News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:27PM (#47509620)
This might sound like snark, but I truly don’t mean it that way.

I think what’s interesting about AI, and why there’s so much conversation, is that in order to be a good user of AI, you have to really understand software development. All the people I work with who are getting the most value out of using AI to deliver software are people who are already very high-skilled engineers, and the more years of real experience they have, the better.

I know some guys who were road warriors for many years —- everything from racking and cabling servers, setting up infrastructure, and getting huge cloud deployments going all the way to embedded software, video game backends, etc. These guys were already really good at automation, seeing the whole life cycle of software, and understanding all the pressure points. For them, AI is the ultimate power tool. They’re just flying with it right now. (All of them also are aware that the AI vampire is very real.)

There’s still a lot to learn, and the tools are still very, very early on, but the value is clear.

I think for quite a few people, engaging with AI is maybe the first time ever in their entire career they are having to engage with systems thinking in a very concrete and directed way. Consequently, this is why so many software engineers are having an identity crisis: they’ve spent most of their career focusing on one very small section of the overall SDLC, meanwhile believing that was mostly all there was that they needed to know.

So I think we’re going to keep talking for quite a while, and the conversation will continue to be very unevenly distributed. Paradoxically, I’m not bored of it, because I’m learning so much listening to intelligent people share their learnings.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by jakelsaunders94 on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:48PM (#47509911)
Hey, I don't think this sounded like snark at all. Super grounded take.

> I think what’s interesting about AI, and why there’s so much conversation, is that in order to be a good user of AI, you have to really understand software development.

This I agree with completely. You can see it in the difference between a prompt where you know exactly what you want and when things are a little woolley. A tool in the hands of a well trained craftsperson is always better used.

> So I think we’re going to keep talking for quite a while Me neither, and to be clear I'm okay with that. This was mostly a rant at the lack of diversity of discourse.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:01PM (#47510078)
Thanks friend! Appreciate it.

Agree, the diversity of the discourse is not great. There's a lot of "omg I just got started waaauw" articles out there along with "we're all gonna die!" stuff. And then a few seams of very excellent insight.

Deep research at least helps with dowsing for the knowledge...

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by artur_makly on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:18PM (#47510287)
your HN handle is one of my top 10 fav tracks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2RSniyYNSc

{heart}

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by mindcrime on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @08:41PM (#47511672)
And here I was expecting this...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6Rl8TpGIP4

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by RyanOD on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @10:45PM (#47512589)
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @01:24PM (#47520427)
You're all wrong, it's this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ln2SDExGDCM

;)

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by RyanOD on Thursday March 26, 2026 @06:24PM (#47536588)
Terrible and hilarious.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by bengale on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:30PM (#47509665)
Spot on take. The people I’ve noticed that say things like “it’s not useful” are the ones who are doing so little they can’t see the value.

This isn’t to say there’s not hype. Just that if you’re not seeing big productivity gains you need to make sure you really are an outlier and not just surplus to requirements.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by imiric on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:08PM (#47510862)
I rarely come across people who flat out say "it's not useful". They exist, but IME they're the minority.

Rather, I hear a lot of nuanced opinions of how the tech is useful in some scenarios, but that the net benefit is not clear. I.e. the tech has many drawbacks that make it require a lot of effort to extract actual value from. This is an opinion I personally share.

In most cases, those "big productivity gains" are vastly blown out of proportion. In the context of software development specifically, sure, you can now generate thousands of lines of code in an instant, but writing code was never the bottleneck. It was always the effort to carefully design and implement correct solutions to real-world problems. These new tools can approximate this to an extent, when given relevant context and expert guidance, but the output is always unreliable, and very difficult to verify.

So anyone who claims "big productivity gains" is likely not bothering to verify the output, which in most cases will eventually come back to haunt them and/or anyone who depends on their work. And this should concern everyone.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by SpaceNoodled on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:14PM (#47510916)
That's only because we're trying to not be too condescending.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by hparadiz on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:27PM (#47512005)
"productivity" is a misnomer. Sort of. The things I'm building are all things I've had on the back burner for years. Most of which I never would have bothered to do. But AI lets me ignore that excuse and just do it.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by ok_dad on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @10:28PM (#47512456)
The productivity comes from not having the startup costs. You don’t need to research the best way to do X, just verify that X works via tests and documentation. I find it still takes T hours to actually implement X with an agent, but if I didn’t know how to do X it eliminates that startup cost which might make it take 3T hours instead.

