's still a benefit, but now Steam's advantage is that most commercial PC games are on Steam. Although many people still dislike Steam for various reasons, it's still overall the best game platform available on PC and is better than console and mobile platforms in many ways. One thing to thing about is that many of the biggest games (LoL, Fortnite, Minecraft, Activision Blizzard and EA titles) are not available on Steam.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by giancarlostoro on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:44PM (#20100581)
This right here... There are game studios that can keep churning out enough games to create their own alternatives to Steam and they have and they will succeed without Steam. What will be left is microtransactions and indie games if they arent careful.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by paulryanrogers on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:24PM (#20100736)
Valve has the network effect being both a top-of-mind store, distribution platform, and friend network.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Theizestooke on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:12AM (#20102403)
I think discord has taken over as friend network #1.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by shearskill on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:04AM (#20102612)
Just wait until Twitch and Discord find a way to merge.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by LoSboccacc on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:40AM (#20102746)
this goes far back. most successful entrepreneur in the gold rush where the concession holders and the ones that sold picks and the likes
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by hoorayimhelping on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:43PM (#20100577)
>All of the most successful tech companies are platforms

This is silly. 4 rather recent internet companies are meant to prove your point that the way to success is as a platform? This post ignores the vast majority of tech companies.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by kbenson on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:53PM (#20100874)
> rather recent internet companies

As opposed to what, ancient internet companies? Amazon, Google and Ebay were all started in the mid to late 1990's. They are all over twenty years old. Facebook, as the youngest, is about 15 years old. How many people were even on the internet in the mid 1990's?

Edit: Or perhaps you meant tech companies pre-internet. But I think the fact that relatively young (although not really, even non-internet tech companies aren't that old) companies quickly rose to supersede non-internet companies (or those non-internet companies shifted to to be somewhat internet centric to not be left behind, like Microsoft) points towards more evidence for platforms (since the internet enabled platforms in a much easier way).

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by dahart on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:23PM (#20100989)
> How many people were even on the internet in the mid 1990's?

I know that was rhetorical, but just to answer the question literally since I was curious, the estimates across multiple sources from the first page of Google results for “internet usage 1995” show it was double digit millions, somewhere in the 10M-50M range, and separate percentage estimates seem to say about 0.5% of the world’s population. Today, by contrast it’s over 50% of the planet.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by skinnymuch on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:12AM (#20103553)
Holy crap. Of course the usage in 1995 would be super low. That’s around the first time I used the Internet. It was a vast ecosystem to my young eyes. So the number makes complete sense but still shocking to me. I’m guessing by Napster peak time the number was relatively much bigger.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by JMTQp8lwXL on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:54PM (#20100618)
Depends on your definition of "success". As a percentage of total market capitalization, these 4 companies comprise a significant portion of that, though by percentage of total companies, it's a low figure.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by m-p-3 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:35PM (#20101040)
the vast majority of tech companies aren't most successful.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by oblio on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:07AM (#20102861)
IBM was a platform company. System/360, the PC (which they botched by opening up).
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by kaidax on Saturday June 08, 2019 @04:43AM (#20131344)
> All of the most successful tech companies are platforms

During a gold rush - sell shovels.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by kbumsik on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:30PM (#20100505)
I think this perfectly explains how Artifact [1], the worst game ever made by Valve, was made. Valve is now not interested in making games but something that makes money with least effort.

[1]: https://store.steampowered.com/app/583950/Artifact

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by stcredzero on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:54PM (#20100621)
now not interested in making _____ but something that makes money with least effort

I substituted the blank for "games." Doesn't this now apply to lean startups?

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by paulryanrogers on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:20PM (#20100717)
Isn't this the goal of every business and employee ever? To make money with the least effort.

Is that so shameful?

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by milchek on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:28PM (#20101014)
That's a great discussion in itself. You can look at Valve as a company that started out focusing on making exceptional products (Half-Life), or focusing on their users (Steam), which then transitioned into a business that directed it's attention more toward optimizing profits.

