News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by cletus on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:21AM (#26807444)
Here's the one lesson I really want us to all learn from this: the only thing the rich fear is prison because prison robs them of time.

Fines are just the cost of doing business.

There are many other scandals: the whole subprime disaster, pollution from plants and the like where no one went to prison and people really should've.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ryandrake on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#26808250)
Corporations (which are usually the payer of fines for bad behavior) don't fear prison because they can't be physically imprisoned. You can't put Exxon in jail. And, lawmakers deliberately make it so damn hard to pierce the corporate liability veil and hold shareholders or directors personally liable for the corporation's actions.

So, we need to both move more towards prison and start digging in to which actual people inside bad corporations were responsible for deciding to do wrongdoing.

"BigCo settled and paid an insignificant $20M out of their river of money" is not very satisfying to read. "Joe Bigshot, former SVP at BigCo, was sentenced to 5 years in jail, and had to sell two of his nine houses to pay the $20M fine" is much better.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by etripe on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:39AM (#26808598)
> You can't put Exxon in jail.

If a corporation is a legal person with inalienable rights (as the SCOTUS seems to have decided on), but is intangible and immortal at the same time, what can you do? Any of the below:

* freezing assets (=~ reclamation)

* seizing accounts (=~ civil forfeiture)

* suspend a business license (=~ locking them up)

* introduce a revenue cap (=~ prison labour)

* remove lobbyists (=~ losing voting rights)

* dissolve or nationalise the company (=~ death penalty)

This is by no means an exhaustive list.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by daniel-cussen on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:56AM (#26808855)
Order the company to operate out of a prison complex, under guard surveillance, with monitored phone calls, the works. Every employee must go there for his entire shift, no telecommuting.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by dimitrios1 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:16PM (#26809178)
They'll carve out exceptions for the ones responsible at the top. You'll just be penalizing the common wage earner who have to feed their families.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by V-2 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @06:53PM (#26814110)
Even if they didn't make any exceptions, still, why should regular level employees get punished for something over which they've never held any responsibility whatsoever?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by daniel-cussen on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:37AM (#26820312)
I think "never held any responsibility whatsoever" is going too far. There's one company I know that narrowly avoided the RICO act and paid out a huge amount in a lawsuit, and admitted to having behaved criminally, only to commit the same crime in the same way, in some cases, to the same persons. You're telling me, their employees had no idea, no impact, no responsibility?

This reminds me of 2006. The subprime bubble. In California, everyone had six magazines about real estate on their brand new coffee table. You'd go to someone's house, they'd talk about their house. And the houses around them. Anybody people admired, it was because she bought 4 years ago and sold 6 months ago, or better still, because she owned 2 houses and not merely 1. "Real estate agent" was one of the "careers" people rattled off as being respectable, along with doctors and firefighters (lawyers barely, engineers not at all). Everyone was afraid of being priced out of the market, and there was a constant cycle between selling your house at a huge profit, paying out the realtor's fees and taxes and costs of the fixer-upper-ing, and then the dread of having all this money but no house, and buying an expensive new house. With a lot of leverage, but somehow the Ferrari-driving hotshots at the mortgage refinancing found a way to get you a HELOC (home equity line of credit, possible because of the appreciation) so you could buy a hummer. And nobody did anything! Nobody could explain their job then, if what you did for a living made sense outside the bubble you were missing out. I couldn't understand how so many people could contribute to society through sales, retail banking, transactions, appraisers was another one. Unbelievable.

The middle class may not have benefitted like the upper class (as it was then called, now you'd say "the rich" or "the 1%"), but they were still avidly playing the game when the music stopped. And they ended up suffering much more for it, (some rich people suffered too), jobs became much more demanding, but they were in on it. It wasn't just Wall Street that kept repeating "real estate never goes down", it absolutely was Main Street too.

With that said, the regular employees probably have something to do with the dirty work the business engages in. Otherwise they'd be contractors or outsourced, like the janitors and moderators are.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by wholinator2 on Friday April 16, 2021 @09:31AM (#26833639)
And what actions should Joe Schmoe with a mortgage, two kids and their college funds, and a wife who was laid off and has no health insurance take against his employer. What do you consider a reasonable level of risk for him to undertake? How much should he be punished for continuing to feed and house his family while the CEO embezzles or otherwise abuses his power?

My point is this, why should we punish people who feel they (and in many cases truly) have no choice in whether criminal action was taken? If I held a gun to your head and said, "Just ignore that or I will take everything from you and plunge your life into chaos", what do you do? What is the responsible thing to do? For you? For your family? Your children? Society? The company? The government? For the most part, people working in these companies don't do so becaus they love to work, they do so because they have to to survive and to keep their families afloat.

Joe Schmoe executed the orders because he's terrified if he doesn't, there will be retaliation and his life and the lives of those he loves will be severely damaged. CEO person gave the orders because they know a fine is just the cost of doing business and they don't give a fuck who or what they hurt, what laws they break, what damage they do. Do you see the power imbalance here? Why should we not use "who had the power" as a determination for who to prosecute? Unless you provide protection from explicit retaliation and even the power dynamic some I don't see reason to prosecute Joe over CEO. Even then, there are other forms of retaliation that are harder to verify or see. Think about trying to get rid of bullying in a middle or high school.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bumby on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:17PM (#26810929)
I think this may create asymmetries between risk/reward for those (real) people making the decisions.

Think about it with a sports analogy. If I cheat and take performance enhancing drugs, there’s huge potential upside: I can drastically increase my salary. If the consequence was spread to the team rather than concentrated on the individual it encourages the individual to take that risk. Maybe the team would be forced out of the playoffs. So the team lost their (smallish) chance at a trophy but I get a (largish) chance to increase my salary. In rare cases maybe the individual becomes a pariah. Regardless, if the individual isn’t held disproportionately accountable it incentivizes bad behavior. I think there’s a reason leagues ban individuals for certain behavior.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by smolder on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:07PM (#26811617)
If workers had to worry about the ethics of their employer getting the whole company in trouble, that would be a good thing in the sense of drying up the labor pool for dubiously run companies. On the other hand, the Justice Dept doesn't always land on the side of justice, so smaller companies could end up victims of abuse of the court system in the name of competitive advantage.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by etripe on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @06:43PM (#26814024)
> smaller companies could end up victims of abuse of the court system in the name of competitive advantage.

The same already goes for things like IP and trademark, so that's a fair bet. Good point.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by etripe on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:07PM (#26813096)
> I think this may create asymmetries between risk/reward for those (real) people making the decisions.

Those asymmetries wouldn't be new, because the corporation as a construct already shields the real people making the decisions, along with the jurisprudence of slaps on the wrist. Are companies held accountable for their "externalities" today, like mass foreclosures in real estate, exploitative labour conditions, poisoning the water supply, oil spills, climate change or destruction of habitats?

In keeping with the prison metaphor, would you work for an "ex-con" company? How about one on "probation" when you've got a family to support? Would you invest in one? As I see it, the potential for self-corrective behaviour is greater with my (admittedly, off-the-cuff) suggestions than the status quo.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bumby on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:57PM (#26813615)
I think we’re in agreement. The asymmetric risk I was speaking of is the status quo where individuals are not held accountable but rather the corporate “team” is via fines etc. It makes risky decisions more palatable to an executive officer because they have less downside skin in the game.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by gremlinsinc on Thursday April 15, 2021 @05:28AM (#26818173)
Require all c-level execs and board members to sign affidavits proving they had zero knowledge of the illegal activity, any who were found to commit perjury later on will get 5x the original sentence that normally is given for the crime.

Anyone who provides proof of perjury on another member of the board/execs will receive leniency/clemency.