The only downside is not learning about method Y or Z that work differently than X but would also be sufficient, and you don’t learn the nuances and details of the problem space for X, Y, and Z.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by abustamam on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @10:32PM (#47512485)
I find it useful to use a brainstorming skill to teach me X Y Z and help me understand the tradeoffs for each, and what it'd recommend.

I've learned about outbox pattern, eventual consistency, CAP theorem, etc. It's been fun. But if I didn't ask the LLM to help me understand it would have just went with option A without me understanding why.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by ok_dad on Thursday March 26, 2026 @10:18PM (#47538428)
In my instance, I’m talking more about using library X or library Y, not the difference between using an atomic versus a mutex. I want to learn the latter, but the former isn’t something I care about.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by abustamam on Thursday March 26, 2026 @11:02PM (#47538666)
Ah, that's fair. I personally don't normally care about library usage as long as it's fairly well documented and effective (like Shadcn vs raw tailwind components vs chakra... I don't really care).
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by ok_dad on Friday March 27, 2026 @02:20AM (#47539583)
Yea I just use LLM agents as tools, I don’t kick whole features to them or have a cloud agent running all the time. I rarely use more than $100 in usage monthly, usually less than half that. I use tab completion a lot in Cursor and use agents to make mechanical changes or integrate features I don’t care about learning, like integrating several libraries together into my application. I also use it to write things I’ve already got examples for, like database APIs.

Software engineers who haven’t tried these tools don’t understand what they are, and vibe coders who never understood software are taking the mindshare in public because it sounds revolutionary to some and apocalyptic to others. You have to stop listening to the claw bros and try using these as tools yourself in small ways to see what it’s really about, IMO.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by abustamam on Saturday March 28, 2026 @01:48AM (#47551995)
Agreed; as in most things, moderation is key. It is a new tool that is here whether we like it or not. May as well learn to coexist with it, but also not defer all our thinking to the tool.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by imiric on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @03:56AM (#47514542)
> You don’t need to research the best way to do X, just verify that X works via tests and documentation.

"Just verify" is glossing over a lot of difficult work, though. It doesn't just require checking whether the program compiles and does what you wanted—that's the easy part. Having the tool also generate tests and documentation is something you should manually verify as well. And at each step of this process there will likely always be something you missed, which considering you're not experienced in X, Y, or Z, you have no experience to properly judge.

You can ignore all of this, of course, which majority of people do, but then don't be surprised when it blows up in your face eventually.

And verification is actually relatively simple for programming languages and software. In many other fields and industries verification is very impractical and resource intensive. It doesn't take a genius to deduce the consequences of all of this. Hence, the net effect of these tools is arguably not positive.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by Andrei_dev on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @01:41PM (#47520692)
Exactly. "Tests pass" and "code is secure" are just different things. AI code makes that gap worse.

I run static analysis on mixed human/AI codebases. The AI parts pass tests fine but they'll have stuff any SAST tool flags on first run — hardcoded creds, wildcard CORS, string-built SQL. Works in a demo, turns into a CVE in prod.

And nobody's review capacity scaled with generation speed. Most teams don't even have semgrep in CI. So you get unreviewed code just sitting in production.

The "10x" is real if you count lines shipped. Nobody counts the fix cost downstream though.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by lenkite on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @05:52AM (#47515281)
> just verify that X works via tests and documentation.

No, its verify that X approach is semantically correct, architecturally makes sense, design is valid and then add tests and documentation. Basically, 80% of the work.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by ok_dad on Thursday March 26, 2026 @10:49PM (#47538601)
Most features I do are not that complex. For the complex ones I’m already feeding designs to the agent via interfaces and specific instructions.

I think people here are thinking I’m building Gmail from scratch when I’m talking about adding additional database APIs and models in the style of stuff I’ve already done twenty times in the same application. That’s easy for even the dumbest LLM and verification is not more than a code review, maybe an hour or two of labor. It’s never perfect, but as stated elsewhere I know how to program this stuff already so I can just fix it on the spot before I commit it.

