News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by young_unixer on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:05AM (#26768738)
> With a full time job as full stack developer at a good company he would have done a lot more. The guy is good, at a FANG he would earn 200+ guaranteed and a pension plan.

I don't want to attack this comment in particular, specially because they're saying this to simply support the argument that the guy is an excellent programmer, but it irks me when people say stuff this assuming that an excellent programmer always has easy access to a FAANG.

Some people simply live in underdeveloped countries where their talents can't shine and they have no way to get an interview at FAANG, some people are either too young or too old to be a good candidate, and a myriad other things that could get in the way of an excellent programmer. In such scenarios, an Internet business like this is the only way out for some programmers. I'd bet there are hundreds or thousands of genius programmers living in Russia, Brazil, the Balkans, Guatemala and many other countries that simply couldn't land a job at FAANG even if they wanted to.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by IvanK_net on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:15AM (#26769141)
Hi guys, I am Ivan, the creator of Photopea :)

I made almost $1 million in the last 12 months, 90% from ads. The rest is from Premium (users paying to hide ads) and licensing a self-hosted version of Photopea.

When you start your own project, you never know, if it will ever make $250k a year. But if you get hired, you can be quite sure, that you will never make more than $250k a year.

Follow Photopea to see my progress :) http://facebook.com/photopea , http://twitter.com/photopeacom

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by system16 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:24AM (#26770193)
I'm not a designer, but for my personal dev projects I always end up needing to do some light image editing. Not nearly enough to justify a Photoshop licence, and I've tried other apps like Pixen and GIMP but have always been met with frustration.

Photopea is one of my favourite tools on the web. Thank you for making such awesome software.

As for the comment about working at a FAANG I'm baffled. In what world would working at a FAANG, dealing with company politics, reporting to managers, having employment reviews, etc. be more desirable than the freedom and satisfaction of launching your own project and being able to very comfortably sustain yourself?

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ramraj07 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:36AM (#26770271)
In the world where for every PhotoPea there’s a hundred other failed ideas that never materialised; to consider the idea of “just create your own product” being simpler than dealing with office politics sounds laughable either because you are not aware of how difficult the former proposition is to a regular engineer. If it comes so naturally to you, it still sounds immature to not realise how rare such an ability is.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by cmmeur01 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:41AM (#26770311)
They are talking about using PhotoPea as leverage to work at a FAANG. This doesn't apply, his project is already successful.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by RHSeeger on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:42AM (#26770321)
You seem to be basing that question on the assumption that both options offer the same pay (or at least that both off "enough" pay). Working on your own project is a tremendous risk; and for every success story like this, my assumption is that there's at least dozens who fail or don't even make enough to pay their bills.

Working on a successful independent software project is, for a lot of people, much more desirable than working at someone else's company; in much the same way owning a startup company would be. But the key there is "successful", which is certainly not guaranteed.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by system16 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:52AM (#26770382)
You seem to be basing it on the assumption that Ivan would be able to invert a binary tree on a whiteboard and get into said FAANG. I'm only half-kidding.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by bennysomething on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:49AM (#26769334)
Plus you now don't have to work full time on it, presumably. Financial freedom Vs corporate job. I know which one I'd prefer. Also congratulations on your outstanding success
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dx034 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:43AM (#26769298)
Congrats! It's an amazing story that shows that a sole developer can create a product on par with paid products from big companies. I think many people assume you always need a big team to create something great, whereas often a sole developer with dedication and talent is enough to challenge even large products.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by nickjj on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:17AM (#26769460)
Hey, I've used Photopea a bunch of times to help create thumbnail images, nice app!

If you ever wanted to jump on a podcast to talk about how you built and deploy it let me know. I'd love to have you on the https://runninginproduction.com/ podcast. You can click the "become a guest" button to get started if you were interested.

(Note: if anyone else wants to be a guest you can submit a request too, I just finished a huge stretch of 8 months worth of backlog episodes so I have openings again)

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by techrat on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:50AM (#26769337)
Ever considered having a completely offline version for those who don't want to run it with their browser?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by IvanK_net on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:49AM (#26769626)
It would take me some effort to make and maintain a separate version. Users would report bugs which have been fixed months ago, because they did not update it, etc.

I think the importance of "offline apps" is overrated today. Personally, I spend less than 10 hours a year on a device without internet, and I think this number is decreasing each year, for everyone.

People use Google Maps and Wikipedia without having them on their hard drives. On the other hand, it is nice, that you can simply close a website and there is no track of that service in your computer.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:57AM (#26769666)
Maybe a Progressive Web App could work? If I remember correctly, it requires basically just adding a cache manifest.

Initial setup can be finnicky (test it on a separate subdomain!) but it shouldn't require much more than a correctly configured cache manifest and a few lines of code to handle updates.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by 411111111111111 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:12AM (#26769755)
there are even some frameworks that make it extra easy, like angular for example (just `ng add @angular/pwa` and you're basically done).

while it is pretty easy and doable in maybe 1-2 days, depending on how fluent you are with these kinds of things... it's not entirely in the authors best interest. if people start using it `offline`, he wont be able to get advertisement revenue after all ;)

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by bckr on Sunday April 11, 2021 @01:41PM (#26772025)
He says in one of his Reddit comments that he does not (and probably will not) use frameworks. It's pure HTML/CSS/JS.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by jannes on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:25AM (#26769844)
Careful! You can get users stuck on an old version if you configure it incorrectly
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:31AM (#26769884)
Doesn't deleting the manifest solve that? I thought serving a 404 for it makes browsers delete their cache exactly to provide a way out of this trap.

But yes, this is why I suggested testing with a separate subdomain.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by FpUser on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:08AM (#26770468)
Why bother. He already has very nice product and makes very nice money.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Winterflow3r on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:29AM (#26769225)
Congratulations! I think your story is very inspiring and I wish you and Photopea lots more success in the future!
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by jfrunyon on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:33AM (#26769897)
If I'm doing my math right, $900,000 from ads @ few dollars CPM = few hundred million impressions - not bad!
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by xNeil on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:26AM (#26770558)
https://www.similarweb.com/website/photopea.com/#overview

SimilarWeb says the website has had 8 million visits in the past 6 months. His CPM must be very, very high.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by hackonr on Sunday April 11, 2021 @03:52PM (#26772897)
How does SimilarWeb obtain this data?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by bardonadam on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:58AM (#26769381)
Congrats Ivan! Well deserved! I've always enjoyed your AMA's on Reddit.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by seapunk on Monday April 12, 2021 @05:14AM (#26777357)
Hi Ivan, Photopea is awesome. I'm glad to know that it's really well profitable. I was wondering, do you have other apps you want to build and you stay focused on Photopea?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by smallnamespace on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:54AM (#26771206)
> But if you get hired, you can be quite sure, that you will never make more than $250k a year.

