News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xnx on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:47AM (#47089504)
Am I understanding this right?

1) US customer pays huge import tax on imported goods in the form of higher prices.

2) Seller sends the collected tax to the US government

3) US government will refund all/most of that tax back to the seller after this ruling

4) Seller gets to keep the returned tax money as pure profit (no refund to customer)

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by sc68cal on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:51AM (#47089565)
The importer pays the tax and passes it on as higher prices to the consumer. So the importers are the one that had the tax collected from them and would be getting the refund.

The importer CAN be the seller, but other times the importer is a middleman in the supply chain.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by sowbug on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:03AM (#47089746)
To the CPAs among us: will the refunded import taxes be treated as extra profit for all the importers who paid them?

I could see an argument that they don't have a legal obligation to pass the refunds on to their customers, any more than my local grocery store owes me 5 cents for the gallon of milk I bought last year if the store discovers that their wholesaler had been mistakenly overcharging them.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by sc68cal on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:13AM (#47089900)
That's a great question. I would also love to know that answer. I agree with you that they're not going to share the refund if the importer was the middleman in the supply chain, and same thing if the importer was also the seller.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by lotsofpulp on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:31AM (#47090183)
There is a 1099 specifically for money received from the government.

https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-1099-g

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by mattas on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:30PM (#47090997)
The idea of getting a refund for mischaracterized tariffs is actually fairly common (it's called a duty drawback and there's a cottage industry around this). It's generally used when an importer incorrectly categorized their import under an HS code that has a higher duty than the correctly categorized HS code.

The difference this time is the scale is orders of magnitude larger. Will be interesting to see how they (importers and CBP) work through this.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Forgeties79 on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:12PM (#47094040)
Smart money is that they will make some token comment about "leave it up to the states" or lower courts and then do absolutely nothing about it
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aardvarkr on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:38PM (#47094348)
The feds are the ones that control import duties, not the states. The courts will decide two years from now what to do.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Forgeties79 on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:13PM (#47096360)
I get how it works, I’m mostly talking about the how admin will spin it/shirk responsibility
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by jopsen on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:48PM (#47094465)
> The difference this time is the scale is orders of magnitude larger.

The administration will just do nothing. They need 3 maneuvers for this to drag out longer than Trump 2.

There is no intention to follow the law here.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by sigwinch on Saturday February 21, 2026 @07:36AM (#47100217)
I wager he’ll:

1. Claim to refund the money to each taxpayer with a Trump-signed check.

2. The number of checks will not total $200 B. Any reporting to the contrary will take up space from the truth about Epstein.

3. Before 2028, a loyal SuperPAC will form with hundreds of billions in dark money.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by JKCalhoun on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:49PM (#47103499)
"…refund the money to each taxpayer…"

I've got receipts.

Literally. I have receipts for hundreds of dollars where the tariff is itemized (from JLCPCB, etc.)

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Animats on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:31PM (#47095557)
A regular importer who routinely pays customs duties is now owed money by Customs and Border Protection. Can they now set off future duties against the balance owed them? Normally, reciprocal debt cancellation is legal.

The U.S. Treasury has a whole system for this, but in the other direction. If the government owes you money, and you owe the government money, the Treasury will deduct what you owe from whatever they are paying out.[1] But they're not set up for that in the other direction.

[1] https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/TOP/

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:40PM (#47091966)
I got charged a $600 tariff from UPS to ship a $30 25-pound sandbag into the US from Canada.

UPS didn't even deliver the product.

I'm suing them in small claims.

We'll see what happens.

I imagine that even after the ruling, our ass backwards legal system will somehow say this makes sense, even though the tariff rate was never near high enough for that bill to make any sense.

Further, they're going to get refunded the $10 it MIGHT have cost them.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aardvarkr on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:40PM (#47094368)
Huh? In what world was the tariff on sand 2000%?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by jacobgkau on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:06PM (#47094682)
It wasn't the tariff. UPS has been tacking on a ridiculously high paperwork fee for the service of processing tariff payments. Other shipping companies have also had fees, but UPS is the main one that's made it exorbitant and disproportionately higher than the tariff itself.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by qingcharles on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:19PM (#47097154)
I'm thinking the delivery agents such as UPS, Fedex, USPS now need to sue the United States so they can pay back all the recipients the fees they charged, plus interest.

There are going to be a raft of class action suits based on this.

As one of my lawyers once said, the only winners here are the lawyers.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by vjvjvjvjghv on Saturday February 21, 2026 @09:17AM (#47101067)
“ As one of my lawyers once said, the only winners here are the lawyers.”

Congress is full of lawyers do it’s pretty natural that they make rules that favor lawyers.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by markbnj on Saturday February 21, 2026 @11:28AM (#47102219)
I suspect that my recent experience confirms this. Our daughter shipped two suitcases home from the UK, paying some local company for "door-to-door" delivery. They contracted with UPS who demanded an additional $32 when the first bag showed up. For the second she paid the same fee online so they wouldn't require a check at the door.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by lostlogin on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:28PM (#47097204)
> 25-pound sandbag into the US from Canada.

It's not the point, but why were you doing this? Surely internationally shipping a sack of sand is more painful than getting a local one?

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aiauthoritydev on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:17AM (#47098322)
This could just be across the border.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by ignoramous on Saturday February 21, 2026 @05:25AM (#47099370)
> just be across the border.

It was interesting to see shops in the border towns of south & south east Switzerland buying & selling products from Italy, a relatively cheaper market.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by gambiting on Saturday February 21, 2026 @12:06PM (#47102548)
I mean, when I was young we lived in Poland right next to the border with Slovakia and we'd drive over once a week for groceries and to buy fuel because it was just so much cheaper over there. Nowadays it's the reverse since they got the Euro - most Polish shops near the border cater to Slovakian shoppers and even accept Euro for payment.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by lostlogin on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:38PM (#47103917)
> even accept Euro for payment.

Pre Brexit, I encounter a shop that did this in London and was surprised.