I understand though, some of you either can’t use agents to code because of one reason or another, or refuse to; both are valid. I’m saying that for my job programming in a specific industry for a specific application in a specific language that AI agents actually help me out more than hinder me, and I still ship quality code in the style that matches the code base.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by abustamam on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @10:30PM (#47512473)
Really? On HN I see so many people AI naysayers who say either it's not useful or it's a net negative on productivity. Perhaps they are a minority, but they're certainly a vocal one.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by kaiokendev on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:53AM (#47513433)
> writing code was never the bottleneck

This is overly dismissive, there are many things that are possible now that weren't before because writing the code is no longer the bottleneck, like porting parts of the codebase from managed to unmanaged for teams with limited capacity. Writing code is about 1/3rd of the job. Another 1/3rd is analysis, which also benefits from AI allowing people who aren't very good at it to outperform. The final 1/3rd is-

> the effort to carefully design and implement correct solutions to real-world problems.

That's problem-solving - that part doesn't get sped up, and likely never will, reliably.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by dvfjsdhgfv on Thursday March 26, 2026 @04:29PM (#47535309)
I'm doing a lot, I see a lot of improvement, I see a lot of uses, but still consider the current generation of agentic coding simply not working for something more than a toy project - no matter how much skills, harnesses and what not you include. Happy to be proven otherwise, but Anhtropic's CCC is a good case in point.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by amelius on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:33PM (#47509697)
This is really not true. There are stories of people who had no background in software engineering who now write entire applications using AI. And I have personally seen this happen.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by strken on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @08:14PM (#47511473)
Before AI, there were also stories of people who had no background in software engineering who wrote entire applications using their fingers. This was called "learning to be a software engineer".

I don't mean to snipe at AI, because it really does seem to have set more people on the path of learning, but I was writing VB5 apps when I was 14 by copying poorly understood bits and pieces from books. Now people are doing basically the same but with less typing and everyone thinks it's a revolution.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by anon-3988 on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @11:36PM (#47512955)
I have never seen people learn how to be a software engineer in a weekend tho.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by pamcake on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @01:29AM (#47513643)
And neither do you today.

There is more to it than "being able to make an entire application", which a novice could also have pulled off in a weekend 10 years ago.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by munksbeer on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @02:51PM (#47521580)
Learning to code and write an application was very hard for most people, because of time and other friction. I know of non-coders who now have applications running for various things they find useful.

You might not consider this productive, but they do, so what you think literally doesn't matter to them.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by mikkupikku on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:43PM (#47509851)
Smart people can hit the ground running if they're freed from the need to first learn the intricacies of a new language. We're going to see an explosion in the number of people writing software as clever people who invested their time in something other than learning to program are now able to write software for themselves.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by switchbak on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:00PM (#47510069)
What is not true, that "so many software engineers are having an identity crisis"?

I don't believe they said that folks new to AI can't make impressive use of it. They did however say that senior folks with lots of scrappy and holistic knowledge can do amazing things with it. Both can be true.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by pojzon on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:40PM (#47509806)
Its silly to say this but one such person is „pewdiepie”
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by leptons on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @08:46PM (#47511720)
I've seen people generate a lot of vibeslop with AI, but they didn't actually "Write entire applications using AI".

They still have absolutely no clue how it works, so how could they "write entire applications"? They vibed it, but they certainly didn't write any of it, not one bit of it, and they're clueless as to how to extend it, upgrade it, and maintain it so that the AI doesn't make it a bloated monstrosity of AI patches and fixes and workarounds that they simply could never begin to understand.

They were also following a dozen youtube tutorials step by step, so even that part was someone else doing the thinking.

Yeah, these are the same guys constantly bugging me to help them figure something out.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by timacles on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:36PM (#47519702)
Yeah no way are people developing actual applications. They’re developing one off apps, tools and websites. The amount of robustness a usable application with actual purpose requires is exactly where LLMs fall apart.

I’m not a naysayer by any means and at this point use Llms all day for many purpose. But it is undeniable that the exact moment complexity reaches a certain threshold, LLMs need more and more guidance and specific implementation details to make worthwhile improvements. This same complexity threshold is where real world functionality lives.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by abustamam on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @10:37PM (#47512530)
This may be true, but define an entire application. Is it a CRUD app? Is it an app that scales to a thousand, ten thousand, a million users? Is it an app that is bug free and if not bug free, easy to fix said bugs with few to no regressions? Is it an app that is easy to maintain and add new features to without risk of breaking other stuff?

