News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by j_horvat on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:17PM (#50187773)
Sure, but where's the jail time for executives. This may be a bit more than the usual slap on the wrist, but its hardly consequence that actually matters to the likes of Meta. This will keep happening until those at the top are held personally responsible for the crimes they sign off on.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:38PM (#50188034)
> where's the jail time for executives

Our American obsession with jail is nuts. The violation at hand was “misleading state citizens about how it safeguards and collects user data.”

Lots of folks at Meta should be criminally investigated. But not for this, not unless someone willfully signed off on a lie.

> This will keep happening until those at the top are held personally responsible

Perfect is the enemy of the good.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by layer8 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:04PM (#50188302)
> But not for this, not unless someone willfully signed off on a lie.

From the judgement: “The extraordinary number of willful violations found by the jury, the duration and repetition of the conduct, the breadth of subjects on which violations occurred, the involvement of senior Facebook leadership, the size of New Mexico audiences reached, and the clear intentional and systematic nature of Facebook’s repeated misstatements established in the trial record support the highest level of penalty allowed by the New Mexico Unfair Practices Act […].”

Emphasis mine.

It isn’t criminal law, but maybe at that level it should be.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:37PM (#50189141)
> the involvement of senior Facebook leadership

If anyone perjured themselves, granted. If not, criminalizing this lets anyone in power go after anything with any economic heft.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by anonymous908213 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:04PM (#50189319)
I am, in fact, fine with anyone in power going after any company's senior leadership which makes a "clear intentional and systematic nature of repeated misstatements" while committing crimes violating privacy laws 40 million times. I am very equal opportunity punishment for all serial lying criminals. What part of what you said was supposed to be undesirable?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:18PM (#50189434)
> fine with anyone in power going after any company's senior leadership which makes a "clear intentional and systematic nature of repeated misstatements" while committing crimes violating privacy laws 40 million times

You’re describing a wet dream for Silicon Valley’s elites. Reducing the courts’ ability to check prosecutorial discretion is an ongoing project there.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by RHSeeger on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:50PM (#50190154)
Beating someone with a stick isn't the only way to cause harm. And if you cause harm to 40 million people, you should be held accountable - it should be treated as a crime.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:08AM (#50191408)
> if you cause harm to 40 million people, you should be held accountable

Yes.

> it should be treated as a crime

Crime means jail. Not just for the folks you want in jails. For anyone who the people with power drive should be in one.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by willy_k on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:58PM (#50189769)
In case it hasn’t become abundantly clear to everyone by now: this is how Facebook operates. The people who do this stuff get promoted, and vice versa. This will keep happening until those people are scared straight, and the incentive structure that turns people into this are abolished.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by mordae on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:50AM (#50192453)
I would dissolve Facebook over blatant intentional breach of law. Better than sending people to jail. Just imagine. One day the FB homepage saying "log in to download all your data, you have 14 days -- gov agency".

And then wipe everything, sell servers on ebay, pay employees couple months of wages as apology, pay off lenders, strike the company off the business register and bye.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:25PM (#50199196)
What’s your plan for the recession you create? Or for the same people just starting the exact same thing again in two minutes—the relationships with the employees and advertisers are between people, after all.

Blind, stupid hate is absolutely how societies collapse. You’re not speaking without precedent. But it’s part of why some places in the world are structurally poor—they can’t help but give into this instinct for blind vengeance.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Zigurd on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:42PM (#50189183)
I'm in complete agreement about the perfect being the enemy of the good. Complaining about this outcome serves very little purpose.

But this case was about selling out democracy. I suppose it falls into the category of great crimes like killing people with cigarettes and deceiving the public and regulators while doing it. If you steal from the rich and powerful you go to prison, but killing tens to hundreds of thousands of children in Africa is too abstract to punish that way.

The American attitude about and system of incarceration is pretty crazy, but so is our idea of scale in crime. At the retail end of our criminal so-called justice system, you have cops that in many places fragrantly engage in overtime and detail fraud, sometimes amounting to hundreds of thousands of dollars, putting minor criminals in prison and penury. It's all pretty crazy.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:18PM (#50189436)
> If you steal from the rich and powerful you go to prison, but killing tens to hundreds of thousands of children in Africa is too abstract to punish that way

This crosses jurisdictions. We have no international legal system that doesn’t rely on voluntary cooperation.

If you’re claiming that every car- and bicycle-theft victim is a billionaire, idk what to tell you.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Zigurd on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:40PM (#50189605)
Oh bike thieves are lower than dog poop, for sure. My ambivalence stems from the cop who might catch that thief stealing 100X more from the municipality in the form of overtime fraud. The rot is in play at every level of scale.

Also you don't need international justice to find criminality in how DOGE was done.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by throwaway81523 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:43PM (#50188732)
> Our American obsession with jail is nuts.

If we were really obsessed with jail for executives, a lot more of them would be locked up right now. There might be an obsession, but it's only about jailing peons.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:38PM (#50189152)
> If we were really obsessed with jail for executives, a lot more of them would be locked up right now

This is the opposite of what happens in any incarceration-happy culture. See: the French Revolution. The rich got away, got richer, in fact. The machines of terror inevitable turned on the poor. Liberties are most valuable to those of us who are not billionaires.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lovich on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:52PM (#50189236)
Sure, but we can still all be pissed about the upper class being beyond consequences that us plebs get.

If I do something to fuck over this many people and harm society this much I’m going to jail. No billionaire is having the same consequences.

Until that changes you are going to have people be willing to back table flipping movements like the French Revolution in a gamble to maybe give consequences to those in charge. Hell that’s more than half the reason we got Trump.

Also I’m going to call out your analysis of the French Revolution as failing entirely as poor. Some of the rich got richer but people wanted the kings head and they definitely got it.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:13PM (#50189401)
> we can still all be pissed about the upper class being beyond consequences that us plebs get

Sure. Light a bonfire. Scream and windmills. And then come to your senses and realises lowering the bar for criminality will absolutely not limits its blast radius to the people you want it to.

