News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by dehrmann on Sunday July 20, 2025 @04:53PM (#44629225)
> With fewer visitors, Stack Overflow is seeing fewer questions posted on its message boards

When you operate a community that's hostile to questions that have already been answered, are poorly researched, or are homework, don't be surprised when people start taking those questions elsewhere, and don't be surprised when they start asking their good questions elsewhere, too.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by atleastoptimal on Sunday July 20, 2025 @08:09PM (#44630612)
Stack Overflow existed because it had a moat on specific bug-fix related coding information that wasn't available elsewhere, or the mechanisms/community to solicit that information wasn't available elsewhere. Its moat naturally dissolves when a chatbot can offer all that plus more. So we have to think, what other moats will dissolve as AI gets better, cheaper, more effectively and widely deployed?

Will law firms be a thing, or basically just a formality because laws still require humans to submit cases? Will therapists still exist when AI therapy could be scientifically and anecdotally shown to be 10x as effective and much less expensive? A lot of inertia will exist because of trust, people's bias towards "the way things have always been", but as the difference in utility between traditional services and AI-powered services grow, that inertia will not be able to resist the force of change.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by zdragnar on Sunday July 20, 2025 @11:36PM (#44631560)
Expertsexchange was around at the time. SO's moat was they gave away access for free instead of pretending that paying got you better answers.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Applejinx on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:28AM (#44632944)
Law is founded on the idea that reality matters and just making stuff up won't work there. If you could just hallucinate things and run with that there would be no reason for law because it wouldn't matter whether anything was true.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by atleastoptimal on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:08PM (#44640434)
The whole point of the legal profession is stretching the truth to the furthest extent towards your aims while remaining nominally within a given framework. LLM's are very good at that and are becoming increasingly good at that, and will be better at humans than that in the near future (if they aren't already)
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by kmfrk on Sunday July 20, 2025 @04:57PM (#44629249)
Yeah, asking a programming question without some bitter old coder tut-tutting you is very much a selling point with AI chatbots, regardless of my reservations with the overall trend.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bazoom42 on Sunday July 20, 2025 @05:20PM (#44629410)
Sure, but this is only possible because the LLM is trained on those answers.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by andy99 on Sunday July 20, 2025 @08:12PM (#44630624)
It was bootstrapped from SO. Now there are third party data companies like Scale AI that pay gig workers to write code examples for LLM training. It's died down but I saw lots of spam for this (ie hiring) earlier in the year.

Sota LLMs didn't get that way by scraping the internet, it's all custom labeled datasets.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by asdff on Sunday July 20, 2025 @11:52PM (#44631657)
I guess that means AI isn't relieving us of our jobs then. Model must ingest ever more experimental data. Full circle.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by golergka on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:15AM (#44631762)
No, at this point it can just ingest official library documentation and produce good SO-like answers.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Shorn on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:44AM (#44631871)
Plus, they're getting real world training data from everyone who either hasn't or doesn't have the ability to opt out of their stuff being used.

For my personal stuff, I don't opt out of training for this very reason. What's more, I resent Stack Overflow and Reddit etc. trying to gate-keep the content that I wanted to give to the community and charge rent for it.

I used to intentionally post question-answer style posts where I would both ask the question,wait for a while, then answer the question on both Reddit and Stack Overflow. I don't do that anymore because I'm not giving them free money if they're not passing some of the benefit on to the community

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by miltonlost on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:16AM (#44634742)
> For my personal stuff, I don't opt out of training for this very reason. What's more, I resent Stack Overflow and Reddit etc. trying to gate-keep the content that I wanted to give to the community and charge rent for it.

And AI companies don't charge for their stuff and charge rent?

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by ack_inc on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @01:34AM (#44643538)
"... resent SO and Reddit trying to gatekeep": Am curious why you felt they were gatekeeping your content. They are free websites, and anybody who wants/needs to read your content, can.

"... not giving them free money if they're notnpassing some of the benefits ..." - Could you expand on the specific benefits you wanted them to pass on to the community? As a user, being able to find other people's content that is relevant to my current need is already a pretty solid benefit.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Jensson on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:13AM (#44633193)
No, no publicly available model can do that, why do you think so?
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by nudgeOrnurture on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:40AM (#44633340)
so you have to ask on SO how to train that into your custom model running on Ponzimbda's hAIrdware
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by asdff on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @05:20PM (#44653143)
Too bad library documentation has taken a nosedive for a lot of modern tools. I blame all those automagic documentation/packaging tools that take some 2 line string and your args for each function and turn it into a boilerplate documentation page. You truly learn nothing you wouldn't by just looking at the source code of the function for pages generated like this. The author spends no additional time adding potentially useful information. A far cry from what you get when you man bash for example, where they even teach you how to file a bug report.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by stuaxo on Sunday July 27, 2025 @03:03AM (#44699402)
Unless you pay decent rates the code will be shite, otherwise outsourcing to underpriced developers would have worked in the last push to rid businesses of the expense of skilled developers.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by protocolture on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:06PM (#44630216)
Sure, but the technology peels off the aggravation and delivers the content without the asshats.