I think it is genuinely impressive to be able to build one app with AI. But I haven't seen evidence that someone could build a maintanable, scalable app with ai. In fact, anecdotally, a friend of mine who runs an agency had a client who vibe coded their app, figured out that they couldn't maintain it, and had him rewrite the app in a way that could be maintained long term.

Again, I'm not an Ai detractor. I use it every day at work. But I've needed to harden my app and rules and such, such that the AI cannot make mistakes when I or another engineer is vibing a new feature. It's a work in progress.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by sigbottle on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:00PM (#47510067)
The "AI Vampire", huh. Unironically, I've been feeling that way.

Well, there was also a lot of unrelated things that happened as well around last November for me, but yes, getting into vibecoding for real was one of them, and man I feel physically drained coming back from work and going to use more AI.

Not sure what it is. I'm using AI personally to learn and bootstrap a lot of domain knowledge I never would have learned otherwise (even got into philosophy!, but man is it exhausting keeping up with AI. I would burn through a week's worth of credits in a day, and now I haven't vibe coded a week.

I think, I will chill. One day at a time.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:03PM (#47510108)
AI Vampire is from Steve Yegge, credit where it's due.

My take is that it's similar to what Amber Case described in Calm Technology - with AI you are not steering one car, you're really steering three cars at the same time. The human mind isn't really designed for that.

I am finding that really structuring my time helps in terms of fighting back. And adopting an hours restriction, even if I could rage for 4 more hours, I don't. Instead I stop and go outside.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by username135 on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:47PM (#47511230)
AI Vampire is so perfect. Ive never thought of it that way but its right there.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by d675 on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:39PM (#47509787)
absolutely. as a early/mid level SDET/SRE, I can move so fast on prototyping full good apps now. That style of thinking is serving me well, knowing about queues, docker, basic infra knowledge, good coding practices, is plenty to produce decent code. Interesting time to be laid off.

AI makes a ton of bad decisions too and it's up to you to work with it. If I had the knowledge of the dangers hidden in things I'm developing, I'd move even faster

Was able to make a great full web app, which I think is hardened for prod but it had to be refactored to do so. Which it happily did.

It's really about asking the right questions, breaking down tasks, and planning now. I'm going to tackle a huge project, hoping to share it here.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by QuantumGood on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:53PM (#47509974)
> I’m learning so much listening to intelligent people share their learnings.

Me too. A key purpose of HN, and a bright time for that.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by deadbabe on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:41PM (#47511171)
If you have to really understand software development to be a good user of AI, we’re screwed. All the best users of AI we’ll ever have already exist I think.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by throwawaytea on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:00PM (#47511827)
That's a good point. Im a novice self taught developer that somehow pushed through and made a decent PM tool for the construction industry. It works, if your users aren't malicious or too demanding.

Now I'm working on a second project, all with AI. I haven't written a single line. It works better than a non programmer would make because I knew what to ask for. But I'll admit I'm not learning anything.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by hparadiz on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:48PM (#47512182)
Can't say the same. I've been super hands on with a C project. Really getting into the details of the event bus and how to make things performant. The AI is still writing 99% of the code but I'm being super strict about what I consider acceptable.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by deadbabe on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @07:05AM (#47515760)
And when you get memory leaks and don’t know how to debug?
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by hparadiz on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @11:12AM (#47518439)
Lol what a silly assumption
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by deadbabe on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:03PM (#47519250)
Fuck, another C developer who will just let memory leaks grow uncontrollably is born.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by hparadiz on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:34PM (#47519674)
You might wanna learn how to set up constraints for your agents. Every memory map is accounted for with docs pointing to the exact structs, allocations, and usage patterns. It's stuff I was already doing. Now I can do it in a fraction of the time.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by deadbabe on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @02:34PM (#47521363)
So you have absolutely NO doubt
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by hparadiz on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @03:16PM (#47521903)
Doubts? I'm full of them. I'm building a new task manager for myself that has things I've always wanted. It's basically a profiler so it must be performant.

https://github.com/hparadiz/evemon

The core if you disable all the plugins is currently topped out at 73.8 MB after several days of running it. I've given it several audits with the AI agents using actual memory maps and doing the math on each variable.