> you are going to have people be willing to back table flipping movements like the French Revolution

The rich got richer in the French Revolution! America’s rich want that.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lovich on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:03PM (#50189817)
> And then come to your senses and realises lowering the bar for criminality will absolutely not limits its blast radius to the people you want it to.

If you’re already in the blast radius of the current system, why would you care if it expands if you think it might include the people fucking you over in the first place?

I’m not disagreeing that there are problems that could result from this idea. I’m disagreeing with you on the idea that people are crazy for wanting this while there’s this class of people who do whatever they want whenever they want to the rest of us.

Like I pointed out with the French king loosing his head during the French Revolution. The fact that one of those people had consequences is worth it to a lot of people even if it means the rest of the noble class is even more empowered.

They are already beyond consequence generally, more power for them doesn’t change the relationship between the common man and the nobles.

You saw the same emotional situation play out with Luigi Mangiones actions despite having scant effect on the system.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:14PM (#50199063)
> fact that one of those people had consequences is worth it to a lot of people even if it means the rest of the noble class is even more empowered

Right. This is stupidity. Except in a world with private jets and international wires we’d be in a Bourbon restoration much quicker.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lovich on Thursday October 22, 2026 @05:49PM (#50201527)
You need to deal with the fact that my theoretical situation doesn’t change.

There’s a boot on my neck either way. The boot squeezing harder doesn’t change the fact that it’s on my neck.

If I see the chance to cut off the leg of one of the people holding that boot down and the only consequence is that I am in the same situation I was in previously, why would I not take it?

I guess I have to preface this with the fact that I know you personally are well off and actually have a material difference in quality of life in this situation.

I am asking you why I should care about your material difference in life when mine won’t change either way?

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by imawakegnxoxo on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:06PM (#50189832)
I don't think "holding rich people to the same standard as the peasants" is equivalent to "lowering the bar for criminality"

In fact, I'd go so far as saying it's much closer to "keep the bar for criminality where it is, but apply it to everyone equally" but personally I'd add a little addendum about scaling up the punishment for crimes by those with greater influence and responsibilities to the people, but that's just me

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:06AM (#50191400)
> don't think "holding rich people to the same standard as the peasants" is equivalent to "lowering the bar for criminality"

Neither do I. But let’s look at the facts and circumstances of this case. Lowering the threshold for criminal guilt to meet it would, I think, expose a lot of ordinary activity to criminal prosecution.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nixon_why69 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:09PM (#50190300)
China jails executives, they just sentenced the CEO of evergrande to life, with a death penalty suspended sentence.

They do this despite jailing fewer people in total (not just per-capita) than America.

One could say that this is because Xi is untouchable but I think it's more about the social norms. Americans can't even consider a world where we prosecute the powerful.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:15PM (#50199077)
> They do this despite jailing fewer people in total

Yup. Putting Meta executives in jail for violating New Mexico privacy rules isn’t following China’s example. Putting them in jail for lying to Congress and targeting teenagers is.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nixon_why69 on Friday October 23, 2026 @02:17PM (#50213237)
I think you're saying bust them for the real social harms instead of ticky-tack small stuff? If that's the case then I totally agree but american culture needs to handle busting any executive for any harm first.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by webnrrd2k on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:31AM (#50191197)
Not all of them... try talking to Marie Antoinette. A lot of the nobility and church-types didn't do so hot. Wealthy urban bourgeois did pretty good, though.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by DannyBee on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:37AM (#50192376)
"Sure, but we can still all be pissed about the upper class being beyond consequences that us plebs get."

HN is mostly the 1%, they just don't think they are the 1%. At least in the US. Outside the US it's often even more crazy, but it's more bi-modal.

In the US, grossing 500k all-in (IE stock + bonus + salary, not take home pay) would put you in the top 1%.

225k all-in would put you in the top 5%.

Watching HN complain about "the upper class" or "the rich" is an exercise in cognitive dissonance.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by llama052 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @04:32AM (#50192761)
I guess I’m not getting paid enough these days…
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by DannyBee on Thursday October 22, 2026 @09:08AM (#50194814)
225k is below the average all-in offer for a bachelors college grad hired in the bay area at Google.

So maybe?

The sarcasm definitely doesn't change the point, of course - most of HN is the rich, and the upper class, but somehow believes they are not.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lovich on Thursday October 22, 2026 @09:50AM (#50195329)
I’ve never made 225k in my life. And I still have more in common with someone getting paid 500k a year than I do with the people who appear literally untouchable
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by guelo on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:42PM (#50189182)
Our system consists of exactly one proposition, to wit: There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by AngryData on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:45PM (#50188752)
I would agree except jail time is what all us peons face for all sorts of far more benign charges. So until poor people's punishments are lessened they are going to advocate for greater punishment for these crimes.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by shermantanktop on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:40PM (#50188694)
The problem with fines is that they don't actually disincentivize bad behavior by companies, as long as they are large enough to absorb the fine as a cost of doing business.

Time in the pokey is unpleasant for everyone.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by j16sdiz on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:41PM (#50189608)
The problem with fines is that they don't actually disincentivize bad behaviour by decision makers.

Corporations don't make decisions, individuals do.

You could argue if we hit the business hard enough, the individual making those decisions maybe suffers from.. maybe... less bonus? but, well....

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by betterunix2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:27PM (#50190433)
Sorry but it sounds like you think "limited liability" should only be understood to refer to corporate debts and bankruptcy proceedings and that "corporate personhood" should be understood as a legal fiction to make things simpler for bureaucrats.

That's crazy talk. Did you miss the part where corporations are actually people?

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by roenxi on Thursday October 22, 2026 @06:53AM (#50193661)
If you don't think the decision makers are considering the cost to the business (as represented in the fine) or the cost to themselves (as measured by a bonus) then whet do you think is motivating their decision making process?

