News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by 4ndrewl on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:19AM (#43702089)
To the "I wish HN would stay out of politics" crew.

You can stay out of politics, but politics will always come and find you.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by h1fra on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:44AM (#43702614)
HN and founders will say "no politics here" on the regulated internet, drinking regulated water, eating regulated food, breathing regulated air.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pjc50 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:26AM (#43702907)
Apart from the few maniacs On Here who seek out the unregulated intentionally. Raw milk (all those tasty diseases). "Research chemicals" (don't hear so much about that lately, but there were whole microdosing fads).
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by avisser on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:56AM (#43704238)
Banning raw milk is for health. Banning research chemicals is mostly an extension of the war on drugs. They aren't the same.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by franktankbank on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:17AM (#43703582)
Raw milk is delicious, my ancestors have been drinking it for millennia.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by user_7832 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:43AM (#43703702)
Isn't this literally survivorship bias? Those who died early wouldn't have had offspring.

1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by franktankbank on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:39AM (#43704102)
Not saying its a good choice for those whose ancestors didn't go through the selection process.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:23AM (#43704485)
Your ancestors didn’t face bird flu.

That said, I’m for people being idiots. I’m just done paying for it. If you’re chugging raw milk during a bird flu epidemic and your family gets sick because of it, basic insurance and the public should only pick up the cost after you’ve declared bankruptcy.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by franktankbank on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:32AM (#43704587)
Similarly I wish I could enact carveouts so I wasn't supporting peoples health problems related to commenting way too much on the internet, hackernews in particular.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by nindalf on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:39AM (#43704094)
Milk is my main drink. I don't drink beer or wine, it's mostly just plain milk for me. And while there is a substantial taste difference based on the % of fat, I have never seen a difference in taste between pasteurised and non-pasteurised. I actually bought a bottle of raw milk from a farmer just to try it. No negative effects, but it just tasted insipid compared to 5.4% fat milk I can get at the supermarket.

People who claim a taste difference between raw and pasteurised, I'd very much like to see someone taste the difference on the same cow's milk blind, before and after pasteurisation. I just don't think it affects the taste much, and certainly not as much as fat %.

And for people who claim health benefits, I would like to see a double blind study demonstrating those benefits.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by franktankbank on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:42AM (#43704123)
You may be onto something about the different cows. This was while I lived in France temporarily. I had no idea that I was drinking raw milk. I was commenting how delicious it was and a coworker said "oh is that the stuff you have to boil". Me "wut". It was much better than the supermarket milk I could get.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by ceejayoz on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:31AM (#43704560)
It isn’t raw if it’s been boiled.

That’s pasteurized. At a higher temp than the supermarket stuff, even.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by franktankbank on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:33AM (#43704600)
Might not have been clear. I wasn't boiling it because I couldn't read the french instructions.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:14AM (#43705098)
The confounding factor is milk fat. In my experience higher fat milk just tastes better regardless of any other factor and milk straight from the cow will have up to 5% milk fat compared to 3.25% for "whole" milk. Try drinking a shot glass of 10% cream sometime, it's amazing.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bitexploder on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:30AM (#43704553)
What the cows eat matters for how milk tastes too. Cows can get sick. Udders can get infections. Milking processes (machinery) and its ease of cleaning can vary. Bacteria is everywhere. Pasteurization is a cheap, effective and has no real drawbacks. This whole raw milk thing is just silly and has become political for some silly reason.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:32AM (#43704578)
I think the main difference is fresh. When I was in high school I stayed with a dairy farmer who brought in a jug of milk from the tank for breakfast after milking the cows. After that I can't drink regular milk.

Pasteurization does affect taste though. Around me there are two different dairies, one does regular pasteurization and one does vat pasteurization and I can tell the difference. There is ultra pasteurization which is just gross. I've never put unpasteurized head to head against equally fresh pasteurized though, and given what I now know I'm not going to.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:59AM (#43704938)
I love ultra pasteurization. I'm lactose intolerant so I have to drink "lactose free"[1] milk and in Canada such milk is often UHT pasteurized since it has to stay on the store shelf longer (lower inventory turnover). It's amazing that we can, non-chemically, disinfect a dairy product in such a way that it will stay good for months even without refrigeration.

In Mexico I suspect that almost all milk is ultra pasteurized since it's not refrigerated in stores and has wicked-long expiration dates. It's also some of the best-tasting milk I've had so I think that flavour has more to do with some of the other milk processes (like skimming) and the livelihood of the cows rather than with how it's pasteurized.

[1] In practice this is just milk with the lactase enzyme added at some point during production.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by numpad0 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:25AM (#43706004)

  There is ultra pasteurization which is just gross.
Are you referring to 120C 3-second ultra high temperature pasteurization? I don't see what would be so gross about it.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:56AM (#43706379)
I don't know the details about ultra pasteurization. I just know anything labeled ultra pasteurized states gross.

Of course the above is subjective. Others have stated they prefer it. To each their own, but I will continue to maintain it makes milk taste gross.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by nindalf on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:24AM (#43705228)
I have no doubt that milk that is 15 minutes old tastes great. My question is if that jug of milk was divided in two and one half was pasteurised, would people be able to tell the difference? You're saying yes, I'm saying I'd like to see blind tests of people tasting both.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:58AM (#43706408)
IF you read close you will see that I didn't say yes. I said that I don't know and am not willing to be part of such a blind test. I will state clearly that all the unpasteurized milk I had was less than an hour old and tasted great, while all the pasteurized milk was unknown age but likely at least a day old and tasted worse. Is it fresh or pasteurization that makes a difference is not something I know.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Nihilartikel on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:53AM (#43704205)
I'd consider drinking raw milk only if I was on a first name basis with the cow that produced it.

Otherwise I would at least demand it be fermented into kefir so the food microbes can muscle out the bad.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:33AM (#43704594)
That won't make a difference. Bacteria is something you cannot see and so you have no idea what is on/in the cow.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by xolox on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:07AM (#43705783)
It sure can make a difference.

Sickness caused by bacteria doesn't happen as soon as one bad bacteria (bacterium?) enters your body, a certain critical mass is usually required. This is very similar to the concept of "viral load" where a certain amount of viral genetic material needs to be exchanged before the viral infection can take hold.

The "beneficial bacteria" on your skin and in your gut make it harder for bad bacteria to take root in many different ways, one of them simply being they provide competition, "crowding out the bad guys".

Another way is that many, many, many types of antibiotics were originally discovered as metabolites produced by bacteria and fungi (examples include penicillin, streptomycin, chloramphenicol, and tetracycline).

And for completeness sake, milk kefir contains many Lactobacillus species that are also a natural part of the mammal microbiome (which makes sense when you think about it; Lactobacillus are named for consuming lactose, an ingredient of mammal milk).

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by skywhopper on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:33AM (#43704049)
And many of them died from doing so.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by chillingeffect on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:33AM (#43703659)
And we enjoyed our milkborne tuberculosis, typhoid, scarlet fever, diphtheria, and septic sore throat thoroughly, too. The risks actually doubled the joys. Why does a supposedly enlightened society step all over my right to choose which eliminated diseases to bring back?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pixl97 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:46AM (#43704778)
Oooh, ooh, oh, don't forget the brucellosis either.

But hey, I only get to enjoy this if the measles here in Texas don't get me first.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by numpad0 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:56AM (#43703793)
not everyone's ancestors
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:34AM (#43704604)
Only about 1/3rd of the world. However by coincidence fluency in English correlates high with ability to drink milk as an adult.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mr_toad on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:06AM (#43705779)
> Raw milk is delicious, my ancestors have been drinking it for millennia.

Before refrigeration most milk was made into butter, cheese and other products. Unless your ancestors actually herded the animals themselves they probably didn’t drink much raw milk.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bbarnett on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:47AM (#43703053)
Will all of these things be free of micro plastics and other contaminants?

If so, is there a signup page?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mulnz on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:45AM (#43703714)
Wait these regulations haven't created total perfection? Better burn the whole thing down.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by fnord77 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:05AM (#43703851)
> regulated ...

not for long

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by dmckeon on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:09AM (#43702391)
People trying to ignore politics are like fish trying to ignore water.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by anon373839 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:19AM (#43702870)
It’s really a question of time and place. There are many foundational topics in life, such as politics, religion, and philosophy. But it’s not always helpful or appropriate to discuss them in a particular setting.

That said, HN already has an extremely wide range of subject matter, so I wouldn’t say politics should be out of place here. It can, though, become a divisive distraction that disrupts other conversations, so I can appreciate that some limits are needed.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:34AM (#43702552)
Not talking about politics is itself a political position (in favor of status quo).
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by stingraycharles on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:39AM (#43702586)
Depends. We’re a small, very international startup and have a super strict “no politics” policy. Politics and work are not a good combination when you’re employing people from all over the world.

But I would not consider it a political statement to adopt this policy.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by orwin on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:14AM (#43702836)
I think it exists two different general ideas of what politic mean.

For some (including me), politics are, following the oldest definition: 'how do I and fellow humans organize ourselves to live together' this often leads to a belief that everything is politics (for me it's true, but it's a belief, not a fact).

For other, I think that when they say politics, they think of geopolitics and partisanship, which is fair, because it's how politicians and political journalists themselves define politics. For this group, hopefully, not everything is politics.

So to me, this disagreement about wether or not all is political is often semantic rather than ideologic.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pseudalopex on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:28AM (#43705273)
The disagreement is semantic and irrelevant in the sense the question at hand usually is which topics and opinions are forbidden at work.