Having just been over there again, it's not hard to be entirely cashless, so the convenience isn’t missed.

Italians seem to like dealing in cash, with various taxis and hotels being cheaper if you pay cash. I guess that means it’s off the books?

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by davidron on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:48PM (#47103990)
American here. My experience is that the US dollar seems to be accepted in tons of stores in countries all over in the Americas Europe and Asia. Trade is trade it seems.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by nullhole on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:51PM (#47094502)
Related question, unanswerable except maybe as a rough estimate: how much will it cost, in accountant/bookkeeper time, to do all the administrivia required to process all these refunds?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by tim333 on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:16PM (#47094789)
I think the tax is basically on the profit made when you add up costs and expenses. Say:

Before: Importer pays China $10 for widget, pays $2 duty, sells to shop for $12 - profit zero, tax on that zero.

Now: Paid $10 for widget. Paid $2 duty, sold for $12, $2 refunded - profit $2, pays tax on the $2.

At least that's the normal way of doing accounting. There can be odd exceptions and complications in local laws.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by sowbug on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:39PM (#47094983)
Yes, I think that's the starting point. Another part of my question was whether a CPA applying GAAP would recommend recognizing the $2 as other income, or else as a liability against a future claim from the customer who bought the widget and is now seeking a partial refund.

I did what passes for research these days and concluded that if the claim is "probable and estimable," then it could be recorded as a "contingent liability" rather than other income. Relevant facts would include whether the tariff refund included a pass-through refund mandate (unlikely with this administration), or whether class actions for refunds against merchants were pending (inevitable).

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by tim333 on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:44PM (#47095057)
I imagine the government will provide some sort of guidance for that kind of stuff?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aucisson_masque on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:17PM (#47094093)
at the end of the day, it's average joe who bought his things more expensive, and he won't get back his money.

That's what matters, don't care if it's the seller or a middleman that gets this money.

That's really a shame for american citizens, i'd be furious if i was american.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by blurbleblurble on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:18PM (#47094107)
Many are beyond furious
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by ikiris on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:38PM (#47094337)
Many voted for this
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by cptroot on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:07PM (#47094697)
Very few people voted for tariffs, specifically. They voted for a promise of a return to a world where they were on top.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by riffraff on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:54PM (#47095758)
tariff were promised and implemented by Trump in his first mandate too, if you voted for him, you mostly voted for America Great Again Through Tariffs.

After the liberation day tariffs were announced, 34% of the people thought they were good.

https://www.kansascity.com/news/nation-world/national/articl...

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by __turbobrew__ on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:19PM (#47096408)
Project 2025 was publicly available prior to the election. Tariffs were one of the many policies within the larger plan. If you voted for Trump you are responsible for the Tariffs, this is not a hoodwink where Trump rug pulled everyone after getting elected — it was literally there in the open.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by deathanatos on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:28AM (#47098028)
Even beyond/disregarding Project 2025, tariffs were a well-known part of the GOP platform in 2024; it was even included and discussed at the Presidential Debate. The Harris platform even called it a tax at that time, to attempt to make it quite clear to the voter who, in the end, would bear the cost, and the Trump platform equivocated on who would pay the tax to distract from that Harris was right.

Even if you knew nothing of Project 2025 (somehow), you were warned.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by larusso on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:53AM (#47098503)
On top you have news outlets and educated people not being clear what they are. See from the article:

He has long argued tariffs boost American manufacturing - but many in the business community, as well as Trump's political adversaries, say the costs are passed on to consumers

It’s reported as if someone still needs to figure out who pays the tariffs in the end. I’m aware that tariffs are a lever to potential move buying behavior and give incentives to move production locally. But in this instance and how it’s/ was implemented it’s clear who is the paying for it.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by vjvjvjvjghv on Saturday February 21, 2026 @09:20AM (#47101088)
“ Even beyond/disregarding Project 2025, tariffs were a well-known part of the GOP platform in 2024;”

The tariff stuff is just a variation of the republican dream to replace income tax with a sales tax. Big tax cut for higher incomes while raising taxes for lower incomes.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by acuozzo on Saturday February 21, 2026 @12:50AM (#47097870)
> They voted for a promise of a return to a world where they were on top.

Very few were on top during The Gilded Age and it has been EXTREMELY clear for quite a long time now that the "Great" in M.A.G.A. is a reference to the 1880s, not the 1950s.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by watwut on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:19PM (#47103233)
Where THEY were on top. Trump voting men wanted the world where they can rule over women. Trump voting whites voted to be over minorities. Trump voting christians want their religious state.

And so on and so forth. In each case, vote for Trump was to harm someone you look down at and to dominate over another group.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by acuozzo on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:17PM (#47103741)
Begging for a 12h day of work every morning on the docks as a stevedore in crowds among hundreds of other men begging for the same job does not give one power to "rule over women".

They'd be too underpaid and exhausted to rule over their own dinner before falling asleep for the night.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by scott_w on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:20AM (#47097994)
No they absolutely did. Trump promised tariffs on multiple occasions: https://www.export.org.uk/insights/trade-news/us-presidentia...

When you vote, you vote for an entire platform and you especially vote for central campaign promises. You don’t get to say “I voted for a world where I’m on top” and then say “but not for the primary method the candidate promised to use!”

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by mapontosevenths on Friday February 20, 2026 @07:08PM (#47095867)
Trump believed that Obama was a secret Muslim infiltrate sent to destroy America because he's black, that's what they voted for. Racism.

