News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by beloch on Thursday February 19, 2026 @04:51PM (#47080018)
>"Billions of dollars have been wiped from research budgets, almost 8,000 grants have been cancelled at NIH and the US National Science Foundation alone, and more than 1,000 NIH employees have been fired."

----------------

Scientists go where science is funded. A large proportion of U.S. scientists are also immigrants, who will tend to go where immigrants are welcomed.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by e40 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:13PM (#47081112)
Meanwhile, China has "genius camps" for young people, to skim off the cream of the cream of the crop, so they can go on to do amazing things for their country. It blows my mind what we've done in the last year, to damage our ability to compete on the world stage.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Arainach on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:33PM (#47081350)
It bears repeating: for everyone who insists that the US Executive Branch isn't compromised by our enemies, what different actions would someone who was compromised and trying to speedrun the destruction of American power, influence, and hegemony have taken?
[dead]
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Terr_ on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:00PM (#47081660)
> seem evil for enforcing immigration law

When people living otherwise-blameless lives begin getting accosted, beaten, or killed on suspicion of the legal equivalent of unpaid parking tickets, then yes, the new enforcement occurring is indeed "evil."

When they start willfully breaking all sorts of other major laws and violating court-orders to enforce the minor law, yes, that's usually evil.

When rationales last-used to jail innocent Japanese-Americans into US "internment" camps during World War II are being resurrected to declare entire nationalities as foreign invaders, yes, that sure looks a lot like the evil it was before.

When people are being snatched off the streets and then shuffled constantly between prisons purely so that their own lawyers cannot find them to challenge their detention, that is evil.

When you're not just normally deporting people under US law, but start sending them--without trial or even charges--to rot for the rest of their lives in an El Salvador torture-prison run by a paid dictator accomplice, YES, that's f***ing evil!

____

I could continue, but I won't, because those should be ample examples for normal Americans who've had over a year to watch all these well-documented things happen... and there is no amount will be enough for someone that secretly likes the evil when it happens to others.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by disqard on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:22PM (#47081902)
I think you might be finding a certain category of apologist over-represented here.

Still, I appreciate you making the effort to engage in Good Faith!

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by zmgsabst on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:44PM (#47082115)
Go try the same in a non-Western country and report the comparative experience.

Histrionics over normal law enforcement that is tame and well-regulated by global standards is embarrassing — it makes Americans look uneducated and childish.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by endemic on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:20PM (#47082431)
Eh, I used to think we had standards in the US, such as “no masked goons roaming the streets asking for papers.”
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by fc417fc802 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:15PM (#47082828)
> tame and well-regulated by global standards is embarrassing

I live in the US. Why should I have to accept the comparatively poor standards of some "shithole country"? (Be sure to recall whose phrase that is.)

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by torstenvl on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:23PM (#47081915)
All of your claims are manifestly dishonest. If you don't have anything to say in good faith, don't say anything at all.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:47PM (#47082144)
I would argue that wherever you're getting your news from is lying by omission and you have no idea what's actually happening out there.

Alternatively, you're engaging in willful ignorance.

Yes, it's reasonable to want to enforce immigration laws, but ICE has been engaging in outright criminal behavior. Arresting and imprisoning US citizens, denying due process, then ignoring court orders to release them.

Meanwhile, ICE and DHS are lying constantly on their social media pages.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by torstenvl on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:51PM (#47082179)
In what universe is it unlawful for law enforcement to arrest U.S. citizens? You are trolling. There's no possibility anyone could possibly believe that.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:11PM (#47082362)
I guess I wasn't specific enough.

Sure, ICE does have the authority to perform arrests for some crimes unrelated to immigration, that's not what I'm referring to. ICE is arresting US citizens based on immigration charges.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Terr_ on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:17PM (#47082405)
Tacking on: I feel that is also just secondary "icing on the cake" versus the bigger problem you identified in the rest of your sentence, a portion which they ignored.

Actually, hold up for a second... What kind of self-described "lawyer" could possibly ignore that portion... except by operating in bad-faith?:

> denying due process, then ignoring court orders to release them.

Right, even if ICE/CBP were somehow only grabbing non-citizens and only for reasons vaguely within their legal mandate, that other behavior is still criminal. Those constitutional rights, and protections from the court system, apply to everyone in US jurisdiction regardless of their immigration status.

For anyone interested in more detail: "How ICE defies judges’ orders to release detainees, step by step" [0].

[0] https://www.politico.com/news/2026/02/10/ice-immigration-det...

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by platinumrad on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:43PM (#47082106)
You first, buddy.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:36PM (#47082046)
The majority of Americans support immigration enforcement, the majority does not support how it's being done. Enforcement of the law is not the evil you see people being upset about.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Sparkle-san on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:32PM (#47081998)
Other comparable countries also having roving gangs of secret immigration police that are unbound by the law and the only departments responsible for overseeing them are managed by the same boss that controls them?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Arainach on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:04PM (#47082301)
Who said anything about immigration?

Let's start with abandoning science funding, abandoning investments in and tax credits for renewable energy sources that are the future. Then there's applying political pressure to academic institutions to drive even more researchers away, abandoning the civil service and science/reason-based governance. Move over to the medical sector and put a dangerous anti-science nut in charge, kill off funding and research.

You pull out of international organizations, trade deals, and treaties. You throw temper tantrums and tariffs around, flip dropping day to day and making it impossible to predict the costs of doing business. You antagonize the rest of the world and give them a constant stream of reasons to stop doing business with you, leaving you isolated, weaker, and poorer.

Then, sure, let's go briefly to immigration. America has been great because it has been where all the smartest people want to be. Our political and academic environment caused the smartest people around the world to want to be here, and the US benefited massively from their contributions and inventions.

So you build a culture demonizing anyone not a specific shade of white. You destroy visa programs. You send thugs to universities to harass people and make them unwelcome. You tell students and researchers who went home to see family that they can't come back to the US. Then you send thugs into cities to terrorize and murder people. So you give all those brilliant scientists even more reason to leave the US, take their contributions with them, and never return.

That's how you kill America.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by hluska on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:23PM (#47081909)
In no stretch of the imagination does this even answer the question. I get that you wanted to make a political point, but this is remarkably weak.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by direwolf20 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:57PM (#47081613)
Idk, I think a much more effective way to destroy the US would be to send armed gangs through the streets and have them kidnap people from their houses at random.

That would cause far more destruction than merely telling people you were doing that without actually doing it.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by torstenvl on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:25PM (#47081929)
Law enforcement is not an armed gang. Arrests are not kidnappings. If you're not going to engage in good faith, then don't engage.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Sparkle-san on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:34PM (#47082023)
Arresting people solely on the basis of their skin color or having an accent is akin to kidnapping. How many legal residents and citizens are you comfortable with being arrested without a sound legal basis? My number is zero.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Arainach on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:09PM (#47082342)
>Law enforcement is not an armed gang

It always has been in America. Literally, the history of policing starts with armed gangs looking for escaped slaves, and never went away from those roots. You can see this in their "us or them" combative mentalities, their utter refusal to hold officers accountable even when obviously guilty, their tactics when governments try to impose rules on them, and everything else they do.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:39PM (#47082077)
What happened to George Retes was not law enforcement
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by zaptheimpaler on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:23PM (#47082885)
The people doing the arresting have no ID and wear masks, arrest people without any evidence, throw them in detention centers and then deny them their legal right to a bond hearing and instead detain them indefinitely. Even someone like you should understand, police are not the judges, they can arrest someone but detaining them for a long period of time requires ascertaining their legal status and offering a chance for bond. The judges also overwhelmingly ruled the same thing, while ICE is directly disobeying their legal orders. If they were law enforcement, they would be following the law not breaking it.

https://news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation/ice-detainees-succe...

