News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by softwaredoug on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @11:24AM (#47249818)
I wonder how a US lab hasn't dumped truckloads of cash into various laps to ensure these researchers have a place at their lab
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by velcrovan on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @11:49AM (#47250235)
What the US has done is dumped truckloads of cash to make it likely that as a legal immigrant you will be abducted and sent to a camp.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by riddlemethat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:25PM (#47250786)
This is FUD. The US has dumped truckloads of cash to make it likely that masked men with no cameras and little training will parade around abducting anyone they even suspect of being an illegal immigrant, after even Yale admitted it's likely that more than 22M+ people came here illegally. https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/yale-study-finds-twic...

It'd be good if Congress could do something to remove the masks, put cameras on these agents, and for the local governments to stop fighting removal of all people who are here illegally so we can pretend we have borders again.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by mattnewton on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:57PM (#47251277)
I feel like we would disagree on the role of immigration in the US but I really appreciate you calling out how the current administration’s approach is only effective at making viral clips online. Meta comment, but it’s refreshing to talk with people who have different goals while still referencing a shared reality. Removing the masks and adding cameras shouldn’t be controversial unless your goal really is to make a paramilitary force for the president.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by WarmWash on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:31PM (#47252611)
Making viral clips is exactly what they want.

Their goal is for every one person violently detained, 10 decide to leave on their own, and 100 decide to not come in the first place.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by KerrAvon on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:07PM (#47253083)
"Goal" implies there's a plan instead of just wanton cruelty for the sake of cruelty.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Sabinus on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:51PM (#47253600)
Illegal immigration has been a political issue in the USA for a long time now. Trump is, however cruelly, fulfilling a campaign promise. One of the few he's managed to do.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:04PM (#47251360)
The unstated but obvious (to me?) goal of what ICE is doing is not to get large numbers of people out of the country, but to drive costs down for migrant labor by further disenfranchising them, making them scared, marginal, etc.

If they actually thoroughly evicted non-status migrant workers they'd have a outright revolt on their hands from farmers and other businesses that depend on them.

Instead those businesses can now take further advantage of the fear of harassment and/or deportation to drive down compensation and rights.

Contrast with countries like Canada that have a legal temporary foreign agriculture worker program that provides a regulated source of seasonal migrant farm worker labour under a non-citizen temporary status, but with some rights (still often abused). It's notable to me as a Canadian that I don't see this being advocated on any large scale by either party in the US.

Anyways, all this just to say that the jackboot clown theater is the point, not a side effect.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by plorkyeran on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:38PM (#47251879)
Limiting the supply of migrant labor drives costs up, not down, and the ICE raids have had a significant negative effect on businesses reliant on illegal immigrants.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:43PM (#47251947)
Do you have numbers on how many migrant farm workers have actually been deported or detained?

Because going around and harassing and deporting other or non-essential non-status immigrants would drive labor costs down because of the chill it would put through those who are grudgingly tolerated.

And besides, given the quality of personality ICE seems to be employing even (especially) at its highest levels, I simply assume there's corruption such that if I'm a large orchard or whatever I simply pay ICE to stay away.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Uhhrrr on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:38PM (#47252693)
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/macroeconomic-implication...

"There was a significant drop-off in entries to the United States in 2025 relative to 2024 and an increase in enforcement activity leading to removals and voluntary departures. We estimate that net migration was between –10,000 and –295,000 in 2025, the first time in at least half a century it has been negative."

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by reactordev on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:15PM (#47251531)
They do have a revolt on their hands from farmers… go watch some of their pleas for help.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:35PM (#47251808)
It's nothing like it would be if ICE was actually doing substantially more than fascist theater.

There'd be no food on the tables, frankly. And people in Silicon Valley would have messy houses and algae in their pools.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by reactordev on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:45PM (#47251977)
Honestly think it’s just a matter of resources and they would rather play theater for their leader than actually do the job. However, the effect has been felt.

Soybean farmers are screwed.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by gordonhart on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:31PM (#47250887)
Surely you know that this is an extreme misrepresentation? There are >35 million legal immigrants in the US. It's far from "likely" that as one of them you're abducted and sent to a camp.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by marci on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:49PM (#47251153)
Unfortunately, the most extreme is that it's the new normal that now, there's >0 chance that someone, whether they are a US citizen or not apparently, child or adult, can end up in a camp, with no due process.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Conscat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:34PM (#47252651)
It's not merely a matter of detainment or deportation. Racial minorities, not just immigrants, face intimidation tactics. These guys are walking into schools, they're walking into social security offices, and courthouses. They stand around menacingly just to scare people. They harass random passerby's on the street, or in the grocery store. You would feel unsafe and stressed if this happened to you, no matter your circumstances.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by autoexec on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:44PM (#47251076)
Give them time, they've only just started. They do waste a lot time abducting random US citizens though.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by halJordan on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:59PM (#47251294)
I think it would be a useful exercise to look at all the revocations of legal access in the us, and then do the division to see how we've increased the likelihood of becoming an illegal, and therefore targeted.

I dont think youre as right as you want to believe. Certainly not as right as I want you to believe

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by mft_ on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @11:27AM (#47249871)
Indeed; or, Europe badly needs a competitive model to hedge against US political nonsense.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by tiahura on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:27PM (#47250815)
Competitive models are illegal in the EU.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ivan_gammel on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:27PM (#47250825)
Offering „You are welcome“ relocation package to Anthropic might be a good idea.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Imustaskforhelp on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:55PM (#47251252)
Given how American govt. has treated Anthropic, I think you might be right. EU truly has a remarkable opportunity to make Anthropic/Claude European.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by impossiblefork on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:45PM (#47253528)
I'm not sure goals are totally aligned though. The current models are created by enormous expense. We know that many stages are done incorrectly. I am confident that they can be replicated without any unique US knowledge.

At the moment my impression is instead that the issue is computational resources. It's important to stay near the frontier though, and to build up ones capacity to train large models.

Consequently I don't think we need Anthropic. It wouldn't be terrible if they came. Especially if they picked a nice location. Barcelona would be very nice, for example.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by petcat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:22PM (#47251634)
This US administration (or any admin) would almost certainly impose export controls on US AI technology before it would allow one of the frontier model providers to be acquired/relocate outside the US. It did the same thing when ASML wanted to acquire Cymer (California company that provides the EUV light source technology). The acquisition was only allowed under strict technology sharing/export agreements with the Dutch government.

