I unfortunately come from a culture where alcohol consumption is accepted, so it's been harder than I would like to break with tradition in the face of science, but doing so it a good thing, and if your cultural background helps you a hand because it does not accept alcohol as readily as mine, more power to you.
Drugs FOMO is some of the stupidest FOMO around. I've nothing against using soft drugs, but making any drug part of your life style is almost certainly a bad idea, and if never even trying suits your personality type (some are just more easily addicted than others), then you are wise for steering clear, not an ignorant traditionalist (or at least, not necessarily so).
That does not mean gathering in third places is problematic, I do wish we could come up with ways of doing it without the expectation of the consumption of alcohol.
You might be stopped in your car in the parking space but someone else might just crash into your car.
So just being in the car on a public road or parking will be safer than driving but not safe as in zero chances of being involved in an accident.
The same goes with alcohol even if you dont consume you are not completely safe from its effects: someone might drink and drive or drink and operate a machinery or drink and build your house …
Probably the same can be said about tiredness or something else. We should pick our battles. I am not sure which ones are better. Just found it funny that even sitting in the car is not safe enough as long as we have vehicles
There might be tangential things you don’t experience too, places you’ll never go, and people you’ll never meet.
-Someone who has experienced “hard” drugs
I've also never drank besides the occasional cocktail, and I can count on my hands the number of times I've bent to a bar. I had other kind of experiences instead and I wouldn't change it, but of course I've missed out on certain things.
But also that was just to point out that IMO the analogy with hard drugs doesn't work, I don't want to debate about a hypothetical world where most people do hard drugs.
Nobody says he just missed out on crashing into a tree on a windy road.
That's the beauty of life. You write your own adventure. Whether people know it or not... eh.
On the other hand, many people drink alcohol and live perfectly normal lives. So I don't think that's an informative comparison.
That's true of most minority positions, just like atheists generally know more about Christians than vice versa ... since you brought up religion, I'd say it is going with the drinking culture flow that is the equivalent of blindly staying with your parent's religion.
And just like with atheism vs. religion, we don't just always make the choice that's easy and comfortable. Like the guy above here who finds that he's more included socially when he drinks - yeah, no shit he is, and he'd be more included in a Pentecostal meeting too if he spoke in tongues. Should we all just go along with things that seem dishonest or insane to us, for the sake of fitting in?
I dare say the opposite, as many drinkers routinely experience not drinking, while the opposite is by definition not true.
I'm a drinker but I have sometimes spent several months without drinking, for various reasons. Including spending months at countries where I didn't drink at all and people I met wouldn't even know whether I usually drink or not.
Honestly I have never saw those wonders of the "never-drinking life" that I'm supposed to be missing. It's the same (drinkers can meet friends during the day and outside of bars, too!) minus the activities that involve drinking.
-- disclaimer I refer to "normal" people who drink but are not addicted. Non drinking people are normal as well.
Aside, this sort of "hilarious reply!" post isn't exactly nice when I'm right here is it.
I didn't say doing that would be wonderful, that was your own words. It's not fun to be the only atheist at a Pentecostal meeting either, but as I said: sometimes you choose what to do for other reasons than fitting in and having fun.
I used not to be a drinker (not total teetotaler, but would never drink when out) well into my 30s. Now I do drink.
I much prefer drinking.
I do think that "alcohol culture" means different things to different people in different places and at different ages. To generalize massively, I don't think much of the stereotypical way way 19yos from the UK drink when in Ibiza.
But I do enjoy 4 or 5 cocktails or whiskys in a good bar (which for me isn't one with loud music incidentally) with good company.
The life of a teetotaler is not just your life minus the time you are drinking. Indeed, you explicitly make GP’s point when you say, “I never saw those wonders of the “never-drinking life” that I am supposed to be missing.”
Now, I would not argue that being a teetotaler is wonderful. I don’t drink because my father was an alcoholic. I feel like I have missed out of vast swaths of life. To me, the experience varies from fine to quite isolating and painful (especially when I was younger and conformity mattered more).