If someone stuck an LLM between me and facebook, so I got all my facebook content without the flat earthers, moon landing deniers and tartarians, meta would never see me again.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by didgetmaster on Sunday July 20, 2025 @09:42PM (#44631044)
That's not good enough. The AI has to give me updates on important events of my friends and family without showing me everything they ate at restaurants, funny cat videos they liked, or what movies they planned to watch.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by rusk on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:50AM (#44633068)
> has to give me updates on important events of my friends and family without showing me everything

That’s a RAG query

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by AznHisoka on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:54AM (#44634131)
If you didnt hear about it directly from them, its not important
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by karaterobot on Sunday July 20, 2025 @06:51PM (#44630124)
Proving that AI is not just parroting back what it reads on the web, ChatGPT manages to correct my programming mistakes without making me feel bad. If it learned from Substack, I'm glad it learned selectively!
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by guelo on Sunday July 20, 2025 @10:42PM (#44631323)
I'm afraid programming is going to be frozen at 2020s tech for the foreseeable future. New frameworks, libraries and languages will suffer from a chicken and egg problem where no one uses them because LLMs don't know how to answer questions about them and LLMs can't learn the new stuff because programmers aren't generating new samples for the LLMs to ingest.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by username3 on Sunday July 20, 2025 @11:37PM (#44631569)
You should see what Elixir is doing with Tidewave and usage rules.

https://www.zachdaniel.dev/p/usage-rules-leveling-the-playin...

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by wombatpm on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:35AM (#44631838)
Rise of the documentation specialist. Where specs and standards and documentation and design documentation is required and not just an afterthought.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by oulu2006 on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:12AM (#44631970)
not sure if that's a bad thing when it comes for FE frameworks - not reinventing it every 5-7 years i think is a good thing.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by rikroots on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:15AM (#44632545)
This is why I've had to spend a huge amount of my free coding time this year documenting my canvas library[1][2] in a way that can (potentially[3]) be used as LLM training data instead of, well, developing my library with new and exciting (to me) features.

On the silver lining side, it's work that I should have been doing anyway. It turns out that documenting the features of the library in a way that makes sense to LLMs also helps potential users of the library. So, win:win.

[1] - Telling the LLM training data Overlords about the capabilities of the library is in itself a major piece of work: https://github.com/KaliedaRik/Scrawl-canvas/blob/v8/LLM-summ...

[2] - The Developer Runbook was long-overdue documentation, and is still a work-in-progress: https://scrawl-v8.rikweb.org.uk/documentation

[3] - Nothing is guaranteed, of course. Training data has to be curated so documentation needs to have some rigour to it. Also, the LLMs tell me it can take 6-12 months for such documentation to be picked up and applied to future LLM model iterations so I won't know if my efforts have been successful before mid-2026.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by imtringued on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:26AM (#44633575)
Small models aren't large enough to have knowledge about every single framework or library through pre-training and yet if you give them a man page/API reference they easily figure out how to use the new code.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by nbaugh1 on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:31AM (#44634878)
Or developers will have more free time to solve novel problems instead of wasting hours digging through Google results and StackOverflow threads to find answers to already solved problems
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by watwut on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:00AM (#44635203)
They will spend more time solving new problems, the same new problems as everyone else. They wont be writing answers anywhere tho.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bluefirebrand on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:57PM (#44637479)
They will be writing the answers into codebases that AI will be ingesting, but it will lack any context about the question it is answering so AI won't know how it relates to anything else
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by watwut on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:59AM (#44635188)
Yeah, I think that too. Same with non programming domains. Since your blog and what not wont be seen, just ingested by LLM, there will be even less motivation to write them. And they were already dying also due to need for SEO, otherwise you dont exist.

So, that stuff will just cease to exist in its previous amounts and we will all move on.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by kmfrk on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:54AM (#44635862)
I've been wondering the same too. uv has completely transformed the Python workflow, and I really hope future documentation and knowledge bases incorporate it, but time will tell.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by mvdtnz on Sunday July 20, 2025 @11:09PM (#44631435)
Not my problem as a user.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by fmbb on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:31AM (#44632321)
Not really.

The overlap between people bothering to answer ”stupid question, RTFM” and people able to give useful answers is extremely small.

The meaningful data the LLMs are trained on is the actual answers.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by mnky9800n on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:32AM (#44632973)
I don’t feel sorry for those that have lost because they couldn’t be nice to others. Being nice costs nothing. And it’s nice to be nice.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Cthulhu_ on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:12AM (#44633502)
True, but the LLM is always polite and in problem solving mode, while SO is in a curating mode. This makes it a great knowledge base and LLM training set, but not a great source to have your questions answered.