The disagreement is semantic and relevant in the sense people who say no politics at work believe their categories of politics and not politics are obvious.

The disagreement is ideological in the sense ethical concerns about products or customers are designated political often.

Politicians, political journalists, and people who say no politics at work do not define politics as geopolitics and partisanship.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by noelwelsh on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:53AM (#43702670)
Your statements are incoherent. Politics is decision making and power relationships within groups of people. It is 100% a political statement to adopt this policy as it exercises power over a group. You cannot function as a group without politics. "Where do y'all want to go for lunch" is also politics, as it involves group decision making and power relationships (Do you go to the vegetarian place? Do you avoid the spicy place?) If what you want is a "don't piss off your coworkers by discussing topics unrelated to work that you know will annoy people" policy, that is fine, but don't pretend you are not engaging in politics.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by concordDance on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:19AM (#43702867)
"Politics" is a stupid word because everyone has a different idea about what it means and so they all talk past each other.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:54AM (#43703089)
The word “politics” is vague, and that only makes banning political discussions worse if it only becomes political when the higher-ups don’t like it.

Say your company has a possibility of working with some client company who is directly or indirectly involved with cause X. If it is “political” to talk about not working with them because of X, but it is “not political” to talk about working with them, then you see what I mean.

It doesn’t have to be a destructive conversation: one employee might say we should avoid them, but you might say we need to work with them because we need the money now and can drop them later when we are in a better place. Other employees could talk how cause X is not that unethical for reasons. If someone balks at a point of view incompatible with theirs and is incapable of expressing a viewpoint in a way that respects other views, maybe that someone is not mature enough and next time your HR can avoid that type.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pixl97 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:51AM (#43704844)
Many people that ban political discussions miss the irony that it's a political decision.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by gedy on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:58AM (#43704259)
Yeah exactly, the same people who shout the loudest about "everything is politics" and want to talk about it at work would go apeshit if someone at work said "I'm not comfortable with abortion", etc. HR would quickly be called and shut them down.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by def13 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:45AM (#43703040)
The politics of saying "no politics" is that you are drawing some line that separates some political issues into "politics" and others into "not politics". Because to truly avoid all politics is impossible; even if you believe banal, purely intra-personal politics are not political so much of the basic organization of a business & capitalism are politics. "Should we allow remote work" for example is a deeply political question that ties deeply into discussions about the rights/value of neurodivergent & disabled people in the workplace. To say 'I don't believe in God' is a deeply political and dangerous statement in some parts of the world, but fairly banal where I live. To contrast, in Indonesia, it is technically _unconstitutional_ to not believe in a "one and almighty God"

I wish people were at least honest about "no politics" to mean "lets avoid to unsafe, potentially divisive issues relative to our geographic location, and take the basic tenets of neoliberal, capitalistic society to be assumed". And yeah, that is a more than reasonable policy. Its a difficult policy in international spaces, because its very hard to not trespass that line when political contexts differ so strongly across the globe

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by lou1306 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:11AM (#43703549)
> take the basic tenets of neoliberal, capitalistic society to be assumed

Well, then any discussion about an illiberal oclocratic executive (such as 47's) should be fair game...

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by DrillShopper on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:17AM (#43705127)
> The politics of saying "no politics" is that you are drawing some line that separates some political issues into "politics" and others into "not politics".

I find someone's heuristics for deciding which category a statement falls into chiefly turns on if they agree with the statement. If they agree with the statement then it is not political, and if they disagree, it's political.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by rini17 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:02AM (#43702740)
I am torn.com player which is a MMORPG as far removed from politics as can be. But when large part of dev team are ukrainians that were suddenly unable to work from clearly political reasons you can't ignore it.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by squigz on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:04AM (#43702748)
One might argue that it's even more important to discuss international politics these days, considering how interconnected the world is and how so many countries seem to be facing many of the same issues.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by tobr on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:24AM (#43702897)
How do you define politics? For example, are employees allowed to be LGBTQ? Are they allowed to mention their relationships to colleagues?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pxoe on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:05AM (#43703503)
Being straight is also pretty much political at this point. With the way it's being slipped into the culture (all that trad stuff, images of lifestyle to aspire to, etc.) and has become (has always been perhaps) a part of political messaging and campaigning, heterosexuality is political. Even within the heterosexuality itself and its expressions, there's still politics - "what's the right way to do it" and such. (not saying this like 'oh those poor straight people' but just that, it is all, all political)
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by tobr on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:30AM (#43703640)
For what it’s worth, I completely agree, I just thought LGBTQ was a clearer example because of how different it is seen in different parts of the world, and how it is at the same time an inescapable part of many people’s identity.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by criddell on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:49AM (#43704814)
For a lot of people on HN, a ban on politics discussions in the office is impossible because we have to deal with software licenses.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:28AM (#43702926)
First, “no politics” is not a political statement to me, more of an implicitly adopted political position.

Personally, if I have a personal political position and my colleague has an opposite one, I don’t see why we can’t talk about it. If you have a workplace rule about no politics during working hours, you better have this rule for all non-work discussions at work, or I personally would feel uncomfortable.

— If politics talk happens at work too much and affects productivity, then it is a problem, but then it is a problem with any non-work topic.

— If it causes heated debate, ruins morale, and makes people dislike each other, then it is a problem, but then it is a problem with any topic that causes heated debate. For some people it’s golf, for some philosophy, for some music. How many topics should be banned?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by dcow on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:27AM (#43703302)
Are you from the US? In the last 15 years it has become impossible for two people to reasonably disagree over political positions because of how much vitriol is thrown around on the attention markets—even if both individuals themselves are rather tame. When having an otherwise normal political opinion makes you a racist bigot or a beta cuck because the opposition is so determined to get their way at any cost, no, you can’t just talk politics at work and have a cohesive team. Someone will feel oppressed.

Work is about making money. Politics is a distraction unless there’s an issue that directly affects the business. Then it’s fair game. Like this one. Many teams of individuals will have to figure out how to navigate this situation so discussing it in context is apropos and can be done objectively.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:56AM (#43703448)
> When having an otherwise normal political opinion makes you a racist bigot or a beta cuck because the opposition is so determined to get their way at any cost

If someone calls me a racist bigot or a beta cuck, that is a problem. That problem also has nothing to do with politics. It has to do with someone not being emotionally mature enough or equipped to handle a discussion with someone who has different views, or someone having a mental breakdown.

I am not from the US, but I had enjoyed some reasonable conversations with people from the US (among other countries) with very different views, and I was never called names. There are awkward moments when you have to hear something you don’t agree with, but that is most of life if you ever interact with people.

The key is to be like an HTTP server: liberal in terms of what you can accept, but strict with what you put out there.

> Work is about making money.

You have just thrown another political position into the mix, I hope you realize that?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:06AM (#43704327)
> It has to do with someone not being emotionally mature enough or equipped to handle a discussion with someone who has different views, or someone having a mental breakdown.

Any moderately sized company is practically guaranteed to have a few people like this. So getting into these discussions has a high risk of becoming an HR issue as tempers flare and conversations become vitriolic.

There's also the issue that the company founders and leadership have political opinions of their own that might inform company policy and any political opinion to the contrary may be perceived as pushback from a "troublemaker".

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:45AM (#43704749)
> getting into these discussions has a high risk of becoming an HR issue as tempers flare and conversations become vitriolic.

Here we can forget that IRL face to face people are much less likely to be offensive to each other. If they get to literal name calling and aggression, sure, that’s an HR issue, HR gets paid to sort this out, doesn’t it? I don’t see how politics is different from any other topic on which people can have strong opinions.

> There's also the issue that the company founders and leadership have political opinions of their own that might inform company policy and any political opinion to the contrary may be perceived as pushback from a "troublemaker".

That is why “no politics” is somewhat dishonest. In my view, either blanket forbid all off-topic talks, or don’t censor by topic and handle fights if they arise. There can also be softer guidelines about how to behave at work without an actual ban of any topic.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by dcow on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:56AM (#43705609)
I agree with your ideal. I used to be one of those people who would just talk about whatever in any context assuming everyone was mature enough to have academic discussions and not get personal. Political viewpoint is a protected class in the US. But we all saw what happened to James Dramore. Real consequences for holding a political opinion that allegedly made him “unemployable at Google” where his politics were so threatening to the established order that Google just couldn’t operate with him in the mix. You’d think G has the most mature employees… and either they do but humans are just toxically unable to hold differing opinions, or they don’t and therefore have to maintain a safe space for the comfort of their sensitive workers.

The silliest part: what was his thesis? Well that using race and gender based quotas during hiring and leveling made Google less competitive. Certainly not a privileged white male tech bro just barreling through the company on a racist bigoted spree leaving tears in his wake. There is more interesting discussion to be had here about how the Civil Rights Act has been weaponized in the US and companies feel they have a legal obligation now to prove that their systems don’t yield “unfair distribution of protected classes”, or whatever the actual wording is. And how that is at odds with a world where you can openly discuss politics at a company without fear of falling afoul of the Chief Diversity Officer (ffs, there are executives installed to maintain the order now). And related: just look at how pockets of people respond to Trump’s second term insisting that he’s a fascist dictator and anybody who doesn’t see it is a de facto fascist. But I digress.

Nobody wants to bet their job on being on the losing end of a kafka traps and thought terminating clichés.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pseudalopex on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:35AM (#43705360)
Or censor by topic specifically and honestly.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by ksec on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:00AM (#43703818)
You would have been cancelled if you said this between 2014 - 2019 at the peak of it all.