When I was younger, going to a bar and not drinking was like being a virgin late in life while everyone is talking about sex. Once you’ve had sex, you realize no one judges virgins. But as the virgin, you feel painfully alone. You know your friends’ awareness of your difference is harshing their mellow a bit.
But in the end, it is absurd to argue with people on the internet over who knows more about life. That’s a conversation better over a beer. I guess.
Heck, if you really want to try it once for the experience, go ahead under supervision. And don't fall for the 'it didn't ruin my life the first time'. That is just the bait. Its never as good as the first time, you chase the dragon, and you feel like crap later.
If you're feeling like crap all the time and waking up with your money gone, perhaps the problem lay within the drinker, not the drink.
FWIW, I've had my deepest conversations in late evenings after a gig with a glass of white wine in my hand from which I sipped for like an hour. (I'm a musician.) My life would be fundamentally different without a single sip or even entering a bar, and I would really miss something.
But I think you’re mistaken to claim that everyone who enjoys great wine, or whiskey, or beer, is getting nothing from it.
It isn't all religion. Alcohol is a poison, by the definition of poison. There are a hundred studies on its negative effects.
No one's saying alcohol is healthy, but you're certainly cutting out a certain potential for social experiences by avoiding bars and alcohol. For some people the effect help them loosen up enough to have positive, meaningful interactions they wouldn't have otherwise.
Many studies do show that alcohol leads to additional stress, which then drives the need for additional drinking.
Granted, there are people that you never meet outside of a bar or pub and there are people that always have to get a drink, but that might depend on the circles you are in.
Alcohol certainly isn't healthy, and a heavily drunk person is certainly more unpleasant than let's say a heavily stoned one, yet I would not discount the amount of conversations that people dared to have just because they had a glas of wine before. Sure, I'd love people to open up without that glas and sure, some people won't be able to ever open up without it and that's bad, but most people don't overdo it with the alcohol, just like most people don't drink 4 kegs of coffee each day. Whether alcohol is a bad thing over all depends on the amount.
On a light note, ... You don't own any pants or shoes at all?
That said, you having never had a sip. Right on! Each to their own path and I completely get why some folks never try it. Just doesn't interest them and you cannot miss what you never had I guess.
It makes you stupider, less able to control your actions, your emotions and your thoughts. That allows for fights, hooking up randomly which isn't good for anybody and even makes people dependent on it in order to have sex.
It basically makes you more like an animal and less like a human. People like it because they don't like being human, it's hard to have fun as a human, much easier to let go of your higher functions and behave on autopilot then blame it on whatever substance they're on for whatever stupid shit they did.
I do not recommend this. Dark times, and I am thankfully past this.
But anyway, I agree with your premise. People do it to subdue their higher order thinking. If you’ve never wished to do this, then you might just be better suited (or better adapted) to your environment.
I used to think the same, and then I started to drink socially and saw
1. all the things I had been just quietly not been invited to previously
2. the social lubricant aspect of alcohol that I didn't appreciate till I experienced it. This is not just the physiological aspect , this is the social effect as well which can't be replicated sober (see freshmen college students getting "drunk" on alcohol-free beer).
Its difficult to articulate, but the excuse of inebriation creates a "safe space" to let loose in a sense. For instance, if you make an offcolor joke sober people may find it very funny , but they'll also think you maybe lack manners or don't know what's appropriate "She's funny, but kinda low EQ". If you are inebriated (or even pretending to be) then you are safe from judgment up to a point. This opens a lot of doors, and opportunities to bond with people.
Bc of the judgment aspect, no one likes to drink with someone sober - so you're just not seeing it for the most part
I had another analogous experience. All through high school and college I didn't use Facebook. In the last year of college I relented - suddenly I was being invited to stuff left and right.