I think a big part of why people prefer to ask an online forum instead of using the search function is the human interaction aspect, but that requires two people, including a mentor who is patient and helpful - and unfortunately, that's difficult to find. An LLM is patient, helpful, and problem-solving, but also responds pretty much immediately.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by rob74 on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:20AM (#44633887)
Yeah, the helpful LLM always has an answer to your questions - if it can't find one, it'll simply hallucinate one.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by FranzFerdiNaN on Monday July 21, 2025 @08:14AM (#44634254)
At least it wont tell you to stfu and get better and close the chat like SO will do.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by dagw on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:39AM (#44634027)
Sure, but so will SO. On most questions it seems that at least a third of the answers are just wrong in one way or another. At least with an LLM you can just tell it's wrong and have a new, hopefully better, answers 30 seconds later, all without hurting its feelings or getting into a massive online flame war.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by BeFlatXIII on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:49AM (#44636631)
But it won't hallucinate a vote to close as duplicate (of another language entirely, last updated in 2013).
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by imtringued on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:23AM (#44633557)
A lot of the questions asked on stack overflow can be answered by reading the source code and documentation of the libraries and frameworks. An LLM can do the same thing. It doesn't need stack overflow for knowledge or content, it needs it for the question->answer format.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by 01HNNWZ0MV43FF on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:15PM (#44636963)
If there's a wiki effort to contribute our private LLM responses back into the public pool, I'll join it to spite the AI companies.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by jay_kyburz on Sunday July 20, 2025 @05:09PM (#44629334)
The sarcastic enthusiasm and fake humanity from the LLMs is wearing thin as well if you ask me.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by theshackleford on Sunday July 20, 2025 @05:32PM (#44629496)
The difference is I can instruct an LLM (and have) to knock that shit off.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bilbo0s on Sunday July 20, 2025 @06:15PM (#44629860)
True. Humans don’t take direction very well.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Gigachad on Sunday July 20, 2025 @08:56PM (#44630830)
Which is good to some extent. We have people off the deep end sharing “unlock/jailbreak prompts” which turn LLMs in to schizophrenia machines affirming any psychosis. While a real person would push back and try to get you help.

ChatGPT can’t tell the difference between being given a harmless instruction / role play prompt, vs someone who is going insane. Probably explains why many of the most vocal AI users seem detached from reality, it’s the first time they have someone who blindly affirms everything they think while telling them they are so smart and completely correct all the time.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by jay_kyburz on Sunday July 20, 2025 @10:17PM (#44631202)
Those stack overflow dudes would be savage if you started posting crazy manifestos looking for feedback.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by morgoths_bane on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:21AM (#44632011)
>Probably explains why many of the most vocal AI users seem detached from reality, it’s the first time they have someone who blindly affirms everything they think while telling them they are so smart and completely correct all the time.

I am glad I am not the only one that has noticed this. The one thing that is unsettling is how they keep talking about the Singularity as if it is this incoming event in our near future. I am somewhat sceptical that somehow the same humanity that is collectively down the Kardaschev scale is going to create a god like being with technology that is not that far advanced in the future.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by jay_kyburz on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:26AM (#44632605)
When I look at how far tech has come in my own life, I'm mid 50's, I don't think the singularity is out of the question in my kids life, or even my own if I'm lucky. When I born there was no such thing as a PC or the internet.

As far as I'm aware, the only missing step is for the llms to be able to roll the results of a test back into its training set. It can then start proposing hypotheses and testing them. Then it can do logic.

I don't understand the skepticism. LLMs are already a lot smarter than me, all they need is the ability to learn.

** Wikipedia definition of singularity. "an upgradable intelligent agent could eventually enter a positive feedback loop of successive self-improvement cycles; more intelligent generations would appear more and more rapidly, causing a rapid increase ("explosion") in intelligence that culminates in a powerful superintelligence, far surpassing all human intelligence.[4]"

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by johnnyanmac on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:22AM (#44633244)
>LLMs are already a lot smarter than me

That's highly doubtful, not unless your definition of intelligence requires volume of regurgiting information and not contextualizing and building on such knowledge. LLMs are "smart" in the same way a person who gets 1600 on the SAT* is "smart". If you spend your time minmaxing towards a specific task, you get very good at it. That skill can even get you as far in life as being a subject matter expert. But that's not why humans are "inelligent" in my eyes.

*yes, there is correlation. Because people who take the time to study and memorize for a test tend to have better work habits than those that don't. But there's a reason why some of those kinds of students can end up completely lost in college despite their diligence to study.

>I don't understand the skepticism.

To be frank, we're in a time where grifts are running wild and grifters are running away red handed. Inside and outside of tech. I am very septical by default in 2025 for anyone who talks in terms of "what can happen" and not what is actually practical or possible.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by jay_kyburz on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:00PM (#44640899)
I'm no Math Olympic Athlete, and I have a terrible memory.

I don't know what they definition of smart is, but you don't have to listen to any of the grifters to know that the current LLMs can do a lot things better than the average person.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by johnnyanmac on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:39PM (#44641631)
It's a machine. I or no I, we knew for decades what they can excel at and what they fall far short of. Llms only amplify those steneghrs and weaknesses.