The rest of it was just gravy.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by nurettin on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:08AM (#47097930)
The problem is USA doesn't get good choices. Given the choice between a walking corpse and trump, they choose the corpse. Given the choice between a woman and trump, they choose trump.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by hermanzegerman on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:39AM (#47099851)
Care to elaborate why a person is a bad choice because she is a women? Especially compared to someone who shits his own pants in the public?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by nurettin on Saturday February 21, 2026 @07:52AM (#47100352)
I think there is a language barrier issue here.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by JKCalhoun on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:55PM (#47103553)
I assume they were suggesting that to those that voted for Trump they saw a woman as the worse choice. Perhaps as well when Hillary Clinton ran against him.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by poisonarena on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:19AM (#47097988)
This is loony, all these guys knew eachother for years before and have cordial if nor friendly relationships. The Clintons, Trump, Bushes, Obamas, etc.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by mapontosevenths on Saturday February 21, 2026 @09:30AM (#47101157)
In 2016 65% of Trump supporters believed Obama was secretly Muslim. [0]

Trump claimed that Obama was "the founder of Isis" and claimed MANY times that he was not born in the United States. [1]

So yes, he is completely loony... and very blatantly a racist who sends dogwhistles to other racists regularly.

No, he is not friends with Obama or Biden. In fact, Trump is the first president in 150 years to refuse to attend the inauguration of his competitor after losing. [2]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barack_Obama_religion_conspira...

[1] https://x.com/realDonaldTrump/status/508194635270062080

[2] https://www.whitehousehistory.org/photos/notably-absent-pres...

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aucisson_masque on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:57PM (#47094567)
These people are not necessary against tariff, they are against paying more for their stuff and having it benefit some middleman because the current government messed up badly.

I can otherwise understand how people would agree on paying more for their stuff if it allows their fellow citizens to have a job.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by jacobgkau on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:14PM (#47094777)
Yeah, I honestly have not been one of those "it's just a negotiating tactic" people and have instead been saying this whole time that I understand why tariffs (and the end of de minimis) are needed at the moment. Seeing Temu ads all over TV and the internet flouting word-for-word that I can "shop like a millionaire" to buy their cheap, disposable, polluting, unethically-produced junk, while I'm not making enough to actually live comfortably (with many worse off than me), comes across as a real and obvious problem to me that needs to be nipped in the bud despite whatever short-term dollars I might save by buying Temu knock-offs on a regular basis. (And I do import personal purchases from overseas a few times a year, and have put my money where my mouth is when it comes to paying tariffs on those.)

I obviously am not particularly happy about the tariffs being struck down like a lot of people are. And having paid those tariffs thinking they were at least legitimate tariffs, I'm also not super happy that I won't be seeing that money come back to me (neither in the form of services paid for by taxes, nor in the form of a refund). It's a crappy situation all around.

I won't sit here and claim the Supreme Court got it wrong, but it does make me wish the administration had worked more carefully to do it in a legal way the first time, for example, or that Congress had been involved to achieve it since the administration's party controlled them this whole time, anyway.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by myvoiceismypass on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:14PM (#47096370)
You are pro thoughtless tariffs against every random country, because of temu ads?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xorcist on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:58PM (#47095790)
There are many reasonable ideas for import taxation. But what you describe was not what happened. China fought back with their own tariffs, and you may well have paid less import tax on your Temu knock-offs than you did for some widget made with both higher environmental and labor standards in some western European country.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Recurecur on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:41PM (#47095017)
Don’t panic too much yet, there are other legal bases for the tariffs.

We’ll see…

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Keekgette on Saturday February 21, 2026 @03:46AM (#47098782)
You can vote for AOC or whatever the Democrats prominent champagne Marxist will be starting 2028+.

Let's see how many countries still likely to deal w/ US if she would be installed.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by qingcharles on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:21PM (#47097164)
Check Truth Social, many are livid that the tariffs were found illegal. A lot of supporters of the current government prefer to pay higher prices for goods.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by JKCalhoun on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:56PM (#47103574)
(I'll just take your word for it.)
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by qingcharles on Saturday February 21, 2026 @04:47PM (#47105153)
It's like a car crash, I have to rubberneck it sometimes for my own morbid curiosity.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by cyanydeez on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:41PM (#47094374)
So they basically figured out how to bribe all these companies?

Such a kleptocracy.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by PowerElectronix on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:01PM (#47094615)
i read that Costco could actually refund everyone, as they can know exactly who bought what.

If they do, that's another matter, but they definitely can.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by latexr on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:32AM (#47099803)
> The importer pays the tax and passes it on as higher prices to the consumer.

So it matters how we’re interpreting “paying”. One way to look at it is that if the cost was passed on to the consumer, the consumer paid it. The importer simply handed over the money.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by jamincan on Saturday February 21, 2026 @07:46AM (#47100313)
It depends on the terms of the transaction. Most business-to-business transactions would have the importer responsible for duties, but many, maybe the majority of business-to-consumer transactions have taxes & duties covered by the exporter and included in the final price which would typically reflect the additional taxes & duties in the prices. In those case, the exporter would be the one refunded.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by DivingForGold on Saturday February 21, 2026 @09:19AM (#47101082)
and if so, do you really believe any importers who paid the tariff will further refund back to the consumer ? It's eventually a net win for the importer.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by sowbug on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:53AM (#47089591)
Or maybe this is used to justify a new emergency federal law that all purchases must be reported on your tax return, just in case the government ever needs to refund any illegally collected import taxes.

I think I'm kidding, but I'm not really sure anymore.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by seanmcdirmid on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:18PM (#47094105)
A federal law has to be approved by Congress, that isn’t happening. An executive order maybe?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by scott_w on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:22AM (#47098003)
That would be no more legal than what the Supreme Court just struck down.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Broken_Hippo on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:48AM (#47098477)
Indiana has sometimes required that for decades, though I think they finally adjusted the law a little after online purchases became popular.

Indiana charges sales tax like a lot of states, but only on things sold in the state or from a company located in the state. If you ordered something from California or overseas, no sales tax was charged. The law required you to track these purchases and report it on your tax return so you can pay the required sales tax.

That said, enforcement wasn't good and I don't know a single person that actually did so. A common tax fraud for the average person, I guess.