You don't know what you don't know. Dogmatic beliefs not grounded in experience aren't worth much
Try drinking (responsibily) for a couple of years and then come back making your proclamations. There are very few people that have actively tried both lifestyles and chosen to be a teetotaler. When that does happen , it's generally because of issues of self control, a predisposition to alcoholism or bc they tried it a few times and never got used to it
A couple of drinks a couple of times a month is well worth the health impact to live a little.
As for the “social lubricant” argument: sure people open up more once you pour a bunch of drinks in. I’ll also take your argument that maybe they truly don’t reveal their selves to sober me (I doubt it, I’m generally cooky and have multiple times been asked “are you sure you’re not drunk?”).
Also isn’t it interesting that alcohol brings out the worst qualities in many people as well? Almost every single instance of me hearing a friend having something “inappropriate” happen to them, it was in a bar or pub and there most definitely was alcohol involved. Only over the top creeps do inappropriate things when sober. I’d rather not be in a place where the likelihood of creepy shit going down skyrockets and watch a movie instead.
But what exactly do you reckon you learn from your friends or colleagues that I don’t get to? I have a good job, which I’ve progressed through quite well, so clearly I didn’t miss out on any inside detail that could have only been gleaned professionally over a drink. I have few friends but from what I hear from many, more meaningful ones than most people. Almost always when I skip a party or pub outing the next time I meet someone they just say “yeah you didn't miss much.”
If I’m missing on some secret second life that is only accessible after you sign up to permanently imbuing this drug forever, yeah I’ll pass. Sounds like a cult and it doesn’t matter what orgy or salvation it promises. Sometimes it’s more important to keep your freedom and senses than to experience everything.
Nothing wrong with not drinking, but alcohol has its pluses and minuses. I myself barely drink these days due to having small kids and getting the worst hangovers at this age, but I can't imagine I'd be the same person socially if I hadn't had alcohol when I was younger. I would not have had as good discussions with friends, nor met a fraction of the people I did (including of the opposite sex, including my wife). No health problems as a result, maybe I would have been slightly more focused in my studies, but it would hardly have made a difference to where I am now. The gained social skills vastly outweigh the lost study potential.
Er...no. The statistics completely back this up.
https://www.ncadd.us/about-addiction/addiction-update/alcoho...
But I was responding to this comment here - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36490348
That comment had no statistics to back it up. They only presented their own anecdotes and biases.
I'd encourage you to take that analogy further and think about
- sugar is significantly more addictive. Almost everyone basically craves sweet things regularly. Unless predisposed to alcoholism the vast majority of people do not crave alcohol. If you start to drink and you are thinking about getting a drink when idle at work - then you have an issue and should probably stop. I get the sense from your response that you think this is the default - but I can assure you it's not. At the moment I drink about once every couple of weeks. During the pandemic I was very busy and didn't drink at all. At no point did I "want a drink". Alcoholism is a very serious issue that affect many, but for the vast majority of society this isn't a direct concern (though it seems to affect European countries a lot harder)
- sugar is consumed regularly and is vastly worse for your health that a few drinks once a week or something to that effect
- sugar has basically no social benefits for you. And basically no longer term benefits. There are no sugar orgies I'm sorry to say. It just momentarily makes you a bit happier
You can continue to not drink and life will pass you by. If you're in an alcohol consuming society you will just make fewer connections with people, make fewer friends and fall in love less. But it's doable. I think back on all my close friends - and if I didn't drink EVER I think I'd estimate I'd have 30-50% fewer friends. It's not the end of the world - but it's a significant difference. Most people are shy and take time to open up (myself included). Maybe you connect a bit, but then life makes you sail-by. I now live in a society where people drink a lot less and I constantly make acquaintances that just don't stick. A night out with some drinks doesn't fix everything, but it definitely gives people a chance to connect in a way that's much harder organically. You could argue that "real" "true" friends will connect regardless - it's probably true.. Like 60% of the time? So you leave 40% on the table
My own mental analogy would be like if you insisting everyone reach out to yo by email b/c you're worried about your privacy. Sure you'd still make some friends and still have a life.. But most people won't even bother - and they'll have their orgies on Facebook without you
Or maybe it’s because my drinking buddies got older and I saw the toll it takes on people
It’s like the day you realize how much better life is when you get a good nights sleep and then can never go back
With close friends I don't particularly need alcohol to let loose. I don't worry about how I come off or feel judged. I can be crass or obnoxious when the mood takes me. Their opinions of me have already been cemented over the years.