Europe really just needs to rally behind Mistral. That's where they should dump their cash.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:26PM (#47253324)
Can they actually prevent it though? In typical cases there would be IP licenses involved. But in this case it's a valuation based (AFAICT) on a team of people plus their infra. What happens if they all just happened to get hired by "AnthropicEU GmbH" a new entity which has been gifted hundreds of millions in computing resources?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ivan_gammel on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:28PM (#47252562)
Having one „champion“ is flawed European approach. We need local competition and headhunting to make it fly.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by azinman2 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:58PM (#47252968)
Hard to compete in an environment that’s anti-996 and the pay is so much less.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ivan_gammel on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:51PM (#47255120)
Yes. 996 is for lazy people.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by dvdkon on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:32AM (#47260418)
Do you consider high working hours to be a benefit akin to higher pay? I think fewer hours and less money is a fair deal for employees.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by azinman2 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:45PM (#47266331)
Fair deal for the employees but hard to compete against smart, well resourced people who are working 996. Everything with AI is moving so fast that moving slower makes you irrelevant.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by kelvinjps10 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:03PM (#47265783)
But can they restrict the researchers from leaving? What if they are just offered regular jobs by a new European company? What the US has done is dictatorial, but this would be even worse if they try to do it.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by lejalv on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:41PM (#47253491)
Given what Amodei thinks of spying non-US citizens, that's a hard pass from me. If you are that loyal (servile) to your country leaders, don't go elsewhere when you "discover" they are thugs. Put up with it or revolt (as Iranians are being asked to do).
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ekianjo on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @06:14PM (#47255335)
There is no capital in the EU
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by rcbdev on Thursday March 05, 2026 @08:52AM (#47261562)
It's all tied up in real estate and horribly inefficient savings accounts.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:15PM (#47251538)
Anthropic has gone out of their way to make a point about how much they love and admire the US state and its defense sector. Only drawing the line at a very far point and even when they drew the line it was with a big thing about how they believe in the American defense sector blah blah blah.

In any case, there's no way Anthropic's investors in Silicon Valley would countenance such a move.

Also, I'm biased the logical place is Canada, not Europe. Much of the fundamental/foundational research on LLMs, and a large part of the talent, came from universities in Canada anyways.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by vasco on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:07AM (#47258511)
Look up how many of the main people are Polish.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by mijoharas on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:23PM (#47253271)
It'd be great if they went to Mistral!
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ecshafer on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:08PM (#47250560)
China is also giving them dump trucks full of cash though. Plus you have to content with the nationalism reason (unfortunately this has died off in America for too many). The idea of building your country is valued for most Chinese I have met. Plus China is incredibly nice to live in, especially if you have lots of money and/or connections. So you can work in China, get paid lots of money, feel like you are doing good. Or In America you can get paid lots of money, and get yelled at by people online because the Government wants to use your model.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by danny_codes on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:15PM (#47250661)
China city life is amazingly convenient. Trains and subways are just such an enormous quality of life boost. Add to that the relative cleanliness of having nearly zero homelessness and you’ve got something very compelling.

I will say we are winning in accessibility. China doesn’t have much of a ramp game

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by softwaredoug on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:32PM (#47250907)
All very true.

I wonder if you max out your options in China. It seems the Party is suspicious of ambition and high profile winners. I'm sure you can live comfortably, but there's a ceiling.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by bdangubic on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:29PM (#47252572)
what is the issue with having a ceiling?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by WarmWash on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:36PM (#47252674)
Star athletes really hate being told they can't score more than 10 goals in a season because it's unfair to the other weaker players. The players will either leave to go play somewhere else, or they become weaker players themselves.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by kelipso on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:53PM (#47254465)
Why would a country want to welcome a psychopath whose goal is to make lots of money and wield political power that results from the money. I'm sure they would be happier with just as psychopathic people who make a bit less money but don't have aspirations of running the country from their secret bunker.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by bdangubic on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:54PM (#47254481)
wowsa - wasn't expecting star athletes and sports to enter this conversation... wild!
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by vuurmot on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @10:06PM (#47257007)
how about explaining why without giving an analogy?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by realharo on Thursday March 05, 2026 @07:45AM (#47260993)
And yet almost all of the most popular sports leagues in the US have a salary cap rule.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by danny_codes on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:29PM (#47254162)
That’s not relevant to normal people. If you’re a billionaire with aspirations of power then it’s probably good there’s a ceiling. Sure beats having Elon randomly firing your public servants while high on ketamine.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by jamespo on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:22PM (#47250746)
Damn that social conscience, huh?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by petcat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:29PM (#47250859)
> Or In America you can get paid lots of money, and get yelled at by people online because the Government wants to use your model.

Isn't it just straight-up illegal in China to refuse the government from using your model? USA isn't perfect, but at least it has active discourse.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by neves on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:45PM (#47251976)
At least it has been decades since China Gov bombed innocent people in other countries. A peaceful and responsible government.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by WarmWash on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:48PM (#47252840)
What's ironic is that China is desperately trying to be that country, but the US has then in a geographic/geopolitical choke hold.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by petcat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:02PM (#47252208)
> A peaceful and responsible government.

People in Hong Kong died. Over 10,000 were arrested and many are still in prison. The rest are permanently disgraced in their social-credit society.

Again, USA is not perfect, but let's not dream up some fantasy about the CCP.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cyberax on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:37PM (#47252686)
This "social credit" thing is dead in China.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by petcat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:47PM (#47252833)
As an American, I have no fear of calling the US President a pedo or saying Fuck the Police on my Twitter. Not the case in China. It's horrifying.

https://reclaimthenet.org/china-man-chair-interrogation-soci...

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cyberax on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:01PM (#47253012)
Oh, China absolutely does not tolerate _public_ dissent very much including highly visible social media posts. Everybody there knows that.

But this:

> According to the social credit system, Chinese citizens are punishable if they indulge in buying too many video games, buying too much junk food, having a friend online who has a low credit score, visiting unauthorized websites, posting “fake news” online, and more.

...is just pure bullshit. There were _ideas_ about including these kinds of stuff into the score, but they have never been implemented. At this point, the social credit score is only used to find people who dodge court decisions.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:40PM (#47253472)
"At this point" being the key phrase.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by kelipso on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:55PM (#47254489)
A key phrase that can be used to speculate about whatever bs one can think of.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:16PM (#47254727)
A low effort and bad faith rebuttal on your part.