My definition of intelligence logical intelligence involves the following factors:

- able to recognize patterns in data, even complex ones (machines have always excelled in this, with aid of a human) - an ability to break down complex concepts into fundamentals. I.e seductive reasoning (LLMs as of now don't really do this) - conversely, the ability to learn new concepts and apply them to more complex situations (LLMs especially cannot do this without human assistance) - the ability to synthesize a set of data and come to a conclusion given an environmental context. I.e. Critical reasoning (Ai as of now is poor at this. Partially by design, as critique is avoided in their behavior).

As a few criteria. Artificial "intelligence" as of now is simply leveraging its superior pattern matching to give the illusion of reasoning, and it's mimicry is close enough for non-subject matter experts to choose to believe its output.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by TheOtherHobbes on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:18AM (#44633533)
Until now computing was running on a completely different model of implied reliability. The base hardware is supposed to be as reliable as possible, software is supposed to mostly work and bugs are tolerated because they're hard to fix. No one is suggesting they're a good thing.

LLMs are more like something that looks like a text only web-browser, but you have no idea if it's producing genius or gibberish. "Just ignore the mistakes, if you can be bothered to check if they're there" is quite the marketing pitch.

The biggest development in tech has been the change in culture - from utopian libertarian "Give everyone a bicycle for the mind and watch the joy" to the corporate cynicism of "Collect as much personal information as you can get away with, and use it to modify behaviour, beliefs, and especially spending and voting, to maximise corporate profits and extreme wealth."

While the technology has developed, the values have run headlong in the opposite direction.

It's questionable if a culture with these values is even capable of creating a singularity without destroying itself first.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by sjsdaiuasgdia on Monday July 21, 2025 @08:45AM (#44634471)
> LLMs are already a lot smarter than me

You are almost certainly underestimating yourself and overestimating LLMs.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by stevedonovan on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:06AM (#44632509)
So the cognitive reality of being a billionaire is now available to everyone?
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by SV_BubbleTime on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:25AM (#44632029)
You’re absolutely right! (tm)
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by ChrisRR on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:28AM (#44633956)
See any brit trying to deal with american coworkers
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by greenavocado on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:08AM (#44634665)
Just add "Respond in an insolent caustic acerbic style" to the end of each prompt
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by kamaal on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:14AM (#44634728)
>>fake humanity

I'd rather be treated nice by a bot, than be abused by a human. Make whatever of this you will.

Though I know the bot is not sentient. I'd rather chat with it, than some human who doesn't talk well.

Im guessing the future of relationships works the same way. All the best competing with a bot that makes you feel nice, than a spouse/partner who doesn't.

It will be a hard era to come for people who misbehave. The tolerance for that sort of stuff is going to go away entirely.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bluefirebrand on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:02PM (#44637542)
> It will be a hard era to come for people who misbehave. The tolerance for that sort of stuff is going to go away entirely

This is perhaps one of the most fascist sentences I've ever read

No more "misbehaving" only perfect conformity

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by kamaal on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @01:22AM (#44643483)
I dont know what this means.

Are you saying people who don't willingly offer to become punching bags for abusive people are fascists?

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Timwi on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @02:50PM (#44651430)
Yeah sorry, but I think you massively misread that take. It's not about conformity. It's about keeping yourself liked so that people will voluntarily interact with you. You can no longer get away with being a narcissistic arsehole.

I'm not sure I agree that's gonna happen, I'm just trying to paraphrase what I think the GP meant.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by jlaternman on Sunday August 03, 2025 @04:56AM (#44775171)
I see what you mean as in no tolerance for abusive people that can currently get away with overtly treating people like shit, but I do immediately think “that generally captures the more trivial abusers.” The most destructive ones tend to be covert, and more often will appear as friendly and polite as LLMs when setting up their targets. That makes me wonder if it will create a harder or easier era for them. Not something I’ve thought on before to have formed an opinion, but it makes me wonder.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by empath75 on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:34AM (#44634906)
I sometimes think that the killer app for LLMs isn't that they are especially smart, but that they are infinitely patient.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by stephenmac98 on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @06:09PM (#44653562)
Is the conclusion here not that you are asking questions when you should instead have been looking for an existing resource?