From https://www.levels.fyi/

Google (total comp):

Level 4 - $266k

Level 5 (Senior) - $353k

Level 6 (Staff) - $484k

... and similarly at other FAANG companies.

If you're good/lucky, you can make it to Senior in 3-4 years as a new engineer.

It used to be that Level 5 -> 6 was a difficult jump, but nowadays there are many Level 6s and 7s. At Level 7, even your base salary >$250k a year.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by jjeaff on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:40PM (#26773702)
I would be curious to know how many engineers are at senior level or higher at google.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by secondcoming on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:33AM (#26769244)
deleted
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by _xy8h on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:51AM (#26769341)
>Edit: I just checked our systems and you're mainly XXXXX. We've given you XXXXX since the start of the year (before the ad network takes their cut)

Are you even allowed to release customer/client info like that?

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by codegrappler on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:05AM (#26769409)
You should probably delete the quoted portion of your comment as well.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by secondcoming on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:54AM (#26769354)
Maybe not! Can you edit my comment? I've removed mine. He's not a client though.

Edit: thank you!

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by bijant on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:52AM (#26769347)
It‘s more than just a bit unprofessional to disclose the earnings of a client on a public forum. (I take that back if he has given You explicit permission)
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by grumpyautist on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:00AM (#26769385)
What makes your product unique or better than GIMP?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by nickjj on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:29AM (#26769529)
IMO it's general usability.

For example a very common thing you might want to do is add text (or any other layer) on top of an image and then center that text / layer either vertically or horizontally relative to the image.

In Photopea you create a text layer and then drag it near the middle and it'll show you guidelines when you're close and then snap into the perfect center (either vertically, horizontally or both). It takes like 2 seconds and feels intuitive.

In GIMP you have to make sure you switch to the alignment tool which is hidden by default so you need to remember to hit Q to activate it or hover over the move tool and select it but if you hit Q you better make sure you're not in any text input because it'll insert "Q" instead of switching your tool, but since you're adding text chances are you will be so you need to remember to click away. Then you need make sure you click an active area of your text layer and click the align horizontal icon, then you need to click the align vertical icon. Then if you decide you want to change your text you have to repeat this whole process again.

Another example is adding a simple stroke (line) around some text or other layer effects that Photoshop has had for over 10+ years.

In Photopea, you open up layer styles, pick the stroke option and can tweak the colors and thickness very quickly. After applying the style you can change and move around your text and the styles are applied to it automatically, it feels intuitive to use.

In GIMP I spent an hour researching plugins to add this behavior and after picking one it technically works but the user experience is pretty hostile. It creates the stroke as a separate layer so you can't move your text and the stroke together unless you remember to link them, and if you decide to change your text content or size you have to delete the old stroke layer and make a new one.

GIMP is really good in terms of what it can do but using it feels like death by a thousand paper cuts because you need to do so many steps to accomplish what feels like basic things that other editors have had for years when it comes to user friendly features.

I understand creating a highly polished image editor isn't easy and honestly if I knew their code base I would open a PR for the snap to center guidelines but at this point I have to imagine if they wanted to add that feature it would have been added. From the outside it feels like it hasn't been added because they don't want that feature, but as an end user that makes me wonder why. It's such a useful thing.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by grumpyautist on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:39AM (#26770632)
That's not how to align text on gimp. The text tool has an alignment feature. It aligns the text within the text box

Outlining text is easy too. true, there isn't a magic text outline button, you must use the same method you would use to outline any arbitrary object.

The sum of your complaints are because you know how to do it in PS. I am a professional graphics designer and artist and I use gimp exclusively.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by cameronh90 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:49AM (#26770689)
What's the point of asking if you're just going to dismiss the answers?

I used to use The GIMP exclusively, but I jumped to Photoshop when I could afford it, due to GIMP's poor UX and adjustment layers (which have been "coming soon" with GEGL since 2008).

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dwild on Sunday April 11, 2021 @01:15PM (#26771848)
> The sum of your complaints are because you know how to do it in PS.

Or PS is just more intuitive than GIMP.

> I am a professional graphics designer

Once you are using a tool professionally, I guess that intuitiveness is no longer a selling point. It is though for someone that only use it from time to time...

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by nickjj on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:07AM (#26770811)
> That's not how to align text on gimp. The text tool has an alignment feature. It aligns the text within the text box

I'm talking about horizontally or vertically aligning a layer relative to the image, not the text within the rectangle bounding box of the text input box when you have the text tool activated.

It's such a common use case to want to take a layer (whether or not it's text isn't important) and center it horizontally or vertically relative to the entire image or another object.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by grumpyautist on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:11AM (#26770832)
So, you draw the text box in the size and position you need? All of these "features" sound like training wheels for graphic designers. It's not hard whatsoever to accomplish, and assuredly not worth paying monthly for. If you know in general how to edit graphics the tool you use is irrelevant
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by nickjj on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:25AM (#26770916)
> So, you draw the text box in the size and position you need?

I'm not sure what you mean.

If you have a 1000 x 1000 image I'd like to put the text "Hello" exactly in the middle of the image, both vertically and horizontally and let the tool determine the exact bounding box of the text input based on how much text I have.

> All of these "features" sound like training wheels for graphic designers.

In GIMP I described the workflow how to do that using the alignment tool. I also described for comparison how to do it in Photopea because it only involves dragging the layer near where it should be and it auto-snaps to perfect center with guidelines that appear when you're close.

This isn't a training wheels feature because both casual and professional graphic designers aren't eyeballing a pixel perfection alignment every time without thinking, but Photopea gives you this outcome with the least amount of effort you can ask for and its accuracy is 100%.

> It's not hard whatsoever to accomplish, and assuredly not worth paying monthly for.

There's a difference between hard and convenient. Executing a checklist of steps isn't hard but it sure is inconvenient if I need to do that every time I want to align something. It's the difference between something having a good / intuitive UI vs not.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:10AM (#26769742)
My standard example for "GIMP is unusable" is "try to draw a straight line" which I had to find a tutorial for (you need to hold some magic keys). That said, I struggled with that in Photopea too (not realizing my intended red line was there, just hidden by the blue vector indicator).
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by grumpyautist on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:40AM (#26770634)
Hold shift? It's not hard
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Pimpus on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:18AM (#26770882)
This kind of attitude in OSS is exactly why GIMP is a piece of garbage that no one uses.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by easrng on Sunday April 11, 2021 @02:36PM (#26772412)
I get that but hold shift for constraints is standard in almost every editor out there. (Not sure about Photoshop, it has weird behaviors for modifier keys.) Also, I find GIMP more intuitive for some things. For example, making solid-color backgrounds transparent is very easy in GIMP but as far as I can tell impossible in Photoshop.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday April 11, 2021 @03:32PM (#26772789)
I'm not talking about constraining a line to a 90 degree angle. I'm talking about "draw a single straight line from one point to another". Most editors have a dedicated tool for that. In Gimp, you take the brush, then shift-click start and end.