Please ignore the gun pointed at your head / social credit score / masked goons roving about Minnesota / flock cameras / etc as it hasn't been used against you at this point.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by phatfish on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @07:49PM (#47256076)
It seems to me your argument is in bad faith because (taking the parents analysis at face value) you created a straw man "social credit score" that doesn't exist. But there ARE masked goons roving Minnesota.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:56PM (#47256524)
I did no such thing - you are the one creating a straw man. The comment chain I responded to has several different parties making various claims about the social credit score. My comments are consistent with those I responded to.

If you wish to dispute the veracity of one or more comments in the thread, by all means do so. But please make a substantive argument and (given the nature of the topic) cite sources.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Barrin92 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:16PM (#47254728)
> I have no fear of calling the US President a pedo or saying Fuck the Police on my Twitter.

Does that matter? In China people don't judge the state of their civilization by how easily you can insult the police but whether you need to be afraid to meet them on the street. "I can insult my pedophile president" (who doesn't care if you do) isn't exactly a flex.

It does tell us something though that the evaluation of American life now consists of parasocial interactions with the president on social media. I'm starting to belief Bruno Maçães, ex Portuguese secretary of state, was prescient with his diagnosis that American material society has rotted to the point where life is now entirely defined by virtual interactions. That's the difference between China and the US today.

The president's a pedophile, a criminal, undeterred by democracy, economy or social disorder but you can freely yell into the void. Have you considered that in the US one can freely say all these things precisely because that's irrelevant?

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by petcat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:33PM (#47254930)
> The president's a pedophile, a criminal, undeterred by democracy, economy or social disorder but you can freely yell into the void. Have you considered that in the US one can freely say all these things precisely because that's irrelevant?

Americans will vote for their Congress representatives in November. They will have a chance to decide how they want their government to be run. The US President was already shot-down once by the Supreme Court (tariffs). The system is working. Let the voters decide, and then let it work.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by vintermann on Thursday March 05, 2026 @01:12AM (#47258141)
> They will have a chance to decide how they want their government to be run.

That depends on what's on the ballot.

> The system is working.

If it is, how did you end up here again?

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by throw5t432 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:41AM (#47257954)
> People in Hong Kong died

Do you have a legit source for this? When I search for information, I only found this case, “Luo Changqing, a 70-year-old Hong Kong cleaner, died from head injuries sustained after he was hit by a brick thrown by a Hong Kong protester during a violent confrontation between two groups in Sheung Shui, Hong Kong on 13 November 2019.”

None of the other legit sources claim the police killed any of the rioters.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by MarsIronPI on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:39PM (#47264688)
Sure, sure. The CCP probably has gotten a lot better since Tienanmen Square.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by strangegecko on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @06:50PM (#47255656)
Constant military drills around Taiwan isn't peaceful or responsible.

China is bullying lots of countries in the SCS (ramming Philippine coast guard ships, building military installations in the SCS, ...). Not peaceful or responsible.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by maxglute on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @07:12PM (#47255817)
AKA defending itself against separatists and sovereignty intrusions from much less powerful aggressors with unreasonable amount of restraint. One would argue overly peaceful, and irresponsible to the point of detrimental peace disease. BTW PRC settled most border disputes in recorded history with most concessions, majority over 50%, that objectively makes PRC the most peaceful rising power in recent history. Even in SCS PRC was second last to militarize, the other disputees started land reclamations and militarization first (apart from Brunei), aka a fucked around and find out situation. Even then all PRC did was build a bigger island, instead of glassing theirs, PRC coast guard last to weaponize as well.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by phatfish on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @07:56PM (#47256119)
If China was serious about a military solution for Taiwan they would be invading right now while the US is unloading into the desert.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by MarsIronPI on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:41PM (#47264719)
The US would get out of the desert and to Taiwan fast if that happened.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by throw5t432 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:43AM (#47257963)
> building military installations in the SCS

Many countries in the SCS are doing this. In fact China was late to the game, as Vietnam did it much earlier.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ecshafer on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:26PM (#47251691)
I would imagine if it isn't illegal its a very bad idea not to. But regardless, I would bet large amounts of money that you would never get any flack for doing anything for the government. If I went on X, Threads, Bluesky, TikTok and said "Hey I am a software engineer selling awesome new technology to the government and military!" I am going to get Americans attacking me for supporting Trump / ICE / FBI whatever the current issue of the day is. If I did the same on Douyin or Weibo the response would be able making China strong, and there would be no criticism of that choice.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:49PM (#47252037)
Sure, but the difference is that while the Chinese state is measurably awful on all sorts of human rights things within their own borders... they're not currently dropping bombs on foreign cities, starving a neighbour of critical petroleum shipments, or heavily funding an ally to slowly exterminate a population.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:47PM (#47253556)
What point are you trying to make here? Are government abuses somehow inherently better or worse depending on where they happen?

Do you imagine an invasion of Taiwan won't involve dropping bombs?

I feel like we should be able to agree that providing authoritarian regimes with high tech tools is immoral in the general case.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:36PM (#47254241)
My point is as a non-American I feel no allegiance to either state, and current events don't make me sympathetic to the geo-political aims of the USA. So I don't see a strong moral case for this tech being an especial purvey of either party.

If you'd asked me two years ago my answer might have been different.

And to the original point, yeah, I would feel entirely justified in the critique of engineers in providing tools to the US defense apparatus at this point.

At least the Chinese shops are giving their weights away for free, and not demanding that any government ban the rest.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by sciencejerk on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:40AM (#47257948)
Why are they giving them away for free?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:40AM (#47259196)
Why did Meta release theirs? The better question is, why not? If you aren't at the cutting edge and don't have a moat then releasing them is pure reputational upside with zero downside.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by sciencejerk on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:55PM (#47264894)
The research costs are not free. The businesses need to recoup the cost in some way shape or form, even if in the long term. Seems expensive as an anti-moat to detrench competitors
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:28PM (#47266843)
It's a winner take almost all competition. Baring a moat, if you aren't at the cutting edge you won't be able to recoup the cost regardless. At that point you might as well release it to the public for reputation.

You might even get lucky and someone else does the same. If you manage to learn from their example you might be more competitive in a future round.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cmrdporcupine on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:40PM (#47268782)
For China it's an existential threat. They cannot let US corporations have exclusive control over this. And they are unlikely to catch up. So by tossing open weights model (note: not open source) out there for the public to use, they are destroying the possibility that Dario and SamA can build a monopoly/duopoly.

I think we are now in the era of oligarchies, and oligarchies maintain power by being highwaymen and extracting tolls, in a kind of rentier capitalist structure.