Decision makers are often quite sensitive to the cost to the business, people who are tagged as causing $25 billion in unnecessary charges would need to start talking very quickly about what justifies the expense. Even in the case of Facebook that much money is more than enough to start swinging decisions.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by betterunix2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:18PM (#50190365)
The fines are not big enough if the companies can just absorb the blow like that. $25B is not large enough to be a problem for Facebook. Add two more digits and the executives would be running to their doomsday bunkers.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by tw04 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:33PM (#50188621)
If corporations are people, then they should face the exact same punishment as a person. If any individual perpetrated this level of fraud they might be spending the rest of their life in jail. See: bernie madhoff.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:22PM (#50189027)
> If any individual perpetrated this level of fraud they might be spending the rest of their life in jail. See: bernie madhoff

…what is the factual basis for comparing this to Madoff?

How is the circle of passing draconian laws instead of proportional response then driving draconian regimes to abuse that permit not a lesson we can learn?

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:09PM (#50189859)
>what is the factual basis for comparing this to Madoff?

the jury's ruling?

- extraordinary number of willful violations found by the jury - the duration and repetition of the conduct - the breadth of subjects on which violations occurred - the involvement of senior Facebook leadership - the size of New Mexico audiences reached - clear intentional and systematic nature of Facebook’s repeated misstatements

That's an extremely high bar to hit and Facebook cleared it. Madoff's scheme, even adjusted for inflation, tops out around 200b dollars or so. Facebook clears the overall financial bar by a whole magnitude, and its effects were felt globally.

You seem very fixated on downplaying just how historical a case this (and/or proceeding cases against FB) will be. This will easily go down in the same lane as cigarettes on how people remember this era.

>How is the circle of passing draconian laws

Do I really need to bring out the Martin Luther King Jr. quote here just because we're so fixated on legalities? Let's remember nothing cigarette companies did were illegal as well.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by spiderice on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:30PM (#50189998)
> Let's remember nothing cigarette companies did were illegal as well

What are you getting at? That we should jail people for not breaking laws?

The fact that you're comparing this to fucking Hitler is insane. Even you know it, which is why you were too embarrassed to say it.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by johnnyanmac on Thursday October 22, 2026 @04:25PM (#50200531)
> why you were too embarrassed to say it.

I'm not embarrassed to say it at all. But I don't like when conversations derail into morality scaling. How about we just make sure we create good incentives to do good and vice versa?

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by wasfgwp on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:05AM (#50191738)
So the implication is that if Madoff used an llc to perpetrate all of his scams he would have face no criminal liability? A llc doesn’t somehow magically shields executives from criminal prosecution
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by johnnyanmac on Thursday October 22, 2026 @04:22PM (#50200494)
Not particularly. But under that lens, sure. If he could have stayed Gierek for 8 more years, he might have gotten a pardon. That's how bad things are these days.

I was simply saying that FB's scale of damage and money impacted is much higher than Madoff's

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:21PM (#50190781)
A sole proprietor would also only face financial damages, not jail time. Employees can be charged with criminal charges. Corporations don't protect from that.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by hereme888 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:14PM (#50188405)
So our obsession with jail is nuts, because... you lean towards no one willfully signed off on a lie, in a company with a history like Meta/Facebook, in a $25B fine?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Maarten88 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:42PM (#50188719)
Full presidential pardons go for just a couple of million, a rounding error on that fine. Invoking social media and complaining about a democrat judge or deep state conspiracy and forking over the money using the right attorneys is all it takes. Nobody with that kind of resources will go to jail.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by hereme888 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:55PM (#50189259)
And your source of information is internet hearsay, I gather?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Maarten88 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:48PM (#50190127)
Just this week the New York Times reported the case of a venezolan banker who received a pardon after hiring a former lawyer of the president. There probably will be litigation if they misreport it so this does not seem hearsay to me.

AI readily provided me a list of 8 other well documented cases of "pay for pardons" and offered detailed research on all of them.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by hereme888 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:28PM (#50198439)
Huh, you were right. I chatted with AI for a while on this as well. Interesting cases, especially the crypto king CZ's pardon. Though unproven by courts, their circumstances and timelines strongly smell like pay-for-pardon, even without proof of agreements.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by throwaway81523 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:45PM (#50188749)
I'm sure the crime reached into all 50 states. Maybe they should be tried and sentenced in all of them, so avoiding jail would need 51 pardons instead of just one.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by infinite_spin on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:23PM (#50189042)
I just want to note that the president can give pardons for federal crimes, but not for state level crimes.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Maarten88 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:02PM (#50190247)
> I just want to note that the president can give pardons for federal crimes, but not for state level crimes.

He can and he did, it just does not work.

But he can make the governor do it, which did work at least once.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by throwaway81523 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:10AM (#50192176)
Yes, you do a state prosecution even if there are already federal charges, since Trump can only pardon federal charges. Pardoning state charges, though, can be done by the state governor, same deal. So you do all 50 states to be very nearly sure.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by mywittyname on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:08PM (#50188916)
> Our American obsession with jail is nuts.

We rarely imprison the people who actually deserve it. Even when we do, it's barely a punishment if the person is wealthy.

Our jails are full, but a lot of that is we harshly punish mundane crimes against people with no real ability to defend themselves. And that's mostly because the grift of for-profit prisons.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by gottorf on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:55PM (#50189257)
Our jails are full, relative to other developed countries, because we have vastly higher rates of crime. Our laws, by design, hamper the ability of the state to "harshly punish mundane crimes against people with no real ability to defend themselves". Talk to any cop in any metro area of note; everyone knows who the criminals are by name and face, but they remain largely out there to offend and reoffend because it's hard (again, by design) to prove it beyond a reasonable doubt.

> the grift of for-profit prisons

Only a single-digit percentage of prisoners are in for-profit prisons, and roughly half of the states do not use them at all. I dislike them for the obvious perverse incentive, but it's a great exaggeration to say that the system puts largely innocent people in prison to line the pockets of for-profit prison execs.

For better or worse, American society is very good at sorting people, so the HN crowd and other intelligentsia usually doesn't encounter the bottom 5% that wreak havoc.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:16PM (#50189902)
>because we have vastly higher rates of crime.