All felonies against corporations must hold at least one person in jail for a minimum of 3 years. Every c-level exec must serve a minimum of 1 year, with very few exceptions... (e.g. CTO started work one day before everything went to shit, literally had no knowledge)...

I also think cops who cover up for, or are "quiet" about other cops who've committed crimes, if it comes out they "knew" and didn't tell anyone should serve the same sentence.

People in authority need to have consequences, the only way to stop corruption is for corruption to be painful and very complicated so that only a "few" get away with it, the more people get away with it the more it happens.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by qwertox on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:18PM (#26810945)
Doesn't it have a different effect, though?

Let's assume you have a company like Volkswagen and the corporate executives have decided they play the game of not getting informed about some really shady business practices which are helping the company to earn good money.

Would it make sense for Germany to punish Volkswagen by any of the means you mention, thus weakening the company in relation to foreign car makers, vs. to hold all (or the relevant) executives responsible, seize all their assets, prevent them from working in any administrative position ever again, limiting their income to a certain amount. Like really sanction them.

The company would continue to run, shareholders would be affected minimally, the problem would have been corrected. Of course this is a blue-eyed look at it, but seriously, you also can't do the comparison you are making. They just don't have the same effect.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by foogazi on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:24PM (#26811020)
> thus weakening the company in relation to foreign car makers

Now you are getting into too big to fail territory where applying the letter of the law affects the workers/citizens

Similar things would happen due to gross incompetence from workers causing and oil spill (Exxon-Valdez disaster)

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by sudosysgen on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:30PM (#26812642)
Punish the shareholders, but let the company continue working. In the minimal case this is a tax on profits, in the maximal case this is a nationalization with no compensation.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by etripe on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @06:41PM (#26814004)
> to hold all (or the relevant) executives responsible, seize all their assets, prevent them from working in any administrative position ever again, limiting their income to a certain amount. Like really sanction them.

All for it, if it actually happened anywhere in recent history. I'm not being facetious, but I'm not aware of any examples or am failing to recall them. Do you have any in mind?

> the problem would have been corrected.

I'm not so sure. Suppose the company made massive profits (or avoided capital expenditure, or limited losses) by cheating at something like emissions. Then, the C-level execs get fired, their assets get seized and they're barred from holding administrative functions again. Did the company not still gain massive profits? Do you think it wouldn't be able to find another set of fall guys, if it pays them enough? Wouldn't the company do it again, if the risk is offset to a bunch of figureheads? Your suggestion would only rule out bad behaviour by those same actors in the future. In a more charitable reading: it would lead to better outcomes than today's rules.

Meanwhile, the damage through emissions and particular matter has been done. According to the WHO (0), about 25 people died of particulate and ambient pollution per 100k people in Germany in 2016. That puts it at 2000 people country wide that year. Did Volkswagen kill anyone by doing this? If so, how many of those could have been avoided had they not cheated on their tests? What about the impact on climate change? How were these problems theoretically addressed by seizing C-level execs' assets without giving them jail time?

> Would it make sense for Germany to punish Volkswagen by any of the means you mention, thus weakening the company in relation to foreign car makers

Yes, because the infractions were socially destructive. After all, the German government's first responsibility is towards the greater good for its citizens. According to Volkswagen's website (1), 44% of their employees or 292,378 people work for them in Germany itself. Directly, of course. Applying a fairly generous, tenfold knock-on effect, less than 4% of the total population - 2% of the active population - works for or with them. According to CNN (2), it represented 2.7% of Germany's GDP.

Also, it would hurt and stimulate competition. Not being able to pay out dividends for a year due to revenue caps, not being able to sell products in Germany that year due to cheating at exchaust measurements, etc might change shareholder voting and investment behaviour. It would damage the brand's image, reduce its ability to attract employees, etc. Maybe market forces would then finally be able to correct bad behaviours. Today's "cost of doing business" slaps on the wrist simply don't seem to have any corrective effect whatsoever.

> you also can't do the comparison you are making.

I was being hyperbolic for effect. When staying within the confines of pragmatism, surely some kind of revision to corporate/criminal law (or its enforcement) is warranted. Most people don't get the death penalty, either, or go to jail. Hell, apparently some people don't even get speeding tickets! The same would probably go for corporate actors even if the consequences were steeper.

[0] https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/indicators/indicator-detai...

[1] https://annualreport2018.volkswagenag.com/group-management-r...

[2] https://money.cnn.com/2015/09/22/news/economy/volkswagen-ger...

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by seneca on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:45AM (#26808681)
> If a corporation is a legal person with inalienable rights (as the SCOTUS seems to have decided on)

Please stop repeating this nonsense. Corporate Personhood is a legal idea, and does not mean a "corporation is a legal person". Without corporate personhood, you wouldn't be able to sue a company for wrongdoing if the guilty employee quit, or even enforce basic contracts.

There are serious problems with corporations not being held liable, but the situation would be worse without Corporate Personhood, not better.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ajcp on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:11PM (#26809109)
I think the (now deeply ingrained) confusion stems from a misconception surrounding the Citizens United vs. FEC ruling, where the majority opinion in part cited campaign finance restrictions as a violation of First Amendment rights.

Since the Bill of Rights are protections of citizens rights, it has widely been misreported that this meant the SCOTUS ruling de jure recognized corporations to be citizens themselves.

This, of course, is not correct. The majority opinion in part says that "if the First Amendment has any force, it prohibits Congress from fining or jailing citizens, or associations of citizens, for simply engaging in political speech." The key phrase here being "associations of citizens", which the majority interpreted broadly to include corporations. This does not at all bestow personhood or citizenship upon corporations, legal or otherwise. It does afford corporations some protections as they are now legally recognized as "associations of citizens".

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by dougmany on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:11PM (#26810851)
At the end of the day the corporation is still enjoying those rights. The majority chose to ignore the veil and freely pass along citizens rights the to association.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ajcp on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:06PM (#26811605)
I agree, it was too broad an interpretation, since corporations already have a legal representation and are an economic entity, not a civil society association through which citizens relate to or exercise their political will.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by simplerman on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:24PM (#26809283)
You would sue guilty employees even if they quit and move to another company. I feel that would be much better for personal responsibility.

And the best part about this would be people cannot hide behind "I am just following orders."

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by mminer237 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:50PM (#26810577)
Also, it would mean you usually would not recover anything since a corporation usually has deep pockets and your average employee is not even worth suing even if you could win.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by simplerman on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:30PM (#26811098)
True, but that may be a good thing. This may prevent people from suing for small infractions.

On other hand, let's say, if your average software developer knows that they can be sued into bankruptcy, then they will not release unfinished code and voice strong opposition to it. Thus shifting responsibility to middle managers. Now if middle managers know that they can be sued into bankruptcy, they will not override developers concerns and extend deadline and refuse to push unfinished product. Executives may try to override managers decisions but then responsibility shifts to them and they would not want to lose significant portion of their net worth. Board or managing-owners may try to override CEO, but then they will be responsible and they would not want to be personally sued and lose a portion of their personal wealth.

Yes this may not impact billionaire owners but that is a small number. Most companies will be more ethical and people will have a high degree of personal responsibility.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bumby on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:57PM (#26812243)
I think my issue with your hypothetical is that is assumed a company is already viable and in business. One of the primary advantages of a corporation or LLC is it’s limited liability. I.e., you can take a risk and if things don’t work out you can still personally recover. I suspect if we took the approach of your post, many, many fewer people would try their hand at starting a business because there are no limits to liability and much less capital to fund businesses if shareholders downside wasn’t capped.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by etripe on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:43PM (#26812807)
I'm open to having misinterpreted the situation. How is corporate personhood not the same as a corporation being a legal person? I mean functionally, not semantically. If you would, help me understand why this is not a difference without distinction.