By throwing LLM models out into the commons, China is disrupting the possibility of this taking hold there.

God bless 'em

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by MarsIronPI on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:38PM (#47264677)
> If I did the same on Douyin or Weibo the response would be able making China strong, and there would be no criticism of that choice.

Right, because in China if you were criticized for helping the government, the people who criticized you would be in for (probably life-damaging) trouble.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by vintermann on Thursday March 05, 2026 @01:09AM (#47258119)
Probably. There are different kinds of political power though; it seems the qwen architects are using one right now.

The real political power we have through our vote is probably smaller than the political power most of us here have from the option to quit.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by 1024core on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:51PM (#47251193)
I got an offer out of the blue for a consulting gig in ML, offering USD 400/hr in China. Assuming this was legit (the offeror seemed legit), it looks like China is also throwing a lot of Benjamins around...
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by VWWHFSfQ on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:10PM (#47251451)
> China is incredibly nice to live in

I'm sure it's a very nice place to live if you're content to just stay quiet in society and never put a political sign in your yard or even just talk about the wrong thing with your friend in a WeChat.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cyberax on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:46PM (#47252810)
This is an exaggeration. Nobody in China cares about what you speak with each other privately, and people talk about stupid policies all the time. The government cares about _public_ actions.

In practical terms, if you're not kind of person who would want to run for an office in the US, China is incredibly comfortable. Cities are safe, with barely any violent crime. Public drug use is nonexistent. And with the US-level AI researcher income, you'd be in the top 0.1% earners.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by petcat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:59PM (#47252992)
> nobody in China cares about what you speak with each other privately, and people talk about stupid policies all the time. The government cares about _public_ actions.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47252833

My comment and the linked video says otherwise. The guy was in a private group chat and said some nasty things about the police for confiscating his motorcycle. Now he's arrested and in the Tiger Chair.

How are we explaining this?

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by maxglute on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:35PM (#47253421)
Group with 75 people. That's a crowd, doesn't matter if gated behind QR code invites. Shit talk cops and gov with the bois is fine. Shit talk / soapbox in a crowd (virtual or real) and get caught or reported = drink tea on the menu.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by bdangubic on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:31PM (#47252606)
try to protest in america and see how that works out for you long-term. or say protest against genocide in gaza at an uni or generally in public…
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cyberax on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:47PM (#47252837)
Sigh. Let's not invent things? You can protest anything in the US just fine, with generally no consequences. Heck, our local _high_ _school_ students go out and protest everything to weasel out of classes.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cheema33 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:10PM (#47253111)
Trump admin did put people in prison and then deported them, for doing nothing more than protesting.

Not as bad as China sure, but not as good as other civilized nations.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:57PM (#47253700)
Let's just clarify that visitors don't have the same rights as citizens. Whether or not you agree with the current administration's policies hopefully we can agree that it is entirely reasonable for them to deport foreign political dissidents more or less at their discretion.

If you want to put this to the test try crossing the Canadian border and when they ask you the purpose of your visit respond that it's to attend a protest.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cheema33 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:37PM (#47256375)
> Let's just clarify that visitors don't have the same rights as citizens.

Yunseo Chung was not a visitor. She came to the United States from South Korea at age 7. She was arrested last year for peacefully protesting. Charges against her were dropped but the govt. canceled her green card.

The govt. has been trying to deport her since then, but the courts keep blocking it.

https://humanrightsfirst.org/yunseo-chung-v-trump-administra...

While the legality of these actions are being debated in courts, I think most of us can agree that this is reprehensible behavior on part of the Trump admin.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @09:13PM (#47256644)
I agree that particular example is reprehensible.

I never claimed to condone the actions of the current admin. The examples of people being deported for protesting that I am familiar with are student visa holders. While I don't personally support the examples that I am aware of, I also recognize that in those specific cases the executive branch appears to be within the bounds of the law. I don't even object to the executive branch having the power to cancel the visas of political dissidents in the general case, merely to how they are choosing to apply it.

It's surprising to me to learn that a green card could be revoked for protected speech. That ought to fall well outside the bounds of the law IMO. Green cards and visas are entirely different things.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by bdavisx on Thursday March 05, 2026 @08:46AM (#47261496)
>While I don't personally support the examples that I am aware of, I also recognize that in those specific cases the executive branch appears to be within the bounds of the law. I don't even object to the executive branch having the power to cancel the visas of political dissidents

It's my understanding that the 1st amendment applies to everyone, not just citizens. So if that's true (not 100% sure about that), how can political speech (protesting) be a valid reason to remove someone from the US?

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:14PM (#47266699)
Well obviously it can't be if that's true. But is it? What led you to that conclusion?

You can certainly be denied entry for entirely arbitrary reasons. Can you also (as a visa holder) be evicted without notice for same? I think that's generally a safe assumption for any country in the world but would be interested in learning about counterexamples.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by kelvinjps10 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:17PM (#47265968)
But the constitution is not worded as if they don't have the same fundamental rights. Even in other countries, it is the same; this is done to prevent slavery and unjust incarcelation. So visitors have the same fundamental rights to free speech, fair trial, etc. The US has also agreed to international conventions. But the current administration seems to not care
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fc417fc802 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:22PM (#47266779)
It's definitely not as simple as you're making out. Political speech aside, visas have routinely been cancelled without forewarning for all sorts of reasons historically.

Does someone on a short term visa have the protected right to purchase firearms? Visitors aren't even permitted to get a job without the appropriate type of visa. Being allowed to work is a pretty fundamental right.

I expect there's a difference between the bill of rights and the constitution, and likely further nuance as well.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by xienze on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @07:02PM (#47255739)
> Trump admin did put people in prison and then deported them, for doing nothing more than protesting.

Link? I’m guessing we’re going to see that this definition of “protesting” involves being aggressive and directly in the face of law enforcement officers, not merely holding a sign at a distance.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cheema33 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:40PM (#47256391)
> Link? I’m guessing we’re going to see that this definition of “protesting” involves being aggressive and directly in the face of law enforcement officers, not merely holding a sign at a distance.

Please read up on this one example of a US permanent resident. And then justify the actions of the govt against Yunseo Chung.

https://humanrightsfirst.org/yunseo-chung-v-trump-administra...

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by bdangubic on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:48PM (#47253575)
this is funny if you are being sarcastic
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by cyberax on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:01PM (#47254579)
Oh, I fully support their right to protest.