And guess what the top reason is for incarceration are? Hint: it beats out sex offences and weapons/arson. And it started right after a certain announcement in the 70's that was largely admitted to increasing incarceration rates.

https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_offen...

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by gottorf on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:31PM (#50190458)
It's widely known that drug offenses are easier ways to stick criminals (who perpetrate crimes other than drug offenses) in prison, analogous to how in the end they convicted Al Capone of tax evasion. There is no epidemic of mere consumers of controlled substances going to prison, at least not in the past decade or longer.

Besides, you can look at the straightforward statistic of homicides to gauge the overall criminality of a population. The US has a homicide rate an order of magnitude higher than its peer countries. By this measure, the US actually has an under-incarceration problem, not one of over-incarceration. Wikipedia has the US incarceration rate at 542 per 100k, compared to Sweden at 92, Switzerland at 77, or South Korea at 115; compare that to the intentional homicide rates of the US at 5.763 per 100k, Sweden at 0.867, Switzerland at 0.504, and South Korea at 0.489. If incarceration scaled with the homicide rate, those other countries are actually much more prison-heavy than the US!

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by betterunix2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:44PM (#50190536)
> prove it beyond a reasonable doubt

Except that proving it is rarely necessary because the system relies on plea deals and because the 6th amendment is not automatically enforced. There are places in the US where the criminal justice system would break down if every defendant refused a plea deal and demanded a speedy trial.

Our jails are full because we have unnecessarily long sentences and a prison system that is meant to be punitive instead of rehabilitative (and which winds up encouraging recidivism and compounding the problem further). Things have improved over the past 20 years but we have not done enough to address the problem.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by gottorf on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:09PM (#50190693)
> There are places in the US where the criminal justice system would break down if every defendant refused a plea deal and demanded a speedy trial

I'm actually not aware of any place in the US that routinely administers what could be considered a speedy trial. It's a shame, really, but perhaps an inevitable side-effect of the ever-increasing burden on the part of the prosecution. Pre-Warren Court, it was normal for criminal cases to take days between arrest and trial.

> Our jails are full because we have unnecessarily long sentences and a prison system that is meant to be punitive instead of rehabilitative

I make the point in a sibling comment that the US actually has lower incarceration rates compared to its peer nations, relative to their homicide rates. Our jails are full because we have a lot more crime. We can agree to disagree on the "root causes" thereof.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by betterunix2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:02AM (#50191051)
I am not sure what "relative to the homicide rate" is supposed to prove. The homicide rate is not the same as the homicide conviction rate, or put another way, perhaps we have a lower incarceration rate relative to our homicide rate compared to other countries because we are solving a smaller fraction of homicides compared to those countries.

(Also possible, but I suspect less likely, is that our homicide rate is higher but not in proportion to the number of murderers; maybe we have a bigger problem with serial killers than other countries, and thus have fewer murderers to incarcerate relative to the homicide rate.)

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by gottorf on Friday October 23, 2026 @09:45AM (#50208892)
The homicide rate is a clean way to compare the criminality of different populations, because it's easy to define and hard to hide. That way you don't get lost in the details of what's a crime in one country and isn't in another.

Given that America has a homicide rate an order of magnitude higher than its peer countries, it stands to reason that its overall criminality is higher, and therefore we can expect to see more people imprisoned per capita than in those other countries.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by betterunix2 on Friday October 23, 2026 @03:50PM (#50214415)
OK, let's assume that all countries have identical legal codes and definitions of "crime." The claim that the homicide rate is correlated with the incarceration rate is still dubious.

As I said in my previous comment, the homicide rate is not the same as the rate at which murderers are convicted and imprisoned. Besides having a higher homicide rate compared with other countries, the US also has a low rate of arrests/convictions for homicide compared to other countries:

https://www.themarshallproject.org/2022/01/12/as-murders-spi...

Really though, the fact that a majority of US inmates are non-violent offenders should be enough to tell you that the homicide rate says little about the incarceration rate. The homicide rate also says very little about the overall crime rate, unless you believe in antiquated concepts about "criminality" that treat "crime" as a monolithic category. In reality, a murderer is no more likely to commit fraud or possess drugs than anyone else, and someone kiting checks is no more likely to be a murderer.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by gottorf on Friday October 23, 2026 @11:15PM (#50218076)
> a majority of US inmates are non-violent offenders

Only true for federal inmates, which is <10% of all prisoners in the US. When you take into account the rest of the prison population, the majority are in fact imprisoned for violent crimes[0] (homicide, assault, rape, robbery, etc.).

> In reality, a murderer is no more likely to commit fraud or possess drugs than anyone else, and someone kiting checks is no more likely to be a murderer

I'm flabbergasted that anyone could believe this on its face. Do you not think that the behavioral factors that drive someone to murder correlates with a whole host of other antisocial behaviors?

In actual reality, studies in criminology repeatedly show both that people who commit one kind of crime tend to commit other kinds of crime; and that there's a strong power law distribution in crime, where an extreme minority commit the great majority of crime. Most people do not commit any. It's farcical to suggest that the average Joe off the street is as likely to be a fraudster as a convicted murderer, or really as any other kind of criminal.

[0]: https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-numbers-dont-lie-its-...

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by hsuduebc2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:47PM (#50188771)
The whole purpose of companies is that the bankruptcy of a company will not ruin entrepreneurs and strip them of all their belongings. You have the possibility of failing softly. That's a good thing because it enables you to take a calculated risk. But that risk is usually just money.

When a company, for example its managers through willful negligence or an outright lie, enables the organization to do something that is considered illegal, they absolutely should be held personally responsible. The existence of a company as an entity shields the entrepreneurship itself, not individuals who are actively harming others.