Please note I didn't pass any judgement on whether a corporate person is a useful construct or whether it should be abolished. I agree it serves a purpose and should continue to exist.

What I would argue is "limited liability" as it applies to and shields company owners shouldn't mean "free from consequences" for the corporation as an aggregate. If I'm reading your post correctly, we don't disagree there.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by monocasa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:10PM (#26809084)
You can sue the government even though they aren't granted personhood.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ac29 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:35PM (#26809451)
Its harder to sue the government than you might think, see for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unit...
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by monocasa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:45PM (#26809622)
Regardless, the argument there isn't that you can't sue the government at all, but instead that the government is granted immunity for some subset of actions.

Going back to the original point, personhood is clearly not a requirement for being named in a suit. For more examples you can also see in rem cases, where the government sues property itself for civil forfeiture. 11 1/4 Dozen Packages of Articles Labeled in Part Mrs. Moffat's Shoo-Fly Powders for Drunkenness did not need personhood to be named in a lawsuit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._11_1/4_Dozen_...

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by iudqnolq on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:13PM (#26810026)
> but instead that the government is granted immunity for some subset of actions.

It's actually the opposite. You can only sue the government when they explicitly give you permission.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unit...

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by monocasa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:22PM (#26810184)
The whole point I'm making here is that you can sue an entity without personhood.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by iudqnolq on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:28PM (#26810266)
That's right. I just pointed out the one of the pieces of evidence you used is slightly wrong. Suing the government is a very special case.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by monocasa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:32PM (#26810317)
See the "Exceptions and abrogation" section of your own citation. It is indeed a (albeit large) subset of actions to which they can apply sovereign immunity.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by iudqnolq on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:44PM (#26810486)
Yes. All I'm trying to say is it's opt-in, not opt out. I don't find this particularly interesting or important so this is the last comment I'll make here.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by monocasa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:56PM (#26810661)
Except it's not opt-in for a certain subset of actions of the government. For instance they can't block a discrimination suit on sovereign immunity grounds.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by r00fus on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:45PM (#26812829)
Civil forfeiture where govt sues "property" to seize it so they don't have to have a trial for the person owning said property is a shady dark pattern that shouldn't be cited as an ethical approach at all. Just my opinion.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by monocasa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:18PM (#26813234)
It's not being cited as an ethical approach, only that the court system clearly doesn't require something to have full personhood in order to be sued.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by jameshart on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:45PM (#26809613)
‘Granted personhood’ doesn’t mean anything. The relevant legal term is ‘legal personality’. Governments certainly have legal personality. If they didn’t they wouldn’t be able to enter into contracts, file lawsuits, or... really make any claim to exist in any meaningful way.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by monocasa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:48PM (#26809667)
Is the government itself granted first amendment protections as an association of citizens?

Or is it thought of a fundamentally different sort of entity, that yes can enter some sorts of legal arrangements, but isn't granted all the rights of a citizen?

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by simonh on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:10PM (#26810829)
The details of that probably haven't been settled by supreme court rulings, but the basic principle is that when a corporate entity says something, what's actually happening is that a person in the company is saying this thing, on the behalf of other people in that company, on behalf of, etc until you get to the shareholders. It's people all the way down, and people have rights. The same could be said of the government.

Note I'm a British Citizen, but the same basic legal principles apply over here, and have done for hundreds of years. I know there's a widely held conspiracy theory that this is all new, but jurists and legal scholars have been discussing and applying these principles for a very long time.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by john_moscow on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:30AM (#26808461)
>Joe Bigshot, former SVP at BigCo, was sentenced to 5 years in jail, and had to sell two of his nine houses to pay the $20M fine" is much better.

Well, they sort of do that in Russia. So the CEO/founder of almost any sketchy company is a homeless person that signed the paperwork in exchange for some free vodka. Didn't particularly solve the problem.

Corporate fines just need to be sufficient to make such "business" unprofitable. "BigCo fined for 5% of its market cap" would be quite a deterrent. Except, it won't be happening as long as the regulators are in bed with the big business they are supposed to regulate.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by mannykannot on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:42AM (#26808635)
The second paragraph of the post you are replying to seems to anticipate this response:

"So, we need to both move more towards prison and start digging in to which actual people inside bad corporations were responsible for deciding to do wrongdoing."

In the post-Enron world, however, executives have learned how to use incentives to motivate their minions to break the law without being explicitly told to do so. On the one hand, this makes it difficult to prosecute those who bear most responsiblity; on the other hand, more effective prosecution might curtail the supply of minions who can be motivated to be compliantly criminal.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by hackflip on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:55AM (#26808844)
"Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest?"
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by rjsw on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:08PM (#26809039)
Also "Working Towards the Führer" [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ian_Kershaw#%22Working_Towards...

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by r00fus on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:50PM (#26812887)
So - stochastic dictatorial regime? (stolen from: stochastic terrorism).
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by 55555 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:08PM (#26809041)
> Well, they sort of do that in Russia. So the CEO/founder of almost any sketchy company is a homeless person that signed the paperwork in exchange for some free vodka. Didn't particularly solve the problem.

Can you find me a reference to this? I could believe it, but by default I'd be surprised if it were true at any real scale.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by postsantum on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:34PM (#26810340)
We refer to such person as "зиц-председатель" which means chairperson-to-be-jailed
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by tfehring on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:54PM (#26809762)
I’d also like to see more fines in the range of multiple years’ worth of revenue, but it wouldn’t change directors’ incentives since they still have limited downside exposure and therefore asymmetric payoffs. Even if a CEO runs a company into the ground they’ll probably still be rich since they only have levered exposure on the upside (through ISOs, etc.) and comparatively limited exposure on the downside.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by fairity on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:40PM (#26809540)
> Corporate fines just need to be sufficient to make such "business" unprofitable.

This seems untenable because large businesses will then be forced to break individual business units into separate corporations to manage risk. At first glance this might seem fine, but you'd basically be creating huge drag on the economy bc large businesses benefit from economies of scale.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by baq on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:36AM (#26808556)
oh, regulators are playing the market both ways. congressmen and senators don't have any issue with trading options.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by throwawayboise on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:49PM (#26810557)
There's no need to put Exxon in jail. Exxon is what the C-level executives make it. If they decide that Exxon is going to break the law (or permit it to happen), and are held personally responsible, that is all you would need to do to see a large change in behavior.

Shareholders are too far removed from personal responsibility, and holding them responsible beyond the financial risk they already carry would basically destroy the rationale for the existence of limited liability corporations.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by newsclues on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:42AM (#26808647)
Normalization imprisonment of boards of directors and executive officers of companies that break the law.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by hamandcheese on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:16PM (#26809179)
I tend to agree, but how do you deal with sketchy companies installing a sham board and executives?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by lostcolony on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:25PM (#26810221)
Why try to stop it? Pretty sure a sufficiently enabled and incentivized prosecutor will be able to find the actual culprits. "Discovery" exists as a legal process after all.

Sham boards/executives only are issues if the prosecution itself is a sham, more concerned with the appearance of the thing than deterrence.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by hamandcheese on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:41PM (#26811234)
My interpretation of the GP was that if companies are guilty of wrongdoing, boards and executives should be imprisoned without any additional burden of proof required to establish individual culpability. This sounds somewhat appealing, as how can these people _not_ be responsible in some way?

Otherwise, no need to single out the board.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by newsclues on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @06:20PM (#26813808)
Yes, target the leaders responsible for criminal activities.