It just looks a bit ridiculous when students walk out in protest against things that are far outside the influence of their school, city, or even state.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by eunos on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:56AM (#47259761)
> never put a political sign in your yard or even just talk about the wrong thing with your friend in a WeChat.

Practically, how many care about that? Consider that in other part of the world they also cancel folks based on social media opinion...

and that Benjamin Franklin's opinion on security and freedom? Thats terminally online phenomenon only. I once tried to bring that without specifically mentioned that it came from ol Ben himself to folks IRL. Many thought it was some anarchist blabbers.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by leptons on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:27PM (#47252543)
Chinese people are very racist towards non-Chinese. It might seem like a happy utopia, but if you aren't Chinese, then you may not really enjoy your time there. It may not be quite as bad as being black in rural US south, but being black (or anything non-Chinese) in China is still not going to be a good time.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by WarmWash on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:45PM (#47252793)
Racism in even the worse parts of America doesn't even begin to touch the racism present in monocultural/monoracial countries.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Larrikin on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:28PM (#47253342)
Have you experienced racism? In Japan atleast, it was evenly applied. That company won't rent to foreigners but this one will. That company won't hire foreigners but this one will. Police will bother you if you ride a bike, but they will be polite while they waste 10 minutes of your time asking for your gaijin card for biking while foreign.

In the US people try to hide it and are far more sinister about it, since there are a lot of laws against obvious racism. The cops are also happy in the US to just kill you.

The racism in the US comes out of hate where as what I experienced abroad was more, we don't think you'll fit in and follow the rules and you have to constantly prove that you can.

I didn't spend too much time in China so maybe it is a racist hell hole.

But my experience in Japan was that white immigrants were way more inclined to make a huge deal about the lighter racism they experienced because they had never been somewhere where their skin color was a disadvantage.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by nozzlegear on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:10PM (#47253887)
This is a weird argument. Japanese racism is fine because the Japanese are polite and apply it evenly?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Larrikin on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:14PM (#47253944)
Despite what some on this site will argue, racism is always bad.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Sabinus on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:57PM (#47253705)
"we don't think you'll fit in and follow the rules and you have to constantly prove that you can"

I speculate that if you were a permanent minority instead of a visiting inconvenience, then that 'nice' racism you describe would metastasize into the type of racism you see in the USA. It's more friction from time and exposure added on. And, you know, slavery.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by segmondy on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:05PM (#47256162)
There's a very big difference between xenophobia and racism. Racism is much worse.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by kelvinjps10 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:27PM (#47266135)
Xenophobia is as bad as racism. The fundamental difference between xenophobia and racism, it's that one is applied because of where you're from and the other your race. But you can receive the same downsides with both.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by px43 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:40PM (#47252730)
Wild to call 1.42 billion people racist despite having met very few of them.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by leptons on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:22PM (#47254806)
It's funny that you think you know who I've met. YOU DON'T KNOW ME.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by losvedir on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:24PM (#47254103)
What do you mean by racist? I'm a white/hispanic American and spent 3 months in China and didn't really notice anything problematic towards me.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by leptons on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:49PM (#47256458)
That's great, but it's pretty well known that racism exists in many forms in many countries. Just google "racism in china".
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by maxglute on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:05PM (#47253058)
> get yelled at by people online because the Government wants to use your model

Well duh, as recently demonstrated, an US model used by the US gov will 100% end up murdering actual children sooner than later, in this case less than a calendar year in some far flung war that many Americans do not support. Alternatively PRC model used by CCP might kill in some hypothetical future but for national reunification/rejuvenation that many Chinese support. At the end of the day, researchers and population on one side sleeps more soundly.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by bilbo0s on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @11:31AM (#47249948)
They probably have tried, but you have to have more cash than those researchers feel they can get starting their own lab. When you consider the fact that their new startup lab would have the entire nation of China as, in effect, a captive market; you start to see how almost any amount of money would be too little to convince them not to make a run at that new startup. If money is their aim.

I think Alibaba needs to just give these guys a blank check. Let them fill it in themselves. Absent that, I'm pretty sure they'll make their own startup.

I do think it'd be a big loss for the rest of the world though if they close whatever model their startup comes up with.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by simgt on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:17PM (#47250689)
> I do think it'd be a big loss for the rest of the world though if they close whatever model their startup comes up with.

That's very likely to happen once the gap with OpenAI/Anthropic has been closed and they managed to pop the bubble.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by bobthepanda on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:42PM (#47251052)
I don’t know, the EV bubble deflated and Chinese firms are still pumping them out with subsidies like their life depends on it.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by gaoshan on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:29PM (#47250860)
ICE has been detaining Chinese people in my area (and going door to door in at least one neighborhood where a lot of Chinese and Indians live). I was hearing about this just last week as word spread amongst the Chinese community here (Ohio) to make sure you have some legal documentation beyond just your driver's license on you at all times for protection. People will hear about this through the grapevine and it has a massive (and rightly so) chilling effect. US labs can try but with US government behaving like it is I don't think they will have much luck.

*edit: not that it matters, but since MAGA can't help but assume, these are all US citizens and green card holders that I am referring to.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by bobthepanda on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:38PM (#47251001)
Yeah, the Hyundai factory fiasco kind of dashed the idea that the enforcement would spare people working in favored industries setting up in the US.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by genxy on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:36PM (#47252672)
The Hyundai factory "enforcement" wasn't even legal. Those workers were here to train US workers and the Hyundai employees had proper visas for this.

https://apnews.com/article/immigration-raid-hyundai-korea-ic...

https://www.koreatimes.co.kr/foreignaffairs/20251112/hundred...

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/attorney-says-detained-k...

The regime is powered by racism and doesn't think through things.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by limagnolia on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @07:10PM (#47255796)
Allegedly, though the local labor unions seem to disagree. I guess we'll have to wait for the facts to come out in court.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by jiggawatts on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:11PM (#47253901)
"Papers, please." comes to the US of A.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by nomel on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @07:50PM (#47256079)
Every administration since the foundation of ICE has removed illegal immigrants and funded ICE and immigration policy/border operations [1].

[1] Removals by president: https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/biden-deportation-re...

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by fragmede on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:07AM (#47260244)
Yes, but the difference in degree, and how are material. The big showy Hyundai plant raid is an example of something that hasn't happened before. Under Obama there were I-9 audits of Infosys, and under Clinton there was a raid of a Filiberto's, but both of those weren't of foreign workers here to train Americans.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by the_gipsy on Thursday March 05, 2026 @08:44AM (#47261486)
Yes what's happening is totally normal, everybody does it all the time.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by littlestymaar on Thursday March 05, 2026 @09:48AM (#47262127)
Every developed country on earth has an immigration policy and an administration dedicated to enforcing it.