Managers who willingly poisoned people with cigarettes or lead, and now with brain rot, while simultaneously claiming that it is not harmful to the public, even when they know that is simply a lie, should absolutely be held responsible.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by mxkopy on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:13PM (#50188394)
Honestly it doesn’t matter what they get them on, half of the PMC in America needs to be indicted on RICO charges for white collar crimes against humanity
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by tt24 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:58PM (#50190624)
Deranged statement here
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by roosterIllusi0n on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:26PM (#50188538)
The CEO is the only one with decision power and is responsible for all crimes. The CEO is also the one making the most money off the crimes. If we don't actual jail them, crimes will keep increasing as we are witnessing. AI companies are now bragging about their crimes publicly.

Good is arresting a CEO and holding them in prison for a few decades. These fines do nothing. These fines are the enemy of good.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by 59percentmore on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:38PM (#50188676)
Hold them in jail pending trial. They are the definition of flight risk.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by joquarky on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:30PM (#50188587)
Besides, aren't C-levels usually the ones that justify their huge compensation by claiming that they deserve it because they take the big risks?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by hsuduebc2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:36PM (#50188652)
Big risk of being fired maybe while receiving humongous payoff. Ridiculous.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by suburban_strike on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:39PM (#50188687)
Golden parachutes mitigate those risks. The company may tank, but they get theirs.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by tt24 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:59PM (#50190628)
Sorry, who claims this? Sounds like you’re confused
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cromka on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:54PM (#50188830)
>> where's the jail time for executives

> Our American obsession with jail is nuts

I am European and I want those American executives in jail as well /s

But in all seriousness, shareholders in 2026 should start pushing for an investment markets reform to introduce criminal responsibility for such actions, because that's a pretty good deterrent to have the executives not act against their fiduciary duty and the shareholders' bottom line.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by mbesto on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:28PM (#50189979)
> Our American obsession with jail is nuts.

Sure but also there has to be some sort of deterrent and an executive who's worth is $100M+ who can't touch their $100M because their in jail is far more of a deterrent than META missing its earnings for a quarter because they owe the government a one-time slap on the wrist.

I'm all ears on what a different penalty could be that ultimately stops this behavior.

PS - META's stock is currently up 2% in after hours trading, so

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by wasfgwp on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:08AM (#50191753)
Because the market believes that the fine will be massively reduced after an appeal. That’s what usually happens..
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by betterunix2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:05PM (#50190278)
Yes, our obsession with jail is nuts. Why do I only hear people say so in response to populist calls to throw corporate executives in prison for actual crimes?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by NegativeLatency on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:59AM (#50191353)
It is, but as they say "what's good for the goose is good for the gander", if we have rules they should apply to everyone equally, or they should be changed.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:09AM (#50191419)
> if we have rules they should apply to everyone equally, or they should be changed

This is tautology, but sure. If you or I did 10x this, e.g. stole a car via financial slipper, we would not be prosecuted.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by xigoi on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:19AM (#50191483)
Even if you stole 43 million cars?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lrvick on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:24PM (#50187853)
No one will bother making a move on the execs until the get-out-of-jail-free cards they bought from the current president are no longer valid.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:27PM (#50187905)
If only software engineers were liable like real engineers are
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lrvick on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:37PM (#50188022)
"But my boss told me to increase engagement at all costs, including substantially increased rates of teen suicides, so shrug guess I have to since my visa will be revoked otherwise and I need this cash to send home to my family."

Even when you cannot get highly employable US engineers to agree to do unethical work, you can always import some indentured servants who are too vulnerable to feel like they can say no.

I know someone that took a job at meta short term to get cash for a family member with cancer.

Go after the people giving the orders, not the workers trying to survive a deeply fucked up system.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by linkregister on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:04PM (#50189322)
I will never understand the framing of visa-sponsored workers at Facebook as indentured servants. These are incredibly highly-paid jobs, easily in the top 5% of earners in the United States even for fairly junior roles. Even in California, these folks are in the top quintile of earners. These are people who could earn a third as much in India, Canada, or the Netherlands, and still be living exceptionally well. They have exercised more agency than the vast majority of Americans or even Bay Area residents.

That said, expecting individual engineers to understand the greater context of building an online addiction machine is probably too much. The product managers and data scientists surface concerns and executives decide. And executives should be held criminally responsible in the event of gross negligence.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by portmanteur on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:46PM (#50189647)
All of the accolades you bestowed upon visa-sponsored workers could be true. But the framing of indentured servitude comes from the visa sponsorship itself. These workers do not feel they have the right to free expression or to speak out against unethical business practices (not just data privacy but even 9/9/6 work schedules), for fear of losing their sponsorship. That’s why “indentured” is used: they’re contracted to a specific employer. They don’t have freedom of movement in the labor market. This also creates labor price arbitrage, which employers use to pay visa workers less than permanent residents and citizens. This labor arbitrage inevitably lowers the wages of non-sponsored workers.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by linkregister on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:13PM (#50190720)
This is more or less an uninformed vibes-based response.

1. Few workers report a 996 work schedule at Meta or other Mag7 companies. This work schedule is reported by smaller AI startups and Chinese and Indian tech firms.

2. H1B and many other sponsored visas are transferrable. I have had several colleagues get laid off or interview for other jobs and get hired elsewhere. The L visa is non-transferable, though it represents a minority of visa sponsorships in the US.

3. You directly ignored my data about workers at Meta out-earning other workers in the Bay Area. My foreign colleagues earned the same as I did at virtually every stage of my career.

In general macroeconomics, yes, the introduction of foreign workers results in wages getting pulled down. This "lump of labor" only has temporary impacts. The overall outcome is an increase in the market for engineers, as immigrants go on to found companies. NVIDIA, the world's most valuable company, is one of these.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by joebig on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:41AM (#50192001)
Reg. 2: What is the time window within which they need to secure the said contract once laid-off, failing which they'll be required to leave the country?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by linkregister on Thursday October 22, 2026 @04:02PM (#50200246)
It's pretty quick! 30 days. I agree it's bad. Hardly comparable to indentured service.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lrvick on Thursday October 22, 2026 @05:43PM (#50201463)
30 days for someone early in their career to find a new job in the bay after being fired for insubordination from Meta is not a bet most feel absolutely sure they can win, and the consequences are high. They may not be able to come back given the immigration climate right now.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by shimman on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:19PM (#50189911)
It's disgusting and a downplay of atrocity of slavery. It's why we should stop allowing tech companies to import so many foreign workers if this is what they are okay with: openly destroying our society for money.