The ability to search across the massive accumulation of knowledge we have already built up is a primary skill for software development, and the tut-tut'ing is a way of letting you know that you failed in that endeavor, which should be valuable feedback in itself.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bubblethink on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:12PM (#44630264)
I still use SO out of habit, but they make it really difficult to use it. Everything on the web is gated behind ridiculous captchas now. More than the AI, the legacy websites will die because they are too busy trying to prevent AI companies from scraping the content and have ruined the product in the process.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bluefirebrand on Sunday July 20, 2025 @09:09PM (#44630886)
Seems pretty crappy to blame the websites for this instead of the AI companies, who are the really bad actors here
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by anigbrowl on Sunday July 20, 2025 @09:41PM (#44631040)
Agreed, but SO was bad before LLMs showed up. Almost all expert communities seem to develop problems with gatekeepers and ego trippers past a certain size.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bluefirebrand on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:03AM (#44631695)
Ego trippers are bad, I agree

But gatekeeping is actually good if you care about quality, and I think we're going to discover that more with LLMs

They might democratize code but the code produced will be very low quality. Once coding communities start getting overrun with "Please help me fix my LLM generated code" we'll wish we did a bit more gatekeeping

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by fragmede on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:51AM (#44636664)
I'll take that job for the right pay, so I don't see the problem. Stack overflow gatekeepers close questions, with links to a similar question, and reasons why it's not a duplicate, as a duplicate. Better yet, the answer scoring system keeps accepted answers from 7 years ago as the top rated answer when the library and ecosystem's moved on, and that answer no longer works. Gatekeeping itself is not inherently bad, I agree, but Stack Overflow has become aggressively hostile to its original mission.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bluefirebrand on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:13PM (#44637676)
> I'll take that job for the right pay, so I don't see the problem

The problem for me at least is that companies can be irrational longer than I can remain solvent, so "the right pay" feels like it is going to wind up being "whatever man I just need to pay my bills".

I suspect I'm not alone. I actually suspect that I'm the very common case. And it's not because I'm bad with money or broke either. it's just because I can't afford to retire and companies can afford to be irrational a long, long time

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by fragmede on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:18PM (#44638531)
Interesting. My thoughts are from the other direction. As someone who's been programming for a while, if we presume novices (with money) are using LLMs to write programs but that the LLMs are getting stuck, and they just need some (human) help fixing their code, then I'm happy to help them untangle their mess, if they pay me for my time.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bluefirebrand on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:24PM (#44640012)
I've actually had this job before in the past, fixing the novice code of someone who came before

It didn't pay nearly well enough to make it worth the headache for me

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @12:39AM (#44643285)
>But gatekeeping is actually good if you care about quality, and I think we're going to discover that more with LLMs

The people who you might be justified in gatekeeping against are the very same who become the gatekeepers. They gravitate towards that role because deliberately or instinctively they understand that they either capture it, or get blocked by it.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by mrkeen on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:39AM (#44633013)
Nope. Stack Overflow partnered with OpenAI.

It's just us humans that get the bad experience.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Mars008 on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @03:22PM (#44651840)
> Seems pretty crappy to blame the websites for this instead of the AI companies, who are the really bad actors here

Not sure who is bad. AI companies trying to make public knowledge easily available or web sites trying to lock and monetize users' content. It's now capchas, JS, and tracking everywhere. I'm supposed to go through all of this to contribute to website so that others go through all of it to read. Add to that flashing and jumping adds which make even more unpleasant. And yes, my contribution will be locked instead of made public.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by 6Az4Mj4D on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:52PM (#44630511)
I prefer Reddit communities over SO any day. SO, folks are so high headed, they will bash you with anything that doesn't suit their framework. I am sure with GPTs slowly they will lose traffic.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by socalgal2 on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:39AM (#44632358)
Reddit has been 1000x worse than S.O. for me. (and S.O. sucks)

Reddit = Question asked 6 months to 5 years ago. Auto-closed because age. Answer is out of date. Ask again, get's closed as already asked.

Reddit has all the same mod problems as S.O. but it's worse because it's goal isn't to provide info, it's to be social media.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by DharmaPolice on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:10AM (#44633171)
Threads don't get closed due to age on Reddit (they used to be archived but this stopped a while back). Mods can lock threads but this is used to moderate content.

And which subreddit locked your thread because a similar question was asked six months ago? I find that difficult to believe.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by iknowstuff on Sunday July 20, 2025 @04:58PM (#44629255)
It's an easy critique of stack overflow, sure, but the same applies to reddit tbh. It's quickly becoming far more worthwhile to chat with AI than get angry at stupid, predictably reactionary reddit comments - and you’re not reaching many people, you’re just used for training a model, or for advertising opportunities for sleazy subreddit owners
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by mittensc on Sunday July 20, 2025 @06:11PM (#44629819)
Try and follow /new on raspberry_pi or similar...

You'll see reason for the hate, mainly with people not bothering to spend any time searching before posting.

And it is getting worse, new people asking help: 'but chatgpt told me X', 'I followed chatgpt and it doesnt work, please help fix bug', or some idiots that might burn the house down and deserve yelling (li-ion batteries aren't a joke, ac current likewise)

Or... LLM generated stuff... which is equal to spam...

If some people like doing unappreciated tech support all power to them, others might fight through spam to find nice items, I mostly stopped bothering and looking for something else. (also yelling at idiots that might kill themselves)

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by pluto_modadic on Sunday July 20, 2025 @09:31PM (#44630992)
> "not bothering to spend any time searching"

because searching has become MUCH worse, and because even when it used to be good, searching is a SKILL.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by eddythompson80 on Sunday July 20, 2025 @11:00PM (#44631392)
If you block beginners questions and posts then the entire community becomes pretty hostile and annoying to be in.

