News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by imiric on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @03:56AM (#47514542)
> You don’t need to research the best way to do X, just verify that X works via tests and documentation.

"Just verify" is glossing over a lot of difficult work, though. It doesn't just require checking whether the program compiles and does what you wanted—that's the easy part. Having the tool also generate tests and documentation is something you should manually verify as well. And at each step of this process there will likely always be something you missed, which considering you're not experienced in X, Y, or Z, you have no experience to properly judge.

You can ignore all of this, of course, which majority of people do, but then don't be surprised when it blows up in your face eventually.

And verification is actually relatively simple for programming languages and software. In many other fields and industries verification is very impractical and resource intensive. It doesn't take a genius to deduce the consequences of all of this. Hence, the net effect of these tools is arguably not positive.

Re:Is anybody else bored of talking about AI? by Andrei_dev on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @01:41PM (#47520692)
Exactly. "Tests pass" and "code is secure" are just different things. AI code makes that gap worse.

I run static analysis on mixed human/AI codebases. The AI parts pass tests fine but they'll have stuff any SAST tool flags on first run — hardcoded creds, wildcard CORS, string-built SQL. Works in a demo, turns into a CVE in prod.

And nobody's review capacity scaled with generation speed. Most teams don't even have semgrep in CI. So you get unreviewed code just sitting in production.

The "10x" is real if you count lines shipped. Nobody counts the fix cost downstream though.