A company can take this stereotypical start-up approach of worrying about users and the 'product' first, but eventually, you might end up in the same position as Valve - and here's the thing, maybe you can only end up in that position if you first focused on something other than pure profit? How many businesses get to be the size of Valve by purely starting out chasing profit vs trying to create a great product first?

It's common to see people begrudge a company - or even an artist - who seeks to make money with the least effort, we sometimes refer to them as 'sell-outs'. We tend to look at people who once concentrated on developing something that has a quality or true value, only to later exchange this for the pursuit of money over everything else, in a negative light. Conversely, we applaud successes where the intentions of the individual or the business were seen as 'honest.'

I think this just boils down to some basic human condition around what we perceive people and companies deserve for their efforts, about fairness. OP wanted to work at Valve because OP believed it was a company that deserved to be where it was because it created something of quality, something of value. OP was disillusioned because what was being produced there at the time didn't deserve the praise and financial success.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by gambiting on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:50AM (#20102557)
No. However, I work for a AAA games publisher, and it's clear that you can do both. We have games which are obviously our money makers and which fund the whole enterprise, but we also regularly make and release smaller games which are unlikely to ever make any money. Those later ones are needed to remain on the top of the game(ha!) in the industry and to give our creative people an outlet where they can experiment with stuff(and that's also how you push forward what games are meant to be and what the market likes/dislikes, without the risk of ruining your AAA big hitters). Valve was once known for pushing those boundaries with revolutionary games, but nowadays they only do what is super ultra safe. That's not great for the industry either.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by caffeinewriter on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:50PM (#20100861)
I mean, yes and no. Every business exists to make profit, but most companies thrive when their customers are happy, not miserable. Many (but not all) microtransactions in gaming, particularly in the more predatory free-to-play models, don't exist for the good of the product, but to offer a relief to the player as the game applies more pressure and pain to try and force the player to cave and spend money. Even the "just cosmetic" microtransactions lean hard on techniques to get the player to spend as much as possible. Both sides of this aren't universal, some businesses are very much "minimum effort, maximum profit" without much care for the quality of their product, and some games take great care to not fall into predatory monetization techniques, even with microtransactions, but speaking generally, it's something that seems rather unique to the game industry.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by leoc on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:31AM (#20101507)
I have to say that as a player I had an absolute blast in the TF2 hat economy: so many stylish and amusing items and combinations. I'm certain that not everyone had such a good time (it helped that I wasn't buying high-roller items or chasing the dream of a trading profit) but I don't think my experience is exceptional at all.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by adam12 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:51AM (#20103066)
I found the hats to be annoying. It ruined the aesthetics of the game for me.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ansible on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:22AM (#20103240)
I recall some in-game commentary from TF2 where they talked about the design of each class. And how they worked hard to ensure that the look and even the outline of each class was unique to aid identification. What happened to that?
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by sincerely on Thursday June 06, 2019 @01:54PM (#20117098)
The same thing happened to Dota2 cosmetics: https://i.imgur.com/jD8L6rh.jpg
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ethbro on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:02PM (#20101135)
I believe parent's point was a bit more about employees at Valve.

I.e. Why would anyone struggle and sacrifice quality of life to make great art, when they can make equal or more money rent seeking?

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by jrmcauliffe on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:07AM (#20101393)
Because they link quality of life to making great art rather than rent seeking(?)
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by walterbell on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:56AM (#20103090)
Do owners, or employees, benefit more from:

  - rent seeking
  - making great art
Is it possible to do both, e.g. pipeline of new creative titles that attract top-tier talent, a subset of which will mature into rent-seeking properties?
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by de_watcher on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:05AM (#20102383)
Valve's hat business feels more like walking into a shop that sells hundreds of shiny little things you don't need, but can buy and put everywhere. Battle Pass is like some kind of on-going carnival with the bulk sale of this stuff.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ddingus on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:48AM (#20102782)
No need for shame, but there is a more subtle dynamic in play, sort of a tragedy of the commons.

Gaming is the commons.

If all the games are max money, least effort, that commons will be shallow, sort of dull.

If all the companies are doing low effort works, that commons will be shallow, dull.