I haven't had time to do Milkdrop yet but it's on my todo. The issue isn't doing the work. The issue is not having enough credits in my accounts to throw some compute at it. I'll get to it eventually. But it's actually way easier now to try new ways of packing the data into binary and profiling it for issues.

The issues I've had are edge cases like a 6 hour youtube stream. At one point the BPM detector was buffering the entire track in the pipewire sink. It took one throwaway prompt to the AI to solve that one.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by gAI on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:45PM (#47509878)
Agreed, though I prefer "Fae Folk" to vampires.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by Terr_ on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:43PM (#47511186)
If LLMs were vampires, they'd be better at counting, if they were fae, they'd be better at legalistic logic. :p
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by djeastm on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:00PM (#47510062)
Any thoughts on what the next generation of software devs is going to look like without as much manual experience?
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by eloisant on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:21PM (#47510317)
When C arrived, programmers wonder how software devs would look like when they won't have assembly experience.

Then the same happened with languages that managed memory.

And with IDE that could refactor your code in a click and autocomplete API calls.

And with Stack Overflow where people copy/pasted code they didn't understand.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by bGl2YW5j on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:37PM (#47511143)
I reckon there's a limit to how long this abstraction can go on before not understanding underlying mechanisms will seriously hamstring you.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by wild_egg on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:02AM (#47513091)
I think we're a long ways from that.

But with that said, those who learn the underlying mechanisms will always be able to solve more problems than the folks who don't. When you know the lower pieces, your mental model tells you when and where the higher level pieces are likely to break. Legit superpower.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by bluefirebrand on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:33AM (#47513279)
> But with that said, those who learn the underlying mechanisms will always be able to solve more problems than the folks who don't

I would define that as being "seriously hamstrung"

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by sellmesoap on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @04:07AM (#47514613)
Well how many times have we seen the S3 bucket set to public while the customer data piles up and leaks out to space.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by calvinmorrison on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:55PM (#47510730)
And over and over time proves that, when you need it, ASM or C or generals system knowledge was handy. One example, I am not a "Windows" or "NT" guy, mostly working in various Unixes and Linux in my professional career. I had a client who had battered every resource trying to fix some horrible freeze/timeout in their application. So I rolled up my sleeves, first search " is there dtrace on windows", found some profiling tools, found the process was stuck in some dumb blocking call loop, resource was unavailable, and the rest was history.

So yeah i mean - who cares how it works - but also if you have experience in how things _do_ work you can solve problems other people cannot.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by eloisant on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @11:26AM (#47518659)
Sure, "it's handy" and once every few years you encounter a bug where ASM or C knowledge is valuable.

Yet most programmers nowadays can't write ASM or C and still manage to produce useful software.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:14PM (#47511920)
It started before that. When assemblers came out, (some) programmers worried about losing touch with the machine if they didn't have to know the instructions in octal.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:08PM (#47510169)
Honestly, I think it will look pretty much like this one. There’s a lot of manual experience that the current generation doesn’t have.

For example, I haven’t racked and cabled a server in over 15 years. That used to be a valuable skill.

I also used to know how to operate Cisco switches and routers (on the original IOS!). I haven't thought about CIDR and the difference between a /24 and a /30 since the year 2008. A class IP addresses, how do those work? What subnet am I on? Is thing running on a different VLAN? Irrelevant to me these days. Some people still know it! But not as many as in the past.

The late Dr. Richard Hamming observed that once a upon a time, "a good man knew how to implement square root in machine code." If you didn't know how to do that, you weren't legit. These days nobody would make such a claim.

So some skills fade and others rise. And also, software has moved in predictable cycles for many decades at this point. We are still a very young field but we do have some history at this point.

So things will remain the same the more they change on that front.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by calvinmorrison on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:58PM (#47510759)
> So some skills fade and others rise. And also, software has moved in predictable cycles for many decades at this point. We are still a very young field but we do have some history at this point.