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by wat10000 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:07PM (#47083162)
How are they not? They’re definitely armed, so only the “gang” part is questionable. Wikipedia says:

“A gang is a group or society of associates, friends, or members of a family with a defined leadership and internal organization that identifies with or claims control over territory in a community and engages, either individually or collectively, in illegal, and possibly violent, behavior, with such behavior often constituting a form of organized crime.”

I’d say that fits some law enforcement pretty well.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by helterskelter on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:15PM (#47082829)
I just said it in another post today, but I had a family member recently die from colorectal cancer when they were on a list for a new treatment at Yale, which was canceled because of the so-called Big Beautiful Bill. The doctor who was to perform it literally said "I want you to think of this procedure in terms of a cure" when they were stage 4 for like 7 years at that point.

BBB slashed funding for cutting edge medical research which would not only save, or at least prolong lives, but also generate revenue for this country -- when we export our IP, or when people come here for some of the most advanced medical procedures. To say nothing of immigration policies which actively repel some of the best and brightest and may be leading us to an actual population decline.

Sure we weren't perfect by an stretch before, but it feels like we're getting drowned in a toilet at the moment.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Cabal on Friday February 20, 2026 @09:33AM (#47088522)
> The doctor who was to perform it literally said "I want you to think of this procedure in terms of a cure"

I have difficulty believing a medical professional would say that.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by helterskelter on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:30PM (#47091001)
This is what my family told me. They may not have been his exact words but he believed it had a very strong possibility to go into complete remission. This was after they had gone through other therapies like HIPEC, where they told me it'd buy them a few years (they got 8). The problem is CRC will often metastasize into areas current treatments can't really get at and that tends to be where the cancer comes back. Apparently this procedure got right in there.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ikrenji on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:42PM (#47091998)
why? state of the art therapies eg genetically reprogramming patients own immune cells to hunt cancer are curative in cases that were previously a death sentence
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by csomar on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:42PM (#47082995)
You are massively under-estimating the destructiveness of idiocy. It's more destructive than whatever your enemy or a compromise could achieve.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by specialist on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:22AM (#47090043)
I learned from playing Diplomacy that a competent enemy is preferrable to an incompetent ally.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by andrewflnr on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:02PM (#47083564)
... I can think of a lot actually. They could try to unilaterally reduce the nuclear arsenal and other military power, for instance. They could close down foreign military bases. A lot of those would even be more left-coded actions. A popular left-ish politician who had a platform of reducing foreign involvement wouldn't even need to hide their agenda.

I get the angle, and I'm not even ruling out that some of the BS is sabotage, but in the big picture it's too easy for me to believe the current admin really is that stupid.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by foxglacier on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:39PM (#47083839)
You clearly haven't thought about that question at all yourself and are just repeating mindless political rhetoric. Why even say it? Other people have proposed obvious answers. I hope you learn those answers and stop asking.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by jimbokun on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:54PM (#47083923)
This suggests that our executive branch has fallen under the influence of foreign agents through blackmail or coercion of some sort.

Whereas the simpler and more obvious explanation is that the US President shares the general outlook and values of America’s enemies and thus naturally acts in their interests without persuasion needed.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by viking123 on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:41AM (#47084222)
It's under the control of Israel, let's just put it how it is. The whole Epstein/Maxwell case was an Israeli honeypot to gather blackmail on the freaks at high level positions in the US. They have huge amounts of dirt on Trump, the Epstein files were like the tip of the iceberg lol

Watch as Trump will attack Iran again on behalf of Israel. Absolutely insane how the whole system is compromised.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by disgruntledphd2 on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:44AM (#47085774)
All monocausal explanations are wrong. (Except for this one, obviously ;) )
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mancerayder on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:57AM (#47088106)
The U.S. is under control of the Israel? We all know what you really mean.

How do messages like this end up on HN? Is it the Reddit sub we have that's attracting these types of people?

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by NietzscheanNull on Friday February 20, 2026 @09:19AM (#47088350)
Highlighting Israel's inexplicably strong influence over US foreign policy is not the dog-whistle you seem to be implying it is.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by throw478722704 on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:07AM (#47088929)
It’s not inexplicable and it’s not strong if you’re not an antisemite.

The US has spent orders of magnitude more defending Europe.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by viking123 on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:04PM (#47092350)
Calling people antisemite is all that you have left. Lets hope we get the rest of the Epstein files out.

USA is free to leave Europe and exit the bases, no one trusts them anymore anyway.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by viking123 on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:06PM (#47092384)
They just scream antisemitism when you point that the bloodthirsty fascist leadership in Israel is trying to get US to die and fight for them in Iran even though Iran is only an issue for Israel. Save the goyim from this one and just go at it alone please.

And btw, I don't think normal Israeli people have anything to do with this stuff, it's mostly the bloodthirsty elites, the plebs in Israel like the rest of the world will take the hit while the Epstein class throws up a party.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by tomhow on Saturday February 21, 2026 @04:16AM (#47098945)
Please don't engage in ideological battle on HN. The guidelines make it clear we're trying for something better here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by throw478722704 on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:04AM (#47088886)
They claim both that Israel is just a puppet/arm/colony of the USA, and that the USA is under the control of Israel, depending on which dog whistle or virtue signalling horn they are blowing.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by viking123 on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:03PM (#47092324)
I mean Mossad was basically running a blackmail operation to catch all the degenerate US elites and the amount of stuff they have on these people is insane so of course they have a strong hold of them. The links to Israel are so obvious you have to be a shill not to see them.

Trump hasn't said a bad word about Israel, even about Putin he has grumbled.

Even the most delusional Fox news boomers are seeing it lmao.

But yeah let's see the goyim (wording that Maxwell and Epstein used) to go die again.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by eunos on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:45AM (#47085784)
> US Executive Branch isn't compromised by our enemies

Or maybe the rots are within? It's tempting to trivially assume it's outside. I'd say they are mostly come from within and beyond Trump admin.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by e40 on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:20AM (#47089097)
I do agree this is a possible explanation, but there is another:

The avarice and narcissism of our leader, along with all the yes-people, grifters and people devoid of ethics and morals he has assembled around him have led to the current situation. Also, it appears a lot of people in the administration are not very smart, but think they are. We can never underestimate the damage that can be done by a stupid person that thinks they are smart. In this case, these people have incredible amounts of power.

[dead]
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by AuthAuth on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:45PM (#47081488)
Its calling for the US to stop copying the bad parts of Chinese Policy and go back to matching the good parts.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by voxl on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:38PM (#47081410)
Don't be an ass. Someone can be an ethically bad person and still do things that you can learn and benefit from. Moreover, saying China is doing good at research does not somehow mean you support their government.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by jmcgough on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:49PM (#47081536)
The US government is now more authoritarian than the Chinese government. Half of what you've been told is propaganda, like the "social credit score" story.

In China they put people to death for corruption, here they just get a well-paid lobbying job.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by s3r3nity on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:01PM (#47081668)
> The US government is now more authoritarian than the Chinese government

Nah we’re not playing this game.

Try asking the CCP officials in person about Uyghur internment camps, or Tiananmen Square, and see if your family isn’t all arrested.

Ask Olympian Alysa Liu how the CCP targeted her father to try to coerce her to skate for China.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by tekno45 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:19PM (#47081868)
they shot unarmed protestors in US streets.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by temp8830 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:16PM (#47081837)
Oh but this game is fun! I see your Uyghurs and raise the Falun Gong. A religious cult that is against pretty much anything liberal, but because they are a thorn in China's side they get US support and are oh-so-persecuted. They even have an anti-Communist acrobatics show called Shen Yun. Yes, that one, the one that spams your mailbox with flyers, and abuses kids.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by hluska on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:26PM (#47081941)
I made the mistake of clicking through to your profile. This isn’t even the most nonsensical reply you’ve made today. That’s unfortunate.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by leptons on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:16PM (#47081838)
I think the next 3 or so years in the US are going to be a real awakening for you, if the last year hasn't. It's going to become more and more difficult to shove your head deeper into the sand.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by s3r3nity on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:44AM (#47089467)
Nah I’m good, and we’re pretty good overall.