A dull commons will sell through well, but will not tend to attract everyone it could. It is a smallish, but high profit commons.

Hold that thought while I relate an experience.

A product I used to manage came in colors, and standard black and white.

It was observed most of the sales and money were standards, black and white, and oddly, one mint color. The rest all did sell, but in much smaller numbers.

When that data was seen, sellers immediately quit buying anything but black, white and some bought that mint.

Everyone sold less. And they sold less of the standards than usual.

Turns out what attracts buyers to the product is a variety. Gotta have interesting colors on display. When they are there, part of the display, more buyers consider the product overall.

They still tend to buy the standards either way. But they buy more more times per unit of foot traffic past the display, so to speak.

Max sales actually happen when there are both a fair number of interesting colors, those colors change every so often, and that is done in tandem with the standards being available.

Going back to gaming I think the parallels are obvious.

Many will just pick the few big hits, but a diverse and interesting set of games is what gets them to be a greater part of culture and more people consider and stay gaming.

There has got to be effort there, even though it may not directly improve revenue on a effort / title basis.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:41AM (#20102753)
The market is a balance of needs and desires between businesses and customers. The perfect balance is achieved when a business focuses on delivering value to customers, and charges a price that's both bearable by those customers and profitable to the business. Trying to optimize for "most money" or "least effort" further generally leads to providing less value in a non-obvious ways - on the light side, through cutting corners and exploiting relatively weaker position of customers; on the heavy side, it transitions to borderline or actual fraud. As a customer, if I sniff that a business has this attitude of maximizing profits[0] at all costs, I do my best to avoid ever having anything to do with them - because it's a strong indication the business isn't focused on delivering value, and will throw the customers under the bus whenever it's beneficial to them.

--

[0] - including, or maybe especially, "delayed profits" (aka. growth), as many startups do.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by bdavisx on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:31PM (#20100772)
Very often the way to make money with the least effort involves some kind of scamming/fraud - and at the very least it's not usually good for consumers, so it's not good for your company in the long run.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by lodi on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:17AM (#20101678)
Not everyone is trying to get rich quick and easy. Some of us are trying to get rich "slow and hard".
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Lewton on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:50AM (#20102325)
> Isn't this the goal of every business and employee ever? To make money with the least effort.

No

Most businesses and employees have some ethical limits whether they’re aware of it or not

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by rocky1138 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:14PM (#20101182)
When it comes to art, yes.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Funes- on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:24AM (#20102203)
I would say it's far more shameful when it involves the food industry, for instance, or any other industry that provides essential resources to people. In that case, their business model becomes forcefully harmful to society.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by icelancer on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:40AM (#20103347)
>> Isn't this the goal of every business and employee ever? To make money with the least effort.

Uh, not mine. Otherwise I would have stayed in finance.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by afpx on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:34AM (#20102253)
What if the most money with least effort is made though tricking or manipulating people? Lately, that seems to be the trend. I’ve played mobile games recently where the only “content” updates were A-B testing schemes.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Funes- on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:14AM (#20102165)
>Doesn't this now apply to lean startups?

This applies broadly to the more advanced stages of capitalism. Minimize the cost and effort; maximize the profit.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by gsich on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:09AM (#20102141)
Mandatory reaction: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OR4jPtrDCLo

The game is essentially dead now. I don't think a new card game is what either Half-Life nor Dota fans wanted.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by zemo on Thursday June 06, 2019 @01:01PM (#20116475)
how much have you actually played Artifact?
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ehsankia on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:26PM (#20101219)
That was my fear too, that anyone who was there for the sake of making quality games (such as you) had left and everyone still at Valve only cared about maximizing profit.