And honestly, I think any emergency federal law would be similar: It wouldn't be for refunds for the masses, but for surveillance and extortion.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by projektfu on Saturday February 21, 2026 @10:32AM (#47101701)
Yeah, most states that have sales taxes have "use taxes" to cover this case and the case of a wholesale item (no tax) being used in house. It gets enforced primarily in retrospect and on big ticket items that the state does see, like a vehicle purchase.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Broken_Hippo on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:57PM (#47106445)
Heh. Indiana charged sales tax at when you registered the vehicle the first time unless you had paperwork proving otherwise.

Very common for a private sale to put the price cheap, but not free - $200 charged sales tax on $200 and a free car was charged on the estimated value.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by jleyank on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:51AM (#47089564)
Seller wasn’t involved in the tariffs. Rather the importer paid them, etc.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by croes on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:14PM (#47090785)
I guess by seller parent means the US company who sold the product to the US customer not the seller who sold it to that company.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xnx on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:05PM (#47090664)
Who pays the importer?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by jleyank on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:42PM (#47092003)
Seller doing the importing, so they pay the foreign entity for their goods and sends the appropriate cut to the US Government. At that point, they either eat the additional cost of business or make their customers do so. Or something in between.

Tariffs are like a national sales tax.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by pests on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:27AM (#47098024)
The person who wants it imported, the buyer?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by magicalhippo on Friday February 20, 2026 @03:14PM (#47093274)
> Seller wasn’t involved in the tariffs. Rather the importer paid them

Strictly speaking it depends on the Incoterms agreed upon by the seller and buyer[1]. If the Incoterms are DDP, then the seller should pay import duties and taxes and as such is involved.

Of course sellers are typically trying to run a business, so they'll bake the taxes and import duties into the sales price. So effectively the buyer ends up paying for it, just indirectly.

This was relevant when the tariffs were introduced, as sellers with DDP goods in transit had committed to a sales price which included any tariffs and would have to swallow the extra costs when they got the bill from the freight forwarder.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incoterms#Allocations_of_risks...

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by not_a_bot_4sho on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:50AM (#47089555)
There have been no decisions about refunds. The court avoided addressing that.

That topic will surely go back to the courts, kicking and screaming

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by conductr on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:40AM (#47098434)
Personally think it should not get refunded. There’s no sane way to get it back to its source. And no one group should be making profit from it. Best if it stays with the government like a federal forfeiture so in theory we all benefit from it as citizens , maybe it goes against the national debt or lessens our deficit next year.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by czl on Saturday February 21, 2026 @03:25AM (#47098657)
Not a bad idea, but how do we prevent this from creating incentives to engineer similar situations in the future?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by nathan_compton on Saturday February 21, 2026 @10:51AM (#47101884)
Presumably such future attempts would be stopped immediately given this ruling.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by ngc248 on Saturday February 21, 2026 @04:51AM (#47099144)
Government is a poor spender, we should not be handing them more money
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by conductr on Saturday February 21, 2026 @10:33PM (#47107865)
We all participate in this system through, most of “us” passively. Use the normal means to enact the change you want to see
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by hermanzegerman on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:43AM (#47099869)
So illegal actions shouldn't have consequences for anyone?

That's a good way to deter such acts in the future

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by conductr on Saturday February 21, 2026 @10:31PM (#47107852)
That’s a separate issue from where the already paid tariffs should go
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by hermanzegerman on Monday February 23, 2026 @06:21PM (#47130492)
No, it isn't. Because there is no deterrent against future illegal actions in the future, if there won't be reimbursements.

Trump will just declare illegal tariffs again, until the Scotus strikes it down and then repeat

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by FpUser on Saturday February 21, 2026 @07:41AM (#47100274)
>"maybe it goes against the national debt or lessens our deficit next year."

And help to prosecute those who broke the law and raised illegal tax /s

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by apexalpha on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:09AM (#47089841)
There are usually a few companies between the importer and the consumer. So the importers could only refund the business they sold it to and likely won't if nothing was specified in the purchase contract.

Though this is obviously a first so expect a billion lawsuits about this.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by lokar on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:56AM (#47089645)
Most of the total tax collected seems to have been absorbed by the importers, lowering margins.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xnx on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:26AM (#47090109)
Where did you hear that? It is conclusively the opposite: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-tariffs-consumers-busines...
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by dawnerd on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:14AM (#47089924)
The price of googs this last year bed to differ. Maybe for some bigger companies on certain products but what stores like Walmart did was spread the price increase across all products so it wasn’t as obvious. And that’s now where it’s going to suck the most, prices are not going to come down. Ends up being a free handout to them.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by furyofantares on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:11AM (#47089877)
Why do we repeatedly say that tarrifs are passed off in full to the consumer in the form of higher prices? Isn't that as obviously wrong as the argument for them, that they're paid entirely by the other countries?

Is there a reason to believe, or evidence, that it's not a mixture of the two?

edit: I want to highlight esseph's reply has a link to evidence that last year's tarrifs were passed off 90% to consumers, which is exactly the type of info I was looking for.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by layer8 on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:05PM (#47090668)
For goods for which no domestic equivalent alternatives exist, why would the foreign suppliers lower their prices to compensate for the tariffs (which are paid by the importers to the government)? More generally, the cost of the tariffs will be split between foreign suppliers and local importers/consumers according to the competitiveness and availability of domestic suppliers, and according to market elasticity for the respective goods.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by cortesoft on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:26PM (#47094205)
Well, they would likely have to lower their profit margin because the demand is reduced by the higher prices. Fewer purchasers will want to/be able to buy the item at the higher price. The supply and demand curve will find a new equilibrium, but it isn’t like the sellers are going to sell the exact same quantity of items with the price exactly increased by the tariff amount.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by wolrah on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:43PM (#47095045)
That assumes that demand is meaningfully elastic, that suppliers have room in their margins to absorb it, and that they're willing to. That is obviously not the case for a lot of things.

Products with inelastic or less elastic demand we can skip over because it's pretty self explanatory.

Products like the random cheap widgets a lot of us would buy from random Chinese sellers are often high volume low margin products with a lot of competition. Think about stuff like a USB->TTL serial board that's basically two connectors, one cloned chip, and a few supporting components on a single layer PCB. Hypothetically this is an ideal case for free market economics and these things should have already been basically as cheap as they can be at every step in the chain.