But perhaps the shareholders should bear responsibility as well.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Ekaros on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:40PM (#26811220)
Maybe if certain percentage of ownership can be proven, by any route. Let's say 1%. So you own 1% of company and it does some criminal. You will suffer 1% of penalty.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by P_I_Staker on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:58PM (#26812259)
Yeah, personal responsibility is great and all; a vital piece of the puzzle. Someone will always be willing to be the fall guy for money, though. It doesn't seem to make logical sense, because what's the point of having millions and being locked up? but people aren't logical.

I do fear shifting too much responsibility to individuals will just absolve the people really pushing for this stuff, in favor of just finding employees to blame, and constantly making individuals fear for their jobs (and being blacklisted), or prison... but the ones responsible will have nothing to fear.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by tacostakohashi on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:21PM (#26810169)
You may enjoy reading this press release, then.

https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2008/September/08-at-...

Unfortunately, there aren't too many of those.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_companies_convicted_of...

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by gumby on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:24PM (#26813311)
When a car runs over a pedestrian the car is not jailed, the driver is.

When a corporation runs over a town, why is the person or people "steering" the corporation not jailed?

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ginko on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:27AM (#26808423)
I guess the corporate equivalent would be the forced shutdown of all company infrastructure for N months.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by i_haz_rabies on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:31AM (#26808474)
that just burns all the regular people working regular jobs at that org.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by hobs on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:32AM (#26808495)
So fix the social safety net, too big to fail is not something we want to have, especially when it comes to actively harmful companies...
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by i_haz_rabies on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:35AM (#26808540)
Jailing the people responsible seems like a way better option than putting potentially tens of thousands of people on welfare.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ericd on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:41PM (#26810439)
Part of the punishment could be that the company still has to pay all salaries and hourly wages while it’s shut down.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by throwawayboise on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:47PM (#26810523)
With what earnings would they do this?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ericd on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:55PM (#26810642)
Their cash balance, debt, or equity raise. Or they go bankrupt. That would be part of the risk of doing something that got your company this punishment.

To be clear, I’m not advocating these shutdowns as a good idea, there are a lot of implications that I haven’t thought through.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bboylen on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:25PM (#26811036)
Who is going to invest cash into a business that has to stop operating for N months, while maintaining everyone on payroll?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ericd on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:51PM (#26811373)
Perhaps one of the many professionals working in distressed debt or special situations? If you're not familiar, there are desks at Goldman, etc called "Special Situations" that focus on relatively niche investment opportunities. Investors just need the price to be right. Would likely be bad for the shareholders, but again, that's part of the punishment.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bboylen on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:06PM (#26811596)
There could be a price that worked but I don't think there are many businesses that can go offline for several months and come back fine. I'm most familiar with the industry I work in, (O&G), where a day not operating is an incredible loss. Is shutting down the oil refineries and petrochemical complexes what is best for the country? I just struggle to see how this wouldn't just punish normal workers and furthermore just make the economy worse off as a whole
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ericd on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:28PM (#26811890)
There would be economic damage, no doubt. And maybe to the level where it's politically impossible to enact this kind of thing. And maybe it's a stupid idea :-)
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by gambiting on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:45PM (#26811291)
Why would anyone invest anything in this scenario? Most companies in the world operate without any investment whatsoever.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bboylen on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:02PM (#26811543)
As we saw with the covid market crash, a lot of companies (like airlines) don't keep a lot of cash on hand. If they had 0 revenue for several months but still had operating costs, I am assuming they would need a loan
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by hobs on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:33PM (#26809429)
Managing the long term cost of reforming entire organizations is probably not worth it, better to destroy it AND jail the leaders.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by a3camero on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:17PM (#26810095)
Who not both? Just because it’s normal that low level workers are fired and get nothing doesn’t mean that’s how it has to be. Severance could be generous enough to make this work out.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by unethical_ban on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:39PM (#26811211)
Banking? Raw materials? Shipping?

How do people think that all corporations/companies are discretionary?

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by m-p-3 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:51PM (#26814980)
I'm against the death penalty, but I would have no problem with seeing a corporation put to death in the worst situations.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Waterluvian on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:57PM (#26815735)
Real consequences for the officers and a complete rejection of "we had no idea this was happening!"
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by DrBazza on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:32PM (#26809416)
> So, we need to both move more towards prison and start digging in to which actual people inside bad corporations were responsible for deciding to do wrongdoing.

And that's like turkeys voting for Christmas. In most Western countries, governments, political parties and businesses are so intertwined, your member of congress/senate/parliament is probably a businessman (Trump!), or is lobbied by businesses, or the party is funded by business.

That's not to say it won't happen, but it takes something fairly seismic to make governments act.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bedhead on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:06PM (#26809004)
This is one reason why CEO pay has skyrocketed: hazard pay. Something goes wrong, even if the CEO had no idea about it, and who gets vilified and maybe even prosecuted? The CEO. Just saying...there are trade offs for everything.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by albatross on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:09PM (#26809076)
Is that really a reason for skyrocketing pay though? Struggling to come up with any instances where this actually happened and such "hazard pay" was "justified."
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by smolder on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:25PM (#26811857)
It's an excuse but not a good reason. The reason is more that people on top of the income/wealth divide have the power to give themselves more power and keep growing the divide, and they're unafraid of the risks that come with the reward. Populist uprisings are a thing of the past in the info age. The little people are sufficiently surveiled and controlled by the network, by partisan propaganda that keeps them infighting, etc.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by vagrantJin on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:09PM (#26810816)
Hazard pay? Why this sounding like CEOs do deep sea diving, welding huge oil pipes while squid and sharks look at you in a tiny cage with a few thousand amps of arc.

Let's call it what it is, It's a golden parachute.

I'd postulate that taking responsibility and leading the effort to genuinely right the wrongs would earn the company way more godwill from the people and media than activating your trump card which in this case is a mountain of cash to land on after successfully escaping responsibility.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by nemacol on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:41AM (#26807718)
Do you think that a system of public service / community service requirements instead of fines would be better for common offenses?

Without any real research I have often thought that instead of fines for parking violations, noise complaints, (other misdemeanors) etc - having someone spend time instead of money would make those sorts of punishments more equitable.

There are issues - child care if a parent has to spend time. This system would need to accommodate peoples schedules, shouldn't have to miss work for a parking ticket, etc. Much harder to administer than mailing fines.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by cletus on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:50AM (#26807885)
The criminal justice system already does this extensively. Often people are sentenced to community service.

So I guess your question is really should this be extended to more low-level offenses like minor traffic violations?

It's an interesting question. In Switzerland, for example, speeding above a certain level ceases to be a fixed fine and is instead a percentage of your income. I'm a fan of that. Fixed fines tend to discriminate against the poor disproportionately.

I can imagine there are many people who would be better off and would prefer 2-4 hours of community service over a $100 fine. So that should certainly be an option instead of paying the fine.

Yeah I think the idea probably does have merit.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:23PM (#26810190)
One of my past bosses had a supercar as his daily driver. He had a specific law firm on retainer purely to handle speeding tickets. He'd call them when pulled over, and apparently they knew what to say to discourage cops from writing the ticket. People with the kind of wealth to routinely retain services like that effectively play by different rules than the rest of us in the US.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by comprev on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:09AM (#26808188)
Same in Finland I believe. The fine is a % of your annual income.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Ekaros on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:46PM (#26811296)
Calculate daily income, minus some protected cut and then multiplied by number of days. For drunk driving for example 50 "day fines". So at net monthly wage of 1800€ would be 1288. At 10k€ monthly netwage 8128€...

Also Finland does have option to turn some of these day fines to prison time at rate of 4 to 1..