It's unfortunate, the thing I kept hearing over and over is that Valve, being a private company, isn't required to maximize profit and can instead focus on making meaningful games. That's honestly what I thought the people who worked there wanted. Gabe himself was a millionaire from Microsoft, and I assumed he started a game company to for the love of making video games.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by dx87 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:16AM (#20101428)
From recent accounts of former employees, he's pretty hands off with the company nowadays, mainly playing Dota 2 in his office and occasionally coming out to see how everyone is doing. I was suprised to find out that he's one of the main reasons that Windows became the most popular PC gaming platform. He was one of the main proponents of porting the original DOOM to Windows, and him and his team were responsible for creating DirectX before he left to create Valve.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by johnchristopher on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @02:31AM (#20101985)
> From recent accounts of former employees, he's pretty hands off with the company nowadays, mainly playing Dota 2 in his office and occasionally coming out to see how everyone is doing.

Uh. That's kinda sad. I remember messages on some forums (edit: around hl2 release) from some gamers asking if he was okay since he had gained a lot of weight at that time.

I remember one of the guy who won a prize competition and was given a tour of Valve offices and took pictures of the crowbar (or something else, details are fuzzy).

It looks like depression from here.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by hutzlibu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:44AM (#20102303)
So he has a money making plattform now, but maybe he should have focused more on making good games, that make people happy, to stay happy himself?
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by johnchristopher on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:35AM (#20102498)
Sorry, I didn't mean to imply anything. It's just what comes to my mind when I picture the Valve of today upon reading OP's comment (playing dota in the office).

It's more a statement about how depressing the whole thing is.

Yeah, I am still bitter about hl3 and the "we have the tools to churn out an hour of hl every week so we are going into episodes".

Sigh.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by badpun on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:17AM (#20104001)
It's telling that it's just assumed that playing DotA is a sign of depression.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by hutzlibu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:44PM (#20106289)
Just playing ... no.

But allmost only playing it and neglecting real world around it, might be.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by onezerozeroone on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @05:09PM (#20099261)
While you were there, how much was Valve still an "anarcho syndicalist" paradise? When you say projects were cancelled, was that because the teams working on them decided to stop (since everybody there is supposed to be their own boss) or was it a decision that came from the top down? Just curious how close Valve still is to its roots -- or at least the popular mythos of them.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by riotnrrd on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @05:32PM (#20099484)
In theory, employees are allowed to (supposed to, even) work on whatever they think is valuable. In reality, you should be working on whatever the people around you think is valuable or you're gonna get fired really quickly. (Fewer than half of new employees make it to the end of their first year.) This usually means doing whatever the most senior people on the team think is important, both because they should know if they've been there for a while, but also because they wield enormous power behind the scenes.

The problem with a company with no defined job titles or explicit seniority is that there is still seniority, but it is invisible and thus deniable. An example: in my first few months, I was struggling to find a good project and a very senior employee (one of the partners, actually) took me aside and recommended I leave my current team since my heart was clearly not in it and take some time to think about what I really wanted to do, or else I'd get let go. I took his advice seriously, came up with a couple ideas, and then approached him a week or so later to pitch these projects. He got _angry_ at me, stressing that he's not my boss, and that it showed a remarkable lack of initiative that I'd ask someone else at the company what I should work on. So: he has the authority to fire me (or at least to plausibly threaten to fire me) but the moment that authority would mean any responsibility or even the slightest effort to mentor someone, he's just another regular Joe with no special role at all. Similarly, there's no way to get meaningful feedback because nobody really knows who's going to be making the performance evaluations. Sure, you can take advice from someone who's been there for ten years, but if they're not included in the group that's assembled to evaluate you then their guidance is worth nothing.

I worked with some very smart people there, but it was the most dysfunctional and broken work environment I've ever witnessed.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by stcredzero on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:19PM (#20100158)
The problem with a company with no defined job titles or explicit seniority is that there is still seniority, but it is invisible and thus deniable.

In groups of humans operating in "communal" mode, this invisibility of the hierarchy is by design. It's not the top brass that's doing it. It's the "will of the people."

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by codesushi42 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:28PM (#20101016)
> In reality, you should be working on whatever the people around you think is valuable or you're gonna get fired really quickly. (Fewer than half of new employees make it to the end of their first year.)

>I worked with some very smart people there, but it was the most dysfunctional and broken work environment I've ever witnessed.