At least now you can say it out now without being downvoted into oblivion.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by concordDance on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:17AM (#43702851)
It's in favor of not having relationships break down in your community/company.

Only a small percentage of people are able to handle fundamental disagreements calmly and without it bleeding over to other interactions.

Will the SE and sales guy work as well together if the former knows the latter donates half his commission money to organizations that help kill babies?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:31AM (#43702947)
I have friendly relationships with a few people who have political opinions some of which are opposite to mine.

> Will the SE and sales guy work as well together if the former knows the latter donates half his commission money to organizations that help kill babies?

A friend of mine is a vegan. Anywhere he works, to him, most of his coworkers not just help kill conscious beings that have self-awareness and feel pain, they literally eat them. Does this mean talking about what you have for lunch should be banned? Does this mean he should throw a fit any time he talks to a non-vegan?

Incidentally, we sometimes have good debates about the nature of consciousness, the effectiveness of individual veganism on reducing suffering, utilitarianism and deontology, vegan food options, etc. I feel being converted and I don’t mind it.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:12AM (#43704381)
> Anywhere he works, to him, most of his coworkers not just help kill conscious beings that have self-awareness and feel pain, they literally eat them. Does this mean talking about what you have for lunch should be banned?

You're making the opposite case of what you think. Your Vegan friend is avoiding taking about politics constantly because they're not bringing up the fact that everyone is consuming the flesh of innocent animals every time they go for lunch. If they started talking about the politics and beliefs of veganism at every meal shared with coworkers, I think it would have a negative impact on those relationships.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:55AM (#43704893)
He does not bring up consuming products of animal suffering (including egg and milk products) directly, but he does order vegan food, which is enough to make a point (for me at least).

What he is doing by expressing his philosophical position simply through his order is turning me subsequently ordering something with eggs into a philosophically loaded action as well. That, of course, shifts my opinion on the question.

I am making the point I am making: if we worked together, we should be free to discuss veganism or paleo diet (which I have discussed with a coworker previously) whenever either of us wanted, and he demonstrated being an adult about it when we do. If he asked to not talk about it because it made him uncomfortable, then we wouldn’t. I do not see why political discussions have to be different.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pjmlp on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:55AM (#43703441)
Turning the question around, will the SE and sales guy work as well together if the former knows the latter donates half his commission money to FSF while the other is hard advocate for commercial software?

Politics are across all layers, including at technology decisions.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by eMPee584 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:30AM (#43702941)
but letting > the SE and sales guy

never find out about their shared passion is kind of cruel, too?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by j45 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:00AM (#43703474)
It's not uncommon for one side to come out with their position/interpretation/belief whether it's passion or not.

Maybe at a work function, team party, conference, etc.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by kortilla on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:33AM (#43703330)
No it’s not. It’s having discipline to not pollute unrelated conversations with your politics. I am very against the status quo but I don’t complain about it to a bunch of anonymous usernames on a forum focused on technology.

You can believe something without proselytizing.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by johannes1234321 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:57AM (#43703453)
Technology and the consequences of using technology are inherently highly political.

New or improved technologies shape communities.

Ignoring that is a political statement as well.

Just see how online media has changed discourse, how Amazon changed retail business, how business analytics change the way businesses work, how always being connected changes relations, ...

When developing technologies one can be Wernher von Braun "(where the rockets land and whether they contain explosives is) not my department" or one can consider consequences.Both are a political position, with consequences.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by drstewart on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:10AM (#43703882)
>Technology and the consequences of using technology are inherently highly political.

So what stance does The Art of Computer Programming take on communism?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by johannes1234321 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:55AM (#43704237)
Between the four books there is a lot of paper being printed, with chemicals which have to be sources somewhere.

But a bit more serious there are different angles to this:

One is that the formalization Knuth did, is basis for the way other research on computer science has been setup.

His work on TeX as part of writing the books has great impact on how scientific reports are being written, which themselves have consequences.

And then there is all the consequence while implementing technology. How optimisations by better algorithms enable data mining, replacing manual labor, ...

Now of course impact differs. Not everybody is building V2 rockets (as well as Saturn rockets) like von Braun did, but there are many wheels in the machinery.

I myself am a small wheel in building database engines. The software is used by sports clubs to manage their members, shop owners to manage their inventory, companies to run their ads and air craft carriers to replicate strategic data across the ship, so that if one part is damaged, the other can still operate. If I were to leave, the organisation would continue developing, but the work has impact.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by acdha on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:55AM (#43704227)
That’s a very narrow redefinition of both technology and politics, and even there it’s only a step away from discussions about how automation affects millions of jobs, how daily lives are shaped by what’s allowed by the software which large companies or governments build, or how amassed data can be misused in ways which wouldn’t be possible without efficient algorithms.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by egoisticalgoat on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:17AM (#43703944)
Is communism the only political topic? Or does whether or not The Art of Computer Programming talk about accessibility in software not constitute a political opinion?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by ttepasse on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:15AM (#43705109)
Knuth in the wake of the Iraq war and the Abu Ghraid crimes asked some "Infrequently Asked Questions" which are of course highly political. He kept this page linked on top of his home page. And in 2022 he wrote a postscript with more political questions.

https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/iaq.html

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by drstewart on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:55AM (#43705600)
I didn't ask about Knuth.

I asked about the book. Everything is inherently HIGHLY political, thus this should be an easy question.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Friday April 18, 2025 @06:44AM (#43726748)
Perhaps you are exaggerating. At least, my original comment was “not talking about politics is a political position”, not “everything is HIGHLY political”.

However, yes, some people would say that, for example, almost everything is political to some degree. I don’t know if I agree with them entirely. In case of Knuth, they would probably say that the choice of what to write about in the book (just like the choice of whether to be a computer scientist in the first place) cannot be divorced from his politics. Like the choice of someone to work in nuclear science or environmental science or “anything that pays good money” is informed by individual’s political positions. “Politics is water” is a great metaphor.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by MiguelX413 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:36AM (#43703345)
Things are often inherently political.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:03AM (#43703492)
> You can believe something without proselytizing.

You can talk about politics without proselytising. Why should discussing a topic even invoke the words like “belief” and “proselytising”?

Not only stating an opinion is compatible with a constructive discussion that could lead to a mutual adjustment of opinions—in fact, stating your opinion is often a pre-requisite to having a discussion that could lead to it being changed.

The magic happens when person A realizes that another, equally sane person B can think very differently about topic X. At that point, the person A has to either 1) write the person B off as crazy (not so easy when that person is obviously sane in every other way), or 2) realize that there may be something to it and ever so slightly adjust own opinion on topic X, or at least become more tolerant.

Not being able or willing to freely exchange and converge on opinions with people whom you routinely meet in real life, only discussing them online in your respective bubbles, is a sure way to having only more and more wildly incompatible and divisive opinions, and I suspect it is exactly what has been happening in recent years.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:27AM (#43704523)
> having discipline to not pollute unrelated conversations with your politics

Discipline isn’t found in hiding. Someone who cannot discuss politics without polluting conversations isn’t disciplined, they’re unpracticed in conversing and thinking through their views.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by iteratethis on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:10AM (#43703884)
Incorrect, not talking about politics does not signal any political affiliation.

I think the "everything is political" statement is technically correct but practically useless. In the workplace the discussion is mostly about allowing or disallowing politics that are irrelevant to the business.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by brightball on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:33AM (#43704048)
No it’s not. It’s a position that comes from experience of knowing that it’s a complete waste of time because nobody’s mind is being changed.

Further, there are entire segments of political groups who just want to assume your beliefs like a political straw man so they can denigrate you.

It’s an unhealthy waste of time and that doesn’t truly hit you until you invest the time in talking to an otherwise rational person, provide the closest thing to proof of your perspective in a situation and then watch them deny it anyway.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:40AM (#43704104)
> it’s a complete waste of time because nobody’s mind is being changed.

What you said can be true if you approach the discussion with an attitude of “I want to change everybody’s mind” instead of trying to get to some agreement and truth.

Not only stating an opinion is compatible with a constructive discussion that could lead to a mutual adjustment of opinions—in fact, stating your opinion is a precursor to having a discussion that can change it.

> It’s an unhealthy waste of time and that doesn’t truly hit you until you invest the time in talking to an otherwise rational person, provide the closest thing to proof of your perspective in a situation and then watch them deny it anyway.

The magic happens when one person realizes that another, obviously sane in every other way person can think very differently about topic X. Repeated exposure to alternative views from other people in your circles leaves no alternative except to adjust your own opinion on topic X.

Thing is, it’s tricky or impossible online. Aside from a handful of well-known people with some reputation or infamy, most of us only know each other as handles with no context. On the Internet, no one knows you are a dog or a basement dweller who lives with his parents and could never hold a job. Meanwhile, access to a group of like-minded people is always at your fingertips when you are online. However, when you are in a company of people who clearly are similar enough in what they achieved, in their choice to work for the same company, maybe good in their software engineering skill, etc., it makes their opinion something that may count.

Not being able or willing to freely exchange and consequently converge on opinions with people whom you routinely meet in real life, and only discussing said opinions in your respective online bubbles, strikes me as a path to having more and more divergent, incompatible, extreme opinions (which I rather suspect might have been happening a lot in recent years).

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by brightball on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:58AM (#43704255)
> Repeated exposure to alternative views from other people in your circles leaves no alternative except to adjust your own opinion on topic X.