If you don't block beginners then the entire community will leave and you end up with the /r/suggestALaptop type subreddit. A woodworking subreddit will have 3 daily "What's the best table saw for a beginner" and "Dewalt vs Milwakee?" threads and anyone who cares will leave and you're left with all the bots and people trying to sell you stuff.

The funny thing is that didn't use to be a problem in online communities back in the day. Every forum has a "New Users" section, a beginner section, maybe an intermediate section and an advanced section. There were forums I would hang out on in the beginners and common areas and only readonly the advanced area until I felt confident enough to participate in the conversation there intelligently or to even have a smart enough question to ask.

This doesn't work in a place like reddit or stackoverflow. Those places are simply too big to have a cohesive consistent "culture" (for lack of a better word). You can't turn newbies away from /r/3dprinting because no body is on /r/4dprinting_for_beginniers. And people on the former don't care about the latter because it's not part of "the community".

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by mittensc on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:10AM (#44632524)
Back in the day it also used to be a problem and answer used to be 'get better' or 'rtfm' and general laughter.

That I used to find mean, now I see it as necessary but nobody does it anymore (lack of anonimity I guess)

If someone fails to do basic research that then it's on them. They lack basic grit or other skills that they should learn.

Also, someone asking the same basic question that, id typed in google would have led them to previous threads is a special type of idiocy or attention seekinf

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by matwood on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:46AM (#44632123)
> You'll see reason for the hate, mainly with people not bothering to spend any time searching before posting.

As a beginner at anything it’s hard to search. It’s the “you don’t know what you don’t know problem”. I see this all the time both as the expert and the beginner.

On topics I understand, I can craft a google query that will drop exactly what I’m looking for as the first result. On new topics I have to query and scan over and over until I start to hone in on some key words.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by mittensc on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:07AM (#44632513)
usual answer before was get better.

get better at searching, read documentation, manuals, books, articles, etc.

When you are stuck with something non trivial usually other people will jump to help as they've likely spent time on it as well.

If someone fails to do that then it's on them. They lack basic grit or other skills that they should learn.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by BeFlatXIII on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:53AM (#44636680)
>utterly failing to understand that it's a bootstrapping problem

How does one know where to start? Which manual to read first?

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by mittensc on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:16PM (#44636965)
search for "<topic x> tutorial"

read the right hand side section on each reddit group dedicated to begginers.

read some manuals/books...

what you said only fails for novel topics like quantum computing.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by BeFlatXIII on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @05:30PM (#44653229)
> search for "<topic x> tutorial"

As if that wouldn't be spammed with SEO slop.

> read some manuals/books

Knowing which ones are credible is part of the bootstrapping.

> right hand side section on each reddit group dedicated to begginers

That's probably a useful advice, as they'd likely list which books are good and which are even better but useless for beginners.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by burnte on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:31PM (#44630390)
I never ask questions on any SO site, and I'm a 30 year professional. It really feels like the only people that post are people who wish no one else would ever post.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by stevage on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:52PM (#44630510)
What is the "elsewhere" you have in mind?

I think it really is as simple as the AIs give better answers faster in most cases.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bluefirebrand on Sunday July 20, 2025 @09:10PM (#44630895)
The problem I have is that is not really true

If the AI is capable of solving the problem quickly then it is usually the case that the question and answer are almost verbatim the first google search result from SO anyways

That's not really any faster

It might be faster for things that don't have a good SO answer, but tbh then it's usually much lower quality

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by morgoths_bane on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:34AM (#44632075)
That has been my experience as well, I would ask Chat GPT a question, and then I would also look on SO and both answers were more often than not basically the same.

I have been trying to reduce how much I use ChatGPT and I think I have made solid progress, I saw two noteable studies that have influenced my decision to go this way, one was the recent MIT study that showed that ChatGPT ruins your cognitive abilities (at least with regards towards coding) and the second was this study https://metr.org/blog/2025-07-10-early-2025-ai-experienced-o... that was able to produce results where their developers were actually slowed down by using LLMs and also more consequently these developers incorrectly believed that they were faster with these tools.

So at least in the current state of things I have decided it is better to not really engage with these tools.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by PenguinCoder on Sunday July 20, 2025 @08:07PM (#44630601)
Before I can even see a question or answer on this Q&A site, I get three overlays entirely covering anything useful. Log into Google. Join stack overflow! Cookie consent banner. Asinine.