For less competitive items, particularly lower volume specialty items, a vendor may also decide that it's just not worth sacrificing profits in other markets by letting them know there's room to come down. A lot of the independent hardware designers I've been wanting to buy things from sell out every batch one way or another so they just don't care, demand exceeds supply even if demand from the US is reduced. Others have decided the volatility of the situation just isn't worth it with the risk of products getting delayed or additional charges added resulting in chargebacks and lost products and have simply stopped selling to the US altogether.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by hermanzegerman on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:47AM (#47099894)
You know they can also sell to other countries than the US which would pay a higher price than the new lower price pre-tariff to the US?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by NoLinkToMe on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:23AM (#47090057)
It is a mixture of the two. But my reading of various studies indicates that in this mixture, the majority was passed to consumers in the form of higher prices.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by JDEW on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:18AM (#47089983)
> by the other countries

That makes zero sense. You mean “by lowering the profit margin on the goods sold to the US by that specific company”.

Countries don’t pay tarrifs (bar state intervention), companies do.

But yes, it’s probably a mix of the two: raising prices and lowering profit margins.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by tombert on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:54AM (#47090503)
What an odd thing to say.

The businesses in the other countries are, you know, businesses. Even if it were Chinese companies that were paying the tariffs, that will be baked into the cost of the good.

This is literally first-day economics. No such thing as a free lunch. The cost of the item that the end user pays should reflect all costs associated with production and distribution to that end user.

I have no idea how the fuck the rumor that these tariffs will be “paid by other countries” started. If there are suspicions that the tariffs are temporary then they might be willing to eat the cost temporarily so it’s not passed onto the consumer immediately, but that’s inherently temporary and not sustainable especially if it would make it so these companies are losing money.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Windchaser on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:08PM (#47090714)
> The cost of the item that the end user pays should reflect all costs associated with production and distribution to that end user.

Eh, standard business school logic these days is that if you want to maximize profits, you should charge what the market will bear, not your costs + some fixed profit.

So if you're already charging what the market will bear, there may be more wiggle room to absorb some of the hit of tariffs, so long as it still leaves you making enough profit or in a favorable position. It still comes down to what maximizes tariffs: at higher prices, demand drops, but at lower prices, your profit/item drops.

Still, yeah, from what I understand, the bulk of the tariff costs were passed along to customers.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by tombert on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:24PM (#47090909)
Sure, there might be some wiggle room in some of the margins, and when tariffs were like 10% that might have been something close to “sustainable”, but that doesn’t extrapolate forever. When Trump enacted 125% tariffs on China, they by definition couldn’t eat the cost.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by furyofantares on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:04PM (#47090650)
> I have no idea how the fuck the rumor that these tariffs will be “paid by other countries” started.

It's what POTUS was saying since day 1. That we've been getting ripped off and we're gonna make the other countries pay us etc etc etc.

It is, as I said in the post, obviously wrong - but that's where it comes from.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by whattheheckheck on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:20PM (#47094820)
Well its completely wrong. Tariffs are regressive consumer taxes that hurt people who make <$200k/year the most while enriching the inner circle of crony capitalism. Corrupt and should be prosecuted for such criminal robbery of the American people
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by tombert on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:27PM (#47096465)
I guess I mostly don't understand how anyone believed it.

He ran on lowering grocery prices, and he was going to do this by making tariffs. So his plan boiled down to "I'm going to lower prices by raising prices".

With Trump it can be tough to tell if it's idiocy of malice but at some point I suppose it's a distinction without much of a difference.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Freedom2 on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:39PM (#47097556)
I've had multiple HNers message me saying that their gas bills and grocery prices have never been lower, and that since day 1 of the new administration prices have dropped. Looking at trends across all states, I wonder how they came to that conclusion at all.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by tombert on Saturday February 21, 2026 @03:49AM (#47098794)
Maybe they’re weird outliers, but I’ve noticed with stuff like this that people will just make shit up.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by RupertSalt on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:57PM (#47091405)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tariff

  A tariff or import tax is a duty imposed by a national government, customs territory, or supranational union on imports of goods and is paid by the importer. Exceptionally, an export tax may be levied on exports of goods or raw materials and is paid by the exporter.
If an analysis says that "domestic consumers are paying 90%" of a tariff then they are simplifying the process that others are describing here as "baked into the cost" and I would say, more accurately, "the cost of tariffs are recouped from consumers/businesses by those who paid them (the importer)"

  The economic burden of tariffs falls on the importer, the exporter, and the consumer. [Wikipedia]
If economists are saying "consumers pay tariffs" then I would expect to see a notation on the price tags and a line-item on my receipts, but the cost of the tariff must be paid by the importer, or there won't be a consumer who can purchase the goods, let alone bear the costs of their tariffs.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by tombert on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:26PM (#47091759)
I am just saying that it eventually is paid by the end user, regardless of the bureaucratic steps in between. We can try and figure out who is directly paying them but I feel like that detail is unnecessary to my overall point.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by RupertSalt on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:32PM (#47091838)
US Consumers pay in fungible dollars, and so if your company paid for three pizzas eaten by an AWS team, and I paid for 1 ounce of Maersk fuel oil, and our Starbucks venti latte purchases paid to rethatch Juan Valdez's hut, who can even trace the serial numbers on our $1 bills?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by quickthrowman on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:59PM (#47092271)
A tariff is included in the cost of a product by the final seller. The final buyer ultimately pays the tariff.

It doesn’t matter who sends the actual tariff payment, it gets priced into the cost of the product.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by vkou on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:02PM (#47094626)
> then I would expect to see a notation on the price tags and a line-item on my receipts,

Trump started threatening anyone who was going to do that, because he doesn't want his face attached to price hikes.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by whattheheckheck on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:13PM (#47094760)
The importer is the consumer...
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by dboreham on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:30PM (#47094247)
It wasn't a "rumor" it was explicit deliberate disinformation. Unfortunately many people in the US have insufficient education and accurate news feeds to realize.