And there'll be a split too... like there's a giant divide between those mechanics who used to work on carburetors and the new gen with microcontrollers, injection systems, etc. People who think cars are 'too complicated' aren't wrong, but for someone who grew up in the injected era, i vastly prefer debugging issues over the canbus rather than snaking my ass around a hot exhaust to check something.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by SpecialistK on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @10:12PM (#47512339)
And to take the analogy even further, I'm sure there will be a subset of people who develop really strong opinions about a particular toolchain or workflow. Like how we have people who specialize in 70s diesel trucks or 90-00s JDM sports cars, there'll likely be programmers who are SMEs at updating COBAL to Rust using Claude.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by calvinmorrison on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @03:27PM (#47522022)
yup. I do early bosch EFI and K-Jet... thats what I know!
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by a1o on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:59PM (#47512251)
I am pretty sure network knowledge and all those things are still necessary for people running data centers and really big computers and I imagine we will build a lot more of that.

Also anyone making a homelab has to know these stuff.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by keybored on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:27PM (#47510405)
A post supposedly about being bored of talking about AI. But psyche, it’s the same AI talking points. And psyche, the top comment is the same sentiment about how the truly skilled will finally have their time to shine.

I don’t know if it’s the Universe delivering this farce or it’s the emergent LLM Singularity.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:32PM (#47510463)
> how the truly skilled will finally have their time to shine.

That's not what I said. I said that those who are already shining, are now shining even brighter. Give a great craftsman a new tool and he will find a way to apply it. If it is valueless, he will throw it away.

For what it's worth, your comment is also an HN trope, the disaffected low-effort armchair keyboard warrior.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by keybored on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:37PM (#47510504)
Expressing a negative sentiment is a trope now?
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by Rapzid on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:58PM (#47510753)
Keybored is a trending vibe, yeah.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by keybored on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @07:55AM (#47516143)
Is anyone else bored of talking about posting with that keybored vibe? Hey, don’t get me wrong!—I’m not some heretic. I love the keybored posting vibe. Lots of sarcasm, complaining about American geopolitical decisions, recommending socialism on some venture capitalist/hacker forum, absolutely no hint of any Show HN bragging rights or any technical accomplishments whatsover, just lots of complaining in general (but I repeat myself). It’s fantastic and I could not go back to posting any other way. But why are talking about it so much? Why not just live it, live that beautiful vibe, and let it permeate our whole Internet persona—in fact just let it become water around us, like we are fish, something vital to our existence and wholly unquestioned until the dam breaks somewhere.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @01:17PM (#47520327)
u mad bro?
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by keybored on Thursday March 26, 2026 @03:12AM (#47527482)
Ask an LLM if that was a joke.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by Rapzid on Monday March 30, 2026 @05:23AM (#47572183)
I read it as satire.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by ludicrousdispla on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @03:00AM (#47514182)
it's essentially the same argument Agile consultants made when faced with criticism about Agile, ... "you're not using it right"
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by cyanydeez on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:46PM (#47509892)
Isn't that scary though: A bunch of people are going to be forced to use a tool that keeps them ignorant and they absolutely won't know if it's doing correct things, to the point that as you retire, the next crop is going to be much less involved in knowing whats going on.

It's what happened with the internet and computer usage. As Apple made it easier to get online with zero computer knowledge, suddenly we're electing people like donald trump.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by scorpioxy on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:38PM (#47510520)
To me, it is very scary. I know people who have sort of "outsourced" their critical thinking to chatgpt. So to me it's extra scary when I see it outside technical circles. They'll just believe whatever that generation of LLM tells them because it is doing it so confidentially and never question or check the information. Maybe I'm naive but I thought easier access to knowledge was supposed to make us more intelligent, not less.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by heavyset_go on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:00PM (#47510779)
> Maybe I'm naive but I thought easier access to knowledge was supposed to make us more intelligent, not less.

Turns out Lowtax was right and ahead of his time

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by vparseval on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:45PM (#47512146)
I don't remember exactly in which book's introduction Hannah Arendt mentioned this, but she pointed out that every time humanity learned a new skill that improved its efficiency in some capacity, that skill as well as adjacent skills diminished irrevocably.

AI is the thing that for the first time can think better than us (or so at least some people believe) and is seen as an efficiency booster in the world of cognition and ideas. I'd think Hannah Arendt would be worried with what we are currently seeing and where we might be headed.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:00PM (#47510061)
Serious reply to this one: I truly don’t find it any more scary than what’s already taken place many times in human history.