Sounds like it. It sounds like a complete vacuum, void of any responsibility. Rife with cowardly management and lack of direction, I could only imagine...

I don't think I have ever read any employee account that's made me want to work in the games industry.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by kbenson on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:53PM (#20101103)
There's been plenty written on Valve's somewhat rare management system and how it works/doesn't work. Just do a HN search for valve and you'll find some explicit ones, and likely good discussions in more than a few in the discussions on submissions about Valve that are about other things.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by oblio on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:53AM (#20103073)
He's saying that nothing he's read makes him want to work there, not that he hasn't read anything about it :)
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by lentil_soup on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:50AM (#20101817)
Just as a side, the way Valve works is quite unusual in the games industry, most studios are more traditional with better defined roles and hierarchies.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Aromasin on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:56AM (#20103087)
AFAIK it's entirely unique. I can't think of any cooperation anywhere that runs on such anarchistic principles.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by avinium on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:49PM (#20100853)
Am I the only one who is astonished that the company suffers 50% employee turnover in the first year?

What an abysmal environment. Sounds like everyone is just lusting for money.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Ygg2 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:31AM (#20101504)
That is some Kafkaesque shit. I mean compare.

> Before the law sits a gatekeeper. To this gatekeeper comes a man from the country who asks to gain entry into the law. But the gatekeeper says that he cannot grant him entry at the moment. The man thinks about it and then asks if he will be allowed to come in later on. “It is possible,” says the gatekeeper, “but not now.”

...

> The gatekeeper sees that the man is already dying and, in order to reach his diminishing sense of hearing, he shouts at him, “Here no one else can gain entry, since this entrance was assigned only to you. I’m going now to close it.

http://www.kafka-online.info/before-the-law.html

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ambicapter on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:19AM (#20101691)
> The problem with a company with no defined job titles or explicit seniority is that there is still seniority, but it is invisible and thus deniable.

The Tyranny of Structurelessness

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by severine on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @02:39AM (#20102019)
For reference:

> "The Tyranny of Structurelessness" is an influential essay by American feminist Jo Freeman inspired by her experiences in a 1960s women's liberation group that concerns power relations within radical feminist collectives.

You can read it here: https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by shearskill on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @07:15AM (#20103193)
Much of this is still applicable today - ironic that this link appeared in a gaming thread but appreciate the knowledge dispensed.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by riotnrrd on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:43PM (#20106274)
Yes! I was looking for that essay but couldn't remember the title. Thank you!
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ido on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @02:34AM (#20102001)
It may sounds naive, but what on your opinion would have been the result if you'd knock on the CEO's office door, asked if he has 10 minutes to talk to you & then earnestly and honestly (but as diplomatically as you can) have told him exactly that story?
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by de_watcher on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:16AM (#20102659)
> I took his advice seriously, came up with a couple ideas, and then approached him a week or so later to pitch these projects. He got _angry_ at me

Isn't it an environment for creating ideas, rallying people around them and then leading them?

If you're new with fresh ideas then you can directly go and try to do that because formally there is no boss. You only have to fight the informal hierarchy.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by whatshisface on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:26PM (#20100747)
Your boss can vigorously deny responsibility just as easily as a senior co-worker. What's to stop them?
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by throwaway34241 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @02:42AM (#20102036)
Your boss reports to his boss. He can deny responsibility and blame his team, but normally if he has the power to hire/fire people that's still his problem.

From what I've heard about Valve, it sounds like there's a class of people that can fire you and therefore force you to do things, but you are still directly responsible if things go wrong. So the high-level people have power without accountability, and the low-level people have accountability without power.

That doesn't sound like a bad deal if you enter with a lot of political capital (maybe you are a world-renowned expert or friends with Gabe Newell). Doesn't seem like a particularly great place to work for everyone else though.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Goronmon on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:36PM (#20100796)
So, Valve is a terrible company bogged down by incompetent middle managers, just like many other terrible companies run by incompetent middle managers. The only difference is that at Valve their official title is "co-worker" instead of "boss".

I'm not sure that perspective is useful.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by codesushi42 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:34PM (#20101030)
It is to some degree since a "co-worker" can be completely absolved of any responsibility for your performance.