See also: disinformation that "other countries charge us the same tariffs", which turns out to be either a plain lie, or they mean VAT (a sales tax, like we have in the US).

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by DonaldFisk on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:41PM (#47094382)
Here's Trump's claims debunked in detail: https://www.factcheck.org/2025/08/recapping-trumps-deceptive...

"But we found that Trump’s so-called “reciprocal” tariff rates weren’t based on tariffs that other countries charged on goods coming from the U.S. Instead, the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative came up with the rates by dividing the size of a country’s trade imbalance with the U.S. in goods by how much America imports in goods from that nation. "

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by AnimalMuppet on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:19AM (#47089990)
Well, the analysis by the Federal Reserve said that domestic entities (consumers and companies) paid 90% of it. So, yes, saying that consumers pay it all is wrong, but it's less wrong than saying that foreign countries pay it all.

I don't recall seeing a split between domestic consumers and domestic companies, but I'm fairly sure that consumers are paying more than the 10% that foreign entities are.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by esseph on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:50AM (#47090440)
"American consumers bore 90% of last year's nearly six-fold tariff increase, adding $1,000-$2,400 to average household budgets, despite overall inflation dropping to 2.4% in January 2026."

https://www.forbes.com/sites/petercohan/2026/02/15/consumers...

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by furyofantares on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:02PM (#47090618)
Exactly the type of info I was hoping for, thank you.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Hikikomori on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:41AM (#47090301)
It's much more true than saying that the foreign company pays it. Depends on how much slack there is in profit margins for both the exporter and importer, but the consumer does pay most of it, like 90%.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by RupertSalt on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:32PM (#47092741)
I recommend that commenters shell out and pony up for a thesaurus before its import duty is magnified sixfold.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by sdenton4 on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:13PM (#47091597)
Here's evidence : https://www.kielinstitut.de/publications/news/americas-own-g...

"Importers and consumers in the US bear 96 percent of the tariff burden."

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by IcyWindows on Friday February 20, 2026 @07:23PM (#47096010)
That's not just consumers. That is "importers and consumers"
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by phil21 on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:24PM (#47097483)
Importer != Consumer. I think that's very obvious to anyone paying attention to this whole thing. In fact, it's a small minority of imports that are direct to consumer.

It absolutely is a mix of the importer (e.d. manufacturer, producer, wholesaler, retailer, etc.) absorbing some in their margin and the consumer picking up the bill via price increases for the rest.

It's quite obviously not 96% being paid by the consumer across the board just from looking at the CPI numbers.

All this study states is the obvious: foreign producers didn't lower their cost by much in response to tariff burden. They largely charged the same rate to a buyer in the US vs. a buyer in Germany.

This isn't to defend the tariff situation - just that this study gets trotted out a whole lot in an extremely disingenuous manner. Other data that exists is better that measures direct consumer impact.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by sdenton4 on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:48AM (#47098145)
The study makes it clear that the people footing the bill for the tariffs are in the US - it is not the rest of the world paying Trump's taxes, it's Americans, whether directly as consumers or importers.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by davorak on Saturday February 21, 2026 @12:21AM (#47097749)
I have to assume that some of that 4% has second order negative effects on US importers and consumers.

Profit margins can not always go down by 4% and in those cases goods and services would then not be available to US importers and consumers is only one example.

My assumption is that the 96% statistic does not fully encapsulate the negative costs to consumers. I have to to wonder how much higher the burden is over 96% when all second order effects are taken into account.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by fastasucan on Sunday February 22, 2026 @12:33PM (#47112847)
Does anyone have a good explanation on how supposedly other countries were paying the tariffs? If so, nothing would deter the american consumer from buying foreign?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by jrmg on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:36PM (#47091101)
Can I get compensation from UPS or FedEx for making me pay illegal tariffs - and making me pay a fee to them for processing it too?

(I know the answer is practically ’no’, but it does still seem to me that the bureaucracy and companies that went along with this obviously illegal operation bear some culpability...)

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xnx on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:53PM (#47091348)
That's be nice, but I place more blame on the half of Congress that was OK with this.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by teeray on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:05PM (#47091489)
If everyone sued them in small claims over it, there probably would be a whole lot of default judgments.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by jagged-chisel on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:29PM (#47094236)
Then you’re on your own to collect.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by staticautomatic on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:17PM (#47097144)
You’re always on your own to collect.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by fn-mote on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:18PM (#47094113)
> Can I get compensation from UPS or FedEx for making me pay illegal tariffs - and making me pay a fee to them for processing it too?

I can see why you are mad, but it seems like the were fulfilling their legal obligation (at the time).

The good news is that having directly paid UPS and not a middleman makes it much more likely that you will receive the money back. If anybody does.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xorcist on Friday February 20, 2026 @07:16PM (#47095953)
> it seems like the were fulfilling their legal obligation (at the time)

Rather, their illegal obligation (at the time)?

It was clear from the start these import tariffs are illegal. Only congress can set them. It says so in the constitution! Hand waving at some pretend emergency doesn't give you the right to ignore constitutional law.

The logistics companies should probably have fought these clearly illegal tariffs from the start. Instead they played along and collected the fees. There's probably some interesting legal precedence here to be made, should this argument hold in court.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by bickfordb on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:21PM (#47096429)
In many cases they charged me ~$25 in processing fees to collect a ~$3 tariff.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by rawgabbit on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:42PM (#47096576)
Yeah. But the guys collecting the tariffs can get guys with guns to back them up. FEDEX and UPS got the “law” on their side.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by balls187 on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:38PM (#47096549)
Unclear.