Sure sometimes you can get together and get trashed and turn it up a notch - but it's never necessary
To me all the benefits i illustrated are in the realm of meeting new people and making new connections - or trying to get with people from the acquaintance stage to the friend stage I suppose
In like 5 minutes I could barely walk. Then they laughed again, told me there was no vodka, they were joking. A minute later I was perfectly sober.
Then they laughed again and said the joke was that there's no vodka, actually it was. Predictably, minutes later I was intoxicated again.
To this day I don't know if there was vodka involved or not.
a) You would have puked it up. b) You would have tasted the disgusting burning crap. c) You would have been out cold within an hour.
Active preaching of alcohol, this is the dumbest advice I’ve ever heard, maybe just after some people preaching for pornography. A drunk you is objectively not any better than a sober one, rather far worse. You have one life, don’t waste it.
Modernity sucks.
The social drinking is about grabbing a drink or two, either solo or friends, to let yourself loose a bit. It’s about temporarily changing your attitude towards your environment, maybe cracking a couple of silly jokes. Maybe sitting at a beach or a park, watching sunset while listening to your surroundings.
Moderation is the key when it comes to mind-altering substances. Obviously it’s easier to say, but if super-majority of your experiences are positive, it is ok to suffer from some mild bad experiences (agonizing hangovers a couple of times a year).
Sorry, I didn’t mention that my religion prohibits the use of any and all mind altering substances. So it’s not possible for me to drink in moderation either. I’m glad for this restriction I choose to obey. I’d rather have me control me at all times rather than some altered version of myself.
Do you think there was any point anywhere in history where people weren’t enjoying drinking together?
FFS one of the miracles of the founding religion of our society is about a guy turning water into alcohol at a party! And that was thousands of years ago!
It’s rather that those who regularly drink can’t enjoy themselves without drinking when the time for a fix comes. It’s an addiction, even if withdrawals are less noticeable due to normalization of drinking and the regularity of the act for most people.
Actually no.
> and mental capabilities such as memory reduced,
OK
> To do and say things you normally wouldn’t.
Again - not really. I'm giving you 1 out of 3.
This is not without correlation.
Between drunk drivers, abused spouses and abused children there is a ton of alcohol related misery. For me personally none of the positive effects of alcohol begin to offset those. Not everybody is able to deal with addictive substances in a responsible way.
I'm perfectly ok with other people drinking (as long as they don't negatively impact others), I just saw the generalization above and figured I would contribute a slightly different point of view.
I do think drinking is great, but part of it is finding what amount you're comfortable with. It's also a skill that needs to be developed. Just saying no and not even trying it... I feel bad for these people people bc they're missing out on a lot
For context I drink maybe once every couple of weeks - unless it's a particularly social period of my life. I find this a good medium for me
There isn't much difference IMHO. Most people don't care if you drink. The single biggest issue is dancing without alcohol, but I managed in high school so I'm fine now.
Maybe I'd still not connect :)) but my gut feeling is that I could at least make 30% more friends if not significantly more
The biggest difference in friend-making was when I graduated and started to work, not when I stopped drinking 5 years later. Also I was never very social to begin with. So maybe what's normal for me is "not connecting" for you :)
Interesting to think about. Thanks for the perspective :)
There are clearly more factors at play than what the law says. What do you believe will happen if you drink alcohol in secret, out of range of the eyes of the State? Muslims believe this will still have consequences in afterlife. Atheists don't. Many Christians believe they'll be saved and forgiven by God as long as they are Christian.
> A 2012 study suggested that belief in hell decreases crime rates, while belief in heaven increases them, and indicated that these correlations were stronger than other correlates like national wealth or income inequality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_correlations_of_cr...