How do you do the solid color background in Gimp? In Photoshop, I'd select the background with the magic wand (contiguous or non-contiguous, depending on preference), potentially use one of those edge-improving tools, then either press delete or create a mask. It apparently also has a special tool for it that I haven't used before but seems to do basically that.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by easrng on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:15PM (#26773514)
Oh, OK. Regarding the background: That works, and you do the same thing in GIMP but that doesn't handle transparency. In GIMP there's the Color to Alpha tool which is pretty much magic.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by easrng on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:21PM (#26773563)
Say you have https://this.is-a-professional-domain.com/4Hhtqcf.jpg and you want that glow on a transparent background. In GIMP, I'd select the chip, Select>Invert, Color>Color to Alpha and it would just work. I tried to do it in Photoshop and couldn't figure it out.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by IvanK_net on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:36PM (#26774128)
BTW. I added Color to Alpha into Photopea: Filter - More - Color to Alpha. Works 100% same as in Gimp :)
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by jfrunyon on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:47AM (#26830000)
Meanwhile, this kind of attitude in users is exactly why everyone is stuck with dumbed-down, more complex/more buggy, less powerful solutions. The more information is available at people's fingertips, the less people are willing to take a few seconds to discover it.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by canada_dry on Sunday April 11, 2021 @04:59PM (#26773379)
Gimp has made some usability improvements, but I agree it is still painful to use.

When Blender finally bit-the-bullet and overhauled their UI - in a way that more aligned itself with how other keys/clicks worked in similar tools - it totally relaunched itself and is now so much easier to use.

It would be great it Gimp (and inkscape) did a similar overhaul IMHO.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:04AM (#26769704)
It works on any machine, including Chromebooks, without installation.

I also find it more user friendly (unlike GIMP where I constantly feel like I'm fighting the bad UX instead of actually doing what I came to do), especially if you're used to Photoshop.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by himujjal on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:09AM (#26769430)
better than a software that doesnt do what users want it to do? a lot of things. Why dont you go and try Photopea. It has achieved so much what Gimp couldnt. Yes, its made for business and its closed source. But considering the number of devs and the number of years spent, Photopea is an excellent replacement for photoshop. I have personally used it for most of the small image editing I needed.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by CynicusRex on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:03AM (#26769700)
Since I come from Photoshop, GIMP always has a way of pissing me off by doing something unexpected or making something trivial needlessly complicated.

While I congratulate its developers for not using ads and making it free, it remains a pain to use sometimes. I mainly use it for cropping, resizing, and image blurring, but for anything else I use Photopea.

That being said, if I took the time to properly learn to utilize GIMP through tutorials, as I did with Photoshop back in the day, I wouldn't be surprised if my opinion does a 180.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by shoto_io on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:08AM (#26769420)
Have you looked at it? For me at least, GIMP never worked really stable on my Mac.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Black101 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:29AM (#26769530)
The Filter menu looks a bit funky to me (edit: in Firefox 87): https://i.imgur.com/S70o2eU.png ... probably one of my addons messing with it but I don't have that problem in GIMP.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by IvanK_net on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:42AM (#26769596)
Your browser is probably too old, or you use some "exotic" browser extensions
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Black101 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @01:41PM (#26772028)
Whatever the reason is, it is not working right and Gimp is, for me.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by nguyenkien on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:09AM (#26769431)
You don't need to install it. It's huge plus for me
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by matsemann on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:20AM (#26769475)
The UX. At least for me familiar with PS that just needs to do quick edits it's very nice.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dmje on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:40AM (#26770633)
This. The toolbars / tools are basically where PhotoShops' are so you don't have to think terribly hard if you're used to them
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by nakodari on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:30AM (#26769227)
Congrats Ivan! Great looking app. Quick question - is this $1 million revenue from Ads alone or does it include subscription as well?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by cinntaile on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:09AM (#26769429)
His comment, that you're replying to, literally says 90% of the $1 million usd revenue comes from ads. The rest, so 10% of $1 million, comes from subscriptions and so on.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by nakodari on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:20PM (#26783053)
It looks like he edited his comment to add this info. His original comment didn’t include info. Thanks!
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Escapado on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:34AM (#26768903)
I mean even in germany it's not easy. The average salary of a SE here is about 65k before taxes. Most senior engineers I met make about 80-85k before taxes (~50k after taxes) (I am located in hamburg). Even for well booked freelancers about 1 in 10 people make more than 200k a year (140k being the average which results in about 72k profit after taxes).

I just had a quick look at google, netflix, twitter and facebook and they don't even offer any SE positions here. Amazon has some in Berlin but they pay around the same salary as stated above.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by igeligel_dev on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:56AM (#26769040)
Amazon pays a lot more here in Berlin. People in Germany forget to add stocks to the total compensation. Source: https://www.levels.fyi/company/Amazon/salaries/Software-Engi...

Otherwise, in Berlin there are other bigger tech companies and with remote opening up more and more the salaries tend to increase. Currently the biggest companies in Berlin when it comes to compensation: Microsoft, GitHub, Airbnb, SAP, Wayfair, Amazon, Datadog (Remote), Snowflake, Shopify (Remote), Hubspot (Remote), Spotify (Remote), DigitalOcean (Remote), MongoDB, Stripe (Remote). I wrote an article about it here: https://www.kevinpeters.net/top-tech-companies-berlin-2021

Most of these companies offer more close to 90-100k or even more (depends on the stock). So it is not FAANG but it gets better and better throughout the years.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Escapado on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:41AM (#26769285)
Thanks for your perspective! I had no idea the stock compensation was THAT high. Sheesh I might want to reconsider my current situation!

Btw, I should probably not post this but we share the exact same name and work in the same field. :D

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by thrower123 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:27AM (#26769211)
That's just not very much money, ouch. At least compared to here in the US where VC money is sloshing around so much, driving all compensation higher.