See how I can have a different opinion and not get arrested? Whereas if you ask someone in China if they’re communist, they’re not allowed to say “No.”

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by leptons on Sunday February 22, 2026 @03:07PM (#47114161)
When your opinion of a fascist authoritarian government is "nah I'm good", then anything that follows is nothing worth listening to. Using whataboutism to excuse the current administration is ridiculous.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Terr_ on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:44PM (#47082622)
Speaking as an American with some personal history in Hong Kong (on both sides of the PRC handover), saying "is now" is not accurate.

That said, I would agree to "may soon become if we don't stop it." We aren't there yet, but we're on a bad trajectory.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by daveguy on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:35PM (#47081377)
I mean, they're both authoritarian right now. But at least one of them doesn't think science is woke. So....
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by juniperus on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:01PM (#47081671)
if you actually think China would even entertain the idea of funding some of the scientific research conducted in the US over the past few decades, you have a fantasy view of what is going on outside the US. That political controversy wouldn't even arise because it's such a nonstarter that it could never even become a controversy.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by daveguy on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:13PM (#47081792)
Past being the key point. Because, right now it's all Dumpty all the time, until we boot his weak tools and fools November. I'm confident we are stronger than that two bit corrupt fraud, and will get back to where science funding is a priority. Hopefully our state of affairs is much more temporary than what China is subjected to. But there's absolutely no question whether the dunce parade in the US is anti science.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by direwolf20 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:58PM (#47081627)
Did you miss Trump's plan to censor the internet except for party approved propaganda? It was on the front page here a few days ago. The propaganda site will be called freedom.gov.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by jimbokun on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:51PM (#47083908)
In the US education for talented students is under attack from the left as well as the right (just in different ways).
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by e40 on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:21AM (#47089129)
How so (genuinely curious)?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by jimbokun on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:49AM (#47089548)
The left doesn't like special programs for advanced students because those students are disproportionately Asian, Indian and white.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ei8ths on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:28PM (#47081293)
have you seen our school systems, k12. Its terrible and in dire need of a revamp. No child left behind really screwed kids over that want to learn. We cant just let kids pass because of feelings. Made schools better, have alternative paths for kids that are not excelling like some of their peers and find school hard to sit through.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by jmcgough on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:32PM (#47081336)
It's really not about this - it's that for decades we've been able to draw top global talent to the US. We've cut research funding so heavy that we can't even support post docs who are American citizens now. My friends are going to Europe, Canada, Hong Kong.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:21PM (#47081886)
How important can that be? America’s only real competitor technologically is China. And they’ve had essentially no immigration of “top talent.”
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by dboreham on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:31PM (#47081983)
China has 3X more people, and America has a relatively terrible education system, so they have to import talented people who were educated elsewhere.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:44PM (#47082109)
America has a very good education system against the backdrop of challenging sociological factors and mass low-skill immigration. In the PISA exam, white American kids outperform kids in Hong Kong and Korea, as well as western european kids of non-immigrant ancestry.

The American education system has major and important challenges, such as how to educate the large share of kids whose parents are economic migrants from non-English speaking countries. But those challenges aren’t relevant to the question of whether the U.S. can produce sufficient highly educated people domestically. China, meanwhile, doesn’t even participate in PISA outside four wealthy provinces.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by lugu on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:09PM (#47083181)
You are wrong at so many levels. Your argument is factually incorrect and logically flawed. And you know it.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:44PM (#47083421)
The facts are in the PISA data collected by the OECD. If you drill down by subpopulation, the majority group in the U.S. goes toe to toe with the majority groups in Asian countries, and beats the majority groups in western european countries: https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpreview.redd....

National competitiveness and distributional equity don’t go hand in hand. China has made tremendous achievements by focusing investment on key provinces instead of trying to bring everyone up together.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by chaostheory on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:30PM (#47083755)
Maybe you should actually prove him wrong. Making a claim without evidence doesn’t help anyone.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by gregorygoc on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:53AM (#47085009)
> In the PISA exam, white American kids outperform kids in Hong Kong and Korea, as well as western european kids of non-immigrant ancestry.

Translation: rich kids have better access to top education in America. Got it.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:49AM (#47088013)
White people in the U.S. aren’t just the “rich” subset of the whole population. They are reflect a complete spectrum, from poor to rich. They’re equivalent to Koreans in Korea or Japanese in Japan. Other groups in the U.S. aren’t just economically different, they’re sociologically different in dimensions that don’t really exist in Korea or Japan.

For example, 71% of hispanics speak Spanish at home. That reflects a group that’s comprised mostly of immigrants and their children. That poses additional challenges to education, beyond the economic differences. Poor whites in the U.S. and poor Koreans in Korea may have educational challenges from being poor. But that poverty isn’t layered with being raised in a household with immigrant parents who are in an unfamiliar country and probably don’t speak English fluently. That’s an additional layer of challenges that needs to be accounted for in comparing across countries.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by disgruntledphd2 on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:46AM (#47085795)
> against the backdrop of challenging sociological factors and mass low-skill immigration

I'm pretty sure that poverty is the issue here. Kids who don't get enough to eat, don't get enough time (or perhaps too much time in some sad cases) with their parents, kids who don't have many opportunities tend to do worse at standardised testing.

This is entirely fixable, but it's not (unfortunately) just a matter of funding schools more.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Friday February 20, 2026 @09:09AM (#47088253)
“Poverty” might be the cause, but it’s not just poverty by itself. Every country has rich people and poor people. The U.S., however, has that normal spectrum, plus subpopulations that have unique circumstances that aren't accounted for just by income level.

Look at NAEP scores: https://fordhaminstitute.org/national/commentary/some-racial... (Table 1). Asians average 312 in 8th grade math, compared to 293 for whites and 269 for Hispanics. The gap between asians and whites is almost the same size as the gap between whites and hispanics. But the poverty metrics for asians and whites is the same: 8% below the federal poverty line. (While asians are richer than whites on average, the subset of both groups who have kids is more similar. There’s a lot of high poverty asian families in places like NYC.)

Why is there such a big gap in test scores between whites and asians when economically the two groups are similar? There must be some additional sociological factor at play behind poverty in and of itself. One might hypothesize that selective immigration plays a role. The majority of the U.S. asian population is foreign born, and is in the U.S. as a result of skilled immigration. That might have an effect on their kids test scores that’s not accounted for by household income alone. That’s the kind of additional sociological factor that countries like Japan and Korea don’t have.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by disgruntledphd2 on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:01AM (#47089719)
> “Poverty” might be the cause, but it’s not just poverty by itself. Every country has rich people and poor people. The U.S., however, has that normal spectrum, plus subpopulations that have unique circumstances that aren't accounted for just by income level.

Culture is a thing, as I'm sure you know (we discussed it some time ago here). Like, in general, (many) Irish people value education above and beyond what would be expected of similar socio-economic groups, which lead to their descendants doing better than might naively be expected. The Asian thing is almost certainly similar, given all the memes that exist around demanding Asian parents. Jewish people have similar cultural beliefs.

However, you can't really aggregate up to an White level, as these factors will vary massively. Same with Asians, you'd need to control for a lot of factors.

Fundamentally though, it's better for society if everyone gets a chance to develop their potential, and my argument is that this doesn't happen to the same extent in the US as it might elsewhere, because of large gaps in income inequality and social forcing functions (if everyone you know drops out of school early, or doesn't take it seriously then most people will too).

> “Poverty” might be the cause, but it’s not just poverty by itself. Every country has rich people and poor people. The U.S., however, has that normal spectrum, plus subpopulations that have unique circumstances that aren't accounted for just by income level.