I have not found this to be true when it comes to politically aligned beliefs.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by strogonoff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:20AM (#43704459)
Maybe don’t always just take their word for it. Some (most?) people will continue to express their view vocally, but the fact of encountering an opinion from someone they otherwise find a reasonable and sane person will cause introspection and adjustment, and maybe in a different group they would express an adjusted opinion. Most people are always affected by others (excluding sociopaths or other unusual cases).
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by brightball on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:04AM (#43704996)
In person when you can communicate tone and know there is a level of mutual trust, I would generally agree.

Over the past few years I’ve even begun to wonder about that though.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by enraged_camel on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:21AM (#43705173)
>> No it’s not. It’s a position that comes from experience of knowing that it’s a complete waste of time because nobody’s mind is being changed.

I think the issue is that when people debate someone, they want to "win" by having the other side accept defeat. You are right, that rarely happens, especially in politics.

However, as someone who has participated in countless formal debates, I'll share a secret: your goal in a debate isn't to convince the person you're debating. It's to convince the audience. And that happens quite frequently, even if it's not immediately visible to the debate participants.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by brightball on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:32AM (#43705326)
That is certainly a valid point, especially in formal debates.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:00AM (#43705675)
You don't need to completely change someone's positions for it to be worthwhile. This is a thread about something that has directly to do with HN's usual tech topics, and it would be hard to not talk at least a bit about the political aspects.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by starspangled on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:07AM (#43705024)
Ignore politics entirely maybe, but people who are tired of hearing the exact same extremist reductive opinions over and over again everywhere aren't necessarily ignoring politics. Yes we know it's all because conservatives are fascists and corrupt and Russian agents and liberals are communists and in bed with the Chinese, etc., not caring to hear about it again is not surrendering the battle of good vs evil.

For me, ironically, the worst casualty of "politics" infiltrating everything is... politics. I mean the respectful and reasoned discussion of politics. Not that it was ever in great supply, but now it is non-existent.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mr_toad on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:13AM (#43705847)
> People trying to ignore politics are like fish trying to ignore water.

Like fish, most people do ignore it until it turns foul.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by atmosx on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:10AM (#43702802)
This quote is essentially unworkable. Everything you say, or choose not to say, inevitably advances some political perspective over another.

What we should really aim for is thoughtful, civilized, and maybe even aesthetically pleasing discourse. That’s what educated people strive for.

Trying to “avoid politics” is like collecting seashells while a tsunami is rolling in.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by surgical_fire on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:51AM (#43703755)
Agreed. Those who don't care about politics are doomed to be ruled by those who care.

Moreover, avoiding politics is impossible. It's all around you. Labor, entertainment, food, housing. Burying your head in the sand will only get you to have your ass in the air.

Maybe "be polite" should be a better rule than "avoid politics".

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by cjs_ac on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:15AM (#43703929)
It's scary how widely this varies between different communities. On Reddit, /r/politics is mostly people acting like they're auditioning for the writers' room on one of those late-night talk shows, whereas /r/ukpolitics and /r/australianpolitics are almost exclusively people making insightful, analytic comments.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by atmosx on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:15PM (#43710465)
Oh really? I will check all of them, thanks for the hints!
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by belorn on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:59AM (#43702709)
I view the archive.org, Wikipedia, CVE program, and Linux Kernel to all have had discussions on HN about how to they should be funded. Is that kind of politics the kind that people wish that HN stayed out from?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by diogocp on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:08AM (#43703869)
No, but the "everything is political" people are not capable of making that distinction. Which is probably why everything seems political to them.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:22AM (#43705194)
> that distinction

What is the distinction?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by t0lo on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:29AM (#43702145)
Everything is political now by design. It's meant to reach into every facet of society and community and restructure it.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:42AM (#43702212)
Everything was always political. Laws, the economy, conflcit. How is any person not affected by these? The government is responsible for all or a large part of how a country functions.

People who say "I'm not political" are deflecting to avoid conflict

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by InsideOutSanta on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:51AM (#43702653)
One of the benefits a working democracy conveys to its citizens is that they largely don't have to care about politics. They can trust that government action is relatively consistent over time, that laws will be enforced fairly enough, that their property will be protected to a reasonable degree, that the currency will be reasonably stable, that the roads will be maintained, that some public transport will be available, that sudden wars won't erupt around them, and so on.

That's what makes working democracies successful. But it seems that it also makes democracies vulnerable because people don't realize they have these benefits because they live in a working democracy. They start to think these benefits have nothing to do with politics and are just the way things are, like the laws of nature.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by demosito666 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:20AM (#43702876)
Interestingly, I believe that the reality is exactly the opposite: on the political regimes' spectrum of democratic -> authoritarian -> totalitarian only the middle one doesn't require people's participation. Both democracy and totalitarism need to be actively maintained by significant part of the population, otherwise they converge to the "natural" state of things - authoritarian order. None of the stuff you listed (fair laws, property rights, etc.) occur naturally once it has been set up at some point in past. That's why they talk about "checks and balances" all the time, and they are impossible without active participation.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by InsideOutSanta on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:51AM (#43703420)
Yeah, I should have phrased this better. When I said that

>citizens (...) largely don't have to care about politics

I didn't mean that it wasn't harmful if they didn't care; I meant that there was no clear, immediate incentive.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @08:34AM (#43715883)
>I meant that there was no clear, immediate incentive.

What about tariffs, that causes price increased. What about changes to the law, like congestion pricing in NYC

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pjc50 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:28AM (#43702925)
What distinction are you making between authoritarian and totalitarian here?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by demosito666 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:01AM (#43703138)
I think the most significant distinction is exactly that:

Authoritarian - leaves people alone in general as long as they stay out of politics. Examples: 90% of regimes throughout human history. Almost all post-soviet countries, almost all of Middle East and Africa, Singapore, etc.

Totalitarian - forces people into actively participating in leader's political goals and penetrates the daily life. North Korea, USSR, Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:30AM (#43704554)
>Authoritarian - leaves people alone in general as long as they stay out of politics.

Directly, yes, but their policies still affect people.

For example, if an authoritarian leaders enacts economic decisions that damage the economy everyone is affected.

If I pay more for goods and services due to Tariffs aren't I being forced to participate in the leader's political goals?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:06AM (#43705771)
The distinction is fuzzy, but I think what is meant here is more directly political. In a totalitarian system, it is considered important for everyone to know and openly and regularly support state ideology with words and deeds. In the least totalitarian but authoritarian system, the state just wants apathy and obedience from its citizenry.

So it would be totalitarian leaning for a leader to make a speech (watching is mandatory btw) saying that buying foreign is anti-patriotic and generating social censure, in addition to the tariffs, for people seen with foreign goods.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @08:08AM (#43715608)
>it is considered important for everyone to know and openly and regularly support state ideology with words and deeds.

People literally do this on social media and they aren't even being forced.

As for the remainder, I do see the forced part but I'm not sure of how meaningful that is. If I don't agree with Trump but I'm forced to watch his speeches what does this do?

As for supporting state ideology, while not forced, there are hats, bumper stickers, flags to identify yourself

Imagine Trump forced everyone to wear his MAGA hat. What effect does it have? I don't think being forced to do this and that has much value

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Thursday April 17, 2025 @02:45PM (#43720662)
> People literally do this on social media and they aren't even being forced.

I think applying the authoritarian-totalitarian distinction in a democracy gets weird because democracies like totalitarian systems but unlike the archetypal authoritarian system expect the average person to engage in politics. So it's not a straight spectrum from democracy to totalitarian with autocracy in the middle.

And if someone forces everyone to wear their symbols, then it becomes obvious who the open dissenters are, and it becomes hard to tell who is neutral, who is enthusiastic, and who is silently dissenting, everyone looks like a supporter and people may start becoming more supporting simply because of apparent social consensus.

Anyway, here's what Wikipedia has to say. Maybe it clears up

> In exercising the power of government upon society, the application of an official dominant ideology differentiates the worldview of the totalitarian régime from the worldview of the authoritarian régime, which is "only concerned with political power, and, as long as [government power] is not contested, [the authoritarian government] gives society a certain degree of liberty."[6] Having no ideology to propagate, the politically secular authoritarian government "does not attempt to change the world and human nature",[6] whereas the "totalitarian government seeks to completely control the thoughts and actions of its citizens",[5] by way of an official "totalist ideology, a [political] party reinforced by a secret police, and monopolistic control of industrial mass society."[6]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totalitarianism#Definitions

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Sunday April 20, 2025 @08:13AM (#43743291)
> the archetypal authoritarian system expect the average person to engage in politics

I still disagree with this, maybe what defines politics is different for you.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:32AM (#43702953)
>One of the benefits a working democracy conveys to its citizens is that they largely don't have to care about politics

The citizens elect the government so how can you not care about poltiics?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by InsideOutSanta on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:50AM (#43703072)
>The citizens elect the government so how can you not care about poltiics?

I don't think there's a direct correlation between the ability to vote and caring about politics. People usually care about politics when it affects them negatively. I would guess that most people in most democratic systems don't have strong negative experiences with their governments and, thus, are not incentivized to care about politics.

Note that I'm not making an argument that they should not care. I think they should, but the very system that allows participation probably also decreases the incentive for most people to participate.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:32AM (#43704584)
>. I would guess that most people in most democratic systems don't have strong negative experiences with their governments

Opinion polls about political parties and leaders seem to always hover near the bottom end, at least in the US [1]

[1] there are always bumps after elections (change), war (nationalism), and tragedy (group sympathy)

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:11AM (#43705818)
Well, a bit. A part of liberal democracy is that elections don't matter that much. The losers can trust that they aren't going to be arrested, have their property confiscated etc. The established system like the courts, constitutions separation of powers and other anti-majoritarian things will prevent most extreme measures. And in at least some political systems, it is expect that no matter what some minimally competent people will win and govern not that differently from what the election loser was going to do.