With everything being remote right now, people have been taking jobs on the California wage scale, but living in Peoria.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dx034 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:34AM (#26769249)
To be fair, living costs are also much lower. I'd estimate living costs in the US to be on average at least 30-40% higher, plus high property costs in the Bay Area. Germany has some expensive areas but most parts are still relatively cheap compared to many US cities or places like London or Paris.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:54AM (#26770392)
To be fair, property prices in Germany (buying) are insane, and if you account for that, it makes the salaries seem low. Munich is currently on par with the bay area per square footage/meters, at much lower salaries.

And unless you've been grandfathered into a rent controlled apartment, inner city rents for newcomers are overpriced AF, especially after the new rent controll law kicked in in Berlin, further restricting supply and increased the prices for newcomers.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by chefkoch on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:45AM (#26769311)
And in low CoL areas in Germany there are almost no IT jobs and pay less than quoted above.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by rijoja on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:11AM (#26768769)
Eh I used to want to work for Google, but now I see it about as sexy as working for AT&T. Doing something like this gives you respect and freedom instead.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by matsemann on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:45AM (#26768972)
Also, working for these FAANGs to get the high salary means moving to the US, which for many Europeans has become undesirable the later years.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by igeligel_dev on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:09AM (#26769104)
I can tell you it is a bit different. The visa is hard to obtain unfortunately, otherwise I think a lot more engineers would move, me included.

The only real options are:

  - L-1 visa: Get into FAANG in Europe and try to transfer to the US. Lots of unknowns if you really get transferred and so on. L-1 to green card seems to be possible, best possibility for Europeans though
  - H-1B visa: Applying from abroad: Nearly no chance, sorry. You will have to schedule your applications to the end of the year to get into the lottery in March or so, and then it is pure luck. 30% chance from what I have heard + you have to rock the interviews hard and the company must be super-willing to wait for you
  - Study in the US. Do a masters degree there and be on Optional practical training (OPT) for up to a year/two years after graduation and hope your H-1B visa goes through in the meantime
All these paths have kind of unknowns unfortunately and the path to permanent residency is even more strict. Or you just marry someone from the US.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by franga2000 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:13AM (#26769442)
This 100x! Sure the salary might be great, but to give up all the comforts of a...you know...actually developed country? No thanks!

I'd much rather work for a local software shop for a slightly above-averege salary in a country where the prospect of owning an apartment is more than a fantasy, where I won't go bankrupt if I have a serious medical issue, won't get shot by a raging idiot if I don't start moving at a red light fast enough, my hypothetical children can get excellent education without taking out predatory loans that will follow them for the rest of their life, not to mention the political system over there.....

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by varjag on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:41AM (#26771074)
I'm also a dev in Europe but this is ridiculous. You ain't going to die on the street of illness if you work at FAANG.

Driving in Bay Area feels positively relaxed to many places in Europe too. Hell, even LA is a lot nicer place to drive than Rome.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by franga2000 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @01:02PM (#26771766)
True, I was definitely exaggerating, but the horror stories I hear from my american friends still make very skeptical that moving to the US for what would probably be a junior position at FAANG would be worth it in any way. Just the story of a friend of mine getting some basic dental surgery in the US makes me not even consider moving there.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by varjag on Sunday April 11, 2021 @02:06PM (#26772198)
At a FAANG you'd have healthcare and dental insurance plans co-sponsored by the employer, in addition to pretty humongous compensation that would easily cover your $50 or so dental insurance contribution.

Don't get me wrong there's plenty of folks who struggle in America, but white-collar employees of the top five tech megacorps ain't them.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by bradlys on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:28PM (#26773615)
Even if you’re not at FAANG, you’re going to get pretty good care for very little cost at any funded startup. Almost every place I’ve worked I’ve never had to pay insurance premiums and almost always had obscenely low copays for visits and operations. (Visit a doctor - $10, surgery - $35... etc.. very cheap)

Being a software engineer in the valley definitely means you’ll likely have a pretty good healthcare situation that might be better than the free version you get in other countries...

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by kybernetyk on Monday April 12, 2021 @06:14AM (#26777784)
>prospect of owning an apartment is more than a fantasy

which european country would that be? owning property is out of reach for most europeans because the high tax and social burden make it pretty much impossible to save up for a house

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by franga2000 on Monday April 12, 2021 @07:58AM (#26778374)
Taxes are hardly the issue, it's the fact that in high-density and high-income areas, there simply isn't enough supply for the demand.

I'm from Slovenia and, ignoring the capital, which has a huge housing shortage (not much room for the city to expand), it's still quite common for people to own apartments. It's definitely decreasing, like everywhere in the world, but not unheard of. I also never said anything about a house - that's a completely different story.

From what I've heard, normal apartments basically don't exist in big tech centres in the US. You either get an expensive moldy hole in the wall or a huge new development that even a C-level will have a hard time getting a loan for.

Again, all of this is just from my perspective with the parameters that I care about. I know it works for many people, but the US really just isn't for me.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by kybernetyk on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @07:46AM (#26790918)
>Taxes are hardly the issue

When your marginal tax rate rises to roughly 40% once you earn 50k Euros I'd say it is an issue.

And that's only direct taxation.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by praptak on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:22AM (#26769182)
You can get the high salary in Zurich, although if you're already in Zurich you'd be better off working in finance. Source: my colleague who moved to Google Zurich and then switched jobs to finance.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by chefkoch on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:51AM (#26769339)
And zurich is even more expensive than every city in Germany.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by praptak on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:30AM (#26769539)
Not surprising, given the strong financial sector whose employees you compete with. London is similar in this aspect.

On the other hand the public transport is great, which means you don't have to live in the most expensive areas to have decent commute.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by hawk_ on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:52AM (#26769350)
switched to finance as a software engineer or more trading_algo/quant engineer?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by praptak on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:24AM (#26769495)
I think it's something close to SRE but don't quote me on that.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by gbin on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:59AM (#26769059)
Do you mean it is bad for their career if they go back in Europe or simply they usually don't like living in the US?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by e12e on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:10AM (#26769110)
The US is seen as a bit of a backwards country; poor medical, technologically poor (banking, internet), little paid time off/vacation, no free/cheap higher education, rampant gun violence/domestic terror - on top of that you risk loosing some pension and health benefits in your "home" country if you stay abroad for years.