I get that you're more familar with US society, but this is a thing basically everywhere. Like, African descendants in the UK are probably one of the most successful immigrant populations, rather than less succesful than the average in the US. I honestly think that the US "unique circumstances" are cope for the lack of decent income mobility and social safety nets that prevent a larger proportion of people from realising their potential.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:54PM (#47091364)
For purposes of this discussion, I'm not trying to identify the causes of the differences between the sub-populations. My point is that if you are talking about the quality of the educational system--which is what this discussion is about--you need to compare apples with apples between countries. And to do that, you need to account for the fact that the U.S. sub-populations aren't equally situated.

For example, Asian Americans outscore Japanese, Korean, and Taiwanese students in PISA, including math. That's not a cultural difference. That's because Asian Americans aren't a random sample of Asians. The vast majority are within one generation of a very tough selection filter that screens for high skill, high intelligence, and high motivation. If the point is comparing schools, it doesn't make sense to include Asian Americans in the average.

> I get that you're more familar with US society, but this is a thing basically everywhere.

It's not a thing in the east Asian countries that top the educational charts, like Japan and Korea. Poor Japanese and Koreans still belong to the majority ethnic group, speak the national language at home, etc.

Say you transplanted Japanese or Korean schools into one of the many majority-Hispanic school districts in the U.S. where most of the kids are children of low-skill, non-English-speaking immigrants (often illegal immigrants). Would those Japanese or Korean schools have higher test scores than the American ones? I suspect they'd actually be worse, because they'd be totally unequipped to deal with a large student population from a non-native language background.

My wife's aunt's kids go to a school in a more rural part of Oregon. Many of the kids are children of agricultural workers. Many of these kids don't even speak Spanish at home. They speak one of dozens of different indigenous Latin American languages. Japanese and Korean schools educate the children of poor agricultural workers too, but those kids still speak Japanese and Korean at home! If the goal is to measure school quality, is it really fair to just put those kids into the average and fault American schools for doing worse than Japanese or Korean schools?

> I honestly think that the US "unique circumstances" are cope for the lack of decent income mobility and social safety nets that prevent a larger proportion of people from realising their potential.

Even if that were true, that would be more a point about the fairness of U.S. society rather than the quality of the educational system. I don't think it makes sense to conflate those two questions in a discussion of the U.S.'s competitiveness against China.

Moreover, income mobility in the U.S. doesn't break down by sub-population the way you might think. For example, while Hispanics have lower incomes because most are immigrants or children of immigrants, they have higher income mobility: https://economics.princeton.edu/working-papers/intergenerati.... Children of Guatemalan immigrants in the U.S. have higher income mobility than children of native-born Americans. Household incomes for Hispanics converges on the household income for whites within a few generations: https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/135/2/711/5687353

So focusing on PISA scores for "whites" isn't really about race or culture. It's just a proxy for "people whose families have been in the U.S. long enough to dispel the effect of immigration filters." If you were conducting the same analysis 100 years ago, you might try to exclude Italians or Irish from the analysis. Again, the point is to compare schools, not all the other sociological factors that are involved when dealing with immigrant populations.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by disgruntledphd2 on Sunday February 22, 2026 @03:09PM (#47114174)
> Why is there such a big gap in test scores between whites and asians when economically the two groups are similar? There must be some additional sociological factor at play behind poverty in and of itself. One might hypothesize that selective immigration plays a role. The majority of the U.S. asian population is foreign born, and is in the U.S. as a result of skilled immigration. That might have an effect on their kids test scores that’s not accounted for by household income alone. That’s the kind of additional sociological factor that countries like Japan and Korea don’t have.

OK, So I've just actually read your fordham institute link, and you realise that it doesn't argue for this point, instead arguing that it's two parent households and expectations around college that create the gap (which is pretty small, to be fair). This is basically the point that I'm trying to make here, in that parental and broader cultural expectations drive these differences, not selective immigration.

Additionally, for your point to be true, you'd need to observe these kinds of effects for 3-4th generation Asian immigrants, which both seems pretty unlikely to me and difficult to collect data around (as there probably aren't enough Asian americans in this group).

I really think that cultural expectations and poverty provide a more parsimonious account of this data, tbh.

> The majority of the U.S. asian population is foreign born, and is in the U.S. as a result of skilled immigration.

On this point specifically, the percentage for ESL (which normally correlates with 1st generation immigrants) is about 12, which means 88% of the Asians in your sample speak English natively. Again, this article really doesn't support your point.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by HarryHirsch on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:37PM (#47082057)
They imported top graduate student talent that went to the us and might have wished to stay but could not or wouldn't put up with the H1-B indentured servitude or was better paid back home or just patriotic.

Also - less financialization. In US, a statistician goes to work for any 3-letter agency or high finance. In a less financialized economy they might devote themselves to crystallography instead.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by jmcgough on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:28PM (#47082494)
Ask this again in 40 years. The people we're losing are early career researchers, so this is really a generational loss of talent that we've created. Brain drains can become self-perpetuating once they start.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by wongarsu on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:46AM (#47085791)
Germany was in almost this exact situation. It was a self-perpetuating machine for centuries, where ambitious students came to study under the best professors, leading to top students, many of which stayed at those universities to become top professors themselves. Then WW1 put a bit of a damper on that, and the 1930s and 1940s broke it. Germany is still not insignificant in science, but really a shadow of its former self

And that was despite putting an emphasis on education, and the 1930s and 1940s having a lot of science funding. Remove the people and the flywheel stops

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by notatoad on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:34PM (#47082949)
>America’s only real competitor technologically is China

this is a very shortsighted view. america's only real competitor technologically right now is china, because america has typically attracted the top talent from everywhere else.

if america is no longer capable of attracting top talent from everywhere else in the world, and other countries can start attracting american talent, it won't be long before america has a whole lot of real competitors.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by brightball on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:34PM (#47082016)
Don’t forget campaigning to remove standardized testing from admissions processes even leading to UCSD having to create remedial math classes for their engineering students.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:59PM (#47081639)
> No child left behind really screwed kids over that want to learn. We cant just let kids pass because of feelings

The whole point of no child left behind was to actually measure student performance instead of relying on feelings: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/no-child-left-behind-wo...

If you try to disaggregate the effects of e.g. immigration, you can see that American education is actually good: https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/18bzkle/2022_pi....

White students in the U.S. do comparably to students in Korea in the international PISA test, and better than students from western europe (excluding the immigrants in those countries).

You have to compare like with like. A huge fraction of American kids grow up to parents who are not native speakers of English. That’s not true in Japan or Korea.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:54PM (#47082217)
Over half of the adults in the US can't read at a 6th-grade level. They aren't all immigrants. Clearly American education is not actually good.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:18PM (#47082420)
Even looking at the entire population, the U.S. has higher reading scores on PISA than the big western european countries (UK, Germany, France, Italy): https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2019/12/pisa-2018-resul.... In reading, the U.S. was basically tied with Japan and the Scandinavian countries.