And remember voting is not mandatory and a lot of people don't vote. Those people are ultimately letting others decide, and a lot of them are hoping the voters are going to pick well, or at least decently.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @01:35PM (#43719921)
>The losers can trust that they aren't going to be arrested, have their property confiscated etc.

Is that what people are worried about? What about the economy, civil rights, wars, etc.

I'm very confused about your argument. Is it that who you vote for doesn't matter because they won't personally attack you and the policies of whatever politician won't harm you?

>lot of them are hoping the voters are going to pick well, or at least decently.

Considering how the popular vote is almost always close to being split (you know like +10/-10) why would a non voter have that trust when from their view it's a coinflip

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Thursday April 17, 2025 @03:07PM (#43720894)
> Is that what people are worried about? What about the economy, civil rights, wars, etc.

I meant this more like what people could be worried about. In a functioning liberal democracy, there are things people usually don't worry about, which allows some people to just ignore politics. Sure the economy is an issue, but there isn't a serious communist contender in the election or a candidate wanting to start wars of conquest.

Imagine this election. Candidate A you think will deliver GDP growth of 2+-0.5%. Candidate B you expect to deliver GDP growth of 3+-2% growth. No other big difference between them. Maybe you prefer A, maybe you don't, but in the end you'll probably be relatively fine either way.

Now imagine this other election. Candidate A hates your ethnic group and you are likely going to be fired from your government job or worse if he wins. Candidate B is from your ethnic group and will do reverse Candidate A. Now the point is that this sort of election isn't supposed to happen in a functional liberal democracy.

Consequences are rarely this extreme, and even when they are it's not a product of personal or group targeting just a general policy like "ban fracking", which means even affected people can still carry on with their lives.

And also this is one of the reasons elections "work" at all. If the losers think they will be chased by the state after losing, there's no reason to participate in the election, might as well arm up before the polls and take your chances in the battlefield and/or negotiate directly with the other side's elites.

> I'm very confused about your argument. Is it that who you vote for doesn't matter because they won't personally attack you and the policies of whatever politician won't harm you?

> Considering how the popular vote is almost always close to being split (you know like +10/-10) why would a non voter have that trust when from their view it's a coinflip

My point is that it's a coinflip between two acceptable choices. Some of those nonvoters would be literally undecided if asked who they prefer. It may matter, but not that much. And even if it does, it may matter in a way where the consequences are hard to predict or not obvious.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by fc417fc802 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @04:40PM (#43721993)
You had asked "how can you not care about poltiics?" which implies there's some force driving people to care about the outcome. Similarly "why would a non voter have that trust when from their view it's a coinflip" is effectively the same question.

If someone doesn't particularly care about the outcome given the available options then it follows that how close or far the odds are isn't going to matter to them.

> Is that what people are worried about? What about the economy, civil rights, wars, etc.

It's important to be clear about the context. There's the thing, and then there's the thing relative to the election where only a few outcomes are possible once the ballot has been set. It is possible to care deeply about the former but not particularly about the latter, either because all options are either good enough or pointlessly bad from your perspective. And of course it is also possible to simple not care (ie be emotionally invested in and go about broadcasting your opinion to others) about the things you listed to begin with.

It's also important to keep in mind that "not caring" can be at odds with "ought to care", although that is obviously a subjective third party judgment.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by silverquiet on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:23AM (#43703982)
And yet the Republicans have campaigned on tearing down government for my entire life. And people treated me like a fool for believing them.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by juliendorra on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:58AM (#43702312)
Alternatively people who say “I’m not political” are benefiting from the status quo and political direction of things (long term, not necessarily short term). They frame inaction as apolitical.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by fc417fc802 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @04:47PM (#43722059)
It is apolitical for any reasonable definition of the term "political". That doesn't mean you don't benefit, or that it's a responsible choice, or anything else. It just means you aren't engaging in political activity - attempting to convince those around you, to gain influence, etc.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by darkwater on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:53AM (#43702279)
> People who say "I'm not political" are deflecting to avoid conflict

A great truth. Even isolating yourself from society like a hermit is still a political decision: you are rejecting society as it is, and prefer to live in your own solo society. That's politics.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by dcow on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:35AM (#43703343)
I don’t think that’s totally accurate. If I live as a hermit but perform my civic duties like voting and paying any taxes, I don’t see how choosing to live in solitude is anything more than a lifestyle choice.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @08:10AM (#43715627)
I don't think he was saying it's more than a lifestyle choice just that your still involved, a non action is an action.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by fc417fc802 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @04:52PM (#43722102)
> Even isolating yourself from society like a hermit is still a political decision

That is a nonsensical definition of that term. It implies that literally any action you take falls into the set "political" instead of outside of it. That defeats the purpose of the term. The point of qualifiers is to differentiate between different sorts of things.

Obviously the intention of the person using such a term is to distinguish between things. Thus such a rebuttal amounts to intellectual dishonesty by intentionally misinterpreting what was said.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by perching_aix on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:56AM (#43702306)
When this is discussed, what's being meant is that everday party politics are spilling out and overwhelming a project's or industry's individual, internal politics, which are often a completely disconnected meta.

Appealing to "well everything is connected" I'm not sure is useful. It's interesting from a semantics perspective the first few times you come across it maybe, then swaps around into being plain frustrating, then lands on just missing the point.

Finally, I think people who want to stay out of said party political meta I think are doing a pretty big favor to their mental health, and I really can't fault them one bit for it. No coincidence either.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:07AM (#43702785)
> I think are doing a pretty big favor to their mental health, and

It your mental health is harmed while defending your political views it's possible your views are the issue.

For example if my view was that "domestic animals shouldn't be abused and penalties increased for such crimes" I wouldn't have mental health issues discussing this.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by concordDance on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:25AM (#43702904)
The vast majority of people will get stressed talking to people they think are evil or against their values. Someone breaking down in tears because another person says they "don't give a fuck about the bloody Gazans" is not behaving particularly unusually.

The views don't matter as much as how strongly they are held.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by graemep on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:07AM (#43703181)
> Someone breaking down in tears because another person says they "don't give a fuck about the bloody Gazans" is not behaving particularly unusually.

it might be reasonable if you have personal close links to Gaza (e.g. you are worried about family who live there), but otherwise it OUGHT to be very unusual.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by saagarjha on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:50AM (#43703417)
Why?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:22AM (#43704479)
> it might be reasonable if you have personal close links to Gaza (e.g. you are worried about family who live there)

That's another problem with political discussions at work - you're often not sure why someone has a particular beliefs and so it's hard to know whether disagreement will be taken as an abstract difference of opinion or as an attack on their family, friends, or homeland.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @01:38PM (#43719961)
"I don't care if people in Gaza die"

"Wait, you don't give a shit if like 10k families are killed?"

"No, no, it's like I don't care from an abstract point of view"

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @08:17AM (#43715711)
I understand this happens and I agree but there's two options.

1. Avoid talking about politics

2. Learn to control your emotions when discussing politics even if you have a strong view.

I think 2 is a better solution otherwise the worse things get the more people will avoid talking about it.

It's worth the effort because, based on your example, if you really cared about the people of Gaza you need to stand up and defend them, not avoid the topic due to how uncomfortable it makes you feel

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pjc50 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:30AM (#43702934)
Funnily enough, one of the UK's odder, more intense, and probably mentally ill domestic terror campaigns was carried out by anti-vivisectionists.

(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_Huntingdon_Animal_Cruelty)

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pseudalopex on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:06AM (#43703174)
Were they anti vivisectionists? Or animal testing opponents who called animal testing vivisection?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by perching_aix on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:25AM (#43703615)
So if I now said some intentionally asinine garbage, e.g. about how dogs need to be disciplined, shown who the pack leader is, and sometimes that necessarily involves a beating, and how if you disagree you're woke, that wouldn't make you very understandably very distraught?

Because it would make me pretty distraught, and I don't think that it's because anything is wrong with the idea of not abusing animals.

Even doing this mental exercise for the sake of this conversation is already extremely frustrating for me. And I don't think this should surprise you, or is anything strange or unusual.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by fc417fc802 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @05:05PM (#43722204)
Actually yeah if someone stating their views in a context that doesn't directly impact you leaves you "distraught" I'd say you have an emotional issue on your end. That said, in the real world people commonly have those and avoiding the situations that trigger them is perfectly reasonable.

Let's just be clear that something can be commonplace while also being a personal issue.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by perching_aix on Thursday April 17, 2025 @06:03PM (#43722718)
I guess people getting extremely worked up in controversial threads are all just exceptional cases like I am then.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by fc417fc802 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @07:06PM (#43723186)
My entire point there was that this is not exceptional in the least. People having emotional issues is quite common!

Incidentally, the response you're exhibiting here - a reflexive emotional rejection as opposed to critical thought - is closely related to the phenomenon being discussed here. That exact response is often (but not always) what leads to people becoming distraught in the first place. It's an emotional feedback loop.

Examining the context we see something of a dichotomy. That mental health being harmed by political discourse is likely to indicate a problem with personal views versus that being normal and expected depending on context. I'm presenting a third viewpoint tied to the example you provided. The idea that it is related to an emotional issue which is largely independent of personal views, that this is a relatively common thing to encounter, and that people should not be criticized for taking steps to mitigate personal issues.