Note that the point with a solid/free education system isn't that kids of rich SEs get free college - it's that society as a whole gets better education - and your kid's friends also have a future/access to education.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by aloisdg on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:20AM (#26769164)
French here. No way I would leave a society who achieve 35 workweek, minimum wage, 25 days payed vacation and free healthcare. As a programmer I could win more in another country, but I dont want this money if people around me cant live a decent life. Even in France it is quite hard. I wont leave for a lesser country like the US. I want my nurse to be able to do a great work and it means having a good life.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by mensetmanusman on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:31AM (#26769545)
Probably no reason to vilify the US as a ‘lesser’ country, everyone in the world has their struggles.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ClumsyPilot on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:48AM (#26769979)
I think the reason it's viewed the way it is, is that it's actually a strange choice. If these problem happen in some random poor country that used to be a conquered colony, that makes more sence
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by aloisdg on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:15AM (#26873110)
In terms of social protection, the US is so far lower than France... It is dystopian.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dx034 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:35AM (#26769251)
Moving away from home is just not something many people want to do. I don't think many Americans would move to another country with different language and far away from their family, just because they'd get a higher salary.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by jokethrowaway on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:24AM (#26769498)
Going to the USA has been my dream since being a teenager but that's not the case anymore.

The USA has some good things going for it: VC money, great salaries, true freedom of speech (unlike the EU), right to bear arms (unlike most of the EU, where only robbers have guns and if you defend yourself you risk getting sued - tried on my skin), beautiful seaside, legal weed, less problems with immigrants (African immigration is a bomb waiting to explode, if it hasn't exploded already), place with good opportunity and enjoy a nice climate (in Europe the choice is between cold places with good work opportunity, aka UK, Switzerland or warm places with a barely functioning economy and ridiculously high taxes).

Unfortunately health care is too expensive, taxes are as high as Europe (where is your freedom?), the food is subpar, mass shooting in schools, you have to drive way too much, a culture that is transitioning kids because they think they're the opposite gender.

All in all, I think I'll stick with Europe for the time being and consider maybe South America or South East Asia in the future.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by glitchcrab on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:04AM (#26770788)
Why on earth would the right to bear guns be seen as a good thing? My mind boggles at this.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by FpUser on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:28AM (#26770577)
>"legal weed"

That would be Canada, not the US. Even though some US states allow it, the feds do not.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by smoe on Sunday April 11, 2021 @12:35PM (#26771563)
Not GP, but besides career opportunities, the US is just not very appealing (anymore) to many. It is not even necessarily about things where you could objectively say something is better or worse, but personal preferences on how to live life.

For me the biggest luxury of being a software engineer is, that pretty much wherever I go, I’m going to be solidly middle class within that region. So I can afford prioritizing other things over maximizing salary.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by FpUser on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:22AM (#26770543)
After quitting in 2000 I work on my own creating products, some under my ownership and some for clients. In average I do just fine, some years are good, some are not that good. However not once have I ever thought of trading my freedom to do as I please to some better paying job at FAANG or the likes.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by roninkoi on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:37AM (#26769265)
Working at Bell Labs would have been great! :)
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by rijoja on Monday April 12, 2021 @05:51AM (#26777633)
Back in the days yeah! Same thing goes for google when it was a fresh company that didn't do evil.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by luch on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:19AM (#26768828)
Not even underdeveloped countries, I live in a G8 country and there is hardly any significant FAANG shop here.

For example if you want to work for Google in Europe it's either UK or Switzerland, which are interestingly the two developed european countries outside of the EU :)

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by varjag on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:31AM (#26768891)
FAANG branches in Europe are just like other bigcorps. Their pay rates are good but not outliers in any way.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dx034 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:37AM (#26769269)
Because in the Bay Area they also pay standard rates. Stock comp has been very supportive over the past years but base salary mostly reflects high living costs. Developers in Europe are still paid well compared to median income. The 80-90k€ that were mentioned in another comment here are an excellent salary in Germany. And if you're in the top 10% of your country, it doesn't matter how big that number is unless you want to take your savings to move somewhere else in the future.

For many people staying close to the place they grew up and their family is important. If you get a well-paid job there it can be more attractive than moving halfway around the world for more money.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by varjag on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:33AM (#26770609)
No, with FAAG in Bay Area you can easily have 2x-3x the median national rate for developers.

And there are numerous places in Germany and Northern Europe where an experienced developer can command €80-90k.

Consider that a senior position at Amazon Berlin wich lists €80-100K range would be more towards €300k in Bay Area.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dx034 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @01:39AM (#26803317)
> No, with FAAG in Bay Area you can easily have 2x-3x the median national rate for developers.

That's not what I wrote. I said they pay as well as others in the area. Yes, not everyone pays exactly like Google or Amazon, but other tech jobs in the Bay Area are also far above national median for developers. FAANG pays well but they still pay in relation to the area, they don't just give away $300k paychecks to people anywhere in the world.

And the rest also just confirms what I mean, 80k in Germany are a great salary. Many people won't gain much moving to the Bay Area to get $250k (if they can). The standard of living won't be that much higher than with 80k in Berlin.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by kristianc on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:38AM (#26768935)
Google has a Dublin office too, as do many others.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dx034 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:39AM (#26769273)
But they pay Irish salaries there, not Bay Area salaries. Which is fine, FAANG developers in Ireland are still doing well. And not everyone wants to live in the bay area, just like not everyone wants to live in Ireland, Germany or any other place.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by croes on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:08AM (#26769101)
I guess for privacy related issues.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by kristianc on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:40AM (#26769284)
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by zoomablemind on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:43AM (#26769299)
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by sofixa on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:53AM (#26770004)
> For example if you want to work for Google in Europe it's either UK or Switzerland, which are interestingly the two developed european countries outside of the EU

Or Ireland, or France, or Belgium.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by knolan on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:24AM (#26768859)
Lots of them have a presence in Ireland too.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by secfirstmd on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:56AM (#26769041)
Yeh and there's are crazy amount of hiring here at the moment. FB, Amazon, TikTok, Stripe, Google, Apple, Microsoft, Salesforces (amongst others) all hiring from Hundreds to a few thousand
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Normille on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:14AM (#26769136)
Yes. Ireland seems to be pretty much basing its entire economy, at the moment, on attracting huge American megacorps to set up shop in Dublin. Rather than actually investing in producing anything themselves.

It's a recipe for disaster. As will become apparent when some other equally strategically placed jurisdiction starts offering even more enticing tax-breaks and the megacorps up sticks and decamp there instead. Then the whole house of cards [and with it most of the Irish economy] will come tumbling down.

What a pathetic pathetic country!

[and I say that as a terminally embarrassed Irishman]

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Silhouette on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:20AM (#26769816)
It's a recipe for disaster. As will become apparent when some other equally strategically placed jurisdiction starts offering even more enticing tax-breaks and the megacorps up sticks and decamp there instead.