That is consistent with other international measurements: https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=1. For example, the U.S. is one of the top performers in the world in the 4th grade literacy--behind Hong Kong but ahead of Macau. In 4th grade math, the U.S. isn't as good, well behind Hong Kong, Singapore, and Japan. But still comfortably ahead of Germany, Italy, Spain, and France.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by jimbokun on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:58PM (#47083941)
TLDR: Western Europeans are dumber than an American 6th grader.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Fricken on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:56AM (#47084628)
I read my first Stephen King novel in grade 6. That seems to me more than sufficient aptitude for reading the things an average person needs to read to get through life.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:33AM (#47086189)
Was it assigned to you in school? Just because you read something in the sixth grade doesn't mean it was written at a 6th grade level.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Fricken on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:26PM (#47094201)
The assignment was to read lots, and lots of 6th graders read Stephen King, because that was the cool thing to do. The size of a typical Stephen King novel is intimidating but the writing is usually straightforward and clear.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by almosthere on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:22PM (#47082456)
They should have gone the voucher route many years ago - competition for the best schools.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:29PM (#47082515)
You don't want there to be good schools that some people can get into and and garbage schools for everyone else. What you need is a high minimum standard that every last school in the nation has to adhere to and it shouldn't be possible to graduate from any of them without being able to read at grade level.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:49PM (#47082664)
Whether you want that or not depends on what you're trying to achieve. China has pursued basically the approach you're talking about: focusing on key province to advance them to the cutting edge. The last time China participated international high-school testing, they published scores only four Beijing and three other wealthy provinces: https://www.milkenreview.org/articles/are-chinas-students-re.... And those scores were spectacular! Clearly that approach has some merit if your concern is competing with other countries rather than domestic equity.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:06PM (#47082770)
I do think it'd be smart to support programs for gifted students and to screen for them. Those programs should be available to anyone in the US who qualifies regardless of where they live or what kind of money they have. Every student should be allowed and encouraged to reach their potential.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:00PM (#47083533)
Your first point is in tension with your last point. A large fraction of the student population has a low ceiling of potential, and it’s very expensive to try and push them past that ceiling. The focus on doing so sucks up vast amounts of money and teacher attention that then gets pulled away from gifted kids.

That’s why sober and clear-eyed countries like Germany conventionally sort students into tracks starting around age 10.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:30AM (#47084169)
> Your first point is in tension with your last point.

It really isn't. Every student should have access to quality education that meets them at their level and challenges them. Money spent doing that is not wasted on the vast majority of students. We do not need to have trash tier schools for the majority of the population so that a select few can get better ones.

Identifying where students are at and what their needs are is a good idea that would enable kids to be moved to classes where teachers can work with them at their level. It doesn't necessitate refusing a quality education to anyone. Even students with special educational needs and disabilities deserve a good education.

When students are placed in classrooms according to their level it means that no teacher is pulled away from gifted kids, because those gifted kids have their own teacher working with them. It doesn't mean that children who aren't gifted can't get a high quality education. Putting kids in a class too far above or below their level is not delivering a quality education to them.

Giving every child an environment where they can learn to the best of their ability is expensive, but it's nowhere near as costly as not doing it. Uneducated illiterate children become uneducated illiterate adults and voters. It's not a coincidence that most prison inmates are functionally illiterate. Having a good education enables more children to have a successful future.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by cmxch on Friday February 20, 2026 @09:30AM (#47088475)
Which basically tier bins and lords over peoples entire lives based on one test score.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by chaostheory on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:35PM (#47083798)
The way it works now is that 20% of the bottom students eat up 80% of a teacher’s time and resources. I’m not saying it’s a bad thing depending on what your goals are. What I am saying is that you can’t have everything. You have to choose. This system this comment describes and the system your comment below describes cannot coexist.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:37AM (#47084202)
That just means that we need to move the bottom 20% of students into their own classes where they can get the extra attention they need. That means they can get a high quality education and so can everyone else. You do not have to choose. You can have both.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by alex43578 on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:29AM (#47084478)
No, you do have to choose because money for education (or anything) isn’t unlimited.

There’s a real question of how many resources and what kind of ROI you’d get from trying to educate that bottom 20% to the same level.

I saw this play out when I was in school: profoundly intellectually disabled students getting 1:1 or even 2:1 teaching, trying to get an 18 year old to be able to read 3 letter words, while AP classes were bloated to 30+ students.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Friday February 20, 2026 @05:49AM (#47086306)
> No, you do have to choose because money for education (or anything) isn’t unlimited.

The US is the richest nation on Earth. It can easily afford to educate its people. If you really think we'd need to find new sources of tax dollars to fund that, I have a whole lot of suggestions for where to start and I'd bet that you can easily think of a few low hanging fruit yourself.

> There’s a real question of how many resources and what kind of ROI you’d get from trying to educate that bottom 20% to the same level.

The ROI is massive. As I've said elsewhere, uneducated children become uneducated adults. Adults who vote. Adults who, if they lack the education needed to live successful lives, end up costing society in many ways over far more years than they spend in school.

I don't know about you, but I want to live and work with people who are educated and literate. If I were looking to move to another country for work, I'd want to move somewhere where the people were educated and literate. Especially if those people were going to be my boss, or my neighbor, or handling my food, or in charge of my visa application. Having a well educated population is pure win. The cost of ignorance and a lack of the kinds of skills a good school teaches is staggering.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by alex43578 on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:28AM (#47086651)
The US already spends significantly more (both in absolute terms, and as a percent of GDP) than other developed countries, but with worse outcomes (particularly for non-white, non-Asian students).

The question is whether anyone actually expects the outcomes to change if we throw even more money at the problem, or if it'll just get gobbled up by teacher's unions, administration, and silly things like non-phonic instruction or DEI programs.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by chaostheory on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:38AM (#47089371)
We are in a record amount of debt and we are about to go to war again. That’s not including the fact that we have a shortage of teachers who are underpaid. As for “new” sources of taxation, increasing the burden on the middle class is yet another way the bottom 20% eats up 80% of the resources. Tax the rich? Unfortunately, if you tax them high enough, they will just leave. They haven’t been patriotic since the last century.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:19PM (#47090844)
> We are in a record amount of debt and we are about to go to war again.

Isn't it funny how nobody ever worries about how much that's going to cost, no matter how unnecessary there's never any effort to make sure that our warmongering is funded before burdening taxpayers with it. Seems like a ripe target for some tax savings.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by chaostheory on Saturday February 21, 2026 @11:00AM (#47101964)
People did worry about the cost pre-Biden because they were unnecessary. Unfortunately, for everyone both Putin and Xi exist. Even if you put your head into the ground, it’s not going to change their intentions or behavior. Only missiles and drones will. Your comment is over a decade out of date.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by almosthere on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:48AM (#47090409)
Yeah, actually you do. What you think Ivy Leagues don't exist? (even though they're crap now because they DEI'd everything)
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Saturday February 21, 2026 @12:07AM (#47097694)
They're a good example of why we shouldn't have that. It wasn't DEI that made them crap it was letting people buy their way in and shifting the focus from education to networking for nepo-babies. George W. Bush is a prime example of a massively uneducated idiot who had no problems getting accepted to and graduating from Ivy Leagues.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by zbentley on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:47PM (#47083038)
Or train (and appropriately credential) more teachers and pay them like the critical specialists they are.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:56PM (#47083502)
If teacher pay made a big difference in outcomes, expensive private schools would have very well paid teachers. But private schools typically have lower teacher pay than public schools.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by autoexec on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:39AM (#47084209)
Teacher pay doesn't have as large an influence on student success as it does on how many people are willing to enter the occupation and stay there. Private school teachers typically deal with far fewer students in the classroom and in much better conditions. They also don't typically have to spend as much of their own money on basic school supplies. Improving conditions at public schools and lowering classroom sizes would help to attract teachers too.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by hunterpayne on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:51AM (#47086854)
Washington state has the highest public school teacher pay in the country (over 100k/yr). It also has educational outcomes which are middle of the pack. That correlation doesn't hold in many cases. Oh, and the fact that half of the funding for the district goes to administration doesn't help either.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by zbentley on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:08AM (#47089834)
You need to have both. Training/credentialing and pay. Just one is insufficient.

Longer/better educator training both increases skills/outcomes and is a gate for the poorly-suited. Higher pay makes the training seem worthwhile and increases stickiness/tenure.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by specialist on Friday February 20, 2026 @11:30AM (#47090176)
Yes and: USA has been reverting education to its pre-Sputnik arrangement since the end of the Cold War. Without an external motivation, our domestic reactionaries have regained the advantage. Its been a generations long fight to roll back the New Deal (including public and hogher education). I have no clue if / when the pendullum will swing back.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by inglor_cz on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:05PM (#47080227)
Not everything is about money. The killer app of the US used to be that the US was rich and welcoming to foreigners and politically quite free.