Expect the GOP to move in this direction as the democratic party starts going after big tech as well.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:28PM (#50197608)
Your response feels like you were just looking for anything to shoehorn your overt racism into

An engineer is liable but so is the firm. A doctor is liable but so is the hospital. I’m going after both.

How would making imported workers liable do anything but disincentivize them from committing these crimes?

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lrvick on Thursday October 22, 2026 @05:48PM (#50201515)
I am racist for having empathy for the complex risks imported workers face that makes them easier to pressure into doing legal (but unethical) things for their employers? Wtf?

Obviously we should hold leadership liable and responsible for harms of their choices and make this stuff illegal. Once illegal, then everyone is held to that standard of course.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Friday October 23, 2026 @02:33AM (#50205172)
Dude look at my original comment. Your reply is a tangent on a tangent and has nothing to do with it. It’s off-topic. If you want to talk about the H1B thing then go do that in another thread. That’s not what my comment is about.

Don’t assume I’m lacking empathy. The goal of holding engineers liable is to protect the public against malicious software. Protecting the engineers is unrelated to my comment. You can have both. In fact, real engineers are mandatory whistleblowers, and protected.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by barbazoo on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:41PM (#50188073)
Why would you personally punish the chumps that execute the orders instead of leadership that gave the orders?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by theendisney on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:21PM (#50188477)
Im not a lawyer but i believe just following orders isnt considered a valid excuse. Now that machines participate in giving instructions it seems quite logical.

If the wires are hanging out of the wall and someone asks me to switch the power on it reminds me how my old boss almost died then chased the guy with a hammer but collapsed from his injuries before he could kill him. So i disassemble the switchboard. If there is someone like that walking around I don't care how long it takes. Sometimes they get angry I just ignore it. They may also report it to my boss.

RL is different like that but also quite similar.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by suburban_strike on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:14PM (#50188956)
> Im not a lawyer but i believe just following orders isnt considered a valid excuse

This is sophistry that was used to condemn Nazis but has never applied to any context outside of the Nuremberg trials. Fail to follow orders and you're shot as a traitor. Follow them and you're hanged as a war criminal. "Just follow orders" is the basis of paid employment itself.

It is assumed that those giving bad orders will be held responsible for doing so, but this rarely proves to be the case. See the eBay harassment of the Steiners. Everybody involved that followed orders was punished except the executive that signed off on and provided support for the operation.

But in the Equifax breach, two executives were fired following criminal intrusion by Chinese hackers they had no involvement with. Everyone that neglected to follow orders to patch Struts probably still works there.

The rules are arbitrary.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by spencerflem on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:29PM (#50189082)
Ok sure, not in the eyes of the law. But ethically
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Friday October 23, 2026 @12:15PM (#50211381)
It’s hilarious that I started this thread by saying that software engineers should start to be held liable like real engineers and in the replies we have somehow decided to use… Nazis… as the analogy? What?

This doesn’t need an analogy.

Why not just look up examples of engineers disclosing breaches of code/contract? Every state has lists of complaints brought to their engineering board with results and disciplinary actions.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:34PM (#50197688)
I’m an engineer and not only is “I’m just following orders” not a valid excuse but you’re legally obligated to disclose crimes
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by willio58 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:26PM (#50188529)
It’s needs to be punishment all the way from the top to the bottom
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by gosub100 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:43PM (#50188105)
Why punish the leadership? they were just following their "fiduciary duty to shareholders" to maximize value.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by wavefunction on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:54PM (#50188198)
Punish everyone, you may be unjust but at least you'll be thorough.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by iririririr on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:47PM (#50188764)
that's how you build a case against the ring leader
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by shimman on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:21PM (#50189925)
"I was just following orders" has never been a valid excuse for anything, continue using it at your own peril.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:33PM (#50197668)
I never said engineers should be liable instead of the firms they work for. Both should be liable.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by vjvjvjvjghv on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:59PM (#50188252)
"Real" engineers aren't responsible for their product being used in nefarious ways as long as the product was built according to the rules.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Thursday October 22, 2026 @04:13PM (#50200377)
Yeah well lucky for all of us, the “rules” you speak of were defined by engineers, not the government. We call them codes. For example civil engineers follow codes defined by the ASCE
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:22PM (#50189931)
Perhaps so. That liability means doctors, engineers, lawyers, etc. need to push back because now their skin is truly in the game.

But a part of that process means introducing licensing to the field of software. Yet another hoop that this field has traditionally rejected. I don't think all SWE's "need" a license. But I do think that maybe it's long overdue to finally distinguish between a "programmer" and an "engineer" more formally.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Thursday October 22, 2026 @04:17PM (#50200411)
What hoops exist today? There are literally zero hoops for software engineers. Zero.

Anyone can create a startup or call themselves software engineers and release insecure, privacy-violating products with no repercussions.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by johnnyanmac on Thursday October 22, 2026 @04:41PM (#50200733)
Yes. I was mostly talking about social hoops to convince people to adopt such practices. There are basically zero hoops as it stands and it seems many in the field want to keep it that way.

I worry about that because at some point, legislation will catch up, and without subject matter experts any implementation will likely be flawed at first.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Friday October 23, 2026 @12:35PM (#50211664)
I got you, you’re right. implementing legislation around software would require appointing a board of experts to create the codes - like building codes. The board licenses the professional software engineers. They also receive complaints and discipline them. From there, legislation follows. The codes and rules of conduct provide the framework required for legislation. Legislation can’t exist in earnest without software professionals and codes.