We have hundreds and thousands of years of history showing humans committing atrocities against each other well before the advent of computers, or even the introduction of electricity. So while the tool may become so ubiquitous that there’s no option not to engage with it, I don’t think it really fundamentally alters the dynamics of human behavior.

Some people are motivated by greed. Others are motivated by nobility. It really just comes down to which wolf they're feeding.

In terms of the tool keeping people ignorant, there’s a part I agree with and a part that I don’t. I think, in terms of information dissemination, AI is probably the autocrat’s wet dream in terms of finally being able to achieve real-time redefinition of reality. That’s pretty scary, and I’m not sure what to do about it.

On the other hand, people have always been free to not really learn their craft and to just sort of get by and make a living. That was true a thousand years ago, and it’s true today. There’s always somebody who can do really a high-quality job, but they’re very expensive, and then there's a vast population who will do a medium to terrible job for less money. You get what you pay for. There's a reason history is primarily written about people with power and wealth, they were the only ones with the means to do anything.

I don’t agree with the assertion about the internet and the election of someone like Donald Trump. Well before the internet existed, politicians were using communication mediums to influence things and get elected—whether it was the telegraph, the telephone, or the TV. JFK famously was the first TV president (notably, he didn't wear a hat).

These technologies simply give politicians more reach, and they may change the dynamics of how voters are persuaded. But what’s true today was true three hundred years ago: there’s the face of power that you see publicly, and then there’s what really happens behind the scenes.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by bluefirebrand on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:21PM (#47510316)
> Serious reply to this one: I truly don’t find it any more scary than what’s already taken place many times in human history

Spoken like someone who thinks they are going to be insulated from the fallout

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by solenoid0937 on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:29PM (#47510426)
Many of us are fine with the fallout because we understand the net benefit to humanity is going to be similar to the previous waves of automation.

Sure, it might hurt me personally. I'm not selfish enough to put that over what will be an incredibly empowering development for our species.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by bluefirebrand on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @08:21PM (#47511528)
I don't believe for even a second that the net benefit to humanity is going to be positive

This will be good for a handful of elites and no one else

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by heliumtera on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:34PM (#47510478)
>They’re just flying with it right now.

Where are they flying and why software has gone to shit?

Maybe this super stars programmers have to keep their reality breaking technology secret, but everything has not only degraded, but turned to absolute trash.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by LogicFailsMe on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:55PM (#47510002)
Spot on, I am having the time of my life with AI, more fun than I've had in decades. But I was in the top 10% of engineering, and top 1% of the bits of engineering I do best, so it's easy for me to use AI to explore more ideas than I could have possibly explored by hand. And if I get replaced, cool bro, my investments are in compute, and compute's just getting started IMO.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by LogicFailsMe on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:20PM (#47519461)
Wow, replying to myself here, but also, wow, yes I'm pretty good at something pretty in demand right now. And that didn't happen by chance, and because I was a decade early on that skill, I got all the arrows in my back along with the headstart. We are all created equal, sure, but if I put 100,000+ hours into something that most barely get past 10,000, if I don't end up world class at it, then what was I even doing? I know, I know, hubris, right? Also, didn't have kids so I had the time.

But that said, this will be the 3rd major industry transition of my career. And having survived the past two, you will adapt, or you won't have a job. And that's why, once again, you will ultimately adapt, kicking and screaming if that's what it takes, so why not start early?

AI coding agents are useful already, but they make too many mistakes and they need handholding from expert engineering talent in 2026. Ask me again in 2027. But that's why the best results are coming from the talent right now with the experience to ask the right questions and propose the right tests and fixes as the human in the loop. Otherwise, it's still hallucinatory vibe coding in a loop IMO.

The surprise and disappointment, well not the surprise, is the usual hatred of success that defines humanity. Whatever, downvotes, right?

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by hbarka on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:52PM (#47510683)
> For them, AI is the ultimate power tool.

Yup

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by SpaceNoodled on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:16PM (#47510952)
When all you've got AI, every problem looks like ... Uh, whatever hole an LLM's output goes into. A garbage can, ideally.