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by yostrovs on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:03AM (#26808100)
You're referring to reported income, that in Switzerland is a national tradition to hide.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by nemacol on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:57AM (#26808012)
I like the % of income idea.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:03AM (#26808103)
I like it simply because screwing the rich and middle as hard as the poors on trivial issues is gonna make it real clear real quick how excessive penalties for common civil offenses are and pretty soon thereafter the laws will change.

HN has this fantasy of $10k speeding tickets. In reality it's gonna look like 100mph speed limits, $100 fines for you and $10 fines for your nanny.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by elil17 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#26808246)
Other countries have $10k speeding tickets for the rich who ignore traffic rules. It’s not such a fantasy, it’s a real world way to reduce emissions and automobile deaths.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by gambiting on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:50PM (#26811364)
The problem is that above a certain level even that doesn't work. Like, answer me this - if you catch Jeff Bezos speeding, what possible fine can we impose on him to "hurt"? Compared to his wealth, we'd probably need to fine him like $1B for it to have any effect, right? And someone would still argue that it doesn't hurt him like a $500 ticket hurts a poor person.

But then literally no court anywhere in the world would agree that a $1BN fine for speeding is "punishment fitting the crime". It's just not.

Like, I like idea in general, but there will ways be people immune to it. Like others have said - the only real punishment is time. And not even necessarily prison - just make a CEO do 300 hours of community service, see how that works out.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by monocasa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:38PM (#26809494)
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by telesilla on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:11AM (#26808202)
Don't excessive speeding tickets lead to a loss of license? This is the perfect response. Perhaps a more sophisticated society will one day know our fears and punish us accordingly (cue film script).
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:17AM (#26808296)
>Don't excessive speeding tickets lead to a loss of license?

Usually.

>Perhaps a more sophisticated society will one day know our fears and punish us accordingly (cue film script).

That was a plot line in 1984 and IMO flies in the face of equality under law.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Spooky23 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:31AM (#26808471)
For a normal person, yes.

If you have money to light on fire you can hire attorneys to delay, appeal, etc. Eventually, it will catch up.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bsanr2 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:26AM (#26808406)
This is true of much of the justice system. Penalties aren't meant to curb certain specific behaviors, they're meant to be used as general control mechanisms for people who can't wiggle out of punshiment by one means or another. I think the advance of physical and digital surveillance is eventually going to force a reevaluation of what behavior we criminalize, because either otherwise-upstanding people start to get caught in the web (see: piracy for personal use in the 00s), or we see an increasing number of highly public instances of clearly malicious or neglectful actors sliding (which we're arguably already seeing wrt police brutality cases).

We're inadvertently about to make the dystunction of our legal system everyone's problem, which is when you'll see change.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by geoduck14 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:09PM (#26809059)
>gonna make it real clear real quick how excessive penalties for common civil offenses are and pretty soon thereafter the laws will change.

I like you. This is good.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by tralarpa on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:46AM (#26808689)
> $100 fines

Where I live, that's what you pay when you drive 10mph too fast.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by mc32 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:00AM (#26808063)
What do you do with crimes committed by people who have little in earnings (students, unemployed, etc.) or folks who earn “$1” in income but obviously are otherwise wealthy?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by nemacol on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:09AM (#26808176)
Interesting question.

I imagine someone has already thought of this from a tax point of view.

Maybe some % of their net worth divided by their age (working age?) - say if they have 100 million dollars and are 60. 60-18 = 42. We would fine X% of 2,380,952.38? The idea being an attempt to come up with what their yearly salary could have been based on current value.

I am sure there are some excellent flaws with that approach as well.

Fun to ponder.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by dec0dedab0de on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:46PM (#26809626)
I hope the government doesn't keep track of everyones net worth, it's bad enough they know everyone's income.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by whatshisface on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:04AM (#26808117)
It would be based on the income of all of the money attached to you, including interest/dividends/appreciation within trusts with you as the grantee. Since wealth makes more money in virtually every way it can be stored, and since not investing it results in the "inflation tax," inflation + income tax = wealth tax.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by distances on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:33PM (#26809423)
In Finland where all larger fines are day-fines the minimum day-fine is 6€.

Calculation is based in your total income (including capital income). Most rich people would be affected due to capital income.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by galfarragem on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:17AM (#26808299)
Nit pick: so income zero means no fines?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by klyrs on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:32AM (#26808486)
Yet another argument for UBI, I guess?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by BTCOG on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:46AM (#26808695)
I'd much rather pay a $100 fine for whatever it is, than waste 2-4 hours of my time.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by baud147258 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:20PM (#26813260)
losing your driving license seems also a good deterrent to avoid speeding
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by hindsightbias on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:41AM (#26808631)
Have a friend who got a driving related offense in a Bay Area county. He asked to go to jail for two or three weeks as he had a good job and income and could make it work with his boss. It was denied and he had to do weekend community service for 8 months.

As a traveling consultant, this was a real wrench into his job and for his employer. He'd have to travel back every Thursday because he could not afford a Friday flight cancellation and missing service. Now, this court and county insists they structure it this way so to have the least impact on people. But he would arrive and watch all his crime peers arrive by taxi, foot or bike (bus service to that area on Saturday morning was a no-op).

The vast majority of his peers were not people who could afford $20 each-way taxi or uber trips and worked jobs on weekends. They lost their jobs because their licenses were suspended. He suspected many of them gave up trying to comply and parked 1/2 mile away, driving their cars with with suspended licenses.

Community service is basically a racket and not necessarily a better work/life deal than prison.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by amelius on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:58AM (#26808031)
I want to see FAANG CEOs do public service, instead of being fined pennies.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by dec0dedab0de on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:46AM (#26807807)
I do, it would also be more fair than fines because it wouldn't be worse on the poor. I also think we should have corporal punishment, not because I believe in it per se, but because I think it is more humane than prison and would satisfy societies need for punishing the guilty.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by nemacol on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:53AM (#26807940)
I can see an argument that poor folks have less free time - if someone worked a couple part time jobs, has kids or other family that rely on them, several hours picking up litter is a pretty big deal. Vs my 9-5 M-F job, no dependants, etc. several hours picking up litter is a bummer or inconvenience.

I think that corporal punishment proposal is batshit insane.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by MisterBastahrd on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:00AM (#26808052)
Common? Sure.

Well educated, comfortable people who rob others of their livelihood? They deserve state penns, just like the poor folks who got three strikes for walking off with hedge clippers.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by backtoyoujim on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:43AM (#26808656)
I disagree.

--

“Bernie really was a successful businessman with quite original insights into the market, and he’s continued applying his business instincts in prison,” Fishman said. “At one point, he cornered the hot chocolate market. He bought up every package of Swiss Miss from the commissary and sold it for a profit in the prison yard. He monopolized hot chocolate! He made it so that, if you wanted any, you had to go through Bernie.”

https://www.marketwatch.com/story/new-series-casts-bernie-ma...

--

Bernie wasn't trapped with them. They were trapped with Bernie.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by sushisource on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:21PM (#26810175)
Assuming that's actually true, what an amazing picture it paints of him just being a complete fucking dick. It's not like the money he was making from that mattered at all... he did it just for shits and giggles. What an unbelievable asshole.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by lostcolony on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:30PM (#26810291)
Not at all. Now he has more buying power in the yard than anyone else.

He successfully managed to leverage market forces to create economic inequality and make himself 'rich' in the micro context he operated in.