Cowards.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ryacko on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:30PM (#20101232)
It sounds more like everyone is terrified of accusations of factionalism and being purged.

But Valve is famous for their speed of work which would normally get people fired in different companies.

They do make perfect games though.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by asutekku on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:47AM (#20103043)
What games?
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ryacko on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:36PM (#20109836)
Ricochet, for one.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by laughinghan on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:49PM (#20100855)
Well, it can help if your boss's job description says they're responsible for your performance. Theoretically, that's why they're given the power to fire you in the first place.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Cypher on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @06:01PM (#20099693)
If it were purely a profit case and they really don't want to make a new game. Then why doesn't valve sell the IP to publishers that want to make HL3, Portal3, Left4Dead3 etc? they'll collect a check with no effort and enable fans to have a new game.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by downrightmike on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @06:49PM (#20099995)
Valve is treading water with their current games. Their current ecosystem is broadly based on goodwill of that system. If other publishers make a Valve game, like BattleField 2, and it gets called out and shunned, that ruins the good will that fuels Valve. And as long as they don't release games like that, they don't rock their boat. The problem with Epic is that they don't have any goodwill to start with that they can lose and they are smearing studios in a level of hate that is destroying those studio's goodwill. At the end of it both will make money, but Valve will come out smelling like roses and able to pick the winners after Epic destroys the low hanging fruit.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by rasz on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:16PM (#20100708)
> Epic is that they don't have any goodwill

none, except Unreal Tournament legacy and one of the best 3d engines on the market for the last 20 years.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by mycall on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:32PM (#20100779)
Unreal Engine is miles better than Value's engine.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by darkpuma on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:08PM (#20100676)
Because HL3 would suck. First person shooters today are very different than what first person shooters were when HL2 was released. It's Quake vs Overwatch. So Valve is between a rock and a hard place; do they make HL3 in the modern style and alienate all their original fans? Or do they make HL3 in the dated style and risk a flop because the market for that dated style has only gotten smaller over the past decade and new players aren't interested in it? That's why HL3 would suck. No matter which path they take, and no matter how expertly they make it, it will almost certainly be something that leaves a TON of people dissatisfied.

So it's better for Valve to not make it. They'd rather HL3 be an urban legend than a disappointment. That's better for their image as experts in their craft.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by pnloyd on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:35PM (#20101036)
I don't think of the style as dated. If you think of Portal 2 as a continuation of the style on a tangent, it's just heading in it's own unique direction. Portal 2 still feels far ahead of today's AAA games in various aspects.

Comparing the HH style directly to other FPS just doesn't seem right.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by darkpuma on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:32AM (#20101508)
First off, Portal 2 was eight years ago. That's a long time and mainstream consumer expectations for what a video game should offer have changed a lot over those eight years.

Secondly, I know plenty fans of HL/HL2 who found the tone/direction of Portal 2 distressing because it was too self-aware or whatever. I don't really agree with that, but it's a point of view that's been circulating around for years. I think a lot of fans have come to terms with HL3 never being released. Continuing to not release HL3 has little apparent risk. Less risk than releasing it and making something a bunch of people will either hate or ignore. So I don't think they will.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by whywhywhywhy on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:50AM (#20102788)
> They'd rather HL3 be an urban legend than a disappointment. That's better for their image as experts in their craft

Sorry but I doubt they're even thinking about it that hard, at this point this post nails it [0], Valve just doesn't care about making any sort of experience that isn't maximum profit for minimum effort and isn't based around a in game item economy.

It certainly isn't out of worry that they'll disappoint their fans with a dated gametype. They look at Portal 2, a beloved game as a huge waste of their time. They're not a company that makes money from art, gameplay and storytelling anymore they make money from virtual items.

But don't be sad, plenty of companies still care about telling single player stories in videogames: Nintendo, Guerrilla, Rockstar, Kojima Prod, Naughty Dog, Sony Japan Studio etc

The concept isn't as dead as Valve believes it is.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20099167

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Unknoob on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @11:24AM (#20105344)
> Rockstar

> still care about telling single player stories in videogames

Yeah, no. They released GTA V simply to use it as a platform for their microtransactions. They knew releasing an online-only game would not work.