In other words, I am largely agreeing with you but going on to point out that it's a personal issue deserving of long term work.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by noelwelsh on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:06AM (#43702770)
Two things:

"Party politics" is ill-defined, and so a "no politics" rule becomes an arbitrary hammer that bosses can use to smash employees. If I say "I'm going to get a COVID vaccine this afternoon" is that discussing party politics? In the UK, where I live, the vaccine was provided by the government, so I'm implicitly discussing the actions of the government. That is under any reasonable definition a discussion of politics.

"everyday party politics are spilling out and overwhelming a project's or industry's individual, internal politics" is how "no politics" rules are usually justified, but this was not what happened in the poster child cases of implementing "no politics" rules (37signals, Coinbase). 37signals in particular tried to spin it this way, but it was the actions of a group within the company approved by the founders that caused the problem. (Coinbase was just completely incoherent from the start. Their mission is something like "End economic inequality" which a reasonable person could take to mean anarchistic or communist discussion is on topic.)

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by graemep on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:05AM (#43703167)
The covid vaccine example is a good one in terms of something in everyday life that is politicised.

It is also illustrates the problem with discussing politics in an international forum. The KCL study of covid conspiracy theories (carried out during the pandemic) found that in the UK young people and those who identified as left wing were more likely to believe conspiracy theories. I am pretty sure this is significantly different from the US. Also matches things I have heard (e.g. my daughter met people at university who refused the vaccine because "we don't trust the Tories".

It is pretty common for Americans to assume that the Conservatives are equivalent to Republicans, and Labour are like the Democrats, which is very far from the truth. It has always been far from the truth but the reasons why change - e.g. in the 80s Thatcher and Reagan were not far apart, but that that time Labour were far to the left of the Democrats (actual socialists).

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by perching_aix on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:30AM (#43703641)
There's no way to define any modality of politics such that someone like you won't come around and start going off about how it's a leaky segmentation, and is actually just an excuse for censorship.

Every artificial segmentation of the real world is leaky. Just like the recognition that politics is everywhere, this too is not actually inquisitive. It's like arguing that stairsteps are chairs. They can be, but that doesn't make the word "chair" ill-defined.

> but this was not what happened in the poster child cases of implementing "no politics" rules

There is no such thing. These may be notable cases in your cohort, for me it's the first time I heard of these. And I've seen my fair share of these rules.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by noelwelsh on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:47PM (#43708964)
What's the purpose of a "no politics" rule at work? Is to stop people starting shit with their coworkers, or is to give those in power an arbitrary hammer to apply to those without power in the organization?

If it's the former, 1) it should be just that and 2) it isn't needed because it's never ok to start shit with coworkers that is unrelated to work. If someone spends all their time starting shit, whether about politics (however that is defined), sports, food choices, clothing, or anything else you can just fire them. No need to have a "no politics" rule.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @08:12AM (#43715654)
I think it's more simple. Just avoid any conflict. As you pointed out "don't start shit" already covers this but they specifically call out politics because some might not think it would cause offense.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by fc417fc802 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @04:57PM (#43722132)
What if you speak about something with no intention of creating conflict, but a few people around you get riled up? You haven't done anything wrong yet the divisive topic isn't a good fit for the workplace.

Some employees either can't or won't see this, hence rules such as "no politics".

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by t0lo on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:52AM (#43702271)
I mean I think The Republican Incumbent was chosen specifically as a tool because he is so extreme, pervasive and demoralising and creeps into everything. Definitely by Russia, maybe also by our "friend" in the ME. Although it's not that reported on they are on friendly terms.

Disaffection lends itself easily to creating a Russia-style society. This all feels pretty Dugin-esque, and his proposition (return to values, reject interest/hope in politics because it is always flawed anyway, bind together under the state) fits perfectly, and is finding prominence at the perfect time.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by ndr42 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:24AM (#43702485)
What is "ME" referring to?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by NikkiA on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:37AM (#43702573)
"Middle East" is the usual expansion, and fits in context here.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by HelloNurse on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:14AM (#43702840)
The "friend" could be Israel or some person like Mohammed bin Salman.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by NikkiA on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:48AM (#43704169)
Given the treatment for supporters of gaza, almost certainly Netting-yahoo
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:03AM (#43702350)
Everything already was, you just didn't recognize it because it was to your benefit / in your interests.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by po1nt on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:36AM (#43702562)
That's because we got reliant on the funds from government. Maybe it's time to break the dependency.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jocaal on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:17AM (#43703244)
> That's because we got reliant on the funds from government

Not we, some people got reliant on the funds from government. It is always at the cost of someone else. The tax the rich and bourgeoisie mentality is what led to Mao Zedong and Stalin, but no-one wants to learn about history anymore.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Moomoomoo309 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:48AM (#43704171)
Tax the rich mentality also led to the "golden age of capitalism" of the 1940s, 50s, and 60s. The tax rates on the wealthiest in the US at that time were huge, and that money went into job programs, housing assistance programs, construction projects, etc.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mrguyorama on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:43PM (#43710174)
Stalin and Mao were both cults of personality being driven by a young, disaffected population who were so sick and tired of the status quo that they were willing to murder and burn and kill and destroy and didn't really care about what came after.

That should sound very familiar right about now.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by paganel on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:20AM (#43702459)
Agree, but it goes both ways, with technology (that many of us here have helped create and maintain) also reaching out into every facet of society and community, many times in close symbiosis with the political powers that be, to the detriment of said society and community.

Not 100% sure what I wanted to say, maybe that said politics (and the political as a whole) wouldn't have invaded almost our entire lives without the help of technology.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by scandox on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:46AM (#43702624)
What people mean when they say this is that they don't want to engage in party political and/or tribal political discussions. They don't want to do this because it just means rehearsing talking points.

People are not dumb. They know that politics is everywhere but they want to live and love and talk about things that are interesting.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by gedy on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:08AM (#43704347)
Exactly, and on the flip side many people who want to "talk politics" mainly want to shout at the outgroup and pick public fights.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by blueflow on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:34AM (#43702557)
The problem is not political topics, it is how people discuss them.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by titaphraz on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:43AM (#43704720)
That's a massive issue. Every topic is so polarized that it's as if it's evil vs. good.

But I think people are waking up, because things they took as non-political god given right is being made political and taken away.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by titaphraz on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:45AM (#43704754)
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by cantrecallmypwd on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:19AM (#43702452)
Yep. It's also true of people who think they can simply move out of the US and that "solves" the problem too. America's problems are still (almost) everyone's problems too.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by goku12 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:33AM (#43704592)
True. But it's much less of a problem outside. For example, does the gun culture in the US affect the rest of the world? It sure does. You can guess where most of the illegal weapons come from. But we rarely even think about getting shot while at school or on our way to the groceries.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by okeuro49 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:09AM (#43702388)
"You can stay out of politics, but politics will always come and find you."

No, it's just recognising that it is silly to talk about politics, as certain views are just downvoted.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by spookie on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:00AM (#43702719)
Of all places I find this one the most shielded from this behavior as long as you're civil.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by goku12 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:11AM (#43705072)
It's true that HN insists on and respects civil behavior. But HN doesn't always remain impartial in terms of downvotes, flagging and removal of comments when it comes to some topics that are inherently political. There was one such overtly political thread recently where some of the opposing comments were flagged and removed. Those comments were not even as inflammatory as the news article itself. It indicates that HN does have a majority political bias that they're not hesitant to impose up on the discourse.

I'm not going to go into specifics of the topic because I don't want to start another episode, though I do have the complaint that such actions distort the discourse unfairly to one side. And I also understand that political biases are human nature and that they can never be fully eliminated. But at the same time, it would be harmful to pretend that the discourse on HN is apolitical, balanced or that it shields you from that sort of censorship. Imagine making a good-faith counterargument, only to have it flagged and removed because the opposition doesn't like it. And when asked, you get cited a point in the CoC, except that it's not applied uniformly and impartially in that thread. Makes you wonder what the purpose of flagging is at all! That will just put certain groups at an undisclosed disadvantage and lets harmful stereotypes flourish without any challenge. All we can do is to be forthright about this fact and try our best to have a civil debate.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mintplant on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:06AM (#43702771)
Saying "I'm not political" is also a privilege. It means that society hasn't come and made your very existence political. (I'm trans.)
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by elcritch on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:27AM (#43702918)
> The ancient Greek understanding of an “idiot” referred to someone who was a private citizen or a person who did not actively participate in public life or politics.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by spacebanana7 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:05AM (#43703169)
To play devil's advocate - it's horrible when gaming, programming, business or even porn forums get overrun by politics.

It's not that the political topics are unimportant but all my feeds just end up looking the same as each other and the same as a newspaper app. I hate election nights because of this.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by acdha on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:44AM (#43704138)
I miss that, too, but the way we get there is by re-establishing democratic norms and boundaries. The United States is flirting with fascism, and globally we are seeing the fallout from that and the cascading effects of climate change, not to mention the impacts of AI on employment, surveillance and censorship, social media, etc. Keeping politics out of forums like the ones you mentioned is like keeping oxygen out of a space station.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jzb on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:19AM (#43704452)
Flirting? That was years ago. Fascism has its shit in U-Haul and is ready to move in.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pixl97 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:48AM (#43704788)
Ready to move in, are we sure it's wallet isn't on the nightstand and the keys are hanging beside the door?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by thfuran on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:52AM (#43704852)
Nah, it's already almost done moving its stuff in.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by ivolimmen on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:55AM (#43704231)
If you are American and you voted for this guy -> https://www.reddit.com/r/leapoardsatemyface/
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Titan2189 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:11AM (#43703546)
"porn forums" is a thing?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by nindalf on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:41AM (#43704118)
Porn forums are a thing. For example, this politician lost what should have been an easy election because someone found his old comments on a porn forum - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_North_Carolina_gubernator.... Among other things he commented on the forum that he'd like to bring slavery back.