Which is a great example for why great wealth is not a virtue, a 'free market' is not a savior, and why greater regulation and taxation on the super wealthy is acceptable - they got there by being, as you say, unbelievable assholes.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Ekaros on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:58PM (#26811483)
Also goes to prove that system was broken. It should not be possible for single individual to corner any market in prison. Either spendable money or amount of items sold per prisoner should be limited...
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Bukhmanizer on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:12AM (#26808225)
As I posted a couple days ago, I have my doubts about whether Madoff actually was that worried about prison. Seems to me like he lived like a literal king until he was 70, then went to jail. Maybe 70 year old Madoff didn’t want to go to jail, but 40 year old Madoff may have been more than happy to make that deal. Seems to me that someone who was trying to avoid jail time would have spend more effort trying to ameliorate the situation rather than cover anything up.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by elliekelly on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:11PM (#26814735)
And he fell on the sword so his sons could walk. There is absolutely no way they were both in the dark.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by kiba on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:57AM (#26808011)
What is this obsession with jailing people?

Prison is pretty inhumane, especially in the context of a limited lifespan. Even if we're immortal, it's still inhumane.

Moreover, how does making people go to prison fixes anything? It's just a way to assign punishment and blame people.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by cogman10 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:08AM (#26808164)
What the US most commonly jail's people for (drug offenses) is barbaric.

That said, the reason for jail is to not only rehabilitate but also to deter.

The problem we have is that white collar crimes almost never result in jail time for the rich. The financial deterrent is just ineffective at stopping bad behavior. They can run the risk/rewards calculations and often come up with the conclusion that "we'll make more money than we lose to a fine" and they proceed to do the bad behavior.

A good example of this is fireworks at disneyland. They pay fines for their daily displays and write it off as a cost of doing business. So what's the point of the fine? Weren't we trying to stop them from launching fireworks or was it just to extract money from a theme park?

Now imagine if the action for launching fireworks was the general manager of disneyland or their manager serving 2 days in jail. I can assure you, those fireworks would be stopped the next day.

That's the point. If the law is only a set of rules for the poor how can anyone be confident that it is going to work or be applied fairly? If you can buy your way out of compliance then what's the point?

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bluedino on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:24AM (#26808380)
>> What the US most commonly jail's people for (drug offenses) is barbaric.

If you're talking about prisons, nearly 4 times as many people are in prison for violent crimes (robbery, assault, rape, murder...) than drug charges.

https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by sooheon on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:18PM (#26809195)
Great link, thanks.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by minitoar on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:18AM (#26808316)
I actually feel like Disney would be willing to pay people to spend 2 days in jail in order to keep their fireworks show. You’ve just moved the cost from a fine to a salary.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by cogman10 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:24AM (#26808378)
You just have to go up the management chain until you find the person that will stop the practice.

I doubt if it ended up with the CEO and going to jail that they'd keep it up.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by leetcrew on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:31PM (#26811114)
yeah and if that doesn't work, you can always go after their family.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by vidarh on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:29AM (#26808449)
In Norway, a "life" sentence used to be 21 years, with parole possible after 14. Now there is a stricter option that in theory can end up being actual life, but it requires extension by 5 years at a time after evaluation to determine if the prisoner is still an active threat to society, and it's rarely used.

US sentencing has always seemed absolutely crazy to me, to the point where if I through some magic found myself on a US jury I'd have a hard time justifying a vote to convict, and the sentences seem to be more about vengeance than about rehabilitation or making society safer.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bobthechef on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:47PM (#26809653)
I see, so Breivik can go kill a bunch of children and hang out in "prison" with his XBox and hope to leave on parole? And that's normal for you?

I mean, if you think that isn't an insult to the victims, their families, etc.; if you don't think that's absolutely crazy, and I don't know what to tell you, man. Heck, if killing someone, let alone that many people, isn't so bad, why do we care about any other crime as much as we do? Why all this ridiculous outrage in the public square about all sorts real and imagined sins when life itself is so cheap?

Whatever the flaws in the American justice system (and there are many), Norwegian law and the sensibilities behind it are insane in this respect.

> sentences seem to be more about vengeance than about rehabilitation or making society safer.

Justice has more than one aim. Deterrence and rehabilitation are two of them, so is the preservation of social order. But justice is also retributive. Retribution isn't about hate, whatever modern confusion tells you. That's why we aim to have qualified impartial third-parties (judges) who are supposed to adjudicate such things instead of leaving things up to a hate-filled lynch mob, one that often confuses envy with anger at injustice.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by vidarh on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:18PM (#26811763)
> I see, so Breivik can go kill a bunch of children and hang out in "prison" with his XBox and hope to leave on parole? And that's normal for you?

Breivik is unlikely to get out because he is likely to continue to be deemed a threat on every re-evaluation. But if he demonstrates that he is reforming and is no longer likely to be a threat, then yes, that is not just normal to me but desirable.

It is a system that works given that re-offending rates in Norway are low.

I'd consider it an absolute insult to victims of violent crime to focus on things like retribution over policies shown to actually reduce the rates of future crime.

Valuing the perpetuation of violence for the sake of retribution over reducing the number of victims seems to me the height of barbaric and immoral behaviour.

But even without any benefits to re-offending rates I'd still consider it barbaric to threat prisoners badly for retributive purposes. Free will is a fiction, and so when we are punishing people for anything other than the practical purposes of keeping society safe we are no better than those we assign blame for crimes, we just tell ourselves we are.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by skwirl on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:33PM (#26812673)
If free will is a fiction, how can you pass judgement on "us" for punishing people? If free will is a fiction then what good is saying things like "if we do X we are no better than people who do Y" when nobody has any choice in what they do?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by vidarh on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:20PM (#26813255)
Well, the obvious answer is that there is no choice in that either, but that in most context it serves us best to act as if we do have choice, because the effects of our actions still affect us.

If we "step into the fiction" so to speak, there is reason for passing judgement if passing judgement leads to better outcomes. A lack of agency does not shield us from those outcomes.

But it makes retribution as a justification fundamentally immoral. Of course, there's recursion here - retribution for retribution would be no better.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by kiba on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:38PM (#26811200)
Justice has more than one aim. Deterrence and rehabilitation are two of them, so is the preservation of social order. But justice is also retributive. Retribution isn't about hate, whatever modern confusion tells you. That's why we aim to have qualified impartial third-parties (judges) who are supposed to adjudicate such things instead of leaving things up to a hate-filled lynch mob, one that often confuses envy with anger at injustice.

And Norwegian society operate just fine with Breivik playing xbox in prison.

In the end, retribution still doesn't fix anything. We're machines. We should act like this is true, not surrender to our monkey brain.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by greedo on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:32PM (#26811124)
It's been a long long time (if it ever existed) where US prisons gave a crap about rehabilitation. It's always been about punishment first, then keeping society "safe" second. And studies have consistently shown that the death penalty acts as no deterrent to murder; I would suspect the same would show that other crimes are not deterred by the threat of prison. Too many crimes are a result of impulse control failures in individuals.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by AshamedCaptain on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:44PM (#26810483)
> if you don't think that's absolutely crazy, and I don't know what to tell you, man

> to adjudicate such things instead of leaving things up to a hate-filled lynch mob

See the duality of your own post.

If I try to be impartial, I can hardly see the point to any sentence larger than a couple decades. When you get to those levels of sentencing where you basically decimate the total useful lifetime of someone, you might as well kill the person.

... and I guess I understand something now.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by anthonygd on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:08PM (#26810807)
> > if you don't think that's absolutely crazy, and I don't know what to tell you, man > > to adjudicate such things instead of leaving things up to a hate-filled lynch mob

> See the duality of your own post.

That reads as though you scored some virtual point, but I can't figure out what you're saying. Can you clarify?