At the moment, if I were the Irish government, I think I'd be more concerned with the likelihood of genuine international collaboration on business taxes than any single rival nation setting up a more favourable tax regime. Even the Biden administration now seems to be acknowledging that this may be the way forward with the need for governments to make up unprecedented economic damage from the pandemic, and if the US moves that way, there is political cover and financial incentive for other governments in the developed world to move that way too.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dagorenouf on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:45AM (#26768976)
Also, for many people, making $100k as an indie is infinitely more satisfying than making the same cash working for a FAANG.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by dx034 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:40AM (#26769282)
Making enough money to live comfortably in a place you like is key. It doesn't matter how much it is, if you have family and friends in a low-cost area, even $30k can be more than enough. I believe most people are happier if they can choose where to live and can live there well rather than chasing the highest salary you can get in the world.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by StavrosK on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:24AM (#26769190)
Right, but the problem is that you're way more unlikely to be making FAANG money outside FAANG.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Silhouette on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:47AM (#26769978)
I don't know how true that is, but I'm not sure it matters anyway. Money is nice, but job satisfaction is about much more than total compensation figures. Are you building something worthwhile, something that will help people to improve their lives in some way? Are you building something that is intellectually stimulating, facing challenges that you enjoy overcoming? Are you working in a comfortable environment, where you have positive interactions with pleasant colleagues? Is there a supportive culture, where you are respected as a contributor and trusted to make decisions according to your level of skill and experience? Is there a healthy work-life balance?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by m12k on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:47AM (#26768982)
Another point is that he is now free to go out and get another job if he wants to, while still getting the ad money from Photopea every year. That's the whole point of building up a passive income stream - once you uncouple the income from actually working, you are then free to do whatever you want with your time - including selling it for a salary like most people so.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ThePhysicist on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:09AM (#26768755)
Yep, I also have the impression you need a lot more to land a job at a FAANG than to simply be an excellent programmer. The interview process at companies like Google can be pretty byzantine and hard to master without an internal "champion" I heard.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by JosephRedfern on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:17AM (#26768820)
Indeed, it sort of assumes that working at FAANG with a pension plan and 200k+ is what the author should be striving for (the objectively better option), and I’m not sure if that’s accurate.

While there are obvious benefits to FAANGing, there’s also a lot to be said for working for a smaller team, or even yourself. Money isn’t the soul (or even main) motivator for a lot of people.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tehlike on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:10AM (#26769111)
There is no pension. There is 401k.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by JosephRedfern on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:19AM (#26769162)
Depends where you are. In the UK and much of the EU it’s a pension, as far as I know.

Either way, isn’t this mostly semantics? My point is that one persons priorities doesn’t necessarily match with another’s.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by lotsofpulp on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:00AM (#26769387)
Some countries call what Americans call a “401k” a “pension”.

Americans use “pension” as short for “defined benefit pension”, meaning you are owed some amount of money every month after the retirement age, and it’s up to the employer to do whatever needs to be done to provide it.

Americans use “401k” or “IRA” to refer to a defined contribution pension, one where the employer (and employee) contributes a certain amount into an account that is withdrawn from after retirement. However, the amount the employee can withdraw is subject to however much is in the account when they retire and however much the employee wants to periodically withdraw, so there is no definite benefit amount.

I have British family that refer to the latter as a pension, but we would not in the US. I would be surprised if any modern tech company offers a defined benefit pension anymore, even in UK/Europe.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by JosephRedfern on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:02AM (#26769394)
TIL! Thanks for the explainer.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tehlike on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:57AM (#26769372)
Fair.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tiagod on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:09AM (#26768757)
And some people, even if they have the chance to move to the US or some rich city where FAANG has engineering offices, would rather stay with their friends and family at the city they were born and make a lot less.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by tonyedgecombe on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:11AM (#26768770)
I'm not sure it would even make much sense for them to work at a FAANG. Running a small entrepreneurial business is so different from succeeding in a large corporation. In one you need to be a master of everything from marketing through to development, in the other you are going to need to be highly specialised to merit a large income.

My guess is he wouldn't want to work in a FAANG and they wouldn't want to hire him.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by jackTheMan on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:35AM (#26769909)
I've worked for Amazon and all I had to do is getting permissions from teams and then do some config changes (or similar level programming) in their software.

Needless to say year-by-year I forgot everything I've learned before. My CV might got a boost, but my skillset decreased a lot. Only thing what I've learned is politics and how to push and decorate an empty promo doc.

I was a braindead when I finally got my stocks. So went back to the startup word, where I could thrive. The average lifespan was like 1 year there, most people did not even wait for the stock so basically worked cheap for amazon.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by sammorrowdrums on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:32AM (#26768894)
Reminds me of this https://mobile.twitter.com/mxcl/status/608682016205344768

And many other similar stories

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by elric on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:12AM (#26769118)
I don't know what it's like in other countries, but here in Belgium, if you want compensation that is anywhere near FAANG levels, you have to go the freelance route and charge high day rates. Then we'd have to be talking rates of 1000eur/day or more, which is extremely rare. And if you didn't incorporate, you'll be taking home less than 500eur/day. Which is still three times more than what the average SE employee gets to take home. But it's a far cry from US FAANG levels.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by quickthrower2 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:21AM (#26769174)
Does FAANG let you delegate your time to other people. E.g. if I don’t feel like coding today I can just hire someone to do it for me and collect my FAANG salary? Can I sell my job for a million when I’m fed up of it? No?

Ok then running photopea is not comparable to a FAANG 9-5

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by onion2k on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:26AM (#26769201)
Besides the fact that he might not want to, I suspect many FAANG companies aren't optimized for hiring developers capable of making something like Photopea. Very little about the hiring process at somewhere like Google or Facebook is about what you can make on your own.

FAANGs hire for people who can make a small part of a larger whole incredibly well. That's mostly good for what they do, which often requires deep knowledge of specialist algorithms, but they miss out on hiring generalists who aren't necessarily good at the deep stuff but who can make lots of simple processes work well together. Which,in my opinion, is what you need to be a good front end developer.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by sida on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:30AM (#26769226)
While I don't disagree with you (and want to start there).

I just think photopea is far more than "generalists who aren't necessarily good at the deep stuff".

I think Photopea is pretty complicated alogrithm wise too

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by odiroot on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:34AM (#26769247)
> Some people simply live in underdeveloped countries where their talents can't shine and they have no way to get an interview at FAANG

And there's a high chance they would be rejected for lack of culture fit anyway. Or fail one of the quirky whiteboard tests.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by kristianc on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:36AM (#26768920)
Kind of goes without saying also that 250k is going to go a lot further in the Czech Republic than it is in SF. 3000 EUR / month in Prague is going to get you a top end 2/3 bed apartment.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by rvz on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:24AM (#26769491)
> I'd bet there are hundreds or thousands of genius programmers living in Russia, Brazil, the Balkans, Guatemala and many other countries that simply couldn't land a job at FAANG even if they wanted to.