No other developed countries have masked goons abducting people in public wearing civil clothes and masks and disregarding every laws of the country (violating private property and foreign embassies, deporting national citizens, and numerous other preposterous bullshit).

Immigration policy enforcement is normal, the madness that has been running in the US for a year isn't.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by gunsle on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @09:56PM (#47256927)
You have to show ID to pick up a prescription or open a bank account. You have to show ID for routine traffic stops. This is such a juvenile, tired argument.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by baby_souffle on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @10:07PM (#47257016)
“You show ID at the bank” is a classic, juvenile and tired argument because it swaps in a voluntary transaction for state coercion.

The concern isn’t IDs exist—it’s who’s demanding them, in what context, and what happens if you can’t comply on the spot.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by jiggawatts on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @10:45PM (#47257287)
Not to mention that the USA has a long history of looking down their nose at the USSR for doing exactly what the USA is doing now.

I forgot that HN is mostly filled with a younger generation that might not get the reference.

The "Papers, please." quote is a common trope in spy movies, books, etc... about the former Soviet Union.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by binarycrusader on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @11:47PM (#47257688)
You absolutely do not have to show ID to pick up every prescription; just some, which is also dependent on state law, federal law, and pharmacy.

But also, I don't care if it's a tired argument--this isn't about how things are, it's about how we want them to be. I don't want to live in a state action-coerced society.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by z3t4 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @07:13AM (#47260723)
In Sweden you have to use your Bank ID to take the buss. Meaning the bank has the same security as entering the bus. If you get robbed in Sweden they take your bank ID, use it to take a loan and then transfers all your money to a foreign bank. Because we got rid of manual cash.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by brorfred on Friday March 06, 2026 @02:25PM (#47279845)
Can you expand on this? SL accepts any credit card for purchasing single tickets and I assume you can buy an SL card using cash in for example Seven Eleven? Also, the issue with bank ID when you are robbed is identical to any bank app anywhere, isn't it?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by DiogenesKynikos on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:29AM (#47260004)
Imagine if you forgot to bring your ID card to the bank, and they grabbed you and the next thing you knew, you were in a concentration camp in El Salvador.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by coredog64 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @01:15PM (#47265139)
"Papers, please" is not just ID, but also authorization to travel internally. The idea that asking for ID* is anywhere equivalent is asinine.

*Reminder that folks visiting the US on a visa are legally required by the terms of said visa to always carry upon their person at least a copy of identity papers backing up that visa, and that this law has been in place for a very long time.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ljsprague on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:56PM (#47251265)
Are the people being detained in the country illegally?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Jcampuzano2 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:34PM (#47251805)
The reality is - it doesn't matter. The fact that they have had as many false positives as they have and the way they treat people in general causes it to have rippling effects even for people who are legally here, or are considering legally immigrating.

The risk and level of publicity is just too high for many people to even consider, especially people already intelligent/capable enough to immigrate anywhere else that doesn't have these issues or stay in their own country.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by 0x3f on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:36PM (#47253435)
Have they had a lot of false positives? Almost every story I see seems to fall apart on further investigation. To be clear, I'm sure they have some false positives, but do they have a lot of them relative to any other immigration system?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Terr_ on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:01PM (#47253764)
Depends, how are we defining "false positive"? Ex:

1. Detained the incorrect person

2. Detained the correct person, with the correct legal status

3. Detained the correct person, with the correct legal status, but in unlawful circumstances

4. Detained the correct person, with the correct legal status, in ostensibly-lawful circumstances, but in a way which is unconstitutional or crazy

An example of the final category are the immigrants that spent years being vetted, following the law, and doing expensive paperwork to be citizens. ICE snatched them when they showed up on at the last second as they were to take their citizenship oath. [0] Not because of anything they did, but because today's Republican party has decided that it's OK to hurt people based on their "shithole" country of birth.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/dec/30/us-citizensh...

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by 0x3f on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:17PM (#47254012)
These are all forms of false positives but the most popular news stories seem to be where they detain the correct person, correct legal status, lawfully, and the story happens to gloss over the facts about the legal status and focuses on the hardship. Yeah, it's a hardship to be split from your family, I can't deny that. But I'm not aware that most countries are very sympathetic to illegal immigrants.

If anything I find the stories featuring white/European people oddly racist because they seem to assume that I, the reader, will assume a white/European person couldn't possibly be in violation of immigration rules. But all the ones I've read turned out that they were indeed in violation of immigration rules.

Overall as a potential immigrant to the US myself, I find the process capricious and that US citizens by birth don't fully appreciate how painful it is or why it shouldn't be that way. But I don't find it notably worse or more onerous than the vast majority of immigration policies of other countries in practice.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by platinumrad on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:47PM (#47254389)
I'm not sure what you're talking about. The most popular stories are the ones when they detain US citizens, rough them up, and then dump them on the side of the road somewhere without even apologizing.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jan/13/ice-immigrat...

[2] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/a-u-s-citizen-says-ice-f...

[3] https://www.propublica.org/article/immigration-dhs-american-...

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by 0x3f on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:20PM (#47254773)
I assume this is probably a function of our respective locations, because the most popular stories I see as an 'outsider' are those that would discourage tourism or immigration, not those that would worry already-citizens.

To address your stories specifically, my point would be that I'm still not sure whether this shows the US is notably worse on this than any other place.

E.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windrush_scandal

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Terr_ on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @10:15PM (#47257068)
> the story happens to gloss over the facts about the legal status and focuses on the hardship

Suppose you have a "civil infraction" against you, like an unpaid parking ticket, running across the road in an unsafe way, or overstaying a visa. It's terms of US law categories, it's less than graffiti on a fence. In this case you were "indeed in violation" of it.

However, what happens next is some recently hired weirdos in mismatched camo-gear claiming to be police (with no ID) surround you on the the sidewalk, drag you into a van, and imprison you for months without trial. You are purposefully shuffled between different prisons in different states to prevent your own lawyer from being able to find you.

Meanwhile, some internet dude nicknamed 0x40 comes along and says: "Ugh, why do you guys keep glossing over the facts about their parking tickets to focus on the hardship? Yes, it's a hardship to be split from your family, I can't deny that, but..."