Honestly did not believe that people commented on porn forums before this incident.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by intuitionist on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:02AM (#43703834)
They’re so much a thing that they came back the other way and overran politics itself in the North Carolina governor’s race last year
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by numpad0 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:59AM (#43703810)
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by amarcheschi on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:55AM (#43703784)
i would be surprised otherwise
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by 7bit on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:50AM (#43703745)
Absolutely
[dead]
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by eertami on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:10AM (#43703532)
I think it's a stretch to suggest _all_ are, I'm not sure I could believe that a game like Super Hexagon is political. Would it be political to paint the tree in your backyard, or to draw a picture of your cat?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jdiff on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:19AM (#43705143)
While I have absolutely no idea what the politics of Super Hexagon could be framed as, with regards to the paintings, yes. Having a tree, having a backyard, having a pet (or a cat specifically), these aren't universal across cultures and ideologies and can carry slight, subtle, political messages. Politics don't have to be intentional.

You could say that this is having political implications rather than carrying a political message, but the politics are still lurking in there all the same.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by scoresomefeed on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:53AM (#43704869)
Inverse devils advocate:

But look at it this way: I see the us political spectrum melting down into authoritarianism and you’re complaining you don’t need to be reminded of it.

A similar analogy would be if we are at your house, and it catches fire, and you complain that it is interfering with watching Netflix while I’m trying to call 911 for help.

From my perspective you are ignoring your own demise and from your perspective I’m just being annoying.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by SkyBelow on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:08AM (#43705035)
Politics are also never discussed with any level of depth. At best, it each side throwing in their opening arguments and nothing more. More often you don't even get that and instead have attacking people directly, stereotyping, straw manning, and all sorts of logical fallacies. Discussion in such a situation does not happens, so either it is an ongoing war or some side wins and pushes out the rest. None of these outcomes would seem beneficial for here, and while I do think there would be some slightly longer form discussions here compared to most places, I don't think it would be enough to avoid the eventual decay.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by keybored on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:22AM (#43703279)
Apolitical person: Ugh politics is so dumb

Same person: Why is the world organized in such a dumb way?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pjmlp on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:52AM (#43703429)
Technology without politics is a pipe dream, even the FOSS licenses depend on politics.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bamboozled on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @06:12AM (#43703557)
100% agree, staying out of politics has been a luxury not everyone has, it's totally unavoidable now.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pif on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:37AM (#43704084)
There's politics and there are facts.

Trump voters are stupid. This is a fact.

Right or left leaning, that's politics.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mrtksn on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:56AM (#43704239)
The problem with discussing politics is that it gives you the kicks. Its very easy to get into a feedback loop and take things quite far off civility. I am also guilty of it, many times.

IMHO there needs to be a mechanism for breaking the loop and then we can have civil online political discussions. Unfortunately most places just ban it or ban those who got into the loop, either way its ugly.

IRL when discussing politics and things don't go badly its thanks to 3rd party who will moderate or calm down the heated debaters.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by kelsey98765431 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:12AM (#43704380)
No thank you. I am absolutely uninterested in civil discussions with people who literally want to kill me and deport my good friends to guantanamo bay cuba. When you accept nazism you throw the concept of civil discourse out the window.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mrtksn on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:22AM (#43704477)
See, its unlikely that its those people that you meet online and you won't be able to do anything to them anyway.

%99.999 of the time its usually trolls or people with good intentions(with wrong solutions based on wrong information or understanding of the situation). Trolls can be fun when they play with hypothetical scenarios and edge cases, conducting thought experiments.

You are also unlikely to change the views of the people with good intentions through discussion but they are very useful to understand what their motives so you can develop beter arguments or solutions. Also, you might find out that on some issues you are one of those with good intentions(but misguided understanding of the situation).

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:35AM (#43704622)
Case in point: you have decided that those who disagree with you want to kill you, deport your friend, and are otherwise nazis. While a minority do, that isn't the majority.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by vultour on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:03AM (#43704980)
This argument went out the window long ago. You're not absolved of responsibility just because you voted for someone who wants to hurt people instead of hurting them yourself.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:53AM (#43706350)
Quit turning the argument around. forget about "them" - what does it say about you when you cannot talk nice about people you disagree with?

People who voted for Trump are not stupid. They have real concerns that they do not see being met and so they are turning to something that while maybe not ideal is at least a promise of maybe better. Maybe it will be worse, but they don't see things on the right track as they were either.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by thrance on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @01:56PM (#43708427)
I feel like by now those people you describe should have realized Trump is doing no good on those issues they supposedly cared about. And if they had even a tiny modicum of empathy, they should be scared shitless about the people getting disappeared.

The economy is shit, eggs are more expensive than ever but those same people that insisted those issues alone should decide the fate of the country don't seem to care anymore. Why?

People who voted for Trump weren't stupid, they've been molded into it by the most expensive proaganda apparatus that ever existed. Ask yourself, why isn't Trump's popularity declining in the face of such incompetency?

Now, what can a nice talk achieve that material reality failed to convince those people of?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:38PM (#43709485)
That you think the president could do anything about the price of eggs (which are driving by fundamentals) shows that you are no better.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by thrance on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:10PM (#43709815)
Then why did he run on that?? That's my whole point! Why did Fox News make this the central issue of the campaign? Why did he promise 100 times he would bring down egg prices? And why is he pretending like the prices are down and lower than ever before???

And most importantly, why aren't there any Republicans that care he lied and continues to lie so shamelessly about it? On that and the thousand other issues he promised he would fix and did not deliver jack shit on.

My point is, they're completely detached from reality. No amount of polite discussion can bring them back. If you haven't realized Trump is a lying crook at this point, you never will.

You're prime example, you just shut your mind completely and said "he can't do anything about it" when 4 months prior you, like the rest of them, certainly would have been adamant Biden should go to hell for making eggs so expensive and that Trump would fix everything.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by bluGill on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:33PM (#43710634)
What do you mean I shut my mind - I never subported him for various reasons. I'm just stating his supporters are not as stupid as you think.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by vultour on Sunday April 20, 2025 @05:32AM (#43742677)
I'm sorry but any charitability was lost after his first term, if you're still voting for him then yes, you are indeed stupid. His actions literally do not benefit anyone other than a few close "friends" that make billions on the massive swings he creates in the market. If you're a money hungry billionaire I understand why you vote for him, if you're the average Joe then you're dumb.

I find it really funny that even now, several months into his seconds term, you're still attempting to paint his supporters as regular level-headed people with "real concerns". Yea, that's why in every interview where they cry about lost jobs or crashed market it's "I thought he was going to hurt the others!". Real fine people he's got there.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mulnz on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:40AM (#43704685)
I am (un)lucky enough to live in an area where I don't have to decide this. People are willing to say it out loud.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by crawsome on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:48AM (#43705526)
Why can't we talk plainly to each other anymore? Can we not talk in loaded statements and projection?

They have valid concerns, and taking steps to minimizing those concerns is just muddying the water in favor of those using political violence against people who don't deserve it.

There's a lot of counter-intel campaigns flying around all at once, and a lot of them are curated to infect brains of people who are willing to accept fascism.

"Well, they're not completely nazis... so you're wrong for likening them to nazis!"

"Well, you've decided to shut off discussion to people opening your mind about the impending fascism. That must mean you're not fit for discussion"

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by thrance on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:03AM (#43704978)
We had a word for people that voted for Nazis, agreed with Nazis, talked like Nazis but claimed they weren't Nazis themselves in the 40s. It was "Nazi".

What matters is that the current administration is disappearing people with no legal reasons, due process or possible recourse. Either you agree with them in which case fuck you, or you don't and you condemn them. There can be no compromise or civility when one side is so aggressive and dangerous.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by citizenkeen on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:00AM (#43704949)
One the one hand, yes.

On the other hand:

“Historians have a word for Germans who joined the Nazi party, not because they hated Jews, but out of a hope for restored patriotism, or a sense of economic anxiety, or a hope to preserve their religious values, or dislike of their opponents, or raw political opportunism, or convenience, or ignorance, or greed.

That word is 'Nazi.' Nobody cares about their motives anymore.”

- Julius Goat

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:50AM (#43704822)
No thank you. I am absolutely uninterested in civil discussions with people who literally want to control everything I say and put my good friends into reeducation camps. When you accept communism you throw the concept of civil discourse out the window.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by abvdasker on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:01AM (#43704959)
Democrats haven't put anyone into a reeducation camp as far as I'm aware. Your enemies are imaginary while the parent comment's enemies are all too real.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:20AM (#43705925)
Yes, but the Republicans literally want to kill some minority groups. /s

Do you know how crazy this all sounds once you're outside of a specific left echo chamber? How is the hyperbole I employed any more unbelievable than that of the poster I was replying to? Another sibling comment to yours says that Trump is rounding up political opponents for a gulag. Nevermind that he has only rounded up non-citizen (most of them in the US illegally) because that's all he can do.

If you look at my posting history, it's wildly left-wing as little as 2 years ago. I've become completely disillusioned with the left after noticing how self-contradictory some of those ideas are and how the language of crisis is deployed to constantly smear their political opponents. Everyone the left doesn't like is Hitler and every policy they don't like is fascism. Give me break.