No thank you and get the hell out of my face.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by muppetman on Sunday July 20, 2025 @06:57PM (#44630163)
Amen. I will have a small party the day that SO goes away. What a bunch of aholes.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by LtWorf on Sunday July 20, 2025 @05:38PM (#44629548)
But without stackoverflow how do you think the AI will be able to reply about next year's new programming language?
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by omneity on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:59PM (#44630546)
Eventually through experience and self-play with the technologies in question.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by unlikelytomato on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:26PM (#44630362)
adding the documentation to the training material and drawing on the vast amount of coding context training it already relies on.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Incipient on Sunday July 20, 2025 @09:02PM (#44630855)
And it's still just going to give me crappy syntax. The number of times I need to tell copilot to PLESE not use Optional[] typing syntax in Python is mind boggling.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by riku_iki on Sunday July 20, 2025 @06:16PM (#44629869)
LLM can give many answers using absorbed docs and codebase.

Rest still could be asked/answered on SO or github.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by LtWorf on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:35PM (#44641165)
What codebase? It wouldn't exist for a new technology. And documentation doesn't have the volume LLMs need
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by riku_iki on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:03PM (#44641366)
language codebase, they have some tests there for example, using which model can see what are the correct typical implementation details.

> And documentation doesn't have the volume LLMs need

why do you think so? It looks like LLM has some level of few shots generalization.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by arwhatever on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:02AM (#44632188)
Stack Overflow is a programming Q&A website where people get mad at you for asking programming questions the overwhelming majority of the time.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bapak on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:26AM (#44632295)
My most souring experience on SO was posting a comment below an answer pointing out that it did not answer the question and merely repeated it.

The comment was deleted, and deleted again when I posted it again.

Then the author of the answer went on meta and complained about my behavior, from which came a barrage of downvotes on my answer.

Now think which answer has 4 times as many votes as his answer, years later? Mine. But why delete the comment? Why not just reply? I don't get it. It wasn't even a mod, it was just someone with 3k points, much less than I have.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by amelius on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:44AM (#44632696)
It was a very useful website, though. If AI didn't kill it, we would still be using it.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by blindstitch on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:32PM (#44638707)
I think something else would come in its place, like an automated way of trying out the options for solutions that you get when using it. Which AI incidentally is pretty good at.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bryanrasmussen on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:47AM (#44632712)
right Stack Overflow over the years has gone from a site where it was useful to ask questions about stuff you knew nothing about in order to learn to becoming a site where you ask things you already almost have the answer to, get 90% of the way done in answering the question and stop because you realized what the answer must be OR get 100% done and then answer your question a few minutes/hours later.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by blindstitch on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:29PM (#44638666)
This is scarily accurate about how I use stack overflow. And then I never make the post, and the information never ends up out there!
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by yorwba on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:32AM (#44632971)
I would definitely be surprised if people who've been asking good questions on StackOverflow so far would suddenly ask them elsewhere, since part of what makes a question good for StackOverflow is that it cannot be easily answered elsewhere. E.g. MathOverflow is a forum for mathematicians to talk about their research, they're unlikely to use LLMs for that anytime soon.

So fewer people asking questions doesn't mean the community is dying, it might very well be a sign that they finally succeeded in their war to keep everyone else out.

Probably bad for the company milking the community for profit, though.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by bayindirh on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:36AM (#44634005)
After being bullied about a couple of questions which were not already answered in Stack Overflow, I stopped participating StackExchange completely.

The point system which meant to motivate people to contribute became the bar itself. Lower score meant you were not taken seriously or considered a noob who stopped using pacifiers and started using computers 30 minutes ago.

So, I returned to what I did best. Digging documentation and taking my notes. They can pat themselves on the back for keeping the purity and spirit of the network.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by 0xEF on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:10AM (#44633495)
I don't even think it's been about asking good questions, at least not for many years. I used SO regularly and even when I wasn't asking a question at all, it was an incredible slog to just find a concise and correct answer instead of sniping comments from people who wanted to flex knowledge, or others answering from some oblique perspective that had nothing to do with the original problem. Asking good questions is always important, yes, but if the community does not know how to provide good answers, seekers seek elsewhere.

Side note, great html book here on asking good questions, since we still absolutely have that problem to deal with even when using Gen AI as a starting point; http://catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Buttons840 on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:33AM (#44633615)
> MathOverflow is a forum for mathematicians to talk...

When StackOverflow was new I visited frequently to enjoy the community talking about programming. For others, the goal was always to build the ultimate wiki.

The people who wanted the ultimate wiki won, and the community left, and that's where we see SO today. No community, but it is the ultimate wiki filled with programming wisdom from 2014.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by thomasz on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:52AM (#44633720)
Ironically, they insisted at a very narrow definition of the question and answer format and consequently failed at creating a good wiki. There is no way to approach broader topics. It’s always „how do I do x“, and the accepted answer since 2013 is a jquery plugin which is missing a maintainer since 2015.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by ryandrake on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:15PM (#44637698)
The rules there just don't encourage updating answers or re-asking things already asked. I've always said, StackOverflow is a great resource if your specific question is "How would I have done this programming thing back in 2010?"
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Timwi on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @02:55PM (#44651497)
Ironically, I predicted this already back in 2010 (or whenever the site started). I knew from the outset that disallowing duplicates forever was not future-proof, and that the voting mechanism will favor answers posted earlier, not answers that are more correct or up to date.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by tonyedgecombe on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:50AM (#44635086)
>When StackOverflow was new I visited frequently to enjoy the community talking about programming.