AI seems great when you have no way of truly validating its output.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by llmthrow0827 on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @08:56PM (#47511792)
This would be a more compelling argument if the conversations weren't so extremely dull and derivative, with most of the articles written in LLMspeak. I see a lot of discussion and not a lot of substance; articles and discussions about AI have a much smaller chance of being compelling compared to any other technical subject posted on HN.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by piva00 on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @06:34AM (#47515538)
The signal-to-noise ratio seems worse than many other hypes but it's the general way hypes go.

It's really hard to separate the wheat from the chaff at this point but I've been positively surprised by the relatively few articles sharing their more advanced workflow, lessons learnt which helps me to avoid the traps, patterns emerging that taught me something new (or at least validated approaches I tried on my own which worked). Gets tiresome to keep pace so I try to not fall for FOMO, and avoid experimenting too much to not get lost until I see a pattern emerging from different sources.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by strangattractor on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:06PM (#47511869)
Agreed - another tool in the old tool pouch. I find it fascinating in that it provides insight into the role of language in intelligence. Certainly not AGI but makes ELIZA seem neolithic;)

I am amazed at the incredible things it can do - only to turnaround and not be able to do a simple task a child can do. Just like people.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by _doctor_love on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @01:20PM (#47520359)
Your handle caught my attention - yes - and for folks studying non-linear and dynamical systems, fascinating how much of prompting is sensitive dependence to initial conditions.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by systemsweird on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:31PM (#47512033)
Completely agree. It’s very telling that the majority of write ups on effect agentic coding are essentially summaries of software engineering best practices.
[dead]
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by dogleash on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:00PM (#47519192)
>The identity crisis observation is the most accurate thing

It's also a nasty tool used to be dismissive of criticism by tearing people down.

Made even nastier by the way the character assassination can be done in such work-friendly language.

It's not a revelation to say profession has turds that shouldn't have jobs. Mostly working for bosses that need warm bodies and/or are themselves turds unable to really evaluate their performance. We been knowing this. It became impossible to ignore in the circa 2010 push to expand the hiring pool and lots of people that didn't even pretend to care about tech showed up.

It's just super convenient that we're suddenly calling them out when there's a need to dismiss informed criticism of AI.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by abustamam on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @10:28PM (#47512460)
This! I've actually learned a lot about what I don't know by using AI. It made me dig into learning proper systems design, app architecture, etc.

But at the same time the more I read about AI, the more I realize I need to learn about AI. Thus far I'm just using cursor and the Claude code extension alongside obra superpowers, and I've been quite happy with it. But on Twitter I see people with multiple instances of Claude code or open claw talking to each other and I don't even know how to begin to understand what's going on there. But I'm not letting myself get distracted — Claude code and open claw are tools. They could go away at any time. But systems thinking is something that won't go away. At least, that's my gambit.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by jimbokun on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @11:25PM (#47512874)
It’s telling those people mostly talk about the complexity of the AI setup they’ve engineered to write code. Much more so than bragging about the software created by that process.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by abustamam on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:56AM (#47513455)
That's a good point, but I've seen a lot of interesting meta-setups as well (like visualizations of agents interacting with one another).

Does it write good code? I dunno. But it looks cool, and I think interesting in its own right, even if it ends up being functionally useless.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by pjmlp on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @04:38AM (#47514801)
I am having an identity crisis that thankfully is sorted out by being senior and close to retirement than early career days.

Since COVID I have seen teams scaled down, lots of custom development or devops/infra work work got replaced with SaaS and iPaaS cloud products, serverless/lambda, managed containers.

This is the next step.

Great that people feel more productive, unfortunely for many of them, us, more productivity means the C-suites can do some head count reduction yet again.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by randusername on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @10:11AM (#47517604)
> Consequently, this is why so many software engineers are having an identity crisis: they’ve spent most of their career focusing on one very small section of the overall SDLC, meanwhile believing that was mostly all there was that they needed to know.

Specialists/generalists, top-down/bottom-up, BFS/DFS, pragmatists/idealists, ADHD/ASD; lots of continuums in software work and those at either extreme have biases.

Personally I think that there will be less programmers needed and the ones that will remain will have had to mellow out towards the center in all these continuums. We won't be able to rely on big teams balancing each other out.

Generalists will need to learn which details matter. Specialists will need to learn the delegation and risk tolerance usually reserved for the bemoaned management track. Hard to say which is the easier journey.