Maybe they know they are just too clever for FAANG companies and can do even better for themselves by starting their own businesses?

We have to stop this constant submission to FAANG companies as 'the dream job' when in fact there are smaller companies out there that are just as good as they are and are also extremely profitable.

I don't they are interested in the glory days of the 2010s which the FAANG companies were the talk of the town. Fast-forward 10 years, they are now under scrutiny by everyone and it's not looking good for them. It's time to find new and emerging companies that will define the 2020s or 2030s.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by IggleSniggle on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:19AM (#26770160)
> We have to stop this constant submission to FAANG companies as 'the dream job' when in fact their are smaller companies out there that are just as good as they are and are also extremely profitable.

I agree! There’s also highly profitable private software businesses that are bigger than Netflix. I work for one. While it doesn’t pay nearly as well as FAANG, it does pay well, and is low-pressure / laid-back (I’m actually thinking about leaving not for better pay but for a faster-paced environment).

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by sildur on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:08AM (#26769098)
> Some people simply live in underdeveloped countries where their talents can't shine and they have no way to get an interview at FAANG

Some other people would consider morally reprehensible to be accomplices of FAANG. I wouldn't work for them even if I could. It would be like working for Fox News.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by f6v on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:39AM (#26769277)
I don’t intend to jump through all the hoops FAANG makes you. Some candidates spend more than one year to get ready for the whiteboard interview.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by freebuju on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:41AM (#26770313)
I don't understand. Is it a cult you are joining?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by mrfusion on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:35AM (#26769562)
Regarding not being able to work at a faang: Don’t forget social anxiety where your mind blanks when they put you in front of a white board.

Or also simply not being a cultural fit. What if you’re a republican?

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by sebastiangraef on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:14AM (#26769132)
He is also building an asset which he can sell.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by benja123 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:41AM (#26770637)
Also there are plenty of excellent programmers that could, but choose not to work in a FAANG for a number of reasons.

In Ivan’s case he has clearly achieved success and financial freedom on his own terms, so kudos to him.

Many of us would love to be able to do that, even if it meant taking a pay cut.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by mrisoli on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:14AM (#26770130)
Not sure what it's like these days but back when I starting university Google had just acquired a local company and setup their first Latin America office in my hometown(Belo Horizonte), salaries were probably a fraction of its SV counterpart but they were still 5-10x higher than just about any other company in the region. It was notoriously difficult to get in, only way to get an interview was to either have a phd or a masters with an impressive resume, even then you probably needed some connection to refer you.

Honestly I hoped their presence would help push local companies to up their game and drive salaries up for developers in a low wage market, unfortunately that is yet to happen 15 years later.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by bluishgreen on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:59PM (#26775113)
Couple pointers.

1. I have worked for FAANG adjacent companies(similar market cap) in the silicon valley. It is not exactly a badge of honor, sure - if other people want to honor you and you want to ride it why not. But it is not a badge of honor IMO. Horror? Sure.

2. People talk about 200+ guaranteed for a long time now. I think no one has caught on to it yet. Programmers of this caliber can and do pull ~600K regularly in FAANG and FAANG adjacent. If they are capable of people management at the same time (very few at this programming caliber are), then they will be pushed into the executive situation with millions in stock.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by seba_dos1 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:07AM (#26769417)
> it irks me when people say stuff this assuming that an excellent programmer always has easy access to a FAANG

...or assuming that an excellent programmer (or, in fact, just a programmer) wants to deal with FAANG in the first place.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by anothernewdude on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:51AM (#26769005)
At FAANG he'd be living in a place where 200+ is worth way less.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by rospaya on Sunday April 11, 2021 @01:55PM (#26772127)
> I'd bet there are hundreds or thousands of genius programmers living in Russia, Brazil, the Balkans, Guatemala and many other countries that simply couldn't land a job at FAANG even if they wanted to.

I could make more money as a waiter in Germany or Austria than in my devops job in the Balkans, but a) money isn't always the main motivation, especially in Europe and b) the same amount of money goes a lot further than in Silicon Valley.

It's not that comparable.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by veidr on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:20AM (#26769170)
That, plus the fact that building your own shit, being your own boss, and making your own mark on the world is probably a lot cooler and more satisfying to most of us here than helping sell more ads or get people to watch even more TV.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by devwastaken on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:50AM (#26770698)
Or simply photopea could have just never been found and became yet another thing to add to a GitHub resume that some hiring manager looks at and says "what's your work experience?"
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by high_byte on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:59AM (#26769058)
my issue is with that comment assuming Photopea is full-time job. maybe it is idk, but maybe it isn't and he can still work a day job and this is a side business. regardless of FAANG ofc.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Teracotage on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:37AM (#26769572)
He reminds me of the oldie irfanview.com from the 90s.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ilrwbwrkhv on Sunday April 11, 2021 @02:39PM (#26772436)
Also why would a talented programmer or a true hacker want to work for FAANG. The pirate mentality of not working for a big box corpo seems to have faded.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by o_p on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:14AM (#26768792)
Its just shocking to think that wasting your talent into making people click more ads for some faceless corp can even be compared to creating something great like Photopea.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by NullPrefix on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:59AM (#26769057)
>The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads. That sucks.

- Jeff Hammerbacher

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by sfifs on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:23AM (#26769186)
Compared to the best mids of previous generations making things that would blast civilization back to stone age in matter of minutes, I'd say this is progress :-)
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Hiopl on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:42AM (#26769950)
Except even the most destructive technologies have lead to incalculably valuable advancements for society. This is clearly a step back when we'd rather funnel our best minds into ads rather than things that could in a very real way help advance our civilization.

We're going to regret this sooner than later.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by darkwater on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:30AM (#26770232)
I hate ads too, but saying they are worse than nuclear weapons sounds just a bit too extreme... I mean, the information spreading helped by Google search was/is incalculably valuable for humanity.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by maury91 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:02AM (#26770445)
Nuclear weapons did lead to nuclear energy, and that is a benefit. They also lead to the end of WW2 and to the peace we are living now ( the reason super powers don't fight each other is that attacking each other with nuclear weapons will mean the end of everything ).

I'm not sure what ads can give us...