This is why COD still has a half-assed campaign mode attached to it.

This is why Fallout 76 failed miserably.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by whywhywhywhy on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:59PM (#20108498)
Ok I don’t play gta:o or rdr2:o but I bought both games full price.

I’m sorry but to pretend for even a second that both those titles didn’t include expertly crafted 50-100 hour single player worlds and stories is being extremely disingenuous.

Rockstar shipped twice what people are asking from valve, yes they tacked on online but they still shipped the single player experience many in this comment section are claiming they’d happily pay valve AAA prices for.

The difference is rockstar manages to do both and just because you dislike one doesn’t mean they didn’t ship the other.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by rgoulter on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:23PM (#20100731)
I don't quite see why a HL3 would necessarily be bad. Doom 2016 managed to be good despite shooters having changed a lot since Doom 1, 2.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by darkpuma on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:55PM (#20100882)
Doom 2016 was a nice tribute I suppose, but compare it to the massive success of Doom 1&2. It's not the same sort of cultural phenomenon. What I will give it though is it nailed the attitude. Doom 1&2 had a certain raw metal attitude, and Doom 2016 captured that well. I've never seen the HL series expressing attitude like Doom did.

What Valve really wants to avoid is a Doom 3 moment. When an old franchise is given a modern tuneup and the result is something nobody really thinks does the IP justice.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by thrower123 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:04PM (#20100927)
I think one could argue that the original Doom had more in common with Fortnite than with its newer iteration. A Doom level wasn't that big, and it was for the most part a quick little stand-alone experience, almost arcadey; you could hop in, frag some demons, and play the same levels over and over. There was no story, no RPG elements, I don't even recall whether your health and ammo and weapons carried over between levels.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by darkpuma on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:14AM (#20101419)
As for size and complexity, there were original Doom levels that surpass the 2016 levels in every quantifiable measure. Larger maps, huge mazes, etc. All thanks to the WAD system that allowed Doom to have such long legs thanks to community driven content. With the new graphics system of 2016, community generated content was just never going to be a real thing with 2016. That is where 2016 and the original differ the most. As for unwanted RPG elements, 2016 at least has a mode that ignores that and dumps you into any level you want. To your point though, the RPG elements did alienate some fans of the original games, which goes back to my original point.

2016 was moderately successful. It got a lot of praise just for being stylistically Doom in every way that Doom 3 wasn't. But I don't think that Doom 2016 counts as strong evidence that HL3 could be made in a way that satisfies fans of the original games without alienating younger/modern gamers.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by ionised on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @04:57AM (#20102586)
You're not describing the Doom I played at all.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:25PM (#20100739)
Execute the old style well, perhaps with some modernizations where appropriate, and your game is lauded for being unique.

Execution is paramount. Valve certainly had the talent to pull it off at one point, I wonder if they still do...

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by flukus on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:23PM (#20100734)
> Or do they make HL3 in the dated style and risk a flop because the market for that dated style has only gotten smaller over the past decade and new players aren't interested in it?

I get your point that they can't win either way, but I wish there were more developers that would stick to older style games, when the goldeneye/timesplitters style of shooters went out of fashion the FPS market left me behind completely, similarly when platformers became 3D there weren't a lot of options for people that preferred the 2D style.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by mysterydip on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:05AM (#20102856)
Have you looked at the indie scene? Lots of 2D platformers there for example: cave story, shovel knight, limbo, thomas was alone, cuphead, rogue legacy, dead cells, and spelunky to name a few.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by easymodex on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:46AM (#20102776)
That's just not true. I really hate the newer FPS style, with the clunky hitboxes and weird movement. I miss the accuracy and smoothness of the HL series, to me HL2 shines because of the gaming experience.

And also they ended it on a cliffhanger in episode 2 instead of concluding the arc at least.