There’s absolutely no reason why professionals at this pay grade and handling this much risk can’t be following this level of rigor.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by cush on Thursday October 22, 2026 @05:53PM (#50201582)
It’s funny reading the responses to my comment here. Most people assume

1. That professional engineers being liable somehow makes the firm they work for not liable. Both are liable.

2. The professional engineer isn’t responsible for breaches of code/contract their colleagues are committing. They are. In most jurisdictions a PE must disclose in writing and are liable for violations they witness.

It’s surprising how uninformed folks are about how rigorous engineering in the real world is.

If you think this is overkill or unrealistic you’re jaded. The privacy and security of the general public is on the line. If engineers and firms were liable for every data breach they’d cease to happen.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by derekdahmer on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:04PM (#50188312)
> This will keep happening until those at the top are held personally responsible for the crimes they sign off on.

Cambridge Analytica was a decade ago and there hasn’t been a similar Meta scandal since, so it seems like the deterrent has worked.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by iririririr on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:45PM (#50188756)
LOL. had a good laugh. thanks
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by giancarlostoro on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:29PM (#50189087)
Idk if Mark really is an android as they suggest, how do you jail a robot?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by dzonga on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:52PM (#50189238)
the chinese legal system somehow in its flaws is able to hold powerful company execs to account.

whereas here in the states - once you're a billionaire - jail or being held personally liable is a foreign concept.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by chilmers on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:37PM (#50189577)
Unless you're Sam Bankman-Fried, Bernie Madoff, Elizabeth Holmes, Allen Stanford, Raj Rajaratnam, Michael Milken...
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by seizethecheese on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:58PM (#50188239)
The judgement here was for violation of civil law, not criminal law. If New Mexico would have gone after the executives, the result would have been a much smaller fine, not jail. Or are you suggesting the executives should have been prosecuted for some criminal law violation? If so, what?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by theendisney on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:29PM (#50188574)
We imprison or fine to motivate others not to do the same. I doubt the current treatment is potent enough.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lenerdenator on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:13PM (#50188400)
The literal point of incorporation is that you as a shareholder or proprietor of a business are legally separated from the corporation in the eyes of the law.

We need reforms on corporate governance. Right now Meta is basically Mark Zuckerberg and a bunch of bag holders. They can't vote him out because he has both a board seat and majority voting power all on his own. Dumping the stock is far from a safe thing for institutional investors to do if they want to avoid lawsuits or regulatory attention.

It needs to be illegal for you to both be the CEO of a publicly-traded company and the voting majority shareholder. Note I say majority, not major plurality.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nradov on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:24PM (#50188508)
There is no law or regulation which requires institutional investors to hold Meta stock. Sometimes people who don't actually understand the law make spurious claims that those investors are legally required as fiduciaries to put their funds into the highest yielding investments. But in reality there is no such requirement, and investment managers have significant flexibility unless there's something more specific in their own organizational bylaws. They can underweight Meta stock if they believe it's overvalued due to potential legal risks or corporate governance problems or whatever.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lenerdenator on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:33PM (#50188620)
> Sometimes people who don't actually understand the law make spurious claims that those investors are legally required as fiduciaries to put their funds into the highest yielding investments. But in reality there is no such requirement

The requirement is what a lawyer can convince a dozen jurors the requirement should be. If there's a lawsuit against a fund manager at an institutional investor saying "you didn't fulfill your duty as a fiduciary because x", there's at least some risk that x becomes a real responsibility for fiduciaries through the outcome of that case. If the zeitgeist dictates that as a responsibility, it is a responsibility.

> They can underweight Meta stock if they believe it's overvalued due to potential legal risks or corporate governance problems or whatever.

The fact that they aren't doing so when the company is losing billions of dollars in legal judgments would suggest either

1) They can't do so because they would lose money doing so

or

2) Our system is in need of reform so that when executives direct a company in such a way that it is routinely facing legal exposure, shareholders remove those executives so that corporations act as better citizens and things are handled at the shareholder meeting level instead of the court system level.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nradov on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @06:47PM (#50188767)
And there it is, another ignorant HN user making an uninformed claim about legal issues they don't understand with no actual case law citations to back it up.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by lenerdenator on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:25PM (#50190415)
It's a jury system. If they manage to get a dozen people through voir dire that dislike the state of the social media market enough, they can, in theory, find Meta liable. Maybe they do, maybe they don't.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:23PM (#50190803)
Anyone who performs criminal actions while working at a corporation may be charged with criminal charges
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:45AM (#50191615)
I agree, every shareholder who owns Meta stock should be financially and criminally liable for these crimes! Especially your grandma, she could have invested that 401k in more ethical ways
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by MiroslavPokorny on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:49PM (#50188149)
Executives cant goto jail, they are already taking responsibilty.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by NuclearPM on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:53PM (#50188187)
I don’t understand your comment.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by vjvjvjvjghv on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @05:58PM (#50188235)
I assume it's the typical "accepting responsibility" of execs and politicians where nothing happens. Best case they throw some underling under the bus or have their institution pay a fine. But they themselves have no consequences
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by MiroslavPokorny on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:20PM (#50190773)
Im making fun of the double speak used by the media when they use the word responsibility following the company doing something wrong.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by tyrabound on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:56PM (#50189748)
As long as a corporation is a shield to commit crimes with impunity, nothing will change. We really need to reassess this perverse concept of a corporation where you can simply commit crimes against people, personally profit, yet never be personally held responsible, let alone accountable.

The same thing is causing problems in the financial markets right now, with massive zombie company portfolios of various private equity firms still paying out fees to the managers to siphon off the debt and assets of investors.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:17PM (#50190746)
Corporations shield shareholders from civil liability not operators from criminal charges. You seem to have no concept at all what a corporate shield is or the difference between criminal and civil law
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by omgwtfbyobbq on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:30PM (#50190851)
It's a problem with the law too, but corporations still effectively shield individuals from criminal prosecution for things individuals would be prosecuted for by breaking up accountability among many different people/groups of people.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:46PM (#50190952)
any organization of people does that lol
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by isolay on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:47AM (#50191625)
What planet do you live on?
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:53AM (#50192470)
Hey Eridanus2 you've got another violator to scold!
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Eridanus2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:47AM (#50191629)
You are correct. You are also in violation of HN guidelines pertaining to eschewing personal swipes.