China or Saudi Arabia can wave their money around, but at least some people will be repulsed by the obligation to keep their mouths shut and praise the Dear Leader.

Their cultural insularity does not help either. You can live in China, but you will never be accepted as Chinese. The US was quite unique (together with Canada, Australia etc.) that it was able and willing to accept you as an American even with a funny accent, as long as you wanted to be one.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Cyph0n on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:33PM (#47081354)
Just to add one more point that makes the US attractive to global talent: citizenship. In particular: 1) citizenship at birth and 2) viable path to citizenship via green card.

Of course, both of these are in the crosshairs for “revision”.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by direwolf20 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:59PM (#47081644)
It's much easier to get citizenship almost anywhere else in the world than to get it in the USA by green card.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Cyph0n on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:52PM (#47082195)
Uh not really? As a comparison, it is almost impossible to naturalize if you decide to work in the two cited examples (China and KSA).

It also very much depends on your nationality.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by deaux on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:55AM (#47084289)
Name 5 wealthy countries (let's say top 30 HDI) where this holds outside of the EU.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by inglor_cz on Friday February 20, 2026 @06:41AM (#47086766)
Plenty of developed countries limit the easy way to their citizenship to ius sanguinus, and if you aren't a descendant of a previous national, you have to pass stringent language and culture tests.

I don't think you would find a Lithuanian or Finnish language test quite so easy.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by tencentshill on Friday February 20, 2026 @09:23AM (#47088393)
We are talking about exceptionally talented individuals, who do in fact have an express path to citizenship.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by dylan604 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:25PM (#47080503)
> The US was quite unique

Well, based on the current admin and supporters, only part of the US was unique

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by bluGill on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:35PM (#47080651)
That has always been true, and for everywhere. However very few countries are anywhere near as accepting for foreigners as the US as a whole despite the many who are not. Canada is just as accepting from what I can tell - I don't know enough about Australia to know. Most other countries are far worse - though many will not admit it just how bad their country is.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by denkmoon on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:54PM (#47080877)
Sadly Australia is very welcoming to foreigners until you get about 50km out of the major cities. Our xenophobe political party (One Nation) has had a significant rally in the last few years, to the point where by some measures it is the second largest party.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by hermanzegerman on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:22PM (#47081226)
It's the same thing in every country.

Big cities and metropolitan areas are very progressive and welcoming to well educated foreigners, and the countryside is filled with racist idiots who live in fear of something they only know from the television

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by BigGreenJorts on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:15PM (#47081141)
That's probably all that matters TBH. If you can attract top talent to major cities where top schools, research firms, and companies in general, what does the opinions and attitudes of people 50km away matter?

Ok It probably matters during elections and the policies that lead up to them (must appease the rural vote with mostly symbolic and emotionally wretching anti-immigrant rhetoric) but cities need skilled (and unskilled) labour and when they get what they need they stand to generate a lot of money (re taxes to the policy makers from earlier).

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by dylan604 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:22PM (#47081222)
> what does the opinions and attitudes of people 50km away matter?

Well, using Texas as an example, it's those people 50km away that win elections. Of course, gerrymandering helps, but even with large metro areas leaning left, there's enough of those 50km away that swings that lean to the right.

Ignore the people in the rural areas as your own peril

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by marcus_holmes on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:20PM (#47081873)
To be fair, they're still welcoming to foreigners in the bush, just as long as they're white. Rural Australia has many towns that have a strong Italian or Greek heritage (for example).

One Nation are flat racist rather than xenophobe, I think.

And it's being pushed by our billionaires for some reason. You'd think Gina would want cheap immigrant workers on her mines

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mulmen on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:15PM (#47083228)
The problem with billionaires is that they truly have more money than they need. The only thing left for them to pursue is power. Cheap labor only helps them get more money. Racism on the other hand can be used to justify the destruction of democratic institutions which are a billionaires only competition.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by gizzlon on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:50AM (#47084982)
> A CEO, a blue-collar worker, and an immigrant sit down together at a table upon which there is a plate of a dozen cookies. The CEO takes 11 of the cookies, then whispers in the ear of the blue-collar worker "Hey, I think he wants your cookie."

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46701886

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by api on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:23PM (#47081231)
It’s the same in the US. Proximity to a city correlates strongly with all forms of openness. It holds nationwide. There aren’t really blue or red states, just predominantly urban or rural ones.

I still don’t quite understand why. The contact hypothesis makes some sense but can that explain the whole urban rural divergence?

Rural populations will even vote hard against their own interests in other areas over culture war stuff.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by globalnode on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:16PM (#47081829)
There's more pressure in rural areas to conform in the sense that people know people that can make your time more difficult if you don't. If you get blacklisted in the bush gl finding any work and that's a survival issue. In the city you can walk around anon most of the time and people are more used to others being different. Dump a new high rise of foreigners that don't speak the local language in a metro area and no-one will notice. Do that in the bush and LOL.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by api on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:08PM (#47082338)
The dilution factor is something I hadn’t thought about.

Dump a few hundred foreigners in a town of 5000 and that’s very noticeable and some people will find it jarring. Dump ten thousand foreigners in a metro of three million and nobody will notice.

The point about conformism and exile cost is good too. Cities present endless options for social circles and employment. Little towns not so much.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by fc417fc802 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:13PM (#47083210)
To expand on this, consider the historic importance of culture for improving survival odds and thus conformism as a natural consequence. So it makes sense that people in smaller groups would exhibit associated tendencies, and also that people who exhibit those tendencies would tend to gravitate towards smaller groups.

Somewhat related recent discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46989124

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by inglor_cz on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:29PM (#47080568)
That is a trivial observation. A nation of such size can hardly be a hive mind with totally homogeneous politics.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Bukhmanizer on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:35PM (#47080656)
You’re right best reserve such observations for small nations like China
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by dougfelt on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:36PM (#47080673)
Yet China is 3 times as big and you are quite comfortable treating it this way
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by dylan604 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:36PM (#47080668)
Yeah. And? So?

When the part of the country that was less unique took power, they immediately did what everyone else that was not unique did and became unwelcoming of foreigners.

I guess to you other countries that the US is becoming more like would also not be of a hive mind by having people that are welcoming of foreigners. Where's your hive mind comment about that part of the original comment?

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mikestorrent on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:59PM (#47080939)
Well, perhaps it is time for large, ethnically-homogenous countries that are on the ascent to adopt diversity policies of the sort that the US was approaching before the "vibe shift"
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by titanomachy on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:11PM (#47081085)
I don’t think diversity policies are what made America diverse.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by afavour on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:16PM (#47081153)
How could they not be? If people cannot emigrate to the US then they won’t settle there. A relatively open immigration policy absolutely helped make America diverse. I’m pretty sure that’s what OP is referring to, not DEI or whatever the latest boogeyman is.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by titanomachy on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:01AM (#47085479)
I don't think open immigration in America's earlier years stemmed from a desire for diversity. It was more like "holy shit we need workers, I guess we can tolerate some Irish and Chinese people if we have to". It seems like a reach to call that a "diversity policy".
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by afavour on Friday February 20, 2026 @10:28AM (#47089224)
Nor did I claim it was. A diversity policy is a policy that increases diversity, whether it is the specific goal or not.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pitched on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:08PM (#47081050)
Canada is largely still homogeneous but still welcoming to immigrants and very close to the US. Rather than China totally changing cultures, I think it’s more likely that US-based companies will have large satellite offices in middle powers.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mikestorrent on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:00PM (#47081663)
I'm Canadian and unless you're talking about the middle of Saskatchewan I don't know what you mean - no city over a hundred thousand here is homogenous.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pitched on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:28PM (#47081965)
I have been in small towns in the Maritimes where people looked shocked to see an Indian immigrant with me, probably for the first time ever. I meant more in relation to the US, though, which is a much more diverse country.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by umanwizard on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:25PM (#47081255)
Canada is not ethnically or culturally homogeneous at all.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by robotresearcher on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:40PM (#47081427)
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pitched on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:34PM (#47081358)
Canada is 70% white where the US is close to 50%. That 20% puts them far above the majority line though. Not at all homogeneous, just much more so than the US.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by drbojingle on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:52PM (#47081567)
White is a color, not a culture. Quebec and Newfoundland are very different than Alberta and Saskatchewan.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pitched on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:22PM (#47081897)
I will say that perogies are amazing and were much cheaper in Alberta than Newfoundland so you get an upvote. But don’t discount that this is also true of the white population in the US.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by umanwizard on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:35PM (#47081380)
"White" is not one ethnicity or culture -- a lot of that 70% are French-speaking Quebeckers who surely cannot be considered part of a homogeneous mass with Anglo-Canadians.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by pitched on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:49PM (#47081534)
I’m upvoting you because you’re 110% right but don’t discount how diverse the US is too, without an obvious divider like that. The New Orleans Cajun are also French immigrants, for example.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by shiroiuma on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:55PM (#47083500)
No, they're not: they're the ancestors of Canadian refugees who were forcibly expelled from what used to be called "Arcadia".
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by alborzb on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:33AM (#47085697)
Incase anyone else is a wikipedia searcher like me, want to point out there's no 'R' in the historic colony.