I live in Turkey, probably the most heavily and forcefully secularized muslim country in the world (Ataturk killed half a million population for his secular reforms according to some sources, Islamic alphabet got abolished, western dress code literally became law and religious clothing got prohibited, religion schools closed, religious scholars executed and prosecuted and Adhan was banned for 18 years).
It's free to drink here, but drugs are banned. Only a very small minority drinks alcohol in my region, I have no relatives I know of that ever drank. Drugs/weed/marijuana are horrible things no one ever wants in my entire social circle, I don't think I have ever seen a user of such substances in my entire life IRL. Western and some coastal cities drink more and there's more drug activity too (and they're less religious too).
From here, it’s hilarious to see Westerners thinking prohibition is impossible and preaching against it.
Of the other muslim countries I've been to (Morocco, Malaysia, Egypt) I had no problems getting a drink anywhere and I saw locals drinking in each one.
I wonder if your idea of what going to a bar is has been coloured by TV, movies etc. It doesn’t have to be glamorous. Most bars do not have a dress code. I don’t usually dress differently to go for a beer than I do when I am working.
Interesting perspective, but I think it’s a little conceited to claim you haven’t missed out on anything because you have deeper conversations with people during the day.
I do agree that it’s an awful drug with terrible health consequences. Living the healthiest life possible as often as possible is not necessarily the best way to live, in my opinion. Of course best is subjective.
I've since done almost a complete 180, and now it's very unlikely that a week goes by without alcohol consumption of some sort. I have tonnes of fun and it makes social interactions so much easier for someone like me. And pretty much all of my close social circles have a reasonably healthy relationship with booze, so it's not like we're going out and getting plastered on weekends.
I guess what I'm trying to say is: there's all sorts.
Edited to add: What 'contrarian1234 said in a sibling comment as well.
Godspeed as long as you are it’s master and not the other way around.
Society could use more emphasis on self control.
That said, I liked the article and might give this a go some time. My hearing is lousy for the same reasons as the author.
Whilst I don't drink regularly I have many friends who do. My favourite place to have a catch up and a deep talk is on the hill walking my dog, but that's a bit intense for some friends, and cafes, restaurants and such can also be pretty noisy.
Judging others' drinking misses the point of the article. As we age, we need different spaces and mechanisms for socialising. This is one I'd not thought of, and I enjoyed the author's solution and story.
It's also interesting that with a PhD in biomedical engineering, this is the conversation people choose to have.
As for what alcohol can give you that you don't already know about... It is the 'joy of being a dickhead' the 'wild abandon' or the 'abasement of self' in a communal ritual of shared identity. Some might go so far as to say that the 'revels of dionysus' or 'the bacchanalian' form an intrisic part of civilised identity where that which is proper is upended. Drinking together makes us human and civilised - for the very reason that drinking is choosing to leave civilisation behind.
Is there a line then, into this baccanalian, that can be crossed - where the party turns to the wretched vomit, the fool, the car-crash? Yes - there is this line, and how many of your detractors have crossed it - more than once?
If you have never used alcohol / went to bar, then how do you know if you dont know the perspective?
After alcohol people are more open tho.
A lot of people enjoy Jenga and other dexterity games. It's just not your cup of tea. But please stop telling yourself that you not liking Jenga is a sign of superior intellect.
In three free days I had, I went to coffee shops, restaurant, parks and a pub. Guess where I met new people. Not saying you can't in other places, but to start an interaction with a stranger is so much more relaxed in(front of) a pub. Sure I could go to that group of people in the park, but wouldn't be that a bit to intrusive? In the blues pub where I went, at least I know they all like the same music as me.
I had a chat with people who lived in the city their whole life. I had a chat with a person from the country with a similar name, the one others constantly mistake us for, I had a chat with a regular from a bar and someone who just arrived to the city. I chatted with someone who studied the same thing as me. I met someone who showed me a similar place couple of blocks away with whom I then walked and talked most of the night (in a park :) ).