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by zymhan on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:01AM (#26808078)
You can't just fine billionaires and expect that they'll reform.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Ekaros on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:04PM (#26811579)
Or maybe we could. Just make them go enough to negative without option of bankruptcy... Paying at couple billion back after selling all the holdings and property don't sound too unreasonable. We could even leave them some money to live like sum equal to minimum wage.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by mpalmer on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:07AM (#26808150)
Time is the only asset we all mostly have in common. If your laws and the enforcement thereof are just (big if), then why shouldn't the punishment be exacted in a way that generally affects everyone equally?

Beyond that, prison is inhumane as a rough function of where you are. Maybe you're thinking of a particular prison system.

How does it fix anything? It should primarily be a deterrent, and secondarily a way to protect society from dangerous people.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by cogman10 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:09AM (#26808182)
I have a sneaking suspicion that if more billionares spent time in prison, we'd see massive reform on the prison system towards the humane.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by cmurf on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:34AM (#26808520)
Rich people already go to low security VIP prisons. Visits with family in parks, better food, internet, and everyone is non-violent. Billionaires aren't put in general population.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by pydry on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#26808245)
Or a class system for prisons.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by cogman10 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:16AM (#26808288)
Probably depends on how many prisons are private vs public.

I could definitely see a class system forming in private prisons (it is sort of there already). For public prisons, that's harder. They have to convince law makers to pass laws to enable them to get special treatment. That'd be pretty unpopular.

But, then again, MJ legalization is very popular and it still hasn't happened yet so who knows if policy popularity even sways politicians at this point.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ericbarrett on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:15AM (#26808265)
My prediction: Start giving perpetrators of financial crimes real prison time and you'll see major prison reform within a few years.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by refurb on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:20AM (#26808338)
You think white collar criminals go to bad prisons?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by SilasX on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:34AM (#26808528)
Yes, most US prisons are inhumane. That doesn’t apply to the minimum security resort prisons that white collar criminals get sent to.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by ecocentrik on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:13AM (#26808240)
oversimplify much?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bobthechef on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:28PM (#26809340)
> Prison is pretty inhumane, especially in the context of a limited lifespan. Even if we're immortal, it's still inhumane.

You have a very warped view of justice. Rape isn't "inhumane"? Murdering someone isn't "inhumane"?

In the case of premeditated murder the murderer forfeits the right to life, so the death penalty, especially for especially egregious acts, is entirely just. To claim it isn't is unjust and an insult to the victim. Mercy only has meaning when the penalty is deserved and prudence will dictate whether the peantly ought to be exercised in the given circumstances given the best account of the facts and our limited knowledge (hence the need for judges who have the authority and the perspective to better adjudicate dispassionately instead of fueling some Sicilian family feud or a lynch mob that confuses envy with anger at injustice).

> Moreover, how does making people go to prison fixes anything? It's just a way to assign punishment and blame people.

Uh, yes? OBVIOUSLY, if someone is GUILTY, he DESERVES blame and punishment. I don't know why this is so difficult for you to understand or how you could possibly think this is wrong or that a world without them is preferable or even feasible. If someone has freely committed a crime, if he has chosen to commit that crime and has carried it out, then OBVIOUSLY he bears responsibility for it and is culpable for his actions.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by LB232323 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:55PM (#26811424)
The only reason this guy got charged is because he was a plain scam artist running everything out of his personal bank account.

Unfortunately, the highest levels of financial crime are tied to lawmakers and corruption of the highest authorities of white collar law enforcement.

It's usually outsiders and smaller operations that get caught. Corporations are in charge of a corporate oligarchy, which is the United States.

These entities are "too big to fail". They are so essential to the economy that the best you can hope for from the government is maybe a scapegoat going to a comfortable prison or a hefty fine.

TL;DR

Bringing down the largest corporations for crime is like trying to arrest the US president for war crimes.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by throwazero on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:40PM (#26812032)
> These entities are "too big to fail". They are so essential to the economy that the best you can hope for from the government is maybe a scapegoat going to a comfortable prison or a hefty fine.

Norway faced a banking crisis in the 90s; to solve it, the government simply invalidated the shares and took control of the bank.[1] The government later reprivatized it - i.e. sold new shares - once it was no longer failing.

That seems a pretty okay approach for entities that are too big to fail: let the shareholders, not the public, pay the price of failure.

(You need a sufficiently strong government to do it, obviously.)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christiania_Bank

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by andrepd on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:20PM (#26814798)
Fines are also fine (no pun intended) if they are massively more expensive than the action they are punishing. In short they must make the risk-adjusted cost of doing $illegal_thing larger than the benefit from doing it.

Fining a corporation 20 million for stealing 500 million... I mean I don't need to point how ridiculous this is.

Of course, direct personal responsibility for the people calling the shots. Someone robbing a liquor store causes an infinitesimal amount of damage and misery compared to what powerful corpos lead by powerful men can cause.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by paganel on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:21AM (#26808347)
And if you do end up stealing, make sure to steal from the less-off. Afaik nobody has yet gone to prison for liquidating an employees' pension fund, for example.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Applejinx on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:58PM (#26812984)
Yet.

Sounds like an aspirational goal to me! Long past time somebody did.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by SkyMarshal on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:44PM (#26811270)
One other thing worth observing: Bernie Madoff had nothing whatsoever to do with causing the Global Financial Crisis. Yes he committed a financial crime and defrauded a few investors with a ponzi, but he wasn’t behind the systemic financial mass destruction of the GFC.

Yet the media implicitly made him into a scapegoat for the GFC with heavy coverage of his trial filling the airwaves just as the public was authorities hold the perpetrators responsible. The media never explicitly claimed Madoff was part of the cause of the GFC, but rather used constant coverage of him to deflect attention from the real perpetrators of the crisis, who got away clean.

What the media doesn’t report is often more telling about its integrity and agenda than what they do report.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by paulpauper on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:03PM (#26808965)
>There are many other scandals: the whole subprime disaster, pollution from plants and the like where no one went to prison and people really should've.

not true. people did go to jail for their role in the 2008 banking crisis

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:44PM (#26810487)
> Fines are just the cost of doing business.

Isn’t that just because the fines aren’t high enough?

I think we should make more fines based on an individual’s (or company’s) net worth.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by dcolkitt on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:04PM (#26808980)
> the whole subprime disaster... no one went to prison and people really should've

This is a pretty common sentiment, but nobody can really articulate specifically who should go to prison and what crime they committed.

Being stupid, arrogant, reckless and willfully ignorant with money is not illegal. Just because hundreds of billions was lost does not mean that there's any criminal act. Major companies, and even financial institutions, fail all the time without there being any sort of crime.

It's easy to fall into the trap of looking for mustache-twirling villains when you see a broken system. More likely the real culprit are misaligned incentives and dysfunctional institutions. If you actually dig into the details of the subprime crisis, the latter story is the much more plausible one.

If you disagree, you have to specify who you think were the criminal masterminds behind the crisis. And more important, you have to show that you can prove criminal action and intent beyond a reasonable doubt. (And don't forget any would-be defendants will have access to the best legal defense teams on the planet.) I've never heard anyone actually present this case instead of just giving vague platitudes about how "the bankers should go to jail".

The only real candidate for viable criminal prosecution are the mortgagees themselves. Many fraudulently misrepresented their income, assets or employment on their applications. And it would probably be hard for them to claim that they weren't aware. (In contrast the mortgage brokers could always claim they didn't bother verifying income because they genuinely trusted the applicants. That's obviously BS, but criminal liability is held to a much higher standard.)

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by devmunchies on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:16PM (#26809181)
so you're suggesting that there should be different punishments based on how much money someone has?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bennysomething on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:44PM (#26809596)
How do you know this? Who exactly do you mean by "the rich"
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by jahewson on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:36AM (#26807657)
Doesn’t seem to be like Madoff feared jail. He did everything in his power to end up there.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by finikytou on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:32AM (#26807604)
that is not the number one learning and I think you are wrong. The real powerful and rich do not fear jail. They fear people like madoff that targets them.