Acadia - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acadia

Wanted to save other people time searching it up too

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by michaelteter on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:22PM (#47081223)
Are you suggesting that anyone who lives and works here in the US can be accepted as “American”?

Are you also implying that in the US anyone is free to speak negatively of “dear leader”?

There are a multitude of current examples to the contrary.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by michaelt on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:22PM (#47081905)
> Are you suggesting that anyone who lives and works here in the US can be accepted as “American”?

Whether you're born in Moscow and named Sergey Mikhailovich Brin, or born in Pretoria and named Elon Reeve Musk, or born in Hyderabad and named Satya Narayana Nadella, born in Frankfurt and named Peter Andreas Thiel - America has a place for you. Maybe even your own government department.

In America a man can find acceptance regardless of the circumstances of his birth, and irrespective of race, creed and colour, so long as he has a billion dollars.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rokhayakebe on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:39PM (#47083383)
America had a place for you.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ted_bunny on Friday February 20, 2026 @07:56AM (#47087430)
(Looking at Elon boat photos) Oh, that's what the founders meant by huddled masses!
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by LtWorf on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:17AM (#47087649)
Does it apply just to billionaires?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by rahkiin on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:27PM (#47081279)
The comment used the past tense in every sentence
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mystraline on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:35PM (#47081372)
Born here.

And yeah, used to. Past tense.

Not any more with der fuhrer.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by misnome on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:28PM (#47081284)
> used to be
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by paulddraper on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:48PM (#47081523)
> There are a multitude of current examples to the contrary.

I see negative opinions of government officials constantly.

It's basically all I see whenever I have the misfortune of turning on the TV.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by warkdarrior on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:54PM (#47081585)
Have you tried OAN or Fox News?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by paulddraper on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:06PM (#47081721)
Many many such negative opinions.

The only difference between channels is which government official is criticized.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mulmen on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:28PM (#47080554)
> China or Saudi Arabia can wave their money around, but at least some people will be repulsed by the obligation to keep their mouths shut and praise the Dear Leader.

I mean we are literally putting people in concentration camps right now. Kinda hard to take the moral high ground at the moment. Scientists are fleeing the United States for their safety, just like they did from 1930s Germany.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by paulddraper on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:50PM (#47081545)
Are you talking about the detention centers for immigrants?

And then comparing that to genocidal camps for Germans and conquered subjects?

Just making sure I'm reading this correctly here.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by dragonwriter on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:55PM (#47081597)
"Concentration camp” is a term that predates its (somewhat euphemistic, when done in retrospect) use for the camps eventually used in the extermnation campaign by the Nazis (which also started out as concentration camps, in the more usual sense, as part of what was nominally a deportation program.)

Though concentration camps are almost always part of systematic, ethnically-targetted abuse, even when they aren't part of genocide campaigns.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by paulddraper on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:01PM (#47081667)
Yes. For example, the U.S. also had ethnically-based "concentration camps" (but not extermination camps) during WWII.

But these are not like the concentration camps of the 1940s.

"Detention camps" are a more accurate descriptor -- both technically and connotatively -- when they are holding foreign nationals prior to repatriation.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mulmen on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:21PM (#47082447)
I’m having a hard time understanding how the ICE detention facilities do not meet the Wikipedia definition of concentration camp: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentration_camp. Can you help me out?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by paulddraper on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:35PM (#47083800)
Certainly!

“A concentration camp is a prison or other facility used for internment”

Internment is long-term (see Wikipedia), whereas the ICE detention centers are short-term (average stay < 30 days but depends on time for deportation ).

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mulmen on Thursday February 19, 2026 @11:45PM (#47083873)
> Internment is long-term (see Wikipedia),

The Wikipedia page for Internment [1] doesn't include the words long-term when I view it.

  Internment is the imprisonment of people, commonly in large groups, without charges or intent to file charges. The term is especially used for the confinement "of enemy citizens in wartime or of terrorism suspects". Thus, while it can simply mean imprisonment, it tends to refer to preventive confinement rather than confinement after having been convicted of some crime.
> ICE detention centers are short-term (average stay < 30 days but depends on time for deportation ).

Seamus Culleton has been held for 5 months so far [2]. I'm willing to accept this is an outlier but to my knowledge ICE isn't providing transparency on much of anything, including how long they are holding people. Do you have a source for your average 30 days claim?

E: According to AP [3] this is not an outlier:

  With the number of people in ICE detention topping 70,000 for the first time, 7,252 people had been in custody at least six months in mid-January, including 79 held for more than two years, according to agency data. That’s more than double the 2,849 who were in ICE custody at least six months in December 2024, the last full month of Joe Biden’s presidency.
This looks even worse when we consider [4]:

  Bond eligibility changed drastically in July 2025. ICE issued a memo eliminating bond hearings for most people who entered without inspection. They’re now classified as “applicants for admission” subject to mandatory detention.

  Cases moved faster before 2025. New policies have expanded mandatory detention. Court backlogs grew worse. The detained docket now averages 60-90 days for initial hearings, but stretches to years for final decisions.  

  As of November 2025, ICE held over 65,000 people. Three-quarters had no criminal convictions. Average detention length climbed from 47 days in FY2024 to over 50 days by mid-2025. Complex cases take much longer.  
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment

[2]: https://www.irishtimes.com/world/us/2026/02/12/seamus-cullet...

[3]: https://apnews.com/article/immigration-migrants-detention-tr...

[4]: https://blog.immigrationquestion.com/ice-detention-process-e...

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by WillPostForFood on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:30AM (#47084171)
Seamus Culleton is allowed to leave detention, he just can't stay in the US. He is choosing to stay in detention while he pursues legal challenges to his deportation order.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mulmen on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:00AM (#47084324)
Is that true of everyone held by ICE? I see that Seamus declined to be deported to Ireland immediately but does that offer remain open?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by paulddraper on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:48PM (#47091262)
It’s not timeframe per se, but rather holding indefinitely without actual charges.

Jails are not concentration camps. Detention centers are not concentration camps. (Unless they hold indefinitely without charges.)

Seamus Culleton is welcome to leave…to his country of citizenship. He illegally overstayed his visa, and wants to stay anyway.

ICE doesn’t want people in detention centers. Generally speaking they are all welcome to leave.