Edit:

For a little more elaboration, look at the speech codes and compelled "DEI pledges" that American universities have employed in the last few years[1]. How is this not speech policing? You might argue that these are private institutions, and maybe that's fair enough, but when the government pulls funding for crap like this the hyperbole and outrage persist.

Or look at Canada's bill C-63[2]. This bill aims to allow the possibility of life sentences for "hate speech"[3]. To me this is authoritarian. To many left wing commentators, it's another day at the office, I guess - meanwhile the Canadian right wing party is regularly called fascist[4][5] despite being basically in line with US Democrats on many issues.

[1] https://unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-last-four-years-wer...

[2] https://www.parl.ca/DocumentViewer/en/44-1/bill/C-63/first-r...

[3] https://bccla.org/2024/09/whats-in-bill-c-63-why-are-we-alar...

[4] https://medium.com/pigeons-peculiarities/pierre-poilievres-p...

[5] https://cultmtl.com/2025/02/pierre-poilievre-has-racked-up-e...

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by thrance on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:42AM (#43706199)
Oh good, "it's only non-citizens". Nevermind that they're still supposed to be protected by the constitution, then. Also, Trump said two days ago that he wishes to send citizens to El Salvador too [1]. Are we allowed to call them fascist or should we wait for that to be made illegal too?

Trump does not care about the law. SCOTUS, in a historic 9-0 ruling, commanded him to bring back Kilmar Abrego Garcia from El Salvador. He unsurprisingly did not comply. Yet you're still insisting he can't legally do X or Y so everything is fine. When has that stopped him, like ever?

If that's not fascism, then what is? What would it take for you to say "OK that's too much"?

[1] https://apnews.com/article/trump-citizens-prison-el-salvador...

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by miningape on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:04AM (#43704998)
Any argument where you can change a few words and it suddenly makes the opposite point was never a good argument to begin with.

In short: it doesn't convince you of anything, it merely reinforces your existing biases.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by btucker on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:58AM (#43704916)
I understand you're trying to "both sides" an argument. What have you found that has achieved for you in the past? Do you change people's opinions with this?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:38AM (#43706142)
I have found that no amount of online discussion has ever changed anyone's mind on larger issues. We're all pissing in the wind here.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by btucker on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:30PM (#43707358)
Then why did you post that?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by frob on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:04AM (#43704992)
What you are saying is the fantastical kool-aid Fox News and alt-right media spin to you.

In the meantime, Trump is actually deporting people without due process to inhumane torture camps run by a dictator while openly bragging about it and defying court orders.

These two things are not the same.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:50AM (#43706310)
> What you are saying is the fantastical kool-aid Fox News and alt-right media spin to you.

What I'm replying to is the fantastical Kool-aid MSNBC and alt-left media spin. I'm pretty sure the Republicans are not going to be rounding up and killing minorities despite hyperbolic descriptions like "people who literally want to kill me and deport my good friends to guantanamo bay cuba".

Wait, you're saying El Salvador is a dictatorship? From briefly glancing at Wikipedia I don't see any evidence of that. Why the need to smear another country just to make Trump look worse?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by enraged_camel on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:13AM (#43705092)
I don't think any Democrat has ever put anyone into reeducation camps. I may be mistaken though - can you cite some examples?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:52AM (#43706336)
I don't think any Republican has advocated for a policy of killing minorities. The hyperbole of my post is the point.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by DrillShopper on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:12AM (#43705076)
> people who literally want to control everything I say and put my good friends into reeducation camps

Then you shouldn't talk to Trump supporters as that's exactly what they want to do for anyone that disagrees with them, and last I checked, they're capitalists.

They are planning on abducting people off the street, completely ignoring the courts and denying due process, and sending them to another country where they're being deprived of their rights, again, with no due process and no (effective) judicial review.

I'd expect most right wingers would be against this, but the Orange in Charge's supporters seem to hew to the "well if you didn't do anything wrong you've got nothing to worry about" angle because it's something happening to people they think deserve it.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:55AM (#43706362)
> but the Orange in Charge's supporters seem to hew to the "well if you didn't do anything wrong you've got nothing to worry about" angle because it's something happening to people they think deserve it.

This is literally the left wing reply when people complain about losing their job or their family for voicing the wrong political belief. "They deserve it, they should 'do better'."

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by DrillShopper on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:07AM (#43706495)
There is a huge difference between losing your job and being black bagged, sent to El Salvador, and possibly killed.

Let's keep that in perspective.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by thrance on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:06AM (#43705009)
Insane talk. Where is that communist political force seeking to open gulags? The Democrats? Hahahahah

Trump has a gulag in El Salvador, right now, that he uses to send his political opponents to. And you people are still making up fantasies to play the victim. Absolutely disgusting.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by galangalalgol on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:53AM (#43704865)
Having civil discussions with people who disagree isn't about politeness or acquiescence. Having political discussions per the same rules we use for technical debates, like steel manning, allows information to actually flow both ways. I'm up to four people now that I changed parties between 2020 and 2024. That doesn't seem like a lot, but if everyone was doing it it would make a difference. It took time. I had to non judgementally listen to their concerns and intuit the fears underneath. They were reasonable intelligent people operating off of propaganda mostly. The emotional hook had been set and used draw them further and further into false narratives that fed their fears and hopes. To think I am immune isn't realistic either. My triggers are getting used to pull me the other direction, to make me uncompromising, and to view those who disagree as inhuman. Some of that is game theory polarizing us, but some of it is the intentional result of the Kremlin's standard divide and conquer they have been using on us for over half a century. The antidote is calm conversations with voters who have been made scared about irrational things, and looking to see what fears we are being manipulated with as well.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by DrillShopper on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:11AM (#43705064)
> Having civil discussions with people who disagree isn't about politeness or acquiescence. Having political discussions per the same rules we use for technical debates, like steel manning, allows information to actually flow both ways.

What additional information do they need to get out there other than they want me and people like me dead? What additional information do I need to get out there other than I don't want them to do that?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by wins32767 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:31AM (#43705305)
The logical end state of this belief is a civil war. I assume that in lieu of trying to change minds you're buying guns and ammo and trying to organize like minded people into a militia to protect your safety? Cause if not, I don't really think you really believe that a significant fraction of the country wants people like you dead.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by DrillShopper on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:06AM (#43706490)
I'm in the process of emigrating to Europe since it's not safe for me and my family here.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by galangalalgol on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:10PM (#43707133)
Not sure which hated demographic you fall in, but I have friends that are suddenly being threatened by individuals who now feel free to expose their true selves. I can't believe almost half the population are like that though. Escape may be the best option for a lot of people at this point. My friend doesn't realistically have that option due to finances and skillset. I do think people who aren't in immediate danger can pull a lot of people supporting those fueled by hate away from their positions with calm dialogue.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mrtksn on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:52PM (#43707629)
In my experience as a chronic immigrant, most people are nice but there are some a-holes who would want to harm you or see you get harmed but they would not act unless they feel in power.

Therefore, most of the time you can just ignore them and your experience wouldn't any different than the natives who would also encounter a-holes for different reasons. The problem starts when someone in power to affect your life is one of those but in normal times you still can push back by questioning their actions as they still seek approval from the larger society.

The case with Trump seems to be the same with the case with Brexit: Those a-holes(not everyone who support those but a subset of them who are a-holes) start believing that they are in power and the society approves them therefore they can act on their instincts or plans.

I was working in London on the Brexit referendum day, some of our Spanish developers had trouble with people from their neighborhood right after the referandum.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by crawsome on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:01AM (#43705704)
The loop is intentionally being closed and sped-up by enemies of the USA who want to exhaust the USA in every way possible.

After the infekktion of 2015, moderators of Right-leaning discussion boards started amping up their censorship. Left leaning and moderate discussion boards still tend to be more moderate, letting most discussions in and censoring less.

Most of the time, one side is trying to play an equal field, while the other shits all over it and just yells "Winning!"

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by deadbabe on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:21AM (#43704472)
Not keeping politics out of our lives is the reason we’ve ended up with a totalitarian fascist dictatorship. If politics is forbidden, people have to just make up their own minds and vote for what makes sense to them, instead of banding together and slowly intensifying to the most radical extremes in bids to outdo each other.

Everytime you discuss politics on the internet, you entrench the current administration.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by timacles on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:25AM (#43706655)
Fascinating logic. The victims are at fault. If only they did something different the abusers would have never had to abuse them.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by throwanem on Thursday April 17, 2025 @10:21AM (#43717278)
I understand how you get here, but you haven't considered what would be required in practice to "forbid politics." Banning speech would be where you would have to start, and by the time you were finished Walter Freeman might grow a bit faint.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by throwanem on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @02:18PM (#43764855)
Oh, excuse me, I see you have considered it. There is a class of cautionary advice I reserve for such situations, but you are obviously well past the reach of that or any other reliable counsel, and I'll bear this in mind henceforward.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Pxtl on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:51AM (#43704839)
> the "I wish HN would stay out of politics" crew.

Sadly, this crew includes the site's moderation.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by mardifoufs on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:54AM (#43704887)
ah yes, losing the... CVE database is truly the wake up call to get engaged in politics.

I mean sorry but I'm not sure if you're being ironic. It sounds like something you'd read on ngate

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by orblivion on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:46AM (#43705497)
HN can stay out of politics just fine for the most part. If a political topic comes into tech we can talk about it then, and stay out of other crap that insufferable people drag in because "there's no such thing as being neutral" or whatever.