The ground reality clearly demonstrates the asymmetry between a 'naked' operator and the one cocooned inside a corporation. The criminal law is identical for both in spirit, in practice; corporations often protect their executives by simply buying out the courtroom: bench, bar and gavel.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:49AM (#50192447)
You can cocoon yourself in any organization. Limited liability, the thing everyone seems to have a problem with, is very important to get investment into risky ventures, is important for technological progress, and is unrelated at all to criminal liability.

I didn't criticize anything except the ignorance of the statement.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Frieren on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:13AM (#50191783)
> not operators

You need a government willing to apply the law. Republicans are lawless criminals. They only put political rivals in prison whenever guilty or not.

The current reality is that laws do not apply to CEOs of big tech companies. It must be solved. They should be send to prison, and no pardons. When criminals are protected by the government all society suffers.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:50AM (#50192456)
The attacks were against limited liability for corporations, now you are changing the subject.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Frieren on Thursday October 22, 2026 @11:27AM (#50196729)
Limited liability for corporations does not protect CEOs. CEOs should go to prison as the law mandates. That's the subject, that's the point, to follow the law that already exists.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by nfw2 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:26PM (#50198409)
I agree with everything you said. People in thread are claiming corporation civil liability protection, a good thing that isn't related to this issue, is the problem, which is what I was objecting to.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by wnevets on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:50PM (#50190150)
> As long as a corporation is a shield to commit crimes with impunity, nothing will change.

AI simply makes it easier for corporations to commit crimes with impunity, now they can distance themselves from responsibility even further. No one has even bothered to levy fines for AI agents hacking or corporations violating copyright to train their models.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by attila-lendvai on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:54AM (#50192486)
why would they? they are on the same team.

the corporation legal framework is the very means of ruling. its entire point is to crack a covert fault line into the idea that everyone is equal in front of the law.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by tyrabound on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:12PM (#50198232)
That is not clearly to me in that way that, nor is corporations getting away with crimes some kind of new thing that AI will make easier, more, or somehow insulates or distances them.

I see a future where AI permits a massive leveling or resources that were required and allowed corporation to insulate and distance themselves in the past. We are in a situation where individual people can do immense amount of work with a few agents. You may say "well, so can all the individuals in corporations", but I could see how corporations were operating not only close to a limit, but the very immense resource constraints of getting access to, parsing, and margin sense of data/information was extremely difficult in the not at all recent past. Just 4 years ago it was still immensely difficult finding the right data/information, let alone parsing it, properly displaying and relating it, analyzing it, and daring conclusions and knowledge from it.

There are some people who are already using AI to investigate people, organizations, networks, and things that relied on that secrecy by obscurity and hiding behind the massive resource constraints.

Just an example, remember the Panama papers and how it took many journalists many months to individually parse and relate all the information; and I am sure they totally missed things their human minds simply could not fully relate or patterns they could not identify. AI can do all that in seconds as you know and with the right conditions, you can even have it highlight things that you didn't know. Frankly, I was not a fan of the gatekeeping of the various releases of that kind of data, including things like the Snowden releases, because I guarantee it was also a partial limitation operation by intel agencies, but if that information and data were released publicly, unreacted, AI could definitely have helped people highlight and identify things that are probably still hidden and were simply overlooked by the hand full of journalists and the data analysis people they hired to make sense of things.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by Jackie360 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:22PM (#50189929)
Just takes one line to change a civil law into a criminal one, “and shall serve a term of imprisonment of not less than . . .”
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by verdverm on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:11PM (#50190321)
Pardons are a cool million away, maybe a bit more if you are Zuck, because the big guy is not going to let in opportunity to extract more pass him by
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by eddieroger on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:30PM (#50190454)
Fines are just permits for companies that can afford it.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by prokopton on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:34PM (#50190479)
I want a new season of Oz starring Zuck.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by fugalfervor on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:40PM (#50190515)
If they get more decisions like this and they're overextended with AI investment, they'll be pretty fucked. Of course, the cockroaches will scuttle away without penalty.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by jorisboris on Thursday October 22, 2026 @01:49AM (#50191637)
There’s an interesting case around this with the Taranto steel plant. This plant was heavily polluted. Italy has criminal liability for executives for ecological violations. The owners went to jail and the government asked Arcelor-Mittal to come in and clean the mess. Arcelor-Mittal received a shield from the government for the criminal liability. The next populist government withdrew the shield. Arcelor pulled out. Now the government is managing a steel plant while looking for a buyer.

Broadening criminal liability for executives might sound like a good idea but there are a lot of second order effects

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by wasfgwp on Thursday October 22, 2026 @02:07AM (#50191745)
25 billion is huge, though. If the market believed that Meta would ever have to pay the full fine (unfortunately highly unlikely) its stock would be doing a lot worse.
Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by penguin_booze on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:15AM (#50192213)
They're busy taking risks and breaking things. They can't waste their valuable time in jails and stuff like that, sir.

Jails are for losers -- not Peter Thiel.

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by mordae on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:37AM (#50192373)
Or such companies could be dissolved for breaching law in a sufficiently big way. And I mean dissolved. Not sold. Not split. All its accounts are frozen, all its physical assets are sold in an auction. Proceedings going to pay everyone in the company 3 months worth of their wage capped at 3x median wage of the country as they are fired, rest goes to state. All imaginary property enters public domain immediately. Patents are cancelled. Done.

"But it would be tremendous loss if we cancelled [bigco]!"

Well, maybe, let that be a lesson the all other such companies and their owners I guess?

Re:Meta ordered to pay $25B penalty in New Mexico Cambridge ... by elric on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:57AM (#50192497)
At least in Volkswagen's "dieselgate", executives got prison sentences. No clue whether they ever served them, but still.