This is not the same as eg FDR’s Japanese internment camps, let alone Hilter’s.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mulmen on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:06PM (#47082320)
The Germans ran work camps, concentration camps, and death camps. Right now the United States is only running two of the three. We have work camps (prisons) and concentration camps (detention facilities).
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by shiroiuma on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:58PM (#47083521)
That you know of. The German people didn't even know about the death camps running in their own back yards; they thought they were just "regular" concentration/work camps. The Allied troops rounded up lots of German civilians near these camps after the war and forced them at gunpoint to walk through the camps and see for themselves what they had been supporting.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by deaux on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:58AM (#47084312)
This is on the level of the myth of the clean Wehrmacht.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by woodpanel on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:23PM (#47081232)
It is abhorrent, that these days, just because it serves one’s domestic political narrative, one is willing to paint the victims of state-organized industrial killings as mere illegal border crossers. The Nazi’s victims were German citizens, not illegal migrants.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by tombert on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:34PM (#47081364)
I’m not sure who told you that the Nazis only killed German citizens, considering that they famously invaded Poland (a sovereign nation at the time) and started executing Jews there.

I also don’t know who told you that they’re only putting illegal migrants in Alligator Alcatraz. It’s not hard to find examples of people who had legal visas being rounded up because of the Trump administration’s idiotic quota policy.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by paulddraper on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:53PM (#47081580)
And you don't see a difference between detaining visitors versus invading other nations?

They are quite literally opposites.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by tombert on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:28PM (#47082910)
Of course there’s a difference. I’m not sure I understand your point.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ethanwillis on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:16PM (#47081151)
Don't get it twisted. While what is happening is not right, explain to me what happens when there is criticism of China from within China on their treatment of Uyghurs.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by mulmen on Thursday February 19, 2026 @08:12PM (#47082370)
[delayed]
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by indiangenz on Friday February 20, 2026 @03:13AM (#47085161)
Where should illegal immigrants be placed, if not in a confinement facility? Which "Scientists" are fleeing the US, and to where exactly? Countries such as China don't have an illegal immigrant issue because they don't care about political correctness and they take action against illegals with an iron hand; nor do they give out citizenship like candies.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by cyanydeez on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:53PM (#47080858)
America is hostile to science and technology. I'm not sure how anyone with a functional desire to improve humanity decides "Hey, those americans, they sure do deserve better vaccines."
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by eleventyseven on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:01PM (#47080959)
> I'm not sure how anyone with a functional desire to improve humanity decides "Hey, those americans, they sure do deserve better vaccines."

Because people understand that people don't get to choose their government or culture and that everyone deserves better healthcare. Every child who is at risk from the rise of anti-vax 100% deserves better vaccines and ought to bear 0% responsibility for what the adults do.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ohyoutravel on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:23PM (#47081233)
Lots of folks vote against better healthcare. Perhaps they “deserve” better healthcare regardless as they’re human, but perhaps they deserve the outcomes they specifically voted for. Otherwise it feels a little paternalistic.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by eleventyseven on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:44PM (#47081478)
Children didn't vote for this, you psychopath. Do you take a smug delight in seeing children die from preventable diseases because of the terrible decisions of their parents?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:53PM (#47082204)
What if I feel terrible for the children, but feel a smug delight over watching their parents mourn the loss that they could have easily prevented?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by eleventyseven on Friday February 20, 2026 @08:10AM (#47087570)
Then you are a psychopath. I truly feel sorry for you.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Sohcahtoa82 on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:19PM (#47090854)
If you say so.

I have empathy, but that empathy ends when people are dealing with direct consequences of their actions.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by dheera on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:23PM (#47080476)
> Not everything is about money.

It is when researchers can't make enough money to eat and live, which is an actual reality in the US right now.

Researchers at top institutions often make less than Uber drivers.

There are other countries where you can live on less and the government isn't dipping their hands into your pockets every 5 seconds.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by inglor_cz on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:27PM (#47080541)
Some people will switch careers, but I do doubt that in an economy with very low unemployment amongst qualified people, any actual scientist will literally starve and become homeless.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ikrenji on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:57PM (#47081611)
maybe not starve, but should scientists live in poverty?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by hsuduebc2 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:57PM (#47080921)
Well yea, but I suppose that exceptional molecular biologist can use his potential somewhere else better than as a lower manager in a corporate.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by dragonwriter on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:58PM (#47081621)
> The killer app of the US used to be that the US was rich and welcoming to foreigners and politically quite free.

Yeah, it used to be the that the US only committed ethnic cleansing against people that were here first, not foreigners, and was so welcoming to foreigners that it would expend resources to have them shipped here as property.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by hunterpayne on Friday February 20, 2026 @07:32AM (#47087203)
We used to teach a nuanced, honest version of history too. Apparently that doesn't happen anymore.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by deaux on Friday February 20, 2026 @12:54AM (#47084279)
> The US was quite unique (together with Canada, Australia etc.) that it was able and willing to accept you as an American even with a funny accent, as long as you wanted to be one.

Very select parts of the US. Would've thought that the last 9 years taught you that for huge swathes of it, this was never true.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by eunos on Friday February 20, 2026 @04:48AM (#47085809)
US State Department already asked for social media accounts. Chinese visa applications dont.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ljsprague on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:36PM (#47080675)
They sound like very loyal people who I would love to have as my compatriots.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by kettlecorn on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:46PM (#47080769)
Many of the world's most intelligent and caring people are loyal to values over tribe.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ljsprague on Monday February 23, 2026 @06:34PM (#47130629)
Values don't reproduce; tribes do.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday February 23, 2026 @08:49PM (#47131847)
tribes don't reproduce; people do.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by AnimalMuppet on Monday February 23, 2026 @09:05PM (#47131972)
Tribes reproduce as the people who make up the tribe reproduce.

Values reproduce as the people who hold them reproduce, plus as others adopt those values, minus as those who hold those values drop them.

But the US was supposed to be a country where values mattered more than tribe. "We hold these truths to be self evident", and all that, and if you accepted the values, you belonged. That was an imperfect ideal, but it was the ideal until rather recently. I'm not sure to what degree it still is.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ljsprague on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @02:32PM (#47156601)
Are we ever allowed to stop being a "values country" and just be a normal one? Or are we at least allowed to change our values? Are we allowed to make that decision for ourselves?
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:09PM (#47158730)
If you want to change values like "equal rights" and "rule of law", you may be able to do so, but you probably have to amend the constitution to do it.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:28PM (#47159550)
A country based on shared values is normal.

And we are of course allowed to change that, if that is what the people want, but a minority should not make that decision on behalf of the whole.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Natfan on Thursday February 19, 2026 @05:42PM (#47080730)
they can't be your compatriots if you imprison them, nor if they've to death due to working without any funding, also know as "pay"
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by Natfan on Friday February 20, 2026 @09:11AM (#47088272)
s/they've to death/they've starved to death/
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by kg on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:45PM (#47081497)
Loyalty is earned. They don't owe me or you any loyalty if we mistreat them.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by ljsprague on Monday February 23, 2026 @06:33PM (#47130624)
There's no mistreatment alleged though: the US is bad because it stopped funding their jobs.
Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by crystal_revenge on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:49PM (#47081538)
> Scientists go where science is funded.

DeepMind, OpenAI, and Anthropic pay quite well for research and have better "labs" than most places on Earth. I don't believe they're struggling to hire either.

This article is using a relatively outdated definition, functionally speaking, of "research institute".

Traditional research institutions, especially academia, have been declining for decades and current funding problems are just another one of many problems thrown into the mix.

I remember well a world where most serious research happened in universities and was publicly funded. I personally think that was a better world, but that is not the world we live in today and I don't see us going back. Even China's most impressive research is not coming from publicly controlled research institutes or universities but from VCs and large corporations.

To be fair, the time of open public science was a relatively brief in it's long history.

Re:We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain ki... by renjimen on Thursday February 19, 2026 @06:59PM (#47081642)
For every scientific discipline that is well represented across modern corporate labs there are a dozen that are not. Most "serious" research is not directly connected to making money.