I don't remember it ever being that and I was on it right from the start. Anything subjective was shut down in an instant (for good reason).

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by Timwi on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @03:01PM (#44651573)
It was not. A lot of the questions that would now be rejected for “subjectivity” were initially allowed, then at some point migrated to a separate instance, called “programmers.stackexchange.com” and deleted from the main site. Of course, over time, even that website lost the community and was later renamed to https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/ and became the same kind of hostile hellhole.

The fact that you added “for good reason” implies that you agree with the sentiment that the website shouldn't have a community that socializes, so I'm not surprised that you tuned it out and didn't notice it being driven off the website. From your perspective this may be a case of “good riddance”, but for many including myself, it was quite sad (and still is).

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by johnnyanmac on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:04AM (#44633142)
>So fewer people asking questions doesn't mean the community is dying,

If you're not growing, you're dying. Businesses completely perverted that saying, but the basis for it is still true. People move on, change inerests, or simply die. You can't have a healthy long term community without new members coming in.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by QuesnayJr on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:57AM (#44634154)
Seeing the culture of StackOverflow, I would choose to be dead in the ground rather than ask a question there, even a question that can't be easily answered elsewhere. Volunteer-run sites need a mix of enthusiasts who do the real work of the site and janitors who keep things from being too chaotic, but enthusiasm dims while the desire to impose order never does, so eventually the janitors take over.

MathOverflow has a much better culture, so I ask (and answer) questions there. I'm not quite sure why it's worked out better there, though I suppose it's something to do with the population.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by assimpleaspossi on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:45AM (#44633040)
I went to SO for the first time in a long time to ask a question. It wouldn't let me do so until I edited three previous questions to better meet their standards. Those three questions were from 12 years ago.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by nudgeOrnurture on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:26AM (#44633263)
yeah, it's always fun when toddlers are told to read the docs, first, and then a few blog posts that clarify things in varying ways, then another article on how to ask (the right) questions and finally, give a summary of what one already tried and documented carefully because one already took a course on journaling one's path through the maze that is deprecation, version requirements, and basic libraries neither included in the most used distros, nor included in the setup of the package one is trying to install.

don't matter, money is the motive and good ol' Ponzi made sure the gut biome of his obedient little army sticks to his divine ways of doin' things: job security, 'just doin' one's job' and that pat on the head TED talk, of course

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by scotty79 on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:48AM (#44633698)
SO is trying to pivot to education and gamification.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by ChrisRR on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:25AM (#44633929)
Stack Overflow is blaming AI for its failing when it's been a steaming pile for a decade.

It's basically always been unusable for anything embedded related, because every question gets closed and marked as a duplicate of some desktop/web/mobile question with 100,000x the RAM

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by hopelite on Monday July 21, 2025 @08:28AM (#44634346)
I think you may be overlooking that those are different and largely unrelated issues even if they are correlated. It is a shift of the whole modality, not just the service or location in which the modality is being conducted.

Stack Overflow was a modality of humans asking and answering questions of each other, AI is totally replacing the humans in the answering step (for the time being), and doing so far more efficiently. Ai does not care how many times someone asks the same question, let alone how unimportant it is to a human ego. Let’s also not act as if it was just SO that is hostile to answering questions of humans. Remember seeing that letter from the aughts that went around the internet, where Linus Torvalds berated people?

Ai does not do that, Ai is patient and supportive, not humanly limited in its patience and support. It is a far superior experience from that perspective.

Ai may be limited still at this point and will not have a certain amount of experience based on second and third order effects and interactions between systems and methods that a human will have experience with from a life of experiences, but I frankly do not have any reason to believe that level of fine grained synthesized expertise will be gained soon enough; it is a mere feedback and learning loop away. The infant that Ai is right now is really not all that far off from becoming a toddler smarter than any genius human coder has ever been in all of human history. I’m thinking it is no more than another year to year and a half, and Ai will be the undisputed expert at every single repeatable programming question there is.

Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by insane_dreamer on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:13PM (#44641000)
Elsewhere where? SO is still the best place for obscure coding questions.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by BrenBarn on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @02:15AM (#44643716)
But if you operate a community that isn't hostile to those things, don't be surprised if it gets flooded with the same few questions 10 million times.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by isk517 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:34AM (#44660399)
I'm diving back into Linux server setup and management after being away for about 2 decades. The number of times the the top 3-5 search results are Stack Overflow questions with someone who is having the exact same issue I'm having and the top answer is 'this has been answered elseware, try searching' was almost enough to make me say, screw this I'm going back to Windows.
Re:AI is killing the web. Can anything save it? by j45 on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @06:17PM (#44728898)
Early Stack Overflow was definitely better where questions were encouraged and maybe guided eventually towards where they need to be instead of hard rules that didn't encourage better questions and continuing your journey of questions.