I am certainly planning on seeking reimbursement from DHL and FedEx for the difference between the Trump rates, and the previous MFN rates. And if not, request charge backs via my credit card issuers.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by rtkwe on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:42PM (#47092009)
Sometimes the consumer (more) directly pays when buying from overseas, most of the time you're right it gets rolled into the price at checkout if the company is large enough or just in larger prices buying in the US. I've had a few packages I had to pay extra import duties on with the UPS/FedEx agent fees tacked on top mostly kickstarters.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xnx on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:22PM (#47092625)
Understandable. With the intentional chaos since last year, tariffs were changing mid-shipment without any prior notice.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by rtkwe on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:59PM (#47093100)
It's less that and more that the sender just didn't arrange to prepay it for the receiver rather than it being in flux. A lot of shippers do handle it to avoid the surprise for customers but some didn't have the setup to do the prepayment.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by pclmulqdq on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:29PM (#47094233)
When I have bought things internationally, I have always been the one doing the importing. This means I paid some Trump taxes and I will get my money back.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xnx on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:17PM (#47094798)
I hope so!
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by webXL on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:47PM (#47094455)
In October, I bought a $250 product from a Canadian company + about $30 shipping & taxes and thought I was good. A few weeks later, FedEx sends me an $92 bill for the duty that they had to pay. I just ignored it since I was never given that notice up front. If they really wanted it, they could have had the vendor contact me. But at least they're not getting that bit of profit now.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by bakies on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:51PM (#47094499)
I'm also ignoring a bill, from UPS, that is a few bucks of duty and a much larger $14 fee. Presumably the large fee is because UPS isn't meant to collect taxes, but they can suck it.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by testing22321 on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:06PM (#47095312)
For what it’s worth, FedEx paid the tariff on your behalf .

You owe them, and I wouldn’t be surprised if they withhold future packages to your address until you settle up.

If they’re smart, they set it up so you owe the government.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by ngc248 on Saturday February 21, 2026 @04:56AM (#47099175)
they may start rcharging you warehouse storage fees and demurrage fees. chec out what happens if you dont take the delivery
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by dgellow on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:59PM (#47094580)
Or the government will not refund, and add more illegal tariffs. That wouldn’t be surprising, unfortunately
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by vkou on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:01PM (#47094614)
> Seller gets to keep the returned tax money as pure profit (no refund to customer)

Elections have consequences.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by SmirkingRevenge on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:24PM (#47094843)
I think people are getting ahead of themselves on the refund business. Refunds might be on the table, they also may not be. It may be a years long battle. Trump and co might put up enough resistance that many firms find it too costly to fight.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by beloch on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:07PM (#47095316)
This will be so in some cases, but there are extra steps in others.

e.g. In a different path, 1 and 2 are the same, but things then diverge.

3) To recoup some of those tariff costs, the company sells the rights to any potential future tariff refunds. They recoup a portion of what they paid immediately but hand away the right to a full refund to another party, such as Cantor Fitzgerald. The seller might use this to reduce prices for their customers, but probably won't. They'll set prices according to what the market will support.

4) US government will refund all/most of that tax back to companies, like Cantor Fitzgerald, that bought the rights to tariff refunds.

5) Seller doesn't get any extra money back, so there's no money to refund to consumers.

IMPORTANT NOTE: Cantor Fitzgerald, while just one of the companies doing this, was formerly headed by Howard Lutnick and is currently owned and operated by his sons.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by madaxe_again on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:52PM (#47095739)
How is this not reverse Byzantine tax farming?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by lesuorac on Friday February 20, 2026 @07:44PM (#47096168)
Where you going with this?

Afaik, Byzantine (or reverse) and other private tax collection setups aren't illegal.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by madaxe_again on Sunday February 22, 2026 @05:26AM (#47109894)
“Not illegal” != “very very good for everybody”
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by lesuorac on Sunday February 22, 2026 @01:50PM (#47113571)
Sure. My point is strictly say what you want to mean.

If you believe this is bad for society then say "I can't see how allowing others to profit from your tax refund is good" and not "How is this not reverse Byzantine tax farming?".

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by madaxe_again on Sunday February 22, 2026 @03:44PM (#47114470)
Sure man - you do your thing, I’ll do mine. I prefer implicit meaning to explicit.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by LeifCarrotson on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:12PM (#47096356)
Some additional context to your note: Howard Lutnick is Trump's Secretary of the Treasury. And also was Epstein's literal next-door neighbor.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by abakker on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:13PM (#47097123)
And bought a house from Epstein for $10
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by lostlogin on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:26PM (#47097195)
Amazing. Did he get the role because of his skillset, of because of his skill at keeping his mouth shut?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by conductr on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:42AM (#47098449)
His brother-in-law is a prison guard. Just kidding but would anyone be surprised?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by tedd4u on Saturday February 21, 2026 @12:04AM (#47097680)
Lutnick is Secretary of Commerce. This is a smaller role than Scott Bessent, who is the Secretary of the Treasury.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by LeifCarrotson on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:43AM (#47099872)
You're right, I'm wrong, sorry, I was checking my memory on Wikipedia [1] which opens the section of his bio "Secretary of Commerce" with the line "Following the 2024 presidential election, Lutnick was being considered as secretary of the treasury." and I swapped the two roles.

While a smaller role, this is a worse conflict of interest as the secretary of commerce is directly responsible for recommending tarriff actions to the President.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howard_Lutnick#Secretary_of_co...

[dead]
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by LeifCarrotson on Saturday February 21, 2026 @08:49AM (#47100831)
?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aaronrobinson on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:36AM (#47099830)
All I can think of are glory holes
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by JimmyBiscuit on Saturday February 21, 2026 @07:26AM (#47100138)
Umm this doesnt seem to be true: https://www.semafor.com/article/02/20/2026/cantor-fitzgerald...

Or is there another source for this claim?