In short, one of the several problems right now is the that even for victims that actually did something wrong, the "hardship" is frequently illegal and disproportional. The truthfulness of the cause does not justify the effect.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by 0x3f on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:13AM (#47258555)
> It's terms of US law categories, it's less than graffiti on a fence

The 'level' of the crime is only one aspect determining the treatment.

Some crimes are inherently more prone to absconders, immigration infractions being one of them.

Now, you could just say "oh well, that means we should just not try so hard to get perfect enforcement". Which is fine. But that's obviously not the view of everyone.

I'm not even sure that's the view of everyone when it comes to grafitti. Plenty of people would like to be zero tolerance on that too, it just doesn't have the political momentum right now that immigration issues do. And immgrants as a class are vulnerable in a way that random natives spraying fences aren't.

Also, I'm not sure this really addresses the question(s) of the thread which were more along the lines of "when compared to other countries, does the US: (a) have a higher false positive rate; and/or (b) a harsher regime of treatment".

On that, I'm still not convinced the answer is yes. The UK, for example, has been up to almost exactly the same things. Many European and Asian countries are much worse.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by 4RealFreedom on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:33PM (#47253406)
"especially people already intelligent/capable enough to immigrate anywhere else that doesn't have these issues or stay in their own country" Isn't that the point? Come here legally or don't come at all.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by jiggawatts on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:14PM (#47253945)
The "legally" part is redefined on the whims of a dictator on a weekly basis.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Conscat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:30PM (#47252585)
Even if you're not likely to be deported from a foreign country, you wouldn't want to face frequent gang intimidation tactics, would you? Simply feeling threatened isn't fun, even if nothing truly terrible will happen to you (not to speak of the real risk in being detained regardless).
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by gaoshan on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:54PM (#47252101)
No, all of the specific cases I heard about were Chinese people that were naturalized citizens (some for decades) who were cuffed and detained for a few hours before being released. As others have said it doesn't really matter, though. It's the sentiment that counts.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by mattnewton on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:59PM (#47251292)
Sometimes, often times no. They have detained multiple US citizens.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by nomel on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:01PM (#47256145)
Any idea what the % is? Absolutes don't really make sense without being compared to the number of correct deportations. Detaining someone, for more information, isn't always unreasonable. For example, I was in a car accident with someone, and was not allowed to leave until the situation was understood. Was I wrongfully detained? Of course not. It was part of the due process.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by mattnewton on Friday March 06, 2026 @03:14AM (#47272346)
When you were detained it was in service of understanding an accident. When these Americans are detained it’s because they were racially profiled. The courts may decide that’s due process now but they didn’t believe so years ago and there is quite an ugly history to that practice.

This article is from October of last year. It’s very hard to get current numbers. https://www.propublica.org/article/immigration-dhs-american-...

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by nomel on Friday March 06, 2026 @03:23PM (#47280609)
According to that article (it's hard to understand their numbers) it seems around 50 (with the remaining being detained for interference?).

According to this [1], ~68k have been deported. So, around 1 in 10,000 (or 0.07%). Next question would be, is 1 in 10,000 reasonable? You would have to compare to other countries or maybe police operations (like I experienced).

[1] https://www.nbcnews.com/data-graphics/us-immigration-tracker...

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by mattnewton on Sunday March 08, 2026 @06:01PM (#47302025)
This analysis is predicated on a few things- that the estimates in the article are accurate, that 1 in 10,000 assumes that the process of deporting the 10,000 was the same that detained those Americans and not in addition to those deportations, and finally that those deportations were necessary and would not have happened without racial profiling.

I don’t think I agree with any of those points. Firstly the article is likely a gross underestimate from a few months ago. Since then a lot has happened - Americans have even been killed by ICE. On the second, we deported plenty of people in previous administrations without the racial profiling that lead to several of these Americans being detained. Finally, I don’t believe this level of deportation is making us safer or benefiting us economically

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by nomel on Monday March 09, 2026 @05:36PM (#47315890)
> On the second, we deported plenty of people in previous administrations without the racial profiling that lead to several of these Americans being detained.

This is false, which should be expected, since not detaining an American would necessarily mean freeing all who couldn't be immediately identified.

https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/latest-report-ob...

https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2013/mar/15/us-citizens...

Here's a realistic scenario that I would like your answer for:

A car is pulled over for having plates that belong to someone with an expired visa, with a deportation judgement. The car contains 5 people, none have valid forms of id. In your opinion, what's the next step? Do you temporarily detain them to figure out who is who, possibly detaining a citizen? What is the correct next action to make sure less than 1 in 10000 citizens are temporarily detained?

I look forward to your answer.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by misnome on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:45PM (#47251966)
Who cares when you get a bonus per person either way?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ljsprague on Saturday March 07, 2026 @09:37PM (#47293809)
How would you quantify the bonus the Biden/Harris/DNC received by allowing 15 million to cross illegally?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by sourcegrift on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:34PM (#47250937)
Yes. Yes, so true. And the phd types building these models are probably even scared in China that ICE will fly there to deport them.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by jwolfe on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:54PM (#47251231)
This thread is about bringing these people to the US.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by swiftcoder on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:05AM (#47259374)
There's no huge reason to bring them to the US. Plenty of US corporations have maintain overseas offices. Even if its impolitic to employ them directly in China, you can employ them in other offices (for example, Amazon has been known to do this with their Singapore offices)
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by user34283 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:09AM (#47260261)
This thread is largely pointless political back-and-forth were predictably the comments with a more positive opinion on current US immigration enforcement will be flagged.

To get back to the original point, personally I doubt sentiment on US immigration enforcement would be so significant a deterrent for Chinese talent, who may not share the political views of the American left for whom this is a big concern.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by Matl on Thursday March 05, 2026 @08:38AM (#47261434)
> pointless political back-and-forth were predictably the comments with a more positive opinion on current US immigration enforcement will be flagged

Given the tactics employed by ICE, it's a true shock and horror that most people have more humanity than that.

But I guess a person who can't form a grammatically correct sentence is an example of the sort of people who can rest easy,

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by iso-logi on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @06:35PM (#47255523)
If they are illegal citizens, they need to go.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by CamperBob2 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @07:56PM (#47256113)
There's a process. If the government won't follow it, why should the "illegals?"
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by nozzlegear on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @07:03PM (#47255749)
Legalize illegal citizens
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by refulgentis on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @06:37PM (#47255537)
It’s beautiful at 37 to still see new phrases sometimes, illegal citizens is a quite beautiful one, lol. (also, note the post is clearly about, to put it in your terms, legal citizens)
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ncallaway on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:55PM (#47256516)
> illegal citizens

???