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by sfifs on Sunday April 11, 2021 @09:07PM (#26775159)
It's difficult to argue with ideology amd frankly the shenanigans of the less ethical parts of the digital ads industry haven't helped, but if you get the chance or inclination to research advertising from the early days of invention of newspapers to the present day, you may find that it is largely advertising money that paid for democratising access to information, culture, communication and entertainment which was till fairly recently in the history of civilization the privilege of the rich. Not a few social revolutions have been enabled by wide access to information and communication by organisations whose bills arr paid by ad dollars.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Synaesthesia on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:58AM (#26770747)
Hooray for progress! Instead of destruction of the world we merely have a mental addictive prison for everyone!

Oh wait, we still have those nuclear weapons too!

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by quickthrower2 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:18AM (#26769157)
Worse than that - buy shit they don’t need having been manipulated by big data. Google doesn’t sell clicks it sells expected customer value.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by rchaud on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:02AM (#26770774)
Google is absolutely selling clicks when an advertiser can perch their website on top of a search query for its competitor.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by quickthrower2 on Monday April 12, 2021 @06:23AM (#26777830)
If I spend $1000 on ads and get zero sales I don’t care about number of clicks. Conversely depending on my market a single click could be worth $1000.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by mensetmanusman on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:26AM (#26769511)
Quote should be modified to ‘Some of the best minds’
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by adventured on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:13AM (#26770504)
It should be modified to: lies that ad tech people tell themselves so they feel better about what they do for a living. If you work in a terrible field doing terrible things, you can at least pretend you're really smart so it's not a total loss.

Back in reality, very few of the best minds work in ad tech.

That fraudulent quote should be challenged every time it's posted, until it finally dies.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by vmception on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:31AM (#26769233)
> are thinking about how to make people click ads and complaining about people using their minds on cryptocurrency
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by mam2 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:53AM (#26769351)
To make money, which is by all account a measure of usefulness in society.

Using the best mind to improve trade is a good thing. Sorry if its not popular around herr but its true.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Silhouette on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:27AM (#26769855)
The trouble with this argument is that you're not starting with a level playing field. Other things being equal, work that produces more value might generate greater expected returns, but clearly in the real world other things are far from equal. There are opportunities available to those who already have money that are not available to everyone else, and consequently everyone else has to pay a premium, usually to the benefit of those who already had money. See also: most of the financial services sector, the standard arguments on the ethics of taxation to fund public services, etc.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by mam2 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:38AM (#26769931)
You think society is that worse now that it was before ?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Silhouette on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:52AM (#26770002)
Do I think society is worse than what, and in what way(s)?
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by 55555 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:28AM (#26768877)
Perhaps an odd thing to say considering Photopea is monetized by ads.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Closi on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:55AM (#26769032)
TV shows are also monetized by ads, but we don't ask talented show writers why they are wasting their time writing episodes when they could be spending their efforts towards creating better ads for washing up detergent.

If the developer of Photopea went to work on advert technology what would happen? The world would loose this great piece of software, one of the worlds richest advertising companies might get imperceptibly better at targeting ads, and the creator has to stop working on his own pet project which he is doing on his own terms and work on whatever his boss tells him to. Besides, if he achieves his goal of becoming one of the most popular image editors in the world, there is a good chance Photopea will be much more valuable than he will have earned as a salary at FAANG.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by 1_player on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:37AM (#26768927)
No. Making use of ads to support your creation is much different than being paid to work on ad technology itself.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Jyaif on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:52AM (#26769011)
Ad technology is what enables products like Photopea to exist in the first place.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by yarcob on Sunday April 11, 2021 @10:39AM (#26770631)
Photopea could just as well be monetized by selling licenses or by non-intrusive unpersonalized ads. When you have a great product making money from it isn't hard.

I think that 90% of ad tech is useless shit technology that just exists to take a cut of the money, without actually providing much of a value to anyone.

It's like realtors or financial advisors or other middlemen like that. The main reason for them being there is that it's a very profitable business to get a cut of somebody else's transactions.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ohgodplsno on Sunday April 11, 2021 @05:59AM (#26769056)
People were making things before advertisers tried to pretend nothing else could exist without them, and will continue to do so long after advertisers are gone.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by katzgrau on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:42AM (#26769294)
> long after advertisers are gone

May have sounded nice, but successful creators eventually become advertisers. As long as they have money to spend on marketing, they'll spend it to get in front of the right people

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ruined on Sunday April 11, 2021 @11:11AM (#26770835)
ad technology admittedly provides a possibility for monetization, which can justify something to an accountant, but it is completely perpendicular to use-value and technical feasibility. it does not "enable" anything to exist.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by Normille on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:07AM (#26769087)
I don't use Photopea enough to justify paying for it. I already own Photoshop and only very occasionally fire up Photopea when I need to make a trivial edit to an image for posting online, or suchlike when I can't be arsed waiting for Photoshop to launch.

And, since I have an almost pathological hatred of adverts, I block them and use Stylebot to remove the space where they'd be.

But I'm glad the dev is making a decent living from what I've previously described as probably the most impressive web app I've ever seen. He deserves rewarded for his work but I'm sorry, I'm NEVER even looking at --never mind 'clicking on'-- a single advert while using the web, if I can possibly help it.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by csomar on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:00AM (#26769062)
Since he has a paid version that doesn't seem to make much money, my guess is that he is not making that much from ads. Probably just enough for me.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by bennysomething on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:51AM (#26769343)
I don't think this a waste of time. Adverts help businesses get their products to consumers. This pays people's wages. It aids wealth generation. Nothing bad about that.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ClumsyPilot on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:48AM (#26769617)
Did consumers need those products? Would they have bought the same thing but from a different company? If not, would they iblnstead put this money into savings for a rainy day? Would they save for a house? Wouod we have less homeless and vulnerable people?

Would the clever people working on ads and manipulating consumers actually pursue careers like chemical enginerting which solves fundamental problems of human civilisation?

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by sokoloff on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:52AM (#26769996)
If everyone saved money in a world where ads didn’t exist, do you think housing wouldn’t be bid up by virtue of many people having extra money to spend?

I hate what web ads have become, but I’m pretty sure they’re not a significant driver of homelessness.

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by ClumsyPilot on Sunday April 11, 2021 @02:00PM (#26772156)
Sure, i am not claiming without ads we will not have homeless people

I am asking whether we have any proof that the advertising i dustry contributes anything substantial to the real economy, or we would be better off if these people were doing something else

Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by loceng on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:55AM (#26769363)
If you keep the consequences and scope of view so narrow like that, sure, that is a single positive that isn't weighing it at all with any of the negatives.
Re:AMA: Ivan Kutskir, creator of Photopea by executesorder66 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @01:36PM (#26772002)
Ads also make sure that I add those businesses to my mental blacklist and never want to interact with them again. This affects peoples wages. It aids wealth destruction. Nothing good about that.