Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ...
by rgoulter on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:23PM
(#20100731)
I don't quite see why a HL3 would necessarily be bad. Doom 2016 managed to be good despite shooters having changed a lot since Doom 1, 2.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ...
by darkpuma on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:55PM
(#20100882)
Doom 2016 was a nice tribute I suppose, but compare it to the massive success of Doom 1&2. It's not the same sort of cultural phenomenon. What I will give it though is it nailed the attitude. Doom 1&2 had a certain raw metal attitude, and Doom 2016 captured that well. I've never seen the HL series expressing attitude like Doom did.
What Valve really wants to avoid is a Doom 3 moment. When an old franchise is given a modern tuneup and the result is something nobody really thinks does the IP justice.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ...
by thrower123 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:04PM
(#20100927)
I think one could argue that the original Doom had more in common with Fortnite than with its newer iteration. A Doom level wasn't that big, and it was for the most part a quick little stand-alone experience, almost arcadey; you could hop in, frag some demons, and play the same levels over and over. There was no story, no RPG elements, I don't even recall whether your health and ammo and weapons carried over between levels.
Re:Valve has mutated from a game developer into a financial ...
by darkpuma on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:14AM
(#20101419)
As for size and complexity, there were original Doom levels that surpass the 2016 levels in every quantifiable measure. Larger maps, huge mazes, etc. All thanks to the WAD system that allowed Doom to have such long legs thanks to community driven content. With the new graphics system of 2016, community generated content was just never going to be a real thing with 2016. That is where 2016 and the original differ the most. As for unwanted RPG elements, 2016 at least has a mode that ignores that and dumps you into any level you want. To your point though, the RPG elements did alienate some fans of the original games, which goes back to my original point.
2016 was moderately successful. It got a lot of praise just for being stylistically Doom in every way that Doom 3 wasn't. But I don't think that Doom 2016 counts as strong evidence that HL3 could be made in a way that satisfies fans of the original games without alienating younger/modern gamers.