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by iso-logi on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:30AM (#47257904)
The term doesn't matter. If you haven't been approved to be in a country, you shouldn't be in said country.

You don't go walking into the Amazon Head Office and walk up to the Executives Offices. You aren't allowed, why do you think this is acceptable?

Sneaking into the office (country) and then benefiting seems not right, what am I missing?

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by nozzlegear on Thursday March 05, 2026 @10:15AM (#47262510)
All my ancestors had to do to become American citizens was get on a boat in Europe and not shit themselves to death by the time it arrived in New York. Why should it be any harder than that?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by iso-logi on Thursday March 05, 2026 @05:03PM (#47267933)
Society has changed. Laws practically didn't exist back then, should we go back to a near lawless society? Should we bring slavery back? Should we prevent woman from working, driving, voting?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by nozzlegear on Thursday March 05, 2026 @07:28PM (#47269153)
You don't even know when my ancestors came over. Why do you think they were on the mayflower and not on a boat headed to Ellis island in the 1900s? We very much had laws back then, though appealing to the existence of immigration laws is a piss poor argument.

“Law never made men a whit more just; and, by means of their respect for it, even the well-disposed are daily made the agents of injustice.” — Henry David Thoreau

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by pixelatedindex on Friday March 06, 2026 @02:01PM (#47279512)
Isn’t it a bit hypocritical to bring up laws, when the current administration really doesn’t adhere to them? Congress today barely does any work, Supreme Court is entirely partisan, and the president is taking bribes in the open.

In any case it’s not the deportation that most people necessarily have an issue with, it’s how they go about doing it. They even killed citizens in the process. Obama deported quite a few.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by ncallaway on Friday March 06, 2026 @06:05PM (#47282295)
A citizen is always someone who has a legal right to be in the country.

They may be imprisoned in the country if they have committed a crime, but a citizen always has a legal right to be in the country.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by pixelatedindex on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @09:02PM (#47256560)
Can’t believe we have people who unironically say things like “illegal citizens need to go”. For shame. You probably are one too, would you leave first?
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by jjcc on Thursday March 05, 2026 @10:44AM (#47262967)
There are 2 groups of new Chinese immigrants in the US, they are quite different:

1.Those who arrived through legal channels (most studied at U.S. universities and remained on H1B visas, with a smaller number through EB5 or other visa categories) and eventualy got green card.

2.Undocumented immigrants, which include several sub-groups/waves. In the 1990s, most came from just a couple provinces, Fujian and southern Zhejiang. After COVID, they were from different parts of China and entered through the southern border.

The contributors to AI development belong to the 1st group. They are spread across the country but a large number work in high-tech companies in Northern California.

The 2nd group was intially concentrated in New York and Southern California (Los Angeles area). Later they have expanded into nearby regions. They provide labor for Chinese-owned small businesses such as restaurants, grocery stores, and hotels.

There is an industry created largely by Chinese political dissidents helping Group 2 through asylum applications using fake materials and exploiting common Western beliefs or narratives about China like human rights concerns. For example, Alysa Liu’s father is an asylum lawyer.

ICE enforcement efforts would likely focus more on Group 2 if they are knowledgable. Ohio should not be a high-priority area. I could be wrong due to changes over time. One indicator you can observe: Are there many Chinese-owned small businesses in your area?

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by hedora on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:36PM (#47264652)
ICE arrests citizens and legal immigrants on a regular basis. Only 5% of the people they arrested had an immigration related conviction on their record:

https://www.cato.org/blog/5-ice-detainees-have-violent-convi...

The Bay Area is mostly exempt for now because, after Trump announced ICE was going to surge in SF, a bunch of tech billionaires with economic interests in the region convinced him not to.

Also, over the last year, there have been a bunch of high-profile arrests of Ohioans by ICE. In one example, they arrested someone for showing up to their immigration hearing, leaving their young kid separated from them outside the court.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by gaoshan on Thursday March 05, 2026 @01:36PM (#47265386)
They were operating in a traditional "China town" neighborhood for the detentions and the neighborhood they were going door to door in is one populated mostly by white collar professionals (tech, college professors, etc.).
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by mmaunder on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:24PM (#47251671)
Yeah that was my first thought is it’s a tit for tat poach. They got the Gemini researcher so google responded in kind.
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by lynndotpy on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:50PM (#47252040)
Well, the problem aren't just the NSF funding cuts. Everyone else is already dumping truckloads of cash. There's also the public health situation (who wants measles or polio?), the risk of retaliatory attacks from the countries we're at war with, etc. You could write paragraphs about why the US is less attractive to researchers.

When I was a deep learning PhD in the first Trump administration, US universities were already very deeply affected by the Muslim ban, and so a lot of talent ended up in other countries.

Sibling commentators are rightfully pointing out that foreigners, especially those who would not be recognized as white, face an onerous and risky customs process with long-term and increasing risks of deportation. When you see a headline like the NIST labs abruptly restricting foreign scientists, _everything_ else feels uncertain. Even if someone doesn't believe they're personally at risk for deportation, they're still seeing everything else.

And then it all boils down to a reputational thing. The era where we were the top choice for research is in the past. If you start a PhD in the US on your resume during this era, you might be anticipating how you'll answe the question of why you weren't good enough to get accepted somewhere better.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by sciencejerk on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:50AM (#47258003)
Where do researchers go instead of USA then? Genuinely curious
Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by lynndotpy on Thursday March 05, 2026 @12:23PM (#47264476)
Canada has always been appealing for people who were set on the United States but taken aback by the political climate. This goes back decades (famously in the AI space, Reagan is why Canada got Hinton instead of the US) but is exacerbated as of late. China also has pretty amazing investment in tech companies and research institutions, but Mandarin doesn't yet enjoy the same widespread adoption of English

Big caveat that I have the perspective of just one US-based former academic.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by expedition32 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @04:29PM (#47254163)
If memory serves the father of the Chinese bomb studied in America and went back. It may be inconceivable to Americans but Chinese patriotism exists.

Besides you can live a comfortable life in PRC nowadays or live in a racist America.

Re:Something is afoot in the land of Qwen by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:01PM (#47254573)
They already kind of do, but I think anyone who was into US money has already left for it, and the money China is throwing at the problem is pretty good also. You can also have a lot more influence in a Chinese company without having to adopt a weird new American corporate culture.