And lastly after Portal came out I was so happy because it all made sense, I was sure Portal will somehow cross paths with HL so in HL3 you'd have a portal gun in your arsenal. So much potential wasted.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by LoSboccacc on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:49AM (#20102784)
they can still do both, modern squad action multiplayer and traditional story driven single player can coexist, call of duty and battlefield made a point of doing that year after year. the rest is a marketing problem, being able to reach both audiences with the correct message
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:13PM (#20100423)
I'd be curious to hear you speculate on how Valve's VR push may have come about. VR certainly has the potential to make money long term, but very long term, and that payoff is far from guaranteed.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by throwaway34241 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:43AM (#20102296)
I'm not GP, but that information is actually publicly available from the people involved, here's a basic summary if you're interested:

Gabe Newell invited Michael Abrash to work at Valve (they knew each other from back at Microsoft, and Abrash was even offered to be a co-founder of Valve originally but turned it down). Abrash was interested in wearable displays as a future platform. Valve missed mobile and even wants to reduce their dependence on Windows, so there's justification to research it and put together a team.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Bombthecat on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:02PM (#20101132)
I guess they are afraid of the oculus store.if vr becomes a thing and something like the quest make it ( standalone vr) steam is gone for good. Then the middle man is Facebook with oculus store.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by leowoo91 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:56AM (#20103091)
> had only made $200 million in profit and that kind of chump change just wasn't worth it

So it's harder to expand the team than keeping an extra 200m revenue? Can't find words to describe if that's the real reason. Every player I know got excited when I told them we need Portal 3 btw.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by Guest0918231 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @08:11AM (#20103547)
This is what I don't understand. Why not hire 100 great game developers, give them $2 million each over 4 years, and have them develop Portal 3?

We know it would sell well. What about Left 4 Dead 3? Once again, it would be an instant hit. Even if Valve develops a game that breaks even, it helps to strengthen Steam as a whole and those users go on to make purchases elsewhere on their platform.

How much money did they lose because someone else developed Fortnite? How many users started buying games at Epic instead of Steam because their first jump into PC gaming was with Fortnite at the Epic store?

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by therealdrag0 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @11:20AM (#20105306)
Yep. I interviewed at Epic and the recruiter gave a big ol spiel about how they're working on developing a platform for cross-system gaming. Basically genericizing what they did for Fortnite and selling it as a game platform service. I could see a lot of those games going into an Epic Store that replaces Steam.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by antisemiotic on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:07AM (#20102862)
>most of which are designed by players, not the employees!

Which is kind of funny, as the original CS and TF Classic were total conversion mods made by players. I fondly remember Natural Selection, which was also later made into a standalone game. Shame Valve didn't explore the market of enabling amateur/semi-professional game design before Unity and UE ate that particular lunch. I guess the hats must be worth it.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by darkmarmot on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:37PM (#20100800)
You should write that book!
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by bytematic on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @11:35AM (#20105460)
Seriously, it seems like every gamer reveres valve and gabe but all I've ever heard from insiders is how awful they are (nowadays).
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by PingalPratyush on Thursday June 06, 2019 @09:33AM (#20114350)
Hey riotnrrd. I report for a video games news website. Would you like to share more about the environment at Valve? Feel free to contact me on discord - pingal#8518 or email - [email protected]
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by de_watcher on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @03:47AM (#20102316)
What about VR?

They are trying to make another breakthrough there.

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by GuB-42 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:07AM (#20102860)
Well, IMHO The Lab is the best "game" made by Valve in the recent years. For a free tech demo, it has a surprisingly large amount of content: 8 minigames, plus the lobby. Three of them are score-based and have some replay value, the others are more like experiences.

Unfortunately, it doesn't seem like there is more to it now. There is the Valve Index, but that's just a nice headset with nothing revolutionary. It may have a best-in-class display but none of the "gen2" features such as wireless communication, inside-out tracking, foveated rendering with eye tracking, varifocal lens...

Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ... by hoffs on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:17AM (#20102666)
Your comment seems to talk about all publicly known information and pretty much reiterates the common hate echo chamber. Which leads me to believe that you made this all up.