And no one really expects you to drink. What is more, if you are not there at strange night hours, most of the people don't act that differently after two or three beers.
This sounds rather self-absorbed.
I think this would benefit most people, the exception are "super connectors" who have social abilities so strong that they effortlessly connect to people and connect other pairs (1% or less of the population afaik) without expenditg effort.
But for me, introverted, if I never used alcohol I wouldn't even understand the concept of stopping being uptight and reserved for a single moment to know what life "could be like". This knowledge helps me fight the overwhelming urge when sober to let the inward inclination be all consuming.
You know that people who drink also meet people sober and most of their life they are sober to do work and much of socializing as well.
Going with comment on "conversations are more memorable and deep" comes off as smug just like you would show off how many IQ points you have.
I don't meet people to have "memorable or deep insights", I meet people because I like them and I feel like giving them my time is nice thing to do and I am happy that they feel that I am worthy enough so they want to spend time with me.
More memorable than what - in pubs which you don't go to? You don't know because you've never partook, as you said. You don't know what you're missing out on. How then can you judge one way or the other?
I wouldn't dismiss alcohol as a net negative to humanity. Beer and wine are Lindy staples in European cultures, not just as intoxicants but primarily as food. And although your family culture is quite different, the majority culture of the wealthy, liberal country you received your world-class education from is alcohol-positive. There's something to that.
Note also that drinking alcohol doesn't mean drinking to excess, which is what many people seem to implicate when they talk about drinking alcohol.
staples as in "staple foods or crops"
Personally I meet many of my friends in pubs and the alcohol isn't a factor at all. We manage to have deep and meaningful conversations often.
It's super weird for the GP to feel such strong superiority over something they find themselves unable to even try without fear of disaster. We're supposed to consider them the more enlightened one?
Disclosure, I enjoy alcohol, but I admire those who say "I won't try, not even once".
There is much controversy around this, but by and large most people agree that US interference in South America, and English interference in the Middle East and South Asia in the late 19th and 20th centuries was a net negative for all the resulting countries. Much of American and English wealth was built on extracting resources and wealth out of these countries and concentrating them in Europe and the US. Heck, the very crown of the King of England has an Indian/Pakistani diamond in it.
More than .. what? The conversations you would have had in the evening in a bar? How do you know?
Reminds me of the sticker on the detergent box "20% more effective at removing stains". ... More than ... what?
With that out of the way:
> Whether it’s work outing or friends gathering, I just pass if it’s supposed to be in a pub.
There's a selection of non-alcoholic drinks in every bar nowadays. You don't really have to limit your social life like that just because you don't drink alcohol, unless you're trying to make some kind of point.
Luckily, sober culture is becoming more popular as people realize the consequences of a society where alcohol consumption is widespread — cirrhosis, alcoholism, and various social ills & wastes of money and time.
Also, pubs do not require any kind of special pants or shoes.
Everyone will agree that eating 6-8 slices of bread per day is NOT good for your health but will sing a completely different tune about drinking 2-3 beers at a bar because "socializing" and other excuses.
Ultimately, drinking is the cheapest/easiest way to "socialize" while investing the minimal amount of time thinking about who they want to associate with. The alternative of finding a club, picking up a new activity, and learning what you like/dislike is way more expensive from a time perspective then kicking back 2-4 drinks in a dimly lit room across the street.
Whether it’s work outing or friends gathering, I just pass if it’s supposed to be in a pub. Heck, I don’t even own pants or shoes worthy of wearing to a pub if I needed to.
Yet I feel I haven’t missed out on much and gained many other things. My friends now meet me during the day. The conversations are more memorable and deep and happen at coffee shops, restaurants or on our way to those places. Or if I’m particularly in a good mood I suppose a park.
As an outsider my opinion is that nothing good has come to humanity from the presence of alcohol. It is the worst drug to have invaded our history and that’s saying a lot given every other drug there is. And I’m not just talking about the deaths it causes.