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by gcanyon on Saturday February 21, 2026 @09:32AM (#47101172)
To the extent this is true, the entire thing could literally be a grift (I'm not saying Trump is smart enough to come up with this, just that people around him are, and he's grifty enough to go along with it):

   1. Trump enacts the tariff, despite knowing it will be struck down.
   2. The tariff extracts hundreds of billions from the economy.
   3. Finance firms buy the potential refund for pennies on the dollar, knowing that Trump has no plan to defend the tariff.
   4. The Supreme Court strikes down the tariff, as planned.
   5. The finance firms profit on the refunds.
   6. We are all poorer, Trump's cronies are richer.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by idiotsecant on Saturday February 21, 2026 @10:45AM (#47101812)
Trump has been obsessed with tariffs for decades. I fully believe he thought this was a great idea. Lutnick, on the other hand, quite obviously forsaw this eventuality (as did anyone who understands how power actually flows in the United States) and encouraged it while preparing to profit massively himself. It's an obvious play, good on him for getting away with it. It's clear at this point that this administration has utterly collapsed the idea of the rule of law, though. 15 years ago this would have been a scandal that would have led to firings and possibly impeachment
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by JKCalhoun on Saturday February 21, 2026 @01:47PM (#47103480)
And now Scott Bessent has single-handedly made tariffs a seemingly illegitimate economic tool. Nice job.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Gud on Sunday February 22, 2026 @10:10AM (#47111614)
It's hardly "good on him". Why is he profiting from failed policies of the government he is a part of?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by layla5alive on Sunday February 22, 2026 @02:35PM (#47113908)
Good on him? Did you forget an /s? Or do you really feel that if you can get away with grifting the public, good on you?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by kjshsh123 on Sunday February 22, 2026 @08:56AM (#47111036)
> The seller might use this to reduce prices for their customers, but probably won't. They'll set prices according to what the market will support.

The price the market supports depends on things like taxes and tariffs.

Why removing taxes lowers prices:

https://open.substack.com/pub/shonczinner/p/why-removing-tax...

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by mandeepj on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:44PM (#47096588)
> 4) Seller gets to keep the returned tax money as pure profit

Seller may not reduce the price as well. Thus, continues to keep the raised price due to tariffs as free profit.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by chii on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:24PM (#47097187)
Unless there's only one seller, why won't one of them just lower their price slightly to gain a market share edge and increase their total profit (even if margins slightly drop)?
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by mandeepj on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @01:49PM (#47140965)
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by kopirgan on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:13PM (#47097120)
Refunds are very complicated. How does the co even know who bought? As it goes thru several layers of distribution chain. Assuming they want to refund of course. I suppose they will claim they reduced prices (or more likely deferred price increases, how nice!)

And then not all tariff was absorbed by importer - some suppliers would have cut prices to compensate wholly or partly. We would never know as it is likely buried in various other discounts and contract terms not a line item that says "for tariff". Down the chain, others with margins could have done the same. That's probably why the inflation impact was less than scary scenarios painted by some economists.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by phil21 on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:30PM (#47097507)
What I think is interesting is if there is going to be a legal distinction between a seller raising their prices 10% for the item itself vs. a seller charging a separate line item for tariffs/customs/duties.

I can see a situation where the courts find that a general price increase is simply they - an offer to sell at a price the buyer accepted regardless of the seller's motivation to increase pricing. However a line item that very clearly states that a charge is for duties paid might be treated differently?

Very curious to see what the legal minds have to say in this scenario. In a way it may punish companies for doing what many to most consumers feel was the "right" thing to do - add a surcharge that can easily be removed if the situation changed in the future vs. using a general increase as a new price anchor.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aiauthoritydev on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:18AM (#47098327)
You are right but the current admin arm twisted folks from showing that kind of line item.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aiauthoritydev on Saturday February 21, 2026 @02:16AM (#47098314)
It is more complicated than that.

Seller sold forward contracts to recoup tariffs at a lower price and passed on the benefits to the consumers already. E.g. For every $1 seller paid as tariffs, seller sold a contract to someone for $0.25 saying if government ever refunds the buyer of the contract can keep it. The $0.25 already passed to consumers as benefits.

> Seller gets to keep the returned tax money as pure profit (no refund to customer)

Not to the specific customer but this benefits will now get passed to future customers as prices will be lowered than usual (lower than pre-tariff prices) due to competition.

Note that consumers who paid more were not necessarily paying the tariffs. Stores like Costco, Walmart increased prices across the board and socialized the impact of tariffs. Even if there was some mechanism to return tariff money to consumer, there is no way you could return it to someone who paid higher due to this socialized nature of price increase.

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by zaik on Saturday February 21, 2026 @10:09AM (#47101527)
Guess who took the other side of those forward contracts: https://www.wired.com/story/cantor-fitzgerald-trump-tariff-r...
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by yalogin on Saturday February 21, 2026 @04:25AM (#47098999)
It’s worse. Sellers raised prices citing tariffs. Not only does the seller get a one time bonus, the prices are now permanently raised as we all know prices are never coming down
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by xnx on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:02AM (#47099594)
The willingness of the customer to buy from competitors is the only thing that ever effects prices.
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by aaronrobinson on Saturday February 21, 2026 @06:35AM (#47099820)
5) US Gov uses a different law 6) Go to step 1
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Betelbuddy on Saturday February 21, 2026 @08:33AM (#47100694)
>> 1) US customer pays huge import tax on imported goods in the form of higher prices.

Not according to the current administration: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/CODFD3j623E

According to them, China and others are paying the tariffs, so any refunds clearly have to go to China...

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by Betelbuddy on Saturday February 21, 2026 @12:39PM (#47102872)
You are downvoting the messenger. In a way...its an IQ test...

"Trump says China is paying for his tariffs" - https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/fact-check-tru...

"Trump Incorrectly Has Insisted ‘China’s Paying the Tariffs’" - https://www.nytimes.com/video/us/politics/100000006661985/tr...

"Fact check: Trump and Vance keep falsely describing how tariffs work" - https://edition.cnn.com/2024/09/09/politics/fact-check-trump...

Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by DivingForGold on Saturday February 21, 2026 @09:16AM (#47101057)
Trump responds that it will be litigated, like 5 years worth . . .
Re:Trump's global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court by gdilla on Saturday February 21, 2026 @12:00PM (#47102482)
yes, because the US elected a clown, and this is the clown show.