That is why Madoff ended his life in jail while banks/funds CEO in the 2008 are now richer than ever stealing money from the poors and taking 0 accountability for the subprime crisis that destroyed a whole decade. In my book he was better than any of those bankers. He shown to the world that some people are smarter than the banks and that they will be severely punished if they do not abide by the laws that helps those banks to win.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by obmelvin on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:34AM (#26807634)
Oh, please. Madoff ruined plenty of "normal" people's life savings. Say what you will about other bankers, but please don't try to elevate someone who destroyed the life savings of others.

EDIT: Yes, non-profits and pension funds as well. That's not taking from the rich. Madoff was not Robin Hood.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by mathattack on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:35AM (#26807648)
Many non-profits who invested their endowments with him got hurt too.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by finikytou on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:38AM (#26807696)
no he did not. 75% of what he robbed was recovered also. Wouldnt call it ruining life... if he did steal to "normal people" that is to a much smaller percentage than he robbed the rich ones. thousands of people that are still in wall street today robbed poor people and are still trading/working in the industry today. While I am not elevating him I am elevating the fact that he rot in jail for robbing the rich. Just look at the papers from 2008 if you don't believe it.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by toomuchtodo on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:44AM (#26807770)
https://www.npr.org/2018/12/23/678238031/for-madoff-victims-... (NPR: For Madoff Victims, Scars Remain 10 Years Later)
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by obmelvin on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:44AM (#26807763)
So, it's ok to steal from people as long as most of them are rich?

And, it's ok to steal as long as you only steal 25% of it?

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by finikytou on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:51AM (#26807892)
I never said it was ok. I said he is in jail because he stole the rich. If he stole the poor he'd be on the trading desk of some bank in wall street. Who is in jail today for the subprime crisis?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by tartoran on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:17AM (#26808308)
If there was only one person orchestrating and solely benefitting from the subprime crisis it would be easy to put them in jail but there are too many to be put in jail, it’s the equivalent of ‘too big to fail’ but for people, ‘too many to pinpoint blame’ type of thinking. All these people knew it was going nowhere but they kept imflating the bubble because all their peers were doing it also and that despite numerous people raising res flags at the same time.

Maddoff was a dumb thief, and very cunning indeed but he operated in silence. That’s not to say the same thing about the others who ‘gamged up’ knowing that in case of failure many fingers would be pointed out in too many directions.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by blowski on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:50PM (#26809708)
I’d be ok if even some of the guilty people went to prison. We don’t imprison every single drug user.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bidirectional on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:11AM (#26808211)
How exactly are sell-side trading desks stealing from the poor?
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by finikytou on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:48AM (#26808723)
I meant Madoff would be free to do whatever he wants. But ill bite. Just look at all the robinhood millenials getting robbed by Citadel that literally has insider knowledge of all the robinhood transactions.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bobthechef on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @12:57PM (#26809795)
The more fundamental problem is that interest is usury and usury is theft. And naturally, the entire modern banking system runs on interest (which is probably the least egregious of all the wacky financial instruments out there). You'll hear nonsense about the opportunity cost and risk, none of which have any relevance to or rebut the notion that charging interest (as opposed to just fixed administrative fees) is theft. Time isn't a commodity, so why am I paying you more the longer it takes me to pay back my loan?

Is your gold and silver ewes and rams? Shylock cannot tell. He makes it breed as fast.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bidirectional on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:20PM (#26810144)
Of course time is a commodity. A (potentially false promise of a) dollar in one year is less useful than a dollar tomorrow which is less useful than a dollar right now.

If you do believe interest is theft and time has no value, you can act as a kind of Robin Hood by putting all of your money into bonds from Goldman Sachs, the US government or whoever you deem the worst perpetrator of this theft. You'll literally be stealing from them!

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bidirectional on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:13PM (#26810031)
That's not what I'm asking about. They specifically said trading desks at banks, Citadel is a market maker.

But what's really you're just parroting baseless conspiracy -- Citadel is a legitimate business which provides a great service to Robin Hood users. Payment for order flow is very good for the retail investor, reducing commissions and improving prices, the recent episode of Bloomberg's Odd Lots podcast with Doug Cifu went explained exactly how this works, it's a classic example of incentives aligning. Also by design no market maker gets access to all Robinhood transactions.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by finikytou on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:58PM (#26810682)
sure. they dont get access to all robinhood transactions. their trading algorithms do the work. if you know a few ms in advance the trades you can literaly make money out of it. and this should be clearly advertised when getting into robinhood.

Your argument that it is to help retail traders to enter for cheap into trading is fallacious. It is exactly like saying getting into real estate nowadays is a no brainer due to low interest loans. even tho the loan means borrowing money for 30years and living like a slave to pay a rent that the generation before you got in 10years. In the same ways FB makes money out of people Citadel and Robinhood does it 0 conspiracy there

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bidirectional on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:20PM (#26810976)
It's nothing to do with knowing the trades 'in advance', they're the ones doing the trades! Market makers like Citadel are regulated to improve the prices offered in the market place. A stock may trade for $50 on the exchange, but Citadel can sell it for $49.50, they must improve prices and they do. Part of the reason they can do this is that Robin Hood orders are 'safe'. If a huge hedge fund comes to Citadel and wants to trade a million shares in TSLA, they likely know something Citadel doesn't and will rip their face off. That's why Robin Hood orders are valuable, luckily, the incentives of the retail investor (buying a stock as cheap as possible) and the market maker (selling to someone who isn't about to pummel them) line up.

If you think Citadel and its ilk are bad, you should see the guys they replaced! Market making is as old as the market itself, the modern advancements allow commission-free trading, massive liquidity and tiny spreads, before you'd be paying commission and buying a stock for dollars more than you could sell it for. They're good for the market and it's a shame this crazy conspiratorial thinking (which is never backed up by any real understanding) has taken hold of so many people.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by finikytou on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @02:43PM (#26811262)
You re right. they do the trades for robinhood users. What do you think they do between the time they receive the order and execute it? don't forget that the default trade on robinhood has no limit to it. you buying market value. now try doing that on millions of users just like madoff did playing with the cents.
Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bidirectional on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:14PM (#26811717)
They make their cents (or less) on the bid-ask spread, as do all market makers. They do this while also improving the execution of the trade for the end user. Some of that spread goes back to Robin Hood via PFOF. Citadel allows people to buy stocks for less than they would normally, this is an irrefutable fact.

What do you think they're doing in that time? Please be specific because I have no idea what part of this mutually beneficial, standard operating procedure is meant to be a criminal conspiracy. The people losing out are institutional investors who cannot access the same execution quality as a retail investor, because they trade in greater volume and are more likely to be behind a market move.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by bidirectional on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:11AM (#26808204)
75% - opportunity cost - inflation.

If you plan your life around having $1 million in savings because that's what your statements from Madoff say, recovering 75% of the fraction you put in is pretty bad.

Re:Bernie Madoff has died by kingsuper20 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:44AM (#26807765)
"That is why Madoff ended his life in jail"

That's an interesting point and probably true. The identity of your victim matters as much as the crime. It isn't like a serial car thief would receive the same sentence.

I've always wondered if jail was appropriate for purely financial crimes. Maybe simply pauperizing people is the right answer and keep them pauperized from some time.

Just imagine a prison system that doesn't contain financial criminals or drug cases. Transfer a certain amount of punishment to Singapore-style caning (probably a better mind-modifier than 6 months in the county clink) and you could shrink the whole industry to a tiny fraction of it's current size.